July 10, 2025

Shield of Sparrows - Devney Perry

1 hour 6 minutes

Why Shield of Sparrows became the #1 New York Times bestseller that pulled TS back into romantasy after swearing off the genre. This comprehensive review compares Perry's monster-hunting debut against Fourth Wing and Quicksilver to see what works—and what definitely doesn't.

Episode Highlights:

Why this book convinced a reluctant reader to try romantasy again

Complete commercial success breakdown and industry impact

Spoiler-free recommendation: who should and shouldn't read this

Shadow daddy comparison: Guardian vs. Xaden vs. Kingfisher

The Witcher connections and missed monster-hunting opportunities

Character motivation breakdowns that don't make sense

Writing style issues and repetitive middle section problems

Game of Thrones arranged marriage comparison and what went wrong

Key Timestamp:

20:04 - ⚠️ SPOILER SECTION BEGINS - Full plot breakdown and detailed craft analysis

Resources Mentioned:

Shield of Sparrows by Devney Perry (available on Kindle Unlimited)

Fourth Wing by Rebecca Yarros comparison throughout

Quicksilver by Callie Hart shadow daddy analysis

The Witcher series parallels and monster-hunting concepts

Game of Thrones arranged marriage execution comparison

Red Tower Books publishing strategy discussion

This is TS's third romantasy review on Bestsellers and Brews. Subscribe wherever you get your podcasts for more honest book breakdowns and writing craft discussions.

Next Episode: Foreign Affairs by Alison Lurie

Connect with us: Join the FREE Skool Community to get good at writing: https://www.skool.com/get-good-at-writing

...more

View all episodes

By Tang Seng

3.3

33 ratings