
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


Why does "I'm sad" tell us nothing, while "my coffee's gone cold" breaks our hearts? In Part 1 of Musical Theater Lyric Writing 101, Brett Boles and Josh Shelton break down what makes a musical theater lyric different from a poem, why being specific is the secret to being universal, and how to write in pictures instead of conclusions.
You'll walk away with practical techniques you can use in your very next lyric, including an image exercise to turn an abstract idea like "love" into concrete details, and why one well-chosen object can carry the emotion of an entire verse.
In this episode:
CHAPTERS
00:00 Welcome to Showtuned
02:25 I Want Songs of the Week
04:46 Lyrics vs. poetry: you only get one chance
07:40 Why pop can be vague but musicals can't
09:03 Why generic doesn't work: specificity is universal
10:37 The image exercise: from abstract to concrete
11:51 Love songs that never say "love"
13:45 "My coffee's gone cold": show, don't tell
16:25 Write in pictures, not conclusions
17:53 One object can carry a whole verse
19:43 The rhyming dictionary that changed the plot
20:59 Writing is rewriting: building layers
BONUS CONTENT & COMMUNITY
Join us on Patreon for bonus content, and come hang out for free while we build the community: Patreon.com/showtuned
ABOUT SHOWTUNED
Showtuned is a podcast about musicals and the craft of storytelling through song. Every week, we explore the ways songs tell stories, from melodies and harmonies to lyrics and dialogue.
Hosts:
Brett Boles, professional songwriter, educator, creator of The MT series on TikTok and Instagram, and founder of The MT Studio: https://www.skool.com/songwriters/about
Josh Shelton, filmmaker, songwriter, and founder of Counterpoint Musicals: www.counterpointmusicals.com
If you love musicals, subscribe, and share this episode with the musical lover in your life.
This is Part 2 of a 2 part episode where Brett and Josh discuss the "10 Commandments of Musical Theater Lyric Writing" as written by Pat Cook, former moderator of the BMI Workshop:
Chapters
0:00 Intro
0:21 Commandment 6 — “Thou shalt not self-pity except in comedy”
4:06 Commandment 7 — “Thou shalt not mis-accent / correctly scan”
9:29 Commandment 8 — “Thou shalt find fresh images”
14:26 Commandment 9 — “Thou shalt not false rhyme or transpose words”
26:20 Commandment 10 — “Thou shalt not be rigid or wordy”
Hosted by Brett Boles and Josh Shelton. Each week we explore the layers of ways songs tell stories - from melodies to harmonies, lyrics to dialogue, characters to scenes - and how it all comes together in this unique medium where songs are the engine of the story! This podcast is an exploration for anyone who loves musicals - if you’re a songwriter, playwright, performer, storyteller, theater kid, accompanist, or just a super fan — our goal is you’ll find something interesting here.
Join us on Patreon: Patreon.com/showtuned
Produced by https://www.counterpointmusicals.com/
This is Part 1 of a 2 part episode where Brett and Josh discuss the "10 Commandments of Musical Theater Lyric Writing" as written by Pat Cook, former moderator of the BMI Workshop:
1 Thou shalt be singable.
2 Thou shalt be understandable.
3 Thou shalt be about one thing and one thing only.
4 Thou shalt be specific.
5 Thou shalt write dramatically.
6 Thou shalt not self pity (except in comedy).
7 Thou shalt not misaccent (thou shalt correctly scan).
8 Thou shalt find fresh images.
9 Thou shalt not false rhyme or transpose words.
10 Thou shalt not be rigid or wordy.
The conversation emphasizes the importance of singable, understandable, and specific lyrics, as well as the need to write dramatically and avoid self-pity (except in comedy!). Crafting effective theater lyrics requires attention to detail and adherence to specific guidelines. Finding fresh and unique imagery is essential in creating compelling and engaging theater lyrics.
Chapters
00:00 Intro
03:24 I Want Songs for the Week
6:30 Differences in Poetry, Pop, & Musical Theater Lyrics.
14:22 Commandment 1: Be Singable
17:14 Commandment 2: Be Understandable
22:45 Commandment 3: Be About One Thing Only
26:57 Commandment 4: Be Specific
34:11 Commandment 5: Write Dramatically
37:21 Outro
Hosted by Brett Boles and Josh Shelton. Each week we explore the layers of ways songs tell stories - from melodies to harmonies, lyrics to dialogue, characters to scenes - and how it all comes together in this unique medium where songs are the engine of the story! This podcast is an exploration for anyone who loves musicals - if you’re a songwriter, playwright, performer, storyteller, theater kid, accompanist, or just a super fan — our goal is you’ll find something interesting here.
Produced by https://www.counterpointmusicals.com/
2026 Tonys: Ragtime & Schmigadoon - Brett and Josh discuss the two big winners from the Tonys for Best Musical (Schmigadoon) and Best Revival of a Musical (Ragtime). Ragtime is Brett’s all-time favorite musical and he saw this production multiple times. Join us as we dive into what makes these shows so unique!
Join for free or as a paid member to enjoy bonus content on: Patreon.com/showtuned
Chapters
0:00 Introduction
3:31 I Want Songs for the Week
5:17 2026 Tonys Recap
8:24 Ragtime
23:30 Schmigadoon
29:55 What We’re Listening To
Hosted by Brett Boles and Josh Shelton. Each week we explore the layers of ways songs tell stories - from melodies to harmonies, lyrics to dialogue, characters to scenes - and how it all comes together in this unique medium where songs are the engine of the story! This podcast is an exploration for anyone who loves musicals - if you’re a songwriter, playwright, performer, storyteller, theater kid, accompanist, or just a super fan — our goal is you’ll find something interesting here.
Produced by https://www.counterpointmusicals.com/
Lists are one of the most powerful brainstorming and creativity inducing processes of songwriting. Why are lists so helpful? What type of lists do we make when songwriting? Why did Sondheim love making lists? In this episode Brett and Josh dive into the importance of writing lists and the transformative effect it has on the songwriting process.
Chapters
Songs referenced available for free on Patreon.com/showtuned
Hosted by Brett Boles and Josh Shelton. Each week we explore the layers of ways songs tell stories - from melodies to harmonies, lyrics to dialogue, characters to scenes - and how it all comes together in this unique medium where songs are the engine of the story! This podcast is an exploration for anyone who loves musicals - if you’re a songwriter, playwright, performer, storyteller, theater kid, Disney adult, accompanist, or just a super fan — our goal is you’ll find something interesting here.
Produced by https://www.counterpointmusicals.com/
In Part 2 of the Top 10 Types of Songs in Musical Theater, Brett and Josh discuss: The Charm Song, Conflict/Confrontation Song, Reprises, Act Finales, 11 O’Clock Numbers
Join us on Patreon (free & paid): https://www.patreon.com/showtuned
Follow on IG: https://www.instagram.com/showtunedpod
Chapters
0:00 Introduction
0:34 Charm Songs
6:09 Conflict and Confrontation Songs
11:00 Reprise and Its Impact
15:45 Act Finale and Ensemble Numbers
20:52 The 11 O'Clock Number
27:22 Conclusion and Final Thoughts
Links to songs referenced on https://www.patreon.com/showtuned
Hosted by Brett Boles and Josh Shelton. Each week we explore the layers of ways songs tell stories - from melodies to harmonies, lyrics to dialogue, characters to scenes - and how it all comes together in this unique medium where songs are the engine of the story! This podcast is an exploration for anyone who loves musicals - if you’re a songwriter, playwright, performer, storyteller, theater kid, accompanist, or just a super fan — our goal is you’ll find something interesting here.
Produced by https://www.counterpointmusicals.com/
In Part 1 of the Top 10 Types of Songs in Musical Theater, Brett and Josh discuss: Opening Numbers, Character Establishment Songs, Ballads, Conditional Love Songs and Comedy Songs.
Join us on Patreon (free & paid): https://www.patreon.com/showtuned
Follow on IG: https://www.instagram.com/showtunedpod
Chapters
Link to songs referenced on Patreon!
Hosted by Brett Boles (The M Tea) and Josh Shelton (Counterpoint Musicals). Each week we explore the layers of ways songs tell stories - from melodies to harmonies, lyrics to dialogue, characters to scenes - and how it all comes together in this unique medium where songs are the engine of the story! This podcast is an exploration for anyone who loves musicals - if you’re a songwriter, playwright, performer, storyteller, theater kid, Disney adult, accompanist, or just a super fan — our goal is you’ll find something interesting here.
Produced by https://www.counterpointmusicals.com/
In this episode of "Showtuned," Brett & Josh explore the fundamental differences between stage and film musicals, including storytelling techniques, audience engagement, technical considerations, and structural differences. Perfect for musical theater enthusiasts, songwriters, and filmmakers.
Key Topics
Chapters
Links to What We're Listening To:
In this episode of Showtuned, Brett Boles (The M Tea) and Josh Shelton (Counterpoint Musicals) delve into the exploration of song structure and form, emphasizing the significance of verse-chorus and AABA forms in musical storytelling. They discuss the role of song structure in character development and story momentum, providing examples from classic and contemporary musical theater. It explores the importance of expectation, repetition and variation in engaging the audience. The concept of through-composed songs in musical theater is also discussed, emphasizing their rarity and the challenges they present.
Join us on Patreon (free & paid): https://www.patreon.com/showtuned
Follow on IG: https://www.instagram.com/showtunedpod
Chapters:
00:00 - Introduction
03:25 - My "I Want Song" for the Week
06:15 - Verse-Chorus Song Form
18:08 - AABA Song Form
33:00 - Through Composed Song Form
Hosted by Brett Boles and Josh Shelton. Each week we explore the layers of ways songs tell stories - from melodies to harmonies, lyrics to dialogue, characters to scenes - and how it all comes together in this unique medium where songs are the engine of the story! This podcast is an exploration for anyone who loves musicals - if you’re a songwriter, playwright, performer, storyteller, theater kid, Disney adult, accompanist, or just a super fan — our goal is you’ll find something interesting here.
Produced by https://www.counterpointmusicals.com/
Today we dive into the art and science of song spotting, exploring the 4 types of "pressure" in a scene that can trigger good moments for songs, and the pacing of songs in musical storytelling. We also do a fun exercise of Song Spotting the movie Toy Story as if we were adapting it into a musical.
Chapters:
0:00 - Intro
2:15 - I Want Songs for the Week
6:00 - Song Spotting Discussion
23:00 - Song Spotting Exercise: Toy Story 1
Takeaways
* Songspotting is the art and science of finding moments in a show that sing, identifying when dialogue is no longer sufficient and when a song must take over.
* Musical theater songs move a character forward or move the story forward in some way, unlike songs written for other genres that exist in a moment. Movie musicals vs. stage musicals
Join us on Patreon (free & paid): https://www.patreon.com/showtuned
Follow on IG: @showtunedpod
Hosted by Brett Boles and Josh Shelton. Each week we explore the layers of ways songs tell stories - from melodies to harmonies, lyrics to dialogue, characters to scenes - and how it all comes together in this unique medium where songs are the engine of the story! This podcast is an exploration for anyone who loves musicals - if you’re a songwriter, playwright, performer, storyteller, theater kid, Disney adult, accompanist, or just a super fan — our goal is you’ll find something interesting here.
Produced by Counterpoint Musicals
From the publisher's feed
Welcome to Showtuned - A podcast about musicals and the craft of storytelling through songs. Hosted by Brett Boles (
Each week we explore the layers of ways songs tell stories - from melodies to harmonies, lyrics to dialogue, characters to scenes - and how it all comes together in this unique medium where songs are the engine of the story! This podcast is an exploration for anyone who loves musicals - if you’re a songwriter, playwright, performer, storyteller, theater kid, accompanist, Disney adult or just a super fan — our goal is you’ll find something interesting here.