Simply Gone Podcast

What does the Milano Inn, the Byzantine Empire, and a pair of boobies have in common? Well, you’ll just have to give this episode a listen to find out. As we scour the Milano Inn in Indianapolis, we uncover more than just delicious meatballs and pasta. So has Mary 1 or Mary 2 come back to haunt the old inn? Or is she, much like my love life, Simply Gone?

We track down a very handsy ghost who is absolutely terrible at pranks. We also discuss the merits of haunting a Chuck E. Cheese and the fact that Moaning Myrtle chose the absolute worst spot in the world to haunt. So is the Ravoli Theater haunted? Or have the previous owners been trying to drum up business? Find out on this episode of Simply Gone.

We investigate Skiles Test who is said to have placed his dead wife in a glass coffin which he wrapped in blue Christmas lights and displayed her in the front window like some kind of morbid trophy for all to see. But does her vengeful spirit haunt the woods around their former home? Is she trapping souls within her mysterious blue lights? Does Arizona from Grey’s Anatomy have a magical leg? Find out on this episode of Simply Gone.

It’s the fight of the century, or at least it would be if Stop Sign Mary and The Shadow Beast actually bothered to show up. Where do these legends come from and why is Brazil, Indiana so full of terrible ghost stories? Find out on this episode of Simply Gone.

We investigate the murder of Amelia and her servant in Thornhaven manor. Did Amelia’s sister kill them both? Did Amelia’s child Lizzie also die violently? Are we even real or professional investigators? Why won’t Steve call us back? Join us as we plump the depths of murder and depravity on this episode of Simply Gone.

In this episode we ramble a bunch, are attacked by hunters, discuss pizza in Europe, get distracted, and Meagan cock-blocks Jared. But did we find the succubus that lives outside of Russiaville? Is Kokomo, Indiana a hotspot for devil worship? Does Meagan’s instinct to run at the first sight of danger make her a better candidate for surviving a horror movie than Jared? Or are we both, Simply Gone?

A werewolf that murders and mysterious cattle mutilations are investigated. Can the team track down and trap a werewolf using Slim Jims? Does the werewolf of Tipton, Indiana still live? Is the cheese in a Slim Jim double pack real cheese? Why won’t Eric let us investigate his haunted school? All of these questions and more are answered in this week’s episode of the Simply Gone podcast.

Halloween Special! In the 1920s, KKK Grand Dragon D.C. Stephenson brutally assaulted and murdered Madge Oberholtzer. Despite his eventual conviction and a life in prison, it’s said that her spirit still haunts the home in which she was tormented and cries over her gravestone when the moon is full. Join us as we investigate this case and as a bonus, you’ll also learn about what happens when alcohol and hot tubs mix, as well as the only phrase worth googling over 400 times.

During Thor’s battles with the Jotun, Agnar the Wicked nearly bested the god of thunder, stealing a portion of his might. Now he waits and hides beneath the earth, but his power can still be felt as he plots his revenge on Thor and the rest of the Norse Gods. Can he be found under the electric bridge? Can anyone withstand his might? Can one pee on this electrified bridge unharmed? Join us this week and find out.

This week we come back from our COVID quarantine and head out to everyone’s favorite town to hate in Indiana: Lafayette. Just outside of town we stumble across Tippecanoe and the mysterious rock once used by an indigenous prophet Tenskwatawa, who, going against his brother Tecumseh’s wishes, fought against the Indiana Territorial governor William Henry Harrison. It’s a history-heavy episode as we trek across the wilderness in search of the spirit of Tenskwatawa. So do we find him? Or is he Simply Gone?