Sinners Among Saints

Send us Fan Mail

Deep in the woods of Indiana sits Fox Hollow Farm, a property with a horrifying history that goes far beyond your typical ghost story. Once home to serial killer Herb Baumeister, the estate became the center of one of Indiana’s most disturbing criminal investigations after investigators discovered the remains of multiple young men on the property.

But the darkness surrounding Fox Hollow Farm may not have ended when the bodies were found. Over the years, reports of unexplained noises, shadowy figures, strange encounters, and chilling paranormal activity have fueled rumors that the spirits of the victims still linger on the grounds.

In this episode, we're exploring the horrifying true crime history behind Fox Hollow Farm, the lives lost there, and the unsettling reports of hauntings that have made this property infamous among paranormal enthusiasts. Are these experiences simply the result of a place burdened by unimaginable tragedy, or could something unexplained still be lurking on the grounds?

Join us as we step into the darkness of Fox Hollow Farm, where the real-life horrors are terrifying enough—and the ghost stories may leave you wondering what happens when the dead aren't ready to leave.

Support the show

Thanks for all the support!! Please follow us on Facebook, Instagram, and Tik Tok, or email us, and remember we now have a Patreon!!
 patreon.com/sinnersamongsaintspodcast
[email protected]
Tik Tok @sinnersamongsaints

Send us Fan Mail

Before we get into today’s episode, we wanted to take a moment to explain why we’re bringing this particular case back to you. We originally covered the case of Christa Pike some time ago, but with Pike’s execution currently scheduled  to take place at 9am MST on September 30, 2026, in Tennessee, we felt it was important to revisit the episode and make it available again. Christa Pike was convicted of the 1995 murder of 19-year-old Colleen Slemmer, a case that has remained in the public eye for decades. Pike was sentenced to death and has spent the last 30 years on death row. So, before we begin, we want to acknowledge that this episode discusses a real person, a real victim, and a case that has affected many lives for decades. Our intention in revisiting it isn't to sensationalize what happened, but to provide the story and the context surrounding a case that is once again making headlines. With that said, let's go back to the beginning and revisit the case of Christa Pike.

Christa Pike is an American woman who became the youngest woman sentenced to death in the United States during the modern era. Born on March 10, 1976, in West Virginia, Pike had a troubled upbringing marked by instability and abuse. At 18, while attending a Job Corps program in Tennessee, she murdered a fellow student, Colleen Slemmer, in 1995, in what was described as a premeditated killing fueled by jealousy and obsession. Pike and her accomplices lured Slemmer to a secluded area, where she was brutally tortured and killed. Pike kept a piece of the victim's skull as a trophy, which became a key piece of evidence during her trial. In 1996, Pike was convicted of first-degree murder and sentenced to death by electrocution.

Support the show

Thanks for all the support!! Please follow us on Facebook, Instagram, and Tik Tok, or email us, and remember we now have a Patreon!!
 patreon.com/sinnersamongsaintspodcast
[email protected]
Tik Tok @sinnersamongsaints

Send us Fan Mail

On this week's episode of Sinners Among Saints, Lindsay and Megan dive into the chilling story of Herb Baumeister — a man who was never arrested, never prosecuted, and never convicted, yet is believed to be responsible for one of the most notorious strings of murders in Indiana history. From a seemingly normal childhood in Indianapolis to the discovery of human remains at Fox Hollow Farm, the hosts trace the early life and warning signs of a killer hiding in plain sight. With missing men, unidentified remains, shifting witness statements, and questions about a possible accomplice, the investigation is far from closed — decades later, it's been reopened, and the search for answers continues. This is Part 2 of 2.

Support the show

Thanks for all the support!! Please follow us on Facebook, Instagram, and Tik Tok, or email us, and remember we now have a Patreon!!
 patreon.com/sinnersamongsaintspodcast
[email protected]
Tik Tok @sinnersamongsaints

Send us Fan Mail

On this week's episode of Sinners Among Saints, Lindsay and Megan dive into the chilling story of Herb Baumeister — a man who was never arrested, never prosecuted, and never convicted, yet is believed to be responsible for one of the most notorious strings of murders in Indiana history. From a seemingly normal childhood in Indianapolis to the discovery of human remains at Fox Hollow Farm, the hosts trace the early life and warning signs of a killer hiding in plain sight. With missing men, unidentified remains, shifting witness statements, and questions about a possible accomplice, the investigation is far from closed — decades later, it's been reopened, and the search for answers continues. This is Part 1 of 2.

Support the show

Thanks for all the support!! Please follow us on Facebook, Instagram, and Tik Tok, or email us, and remember we now have a Patreon!!
 patreon.com/sinnersamongsaintspodcast
[email protected]
Tik Tok @sinnersamongsaints

Send us Fan Mail

On the night of July 5, 2012, 16-year-old honor student Skylar Neese slipped out of her bedroom window in Star City, West Virginia, climbed into a waiting sedan, and disappeared into the night.

Initially dismissed by authorities as a typical teenage runaway, Skylar’s disappearance quickly turned into every parent’s worst nightmare as days stretched into weeks with zero contact. At the center of the frantic search were her two inseparable best friends, Shelia Eddy and Rachel Shoaf. Shelia spent hours comforting Skylar’s grief-stricken parents, helping hand out missing-person flyers, and posting emotional pleas across social media. But as investigators began pulling cell tower records, dissecting security footage, and uncovering erratic online posts, the girls’ alibis started to unravel. 

Six months later, a psychological breakdown triggered a confession that shattered the tight-knit community: Skylar hadn’t run away. Her two closest confidantes had lured her into a remote patch of Pennsylvania woods with a premeditated plan, murder weapons, and a calculated count of three. When asked why they did it, the motive proved far more terrifying than any crime of passion. 

In this episode, we unpack the timeline of Skylar’s disappearance, the digital breadcrumbs that cracked the case wide open, the chilling coldness of adolescent psychopathy, and the lasting legacy of "Skylar’s Law" that reformed missing-child alerts nationwide.

Support the show

Thanks for all the support!! Please follow us on Facebook, Instagram, and Tik Tok, or email us, and remember we now have a Patreon!!
 patreon.com/sinnersamongsaintspodcast
[email protected]
Tik Tok @sinnersamongsaints

Send us Fan Mail

Madeline Soto was a 13-year-old girl from Florida, whose disappearance in February 2024 sparked a desperate search and quickly became a case filled with disturbing questions. On February 26, Madeline was reported missing after she failed to show up at school. Her family initially believed she had been dropped off that morning, but investigators soon began piecing together a very different timeline. As detectives retraced Madeline’s final days, attention turned toward her mother’s boyfriend, Stephan Sterns, who had been living with the family. What began as a missing-child investigation soon became a homicide investigation. Investigators uncovered surveillance footage, digital evidence, and other discoveries that raised troubling questions about what happened to Madeline inside the home—and what happened during the hours after she disappeared. As the investigation unfolded, Sterns was arrested and charged in connection with Madeline’s death. The case would reveal a heartbreaking story of a young girl whose final days were surrounded by secrets, unanswered questions, and people who should have been protecting her.

Support the show

Thanks for all the support!! Please follow us on Facebook, Instagram, and Tik Tok, or email us, and remember we now have a Patreon!!
 patreon.com/sinnersamongsaintspodcast
[email protected]
Tik Tok @sinnersamongsaints

Send us Fan Mail

In 1956, a shadow fell over Toronto when a quiet teenager named Peter Woodcock committed a series of unthinkable crimes, shattering the city's sense of safety. Deemed legally insane, he was locked away in the fortress-like walls of Oak Ridge maximum-security psychiatric facility—presumably never to harm another soul. Decades quietly passed, and to the outside world, Woodcock became a forgotten ghost of the past. Until July 1991. After 34 years in psychiatric custody, the killer—now living under the name David Krueger—was granted his very first unescorted day pass. What was meant to be a test of rehabilitation quickly transformed into a nightmare: on that very same afternoon, Woodcock unleashed a lethal conspiracy inside the facility's walls, proving that time had done nothing to tame his darkest impulses. In this episode, we unravel the haunting story of Canada’s infamous "Day Pass Killer," the tragic systemic failures that allowed a predator to strike again, and the unsettling legacy of a man who manipulated the system to the very end.

Support the show

Thanks for all the support!! Please follow us on Facebook, Instagram, and Tik Tok, or email us, and remember we now have a Patreon!!
 patreon.com/sinnersamongsaintspodcast
[email protected]
Tik Tok @sinnersamongsaints

Send us Fan Mail

Harmony Montgomery was just 5 years old when she was murdered by her father, Adam Montgomery, in Manchester, New Hampshire, in December 2019. Despite multiple warning signs of abuse and concerns raised by relatives, Harmony had been placed in her father's custody earlier that year. After her death, Adam concealed her body, which has never been recovered. Shockingly, Harmony wasn't reported missing until December 2021, when her mother, Crystal Sorey, realized she had not seen or spoken to her daughter in years.

During Adam Montgomery's 2024 trial, prosecutors argued that he fatally beat Harmony during a drug-fueled period of homelessness and then moved and hid her body for months with the help of his estranged wife, Kayla Montgomery, who later testified against him. Adam was convicted of murder and several related offenses in 2024, but in 2026 the New Hampshire Supreme Court overturned his murder conviction on procedural grounds and ordered a new trial. His convictions for abuse of a corpse, evidence tampering, witness tampering, and other offenses remain in place, and prosecutors have announced they intend to retry the murder charge. Harmony's body has never been found, and her case has prompted widespread criticism of the child welfare system for failing to protect her despite repeated reports of abuse.

Support the show

Thanks for all the support!! Please follow us on Facebook, Instagram, and Tik Tok, or email us, and remember we now have a Patreon!!
 patreon.com/sinnersamongsaintspodcast
[email protected]
Tik Tok @sinnersamongsaints

Send us Fan Mail

In 1984, 22-year-old engineer Laura Black began working at ESL Inc. in Sunnyvale, California, where coworker Richard Farley quickly became obsessed with her. Despite repeatedly rejecting his advances, Farley stalked Laura for nearly four years—bombarding her with hundreds of letters, gifts, phone calls, and unwanted visits. He even obtained her personal information through deception, followed her to social events, and vandalized her property. After losing his job and just one day before a restraining order against him was set to take effect, Farley returned to ESL on February 16, 1988, armed with multiple firearms. He killed seven people, wounded four others—including Laura—and held police at bay during a five-hour siege before surrendering. The shocking case became one of the driving forces behind California's first anti-stalking law and inspired the 1993 television film Stalking Laura.

Support the show

Thanks for all the support!! Please follow us on Facebook, Instagram, and Tik Tok, or email us, and remember we now have a Patreon!!
 patreon.com/sinnersamongsaintspodcast
[email protected]
Tik Tok @sinnersamongsaints

Send us Fan Mail

To the outside world, Betty Broderick had the perfect life. Living in an affluent San Diego suburb, she was the ultimate high-society housewife, mother to four children, and the rock behind her husband Dan’s meteoric rise to becoming one of the city's top medical-malpractice attorneys. For years, Betty sacrificed everything to support his dreams, expecting to finally enjoy the lifestyle they had built together.

But the dream turned into a suburban nightmare when Dan hired a young new assistant, Linda Kolkena. What followed was a brutal, five-year disintegration of a marriage that would become widely known as the most toxic divorce in California history. As Betty found herself increasingly isolated, financially cut off, and pushed to the margins of the life she created, her retaliation escalated from angry voicemails to actions that shocked her community.

On a quiet November morning in 1989, the escalating psychological warfare reached a point of no return inside a darkened bedroom. In this episode, we dive deep into the messy, polarizing story of the Broderick marriage. Was Betty a calculated, vindictive killer who refused to let go, or was she a woman driven to absolute madness by years of gaslighting and systemic legal torment?

Support the show

Thanks for all the support!! Please follow us on Facebook, Instagram, and Tik Tok, or email us, and remember we now have a Patreon!!
 patreon.com/sinnersamongsaintspodcast
[email protected]
Tik Tok @sinnersamongsaints