Skip the Queue
Download on the App Store

All Skip the Queue episodes

  • Leadership learnings and looking to the future at St. Paul’s. With Sandra Lynes Timbrell

    Skip the Queue is brought to you by Rubber Cheese, a digital agency that builds remarkable systems and websites for attractions that helps them increase their visitor numbers. Your host is Kelly Molson, MD of Rubber Cheese.

    Download our free ebook The Ultimate Guide to Doubling Your Visitor Numbers

    If you like what you hear, you can subscribe on iTunes, Spotify, and all the usual channels by searching Skip the Queue or visit our website rubbercheese.com/podcast.


    If you've enjoyed this podcast, please leave us a five star review, it really helps others find us. And remember to follow us on Twitter for your chance to win the books that have been mentioned in this episode.

    Competition ends April 29th 2022. The winner will be contacted via Twitter.

    Show references:

    https://www.stpauls.co.uk/

    https://twitter.com/SLTHeritage

    https://www.linkedin.com/in/sandra-lynes-timbrell

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell has worked in the cultural sector for 20 years, holding senior roles at some of the UK’s most recognisable sites, including Shakespeare’s Globe and English Heritage properties. She is Director of Visitor Engagement at St Paul’s Cathedral, where she leads several teams including commercial, visitor experience, security, collections and marketing. She is responsible for creating and delivering operational models that enable attractions to be financially secure whilst simultaneously creating a welcoming environment for visitors.

    Sandra has mentored young people starting out in the heritage industry, and delivered numerous talks and training sessions for Museum & Heritage Show; Women in Leadership and SOLT; the leading membership organization for the performing arts in the UK. She holds an MA in Heritage Management.

    Transcription:

    Kelly Molson: Welcome to Skip the Queue, a podcast for people working in or working with visitor attractions. I'm your host Kelly Molson.

    In today's episode I speak with Sandra Lynes Timbrell, Director of Visitor Experience at St. Paul's Cathedral.

    Sandra shares an emotional recollection of starting a new role right at the start of the 2020 lockdown. And we discuss the unique perspective of St. Paul's as a place of worship, and also a tourist attraction.

    If you like what you hear, subscribe on all the usual channels by searching Skip the Queue.

    Kelly Molson: Sandra, it is so lovely to have you on the podcast today. Thank you for coming on.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: Thanks for having me. I'm been a bit of a fan, so I'm quite chuffed to be here to be honest.

    Kelly Molson: Oh, I love it when fans come on the podcast. I have to say you look super fabulous today as well.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: Oh, thank you very much.

    Kelly Molson: As a fair, we're going to start with our icebreaker questions. So I want to know because this has happened to me. Have you ever met anyone famous and lost your mind a tiny little bit?

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: Yes. There's been a couple of people and there was an international incident with Barack Obama, which is a whole other podcast subject.

    Kelly Molson: Oh.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: But I suppose Michael Palin was my big one. Because I think he's amazing. I love Monty Python. And I had a bit of thing for him when he was younger. Obviously not now, he's a bit older. And I met him a couple. I met him at this book launch and I queued up during a lunch break to go and see him. And just got there and then just stood there and he was saying, "Hello, how are you? Thanks for coming.". And I just went, "Thanks".

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: And then I met him again and he asked again how I was and just said something really stupid. I'm getting married. And he said, "Oh, that's lovely. Thank you.".

    Kelly Molson: But that is lovely.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: It is, but then I saw him again at another event, I thought I can't go anywhere near him because [inaudible 00:01:55].

    Kelly Molson: He would be, oh look, there comes that crazy lady again. Let's not go [crosstalk 00:02:01] next time.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: Exactly.

    Kelly Molson: Oh, I love that. Thank you for sharing.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: But I have to say working at the Globe, I met lots of famous people. And I have a really bad... I'm really good with faces and terrible with names. So I used to meet lots of really famous people and then just say, "Oh hi, how are you?" And then realise they were Gemma Artetan.

    Kelly Molson: I've done this on a train before. Because I'm good with faces too. And I always think maybe I went to school with them or something.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: Yeah.

    Kelly Molson: I know them from the past. No, just the tele. Amazing. Thank you. Okay. If you could travel back in time, what period would you go to and why?

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: That's tough because I love history. I'd be like Dr. Who's TARDIS, just doting all over the place. Wow, I don't know. Okay, let's think about this. I'd love to be around the Tudor Court. I think that would be really exciting. I'd love to go to the Restoration of Charles II. Because I always imagine that was like a carry-on film.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: Because I think if you look at a picture of Charles II, he looks like St. James. So I almost imagine that after the austerity of the Puritan Commonwealth, there would suddenly be this almost Dorothy emerging into Oz and everyone was just having a really good time. So I think the Restoration Court would be exciting.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: And I'll tell you where else actually, my Nana used to talk about The Blitz. She had quite a good time. She was in her late teens, early '20s. And obviously, it must have been difficult for her, but she had a good time going dancing with GIs and she was in Trafalgar Square on VE day. So something like that maybe, joining my Nana for a night out during the war.

    Kelly Molson: Oh that's nice, isn't it? Love that.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: There you go.

    Kelly Molson: Good. Thank you. Okay. And what is the worst job that you've ever had?

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: Oh gosh. Without a doubt, it has to have been, it was way back when, when I was trying to get into museums, and I worked for an audio guide company who shall remain nameless. But I had to spend a week and a half stuffing envelopes for them. And it was proper 9:00 till 5:00, just stuffing envelopes. They were just launching their audio guide for the Bilbao Museum in Spain.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: And it was just soulless because I just sat in this room and no one came to talk to me. And I just stuffed envelopes for a week and a half. And I thought, is this what museums are about?

    Kelly Molson: Oh, yes. It's not the greatest first experience, is it?

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: Not brilliant, no.

    Kelly Molson: Okay. Well, things have moved on quite well since then, shall we say? All right. What is your unpopular opinion? And then you can tell us all about your background.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: Oh, my unpopular opinion. You're going to get letters about this. I'm really sorry. I don't understand why The Great British Bake Off is so popular.

    Kelly Molson: I'm with you. No, it's OK. I'm with you.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: Oh, really?

    Kelly Molson: Yes, it's all right. Oh God, me neither.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: Watch the complaints rolling in.

    Kelly Molson: Oh, God. They're going to come, aren't they?

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: They are. It's just, I don't get watching people bake cakes. I've tried watching it. It just doesn't make any sense. And then I don't understand why people want to enter the competition to make these big elaborate cakes when you could just go to the cake shop and buy one.

    Kelly Molson: I totally agree.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: Anyone else who does. And I always feel I'm saying something really awful when I say I don't like-

    Kelly Molson: I do think it was better when it was first one. When it was a bit of a novelty and I did watch a few episodes then. But I still didn't really... I didn't love it. I didn't get into it. I know people who have bake off parties and stuff.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: Yeah.

    Kelly Molson: They'll bake cakes, especially for bake off week. And I'm just...

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: Well people say, oh, you know it's whatever week this week. I was, I'm going to go to Marks & Spencer and I'm going to buy some ready made cakes and...

    Kelly Molson: And I am all about convenience.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: Yes.

    Kelly Molson: Time. And your valuable time that you need to spend on other things.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: And I'd just be stressed.

    Kelly Molson: We're going to get on Sandra.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: We are.

    Kelly Molson: We're going to get on. Well, this all started with a little rubber, didn't it? Rubber collection? So here was my little...

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: Pretty nice.

    Kelly Molson: St. Paul's Cathedral rainbow rubber. Look at that. Amazing. Now, this was from my 35-year-old rubber collection. And for our American people that are listening, I'm talking about erasers, novelty erasers.

    Kelly Molson: But eight year old me used to have a big old collection. And every time I went to a different attraction, I would pick up a rubber. So we have one here from Fourty Hall in Enfield, which is my local place I used to go to, the National Gallery. And I just found all of these in my mum's loft a couple of months ago. I decided I was going to get all of the people that could come on the podcast and the attractions. And you're my first one, Sandra. I'm really pleased.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: Yay.

    Kelly Molson: So tell us a little bit about your background?

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: So I did a Degree in Ancient History and Archeology because I thought I was going to be Indiana Jones and I was going to find treasure. And then I spent a lot of time in some very wet trenches just outside of Manchester and realised it probably wasn't quite as glamorous as I thought it was going to be.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: And I really wanted to go into curatorial. I didn't really quite know what. And for various reasons I ended up, just after I finished my degree, volunteering at the Verulamium Museum in St. Albans. And I originally went to help the curatorial team. They were closing for renovations. So I originally to help the curatorial team to pack up the exhibitions and items.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: But as time went on, I was there for a few weeks, and it gradually got, so could you help an education team? Could you help the front of house team? Could you help with the group book? All those things were happening. And I remember as the placement was coming to an end, I sat down with the Museum Director and I said, “You know what I've really enjoyed the most, is the variety”. And he said, "Ah, you're an operations person".

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: And this light bulb went off because I never knew. And I think that's part of a bigger conversation. I never knew there was such a thing as operations. You get taught about the curatorial side, the conservation side, maybe the education side, but no one really talks about the day-to-day running, the operational stuff.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: So I then went off and did a Master's Degree in Heritage Management. And at the end of that was really fortunate, I got a job in English Heritage up at Kenwood House. And I stayed in English Heritage for seven years. I cut my teeth there. I had a really good time there. It was hard work, but it was fun work. And we were all learning and moving at the same pace.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: So, I was there for seven years, by the end of it I was Head of Visitor Operations for South London. So I had five beautiful historic properties and public parks and gardens. I moved on to a Heritage Lottery Fund Project Management. And then from there, I went off to the Museum of London as Deputy Head of Visitor of Operations. And that was just before London 2012.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: So the whole lens, the focus of the world was on London. It was such a wonderful museum to be at. And again, they were just opening the Galleries of Modern London there. So we have this amazing new team, this amazing new gallery. We were looking at fresh ways to engage our visitors, looking at fresh commercial ideas and again, a really exciting time to be part of the museum. And that place will always hold a really special place in my heart.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: And then moved on from there two Shakespeare's Globe, where I set up the Visitor Experience Department. I went there as Head of Visitor Experience and seven years later left as Director. And the Globe had grown quite organically. It started as a theatre and someone thought we'd better have a box office. And someone else thought, well, we'd better have a shop for people to buy things. And we should have some levies. Be very organic. And no one has ever really been the champion of the visitor. So I came along to knit all of those operational teams together.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: And so I got the role at St. Paul's and the idea was to leave the Globe on the 20th of March 2020 and had a nice week off, go to a couple of exhibitions, spend some time with friends and a little boy. And then start this fantastic new job at St. Paul's on the 30th of March 2020.

    Kelly Molson: Wow.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: Wow.

    Kelly Molson: So, where do we start? Because that's a pretty spectacular time to start a new job. And that must have been quite challenging just to say the very least.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: Yeah.

    Kelly Molson: Can you take us back to then, can you share with us what it was like for you? Because I can only imagine what you were thinking.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: Yeah, it was the best of times and the worst of times to quote "Tale of Two Cities". As I was leaving there was this... I'll go back a bit further, but there was this infamous now I think, meeting with the VE forum. I know you've done a podcast on the VE Forum before. There was this infamous meeting at which a load of us were at Central London attractions and Bernard Donoghue came in and we'd all been watching the news. It must have been mid-late February and Bernard Donoghue came in, and there was this thing happening in China.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: And he started talking about the impact that was beginning to have in new Europe and also on hotel bookings in the UK. And as he was talking and he said, the words, are paraphrased, but it was along the lines of this will have a bigger impact or as big an impact as the second world war had.

    Kelly Molson: Wow.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: And there was this palpable intake, audible intake of breath across the room. Because I think until that point no one had ever realised just what this was going to be. And at the Globe we talked about, we might have to stop a show or not have a show.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: And I remember I went back, I went to St. Paul's on my way back home. And I presented this to a couple of the team that I'd already met and said, look, this is what Bernard's saying. And, okay, well, we'll probably need to think about if we can't do a service or if we have to close for a day or so. And I went back to the Globe and we were having the same conversation. Well, maybe it'll be a couple of days that we might have to close for.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: And then gradually, just as time went on and you just see these horrendous news reports and things creeping up, we started to have these bigger meetings. The senior leadership team meetings I was having just about financials, where we were, what the impact of this was going to be, how we were going to manage. It was before things like furlough and all the grants that were there. It was this really stark reality that this was massive. Something was about to happen. And we're all about to fall off the edge of the cliff. And no one knew if there was going to be a net there for us, no one knew what was going to happen next.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: And that last week I was meant to leave the Globe. I was meant to have the leave due on the Friday. I just remember from the Tuesday onwards people saying, I'm really sorry, I'm not coming in for the rest of the week, I was getting these emails. Until by I think the Wednesday or the Thursday that I left, there were four of us in and I had this moment, even though I'd been there seven years and it was just, well, thanks very much, take your stuff and we'll see you when we see you.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: And I remember phoning St. Paul's and if you know the geography, the Globe is just across the river from St. Paul's. Phoning up and saying, can I bring some things across? And the response was, there's no one there, we've all gone. We've closed. So I had that week where I think I had coronavirus, but I was very, very sick. I don't know. But I couldn't move out of my bed for the week.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: And then I started on the 30th of March. And day one is usually here's the photocopier, here's your colleagues, here's where to get a coffee. Day one was, we are going into a restructure. What do you want your department to look like? And I hadn't spent any time with my team.

    Kelly Molson: Wow.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: I'd had one coffee with a couple of them. I knew nothing about the operations and yet I'm standing there or sitting there at my kitchen table of it, having to make decisions that are going to impact people's lives, people's livelihoods.

    Kelly Molson: I know. I'm breathing out, because I feel quite anxious, even just hearing you say that. But I can't imagine how... I can imagine how unbelievably stressful that situation would you've been. And how awful, you don't know these people, you haven't worked with them. How do you even start to look at that?

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: With difficulty and with a lot of trust. And I think the other thing just to throw into the mix, that my full-time job they then terminated my contract and gave me a contract for two days a week. So I was also looking at, I might not have a job by the end of this. And looking really coldly at what those... I was almost looking at it as a consultant in a way, that I'm not really part of this organisation. But I'm just going to have to look at this really objectively.

    Kelly Molson: Yeah.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: And see what I think. Because otherwise I was just... And it was almost a good thing that I wasn't at the Globe and then getting tangled up in the emotion of that. And I don't want this to sound cold, but it was almost better that I didn't know people, because I was talking about job titles and job roles rather than people.

    Kelly Molson: Yes.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: Names. But having said that, it was really bloody tough and it was this huge weight, that I felt of responsibility about what I was doing and what I was shaping. But I had to put the trust in the team that were around me, who I have to say, have been and were absolutely brilliant. I didn't get one person saying, what are you doing here? I didn't get one person... Everyone was there supporting me and saying, if you need anything, this is my phone number, give me a ring, let's talk it through.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: So we lost 25% of the workforce, which was huge. But I had to trust that when my teams were telling me that I needed this amount of expertise to keep the Cathedral floor open, that's what they needed. I do remember sitting in several meetings. I had this PDF map that I picked up when I was doing the recce for the role, next to me. Because we were going into the granular detail of where these people would be and how that would affect the experience, whatever that experience may be.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: And they were talking north transit. I was, hang on a second, north, where's that, north? And I'd look up, and the conversation moved on. I was thinking, I don't know what they're talking... I'd have to keep stopping and saying, where is that? What do you mean? So I had to trust that they were telling me the right things. And for them, they had to trust me. And there was a lot of patience. As I say a huge amount of patience for me, to pick those things up, which in an ideal world I would've done gradually over a period of time.

    Kelly Molson: Yeah. I guess it's such a difficult situation. Because like you said, I think the way that you approached it from a consultative perspective, I think that's brilliant. That's the only way that you could have done it, isn't it? To try and take the emotion out of what was happening.

    Kelly Molson: But I think that must have been really difficult for you as a leader, because you are in a position of leadership at that point and people are looking to you.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: Yeah.

    Kelly Molson: Regardless of how long you've been in that role, they're looking for you to tell them what they need to do or what's going to happen. And that must have been such a weight on your shoulders.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: It was a huge weight. And as I say, I was only there two days a week. So I chose Mondays and Thursdays because they were when the senior leadership team were meeting. So I'd be from 9:00 in the morning Monday back-to-back Zooms trying to get to know people, trying to work out what the impact of saying yes to this and no to that was. Trying to get under the skin of the finances, the operations.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: And then I'd be off Tuesday, Wednesday, and I'd be looking after my little boy and doing all the other things. And then Thursday would come along and I'd have a million emails, and people, I'm really sorry we changed that decision and you weren't part of that. And I'm really sorry you weren't part of that.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: So as a leader, I felt constantly on the back foot and I felt, I always want to have the answers or if I don't have the answers, I want to say to my team, I'm going to find a way to give you the answers. I'm going to get back to you on that. And what was so difficult was not being able to do that. We were reacting, and it's not just some rules, it was across the organisation. We were reacting constantly to other people's decisions.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: And one of the things I had to say, and I've spoken to other people. And I know I'm not the only one who has said this. There was a certain point where Boris was doing those super helpful press conferences at 5:00 every day. And there was a certain point where we had to shut down the idea that Boris gave us all a call just before he went on the TV to say what he was going to talk about. It was, we are getting this information at the same time as you at 5:00 at night when we are also exhausted from being on back-to-back Zoom calls all day.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: And then we are having to react to what we are being told. And in some instances it was, well, this will be happening in two weeks' time. In other instances, this is happening tomorrow. So we then had to make very quick decisions off of the back of that. And working so reactively, firefighting in a way, it's so tough because you don't have that stepping back, that evaluation, what worked well, what didn't work well, how could we do it better next time? It's just, we're just going to have to go with this and keep going with this.

    Kelly Molson: And it's exhausting, isn't it? And that reactive nature was like you say absolutely accurate for people because you all Zoomed out and then you'll have to make really strategic decisions based on information that's just been thrown at you that might suddenly come into act the next day. And so then those days get longer and longer and longer.

    Kelly Molson: From all of that, looking back though, what do you think are your biggest learnings that you took away from the situation?

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: I think two. The first one was, to be honest. And the idea of honesty that I talked about, saying to the team I don't have the answers. I don't know. Making really clear that we were all... What's the phrase that you're all in the same boat and it might be... Well, we're not, it's the same storm, but different boats.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: But the idea that we were all going through this in some way, shape or form together. And that there weren't answers, there wasn't a usual, this is our five year plan. And this is how we're going to get there. It was just... It goes back to the idea of trust. But being honest, we were doing our best and we didn't know, but we were trying to find out the answers or trying to do as much as we could to make it easier for the team.

    Kelly Molson: Yeah.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: And I think the other thing I've learned, and I keep telling myself this, is to be kind to myself. Because I started the first day of my job on the 30th of March, a week into lockdown. And I had to keep reminding myself that I didn't know. I wasn't expecting to know. And I've been there, it's coming up on two years. But I say to everybody, it feels like six months.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: This is the first time that I've seen any kind of normal cycle to the Cathedral. That I've been in any kind of normal planning meetings, that we've been talking about the next five years, as opposed to the next five minutes, the next five days.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: So I sometimes feel a bit fraud. I sat in a meeting the other day and I said, I'm really sorry, I don't know anything about this. And someone said you've been here two years. But this is the first time I've had this discussion. This is the first time this has ever been told to me as an operations manager. And it's just reinforcing that. And as I say, being kind to myself that I shouldn't have expected that I would have all of the answers. Because we were all navigating this pandemic together. None of us had been through it before, so why should I know what to do?

    Kelly Molson: Yeah. It's really interesting. And I don't think we're all kind enough to ourselves.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: I don't think so.

    Kelly Molson: On a day-to-day basis anyway, let alone when there's a global pandemic, how can we...

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: Exactly.

    Kelly Molson: I had a really similar chat to my team a little while ago about how me and my co-founder suddenly had to understand how to run a business in a completely different way. We'd never done... We had one team member that worked virtually for us or worked remotely for us.

    Kelly Molson: But we suddenly had to understand how we were going to run our whole business completely differently than we had before, at a time where we weren't sure if we were ever going to win any more business ever again, or if clients were going to stay with us. We just didn't have a clue what was going on. But everybody was looking to us to tell them what was going to happen. And we were just, "I have no idea".

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: That's the assumption, you were digital. You were going to come save the world, weren't you?

    Kelly Molson: Apparently so, yeah. And touch wood, things were okay and we got through it. But we still didn't really have a clue. It was all just guesswork. And like you, we were reacting on information that we were hearing on the tele and going, okay, oh, we can do that now, then. Okay. Well we better do that. I'll ring up HMRC. I'll ring up the VAT office. We'll just put everything on pause. Absolute chaos. But now we're in a very, very different place. Incredible to think how far we've come.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: I think if anyone had said you'll still be here in two years time, I think we all would have just thrown ourselves in the Thames, wouldn't we? But hey, we are where we are in this.

    Kelly Molson: Well, I'm just glad I get to go back into London and see the Thames. That's exciting.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: Yay. Of course, yeah.

    Kelly Molson: So I do want to talk to you about a very unique challenge that you have. And I think what's really interesting, obviously we all know St. Paul's, I've such fond memories of St. Paul's. I think we spoke about this when we had a pre-interview chat. It's one of my dad's favourite buildings and it is absolutely stunning. I have such good memories of visiting it with him as a child and going up to the Whispering Gallery.

    Kelly Molson: I can remember having a... My rubber is not the only thing that I have from St. Paul's Cathedral. We had a beautiful puzzle. We used to do puzzles. That's a lockdown thing, isn't it? But it was of the dome of the Whispering Gallery, the beautiful pattern. A lot of people see it as a tourist attraction, which it is, but first and foremost, it's a place of worship.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: Yeah.

    Kelly Molson: And so I'm intrigued just to understand how you get that visitor experience right. For two audiences that are coming for very, very different reasons.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: Yeah.

    Kelly Molson: One to worship, one to look at the architecture, for example.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: The sightseeing. Yeah. And it is a really fine balance that we have to strike. I think the thing that we have to think about, is I come from a very commercial angle about, if we keep the building open then we allow worship to happen. And that's a really stark way of looking at things.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: And I have some clerical colleagues who come from the other angle, which is this building is just here to worship. And we have to be very careful about what we do in order to raise the money. I think the first thing that we all sign up to is that we are respectful of other people's opinions and other people's beliefs and other people's needs.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: So there is a chapel that you can go into. So to come to worship, to come to pray, that will always be free at St. Paul's. And there's a chapel that you can come into and set aside for private prayer. And you just announce yourself and you can go straight through into there and you can pray. Or you can come along to one of the Eucharists or you can come along to one of the bigger services. And you are there for free. There is no assumption that you would pay any money.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: However, what we do find is that worship and tourism aren't mutually exclusive. And that's something that the Dean and certainly the more pastoral colleagues I have, are really keen to point out, that you don't simply have to just be a tourist. You don't simply have to just be here to worship. You can come and worship and think, look at that amazing architecture. You can come as a tourist and think actually that's a really beautiful service. Or I'd like to listen to the words that's being said.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: And as someone who isn't particularly religious, when you step into the space, you can appreciate the spirituality and the mindfulness of the building. It is an absolutely beautiful building. And there is a sense of still and calm when you go through. I think it's a lot in many churches I've been through, a sense of still and calm. That you don't have to be there specifically to worship to appreciate that you are in a place that is absolutely stunning and absolutely beautiful.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: And I've seen some really amazing services. Some of the Christmas, we have the Consecration of Bishops. And they're absolutely joyous. And it's just amazing to see people just really enjoying being there and using the space, what it was intended for.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: So the way that we look at things and the way that we market is that it's about the building. Yes, it's a place of faith, but it's also a place that's been at the heart of London, the heart of our nation for over 1000 years, not the same building. Building in that place. It's been there for over 1000s of years. And so it's part of our lives. It's part of our collective memories of things like Charles and Diana's weddings, or the Jubilee celebrations that we've got coming up.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: So when we are looking to market the church, we talk about it being alive with stories, we talk about the hidden cathedral. So those places that you don't usually get to see on the tourist trail, that actually might also appeal to people who are worshippers as well. But there is a challenge, as a working church we stop for Eucharist at 12:30 every day, we stop for prayers on the hour, every hour.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: We have some big services, for example, the Consecration of the Bishops, which is not ticketed to the public, it's ticketed to the Bishops who are being consecrated. So we have to be closed to the public. So we have those challenges of how to work around that. We can't just simply say that we're open.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: The website has got some very complicated, but not at this time, messaging there. But actually again, that's part of the beauty of it. Why are we closed? This is why we're closed. This is what we're doing. This is what we're celebrating. So I find it's a challenge, but it's not as big a challenge I think, as you would expect.

    Kelly Molson: Does it bring any advantages or disadvantages with that as well? I guess that's really what we've spoken about in terms of the disadvantage of closing, and how can you explain why you're closed for certain things.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: I think the advantages are learning about why it's there. Learning about what St. Paul's is. And you can get married there. People get married there, people have their children baptised there. So when people find that out, oh, that's really interesting, how do I do that? So again, it's just opening up and unlocking those stories that I talked about. Unlocking the building for people.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: I suppose another challenge is that we can't be... This is a nation's church, we are the place where the Queen comes to worship. So what we can't do is we can't be provocative. We can't be aggressively commercial. We have to respect that this ultimately is a church. This ultimately is a place of worship. But the understanding also is there that we need to be commercial in some way, shape or form. It cost eight million pounds to keep St. Paul's Cathedral open.

    Kelly Molson: Wow.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: Every year.

    Kelly Molson: Gosh.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: So we need to raise that money. So when I'm talking about driving visitor numbers up, when I'm talking about driving income, it's not the detriment of the core values of what St. Paul's Cathedral is, that value of faith comes first.

    Kelly Molson: Yeah. And it's like you say, it goes back to that. It's a very fine line, isn't it? To try and keep everybody happy and everyone considered in those circumstances.

    Kelly Molson: Look into the future. Because we're all about future and positivity now. You've got the Platinum Jubilee Exhibition.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: Yeah.

    Kelly Molson: Opening the 25th of May.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: 25th of May, that is right. So it's all about all of the Jubilee celebrations that we've had at St. Paul's. So there are four of them, which are celebrating George III, Victoria, Edward, and the Queen herself, who will be having, it's her fourth celebration.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: And I was in a really exciting multi-agency Jubilee meeting the other day for the actual service. So that was lovely again, to be part of, seeing St. Paul's opening up again and being part of these bigger services. But come along, it's going to be great.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: So as part of HRL funding, which was when we were in lockdown, I got an audience development plan and pull together. And what we found was before the lockdown, almost 90% of our audience were international tourists and the remainder were domestics, but the reason the domestic market weren't coming were broadly because a bit like you, came with your dad when you were at school, you went up to the Whispering Gallery. What's the reason for coming again?

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: So part of my engagement strategy is trying to put things into place, which encourage people to come back to St. Paul's and think of it a bit more of a return visit. So we've got kids go free happening this half term, we've got the Jubilee Exhibition going in this year, which runs on the 25th of May all the way through, hopefully into about Christmas. And then we're looking ahead to Wren 300 next year, which is going to be huge. That's the 300 anniversary of Wren's death.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: So again, trying to think of some events that we can do on the cathedral floor, we've got our Summer Lates Program, which I'm in talks with a brilliant, a company to do partnership with some events with us. And maybe it's something a little bit more unexpected on the cathedral floor, but all bring it back to the idea of mindfulness about where we are. And we can't be too provocative. We can't be aggressively commercial. But actually, let's look at St. Paul's in a different way. Let's look at the architecture. Let's take our inspiration from the mosaics, from all the other wonderful things that we have there.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: So we are really looking forward to the Jubilee. It's massive for us and everyone's super-excited. Our guides doing guided tours, pulling those together. We've got our VA teams, are bringing some objects down to the cathedral floor for people to... Part of our handling collection. It's really something we're all pulling together for. I think after the past couple of years, this is just the joy that we need.

    Kelly Molson: Oh, yeah. It feels like a big celebration.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: Yeah, it does.

    Kelly Molson: It feels like it's really well-timed, isn't it? The Jubilee, and it happening. I feel it's going to bring everyone back together again.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: It will.

    Kelly Molson: I love the idea of the Lates. I'm very excited and intrigued to find out what's happening there. But you are right, it's been difficult, isn't it? For attractions that are predominantly international tourists that come. That must have been really difficult for you. And I think it's wonderful that you've now got this program where you are encouraging people to come back. I'm definitely going to come back and-

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: Brilliant.

    Kelly Molson: And come and see the exhibition. I'm really excited to come and see that. And I'm going to bring my daughter.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: Yay.

    Kelly Molson: For the first time. It'll be her first trip to London.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: Really exciting.

    Kelly Molson: Yeah. I just think it is one of those places that you do go to as a child and there needs to be that continuation of why you should come back. So very excited to see.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: We just need to... As I say, we're obviously restricted with many... We don't have an outside space really. We can't just put exhibitions anywhere. We can't be as reactive as some can. We do what we can.

    Kelly Molson: And do it beautifully as well.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: Oh, thank you.

    Kelly Molson: So I always ask our guests about a book that they love.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: Yeah.

    Kelly Molson: Now it can be something that you love. It can be something that's inspired you in your career. It can something that you love personally. What have you got to share with us today?

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: I found this really tough, because I read all the time. And so choosing one book, I can't do that. So I came up with a couple and then I had to pair it down. So I've got the Night Circus by Erin Morgenstern, which is absolutely brilliant. And then anything by David Mitchell. But I decided that the one I would tell people they had to read and if they could win it, they should, was Life after Life by Kate Atkinson.

    Kelly Molson: Oh, okay. I have not read this book. No.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: It's a story of a girl Ursula, who is born in 1910 and it's the multitude of lives that she goes through. So every chapter she has a different life. And the first chapter she isn't born and it goes all the way through, it goes through two world wars, where things happen to her or don't happen to her.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: And she begins to have this memory of what her life was. And she takes herself out of certain situations. And I just love it because it's this idea of... It's almost if you take that turn, that doesn't happen, but something else happens. And Kate Atkinson writes absolutely beautifully. So it's a really lovely book to read, just to think about, maybe if I'd opened that door I would've been over here, but here I am.

    Kelly Molson: Oh, I like that. It's got arching back a little bit to our little time-traveling question there at the beginning as well, isn't it?

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: It is a bit, isn't it? I told you.

    Kelly Molson: A little trick to travel through history. Well, as ever listeners, if you want to win Sandra's book, if you go over to our literature account and you retweet this podcast announcement with the words "I want Sandra's book", then you will be in with a chance of winning it.

    Kelly Molson: It's been so lovely to have you on today. Thank you for sharing what I can imagine. And I felt it while you were talking, a very emotional and very challenging time. And so I'm very grateful that you were open to sharing that with us today, but I'm really excited about what's coming next with St. Paul's. And I think that there's lots of good things to be really, really positive about. And I'm looking forward to coming to see them.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: Oh, looking forward to seeing you, it's going to be an exciting summer. We saw some international tourists yesterday, so it's all going to be okay.

    Kelly Molson: They're back.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: They're back.

    Kelly Molson: The world is open.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: It's all right.

    Kelly Molson: Brilliant. Thanks so much, Sandra.

    Sandra Lynes Timbrell: Thanks so much, Kelly.

    Kelly Molson: Thanks for listening to Skip the Queue. If you've enjoyed this podcast, please leave us a five star review. It really helps others find us. And remember to follow us on Twitter for your chance to win the books that have been mentioned. Skip the queue is brought to you by Rubber Cheese, a digital agency that builds remarkable systems and websites for attractions that helps them increase their visitor numbers. You can find show notes and transcriptions from this episode and more over on our website rubbercheese.com/podcast.

    Download The Visitor Attractions Website Survey Report - https://www.merac.co.uk/download-the-visitor-attractions-survey

     

    We have launched our brand-new playbook: ‘The Retail Ready Guide to Going Beyond the Gift Shop’ — your go-to resource for building a successful e-commerce strategy that connects with your audience and drives sustainable growth.

     

    Download your FREE copy here

    37 min
  • What is Conversion Rate Optimisation and why does your attraction need to know about it? With Matt Scaysbrook

    Skip the Queue is brought to you by Rubber Cheese, a digital agency that builds remarkable systems and websites for attractions that helps them increase their visitor numbers. Your host is Kelly Molson, MD of Rubber Cheese.

    Download our free ebook The Ultimate Guide to Doubling Your Visitor Numbers

    If you like what you hear, you can subscribe on iTunes, Spotify, and all the usual channels by searching Skip the Queue or visit our website rubbercheese.com/podcast.


    If you've enjoyed this podcast, please leave us a five star review, it really helps others find us. And remember to follow us on Twitter for your chance to win the books that have been mentioned in this episode.

    Competition ends April 29th 2022. The winner will be contacted via Twitter.

    Show references:

    https://www.weteachcro.com/

    https://www.weteachcro.com/download-guide

    https://www.kallaway.co.uk/blog/post/id/141

    https://www.linkedin.com/in/mattscaysbrook/

    Matt Scaysbrook, Founder & Director of Optimisation at WeTeachCRO, a specialist Conversion Rate Optimisation agency working with enterprise-level clients such as GoDaddy, Nando's & Sage.

    Transcription:

    Kelly Molson: Welcome to Skip the Queue, a podcast for people working in or working with visitor attractions. I'm your host, Kelly Molson. Each episode, I speak with industry experts from the attractions world.

    In today's episode, I speak with Matt Scaysbrook, Founder of WeTeachCRO. We explain exactly what Conversion Rate Optimisation is and why it's so very important for your attraction's website.

    If you like what you hear, subscribe on iTunes, Spotify, and all the usual channels by searching Skip the Queue.

    Kelly Molson: Matt, it's so nice to have you on the podcast today. Thanks for joining me. We start off with our little icebreaker question. So I want to know, what are your hobbies outside of work?

    Matt Scaysbrook: Not as many as I had back when I was a salaried employee. Rugby is the main one.

    Kelly Molson: You play?

    Matt Scaysbrook: Yes. Yeah, I still play. There will come a point where physically, I can't do it anymore, but I haven't reached that point yet. So my wife has reconciled to the fact that I will continue to play until such time come.

    Kelly Molson: Until there is a broken bone that you decide is taking too long to heal and that's it.

    Matt Scaysbrook: Well, yeah. I mean, you can come back from broken bones. It's more of, that I physically can't get out of bed on a Sunday morning. I've noticed post-30, it does... Like the recovery speed is definitely not what it used to be.

    Kelly Molson: Mate, wait until you're post-40 and then you'll [inaudible 00:01:25]. All right. What's your favourite all time movie?

    Matt Scaysbrook: Oh, that's a difficult one. I'll probably go, Gladiator.

    Kelly Molson: Oh, good choice. Good choice.

    Matt Scaysbrook: There a lot that are at that level, but probably Gladiator. I've seen it God knows how many times. Maybe 25, 30.

    Kelly Molson: I bet you know the words as well.

    Matt Scaysbrook: I know quite a lot of them. Yeah, which is one of the reasons why I always have to watch it on my own if I'm going to watch it, because otherwise, I annoy everyone else in the room because I do know what's coming.

    Kelly Molson: All right. If you had to eat one meal every day for the rest of your life, what would it be?

    Matt Scaysbrook: Probably... It's really sad.

    Kelly Molson: It's a tough choice.

    Matt Scaysbrook: Yeah. I'd probably just have burger and chips. Well, when I say chips, sweet potato fries.

    Kelly Molson: It's quite specific.

    Matt Scaysbrook: Yeah. It's quite specific and there would have to be cheese and bacon in the burger with a bit of barbecue sauce. I don't think it would be good for me to eat that every day of my life.

    Kelly Molson: Well, that'd end your rugby career.

    Matt Scaysbrook: Yeah. Pretty rapidly, I imagine. Yeah.

    Kelly Molson: All right. And what is your unpopular opinion?

    Matt Scaysbrook: Oh God, I've got loads of... I got thousands of unpopular opinions.

    Kelly Molson: I love loads.

    Matt Scaysbrook: I guess I'll use one from agency world. So from my experience, and I coach a number of other agency owners as well, and what I have found is that the principal problem in most agencies is the person who runs it.

    Kelly Molson: Oh, well, I have to agree with that. Being an agency owner who runs an agency, I'll definitely say yes, tick.

    Matt Scaysbrook: 95% probably of the problems, the things that we're dealing with in our businesses, we caused either consciously or unconsciously. Unfortunately, generally speaking, we are the problem.

    Kelly Molson: Yeah. I mean, there will be other agency owners listening to this and I'm pretty sure they'll agree with you. So I'm not sure how unpopular that opinion is going to be, but thank you for sharing.

    Matt Scaysbrook: Well, I've told people in the past and it's been great. Oh, well, I'm doing my best for those. I'm not having to go. I'm just stating a fact that [crosstalk 00:03:20].

    Kelly Molson: We're all doing our best, but it's still us.

    Matt Scaysbrook: Yeah.

    Kelly Molson: All right. Okay. So before Christmas, the lovely team at Kallaway, who we've had on as a guest previously, invited me to present a webinar. And the webinar was titled, why your website isn't selling enough tickets and how to fix it. And I will pop the link to this in the show notes, if you haven't been able to catch up on that recording, and then you can watch it for yourselves. But the main focus of the webinar was around cart abandonment and why it happens and what can be done to avoid it. And I touched on a process that we use internally called Conversion Rate Optimisation, or CRO for short. And I thought it'd be really great to have a dedicated CRO expert on the show to discuss this in a bit more depth, because although it's a process that we use, it's not what we specialise in as an agency. And this is what Matt's agency, WeTeachCRO, specialises in, that's what you do, isn't it?

    Matt Scaysbrook: It's the only thing we do. Yeah.

    Kelly Molson: So Matt is a great person to come on and talk to us about it. And the relevancy of this to the attraction sector is, there's lots of things that you can do to improve your booking process. And CRO is a process that we would use to go through and make those improvements. So they're some of the things that we want to talk about today. But Matt, big question, what is CRO? What is conversion rate optimisation?

    Matt Scaysbrook: Yeah. So one of the things that just about everyone in the CRO industry agrees is that CRO is a terrible description of what it actually is. Obviously the words conversion rate optimisation suggests that it's all about that. How do you get the most number of people through that process? For the vast majority of businesses, there is a balance that needs to be struck there between effectively the revenue that's generated through that process and the number of people who do it. So it's always a balance between what the conversion rate is of a process and the average order value or average booking value. Are people adding extras, q-jumps, et cetera, into that?

    Matt Scaysbrook: We always liken it to a bell curve, I guess. At one end, you've got an absolute total conversion rate, 100%. The only way you will ever achieve that is if you gave everything away for free. And even then, you'd probably have some people who are suspicious of it. But if you assume at one end, you'd have to give everything away free to have a perfect conversion rate, that makes you no money whatsoever. At the complete opposite end of that bell curve, there is absolute perfect order value or booking value, that is obviously an infinite number and therefore impossible. What you are trying to get to is the point in that bell curve in the middle, where you've got a balance between the number of visitors coming through and booking and the average value of that booking. So you're just trying to move that needle left and right to get the right balance between the two.

    Kelly Molson: Talk us through a little bit about what you do at your agency then, what you do for your clients.

    Matt Scaysbrook: I guess where you start always has to be about the people that you are trying to influence. One of the most common mistakes in our industry is that people spend too much time looking at numbers and go, "Oh, we need to move that rate." Or, "We need to move this rate." It's like, no, you don't. What you need to do is change how people act and what decisions that they will make. So the sooner you start thinking about those people, their concerns, especially the objections that they're going to have to following something through, the sooner you can do that, the more effective any of your optimisations will be. For us, the vast majority of those optimisations are done in the form of a test, usually in AB tests. So where you have the current version of the page tested against a new version of the page. If you've ever done any sort of user testing with new elements for the site, similar principle, the difference being that number one, these people don't know they're being tested against.

    Matt Scaysbrook: Number two is scale. Obviously, user testing is hugely valuable, but the total number of people you can talk to is limited because per person is expensive. So if you can run that onsite, you can do it a much greater scale. And the last part is that rather than someone in user testing, who's usually being paid for their opinion, visitors that you are testing in this way, they're voting with their own money. I have seen too many times over the years, user testing that presents a certain picture and says, "Oh, okay, this is what our visitors want." When you put it at a grander scale where people don't know that they're being tested against, they do something different. So it's getting a balance between those two things, user testings, brilliant for a depth of insight. But if you want to look at, can that be applied more broadly running something at scale on the site itself is a great way to work that out.

    Kelly Molson: So I'm going to get you in a minute to talk through a case study that you've worked on for Nando's, which I think is really... Although it's hospitality, food and drink, it's really relevant to what we talk about a lot from the attraction sector. So some of the things that we at Rubber Cheese talk about all the time is, can visitors find what they're looking for? So essentially, what we are trying to do is funnel users through the right places on a website. So can they find what they're looking for? So essentially, if you are an attraction, your number one objective is to sell tickets. So can they actually find the area to sell the tickets? Is that simple enough to see? Can they follow a simple journey from entering your site to actually purchasing the ticket? Do they understand what the next step is to take? Are you confusing them with multiple calls to action?

    Kelly Molson: So all of these questions and what we are asking our users over and over and over again. Can they find their opening times? The prices, how is it big? Is your booking system integrated? Does it pop them off somewhere else, which is again, causing them a distraction. And the process that you've been through for the Nando's case study is very, very similar to the things that we talk about. So I wondered if you could talk us through what you did for them and the improvements that you made and how that affected that booking journey.

    Matt Scaysbrook: So we've worked with Nando's for almost three and a half years now, when we first started working with them, they didn't have an online ordering process at all. And we came on board because they knew they were working towards that launch and we came on board so that once it was live, they would have a means of constant improvement and iteration to it. And there's been a huge number of changes, obviously in that industry, over the course of the last few years and online ordering has become... It's no longer like the poor cousin, I guess, to bricks and mortar. So with Nando's, this is one that did start with some user testing that they did. They sat down with a group of users and found that the order process, particularly on mobile, was... The word cumbersome came up quite frequently.

    Matt Scaysbrook: And it wasn't something that the guys in Nando's didn't know. They knew that bit already, but it's one of those challenges of getting what is effectively a large offline menu, which is, I guess A3, folded out double-sided A3. You've then got to get that on a screen that's seven or eight inches. It's a challenge in itself. What that user research flagged up was that it was just moving through the different sections of that menu. You constantly had to go backwards and forwards. So if you clicked into Peri-Peri Chicken, for example, you couldn't then immediately jump to say burgers, pizzas and wraps. This is where you realise how sad I am, how much the Nando's menu I know, but we won't talk about that. But it's constant back and forward.

    Matt Scaysbrook: As you mentioned a moment ago, about a process that can be followed, virtually, no one wants to go back and forward. People do not like going backwards or do not like feeling like they're going backwards. So we knew that the current navigation and the menu selection was not as good as it could be. The bigger question was, how do we improve it? Because it is to some extent, like I said, a menu of that size being dealt with on a screen that small, it is going to be reasonably cumbersome to some extent, but we were adamant that there had to be a better way of doing this. So the first time around, the first test that we ran on this, rather than making a visit, jump backwards and forwards, we put a menu across the top of the screen, which was scrollable. So instead of scrolling up and down, you could scroll left and right across this menu. There were a couple of challenges with that.

    Matt Scaysbrook: Firstly, the width of the element that you would have to tap on to get there was dictated by the length of the title of that section of the menu. So it is inherently inconsistent with itself. It's not particularly visually appealing and also it isn't something that's all that commonly used. And what we found, having run that as a test, is that more people use the navigation in that format, in that side scroll, the problem was that fewer people actually went on to buy. So as with a lot of tests, there are two core things that most clients are trying to get out of it. The first one is I guess, some sort of commercial benefit, but the other one, which should be viewed at least, at least as important, if not more important, is why. Why have we got the results that we have?

    Matt Scaysbrook: So what we found from this one has said, more people would use the menu now than they did before is their means of navigating through, but they actually viewed fewer sections of the menu in total. So that tells us two things. One from a data perspective, they absolutely must have been clicking on the same things multiple times. So again, that behaviour that we were trying to avoid with people having to go backwards and forwards, we hadn't solved it at all. And the reason that that impacted on revenue was that what we found is that visitors do a fair amount of impulse purchasing. So if you led them through a process, they would be like... They wouldn't consider an item until they saw it. And then they saw it and like, "Yeah, you know what? Yeah, I am going to get some ice cream. Why not?"

    Matt Scaysbrook: I guess similar in a booking journey, if somebody doesn't know that you could buy a season pass for 50% more than the one-day ticket, well, they aren't going to buy it, are they? Because they don't know they exist. They're not against the idea. They just didn't realize the idea was even an option. So it seems odd to use a case study where a test that we ran that results in effectively a negative outcome, but what you will find if you run tests frequently is, that is often the case. If we knew all of the answers, we just make changes. I wouldn't run a business that prizes itself on testing. I'd also be a billionaire by now if I was always right about stuff.

    Matt Scaysbrook: So the key thing is what do you do when the test doesn't win? And that's where the learning element comes in because saying, "Yes, this is better because it makes more money," is great when it wins. When it doesn't, you need to understand why, so that you can look at, okay, well, what do we do next? So we sat down with this one, and I'll be honest, myself, the team here, the client as well, we all thought this would win. And it didn't. So we sat down to understand, okay, why do we think that is? Effectively, what we came to is that we're over-engineering this entirely. One of the problems with the existing menu is that it was not the way that most other menus work. So we invented another menu that was different to the way that most menus work. It was technically more complicated, but it wasn't easier to use. So the next iteration of that test introduced effectively a burger menu. You just tapped on it and it opened with all of the elements that you need.

    Kelly Molson: So for anyone listening that doesn't understand why we're talking about burgers, a burger menu is a little icon that's used on websites or apps. And when you click it, it opens the navigation or like a little side menu. It kind of looks like a burger, so we call it a burger menu.

    Matt Scaysbrook: Yeah. And is it as visually appealing as the side scroll? No. And there were some members of the wider organisation at Nando's who weren't entirely happy with it visually, and understandably, it's a bit dull. And Nando's as a brand, is anything but dull. But they allowed us to test it. So instead of this big side scroll, just had a burger menu, three lines, the word menu, and there you could go. So we ran that and navigation usage increased again, but this time the conversion and the revenue uplift came with it too. And I think therein lies, I guess the value of testing is that as good an idea as you think you've got, there is at least a 50% chance you're wrong. It'll make a positive improvement. Whenever you make those changes without testing them, you are effectively assuming the risk there for yourself straight away. If it tanks, and it might, how are you going to back it out? How quickly can you back it out?

    Matt Scaysbrook: If you are running a test, I tell you how quick it is to stop. About five seconds. You open whatever platform you're on the test and you hit stop. And that is, I guess, the side of CRO that people don't necessarily... And it doesn't necessarily come to mind first and foremost, they think of it as a way of helping their site to make more money. The bit they overlook is its ability to help them manage risk. And the bigger a business is, the more you have to lose if you get things wrong. There is a phrase that I've used repeatedly over the last almost two years, I think after coining it in, it was in the middle of a webinar that I was doing. And it was DAB, DAP, which is design and build, deploy and pray. Because for the vast majority of changes two-way website, that is how it's done. There is a design phase. There is a build phase. It goes live and everyone crosses their fingers and hopes it works. That introduces a certain level of risk.

    Kelly Molson: I mean, Matt, I'm not going to agree with you there. There's still the testing that goes through on our part before we launch. But no, I hear what you're saying. So all the will in the world, we can do all the testing internally. We can do all the testing externally, but essentially, when you release something to the world and you have thousands of people using it, problems are going to come up that you just haven't been able to come across throughout that testing process. It's really interesting what you were saying about the solution that looked beautiful, but didn't work that well. And I think that's something that we are always really acutely aware of when we were designing things because let's face it, everybody wants their site to look great. We work with attractions. The sites have to encompass the feeling that you're going to get at that attraction before you've got there.

    Kelly Molson: We always say "The fun starts from the first click" and they have to give the perception of what it's going to be like, if your attraction's really exciting, your website has to be really exciting. And sometimes attraction websites can look really fun, but work really badly. So that's something that we are really aware of all the time when we are designing, is that you have to go sometimes from like a desktop solution that does look really beautiful down to how does that translate to mobile? How is that actually going to work at, like you say, like six or seven inches screen width? Can we still make it functional and beautiful? Or are we going to have to make some compromises there? And testing is the only way to know whether you've got that right or not.

    Matt Scaysbrook: Yeah. I think one of the things that comes up a lot with that is basic common UI elements. I have seen so many sites over the years that have gone, "You know what? We're not going to make a button a button because we want to be edgy." And it's like, yeah, but people understand buttons, they are drawn to them because they understand that it is usually a step forwards. Same as the example of the burger menu for Nando's is that, it isn't flash and you're not going to win any design awards for it, but you will sell more stuff. Therefore, we can iterate from there on and go, "Okay, is there a way that we can make that same function, but in a prettier and more visually appealing way? But if for overall that time you are benefiting from the extra conversion value of something that just works that people understand, you're effectively then helping to pay for the extra iterations that you want to do again in future.

    Kelly Molson: Yeah, absolutely. Matt, I am going to try and pronounce some words here that I always get a bit tongue-tied with. So forgive me, but quantitative and qualitative, did I get that right?

    Matt Scaysbrook: You did.

    Kelly Molson: Well done me.

    Matt Scaysbrook: I have to say them the exact same way you do. Very slowly, syllable by syllable.

    Kelly Molson: I'm glad this is being recorded for prosperity. Look, I know that when you are going through your processes, you are looking at both of those options. Explain what the difference is and why they're both equally important.

    Matt Scaysbrook: Yeah. So quantitative, that is numbers-based stuff. So for the vast majority of sites that comes through Google Analytics, that is those what most people use, what it is presenting to you is effectively a count. A count of X number of people did this, these things or X number of sessions or this action take place, but that's all it is. It's just numbers. And obviously, it's always backwards-looking as well. It's what they did do. It isn't what they're going to do. On the qualitative side, this is basically data that isn't just numbers. And it comes in a lot of different forms. So heat maps, so for where people click, where their mouse is, how long, certain elements of the screen are in view on a particular page, how far down a page they scroll, that's one element of it. Session recordings, where you can watch how a visitor interacted with a particular site or a particular page.

    Matt Scaysbrook: And then you've got the other, I guess the complete opposite end from the numbers, where you've got feedback. So verbatim feedback from surveys that run onsite and offsite, your user research as well comes into that. So there's a lot of things that qualitative covers and the best description of it is it isn't just numbers.

    Kelly Molson: It's description.

    Matt Scaysbrook: It's description, it's not the other one, basically. Why does it matter? So if you're looking to identify areas of improvement, it is easiest to do that from a numerical base. Comparing numbers is a lot faster than comparing 100 survey responses. Numbers are simpler to do that with. The problem with them is that they only really tell you what occurred. They give you a very limited view on why, and if you're going to solve some of those challenges that you've got, it is the why that will help you to solve them. And that's where the qualitative side comes in. So my recommendation on this stuff is that, use your quantitative, use your numbers to identify those areas. Then once those areas have been identified, then go to your qualitative tools and investigate those more closely.

    Matt Scaysbrook: If you go into Hotjar, as an example, as a qualitative tool, if you go into that, searching for problems to identify, you will lose days, weeks, months of your life, because it is not designed to do that at scale. It is great if you have a specific question or set of questions that you're trying to ask. It is not really there for, call it high volume discovery. So one is good for telling you what happened and identifying areas where improvements could be made. The other one is a lot better at understanding, okay, well, why aren't people getting from point A to point B? And therefore, is a key part informing, okay, well, how are we going to execute that page or that process differently in order to see a change in the quantitative?

    Kelly Molson: Yeah. So to be able to make real improvements, you have to take a holistic approach. You can't just rely on one or the other. And obviously, there's nothing better than getting people in a room and actually watching what they're doing as well while they're using the site too. This might be a difficult question to ask because I'm sure there are different answers to this question depending on when you ask them. But what do you think are some of the most important metrics that attractions should be tracking?

    Matt Scaysbrook: Yeah. So what you tend to find is that if you ask someone about their key metrics, they'll tell you what their conversion rate is globally across the site. And they will tell you what their average booking value is. Those are great as a report to the board, but they're borderline useless in helping you to advance the site yourself. I have worked with clients who have a conversion rate of 0.5% who are very happy with it. And I've worked with some who've got a conversion rate of 8 or 9% and are disappointed. There is not a rate that is good or a rate that is bad. Also, there are so many different types of people, different types of visits in those global metrics. They're basically a mess. You're not going to get actionable stuff out of going, "Well, our site conversion rate is 3%."

    Matt Scaysbrook: So whenever we look at a site, and this applies to eCommerce the same that it applies to attractions or to ordering of food, is that you break the site down into effectively three blocks. So out of every visitor who comes to the site, how many of them bounce? So how many of them see one page and nothing else? There are two types of bounce, but basically, there's hard bounce and soft. Hard is hits page, does nothing and leaves. Soft is, comes to the page, reads 50%, 75% of that page, and then leaves. By default, they'll track the same, unless you do some additions, but obviously, that experience is entirely different. Hence why you want to know the difference. So first one is bounce rate. If that is super high, you are losing your opportunity right there and then to ever sell to those people.

    Matt Scaysbrook: Landing page, job number one, keep people on site. So if you've got a rate there that is particularly high, that's probably the first place you're going to look. A lot of the time is, what's happening offsite? How are you linking people to that site? Is it advertising that you're doing? If so, the two need to marry up. What someone's being advertised and what is on the landing page? So it's bounce rate is the first one. Then we look at, of everyone who does not bounce, what percentage then add to basket? And again, that applies the same way, regardless of whether you're talking about physical items or digital items, or even the ordering of food, is how many people actually add something into the basket?

    Matt Scaysbrook: The reason for that is, basically, is it the process for the checkout, that is part of your challenge or not? How are you explaining effectively the product value and at least enough that somebody is confident to make one of the first decisions they need to make, which is "Yes, that's the one I'm interested in". So non-bouncing people to add to basket, that's the next rate that we look at. And then it's, of everyone who adds to basket, what percentage then go on to buy? So that obviously is looking at how your checkout process works out.

    Matt Scaysbrook: So we split those three up, identify which of those we believe to be the biggest challenge. And then you want to take whichever one you've picked and split that down again. So I'll give you an example from one we did recently, eCommerce client, their belief was that their checkout process was too long and that was what was negatively impacting their conversion rate. And now, okay, their checkout process was quite long. I think it was seven steps, which is probably a little excessive. But what we found once we broke that process down is that actually, they lost over 50% of people in the first step to the second, the rest from there on it was pretty good. It was actually really good.

    Kelly Molson: And this is at the checkout process, the first step of-

    Matt Scaysbrook: Yeah.

    Kelly Molson: Alright. Okay.

    Matt Scrasbrook: Yeah. So from the basket page itself to the next step was a log in step. They lost most people in that block.

    Kelly Molson: Was that because they made people log in?

    Matt Scaysbrook: No. The problem was people weren't even getting to that log in step. So that tells you a lot. What we then did, as I mentioned earlier, we then went to look at the qualitative stuff. What are people on that page doing? And what we found was that you saw video after video, after video, of people going back to the main site from the basket page and looking at either alternatives for the product that was in their basket, or at the product that was in their basket, to read more information about it. It's like, okay, these people have zero confidence in what they've put in that basket. They thought, "Oh, I'm going to add it". But then when it came to the next point of, "Yeah, okay. I'm going to move through this process," they weren't sure.

    Matt Scaysbrook: It's like, okay, how do we reassure people that this brand is one that they can trust, that this process is one that they can trust? What are the things they're going to be thinking about? When am I going to get it? What if I don't like it? All of those objections that you need to handle. I think you mentioned earlier, Kelly, about how people got all the information they need. And it's like, we all buy stuff online, we all book events and attractions and the such like online, so what questions do we ask ourselves? What if I can't go that day? What if I want to move my ticket to another day because it's hammering it down with rain and I don't want to get wet?

    Matt Scaysbrook: All of the things that you would ask, that's what thousands of other people are asking. And you need to, I guess, to think about, when are those questions going to get raised? The basket step is quite a common one because it's the move from... The brain has moved on from product selection and it's now on effectively the buying element of it. So the kinds of questions that you need to ask are then different. It was a really long explanation, wasn't it?

    Kelly Molson: Yeah. But it was a really perfect explanation of why it's so important to do the qualitative and the quantitative testing. It's a really very clear example because obviously, that client had made a massive assumption about what they thought the problem was. But actually, without doing those two testing processes, you would never have found the actual correct answer as well. I love that, it's such a good example. Thank you. Okay. So being a CROer, you need a lot of different skills, don't you? So I'm guessing that in your team, you've got strategists, you've got data people, you've got designers as well. What skills do you need to be a CROer?

    Matt Scaysbrook: So we actually have a model for this, which probably tells you how sad I am. But we have a model called CATSPA. So it's split into two halves, CAT and SPA. So CAT is skill areas that you have to have, so it's creative, analytical, technical. I guess every single person who does this work is better at one of those three than the others, and they're weaker at one of those three than the others. So for me, analytical is my strength, always has been. My technical skills are pretty good, years of practice didn't have them when I started doing this work. I'm not particularly good with pictures though. I am not a classic creative person.

    Kelly Molson: That's where I come in. I'm the designer to your analytical skills.

    Matt Scaysbrook: Yeah. Exactly. There are other members of my team who are creatively very, very good, technically strong, analytical, not as good. We all have those strengths and weaknesses, but the role sits so perfectly on that, on the cusp of those three, that you can't be useless at any of them, I guess. And then the SPA element of it, that is we call those the sub-roles of the job. So you're effectively a subject matter expert, but for a client, you are also their project manager and to some extent, their account manager as well. Our work is very collaborative. We speak to most clients most days in some form or other, be it on call or Slack or emails, whatever it is. So it isn't an easy thing to get into. You have to want to practice all of those things.

    Matt Scaysbrook: And so when we take on someone new, the time to getting them up to speed is pretty long. But if you can master things that are creative, analytical, and technical, and talk to people for whom those things are specialisms, can you converse with developers? Can you converse with analysts? Can you converse with designers? If you can do that, pretty much any job that our guys may go into in future, they'll be good at it, because they can speak the language of three different people. And that makes a massive difference.

    Kelly Molson: Oh God, doesn't it? So considering that to have the skills to do this well, it's quite rare to be pretty good at all of those things, I would say. So that's quite a hard person. You need to fit someone to quite a difficult mold. Can our listeners start to do this process themselves? Because I guess our listeners vary from huge attractions, thousands and thousands of people through the day to down to some quite small museums who might have a very stripped back team, but still need to be able to look and analyse their site and understand how it's working. Can people do this? Can they do this themselves?

    Matt Scaysbrook: They can. One of the things that you have to believe in, if you do this work, is that whatever you are doing today is not as good as it could be. And that goes for ourselves as well. What I know about my industry now, versus when I started my agency five years ago is massive. The only way to improve is to accept that today's you is not the best version that it could be. And the only way that those improvements will happen is if you try things. The very core of testing is accepting that improvement is out there, but you'll make some planners along the way before you get there. We actually wrote, few months back, we published a guide, which is for that exact purpose, which is okay, you can do this yourself. Here are some of...

    Matt Scrysbrook: I can't remember how many questions they're in it now. I think it's like 51, is basically 50 odd questions that every experienced CRO person has asked at some point. Because what I know about the industry and its practice, I didn't read a book. I'll tell you that. I spoke to a lot of other people who gave me their time and their input to answer, at the time, what probably seemed like quite dumb questions, but we're all built on the back of other people's selfless efforts, I guess. So they absolutely can do it themselves. There are free tools available to help you start running tests. What I would recommend is that you do do some reading about it. I can give you the link to our guide afterwards, Kelly, and-

    Kelly Molson: I already have it, Matt.

    Matt Scaysbrook: Oh, you already got it. Okay.

    Kelly Molson: I have already prepared for the show notes.

    Matt Scaysbrook: Oh yeah. You've actually downloaded it, haven't you?

    Kelly Molson: I have downloaded it. It's called 52 Questions Every Experienced CRO Once Had To Ask Because We All Started Where You Are Now. It's a brilliant book actually. I've learnt a lot from it and we'll pop the link to this book in the show notes. So if you are thinking of looking at this process, this is a really, really great place to start.

    Matt Scaysbrook: Laura, our marketeer, will shoot me for not remembering the name.

    Kelly Molson: Don't worry about it, this is what I'm here for. I prepared. No, I do highly recommend it. So I've learned so much from having a look through this booklet. And like Matt says, it's a really great place to start. And in it, you do actually recommend some of the best tools to use, which are free or some that will then start to incur costs as well. Brilliant. Matt, thank you. I have really enjoyed having you on to chat today. We always ask our guests to recommend a book for us. Something that they've loved, something that's influenced them, their career. Can be absolutely anything. What have you prepared for us?

    Matt Scaysbrook: So mine's boringly professional, I'm afraid.

    Kelly Molson: Nothing's wrong with that.

    Matt Scaysbrook: Mine is a very small book actually called Built to Sell by John Warrillow. It is about a fictional agency that the owner decides he wants to sell. And he goes to someone who's built, installed multiple businesses, who advises him on how to move his business to a point where it is sellable. But even if that's not the thing that you're interested in, what the book really focuses on is how do you make sure that you are not the problem in your business? So to my unpopular opinion earlier, reading that... I can't remember how long it is. It's like 120 pages maybe, you literally can read it in a few hours.

    Matt Scaysbrook: But the first time that I read that book, I was just looking at all the things he says, points out, make sure you don't do this, make sure you don't do this. And you sat there thinking, yeah, I'm doing that. There's like 15 or 16 lessons that you should learn from it. And I just remember looking at it thinking, I'm literally doing pretty much all of those. And it's just that one of those proper sorts of light-bulb moments where you realised that you didn't have to learn all this stuff yourself through painful experience. I had a fair amount of painful experience by that point anyway, but it's like, other people have been here before. You're not unique as they were, other people have been through this experience, you learn from them and they will help you.

    Kelly Molson: Yeah. Great book. Listen, as ever, if you want to win a copy of Matt's book, then head over to our Twitter account and retweet this episode announcement with the words, "I want Matt's book". I might get there first because I feel like this is a bit for me. I've had 19 years of making mistakes.

    Matt Scaysbrook: It's really good. Really, really good.

    Kelly Molson: I'm pretty sure that paints a good picture of me in that book, but we're all here. We're all doing our best. Matt, it's been a pleasure having you on today. Thank you. If any of our audience wants to get in touch with you to talk through CRO, ask a few more questions, where's the best place they can get a hold of you?

    Matt Scaysbrook: On our website, there is a page where you can basically book in directly with me just to have a conversation. Those things have been from, some people want to talk about formally working together. Other people just want to have a chat about what they're currently doing. I keep my diary open on that because I have so many good conversations with people. And if I can help someone out, even if they're not someone who's ever going to work with us, I feel good about it at the end of the day, still, I'll share the link with you.

    Kelly Molson: Matt, thank you. That's lovely. I think that's a brilliant way to end the podcast. Thank you very much for coming on and for your generous offer of helping out our audience.

    Matt Scaysbrook: Thanks, Kelly.

    Kelly Molson: Thanks for listening to Skip the Queue. If you've enjoyed this podcast, please leave us a five-star review. It really helps others find us. And remember to follow us on Twitter for your chance to win the books that have been mentioned. Skip the Queue is brought to you by Rubber Cheese, a digital agency that builds remarkable systems and websites for attractions that helps them increase their visitor numbers. You can find show notes and transcriptions from this episode and more over on our website, rubbercheese.com/podcast.

    Download The Visitor Attractions Website Survey Report - https://www.merac.co.uk/download-the-visitor-attractions-survey

     

    We have launched our brand-new playbook: ‘The Retail Ready Guide to Going Beyond the Gift Shop’ — your go-to resource for building a successful e-commerce strategy that connects with your audience and drives sustainable growth.

     

    Download your FREE copy here

    42 min
  • How can a mobile app help improve an attraction's sustainability? with Jacob Thompson

    Skip the Queue is brought to you by Rubber Cheese, a digital agency that builds remarkable systems and websites for attractions that helps them increase their visitor numbers. Your host is Kelly Molson, MD of Rubber Cheese.

    Download our free ebook The Ultimate Guide to Doubling Your Visitor Numbers

    If you like what you hear, you can subscribe on iTunes, Spotify, and all the usual channels by searching Skip the Queue or visit our website rubbercheese.com/podcast.


    If you've enjoyed this podcast, please leave us a five star review, it really helps others find us. And remember to follow us on Twitter for your chance to win the books that have been mentioned in this episode.

    Competition ends April 29th 2022. The winner will be contacted via Twitter.

    Show references:

    https://attractions.io/

    https://www.linkedin.com/in/jacob-thompson

    Jacob Thompson joined the industry at the height of the pandemic and heads up business development for Attractions.io, a mobile app platform dedicated to creating better guest experiences.

    Before joining Attractions.io, Jacob has worked across varying sectors, including financial services, not-for-profit, education and tech, and has a passion for helping businesses realise the fantastic opportunities that technology presents us with.

    When he's not working, Jacob is a keen reader, an average basketball player and a below-average golfer.

    Transcription:

    Kelly Molson: Welcome to Skip the Queue, a podcast for people working in, or working with, visitor attractions. I'm your host, Kelly Molson. Each episode, I speak with industry experts from the attractions world.

    In today's episode, I speak with Jacob Thompson, Business Development Manager at Attractions.io.

    We discuss exactly why your attraction needs an app, and the incredible positives of going digital, from an environmental perspective.

    If you like what you hear, subscribe on iTunes, Spotify, and all the usual channels, by searching Skip the Queue.

    Kelly Molson: Jacob, thank you for coming on the Skip the Queue podcast this morning. It's lovely to have you.

    Jacob Thompson: Thanks for having me. Listened to it for a long time. So it's an absolute pleasure to finally be on it as well.

    Kelly Molson: Oh, I love that. I love it when guests come on and they already love the podcast. Maybe I'll be kinder to you with the icebreaker questions because of that. Or maybe not.

    Jacob Thompson: Please do. Please do.

    Kelly Molson: Right. Let's get cracking. I want to know what your favourite movie quote is?

    Jacob Thompson: "We're going to need a bigger boat." I think it's got to be, hasn't it? Iconic. And I find myself using that expression a lot, especially with how busy things are currently. I think it kind of translates very well.

    Kelly Molson: Love it. Yeah. That is a perfect one for how we're all feeling right now. Jacob and I had a little conversation just before we started recording, about how busy we all are right now. There seems to be an influx of very positive, new leads and inquiries, which is wonderful, but also, oh, I think that probably sums up how we're feeling, right?

    Jacob Thompson: Absolutely. Absolutely.

    Kelly Molson: Okay. If you could get rid of one food, so nobody ever had to eat this food ever again, what would it be? What would you destroy?

    Jacob Thompson: Oh, Stilton. Oh, is that going to be an unpopular-

    Kelly Molson: Cheese?

    Jacob Thompson: Can I use that as my unpopular opinion? It's just when you have a cheese platter, the smell just ruins it for me. And I think just get rid of it. There's plenty of other cheeses to choose from, so that... Can I use that as my unpopular opinion as well, maybe?

    Kelly Molson: No, you can't. We were getting on so well up until that point as well.

    Jacob Thompson: I'm sorry. I'm sorry. Had to be honest.

    Kelly Molson: Wow. Okay. This might not go as well. All right. Okay. Tell me something that you are not very good at?

    Jacob Thompson: Oh, there's a lot of things. I think maybe this is a little bit deep, but I think reflecting on previous achievements, I think I often get so focused on what needs to be done that actually, I forget all of the things that I have done already. And I think maybe that's a bit deep and philosophical for what you are looking for. But that's yeah... That's what I go with.

    Kelly Molson: That's a really good one. Because I think that that is a good reminder that we all need to celebrate the small wins, don't we? We really need to take time out. And I think that's quite a common challenge with a lot of us. I am exactly the same as you. I'm always focused on what's next. What's next? What's next? And then don't sit back and go, oh actually we did a really good job there.

    Jacob Thompson: Definitely.

    Kelly Molson: Pat ourselves on the back a little bit.

    Jacob Thompson: Need to do it a little bit more.

    Kelly Molson: Definitely. All right. You're unpopular opinion. Not about cheese.

    Jacob Thompson: Oh, so I've probably already alienated that half of the listeners already. Probably more than half, but oh, yeah. What could I give you that's not too controversial? I think firstly, I fully get behind the England team and really get into it when it comes to the World Cup and the Euro's. But when I put them side by side, I think rugby is the better sport, over football. So sorry if I offend anyone there.

    Kelly Molson: Okay. All right. No, that's fine. I think this has come up before as well actually, that rugby is the far superior sport to football. I'm a massive football fan.

    Jacob Thompson: Yeah.

    Kelly Molson: So I'm going to disagree with you.

    Jacob Thompson: Yeah.

    Kelly Molson: But I think there's plenty of people that will agree with your unpopular opinion. Let us know what you think about that one listeners? And Jacob, tell us a little bit about you, and what your role is at Attractions.io?

    Jacob Thompson: Yeah. So I'm the business development manager for Attractions.io. So basically my role is to speak with attractions at an early stage to understand obviously, what we can help them with, what they're struggling with at the moment. And I've been doing that for the past two years now. So a relative rookie in the industry compared to some of the big hitters that you've had join you on the podcast. But yeah, it's really just, I'm here to help attractions, especially not just with a mobile app, but just their approach to their digital strategy. How they can engage their guests, how they can better communicate them. And obviously, most importantly, create better guest experiences. And that's what I'm here to do.

    Kelly Molson: Did you come from an attractions background? Have you got a slightly different...

    Jacob Thompson: So I'm still pretty young. So I left school with not really a clear direction on what I wanted to do. But I thought if I give everything to go work hard at it, and see what opportunities present themselves to me. So after leaving school, I quickly moved into to the tech background, and working with mobile app providers, for conferences and events. And after a few changes and moves, I found myself at Attractions.io. And I think obviously there was huge imposter syndrome entering the industry because I know, I learned very quickly how kind of tight knit it is. But I guess I kind of went in with a mindset of, if I've been visiting attractions since as young as I can remember. So I've got the experience, I know what a good guest experience feels like. And I've just tried to bring that to the role. But yeah, so still very, very new to the industry.

    Kelly Molson: But you've got real world experience. So that's-

    Jacob Thompson: Exactly.

    Kelly Molson: ...what's important. And I love that you mentioned customer experience there.

    Jacob Thompson: Yep.

    Kelly Molson: Because that's what I really love about Attractions.io. So all the content that you produce or the webinars that I've watched, that yourself and Mark have spoken on, is that you are all about improving the customer experience. And I love that because that's exactly what Rubber Cheese is all about as well. But it's interesting because we come from slightly different ways of looking at that.

    Jacob Thompson: Yep.

    Kelly Molson: So I guess we are all about that kind of pre-visit experience and making people feel excited about what they're potentially buying and what they're potentially going to see. And then you guys take over with the-

    Jacob Thompson: Yep.

    Kelly Molson: ..app visitor experience. So we are very complimentary. I've got loads of questions around what you do today, but I think the most important question that I want to know is, why does an attraction need an app?

    Jacob Thompson: Yeah. So I think there's kind of two sides to this. I think firstly, and this has been largely because of the pandemic, but it's always changing, is guest expectations. So I think we all know that we spent however long in lock down. Everything turned digital for us, our whole lives and experiences were digital. And we got very used to being served personalised content, whether that's Netflix, given recommendations, personalised ads, Amazon offering discounts on products we've viewed, things like that. It shaped that, experienced in the expectations we now have, is that wherever we go, we want that same personalised experience. It makes us feel special. It creates a better experience. I think also there's now more digital natives. So people that have grown up with technology, than there has been previously. And I think, I know for one that I'm comfortable and happy to order, when I go to McDonald's or Wetherspoons, or wherever I may go, ordering through my phone as much-

    Kelly Molson: Still, insight in there, to get your free time Jacob.

    Jacob Thompson: I don't get, don't go to McDonald's as much as they used to. So yeah, no, but I think it's that whole expectation. It makes people's lives easier. And I think, tying into that, is actually solving the problems that I guess, some we knew of and tried to hide. And some, we hadn't even really kind of come across before, that were highlighted during the pandemic. So I think that the biggest one was queues, and social distancing. Queues are kind of that number one complaint that guests have, especially a theme park, you spend more time queuing than you do on rides. So suddenly, parks and operators needed to look at that, and go, how do we remove those physical queues? Because we can't have people standing next to each other for that long.

    Jacob Thompson: And that's where things like virtual queuing came in, and just adapting to use technology, to solve a lot of the problems that already existed and unlock new benefits that we didn't have before. So being able to have that direct channel of communication. You mentioned that pre-visit experience, you've got so much control around building that excitement, understanding who's on your website, what they're clicking on, what they're engaging with most. But then they arrive on site and we've lost that channel there. And that's obviously what we're out here to provide.

    Kelly Molson: I love that. Yeah. And it's really important. Isn't it? Because like you say, once someone's in, you've essentially lost them. If they're not attached to their app or they're not like engaged with it in some way. You're giving them, it's harder to understand where people are, where they're interacting, what their challenges are, what their frustrations are, what their positives are, I guess. So tell me some of the biggest challenges that attractions will bring to you, that might shape what their app would look like?

    Jacob Thompson: Yeah. That's a tough one, because I think every attraction is slightly different. And I mean, we work with theme parks, zoos, resorts, heritage attractions. They've all got their independent challenges. I think when I joined the industry, so I joined right in the middle of the pandemic. So early on, maybe just before summer 2020. So right in the middle of it, and obviously everyone was panicking, going, how do we reopen safely? And a lot of that was around, obviously supporting social distancing, with things like virtual queues, using heat map data of guest flow to understand where people going, and making sure that we're spreading people out. Now we're, fingers crossed, at the tail end of that. I think it's still highlighted a lot around the guest experience. So making sure guest flow is spread out. So people aren't queuing for ages.

    Jacob Thompson: That they're not having to wait to get on rides, or to see an attraction, that they can move around freely. I think another thing, and it starts to crop up a lot more, is ungated attractions. So whether that's free to enter attractions, there's some theme parks that we work with, where you can go in for free and you just pay per ride. A lack of understanding of who's visiting them.

    Kelly Molson: Yeah.

    Jacob Thompson: So they may get the odd bit of information, maybe on pre purchase of car parking, but largely they can maybe only understand 10% of their visitor base, which we need to unlock as much of that data as possible. By having that app there, is we can collect email addresses and behavioural data to attach to that, which in turn, just opens up that world of possibility, to engage guests and understand who they are.

    Jacob Thompson: But I think the biggest thing now that I've noticed is that people, as we spoke about expectations, changing, do understand the importance and need for that digital presence and that experience on site. So I think the biggest challenge that's coming to us now is, how do we do this right? Because there's so many ways to approach building an app and it's about rethinking, okay, how can we not only benefit the guest and create a really good guest experience, but how can we obviously gain those benefits as operators? So that data, those insights, and often rushing into building an app can lead to just an interactive map and not much more, and not giving much substance. So yeah, again, from your experience, I don't know from the previous experience, what it's like for you, when you get operators coming to you, because digital is so important now, how they approach that. And whether they want to jump in and just make sure they've got the basics, or it'd be really good to understand how you've approached that as well.

    Kelly Molson: Yeah. So I guess it is interesting. So as a web design agency, we often get asked about apps. And it's always, okay, well, we've had this idea and we think that we need an app. And you go, okay, well, let's pull that apart. What does this app need to do for you? What does it need to deliver for you? And then essentially they will kind of explain something that their website already does. And so we are like, okay, well, you don't need to create an app that's a carbon copy of your website. It has to do something more for the guest. They can go to your website and they can find that information. What is, what's the use of just replicating that in an app.

    Kelly Molson: And I think that's the challenge, is understanding really, what the benefit to the client, what the benefits are to the customer is, and what the benefit to them is going to be, and not just replicating what they already have, because that doesn't make any sense. So that's what I see as the biggest challenge is. Do attractions, and then not just attractions because we work with a variety of people. Do people really understand what that need, and what that benefit is going to it be by having an app? I think that's what we get asked all the time.

    Jacob Thompson: Yeah, absolutely. And I think one thing that people often, until they start to speak to us, and I think the biggest thing is, is that education piece around, there's no point in doing this kind of just have an app for the sake of it. It's really making sure that it's delivering value. And most people see the app, but then forget that we've not just spent a long time building an app dedicated to the attraction's industry. We've also got a whole operator experience as well in the background, where it's given those data and insights, allowing you to use the data capture, to communicate with guests. And I think that's one thing that the education is so important, because what we don't want is, is attractions taking that leap, trying to build an app themselves, and have not really thought it through.

    Jacob Thompson: And we really want to make sure that they've got all the information they need to make an informed decision around how is this going to add value to the guest experience. And also how is it going make our lives easier, solve our biggest challenges, and obviously bring the benefits of increased revenue, increased NPS. So there's a whole host. And I think education's just that big piece that we really have to work with when we speak to attractions.

    Kelly Molson: Yeah, definitely. And I think what was really interesting. So I listened to Mark.

    Jacob Thompson: Yep.

    Kelly Molson: Founder of Attractions.io. I listened to his podcast interview that he did with the great guys at AttractionPros. And I really liked how he described the approach to what you guys do for app development, as a holistic approach. And this was really interesting because he described it as, "A lot of the time when attractions want to develop an app, it will sit with marketing, and it'll be very much in the marketing departments pile." But where he said, actually, this is a whole operational piece, that this app could be. And it was really interesting to hear, how this app can have an effect on so many different departments. From operations, in terms of customer flow, like you mentioned, yes it is a marketing piece as well, but yes, you can order your food.

    Kelly Molson: So the beverage team need to be involved in these decisions as well. And I just, I kind of thought, yeah, that this is so much bigger, isn't it? It's such a, it could be such an integrated piece that could really help so many different departments across the organisation, rather than it just being something that marketing pick up and go, we need an app.

    Jacob Thompson: Yeah. Yeah. And I think that's, again, it's probably my biggest challenge when speaking to attractions, is getting that message across. And yeah, like you say, it's very easy for marketing to have, own the app and do a good job with it. But in that siloed approach, they miss out on so many opportunities. And just from the deployments we've done, and even attractions that have apps with different providers that have done it right, or built it themselves, is the best ones are where it really just span the entire guest experience, which as you mentioned, it spans the whole team at that attraction. So retail, food and beverage operations, ride operators, even senior management, in terms of planning, expansion, understanding what guests are doing, where they're spending the time. It really is. Yeah. That, that holistic approach to the whole digital strategy.

    Jacob Thompson: And I think it also ties into, again, what you and the team do is, tying the whole journey together. So it's a seamless digital experience from the moment they see an advert online, to going through to the website, to purchasing their tickets, uploading their tickets into the app, using scanning it when they arrive. Using the app through the whole experience. And then obviously the data that we've captured from the start of the journey. So the booking phase to the app phase is then continuing to own that relationship going forward, and being able to communicate with them. So you want people to come back, you want them to bring friends and family, you want them to purchase season passes. So by creating that end to end guest journey, you've then got full control to engage and influence that the guests that are visiting with you.

    Kelly Molson: Yeah. It's really powerful, isn't it? When you actually timeline that journey through, that's a really powerful, to be able to contain that data for so long. Here's a question for you. Now this is something that's come up a few times when I've had guests on. And I think actually it was one of our guest's unpopular opinions. I'm pretty sure it was.

    Jacob Thompson: Yeah.

    Kelly Molson: How do you get the balance right, of wanting guests to engage with the app, but not trying to detract their attention from the attraction that they're currently in. So this was definitely, I can remember now, it was the interview that we carried out with Edinburgh Zoo.

    Jacob Thompson: Yeah.

    Kelly Molson: David Field of Edinburgh Zoo.

    Jacob Thompson: Yep.

    Kelly Molson: The unpopular opinion was, "I just, I don't, I want people off of their phones while they're here. I don't want them on their phones. I want them to be present. I want them to be in the moment." And so I guess that's really tricky, isn't it? Like, how do you do that?

    Jacob Thompson: Yeah. And do you know what? That is quite a common early objection that we'll come up against. And I think the kind of highlight is, is we don't want people on the phones the whole time. We don't want them staring at the phone. We want them experiencing it. We want to enhance that experience. I think there's a few ways we do that. And just that is, firstly, it's getting people from A to B quicker. So let's say we're at the zoo and we want to go find the penguins. So a paper map, obviously we can talk about sustainability, and the printed maps aren't great for the environment and cost money. Having the app there, we've got, rather than having to rotate the map, you've got the whole family standing around. It is, we can quickly find where we want to go and use the wayfinding abilities to get, to see the animals quicker.

    Jacob Thompson: So we don't miss the keeper talks, the animal feeding time. So it's removing some of those challenges to allow people to actually spend more time engaging, whether that's getting on the ride, seeing the animals, rather than all the little bits in between. The other thing is reducing, as I mentioned, some of those real pain points around queuing. So let's say the kids are on the playground, and you want to go and order food. Normally you'd have to queue, but now with a mobile app, you can stand there, watch your kids play in, they can have fun, you can order your food and you'll get an alert to say, right, go and pick it up now. And you've just saved all of that time where the kids would be kicking and screaming, because you're dragging them away from the playground. That you can just sit back order your food, and wait for it to be ready.

    Jacob Thompson: And then the other aspect and the third aspect that kind of ties it all together is, enhancing the experience. So when people are looking at, let's say some of the animals is, that we can supplement that with audio and video guides, to just really educate. And that's one big thing that we work with zoos on, is more than just having kind of the name plaque and the name in Latin, is how can we engage, especially a younger audience, and educate them and start to promote those conservation initiatives, which obviously drives revenue.

    Jacob Thompson: So there's a few different areas, but I think ultimately we just want to enhance that physical experience. We're not here to replace it. And I think, hopefully, all of the attractions that we've work with, will affirm that, and understand that it's helped. It's really helped engage guests in a better way but still hasn't taken away. Because you can't replace the feeling of seeing your favourite animal for the first time or going on that roller coaster. So it's all about being that companion, to make that experience better and not take away from it.

    Kelly Molson: That's a great word, a digital companion. I love that.

    Jacob Thompson: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Absolutely.

    Kelly Molson: I actually prefer that to app. We should all use-

    Jacob Thompson: Yeah, there you go. Maybe we'll, yeah, I'll rebrand my sales material. But yeah, I think that's exactly what it is and yeah, we're here to supplement and enhance it. Not take away from it, or replace it.

    Kelly Molson: Yeah. It's great. And there's some great benefits in there as well. Just from, from talking about that, I could, it was, I could see myself kind of at the playground waiting for my kids.

    Jacob Thompson: Yeah.

    Kelly Molson: I could put myself in that situation. Something that you touched on actually was sustainability. And I'd really like to talk about this. I mean, sustainability is something that all attractions need to be really focused on anyway. But we had a really great past episode on this specifically, with Lucy Downing and Sue Pennington from Holkham Hall. And they talked through, I mean, phenomenal sustainability policies that they have in place there and their Wonder program that they've initiated there, which is incredible. There's a really good case study on your website that I've read a number of times now, from ZooTampa.

    Jacob Thompson: Yep.

    Kelly Molson: I would really love to hear a little bit more about this, because it does some really incredibly positive things for the environment, the sustainability around the zoo. And they've made some, like quite phenomenal cost savings as well.

    Jacob Thompson: Yeah, absolutely. So I think that the case really kind of came off the back of, I think it was Green Loop. Me, Mark, and the team at ZooTampa, did the talk just around how having a digital presence like that, and having a mobile app can help with sustainability. So yeah, hopefully I'm quoting it right. So I think the kind of amazing results, that even blew me and Mark away, when we heard them, was that ZooTampa were able to save $50,000 a year, which is just phenomenal. Especially for a charity, a zoo. But they're cutting their print waste by 95%.

    Kelly Molson: That's amazing.

    Jacob Thompson: And it's almost nothing. And what that has done, obviously apart from having that immediate impact on the reduced print and the cost savings, is that there's two things that have happened. Obviously, those cost savings can now be redirected to something much more important. Whether that be the conservation initiatives that they run locally, to them, or obviously internationally that they're involved in. But also the way they went about it was not only digitising maps and not printing maps anymore but pushing for digitised tickets.

    Jacob Thompson: So they now get people to upload their tickets into the mobile app. And that means that more people, because there's a need now to have everything within the app, that they now can communicate those conservation initiatives, because they've got that direct channel during the visit, during the experience. So they can educate and really capture the whole audience. And I think it's not just ZooTampa obviously that yet, absolutely incredible results that they've seen, but we've seen a lot of attractions, not just zoos, but theme parks as well. In some of our partner attractions, reducing printed, like guest printed information, completely. So the only option is that digital companion, we'll call it now, I like that one. So I think it's been a real shift and it's so important. And I think it's been ever present recently, but it's something we need to continue to think about, sustainability, and it all ties back to those expectations as well.

    Jacob Thompson: And the digital natives especially is that people either expect or are really comfortable now, in the majority of cases, using a digital channel. So if it makes life easier, if it enhances the experience, then it's a perfect way to channel people in that direction, rather than picking up a printed map. And I know a lot of parks that haven't, are on that path now, from handing out loads of maps, to now, just printing maybe 10, 15% of what they used to. Just to have it on hand. But I think over the next couple of years, especially we're just going to see that shift towards a 100% digital, because it has all the added benefits, not only just of the sustainability angle as well.

    Kelly Molson: Yeah. I mean, it's phenomenal, isn't it? The cost savings.

    Jacob Thompson: Mm-hmm (affirmative).

    Kelly Molson: And the advantages to sustainability that, that can bring. I mean, I think it's important to acknowledge that, we probably talk from a place of privilege that we have mobile phones, and we know how to use them, and there will be a lot of people out there that, it's accessible for them. So there is self place for printed maps.

    Jacob Thompson: Yeah.

    Kelly Molson: But to be able to save so much and channel that into other things, is just incredible. Who knew that an app could be so valuable?

    Jacob Thompson: Who knew, and yeah. It's just been, yeah. It's been amazing to see. And I think the results like that, when we can save charities money through our product, it's obviously, yeah. It's very rewarding to see. And yeah, I think, always got a soft spot when working with zoos, because I know there is that opportunity out there to really help them.

    Kelly Molson: Yeah, absolutely. I want to go back a little bit. To what we talked about earlier, about some of the common challenges that attractions bring you. And kind of what I mentioned as well, about how we often get asked, hey, I need an app, but then it's not really, they are not very clear about what that app needs to do. What do you need to understand from an attraction to be able to work out what would be the perfect solution for them? Like, what do they need to think about before they come to speak to you?

    Jacob Thompson: Yeah, well, there is a lot to think about, and that's what we're here to help with. I think firstly, it's really zooming out a little bit. And we did run bit of initiative last year to help attractions around mapping out the entire digital guest journey. Because as we mentioned, that timeline is really powerful, but we almost want to see it as a bit of a flywheel rather than an end to end timeline, because what we want to do is make sure the app is connecting the start and the end of the visit, but ties it all back together. So I think firstly just, just mapping out, understanding what technology they're currently using. So things like ticketing providers is incredibly important because we want to be able to integrate with them, through to point of sale, CRM systems.

    Jacob Thompson: Once we've started to tie that together, it's then to really look at guest feedback, and feedback from the wider team as well. When we look at that holistic approach, to understand, okay, what challenges can we solve? So what are the biggest pain points for the guest experience right now? And like I said, that they'll differ for each attraction. But once you can pinpoint those, whether that be queue times, whether that be everyone is going into the same food outlet at lunch, and we're just getting people waiting around for ages. Whether that be the animals, aren't always visible. It's how can we communicate with guests, to let them know when the animals might be visible or when there's the next keeper talk so they can make sure they can obviously see the animals they've gone there to see.

    Jacob Thompson: I think obviously that's just a flavour of some of the problems. But I think most important, is mapping that guest journey out and then pinpointing where an app is going to be able to solve those problems. There'll be some added benefits along the way. And once you've got that, and that's what we are here to help attractions do is, then you can start to really evaluate the process of, okay, how do we go about implementing an app. So it's not just let's launch an app in the app store. It's how do we market that properly? Because otherwise, if you don't explain the benefits or the reasons behind the launch, the app, people won't download it, if you don't make it visible. So if you don't promote it, when people are purchasing tickets, when they're receiving the ticket confirmation, when they arrive on site.

    Jacob Thompson: So again, it's that holistic approach that attractions need to just zoom out a little bit, understand what they're currently doing, identify those pain points, and then start to evaluate the solutions that are out there. So there's kind of three approaches that we often see. There's the do it yourself, which larger attractions, no doubt, have the capital to throw at that kind of project. It takes millions of pounds of investment and years of work to get a solution, to be that world class solution. And obviously, Mark and the team at Attractions.io, have learnt that the hard way I guess. And they've gone and done that, so other attractions don't have to. There's bringing in teams to help with that, which especially with an app for a visitor attraction, it's such a specific thing. So things that need to be considered like battery life conservation.

    Jacob Thompson: So it's not just like ordering a Domino's and you can put your phone away, you out for the whole day, you need to make sure that your battery life will last. And there's loads of work just around optimizing that. Things like being an offline solution as well, that often someone coming in wouldn't really understand if they're not from the attractions space, is that we know you can go to a lot of visitor attractions, and I think most of them admit themselves, there's always going to be a patchy signal in some places.

    Jacob Thompson: So we need to make sure that experience doesn't, isn't impacted because of that. And then I think finally, is ourselves and obviously platforms like ourselves. So like I said, there's been loads of investment going into the platform and it now means that we can scale that out to attractions very quickly. And they're kind of the three approaches that people will look at. So yeah, I guess looking at their current guest journey and then starting to evaluate the approach to how to launch a mobile app. And that's, they're the two big areas that I guess attractions will look at, on that journey.

    Kelly Molson: That's brilliant. Thank you for detailing that out for us. It's interesting, because it's a really similar process that we go through when we are asking about websites at the start.

    Jacob Thompson: Yeah.

    Kelly Molson: What technology are you already using? What does it need to integrate with? What are your challenges? What are your customers saying are big issues with stuff. And again, taking that real holistic approach, and making sure that everybody is having their say, and what gets produced, and what is going to be of benefit. So, yeah. Brilliant. Thank you. We always ask our guests that come on the podcast, if they can share a book that they love with us, something they love, something that's influenced their career in some way. It can be personal, it can be work related. What have you got to share with us?

    Jacob Thompson: Yeah. So I know that, I think I've seen Mark Ellis and Johnny both recommended, I think Mark went to the extreme of recommending 43 books, I think. I know it was obviously part of a larger series and I could have easily done maybe not 43, but a few, but I have taken it down to one book, which is Atomic Habits, by James Clear. I don't know whether it's been recommended before, but I picked this. In fact, I listened to it on audiobook first, and then loved it that much, that I bought the physical copy. I think it's impacted so many areas of my life personally, professionally. I think it's, I won't give too much away. People should read it, but it's all about making change. So whether that be implementing new habits, getting rid of old ones, it's all that, there's so much really useful information and tips in there that a lot of books tend to waffle on and pad it out.

    Jacob Thompson: This is page to page, really actionable advice on making change, implementing change and basically just starting off small. And then yeah, like you say, look back and see all those changes that come together to have that big impact. So that's, that's my one recommendation, I'll stick to.

    Kelly Molson: One book recommendation. Did you hear that listeners? One book. Well done Jacob.

    Jacob Thompson: Yep. It was hard.

    Jacob Thompson: It was hard.

    Kelly Molson: Following instructions though.

    Jacob Thompson: Yeah.

    Kelly Molson: It's a great book. I have read that book.

    Jacob Thompson: Yeah.

    Kelly Molson: And it is an awesome book. I really like, it's about marginal games really, isn't it?

    Jacob Thompson: Yep.

    Kelly Molson: It's about being one percent better. One percent better all the time.

    Jacob Thompson: Mm-hmm (affirmative).

    Kelly Molson: And that is something that I think is really important, rather than taking a massive jump into trying to do something huge and looks really scary. But yeah, it's a big thing about celebrating your progress in there.

    Jacob Thompson: Yeah.

    Kelly Molson: So that's one that we all should take away from today. Thank you. As ever, if you want to win a copy of that book, if you head over to our Twitter account and you retweet this episode announcement with the words, "I want Jacob's book", then you will be in with the chance of winning it. Jacob, thank you. I've really enjoyed our talk today. It's really interesting to see, I think how aligned both of our approaches are. And I hope that our listeners today will take away from this, how important and how beneficial an app can actually be, as long as it's thought out, and processed, and constructed in the right way.

    Jacob Thompson: Yeah, absolutely. Yeah. You've summed that up perfectly. So yeah, it's been an absolute pleasure to talk about it today, and yeah, thanks for having me on the podcast.

    Kelly Molson: Thanks for listening to Skip The Queue. If you've enjoyed this podcast, please leave us a five star review. It really helps others find us, and remember to follow us on Twitter for your chance to win the books that have been mentioned. Skip The Queue is brought to you by

    Rubber Cheese,, a digital agency that builds remarkable systems and websites for attractions, that helps them increase their visitor numbers. You can find show notes and transcriptions from this episode and more over on our website, rubbercheese.com/podcast.

    Download The Visitor Attractions Website Survey Report - https://www.merac.co.uk/download-the-visitor-attractions-survey

     

    We have launched our brand-new playbook: ‘The Retail Ready Guide to Going Beyond the Gift Shop’ — your go-to resource for building a successful e-commerce strategy that connects with your audience and drives sustainable growth.

     

    Download your FREE copy here

    36 min
  • Football stadiums as visitor attractions, with Laura Chiplin

    Skip the Queue is brought to you by Rubber Cheese, a digital agency that builds remarkable systems and websites for attractions that helps them increase their visitor numbers. Your host is Kelly Molson, MD of Rubber Cheese.

    Download our free ebook The Ultimate Guide to Doubling Your Visitor Numbers

    If you like what you hear, you can subscribe on iTunes, Spotify, and all the usual channels by searching Skip the Queue or visit our website rubbercheese.com/podcast
    If you've enjoyed this podcast, please leave us a five star review, it really helps others find us. And remember to follow us on Twitter for your chance to win the books that have been mentioned in this episode.

    Competition ends April 29th 2022. The winner will be contacted via Twitter.

    Show references:

    https://www.linkedin.com/in/laura-chiplin-85468b42/

    https://experience.tottenhamhotspur.com/home.htm

    https://www.tottenhamhotspur.com/

    Laura Chiplin has over 12 years’ experience in the heritage, arts and attractions sector. With a passion for delivering great visitor experiences, Laura is currently Head of Visitor Attractions at Tottenham Hotspur Stadium in North London.

    Laura’s early career was greatly influenced by her love of music and theatre, taking up her first role at the Barbican Centre whilst studying at the City of London University in 2007. Laura spent the following 9 years at Europe’s leading art centre, before embarking on a new chapter in her career with the V&A Museum, where she headed up the visitor experience team.

    During her time here, Laura lead a growing team at a key period in the museums history with the opening of the Exhibition Road Quarter; the first major expansion in the museum’s 100 year history.

    This influential period in Laura’s career fuelled her passion for delivering exceptional visitor experiences and she was ready for a new challenge…one with slightly different goals.

    With a ground-breaking stadium project underway in North London, Laura was approached to lead the Visitor Attractions team at the newly built Tottenham Hotspur Stadium in N17.

    As Head of Visitor Attractions, she leads a 70 strong team at the Premier League ground, developing and delivering world class experiences, in an exciting and fast paced environment.

    When not in the office, Laura enjoys reading, eating out and walking her dog, Morris in North East London.

    Transcription:

    Kelly Molson: Welcome to Skip the Queue, a podcast for people working in, or working with visitor attractions. I'm your host, Kelly Molson. Each episode, I speak with industry experts from the attractions world.

    In today's episode, I speak with Laura Chiplin, Head of Visitor Attractions at Tottenham Hotspur Football Club.

    We discuss the concept of a football club as an attraction, and how Spurs have taken the visitor attraction concept to a whole new level.

    If you like what you hear, subscribe on iTunes, Spotify, and all the usual channels by searching Skip the Queue.

    Kelly Molson: Laura, thank you so much for coming on the podcast today. I'm really excited to chat with you.

    Laura Chiplin: Thank you so much for having me. I'm really excited to be talking to you too.

    Kelly Molson: Well, I'll be very kind with the icebreaker questions, I think.

    Laura Chiplin: I hope so.

    Kelly Molson: Don't worry. Okay, so start with this one. If you could take three things to a desert island, what would they be?

    Laura Chiplin: Ooh, I would take sun cream, because I don't want to get a sunburn. Very important. Maybe a barbecue, so I can cook some nice fish. I don't think I'd be that good at making a barbecue on my own. I probably wouldn't last very long at all, but I could, lying there, a bit of fish on the barbecue. What would my final thing be? A good book, a really long book, so it will take a long time to read.

    Kelly Molson: A long book that could read over, and over, and over again and not get bored.

    Laura Chiplin: Exactly, yeah. That's on my list.

    Kelly Molson: Now I've got this picture of you hunting for fish as well, with like a spear. Strong woman.

    Laura Chiplin: Yeah, absolutely. That's definitely the vibe I'm going for.

    Kelly Molson: Good, okay. If you could choose a talent to grow and to develop, what would you most like to learn?

    Laura Chiplin: Actually, this one's quite topical. So at the weekend, my brother and I made some curtains. And when I say we did it together, he mainly did it. He's very talented, he can really turn his hand to anything. But now having made the curtains, I know I need to make other blinds and curtains. So I think having a practical skill, like sewing or something like that, actually it's nice because you can help other people, it's something can do yourself. It's quite mindful as well, if all goes well. Something like that, I think would be quite good. And curtains are also very expensive, so that's also another positive.

    Kelly Molson: They are really expensive, phenomenally expensive. I really like that you picked that one, because that's one of my goals this year is to learn how to use the very beautiful sewing machine that is sitting up in my spare room, just looking pretty and not getting a lot of action.

    Laura Chiplin: We'll have to learn together.

    Kelly Molson: We can be accountability partners on that one. All right, noted. Have you ever been mistaken for somebody famous?

    Laura Chiplin: Oh, don't. When I worked at the Barbican, the guys always used to take the mick out of me and said I look like Celine Dion, which I absolutely do not look like Celine Dion. I love her, absolutely love her. She's brilliant, obviously some great tunes, but she is quite a bit older than me. And I'm not sure we look like each other, but yeah, my old colleagues at the Barbican can had a bit of a running joke with that one. I do love karaoke as well, and singing, so that was probably part of it.

    Kelly Molson: There's a bit of a link there then. You are very fresh faced, she is considerably older than you. But there is a little touch there, I would say there is a touch of Celine there.

    Laura Chiplin: Yeah, okay. I slightly walked into that one.

    Kelly Molson: Thank you for sharing. What's your unpopular opinion, then?

    Laura Chiplin: Oh, my unpopular opinion is fruit in puddings. If it's got fruit, in my mind, it should not be a pudding. Pudding should be chocolate, meringue, cream. I don't want to see any fruit inside.

    Kelly Molson: Not even an apple crumble?

    Laura Chiplin: I knew you were going to ask this. So apple crumble is only acceptable, if the ratio of apple to crumble is like 25% apple and 75% crumble. And then like a hundred percent cream on top of that.

    Kelly Molson: Very specific ratios there.

    Laura Chiplin: There's no thin crumble toppings, I'm not into that. It's like a very thin layer of apple, and then hell of a lot of crumble

    Kelly Molson: And really it's all about the cream, in all honesty.

    Laura Chiplin: Absolutely, yeah.

    Kelly Molson: All right, thank you. I would love to know what people feel about the whole fruit in pudding scenario. I'm probably with you, because mine's a chocolate brownie. That's the best pudding.

    Laura Chiplin: Yeah. Anything chocolate, I'm more than happy. I'm up for that.

    Kelly Molson: Good. Excellent, thank you for sharing. I want to talk about today, the concept of a football club as a visitor attraction. Now listeners, you'll know that I am a big Tottenham fan, so I'm really excited that I've got Laura in from Spurs today. And I think we've all become quite accustomed to stadiums having stadium tours, and that's pretty much the norm for a football club. But Spurs have taken the visitor attraction concept to a whole new level, and I want you to tell us about it today. So, can you share with us the experiences that Tottenham now offer as a visitor attraction?

    Laura Chiplin: Yeah, absolutely. So as you mentioned, stadium tours, which are something that happen in many stadiums across the UK and the world. So, we have a stadium tours program here, so we offer a number of stadium tours. But our main one, which most visitors will go on, will take them through some of the key areas of the stadium, so really go behind the scenes and get to see the places that they would never normally get to see, if they were coming on a match day. And those are mainly the player areas, so they would go into the first team dressing room, walk out the tunnel, pitch side, sit in the dugout. And also with this stadium, they would also go into custom built NFL facilities, explore some of our premium areas, and really get an overview of Tottenham Hotspur the club, but also Tottenham Hotspur the stadium. So, that's our stadium tour that we offer and deliver.

    Laura Chiplin: And you mentioned taking things to new heights, so this is very relevant for the Dare Skywalk. So, this is a new attraction which opened in August, 2020, so this really takes visitors on a different experience in the stadium. And people harness up, they clip on, and they go on a journey which takes them up to the roof of the stadium, across an apex which is 46.8 meters above the pitch. So it's clear glass, you can see the stadium below, and then onto a viewing platform which has amazing views out to London. Because we are in North London, a really different aspect of the city, and quite a wide panorama which is absolutely lovely. So visitors can have a drink there, a glass of champagne, a beer. And then our latest attraction is the Dare Skywalk Edge, which if visitors are feeling particularly brave, they can finish their Dare Skywalk experience by going over the edge, and descending on a controlled descent 42 meters to the South podium below.

    Kelly Molson: Crazy.

    Laura Chiplin: You've been, right?

    Kelly Molson: I have been, yes. We actually went in September, 2020, so during the pandemic, but at a point where we were all allowed out to do things. And we actually saw Jose that day, so he came out while we were up on top of the roof, he came out on the pitch and shouted up. I can't remember what they were saying, but people were shouting down at him and he was shouting up. So, it was incredible. It was such an organised experience, like everything felt very safe, everything felt very slick. And actually being on the roof of your football stadium was mad. I could look down and see where my season ticket seat was. Yeah, it was just a really crazy experience. Like you say, part of it, looking at the views of North London and then into London, far across London was pretty spectacular, actually. Yeah, where did the idea come from to do this?

    Laura Chiplin: So, I guess Tottenham Hotspur Stadium is home to Tottenham Hotspur Football Club, but it's much more than just a football stadium. It's host to other sporting and entertainment events. So the stadium is the London home to the NFL, so it's the only stadium outside of North America that's been specifically designed for American football. So we've got custom-built NFL spaces, locker rooms. And we actually have two pitches, so we have a grass football playing surface, which then slides out, and underneath there's an NFL artificial surface below. So, we've got a partnership with the NFL that they will play at least two of their London games here for over a 10 year period. We've already hosted a major boxing event, we've got rugby coming later this year, we've got concerts coming later this year. So, it's already been announced that Lady Gaga and Guns N' Roses will be playing in the summer.

    Laura Chiplin: So, it's really a multipurpose sports and entertainment venue, and a new landmark in London. And I think that's where the idea of the Skywalk and the attractions, they really support and tie into that idea of it being a London venue, that's host to major events, and is also open and activated throughout the year. So, it's not just on traditional football match days, which there's 25 days a year, and there's a lot more that we can be doing with the stadium. So, it's about activating the stadium throughout the year, and it's about bringing people to Tottenham and the local area, creating new opportunities.

    Laura Chiplin: And also we're engaging with, and connecting with new people beyond our fan base. So, you could argue that the stadium tour is perhaps more aligned to her football fans, which of course it is, but there are lots of interesting elements about our stadium, the architecture, the design, the technology. But especially with something like the Dare Skywalk, we do see it as, it's an attraction within London. And you can come and enjoy amazing views of London, it's adventurous, there's lots of things that it ticks. So yes, of course it's for our fans, but also it's beyond, and helping us to engage with new audiences as well.

    Kelly Molson: Yeah, I love that idea. I think that the idea that a football stadium, if you are a fan, I think obviously if you're a Tottenham fan, these are a attractions that you want to go and visit, you want to be able to take part in. But as a football fan, the stadium is a huge draw. It is a phenomenal piece of engineering, it is beautiful, the facilities are incredible. I think anyone that has an interest in football would love to go there and to be able to see that. So, that must be a draw for some of the stadium tours. What was interesting is when we were on the tour, there were actually two Arsenal fans.

    Laura Chiplin: Exactly.

    Kelly Molson: Which was like, oh, okay. They kept it quiet for a while, and then told us when we were at the top. But from their opinion, they wanted to come and see... It wasn't necessarily about the football stadium, it was about the attraction and being able to take something fun.

    Laura Chiplin: Exactly, yeah, definitely. We welcome anyone, no matter what team they support. Obviously it's quite fun, have some fun with anyone who supports our North London rivals. But that's exactly it, it's about an attraction in London, a fun thing to do, things with families, couples, there's lots of different people that we're trying to attract.

    Kelly Molson: That's brilliant. What were the biggest challenges in getting those attractions up and running? Obviously from a health and safety point of view, I can imagine that that conversation was like, "We've got this idea about taking people up on the roof, and then dangling them over the side. How do you feel about it?"

    Laura Chiplin: Yeah, exactly. I guess the biggest challenges, firstly, just going back to the stadium tour, so we opened a stadium tour in July, 2019 and the stadium opened in March, 2019. So it was an exceptionally busy time at the club, not only were we opening a new attraction experience, but we were opening a brand new stadium, so it was a rapidly expanding team. We'd been at White Hart Lane, capacity of 36,000. The club had been playing at Wembley, and then we were opening the new Tottenham Hotspur stadium, which has a capacity of over 62,000 and it's a multipurpose venue.

    Laura Chiplin: So, the first priority was obviously to open the stadium, to have Spurs return to playing, and fans return to being at home. So what we needed to do as an attractions team, was to develop and open the tour experience against this backdrop. So, much of our planning was when the stadium was still a construction site, there were thousands of trades working on the stadium a day, it was so, so busy. But what we really wanted to do, was there was so much momentum and it was such an exciting time at the club, so we worked with our colleagues to be involved in that momentum. And how could we get involved in the match day experiences?

    Laura Chiplin: One of the key things the club wanted to deliver with this new stadium was an unrivaled fan experience, and that's what we want to do, an unrivaled fan guest experience on the visitor attraction. So, much of the things that we did when we were setting up, were also aligned with the opening of the stadium. So for example, part of that, we delivered our Spurs Way training to a wide range of people who would be working on a match day. I'm talking people who do sniffer dog patrols, to catering, to retail, and the attractions were very much a part of that. So, that meant that we could be involved with the approach for the stadium, and make sure there was that cohesion and consistency across what we were doing.

    Laura Chiplin: And then on the other side, we also needed to make sure we could actually deliver something with a moving timeline, and work out what we could open realistically, that matched the ambition that delivered a great thing for our guests, and for our visitors and fans. So, we decided to open with a guided stadium tour, and really tell the story of Tottenham and the stadium through people when we first opened. So, that enabled us to incorporate with obviously the focus of opening the stadium, and then deliver the first of the attractions quite quickly after that. And then we knew we would develop them further on.

    Laura Chiplin: And then with the opening of the Skywalk, so all of this was incorporated into the design of the stadium, which is obviously great because we're not retrofitting everything, it's all very much part of the stadium build. So, a lot of those conversations began 10 years ago before I was at the club. So that was very much, that was intrinsically part of the stadium build and design, which obviously always helps.

    Laura Chiplin: I guess, really the biggest challenge from our side, was that we ended up doing a lot of the last four months, yeah, four month period, we were doing it in a lockdown. Because as I've mentioned with the dates, where we've all tried to slightly block out of our minds, we opened the Dare Skywalk at the end, very end of August, 2020. I think we opened it on the 31st of August, that was our first public day. So, much of the things that when you are mobilising a new attraction, that come in that last three to four months, they're very much the onsite, the people, the recruitment, testing, training, all of those things. And that ended up having to be done within the national lockdown, and a very strict national lockdown, as was right of course at the time. But not work from home if you can, it was like everyone was working from home.

    Laura Chiplin: So, we were already very much on the journey in terms of when we were going to open the Skywalk, and then the pandemic happened. So we moved the timeline slightly, it was probably about six, maybe six to eight weeks from what we had originally planned. Obviously you never normally plan to open a new attraction the last day of August, but yeah, we decided that we were still going to open it, and open it when it was safe and we were allowed to do so from a government perspective, and also when we were ready. So, that was the biggest challenge. Loads of people have talked about pandemic challenges on this podcast, and just generally of course, it was a very challenging time. But especially with such a physical attraction, where people are coming and doing an activity, yeah, it brought new challenges.

    Kelly Molson: Oh, I can only imagine how challenging that was. It's interesting though, because it wasn't delayed as much as I thought it was, only six to eight weeks actually. I would have thought, oh, it was going to be months and months and months where you had to keep pushing back. But in the grand scheme of things, that doesn't sound too bad. What were the reactions from visitors, when they were able to come? Was there a pent up demand, because you'd been talking about it for so long?

    Laura Chiplin: Yeah. The reaction was really fantastic, feedback has been really, really positive. The funny thing for us, is that we've been open since the end of August, 2020, but we've never actually done a full year of operation, so that's the difference. And it's like the stadium's been open three years, but we don't have three years worth of experience, because it's been such a fragmented time within that period. We opened in August, we had a good September, then I think October was good. Then we got to the end of October, half term, and then I think we went into the circuit breaker lockdown for November. We then reopened for a bit in December, and then we ended up closing. And then we had that, I think at the time we thought, oh, maybe it's like a month lockdown. And then of course it ended up, I think being until around April.

    Laura Chiplin: And we could open the skywalk earlier, because it's an outdoor traction, so that was a positive, so we were able to get people through. But yeah, the initial reaction and the reaction we've had subsequently, feedback's been really positive, which is great. But it's also on the flip side, we are now I feel in a period where we've had like a good run at things, but we've kind of missed out that first bit that you would normally get with something new, where you're tweaking and perfecting in the traditional sense. Whereas we were tweaking and perfecting. Right, outdoor attractions. Okay, so this is outdoor, but some of our elements are inside. How do we re-look at that to bring them in line, make sure everyone's safe and things?

    Laura Chiplin: But actually, in doing that, we have slightly changed the flow of things, that they actually work better. So we're, of course, obviously looking to constantly improve, constantly tweak, constantly monitoring customer feedback, net promoter scores, Trip Advisor feedback, all of those kinds of traditional things that you would think. But also then having the pandemic side within it as well.

    Kelly Molson: That's really interesting. So, do you think that the kind of stop start challenges that you've had, have actually helped in some way, by making you step back and refine it maybe quicker than you would have?

    Laura Chiplin: Yeah. I guess if we were to take a positive, which I'm always happy to try to have a positive, yes. I think it was obviously very challenging at that time trying to work out. But yeah, I think subsequently we probably have made some tweaks and small updates to the overall visitor flow and operation, which probably worked better, that had we not been forced into that situation they may not have arisen. So yeah, probably a small few things like that.

    Kelly Molson: There's always a positive, isn't there?

    Laura Chiplin: Exactly. I'm desperate to find a silver lining in anything.

    Kelly Molson: I like to find that spin as well. And so, I can remember when we came on our visit, and there was certain hashtags that we could upload our pictures and social media and stuff too, which we did, we loved to get involved. How much has digital and social media played a role in the marketing of that attraction?

    Laura Chiplin: Yeah, hugely. We haven't done any out of home marketing yet, and that was really a decision at the time, because why would you do that when people aren't necessarily traveling in the normal way? So yeah, digital and social were hugely important. We also had a really great launch, which our PR team did, and working with influencers, and key people on social media, and also digital channels to make sure that we could get the message out there, launch it, so that was really fantastic. We always want people to review us on Trip Advisor and share their experiences there. That's a huge thing for us, because obviously with attractions it's so vital, people finding new things to do.

    Laura Chiplin: And especially because of the situation that we've been in, there's obviously a huge market that missing, and that's the international market. And at the beginning, the pandemic and that time, actually people were wanting to go and do things outside of London, and outside of the city. And that was also a concern, especially with the attractions and venues in London, that actually people were going to stay away because they wanted to go to seaside locations, countryside. So yeah, that was really important. And that's something that we're building on, and making sure that we can build on, and again expand to new audiences. So we also used a lot of our own channels at that time as well, and we're really lucky that we've got such a fantastic fan base that we can talk to. And we do have a lot of internal channels that we can use. So that along with digital and social, was a key thing that the marketing teams focused on. And now we're looking to take that, to develop that even further.

    Kelly Molson: Yeah. So I guess now that we're seeing people starting to come back, there's more opportunity to start looking at that international market, and really getting new people through the doors.

    Laura Chiplin: Yeah, absolutely.

    Kelly Molson: What about people coming back? Because this is always a thing with repeat visitors. So an attraction like a theme park, there's annual passes that you can purchase. You might take your kids to that every couple of months depending on where you live, if you're located to it. How do you keep these attractions current, and how do you keep people coming back to do return visits?

    Laura Chiplin: Yeah. It's so important to keep the attractions current, and it's something that we very much focus on. So talking about stadium tours for a bit, so as I mentioned, we opened with a guided stadium tour, but it was always our ambition that we would go to a multimedia guide option. But guided tours perform very well with focus groups, and they perform very well based on feedback. Customers really like guided tours, but it's how we could take those elements and use more of multimedia, the technology that we have in the stadium to help bring in the story to life even further? And also offer more flexibility, and also more personal experiences for our customers, that was something that was really important to us.

    Laura Chiplin: So, we've already done quite a lot of updates to our stadium tour just in that time period, and we have a program of work scheduled to make sure that we can keep things current, keep things fresh. It's really important for us that we can keep using new technologies that are coming out, that maybe we already have in the stadium, or that are perhaps more traditionally attractions focused that we can bring in. We are lucky that we have lots of brilliant spaces in the stadium, and actually to do a whole tour of the stadium, we'd probably be here for about five hours. But it's how we can bring in different areas on the route that people haven't seen before, add new things in, and also looking at certain periods where we might open a space during the summer period, or tying into things like that. So, that's really important for us.

    Laura Chiplin: And then on the Skywalk, so we started with the Skywalk Roof Walk Experience, which I've mentioned. And then the Edge, which is the controlled descent element that opened in summer last year, so we've already added onto the experience within that time. And we're looking at ways in which we can, I guess, use the space that's up there. You've been up there yourself, but for people who haven't, there's actually quite a large viewing platform, so that would really lend itself to events or pop up things, so that we can incorporate things within that experience that are perhaps a bit different.

    Laura Chiplin: And then the other things we are looking at is just how we talk about, and also market the different climb experiences. So for example, coming on a day like today, which actually would be a perfect day, because it's such a nice sunny day with a blue sky. But coming on a day like today, versus coming in the evening, when it's sunset or the stars are out. So, it's how we talk about those different experiences, because it's a different element. Or coming on a match day, so the Dare Skywalk is open up to two hours before kickoff. So as you said, when you came you actually saw the manager at the time, which was a real treat. And it's not saying that, obviously we don't have that every day, but if you come on a match day, obviously that is a completely different experience, and there's lots of activity happening in and around the stadium. Both in the exterior with people arriving, but also when you're looking down into the pitch, that's a different element, as opposed to a day like today where it's probably a bit more calm and quiet down there.

    Kelly Molson: It was super windy the day that we came as well. I've got this video of me, and my hair is like.

    Laura Chiplin: That's just part of the experience.

    Kelly Molson: Yeah, it was great. It was good fun.

    Laura Chiplin: Even more adrenaline.

    Kelly Molson: I'm thinking weddings on the roof. That is a lovely big space up there with the beautiful views. I'm thinking weddings up there.

    Laura Chiplin: Well, we've had quite a few proposals, which is lovely. So yeah, and again with those personalised experiences, so we do proposal packages for people that really want to take that proposal to the next level, no pun intended. But yeah, we have had quite a few up there, which is really lovely, and also a few in the stadium as well. But we are licensed for weddings up there, so if anyone's interested.

    Kelly Molson: Yeah. I'm glad that this is going out after I've just got married, because I'm pretty sure that would have been on Lee's list of venues to do the wedding at. And I love Tottenham, don't get me wrong. Just not sure if I'd want to get married up there.

    Laura Chiplin: A climbing suit and a wedding dress.

    Kelly Molson: It's not a good look for me. Too windy, it would mess up my hair. So, what's next? Are there any more exciting plans for different attractions, or anything new that's coming that you can share with us?

    Laura Chiplin: Yeah, so there are some new things coming. Probably not that I can say right now, but we are looking at a number of new attractions that we could add into our existing experiences. We're also going to be launching later this year, technical tours. So these are quite detailed and specific, but they will give customers another kind of view of the stadium, and really focus on the technical capabilities, the design, the architecture. So, it would take people underneath the pitch pocket, underneath the pitch, so to really get a completely different perspective. So, we're really looking at how we can bring in different interests, again, attract different audiences that perhaps wouldn't necessarily come to go in the dressing room, but they're very interested in the architecture and the design of the stadium. And then yeah, with the Skywalk, as I say, looking at how we can use that space on the roof and how we can incorporate different things into there, to give different experiences to our visitors.

    Kelly Molson: Love it. I'm very excited to see how these new things develop. I do probably need to come back, and be brave, and dangle myself over the side of the building as well. Because that wasn't open when we came, so that was my excuse for not doing it.

    Laura Chiplin: You absolutely do.

    Kelly Molson: Oh God, I don't know. I don't know. I'm actually not that great with heights, but I did feel very safe and secure up there, so I was okay.

    Laura Chiplin: If I can do it, you can do it.

    Kelly Molson: Have you done it?

    Laura Chiplin: Yeah.

    Kelly Molson: Oh, you've got to test them all, of course.

    Laura Chiplin: Of course. Yeah, no, I couldn't possibly not do it. But I also would not naturally dangle myself off the side of Tottenham Hotspur stadium. But I have done it a couple of times, so yeah, you must come back and do it.

    Kelly Molson: That's something to tell, "What did you do at work today?" "Oh, just para-sailed down the side of the building. Standard day in the office."

    Laura Chiplin: Yeah, exactly. Just another day.

    Kelly Molson: I love it. Thank you for coming on and sharing. We're at the end of the podcast, and I always our guests, if they want to share a book that they love. Something that can be work related or just a personal book that they really love to share, what have you got for us?

    Laura Chiplin: So, I'm going down more a personal route. I do love self improvement, I call them self improvement books, but kind of mindset, and I'm really interested in those things. But I was thinking about it, and I was like, sometimes actually just reading a good novel, if you're feeling quite stressed, or you've got a lot on, sometimes just reading a good book can really take you out that headspace. And actually, that's always a good thing. So I really like the writer, David Nichols, so I really love The Understudy. I also really like it because David Nichols used to be an actor before he was a writer, and actually The Understudy is a bit... It's not autobiographical at all, but it does take a bit from, he was an understudy for a long time. And I guess from working in theatrebefore, I just really like that book.

    Laura Chiplin: And that led me to One Day, which you might have seen the film, you might have read the book. But One Day is a really beautiful book, in my opinion, to the point where I'll always pop into a charity shop, I love going into charity shops. And they'll often have it in there, because it was a such a best seller, for a pound or something. So I'll normally pick them up and then just give them to people, for a nice, "Have you read this book?" "No." "Oh, here it is." It's a nice thing to do.

    Kelly Molson: That's really lovely. That's such a nice thing to do, I think giving a book as a gift that you love is such a personal thing to share.

    Laura Chiplin: Yeah, so I've also kind of cheated because I've given you two things, two books. Sorry.

    Kelly Molson: Everyone does this, everyone blows my marketing budget on a weekly basis on this podcast. But thanks.

    Laura Chiplin: You just need to go to the charity shop.

    Kelly Molson: Yes.

    Laura Chiplin: I'll have a copy at home now. I was looking at my bookshelf last night, and I actually have two copies of One Day on there at the moment. So, I should just send you one.

    Kelly Molson: Well, there you go. So if you want to win Laura's book, as ever, if you go over to our Twitter account and you share this announcement, podcast announcement with the words, "I want Laura's book," she's going to send you that. I'll get her to send it directly to you.

    Laura Chiplin: I will.

    Kelly Molson: Thank you, you've saved my marketing budget. It's been so lovely to have you on today. Thank you so much for coming on and sharing. I didn't ask you though, are you actually a massive Tottenham fan?

    Laura Chiplin: I wasn't a Tottenham fan before I started working here. That's what I'll say, but I'm absolutely a Tottenham fan now.

    Kelly Molson: It's evolved, the love is there. Thanks so much for coming on, it's been great to chat to you.

    Laura Chiplin: Thank you so much for having me.

    Kelly Molson: Thanks for listening to Skip the Queue. If you've enjoyed this podcast, please leave us a five star review. It really helps others find us. And remember to follow us on Twitter, for your chance to win the books that have been mentioned. Skip the Queue is brought to you by

    Rubber Cheese, a digital agency that builds remarkable systems and websites for attractions, that helps them increase their visitor numbers. You can find show notes and transcriptions from this episode, and more, over on our website, rubbercheese.com/podcast.

    Download The Visitor Attractions Website Survey Report - https://www.merac.co.uk/download-the-visitor-attractions-survey

     

    We have launched our brand-new playbook: ‘The Retail Ready Guide to Going Beyond the Gift Shop’ — your go-to resource for building a successful e-commerce strategy that connects with your audience and drives sustainable growth.

     

    Download your FREE copy here

    33 min
  • Visitor Experience restructure at Tate, with David Hingley

    Skip the Queue is brought to you by Rubber Cheese, a digital agency that builds remarkable systems and websites for attractions that helps them increase their visitor numbers. Your host is Kelly Molson, MD of Rubber Cheese.

    Download our free ebook The Ultimate Guide to Doubling Your Visitor Numbers

    If you like what you hear, you can subscribe on iTunes, Spotify, and all the usual channels by searching Skip the Queue or visit our website rubbercheese.com/podcast
    If you've enjoyed this podcast, please leave us a five star review, it really helps others find us. And remember to follow us on Twitter for your chance to win the books that have been mentioned in this episode.

    Competition ends April 29th 2022. The winner will be contacted via Twitter.

    Show references:

    https://www.linkedin.com/in/david-hingley-58471524/

    https://www.tate.org.uk/

    https://twitter.com/David_Hingley

    David Hingley has over 20 years experience leading large teams in delivering customer and visitor experience.

    A lifelong lover of history (honestly there used to be a badge for that in cubs and that’s where it all started), David followed a history degree by joining the graduate trainee scheme at Sainsbury’s before moving on to a number of roles in Marks and Spencer, ending up running a department store when they were still fashionable. Having been told during a career development conversation that a future desire to ‘run a castle’ was a daydream not a career plan - David was able to combine his passion for history with transferrable retail skills in the role of Head of Operations at Hampton Court Palace for Historic Royal Palaces. During this time he worked on projects such as the 2012 Olympic cycling time trial, the 2014 Poppies installation at the Tower of London, and the Magic Garden. He is currently Head of Visitor Experience at Tate Modern and Tate Britain which, thanks to Covid, has involved a lot more discussion about one-way routes, Perspex screens and face-coverings than the initial application process suggested.

    As well as Tate, David’s a Trustee at Painshill Park, an average runner and a keen reader and walker.

    He believes that ‘people make places’ and it’s the shared enjoyment of unique sites by the volunteers and staff who care for them, and the visitors that make their memories there, that ensure they continue to thrive.

    Transcription:

    Kelly Molson: Welcome to Skip The Queue, a podcast for people working in or working with visitor attractions. I'm your host, Kelly Molson. Each episode, I speak with industry experts from the attractions world.

    In today's episode, I speak with David Hingley, Head of Visitor Experience at Tate. We discuss the visitor experience restructure at Tate, why people make places and how visitor experience makes crazy ideas happen.

    If you like what you hear, subscribe on iTunes, Spotify and all the usual channels by searching Skip The Queue.

    Kelly Molson: David, thank you so much for coming on the podcast today. It's lovely to see you.

    David Hingley: Great to see you. Thanks for having me on.

    Kelly Molson: Well as ever, we are going straight to icebreaker questions. I would like to know if you could live anywhere in the world for a year, where would it be?

    David Hingley: At the moment, I think I would like to live... This will be popular with some people I know... in Iceland. It's because we went years ago on a whale watching trip to Iceland in the coast, and it was fantastic. Ever since, I've wanted to go back, it is just completely different to anywhere else I've been on, I think, on the planet. A week wasn't enough.

    Kelly Molson: Totally agree with you. We went... Oh, 2017, maybe around then. Absolutely spectacular. Like you say, so different to anywhere that we'd ever experienced before. Bonkers, bonkers snow and weather and just everything is icy, but magic. Absolutely magic.

    David Hingley: Yeah and the belief in that magic as well. It's the whole mythology and stuff that's going on there, but also I loved... At the end of it all, we were in the back of beyond for a lot of the trip, obviously, but we're in Reykjavík. I think it was 20 degrees, and everyone was complaining how hot it was. We went to this little coffee shop. It was all as if you were in the busiest part of London, but there were honestly maybe three, four people there. It was, "You're in the big city now. This is how we roll." I just love that.

    Kelly Molson: While we're on this subject, did you eat the fermented shark?

    David Hingley: Yes, not much. Not very much at all.

    Kelly Molson: So bad. Yeah, so bad.

    David Hingley: We had a tour guide who was very keen that we did, and we did the very British polite thing, but it was not good.

    Kelly Molson: Was not for me, David, either. Okay. Would you rather be a super hero, and what would be your superhero talent, or the world's best chef?

    David Hingley: I feel like my family would say that if I was the world's best chef, that would be a super talent, compared with where we are at the moment. I'm not really sure about being a superhero. I think I'd rather be a chef. There's a lot rests on you as a superhero. I'm not sure. Especially after the last few years, I'm not sure I could deal with it. I think to be a chef and have people come and enjoy the food, that'd be great. I'm not sure how my signature dish of Toad in the Hole followed by like a kind of version of school dinners, chocolate concrete and custard would go down, but I'm sure I could deconstruct it.

    Kelly Molson: The Toad in a Hole sounds okay. The rest that came afterwards, let's just park that, shall we? Okay. I don't ask enough people this, and I should, but often it's like asking what your favourite child is. But what is your favourite attraction?

    David Hingley: Oh, that is...

    Kelly Molson: It's a hard one, isn't it?

    David Hingley: I think a lot of it's down to what your mood is at the time. It's predictable. I would probably go for Hampton Court. I know I've worked there, but I do... The reason I say that is even though I kind of know how it's done, I still love going back and visiting it. I can properly enjoy it as a visitor now because I was a visitor before, then I worked there. Now, I'm a visitor again. It's still got something about it because there's so many different facets to it with the gardens or the kind of... It's family friendly. It's got all the history. So yeah, that would be my favourite attraction.

    Kelly Molson: That's good. That's good that you can step away from it, having worked there because I think sometimes that might ruin it a little bit for you. It's good that it still got the magic. Great answer. Thank you very much. All right. It's time for your unpopular opinion. What have you prepared for us?

    David Hingley: I feel quite strongly that Ant & Dec's early work was their superior period. As much as I know the nation loves Ant & Dec, I think you look back on Let's Get Ready To Rumble, I think... The fact that when they revisited that it went... Everyone was so pleased. For me, that shows the quality was there from the start. I think growing up Grange Hill might have done Just Say No To Drugs, which was very laudable, but Ant & Dec were in Biker Grove. We got that warning about the dangers of paintball. For anyone in my generation that had to go on a lot of management away days, where people thought it'd be fun if we did stuff like paintball, I think that kind of early warning was important. And, yeah, Wonky Donkey, I mean, you're never going to beat that.

    Kelly Molson: Oh my God. Wonky donkey is the best.

    David Hingley: Yeah.

    Kelly Molson: I mean, there's nothing like an aggressive Dec, is there? Nothing. It's glorious.

    David Hingley: Saturday morning with a bit of a hangover watching them basically losing it with kids, who are trying to answer a very simple question. I mean, I don't know why they don't bring that back on Saturday Takeaway or something like that. I just think it would... I do think it's a superior period. I mean, I like what they do now, but I think they've lost some of the edge. Got to be honest.

    Kelly Molson: I agree with you, David. I am completely on the same page with you. Ant & Dec were... They're like my little heroes that I grew up with. I actually saw them perform Let's Get Ready To Rumble live once at an under 18s gig in Romford.

    David Hingley: Wow.

    Kelly Molson: I don't know why that was important, but yeah, it was a great, great moment. Really great moment. Thank you. Let's see what our listeners feel. Please tweet me. Let me know how you feel about Ant & Dec's earlier work and whether they should bring back Wonky Donkey obviously. Right, David, let's get onto the serious stuff. I'd like to know a little bit about your background. You alluded to the fact that you've worked in other attractions as well. So tell us about your background and where you're at too now.

    David Hingley: My background's kind of fairly mixed and quite a lot of different things. Years ago... My daughter reminds me years ago. Years ago, I did a degree in history. Absolutely loved it. My parents always said, "You know what'll happen with that? You'll end up working in a shop," because nobody knows what to do with a degree in history. So I proved them right and went and worked in shops. I worked for Sainsbury's on the graduate training scheme. I thought I'd do it for 12 months, just get some great knowledge, and then I'll move on.

    David Hingley: I did that for seven years, did different jobs there, night shift managers, fruit and veg managers, that kind of stuff because I just like working with the people. Then I went work for M&S when running department stores was still a thing. God, I spent seven years with M&S. I was a food hall manager because that's what they do with anyone who's come from supermarkets. I worked in some really interesting shops. I worked in the Kings Road, which is quite a fancy place, obviously. Ken High Street, where we used to have flamingos on the roof because the roof gardens were above us, so that was quite cool. Then Marble Arch and Oxford Street.

    David Hingley: But all the time I was thinking I'd really like to do something that I felt more at home with. I was reading my history books on my breaks. Then Hampton Court advertised for a head of visitor services, I think it was. I thought, "I'll give that a go." I stuck my CV in and yeah, I was successful. I got the job, which feels like a real cheat, because I know how hard people work and. I feel like I had loads of transferable skills, and the organisation took a bit of a flyer on me.

    David Hingley: I know that's true because on the first morning when I started, I was having a coffee with the director, and he's very... You can imagine, all the rooms at Hampton Court are very grand. It was quite a grand room. He just said, "It's amazing who comes out top of these recruitment processes, isn't it?"

    Kelly Molson: "Oh, thanks."

    David Hingley: ... which I think was well meant. Then I got to work at Hampton Court. It was head of visitor services and it became head of operations. As those roles always change names. Then we had the Olympics, the Jubilee. We had the Magic Garden opened, which was massive for Hampton Court. The kids' garden opened. I was involved with the Tower of London when they did the poppies in the moat as well.

    Kelly Molson: Oh, amazing.

    David Hingley: Remember the delivery of every one of those because that was part of the team I was involved in, delivering them for like a year afterwards. Then I did a bit of time at Landmark Trust, where I was the Chief Operating Officer. They've got about 200 historic buildings all over the country, rescue them. If they're not big enough to be a tourist attraction, you can get the keys to a castle and stay there for a weekend, which is amazing, but they don't like you popping in to see how their holidays going, those visitors, so you miss all the... I missed all the kind of visitor interaction.

    David Hingley: Then the Tate role came up, which is Tate Britain and Tate Modern and working with the teams, looking after the day-to-day visitor experience. I've been doing that for a couple of years, although sometimes feels like it is longer given the last year and a bit.

    Kelly Molson: Imagine. Yeah, I could imagine.

    David Hingley: That's really potted history of how I ended up where I am.

    Kelly Molson: So it's Tate and Tate... Sorry, Tate Modern and Tate Britain.

    David Hingley: Yes.

    Kelly Molson: What does a typical day for you look like then? Are you rushing from one to the other and working out what the hell's going on?

    David Hingley: Not as much as it used to be, thanks to Zoom. Used to spend quite a bit of time on the boat going between the two sites. Anyone who works at Tate would tell you, it's quite nice if you've got to go from Tate Modern to Tate Britain from me. You can get the boat because you feel like a tourist for that 25 minutes. I know this sounds like every glossy catalog, but there isn't a typical day. Whilst my teams are making sure the doors are open, all the exhibitions are staffed and we're all looking ready to go and everything, my job is kind of 50% thinking about what's going on at the moment. I often say I have to think about the worst day out anyone can have and then stop that happening. In the last year with COVID, how do you open sites with COVID and make sure they're still fun?

    David Hingley: Then the other 50%'s kind of looking at what's coming next. Typical days can be in the mornings, I could be in meetings about exhibitions that are going to open up at Tate Britain or Tate Modern in next kind of two years, 12 months or just around the corner. Then there's all the stuff around looking after the team, one to ones with colleagues, look after the senior teams at each site, planning what we're going to do to kind of train everybody up on whatever's coming next, all of the business continuity planning stuff, making sure that we're operating safely, thinking about risk assessments, kind of all the-

    Kelly Molson: All the fun stuff.

    David Hingley: All the fun stuff, yeah. I say if it's kind of tricky, tedious or terrifying, it's probably going to fall into the operations teams part. Not in a bad way because we like doing all that stuff, but yeah, a mix of project planning, thinking about how we work with the programming teams and bring that to life and then looking after our own teams day to day and making sure they've got what they need to get through a day and operate smoothly.

    Kelly Molson: I can only imagine how reactive that has needed to be over the past 18 months and potentially the next few months to come.

    David Hingley: Yeah. Constantly. I think the trick is kind of finding the spot as well between being reactive and trying to be proactive, which has been even harder in the last year because many of us don't know what's going to happen until the evening before, do we?

    Kelly Molson: No. No. Then you found out from Bernard in his updates rather than the government.

    David Hingley: Yeah. Bernard and his flowers and his updates.

    Kelly Molson: Yeah, yeah. Famous flowers. We've been emailing backwards and forth and talking about different topics for the podcast. One of the things that you mentioned that I think is really interesting is about the visitor experience restructure that you were looking at at Tate. You said it actually accelerated a not-change program. Talk us through what you mean by that because I'd love to understand, one, how that came about and, two, what it kind of looks like.

    David Hingley: Yeah. Kind of fortunate, unfortunate, I took the job about two and a half years ago. So I didn't have that long really before COVID to get my head around the two sites, Tate, the way things worked, but when I started, the role was very much... It was a slight rejigging of roles as happens in organisations. Was talking to obviously the team that recruited me about what it was they wanted from the role. It was about moving from, if you like, a more traditional visitor service, visitor operations to engagement.

    David Hingley: Engagement was a big word that was used a lot. I don't think any of us were quite sure exactly what that meant. It was quite terrifying for some of the team not because they can't do it, but because the word was used a lot. The team were like, "Well, we do engage with people. We talk to people all the time," or, "We were taken on as gallery assistants back in the day when engagement would mean telling someone to back off if they got too close to a painting because it was our job to protect the stuff."

    David Hingley: It was always going to be about looking at how we could change the way that we worked as a team because Tate obviously used to millions of visitors, operated very smoothly. I mean, you go in and do your kind of casing the joint before you go for the interview. You can see there's kind of a well oiled machine, but one of the things is that it can be quite hot and cold as you go around the building. You can have brilliant individual interactions and then they've asked buildings... There's other areas where you don't meet anyone.

    Kelly Molson: Right.

    David Hingley: How can you help a thinly spread team to embody the place and have confidence and get it right for all kinds of visitors? From a visitor to Tate Modern's wandered in off the South Bank just to have a look around because they're curious, to someone who's come to Tate Britain on a mission to see a particular painting because that's what they want to see. That's their day out.

    David Hingley: I call it a bit of a not change program because it deliberately didn't do a change program. I think as soon as you start saying like, "I'm the new person. I'm here to do a change program," it terrifies people quite often. Everybody knows that if somebody new turns up when there's a new structure, that there is going to be change. So rather than labeling it in that way, what I did and what my team did and what we agreed to do was to work collectively on what that needed to look like because many of the visitor assistants, they knew what they wanted to do differently.

    David Hingley: It was a case of doing a lot of... I don't know. It sounds kind of slightly old hat, but focus groups, discussion groups with those teams to just tease out of them what great service looked like, what got in the way of delivering it, how they would like things to be different and then being able to almost play that back to the teams and use that to shape the changes that we were going to make. You can write a lot of that down in advance on the back of an envelope, if you like, because you genuinely know what people feel makes a good experience or you can generally guess what the barriers are going to be.

    David Hingley: But it's about making sure you've uncovered that all as a team. We really took... Tate, fortunately for me, had just had some new values that they've been working on, again, as an organisation around being kind, rigorous, open and bold. What we were able to do was we were able to say... Well, I was able to say, "I'm not sure how a painting or a piece of art is kind, but I know how a person can do that if I come in as a visitor and I'm looking a bit lost or my kids desperately need the toilet and I need to find it first.

    David Hingley: We took on thinking about how we, as people, embody Tate's values and really pulling it all back to that, which on the one hand, can sound a bit corporate, but actually I think it was really important that we... What we wanted to do was build a common language and a way of talking, so we could sort of hold ourselves to account and work out whether we'd had a good day or not.

    Kelly Molson: It's interesting because when you talk about it like that, from the aspect of our values, it feels very much that the visitor experience is... It's almost about giving... It's giving people the allowance to do what they need to do at that time. We had Liz Power on from Water And Steam a few weeks ago. That was one of the things that she spoke about in her team is that she empowers them to make the right decision about a circumstance. That might be somebody gets to give a free ticket away to somebody for them and their family. That, to me, sounds very similar to what you're talking about.

    David Hingley: Yeah. I think it is about that. It can be really hard, particularly in big institutions where you've got people, let's be honest, standing in certain spaces and galleries... I mean, that's part of the insurance and the fire evacuation, right? That's what's led to a person being stood there, first and foremost. You've got to do that and it's really important, but then how can you enable that person still to kind of bring themselves... A lot of my team, they're highly skilled. A lot of them are artists. This is another job that they do. It's how you can enable them to bring that to an institution and yet still kind of have a feel of like, "Okay, this is Tate. This is what Tate feels like."

    Kelly Molson: Yeah. How difficult was this to do because I guess, did this start just before the pandemic?

    David Hingley: We started just before the pandemic with all my kind of like... Having talked to everybody, we kind of set the direction. There was this brilliant five-year plan because we all [inaudible 00:17:39]. "And this is what we're going to do in year one."

    Kelly Molson: Then it got ripped into tiny little pieces.

    David Hingley: Absolutely. It was hard. Most of the core team were furloughed because we weren't open. So I think what we did, those of us who were still in, was we kind of already pitched where we were going to the team. Then we were able to... In one sense, alongside planning how to reopen, we were allowed to do a lot of work on what kind of material we needed, training materials, what kind of... Just going back on basic stuff like we have a handbook for people. Just getting that all tidied up. It kind of really captured the role.

    David Hingley: Then we were already thinking about what change to the job role we would want to make because the key change, I think, in terms of the restructures actually have been keen to make sure people understand the skills involved in being a gallery assistant, for example. We call it visitor engagement assistant now. We do laugh and say that all of our jobs have gained an extra letter. The visitor engagement managers are now visitor engagement and operations managers because that shows the breadth of their job. We have redone everybody's job descriptions based on the fact that as time's gone on, people have taken on a lot more of the kind of security aspects. The duty management aspects become bigger.

    David Hingley: People are more demanding. We deal with more incidents than we used to in the past. For the visitor assistants, there were seven things on their job description, which I think somebody thought was kind of, "Let's keep it nice and simple and have some basic stuff on there," but actually it meant a lot of the time, the team were... The team themselves said they felt they were defined by what they weren't. We were able to take some of those ideas and suggestions that they had and incorporate them into a job description and have that ready for when they returned. Then when we returned and we were back in the galleries, then we'd be in again, doing same process. We went through what the proposed changes were, what that would mean and getting people to buy into it and agree to it.

    Kelly Molson: Do you think that that was harder to do because of the pandemic, trying to get people motivated to make those changes?

    David Hingley: Physically harder to do? Everything's been hard, I think, from a mental health point of view for people in terms of the backwards and forward of the pandemic, but I think some of the changes that potentially people would've seen as major actually in the scheme of all our lives and what's happened in the last year and a bit, people were... They're almost like, "Oh gosh, is this all you want me to do?"

    Kelly Molson: "Phew."

    David Hingley: I also think one thing that's helped a lot is during the period when we've been in and out... At the moment, we've got people working from home, largely if they can office based. Most of my team, we're in most of the time... So my team have to be in all the time. You can only do your job face to face.

    Kelly Molson: Yeah.

    David Hingley: But it really showed how... It sounds daft because it's obvious, but it really showed how important those teams are and the weight that they take on. We found that because there's been a, "What's the latest legislation? How does it work... And you go to the operational teams because they're dealing with it all the time. The teams get much more listened to than we perhaps did in the past because it's been really necessary and really important. I think the organisation as a whole never intended not to listen to those teams, but I think it's just kind of fine tuned the need to hear what's said and what the experience is on the ground.

    Kelly Molson: Yeah. It's really interesting. How have you been able to test the impact of the program? You've been open for pockets of time, obviously clearly open at the moment. Let's hope that that continues. How have you been able to test it with the general public?

    David Hingley: Yeah. There's a few things that we've done. We've started doing a mystery visitor. I mean, that's not groundbreaking. Loads of people do it, but I think it's good to have kind of a snapshot. We started to do that before we ran some of our training. We worked with a company called the Whole Story on our customer engagement style, if you like. We ran sessions on that before we reopened last time from the last lockdown. We were able to benchmark where we were before and where we are now. We've seen positive movements. We're in a good place, we're in a better place.

    Kelly Molson: Great.

    David Hingley: Especially around consistency. The feedback we get from... Visitors because we've had booked tickets, which we haven't had before for the free collection. So there are issues with that, but one of the positives is we ask people for feedback afterwards and we get really good rates of response. Those responses have been... We saw them become more positive over time.

    David Hingley: I think part of that is because we've got better with our COVID measures and some of that, but also positive comments about staff and what they're doing. I think there's another element of reopening after the first lockdown, certainly, we did have visitors in tears because they were seeing staff again that they hadn't seen for ages. It just been spaces. I think that probably gave some of the team confidence to realise that they do play a significant part in people's lives, even if those people don't spend a lot of time interacting, don't know them by name. Some of them, they do, but that's kind of reaffirmed the importance. We've seen more positive comments definitely, and I think that is testament to how hard the team have all worked as well actually because it's been a tough time generally.

    Kelly Molson: Yeah. What an amazing reaction though. Isn't that just lovely? I mean, that really showcases how important people are.

    David Hingley: Yeah, yeah, absolutely.

    Kelly Molson: What tips would you give other organisations attractions that are thinking about going through this process?

    David Hingley: Again, it's tried and tested, but definitely over communicating all the time. I mean, I'm not going to say... Obviously there've been times when some of the stuff we've been doing has not been so popular with some of the team, and I kind of understand that. I think it was important to hear that and to be honest about what I could change and what I couldn't change. I do think there's a point around when it didn't go well. I could think of at least one occasion where I stuffed up when I just went out to everybody and went, "Do you know what? I stuffed up. There was an email you shouldn't have received... It wasn't a particularly batting, but... You shouldn't have received that email timing wise." I wanted to make sure that I communicated things differently, but I did the classic thing and sent it to the wrong people.

    David Hingley: I just went straight out and to everybody, "I stuffed up," and a lot of the team came back and said, "We really respect that." Then we just quickly arranged meetings afterwards. I think we did listen, and we made changes to the proposals in some areas. So if I take this idea of more engagement, I know some of the team have worked with us for over 20 years, and they're fantastic, and we don't want to lose them. But what we're asking them to do is very different from what they signed up for. I think we would... I used to joke.. I still do that... that some people were worried that engagement meant kind of almost juggling in front of their favourite painting.

    David Hingley: It doesn't. If you've been there for 20 years and you've seen Tate Britain evolve or Tate Modern from when it opened, those people have got great stories to tell. What we've got, for example, in one of the job descriptions is there's almost kind of three options where it's like if you want to be someone who knows the history of the building and shares it with people, build that up and do that. That's your interaction, but that'll be what you work on. If you want to give a talk in front of people, great, you can work on that. We need people like that. It's part of our recruitment process now. We'd recruit people who wanted to do that.

    David Hingley: But if you're someone who joined us before then, and that's not your thing, but you've got years and years of research, as some of my team do, then you can, by all means, provide that content for somebody else to deliver the talk for you. So trying to just, I suppose... Again, it's an element of being realistic and working with the team you've got because none of us are great at everything. So long as we've got all the bases covered and everybody's kind of pulling their weight, that's what we're trying to create.

    Kelly Molson: Yeah. It's playing to everybody's strengths using, everybody's talents in the best possible way and not by making anyone feel excluded because they're not comfortable standing up in front of an audience and delivering or that's just not their bag, but they have got the knowledge.

    David Hingley: Yeah.

    Kelly Molson: And someone else can do that for them as well. I really love that idea of being able to collaborate with people to share your experiences. Fantastic. Is this leading anywhere? I feel like this change program could be rolled out elsewhere, couldn't it?

    David Hingley: Yeah. Well, I really have been talking to colleagues. I really feel that we're in a tough time. We're all going to be struggling in different ways and in different contexts with things like budgets. It's always hard to get people off the floor to do training. It's something that we've struggled with for a long time. One of the things I'm keen to do is to work with other institutions and say this is the range of training programs we're running for front of house teams at Tate. What are you doing? Where's there some crossover. If we've got a room and we can get five people in it... And you've got a couple of people that want to come along and see what that's like, well, why don't we start to pair up? I don't think there's enough.

    David Hingley: I know different organisations have done it at different times, but I think if you want to change the way we look at front of house teams, it's quite hard. You can be starting your career. You might start as a visitor engagement assistant at Tate, and it might not be where you want to be long term, but often people can get stuck there and think, "Well, how do I get to the next place? It's hard when you're in that role as well to network, et cetera." If we can open up opportunities for someone to go and do a few shifts at a different site, for example, and I can kind of backfill and swap it around between us... Because we know our teams have got very similar skills, then I feel like that's something that we could really be doing more of. Organisations like Tate, we've got an opportunity to help to do that.

    Kelly Molson: Love that. It's building on what we've seen in the sector throughout the whole of the pandemic, isn't it? That kind of collaboration that's really come through and it's been there. It has been there to a certain extent, but it's been so much deeper whilst the pandemic has been going on, everybody helping each other. Something that you said about the networking thing when people are in those kind of entry-level roles, that's something that we spoke out with Rachel and Carlton quite a long time ago, actually right towards the beginning of the pandemic about the Visitor Experience Forum.

    Kelly Molson: That was the reason that that organisation was kind of set up to be able to give that platform to some of those audiences as well. I can definitely see the benefits of what you are suggesting. The organisations working together for the greater good. I think that's a fantastic idea. That comes back to something else that you talked about as well when we were emailing. I love that segue so well in there, but you said you'd like people to understand that visitor engagement is a career choice.

    David Hingley: Yeah.

    Kelly Molson: Your quote was "People make places, visitor engagement make crazy ideas happen."

    David Hingley: Yeah.

    Kelly Molson: I love this. I love this. Where's this come from?

    David Hingley: People make places, and my team now roll their eyes and repeat. Everybody repeats it, which is great actually because that's... But it comes from years ago when I worked at M&S actually. It's where it kind of triggered the idea. I don't think they used the phrase, but we went to... They used to do big conferences back in the day and get the store managers along. They showed this big black and white film. It was our latest store that was about to open. It was all black and white. It all looked beautiful, but it was all black and white.

    David Hingley: Then they put the people in, which was the staff and the customers, and they turned it all to colour. It was like a goosebump moment, which it's supposed to be, but it did stick with me. Then when I started working in the heritage sector... It's not a criticism, but I think it is genuinely surprising to me how many areas of the organisation just don't... Because they don't interact with people in the same way, they're not out there seeing what the visitors are doing. Sometimes I bet that's a blessing for them. Sometimes I think they're really missing out, but we've all got our jobs to do.

    David Hingley: I think there was a real... When I get emails... When we get emails in, and it's emails now rather than letters. It's never like, "I came... Well, very rarely is it, "I came to Tate and the art was amazing," because like that's a given. You come to Tate, you expect the... You might not like it, might not be to your taste, but you know it's a certain standard or the buildings were amazing. You expect the buildings to be amazing. Hampton Court, same thing. It's a palace. It's going to look good.

    David Hingley: But people write in and say, "I met Frank" or, "I met James, and he told me why he loved this painting," or a story about this room. Or he opened a hidden door and showed my child what was through there. That's what sticks with people. It's the thing that you don't immediately come up on your Google search or isn't in the guidebook, those are the kind of moments where memories get made. Bernard always says staff, not stuff. I think it's a version of that really. It's like the stuff's important, but the people make the interaction, and they're what you come back for.

    David Hingley: That's that element. It is definitely a career. I know lots of people join front of house teams, and they want to get on and work in other areas of heritage, culture attractions. That's absolutely fine, but I think we need to be quite honest about where we can get people. We managed to get to a point when I was at Hampton Court, where at the end of a summer season quite a lot of our staff would get stolen by interpretation or membership or other teams because they knew they were good with people. That's great, but there's only a limited number of opportunities.

    David Hingley: I used to say to people you can't hang around in the Great Hall at Hampton Court and hope that Lucy Worsley's going to pluck you for obscurity and make you curator because that isn't how it works. It's about people using their in to kind of look at where they want to go and to understand what they might need to do to get other roles rather than... It's just a bit disingenuous to lead people thinking if they work really hard front of house, that they're definitely going to get a different role.

    David Hingley: But then I would also encourage people to stay front of house, stay in the teams that I get to work in because I look at the meetings in other people's diaries. I say I don't have a typical day. I don't know many other people that get to go along and talk about future acquisitions for Tate in terms of paintings, go along to what's the next project that's coming up, hear about what a curator's working on next, then be in a meeting about membership. The variety, you get to stick your oar in everywhere when you work in visitor experience. That's cool.

    David Hingley: We used to have museum studies group come every year to Hampton Court. I always used to think if I can convert just one of those 35 people who are all hoping to become curators or similar to operations, then that's like a win. That's where the crazy ideas happen thing comes in. You can dispute whether the ideas are crazy, but I've been in meetings where somebody says, "We're going to plant 888,246 poppies in the Tower of London moat and then sell them around the world," and everyone's gone, "Really?" Or, "We're going to have a pie that opens up every day and the kids are going to jump out of it in front of Elizabeth the first. The kid that's going to go in the pie is going to be one of the visitor's kids."

    David Hingley: "Oh right, okay. That's safeguarding risk assessment." "We built a dragon that gave out steam in the kid's garden." There's all kinds of issues there you've got to think about. I think operations teams can be seen as people that say no quite a lot, and sometimes there's good reasons, but actually the job is more yes if or how do we do that? I think it's a really creative job and people don't see it like that.

    Kelly Molson: That needs to go on your job ads, doesn't it? "Come and work with the team that puts children into pies."

    David Hingley: Yeah.

    Kelly Molson: Maybe not. Maybe not so much like that, but that's part and parcel of it, isn't it? I spoke to Kate Nicholls from UK hospitality about the real challenge that we've got at the moment with recruitment in that sector. I think it's about making the best of it. It's about finding those hooks that make it an interesting place to be and to explain the career path. Actually a lot of front of house, they might only be thinking one way. They might be relatively narrow minded in the sense of that's the way that they see their career going, where it's about showcasing all of these brilliant things that they could go on and do, but making it fun and making it interesting. some of the things that you've just described, I wouldn't have even put in the operations hat?

    David Hingley: Yeah. I think this is it because operations are so different at different places as well. You kind of have operations experience, business services, engagement, and they're all so different. Some people doing my job are looking after all of the maintenance as well. I've done the job where I've looked after security. At the moment, I work with security. I don't have to look after them. So often it is configured around what it isn't. It's really clear what a curatorial job is, for example. I'm not picking on it. It just is really clear. If you ask most members of the public who works in a museum, the first thing they'll say is a curator understandably.

    Kelly Molson: Yeah.

    David Hingley: But they don't really appreciate all the different jobs that surround that. I think that's a problem because then people think it's not the place for them.

    Kelly Molson: Yeah.

    David Hingley: If you want a more diverse workforce, it's about saying, "Well, these are the opportunities we've got. This is the stuff we do."

    Kelly Molson: Yeah, absolutely. Brilliant. David, thank you. I've really enjoyed this talk. We always end the podcast with a book recommendation from our guests. Something that they love or something that's helped shape their career in some way. It can be anything. What have you got for us today?

    David Hingley: I had a real think about this. It's tricky. I always recommend any book by John Falk. Got one here at the moment. He's just got one out called the Value Of Museums. You've probably come across him. I'm sure quite a lot of people will have come across him. I think he writes brilliantly about not just museums, but about all the kind of baggage that we all bring on our visit. I think he really, in his writing, gets that when somebody rocks up, we do a lot of work on things like personas all of us, but you can be in a different persona depending on who you come with. My experience when I used to take my daughter when she was small round somewhere would be that I'd see the whole exhibition at a million miles an hour, maybe read one label because then we're off to get a brownie and a cup of tea.

    David Hingley: But if I went on my day off on my own, could be there for two hours. It could be a completely different visit. I think he really gets that in his writing. I think he really kind of sums up the operational side of it. Then I've got a slightly off the wall one, which is Dylan Thomas. The Dylan Thomas Omnibus has his broadcasting about... He just used to do weekly broadcasts. I pulled one out because he's got a bit about the Festival of Britain Exhibition in 1951.

    Kelly Molson: Right.

    David Hingley: He's just totally gets what visitors are like. I didn't know whether I could read you just a paragraph of it.

    Kelly Molson: Please do.

    David Hingley: Pitch people if you work in visitor attractions, look it up. He talks about visitor flow basically. This is the exhibition in 1951. It says, "Most people who wish, at the beginning anyway, to make sense of the exhibition follow the course indicated in the official guidebook, a series of conflicting arrows, which lead many visitors who cannot understand these things splash dash into the Thames. And work their way dutifully right through the land of Britain, the glaciers of 20,000 years ago, the inferno of blown desert sand, which is now Birmingham, out at last to the Pavilion of Health, where perhaps they stop for an envious moment at the sign that says euthanasia." It just goes on. It talks about levitating doors and basically how people prefer the cafe to the rest of the site. It's like four or five pages, but I would recommend looking it up. I can't find it anywhere else.

    Kelly Molson: Oh, that's brilliant. Yeah, he really did get it, didn't he?

    David Hingley: Wasted as a poet.

    Kelly Molson: David, thank you so much. Listen as ever, if you'd like to win a copy of David's books... Are there two books there? Two books?

    David Hingley: Yeah. I've got two books. Yeah.

    Kelly Molson: There's two. If you'd like to win a copy of David's books, as ever, go over to our Twitter account and retweet this episode announcement with the words "I want David's books", then you will be in for a chance of winning them. David, thank you for coming on. What's next? Is it all rolled out now, everything's working?

    David Hingley: Now is the fun bit I hope. We keep talking about 2022. Let's hope with where we are at the moment with the virus, but now is the bit where we can really concentrate on the team. We've got the team all in place. We've kind of got them the job roles that they kind of deserve and hopefully the recognition. Now should be the bit where we can really develop the people. Our aim is we know it's been a success, we've said if everybody wants to steal our staff, but nobody wants to leave. That's kind of the challenge. By the end of the year, the next year, that's where I want to be.

    Kelly Molson: All right. Well, come on at the end of next year and tell me how that worked out. I hope all your staff are still with you, but they're being poached like crazy.

    David Hingley: Yeah. Fingers crossed.

    Kelly Molson: Thanks ever so much, David.

    David Hingley: Thanks very much.

    Kelly Molson: Thanks for listening to Skip The Queue. If you've enjoyed this podcast, please leave us a five-star review. It really helps others find us. And remember to follow us on Twitter for your chance to win the books that have been mentioned. Skip The Queue is brought to you by

    Rubber Cheese, a digital agency that builds remarkable systems and websites for attractions that helps them increase their visitor numbers. You can find show notes and transcriptions from the episode and more over on our website, rubbercheese.com/podcast.

    Download The Visitor Attractions Website Survey Report - https://www.merac.co.uk/download-the-visitor-attractions-survey

     

    We have launched our brand-new playbook: ‘The Retail Ready Guide to Going Beyond the Gift Shop’ — your go-to resource for building a successful e-commerce strategy that connects with your audience and drives sustainable growth.

     

    Download your FREE copy here

    40 min
  • The fight for talent with Kate Nicholls, CEO of UKHospitality

    Skip the Queue is brought to you by Rubber Cheese, a digital agency that builds remarkable systems and websites for attractions that helps them increase their visitor numbers. Your host is Kelly Molson, MD of Rubber Cheese.

    Download our free ebook The Ultimate Guide to Doubling Your Visitor Numbers

    If you like what you hear, you can subscribe on iTunes, Spotify, and all the usual channels by searching Skip the Queue or visit our website rubbercheese.com/podcast
    If you've enjoyed this podcast, please leave us a five star review, it really helps others find us. And remember to follow us on Twitter for your chance to win the books that have been mentioned in this episode.

    Competition ends April 29th 2022. The winner will be contacted via Twitter.

    Show references:

    https://www.ukhospitality.org.uk/

    https://twitter.com/UKHospKate

    https://www.linkedin.com/in/kate-nicholls-093b0514/

    Kate Nicholls is CEO of UKHospitality, the powerful voice representing the broad hospitality sector, having previously worked as CEO and Strategic Affairs Director of the ALMR.

    In July 2019, Kate was appointed Chair of the Tourism Alliance, the membership organisation for the tourism industry comprising of leading trade associations/trade bodies within the sector. Kate is also Chair of Mayor of London’s Night Time Commission and is also a member of the Events Industry Board, London Food Board, Tourism Industry Council, Cultural Cities Enquiry, London & Partners Members Group and the Advisory Board for the Institute for Industrial Strategy.

    After gaining a degree in English and a post-graduate diploma in competition law, Kate worked as a researcher in the House of Commons and European Parliament before joining Whitbread as Government Relations Manager, starting her career in hospitality in 1993. Kate was Director at one of the largest independent public affairs companies, working with a number of hospitality, retail and leisure accounts before establishing her own strategic communications consultancy in 2000. She is a graduate of Fitzwilliam College, Cambridge and Kings College London.

    A highly motivated Board-level adviser with a proven track record in devising and delivering strategic public policy and communication campaigns. Over 25 years experience working in a variety of government, corporate, agency and freelance roles.

    Transcription:

    Kelly Molson: Welcome to Skip the Queue, a podcast for people working in or working with visitor attractions. I'm your host, Kelly Molson. Each episode, I speak with industry experts from the attractions world.

    In today's episode, I speak with Kate Nicholls, CEO of UKHospitality and the Co-chair of the London Tourism Recovery Board. Kate answers your burning questions on how to attract and maintain talent in the current challenging climate.

    If you like what you hear, subscribe on iTunes, Spotify, and all the usual channels by searching Skip the Queue.

    Kelly Molson: Kate, thank you so much for coming on the podcast today. I know how incredibly busy you are, so I'm very grateful.

    Kate Nicholls: Thank you. It's great to be with you. I don't think I've had any time in the last two years really where it hasn't been incredibly busy, so it's good to take some time out and have a chance to have a chat. So thank you for having me.

    Kelly Molson: You are very welcome. You are very welcome. I'm glad I could give you that time. Right, Kate, icebreaker questions, because this is where we start all of our podcast interviews. I want to know what is at the top of your bucket list?

    Kate Nicholls: Ooh, well, for the last two summers we'd been planning ... My eldest was just about to go to University when COVID hit, and for the last two summers we'd been planning to go to Costa Rica as a sort of last big family holiday. And of course that's been canceled for the last two years. So top of my bucket list at the moment is to go on holiday with my two daughters, ideally Costa Rica, but actually I'd settle for anywhere at the moment. I haven't really had a proper break. But yeah, Costa Rica.

    Kelly Molson: Costa Rica, definitely. Yeah. I hear you. I feel like anywhere with some sun right now would probably do you the world a good, Kate.

    Kate Nicholls: Exactly.

    Kelly Molson: Okay. If you could bring back any fashion trend, what would it be?

    Kate Nicholls: Well, to be fair, they've never gone away from my wardrobe, but I would really like to bring back the wrap dress. They were such a good staple for anybody who worked in the '80s and '90s and the early '00s. Quite like to bring them back as a major fashion trend.

    Kelly Molson: Yeah, good. Can't go wrong with a wrap dress, can you? Boots, wrap dress, cardie, done.

    Kate Nicholls: You can't. Very forgiving, pair with boots or heels or flats or trainers, and you can just adjust it according to how you're feeling during the week.

    Kelly Molson: It's the perfect work-to-evening outfit. They're perfect.

    Kate Nicholls: Exactly.

    Kelly Molson: Okay, Kate, and this might be a little bit like asking you what your favourite child is, but I want to know what your favourite restaurant is?

    Kate Nicholls: Oh, that's the difficult one because it changes so much depending on how I'm feeling and the time of day and what I'm doing. But during the lockdown, my local Korean cafe has been my go-to place for getting a quick fix, some comfort food, and they've kept me going throughout lockdown. I'm a big fan of street food.

    Kelly Molson: Oh yeah, love street food. We have a really big street food community in Cambridge, actually, and it's just amazing, isn't it? Like being able to try all those different cuisines in one place? Fantastic.

    Kate Nicholls: It is. It is. And I think I've got kind of a butterfly brain, so being able to go try lots of little things, lots of little samples and eat that kind of stuff is great. But the other thing we did do over the summer, my daughter and I, we went and celebrated the new three Michelin star female chefs that we had in London that were awarded. So again, I go from street food to high-end.

    Kelly Molson: Love it. Absolutely love it. Okay, Kate, it's unpopular opinion time. I ask everybody that comes on the podcast to share an unpopular opinion with us. It can be humorous, can be serious, whatever it needs to have to be your unpopular opinion.

    Kate Nicholls: Well, I did think long and hard about this one because there are so many unpopular opinions I think I could have. But if I'm sort of talking about the biggest one that would sort of divide a lot of people, cats are better than dogs. I'm really not a dog person.

    Kelly Molson: Oh, okay.

    Kate Nicholls: That's going to be controversial and split.

    Kelly Molson: It's very controversial. And I'm not going to lie, I've got two dogs, so I am a dog person. But Kate, my dogs are a nightmare at the moment. We've had a flea situation this year. I've got a very noisy little dachshund who is absolutely filthy. The weather is disgusting. You have to go out with them all the time. Cats are sounding more and more appealing to me by the day.

    Kate Nicholls: Cats are sort of neat, clean, undemanding. They're not as problematic as dogs. I always think dogs, you feel as though you've got another kid in the house. I mean, my unpopular opinion is based on the fact that I did have a nasty encounter with a dog when I was little, so I am quite scared of them. But yeah, dogs are not as good as cats.

    Kelly Molson: All right. Well, let's see what our listeners think. I'm not going to lie because it's the time of year I'm swaying towards a swaying cat, Kate. Yeah. You might have changed my opinion there. Nice. Listen, thank you again for coming on the podcast. I really do appreciate it. I mean, I'd be super gobsmacked if anybody that's listening to this podcast episode doesn't know who you are, but just give us a little brief overview of what your role is at the moment, just to explain how critical it has been over the past couple of years.

    Kate Nicholls: Yeah. So I'm currently Chief Executive at UKHospitality. That's the national trade body that represents hospitality operators and businesses and employers. And so we have 700 member companies. Between them, they operate just over 100,000 outlets across the UK, from a single-site pub, coffee shop, cafe, restaurant, park bar, hotel, holiday accommodation, right the way through to the national chains.

    Kate Nicholls: Our role as the trade body is to be the voice and face of the industry to promote the sector as a great place to grow, work, and invest, to engage with the government, to make sure we've got the most supportive regulatory and tax environment within which businesses can thrive and survive. And then to provide insight, advice, and guidance to our members on the way in which they can operate to be compliant and to help their businesses grow.

    Kate Nicholls: And so normally that's quite a broad-based role, but it was really front and centre as soon as COVID hit because clearly, we've got inbound tourism. We've got hotels that were hit first. City centre restaurants, pubs, and bars started to feel the effects of COVID back in February. And really since February ... I mean my first meeting on COVID with the government was the 28th of January last year.

    Kate Nicholls: And since then, it's been pretty full-on making sure that in real-time we can present the views, concerns, impact of COVID on our business sector and try and make sure that we get the support needed to sustain those businesses, to maintain the employment, to protect jobs within the industry when we've been so hard hit by COVID.

    Kate Nicholls: So really a big role with government, meeting government ministers and officials two, three, four times a week at the height of the crisis, and also being on the media to try and explain what the impact is of what appeared to be relatively small scale changes, what big impact that can have on business viability and really spelling it out to make sure that people understand what that means potentially longer term in terms of viable businesses, the economy, employment in the UK.

    Kelly Molson: And, as I said, you have been the spokesperson for the sector throughout the pandemic. And I have to say, Kate, you were in my top five Twitter accounts that I followed continuously throughout. So I had Kate's, I had Bernard Donoghue, I had ALVA, ASVA and Blooloop. And that was my top five to find out what the hell was going on in the sectors that we worked in. So thank you so much for sharing and for doing that role.

    Kelly Molson: So what I want to talk about today is about attracting and retaining talent within the attractions and hospitality sectors. But I guess, from a ... I don't run an attraction. I work with them. I'm an associate in that sector. So I guess I want to ask a couple of questions about the general public and what we can do right now.

    Kelly Molson: So we have a situation in our local town. I live in a town called Saffron Walden just outside Cambridge, a beautiful town, a market town, lots of lovely pubs. One of my favourite pubs, which is one of a chain, has had to close for a good couple of months now. And essentially, it closed because some of its other restaurants were so overwhelmed and so busy but so short-staffed that they had to redistribute staff from our pub to their pubs.

    Kelly Molson: And I guess that's happening in a lot of different places as well. So if we're unable to book a table because a venue is short-staffed, what can we, as the general public, do right now to support the sector?

    Kate Nicholls: Well, I think it does highlight a challenge that the industry has got. It's more acute in certain parts of the country, but up until Omicron hit and we were all going back eating and drinking out more regularly, the industry as a whole just did not have sufficient labour to be able to operate at full strength. So a quarter of our businesses in the same situation as the one you just describe saying that they were having to restrict hours, cut covers, not open for certain days of the week, turn away bookings simply because they didn't have the staff.

    Kate Nicholls: So I think as the general public, what we can do with those businesses is try and be a bit more creative in supporting them. Is there a different time that we can book? Because everybody tries to book dinner or lunch at the same time. Can we spread it out a little bit throughout the day? Can we look at going for early suppers or late suppers or brunches or afternoons? If we can't, then can we help them in other ways if they're still doing takeaway, if they're still doing delivery, we can support our businesses in that way. Or booking ahead in advance and making sure that we take out gift cards and those kinds of creative solutions some of our businesses have done where you can get cash through the tills and book two or three meals in advance.

    Kate Nicholls: So that's a main bit of support. The second thing is that if you do have a booking and your plans change and you can't make it, let them know, and let them know in sufficient time. Because we still are getting quite a lot of no-shows that people make these bookings, something changes. Plans always change, we do know that, but people aren't letting them know. And particularly at the moment when you've got larger scale bookings for Christmas, people will have bought that food in well in advance and will start cooking it well in advance, so you do need to let them know the day before or at least a good couple of hours before if you can't make your booking, and then they can pass it onto somebody on a waiting list.

    Kelly Molson: That actually leads to another question is how is the sector feeling right now? So with Omicron, with the Christmas rush, what's the general mood like in the hospitality sector at the moment? Are we seeing a lot of people booking, cancelling reservations that they have for large groups of people? Is it quieter than it should be?

    Kate Nicholls: Quieter than it would be at a normal Christmas. So even before we had Omicron, we knew that we weren't having the same level of bookings as we were seeing Christmas 2019 and previously, so trade is down. We have seen cancellations. They're running at about 10% at the moment, and we have seen a downturn in footfall over the last week. Not just for those bookings and corporate events, Christmas parties, Christmas socials, but just a more general decline in walk-in bookings and walk-in activity. So we are seeing revenues down over the course of the last week, 15, 20%, and that's as a result of the uncertainty.

    Kate Nicholls: There's a high degree of nervousness within the industry and a great degree of fear at the moment because we've all been in this situation before. Sadly, this time last year, people will have invested heavily to be able to open and operate at Christmas, and unless you get that Christmas trade-in, it can be very damaging to the businesses. They rely on having a good December in order to get them through the quieter months of January to March. And without that good December, there are many businesses that will undoubtedly go to the wall. What should be a very optimistic and hopeful time has, in the space of a week, turned to be very uncertain and very concerning.

    Kelly Molson: Okay. So look, some great advice there from Kate. If we can look at when you're booking, changing times, if you can look at supporting your local restaurants by booking gift vouchers, for example, or if they are doing takeaway, please do do that and let's try and get them through this really difficult period that we're seeing.

    Kelly Molson: Now Kate, as I said, I want to talk about attracting and retaining talent in the visitor attraction sector. I don't run an attraction. So what I did, and what I thought was a good idea, is to ask some of the past guests that have been on to ask me to ask you questions. And I've had some fantastic questions in from many of the different guests that we've had on. So let me just ask you a few of the things that have come in. Gordon Morrison, the CEO of ASVA, and Adam Goymour, park director at ROARR! Dinosaur Adventure, actually had really, really similar questions. So let me read out what Gordon wrote over because he puts it far more eloquently than I ever could.

    Kelly Molson: So Gordon said, "Staff are the beating heart of every tourism business and can undoubtedly make the visitor experience memorable both positively and negatively. As we face up to what is quite possibly the most difficult recruitment and retention environment in the tourism industry has ever seen, is it right that we should continue to rely on our people so heavily to deliver outstanding experiences? And if so, how do we ensure that our businesses are attractive, and how do we keep that top talent in the industry?"

    Kate Nicholls: I think this is the number one issue that all operators are grappling with at the moment as we come out and we've got a very tight labour market and we've got a real battle just to get staff in, nevermind the battle for talent that we had going into COVID. So we were already facing those challenges. I do think what we need to do is to use COVID as a reset moment and look again at our ways of working, style of working, what we're expecting of people. This gives us an opportunity to revise terms and conditions and to look again at hours of work in the sector to make sure that we are being as flexible as we possibly can and we are being as responsive as we possibly can to what new recruits are telling us.

    Kate Nicholls: Because we've got lots of new, younger people coming into the industry, many have had no experience before and are questioning, quite rightly, some of the ways that we do things. So particularly in food and beverages and things like that, less so in attractions, but you do get some antisocial hours. You do get double shifts. And people have different ways of paying people. And I think the labour scheduling and the flexibility that we can provide should be a positive rather than it being something that holds us back.

    Kate Nicholls: So I do think we can look again at making sure that we are as attractive as we possibly can be and that we've got our best foot forward. I think secondly, what we need to be doing as an industry is to look after the sector's employer brand. Individual business is very good at doing this, promoting themselves as a career of choice, but we want to get across the fact that we're a career and we have a great plethora of opportunities available to people if they come and work within our businesses.

    Kate Nicholls: Because we're an industry largely of small and independent businesses, we don't have the size and scale, but I think we can look again at the sector branding to be able to make sure we put the best foot forward, that we describe how important it is as a career, how meritocratic it is. Because there's no sector likes ours that provides young people with such opportunity where you can come in with limited experience, limited qualifications and skills. We will upskill you very rapidly and you can move into management within about two years. There's no other sector that will give you that level of responsibility and authority at such a young age and at such a low level within the business, and the pay and salary that goes alongside it.

    Kate Nicholls: So I think there's more we can do around that in terms of communicating career of choice. And also communicating that even if you only want to come with us for a short time, we will equip you with common transferrable skills that other employers will find valuable; business, finance, people management, leadership, conflict management. You get that by working in hospitality businesses and visitor economy businesses, again, at a very low entry-level, and these are soft skills, people skills that are valuable at all levels.

    Kate Nicholls: And then the final element is about making sure that we do invest in our people, that we do train them to provide continuing professional development and we invest in leadership and management as people go through. We're very good at taking people at entry-level and doing the immediate skills and training they need to be able to function. We need to look at how we can continue to invest in those people. That's what young people particularly are looking for from careers and employers now.

    Kelly Molson: Yeah, absolutely. It's really interesting what you said about the soft skills as well, because I think that one of the best starts that I ever had to my working career was working in hospitality and in retail because it gave me so much experience of understanding how to talk to people, how to communicate with people. And from that customer service perspective as well. I think it gave me such a good grounding in my career, and all of those skills I learnt then, I've taken through into what I do now in terms of sales and an account management role.

    Kate Nicholls: Absolutely. And if you think about some of the young people who've been most affected by COVID and had their schooling disrupted, their social lives disrupted for a couple of years, those are the skills that they are lacking. When teachers are talking about young people coming back into school, it's time management. It's personnel skills. It's social skills. It's communication. That's what they get from us.

    Kelly Molson: Yeah. Completely, completely agree. Mark Ellis, who's the interim lead at the National Memorial Arboretum, actually has asked a question that picks up on some of your earlier points there. He says that, "One of the outcomes of the industry-wide staffing shortage is that staff are able to negotiate a better work-life balance, which is a really good thing. Ultimately that is going to lead to better conditions throughout the industry, hopefully, more job satisfaction, higher standards and a better customer experience." Mark asks, "Do you think that we will see the appearance of some widely-accepted examples of best practice?" So things like how businesses will manage seasonal contracts or flexible hours or unsociable hours like you mentioned?

    Kate Nicholls: Yes. I think we will start to see that evolving as we go further forward and as we come out of this. I think that's what I mean by a COVID reset moment, that we can look again at the ways that we've done things to be able to offer that kind of attractive proposition to people. So moving away from some of the zero-hours contracts, moving away from some of the seasonal changes where people don't have that much certainty, and towards one that is focused on what the applicant is looking for and wanting and the flexibility that they're needing, and presenting it in a way which is appealing to them.

    Kate Nicholls: I think we will, if we work carefully at it, I think there's a great opportunity for us across the entire sector to pick up some of those really good case studies and examples and promote them and push them out around the sector so that we have a positive employability story to tell.

    Kelly Molson: That is great. Now, I'm going to pick up on that a little bit later on because we've had a really good question about that very topic. Let me ask you about the supply chain, though, and again, this is another question from Mark at the National Memorial Arboretum. So the supply chain at the moment is disrupted. Food costs are increasing. We all need to find a more sustainable way to feed humanity. What can we do as an industry, and this is the attractions industry, to help the public recognise that hospitality outlets that source locally, use seasonal ingredients, increase their plant-based options, that they are the best place to respond to these pressures? But at the same time, costs are going to rise through dual pressure of food and wage increases.

    Kate Nicholls: Well, I think this is going to be a collective challenge for all of us because it's inevitable that with the cost pressures that we've got that are building across the sector, and not just our sector but across the economy, prices are going to have to go up to consumers irrespective of what we're talking about in terms of local sourcing, et cetera, and the positive efforts we've got. So I think as an industry we're going to have to work to be able to communicate to consumers clearly why we are having to put prices up post-pandemic, and it is going to be a struggle and a challenge and there's going to be that juggling act which there always is around pricing decisions about how far you can push prices onto consumers before you turn off demand.

    Kate Nicholls: But with VAT alone going up, there is going to have to be a price increase that we are going to have to pass on. So I think that's one challenge that we need to look at separately. I think the advantage is it's going to be across the economy as a whole and we're not going to be doing it in isolation. So I think customers are going to get more used to hearing about prices and hearing about costs coming through.

    Kate Nicholls: And then I think, you're right, there is a real opportunity there for turning that conversation around and explaining about how local sourcing is more beneficial, meets the broader sustainability issues that consumers are increasingly concerned about. Not just consumers, potential employees. So sustainability and environmental and social governance issues are coming higher up the agenda when we're talking about recruitment and putting ourselves out as an attractive proposition.

    Kate Nicholls: People are looking for authentic stories about local sourcing, local supply chain, carbon net zero, limiting waste, all of those kind of positive issues that we can turn to our advantage. But I do think customers understand it doesn't come cost-free. So I think they are two sides of the same coin. I don't think we should be apologetic about the fact that we need to be able to invest in good quality produce in order to deliver a more sustainable food supply chain.

    Kelly Molson: Do you think those conversations are slightly easier to have now as well, since the pandemic? Because I think what we did see when attractions were able to open up and hospitality were able to open up is that we saw a huge increase in demand for things that were local. We wanted to understand more about our local environment. We wanted to be able to support our local independents. So do you think that's going to be an easier conversation to have now that we're in that mindset already?

    Kate Nicholls: I think so. I think COVID provides us with that opportunity. Certainly one of the strong trends, and it sees no sign of abating as we come out of COVID, localism and hyperlocalism was a trend we saw during lockdown when, inevitably if you can't travel, you explore in your neighborhood. But even as we reopened, people were exploring in their locality before they've got confident enough to go further across the country or into city centres. And clearly you're moving away from global travel for two years. Again, those are trends that become sticky with consumers and consumers are interested in hearing and exploring it more.

    Kate Nicholls: So I think neighbourhood is going to stick with us for a lot longer. Certainly as well in terms of the different ways in which we work, I don't think it's going to be as polarised as in the office or at home, but I do think you're going to be working remotely and people are going to be looking at neighbourhood and local options to be able to facilitate that. So I do think that that frees up the conversation to be had more generally about how we are making a more sustainable, more robust, more resilient supply chain by looking locally. But equally, that doesn't come cost-free.

    Kelly Molson: Absolutely. Let's talk about opening hours. So Mark had a really good question around that. So he says, "Over the last few months, as venues have reopened, we've seen many places change their opening hours, and that's to enable them to offer fair shifts for their staff in response to business needs." He actually says some are open fewer days each week, and some are closing earlier. The micropub and brewpub and taphouse that he tends to frequent, he does put in brackets here, "On an all too infrequent basis though. Nights out are a rare treat. But they're all offering a brilliant experience with great staff during their opening hours. Does Kate think that the public will learn to understand that not opening all hours is a new thing to be embraced, or do you think that pressure to increase the venues to go back to 11:00 to 11:00 will be the norm?"

    Kate Nicholls: I think it's probably too early to say yet with consumers and consumer habits and trends because I don't think people are going out in the same way that they were yet. What we have seen after this reopening, post the 19th of July, that there is an expectation from consumers to go back to normal and they're not very forgiving of those who aren't. So I think consumers during COVID have got used to having things when they want it, at the time that they want it, and rapidly, and they don't take kindly to things not being available for them.

    Kate Nicholls: So I suspect it will be more challenging to have that on a longer-term basis if that's a longer way of working. What we do know, however, is that what consumers really don't like is uncertainty. So if they can guarantee that you are always open for these particular days, these particular hours, they will understand that more readily than they turn up at your door and you're not open today because you can't get the staff. That's the bit that seems to create the disconnect.

    Kate Nicholls: And what we don't have yet is a loyal customer base back. So if they can't get it from you, they will go and find it somewhere else is what we're seeing very rapidly. So I don't think it means that everybody has to go back to 11:00 to 11:00, seven days a week and full service, but you do need to get back to some consistency and some standardisation for customers. And certainly what we're finding in the restaurant side, for example, are quite a lot of businesses in city centres are closing Monday and Tuesday, and that causes a degree of confusion for consumers when they're back out.

    Kate Nicholls: Now, having said that, our customer habits are going to change a little bit again over Christmas if we do have restrictions brought back in due to Omicron and therefore customers again will be adapting to changes and the ways that they're doing things and changes in the ways of working. But I do think that will depend on where you are located. If you are located in a city centre and people are not visiting the city centre as regularly, you need to have that certainty about when you are available and open that matches and meets with them. If you are in a local neighbourhood and a local area and you're part of the community, I think there will be increasing pressure back being available when the customers want you.

    Kelly Molson: Earlier in this question you mentioned that it's too early to tell because we're not seeing the demand, we're not seeing people going out as frequently as they were. It's a difficult question, but how long do you think that we need to leave it until we do start to see some data around that?

    Kate Nicholls: Again, I think that's difficult to be able to work out because of the uncertainties of new variants and changes in restrictions. We haven't had a clear consistent period where we've been able to trade normally. Had we not had Omicron coming along, I think we would have got a better feel for it. After Christmas, we would have been able to look back at five, six months where we could see what customers were doing, how confident they were, and could try and see trading was doing without the blips that were caused by supply chain shortages, delivery shortages, pingdemics, labour shortages across our industry. I suspect that it's going to be until the middle of next year before you can really start to plan with any certainty around what's stuck, what's a long-term trend and what's something that you're nudging consumer behaviour around.

    Kelly Molson: Thank you. You mentioned earlier about sharing best practices and we've had a great question from Hannah Monteverde who's the Park Manager at BeWILDerwood in Cheshire. So Hannah says, "It's not always feasible to be able to offer an increased salary or market-leading benefits." She'd be really interested to know of any examples of curveball ideas that have attracted staff recently. Do you have any case studies or examples of attractions that you feel have really bucked the trend for recruitment particularly well?

    Kate Nicholls: I think the ones that are doing interesting stuff around flexible hours, hours when you want it, more frequent pay. One of the things that we found across our sector was that people were getting paid after four weeks, six weeks in some cases when they were a new starter, compared to some of the newer startup companies and labour scheduling companies and temporary recruitment from Amazon where they were getting paid within the week. So as soon as they did a shift, they were getting paid.

    Kate Nicholls: And actually that was something that people found was really attractive, that as soon as they'd done their job, they were getting their pay almost immediately, so a return almost back to weekly pay packets was quite an interesting one. It's not necessarily creative or curveball, but it's just listening to what people were saying that was a frustration for them that they wanted to be able to have.

    Kate Nicholls: Food, uniforms, selling those kinds of benefits, the walking to work for anybody who's in a local attraction or provision of transport for those people who were off the beaten track and people relying upon cars, et cetera. Those are things that have been used quite creatively. And then flexible labour scheduling, giving people the ability to tell the employer when they were available to work and how many hours they had rather than getting that rota coming down on a fixed basis saying, "This is when we rota-ed you and you have to go away and work out somebody else to swap with if it coincides with your yoga class or your student lesson or a GP's appointment."

    Kate Nicholls: So I think putting more power in the hands of the employees and giving them the ability to be able to ask for what they want, when they want, hours and pay, those are the two creative ones I've seen most frequently.

    Kelly Molson: That's fascinating. I mean, the crux of it is flexibility, ultimate flexibility as the employee. That is such a simple change to be paid weekly, so that instant gratification, "I've done a really good job. I've been paid for it." What a simple change to be able to make that could make such a big difference.

    Kate Nicholls: Yeah. And there's technology that enables you to do it now. So on the labour scheduling front in terms of, "I'm available for these hours and I'd like some work." Stint provides the opportunity and there's labour scheduling that provides the opportunity to do that, to just log on and say, "I can do four hours," rather than, "I can do a full day." And that sometimes is better. And equally, there's technology that allows you to drawdown. So if the business still wants to keep a monthly salary payroll, you can draw down earlier ahead of your salary, so you just get it a bit more when you've been doing your work. Particularly relevant for young people coming into the sector.

    Kelly Molson: Yeah, absolutely. And hopefully retaining them for a little bit longer, because that is the challenge with the sector is that it has always been seen as a bit of a stopgap, hasn't it? And ideally, we want to-

    Kate Nicholls: It has, and in some respects, we shouldn't be apologetic for that because it is a good first job. It's a good first base. Transferrable skills that we talked about before. We obviously want to keep and capture those people who want to use it as a career. But equally, given the labour shortages we're facing, if we can keep those people with us for longer who are just looking at it as a stopgap, that's all to the good as well. And that's about making sure we invest in them and make sure that they're supported as they come into the company.

    Kate Nicholls: Because at the moment, churn is so high across the sector as a whole. People come in, find that the work's too busy, too demanding, not for them, and they go away again. So let's just support them, nurture them and try and help to make sure that they have as good an experience as they can while they're with us.

    Kelly Molson: Definitely. Final question for you from our attractions audience. And again, this is from Hannah. So Hannah asks, "Do we have any realistic idea of timescales in terms of the forecast for recovery?" And this is specifically around the recruitment challenges that we're having at the moment. She asks, "Is this something that we have to adapt and change to live within the long term, or is it something that we could potentially predict will slowly improve and recover back to a pre-Brexit and pre-COVID-19 scenario?"

    Kate Nicholls: Gosh. There are two factors to that, particularly if we're talking about labour markets. So the government-commissioned independent research to look at when domestic tourism for fallen revenues would recover to pre-pandemic levels, and I suppose that's the best indicator of when do you think demand is going to get up there? When do you think your money is going to come back? And the independent forecast suggested that domestic tourism revenues would recover by the end of 2023 and international, that's not until 2024.

    Kate Nicholls: Now the government has said it will work with the industry to try and bring that forward a year, but that still looks as though you're going to have most of 2022 where you are operating suboptimally, that you're not operating at full demand. And I think in terms of labour shortages and challenges, again, likely to be temporary but let's not forget that pre-COVID, we had a 5% vacancy rate. Post-COVID, it's 10%. So it was a tight labour market before we went into the COVID crisis.

    Kate Nicholls: How temporary is temporary? I think you're going to be living with cost price inflation and the disruption to the supply chain for at least six months of 2022 and I think the labour issues are going to be with us probably for a year or two. If nothing else changes, our biggest challenge for getting people back into work is twofold. One is we've got a hiatus in the talent pipeline where we haven't been able to train our own. Our apprentices haven't been able to go through people and vocational training, haven't been able to go through catering colleges, et cetera. Haven't been able to go through because people have been disrupted in education.

    Kate Nicholls: And the same goes at the higher levels for hospitality degrees, but also curator jobs and those kinds of occupational training skilled jobs in the sector. So you've got a two-year talent hiatus, talent pipeline hiatus, and you've got COVID travel restrictions that are preventing people from moving globally. And you can only see what's happened with Omicron to see that that's going to be with us probably for at least another year. So you are going to have a global disrupted labour market and you're going to have global disrupted supply chains for at least another year.

    Kelly Molson: Gosh. Another year of this.

    Kate Nicholls: Sorry.

    Kelly Molson: Weren't we saying this last year? We were nearly-

    Kate Nicholls: I don't mean that we're going to be having another year of COVID restrictions or the challenges that we've got, but I think the global supply chain, the global economy is still going to be in quite an uncertain state for the whole of 2022. And people certainly won't be moving around the globe as freely as they have been pre-pandemic. We're not going to get back to that sort of free movement. It's nothing to do with Brexit, but just that movement of people isn't going to be happening to the same degree, hence you've got a delay in domestic and international recovery. You've got a delay in international recovery.

    Kate Nicholls: The people who've moved abroad during COVID or people who would normally be coming into the UK to look for work or those with settled status who might be returning, they're not moving around because of COVID and they're not moving around because of the problems of international travel.

    Kelly Molson: Kate, thank you. Thank you so much for answering the questions today. It's been incredible to have you on. I'd like to end the podcast the way that I always end the podcast which is to ask you about a book that you could recommend to our listeners. It might be something that you love. It might be something that's helped your career in some way or helped shape your career in some way. What would you recommend for us today?

    Kate Nicholls: I am a voracious reader, so I usually have three or four books on the go at any one time. But I'm definitely a fiction reader. I've got two books. One that was really ... is a business book that I found really quite useful when I first was made chief executive about six, seven years ago. And that was Sheryl Sandberg's Lean In, which I would definitely recommend for any female leaders in the industry to look at. It talks about some of the different ways that people experience things at work and certainly helped me to think about how I wanted to support the next generation of women coming up and making sure that we had more female representation on boards.

    Kate Nicholls: And then my absolute favourite book, which is my go-to book at any time that I just want a little bit of escapism and a really good story is Wuthering Heights. However bad you're feeling, there's always something entertaining and enjoyable in getting lost in somebody else's story and that's my recommended read.

    Kelly Molson: Fantastic recommendations. I actually do remember on Twitter you tweeting photos of your book pile, your COVID book pile. They were huge.

    Kate Nicholls: Yeah. Because everybody knows I'm a reader and I read an awful lot, at Christmas I get big ... And that's what everybody buys me as a gift. So I always get quite a lot of books at Christmas, and last Christmas I got 20. And as we went into lockdown, of January, I thought, "Right, can I complete my reading pile before we come out of lockdown?" Actually, I had to go and buy another 30 books. By the time we came out of lockdown on the 19th of July, I had read 56 books.

    Kelly Molson: Oh my goodness, 56 ... Well, I guess books are a much better option than getting socks for Christmas, right?

    Kate Nicholls: Absolutely. Absolutely. So yes, I do have big piles. I still have piles of books all over the house that I'm still reading. But yeah, I usually have ... I finish three books a week.

    Kelly Molson: Oh, I love that. Well, listen, so if you want to win a copy of Kate's books, you know what to do. Go over to this podcast announcement on Twitter, retweet the announcement with the words I want Kate's books, and you might well be in with a chance of winning them. Kate, thank you once again for coming on the podcast today. Very, very grateful that you've been able to spare us some time to come on and chat, and I very much hope that you get that well-deserved rest and holiday to Costa Rica sometime very soon.

    Kate Nicholls: Thank you so much. It's been an absolute pleasure. Thank you for having me.

    Kelly Molson: Thanks for listening to Skip the Queue. If you've enjoyed this podcast, please leave us a five-star review. It really helps others find us. And remember to follow us on Twitter for your chance to win the books that have been mentioned. Skip the Queue is brought to you by Rubber Cheese, a digital agency that builds remarkable systems and websites for attractions that helps them increase their visitor numbers. You can find show notes and transcriptions from this episode and more over on our website rubbercheese.com/podcast.

    Download The Visitor Attractions Website Survey Report - https://www.merac.co.uk/download-the-visitor-attractions-survey

     

    We have launched our brand-new playbook: ‘The Retail Ready Guide to Going Beyond the Gift Shop’ — your go-to resource for building a successful e-commerce strategy that connects with your audience and drives sustainable growth.

     

    Download your FREE copy here

    41 min
  • You can't furlough a Penguin. Experiences from the last 19 months at the Royal Zoological Society of Scotland

    Skip the Queue is brought to you by Rubber Cheese, a digital agency that builds remarkable systems and websites for attractions that helps them increase their visitor numbers. Your host is Kelly Molson, MD of Rubber Cheese.

    Download our free ebook The Ultimate Guide to Doubling Your Visitor Numbers

    If you like what you hear, you can subscribe on iTunes, Spotify, and all the usual channels by searching Skip the Queue or visit our website rubbercheese.com/podcast
    If you've enjoyed this podcast, please leave us a five star review, it really helps others find us. And remember to follow us on Twitter for your chance to win the books that have been mentioned in this episode.

    Competition ends April 29th 2022. The winner will be contacted via Twitter.

    Show references:

    https://www.edinburghzoo.org.uk/

    https://www.rzss.org.uk/support/

    https://www.highlandwildlifepark.org.uk/we-are-open

    https://twitter.com/Lisa_Robshaw

    https://twitter.com/EdinburghZoo

    https://twitter.com/HighlandWPark

    David Field, Royal Zoological Society of Scotland (RZSS) CEO, returned to RZSS in 2020 having been a section moderator at Edinburgh Zoo early in his career. David’s previous roles include chief executive of the Zoological Society of East Anglia, zoological director of the Zoological Society of London (ZSL), curator of ZSL Whipsnade Zoo and assistant director of Dublin Zoo. An honorary professor of the Royal Veterinary College, David has served as chairman of the British and Irish Association of Zoos and Aquaria (BIAZA) and is the current president of the Association of British and Irish Wild Animal Keepers.

    Lisa Robshaw is a visitor attraction marketing specialist with 20 years’ experience of working in the tourism and hospitality industry after studying International Tourism at the University of Lincoln. She joined the Royal Zoological Society of Scotland (RZSS) in August 2019 after a brief stint agency side. Prior to this she has worked for Historic Environment Scotland, Continuum Attractions and British Tourist Authority (Now Visit Britain).

    As Head of Marketing and Sales at RZSS, Lisa leads the teams responsible for the wildlife conservation charity’s marketing, sales activity, membership, adoptions, events and experiences . No day is ever the same and what she enjoys most is sharing the amazing experiences Edinburgh Zoo and Highland Wildlife Park have to offer and telling people about the important work RZSS does to protect threatened species in Scotland and around the world . When she’s not working, Lisa can usually be found chasing after her young family and planning visits to the south coast of England from where she originally hails!

    Transcription:

    Kelly Molson: Welcome to Skip the Queue, a podcast for people working in or working with visitor attractions. I'm your host Kelly Molson.

    Each episode I speak with industry experts from the attractions world. In today's episode, I speak with David Field, CEO, and Lisa Robshaw, Head of Marketing and Sales, at the Royal Zoological Society of Scotland.

    We discuss the zoo's experiences over the pandemic, highs, lows, and why you really can't furlough a penguin.

    If you like what you hear, subscribe on all the usual channels by searching Skip the Queue.

    Kelly Molson: Lisa and David, thank you so much for coming on the podcast today. I'm really looking forward to speaking to you both.

    Lisa Robshaw: Yeah, looking forward to speaking to you. It should be good fun.

    Kelly Molson: Well, let's see how we get on with the icebreaker questions, and see how much fun it is going to be.

    David Field: Yeah. I'm dreading this.

    Kelly Molson: I've been quite kind to you both, actually, I feel because we've got two of you today and we've got a lot to cram in. So what is the worst food you've ever eaten and why isn't it peas?

    Lisa Robshaw: Oh my God. I think it was snails for me. And it was when I was 12, in France. So that probably doesn't help. So we're talking like 1990, giving away my age now. And we're in this awful school canteen on this French exchange trip, we were forced to eat these snails. We weren't rude to our hosts. I don't actually think they were cooked particularly well because I think some of us were ill afterwards.

    Kelly Molson: Oh gosh.

    Lisa Robshaw: The texture, the smell, the whole experience.

    David Field: Yeah. I adore snails and I adore peas. I'm not sure your listeners would particularly want to hear about my adventures when we've been out on ... doing field work in Indonesia, some of the things that we had out there. But we did have to eat animals which were hunted and caught, and we ate. And they were kind of animals, which suffice to say, had a very strong aroma about them. So you're in the jungles, you're surviving, and it was not nice. But it was the aroma of their scent glands which permeated the meat.

    Kelly Molson: Oh Gosh. Yeah. I'm getting a really lovely ... a lovely image of that, David. Thank you.

    David Field: It makes celebrity in the jungle thing a walk in the park.

    Kelly Molson: You were the real celeb. Get me out of here.

    David Field: I really wanted to get out of there.

    Kelly Molson: Okay. Brilliant. Thank you. Okay. To both of you, if you could have an extra hour of free time every day, how would you use that free time?

    David Field: I would do more moth hunting. I like trapping moths and counting moths. And I never get a chance in a morning to do that. So that's what I would do, every single day if I could.

    Kelly Molson: Moth hunting, can we just elaborate on this? So this is a hobby of yours?

    David Field: Yeah. Yeah. You just hunt ... and butterflies. It's amazing. It's the best thing in the world. And you just ... every night you set at this light trap and moths are attracted to it at night. And then you get in there in the morning, first thing in the morning, and you've got all these hundreds of different species of moths, and it's just the most beautiful thing. They are the most gorgeous thing that we never think about that just roam our gardens. And I'd do that every day if I could.

    Kelly Molson: Oh wow. I honestly have never heard anyone have that as a hobby before. That's something completely new for me. How lovely.

    David Field: Yeah. Try it.

    Kelly Molson: This is why I ask these questions. You never know what you're going to get. What about your unpopular opinions?

    Lisa Robshaw: Harry Potter books should not be read by adults. They are a children's book.

    Kelly Molson: Oh. I mean, no one can see my face because this is a podcast. So if you're not watching the video it's ... Gosh.

    Lisa Robshaw: But I don't know what it is. I remember when Harry Potter came out. Again, I'm aging myself here. I was at university and I didn't understand why people were going mental. And then I think right about the time of ... in the middle of it all, they re-released the same book with a different cover to appeal to adults. And I was like, that is wrong. You're ripping people off. It's a children's book. That’s what I talk about. No, no, no.

    Kelly Molson: I am quite shocked by that. I love the Harry Potter books.

    Lisa Robshaw: I'm sure they're great. I've tried reading them. I just ... they're not for me.

    Kelly Molson: What about the films? Fan? Not bothered?

    Lisa Robshaw: I kind of class those as a sort of Boxing Day, fall asleep in front of it after a few glasses of red wine type of film. Anything that keeps the kids' kids quiet for two and a half hours. You know what I mean? It's that kind of thing. But I just don't ... I mean, this is ironic that I've been to a Castle and done the broomstick riding three times and my kids, and it's a brilliant experience. But like grown adults losing their minds over it, I just don't get it.

    Kelly Molson: Oh my God. Well, David, I don't know, can you top that for an unpopular opinion? I'm not sure.

    David Field: Well first off, who's Harry Potter?

    Kelly Molson: What are you doing to me, David?

    David Field: So perhaps this segues a little bit into talking about the visitor attractions and that type of stuff, but mobile phones should be banned at visitor attractions because it's about family time.

    Kelly Molson: Oh, that's a bit serious.

    David Field: I really do think they should be banned from visitor attractions.

    Kelly Molson: I can see where you're going with that. Yeah. Like being present, not on your phones, not looking for the opportunity to be on your phone, but just being present with your family. I get that.

    David Field: Yeah. Yeah.

    Kelly Molson: Oh, this is ... isn't it really interesting though. But from the perspective of being a CEO of an attraction, wouldn't you want people to be engaged with the stuff that you have there so that they share that on social media, so that then drives more people to come?

    David Field: They can do that when they go home. They can do that on their way there. They can do that every time. When they're in, and particularly when they're in the zoo, we want them to be engaged with nature, we want them to be there in front of them, not encasing them in some sort of cloak of electronic gadgetry, putting these barriers between them and nature and putting the barriers between them and their family. Live in the moment, not on your phone.

    Kelly Molson: Oh, what a great quote. Okay. Listeners, I really ... well, I want to hear what you've got to say about both of those unpopular opinions. Thank you for sharing. Okay. I was going to ask you what you do in your roles. But I think from your job titles, it's probably pretty obvious to people, especially the people that are listening to this. So I thought I'd actually ask you if each of you could tell me what your favourite thing is about the zoo or the wildlife park?

    Lisa Robshaw: It's like choosing a favourite child, isn't it?

    Kelly Molson: I've only got one, so it's really easy.

    Lisa Robshaw: Yeah. Highland Wildlife Park. For me, it's the expanse and the fresh air. I mean, I'm a city girl. I'm originally from Portsmouth. I've lived in New York and all this kind of thing, and I've lived in Edinburgh for 20 years now, but ... or 15 years. But when you get up to Highland Wildlife Park in the beautiful Cairngorms and it's just the fresh air and the space, and even when the park's busy, it's almost still silent. Do you know what I mean? It's just this sort of really relaxing place. When I get the chance not to be sitting in meetings all day, as is the danger sometimes when you're on the kind of hamster wheel of working and that kind of thing. So I love getting up there and just spending time and relaxing and enjoying the surroundings.

    Kelly Molson: Great answer.

    Lisa Robshaw: That's my professional point of view. I mean, the animals are amazing, and asking me to pick my favourite animal is always a difficult one. Red panda, but ... penguin. Now see, that's the problem. But yeah, that's mine.

    Kelly Molson: I love it. David, what about yours?

    David Field: So, as part of my job ... and I've been knocking around this zoo world since I was 12 years old. So for me, it really is about the animals and the beauty and that connection with the animals. And as part of my job now, I insist that I have a couple of hours ... an hour or so in the day that I go pottering around the zoo. And zoo directors need to potter around their zoo. Because every day, every different hour of the day, every season, there is something different going on. There's a different animal, doing something different, something exciting. And my favourite animal changes each day. But I go out and because the zoo and the wildlife park are so different, every single time you go around, that's what makes them so amazing and beautiful and inspiring and glorious, and why I've been doing this for 30 odd years.

    Kelly Molson: Oh, perfect answer. I love that you're just pottering around, just having a little walk around your zoo, just checking out the animals. It's really nice. I'd like to do that. There you go. And I'd like to spend my hour pottering around the zoo if I got my extra hour. Thank you both. So the title of this podcast episode is You can't furlough a penguin. Experiences from the last 19 months at the Royal Zoological Society of Scotland.

    Kelly Molson: Now, I was at the Visitor Attractions Conference a little while ago, back in October and you can't furlough a penguin was something that I heard Bernard Donoghue say while he was given one of his very fantastic talks, as always. And I thought, that's a great podcast title. I'm going to use that when I get Lisa to come on this podcast.

    Kelly Molson: I want you to take us back to kind of Feb., March time 2020, when coronavirus was something very new and nobody in the UK had ever heard the word furlough before. I can very vividly remember what it was like for me with a team of seven thinking, gosh, we've got to pack up, we've got to work from home. Is anyone actually going to buy anything from us for the next ... I've got no idea what's going to happen. I can only imagine what was going through your heads, having a team of people that you were both thinking about and thousands of animals that you have to care for, that you're responsible for. What was that even like?

    David Field: Well, I think every day you are looking back on that time and hindsight's an amazing thing, to look back on how you handled it, how many hours you spent lying, awake thinking about it. But then, in some respects, we were no different to others. And everybody was facing a crisis in so many different ways. And this has been one of the most important sort of most significant kind of social impacts in our lives. Hopefully we'll never get anything like this. My parents, my grandparents had world wars and stuff like that to deal with. We just had to deal with a bit of a pandemic, which quite frankly, we should all have been prepared for. It was coming. And the next one will come.

    David Field: For me, it was very odd because just February, March, I was leaving my previous job, ready to come up to Edinburgh to start a new job. So I was having to sort of resolve the issues in one zoo and leave it in a good enough state, ready to come to Edinburgh, where my board, etc. at the time were already trying to deal with the organization that at the time, we didn't have a CEO in place then, did we? You just had to react. You just had to understand that you had so little information that you had to be incredibly dynamic and react to situations.

    David Field: And the crucial nature, before anything else, was just securing money, was securing funding, just so that you could make sure that you could stay open. And the difference in dealing with governments in the UK as compared to governments in Scotland, were miles apart. And so that was the crux. And you were so focused into that, that other things did disappear. Once you could get the money, once you could get the bank loans, once you got that, then you could start some sort of planning. So that was the crux. It was money, money, money all the way, just so you could stay open. Now, as good charities, we all had some reserves, but we just didn't know what the endpoint was going to be. And so securing funding was the be all and end all.

    Kelly Molson: And I guess, so David, were you ... I mean, you talked a little bit there about the challenges dealing with English government, Scottish government. What were the differences? What was difficult about that process?

    David Field: Access, getting people to listen to you. Now look, we know the governments had so much on the plate that wanting to listen to the zoo director down the road was probably fairly low down the list. But it was trying to get the message across that you couldn't, not so much furlough a penguin, but you couldn't furlough a penguin keeper. And just trying to get those individual messages through. But being able to get that through to Scottish government made life so much easier, having people that would listen made so much easier for you. To be fair, DEFRA were excellent, but it was trying to get to the ministers. The civil servants, hats off to them, amazing. But try and get through to ministers who actually make the decisions, was nigh on impossible.

    Kelly Molson: Yeah, I can completely imagine. And Lisa, so where did this leave you? Because I guess you then have to think of different ways to drive donations. You have to think about how you're engaging with the audience who aren't able to come to your venues. You've got to engage with them on social media, online, and virtually in some way. How did you even ... how did you start that process and where did some of the ideas ... and what did you do? Where did they come from?

    Lisa Robshaw: I mean, for me, it was a massive learning curve. I'm a visitor attraction marketer by trade. I'm not a fundraiser. And it's obviously a different discipline. Although we're talking to the same people, we're having to talk to them in a slightly different way. So I mean, back to that week in March, it was a sense of disbelief of what was going on. All of a sudden, I had to put a different hat on and I was learning a new trade almost from our sort of development team, and all that kind of thing. We put a lot of people on furlough, which meant we all had to wear different hats and support people in a different way. I suddenly became a web developer and yeah, I'm a digital marketeer, I'm not a web developer.

    Kelly Molson: You want a job because it's really hard to find web developers right now.

    Lisa Robshaw: I don't think anyone would want to employ me, to be honest. I gave that part of my career up as soon as I could. But very quickly, it was long hours, long days, adapting our messaging. Because to be fair, Edinburgh Zoo and Highland Wildlife Park, visitor attractions first, almost kind of ... in terms of individual giving, it was such a small part of our charitable income at that stage that we just had to completely do a 360. So in terms of fundraising, it was really just making sure that our development team were well supported in making sure our messages got out, and working with the comms teams to make sure the messaging was appropriate, emotional enough to elicit that donation.

    Lisa Robshaw: And then it was working with kind of our discovery and learning team, I think there was only one after we'd furloughed everybody, on how are we going to engage with people virtually? So obviously we were looking at the great work that other zoos were doing. Chester, for example, with their Friday kind of online videos and Facebook lives and all this kind of thing. Almost, okay, what can we do, which is really Edinburgh or Highland Wildlife Park-esque? You know? And all this kind of thing.

    Lisa Robshaw: And one of the light bulb moments, I think in think in lockdown two, when we were all getting really quite professional at lockdowns, professional lockdowners, all this kind of thing, was thinking about how we can do virtual birthday parties and take that experience into people's homes, and do something different to what other people were doing. That's what we wanted to do. And that's how we honed our kind of skills, I guess, and how we developed, and how we all evolved during the two lockdowns. It was incredible.

    Lisa Robshaw: But the outpouring of support from people we had. I mean, I was very much the same as David, how ... and other attractions, not just zoos, but other attractions, how are we going to keep the money coming in while we're closed? How am I going to sell a membership to somebody when the zoo's closed and they not having the experience? It's things like making sure the membership didn't start until we reopened, so people felt, we'll get them the money at that point, but their membership wasn't starting. They were getting the added value when we opened. And our membership, the support we had from our members and our new members was just incredible during lockdown. It really was. And that just ... yeah, it was a massive learning curve.

    David Field: I mean, that support Lisa, that you talked about, was huge, was overwhelming. It was remarkable. And certainly Edinburgh Zoo and Highland Wildlife Park, certainly the zoo, hadn't had that level of support previously. The level of support that we received from the community was incredible. But I think that came because the authenticity of our message. We were very, very transparent with what was going on. We spoke to everybody and anybody, whether they wanted to do a podcast, whether they wanted to do a newspaper piece, whether they wanted to talk to us on the phone. We spoke to anybody. And it was the honest truth of what we were putting out there, that we didn't know what was happening day to day. We didn't know about the future of some of these animals. There was questions about our pandas. There was questions about our penguins. But we went out there and talked. We opened our hearts, we opened our zoos to information and messages, and the response that we got was incredible.

    David Field: Do you know, I think Edinburgh fell in love with its zoo again. They began to value what they might just miss. And it was about the ... I truly believe it was the authenticity of our message and what people saw and heard from our zookeepers, from our conservation teams. And that work with the D and L team, the Discovery and Learning team, was incredible, because they didn't just put material online. They made it just a zoo visit online. They made it so interactive. They made it one on one. It was remarkable. It was just so exciting.

    Kelly Molson: I love what you said there about Edinburgh realises what they could potentially miss if the zoo wasn't ... if it didn't exist anymore. Have you seen, since the zoo has reopened, that you are getting a lot more kind of people ... a lot more local visitors? Have you seen that that's kind of increased, that people ... they are really loving Edinburgh Zoo again?

    David Field: I think so. I mean, Lisa might ... you might be able to give a bit more of the kind of stats and facts of it all. I look at it from a more emotive sense and you do just get that level of feeling that people believe in what we're doing and they're really supporting what we are doing. But I think one of the most remarkable things for me was when we did reopen and you saw people coming back into the zoo for the first time. And it was also a time when the families were probably meeting each other for the first time again, because we were one of the few places that were open, one of the few places where people could meet. And suddenly the emotion of people meeting in a place like the zoo, it was remarkable. And we tend to forget the social value of our visitor attractions for quality family time. And that period of just as we were starting to reopen, just emphasized it perfectly of how important the zoo was as a family place, a place for real quality time.

    Lisa Robshaw: Yeah, absolutely. I completely agree. And the amount of people that were coming back that were saying, "I haven't been for years, and I'd forgotten how wonderful it was or it is." You still get that in the school playground, anecdotally, the mums going, "Oh my God, I can't believe you work at Edinburgh Zoo. You've done so much amazing work during lockdown. The kids have loved the films and all this kind of stuff." And you just go, wow, that social value is an absolute, really good point. And yeah, anecdotal evidence is that everyone did fall in love with the zoo again. It's incredible.

    Kelly Molson: And they're coming back in droves to show you that love now as well.

    Lisa Robshaw: Absolutely, yeah. Our visitor numbers this year have been amazing, better than ... I think summer 2020 was better than summer 2019. But we have to make ... or '21, sorry, was better than 2019. But we have to remember 2019's a pretty bad summer weather wise as well. But I do ... so couple the bad weather with this new affection and the fact that people haven't been able to go anywhere else, I mean, it's ... yeah. We're reaping the reward and the challenge is going to be keeping the momentum going into next year when we've got so more competition.

    Kelly Molson: Yeah.

    David Field: Absolutely. We've got to seriously up our game for the ... when the period sort of as we were reopening and lockdowns were being lifted, so people just wanted to get out and be local, there was a benefit there. People started to see, as Lisa said, actually this is a pretty, pretty great place. Look at all this exciting stuff that's going on. But now we've got to just keep going and maintaining that excitement and that wonderful visitor attraction element, which drives our charity mission, is essential. So it's challenging going forward.

    Kelly Molson: It is. And actually one of the questions I was going to ask you is about how you kept your team motivated through the pandemic. Because, like you said earlier, it's not just, you can't furlough a penguin, it's you can't furlough the penguin keeper. So you had a lot of people that were still coming into work during the pandemic because there was a need for them. They had to be there. But I guess an extra question to that is how do you now keep your team motivated to keep that excitement and keep that enthusiasm going, to keep drawing the people in again? So two different questions, or same question, but for two different situations there.

    David Field: Yeah. I think there's ... it's a really, really tough time for the staff. They're absolutely shattered. Staff such as the ... say the keeping staff, and I mean ... were coming through during the pandemic to work. So they weren't getting time off particularly. And even now our other teams, which are so crucial to making the place work and be great place to visit, there's so much going on that people can't take their ... are struggling to take their holidays because of the momentum that's going on. So people are tired.

    David Field: And then with the challenges that we are getting there with trying to recruit new people, where there is nobody to recruit, it is putting pressure on people. But it's humbling to work for a team like team RZSS, because they just step up and go above and beyond constantly. And it's the belief in what we do. It's the love of the animals. It's the love of the institution, that people step up to such an extent. And it's remarkable. But they are tired. And we would like to recruit more staff so that they could actually recover.

    Kelly Molson: We have Kate Nichols on from Hospitality UK, speaking with her next week about the recruitment challenge. So if you do have any questions that you'd like to pose to her, feel free to send them in, because I know that this is widespread right now. And if I'm honest, it's not just the attractions industry. We're struggling ourselves. Like I said, no joke society, if you have got web development skills hit me up. It is a huge challenge right now. And like you said, people are really, really tired. So there's still a long way to go to get everyone motivated and to keep everyone going. I really hear you on that.

    Kelly Molson: Lisa, I want to talk a little bit about what you said earlier about the birthday parties and some of the things that you did in terms of engaging with your audience while you couldn't open the zoo. Will you still carry on some of those things? And if so, are there any new things in development or anything that's coming up that you're quite excited about that you'd like to share with us?

    Lisa Robshaw: Yeah. I mean, the demand for the virtual birthday parties has obviously waned now. And actually they'll always be secondary to trying get these groups of kids into the zoo so they can actually, like David say, get close to nature and sort of be around the animals. That's our number one reason for being really, in terms of engagement. But that was great, to see the reactions and all that kind of thing. Not only because we tested it on my own six year old who had a second lockdown birthday, but also just the demand, and people by that point were wanting something different for their kids. That was great.

    Lisa Robshaw: I mean, one of the things I loved were the amount of companies that came out and actually wanted to work with us, and companies that traditionally the zoo have worked for ... worked with kind of on a sort of cursory ticket selling level. So hotels, for example. We had so many hotels that wanted to come and work with us in a completely different way. So one hotel wanted to do a giraffe themed bedroom, and a certain portion of percentage of the room rate would come to the hotel ... to the zoo. So I mean, I'm under no illusion, a lot of that was for PR and unusual ideas. But never before have we had hotels being that actively courting us.

    Lisa Robshaw: The big one is the Waldorf Astoria, the five star Waldorf Astoria Hotel, more sort of known as the Cally here in Edinburgh. And they did a zoo themed afternoon tea. Five pounds from every afternoon tea that they sold came to the zoo with an option to top up it to another five pound donation. And I think it was three and a half months that was for sale with, just as we were coming out of lockdown. So you could get home delivery or you could get the whole Waldorf Astoria experience. And they raised eight and a half thousand pounds.

    Kelly Molson: Wow.

    Lisa Robshaw: So you work out how many they sold. And that was a partnership we would never have had the opportunity to do had lockdown and COVID and the pandemic not happened. So that was fantastic. So moving forward, I'm really looking forward to working with loads of other different companies, in the next couple of ... next year or so. We've started that initiative with our art trail that we're doing next year, called Giraffe About Town. So this is one of the Wild In Art trails. You might remember things like Cow Parade. Here in Scotland we have the Oor Wullie Bucket trail, but they're popular all around the country. I think there's been Elmer Elephants in Luton, that were involved with. All this kind of thing.

    Lisa Robshaw: So we're going to have our own herd of 40 sponsored eight foot giraffes around the city of Edinburgh next summer. And at the moment we're going out and talking to companies about sponsoring those giraffes. And what ... this is a complete unknown of a project for me. I've never been involved in something like this to this scale before. But what is really heartening is that a variety of companies that are coming out and actually wanting to support their zoo, from big house builders to a company, a sort of a one man band who does synthesizer things for electric guitars and bands. It's just so random, but it's so amazing to see the outpouring of support that's happening.

    Lisa Robshaw: And also the public are really excited about ... Every time we talk about Giraffe About Town, there's people making arrangements to come to the city and have a weekend break so they can find all the giraffes. That's kind of our way of giving back to the city as well. So that's a really exciting initiative. Alongside the day job, it's quite hard work, but it's going to be so exciting. And the whole process is a whole new thing for me, from talking to sponsors, to people who create concrete plinths and these things to sit on and then looking at venues for auctions at the end to raise money for our wildlife conservation projects around the world. So yeah, that's a really exciting initiative and that would never ... we would never have taken that type of project on if it wasn't for the pandemic and have the confidence to do it.

    Kelly Molson: That's amazing, isn't it? That that's something so fabulous that has actually come out of something so horrendous.

    Lisa Robshaw: I'm going to have a lot of gray hair by the end of it. It's great that I am already. But already. I get quite emotional thinking about what the end result's going to be, and from people ... sort of companies actually getting a lot of extra PR and marketing value out of working with us, to people having a great time around Edinburgh and exploring parts of the city they've never explored, trying to tick off all their giraffes, to the impact they're going to make at auction with real money for charity. It's quite exciting.

    Kelly Molson: It feels like people want to take ownership of an experience in some way. They want to be part of it, not just come to visit. They want to be part of that for a longer period. Do you know what I mean? Like you come and visit the zoo and then you might adopt an animal, but actually being part of the walking trail, that's really kind of embedding yourself into that experience. Something that Gordon and I discussed actually, when we had it on, was the desire for more personalised experiences, that people want to do things that are not just the norm now. They want something that's really kind of tailored to them. Have you seen an increase in demand for your zoo experiences this year?

    Lisa Robshaw: Yeah. Massive. Massive demand, to the point where we're getting so booked up in advance. It's great, but you almost get to a situation where we can't fulfill some of them. So we're having to manage that really carefully to make sure that we don't lose the sale, but we're also managing people's expectations. But people want that experience. And if nothing else, the pandemic sort of reignited that passion. People don't just want a tangible kind of gift. It's this thing where ... that experience that people really want, which is ... we are just made for that kind of experience.

    David Field: I think that is really interesting with the need for personalised experience, but deeper and more emotive experiences. And I think that's a way ... not everybody who comes to the zoo can possibly have a personalised experience. We don't have enough animals. There's not enough time in the day. For all different reasons. I'm very lucky. I get that kind of contact with animals constantly. And people need that in their lives. They cry out for this contact with nature, and it makes people better.

    David Field: And somehow we got to deliver within the zoo more and more of these emotional experiences. We've got to get people to not just look at an animal from a distance, but when they go into the giraffe house now at the zoo, they don't just see animals. They're really, really close. They can smell them, they can hear them, they can almost taste them. That sounds a bit weird, doesn't it? But it's a full multisensory experience. It's a deeper meaning, which is why the zoo experience means so much more than something you just see on screen. It has to be ... we've got to make the hairs on people's necks sort of stand up, get them really emoting, get those emotions running about animals. Then people care about animals more and want to hear our messages about how we can do more to protect them or conserve them. So emotion is huge for us.

    Kelly Molson: And is that part of how you kind of inspire people to help you now? Because I guess the zoo ... we're heading into winter, so you're going to have less people visiting. I wanted to ask what the kind of shape of the zoo is as you head into winter this year. But I see that you've got the Help the Animals that you Love campaign still running. Is that something that you run all year through? Are you going to be doing a big kind of driver of that to kind of help get through the winter? Like where are you at?

    David Field: I mean, I think there's a couple of questions there. I mean, in terms of ... we will do various fundraising activities at different times. And there's a recent appeal gone out just for more of our general work. When there's some specific project, we might do other appeals. But I think where we are really trying to get to is that ... and we touched on it before, is that long term relationship with the zoo. And I said, the zoo is different, whether it's winter, summer, spring, autumn morning, noon, evening, it's always something different. So we want people to be able to experience that and really pushing our membership, pushing that long term relationship with the zoo. And really there's a cradle to grave relationship that you can have with the zoo. And that's what we want to achieve because it's more than just a visit.

    Kelly Molson: Yeah, it is. This is something that I saw Bristol Zoo has just said, that it's going to open its grounds to the public for free after it moves to a new home next year. Circling back to what you said earlier about the zoo being at the heart of the community and people falling back in love with Edinburgh Zoo, do you have any more initiatives to kind of connect with that local community aside from the walking trail that we've just discussed, which I think is an absolutely wonderful way of connecting with the local community? Have you thought about anything long term for the zoo where you get more of the community engaged with it?

    David Field: Well, I would say kind of watch this space, because we will be launching next year, a major part of our future strategy is about community and it's about using the unique resources of the zoo and the power of animals to do good, to actually build improved wellbeing in individuals and also in the communities where we work, helping to strengthen the communities where we work. That's really powerful for us. When Edinburgh Zoo first opened back in the early 1900s, it was designed by the social architect, Patrick Geddes, so it was a place where communities could come and walk and commune with nature outside of all the industrial areas and built up areas of Edinburgh. And we still appeal to that. That idea appeals to us, so that it is a place of sanctuary. It is a place where people can come.

    David Field: And we are undertaking a range of initiatives that we can link with the community. We already do that in many ways. We work with different community groups, both in Edinburgh and up at the Highland Wildlife Park. And we want to look at all of those barriers that are cultural, social health wise, which stops people getting to the zoo. We need to work with that. We need to work with local businesses, with local council, with Scottish government, in order that we can become the most inclusive and accessible visitor attraction, not just in Scotland, but in the UK and beyond.

    Lisa Robshaw: It's probably worth talking about Highland, Wildlife Park as well, the developments that will start next year for the Scotland's Wildlife Discovery Center. We've got HLF funding for some massive new developments at Highland Wildlife Park, which are just around that sort of engaging with the community, the people that would normally be able to have those experiences, getting close to nature and that kind of thing, and really telling the story of sort of Scotland's wildlife heritage as well. And no better place to do that than in the Cairngorms. So we're really excited about that project and that's going to be an absolute game changer for Highland Wildlife Park.

    Kelly Molson: Oh, can you share a little bit more about what makes it game changing? Or is this top secret information for the time being?

    David Field: No, not at all. I mean, there's been quite a lot of information out there about it already. And the Scottish Wildlife Discovery Center is ... it's a transformational project, both for the park and for the society because it will be ... in reality, it's a network of hubs that takes you on an expedition across the Highland Wildlife Park. But this expedition exposes you to the people, the place, and the animals of the Cairngorms. It brings the beauty of the Cairngorms and all the knowledge and information that we need the people that will come and visit.

    David Field: But we will have ... there's a large discovery centre where you can find all this information. There will be hubs, which overlook our wildcat breeding program project, and our peat restoration project. Then there's a wonderful new accessible learning hub, which will be open for the community as well so that we can bring people to the park that would never have dreamed of coming to the park before or wouldn't have been able to come to the park. But they'll be able to come for different events, community outreach. But it is designed so that we can celebrate the Cairngorms and the people, the place, and the animals therein.

    Lisa Robshaw: What he said.

    Kelly Molson: What David said. Do you know what's lovely? Is you speak ... there's a real sense of positivity in this interview. Whenever you both speak, there's a real kind of uplift and a real kind of sense of excitement about what's coming next. So it's been really lovely to hear that come through from you both.

    David Field: Oh, fantastic. Thank you. I mean, we work with animals. It's amazing. You're having a bad day, go and sit with the penguins.

    Kelly Molson: That is not dreadful, isn't it? Yeah. I mean, the closest I get is to picking up a dog if I'm having a bit of a bad day, but a penguin would top it.

    David Field: But that is ... it's so important to us. And it's not a trite statement, but we know that people just visiting a zoo, your stress levels just go down. We know that. We know that again, it's that quality social time. It's memories. It's access to nature. All of this is important for us from so many aspects. And the power of animals to do good is just ... it's beyond. They're amazing.

    Kelly Molson: Couldn't have said that any better myself, David. I totally agree with you. Thank you both for coming on the podcast today. I always like to end our interviews by asking if you have a book that you would recommend to our listeners. So it could be something that's helped you in your career. It could be something that you just ... you absolutely love. It's definitely not going to be Harry Potter. We know that. Hopefully Geoff is not listening to this, our past-

    Lisa Robshaw: I'm to going to get an invite to the Warner Brothers Studio at any time soon, am I?

    Kelly Molson: No, it's not happening, Lisa. But yes, I would like to ask you both if you've got a book that you'd like to recommend?

    Lisa Robshaw: I'll let David go first.

    David Field: Well, I love my books. Absolutely love my books. The Zoo Quest Expeditions by Attenborough were an inspiration to me. But more recently, it's The Invention of Nature: The adventures of Alexander van Humboldt. Amazing book by Andrea Wulf. Alexander von Humboldt, one of the greatest naturalists, a real kind of polymath that was there. He invented ecology. He saw climate change before anybody else. And it's so beautifully written and a real inspiration in terms of what he achieved. He's one of my scientific heroes.

    Kelly Molson: Fabulous. That's very topical. All right, that's David's one. Lisa, what about you?

    Lisa Robshaw: I'm now regretting asking David to go first. Mine is ... I'm not sure I'm allowed to swear on this podcast.

    Kelly Molson: You can.

    Lisa Robshaw: The Life-Changing Magic of Not Giving a F*ck.

    Kelly Molson: Excellent book.

    Lisa Robshaw: It was given to me, the actual book was given to me by a friend, God, probably about six or seven years ago when I was having a bit of a hard time. And David ... it'll probably make David smile, and my boss, Ben, but I give myself a really hard time over things sometimes. I just want things to be perfect all the time. It's quite topical at the moment. And actually, I just ... sometimes when I'm feeling a bit overwhelmed, I just go into this book and it reminds me that I can't control certain things. I just need to give a fuck about the things I can control and let go of the things I can't. I recommend it to so many friends that have found it useful as well. I know Ben, my boss, would probably want it to be like a bit of a marketing book that I'm recommending or something like that, I thought I really let him down with this. This is well worth a read.

    Kelly Molson: Lisa, I have read that book. It is an excellent book. So basically what we are recommending is grab a copy of that book, head to the zoo, go and sit by the penguins, life will be sweet.

    David Field: Perfect.

    Kelly Molson: All right, well, listen, listeners, as ever, you can have the chance to win copies of those books. So if you would like to win a copy of Lisa's book and David's book, then head over to this episode announcement and retweet it with the words, "I want David and Lisa's book," and we will put you ... books even, and we will put you in the draw to win a copy of each of them. Thank you very much. I really like those suggestions and I really am very grateful for you both coming on and sharing your experiences today with the listeners for the podcast. So thank you.

    David Field: You're more than welcome, Kelly.

    Lisa Robshaw: Thanks, Kelly.

    Kelly Molson: Thanks for listening to Skip the Queue. if you've enjoyed this podcast, please leave us a five star review. It really helps others find us. And remember to follow us on Twitter for your chance to win the books that have been mentioned. Skip the Queue is brought to you by

    Rubber Cheese, a digital agency that builds remarkable systems and websites for attractions that helps them increase their visitor numbers. You can find show notes and transcriptions from this episode and more over on our website, rubbercheese.com/podcast.

    Download The Visitor Attractions Website Survey Report - https://www.merac.co.uk/download-the-visitor-attractions-survey

     

    We have launched our brand-new playbook: ‘The Retail Ready Guide to Going Beyond the Gift Shop’ — your go-to resource for building a successful e-commerce strategy that connects with your audience and drives sustainable growth.

     

    Download your FREE copy here

    41 min
  • How to drive visitor numbers by focusing on the local community, with Liz Power

    Skip the Queue is brought to you by Rubber Cheese, a digital agency that builds remarkable systems and websites for attractions that helps them increase their visitor numbers. Your host is Kelly Molson, MD of Rubber Cheese.

    Download our free ebook The Ultimate Guide to Doubling Your Visitor Numbers

    If you like what you hear, you can subscribe on iTunes, Spotify, and all the usual channels by searching Skip the Queue or visit our website rubbercheese.com/podcast
    If you've enjoyed this podcast, please leave us a five star review, it really helps others find us. And remember to follow us on Twitter for your chance to win the books that have been mentioned in this episode.

    Competition ends April 29th 2022. The winner will be contacted via Twitter.

    Show references:

    https://waterandsteam.org.uk/

    https://twitter.com/epuddick

    https://www.linkedin.com/in/liz-power-a79717198/

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B5nggnfC6B8

    https://www.bdadyslexia.org.uk/

    Liz Power has been the Director of the London Museum of Water & Steam since 2018, which follows 20 years working in Museum learning at the Science Museum, Imperial War Museum and London Transport Museum.

    When not at a Museum Liz can be found running around after her three children, volunteering as a trustee for her local grassroots youth work charity, or playing the Baritone horn badly in her local brass band.

    Transcription:

    Kelly Molson: Welcome to Skip the Queue, a podcast for people working in or working with visitor attractions. I'm your host, Kelly Molson. Each episode, I speak with industry experts from the attractions world.

    In today's episode, I speak with Liz Power, Director of the London Museum of Water and Steam.

    We discuss their excellent reopening video, and how they drove their summer visitor numbers sky-high by focusing on their local community.

    If you like what you hear, you can subscribe on iTunes, Spotify, and all the usual channels by searching Skip the Queue.

    Kelly Molson: All right, Liz, welcome to Skip the Queue.

    Liz Power: Thank you so much for having me.

    Kelly Molson: Well, it's my pleasure and I'll tell you why it's my pleasure in a little while. But first, ice breaker questions. So, if there was a zombie apocalypse, which three people would you want on your team? And they can be friends or celebs.

    Liz Power: Wow.

    Kelly Molson: Or famous, not celebs.

    Liz Power: We’ll see, for years and years me and my husband had a zombie apocalypse plan when we lived over in Wimbledon. We'd meet at the windmill on the common, and so we would... This is before we had children, we had this actual zombie apocalypse plan, so I think I'm going to take him, because he's in on the plan already and I think it's completely rational to have a zombie apocalypse plan, completely. So, I'll have him because he's good. And then who else would I have? I mean, I basically want somebody who knows a lot about zombies. There's not many of those around. Maybe I'll just take any mortician.

    Kelly Molson: Yeah, yeah. Okay.

    Liz Power: Because they're used to handling the dead, and it's not the zombie's fault that they're trying to eat our brains, so maybe they would handle the zombie relationships while I do fighting.

    Kelly Molson: I love that. I like that you've thought so in-depth about this. Now I feel like I need to put my own zombie apocalypse plans together.

    Liz Power: Everyone needs one.

    Kelly Molson: Okay. All right, if you could eliminate one food so that no one ever had to eat it ever again, what would you destroy?

    Liz Power: Without a doubt it is celery. I mean, it is obnoxious, horrible, does nothing for you. Just the presence of it in a space stinks it out. I can spot it in a mixed up food a hundred miles. It is the filthy devil's food, and eating it would kill you if you ate nothing else. So, the world could do without it. It's very much the mosquito of the food world, celery. Yeah, everyone would be delighted. Nobody would believe me for that.

    Kelly Molson: Great. Okay, good. Exactly how I feel about peas, so... It's similar.

    Liz Power: Similar. Similar. Maybe we could do both, sort of a two-for-one offer.

    Kelly Molson: I'm all down for that. Celery has no part in my life.

    Liz Power: No, nor mine. Nor anybody's I'm sure, but anyway. Still should be banned.

    Kelly Molson: All right. Final one, what is the best advice you've ever been given?

    Liz Power: So, I have three children, and my daughter turned two the day after my twins were born. It was unbelievable chaos for the last... Well, for the last eight years to be honest, but particularly the first kind of six months. At one point, I cried on a health visitor and said... Because they would just scream and hit and it was oh, they were such messy little creatures. I said to her was it ever going to be like this forever? Had I ruined everyone's lives? Had I ruined my daughter's life by bringing these two horrible screaming babies into her world, and she said to me, "They are learning about relationships in the safety of your love."

    Kelly Molson: Aw, that's lovely.

    Liz Power: And it was the best bit of advice, and I probably reference it about three times a week, because even though they're now 10 and eight, my boys are eight, it's still chaotic and it's still argumentative. The small one had an argument over jumpers. I mean, it is that... They are going to just be the best humans, they're going to make the best friends, they're going to have the best relationships because they're learning about that in complete safety. So, that's what reassures me when it all goes horrifically wrong.

    Kelly Molson: Oh my God, that is so special. What a... That's a really lovely gift that she gave you with that saying, isn't it?

    Liz Power: Yeah, and I was at a very, very low point, and it just gave me enough to keep going, that I hadn't ruined everything. Not that you can choose to have twins, but it just felt like I'd blown everything apart. She was like, "No, this is for their good." And it is for their good.

    Kelly Molson: Hats off to you, because I'm juggling a four-month-old right now, and that's tough enough. So, well done you. All right, what is your unpopular opinion?

    Liz Power: I've been thinking about this, because I have so many opinions, but I tend to have a tendency to think I'm right, so I think they're more popular, but I thought of one particularly for museums. We have so many museums in this country. That worries me. We just have so many, and I'm not sure that every single museum in the country is viable, so I think my unpopular opinion should be that if we're going to have to make choices about which museums we can sustain as a country, then we should make it purely based on which ones have mannequins or not, and get rid of every single mannequin museum. If you have a mannequin, I don't care how pretty it is, it must go. The things are terrifying, horrific. Maybe we'd have an amnesty and give everyone 12 months to get rid if they wanted. And then anybody who was like, "No, my mannequin must stay." I'm like... I don't mind a headless one to display clothing, but the ones that are just kind of an actual person. Horrific.

    Liz Power: When I worked at the Transport Museum, there was one... Well, Transport Museum, I love it dearly but they'll definitely have to close or get rid of the mannequins. There's one there that is actually modelled on Sam Mullins, the director. And so, it's even more horrific, and then in their store in Acton, there's just trains full of random mannequins. I mean, it's horrible.

    Kelly Molson: Kind of spooky having a mannequin of yourself, isn't it? That's a bit creepy. But where would all the mannequins go, though? There would just be a landfill of weird, creepy mannequins.

    Liz Power: No, we'd burn them.

    Kelly Molson: Okay.

    Liz Power: Yeah, we'd burn them. We're very industrious in museums. We'd probably sell tickets to the bonfire. We'd burn all the mannequins that were given over in the amnesty, and the museums that don't comply, that is it. No more of your museum. You just have to be... Though, I think that's probably going to turn out to be an incredibly popular opinion.

    Kelly Molson: I think it might as well. Let's find out. Listeners, can you let us know how you feel about the burning of the mannequins?

    Liz Power: I think it just feels right. I don't know how you'd object to it. It's so good.

    Kelly Molson: Also, let me know if you buy a ticket for that as well. I'm intrigued.

    Liz Power: I'll get that Arts Council application on the go right now.

    Kelly Molson: Liz, thank you for that. Okay, I've had so many wonderful unpopular opinions this season already, I just... Yeah, where you pull them from, I do not know. Right, tell us a little bit about the London Museum of Water and Steam.

    Liz Power: Well, of course, everyone has visited, but just for a couple of people that have never been, we are a very small micro-museum over in West London, and we're based at Q Bridge train station, but actually in Brentford and Hounslow. We are a historic site, and we have 200 years of water pumping history and the impact it has on London. So, we have a collection of static steam engines, we have a small, really small [inaudible 00:08:22] gauge loco that runs around our site, and we are a community museum, so we're really focused on what we can do for our local community. That's a massive part of what we do, and then the other part of what we do is our visitor profile is the classic split of the under-fives and the enthusiasts.

    Liz Power: So, it's a really unusual place and massive plug for everyone to come and visit and come and see me because everyone at all. Yes, I know this standpipe tower, so if you've ever sat on the traffic queuing to the A40 with that big tower that you're like, "Oh, I don't know what that is." Yeah, that's us, and it's a standpipe tower, not a chimney. So, come educate yourself, because everyone's like, "Oh, I've queued past so many times." Yeah, that's us, that's the Water and Steam.

    Kelly Molson: Oh, I love it. That was a very good synopsis, and you mentioned community. We're going to come back to that because that's what we want to talk about on today's podcast. But listeners, as you know I basically stalk people on Twitter and LinkedIn and various social media platforms and ask them to come on the podcast. I'm always looking out for interesting guests, interesting stories, and I have been stalking Liz for a little while, actually, after I saw their rather brilliant reopening video that the museum produced.

    Kelly Molson: Now, this was when the museums were allowed to reopen after the first wave of pandemic. I know we are still in it, but I thought it was such a great example of one, a video that was on brand. It was really fun, really authentic, and I'm going to say really inexpensively-made, and I just thought, I just thought it was perfect. It was such a lovely way of kind of showcasing to your potential visitors that it was a safe place to come.

    Kelly Molson: It was really fun. You really explained visually really well what they could and couldn't do, and I just think it's excellent. I've referenced it in many... Well, I've referenced it on the podcast, I've referenced it in a few webinars that we've done for ASVA, and I just think it's banging. Can you just talk us through the process of how you... I will put the link to the video in the show notes, so if you haven't seen it you can have a watch.

    Liz Power: Cool, thanks. We were fully furloughed as staff from April the first, including myself. So, we were out of work, but that didn't stop you from attending webinars, and so myself and the team were attending anything we could do to just feel like we still had a job. One of the webinars, we heard Bernard Donoghue who I know you've had on before talk about a reopening video that would be an important part of reopening. We didn't have any money or any budget or anything, but we had enthusiasm and an incredible ability to chuck ourselves into having a go at anything. And I just thought we could do it. I looked at some of the ones that other people were making, and I was like, "You know what, it doesn't look that hard."

    Liz Power: So, we filmed it on my iPhone, because I had the newest phone of the team, so that's how that choice was made. Myself and Gemma, who... We only have three staff majoritively, so the two of us filmed it together and we wrote a little skit. We filmed it in order, so we'd find it easier to edit, and we filmed it without a microphone or anything, and then we took a few takes of a few things, but pretty much did it short and sharp, under a minute long. We knew the messages we wanted to get across about space and fun...

    Kelly Molson: That's my favourite bit. The space bit is my favourite bit.

    Liz Power: There's so much space.

    Kelly Molson: There's so much space. But it's filmed from really far away, so it sounds like you've got loads of space as well, and I was like it’s really brilliant.

    Liz Power: In our garden, yeah. And then we used free editing software to bring it together, and then my friend Vicki Pipe, who is the manager of the amazing Bow Street Police Museum, check that out, who's a brilliant editor. She's @vickiexplores on Twitter. She did a time to edit for me and put some music over the top, and that was it. And then we did a really important thing, and I know this sounds silly, but I lost all sense of shame and I set up a WhatsApp group which was absolutely everybody I knew who I thought would retweet it for me. I sent out a WhatsApp group to them and sent a message to them all saying, "I really need your help. Good news, I'm not asking for money. All I'm asking for is a retweet. Can you retweet my video when I bring it out next week?" And sent them a little preview.

    Liz Power: And then everyone did, including the amazing Scummy Mummies, who retweeted it for me, and they've got a massive following. So, it really got out into the world. It was fantastic. Anyway, so we loved it so much that we made another one for October when we reopened, so that was our outdoor spaces. When we reopened our indoor spaces, and this time I roped in my kids to star in it, and we did exactly the same process. For us, it worked really well. When we'd had to close, all of our engagement with our audience had gone on to social media, and there was nothing else we could do. We were furloughed, we were really tight but we have always been really open with our visitors and our community about who we are as an organisation but also as individuals.

    Liz Power: So, it's really not unusual for our social media to feature us messing around, or us just talking about our lives or... It's not my kids' first appearance. It is very much community work. You have to give so you can receive, and it fitted our brand because if we'd suddenly had come out with something that was so slick, they'd all gone, "Well, they said they have no money." We haven't gotten any money, so we have to film it like this. It fits. This is us, this is me and Gemma. We're the people you will meet, and so in every way, it fitted what we did. It was so well-received, and it really held its own against people who spent a lot of money on theirs, and we spent, for the record, nothing.

    Kelly Molson: Amazing. Yeah, I love that, and I think that's part of seeing... The pandemic has forced people to be more innovative and be more creative with the budget that they've got, which was zero, and to do things like this. I think one of the nice things that you mentioned is about, you were in it and your children were in it, and it was... If people are going to visit, they're going to meet those people, and that brings me back to that community aspect that I want to talk about. Because you've had a really, really successful summer, and this was something that I saw on Twitter a little while ago.

    Kelly Molson: You posted, and again, I'll reference this in the show notes, but you posted up a graph. Your tweet said, "The grey are the numbers we expected. Yellow is what we had before, and blue is what we got." And basically the numbers were phenomenal. They were far over what you were predicting, like far over.

    Liz Power: Yeah.

    Kelly Molson: You said this had all come about because you'd focused on your local community. I want to know what you did.

    Liz Power: Yeah.

    Kelly Molson: So, you've got your summer 2021 results are pretty phenomenal. Talk us through how you got them, because they were so much better than what you expected.

    Liz Power: So much better, and I just want to say that halfway through the summer, I had failed the basic mantra of "know your numbers" and was in the pit of despair unknowing if we were doing well or not. And then I was like, "Actually, Power, sort yourself out. Just count the numbers up and have a look," and we were doing so well. We had forecast that we would get 25% of our normal visitor numbers. Now, for a sense of scale, we are tiny, so if we get over 200 visitors, we're emergency going to say we need to get more loo roll, just to give you a sense of scale. But we had forecast 25%, and we were smashing it. Absolutely smashing it.

    Liz Power: We are very lucky in Brentford where we sit. We're surrounded by people, so we're overlooked by the Brentford Towers Housing Estate, which is a high-rise accommodation, high-density, and then we have new-build flats all the way around us, and that's why in the summer of '21... In the summer of '20, we had decided to open this outdoor space, because to be brutally honest, nobody needed a static steam engine at that point in their life. Did they need a place to play with their kids? Absolutely. So, we did that instead. When it came to this summer, what we really wanted to do was kind of take that same approach and feel, and bring it into the museum. Despite all the new people we met last summer... All the new people we've met since we reopened in May, come to the museum and just, we want it treated like a park.

    Liz Power: We want people to feel like they can come time and time again, have a play. That kind of feel, so when we had opened... I don't know what you call the October opening. Almost open. When we'd almost opened in October and done the half term, and then again when we reopened in May, the first thing we did before we let the public in is have a week of community opening, where we invited all of our local community groups in to have the space for themselves, get them back through the door, just kind of build up those relationships. We'd had some funding from the Council over the autumn of '21 for a project we called Sharing Spaces. Sounds really posh, but what they actually did was pay for a duty manager and a cleaner so that we could open the museum not for the public but for community work, because we were a large space.

    Liz Power: So, we were ventilated and groups could meet inside, and particularly for the local communities work we do with people with autism. Having a regular meeting place had been really important. So, it started to kind of snowball all of this work we were doing in the local community, being helpful. Helpful is one of our museum values, and so we're like, "What would be helpful to do now?" Again, still nobody needs a static pumping engine, but they do need a place to come and do a regular craft group or whatever it is. We had carried on this mantra, and then we'd closed again and gone into that really long lockdown. Then, with the help from the Culture Recovery Fund, we'd been able to open up in May, and again, focus on the community groups. What can we do that is helpful?

    Liz Power: We've got a brilliant new community partner in the Au Bon community, who are a charity who work with young people with learning disabilities. They're our new café, and that's really exciting and we've got all these new community groups coming in and out. And then we've just got local people, and we swapped our annual tickets, so we are unashamedly a Robin Hood organisation. If you travel from Brighton to buy a ticket for the day, we're an expensive day out for you at 17 pounds. If you live next door, we are an absolute bargain. 17 quid for the year, come in every week. Brilliant.

    Liz Power: So, we have this. We knew we'd have people coming time and time again, and annual ticket members bring other annual ticket members. And then we knew we couldn't do seven days a week. We didn't have the staff, so we consolidated down to five days a week. Still, at five days a week, we beat what we had done in 2019.

    Kelly Molson: Wow.

    Liz Power: It was just local people because we know them, and we see them, and we chat with them. They help us find the leak buckets when the roof rains, and they say things like, "Are you doing that story again, Liz?" And you're like, "Yes, I'm doing that story again." And we put together a simple program that we felt was manageable and deliverable, we had a good summer. But local people had built this relationship with us, which meant that they knew what they were getting, they know the approach they're getting. We're a friendly place. You really can't go far wrong. Of course you can touch something. You're going to get covered in oil, but help yourself. Come in the water play, just come and sit and chill. You walk a coffee through our museum, it's absolutely fine. We want to be that kind of relaxed environment, and that's just what people needed this summer. We just got it just right for our local people, and I think we've done a lot of listening and a lot of thinking about them.

    Liz Power: And also a lot of reflecting on our own lives. What do we want this summer? I certainly don't' want anything too intense. I wanted a chill place that made me feel safe and relaxed and happy, and that didn't have to go too far. So, that's what we provided for a lot of people in Brentford.

    Kelly Molson: How did you get the word out? Did you use... You've obviously got quite a tight-knit community around you anyway, so you've got people that would come back and visit regularly, and they're going to spread the word organically for you. Is that what happened, or did you go to any other lengths to...? So, did you invest in digital, for example? Did you do any online campaigns? Or did you do any flyer dropping, or...?

    Liz Power: No. The Cultural Recovery Fund’s money, obviously, was only for the three months and it ran out before the summer holiday, so we had pre-invested in that well-known marketing tool, the banner. We have two banners out saying what we were doing for the summer, and we use our social media a lot, so we chat to people and we often say to people, "Oh, if you want to know what's going on, just follow us Facebook." We've got a big Facebook following, big for us. Lots of people do follow us on that, but then also, we're really unashamed about it. This half term, we've been doing science shows and at the end of every science show, we end with an appeal, thanking everyone for coming, saying that museums will only keep going if we have visitors. It's their homework to go away and tell five people, "Help keep us going."

    Liz Power: I think a lot of it is word of mouth, and just kind of the good feeling we can create from being helpful, from being positive, so you get people whose child maybe attends a club that meets in the museum, or maybe they're a carer to one of the young people who does their bunchy work in café... That kind of good atmosphere, and then that's it. We don't have any money for any new marketing or leaflets or anything like that, so it's simple at the moment until we build our income back up...

    Kelly Molson: Yeah.

    Liz Power: ... and are able to put a bit more money behind it.

    Kelly Molson: That's phenomenal. To have achieved those kinds of visitor numbers without actually any additional spend is pretty impressive.

    Liz Power: Yeah, I forgot one thing, as well, which was before the summer, I did a request out to Thames Water. Thames Water doesn’t fund us or anything, but I kind of think they should. So, I'd phoned them up and asked them if there was anything they could do for the summer to help us, and their engagement team came down every Wednesday with a bunch of activities, and so we were able to have additional programming for no additional cost. If in doubt, ask.

    Kelly Molson: That's excellent.

    Liz Power: Yeah, and that came out of... I was at training or networking, and somebody said, "If you need help, ask for help." And I was like, "We need help. We need help to put on programming for this summer. Let me ask." And they said yes.

    Kelly Molson: That's phenomenal. So actually, a big part of it is finding new partners to support you. It's not just about relying on the general public to spread the word. That's one part of it, but the other channel is actually, if we look at the community and we look at partners that can come and support us, that's another way of developing... Because, are you getting new people coming through the doors as well? You talked a lot about your annual visitors, but are you getting new visitors? You can see that split?

    Liz Power: Yeah, we can see the split. I'm not very good on stats, so I haven't got the stats for you, but yeah. We can see the new people coming in, so when I was changing the ticket prices... In 2019, we had 13 different ticket prices, and to volunteer on our front desk, you basically needed a degree in mathematics. We simplified it and we now have the classic two ticket prices, adults and concessions, and we made all kids go free because it's such a good line. I worked out when I was doing the calculations for that ticket change, the percentage of new tickets that we would have coming through the door, and I was heavily indebted to the AIM guides, an Association of Independent Museums who are brilliant. I mean, they've got a guide for everything you need... If you want to run a museum, just use that website. Their ticket guide basically said, "If you change to an annual ticket, annual tickets bring other people." As soon as you read it you think, "Do you know what? I've done that."

    Liz Power: So, you get an annual ticket to somewhere and then you say to your friend, "I'll tell you what, I've got a ticket to Kew Gardens, do you want to meet me there? That would be great, and then you could get a ticket, and then the two of us can meet in Kew Gardens." And then they say to their friend, "Do you know what? I've got a ticket to Kew Gardens..." That's the word of mouth that comes with that investment in that annual ticket for those families, and we'd had people who'd bought annual tickets at October half term, we're very liberal at just extending those, thanking them for support. Lots of families said, "Don't be ridiculous, we'll buy a new one," which is lovely. But the annual ticket is something that... Now, you can come every weekend like everyone else.

    Liz Power: You can just have a play, or did you know the trains are coming back? Or did you know that we've got the model railway, or whatever is coming in, they feel we are a hop in-able venue, and then that's how they kind of spread the word to their friends, really, and start the snowball off.

    Kelly Molson: And is this kind of constantly evolving? Because I guess just going back to what you mentioned right at the start, is that you said, "What is it that people need right now? They need outdoor space, they need somewhere to come with their kids where they can burn off steam, and they need it to be a calm space where they don't have to worry about anything." How does that translate now that the winter's coming? Are you speaking to the community to find out what it is that they need?

    Liz Power: Yeah, so on our community work site, at the moment we're only open to the public at weekends, during term time. But we're open for the community Thursdays and Fridays, and that's when we're also starting to welcome schools back in. Watch this space, and also when we have our volunteers come in on Thursdays and Fridays. The big request from the community is to open more. I mean, we could fill the building four days a week, easily, with community work. So, that's a real challenge for us, to look for sources of income to make that happen, so I have a couple of proposals out with corporate donors who, I think it should help the community by opening our museum for a couple extra days a week. For them it would be, in case they're listening, a very low-cost investment, so we need a duty manager and we need a cleaner, and that's pretty much it. And some overheads to keep the lights on, so we know that's what the community really need.

    Liz Power: They need a dry space, they need a ventilated space, they need toilets. So, that's really, really important, and then for our kind of family visitors, it's really interesting. So, half term just gone, we had good numbers. I was really pleased. We beat our 25% target, we didn't have those numbers like the summer. What is really interesting, families were saying to me, "I'm so glad you're not busy. I thought you were going to be busy."

    Kelly Molson: Oh.

    Liz Power: Which I think is fascinating. I mean, it's an independent museum's worst nightmare, that people want to avoid busy places because busy is what we love, but I thought that was really interesting and made me think about kind of the messaging we're going to do this winter. We are big, we do have plenty of space. You can safely navigate our museum without hitting a queue or feeling hemmed in. So, I think that we're going to have to think about how we communicate that, and how we make sure that we... Instead of going what is more traditional for us pre-pandemic years, October half terms is manic, and then winter toddles along. How can we spread that out? How can we say to our families, "You know the offer that you love at half term? Well actually, this weekend in November, we're also doing some of that."

    Liz Power: So, we can spread all visitors out and make them feel safe and secure this winter, and safe and secure I think is just about not being busy for them. Actually, it's going to be a really fine balance.

    Kelly Molson: Yeah, it's difficult, isn't it? It's a conundrum of... And I guess this comes back to a pricing strategy as well, is do you have less visitor numbers, higher entry price? But then that's a challenge in terms of the local kind of community you've built up. You don't want to whack the price up for them, but will people travel and pay more to come?

    Liz Power: Brentford's a very deprived area, and Hounslow is a little rich borough, and I'm very aware of not wanting to kind of price our local community out of the museum. For me, working in independent museums as I have for the last 13 years, for me it's all about demonstrating worth, so £17 is a lot of money. Some families, for an adult, I can't do the maths quick enough to tell you what it'd be for two, but for some families that is beyond their reach, right? They're never going to be able to afford that. Those families, we will give tickets to for free. That is not a lost income for me, they are never coming. So, I will give them a ticket because that is gained love, gained support, gained word of mouth. That's all pluses for me, there's no loss at all.

    Liz Power: In the past, we've given away tickets with a food bank, which has been really good, and we're delighted to see some of those families in. We work very closely with the Children's Centre, who hold a stay and play on a Thursday in term time in our museum, and we give tickets away to those families, and all of my duty managers are on strict instructions that if somebody arrives with a family and when they're told the price, they say, "This is not for us, then," and you can tell, you know those families aren't faking it. They absolutely can let those families in.

    Kelly Molson: That's wonderful.

    Liz Power: That's not lost money. That's just a total bonus, but it's about demonstrating 17 quid, for a lot of people, is a big spend. So, what are you getting? What's your value for money there? I always think about the cinema, the thing about paying for the cinema is you know how long you're going to be in it, you know what it's going to be like, and you know what it's going to be like when you finish. So, that's a safe bet for a family, they understand that transaction, and I think the thing with museums is people who aren't museum-goers don't understand that transaction. They don't see what they're getting, and this kind of loops back around to the film and the social media and the being very open, and welcoming community groups in.

    Liz Power: All we're trying to do is show you what you're going to get, that it's not scary. You're going to meet me and Gemma. It's really fun, your kid doesn't have to behave, tantrums are incredibly welcome and totally normal, as is shoplifting from our shop. Toddlers running across the carpark with a bouncy ball, you don't have to put on your best. I don't want it to be a place where you feel you can only go if your children are on their best behaviour. You need us most when your children are at their absolute worst. That's when you should feel safe to come to us and go, "God, they're having a hideous day. Water and steam, that's what we need. Let's go get wet in the splash zone." Doesn't matter if they've got soaked. They keep their clothes. Doesn't matter if they're having a screaming tantrum on the floor, Liz has got that secret packet of stickers that she gives to screaming kids.

    Liz Power: That's the kind of safety we want to create, and then that means for them that they know that value of that 18, 17 quid. They really understand what they're getting in return, and it's a good investment for them. And we've done this... Hounslow Council have given every household a 20 quid voucher, like an e-voucher thing, and we've signed up and some families have been swapping that for their adult ticket.

    Kelly Molson: Ah, that's great.

    Liz Power: Yeah, it's absolutely brilliant, because 17 quid, you could spend it in lots of different shops in Hounslow and restaurants and things, but if they spent it with us, they get something that lasts all year. That's been wonderful to see that coming through.

    Kelly Molson: That's really smart. Liz, I don't think that you could have sold a trip to this museum any better than you just did. It's just perfect. It's perfect. I'm bringing Edie, I'm bringing Edie.

    Liz Power: Yeah, do it. Bring her when you're having a rubbish day. I will happily cuddle a baby for you.

    Kelly Molson: Excellent, I'll take that. I'll definitely take you up on that. Liz, what is next for the museum? We talked a little bit about how your offering is going to change slightly, and obviously, there is still a nervousness from people, and they want to know that they're going to have enough space and be safe over the summer months. What comes next?

    Liz Power: We've got to work out how to grow. Okay, so we've luckily not had to make anyone redundant, but we haven't replaced anyone who's left, and so I think we've kind of been in survival mode quite a long way. But I wrote a business plan in 2019, and I've got to trash it because we've leapt so far forward in everything we wanted to do, so that's fantastic news. There's a bit of kind of structural replanning that needs to happen, thinking about our business plan going forward, and then how do we grow back to where we were? How do we get back to the starting levels? Then, how can we do more for our community?

    Liz Power: We're just about to advertise for a volunteer coordinator part-time if you'd like to come work with me. That is going to be a really big thing for us, and we need to build our volunteer team back. That's incredibly important, we have started a years' worth of work, working on young volunteering. A lot of young people who are long-term mates, volunteering in the museum, so I'm just trying to explore every version of volunteering possible because I think we're a fantastic resource for skills and all the rest of it. I'm having conversations with all sorts of people that might be able to make volunteering doable for us. That's really exciting, and then we're again thinking about what our community needs.

    Liz Power: I want to do some work on our outdoor spaces, which are before the pay line. We're very lucky, we've got a beautiful garden with frogs and a playhouse and more children's watering cans than you've ever seen, but there's space at the back that I'm hoping that I am going to be able to redevelop into a wild play space that could be used by the local community for playing for a school. Something that's kind of lacking in Brentford. I'd like to get open more, because I think we need to be doing more community work. So again, as you can see these things are about kind of what can we look for funding to take our work forward, while maintaining our core work of the work that we do with the communities and the work we do with our visitors who come in all the time?

    Liz Power: So, slowly, slowly nudging forward and always just being really honest with people about where we are, and just explaining we can't do everything, and the things we can't do, explain why we can't do them. Just the things we can do, being enthusiastic and going for it. We try to have an attitude of promising to everyone that we'll say no if we can't do something, because in some cultures, saying "no" is perceived as incredibly rude. So, people don't ask, because they're worried they're going to put a burden on you. We want to have the opposite, so we operate on a promise to say no, so you may as well ask because I'm going to feel I have to do something.

    Liz Power: Kind of continuing to listen and respond to the community, and just trying to be the most helpful, responsive, reactive museum we can, and get our reaccreditation. So, just a couple of things.

    Kelly Molson: I mean, that's not a shortlist by any means, is it? What we really need are those corporate sponsors to get their wallets out, get their purses out, and spend some money.

    Liz Power: Absolutely. To spend some money, and to think about how they can support the museum because the visitor numbers will return and that income will return, but it's going to be a slow-moving thing. There's no rushing that, and I don't know if we'll ever see numbers like we did before the world changed. So, this is time to think differently, and think a bit laterally about how can we still achieve what we want to achieve? And it might work, might not work, but at least they're going to try, and try everything.

    Kelly Molson: Yeah. Liz, I've really loved speaking to you about this, because you can see when you talk, you can see the enthusiasm that comes through you, so I just think it would be... Definitely, I'm going to come and visit, because it would be so lovely to meet you in person because you kind of... The museum just is you, you just glow when you talk about it. It's really lovely.

    Liz Power: I was very lucky. So, I've only ever worked in museums. I've never worked anywhere else, and then slowly over the 20 years of careers, I've made a list of all the places I would never work, which I might tell you if you come in and have a coffee. I was really, really lucky I was working so much on community engagement in museums and younger people in museums. That's really where I felt my focus should be, is on the social purpose of museums. I'm just really lucky that when I went to the interview at Water and Steam, I pitched them this left-wing community utopia they went for it. They trusted in me and backed me, and I think it's starting to come good.

    Kelly Molson: Yeah, it is. Absolutely. All right, so something else that I want to discuss with you. Now, this is the time in the podcast where I normally ask our guest to give a book recommendation. So, something that they love, something that maybe has shaped their career, and when I asked you this, you very... No, it was really such a valid point, and I thought, "No one's ever said that to me before, and nobody's ever raised this as a topic," but you basically said that books, they're not at the top of your list of things to do, because you have Dyslexia.

    Liz Power: Yes.

    Kelly Molson: Let's talk about the... museum and cultural world is extremely academic. How do you deal with this? What's your strategies?

    Liz Power: Well, it's super academic, isn't it? And I've got a terrible degree in drama. I could be a tree, but that's kind of where my academia ends. And as I made my way through my career, I was very aware that you just... Goodness, people are clever, aren't they? And they've done all sorts of qualifications and all the rest of it, and my idea of hell is doing an MA. Sounds horrific.

    Kelly Molson: Same.

    Liz Power: Degree in drama was bad enough. I'm not a studier, I hate it. The day I worked my first job, which was at Buckingham Palace, I worked in the security team. Literally, I was like, "Oh, I'm a worker bee. I'm happy. I don't want to study, I just want to work," and it's not been easy, because there is this presumption that you come from this academic background, and that you will gain your knowledge about the sector through reading and absorbing this. I could read a textbook on museum practice. I am not going to remember it, I'm not going to be able to take it in, and I won't understand the majority of the words, so my reading and writing age is about that of a 12-year-old, and that is not what museum books are written for. Though I am excellent at editing texts for exhibitions because 12 is what we should all aim for.

    Liz Power: So, I'm not a natural museum person like that. I also don't particularly like exhibitions, because I find reading hard, and so why would I choose to do that, stood up? If I'm going to read, and I do read for pleasure, I will be sat somewhere snugly, and so I can give my full concentration to it. Certainly not in a room with other people stood looking at a wall. So, accessing information throughout my career has kind of come from two places. First of all, from being brutally honest about my abilities and my limitations. My dyslexia affects my short-term memory, it affects my processing skills, it obviously affects my reading and writing skills. If I had to read something, then I need to kind of set aside time to actually do that, and be in the right environment to make myself read it.

    Liz Power: My own learning has mainly come from people. I mean, the best source of learning, they are. They are the people that write the books, after all, so you just go talk to the person. Skip out the middle page. I've done a lot of kind of following and networking and chatting to people. I've worked with some extraordinary people, and being so lucky to manage some brilliant people who have really challenged me in what I think and do, and if I'm able to kind of share how I need to work... If you're going to be managed by me, this is what you need to know. If I'm going to report to you, I mean, my poor trustees, what a learning curve.

    Liz Power: This is how this information will be coming to you, and best of luck deciphering this. So, I do do written reports, but they will quite often say, "Well, we'll have a verbal report on that one. Have a verbal report on that." And we only do one basic written report, so like our board meetings, that's majoritively kind of bullet points and things like... They kind of adapted to my issues, but the massive, massive plus side, and the reason I wouldn't turn off my dyslexia even if I could, is you choose me to be part of the team. You get all that hard work, but you also get an incredible dyslexic superpower, which I that I can see something complete. I can see what Water and Steam will be. Not might be, not could be, but will absolutely be. I can see the people walking through the door, I can see the interactions, and then what I can do once I can see something, I can take it apart and work out how to get there.

    Liz Power: I didn't realise this was a superpower until a former line manager said to me once, "You have three good ideas a year, Liz, and that's what we keep you around for." I said, "I do actually." But my ideas come fully formed, and that's really unusual to go, "I have a fully-formed vision of this." I woke up the other day and I had a fully-formed vision of how I would revolutionise sports engagement for the under-16s. I mean, for God's sake...

    Kelly Molson: Is there nothing that you can't do, Liz?

    Liz Power: No. Well, I'm not going to do it. But it's like, seriously brain, could you just switch off? That's the plus side of my dyslexia, is that I see things in a very different way to a lot of people, and then I have the ability to kind of undo it all. Yeah, so super dyslexic, now parent to two, potentially three super dyslexic children. I was lucky to be brought up in an incredibly dyslexic-positive household. My dad's dyslexic, my brother's dyslexic, my poor mother dealing with us all. It's got lots of downsides, but the upsides are so totally worth it. But it does mean I can't recommend a book.

    Kelly Molson: Oh, that's fine. Liz, this has been better than a book recommendation, because the fact that you've been able to kind of speak so openly and humorously about the subject, that's going to help more people than reading a book.

    Liz Power: Yeah, absolutely. If you have somebody who's dyslexic who's joining your team, or you're going to be working with them, there's a lot of resources from the Dyslexia Association that can talk to you about managing somebody with dyslexia or working with somebody with dyslexia. That really helps. It's a neuro-difference the same as any other, so get yourself clued up, work out what the plus sides are, and adapt as best as possible. I wouldn't change it, it doesn't make life easy, but it certainly makes it more interesting. I definitely couldn't do my job if I wasn't dyslexic. No chance.

    Kelly Molson: Amazing. Thank you for sharing that, Liz. Again, we will pop all of the links to the Dyslexia Association in the show notes as well, so if you haven't ever gone and looked at their website, go and browse it. I'm sure there's a lot of things on there that would be able to support your teams. Liz, it's been brilliant to talk to you. Thank you. Wishing you all the best of luck as you head into the winter months, and I'll check back in on you in a few months, and see how it's all going if that's okay.

    Liz Power: I would love that, and you must come in and have a coffee. And anybody else who wants to come in and abuse my brilliant coffee shop, then just send me a message on Twitter, and yeah, everyone's welcome. The more people I can show my museum to, the happier I am.

    Kelly Molson: Well, you heard it there, folks. Everyone needs to head over. Please, I know we did mention it earlier, but don't steal anything from the gift shop.

    Liz Power: I will catch you.

    Kelly Molson: Thanks for listening to Skip the Queue. If you've enjoyed this podcast, please leave us a five-star review. It really helps others find us. And remember to follow us on Twitter for your chance to win the books that have been mentioned. Skip the Queue is brought to you by

    Rubber Cheese, a digital agency that builds remarkable systems and websites for attractions that helps them increase their visitor numbers. You can find show notes and transcriptions for this episode and more over on our website, rubbercheese.com/podcast.

    Download The Visitor Attractions Website Survey Report - https://www.merac.co.uk/download-the-visitor-attractions-survey

     

    We have launched our brand-new playbook: ‘The Retail Ready Guide to Going Beyond the Gift Shop’ — your go-to resource for building a successful e-commerce strategy that connects with your audience and drives sustainable growth.

     

    Download your FREE copy here

    49 min
  • Scottish sector update with Gordon Morrison

    Skip the Queue is brought to you by Rubber Cheese, a digital agency that builds remarkable systems and websites for attractions that helps them increase their visitor numbers. Your host is Kelly Molson, MD of Rubber Cheese.

    Download our free ebook The Ultimate Guide to Doubling Your Visitor Numbers

    If you like what you hear, you can subscribe on iTunes, Spotify, and all the usual channels by searching Skip the Queue or visit our website rubbercheese.com/podcast
    If you've enjoyed this podcast, please leave us a five star review, it really helps others find us. And remember to follow us on Twitter for your chance to win the books that have been mentioned in this episode.

    Competition ends April 29th 2022. The winner will be contacted via Twitter.

    Show references:

    www.linkedin.com/in/gordon-morrison01

    www.asva.co.uk

    https://www.eventbrite.co.uk/e/scotlands-national-tourism-industry-conference-tickets-168074341881

    Conference - Scotland's National Tourism Industry Conference

    November 24th-25th, 2021

    https://scottishtourismalliance.co.uk/speakers/

    Gordon Morrison is the CEO of the Association of Scottish Visitor Attractions (ASVA), the representative body for the attractions sector in Scotland, a position he has held for the last 3 years. In this role, he has responsibility for the day-to-day operations and overall leadership of the organisation. Over the last 19 months, he has been instrumental in helping the sector in Scotland navigate a path through the pandemic, providing advice and guidance to attractions across the country and ensuring that the needs of the sector are heard within the corridors of power at Holyrood. He currently sits on a number of key industry groups, including the Scottish Tourism Recovery Taskforce, the Scottish Tourism Skills Group, the Scottish Thistle Awards Industry Panel and Scottish Tourism Emergency Response Sectoral Organisations Group.

    Gordon previously worked as Quality & Tourism Manager with VisitScotland where he was responsible for the delivery of the highly regarded Visitor Attraction Grading Scheme. He was also Commercial & Visitor Services Manager with Museums & Galleries Edinburgh where he led on shaping the visitor experience at iconic attractions such as the Scott Monument and Museum of Childhood.

    In over 15 years of working with the sector, Gordon has visited and offered advice to hundreds of different attractions across Scotland. He is universally known within the tourism industry as the authoritative voice on all things relating to the visitor attractions sector in Scotland.

    Transcription:

    Kelly Molson: Welcome to Skip The Queue, a podcast for people working in or working with visitor attractions. I'm your host Kelly Molson. Each episode, I speak with industry experts from the attractions world.

    In today's episode, I speak with Gordon Morrison, CEO of ASVA, the Association of Scottish Visitor Attractions.

    We discuss the state of the Scottish attraction sector, the need for more personal premium experiences, and what's happening at Scotland's National Tourism Industry Conference.

    If you like what you hear, subscribe on all the usual channels by searching to Skip The Queue.

    Kelly Molson: Gordon, welcome to Skip The Queue.

    Gordon Morrison: Thank you so much for having me, Kelly. I'm guessing that you've started at the bottom and you're going to work your way up for the rest of the series.

    Kelly Molson: No, it doesn't work like that at all, started at the top, Gordon, started at the top. Now, as you know, I know that you listen to the podcast, so we're going into our icebreaker questions. I'm going to ask you what your favourite film is and why it isn't Top Gun.

    Gordon Morrison: Wow, that's a great question. And how did you know it's not a Top Gun because Top Gun is a wonderful movie. I am a child of the 1980s. I could be obvious and I could go down the Star Wars route because I am a big Star Wars fan. But however, undoubtedly, the greatest movie ever made is National Lampoon's Vacation.

    Kelly Molson: Yes, that's a great film.

    Gordon Morrison: It's just beautiful in every way. It is funny, it is moving, it is heartwarming, and it's also a bit crude. All of the things that I really enjoy. And I'm a huge Chevy Chase fan, a huge Chevy Chase fan. We had the opportunity to meet him a few years ago in London. He actually was over in London and I paid a considerable amount of money to do a meet and greet with the great man himself.

    Kelly Molson: That's amazing. I don't know anyone that's done one of those. This is-

    Gordon Morrison: Really?

    Kelly Molson: ... is news to me, no.

    Gordon Morrison: I would not do it for, probably not for anyone else, but for Chevy Chase, I was determined to meet him before he pops his clogs because he's getting on. He's getting on, he's an older man nowadays. I also love The Three Amigos as well I should say. And Steve Martin and Martin Short are also two fantastic comedy actors and they've actually got a great show on Disney Plus just now, which is well worth watching. But however, Chevy Chase is my idol. National Lampoon's Vacation, I don't know how many times I've watched it. But I can pretty much recite it.

    Kelly Molson: I love this. And National Lampoon's Christmas Vacation is-

    Gordon Morrison: Probably the second greatest movie of all time and becomes the greatest movie of all time at Christmas-

    Kelly Molson: At Christmas time, yeah. So I'm going to say that, is it my favourite Christmas film? It's definitely one or two. I think that and Home Alone are like the two, they're the ones that I would watch every single Christmas, got to watch those. Oh, this is great. I'm finding out so much about you today. Okay, if you had a human body, which you do, but the head of an animal, what animal would you pick?

    Gordon Morrison: That's an interesting question that I haven't thought about before, strangely enough. I think if I could have any animal's head, I'd want it to be a really cute puppy. That's what I'd want it to be. I think I've got some doglike qualities to me anyway. But yeah-

    Kelly Molson: Loyal.

    Gordon Morrison: Yeah, yeah. Very loyal, like to sniff my own bum, that sort of stuff. So yeah, I think a acute, maybe a Golden Retriever, a Labrador, because it'd also be quite useful to have a really powerful nose and be able to sniff out trouble and things like that. So yeah, but mainly because I do quite enjoy getting my head stroked, so it'd be quite nice to constantly have that happening to me.

    Kelly Molson: We are learning so much about you today, Gordon. I would go giraffe because as we met in person a little while ago, we are both slightly vertically challenged.

    Gordon Morrison: We are.

    Kelly Molson: So I thought giraffe would help me grab stuff from the top shelves.

    Gordon Morrison: So you're including the neck then as part of the-

    Kelly Molson: Yeah, yeah. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, that's part of your head, kind of, isn't it?

    Gordon Morrison: Yeah, absolutely.

    Kelly Molson: Okay. If you could be in the Guinness Book of Records, what records breaking feat you attempt?

    Gordon Morrison: I would attempt the longest continuous Elvis tribute act performance. I have said that Chevy Chase is my idol, he absolutely is, but I'm also a massive Elvis Presley fan, to the extent that I used to, on occasion, don the outfit and take the stage as Elvis Presley.

    Kelly Molson: Is there any video evidence of this?

    Gordon Morrison: No, there is not because it was the sort of mid to late '90s or early, it was early 2000s. It was early 2000s that I did this. And it was still really early stages of mobile phones and all that sort of stuff. So therefore, there is unfortunately, no... But listen, if you want me to record something, I'll do it.

    Kelly Molson: Well, I mean, I'm thinking at some point next year of doing, a group meetup for podcast guests and listeners. So maybe you could be the entertainment.

    Gordon Morrison: I have a gold lamé suit and I also have a jumpsuit. Whether I can still fit into them is an entirely different... But surely that looks even better. That's more authentic if I can barely fit into-

    Kelly Molson: Completely authentic, you are hired. Okay, and what is your unpopular opinion?

    Gordon Morrison: Sure, I'll go topical. Adele is rubbish.

    Kelly Molson: Oh God, oh wow.

    Gordon Morrison: Cannot stand anything that she does.

    Kelly Molson: Nothing at all?

    Gordon Morrison: Nope. I thin-

    Kelly Molson: Never had a little weepy moment to an Adele song?

    Gordon Morrison: Not once.

    Kelly Molson: You are stone cold.

    Gordon Morrison: Well, I've had a weepy moment, but the weepy moment is more I'm like, "Good grief, get this awful banshee off of my radio." I cannot stand anything that she does. I think her vocal style is lazy.

    Kelly Molson: Oh, Gordon.

    Gordon Morrison: I think she sings in a lazy way.

    Kelly Molson: I don't even know where to go with this, I really don't. Started with a bombshell people. Let's now-

    Gordon Morrison: Keeping it topical. That's good, isn't it? Come on, keeping it topical.

    Kelly Molson: It is topical. Let me know how you feel about that, listeners. I'm feeling uncomfortable. I'm really excited to have you on the podcast today. So Gordon and I, listeners, if you don't follow me... Oh, did I put this on? I think I'll put this on Twitter. If you don't follow me on Twitter, why not? But Gordon and I met in 2020. We met in COVID times, but we met virtually. So we didn't actually see each other when we first met. Gordon and I were at the Visitor Attractions Conference, which actually brilliant, a brilliant virtual conference in 2020 that they were forced to do because of COVID. And Gordon came to visit me on my virtual stand, which if you've ever done a virtual stand at a virtual conference, it's a very, very lonely place.

    Kelly Molson: Not many people come and check in on you. It's hard enough when it's an actual stand and you have to drag people to speak to you. But a virtual one, yeah. It's tough times. But anyway, Gordon came over, had a little chat, and then we arranged to have a Zoom meeting, which we then had a great Zoom meeting. But I was a bit poorly and I did it in my pajamas because that's how all the best Zoom in start, in your pajamas. And then since then, we've gone on to do a few webinars for ASVA and their members. And the two of us have spoken quite a few times. And we actually got to meet in real life a couple of weeks ago, didn't we? At the Visitor Attractions Conference.

    Gordon Morrison: Obviously lovely to meet you in person and see other people I've only communicated with via this medium before. So it was quite special actually, it really was quite special. And it was lovely to see just how diminutive you are, Kelly, such a big personality, such a diminutive form.

    Kelly Molson: Big gob, small stature, I think that's how I would be described. So tell us a little bit about ASVA and what your role is there.

    Gordon Morrison: Okay. So ASVA is short for the Association of Scottish Visitor Attractions. We are the trade body that represents the attraction sector in Scotland. We have over 250 member organisations, which equates to roughly 500 visitor attractions all across the country. I'm the Chief Executive. I've been chief executive there for three years. A particularly interesting last two years, as I'm sure you can imagine.

    Kelly Molson: Yep.

    Gordon Morrison: And really, the organisation almost like the way that our members have had to pivot during the pandemic, ASVA had to pivot during the pandemic. We certainly existed, initially, to provide inspiration and best practice. That really what we were there to do, shine a light on all that was great and good happening, not just in the attraction sector in Scotland, but nationally and internationally as well. During the pandemic, we really had to become much more of a lobbying organisation. I had to cut my lobbying teeth very quickly, Kelly and was fortunate to work with some great people within the industry, that helped me with that as well.

    Gordon Morrison: I know that you had Bernard on your podcast the other week, who's a very experienced lobbyist. And I learned from people like him. We also had to take everything online as an organisation, which is truly fascinating for us because we were an organisation that did everything in person, absolutely everything in person. We are 32 years old and had never once hosted an online event, online meeting. Then, pandemic hits, everything changes. And we have now run something like 60 online workshops or events throughout the pandemic. All about supporting the sector, helping the sector get through to where we are today, which is still not in a perfect situation. There are still many challenges ahead for the industry.

    Gordon Morrison: But ASVA played a hugely important role in informing the sector, and supporting the sector, and fighting for the sector throughout the pandemic. At the height of the pandemic, we were actually producing daily bulletins that went out across the entirety of the industry, about what they needed to know. All very much tailored to the visitor attraction sector, nothing cut and pasted from any other areas. It was all tailored specifically to visitor attractions. We've had many, many meetings with the Scottish government in particular, but also the UK government as well, to highlight just how desperate it was for a spell, just how desperate it was for a spell.

    Gordon Morrison: And we were successful in getting funding for the visitor attraction sector in Scotland, which I was particularly proud that we were able to do. And indeed, we helped to ensure that when we got the funding, that funding went to the right places and went to the attractions that needed it the most. And therefore, we got ourselves into a situation where our sector has not had the catastrophic failure that we feared it may have had. Well, things are still not great. And I know we'll talk about that shortly. We are now seeing, hopefully, some of the green shoots of recovery and we'll get the sector back on an even keel in 2022.

    Kelly Molson: That's really good to hear and we are going to talk about that in a minute. But I just want to, just something that you mentioned about how when this all kicked off, when the pandemic happened, I mean, that must have been unbelievably overwhelming for you. Because not only are you looking at your own organisation and saying, "Wow, we have got to change absolutely every way that we've done things in the past, everything has to change now. We can't do any in person whatsoever." So having to deal with all of that whilst also, like you say, learning how to lobby. So putting hat on, and then being there as a support. And I guess a shoulder for people to cry on, scream at, shout out, whatever they needed to do, for all of your members as well. That must have been an unbelievably overwhelming time. How did you feel?

    Gordon Morrison: Yeah. I mean, overwhelming is the correct word. And of course, none of us had ever been through anything like this before. That's the other thing, there was no guide book for this. There was nowhere for me to turn and say, "What have you done when we've previously seen a pandemic such as this?" We had never seen anything like this before. You mentioned being a shoulder to cry on or cry at, that genuinely happened on quite a lot of occasions. I had members phone me up in tears, sometimes angry tears, sometimes just sad tears. And that was particularly challenging. When sometimes you didn't have answers, you couldn't just tell them, "Oh, everything is going to be okay." Because it didn't necessarily look like everything was going to be okay.

    Gordon Morrison: I think for me, there was one crucial decision that I made, which at the time didn't actually feel crucial. But we looked at ourselves and our own operation at ASVA, and we're a pretty small team, Kelly. Well, at the time, there was only three of us working for the organisation. And I was and still am the only full-time member of staff. ASVA, we've got two and a half full-time equivalent staff working for us at the moment. We had, at the height of the pandemic, just two full-time equivalent staff working for us. We had an office in Glasgow and I took the decision that whilst we would get rid of our office and felt that we didn't need an office anymore, we would not scale down our operations. We were there to support our sector.

    Gordon Morrison: We would actually scale up. We would do more to support the sector, which it was a difficult decision because the obvious thing to do was protect the business. And so therefore, why don't we put the team on furlough and you'll ride this through? But however, it was a no brainer for me in the end to say, "No, we are there to support our sector." Therefore, like I said, we scaled up what we did. We pushed everything online, we learned really fast. I developed really close contacts within the Scottish government as well. Not necessarily always talking to the ministers, officials are often the right people to get in front of and talk to.

    Gordon Morrison: And as a result, ASVA actually grew. We were really worried at the beginning of the pandemic that we would lose members, obviously, because you think, "Well, who can afford a membership fee when they've got huge, huge financial problems?" But actually, what we found was that not only did we retain our members, we grew our membership because of that desire that we had to truly, genuinely support the industry. And I have to thank my own board as well, the Board of Directors of ASVA, for giving me steer on what the industry needed. We've got 12 board members, who all work within the attraction sector. And they were there at a drop of a hat every time I needed them.

    Gordon Morrison: I said, "Right, what do we think of this? What do we think of this new guidance that's come out from the Scottish government? What does that mean for our sector?" And I could then feedback because the Scottish government were very much looking for me to feedback from the attraction sector and say, "Right, this is what this will mean. This is what will happen to the attraction sector if you do this." But I do think that decision to scale up, rather than contract and just try and save ourselves was the crucial, crucial decision. Crucial decision for ASVA, but also for the sector as well. Because we really did step up to another level at that point.

    Kelly Molson: Yeah, it's brilliant. I mean the amount of content that went out, and the webinars that you put on, and the research, which we'll talk a little bit about now actually. Because throughout the pandemic, you were surveying the sector, finding out what was happening, where they were at, what the visitor numbers were like. And you've just released the latest survey, which was conducted by the Moffitt Center, which let me read this out.

    Kelly Molson: It reveals that a majority of Scottish attractions are still in survival mode, which is not surprising. The sector is not seeing any evidence of a staycation boom. And obviously, the press have talked about staycation boom a lot. I think UK attractions have mixed results in that, depending on where they are located up and down the country. But Scotland seems to not be seeing any evidence of that. So can we talk about that? How's the sector currently feeling?

    Gordon Morrison: So I think firstly, on the point about being in survival mode, that is still the case universally, I would say, doesn't matter which part of the UK you're in. I think that the vast majority of the sector is still in survival mode, rather than recovery mode. Actually, I was fortunate enough to attend the Association of Visitor Experience and Attractions Conference in Ireland, attended that virtually and it was exactly the same narrative there. That are still in survival, but looking towards a recovery. And that's where our sector is in Scotland. We are in survival mode, but very optimistic that we will recover, rather than now thinking we are going to lose 50%, whatever, of the sector.

    Gordon Morrison: But in terms of the staycation boom, it's been a really... This is an area where I've been banging in my head against the wall sometimes, Kelly, because it's actually impossible for the majority of visitor attractions in Scotland and indeed in other parts of the UK, or it has been impossible for us to truly benefit from the staycation boom. Because don't get me wrong. I agree that there have been lots of domestic visitors, there have been lots of people going on holiday in the UK because frankly, they've got no other opportunity or no other option than to go on holiday in the UK. But there have been restrictions in place and let's not forget this.

    Gordon Morrison: There have been restrictions in place in Scotland, on things like well, we call it physical distancing, social distancing in England. These restrictions weren't lifted in Scotland. We still had physical distancing restrictions in place right through to mid August. And if you've got restrictions in place that limit, that severely limit the number of visitors that you can physically get in your door, you can be at capacity. You can be, "Right, we're at 100% capacity." Which sounds fantastic. But that 100% capacity is actually only 20, 30% of where you would normally be. And therefore, we have missed the majority of the traditional season. And by missing the majority of the traditional season, you're then left with a very small window of opportunity, sort of mid August to October holidays, just beyond October holidays, to make your money.

    Gordon Morrison: And that's a very limited window. Let's be honest, that really is. And that's why our sector's still in survival mode as we go into the winter. I think perhaps one of the most telling stats from the survey was in relation to the amount of reserves that attractions still had. And we've got more than one in five visitor attractions in Scotland, holding fewer than three months reserves, right? Why is that important? That is important because the winter is longer than three months and you need those reserves. In a good year, you need those reserves to see you through the winter. That's how attractions operate. They make the money in the summer, to then see them through the winter. So that's where the issues still exist for our sector. And again, it was interesting at the Irish conference, to see that the latest budget has just been published by the Irish government.

    Gordon Morrison: And they have pledged to continue their version of the Coronavirus job retention scheme right through to spring of next year. And they've also pledged an extra 50 million euros of support for tourism businesses, to get them through to next season. And I think that's very telling that they have recognized the call that's come from the tourism industry in Ireland is, "We are still in survival mode. Let us get through to next season when we will fully lead the recovery." And I think that's a lesson that still needs to be heard in both Scotland and the UK. Because there seems to be a feeling that, "Well, you have made it through. Well done, guys, you've made it through." But there's still a proportion of the sector that will face a very difficult winter ahead.

    Kelly Molson: So are you still in lobbying mode then? Because it feels like-

    Gordon Morrison: Oh, must be.

    Kelly Molson: Yeah, so the sector still needs support. So the results of this survey say that very, very clearly. So you're still in lobbying mode.

    Gordon Morrison: Yeah, yeah. There's no doubt about that. I mean, the survey is produced. We like to do it for our members and they can get an idea of where they are sitting in comparison to other parts of the sector. But primarily, I'll be fully honest with you, we do it so that I can use it in my lobbying efforts. The first person that received this survey results, was the tourism minister. The very first person. I was like, "Bang, here you go. Can we now meet and discuss this?" Don't get me wrong, it's a challenge because there's also an element of politics being played in the UK, as you'll know, Kelly.

    Gordon Morrison: The fact that the Scottish government takes a different route from the UK government, sometimes that that route is taken for, as far as I'm concerned, for political reasons, to create a differentiation. But also, that there are challenges with things. But when I speak to the tourism minister and say, "We really could use the Coronavirus job retention scheme extended, or we could cut to be extended further." Those are not really issues that he can do much about, other than agree. Other than say, "Yes, I 100% agree with that." That's then reserved at the UK level, which is why it's hugely important that I also feed into the lobbying that's done at a UK level as well, by the likes of Bernard and others.

    Kelly Molson: Yeah, okay. So let's have a look more at some of the stats that have come in. So it says here, almost half, so 47.5% of the sector has seen a decrease in visitor numbers of greater than 50% this year compared to the same period in 2019. I mean again, that's not shocking, is it? Because, like you say, you've had so many restrictions still in place for longer than in the UK attractions.

    Gordon Morrison: That's entirely it.

    Kelly Molson: And it says turnover is down by over 50%, a third of attractions when compared to the same period in 2019. Again, not a shock, is it? None of this is a surprise.

    Gordon Morrison: No.

    Kelly Molson: What can be done about it? What's the positives that can taken from it?

    Gordon Morrison: Well, yeah. I think that's important to emphasize here, Kelly, is that, don't get me wrong, when I'm doing my lobbying, I'm painting the doom and gloom picture to the government to try and leverage as much support as we can get. But however, there are positives emerging from the pandemic. Just now, for a start, when you delve into the data in a bit more detail, it's clear that the numbers are getting better. We are seeing an improving picture just now. And indeed, you mentioned yourself, it depends on what type of business that you have and where in the country you're located. If you were to look at, for example, wildlife related attractions or animal related attractions, they're booming.

    Gordon Morrison: They are absolutely booming, or least the majority of them are booming just now. We just published our visitor figures for ASVA members, for the month of August. So that's the most recent data that we've got and the wildlife operators were up by 14% on 2019 levels.

    Kelly Molson: Oh, wow, wow.

    Gordon Morrison: Yeah, they're up on 2019, which is incredible, that really is. I mean, primarily driven by the huge popularity of Edinburgh Zoo, it has to be said, which you can imagine, if you're an outdoor family attraction, it's a good time for you. Speaking as a dad, you are desperate to take your kids somewhere. You are absolutely desperate to do that. And a zoo is an absolutely fantastic place to take the kids. So it's not universally the case that things are awful. That's the first point.

    Gordon Morrison: And we are seeing a generally improving picture month upon month. If you look at the figures from July compared to June, compared to July compared to August. It's going in the right to direction. And of course, we have now got rid of the physical distancing restrictions entirely, which releases the sector to actually begin to trade at a viable level. Although, interestingly, in the survey, we did ask members whether they were maintaining restrictions themselves and many, many were. In fact, we had, was it 92% of the sector said that they were going to maintain COVID safety measures above and beyond what was required by law. And that again is useful for me when it comes to lobbying. Because what it shows is that our sector puts the safety of visitors and staff above everything else.

    Gordon Morrison: You cannot necessarily say that about every sector in the UK. But for our sector, we have consistently proven, throughout the pandemic, that we are putting safety and wellbeing above everything else. And therefore, for me, if there are... We're seeing COVID spiking again, let's not beat around the bush here. The number of cases is at, I think it's highest level for something like six, seven months. It's a huge, huge increase. If further restrictions are introduced again, I think it's... But I've already spoken to the Scottish government about this as well. Our sector's the one sector that actually, you're not seeing any transmission come from, because we are very, very responsible. And I would hope that that would be recognised if restrictions get introduced again.

    Kelly Molson: Well, I was going to ask about the locality thing. So obviously in the UK, during lockdown, there was a lot of appreciation for where you lived. I think that's how we looked at it. People went out on their hour's walk of exercise, and then they found new places to visit. But they actually, you've seen that kind of boost in tourism to the local places, people shopping more local. And again, that was happening prior to pre-pandemic, that was a trend anyway. But I think we're still seeing that happen. People stay local, people visiting. Is it the same in Scotland? Are you finding that?

    Gordon Morrison: Absolutely. And on top of the fact that we're getting more of a sense of place. And I think attraction operators are actually understanding that sense of place a bit better as well. On top of that, the visitors that are coming to see us, our local bread and butter visitors, are spending money, Kelly, they really are spending money. And that is a key lesson that we need to take away from this. Secondary spend in shops and in cafes is considerably up on pre-pandemic levels across the board. Now that's a combination, I think visitors have maybe got a wee bit of disposable income to spend after being stuck in lockdown for a long period of time.

    Gordon Morrison: Also, they want to spend. They want to get there and spend some money. And indeed, they are having a good experience. And that's probably the crucial point here. Again, looking at the results from a most recent survey, we asked a question about, right, what's happened to your visitor reviews? Are your visitor reviews on Trip Advisor, on Google, whatever platform you use, are they improving? Are they getting worse? And for the majority of the sector, the reviews have actually improved throughout the pandemic. And that is because visitors have had more time, more staff interaction, and a more personalised experience.

    Gordon Morrison: Now, by having that, more time, more personalised experience, they then are more inclined to spend more. And this is not your rich international visitor. This is not an international visitor who's going to want to take back an expensive souvenir. This is a local domestic visitor, who's coming to your attraction and they are having a really great experience and therefore. They're spending money. And that is the key lesson that I think we have to take. And the key positive that we can take, out of the pandemic, which is that I think attractions have had the opportunity, in the various lockdowns, to take a breath almost, to think about their offering and what they're doing for their visitors.

    Gordon Morrison: I think, are we doing everything we can do to ensure that our visitors get a great experience? Is the model of cram as many visitors into your attraction as possible, the right model that we want to operate? And it's proven to be throughout the pandemic, that that is not what we should be doing. What we should be doing is providing a high quality experience, which then encourages the visitors that we do have to spend a bit more money with us. And that's where we're going now, that's the direction of travel that we're going in. We're not going to see pre-pandemic levels of visitation for many, many years, possibly ever again.

    Gordon Morrison: And I've spoken about this before in various meetings that I've attended. If we take somewhere like Edinburgh Castle, as an example, Edinburgh Castle, over 2 million visitors in 2019. If you speak to Historic Environment of Scotland about that. First it was, you're a big success to have that number of visitors. Was it actually great for the castle itself? Was it great for the visitor experience? Certainly not as good as it could be. Therefore, we should be moving more to the model of, it's been spoken about it before, value rather than volume. And that is where we are 100% going. And I think that's going to be really positive for the sector.

    Gordon Morrison: And also, I think the sector actually now begins to understand what their value is. And the fact that attractions in Scotland and across the UK are actually offering really unique, memorable experiences, really fantastic experiences. And shouldn't be scared, therefore, to charge accordingly for those experiences. And we have seen some of our operators in Scotland have increased the pricing or are delivering a premium version of their standard experience and charging a bit more to do that. And that, to me, is the way that we should be going as a sector and we will continue to go as a sector.

    Kelly Molson: Yeah, I totally agree. It's weird actually, I gave a talk for Anglia Ruskin University back in summer about that very concept of attractions having less visitors, a more personalised experience that they will pay more money for. So ultimately, less visitors doesn't mean less revenue.

    Gordon Morrison: Exactly.

    Kelly Molson: That's exactly where I see the sector going. And that actually leads really nicely onto a new attraction that's opened, that has that mentality. And that's the Johnnie Walker Experience that's just opened, which looks absolutely incredible. And I know that you've been lucky enough to go and visit already, haven't you?

    Gordon Morrison: Yeah. And it is actually the perfect model, Kelly, for what we've just spoken about there. It's an outstanding visitor experience, it's truly unique and it's personalised to yourself. The way I've talked about it since I've been is that you go in and you're immediately met, firstly with a smiling face, which is always a nice thing to be met with. Although, behind the mask, but still a smiling face. And you're instructed to create your own flavour profile for your best ever Johnnie Walker drink.

    Gordon Morrison: It's like the Tinder of whiskey. You're swiping left or swiping right on whether you like mango, or whether you like apple, or whatever. And it then creates your ideal flavour profile. You get a wristband that is colour coded. And when you go up to experience the next part of the experience, you present this wristband to a dispenser and it pours for you, your ideal highball, Johnnie Walker highball. It's incredible. I don't know how it works. For all I know just everyone's getting the exact same highball. I don't-

    Kelly Molson: Ah, but the experience is that it's personalised to you.

    Gordon Morrison: That's exactly right. And what Johnnie Walker, what Diageo have successfully done with this experience, is they've said, "Right, we're not going to create a high volume, low value experience." They limit the numbers on their tours to a really low level. It's never going feature at the top 10 most visited attractions in Scotland or the UK. It's never going to feature on there because they're limiting the numbers. But I'm sure they wouldn't mind me saying this, unashamedly charging a premium for it. It's 25 quid if you want to take that experience, which in an attraction ticket entry place, is a high price point, it is a high price point to do that. But that is because you're going to get a unique, personalised experience. And of course, they'll chuck it in a high ball as well, which is a nice thing.

    Kelly Molson: Oh, high praise indeed. I've got to give my friend, my good friend, Kazia, is actually the Brand Home Experience Manager at Johnnie Walker. So I hope that she's listening. She'll be thrilled to hear such fabulous feedback.

    Gordon Morrison: That is a must visit, Kelly. I'm not just saying that because they're ASVA members. But anyone who gets the opportunity to visit Edinburgh, it's a truly unique experience. And topped off by this incredible rooftop bar that has got the best panoramic views over Edinburgh. Edinburgh Castle will argue they have the best panoramic views of the city. But what the Johnnie Walker Princes Street has got, is a view of the castle as well.

    Kelly Molson: And they haven't got the whiskey, have they? Let's face-

    Gordon Morrison: That's true. That is true.

    Kelly Molson: They've not got the whiskey to have up there. I really would like to see where this leads. I would love other attractions adopting this model. So it'll be really interesting to catch up, maybe a year from now and see how attractions have kind of shifted their offer in Scotland, to see if they follow suit in terms of this kind of premium level, better experience, less visitor numbers.

    Gordon Morrison: I think they're have to, Kelly. That's the interesting thing here is that I still speak to you lot of my members, who are waiting for things to go back to normal. That's how they put it, "I can't wait for things to go back to normal." And my answer to that is that they're not going to go back to normal. There is pre-pandemic times and then there is post-pandemic times or pandemic times, because the pandemic's not going away.

    Gordon Morrison: We're still going to have COVID-19 for many years to come. And I think that the sector has to embrace this now and say, "Okay. Well, if we are not going to have those pre-pandemic level of visitation, we all have to adapt our experiences." And without doing a shameless plug, but why not? We hosted a conference this year in November and that is a big theme of the conferences, is looking at how you are shaping, how you are creating those memorable experiences in this new normal that we live in. And we'll be really shouting from the rooftops about that.

    Kelly Molson: Let's talk about the conference. So Scotland's National Tourism Industry Conference, 24th to the 25th of November. This is a culmination really, of all of the support that you've been giving to your members throughout the pandemic anyway. So what's going to be there? Why should people come?

    Gordon Morrison: Yeah. I mean, firstly, we're absolutely delighted to be hosting it, both in person and online. Again, one of the great things for ASVA actually, throughout the pandemic, Kelly, was that we delivered this host of great workshops online, including some with yourself of course. And it opened us up to a much bigger audience. When we’re delivering in person events, we were delighted if we got, say 40 people to attend one of our workshops, maybe 50 people to attend one of our workshops. And I thought, "That's a great turnout, that's really great." And all often from the central belt of Scotland, everyone from Edinburgh or Glasgow. Whereas, when we hosted events online, we opened it up to a much larger audience.

    Gordon Morrison: And we had our members from Shetlands, from Hebrides, and far flung areas, joining as in taking part in these sessions. So therefore, when it came to the conference this year, we had a clear idea that we wanted to do it in person because we think the sector wants to get by it together. But it also needed that online element as well. So regardless of where you are, and indeed, regardless of whether you're an ASVA member, you can actually attend the conference virtually if you would like to do so. We're also doing it in partnership with other leading associations in Scotland, including the Scottish Tourism Line. So sort of the overarching Tourism Association representing the attraction sector. And we're doing that intentionally, because we want to not just bring attractions together, we want to bring the whole industry, the entirety of the Scottish tourism industry together, as much to celebrate that we've made it this far as anything else.

    Kelly Molson: Yeah, it's really important to acknowledge that, isn't it? It's been so tough.

    Gordon Morrison: It's been massively, massively difficult. And we've all had many stresses and strains throughout the pandemic. Not all of us have given birth to a child, of course, Kelly, which is even bigger stress and strain. But about, however, it has been a hugely difficult time. And we want to bring the sector together to just say, "Pat on the back. Well done guys, we have made it through to this level. Now, let's push on. Now, let's push on to the next level."

    Gordon Morrison: And that is what the theme of the conference really is about. So I'm leading one of the days of the conference and I'm really excited about the part that I'm leading, which is all about delivering memorable experiences as we move into the year of Scotland Stories 2022. Yeah, Scotland has themed years every year. There's a tourism related theme year. So this year we're in the year, of course, of waters, for example. And like I said, next year we move into the year of Scotland Stories, which is a wonderful theme year for visitor attractions, because we're all about storytelling, that's what we're all about-

    Kelly Molson: Yeah, it's perfect.

    Gordon Morrison: Yeah, exactly. So, so we are really, every part of the conference has got some link to delivering memorable experiences and delivering great stories. But what we're trying to do, Kelly, is really put it in a, not an airy fairy way at all, as in put it in a commercial way. Say, "Right, this is what delivering a great story will mean for your business. This is how you can actually improve business performance, by delivering these great stories." And we've got a host of wonderful speakers coming along. If you don't mind me saying it, I'm most excited about the fact that we've got the Creative Director from Walt Disney Imagineering joining us, to talk about the galactic star cruise experience that Walt Disney World is introducing next year, which is-

    Kelly Molson: That's a clever coup, isn't it? You've got that speaker, it's amazing.

    Gordon Morrison: That's a mind blowing story. They don't even call it storytelling, let's call it a story living experience because you actually go and live on a star cruiser in the Star Wars Universe for two days. Kelly, I'm there. I am there.

    Kelly Molson: It's blowing your mind, isn't it, Gordon? I can see.

    Gordon Morrison: Oh my goodness, yeah. But actually referring back to what we spoke about earlier, what's interesting about it is, that's a premium experience, that's about as premium as it gets. They are not ashamed of the fact that they are charging $6,000 for a two night experience, $6,000. And they know that they will get an audience for that.

    Kelly Molson: Oh yeah.

    Gordon Morrison: But that's because it is a high quality, truly unique storytelling experience. And those are the lessons that we're looking for, on a smaller scale to take. I'm not saying to our members, "Right, the way you create memorable experiences, have light saber jewels throughout it." As much as love that, I would love that and the Johnnie Walker Princes Street, that'd be fantastic.

    Gordon Morrison: I think what attractions need to do is think about what their unique stories can be. And then implement those storytelling experiences at their attractions. And they will find that they can charge an appropriate level to their visitors, because visitors will eat these things up. They will want these truly unique, different experiences. And so that's what we're covering at the conference. And it's going to be a wonderful couple of days, it really is.

    Kelly Molson: It really sounds like it. And I will be there virtually. I'd love to be there in real life next year, definitely. I don't think that tiny person that I gave birth to will be too comfortable with me leaving her for a couple of nights, to head up to Scotland. Thank you for sharing that. I do think that that conference is going to be a real celebration of just like you say, yes, we've absolutely made it. We've made it this far. Now, what can we do to push on and be better? Open better, that's what we need to be driving the message of. And that's absolutely going to do that at that conference. So I'm super excited about it.

    Gordon Morrison: Thank you.

    Kelly Molson: We are at the end of our podcast interview. And I always ask our guests for a book recommendation, so something that you love or something that's helped shape your career. Just something that you'd like to share with our listeners.

    Gordon Morrison: I had a long think about this, Kelly, what I would recommend for a book, I'm an educated man. I'm a historian. I could recommend some really great historical texts and some very worthy books that have helped to educate me and take me to the level that I am today.

    Kelly Molson: I feel like you're not going that way though.

    Gordon Morrison: I'm not going to go that way at all, because it's not actually who I am. I am deeply in love, deeply in love with Calvin and Hobbes. I don't know if you've ever read any Calvin and Hobbes before.

    Kelly Molson: I haven't, no.

    Gordon Morrison: So for those who don't know, it's a comic strip effectively, a newspaper comic strip from the United States that has been brought into a whole series of different collections that are available in all good book shops. And it's two characters. Calvin is a five-year-old boy and Hobbes is his tiger. And Hobbes is a stuffed tiger, who only comes to life in front of Calvin. And there's a question about whether Hobbes is real and just no one else gets to see him as being real or whether it's all in Calvin's imagination.

    Gordon Morrison: And Calvin is a wee cynical, hilarious boy, and Hobbes is a much more stoic and measured character. And combined, they have these incredible adventures. And it really is, it's a moral compass thing, that's the only way I can put Calvin and Hobbes. Calvin and Hobbes is a moral compass thing. You can read Calvin and Hobbes and it will set you straight on the path that you need to be going on because they are righteous. They are genuinely righteous. And it's also hilarious. It is one of the most hilarious things you could ever read.

    Gordon Morrison: But my favourite... I mean, any of them are good, Kelly. Because I know you'll then say, right, here's one that you can look at. I would say that There's Treasure Everywhere is a great compendium. And the last one that was ever produced is called It's A Magical World. And it has the most beautiful end story of any story you can ever want to read. And the last words of it are, "It's a magical world." And I'm actually, I can feel my emotions rising as to talk about it just now. So Calvin and Hobbes, It's A Magical World. I would urge everyone in the world to read it. You'll feel like a million dollars.

    Kelly Molson: Ah, what an absolutely wonderful book recommendation to end this podcast interview on, that's perfect. As ever, if you want to win a copy of Gordon's book, then head over to our Twitter account, which is Skip The Queue and retweet this episode announcement with the comment, I want Gordon's book. And you could be in with the chance of winning it. I feel all emotional. This is how I feel when I listen to Adele.

    Gordon Morrison: Oh, oh, you've just ruined it.

    Kelly Molson: Thanks for listening to Skip The Queue. If you've enjoyed this podcast, please leave us a five star review, it really helps others find us. And remember to follow us on Twitter for your chance to win the books that have been mentioned. Skip The Queue is brought to you by

    Rubber Cheese, a digital agency that builds remarkable systems and websites for attractions that helps them increase their visitor numbers. You can find show notes and transcriptions from this episode and more over on our website rubbercheese.com/podcast.

    Download The Visitor Attractions Website Survey Report - https://www.merac.co.uk/download-the-visitor-attractions-survey

     

    We have launched our brand-new playbook: ‘The Retail Ready Guide to Going Beyond the Gift Shop’ — your go-to resource for building a successful e-commerce strategy that connects with your audience and drives sustainable growth.

     

    Download your FREE copy here

    44 min
  • How to write a website brief that agencies will thank you for, with Sophie Ballinger

    Skip the Queue is brought to you by Rubber Cheese, a digital agency that builds remarkable systems and websites for attractions that helps them increase their visitor numbers. Your host is Kelly Molson, MD of Rubber Cheese.

    Download our free ebook The Ultimate Guide to Doubling Your Visitor Numbers

    If you like what you hear, you can subscribe on iTunes, Spotify, and all the usual channels by searching Skip the Queue or visit our website rubbercheese.com/podcast
    If you've enjoyed this podcast, please leave us a five star review, it really helps others find us. And remember to follow us on Twitter for your chance to win the books that have been mentioned in this episode.

    Competition ends April 29th 2022. The winner will be contacted via Twitter.

    Show references:

    www.linkedin.com/in/sospot

    https://twitter.com/sospot

    www.eureka.org.uk

    www.eurekadiscovery.org.uk

    Alex Holliman’s - Choosing An Agency Podcast

    www.alexholliman.com/podcasts

    www.rubbercheese.com/insights/how-to-write-a-website-brief-that-agencies-will-thank-you-for

    Sophie Ballinger is a Communications Specialist with a background of 10 years working in the NHS and universities, before hopping across to the charity sector in 2008. She’s a skilled communicator with a playful, creative outlook (on both life and work).

    She joined Eureka! The National Children's Museum in September 2011 to develop their digital communications and press, having previously been Communications Development Officer at CDX (a national community development charity) and Communications & Social Media Officer at NAVCA (a national umbrella organisation for the third sector).

    In 2014 she was one of two people that set up #MuseumHour - a weekly Twitter discussion (which she co-ran for two years) and regularly volunteer to help groups and organisations develop their communications.

    Transcription:

    Kelly Molson: Welcome to Skip the Queue, a podcast for people working in or working with visitor attractions. I'm your host, Kelly Molson. Each episode I speak with industry experts from the attractions world.

    In today's episode I speak with Sophie Ballinger, Communication and Digital Content Manager at Eureka! The National Children's Museum.

    We'll be discussing the website tendering process and all the things you need to include to make a perfect website brief.

    If you like what you hear, subscribe on iTunes, Spotify, and all the user channels by searching Skip the Queue.

    Kelly Molson: Aye up, duck.

    Sophie Ballinger: Aye up, duck.

    Kelly Molson: Oh, I'm so excited. I've got the lovely Sophie Ballinger in here today from Eureka! Museum.

    Sophie Ballinger: My official title-

    Kelly Molson: Yes. Eureka! The National Children's Museum. We are going to talk all things how to write a website brief that agencies will thank you for. But first, it's the icebreaker questions time. All right. Weirdest thing you've ever won a prize for?

    Sophie Ballinger: Oh. I got given a tiny, little trophy for the best social media response, and it was a visitor to Eureka! one very busy February half term who compared it to the fall of Saigon in '76. I just replied, "You weren't there, man." That was quite weird, I think.

    Kelly Molson: That is excellent. I have to say, your social media feed is excellent.

    Sophie Ballinger: Well, thank you.

    Kelly Molson: You have a good Twitter chat, which I like. What is your favourite smell and why?

    Sophie Ballinger: I could be really corny and say my daughter's head. I love the smell of creosote.

    Kelly Molson: What?

    Sophie Ballinger: I love the smell of creosote. I think it's an association with my nan, who I loved to bits. Absolutely adored my nan. In order to go into her house, you had to go past a fence, which she creosoted religiously every couple years. I think that's the association, but I don't know. I love the smell of creosote.

    Kelly Molson: Wow. Nanas and creosote, it's quite an unusual combo, right? I thought you were going to say Werther's Originals from my nana. Nope, creosote. To be fair, tarmac is the same for me because my dad was a tarmacker years ago. He used to tarmac kids' playgrounds. So every time I smell the tarmac, it always reminds me of my dad because he used to come home stinking of it. Okay. What's your unpopular opinion?

    Sophie Ballinger: See, I've really struggled with this. This is a relatively recent one that's just doing my head in, and it's why and how are Coldplay still a thing?

    Kelly Molson: Oh, I've got someone that would 100% agree with you on this.

    Sophie Ballinger: It's just doing my head in. I didn't even realise they were still a thing until relatively recently. I've got an eight-year-old daughter who has discovered Radio 1, and I haven't really listened to Radio 1 for years. I remember seeing Coldplay playing Glastonbury on the tele. I wasn't there. We're probably talking late '90s, I guess '99, around then, I think, "You know, maybe they've got something interesting." Then I got really bored of them really quickly, and I wasn't aware that they were still a thing all this time.

    Sophie Ballinger: Then suddenly, every time I look at the BBC website, the other day there was a story about them going on tour. They're doing an eco-friendly world tour where people dancing on the floor charges. Now they've done a single with BTS.

    Kelly Molson: I know. They're current now. That's why they've done it, right?

    Sophie Ballinger: I know, but why? They've got teenage children. Their kids must be mortified. They're the same age as me. It's like me doing a collaboration with Doja Cat or something.

    Kelly Molson: This is my favourite unpopular opinion ever.

    Sophie Ballinger: Yeah. Why? How?

    Kelly Molson: Why is Coldplay a thing?

    Sophie Ballinger: Explain it to me.

    Kelly Molson: Also, Chris Martin does dance like a nana as well if you ever watch.

    Sophie Ballinger: Yes.

    Kelly Molson: Excellent. All right, well. I mean, I look forward to the tweets about this. Tell me what you think.

    Sophie Ballinger: If someone can explain it and if someone can tell me who it is that's buying their records, put them down.

    Kelly Molson: The wrath of Sophie. All right, great. Thank you for sharing that.

    Sophie Ballinger: I feel lighter for it.

    Kelly Molson: Right. So a few months ago I was on a mutual friend's podcast. I was on Alex Holliman's podcast, the Choosing an Agency podcast. He asked me, "What is the best brief that you've ever received," like website brief. I said, "It was the brief that we got from Eureka! The National Children's Museum, because it was excellent." And I went into great detail as to why. I thought it would be really interesting to have a chat with you about that tender process that you went through and why I think that your brief is excellent or was excellent.

    Kelly Molson: We actually wrote a blog, which is up on our website. It's called How to write a website brief that agencies will thank you for, which is the same title as this podcast. We detail in it all of the things that we would love to see as an agency from a brief, and it's things like really understanding your company profile, your project goals and objectives, target audience, what's up with the current website, really what you want from your new website, competitors, schedule, budget, what that selection process and the feedback is going to look like.

    Kelly Molson: There's quite a lot to it. Probably some more things that we could add to that now. But I thought, "Yeah, let's have a chat about the tender process to start with," and then we can go through in detail why I feel like your brief is superb. That sound good?

    Sophie Ballinger: Yep.

    Kelly Molson: The way that we got involved in the Eureka! brief, it wasn't direct. It was a bit of a weird one. I think it was back in March 2016, you'd actually put out an invitation to tender for the new Eureka! website. It was an open tender, wasn't it? It went out.

    Sophie Ballinger: Yeah. We did an expression of interest. We didn't put it on any kind of special tendering sites. We just put an expression of interest out on all of our social media channel, anyone that wants to get the tender once it was ready. We got, it was I think 100 or 101 expressions of interest. Rubber Cheese wasn't one of those agencies.

    Kelly Molson: No. We were the 102nd one. We were 102 then.

    Sophie Ballinger: Yeah.

    Kelly Molson: Okay. We found out about it through another agency. A really good friend of mine, Eddie, he was at Hat Trick Media at the time. He'd done a photoshoot with you years before.

    Sophie Ballinger: Yeah. His partner and children were... Oh no, and him. I've got pictures of him with a laundry basket under him.

    Kelly Molson: Yeah.

    Sophie Ballinger: Yeah. They were the start of our Play 20 campaign and website randomly.

    Kelly Molson: Random. I think he got the tender or he'd seen it somehow. Then it wasn't for him, and he called us and was like, "Guys, this is a tender for you. I'm going to introduce you to Sophie. I really feel like you should go for this." We saw it and went, "Uh, yeah. Defo." That was how we got involved. So yes, we were like the 102nd person or agency that got in touch. Wow. How do you even manage that? At that point, were you thinking, "Maybe an open invitation was not the best of ideas"?

    Sophie Ballinger: Well, we had done just open tenders before. I think from the previous one we had really, really good response to, but we hadn't been anywhere near as open with that. I mean that was the bit of learning that I took from doing the open tender previously was that actually there were lots of people that just weren't able to do it.

    Sophie Ballinger: The reason Eddie couldn't go for it was because one of the things I did specify in it was that I wanted the CMS, content management system, to be open source. And the CMS that they work with wasn't, but they said, "Look, we can't go for this, but we know someone who'd be brill for it." That was when they put it through to you. But again, had we not specified that in the brief, they would've wasted their time doing a submission for it, and they would never have got the gig, basically. That was actually one of those things, it was a learning curve from the previous time we'd done it.

    Kelly Molson: Yeah. So 102 submissions of interest. What did that look like? Because I know what we went through, so we got in touch with you. We got the brief late, so there was timeframes in it that you wanted a response for. We got this a lot later than everyone else. You very kindly actually gave us an extension so that we could come up and visit you, really get a good feel for Eureka. Actually, you gifted us some time to talk to you as well.

    Kelly Molson: But what I really liked about the brief, and this is one of the things that I think is key about a brief, is you said, "I'm happy to answer questions. I'm happy to schedule time to speak to people." That is quite a rare thing sometimes with a brief is that, especially with very formal ones that go out on the formal tender platforms that I can rant about all day long, you don't often get the opportunity to actually meet somebody in person or even grab a phone call to talk through the project and talk through the brief. But if you had 102 interests, how many people did you meet and speak to?

    Sophie Ballinger: Well, the actual submissions, I think we got, oh gosh, 38. I did meet a lot of them, not all of them. But for me, first of all, when I've gone through tender processes previously I've often had my eyes pretty tied on them anyway. So I might be working public sector or other institutions where you are told what you can and can't say, and they're really strict on it. I've brought that approach across to Eureka!, and my Director at the time, that was how he viewed it. Whereas this time around, I just said, "But why?"

    Sophie Ballinger: For me, the relationship and my ability to get on with the people I'm going to be working with and vice-versa, they might spend some time with me and never want to see me ever again, but that is a key part of an effective working relationship with an agency. So I did say, in fact, my boss then, who's my boss now, Michelle, was on here before, wasn't she?

    Kelly Molson: Yes.

    Sophie Ballinger: She was just, "Go for it." I said, "It will take a lot of time and I probably will have to spend a lot of time going and meeting people, explaining the museum. But I really want them to understand us." I want them to understand me. I want to see if we get on. I want to get some kind of feel for whether I think they get us, and a big part of that actually which you and Paul were brilliant at is I want to see if they're going to come into the museum and interact with stuff and have a go and throw themselves into it.

    Sophie Ballinger: I can't remember how many people I met with. I basically say, "If you want to come, I'll give you some tickets and I'll give you some time." Everyone that took us up on that, I blocked out an hour to spend with them. It did take up a hell of a lot of time, a hell of a lot of time, but for me it was absolutely invaluable, absolutely invaluable. You just get a sense about people's creativity, just whether they get us or not.

    Kelly Molson: Yeah. I love that. Actually, I would say from our perspective as an agency, it's a really generous thing to do. Because we want to see how the relationship is as well from our side, but also, there's something really important about visiting the place that you're pitching to do work for. I think that's a necessity. Yeah, having the generosity to give agencies that time is really, really important. You're asking them to commit an awful lot of time in putting a proposal together.

    Kelly Molson: I mean when we pulled this proposal together, it was not a, "Oh, we'll just knock something out in a day and it'll be done." There was a lot of time and effort that goes into it, so I think it's really respectful to give the agency that initial time to ask those questions.

    Sophie Ballinger: I was going to say, it's the least we can do. Yeah. We're expecting agencies to do or we're hoping they're going to put a decent amount of time in and thought. Yeah, as you say, it's respectful. It's good manners.

    Kelly Molson: Fast forward to the chosen agency, which was us. Thank you very much. We obviously enjoyed your company and didn't want to sack you off as a client, which is good. Another thing that was really good about the process is you communicated really clearly. Well, you communicated really clearly upfront what was going to happen, what the evaluation process was going to look like, how long it was going to take, how many agencies you were going to shortlist to, and then actually what you were going to ask of them over the next stage as well. Because sometimes that's a bit loose, we're not sure.

    Kelly Molson: I'll be honest, you did ask for creative for the next stage. So you shortlisted down and the next stage was meeting the agency with the team that were going to be making those decisions. This is always a really controversial thing in a brief is to ask for creative, but you did it in a way that, again, I think was really respectful of the agency and their time, is that you actually offered to pay for the creative. That for us, we very rarely do creatives as part of a tender process because I think that if you haven't had that chance to speak to the client and that team...

    Kelly Molson: You know our process. You know it's really collaborative. We're going to ask a lot of questions. There's a lot of research and stuff that goes into that before you come up with the creatives for it. It's very hard to pitch something that you're never going to like what we pitch. It's going to be impossible. It'd be like one in a million if we pitched something in this process that you went, "Oh, yeah. That's it. We'll have that one." The fact that you offered to pay for the time for people to do that, again, brilliant. That was a massive tick for us.

    Sophie Ballinger: I'll be really honest about that. Again, the previous brief that we'd done, which was I guess four or five years before, we asked for creative and we didn't pay for it. We had a similar level of interest and we got one agency that contacted us and said, "Nah, we don't do creative." That was it. This time around, actually initially we asked for creative and we weren't giving a payment. We got within hours people saying to us, "We're not so sure about that. We're not very happy with that."

    Sophie Ballinger: Of course, there were agencies that were fine and probably would've gone ahead with it, but for me, I guess partly because my background, I went to art school and did all that stuff. And it's like, actually, I know how much goes into the creative process and it just absolutely resonated with me straightaway. It was really interesting the huge sea change in the space of a few years from people just sucking it up and doing it to actually raising concerns.

    Sophie Ballinger: I think it was literally within about 24 hours of us sending that information out, we'd backtracked on it and we re-enhanced the budget. Actually, we knew as well that that budget wasn't enough realistically to cover the time that an agency would want to put into that creative work. It was all that we could afford. But apart from anything else, as you said, it just felt respectful. I have been involved in tender processes before at other places, I'll say very clearly, where there hasn't been a respectful attitude to that work as far as even with just the intellectual property of it. It's like, "Ooh, we like that idea, and can we squeeze that into there?" It's never sat right with me.

    Sophie Ballinger: I've also been involved in tender processes where I'm aware that agencies are being seen and they're not going to get the gig, again, for whatever reason. I mean we'll come onto budget. I've been involved in ones where the budget that an agency's quoted is far beyond the budget that we had available, so they were never going to get it but bosses at the time were kind of curious to see what more they'd get for the money. I'm sitting there looking at how much work they've done, and it just feels wrong.

    Sophie Ballinger: Yeah. Again, I'll be really honest. It came back in a huge wave of people just going, "I really want to go for this brief, but I'm not comfortable with that element of it." So we changed it and I was relieved and actually really, it made me even more enthusiastic for the project that we were doing. I liked the fact that straightaway the people that we were working with weren't afraid to voice a potentially unpopular opinion.

    Sophie Ballinger: Yeah, it was fundamental for me. I'm really glad it happened and I'm really glad to say that it's something that Eureka!, we have adopted subsequently for any tender that we do that has a creative element. We did one recently for a digital marketing agency based in Liverpool where we're putting a second site next year. We asked for creative for that and we made that payment as part of that as well.

    Kelly Molson: Oh, that's excellent.

    Sophie Ballinger: Yeah. We have adopted that for policy now. I don't see it very often. I do see it every now and then. Would love to see it more.

    Kelly Molson: I would love to see it more. But I just think, yeah, like you say, it's that level of... It's respecting the time that goes into it. I think that was really a bit of a game changer for us. Okay, let's talk about the brief. Let's talk about why it was so good. The first thing, we've talked about this, is that you let people talk to you. That was the best thing about this. You let people talk to you. You let people come to visit, and you met with them. Massively time consuming on your part, but awesome for everybody involved and really important from your perspective in terms of how that relationship's going to be, what those people are like.

    Kelly Molson: It's really interesting that you said about interacting with the venue as well. I hadn't thought about that. That just was an actual thing that we did because it's awesome, but yeah, I hadn't thought about that you'd be looking for that, necessarily.

    Sophie Ballinger: Yeah. I love taking people on tours of the place. I get quite a good read on them just from that. Yeah, it's interesting.

    Kelly Molson: Okay. The second thing that really stood out for us about the brief was the tone of voice, the way that it was written. Let's face it, web briefs can be a little bit dry. You're talking about content management systems. You're talking about functionality and things it needs and payment processing and all that kind of stuff. However, you made this brief really fun. You wrote it in Eureka's tone of voice, and it was excellent.

    Kelly Molson: I'm going to read out a bit here. I'll probably read it wrong, but in an ideal world, we'd love families to look at our website, let out an audible, "Wow!" And then think, "I've got to go there." And potential funders to gasp but be inspired to support our work, "There must be a way." For our part, we're absolutely, positively, definitely, completely unwavering in our determination to be a little less loquacious. I don't even know if I pronounced that right.

    Sophie Ballinger: Loquacious.

    Kelly Molson: Loquacious, sorry. I did not pronounce it right. Loquacious. We mean we won't be so wordy, promise. Just even that, I mean apart from the fact that I can't read properly, I mean that sums up the tone of the brief, right? It was just lovely to read. Yeah, we really got a feel for what it would potentially be like working with you and with your organisation just from the tone of voice of that. Did you get any help with this? I think you did, didn't you? Was there a workshop that you went on?

    Sophie Ballinger: Not with the tone of voice element of it, although I felt really inspired by it. I went to Aalia Walker, who at the time, she was with the SMACK agency. She's with Milk & More now, I think. She had done a workshop at a Kids in Museums event that I went to, and it was about the briefing process, what the perfect brief would be. It fired me up. The timing was perfect because it was just before I started working on this brief.

    Sophie Ballinger: She was just talking about why can't you tell us what the budget is? Why can't you be open about this? Why can't you just tell us what the challenges are? Tell us some things you don't know and the things that you don't know that you don't know. It's just, be really open and A, you're more likely to find an agency that's on your wavelength. And that inspired me to... I'd done quite a lot of work at Eureka! generally since I joined it, and I've been there 10 years last month.

    Kelly Molson: Wowsers.

    Sophie Ballinger: My Eureka! birthday. I mean, I'd been there a few years at that point and they hadn't had a digital person. They hadn't really got a tone of voice for their external communications. They very much did in the museum, very much did in the museum. You talked to the staff, they are chatty and confident and friendly and funny and human. And they'll admit if they don't know something, and then they'll go and find out for you. They're really a bit geeky about little... They have little snippets of information, and everyone has their own talents. We absolutely try and encourage those because it's what makes a visit to Eureka! memorable for me.

    Sophie Ballinger: I couldn't quite understand why you get into it and it's very human and conversational as soon as you walk through the doors, but externally, it wasn't particularly human and it wasn't particularly conversational. Obviously, initially with social media channels, that made absolute sense. But that started to filter through to the other content and the other copy.

    Sophie Ballinger: Actually, one of the big things that we knew about the website is we tied ourselves in knots trying to explain what a children's museum is. We're not a science and discovery center. We're not a museum where everything's in cabinets or there's a historical collection or a collection of some nature. We're not a collections-based museum. It's an interactive space designed with kids, for kids. On previous websites, we again were tying ourselves in knots trying to explain that and it's like, "Well, let's just show them."

    Sophie Ballinger: I mean, that was one of the challenges that went into the brief was how can we show this, but a key part of that as well is that tone of voice filtering through. Again, it was a conscious decision to do it in that way because for me, if you don't get it, you don't respond to that tone of voice, we don't particularly want to work with you anyway. We know that people will have looked at that brief, cringed and never wanted to go back to it ever again. I mean, I can't think who and obviously they're philistines. But yeah, it was an important bit for us.

    Sophie Ballinger: Again, I will say, because I sat down with it and I just started writing the brief I'd always wanted to write and expected it to go up to my director and them to go, "What?" But they loved it and encouraged it. Yeah, it was absolutely inspired, a fire was lit under me by Aalia. I did run it past her as well before we sent it out. I just said, "Look, you've inspired me to do this. Can you have a look at this and tell me what you think?" She had a look at it and was just...

    Kelly Molson: Excellent.

    Sophie Ballinger: Yeah.

    Kelly Molson: A big shout out to Aalia, and Lubna from SMACK agency. I know that agency very well and they are superb. Okay, next thing. You defined the feeling of the brand really, really well. The tone of voice, that set our tone of voice because we knew how we'd have to communicate with you. I can remember writing our brief. You know us, we're quite chill. We're quite laid-back about... Just the way that we speak is quite friendly and it allowed us to be a bit friendlier in our response. Do you know-

    Sophie Ballinger: Yeah.

    Kelly Molson: So you get us as well. That was really great, but I think that the way that you defined the feeling of the brand was really incredible. So we could really understand what it was all about without necessarily... Sometimes it's difficult to describe what Eureka! is, but describing that feeling of it, that really gave us a sense of, "Oh yeah, we really want to work with this organisation. This is for us."

    Kelly Molson: The other thing was that there was a challenge in this brief. The website brief was the website that needed redesigning. It wasn't performing particularly well. There were some things that were challenging. There were things that people were potentially not understanding about the museum. But you also had this kind of challenge that, actually, it wasn't necessarily a digital challenge. It was a, look, we've got this issue with people having to queue, and if they want their annual pass, they're going to have to queue again when they get here. So then they've got this double queuing situation. They're just basically just getting really pissed off and what can we do about it?

    Kelly Molson: That was great. To have an open ended, "Well, here's the brief for the thing that we really need, but actually, we've got this problem as well. What do you think you can do?" We were like, "Ooh. Well, this is good, isn't it?" It was really open like, "What do you think that we could do about this?" This was like, oh, great. This is a real challenge for us to think about. That was awesome.

    Sophie Ballinger: Yeah. I was just trying to find a way to write, help!

    Kelly Molson: Help, but constructively. Help me. Then you actually carried out some internal testing as well, which was really useful.

    Sophie Ballinger: Yeah. And fascinating. I wish I had time to do it constantly. Yeah. Obviously, I dived face first into Google Analytics and had a look at where the traffic was and actually where we wanted it to be, so there's that element of it. But we also did some really intensive qualitative stuff with some user testing, and it was stuff I've done previously in the university sector. Tends to be on a much bigger scale, but with this, we spent a day.

    Sophie Ballinger: We had six people who were our audience, including... we found some teachers. We tried to identify people, all but one of them, who weren't aware of Eureka!, hadn't visited us. Then we had someone that knew us really intimately as well. That sounds a bit rude. And spent a day. So we gave them a number of tests. I sat with them. I was just mostly observing. The agency we were working with at the time, Reading Room, they run the actual process for us. We just gave them a number of tasks and asked people to vocalise what they were doing and where are you looking for, what search terms are you using.

    Sophie Ballinger: This is a website you want to find out about this and watch people trying to do it. Within I think the first two people, there were some huge things. We had, for example, really a low conversion rate on the book tickets page. I forget what the conversion rate was, but we knew it was low and we thought it was really weird. Really quickly, it's because that was the quickest way for people to find out how much it costs. So they're not actually necessarily going to go and book that way, but they're struggling to find prices elsewhere. That's what the vast majority of people wanted to know. It was how much, where are you, are you open now, when are you open? That was the bulk of it.

    Sophie Ballinger: We also knew we had a lot of other audiences. One of the other ones that we did, I sat with a teacher and went through. The way we had the school information, there wasn't enough information for her. She needed really quiet details. She needed downloadable things that she could print off for her class. She needed lengthy information about what the curriculum links were. She's one of the rare web visitors who wants lots and lots and lots of information, lots of wordy information. Whereas, of course, the vast majority of people, how much, are you open?

    Sophie Ballinger: It was really, really, really useful. Again, it was time consuming because we were coming up with, planning what the scripts were and what we wanted to do before, but absolutely worth it, invaluable, invaluable insights that we got from people.

    Kelly Molson: Yeah. And really helpful for us as well. Because we do our own testing, but yeah, having that outside of you is always better than just our own internal kind of opinions about something. Going back to what you said at the beginning around Eddie and not being able to take the project on because he didn't work with an open-source CMS, that was really important as well, the fact that you defined what...

    Kelly Molson: You didn't define the platform. I know you were familiar with WordPress, so there was maybe a bias toward it, but you just defined what you needed from the CMS. That was really great for us as well because we could understand if we worked in a platform that was actually going to fit what you needed. That was quite great, so there was a lot of specification around the things that you really needed to have as well.

    Kelly Molson: You defined what you needed for the project and we'll talk about budget in a bit. But you defined exactly what you really needed and then some things that you might like to have, but you were realistic that some of those things that you might like to have might be outside of that budget as well, which was really good. There was a must have and then a like to have. Sometimes you don't get that. Sometimes in a brief you get, this is everything that we want and this is the budget for it. And you have to go, "Whoa, okay. Well, look, we might need to strip some of these things out and think about them as a phase two."

    Kelly Molson: That's another thing as well is that when we talked to you, it was really clear that you could take a phased approach as well. I think that comes out of being able to speak to somebody about what's the real need here, what's the necessity. What do we need to launch with, and then what are things that maybe potentially come later and how does that affect what you're doing?

    Sophie Ballinger: Yeah. I'm always really aware of fake deadlines. We pluck a date out of thin air and we're going to work towards that. With a project as big as this with so many different elements, I knew, I mean we were coming up to our 25th birthday, so we couldn't move that. There were elements of it that had to be ready for that and then others that actually it's not the end of the world if we don't. If we can deliver more for then, great.

    Sophie Ballinger: But yeah, it's something about being really clear because if people don't know the fixed parameters that you've got, then they're going to rule themselves out the minute they've done a submission for it. It's not fair asking someone to do all that work if they can't... It's like writing a good job description. You put the things in there that you absolutely need and the things that are absolutely necessary. Being vague just to see what's out there doesn't really benefit anyone. It was really important for me, so we knew there were some things here that are deal breakers. So let's be really upfront about that.

    Sophie Ballinger: Then there are some other things that, like the example you gave with some of the features, we didn't know how much they cost. We thought we'd quite like that, but can you do that within the brief? Actually, we're not going to discount you if you say, "Well, that's not something that you could afford within that brief, but for the sake of a bit more money... " We were just really open about that and receptive to the answers that we got, which were pretty consistent on that particular element, to be honest.

    Sophie Ballinger: Yeah. I've seen a few briefs recently where it's really vague. To me, that's just a waste of everyone's time. Because the submissions that you read, again, I'll go back to the previous tender process and I don't know how long I spent reading responses. You read them through and like, "This is really good." And then you get to an element and it's like, "Ugh. Well, they can't do it." Actually, it's wasted their time and it's wasted mine, not anywhere near as much as mine potentially. Yeah, it's the more open you can be, the more efficient you can be for everyone's sake.

    Kelly Molson: Absolutely. Let's talk about timeframes and budget. Because again, with this brief it was a really realistic timeframe, and I think that's important. We see a lot of briefs that come in and you'll look at the timeframe and then you'll think, "Okay. Well, by the time we've submitted and they've reviewed and they've chosen, actually that leaves about eight weeks for this project. And that's nowhere near enough." Then when you push back, they're like, "No, no, no. That's the deadline. That's it. It's not moving."

    Kelly Molson: I check sometimes. I have a tendency to keep either briefs that we haven't won or briefs that we've decided, for whatever reason, we're not a good fit for. We can't achieve that deadline. We've had the discussion and they're like, "No, it's not going to move." Then I check. I set a little diary reminder to go, "I'm going to go and check to see if that website went live then." And they never do. They never do.

    Sophie Ballinger: They never do.

    Kelly Molson: I always think, "Well, look. Yeah, be realistic about it." If most agencies are coming back to you going, "This isn't achievable. This is maybe achievable. Is there any wiggle room on this deadline?" It's not an achievable timeframe, so definitely have a little word with yourself about that.

    Kelly Molson: But also, budget. There was a budget indicated in this brief. I cannot express how important it is to have a budget, and I think there's still that perception that it's because agencies are going to go to the top of it. It's not about that. Genuinely, really is not about that. It is about what can we deliver for you that is going to work for your budget and for your timeframe and all of the things that you need. It will have an effect on the CMS, for example, that we use, or it might have an effect on what level of testing we can do or how much time we can spend on wireframes or how many meetings we have. It has an effect on every single part of that project.

    Kelly Molson: We might have just the most incredible idea and we can pitch it to you, but then we've got to work out how we make that idea happen with the budget that you've got. If we know upfront, we can do all that before we speak to you rather than actually going, "Oh my God, you could have this amazing thing," and then finding out that your budget is 5K and then we're going, "Oh, you can't have that now. There's no way we could do that for you now." It's so vital for us, but I want to stress how much it isn't about us going, "We're going to go to the top end of that."

    Sophie Ballinger: Which I do get and I hear that a lot, the fear that if we say, "We've got 15 grand," then everyone's going to say, "Well, we can do this for 15 grand," whether it's going to cost them two or 30. Again, going back to a previous tender process I was involved in that didn't have a budget on it, obviously, everyone received the exact same brief and I think on this particular instance we got about 14 or 15 responses to it.

    Sophie Ballinger: Hand on heart, the bottom one was 4K and the top one, I'm sure it went up to 160 or 180 responding to the same brief. So of course, they were just straight out because we have nowhere near that much money. That was one of the processes where they interviewed someone that had quoted for higher than the budget that we had just to see what the difference was, which just felt really unfair to me. There's something fundamentally wrong with that brief if you've got such a difference in it, but that's always really stayed with me. Because I do remember getting this eight-page 4K submission versus this, I think it was, 160, 180. Again, it just felt unfair and like a waste of their time.

    Kelly Molson: That's crazy. Totally going to put my prices up now.

    Sophie Ballinger: I did say, "What kind of website are we getting?"

    Kelly Molson: Gold plated.

    Sophie Ballinger: Gold plated, or we figured maybe there was some kind of reenactment that went to people's houses and started reading content for them. Yeah, it was nuts.

    Kelly Molson: Yeah. But then that just shows you why it's really important to put something in there. And don't get me wrong, we will always push back. If we don't feel the budget is enough, we definitely push back. But we've also been like, "Yeah, this is a great budget. We could do everything that you need with this and probably have some left over as well." Okay, clear feedback.

    Kelly Molson: Oh, this is another thing that happens loads and I don't know how to solve it. Whenever we get a brief and it isn't as perfect as this one, there's always loads of questions that we ask regardless of what brief comes over. And one of the questions is, if we don't win this, can we get feedback? Actually, if we do win, can we have feedback as well? Because even if you win it, there might still be stuff that you've not done as brilliantly as someone else that's proposed. It's just on the day you swung it or whatever, something made you win it. You got on well with that person, I don't know.

    Kelly Molson: Either way, you really, really need feedback and partly because there's so much time that goes into putting a tender submission together, it would be really great to get some feedback. Because if that's all we're going to get, at least we can then... There's something constructive that's come out of it. We can improve for the next one. We can understand why we didn't win it or what we could've done to win it, what we could've done better. Even when I ask, I would say 60% of the time, maybe 70% of the time we don't get feedback.

    Sophie Ballinger: That often?

    Kelly Molson: Yeah.

    Sophie Ballinger: That really surprises me.

    Kelly Molson: It's really frustrating and I really push as well. I don't let it go. I will send multiple emails. If there's a phone number, I will be ringing you. There is a few things. I think it is quite hard to give constructive feedback. And if you're not very good at it, you shy away from it. I think that people are uncomfortable about delivering bad news a lot of the time, but we're really thick skinned and we really need it. We really need to understand what we did wrong. Maybe it wasn't anything wrong. Maybe it was just someone just absolutely nailed it. And yeah, if in another circumstance, we would've won it with what we delivered, but actually these guys blew it out of the water.

    Kelly Molson: But if we don't know, you just have this feeling of, "Oh, I just feel really sad." I'm kind of used to it now and I am really thick skinned, but it's a bit demoralising to the team. They need to know why we didn't win that. Because we're all excited about it, the whole team is invested in a brief when it comes in. And we're all invested in really wanting to work with that company or we wouldn't put the effort in to put in that tender submission together. It has sometimes a quite negative effect on the agency when they don't get the feedback. Not that they don't win. We all know we can't win everything, but it's about not understanding what is really hard.

    Sophie Ballinger: I guess as well and for people that don't work in agencies and don't go through that process, it's trying to explain to them that you go for a job interview. You get called back for a second interview and you do a task as part of that. You work on a big presentation. Then you don't get the job and you never hear anything from them ever again. Yeah, of course, yeah get invested in it. If that keeps happening to you over and over again, of course, it's going to start to knock your confidence or start to, as you say, it can be really quite disheartening.

    Sophie Ballinger: Again, I'm a big gobsmacked by it because it's something that we, and it's not just me, I'm not going to say I'm an angel on it, but the ethos at work and the people that I work with at Eureka!, it's really important to us. For example, with the tender process you were involved in, we did feedback. For all the people that were shortlisted, we do feedback in a spreadsheet on every single one so that we could offer feedback. Realistically, we couldn't necessarily have a conversation with everyone that had submitted, but what we did say is, "We will give you written feedback if you want it." Sometimes they don't. And for anyone that came to the actual doing creative stage, we would have a conversation with them.

    Sophie Ballinger: I had a phone conversation, I think, with everyone that pitched. I should say sometimes it's not necessarily going to be that constructive. In fact, to me, I'd say it was a closer thing, but this was one of those, not to blow smoke up your behind, but this is one of those where we just said, "Actually, this agency just blew everyone out of the water." It was quite difficult because one of the agencies that had pitched for it was an agency that we'd been working with, so it wasn't an easy conversation. But I respect it enough to try and be honest about what was going on. It's fair. As I say, I know that that's just not me. I think I've been influenced by the people I work with and probably vice-versa, but we know how important it is.

    Kelly Molson: Yeah. Very important and really appreciated from our perspective as well.

    Sophie Ballinger: Yeah. It can be really painful.

    Kelly Molson: Actually, one of the questions that we often ask, I don't always want to know and I didn't in this circumstance, but sometimes it's nice to know what agencies we're up against. With this process, it's slightly different because I think we knew it was an open tender. I mean, we had no idea that you were going to get up to 40 submissions. That was mad. But when you get shortlisted to go through to the next stage, it's often quite nice to know who you're up against. You were open to telling us, but I actually said I didn't want to know for this one.

    Sophie Ballinger: Yeah. We asked all the agencies because I think one or two of them had asked. We asked the agencies if they were happy for other people to know they were involved if they wanted to know. I think, did you say you were happy for other people to know but you didn't want to? I can't remember now.

    Kelly Molson: Yeah. I didn't want the pressure. I think we really wanted to win it so much that I didn't want the pressure of looking at who we were up against and going, "Oh, they're much bigger than us," or they've got much more experience in that sector, or this, that and that. Their work's awesome. I just thought, "Don't know. Just be yourself, go in and do your thing. Don't know about all those things."

    Sophie Ballinger: Yeah. And have a look afterwards.

    Kelly Molson: Oh, I did. Yeah. Yeah, I definitely did afterwards. But what I would say, what's happened, so recently a few briefs have been sent to us and it's lovely. What's really nice is that we're chosen for people to send a brief to. More and more so we'll receive a brief and they'll say, "Look, we've chosen four agencies that we've sent this out to."

    Kelly Molson: Some will say, "We've sent this out to 10 agencies," and I think that's too many, personally. But it's nice that you've been chosen as one of those four agencies, and in those circumstances, I do always ask who the other agencies are. I don't always get told, but I do always ask because I think for us, it's a way of gaging, do we think that we're actually in with a chance of winning this?

    Kelly Molson: I think that's a really honest thing to say is that we will not go for every brief that lands on our desk because, honestly, some of them we just don't think that we're going to win. It might be because there's an existing relationship with an agency that's on that list that it's gone out to and we don't understand why you would want to change from that. There might be potentially some research that's been carried about by an agency and the research has been included in that brief. And you're like, "Why would you get them to do the research? You must have a good relationship with them to do that. If you're not going to give them this, why don't you just go to them like, is everyone just wasting their time?" Do you know what I mean?

    Sophie Ballinger: Yeah, yeah.

    Kelly Molson: It's really honest, but sometimes that happens. I think sometimes we go, "Okay. Well, what work have we got scheduled in?" And we have to be really realistic and say, "We are really busy right now. What time can we dedicate to this pitch? What time can we dedicate to putting this tender document together?" If we don't think that we've got enough time to do it justice, we'll also say, "We don't think that the timing's right for us to be able to do this." I think sometimes knowing who you're up against is important. In this circumstance, I felt it was going to be a distraction rather than something useful.

    Sophie Ballinger: Yeah, yeah.

    Kelly Molson: Okay. Your brief essentially covered all of the points that we go through with what is a great brief. I've talked about this at the start and I will link to our blog post in the show notes for this episode, but essentially, we're looking for a really detailed company profile and doing that in a way that it really showcases what it's going to be like to work for that brand. So that tone of voice is so hugely important in that essence.

    Kelly Molson: We need to know what the project goals and objectives are, and we really need to be able to ask you questions about that as well. If you're putting a brief together, think about how much time you've got to dedicate to this process because being able to speak to the person that's wrote this brief and ask them questions for an agency is absolutely vital. You are going to get a much better response if you allow that to happen.

    Kelly Molson: We need to know about your audience. If there's been any persona work done, that's always helpful. Where the current website has failings that we can't see that we don't know about. What the new website needs to deliver and really be specific about if there's a content management system that you are totally wedded to, we need to know about that upfront because it might not be one that we use.

    Kelly Molson: I put competitors on this list, but I think from an attractions perspective, I mean obviously you've got competitors, but it's more about what space do you sit in and what are you and where do you sit into that kind of ecosystem. A schedule of timelines and that's not just for the project, that's for the process of potentially winning this project might look like. Budget, big thumbs up for putting a budget in there.

    Kelly Molson: Then actually, the feedback and selection process. I think some of the best briefs we've ever had, it's specified what that's going to look like as well and so we know if there's going to be an expectation of creative. And we're going to bring you and say, "Hey, we don't do that," or, "Do you really need to see a creative at this point? Because I don't think it's going to work, and maybe we should look at stuff that we've done previously. Will that work?"

    Sophie Ballinger: Can I make a quick point about creative, actually?

    Kelly Molson: Yeah.

    Sophie Ballinger: I was thinking about this because different people respond to creative in different ways. Something that I thought was really interesting in this process, because I absolutely take the point in the process as well where it's like, well, you can not get a job because you've done something in green and they didn't like green. It's like, "I could've made it blue or purple or whatever," and you can lose it. There are people who could take creative too literally. I think that's a real issue and that's why I can see why people don't like creative, the amount of work that goes into it aside.

    Sophie Ballinger: If you were doing the process from my side of it as the client, it's understanding that creative is changeable. Yeah, as you say, it's not going to be the final thing. But also, because what I would say with the creative is that when Rubber Cheese presented, actually the end website is very different, very different from the creative that was in the pitch. That didn't matter. The thing that particularly me and Michelle Emerson, my director, look out for is the process that took you there, the walk that you went on to get there and how you respond to us pointing out elements that wouldn't work for our brand.

    Sophie Ballinger: It'd be wonderful if you came in and at your first attempt it was absolutely nailed it, but we also understand that it's an iterative process. Anyway. I think that is really important if you are asking for creative, it's understanding that you've given someone one bash at your brief. I have worked with people who take that creative very literally and don't understand that it's just an example. For me, it's really useful to see someone's design ethic, their approach to it, the creative process, the feedback process, how open they are to it.

    Sophie Ballinger: The pitch that I was involved with yourself, I think it was the longest one that we had and there was a really long discussion between everyone that was involved in that pitch that was prompted by the creative. That's really telling for me.

    Kelly Molson: Yeah. I can remember it felt quite brutal. I'm not going to lie.

    Sophie Ballinger: Yeah.

    Kelly Molson: I mean, I like pitching and it was great. I felt like it went well, but we left going, "I don't know if they actually liked what we delivered because they really went in on us on it." There was a lot of picking it apart, and I was thinking, "Well, this was just supposed to be a creative. It was never going to be the final ka-bang." Yeah, it was interesting to see the discussions that it sparked, and I guess that's part of the process as well, isn't it?

    Sophie Ballinger: Yeah. But don't ditch something because you didn't like green.

    Kelly Molson: I mean, that's a life lesson there, isn't it?

    Sophie Ballinger: I like green very much.

    Kelly Molson: Same. Can I ask, and it might be that this is just the way the organisation does things, but would you do it again in the same way? Would you have an open tender? Because I guess you then had to spend time reading 38 submissions. That's a hell of a lot of time to then get them down to five, so the timeframes would've been... Because if it's an open tender, you never know how many you're going to get, right? So you might have got five, but actually, you got nearly 40 and you've got to distil that down.

    Sophie Ballinger: Yeah. Could've had 102.

    Kelly Molson: Wow.

    Sophie Ballinger: Short answer, no. Again, it's interesting. Because that process went so well, we adopted the same for a number of other briefs. We did a number of open tenders on, the next example that my team was directly involved was a PR agency brief. We would not do that again. That sounded really negative. It was still a really good experience, but it was too much, I think.

    Kelly Molson: What would you do?

    Sophie Ballinger: I think obviously I haven't done another web tender since then because we still have a relationship with Rubber Cheese and we're very happy where we are.

    Kelly Molson: Why would you need to? Oh, the horror.

    Sophie Ballinger: Why would we ever need to? It's really interesting. When we have done briefs for other stuff, so creative design agencies for, obviously, we're opening our second site, a science and discovery centre. We've been going through the process quite a lot there, and we have identified agencies and we've done quite a lot of our homework. We've gone out to a number of them to invite them to pitch for it or tender for it initially.

    Sophie Ballinger: It's really weird because, of course, then you end up everyone knows each other. So with Mersey we aren't based in Liverpool so we don't know a lot of agencies there. So we went to partners that we're working with on that development and asked them who they'd work with, who they'd recommend. On the one hand, you lose the wildcard element of it, but then, on the other hand, it can be faster, a hell of a lot faster and a lot less time consuming. It's really weird because I'm also aware of the fact that had we not done an open tender, then we wouldn't be working with Rubber Cheese now.

    Kelly Molson: I know. It's a really tricky one, isn't it?

    Sophie Ballinger: Yeah. But it hasn't worked for us. I mean, it may be one of those that case by case. There might be other briefs that come up and actually, we know that we should just go for it. We did do an open one. We worked with Playmaker Studios, who basically are over in Liverpool, to develop our brand for Eureka Science and Discovery. Was that an open one? Yeah, we did an open one for that. We promoted it on social, but we did also send it to people.

    Kelly Molson: Oh, okay. So you did a bit of both.

    Sophie Ballinger: Bit of both. Again, that worked out really well for us and who knows whether we would've ended up working with them if we did it differently. But yeah, it's a funny one. I really don't know. What's your take on it from the agency perspective?

    Kelly Molson: It's really difficult. Actually, in the podcast I mentioned at the beginning of the interview, the Alex Holliman Choosing an Agency podcast, I did state in that podcast that I like it when the organisation has done their own homework and they ask you, so they know who that tender's going out to. Because honestly, I just think it saves a lot of time for everyone. I just can't imagine how long it would've taken to read through 38 submissions.

    Sophie Ballinger: A long time.

    Kelly Molson: So long, because I remember how long our submission was as well. From a time perspective, and I think fewer agencies, the better. Again, it's from a selfish perspective. When you're one of 10 agencies that it's gone out to, does it really need to go to 10? Do you really need 10 submissions? I think four, five max is about right. But then on the other hand, like you say, in this circumstance if Eddie hadn't sent this brief to us, we would never have been working with you. So there is something to be said for having it a little bit open. I like that mixed approach that you took. I still think I'd sway towards doing the research and sending it to a handful.

    Sophie Ballinger: Yeah. I think generally, that's what we do for the most part now, but I wouldn't be closed to the idea depending on the brief and depending on the project as well. I mean in all honesty with the PR one, I mean we benefited greatly. You can imagine PR and reputation management agencies, we got so many things sent to us. Every day we were walking into the office and there was a new kind of mystery box with a crown in or one that had a knitted beard in it. I mean, it was just really random stuff. It was kind of fun, but it was so much time and so much effort that was being put into it and money.

    Sophie Ballinger: When we've been looking beyond that, we haven't repeated that because, again, it didn't feel fair and it took a hell of a lot of time. Actually, out of web agencies that wanted it, I met with a lot of them. PR agencies, just so many of them wanted to come. It wasn't me that had to spend time with them. It was my colleague, Ruth Saxton. But it was so time consuming for her. It was insane. So many things around that. Yeah, I don't know.

    Sophie Ballinger: There probably are briefs that I would say, go for it. And if you don't know really what you want, it's that being honest. If you're very specific about where you want to be with it and you have a vision in your head and you want it to be very comparable to this competitor or that competitor, but maybe you do try and look for source agencies or find examples that do that for you.

    Sophie Ballinger: But actually, when it's a brief of that nature, when it's like, "Look, these are the problems we've got. We don't really know what we want. Otherwise, we could just go find someone and get them to do it for us. We want creativity. We want innovation. We want help, support. We want a relationship. We want this." We didn't know where to turn for it, so I think it was right for that one.

    Kelly Molson: Thank you. I really appreciate you talking through this with us today. Two last questions for you. Actually, three questions. What happened to the fake knitted beard? I hope that you kept it. Second question-

    Sophie Ballinger: It could-

    Kelly Molson: Second question on that, is that better than the fake fringe that I once sent you? I think not.

    Sophie Ballinger: No.

    Kelly Molson: I think not.

    Sophie Ballinger: Nothing. Do you know that I'm in the process of moving and that fringe has appeared again recently? But even better than that, I think my mum was babysitting and she found it and was just...

    Kelly Molson: What is this? A fake fringe, everyone needs one.

    Sophie Ballinger: Obviously.

    Kelly Molson: To explain, listeners, I wasn't sure whether to have a fringe cut at what point, so I bought a fake fringe that I could wear to see... I didn't wear it out. I just wore it around the office to see if I looked okay with a fringe. There's nothing weird about that at all.

    Sophie Ballinger: It doesn't look like a merkin at all to the untrained eye.

    Kelly Molson: I'm so glad that you said that and not me. Okay. Final question.

    Sophie Ballinger: You horrified my mother.

    Kelly Molson: Wow. On that note, final-

    Sophie Ballinger: What was the question?

    Kelly Molson: Final question for you. No, final question, a book that you would like to recommend to us?

    Sophie Ballinger: A book? Oh, The Beard, circling back, came home with me and I may or may not have put it on my baby daughter several times and taken a photograph. Book, I'm even prepared for this. I've got, look. I've got it here.

    Kelly Molson: Ah, ooh.

    Sophie Ballinger: I was going to be really geeky and do a workbook that's really good for people that work in content, and I decided not to do that. I love books, but I'll be really honest. Particularly since I've had a child, I've struggled. If you go downstairs, I've got a bit of a show-offy book collection. There's lots of Russian literature and when I had a brain that could process all this stuff. I can't do it anymore. Anyway, this guy is a chap called Craig Clevenger, and this is his first novel, The Contortionist's Handbook.

    Kelly Molson: Oh.

    Sophie Ballinger: The reason I've done this one is I reread it a couple of times. I don't tend to reread books very often. I love them, but I very rarely reread them. This one I inhaled. It's about a chap who fakes his own identity and goes in cycles, and he rebuilds his identity each time. It's him trying to get out of a very difficult situation, so it's kind of a thriller.

    Sophie Ballinger: I just loved it and I love the fact it felt like, you know when you discover a new author? It was recommended to me by a member of staff in, I think it was, Waterstones in Derby. I just bought it on the off chance, and it's a debut novel. He's written a couple of others since. He works in a library in Texas. I might've spoken to him, and he might've sent me a copy of his second book. Yeah, so I wanted a bit of a pay it forward as well. I've also got, this is the paperback copy that I bought at the time. So if anyone wants it, if they tweet me, the first person to tweet me, I'll post a copy of it out to them.

    Kelly Molson: Oh. Well, I was going to give it away as a prize. Totally ruined my prize giving, but whatever.

    Sophie Ballinger: Oh, sorry. But this is the copy that I got given in Waterstones in Derby. Oh, I've obviously lent it to someone else as well because I've got a little, it says, "Enjoy." Enjoy, S.

    Kelly Molson: Oh. Well, leave that in there. Okay. I'll tell you what, let's do it properly. If you want to win Sophie's book, head over to our Twitter account and you retweet this episode announcement with the comment, "I want Sophie's book", you can win it. I will make sure that she sends it out to you.

    Sophie Ballinger: I will do, with the, "Enjoy."

    Kelly Molson: Thank you for coming on. It's been a delight to chat with you. I am going to see if I can get the word loquacious into a conversation today. Hey, I said it right. Woo-hoo! Yeah, thank you for coming on and sharing with us, Sophie.

    Sophie Ballinger: Pleasure.

    Kelly Molson: Thanks for listening to Skip the Queue. If you've enjoyed this podcast, please leave us a five-star review. It really helps others find us. Remember to follow us on Twitter for your chance to win the books that have been mentioned. Skip the Queue is brought to you by Rubber Cheese, a digital agency that builds remarkable systems and websites for attractions that helps them increase their visitor numbers. You can find show notes and transcriptions from this episode and more over on our website, rubbercheese.com/podcast.

    Download The Visitor Attractions Website Survey Report - https://www.merac.co.uk/download-the-visitor-attractions-survey

     

    We have launched our brand-new playbook: ‘The Retail Ready Guide to Going Beyond the Gift Shop’ — your go-to resource for building a successful e-commerce strategy that connects with your audience and drives sustainable growth.

     

    Download your FREE copy here

    1 hr