Guest Host: Jimmy McBride

Substitute Host: Mario Francesco

Plum Problems: The phrase “I love that for you”, people talking about egg prices, being rude to canvassing political candidates, the Pittsburgh Pirates, allergy season, and Mike Devine.

The Minority Report: Justin reveals a tip to prolong the life of your mattress.

Would You Rather: have the ability to see into the future for a short period, or to remember everything you've ever learned?

Drew’s Clues: the boys have five guesses to come up with the answer in the category of Award-Winning Actors.

Blind Rankings: The panel blindly ranks five top Easter candies.

Top 5: The boys have to identify the WWE/WWF wrestlers who have won the most matches in history.

Thank you to our sponsors: Lelulo's Pizzeria, Tresco Concrete, Continental Comb, The Jen Mascaro Real Estate Team, Salute Beer Distributor, Busy Little Me, Pittsburgh Sports Complex & Self Storage, Nesbit’s Lanes, and Coyote Outdoor.

Guest Host: Ryan McBride (Linoleum Comedy, OneBurgh)

Plum Problems: Replying All to mundane work emails, Plum High School Student Assassins game, Pittsburgh Pirates Clemente / Surfside sign drama, Chat GPT, scrub hot dog eating contestants

The Minority Report: Justin has just a questionable solution to watching TV shows and movies on your phone while in your car. Would it work for you?

Would You Rather: Always get stuck in traffic or have a terribly slow Internet connection?

This or That: GOAT edition for each of the four major U.S. sports: NBA, NHL, NFL, and MLB.

Blind Rankings: The panel blindly ranks five top potato chip flavors.

Top 5: The boys have to identify the top 5 most watched series finales in TV history.

Thank you to our sponsors: Lelulo's Pizzeria, Tresco Concrete, Continental Comb, The Jen Mascaro Real Estate Team, Salute Beer Distributor, Busy Little Me, Pittsburgh Sports Complex & Self Storage, Nesbit’s Lanes, and Coyote Outdoor.

Guest Host: Steve Lintelman

Plum Problems: Loud restaurant patrons, boys peeing on toilet seats, insane YMCA basketball parents, and people who can't sit in silence.

The Minority Report: Justin has just the tip for people who are packing and moving into a new home.

Would You Rather: Kill a cow or butcher it after it's been killed.

Drew's Clues: The boys have up to five chances to guess an obscure Pittsburgh Pirates player from the 2000s.

Blind Rankings: The panel blindly ranks five top March Madness moments from over the years.

Top 5: The boys have to identify the top 5 actors who made the most money from movies in 2024.

Thank you to our sponsors: Lelulo's Pizzeria, Tresco Concrete, Continental Comb, The Jen Mascaro Real Estate Team, Salute Beer Distributor, Busy Little Me, Pittsburgh Sports Complex & Self Storage, and Nesbit’s Lanes.

Guest Host: Jeremiah Diebler

Plum Problems: Unaware shoppers, left lane drivers, cease and desist letters, fish fries, dog walkers, and phone chargers.

The Minority Report: Justin educates the audience on a quick way to make taco Hot Pockets.

Would You Rather: Get $1 every time you compliment a stranger or get $10 every time you insult a stranger in the worst possible way.

Grammar Hammer: Drew reads five sentences featuring homophones and asks the boys to spell the correct version of each homophone. The boys never fail to disappoint.

Blind Rankings: The panel blindly ranks five cereals. Which is your favorite?

Top 5: The boys have to identify the top 5 cities with the highest major crime rate per 100,000 residents.

Thank you to our sponsors: Lelulo's Pizzeria, Tresco Concrete, Continental Comb, The Jen Mascaro Real Estate Team, Salute Beer Distributor, Busy Little Me, Pittsburgh Sports Complex & Self Storage, and Nesbit’s Lanes.

Guest Host: Jimmy McBride

Plum Problems: Internet trolls, Mark Devine, fitted sheets, Facebook jerks, out-of-control youth basketball parents.

The Minority Report: Justin shares a travel tip on how to check for bed bugs when you get to your hotel room...using an iron.

Would You Rather: always speak in rhymes or sing everything you say like you're in a musical?

Drew's Clues: Mario gives up to five clues for the boys to guess the subject of this week's Drew's Clues in the category of American Podcasters.

Blind Rankings: The panel blindly ranks five catchphrases from the late Pittsburgh Penguins play-by-play announcer Mike Lange.

Top 5: The boys have to guess the hitters with the top 5 batting averages in Major League Baseball in 2024.

Thank you to our sponsors: Lelulo's Pizzeria, Tresco Concrete, Continental Comb, The Jen Mascaro Real Estate Team, Salute Beer Distributor, Busy Little Me, Pittsburgh Sports Complex & Self Storage, and Nesbit’s Lanes.

Guest Host: Jimmy McBride

Plum Problems: The hosts of Sour Plums, the Super Bowl Halftime Show, the end of Jimmy's voicemail streak, and the lack of helpfulness and manners of people in public places.

The Minority Report: Justin gives just a tip on a better technique for lining your pans with aluminum foil to avoid clean-up.

Would You Rather: Have a time machine or a teleporter?

Grammar Hammer: Drew reads four separate sentences and asks each co-host to answer if the sentence is grammatically correct or not. This was harder than it should have been for the boys.

Blind Rankings: The panel blindly ranks the best appetizers. Newman wasn't a fan of many.

Top 5: The boys have to guess the top 5 automobiles sold in the United States (by sales volume). Might have been our worst performance.

Thank you to our sponsors: Lelulo's Pizzeria, Tresco Concrete, Continental Comb, The Jen Mascaro Real Estate Team, Salute Beer Distributor, Busy Little Me, Pittsburgh Sports Complex & Self Storage, and Nesbit’s Lanes.

Guest Host: Michael Caliguiri

Plum Problems: People taking shoes off on an airplane, Plum trash pick-up issues, Chiefs/Eagles Super Bowl matchup, and Mike Devine.

The Minority Report: Justin gives tips on when to replace your air filter and how to make your entire home smell amazing when you do.

Would You Rather: Take a guaranteed $1 million or flip a coin for a 50/50 chance to win $1 billion or $0.

Drew's Clues: Drew continues a new segment whereby the boys compete to earn points by guessing the correct answer with the fewest number of clues given. This week's category was Comedian: Dead or Alive. This will be a season-long contest, and we encourage you to play along at home.

Blind Rankings: The panel blindly ranks the best places/times to drink a beer (or any beverage of your choice) as rated by this week's co-host filling in for Mike, Mario Francesco.

Top 5: The boys have to guess the top 5 most popular cocktails according to Forbes. This was our most difficult Top 5 to date.

Thank you to our sponsors: Lelulo's Pizzeria, Tresco Concrete, Continental Comb, The Jen Mascaro Real Estate Team, Salute Beer Distributor, Busy Little Me, Pittsburgh Sports Complex & Self Storage, and Nesbit’s Lanes.

Guest Host: Mario Francesco

Plum Problems: Plum social media know-it-alls, citizens who need to proof before posting, the perils of sled riding in Plum, too many folks booking Mario Francesco for odd jobs, and people using FB like it's Google.

The Minority Report: Justin reveals a better way to use scarves.

Would You Rather: Make an extra $100 per day or gain an extra hour per day for the rest of your life?

Drew's Clues: Drew introduces a fun new segment whereby the boys compete to earn points by guessing the correct answer with the fewest number of clues given. This week's category was 90s Rappers. This will be a season-long contest, and we encourage you to play along at home.

Blind Rankings: The panel blindly ranks the most fun outdoor winter activities.

Top 5: Mike asks the group to identify the top 5 all-time winningest goalies in Pittsburgh Penguins history.

Thank you to our sponsors: Lelulo's Pizzeria, Tresco Concrete, Continental Comb, The Jen Mascaro Real Estate Team, Salute Beer Distributor, Busy Little Me, Pittsburgh Sports Complex & Self Storage, and Nesbit’s Lanes.

Guest Host: Rick Berrott, who discusses key facts and figures surrounding the 24th Annual Plum Borough School District Make-A-Wish Telethon.

Plum Problems: We settle the argument on whether or not Die Hard is a Christmas movie. Or do we?

The Minority Report: Justin reveals the benefits of adding carrots to your frying oil.

Would You Rather: A spin on the classic where Mike lists four items (slices of pizza, miles to run, days without showering, and punches from Mike Tyson) and the boys have to assign one of these numbers to each of the items: 6, 12, 18, and 24.

This or That: 5 Christmas-themed matchups.

Blind Rankings: The panel blindly ranks 5 NBA legends not named Michael Jordan or Lebron James.

Top 5: Mike asks the group to identify the top 5 most visited websites in the world. Can you guess them? Without cheating?

Thank you to our sponsors: Lelulo's Pizzeria, Tresco Concrete, Continental Comb, The Jen Mascaro Real Estate Team, Salute Beer Distributor, Busy Little Me, Pittsburgh Sports Complex & Self Storage, and Nesbit’s Lanes.

Guest Host: Jen Dintini

Plum Problems: Unnecessary toaster settings, never-ending Plum road construction, obnoxious Noggin Boss hats, pitfalls of running for political office, and The Adventures of Mole Man Part IV.

The Minority Report: Justin gives us insight on how to get the skins off of potatoes without peeling them.

Would You Rather: Take $1 million right now, free and clear, or get $1 million for every hit you could get in 50 Major League Baseball at-bats?

This or That: 5 Thanksgiving food matchups. Build your favorite plate!

Blind Rankings: The panel blindly ranks 5 non-food Thanksgiving traditions.

Top 5: Mike asks the group to identify the top 5 first languages spoken in the world (by population). Will they finally get all five correct?

Thank you to our sponsors: Lelulo's Pizzeria, Tresco Concrete, Continental Comb, The Jen Mascaro Real Estate Team, Salute Beer Distributor, Busy Little Me, Pittsburgh Sports Complex & Self Storage, and Nesbit’s Lanes.