”…all the wherefore and the whiches…”

Adam and Melanie reunite at Biscuits Diner and compare notes. 

·     Amir Darvish as Gus Finch

·     Matthew Cohn as Adam Kleinhoffer

·     Keilly McQuail as Melanie Lavin

·     Inés del Castillo as Female Voice Two

·     James Weber as Red

·     Meg MacCary as Laura

·     Owen Smith as Trevor

·     Sara Jane Munford as Singing Woman

·     Written by Caroline V. McGraw

·     Directed by Eddie Prunoske

·     Sound designed and engineered by James Hansen

·     Original music by Luke Santy

·     Cover art by Matthew Cohn

·     Produced by Five on a Match: Matthew Cohn, Amir Darvish, and Meg MacCary

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

“You are closer than you think.”

Back to that night at the Icarus Motel, Adam goes in hot pursuit of a mysterious car.

·     Susannah Jones as Soothing Female Voice

·     Matthew Cohn as Adam Kleinhoffer

·     Written by Caroline V. McGraw

·     Directed by Eddie Prunoske

·     Sound designed and engineered by James Hansen

·     Original music by Luke Santy

·     Cover art by Matthew Cohn

·     Produced by Five on a Match: Matthew Cohn, Amir Darvish, and Meg MacCary

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

“We Made Signs.”

Melanie finds an important clue on the Caldwell Cosmetics message board.

·     Keilly McQuail as Melanie Lavin

·     Meg MacCary as Laura

·     Susannah Jones as Female Voice One

·     Michelle Beck as Steph

·     Written by Caroline V. McGraw

·     Directed by Eddie Prunoske

·     Sound designed and engineered by James Hansen

·     Original music by Luke Santy

·     Cover art by Matthew Cohn

·     Produced by Five on a Match: Matthew Cohn, Amir Darvish, and Meg MacCary

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

“The best stuff comes up when people don’t know we’re listening.”

What happened to Adam that night at the Icarus Motel?

·     Paul Guyet as Soothing Male Voice

·     Amir Darvish as Gus Finch

·     Matthew Cohn as Adam Kleinhoffer

·     Keilly McQuail as Melanie Lavin

·     James Weber as Red

·     Anthony Cohn as Older Man

·     Meg MacCary as Laura

·     Michelle Beck as Steph

·     Emily Batsford, Monica Lerch, Sara Jane Munford as Women’s Chorus

·     Written by Caroline V. McGraw

·     Directed by Eddie Prunoske

·     Sound designed and engineered by James Hansen

·     Original music by Luke Santy

·     Cover art by Matthew Cohn

·     Produced by Five on a Match: Matthew Cohn, Amir Darvish, and Meg MacCary

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

“It’s weird to, like? Talk about her in the past tense…”

Melanie is surprised by what she finds in the woods.

·     Paul Guyet as Soothing Male Voice

·     Keilly McQuail as Melanie Lavin

·     Michelle Beck as Steph

·     Owen Smith as Trevor

·     Emily Batsford, Monica Lerch, Sara Jane Munford as Women’s Chorus

·     Written by Caroline V. McGraw

·     Directed by Eddie Prunoske

·     Sound designed and engineered by James Hansen

·     Original music by Luke Santy

·     Cover art by Matthew Cohn

·     Produced by Five on a Match: Matthew Cohn, Amir Darvish, and Meg MacCary

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

“If he had done this thing, I wouldn’t be talking to you.”

“Nowhere to Run: Injustice in East Cleveland,” the investigative podcast that made Adam famous, follows the case of four young men wrongfully convicted of murdering sixteen year old Tabitha MacGill.

·     Paul Guyet as Soothing Male Voice

·     Matthew Cohn as Adam Kleinhoffer

·     Keilly McQuail as Melanie Lavin

·     Christine Campbell as Mrs. Delphin

·     Susannah Jones as Female Voice One

·     Inés del Castillo as Female Voice Two

·     Alice Jokela as Female Voice Three

·     Written by Caroline V. McGraw

·     Directed by Eddie Prunoske

·     Sound designed and engineered by James Hansen

·     Original music by Luke Santy

·     Cover art by Matthew Cohn

·     Produced by Five on a Match: Matthew Cohn, Amir Darvish, and Meg MacCary

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

“What’s the worst thing that ever happened to you?” 

Melanie Lavin, Adam’s assistant, left alone, goes searching for clues in the woods.

·     Paul Guyet as Soothing Male Voice

·     Meg MacCary as Laura

·     Keilly McQuail as Melanie Lavin

·     Michelle Beck as Steph

·     Written by Caroline V. McGraw

·     Directed by Eddie Prunoske

·     Sound designed and engineered by James Hansen

·     Original music by Luke Santy

·     Cover art by Matthew Cohn

·     Produced by Five on a Match: Matthew Cohn, Amir Darvish, and Meg MacCary

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

“What do you think it is? Some kind of symbol?”

Adam Kleinhoffer, journalist and podcaster for Columbia Public Radio, receives a mysterious postcard beckoning him to Split Valley, the second-smallest town in New York State.

·     Paul Guyet as Soothing Male Voice

·     Amir Darvish as Gus Finch

·     Matthew Cohn as Adam Kleinhoffer

·     Keilly McQuail as Melanie Lavin

·     Inés del Castillo as News Anchor

·     James Weber as Red

·     Written by Caroline V. McGraw

·     Directed by Eddie Prunoske

·     Sound designed and engineered by James Hansen

·     Original music by Luke Santy

·     Cover art by Matthew Cohn

·     Produced by Five on a Match: Matthew Cohn, Amir Darvish, and Meg MacCary

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

What would you do if you received a postcard saying only “We are here. Come find us?” No signature. Just a postmark: SPLIT VALLEY, NY. Adam Kleinhoffer, journalist and podcaster for Columbia Public Radio, and production assistant Melanie Lavin follow this breadcrumb to the second-smallest town in New York State.

SPLIT VALLEY is an immersive experience. Using only “found audio,” Split Valley takes the listener on a journey into the woods upstate, to a small town diner, a local motel, searching for clues to the mystery of the cryptic postcard. Pull up a chair, dim the lights, and tune in to Split Valley.

Cast

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices