This random week, Natalie dishes about Dennis Nilsen, the British Jeffrey Dahmer, and Katie recounts the creppy tale of The Watcher. This episode is dedicated to all the Dick Butts out there!

This week's theme is ghosties! Katie recounts the haunting tale of the Bell Witch and Natalie shares about the Stanley Hotel.

Another episode with no theme! Natalie enchants us with the story of Helen Duncan, the last witch in Scotland and Katie recounts the disappearance and murder of Skylar Neese.

This week we are talking local. Katie covers the tragic death of Karen King in Saginaw, MI and Natalie details the Brown's Chicken Murders in Palatine, IL.

This week we tell each other short stories of spoopiness and creppiness. Natalie tells the tale of Blanche Monnier and Katie dives into the Hinterkaifeck murders.

In an episode with no theme, Katie starts with the story of Australian killer Katherine Knight, and Natalie dishes on her "Electric Love" for the story of Topsy the Elephant and Thomas Edison.

This week we go on lots of rants and talk about cryptids. Natalie reveals the story behind the Hodag of Rhinelander, Wisconsin, and shares our first hometown story from Rhinelander natives, Lindsay and Ryan Lieck. Katie explains the legend of the Wendigo and reads a spoopy story.

This week's episode theme is not a murder. Literally anything that's not a murder. Katie relays the story of the missing Sodder children and Natalie shares a collection of conspiracy theories about the Denver International Airport.

Our theme is: The Year You Were Born. Natalie covers 1994 serial killer, Gary Ray Bowles aka the I-95 Killer. Katie relays the tragedy of Shanda Sharer's 1992 murder.

In our first episode, Katie covers the Italian Hall Disaster of Calumet and Natalie discusses the murder of Brenda Wright Lafferty.