
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


In 1979, a beloved English teacher at Upper Merion High School vanished from Pennsylvania’s affluent Main Line community. Days later, Susan Reinert’s body was discovered in a Harrisburg motel parking lot in the back of her own vehicle— but her two young children, Karen and Michael, were nowhere to be found.
What began as a missing persons case quickly unraveled into one of the most controversial murder investigations in Pennsylvania history.
In Part One of our deep dive into the Main Line Murders, we examine:
• Susan Reinert’s life at Upper Merion High School
As investigators began piecing together timelines, alibis, and financial motives, what emerged was a story involving deception, betrayal, and a high school faculty hiding more than anyone realized.
Was this a crime of passion?
Join us as we break down the beginning of the case that would later become known as the Main Line Murders — a scandal that would divide a community and leave haunting questions that still linger decades later.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Jackie and Jenna dive into the mysterious death of Ellen Greenberg, who was found stabbed 20 times in her apartment, with her death initially ruled a suicide.
They discuss the background of Ellen's life, the day of the incident, the controversial 911 call made by her fiancé, the autopsy findings, and the subsequent legal battles her family has faced in their quest for justice.
They explore the inconsistencies in the investigation, the changing rulings regarding her death, and the recent involvement of the federal government.
The episode concludes with reflections on the ongoing mystery surrounding Ellen's death and the impact it has had on her family and community.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
PLEASE NOTE: This episode may be best viewed on YouTube
In this episode, Jenna and Jackie discuss the alarming issue of missing juvenile males in Philadelphia, focusing on 16 boys who have gone missing in recent months. They highlight the lack of media coverage and public awareness compared to other missing persons cases, particularly those of white children.
The hosts explore individual cases, patterns of disappearances, and potential reasons behind these incidents, including the influence of online interactions and gang recruitment. They emphasize the need for community awareness and action to address this growing concern.
Keywords:
#MissingChildren #Philadelphia #TrueCrime #UnsolvedCases #MissingPersons #CrimeNews #Awareness #HeadlineHighlights
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
On Valentine’s Day 2007, a quiet coastal neighborhood in Carlsbad, California became the scene of a haunting mystery that would take more than a decade to solve. In this episode of Stop! Who Does That?!, Jackie and Jenna break down the tragic and complex case of Jodine Serrin, a kind-hearted 39-year-old woman found murdered inside her own home after her parents stopped by for a routine check-in.
What started as a welfare visit quickly turned into a chilling investigation involving an unidentified man seen inside her bedroom, a crime scene filled with clues, and a DNA profile that wouldn’t match anyone for years. The case went cold — until advances in forensic science and genetic genealogy finally revealed the truth behind her killer’s identity.
This episode explores the timeline, the investigation, the forensic breakthroughs, and the emotional impact on Jodine’s family, who lived for years knowing they had unknowingly come face-to-face with the person responsible.
🕒 Episode Chapters
🔎 Topics Covered
Jodine Serrin cold case
Carlsbad California murder case
DNA genealogy solved crimes
Cold cases solved by DNA
True crime podcast analysis
Unsolved mysteries solved years later
📢 Support the Show
📌 Hashtags
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Most people think they know everything about friendship, betrayal, and the dark secrets lurking beneath seemingly innocent relationships. In this episode, we uncover the shocking case of Megan Sundwell—a nurse accused of convincing her best friend to take her own life for insurance money. Discover how a seemingly close friendship spiraled into a diabolical plan with medical deception, hidden motives, and courtroom battles over what evidence can be admitted.
Then, we take you to Ohio, where the mysterious death of 17-year-old Hailey Buzbee raises questions of predatory online luring, police slow-motion investigations, and missing evidence. Why hasn't the suspect been charged with homicide yet? Why is the justice system moving at a snail’s pace?
Finally, we explore the bizarre, terrifying kidnapping of Nancy Guthrie—an 84-year-old woman whose abduction might be more than just a random crime. With blood droplets, missing security cameras, and ransom notes, this case hints at a carefully orchestrated attack meant to send a message to her famous daughter Savannah Guthrie. Could this be linked to political secrets or dark webs of power? We unpack the evidence, speculate on motives, and reveal how close the family came to tragedy—highlighting the dangers of corruption, influence, and cold-blooded planning.
#stopwhodoesthat #truecrimepodcast #crimenews #podcast #haileybuzbee #meggansundwell #nancyguthrie #murdaughmurders #d4vdupdates #crimetok
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
The conversation delves into the shocking case of Richard Greist, a Pennhurst State School Aide, who committed a heinous crime in Sanatoga, PA, on May 10, 1978, resulting in the deaths of his pregnant wife and unborn child.
Jackie and Jenna explore the complexities of his mental illness, the trial that found him not guilty by reason of insanity, and the subsequent years of rehabilitation. They discuss the implications of his release after 44 years and the ongoing debate between justice and rehabilitation in the criminal justice system.
REFERENCES:
https://www.nytimes.com/1978/05/11/archives/police-subdue-a-hospital-worker-who-killed-wife-and-unborn-child.html https://www.religionnewsblog.com/20865/richard-greist-2 https://www.religionnewsblog.com/20865/richard-greist-2 https://patch.com/pennsylvania/norristown/man-who-killed-wife-cut-out-unborn-son-78-released-hospital https://www.dailylocal.com/2022/08/02/richard-greist-to-be-discharged-from-norristown-state-hospital/?clearUserState=true https://www.dailylocal.com/2022/08/08/recalling-a-1978-murder-and-the-long-court-saga-of-richard-greist/ https://www.readingeagle.com/2023/01/12/richard-greist-will-remain-free-but-must-continue-care-privately-on-outpatient-basis/
Keywords Richard Greist, true crime, mental illness, rehabilitation, insanity defense, Pennsylvania crime, justice system, psychosis, family tragedy, crime history #RichardGreist #TrueCrime #TrueCrimeYouTube #TrueCrimePodcast #InsanityDefense #NotGuiltyByReasonOfInsanity #CriminalJustice #MentalIllnessAndCrime #CourtCase #pennhurst #pennsylvania
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
In this episode of Headline Highlights, hosts Jackie and Jenna discuss several tragic and shocking murder cases, including a family annihilator in Pennsylvania, the murder of an Oklahoma mother by her adopted son, and the ongoing New Jersey mansion murder trial.
They also provide updates on the Brendan Banfield/Au Pair murder trial, reflecting on the complexities of justice and family dynamics in these cases, as well as "low-hanging fruit" case updates in the Luigi Mangione and Gabby Petito cases.
#brendanbanfield #pennsylvaniaman #njmansiontrial #luigimangione #gabbypetito
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
In this episode, hosts Jackie and Jenna delve into the unsolved murder of Gary Redner, a successful grocery store executive found dead outside his home in Pennsylvania. They explore the background of Redner, the circumstances surrounding his death, and the ongoing investigation that has left the community in silence.
The discussion highlights the theories surrounding the murder, the potential motives, and the impact on Redner's family and community.
Not a lot of men named Gary these days...
Be sure to check us out at the Beyond the Crime Convention in Albuquerque, NM, April 10-11 where we will be recording in front of a LIVE audience!
Get your tickets here:
https://www.beyondcrimeconvention.com/
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
On this episode of Stop! Who Does That? Headline Highlights (January 27, 2026), Jackie and Jenna break down some of the most disturbing and fast-moving true crime stories making headlines right now.
We begin in Orlando, Florida, where a beloved therapist is brutally murdered by her former patient — raising serious questions about safety, accountability, and systemic failures meant to protect mental health professionals.
Next, we head to Los Angeles, where a firefighter allegedly learns of his wife’s infidelity moments before bludgeoning her to death with an ax in their home — a shocking case of intimate partner violence that prosecutors say underscores how quickly domestic situations can turn deadly.
Then, a Thanksgiving family dinner in North Carolina ends in tragedy when a mother is officially charged with poisoning her own daughter’s wine. Investigators say this may not be the only suspicious death connected to her.
We also cover several quick but important case updates, including: Anna Kepner, Ashlee Buzzard, Luigi Mangione and more!
As always, we wrap things up with a round of Florida Man Google Roulette, because Florida never disappoints.
✨ Special announcement: We’re thrilled to share that Stop! Who Does That? has been invited to present a live podcast at Beyond the Crime in Albuquerque, New Mexico this April! We’ll be sharing discount ticket codes soon — stay tuned.
https://www.beyondcrimeconvention.com/
If you enjoy the show, please subscribe, rate, and follow us on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, YouTube, and TikTok. Your support means everything to us.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Sources: https://abc7ny.com/post/west-wing-actor-timothy-busfield-faces-new-assault-claim-16-year-old-victim-court-documents/18403862/
https://www.courttv.com/news/prosecutors-fight-back-after-judge-suppresses-amish-mans-murder-confession/
https://www.instagram.com/p/DTfxW8hEtZ0/
https://people.com/man-wearing-chilling-hoodie-arrested-after-womans-death-texas-11888024
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
From the publisher's feed