Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan

Sugar, Support, and Frankie


Listen Later

A seven‑month marriage sparked on a sugar‑arrangement site, a $12,000/month support bid, and a dog named Frankie—this one has layers. We open with a candid walk‑through of interim spousal support: what it’s for, how courts weigh “capacity to pay,” and why selling capital assets to fund an opulent lifestyle isn’t the same as earning income. The applicant’s luxury‑level budget meets judicial scrutiny, while the respondent’s push to impute escort income and point to family wealth hits legal limits. The end result—$4,000/month plus a retroactive lump—shows how judges balance short marriages, realistic needs, and the difference between lifestyle and income.

Then the plot thickens. A same‑day, ex parte protection order leads to disputed removals from the home and a tussle over Frankie. We unpack how BC’s Family Law Act treats companion animals: not as handbags, but through factors like who provided care, safety concerns, and well‑being. On an interim basis, Frankie stays put—illustrating how courts separate urgent stability from final outcomes and insist on full candour when seeking protective relief.

The second half pivots to evidence law and a rare rebuke: the province sought a lifetime ban on a man from a welfare office, relying on an internal incident report as a “business record.” Both the trial court and the Court of Appeal said no. We explain why “ordinary course of business” demands reliability—think automated receipts and bank statements—not a narrative drafted post‑incident for litigation. Even beyond admissibility, the appellate court flags proportionality: a permanent injunction is an extraordinary remedy, not a default response.

If you care about how courts actually draw the line between income and spending, how interim orders stabilize without deciding the future, how pet custody really works, and when business records are admissible, this conversation is your blueprint. Listen, share with a friend who loves law done plainly, and leave a quick review to help others find the show.


Follow this link for a transcript of the show and links to the cases discussed.

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

Legally Speaking with Michael MulliganBy Michael Mulligan

  • 5
  • 5
  • 5
  • 5
  • 5

5

1 ratings


More shows like Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan

View all
As It Happens by CBC

As It Happens

425 Listeners

Ideas by CBC

Ideas

398 Listeners

CANADALAND by CANADALAND

CANADALAND

219 Listeners

The Current by CBC

The Current

205 Listeners

The House by CBC

The House

64 Listeners

CTV Power Play with Vassy Kapelos Podcast by CTV News

CTV Power Play with Vassy Kapelos Podcast

36 Listeners

Michael Campbell's Money Talks by HPC Inc.

Michael Campbell's Money Talks

73 Listeners

At Issue by CBC

At Issue

110 Listeners

The Big Story by Frequency Podcast Network

The Big Story

87 Listeners

Front Burner by CBC

Front Burner

452 Listeners

The Herle Burly by Air Quotes Media

The Herle Burly

53 Listeners

The Decibel by The Globe and Mail

The Decibel

114 Listeners

Honestly with Bari Weiss by The Free Press

Honestly with Bari Weiss

8,505 Listeners

Hub Podcasts by Hub Media Canada

Hub Podcasts

36 Listeners

The Ben Mulroney Show by Corus Radio

The Ben Mulroney Show

55 Listeners