Coffee and a Case Note

Sutton v NRS(J) Pty Ltd [2020] NSWSC 826


Listen Later

“We’ve lost the trust deed!”


___


A trust was settled in 1972 with 3 trustees, all brothers. The trustees’ dad was settlor: [4] – [6]


The trust was dormant until 2007 when, after the sale of a business, it was reactivated: [7]

Around this time each brother was replaced by a separate Co as trustee, leaving 3 corporate trustees: [8]

The trust assets were substantial and generated significant income: [10] The trust had been administered based on a photocopy. No one knew where the original was!

A bank used by the trust required production of the original deed as part of its “know your customer” program (the interpretation of which the Court left as an open question): [11], [12]

Searches were conducted for the original deed, including of the records of the father’s solicitor. Only a photocopy, identical to the photocopy that was already being relied on, was found: [14], [15]

One of the brothers sought a declaration that the photocopy was a true copy of the original. However, the Court found that a declaration like this was not appropriate: [20] – [22]

Instead, the Court provided s63 judicial advice to the trustees that they would be justified in continuing to administer the trust on the basis of the photocopy: [25]

As the trustees might agree: phew!

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

Coffee and a Case NoteBy James d'Apice

  • 5
  • 5
  • 5
  • 5
  • 5

5

2 ratings


More shows like Coffee and a Case Note

View all
Newshour by BBC World Service

Newshour

1,068 Listeners

Law Report by ABC

Law Report

23 Listeners

Conversations by ABC

Conversations

794 Listeners

All In The Mind by ABC

All In The Mind

773 Listeners

The Economy, Stupid by ABC

The Economy, Stupid

26 Listeners

Politics Now by ABC News

Politics Now

90 Listeners

NAB Morning Call by Phil Dobbie

NAB Morning Call

17 Listeners

Lawyers Weekly Podcast Network by Momentum Media

Lawyers Weekly Podcast Network

1 Listeners

If You're Listening by ABC

If You're Listening

313 Listeners

FT News Briefing by Financial Times

FT News Briefing

655 Listeners

Behind the Money by Financial Times

Behind the Money

227 Listeners

Full Story by The Guardian

Full Story

168 Listeners

15 Minutes with the Boss by The Australian Financial Review

15 Minutes with the Boss

8 Listeners

Chanticleer by Australian Financial Review

Chanticleer

14 Listeners

The Fin by Australian Financial Review

The Fin

18 Listeners