This is the one where Jodie and Eric sit down with Steve Spingola, a former Milwaukee detective and investigator for Oxygen's 'Cold Justice' to talk about some of their favorite subjects, including Dahmer, Walter Ellis (aka the Northside Strangler), and the Smiley Face Killer.

This is the episode where Eric talks about a forgotten person involved in the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor and Jodie revives the unlikely story of Laurie Bembenek.

In this one, Eric talks about his newly discovered weird love for artist Jimmie Durham and Jodie tells you all about some icy Lake Superior murder.

In this one, Eric talks about his newly discovered weird love for artist Jimmie Durham and Jodie tells you all about some icy Lake Superior murder.

In this one, Eric and Jodie are joined by special guest Greg Gilbertson to talk about the book 'Wisconsin Death Trip' and the subsequent film adaptation.

In this one, Jodie talks about a murderer who was apparently very thorough, and Eric tells the story about Joyce McKinney and the Manacled Mormon.

In this one, Jodie talks about a murderer who was apparently very thorough, and Eric tells the story about Joyce McKinney and the Manacled Mormon.

This enthralling new edition of Tell Me Something Weird, Eric tells Jodie about the other UFO recovery incident in New Mexico and Jodie talks about Bigfoot sightings in northern Wisconsin.

In this exciting new episode, Eric and Jodie do stuff outside! Eric went to visit a straight up erratic and Jodie checked out some nearby haunted places. What kinds of shenanigans are these two going to get up to next?

This is the one where Jodie warns you to be careful who you let attack you in a pool and Eric reminds you that all cats are unconscionable, cold-blooded killers--no exceptions. Yes, even yours.