Yishmael asks about the onion bulb from 7 that grew in 8thyear
1. Rabbi Yannai Terumah that grew is permitted
2. Rabbi Yohanan grafted branch with fruit is prohibited
3. Rabbi Yonatan onion in a vineyard is prohibited
4. Rabbi Ami - Rabbi Yohanan – onions planted must take maaser. Rejected b/c stringent
5. Sheviit is not batel. Rejected b/c stringent.
6. Onions on ground sprouted in 8th year permitted. Maybe crushed.
7. Weeding with suspected Jew after Sheviit is permitted.
(2-3) Challege to Rabbi Yohanan and Rabbi Yonatan?
Shemita is different because prohibition and nullification are from the ground.
(4) Challenge to Rabbi Ami – from our Mishnah
Can become permitted so no nullification
No misvah to undo Terumah.
Further challenge, comparison to (6)
(1) Challenge to Rabbi Yannai
Dedicated by Mourad Shehebar for Refuah Shelemah of Chaya Sarah Bat Simcha