Hagigah 23

3) Carrying two items together:

Why is carrying item and kodesh together prohibited?

Actual case

Why not Terumah?

Only like details of actual case – R. Hananiah

Three questions, one answer

6) Vessel completed in purity:

Completed by Haver, but worried about saliva

Does NOT require setting of sun

Good for R. Yehoshua – that’s why another impurity is needed

R. Eliezer must think setting of sun IS required -no added impurity?

Rav – as if were a more severe impurity

Dedicated in loving memory of Sharon Wahba a"h by Rita and Sam Franco.

Rabbi Ila – heavy vessel inside

Rava – narrow opening

A. Difference between them

B. Leniency for narrow vessels

C. Parallel to Tannaitic dispute

D. Challenge – why distinguish Terumah from Kodesh?

Haberim won’t accept Terumah from Am Haaretz

But will accept Kodashim to avoid hatred

More about avoiding hatred

We should prohibit Terumah case b/c of borrowing vessels

Long proof from Mishnah Eduyot re borrowing vessels

Response – corpse impuirty

E. Inside and Outside

Dedicated in loving memory of Sharon Wahba a"h by Rita and Sam Franco.

Dedicated in loving memory of Sharon Wahba a"h by Rita and Sam Franco.

A. Stringency to treat regualar food like sacrifice

Proof that this is effective

B. Impurity enters when distracted

a. Friend picks up shawl - impure

b. Shabbat and weekday clothes switched - impure

c. Clothes switched in the bathhouse – impure

Challenge - Switched wheat and barley – pure

Stories of Rabbi Ishmael

Responses

A person does not watch what another is holding

Unless you purify the watcher and watch him

C. Eleven ways Kodesh is more stringent than Terumah

Dedicated in loving memory of Sharon Wahba a"h by Rita and Sam Franco.

Dedicated in loving memory of Sharon Wahba a"h by Rita and Sam Franco.

Dedicated in loving memory of Sharon Wahba a"h by Rita and Sam Franco.

Shavuot has 7 days to offer sacrifices

1. Rabbi Oshaia – proof from Passover

Challenge from our Mishnah

Challenge from a baraita

Challenge from baraita of Rabbah bar Shemuel

2. Rabbi Eliezer ben Yaakov – proof from Vayikra 23:21-22

Dedicated in loving memory of Sharon Wahba a"h by Rita and Sam Franco.

Dedicated in loving memory of Sharon Wahba a"h by Rita and Sam Franco.

Dedicated in loving memory of Sharon Wahba a"h by Rita and Sam Franco.

Dedicated in loving memory of Sharon Wahba a"h by Rita and Sam Franco.