Send us a text
The episode explores our unconscious participation in traditions--such as "Twixmas," the period between Christmas and New Year’s, and "Tsundoku," the Japanese term for buying books and not reading them--and links this reality to a discussion of two competing educational philosophies: progressive education, championed by John Dewey, and traditionalist education, represented by the lesser-known William Chandler Bagley. Dewey’s approach, emphasizing individualism and student-led learning, has overshadowed Bagley’s structured, teacher-led model.
Central to this debate is Thomas De Quincey’s distinction between the literature of power and the literature of knowledge. The former inspires and moves, while the latter teaches facts. Dewey and progressive education favor power, believing true understanding emerges through personal experience rather than direct instruction. Traditionalists argue that progressive education romanticizes self-discovery and downplays structured learning, leading to a diminished respect for knowledge and community.
Three key themes emerge: individualism, which prioritizes personal intuition over communal learning; naturalness, which favors self-guided discovery over teacher authority; and moral idealism, which frames progressive methods as superior while dismissing traditional education as rigid. Civilization depends on knowledge transmission, yet progressive ideals often obscure this reality.
Progressive education’s rejection of structured learning results in a system where teacher authority is hidden rather than removed, creating a false sense of student autonomy. Meanwhile, traditionalists argue that education is a communal process that requires shared knowledge, structure, and discipline. Without this foundation, students lack the tools to fully engage with powerful literature and complex ideas.
The episode concludes by advocating for a balance between the literature of knowledge and power. Rather than seeing structured learning as oppressive, it should be viewed as the foundation that enables individuals to engage meaningfully with transformative ideas. Knowledge is not a constraint but a gateway to greater understanding, autonomy, and creativity.
