The Ad Watchers

The Ad Watchers

By BBB National ProgramsBusinessNewsTech NewsNon-Profit
Download on the App Store

The Ad Watchers episodes

  • 5 Years of SWIFT – Does it meet the need for speed?

    A single-issue ad law case does not mean it is not an important issue. For the last 5 years, the Fast-Track SWIFT filing track has addressed the increasing speed of online campaigns and the demand for the challenge process to keep pace, issuing decisions within 20 days of the challenge.

    In this episode of Ad Watchers, hosts Annie and Eric discuss the rapid rise in single-issue advertising NAD challenges, a 3-fold increase in the last three years, and outline the types of cases seen, such as disclosure and #1 claims.

    Related Resources:

    • Fast-Track SWIFT
    • National Advertising Division Finds ‘Verizon Is the Number One Network Choice in Public Safety’ Claim in Verizon Frontline Commercial Supported
    • National Advertising Division Recommends DREO Limited Discontinue “#1 Brand” Claims for its Fans and Heaters
    • National Advertising Division Recommends Tempur-Pedic Discontinue Disparaging Claims Against Sleep Number
    • National Advertising Review Board Recommends that Perrigo Discontinue ‘#1 Brand of Flossers’ Claims for its Plackers Brand Dental Floss Products
    • National Advertising Division Finds T-Mobile’s Claim that it is the First and Only Wireless Provider to Partner with Starlink Supported
    • In National Advertising Division Fast-Track SWIFT Challenge Behr Voluntarily Discontinues “No Comparable Product” Claim 
    • National Advertising Division Recommends Oral Essentials Discontinue “Enamel Safe” Claim for Lumineux Whitening Mouthwash

      • The post 5 Years of SWIFT – Does it meet the need for speed? appeared first on BBB National Programs.

      29 min
    • The Ad Law Trend Report – What were 2024’s hot topics and trends?

      The National Advertising Division (NAD) Annual Report provides a comprehensive look at the year’s ad law trends and hot topics, from influencers to AI to reviews and rankings. 

      To kick off a new season of Ad Watchers, hosts Eric and Annie provide insights from the 2024 Annual Report and discuss what’s next in the year ahead, along with some timely best practices for advertisers. 

      Annie and Eric discuss the report, highlighting key trends in advertising law, including the rise of influencer marketing, AI challenges, and comparative claims. They emphasize the importance of compliance in health and safety claims and preview upcoming events, including the 2025 NAD conference.

      Key Takeaways:

      • NAD has over 50 years of experience in advertising law.
      • The annual report reveals significant trends in advertising disputes.
      • Fast-Track SWIFT filings have increased by 50% since 2023.
      • Influencer marketing cases are on the rise, especially in beauty.
      • AI-related advertising issues are becoming more prevalent.
      • Comparative claims continue to be a major focus for NAD.
      • Health claims require competent and reliable scientific evidence.
      • NAD is seeing new product categories and challenges.
      • The 2025 NAD conference will be held in September in Washington, D.C.

        • Chapters:

        [00:00] Introduction to NAD and Advertising Law

        [02:12] Annual Report Insights and Trends
        [07:29] Influencer Marketing and AI Challenges
        [12:11] Comparative Claims and Industry-Specific Cases
        [17:03] Health and Safety Claims in Advertising
        [19:29] Looking Ahead: NAD Conference and Future Trends

        The post The Ad Law Trend Report – What were 2024’s hot topics and trends? appeared first on BBB National Programs.

        21 min
      • A Chat with ICAS: What Are Ad Law’s Global Hot Topics?

        In the final episode of the season, Ad Watchers hosts Annie Ugurlayan and Eric Unis go global. They are joined by Sibylle Stanciu-Loeckx, the executive director of the International Council for Advertising Self-Regulation, to discuss the international landscape of advertising self-regulation, including global hot topics, how countries find consensus on critical advertising issues, and the launch of a new Global Think Tank established to explore advertising’s next frontier.

        Annie, Eric, and Sibylle discuss the importance of advertising self-regulation on a global scale. They cover the diverse approaches to advertising standards across different countries, the current challenges faced by self-regulatory organizations, and the launch of a new Global Think Tank aimed at fostering collaboration and developing better advertising guidelines. This episode emphasizes the need for ethical advertising practices and examines the role of AI in shaping the future of advertising self-regulation.

        Key Takeaways:

        • Cultural differences shape advertising self-regulation systems.
        • AI presents both opportunities and challenges in advertising.
        • Collaboration among self-regulatory organizations (SROs) is essential for effective self-regulation.
        • The ICAS Think Tank aims to enhance global advertising standards.
        • Consumer complaints are a significant focus for many SROs.
        • Sustainability and responsible advertising are hot topics globally.
        • US advertising regulations influence global practices.
        • Ethics in advertising is a universal commitment.

          • Chapters

          00:00 Introduction to Advertising Self-Regulation

          02:02 Exploring ICAS and its Global Impact
          10:10 Diverse Approaches to Advertising Self-Regulation
          14:52 Current Challenges in Advertising Self-Regulation
          20:06 Building Consensus Among Global SROs
          24:51 Future Trends in Advertising Self-Regulation

          Relevant Resources:

          • Solving Shared Challenges: A Global Approach to Advertising Self-Regulation
          • ICAS Global Think Tank Press Release
          • ICAS/EASA Global Guidance on Environmental Claims
          • Listing of ICAS Members
          • NAD 2025 Annual Conference – Sign up for updates
          • Monthly Ad Law Insights Newsletter

            • The post A Chat with ICAS: What Are Ad Law’s Global Hot Topics? appeared first on BBB National Programs.

            30 min
          • AI is Everywhere: What about advertising?

            Artificial intelligence (AI) is top-of-mind for most businesses and on the radar of the National Advertising Division (NAD). In this episode of The Ad Watchers, NAD attorneys Eric Unis and Annie Ugurlayan are joined by guest Ken Crutchfield from Wolters Kluwer Legal & Regulatory U.S. to discuss AI’s potential impact on advertising.

            Annie, Eric, and Ken chat about how AI is shaking things up in advertising and the law. Their discussion includes a comprehensive overview on the types of AI, how it works, and where advertisers may want to tread lightly. They dive into a recent case where AI was in the spotlight and break down the different kinds of AI out there. Ken brings insights on how AI is changing the legal field, how it can help advertisers get a grip on markets, and why using AI correctly is so crucial. The conversation covers the ups and downs of using AI in ads, what advertisers need to think about, and tips for navigating AI-related challenges.

            Key Takeaways

            [03:00] Clear disclosures are crucial when using AI in advertising to avoid misleading claims and copyright infringement.

            [11:36] Validation of AI-generated content through trusted sources is essential to ensure accuracy and reliability.
            [15:07] Regulating AI poses challenges, and laws may vary internationally, requiring careful consideration of legal requirements.
            [21:39] Courts are encountering AI-related cases, and the use of AI in legal proceedings is a topic of discussion.
            [24:01] The conversation around AI in advertising and the law is ongoing, and further exploration of its implications is necessary.

            The post AI is Everywhere: What about advertising? appeared first on BBB National Programs.

            26 min
          • Clear and Conspicuous Disclosures: Can You Read the Fine Print?

            For this episode of Ad Watchers, our hosts Eric Unis and Annie Ugurlayan, attorneys at the National Advertising Division (NAD), dive into the fine print to discuss disclosures – the what, when, where, and how of ensuring consumers receive the material information they need to make an informed purchasing decision. 

            From small fonts to fast talking and distracting music, our hosts revisit this common issue area in advertising law. Listen in for a discussion of what it takes for a disclosure to be considered clear and conspicuous and uncover lessons learned from a series of print and TV advertisements that didn’t quite meet the standard for transparency. 

            For more, listen to Season 1’s episode covering the 4 P’s of a proper disclosure: prominence, presentation, placement, and proximity.

            Key Takeaways

            • (1:30) Proper execution of disclosures in advertising is crucial to ensure that consumers notice, read, and understand them.
            • (3:26) Disclosures should be clear and conspicuous, using plain English and being in close proximity to the claim or drawing attention to the disclosure. Hyperlinks should be used carefully, ensuring that important information is not hidden behind them and that they are easily noticeable and understandable.
            • (04:23) Consider the specific requirements of different advertising formats, such as TV, radio, and mobile devices, when designing and placing disclosures.
            • (22:06) Disclosures on packaging should be on the same panel as the claim and easily visible to consumers.
            • (24:30) Font size and readability of disclosures should be prioritized, avoiding the need for magnifying glasses.
            • (25:26) Use plain English in disclosures, keeping in mind that they should be easily understood by the average consumer.

              • The post Clear and Conspicuous Disclosures: Can You Read the Fine Print? appeared first on BBB National Programs.

              25 min
            • The Best Subject In Advertising Law: Is It Puffery?

              For this episode of Ad Watchers, join us for Eric’s favorite ad law topic: puffery, an exaggerated, blustering, or boastful statement or general claim that could only be understood to be an expression of opinion, not a statement of fact. But where is the line between puffery and a claim that needs a reasonable basis?

              Our hosts once again revisit a fan favorite and discuss the most recent puffery cases seen before the National Advertising Division, breaking down the various facets of puffery, including the use of emojis, to answer the burning question – does it require substantiation?

              Eric and Annie discuss the concept of puffery in advertising law, exploring its definition, application, and recent cases. The conversation delves into the nuances of puffery, its context-specific nature, and the challenges of distinguishing puffery from objective claims. It also addresses the use of symbols, emojis, humor, and pride in advertising, providing valuable tips for navigating puffery in advertising claims.

              Key Takeaways:

              • (2:00) Puffery in advertising law is a nuanced and context-specific concept that requires a deep understanding of consumer expectations and the distinction between subjective and objective claims. Advertisers must assess how their target audience perceives various claims and differentiate between what is considered a mere opinion and a factual statement.
              • (8:21) The use of symbols, emojis, humor, and pride in advertising can impact the interpretation of puffery claims. It may lead to challenges in distinguishing puffery from objective claims since symbols and emojis can add ambiguity, humor can blur the lines between exaggeration and deception, and pride-based claims can appear subjective but sometimes imply objective standards.
              • (9:40) When navigating puffery in advertising claims, it is important to fully brief the issues, keep claims general, and tread carefully with humor to avoid denigrating messages. Ensure all team members are aware of the legal nuances, use generalized statements to reduce the likelihood of factual interpretations, and employ humor cautiously to prevent misinterpretation or offense.
              • (12:57) Understanding recent puffery cases and their outcomes provides valuable insights into the application of puffery in advertising law and the challenges faced by advertisers in defending their claims. Analyzing court decisions helps predict how similar claims might be judged, illustrates the evolving standards and expectations in advertising law, and aids in crafting defensible advertising strategies.

                • More episodes on puffery:

                It’s Not Puffery. Do You Have The Evidence To Be #1?

                Best Podcast Episode Ever: What is Puffery?

                The post The Best Subject In Advertising Law: Is It Puffery? appeared first on BBB National Programs.

                29 min
              • Revisiting Consumer Reviews: Incentivized, Inflated, or Authentic?

                In this episode of Ad Watchers, the hosts discuss the topic of consumer reviews and the actions taken by the National Advertising Division (NAD) to ensure their accuracy. They highlight several recent NAD cases related to consumer reviews, including challenges to claims made by Proz hair care products, MyPatriot Supply, Goose Creek candles, and Dr. Squatch. The hosts also provide tips for advertisers on collecting and using reviews, such as ensuring reviews are representative, disclosing incentives, and not inflating star ratings.

                Key Takeaways

                • (00:30) Consumer reviews have become an important part of the purchasing process. In the digital age, consumers heavily rely on reviews to inform their buying decisions. The feedback provided by other consumers offers valuable insights into product quality and performance.
                • (6:45) NAD has been actively involved in reviewing claims related to consumer reviews. The National Advertising Division (NAD) diligently scrutinizes advertisements that make assertions based on consumer reviews. NAD takes decisive action against advertisers found guilty of disseminating deceptive or misleading claims.
                • (9:10) Advertisers should not take actions that distort or misrepresent consumer opinions. Distorting or misrepresenting consumer opinions, even if disguised as endorsements, erodes trust and damages brand reputation. Upholding integrity in representing consumer sentiments is paramount for fostering long-term relationships and brand loyalty.
                • (18: 58) Advertisers should be mindful of how reviews are collected and counted. Advertisers must ensure that the methodology used for collecting and tallying reviews is transparent and unbiased. It’s crucial for reviews to accurately reflect the sentiments of the target demographic to maintain credibility
                • (19:34) Incentives for reviews should be disclosed, and star ratings should be representative. Transparency regarding incentives for reviews is essential to maintain trust and credibility with consumers. Star ratings should accurately mirror the overall sentiment of all reviews, providing an unbiased assessment of product performance.

                  • The post Revisiting Consumer Reviews: Incentivized, Inflated, or Authentic? appeared first on BBB National Programs.

                  22 min
                • Endorsements & Testimonials – So What’s New?

                  In this episode of Ad Watchers, hosts Eric Unis and Annie Ugurlayan, attorneys at the National Advertising Division (NAD), revisit the Federal Trade Commission’s (FTC) Endorsement Guides. Given the recent updates to the Guides, the Ad Watchers have refreshed the tips and best practices from Season One for ensuring ad law compliance when using influencers, endorsements, and testimonials in your advertising campaigns. 

                  This episode presents recent cases before the National Advertising Division (NAD) demonstrating the issues outlined in the FTC’s Endorsement Guides and for each case, outlines the best practices you should follow to stay off the radar of the FTC and NAD.

                  Some Key Takeaways from today’s episode:

                  1. (1:28) Endorsements and Testimonials Integrity: Endorsements and testimonials are essential elements of advertising but must authentically represent the genuine opinions of the endorser. Any material connections between the endorser and the advertiser must be transparently disclosed, ensuring honesty and integrity in consumer communication.
                  2. (7:51) Combating Fake Reviews and Influencer Misuse: Addressing the prevalence of fake reviews and the misuse of influencers, including animal influencers, is crucial in maintaining the credibility and trustworthiness of advertising channels. Regulators and industry stakeholders must collaborate to establish stringent measures to mitigate these issues and uphold the integrity of consumer information.
                  3. (14:11) Transparency in Review Sites: Review sites play a significant role in consumer decision-making, and it’s essential that they transparently disclose whether rankings and reviews are advertisements or independent assessments. Such transparency empowers consumers to make informed choices while safeguarding against misleading advertising practices.
                  4. (19:00) Clear and Conspicuous Disclosures: Transparency is key in consumer communication, necessitating clear and conspicuous disclosures visible across all devices. These disclosures should be positioned in the same location and format as the endorsement, ensuring consumers readily recognize affiliations between the endorser and the advertiser.

                    5. For more information, visit: NAD FAQs

                    Contact Information: [email protected]

                    The post Endorsements & Testimonials – So What’s New? appeared first on BBB National Programs.

                    21 min
                  5. What is the Appeal of an Appeal? Getting to Know NARB

                    In this episode of Ad Watchers, your hosts discuss a critical link in the chain of advertising industry self regulation: the National Advertising Review Board, or NARB, the appellate body for National Advertising Division cases. 

                    This episode welcomes NARB Chair and Vice-Chair, Ken Plevan and Heather Hippsley, as well as NARB Manager, Saveeta Dhanai, to discuss the voluntary appeal process, an overview of the distinguished board of experienced industry professionals that hear appealed cases, and some important practices to keep in mind when taking your case to the NARB. 

                    For more information about this episode, read the show notes here. 

                    Online-Casinos in Deutschland, die die Paysafecard als Zahlungsmethode anbieten, erfreuen sich großer Beliebtheit bei Spielern. Die Paysafecard, eine vorab bezahlte Karte, bietet eine sichere und anonyme Möglichkeit, Geld in das Casinokonto einzuzahlen im Casinobonusgermany.

                    The post What is the Appeal of an Appeal? Getting to Know NARB appeared first on BBB National Programs.

                    37 min
                  6. The NAD Top 10 — Did you know?

                    In this episode of Ad Watchers, hosts Dan and Annie take you behind the scenes of the U.S. system of self-regulation in the advertising industry and discuss some of the myths, the misconceptions, and misunderstandings advertisers have.

                    This episode presents the Top Ten things the National Advertising Division (NAD) wants to make sure you know about ad law and the NAD process, valuable for new and seasoned practitioners with the goal to make the self-regulatory forum user friendly, fair, and efficient and effective.

                    For more information about this episode, read the show notes here.

                    The post The NAD Top 10 — Did you know? appeared first on BBB National Programs.

                    36 min

                  About The Ad Watchers

                  From the publisher's feed

                  Join National Advertising Division attorneys on this podcast as they explore advertising claims and what it means to put them to the truthfulness test.