Cora Rennie was a good girl who did everything “right.” Military. Marriage. Motherhood. Long-term partnership. From the outside, her life looked good. Inside, though, something felt off. Cora shares how divorce, a passionate but painful second relationship, and the looming reality of an empty nest forced her to confront the fact that her nervous system, not her conscious mind, had been choosing her partners. As she learned about people pleasing, the fawning response, and what safety really feels like in the body, she started making choices from a different place. If you have ever wondered why you keep repeating patterns in love, or why midlife feels like a blank slate you did not ask for, this episode will land.
Guest Bio Cora is a recovering people-pleaser, and identifies as a highly sensitive deep-feeler. Through her training to become a biodynamic craniosacral therapist, Cora gained profound insights into the body's innate wisdom, and learned directly in her own body, the importance of a felt-sense of safety.
Cora incorporates the foundations of the cranio modality with her personal gifts and own lifelong healing experiences, to support others in their recovery-of-self processes. She believes there are key components to true, deep, lasting healing that communicate directly to the physiological wiring of our systems, and providing those elements allows for us to cultivate a deep sense of self, resilience, and trust.
Her work combines an understanding of natural body responses with deeply attuned presence, for those navigating complex emotional landscapes.
Turning 40 and choosing safety over chemistry
When Cora Rennie divorced her husband at 36 after 18 years together, it shocked everyone around her. From the outside, their marriage looked steady and intact. Inside, they were two conflict-avoidant people growing further apart through miscarriage, postpartum struggles, military deployments, and years of emotional disconnection. What followed was a fast, passionate relationship filled with chemistry, red flags, financial strain, betrayal, and hard-earned clarity. But beneath the relationship drama was a woman beginning to understand how a lifetime of living by “the next step” had shaped her choices. In her early 40s, staring down the reality of becoming an empty nester, Cora finally made a choice that felt like her own. And that changed everything.
In This Episode, We Talk About:
- How a “good girl” identity can quietly become a people-pleasing pattern that runs your life
- The moment Cora realized she could not stay in a marriage where emotions were unwelcome but intimacy was expected
- Why intense chemistry can cloud discernment, and how oxytocin plays a role in bonding
- Overlooking red flags, merging finances, and losing herself in a relationship that felt like a “love story” but not a “life story”
- Reconnecting with creativity, sensuality, and art as part of reclaiming her identity
- Discovering the fawning response and how the nervous system can unconsciously choose our partners
- Facing the empty nest transition and asking, “Who am I now?”
- The difference between living by default and making a conscious, heart-led choice
- How biodynamic cranio psychotherapy and nervous system regulation reshaped her healing
Cora’s story is not just about divorce, dating, or even people pleasing. It is about the shift from living by internalized programming to living by conscious choice. For most of her life, each step she took felt predetermined, like the next logical box to check. Military. Marriage. Motherhood. Partnership. Even divorce felt like the inevitable next move. But in midlife, she looked at a blank slate. In the stillness before her youngest left home, she realized this was the first time she could choose without reacting, without fawning, without following a script. When the external noise quieted enough that she could hear something internal speak up, she found the heartbeat of this midlife transition so many of us experience.
If this episode resonated with you, please take a moment to rate, follow, and share The Big Four Oh. It helps more people find these conversations and realize they are not alone in their own turning-40 transition.
Guest ResourcesCora’s offer for listeners: $40 OFF the Understanding People Pleasing Summit VIP All Access Pass
Use promo code BIGFOUROH
Find Cora on YouTube
Connect with Cora on Facebook
Connect with Cora on Instagram
Recovering people pleaser? Same here.
From Pleasing to Peace is a free guide based on real stories from this podcast: people who’ve done the brave work of untangling people pleasing at midlife. www.thebigfouroh.com/peoplepleaser
Connect
TheBigFourOh.com
TBFO on Instagram
TBFO on Facebook
Get the Email Digest
Listen, Rate & Subscribe
YouTube Podcasts
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
Amazon Podcasts
SponsorThe Big Four Oh Podcast is produced and presented by Savoir Faire Marketing/Communications