We've had to downsize, restrict, or cancel carnivals across the Caribbean since the onset of Covid-19. That's no surprise. But can we adapt? And is there a chance of returning to what once was? Will mass vaccination give us that chance? And in the interim, what? Virtual events? Smaller mas? Televised competitions only? Highly policed, distanced celebrations?
Next month, the Miami Carnival, which was cancelled in 2020 due to the pandemic, is set to go ahead with thousands of participants. A negative Covid-19 test is required to attend the big event. Temperature checks and masks are reportedly to be required. It's not clear if vaccination restrictions will be in place. The event is Caribbean themed and attracts many from the regionally diaspora. The last time it was held in-person was in 2019. Many will be watch closely.
You may ask: What if regional events went on with only vaccinated participants? That might not help stop Covid-19 transmission and hospitalisation as much as we think. We now know that because of new variants of Covid-19 like the Delta strain, symptomatic breakthrough infections amongst the fully vaccinated are more likely, meaning that some vaccinated people will more often become carriers and spreaders of the virus and can spread it to others. Being vaccinated is still the best protected against hospitalisation.
So there's the risk that carnival events, if held traditionally, and even if attended only by vaccinated people, would increase the rate of transmission of Covid-19 in society through symptomatic breakthrough infections, which are more likely with Delta. With a large unvaccinated population in each island, any rapid increase in the rate of Covid-19 transmission would begin to put people (mostly unvaccinated people) in the hospital. Then comes the curfews, the restrictions on movement, the ban on indoor dining, and so on. You know how it goes.
And yet, the social and economic reasons for carnivals to go on are many. Here in Antigua and Barbuda, and in the Caribbean region, the loss of work for the many artists, artistes, artisans, and the myriad of others that benefited economically from the sector has been overwhelming. In this episode, we ask guests from Antigua and Barbuda, St. Kitts and Nevis, and Trinidad and Tobago, about the future of their carnivals in the Covid-19 era. Will it ever be the same again?
The host is Kieron Murdoch. The guests are:
Kayode O’Marde, a former Chairman of the Carnival Development Committee (CDC) which is now the Festivals Commission of Antigua and Barbuda.
Fana Allaway, member of the management team for the Myst Mas Troupe in Antigua and Barbuda.
David Lopez, President of the National Carnival Bands Association of Trinidad and Tobago (NCBA) for the past ten years. He’s also Managing Director of DGL Carnival Consultancy Agency. He has been involved in Trinidad and Tobago's carnival and carnivals abroad for the past thirty-eight years.
Noah Mills, a former National Carnival Junior Calypso King in St. Kitts and Nevis. Has written and judged Calypso, Coached Queen Show Participants, Judged Pageants, and Judged Soca Competitions. He’s currently part of the Management Team for the A+ All-Star Band being launched for Sugar Mas 50, St. Kitts and Nevis' carnival Noah Mills is a past Chairman of the Carnival Development Committee (CDC) in St. Kitts and Nevis.This programme first aired on NewsCo Observer Radio 91.1 FM on September 5th, 2021. Get the latest news from Antigua and Barbuda at the Antigua Observer online.