The Book Is Better - Book to Film Adaptation Reviews

Baby listeners, this week we're comparing Peter Heller's The Dog Stars with Ridley Scott's film adaptation, and somehow a story about the end of civilization left us mostly fighting for our lives against the pacing. We're talking Jacob Elordi's one-note grief, Josh Brolin being way too lovable to be Bangley, why Jasper is the actual star of this entire thing, and the exact moment Grand Junction turns into Alien with cannibals.

Plus, Rebekah declares war on quotation-mark-free prose, Tim listens to an audiobook at unprecedented speeds, and we ask the most important question of the apocalypse: Why are you walking onto a stranger's property WITH A GUN?

Support us on Patreon >> https://patreon.com/bookisbetterpod

Find us everywhere at @bookisbetterpod.

Episode page: https://bookisbetterpod.com/bibpod-episodes/ep-077-the-dog-stars/

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

This week, baby listeners, we're comparing Leonie Swann's Three Bags Full with The Sheep Detectives, two stories that technically begin the same way—George is dead and his sheep decide to investigate—and then promptly wander into completely different meadows. The Shee p DetectivesWe're talking Mopple vs. Maple, the book's approximately seventeen thousand sheep, a Guinness-drinking alcoholic ram, the big invisible lamb-beaver made of bread, and why a murder mystery probably shouldn't end with, "Surprise! Nobody murdered him."

And for once, there is basically no family argument over the final verdict.

Which honestly feels suspicious.

Support us on Patreon >> https://patreon.com/bookisbetterpod

Find us everywhere at @bookisbetterpod.

Episode Link: https://bookisbetterpod.com/bibpod-episodes/ep-076-the-sheep-detectives/

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Baby listeners, we have THOUGHTS.

We’re digging into the bizarre, brutal, occasionally cannibalistic epic poem and Nolan’s massive adaptation, including why Matt Damon’s Odysseus feels like a completely different man, whether Tom Holland was wildly miscast, the Circe scene we absolutely loved, the deeply depressing dog on the dung pile, and why kicking said dog means you obviously deserve to visit Hades first.

We also read four different translations of The Odyssey, which means we technically all read the same book while somehow not reading the same book at all. And after nearly 3,000 years of waiting, we finally answer the question Homer was definitely asking: Is the book actually better?

Support us on Patreon >> https://patreon.com/bookisbetterpod

Find us everywhere at @bookisbetterpod.

Episode page: https://bookisbetterpod.com/bibpod-episodes/

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Alright baby listeners... our dad refused to record this episode, so naturally Josiah stole his face and took his place.

This week we're talking about The Silence of the Lambs, one of the few adaptations that made us say, "Wait... the movie might actually be better." We unpack Anthony Hopkins' legendary performance, why Clarice Starling is an absolute powerhouse, and how this story somehow convinces you to root for a cannibal without ever making you forget he's a monster.

It's creepy, it's brilliant, it's surprisingly funny, and yes... we somehow end up talking about moths way longer than anyone should

Support us on Patreon >> https://patreon.com/bookisbetterpod

Find us everywhere at @bookisbetterpod.

Episode page: https://bookisbetterpod.com/bibpod-episodes/ep-074-the-silence-of-the-lambs/

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Alright baby listeners… this week we’re heading to Battle School. 🚀

We’re talking Ender’s Game, the beloved sci-fi classic that somehow manages to be about genius children in space while also being deeply upsetting the entire time.

We break down the massive differences between the book and the 2013 movie adaptation, including why the film feels way more like a YA blockbuster, why the book’s political themes hit so much harder, and why aging the kids up changes basically everything.

Support us on Patreon >> https://patreon.com/bookisbetterpod

Find us everywhere at @bookisbetterpod.

Episode page: https://bookisbetterpod.com/bibpod-episodes/ep-073-enders-game/

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Alright baby listeners… you’ve had almost 200 years to read Frankenstein, so we’re not holding back.

This week we’re talking about the original story, the one that somehow started everything, and then diving into multiple film versions that all looked at that same idea and said, “what if we did something completely different?”

We get into the book itself, the choices that still don’t make sense (yes, we’re looking at you, Victor), and why the creature might actually be the most sympathetic character in the whole story… depending on who’s telling it. Then we jump into the movies, from the iconic 1931 version to the newer adaptations, and try to figure out why no one can seem to agree on what this story is supposed to be.

There’s science, there’s chaos, there’s questionable decisions, and at least one version that had us genuinely asking, “why did they do that?” Baby listeners, this one is messy, philosophical, and a little bit unhinged… just like the story itself.

Support us on Patreon >> https://patreon.com/bookisbetterpod

Find us everywhere at @bookisbetterpod.

Episode page: https://bookisbetterpod.com/bibpod-episodes/ep-072-frankenstein/

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Alright baby listeners… we kept waiting for one of us to turn on it, and it just didn’t happen.

We all kind of landed in the same place on this one. The book does what books do best, it slows down, builds things out, and lets you sit in the story a little longer. And then the movie comes in and instead of ruining it… it actually holds up.

Like, it’s not the exact same experience, but it still feels right. The pacing works, the choices mostly make sense, and we weren’t sitting there asking “why would they do that” every five minutes, which already puts it ahead of a lot of adaptations.

We talk through the differences, what each version leans into, and why this ended up being one of those rare times where it doesn’t feel like you have to pick a side.

Support us on Patreon >> https://patreon.com/bookisbetterpod

Find us everywhere at @bookisbetterpod.

Episode page: https://bookisbetterpod.com/bibpod-episodes/ep-071-project-hail-mary/

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Alright baby listeners, this week we’re stepping away from book adaptations and heading straight into theme park chaos. We’re recapping our trip to Universal Studios in Orlando and sharing everything that made the adventure memorable. There were incredible rides, a few unexpected moments, and plenty of laughs along the way as we experienced the parks together.

We talk about the attractions that impressed us the most, the moments that caught us off guard, and why some rides instantly became favorites. It’s part travel story, part family chaos, and completely different from our usual episodes. If you’ve ever wondered what it’s like exploring a massive theme park with our crew, baby listeners, this episode gives you the full ride.

Support us on Patreon >> https://patreon.com/bookisbetterpod

Find us everywhere at @bookisbetterpod.

Episode page: https://bookisbetterpod.com/bibpod-episodes/ep-070-universal-trip-recap/

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Alright baby listeners, this week we’re heading to Mars… or are we? We’re diving into Total Recall, where memory is optional, reality is questionable, and Arnold Schwarzenegger solves existential crises with explosives. The original Philip K. Dick story is sharp, compact, and deeply unsettling, playing with identity in a way that leaves you slightly dizzy. The movie takes that same concept and says, “What if we add mutants, political uprising, and the most aggressively 90s action energy imaginable?” We talk about what makes the short story so clever, why the movie is wildly entertaining even when it abandons subtlety, and whether the spectacle enhances the idea or completely bulldozes it. Is it all a dream? Is it implanted memory? Does it even matter once someone says, “Get to the chopper” energy in space? Baby listeners, this one is chaotic in the best way.

Support us on Patreon >> https://patreon.com/bookisbetterpod

Find us everywhere at @bookisbetterpod.

Episode page: https://bookisbetterpod.com/

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Alright baby listeners, buckle up, because this episode fought us every step of the way. We’re talking The Lost World: Jurassic Park, a sequel that somehow managed to give us more dinosaurs and less joy. We break down why Michael Crichton’s book, while not his strongest, still feels thoughtful and intentional, and why the movie feels like it was assembled by committee five minutes before filming started. We rant about wasted potential, weird chemistry, and the difference between tension and noise, all while asking the same question over and over: how did this follow one of the greatest movies ever made? Come for the dinosaurs, stay for the disbelief, and learn an important life lesson—greed never ends well, especially when it involves prehistoric murder machines.

Support us on Patreon >> https://patreon.com/bookisbetterpod

Find us everywhere at @bookisbetterpod.

Episode page: https://bookisbetterpod.com/bibpod-episodes/ep-068-jurassic-park-the-lost-world/

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.