The final episode covers Mothman, the winged entity that allegedly terrorized Point Pleasant, West Virginia between 1966-1967 before the tragic Silver Bridge collapse. Wade examines the original sightings, the historical context of the abandoned "TNT area" where encounters occurred, and the various theories about Mothman's nature—from misidentified wildlife to supernatural harbinger. The episode traces how John Keel's "The Mothman Prophecies" and its film adaptation transformed a local legend into a global phenomenon, exploring Mothman's unusual cultural adaptability across different countries and belief systems. Wade reflects on how this relatively modern cryptid demonstrates the continued human need for meaning in mystery, even in our technological age.

The second episode examines the Jersey Devil, a creature that has terrorized New Jersey's Pine Barrens for over 300 years. Wade investigates the legend's historical connections to the Leeds family, their conflicts with Benjamin Franklin, and how these real events transformed into supernatural lore. The episode details the remarkable 1909 "flap" when thousands of sightings caused widespread panic, explores the unique ecology and history of the Pine Barrens, and analyzes how the Jersey Devil evolved from feared monster to beloved cultural mascot. Wade reveals how this cryptid has maintained remarkable consistency across three centuries while adapting to changing cultural contexts, making it America's longest-continuously-reported monster.

The series begins with Pennsylvania's peculiar Squonk, a forest creature so ashamed of its warty, ill-fitting skin that it weeps constantly and dissolves into tears when captured. Wade traces the Squonk's origins in lumber camp folklore of the early 20th century, examining how this melancholy being reflected the isolation and alienation felt by immigrant workers in Pennsylvania's hemlock forests. The episode explores William T. Cox's 1910 documentation of the legend, its literary elevation by Jorge Luis Borges, and its subsequent appearances in popular culture. Unlike frightening cryptids, the Squonk represents emotional vulnerability, making it uniquely relevant to modern discussions of self-image and mental health despite its century-old origins.