Episode 9: The Delphi Case: Part 3

In Episode 9 of The Casewalker Chronicles, we examine the appellate phase of the Delphi case, focusing on how the case moves from trial to legal review within the Indiana Court of Appeals.

Following the conviction and sentencing, this episode examines how the case enters the appellate process and what is reviewed at that stage.

This episode does not retry the case or present new evidence.
It examines how a conviction is reviewed.

Using the Casewalker Method, we analyze how the appellate record is constructed, how transcripts and filings define the scope of review, and how legal arguments are built from what is preserved in that record.

We clearly distinguish between what exists in the record, what is argued on appeal, and what is not considered at the appellate level.

We examine the structure of the Appellant’s Brief, the claims raised by the defense, and the State’s response, focusing on how each side interprets the same record within legal standards.

This episode focuses on the structure and limits of appellate review, and how those limits define what can be evaluated after a conviction.

This episode reflects our investigative commitment:

Every step.
Every limitation.

Only what the record supports.

⚠️ Listener Note:
This episode discusses violent crime, including the deaths of two minors, and the legal proceedings that followed. Listener discretion is advised.

🔦 Missing Person Spotlight:
This episode includes a spotlight on Jacob Curry, a 14-year-old missing from Indianapolis, Indiana.

Full documentation, sources, missing-person spotlights, and episode updates are available at: www.thecasewalkerchronicles.com

Support The Casewalker Chronicles

If you value independent, evidence-based investigative work, you can support the research and production behind the show.

Patreon (monthly support)
https://www.patreon.com/cw/TheCasewalkerChronicles

Ko-fi (one-time support)
https://ko-fi.com/casewalkerchronicles

Support helps fund:
-> research time
-> public records requests
-> document review
-> podcast production

Support the show

Episode 8: The Delphi Case — Part 2

In Episode 8 of The Casewalker Chronicles, we continue our examination of the Delphi case by focusing on the forensic evidence presented in the investigation.

Following the timeline established in Part 1, this episode examines the reported recovery of an unfired cartridge and the toolmark analysis used to associate that cartridge with a firearm.

This episode does not reconstruct events or present theories.
It examines how evidence is interpreted.

Using the Casewalker Evidence Book Method, we analyze how firearm-related toolmarks are created, how cartridges may be marked without being fired, and how those markings are compared within forensic examination.

We clearly distinguish between documented information, expert interpretation, and the limitations of this type of evidence—particularly where conclusions rely on pattern comparison rather than statistical certainty.

This episode focuses on the structure and limits of forensic evidence, and how those limits shape what conclusions can be supported.

This episode reflects our investigative commitment:

Every method.
Every limitation.

Only what the record supports.

⚠️ Listener Note:
This episode discusses the murders of two minors and the forensic examination of evidence within a criminal investigation that has resulted in a criminal prosecution. Listener discretion is advised.

🔦 Missing Person Spotlight:
This episode includes a spotlight on Kylin Hammons, a 16-year-old missing from Indianapolis, Indiana.

Full documentation, sources, missing-person spotlights, and episode updates are available at:  www.thecasewalkerchronicles.com

Support The Casewalker Chronicles

If you value independent, evidence-based investigative work, you can support the research and production behind the show.

Patreon (monthly support)
https://www.patreon.com/cw/TheCasewalkerChronicles

Ko-fi (one-time support)
 https://ko-fi.com/casewalkerchronicles

Support helps fund:

-> research time
-> public records requests
-> document review
-> podcast production

Support the show

Episode 7 - The Delphi Case: Part 1

In Episode 7 of The Casewalker Chronicles, we begin a multi-part examination of the murders of Liberty “Libby” German and Abigail “Abby” Williams, who disappeared while walking the Monon High Bridge Trail in Delphi, Indiana, on February 13, 2017.

Their deaths would become one of the most widely followed criminal investigations in Indiana history.

This episode does not attempt to resolve the case or reinterpret the outcome of the prosecution.

Instead, Part 1 establishes the documented timeline of February 13, 2017, reconstructing the movements of Abby and Libby, the geography of the Monon High Bridge Trail system, the early search efforts, and the evidence that first entered the public record.

Using the Casewalker Evidence Book Method, we examine the case through publicly documented information, including law-enforcement statements, publicly released materials, and the timeline reflected in investigative reporting. Throughout the episode, we clearly distinguish between documented facts, official summaries, and areas where the public record remains incomplete.

This episode establishes the evidentiary foundation for the series that follows.

Every timeline entry.
Every released detail.

Only what the record supports.

⚠️ Listener Note:
This episode discusses the murders of two minors and the early stages of an active criminal investigation that has since resulted in a criminal prosecution. Listener discretion is advised.

🔦 Missing Person Spotlight:
This episode includes a spotlight on Penelope McGowan, a 17-year-old missing from Plainfield, Indiana.

Full documentation, sources, missing-person spotlights, and episode updates are available at: www.thecasewalkerchronicles.com

Support The Casewalker Chronicles

If you value independent investigative storytelling, you can support the research and production behind the show.

Patreon (monthly support)
https://www.patreon.com/cw/TheCasewalkerChronicles

Ko-fi (one-time support)
https://ko-fi.com/casewalkerchronicles

Support helps fund:

-> research time
-> public records requests
-> document review
-> podcast production

Support the show

In Episode 6 of The Casewalker Chronicles, we conduct a structural examination of discretionary authority under Indiana’s Access to Public Records Act (APRA), focusing on investigatory-record exemptions and the legal architecture that permits indefinite withholding.

This episode is not a case recap. It is not a personal dispute. It is not an allegation of misconduct.
It is a statutory analysis.

Using a recent public-records denial letter as a case study, we read the statute in full, examine the exemption cited (I.C. 5-14-3-4(b)(1)), and analyze the appellate decisions referenced to justify discretionary withholding, including:

• Carroll County E911 v. Hasnie (2020)
• Lane-El v. Spears (2014)
• Indianapolis Newspapers, Inc. v. Trustees of Indiana University (2003)

We define investigatory records, explain how classification determines access, and examine why permissive language (“may”) differs fundamentally from mandatory language (“shall”) in statutory construction.

This episode explores how discretion functions structurally—how legality, judicial deference, economic friction, and informational asymmetry interact—and what happens when transparency is permitted but not compelled.

No accusation.
No speculation.
No rhetoric.

Only the statute.
Only the record.
Only what the documentation supports.

⚠️ Listener Note: This episode discusses public-records law, investigatory exemptions, and civic transparency. It includes a missing-person spotlight involving a juvenile. 

Listener discretion is advised.

Full documentation, statutory citations, case references, and missing-person updates are available at: www.thecasewalkerchronicles.com

Support the show

On November 21, 2016, an early-morning fire on East Columbia Street in Flora, Indiana claimed the lives of four children.

In January 2017, the Indiana State Fire Marshal determined the fire was intentionally set. Nearly a decade later, no arrests have been made.

In Part One of our examination of the Flora fire, we reconstruct what can be verified through public reporting, official agency statements, and documented timelines. We examine the confirmed facts, the arson determination, and the observable gap between public statements and sustained public updates.

This episode does not speculate.
 It documents.

Using the Casewalker Evidence Book Method, we distinguish between what was said, what was corrected, and what remains publicly visible.

Where the record ends, we stop.

⚠️ This episode discusses the deaths of minors in a residential arson fire. Listener discretion is advised.

Full documentation and source index available at:
 www.thecasewalkerchronicles.com

Support the show

In Episode 4, we examine the unsolved 1985 murders of Kimberly Dowell (15) and Ethan Dixon (16), who were found shot inside a vehicle in Westside Park in Muncie, Indiana, shortly before midnight on September 28, 1985, as reported in public sources.

Nearly forty years later, the case remains open. There has been no arrest, no trial, and no judicial resolution.

Because the underlying investigative file is not publicly available, this episode carefully distinguishes between what has been publicly reported and what cannot be independently verified. We explain how long-unsolved cases become shaped not only by facts, but by access, including where records are held, how custody affects availability, and how public-records law governs disclosure decades after a crime.

Using the Casewalker Evidence Book Method, we document the public record as it exists, identify where summaries replace primary documentation, and clearly mark where the record ends. This episode does not speculate, propose theories, or assign blame. It examines process, structure, and absence.

This episode reflects our investigative commitment:
Every record. Every limit. Only what the documentation supports.

⚠️ This episode discusses violent crime involving minors and an unsolved double homicide.

Listener discretion is advised.

Full documentation, sources, missing-person spotlights, and episode updates are available at:
www.thecasewalkerchronicles.com

Support the show

In Episode 3B, we continue our examination of the death investigation of Joseph William Smedley II, a 20-year-old Indiana University student whose body was recovered from Griffy Lake in Bloomington, Indiana, in October 2015. Joseph’s death was classified as suicide by drowning, and the case was administratively closed.

This episode does not seek to overturn that determination. Instead, it examines what documentation is available to the public when a case is closed, what records were released in response to formal public-records requests, and what information remains unavailable under Indiana public-records law.

Using the Casewalker Evidence Book Method, we review the released materials, distinguish between documented records and summary-level statements, and clearly identify where investigatory documentation is not accessible to the public. This episode focuses on structure rather than interpretation, showing how conclusions are communicated when underlying records are limited or withheld.

Every record. Every gap. Only what the documentation supports.

⚠️ This episode discusses death investigation, suicide classification, public-records law, and the limits of documentation in closed cases. It also includes a missing-person spotlight involving a juvenile.

Listener discretion is advised.

Full documentation, sources, missing-person spotlights, and episode updates are available at: www.thecasewalkerchronicles.com

Support the show

In this episode 3A, we examine the disappearance and death of Joseph William Smedley II, a 20-year-old Indiana University student whose body was recovered from Griffy Lake in Bloomington, Indiana, in October 2015.

Within days of recovery, Joseph’s death was ruled a suicide by drowning, and the case was administratively closed.

This episode does not seek to overturn that ruling.
Instead, it examines how that ruling was constructed, explained, and presented, and what information is available to the public when a case is closed without judicial testing.

Using the Casewalker Evidence Book Method, we review the publicly visible record of Joseph Smedley’s case, including summarized timelines, law-enforcement statements, and limited incident-level documentation that has been released. We clearly distinguish between what is documented, what is stated in secondary reporting, and where investigatory records are not available in the public record under Indiana public-records law.

This episode reflects our investigative commitment:
 Every summary. Every gap. Only what the documentation supports.

⚠️ This episode discusses death investigation, suicide classification, and unresolved questions surrounding closed cases.

 Listener discretion is advised.

Full documentation, sources, missing-person spotlights, and episode updates are available at: www.thecasewalkerchronicles.com

Support the show

In this episode 2 , we examine the verified timeline and unanswered questions surrounding the disappearance of Indiana University student Lauren Spierer, who was last seen in Bloomington on a summer night in June 2011.

Despite extensive searches, public attention, and years of inquiry, Lauren’s case remains unresolved. We trace her final known movements, review documented statements and search efforts, and highlight where the public record grows quiet.

Using the Casewalker Evidence Book Method, we reconstruct what is confirmed and clearly identify where uncertainty begins, relying on law-enforcement releases, media reporting, official statements, and on-location fieldwork in Bloomington.

This episode reflects our investigative commitment:
Every step. Every gap. Only what the documentation supports.

⚠️ This episode discusses a long-running missing person case without resolution.

Listener discretion is advised.

Full documentation, sources, missing-person spotlights, and episode updates are available at: www.thecasewalkerchronicles.com

Support the show

In our first episode, we examine the disappearance and murder of Indiana University student Jill Behrman, tracing the publicly documented timeline of her final morning, the early search efforts, and the decades-long legal and investigative aftermath of her case.

Jill’s case is a defining moment in Indiana true-crime history, shaped by investigative focus, disputed testimony, overturned convictions, appellate review, and a long wait for certainty that never fully arrived.

Using the Casewalker Evidence Book Method, we reconstruct this case through publicly available law-enforcement records, court findings, appellate rulings, and on-location fieldwork in Bloomington, Indiana. We clearly distinguish documented facts, court analysis, and unresolved areas of uncertainty.

This episode lays the foundation for how cases are approached throughout The Casewalker Chronicles.

Every route. Every minute. Only what the documentation supports.

⚠️ This episode discusses criminal prosecution and appellate review. A conviction currently stands.

 Listener discretion is advised.

Full documentation, sources, missing-person spotlights, and episode updates are available at: www.thecasewalkerchronicles.com

Support the show