The podcast kicks off with a story about Papal Peanut Butter. After that, a caller asks Lino about a life of crime. Then, the guys play Saint Teasers. And the podcast wraps up with Lenten Song Parodies!

The podcast kicks off by Lino going shopping...and runs into a Cliche Catholic Listener. After that, Tyler rips off Songs from the Heart and picks songs to Biblical stories. And the podcast wraps up with Lino's Mom playing a round of Hickety Pickety!

The podcast kicks off with Lino flying directly from the Holy Land to MN...to the hospital. After that, it's time to pay our dues. Then, a listener asks what to do when you're far from God. And the podcast wraps up with Lino sharing memories of Cardinal Dolan!

The podcast kicks off with Lino chatting Foo Fighters, football, and faith at...a bar, of course. After that, the guys do Brilliant Brackets: Strange Stories in the Bible. Then, it's Atheist Parable Review. And the podcast wraps up with Lino and Claire and some Daddy/Daughter Time!

The podcast kicks off by looking back at 2025 Moments Of The Year. After that, Claire calls Lino by his first name. Then, a caller asks why Lino stays Catholic. There's a story about Failed Confessions. And the podcast wraps up with Best Misprounciations!

The podcast kicks off with the 19th anniversary of the show and an awkward walk down memory lane. Then, Lino tells stories of Cardinal Dolan in honor of his retirement. After that, the Advent Calendar and local news celebrates the season. And the podcast wraps up with taking a chance on Email of the Week!

It's that time once again: the craziest show of the year. With Tyler, Lino's Mom, Jill, Claire, and more. Cooking, complaining, and theoretically giving thanks: The Big Fat Italian Catholic Thansksgiving!

The podcast kicks off with Lino returning from Japan with stories to tell. After that, Tyler does an Atheist Bible Study. Then, it's Claire's 2nd birthday with Father Gooch Nursery Rhymes. And the podcast wraps up with Sumo Wrestling!

The podcast kicks off with a Catholic vs Christian Halloween. After that, it's Memento Mori remembering that we'll all die (yay). Then, Lino starts in a good mood with Foo Fighters tickets and lands in a bad mood. And the podcast wraps up with baptizing aliens!

The podcast kicks off with Domesticated Lino going to a pumpkin patch. After that, Lino's Mom calls in for a round of Hickety Pickety. Then the guys decide what's overrated, underrated, and properly rated. And the podcast wraps up with something that hasn't happened in 500 years!