The podcast kicks off with a Mother's Day special: Fr Jim's mom, Lino's mom, and Tyler's mom? After that, Fr Jim talks about his plans for a Mom Homily. Then, Lino breaks down Creed II and the Bible. And the podcast wraps up celebrating Tyler's birthday by playing his Greatest Hits (or misses)!

The podcast kicks off with Tom Leopold stopping by to talk about their recent Holy Land pilgrimage (and anything else Tom wants to talk about). Then, Tyler enlightens Mark and Lino all about Saint Longinus. After that, it's a brand new segment: Whats Your Story with the anonymous "Mr. Z". And the podcast wraps up with Lino and Fr Jim talking good priests - and Fr Jim's good homilies! 

The podcast kicks off on April Fools Day with the guys sharing some of their favorite pranks...that weren't sins. Then, it's time for a Brilliant Brackets: Biggest Biblical Fool. After that, Tyler asks if Lino has ever shared something on the air that has been embarrassing for others; the answer, of course, is yes. And the podcast wraps up with comedian Jim Breuer stopping by the show!

The podcast kicks off with Lino and Jen Fulwiler...in the NYC studios! Weird. Then, Tyler asks what time of Catholics annoy them; Lino loses his mind. After that, Dave Grohl appears in a dream. And the podcast wraps up with Fr Jim deciding what tattoo Lino should get next!

The podcast kicks off with Lino's wife Jill buying a plant; which means Fr Jim, Tyler, and Lino get to "name that plant"! After that, Lino tells a story of disappointing people - that has nothing to do with the show, for once. Then, Jen Fulwiler stops by and talks Lino's Instagram. And the podcast wraps up with What's on Tyler's Mind (DMV) and What's on Jen's Mind (neighbors)!

The podcast kicks off with Tyler premiering a new Lenten song parody. With only a one or two Catholic mistakes. Then, Jen Fulwiler stops by the show to talk CatholicGuyCon2 and her Hispanic heritage. After that, Lino and Jen try to play Catholic Password. And the podcast wraps up with Mark Hart and Tyler trying to convince Lino his bad luck proves he's the Gooch. 

The podcast kicks off with Lino and Mark Hart together in Arizona. Kind of in the sunshine. Then, Lino and Mark sing a duet about Lino's shallowness. After that, Fr Jim Chern stops by for the rare 4 person Old Tyme Catholic Radio Drama. And the podcast wraps up with Fr Jim's plans for a mission trip in Kentucky! 

The podcast kicks off with Lino at his alma mater, St. John's University, for a week of residency. And he has laryngitis. Since he needs a miracle, they do an All-Star list of Jesus miracles. Then, they do a Pious Playlist of music to listen to in college. After that, Fr Jim stops by to wrap up Lino's insane week on campus with a Snow Day!

The podcast kicks off with Heimsman trophy winner, NFL quarterback, and MLB player Tim Tebow stopping by! After that, Lino talks Valentines Day with a celibate priest and a muppet. Then, marriage is on Tyler's Mind. And the podcast wraps up with an always entertaining round of Scathegories!