The Disappearance of the Sodder Children: A True Crime Mystery


It was Christmas Eve, 1945, when the Sodder family’s home went up in flames. By morning, the house was gone, five of the children were missing, and the official explanation was… unsatisfying, to say the least. Authorities claimed the fire had been so intense that the children’s bodies were completely destroyed. But no bones were ever found. No teeth. Not a trace.

Over the next few decades, the Sodders uncovered a string of clues that pointed anywhere but toward a tragic accident: a cut phone line, missing ladders, trucks that mysteriously wouldn’t start, strangers watching the house, sightings of the kids after the fire, and even an anonymous photo that arrived in the mail decades later—showing a man who looked a lot like their missing son.

This wasn’t just a house fire. And the Sodders knew it. They spent the rest of their lives searching, chasing leads that always seemed to stop just short of the truth. Nearly 80 years later, we’re still left with the same haunting question: what really happened to the Sodder children that night?

#sodderchildren #unsolvedmystery #truecrimepodcast #historicaltruecrime #missingpersons #coldcase #truecrimecommunity #unsolvedcases


Thanks for listening to 10 Minute Mystery! Your curiosity fuels this little corner of history and intrigue, and I’m so glad you’re here for the ride. If you enjoyed this episode (or even if it just made you say, “Wait, what?”), make sure to subscribe, leave a review, or share it with someone who loves a good mystery. Every listen and share helps keep these stories alive—and keeps me caffeinated enough to dig up more for you. See you next time!

If you'd like to get in touch with me, email: [email protected]