Tis the season for the Top 5 Holiday Movies debate. The guys discuss how they learned about Santa and about the magic of Christmas. Antonio outs Casey for his terrible strategy for playing White Elephant & Casey opens up about his favorite Christmas traditions. Casey and Antonio FINALLY agree on the same rating of one of their movies.

Casey and Antonio share the top 5 foods they refuse to eat while discussing traumatic food stories that lead them to their hatred of their foods. Plus, Casey tells a hysterical story about the time he put chicken nuggets in his pockets and Antonio shares his food life hacks that everyone should try! 

This is the episode that tarnishes Casey and Antonio's relationship. The guys discuss their Top 5 Pixar Movies and for the first time argue about one of their choices. Plus, they discuss their true feelings about Disney her Pixar and talk about how these movies have shaped their lives. 

Casey and Antonio discuss their Top 5 fictional families they always wanted to be a part and share their thoughts on Thanksgiving traditions. Antonio talks about the time he almost worked on the set of Game of Thrones and the guys stir up controversy when they discuss whether to decorate before or after Thanksgiving. Plus, hear to find out what they find to be a dumb gift to give for Christmas. 

Casey stirs up controversy with his Top 5 list and they discuss and unexpectedly hilarious near death experience. Plus, they navigate fun stories from their childhood as they recall how Nickelodeon shaped their lives. 

In this episode, Casey and Antonio  discuss the Top 5 As Seen on TV Products they always wanted and have a hilarious conversation about ridiculous informercials. They also play a fun game of "Spot the fake As Seen on TV Product" and "Describe that Product" that will make you question humanity. Antonio talks about his most disappointing experience with an infomercial product and Casey discusses how his curiosity lead to disappointment. 

Casey and Antonio go at it again as they put their Top 5 lists up against each other. They discuss whether its sauce or gravy and Antonio shares his pet peeve's as an Italian-American. Also, Find out why Antonio thought Americans put salt on clothes and about the time he almost burnt down the house when he found out his wife was pregnant. Plus, Casey will fight anyone to the death about his number 1 Pasta shape and find out which pasta he calls the "Miss Congeniality" of pasta.

Casey and Antonio rate their Top 5 Worst Halloween Candy and share funny Halloween stories from when they were children.