The Evidence Room

The Evidence Room

By OwenTrue Crime
Download on the App Store

The Evidence Room episodes

  • The Boys Came for a Supervised Visit. The Door Locked Behind Them.
    After Susan Powell disappeared, her sons Charlie and Braden became the living connection between two families.
    Then investigators searched the Washington home where they were living with their father, Josh Powell, and grandfather Steven Powell.
    What police discovered led to Steven's arrest and the removal of the boys from the home.
    Josh began fighting to regain custody.
    A court ordered psychological evaluations.
    Supervised visits continued.
    Then, on February fifth, two thousand twelve, a social worker brought Charlie and Braden to their father's rented house.
    Josh opened the door.
    The boys went inside.
    The social worker did not.
    What happened next transformed Susan Powell's disappearance into something even larger: a case about warning signs, risk, and how institutions make decisions when suspicion is strong but certainty is not.
    15 min
  • Susan Left Instructions for What to Do If Something Happened to Her
    More than a year before Susan Powell disappeared, she opened a safe deposit box.
    Inside, she placed documents.
    A will.
    Personal records.
    And a handwritten warning.
    If something happened to her, she wrote, it might not be an accident.
    Susan also recorded a video inventory of the family's possessions and told friends about problems inside her marriage.
    After she vanished, investigators discovered that she had not simply been documenting property.
    She had been building a record.
    And suddenly, the woman who could no longer speak was giving detectives a way to examine the life she had been living before she disappeared.
    16 min
  • He Took the Children Camping at Midnight. His Wife Was Never Seen Again.
    On a freezing December night in two thousand nine, Josh Powell says he made an unusual decision.
    Shortly after midnight, he woke his two young sons, put them into the family minivan and drove into Utah's remote West Desert to go camping.
    His wife Susan stayed home.
    By the following morning, Susan had vanished.
    Inside the house, police found fans blowing across a recently cleaned area. Inside Josh's minivan, they found Susan's phone, turned off and missing its SIM card.
    Josh's explanation was that he had gone camping.
    The problem was not simply that the trip sounded strange.
    It was that almost everything investigators discovered afterward made the timing of that trip more important.
    13 min
  • He Said She'd Gone to Denmark. Investigators Found One Tooth by the River.
    When thirty nine year old Helle Crafts disappeared from her Connecticut home in November of nineteen eighty six, her husband Richard suggested she had simply gone away.
    There was no body.
    There was no eyewitness to a murder.
    And investigators could not even begin a conventional homicide case until they could establish that Helle was actually dead.
    Then a highway worker remembered seeing something strange near the Housatonic River.
    A truck.
    A wood chipper.
    A man working in the middle of the night.
    Police searched the riverbank.
    What they recovered was almost unimaginably small.
    Hair.
    Bone fragments.
    A fingernail.
    And one damaged tooth.
    It was enough.
    14 min
  • She Deleted the Photos. The Camera Remembered Everything.
    When Travis Alexander was found dead inside his Arizona home in June of two thousand eight, investigators discovered a digital camera inside his washing machine.
    The memory card appeared to have been erased.
    It had not been erased well enough.
    Forensic technicians recovered photographs taken on the day Travis died, including images showing him alive only minutes before the attack and accidental photographs created during or immediately after it.
    The timestamps gave investigators something unusually powerful.
    A clock.
    And the woman who initially insisted she had not even been in Arizona was suddenly placed inside Travis's home during the final hour of his life.
    12 min
  • His Father Was About to Expose One Lie. Then Both Parents Disappeared.
    For years, Chandler Halderson told the people closest to him that he was building an impressive life.
    He said he was attending college.
    He said he had a job waiting for him at SpaceX.
    He claimed he was working with law enforcement and preparing for a future that seemed increasingly successful.
    Then his father began asking questions.
    On July first, two thousand twenty one, Bart Halderson was supposed to speak with Chandler's college to resolve a problem with his records.
    Days later, Chandler reported both of his parents missing.
    Investigators soon discovered that nearly every important part of his story was false.
    And one screenshot from Snapchat would lead police toward the places where the truth had been hidden.
    15 min
  • One Stranger Approached Her. Then the Phones Started Ringing.
    For nearly two years after law professor Dan Markel was murdered in his Tallahassee driveway, investigators had suspects but struggled to prove how the people at the top of the alleged conspiracy were connected to the men who carried out the killing.
    Then the FBI tried something unusual.
    An undercover agent approached Donna Adelson on the street and pretended to know who had killed her former son in law.
    Investigators called the operation the bump.
    What happened next was captured through wiretaps, surveillance, phone records, and conversations prosecutors later said exposed the structure of a murder for hire conspiracy.
    More than eleven years after Dan was killed, Donna Adelson faced a jury.
    15 min
  • Her Phone Recorded the Man Who Took Them Down the Hill
    On February thirteenth, two thousand seventeen, thirteen year old Abigail Williams and fourteen year old Liberty German went for an afternoon walk near the Monon High Bridge outside Delphi, Indiana.
    They never came home.
    But Libby had done something extraordinary.
    Before the girls disappeared, she used her phone to record a man approaching them on the bridge.
    His image was unclear.
    His voice was brief.
    For more than five years, investigators searched for the person in that recording.
    Then they returned to an overlooked interview from the first days of the investigation.
    The man who had told police he was on the trail that afternoon was Richard Allen.
    14 min
  • They Convicted Her Killer. They Still Couldn’t Find Marta.
    Miguel Carcaño was convicted of murdering Marta del Castillo.
    But he never gave investigators a reliable answer to the question that mattered most to her family.
    Where was her body?
    Over the years, police searched the Guadalquivir River, a massive landfill, fields, abandoned mines, wells, and rural properties. Divers, dogs, sonar, excavators, and ground penetrating radar were used. Each new version from Miguel created another possible location.
    Then an undercover informant spent years recording people close to the case.
    More than a decade after Marta disappeared, some of those recordings helped expose false testimony.
    But even that did not bring Marta home.
    14 min
  • Seven Versions of the Same Night
    Miguel Carcaño confessed to killing Marta del Castillo.
    Then he changed his story.
    Again.
    And again.
    Over the years, his versions shifted responsibility between himself, El Cuco, and eventually even his own brother. Each new account sent investigators toward a different location and forced them to reconsider what had happened inside the apartment on León Trece.
    But while the stories changed, forensic evidence began to establish parts of the night independently of Miguel's words.
    This episode examines the contradictions, the evidence, and the trial that ultimately left one man convicted of Marta's murder while others walked free.
    16 min

About The Evidence Room

From the publisher's feed

The Evidence Room is a research-first true crime documentary podcast that examines what the evidence actually shows.
Each episode reconstructs a real case through timelines, witness accounts,…