The Feed & The Thread

The Feed & The Thread

Download on the App Store

The Feed & The Thread episodes

  • The Feed & The Thread - October 6, 2026

    We’re asking whether the tools that make us faster are quietly eroding the deep expertise that defines our craft, as Slava Polonski warns of "AI skill atrophy" and Jessica DeMartini argues we must retain human judgment over mere artifacts. This tension between efficiency and depth is mirrored in our Thread, where we examine if seamless technical transitions and perceptual typography biases actually serve the user or just mask a lack of substance. It’s a conversation about knowing where to stop delegating to machines and start deciding for ourselves.

    From The Feed
    • Many Agents, Many Views ([email protected]) — Traditional dashboards fail to coordinate multiple AI agents, requiring dynamic views that visualize intent and progress in real time.
    • Jessica DeMartini – You’re Not Behind: Finding Your AI Workflow (Chicago Camps) — LLMs function like interns with infinite stamina but no taste, meaning humans must retain the judgment to select and decide.
    • AI skill atrophy: Are we forgetting how to think? (Slava Polonski, PhD) — Outsourcing critical analysis and problem solving to AI causes skill atrophy, eroding the deep cognitive muscles needed for high-level strategy.
    • The taste paradox: why the skill everyone says matters is the one we’ve stopped building (Nicole Alexandra Michaelis) — The podcast argues that while AI handles artifacts, the human skill of taste and judgment is atrophying due to over-reliance on tools.
    • From The Thread
      • Foundational Four: IT, Mechanics, Carpentry, Fabrication. (r/ProductDesign) — A user plans to build four physical workspaces starting with an IT lab in a static caravan, applying design principles to physical infrastructure.
      • May I get some feedback, I made this offline music player (r/UI_Design) — A junior designer seeks feedback on a self-built offline music player, highlighting the gap in mentorship for beginners learning in isolation.
      • Are the titles too heavy on light mode? (r/UI_Design) — Typography that appears balanced in dark mode can feel oppressively heavy in light mode, increasing cognitive load if not tested across themes.
      • Homepage to About Sub-Page Transition (WIP) (r/UI_Design) — Seamless page transitions that avoid loading screens raise the question of whether technical smoothness serves the user or merely showcases code.
      • Today's Notable Articles
        • Claude Code Mods are game changers — Nick Babich
        • Today's Notable Discussions
          • Update to Previous Post — r/ProductDesign
          • How are product designers using AI tools across the design process? — r/ProductDesign
          • About The Feed & The Thread

            The Feed & The Thread is a daily summary of UX articles found in the industry and some light-touch updates from the UX Community found in online forums. It’s brief, and meant as a light-touch overview of what’s happening across UX.

            7 min
          • The Feed & The Thread - October 5, 2026

            We’re drowning in AI tools but starving for strategy, so we ask whether we’re using these tools to ship faster or to understand deeper. Jeff Gothelf proposes a lightweight canvas to cut through the feature-stuffing chaos, while Pavel Samsonov warns that our obsession with speed is killing real learning by bypassing the discomfort of challenging existing opinions. We also explore how design styles install mental categories in users' minds and debate the tension between high-performance visual rendering and the need to preserve the human story behind our metrics.

            From The Feed
            • Under Autumn’s Spell (October 2026 Wallpapers Edition) ([email protected] (Cosima Mielke)) — Smashing Magazine discusses seasonal wallpapers as a minor read in the feed.
            • The building was there first (Takuma Kakehi) — Design styles install mental categories in the user's mind, shifting from visual artifacts to cognitive frameworks.
            • The Lean Strategy Canvas — A focusing tool for the AI era (Jeff Gothelf) — A lightweight canvas forces teams to define goals and barriers in one afternoon to guard against feature-stuffing.
            • The fake double diamond is dead. The real double diamond is immortal. (Pavel Samsonov) — Industry obsession with speed kills real learning, using AI to ship faster rather than understand deeper.
            • Product Ethics in the Age of AI (Roman Pichler) — Roman Pichler addresses product ethics as a minor read in the feed.
            • From The Thread
              • Job titles (r/UXDesign) — A job title crisis is mentioned as sitting next to a cinematic login screen in the feed.
              • How do you stop research insight getting watered down before it reaches a decision? (r/UXResearch) — Nuance dies in translation because metrics travel well to executives but lack the emotional depth of case studies.
              • SwiftUI + Metal — turning particles into a cinematic login screen (r/UI_Design) — High-performance rendering is becoming viable for standard product interactions, raising accessibility and battery concerns.
              • I like the idea behind this design for iPhone Duo (r/UI_Design) — The concept blends nineties nostalgia with modern hardware, reflecting a desire for simpler, tactile interfaces.
              • [AI] Shockingly good taste coming from Opus 5.5 (r/UI_Design) — Newer AI models are producing hero sections with refined taste, moving away from generic AI slop.
              • Today's Notable Articles
                • Prompt as self-portrait, De-slopifying your designs, The strategic designer — Fabricio Teixeira
                • Today's Notable Discussions
                  • New cloud platform dashboard design — r/UI_Design
                  • About The Feed & The Thread

                    The Feed & The Thread is a daily summary of UX articles found in the industry and some light-touch updates from the UX Community found in online forums. It’s brief, and meant as a light-touch overview of what’s happening across UX.

                    7 min
                  • The Feed & The Thread - October 4, 2026

                    We keep building for the average user, but the real friction lives at the edges where standard heuristics fail the bottom third of our audience. Patrick Neeman argues that we must respect Doherty’s threshold to keep humans in the loop long enough to catch AI errors, while Kai Wong suggests looking to farmers’ markets to design tangible, inclusive experiences for those with lower literacy. Meanwhile, the community is dissecting the subtle affordances of hover states and cross-platform iconography to bridge the gap between static interfaces and responsive, native-feeling design.

                    From The Feed
                    • Another Saturday, Another Song. (L. Jeffrey Zeldman) — Creative output remains meaningful even when it stays personal and away from professional pressure.
                    • Stop blaming the model for slow AI. Using Doherty’s threshold as a guideline. (Patrick Neeman) — The 400ms threshold applies to immediate acknowledgment, not final generation, to preserve user supervision.
                    • If you want to design for underserved users, look at farmers’ markets (Kai Wong) — Farmers' markets offer tangible, face-to-face feedback that accommodates diverse needs better than rigid UI patterns.
                    • From The Thread
                      • What's the best Hover state option? (r/UI_Design) — Subtle visual cues in hover states serve as the critical bridge between static interfaces and responsive feedback.
                      • learning ui design. design n1 VS n2. opinions? (r/UI_Design) — Cross-platform design requires deliberate rethinking of visual hierarchies rather than simply copying iOS aesthetics to Android.
                      • Any practical AI-assisted workflow? (r/DesignSystems) — The lack of two-way syncing in AI tools prevents designers from supervising intermediate steps and catching errors.
                      • Why does the Sort By button in Finder look so neglected in the Liquid Glass design? (r/UI_Design) — User perception of polish can diverge from actual effort, revealing blind spots even in flagship products.
                      • Painting App, UI feedback would be appreciated! (r/UI_Design) — External validation helps refine the tension between technical constraints and artistic intent in retro-styled interfaces.
                      • Today's Notable Articles
                        • What the Bible got wrong about AI — Dan Maccarone
                        • Federal pressure may force design education to rethink its identity — Michael Buckley
                        • Headless AI will make every product a platform. Here’s what to consider when designing for this. — Patrick Neeman
                        • About The Feed & The Thread

                          The Feed & The Thread is a daily summary of UX articles found in the industry and some light-touch updates from the UX Community found in online forums. It’s brief, and meant as a light-touch overview of what’s happening across UX.

                          7 min
                        • The Feed & The Thread - October 3, 2026

                          We examine whether AI speed is actually a pressure valve that traps us in constant cognitive load, as Pedro A. Brêtas argues that saved time just fills with new demands. This tension deepens when we look at the "vibe architects" creating fragile, unmaintainable systems and the atrophy of human judgment that Adam Cutler warns against. Meanwhile, we unpack the undervaluation of research rigor and the educational gaps in foundational UX skills that are leaving new designers without the evidence to back their artifacts.

                          From The Feed
                          • The feed I produce myself (Pedro A. Brêtas) — Saved time from AI doesn't rest but fills, creating a trap of constant cognitive load.
                          • Adam Cutler – What’s Yours to Keep: Designing alongside AI without giving up the work that made you a designer. (Chicago Camps) — AI can generate screens but cannot select the best one, making human judgment a critical skill.
                          • The New Big Ball of Mud: Why Agentic AI Systems Turn Fragile (Tanner Kohler) — Low barriers to entry create unmaintainable systems that become hard to diagnose.
                          • From The Thread
                            • Need User Research and User Journey Map Advice (Beginner) (r/UXDesign) — Students often learn to create artifacts without understanding the underlying research process.
                            • Anyone works in lingotech? grammar ux/ui, meta derivatives etc..? (r/uxwriting) — The specific terminology of lingotech may not be standard in the UX field.
                            • Getting into UX for Robotics/Physical AI (r/UXDesign) — There is a growing demand for interaction design skills that bridge physical and digital worlds.
                            • UXR -> Product Design (r/UXResearch) — Senior researchers feel their rigorous work is undervalued compared to faster, tangible creative outputs.
                            • Today's Notable Articles
                              • Empathy Mapping: The First Step in Design Thinking — Rachel Krause, Sarah Gibbons
                              • 3D Modeling with Claude Code: A Practical Blender Workflow — Nick Babich
                              • Design’s consensus was AI’s first casualty — Anamol Rajbhandari
                              • Today's Notable Discussions
                                • Lmaooo what??? 😭😭 — r/UXResearch
                                • Explain UX to stakeholders — r/UXDesign
                                • Looking for UI/UX feedback on a personal engineering portfolio — r/UXDesign
                                • Have we over-personalized discovery? — r/UXDesign
                                • Approaching Projects On Subjects You Don't Understand — r/UXDesign
                                • About The Feed & The Thread

                                  The Feed & The Thread is a daily summary of UX articles found in the industry and some light-touch updates from the UX Community found in online forums. It’s brief, and meant as a light-touch overview of what’s happening across UX.

                                  7 min
                                • The Feed & The Thread - October 2, 2026

                                  We ask who actually holds the power to decide in design, exploring Stacie Sheldon’s argument that empathy often masks unchecked authority and Luke Wroblewski’s shift of that control from documentation to code. We contrast this structural shift with the human cost of the industry, from a professor advising students to hide their identity to a designer pausing history for user choice. It’s a look at how we navigate the tension between systemic power and individual voice in a field that is rapidly changing.

                                  From The Feed
                                  • AI beyond average: from chatting to collaborating (Sen Lin) — Moving from simple AI chat to true collaboration is a key shift in design workflows.
                                  • Sonnet 5.5 vs Opus 5.5: Which one is better for product design? (Nick Babich) — A comparison of Sonnet and Opus models for their effectiveness in product design tasks.
                                  • How to test MCP Apps for accessibility, and why it matters (Harris Schneiderman) — Testing MCP apps for accessibility is essential to ensure inclusive user experiences.
                                  • Anne Cantera – The New Design Stack: The Skills Traditional Designers Need to Add To Their Toolboxes ASAP (Chicago Camps) — Designers must orchestrate multimodal interfaces based on context rather than forcing interactions into single visual formats.
                                  • Design Systems for AI Agents ([email protected]) — Using AI agents as a steering layer enforces design tokens automatically, shifting the source of truth from documentation to code.
                                  • In/tension modeling: what gives us the right? (Stacie Sheldon) — Empathy often masks unchecked power, so designers should surface tension between conflicting user voices instead of silencing them.
                                  • From The Thread
                                    • Moralia - designing a live historical dilemma game around one story every day (r/UI_Design) — The project pauses history for user choice and explicitly discloses AI use to retain designer creative authority.
                                    • Junior UXR (r/UXResearch) — The field demands senior-level strategic insight from entry-level candidates, creating a structural catch-22 for junior researchers.
                                    • How many designers do you think actually work on a website like Apple? (r/UI_Design) — The question reveals anxiety about who holds authority in design systems and the tension between local context and global consistency.
                                    • "Racial Profiling" in Design Portfolios and recruiting? (r/Design) — Students are pushing back on outdated gatekeeping mechanisms that advise hiding Asian identity to get hired.
                                    • Today's Notable Discussions
                                      • Portfolio website — r/Design
                                      • How much should I charge for a major dieline/orientation change? — r/Design
                                      • What’s the tool behind this called? — r/Design
                                      • Looking for opportunities — r/UXResearch
                                      • Design Interview Structure — r/Design
                                      • ¿Cómo puedo empezar un diseño? — r/Design
                                      • About The Feed & The Thread

                                        The Feed & The Thread is a daily summary of UX articles found in the industry and some light-touch updates from the UX Community found in online forums. It’s brief, and meant as a light-touch overview of what’s happening across UX.

                                        7 min
                                      • The Feed & The Thread - October 1, 2026

                                        We explore the widening gap between AI capability and human intent, asking whether precision in prompting, as argued by Theresa-Marie Rhyne, or owning the feedback loop, as Christian Crumlish suggests, is the key to bridging that distance. We also examine the emerging need for AI restraint, from a student’s prototype that chooses when to stay silent to the push for standardized compliance patterns that reduce cognitive load. Ultimately, we ask if the future of UX lies not in making AI more available, but in teaching it when to disappear.

                                        From The Feed
                                        • Five-step color balancing with GenAI (Theresa-Marie Rhyne) — Designers must feed qualitative data and specific constraints into AI to turn it into a collaborative partner for iterative design.
                                        • B2B Electronic Components & Machinery UX Benchmark: 2,600+ Performance Scores and 2,000+ Best Practice Examples (Anders Nielsen) — Baymard Institute provides extensive B2B UX benchmarks and best practice examples for electronic components and machinery.
                                        • GPT-6.1 Sol vs Claude Sonnet 5.5: I Tested Both for Web Design (Nick Babich) — UX Planet compares GPT-6.1 Sol and Claude Sonnet 5.5 for their effectiveness in web design tasks.
                                        • Intelligent Accessibility: What If Accessibility Could Adapt to You? (Dulanjala Aluthge) — UX Design.cc explores how accessibility features can adapt dynamically to individual user needs.
                                        • Christian Crumlish – Hilarious Tales of Failure: What a Year of Building With AI Taught Me (Chicago Camps) — Human ownership of the feedback loop is essential to maintain trust when AI agents hallucinate or fail silently.
                                        • What gestures reveal about users with Dane DeSutter and Stephanie Scopelitis (aedwards) — Spontaneous gestures reveal mental models that words miss, allowing researchers to systematically interpret ambiguous user ideas.
                                        • From The Thread
                                          • Should AI-related compliance patterns be part of a design system? (r/DesignSystems) — Standardizing AI compliance components in design systems reduces fragmented experiences and cognitive load for users and teams.
                                          • Graphic Design graduate transitioning to UX/Service Design — which European Master’s would make the most sense? (r/hci) — The field maintains a broad entry point for non-technical practitioners who can articulate the value of strategic, human-centered thinking.
                                          • I built a prototype for an AI that knows when NOT to help (r/hci) — Defining the threshold where assistance becomes intrusion allows tools to manage their own presence rather than forcing users to filter noise.
                                          • Today's Notable Discussions
                                            • What is the best way to design animations for a landing page? — r/UserExperienceDesign
                                            • is it worth it to learn web design with business mindset? — r/web_design
                                            • What are the most frustrating aspects of being a design systems designer? — r/DesignSystems
                                            • About The Feed & The Thread

                                              The Feed & The Thread is a daily summary of UX articles found in the industry and some light-touch updates from the UX Community found in online forums. It’s brief, and meant as a light-touch overview of what’s happening across UX.

                                              7 min
                                            • The Feed & The Thread - September 30, 2026

                                              We’re shifting from capturing attention to governing it, a move Aurélie Radom argues is necessary now that AI has made machine focus cheap and human attention the true scarce resource. This governance challenge extends to our tools and processes, from Will Schiavone’s findings on AI’s nuanced but fragmented coding of user responses to the practical headache of retiring static design assets that live on in local libraries. We explore how these shifts force us to rethink everything from organizational headcount to the statistical foundations of our research, asking whether we are truly building systems or just filling templates.

                                              From The Feed
                                              • Guppy Ahluwalia – Token times: Organizational practices in a resource-constrained environment. (Chicago Camps) — Teams must abandon headcount-heavy structures to build scalable, strategic processes in resource-constrained environments.
                                              • ChatGPT vs Humans for Coding Open-Ended Responses, Three Years Later (Will Schiavone, PhD • Eva Sundberg, MPH • Jeff Sauro, PhD) — Newer AI models generate finer subcategories for coding responses, requiring new alignment methods to prevent data fragmentation.
                                              • The economics of attention in the age of AI (Aurélie Radom) — AI makes machine attention cheap, forcing human attention to become the scarce resource that design must govern rather than capture.
                                              • From The Thread
                                                • Fong test? (r/UXResearch) — The Fong test for Kano questionnaires is mathematically shaky because it assumes independent samples from the same people.
                                                • How are UX teams using AI for ​​​​s​​​​t​​​​a​​​​k​​​​e​​​​h​​​​o​​​​l​​​​d​​​​e​​​​r​​​ presentations? (r/UserExperience) — disconnect insights from their source by prioritizing speed over data integrity.
                                                • Why do people say to get experience before applying to a masters program? (r/hci) — The requirement for experience before a degree creates a catch-22 that raises questions about industry hiring barriers.
                                                • How do you retire an icon once people have already downloaded the SVG? (r/DesignSystems) — Design systems face a governance gap where static copies of assets persist in local libraries even after source code is updated.
                                                • Today's Notable Articles
                                                  • How to de-slopify your designs — Maya Brennan
                                                  • My Glamorous Life: in Which I am a Target — L. Jeffrey Zeldman
                                                  • I Tested Claude Sonnet 5.5 for Web Design — Nick Babich
                                                  • Today's Notable Discussions
                                                    • Giving away UX books — r/UXResearch
                                                    • Are there people in Alabama who I can't talk to about UX/UI Research? — r/UXResearch
                                                    • "Why do people ignore new feedback or notifications when they're already overloaded with work". — r/UXResearch
                                                    • About The Feed & The Thread

                                                      The Feed & The Thread is a daily summary of UX articles found in the industry and some light-touch updates from the UX Community found in online forums. It’s brief, and meant as a light-touch overview of what’s happening across UX.

                                                      6 min
                                                    • The Feed & The Thread - September 29, 2026

                                                      We explore whether AI’s speed is liberating us for strategy or simply triggering a Jevons Paradox that demands more output, drawing on Daniel Ruston’s warning about the shift from maker to orchestrator and Caitlin Steele’s call for building “defensible space” against constant crises. By examining community debates on original craft versus automation and the tension between thematic aesthetics and functional readability, we question what truly matters when execution becomes nearly instant.

                                                      From The Feed
                                                      • I Tested Opus 5.5 at Every Effort Level for Animation Design (Nick Babich) — Higher effort settings yield nuanced animations but require careful prompt engineering to avoid artifacts.
                                                      • The strategic designer: navigating the Jevons paradox in the AI age (Daniel Ruston) — AI efficiency triggers higher demand, requiring designers to evolve into strategic orchestrators.
                                                      • Caitlin Steele – Defensible Space (russu) — Designers must build preventive buffers before crises strike rather than just reacting to emergencies.
                                                      • From The Thread
                                                        • Hi, I'm working in a medieval map strategy game. Do you think this UI looks good? (r/UI_Design) — Balancing historical aesthetics with modern readability is key for competitive play legibility.
                                                        • What would you change? Academy screen for a self-improvement app (skill tree UI) (r/UI_Design) — Community feedback helps designers overcome iteration fatigue and regain objectivity.
                                                        • i made a little farming/cozy themed UI!! [AI generated screenshot but the assets are mine] (r/UI_Design) — Designers must own the visual language and IP even when AI handles rendering.
                                                        • Comment sheet on Reddit 😖 (r/UI_Design) — Overlapping icons obscure content, showing aesthetic updates must not compromise functional utility.
                                                        • Today's Notable Articles
                                                          • The next larger context — Chris R Becker
                                                          • What makes a brand last? — Dora Czerna
                                                          • Today's Notable Discussions
                                                            • How does our inventory UI look? What would you change? — r/UI_Design
                                                            • I rebuilt the Home screen of my wellness app does this UX make more sense now? — r/UserExperienceDesign
                                                            • Looking for a community partner for my capstone — r/ProductDesign
                                                            • About The Feed & The Thread

                                                              The Feed & The Thread is a daily summary of UX articles found in the industry and some light-touch updates from the UX Community found in online forums. It’s brief, and meant as a light-touch overview of what’s happening across UX.

                                                              7 min
                                                            • The Feed & The Thread - September 28, 2026

                                                              We’re building AI systems faster than we can define who’s responsible when they fail, creating a dangerous gap where everyone feels they’re doing their job but no one owns the outcome. Jeff Gothelf argues we must name a specific accountable human before automating decisions, while Pavel Samsonov warns that we’re inverting design by seeking solutions before defining problems. This tension is mirrored in the community, where we’re seeing hollow AI-generated conference talks and designers scrambling to save the entry-level craft that AI is eroding.

                                                              From The Feed
                                                              • LLMs are just normal technology. But tech is just a normal medium. (Pavel Samsonov) — LLMs invert human-centered design by seeking solutions before defining problems.
                                                              • Before you automate a decision, name the person accountable for it (Jeff Gothelf) — Leaders must identify a specific individual who bears consequences before automating decisions.
                                                              • How we save entry-level UX work that teaches craft in the time of AI. Our field depends on this. (Patrick Neeman) — AI erodes entry-level tasks that teach core craft, creating a significant employment gap for young workers.
                                                              • From The Thread
                                                                • Content designer to product designer: what helped you make the switch? (r/UXDesign) — A principal content designer pivots to product design as a survival tactic against automation fears.
                                                                • Are conference talks getting worse? (r/UXDesign) — A conference talk written entirely by AI highlights a lack of innovation and accountability for intellectual labor.
                                                                • Unable to create AI Skills for workflow that other Designers can use? (r/UXDesign) — Shared AI workflows fail because they ignore the specific nuances each designer relies on.
                                                                • Today's Notable Articles
                                                                  • Regulating AI, Quantifying stress, The variance problem — Fabricio Teixeira
                                                                  • Today's Notable Discussions
                                                                    • As a designer, do you use GitHub in your role, and if so, for what? — r/UXDesign
                                                                    • Seniors+, how do I go from an intermediate level designer to a senior? — r/UXDesign
                                                                    • Professional development resources that are actually worth it? — r/UXDesign
                                                                    • Feedback on a nonpartisan voter guide experience — r/UXDesign
                                                                    • Showoff Monday — First impression of this healthcare website? — r/UXDesign
                                                                    • About The Feed & The Thread

                                                                      The Feed & The Thread is a daily summary of UX articles found in the industry and some light-touch updates from the UX Community found in online forums. It’s brief, and meant as a light-touch overview of what’s happening across UX.

                                                                      6 min
                                                                    • The Feed & The Thread - September 27, 2026

                                                                      We ask who is responsible when the tools we rely on to store our work disappear, noting that a quarter of web pages from the last decade have already vanished. Dora Czerna argues that this loss forces us to take ownership of our data, while Fabricio Teixeira challenges the notion that static deliverables are the final product. We also examine a designer’s controversial shortcut of skipping manual ideation to use AI-generated drafts as a starting point, and a plea for resources to bridge the empathy gap in rigid waterfall environments.

                                                                      From The Feed
                                                                      • For the Designless, The death of the deliverable, iPhone Duo’s UX (Fabricio Teixeira) — The real value lies in the problem-solving process rather than static deliverables like wireframes.
                                                                      • Where does your work go when the tool shuts down? (Dora Czerna) — Relying on third-party tools for data storage risks losing critical work if those services disappear.
                                                                      • From The Thread
                                                                        • Made a thing to discover quality kids’ products (r/ProductDesign) — Effective design often involves removing friction and trust barriers for specific, vulnerable audiences.
                                                                        • Sharing My Agentic Workflow (r/UXDesign) — Using AI to generate initial drafts reframes the designer's role from creator to editor.
                                                                        • Today's Notable Discussions
                                                                          • Book Recommendations - research and requirements — r/UXDesign
                                                                          • Your favorite books on mobile UX Design? — r/UXDesign
                                                                          • how to improve my app? — r/ProductDesign
                                                                          • About The Feed & The Thread

                                                                            The Feed & The Thread is a daily summary of UX articles found in the industry and some light-touch updates from the UX Community found in online forums. It’s brief, and meant as a light-touch overview of what’s happening across UX.

                                                                            6 min

                                                                          About The Feed & The Thread

                                                                          From the publisher's feed

                                                                          The Feed & The Thread is a daily summary of UX articles found in the industry and some light-touch updates from the UX Community found in online forums. It’s brief, and meant as a light-touch…