Former NRL judiciary chairman and NSW District Court Judge Paul Conlon joins Tim Fuller and Matt Krog for a frank conversation about how sport judges its own.
The episode covers Lachie Neale's grand final week tribunal fight, the NRL's no-fault stand-down policy, the Cronulla ASADA saga and Shayna Jack's anti-doping case.
Paul brings more than four decades in criminal law and eight years at the head of the NRL judiciary to the rules that make or break athletes' careers.
Paul explains how the old three-player NRL judiciary actually worked. He describes the advice he gave ahead of Billy Slater's famous shoulder charge hearing, and he explains why he believes the current two-person panel is pushing clubs to take early pleas rather than risk a hearing.
He is candid about why he does not like the no-fault stand-down rule and why he is wary of codes relying on untested police statements of facts. He also argues that voluntary assumption of risk makes US-style mass concussion litigation unlikely in Australia.
On anti-doping, Paul looks back on the 2013 "blackest day in sport" announcement, the fight for disclosure in Shayna Jack's case, and USADA chief Travis Tygart's call for case-by-case treatment of inadvertent low-level positives.
To close, each of them makes a call on the week ahead. Tim backs Lachie Neale to beat his ban and farewell the Lions in the grand final. Matt says Kylian Mbappé's cash and equity deal with On signals a new era of athlete entrepreneurs, and the complex advice those deals will demand. Paul, a proud Blues man, tips New South Wales to spoil Darius Boyd's debut as Queensland coach.
Tim Fuller is Special Counsel at Bennett & Philp. He has Court of Arbitration for Sport experience and was part of Shayna Jack's legal team. Matt Krog is the founder of Aus Sports Law and represents NRL players in judiciary hearings, contracts and tribunal appeals.
Follow The Field of Law, if you enjoyed this conversation, and send us the sports law question you want answered next.
This episode is general commentary and education only. It is not legal advice. For advice on your own circumstances, speak to a qualified legal practitioner.