
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


📍 Merom, Indiana | Year: 2012
🎧 Chapter 45 — The Final Trace of Lowell Badger
Lowell Badger lived a life of routine, faith, and quiet consistency.
But on a cold December night, that peace was shattered inside his own home.
For eleven years, his family waited—while the truth remained just out of reach.
Until the silence finally broke.
Primary News Reports & Investigation Details
Lowell Badger Cold Case Summary (Indiana State Police)
The official investigative profile detailing the stolen Sentry safe, the Sony Bravia TV, and the early 2012 crime scene details.
Police Release More Information in Sullivan County Murder (WTHI-TV)
An archival report from the eighth anniversary of the crime, highlighting the $50,000 reward and the search for a dark-colored pickup truck.
Alan Badger Recalls Finding His Father Dead (WTHI-TV)
Detailed courtroom coverage of Alan and Audrey Badger’s testimony regarding the locked doors and the morning of December 8th.
Trial Testimony: Victim Was Not Supposed to be Home (WIBQ AM)
Coverage explaining the motive for the burglary and the revelation that the suspects believed Lowell was away for the night.
The Breakthrough & Legal Proceedings
Probable Cause Affidavit: The Investigation of Richard Taft (MyWabashValley)
The legal document outlining how 2023 interviews and forensic breakthroughs finally connected William Grimes and Richard Taft to the murder.
William Grimes Found Guilty in 2012 Murder Case (WTWO/WAWV)
A report on the May 2025 jury verdict, detailing the counts of murder and conspiracy to commit burglary.
Prosecution Calls Witnesses Against Grimes (The Sullivan Times)
In-depth reporting on the forensic evidence, including the "man door" locks and the lack of fingerprints at the scene.
The Sentencing & Aftermath
William Grimes Sentenced to 120 Years (WTHI-TV)
June 2025 coverage of Judge Hugh Hunt’s maximum sentencing and the impact statements delivered by the Badger family.
Third Suspect Charged in Lowell Badger Murder (MyWabashValley)
Details the April 2025 arrest of Arthur Lee Grimes, brother of William, and his alleged role in the 2012 burglary.
Lowell Badger Trial Updates (The Sullivan Times)
A comprehensive chronological collection of daily trial updates and witness lists from the 2025 proceedings.
Court Testimony: During William Grimes' 2025 trial, a witness named Jeremiah Mahan confirmed seeing Grimes at the Merom home where underage drinking was occurring. While Mahan had previously told police in a report that he saw the men return with the TV in the truck, he claimed during the trial that he could no longer recall that specific detail, though he admitted he was telling the truth when he originally gave the statement under oath.
Sullivan Daily Times +5
WTHI-TV YouTube
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
📍 Vincennes, Indiana | Year: 1975
🎧 Chapter 44 — The Final Trace of Sherry Lee Gibson
A knock in the dark.
A scream no one heard.
And a fire meant to erase everything.
For years, the case was closed.
The killer was named.
The story… finished.
But the truth doesn’t always stay buried.
A confession from a church pew.
A second story that matched the first—26 years later.
And a realization that the wrong ending had been written all along.
Some stories don’t disappear.
They wait.
Primary News Reports & Investigation Details
Tri-State Murder Case capturing National Attention (14 News)
Details the Investigation Discovery feature and the confession that broke the case after 26 years.
Murder Case Reopened after 27 Years (14 News)
An early 2002 report on the new suspects and the reaction of the Gibson family.
Man Guilty in 1975 Slaying of Woman in Indiana (Chicago Tribune)
Covers Wayne Gulley’s conviction, the 11-hour jury deliberation, and the tragic 1998 death of eyewitness Lindy Alton.
Confession leads to 2 Arrests in '75 Killing (Chicago Tribune)
Details the initial arrests of Dicks and Gulley and the realization that Jeffers was innocent.
Knox County Convicts Man in 1975 Murder Case (Journal Review)
Summary of the final verdict against Gulley and the clearing of the previous conviction.
WFIE +11
The Story of the False Confession
John Jeffers Case Profile - National Registry of Exonerations
The definitive record of how John Jeffers falsely implicated himself and Ken Shaner, leading to a wrongful 30-year sentence.
Georgia Woman Allegedly Confesses Late (The Intelligencer)
Article exploring why Dicks came forward and the initial skepticism from Gulley’s defense team.
National Registry of Exonerations +2
The Trial & Legal Proceedings
Trial Begins in 1975 Murder Case (14 News)
Coverage of the start of the 2003 trial, including comments from lead investigator Larry Eck.
Stefanie Silvey Investigates: Wayne Gulley (14 News)
Detailed investigative piece including excerpts from Gulley’s interrogations and the composite sketches.
Jailed Suspects' Descriptions Fit Other Crimes (14 News)
Explores how Gulley and Dicks were tied to other unsolved robberies and shootings from the mid-70s.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
📍Nairn, Scotland I Year: 2004
🎧 Chapter 43 — The Final Trace of Alistair Wilson
It was supposed to be an ordinary night.
Bedtime stories upstairs.
Children getting ready for bed.
Then came a knock.
Minutes later, Alistair Wilson was dead — and the person responsible vanished into the dark, leaving behind more questions than answers.
Sources & Further Reading:
BBC News: https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-scotland-highlands-islands-63839186
Police Scotland: https://www.scotland.police.uk/what-s-happening/campaigns/2022/december/alistair-wilson-murder-investigation/
The Guardian: https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2022/dec/05/alistair-wilson-murder-scotland-police-new-leads
STV News: https://news.stv.tv/highlands-islands/alistair-wilson-murder-police-issue-new-appeal-18-years-on
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
📍Vincennes, Indiana | Year: 1987
🎧 Chapter 42 — The Final Trace of Lisa McCracken
She was 19 years old.
Outgoing. Kind. The kind of person you didn’t forget.
But inside her apartment on North 6th Street… something went terribly wrong.
Lisa McCracken was found murdered—her life cut short in a place that should have been safe.
And for years, the person responsible walked free.
Until decades later… science caught up with the truth.
But even with a name… some questions never fully fade.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
📍Knoxville, Tennessee | Year: 1996
🎧 Chapter 41: The Final Trace of Blair Adams
In July 1996, 31-year-old Blair Adams fled his home in fear—telling friends and family that someone was trying to kill him.
Within days, he crossed international borders, carrying thousands of dollars in cash and gold.
Then, in a quiet parking lot in Knoxville, Tennessee… Blair was found dead.
Partially undressed.
Surrounded by scattered money.
And with no clear cause of death.
Nearly three decades later, the questions remain.
What was Blair running from?
And who Killed Blair Adams?
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
📍 Grants Pass, Oregon I Year: 2020
🎧 Chapter 40: The Final Trace of Fauna Frey
Just days after the sudden death of her brother, Fauna Frey set out on what she told her father would be a simple trip—one last mission to deliver her brother’s silver coins to his friends.
But somewhere along the winding roads of southern Oregon… the story began to drift.
Then Fauna vanished.
Months later, her Jeep was discovered hidden deep off a remote logging road—locked, abandoned, and surrounded by wilderness.
Her purse was missing.The silver was gone.And Fauna Frey had disappeared without a trace.
Did grief lead her to walk away from everything she knew?Or did someone see an opportunity… and make sure she never came back?
📞 If You Have Information please contact:
Investigative Deep Dives & News Reports
Podcasts & Media References
Community & Tip Lines
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
📍Vincennes, Indiana I Year: 1997
🎧 Chapter 39: The Final Trace of Brook Baker
In 1997, 19-year-old Brook Baker was brutally murdered inside her home.
The crime stunned the small Indiana community—and despite the evidence left behind, the case quickly went cold.
For years, Brook’s family waited for answers… until the person responsible struck again.
And when investigators finally connected the dots, the truth was even more chilling than anyone imagined.
The Final Trace of Brook Baker
The Killer They Knew: One Man’s Rage Led to the Deaths of Two College Students in Vincennes
(Feature coverage connecting Brook Baker & Erika Norman)
👉 https://www.mywabashvalley.com/news/special-report/the-killer-they-knew-one-mans-rage-lead-to-the-deaths-of-two-college-students-in-vincennes/
Jury Finds Brian Jones Guilty of Raping and Murdering Brook Baker
👉 https://www.mywabashvalley.com/news/jury-finds-brian-jones-guilty-of-raping-and-murdering-brook-baker/
Vincennes Man Sentenced to Life in Jail
👉 https://www.mywabashvalley.com/news/vincennes-man-sentenced-to-life-in-jail/
High Court Rejects Appeal in Baker Case
(Indiana Supreme Court ruling affirming conviction)
👉 https://law.justia.com/cases/indiana/supreme-court/2002/12200201-bed.html
25 Years Later: Remembering Brook Baker — Vincennes University Trailblazer
👉 https://vutrailblazernews.com/1836/features/25-years-later-remembering-brook-baker/
Brian Jones Killed Vincennes Students Brook Baker & Erika Norman (Oxygen)
👉 https://www.oxygen.com/one-deadly-mistake/crime-news/brian-jones-killed-vincennes-students-brook-baker-erika-norman
Amateur Sleuth – Brook Baker
👉 https://amateursleuth.wordpress.com/tag/brook-baker/
AKA 137F Strikes Again — Anatomy of Murder (Podcast Coverage)
👉 https://anatomyofmurder.com/aka-137f-strikes-again/
Jones v. State of Indiana — Supreme Court Opinion
(Full appellate decision outlining evidence and sentencing)
👉 https://caselaw.findlaw.com/court/in-supreme-court/1036733.html
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
📍 Brownsville, Brooklyn — New York City
🎧 Bonus Mini: The Final Trace of Jacob Pritchett
A boy disappears.
A story begins to unravel.
And investigators now believe the truth may be far darker than anyone first imagined.
Jacob Pritchett vanished without a trace — but the clues left behind point to a case that may be more than just a disappearance.
In this bonus mini episode, we tell you the haunting story behind a boy who "never existed".
If you have any information about the disappearance of Jacob Pritchett please call 1-800-577-TIPS
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
📍Mediterranean Sea — aboard a Royal Caribbean cruise. | Year: 2005
🎧 Chapter 38: The Final Trace of George Smith
A honeymoon meant to celebrate a new beginning ended in mystery just days after it began.
When George Smith disappeared from a Royal Caribbean cruise ship in 2005, investigators discovered a troubling clue — a dark bloodstain on a canopy below the couple’s balcony. Witnesses described chaos in a nearby cabin, but George was never seen again.
Two decades later, the question still remains:
Did George fall… or was he pushed?
Not all secrets stay buried.
Instagram: @thefinaltracepodcast
The Final Trace of George Smith
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
📍Seaside, California.
🎧 Chapter 37: The Final Trace of Mary Day.
For decades, Mary Day was believed to have vanished without a trace.
But when a woman claiming to be Mary suddenly resurfaced… the truth became even more complicated.
Was this a case of abuse, survival, and escape?
Or something far more sinister buried beneath the surface?
📘 Readings & Other Sources :
👉 Wikipedia – Mary Louise Day — overview of her disappearance and later developments. Mary Louise Day (Wikipedia)
👉 Investigation Discovery – The Curious Case Of… The Girl Who Died Twice (Episode focused on Mary Day). The Girl Who Died Twice (ID episode)
👉 IMDb – The Girl Who Died Twice (episode info & credits). The Girl Who Died Twice (IMDb)
👉 People – Inside the Mary Day mystery and the ID series coverage. Inside the Mystery of Mary Louise Day (People)
👉 Dexerto – Explained article on the Curious Case Of episode. Where Is Mary Day Now? Explained (Dexerto)
👉 CBS 48 Hours: What Ever Happened to Mary Day? (TV episode overview). What Ever Happened to Mary Day? (48 Hours)
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
From the publisher's feed
Ranked by our users in the last 21 days