Eleanor, an avid gardener, writes to the Nightmare Neighbors Podcast to share her experience with her new neighbor, Victor. After Eleanor wins the town gardening award for her beautiful roses, Victor becomes envious and decides to sabotage her garden, all while elevating his own gardening status and spreading rumors about Eleanor using harmful chemicals. Despite Eleanor's efforts to expose Victor's actions, she is met with disbelief from the community and the police. Victor's actions escalate until Eleanor's garden is destroyed, and it is only with the help of another witness that Victor's deceit is finally revealed, leading to his removal from community organizations.