Feeling stuck on psychiatric meds and wondering if there's another way?
This episode will change the game.
Today I'm joined by Dr. Amy O'Donnell, a brilliant integrative psychiatrist who specializes in psychiatric deprescribing and women's mental health. She's helping clients move from surviving on scripts to thriving in mind, body, and spirit.
Amy and I get real about the limits of traditional psychiatry, the risks of long-term medication use, and how integrative care offers hope and healing—especially for women navigating anxiety, depression, trauma, and reproductive life stages.
This conversation is a must-listen for therapists, Christian clinicians, and women in their 20s and 30s who are done with the one-size-fits-all model and ready for faith-informed, evidence-based alternatives.
What You'll Learn in This Episode:
-
What deprescribing actually means—and how to do it safely
-
Why psychiatric meds should be a last resort, not the first step
-
The risks of benzos, SSRIs, and antipsychotics—especially long term
-
How trauma, pregnancy, and meds interact (and what most providers miss)
-
Why faith and science aren't opposites—they can work together
-
Practical, affordable holistic strategies (backed by research!)
-
What to ask your psychiatrist if you're considering tapering
Quotes to Remember:
"I was trained to prescribe—no one taught me how to deprescribe. That's what woke me up." — Dr. Amy O'Donnell
"Just because you're on medication now doesn't mean you'll be on it forever." — Diana S. Rice, LMHC, CIMHP
"Some clients tell me, 'I've been on meds since I was 13, and now I want to have a baby—what do I do?' That's why this conversation matters." — Diana S. Rice, LMHC, CIMHP
"We don't just treat brains—we treat people with stories, trauma, and purpose." — Dr. O'Donnell
"Small steps lead to big shifts. Start with what you can do today." — Dr. O'Donnell
Holistic Tools & Resources Mentioned:
-
Open Path Collective – Affordable online therapy options
-
NAMI (National Alliance on Mental Illness) – National support and education
-
The Emotion Wheel PDF – For emotional regulation
-
[Fish Oil & Multivitamins] – Evidence-based support for depression/anxiety
-
Mind-body practices: yoga, tai chi, breathwork, grounding
-
Functional nutrition: real food > processed, healthy fats, protein balance
-
Apps: Insight Timer, Headspace for mindfulness
-
Conscious Clinician Collective
Related Episodes You'll Love:
A Faith-Informed Mental Health Lens
We also explore how the faith community often misunderstands mental illness, labeling it as weakness or even demonic. Amy and I unpack the damage that causes and why holistic, Christ-centered care is about empowerment, not shame.
"Your biology, psychology, and theology are all divinely connected. You are fearfully and wonderfully made." — Diana
Connect with Dr. Amy O'Donnell:
-
Website: naturesplowpsych.com
-
Licensed in: Florida & Pennsylvania
-
Offering virtual services and relocating to Northeast Florida in 2026
Support the Mission:
Like this episode on YouTube Leave an honest review wherever you listen (Apple, Spotify, etc.) Share it with a friend who's navigating mental health with faith Follow us and tag your insights: @theholisticcounselorpodcast | @throughthevalleytherapy | @transformedmindcc