In 1962, 18 year old Paula Herring was brutally murdered while babysitting her 6 year old brother, and a man went to prison for the crime. Several decades later, however, a man named Michael Bishop stumbled upon some evidence that called that conviction into question and spent the next 20 years learning what really happened that night. 

This episode is sponsored by Care/of. For 50% off your first Care/of order, go to TakeCareOf.com and enter code theywill50.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices