Two young women go missing almost 10 years apart. Kara Kopetsky and Jessica Runions never met in real life, but have a commonality that will forever link them in death. These lives were taken too soon by a familiar face in the community, Kylr Yust. After his 17 year old girlfriend, Kara, goes missing in May of 2007, he comes under suspicion in her disappearance, but it is not until another young woman, 21 year old Jessica, is last seen leaving a party with Yust before disappearing, that further evidence emerges exposing the evil acts of Kylr.
These cases are not wrapped up until 2021, but justice has finally been served and a convicted killer is finally behind bars.