
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


Groundbreaking technology is coming down the pike in the world of impaired driving. In 2021, Congress passed the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act, which included a section on Advanced Impaired Driving Technology. The Act states that "to ensure the prevention of alcohol-impaired driving fatalities, advanced drunk and impaired driving prevention technology must be standard equipment in all new passenger motor vehicles." If you regularly handle DWI cases, then this technology is going to significantly impact your law firm.
Highlights:
· Discover when this technology will be required on all new consumer vehicles.
· Uncover the reasons that Congress has mandated this technology to be developed and implemented.
· Learn about the two types of systems that are in research and development: the breath based system and the touch based system.
· Find out where to get information on this technology so that you can start planning for the impact it will have on your firm.
CHECKPOINTS
State v. Parham, 2022 NCCOA 584 (N.C. App. 2022) (unpublished)
Holding: Signed authorization of a checkpoint by a supervising officer prior to its initiation is irrelevant as long as the supervising officer gives sufficient verbal instruction on how the checkpoint is to be conducted.
Practice tips: (1) focus cross-examination on the specific instructions (verbal or written) being given by the supervisory officer prior to the checkpoint commencing; (2) sequester officers when challenging a checkpoint case.
REASONABLE SUSPICION
State v. Abernathy, 2022 NCCOA 607 (N.C. App. 2022) (unpublished)
Holding: Reasonable suspicion exists to stop a driver travelling under the speed limit in the left lane for a prolonged period causing other vehicles on the highway to pass in the right lane.
State v. Barstow, 2022 NCCOA 368 (N.C. App 2022) (unpublished)
Holding: An officer dispatched to investigate a domestic dispute has reasonable suspicion to stop a vehicle matching the color, make, and model of the one connected to the domestic dispute leaving the subdivision where the domestic dispute occurred.
State v. Bolick, 2022 NCCOA 875 (N.C. App 2022) (unpublished)
Holding: Reasonable suspicion to stop exists based on an anonymous tip where the 911 caller has face-to-face interaction with the Defendant, smells an odor of alcohol, was tailgated by Defendant, gave the make, model, and license plate of Defendant's vehicle, and told the dispatcher which direction the vehicle was travelling.
Practice tip: The Court goes through a lengthy analysis of traffic stops based on an anonymous tip. If you have an anonymous tip case be prepared to distinguish Bolick from your case.
State v. Duncan, 2023 NCCOA 5 (N.C. App. 2023)
Holding: Reasonable suspicions exists if an officer believes that a driver has a medically cancelled license.
State v. Dyer, 2022 NCCOA 880 (N.C. App. 2022) (unpublished)
Holding: No reasonable suspicion exists when a stop is based on Defendant's failure to use a turn signal if no other vehicle will be affected by Defendant's turn.
EXPERT TESTIMONY
State v. Lewis, 2022 NCCOA 887 (N.C. App. 2022) (unpublished)
Holding: Based on the plain language of N.C. Gen. Stat. § 8C-1, Rule 702(a1)(2), an officer who does not hold a currentcertification as a drug recognition expert (DRE) cannot testify that Defendant was under the influence of one or more impairing substances, or the drug category of such impairing substances. [The trial court erred in allowing such testimony, but the Court of Appeals found in this case the error was not prejudicial.]
Practice tip: With the rise of ARIDE officers don't let the state get around the rigid requirements of Rule 702. The opinion is either lay or expert opinion and lay opinion is not allowed in this arena.
RIGHT TO SILENCE
State v. Dunn, 2022 NCCOA 818 (N.C. App. 2022) (unpublished)
Holding: Despite erroneous admission of statements into evidence regarding Defendant's refusal to answer questions after being advised of his Miranda rights, the error was harmless.
BLOOD DRAW
State v. Bobbitt, No. COA22-510 (N.C. App. 2023) (unpublished)
Holding: Medical reports or records created for treatment purposes are not testimonial in nature and as such do not implicate the requirements of the Confrontation Clause.
State v. Cannon, No. COA22-572 (N.C. App. 2023)
Facts: Defendant was involved in a head on collision with another vehicle killing the driver. Investigating officers found beer cans and an aerosol can of "ultra Duster" in Defendant's vehicle. Officers noticed an odor of alcohol on Defendant, slurred speech and glassy eyes. About two hours after the accident, Defendant's blood was taken at the hospital by law enforcement. At the time of the blood draw, no warrant had been issued and no implied consent had been given under N.C.G.S. § 20-16.2.
Holding: Based on the time it took to investigate an accident involving a fatality, the time to transport the Defendant to the hospital, the lack of police assistance for the investigating officers, and the extra time it would have taken to prepare and submit a search warrant, exigent circumstances existed to justify a warrantless search of Defendant's blood.
Practice tip: In distinguishing Cannon, focus on the (1) the fatality investigation; (2) lack of police assistance; and (3) drug impairment case. Cf. State v. Romano, 369 N.C. 678 (N.C. 2017).
SUFFICIENCY OF EVIDENCE
State v. Rouse, 2022 NCCOA 496 (N.C. App. 2022)
Holding: Sufficient circumstantial evidence of driving was presented in this case by the State to avoid a Motion to Dismiss.
SENTENCING
State v. Adams, 2022 NCCOA 845 (N.C. App. 2022)
Holding: N.C.G.S. § 20-179(r) does not authorize a judge to mandate a transfer from supervised to unsupervised probation on the passage of a certain amount of time.
Practice tip: On a level 3, 4 or 5 sentence make sure that the judge is following the mandates of N.C.G.S. § 20-179(r) in requiring supervised versus unsupervised probation.
State v. King, No. COA22-469 (N.C. App. 2023)
Holding: N.C.G.S. § 20-179(a2)(2) requires a jury to decide whether aggravating factors exist.
Practice tip: There appears to be grounds for an argument based on this holding that the statutory framework providing that prior convictions under 20-179(c) fall within the purview of the judge vs. the jury is not permissible and a jury should decide. (One aggravating factor found by the superior court judge in this case was a prior conviction of death by motor vehicle).
DWLR IMPAIRED
State v. Rabas, No. COA22-616 (N.C. App. 2023) (unpublished)
Facts: Defendant was charged with DWI. Immediately upon release, defendant went back to his car and drove away. He was stopped again and charged with a second DWI and DWLR impaired.
Holding: Defendant possessed actual and constructive knowledge that his license was revoked creating sufficient evidence for conviction of DWLR impaired.
A Man for All Seasons, the 1966 film based on the life of Sir Thomas More won six Academy Awards including Best Picture, Best Director, and Best Actor. During the film, Richard Rich, an ambitious young man, is seeking More's assistance in finding a position at Court. More tells Rich that he has found him a teaching position. When More tells Rich that he might be a great teacher, Rich responds despondently "and who would know it." More replies, "You, your pupils, your friends, God. Not a bad public that." In a world where professional success is often scored based on income and generally meaningless awards, it is important to take time to determine what your personal vision of success in life looks like.
On today's episode Jake walks you through, the EOS Personal/Family V/TO which is a tool to help you chart your vision of the future, the person who you hope to be in 10 years. Make sure to download this tool before tunning into today's episode to get the most out of this incredibly important exercise.
An out of state prior DWI or DUI conviction can frequently rear its ugly head in a North Carolina DWI sentencing hearing. Does the prior conviction aggravate or grossly aggravate the sentence? Only if the trial judge finds as a matter of law that the out of state offense involving impaired driving is substantially similar to North Carolina's impaired driving statute. In today's episode we take a deep dive into how substantial similarity is determined and arguments that the defense can make during a sentencing hearing.
Highlights:
· Uncover why focusing on substantial similarity can make a huge difference in your practice given the frequency of this issue popping up.
· Learn how to use the rule of lenity in arguing that another jurisdiction's impaired driving statute is not substantially similar to North Carolina's DWI laws.
· Discover the statutory framework and key cases related to "substantial similarity" in North Carolina and find out why knowing this framework gives you a huge leg up in a sentencing hearing.
· Hear how the state should be arguing this issue and how to hold a ADAs accountable to their burden on this front.
Professional poker great Doyle Brunson once said "poker is war. People pretend it's a game." There are many lessons from the game of poker that can be applied to the Courtroom. If you want to improve your chances of winning in poker, you need to understand the game you are playing. If you want to improve your chances of winning at trial, listen to today's episode.
Highlights:
· Learn how to call the State's bluff before and during trial.
· Understand why keeping your cards (your defense) close to the vest is such a powerful advantage for the defense lawyer in a criminal trial.
· Discover how "counting cards" (using probability) over repeated "hands" (trials) can help you gain a long-term advantage where the art and science of criminal defense intersect.
Leadership guru Jocko Willink advocates taking a position of being default aggressive. In business, Willink describes default aggression not as angry behavior but rather as an attitude of action, an attitude of getting things done. On last week's episode, Rob Heroy discussed how being a professional poker player has made him a better attorney because (to paraphrase) it helped him to develop an attitude of being default aggressive. On today's episode, Jake discusses five benefits for criminal defense lawyers that develop a default aggressive mindset.
Highlights:
· Learn the massive impact that taking cases to trial has on building a lawyer's reputation in the legal community.
· Discover why trust is built with a potential client in the consultation when a lawyer frames the conversation in trial language.
· Uncover the recruiting power of attracting the best and brightest young defense lawyers by creating a trial firm culture.
· Find out why a default aggressive mentality has such a positive impact not only on your defense practice, but in all areas of your life.
On today's episode Jake and guest Rob Heroy discuss a variety of topics, including: law, running, and poker. Rob is a partner at Goodman, Carr, Laughrun, Levine & Greene and is the immediate past President of the Mecklenburg County Criminal Defense Bar. He has taught a number of criminal defense CLEs and taught advanced criminal law courses at the Charlotte School of Law. Being a former assistant district attorney, Rob shares the lessons he learned as a prosecutor with both young ADAs and young defense lawyers.
Highlights:
· Hear Rob's practice tip for how to present your client's case to the assigned ADA.
· Discover how Rob's time as a high-profile poker player has helped him take a position of being default aggressive in the courtroom.
· Learn how Rob has built his network over the years to the point where his firm spends very limited budget on online advertising.
· Listen to Jake and Rob discuss their shared passion of running and the value of finding a passionate hobby for everyone in a high stress profession.
Jake spent part of his weekend volunteering at the Hellbender 100 trail race in Black Mountain. On today's episode, Jake offers his takeaways from working at the aid station and applies them to the practice of law. So many incredible lessons learned from an endurance sport that apply to playing the long game in professional life.
Highlights:
· Hear Jake talk about the importance of inspiring young lawyers and law students to greatness.
· Detach – learn how to step back from the practice and business of law in order to discover lessons that can be used to improve.
· Find out the importance of high frequency mental aid stations.
· Learn why staying at an aid station for too long can create problems and why this is important in the legal profession.
· To avoid burnout, don't blow past a mental aid station when you are on fumes.
· Discover why warriors thrive on competition and why the same should be welcomed with open arms.
On today's episode Jake explores the minutiae of North Carolina's DWI sentencing statute, N.C.G.S. § 20-179. Having previously done a deep dive on the big picture of § 20-179 on Episodes 31-33, Jake looks at the less frequently cited sections of NC's DWI sentencing framework.
Highlights:
· Learn the strict criteria required for a judge to impose supervised probation on a level 3, 4 or 5 sentence.
· Discover when a driver's high speed can be used as an aggravating factor in a DWI sentence and strategies for avoiding multiple license suspensions for your client.
· Uncover the State's notice requirement for GAFs and AFs in Superior Court and how to use lack of notice to your tactical advantage.
Having discussed how to avoid burnout back on Episode 157, Jake looks at the flip side of the coin on today's episode: how to build the dream job as a criminal defense attorney. Do you have a dream law practice? If so, congrats! If not, take a listen to today's episode to get some practical tips on how to create the practice that will fill your cup.
Highlights:
· Finding the mission of your practice is essential to your career fulfillment.
· Don't like the perks of your current position? Create your own!
· Learn how your business goals must mature with your law practice in order to remain fulfilled in your professional life.
· Focus on output, not on income.
From the publisher's feed