In a single night, New Years Eve 1983 to 1984, 16,000 people were reported missing. One of those people was Samuel Todd. A 24 year old student of religion at Yale University in Manhattan, NY. He had been partying all night long with friends and his younger brother, he'd even run into an ex-girlfriend, when he suddenly left the dance floor to... JOG?! Yup, jog. It has been 35 years since that mysterious night and yet, that was the last anyone has seen of him. What the heck happened to Samuel Todd?