The Nonlinear Library

The Nonlinear Library

By The Nonlinear FundEducation
Download on the App Store

All The Nonlinear Library episodes

  • EA - AI Safety Needs Great Product Builders by goodgravy
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: AI Safety Needs Great Product Builders, published by goodgravy on November 2, 2022 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    In his AI Safety Needs Great Engineers post, Andy Jones explains how software engineers can reduce the risks of unfriendly artificial intelligence. Even without deep ML knowledge, these developers can work effectively on the challenges involved in building and understanding large language models.
    I would broaden the claim: AI safety doesn’t need only great engineers – it needs great product builders in general.
    This post will describe why, list some concrete projects for a few different roles, and show how they contribute to AI going better for everyone.
    Audience
    This post is aimed at anyone who has been involved with building software products: web developers, product managers, designers, founders, devops, generalist software engineers, . I’ll call these “product builders”.
    Non-technical roles (e.g. operations, HR, finance) do exist in many organisations focussed on AI safety, but this post isn’t aimed at them.
    But I thought I would need a PhD!
    In the past, most technical AI safety work was done in academia or in research labs. This is changing because – among other things – we now have concrete ideas for how to construct AI in a safer manner.
    However, it’s not enough for us to merely have ideas of what to build. We need teams of people to partner with these researchers and build real systems, in order to:
    Test whether they work in the real world.
    Demonstrate that they have the nice safety features we’re looking for.
    Gather empirical data for future research.
    This strand of AI safety work looks much more like product development, which is why you – as a product builder – can have a direct impact today.
    Example projects, and why they’re important
    To prove there are tangible ways that product builders can contribute to AI safety, I’ll give some current examples of work we’re doing at Ought.
    For software engineers
    In addition to working on our user-facing app, Elicit, we recently open-sourced our Interactive Composition Explorer (ICE).
    ICE is a tool to help us and others better understand Factored Cognition. It consists of a software framework and an interactive visualiser:
    On the back-end, we’re looking for better ways to instrument the cognition “recipes” such that our framework stays out of the user’s way as much as possible, while still giving a useful trace of the reasoning process. We’re using some meta-programming, and having good CS fundamentals would be helpful, but there’s no ML experience required. Plus working on open-source projects is super fun!
    If you are more of a front-end developer, you’ll appreciate that representing a complex deductive process is a UX challenge as much as anything else. These execution graphs can be very large, cyclic, oddly and unpredictably shaped, and each node can contain masses of information. How can we present this in a useful UI which captures the macro structure and still allows the user to dive into the minutiae?
    This work is important for safety because AI systems that have a legible decision-making process are easier to reason about and more trustworthy. On a more technical level, Factored Cognition looks like it will be a linchpin of Iterated Distillation and Amplification – one of the few concrete suggestions for a safer way to build AI.
    For product managers
    At first, it might not be obvious how big of an impact product managers can have on AI safety (the same goes for designers). However, interface design is an alignment problem – and it’s even more neglected than other areas of safety research.
    You don’t need a super technical background, or to already be steeped in ML. The competing priorities we face every day in our product decisions will be fairly familiar to experienced PMs. Here are some example t...
    11 min
  • LW - Far-UVC Light Update: No, LEDs are not around the corner (tweetstorm) by Davidmanheim
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Far-UVC Light Update: No, LEDs are not around the corner (tweetstorm), published by Davidmanheim on November 2, 2022 on LessWrong.
    I wrote a tweetstorm on why 222nm LEDs are not around the corner, and given that there has been some discussion related to this on Lesswrong, I thought it was worth reposting here.People interested in reducing biorisk seem to be super excited about 222nm light to kill pathogens. I’m also really excited - but it’s (unfortunately) probably a decade or more away from widespread usage. Let me explain.
    Before I begin, caveat lector: I’m not an expert in this area, and this is just the outcome of my initial review and outreach to experts. And I’d be thrilled for someone to convince me I’m too pessimistic. But I see two and a half problems.
    First, to deploy safe 222nm lights, we need safety trials. These will take time. This isn’t just about regulatory approval - we can’t put these in place without understanding a number of unclear safety issues, especially for about higher output / stronger 222nm lights.
    We can and should accelerate the research, but trials and regulatory approval are both slow. We don’t know about impacts of daily exposure over the long term, or on small children, etc. This will take time - and while we wait, we run into a second problem; the Far-UVC lamps.
    Current lamps are KrCl “excimer” lamps, which are only a few percent efficient - and so to put out much Far-UVC light, they get very hot. This pretty severely limits their use, and means we need many of them for even moderately large spaces.
    They also emit a somewhat broad spectrum - part of which needs to be filtered out to be safe -/ - further reducing efficiency. Low efficiency, very hot lamps all over the place doesn’t sound so feasible.
    So people seem skeptical that we can cover large areas with these lamps. The obvious next step, then, is to get a better light source. Instead of excimer lamps, we could use LEDs! Except, of course, that we don’t currently have LEDs that output 222nm light.
    (That’s not quite true - there are some research labs that have made prototypes, but they are even less efficient than Excimer lamps, so they aren’t commercially available or anywhere near commercially viable yet, as I’ll explain.)
    But first, some physics! The wavelength of light emitted by an LED is a material property of the semiconductor used. Each semiconductor has a band-gap which corresponds to the wavelength of light LEDs emit.
    It seems likely that anything in the range of between, say, 205-225nm would be fine for skin-safe Far-UVC LEDs. So we need a band-gap of somewhere around 5.5 to 6 electron-volts. And we have options. Here’s a list of some semiconductors and band-gaps;.
    Blue LEDs use Gallium nitride, with a band-gap of 3.4 eV. Figuring out how to grow and then use Gallium nitride for LEDs won the discoverers a Nobel Prize - so finding how to make new LEDs will probably also be hard.
    Aluminum nitride alone has a band gap of 6.015 eV, with light emitted at 210nm. So Aluminum nitride would be perfect. but LEDs from AlN are mediocre./
    Current tech that does pretty well for Far-UVC LEDs uses AlGaN; Aluminium gallium nitride. And when alloyed, AlGaN gives an adjustable band-gap, depending on how much aluminum there is.
    Unfortunately, aluminum gallium nitride alloys only seem to work well down to about 250nm, a bunch higher than 222nm. This needs to get much better. Some experts said a 5-10x improvement is likely, but it will take years.
    That’s also not really enough for the best case, universal usage of really cheap disinfecting LEDs all around the world. It also might not get much better, and we’ll be stuck with very low efficiency Far-UVC LEDs, at which point it’s probably better to keep using Excimer lamps.
    But fundamental research into other semiconductor materials could a...
    7 min
  • EA - Mildly Against Donor Lotteries by Jeff Kaufman
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Mildly Against Donor Lotteries, published by Jeff Kaufman on November 1, 2022 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    Let's say you're going to donate some money, and plan to put some time into figuring out the best place to donate. The more time you put into your decision the better it's likely to be, but at some point you need to stop looking and actually make the donation. The more you're donating the longer it makes sense to go, since it's more valuable to better direct a larger amount of money. Can you get the benefits of the deeper research without increasing time spent on research? Weirdly, you can! About five years ago, Carl Schulman
    proposed (and
    ran the first) "donor lottery".
    Say instead of donating $1k, you get together with 100 other people and you each put in $1k. You select one of the people at random (1:100) to choose where the pool ($100k) goes. This turns your
    100% chance of directing $1k into a 1% chance of directing $100k. The goal is to make research more efficient:
    If you win, you're working with enough money that it's worth it for you to put serious time into figuring out your best donation option.
    If you lose, you don't need to put any time into determining where your money should go.
    This isn't that different from giving your money to GiveWell or similar to decide how to distribute, in that it's delegating the decision to someone who can put in more research. Except that it doesn't require identifying someone better at allocating funds than you are, it just requires that you would:
    Make better decisions in allocating $100k than $1k
    Prefer a 1% chance of a well-allocated $100k to a 100% chance of a somewhat less well-allocated $1k.
    If you come at this from a theoretical perspective this can seem really neat: better considered donations, more efficient use of research time, strictly better, literally no downsides, why would you not do this?
    Despite basically agreeing with all of the above, however, I've not participated in a donor lottery, and I think they're likely slightly negative on balance. There actually are downsides, just not in areas that the logic above considers.
    The biggest downside is that it makes your donation decisions less legible: it's harder for people to understand what you're doing and why. Lets say you're talking to a friend:
    Friend: You're really into charity stuff, right? Where did you decide to donate this year?
    You: I put my money into a donor lottery. I traded my $10k for a 1% chance of donating $1M.
    Friend: Did you win?
    You: No, but I'm glad I did it! Let me explain why...
    There are a few different ways this could go. Your friend could:
    Listen to your explanation at length, and think "this is really cool, more efficient donation allocation, I bet
    EA is full of great ideas like this, I should learn more!"
    Listen to your explanation at length, and think "maybe this works, but it seems like it could probably go wrong somehow."
    Not have time or interest for the full explanation, and be left thinking you irresponsibly gambled away your annual donation.
    I think (b) and (c) are going to happen often enough to outweigh both the benefit (a) and the benefit of the additional research. And this is in some sense a best case: your friend thinks well of you and is likely to give you the benefit of the doubt. The same conversation with someone you know less well or who doesn't have the same baseline assumption that you're an honest and principled person trying to do the right thing would likely go very poorly.
    The other problem with that conversation is that you're not really answering the question! They're trying to figure out where they should donate, and are looking for your advice. Even if they come away thinking your decision to participate in the lottery makes some sense, they're unlikely to decide to participate the first time they...
    6 min
  • EA - Intro Fellowship as Retreat: Reasons, Retrospective, and Resources by Rachel Weinberg
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Intro Fellowship as Retreat: Reasons, Retrospective, and Resources, published by Rachel Weinberg on November 2, 2022 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    Summary
    Introductory EA Fellowships are the default way that EA university groups introduce new members to EA concepts. These ~8-week-long discussion groups have some virtues: they’re scalable, high fidelity, accessible, and not that weird looking. But only 2-10% of students who start an intro fellowship end up engaging with EA afterwards; it feels like we can do better.
    I ran a 4-day retreat to get new people to the same level of EA knowledge as an intro fellowship would, inspired by the ideas in We Need Alternatives to Intro Fellowships and University Groups Should Run More Retreats. I had 8 fellows, 5 of whom were on the intro track and 3 of whom were on the in-depth track, plus 4 facilitators/organizers, and 4 professionals who came up for one day.
    With n=1, it’s hard to draw concrete conclusions, so I’m not intending to sell people on retreats vs. fellowships. Rather, I hope this post helps other group organizers generate ideas about alternatives to intro fellowship, and makes it easy to iterate and improve upon what I did.
    Retreats vs. Intro Fellowships
    Advantages of Retreats
    Here are the main points in favor of retreats, which my experience running this event corroborates:
    Manic retreat magic:
    In Trevor’s words: “Retreats encourage the kind of sustained reflection, one-on-one conversations, and social network construction that actually get people to reevaluate their plans. Most other EA programming occurs in classroom-type settings where people are used to engaging with ideas intellectually but not taking them seriously as action-relevant, life-affecting things.”
    Or, in Duncan Sabien’s terms, retreats make people’s minds muddier—more flexible, open to new ideas.
    The flip side of intro fellowships being “accessible” or “not weird” is that there is no manic magic—instead, people show up, have intellectual debates often in a literal classroom setting, and never seem to realize how life-changing all those ideas would be if they really took them seriously.
    Faster/more interesting for fellows: this is a key point of Ashley’s post and is supported by ~2/10 of my closest engaged EA friends saying they would have never signed up for/made it through an intro fellowship, and wouldn’t have gotten into EA if that was the on-ramp presented to them. Worse, it seems that the most curious/driven/agentic people are most likely to feel this way. Retreats are less likely to lose that demographic.
    Social bonding: People are way more likely to feel drawn to engage with EA more if they have friends there, feel a sense of community there, and doing so lets them talk to people that they like. EA can also be intimidating—probably particularly for minority demographics in EA—so feeling comfortable reaching out/asking “dumb” questions to more highly engaged members of the group seems important. Retreats leave more time for socializing in general, in particular for late night mushy/emotional conversations, and have people together at more vulnerable/less put together times (sleeping in the same rooms, hanging out in PJs, eating all meals together). I felt far closer to these intro fellows after the retreat than I have ever felt to a typical cohort.
    Faster path to doing impactful things: getting people on board in 4 days instead of 8 weeks adds 52 days to their more impactful career.
    One notable thing I did with this retreat was to mix intro fellows with in-depth fellows, university EA organizers, and EA professionals. The advantages of this were:
    Less Dunning-Krueger effect: it’s common for people after the intro fellowship to feel like they understand EA pretty extensively, and having a bunch of in-depth people there shows them what’s comin...
    21 min
  • EA - The "Inside-Out" Model for pitching EA by Nick Corvino
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: The "Inside-Out" Model for pitching EA, published by Nick Corvino on November 1, 2022 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    When trying to pitch EA to someone who cares about local politics, climate change, social justice, being a doctor, or something else that you might not think is highest of EVs, I see most people getting it wrong. They lead off with something like, “well, it seems implausible that extreme climate change will be an existential risk, so you should probably focus on something else instead.” Put yourself in their shoes. If this was the first thing you’d ever heard about effective altruism, would you feel welcomed? I think it frames EA as adversarial and closed-minded, and some people won't give EA another shot.
    I had these types of conversations a lot these when running an EA uni group, and have developed a mnemonic called the Inside-Out Model that I find helpful. Rather than immediately comparing the cause they are interested in with one you think is more impactful, start by applying the EA mindset within their cause, then work your way out.
    For example: “you’re interested in climate change—great! Well, within climate change, it seems like certain interventions are way more effective than others, such as working on green technology or making effective donations.” This gives your conversation a vibe that seems congenial rather than dogmatic. After talking from within their cause area for a bit, transition out, with something like “in fact, in the same way there are more effective interventions than others for combating extreme climate change, there may be more effective causes than climate change altogether.” By this point, hopefully they will listen to your opinion in good faith.
    I think it’s important to keep high-fidelity and not stay on the “inside” for too long. If you think AGI is more important than climate change, don’t roll over on your belly. But maybe wait 30 seconds.
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    2 min
  • AF - Humans do acausal coordination all the time by Adam Jermyn
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Humans do acausal coordination all the time, published by Adam Jermyn on November 2, 2022 on The AI Alignment Forum.
    I used to think that acausal coordination was a weird thing that AI’s might do in the future, but that they certainly wouldn’t learn from looking at human behavior. I don’t believe that anymore, and think there are lots of examples of acausal coordination in everyday life.
    Examples people do
    Voting
    The political science argument against voting goes:
    The probability that my vote tilts the election is tiny, so the expected value to me is tiny, so it’s not worth my time to vote.
    And the standard rebuttal to this is:
    If everyone thought that way democracy would fall apart, so I should vote.
    More precisely, I expect that the people who justify voting on these grounds are doing the following reasoning:
    I’m like the people who share my views in my tendency to vote. That means that there is a correlation between my decision to vote (or not) and the tendency of other people in my coalition to vote (or not). Lots of people who share my views vote, enough to make our collective vote worth my while. So I should vote, so that we all vote and we all win.
    This is an example of acausal coordination! The pro-voting position amounts to reasoning about what other actors with correlated thought processes will do and picking the option which, if each actor does the same reasoning and comes to the same conclusion, leads to a better outcome.
    Recycling/Carbon Footprint Reduction
    The usual argument against recycling/reducing your personal carbon footprint goes:
    I only have control over my environmental impacts. The effect of choosing to reduce these is tiny, so there’s no point in bearing even small costs to do it.
    And the standard rebuttal is:
    If everyone decided to reduce their footprint/recycle/etc. we’d have the problem(s) solved.
    Again, the rebuttal is fundamentally an argument about how to acausally coordinate with other people to achieve a collective goal. Whether or not I recycle is logically connected to whether or not other people who share my reasoning recycle. There are lots of those people, which makes me want to recycle so that they recycle so that we collectively help the environment a significant amount.
    Dieting
    Why do people feel (psychologically) bad when they go over the limits on their diet? I don’t think it’s because they screwed up once, I think it’s because they view their commitment to a diet as a coordination effort between their present and future selves. Specifically, the reasoning goes:
    I couldn’t stick to my diet this time. My ability to stick to my diet is logically connected to the ability of future versions of me to stick to their diets, so by failing to do so now I have failed to coordinate with future versions of myself.
    The most explicit example I’ve seen of this in action is Zvi’s reasoning about diets:
    For each meal I would consume, I decided what quantity was worth it and forbade myself from ever consuming more. I motivated myself to stick to that rule in the face of hyperbolic discounting by reminding myself that I would make the same decision next time that I was making now, so I was deciding what action I would always take in this situation. More generally, sticking to the rules I’d decided to follow meant I would stick to rules I’d decided to follow, which was clearly an extremely valuable asset to have on my side.
    An example people don’t do: paying extra taxes
    As far as I can tell, almost no one voluntarily pays extra taxes. And yet, there is an argument for doing so:
    If everyone decided to pay extra taxes, the government would have more money for services/we could quickly pay down the debt/etc.
    Why does voting coordination work but extra-tax-paying doesn’t? For some people it could be a general disapproval of the things tax dollars p...
    5 min
  • AF - AI X-risk >35% mostly based on a recent peer-reviewed argument by michaelcohen
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: AI X-risk >35% mostly based on a recent peer-reviewed argument, published by michaelcohen on November 2, 2022 on The AI Alignment Forum.
    My recent paper Advanced Artificial Agents Intervene in the Provision of Reward is a prerequisite to this essay (~5800 words; the section on the Assistance Game can be skipped). In that paper, I identify 6 assumptions from which it follows that a sufficiently advanced artificial agent planning over the long-term toward a goal in an unknown environment would cause everyone to die. This essay aims to establish that the probability of such an existential catastrophe is greater than 35% for the purpose of the Future Fund’s AI Worldview Prize.
    In the main part of this essay (~5700 words), I will divide up possible futures and assign credences to these outcomes. In particular, I will assign credences to each of the assumptions from my recent paper. Two appendices follow that can be skipped if necessary. In Appendix A (~7000 words), I review much-discussed proposals from the AI safety research community and explain why they do not solve the problem presented in the paper. In Appendix B (~1300 words), I extend the "Potential Approaches" section from my recent paper to add a class of approaches I hadn't recognized as potentially viable.
    I understand not all arguments will necessarily be read by the Future Fund, so let me briefly argue that this is worth the reader’s time. The antecedent paper is the only peer-reviewed argument that AI X-risk is likely. It has been certified as valid by professional computer scientists who are obviously not just deferring to conventional EA wisdom. My position cannot be accused of merely being tuned to the resonant frequency of an echo chamber. Finally, I am willing to bet up to $500 against someone else's $250 that: conditional on Nick Beckstead confirming he has read my recent paper and this essay, I will win prize money from the Future Fund.
    Section 1. Existentially dangerous levels of capability
    In my previous paper, I only make statements about "sufficiently advanced AI". What this means in clearer terms is AI that is capable enough to take over the world if it wanted to. Taking over the world appears to be hard. I do not claim and I do not expect that merely human-level AI presents any existential risk to us, except through their assistance in creating more advanced AI. Killing everyone requires being impervious to our attempts to shut it off once we notice something is wrong. If we are not able to destroy it, even just with conventional weaponry, that requires taking over our strategically relevant infrastructure, which is what I mean by taking over the world. I'll call an AI that is capable enough to present an existential risk "dangerously advanced AI".
    A note of interpretation: I understand the Future Fund to be asking about the probability that an AI-caused existential catastrophe ever happens conditional on AGI being deployed by 2070, not p(AI existential catastrophe by 2070 | AGI by 2070). So I do not suggest any upper limit on the time it may take to go from human-level AI to dangerously advanced AI.
    Section 2. Outline
    I will identify several possible routes to survival, and assign credences to each. All credences here will be optimistically biased, and they will still imply an X-risk >35%. To get the total chance of survival, I will add up the credences on each of the several routes, as if they are perfectly anti-correlated; this is an optimistic treatment of the correlation between these possibilities. Don't assume my true credences are close to the optimistic ones here. Or that if optimistic credence A > optimistic credence B, then true credence A > true credence B. The optimistic credences are just such that I am willing to spend some time defending them against a more optimistic objector.
    T...
    1 hr 15 min
  • EA - All AGI Safety questions welcome (especially basic ones) [~monthly thread] by robertskmiles
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: All AGI Safety questions welcome (especially basic ones) [~monthly thread], published by robertskmiles on November 1, 2022 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    1 min
  • LW - All AGI Safety questions welcome (especially basic ones) [~monthly thread] by Robert Miles
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: All AGI Safety questions welcome (especially basic ones) [~monthly thread], published by Robert Miles on November 1, 2022 on LessWrong.
    tl;dr: Ask questions about AGI Safety as comments on this post, including ones you might otherwise worry seem dumb!
    Asking beginner-level questions can be intimidating, but everyone starts out not knowing anything. If we want more people in the world who understand AGI safety, we need a place where it's accepted and encouraged to ask about the basics.
    We'll be putting up monthly FAQ posts as a safe space for people to ask all the possibly-dumb questions that may have been bothering them about the whole AGI Safety discussion, but which until now they didn't feel able to ask.
    It's okay to ask uninformed questions, and not worry about having done a careful search before asking.
    Stampy's Interactive AGI Safety FAQ
    Additionally, this will serve as a way to spread the project Rob Miles' volunteer team has been working on: Stampy - which will be (once we've got considerably more content) a single point of access into AGI Safety, in the form of a comprehensive interactive FAQ with lots of links to the ecosystem. We'll be using questions and answers from this thread for Stampy (under these copyright rules), so please only post if you're okay with that! You can help by adding other people's questions and answers to Stampy or getting involved in other ways!
    We're not at the "send this to all your friends" stage yet, we're just ready to onboard a bunch of editors who will help us get to that stage :)
    We welcome feedback and questions on the UI/UX, policies, etc. around Stampy, as well as pull requests to his codebase. You are encouraged to add other people's answers from this thread to Stampy if you think they're good, and collaboratively improve the content that's already on our wiki.
    We've got a lot more to write before he's ready for prime time, but we think Stampy can become an excellent resource for everyone from skeptical newcomers, through people who want to learn more, right up to people who are convinced and want to know how they can best help with their skillsets.
    PS: Based on feedback that Stampy will be not serious enough for serious people we built an alternate skin for the frontend which is more professional: Alignment.Wiki. We're likely to move one more time to aisafety.info, feedback welcome.
    Guidelines for Questioners:
    No previous knowledge of AGI safety is required. If you want to watch a few of the Rob Miles videos, read either the WaitButWhy posts, or the The Most Important Century summary from OpenPhil's co-CEO first that's great, but it's not a prerequisite to ask a question.
    Similarly, you do not need to try to find the answer yourself before asking a question (but if you want to test Stampy's in-browser tensorflow semantic search that might get you an answer quicker!).
    Also feel free to ask questions that you're pretty sure you know the answer to, but where you'd like to hear how others would answer the question.
    One question per comment if possible (though if you have a set of closely related questions that you want to ask all together that's ok).
    If you have your own response to your own question, put that response as a reply to your original question rather than including it in the question itself.
    Remember, if something is confusing to you, then it's probably confusing to other people as well. If you ask a question and someone gives a good response, then you are likely doing lots of other people a favor!
    Guidelines for Answerers:
    Linking to the relevant canonical answer on Stampy is a great way to help people with minimal effort! Improving that answer means that everyone going forward will have a better experience!
    This is a safe space for people to ask stupid questions, so be kind!
    If this post works as intended then...
    5 min
  • EA - Superintelligent AI is necessary for an amazing future, but far from sufficient by So8res
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Superintelligent AI is necessary for an amazing future, but far from sufficient, published by So8res on October 31, 2022 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    1 min