The Nuzzo Letter

The Nuzzo Letter

Download on the App Store

The Nuzzo Letter episodes

  • “What Will Happen When Bobby Knight Dies?” – An Essay That I Never Finished

    For several years, I have had scribbled down in my notes an idea for an essay that I had planned to title, “What will happen when Bobby Knight dies?”

    Obviously, I never got around to writing this essay, and on November 1, 2023, legendary basketball coach Bobby Knight passed away. Here, I want to share some notes that I had written for this unfinished essay. I think the notes will suffice for understanding what the essay was intended to be about.

    In the essay, I was going to present the idea that society is not perhaps adequately replacing iconic male figures, and that the death of Bobby Knight, who is one of these iconic figures, might represent the end of a particular era or generation of men who boys and other men looked up to in awe, admiration, and in interest.

    The reason that I believed that this was an important topic to discuss is because of what has been called the “Boy Crisis,” in which boys and men do not seem to be doing particularly well these days across a number of life outcomes, for example, delinquency, criminality, imprisonment, and a myriad of other issues.

    I was going to explain how the male figure that Knight was – a strict disciplinarian who had a no-non-sense approach to coaching and education and demanded perfection and professionalism from his players – seems harder to find these days. And, I believe it is this sort of man – the man who delivers clear, authoritative, and decisive messages – that is desperately missing throughout various realms of society. Consequently, boys today might be lacking the same type of iconic male figures that someone like me, who was born in the 1980s, had the opportunity to look up to.

    In the essay, I was going to ask readers to think about the various athletes, professional wrestlers, actors, musicians, and politicians that they looked up to as kids. And then I was going to ask who are today’s boys looking up to? Are their heroes as clearly defined as they were for boys like me in the 1980s and 1990s? To me, it seems that we are missing a certain male or masculine energy in society, and that we are surviving primarily on the fumes of that fuel left by the likes of Bobby Knight.

    I was going to ask readers to think about male icons in professional wrestling. In the 1980s and 1990s, professional wrestling was booming and most boys had a favourite wrestler to look up to – Hulk Hogan, Ultimate Warrior, Sting, Bret the Hitman Hart, or Ricky the Dragon Steamboat. But what has become of professional wrestling today? From what I can tell, it is not the mass gathering of male icons that it was 30 or 40 years ago. In fact, some of its more interesting draws have been when they have brought older wrestlers out of retirement, evidence that we are riding on the masculine fumes of a previous generation.

    Then, I was going to ask readers to think about male rock bands. Today, people appear to be clinging to the past, wanting desperately to see the likes of Metallica, Iron Maiden, and AC/DC give it one more go. Yes, attendees are buying tickets because they want to hear the music and experience the spectacle, but they are also wanting to see the faces of those men whose posters use to hang on their wall, and they want to watch those men display their mastery over their instruments.

    Then, I was going to ask readers to think about Hollywood. In the 1980s and 1990s, we had numerous male icons to look up to. We had Sylvester Stallone, Mel Gibson, Tom Cruise, Harrison Ford, Bruce Willis, Arnold, and many others. But who are the young and up and coming male actors of today for boys to look up to?

    In closing, a lot of news and stories are likely to be shared about Bobby Knight over the next several days. Some of this news will frame Knight in a positive light, owing to many of the characteristics that I described earlier. Other news will focus on Knight’s not-so-admirable characteristics, such as his bad temper. Either way, it does not change the fact that an American male icon is now gone. And perhaps his passing can be used as a time for reflection about boys and men and their development and their roles in society. It is hard to imagine the victim culture of today’s university campuses ever taking hold if the likes of Bobby Knight were staffed throughout the university offices and classrooms. Can you imagine an interaction between Bobby Knight and some of today’s entitled campus students? It would be an ugly site for the student.

    So, now that iconic basketball coach Bobby Knight is no longer with us, the question of the essay that I intended to write, “What will happen when Bobby Knight dies?” is no longer appropriate. Now, we have a more pressing question to contemplate: “What will happen now that Bobby Knight is dead?”

    Related Content at The Nuzzo Letter

    SUPPORT THE NUZZO LETTER

    If you appreciated this content, please consider supporting The Nuzzo Letter with a one-time or recurring donation. Your support is greatly appreciated. To donate, click the DonorBox logo. In two simple steps, you can donate using ApplePay, PayPal, or another service. Thank you.

    Thanks for reading The Nuzzo Letter! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.



    Get full access to The Nuzzo Letter at jameslnuzzo.substack.com/subscribe
    8 min
  • Disproportionately Fewer Funds for Men’s Health Research in Australia

    In 2022, American astrophysicist Lawrence Krauss brought international attention to Australia’s National Health and Medical Research Council (NHMRC) by writing an essay in Quillette about the bias against men within the agency. The NHMRC resides within the Australian federal government and is tasked with funding much of the country’s health and medical research. Krauss’ criticism of the agency centred around a new policy that was informed by their Gender Equality Strategy and designed to “address systematic disadvantage faced by female and non-binary applicants to its Investigator Grant scheme.” The NHMRC’s policy is a gender quota system, which was established because applications for Investigator Grants submitted by men were more likely to be funded by the agency than applications submitted by women. The point of Krauss’ essay was to highlight the extent to which such gender quotas discriminate against men.

    Last week, I stumbled across another example of anti-male bias within the NHMRC. This time, the bias was not in regard to the sex of the researcher receiving funds. Instead, the bias was related to Australian demographic groups who are intended to be the beneficiaries of funded research. This information was made available by the NHMRC in a table that they published on their website. The table listed how many millions of taxpayer dollars the agency distributed from 2013 to 2022 for research on Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander health, child health, adolescent health, older adult health, maternal health, men’s health, and women’s health. Here, my purpose is to highlight the substantial difference in funds allocated for research on men’s and women’s health.

    According to the NHMRC, in 2022, $92.3 million Australian dollars were allocated to research on women’s health. By comparison, in that same year, $14.1 million dollars were allocated to research on men’s health. Over the 10-year period presented in the table, the funds allocated to women’s health research ranged from $81 to $100 million dollars per year, with a yearly average of 88.1 million dollars. For men’s health, the funds ranged from $13 to $21 million dollars per year, with a yearly average of $17.5 million dollars. When the funds from 2013 to 2022 were summed, women’s health received $970 million dollars compared to $193 million dollars for men’s health.

    The NHMRC also reports that it has allocated around $50 million dollars per year in the area of maternal health. On the website, the NHMRC does not specify if the funds allocated for maternal health make up part of the total for funds allocated to women’s health. Nevertheless, if funds listed for maternal health are subtracted from funds listed for women’s health, the remaining value, about $40 million per year, is still double that of the funds allocated for men’s health.

    Also, no category for paternal health is presented in the NHMRC’s table, which implies few funds from the agency have been allocated to the study of fatherhood and health. Such research might, for example, examine the impact that fathers have on child health and the impact that children have on fathers’ health. I do not necessarily believe that equal funds should be spent on maternal and paternal health, given that the woman carries the fetus inside her body for many months and then breastfeeds the baby after birth. Nevertheless, the fact that there is no category for paternal health is troubling. It represents a lack of understanding of the importance of a father in a child’s development, a lack of interest in exploring how children impact a man’s life, and how fathers who are engaged with their children are important for society more broadly. And all of this signals back to boys, young men, and older men that their roles in developing healthy offspring are not particularly important. Yet, we know fathers are immensely important, as a substantial body of research has shown that kids raised in single-parent homes have significantly worse behavioural and health outcomes than kids raised in homes with both biological parents present. This research has been summarized in David Popenoe’s book, Life Without Father. 

    Another reason that the NHMRC’s disproportionate interest in women’s than men’s health is concerning is that men have worse outcomes than women for numerous health issues, culminating in shorter life expectancy among males than females in every country in the world. In Australia, the life expectancy difference is 4 years – 81.3 years for males and 85.4 years for females (figure below).

    Some of the causes of earlier death among males than females include suicide, deaths from occupational and motor vehicle accidents, deaths from various types of cancer, deaths from cardiovascular disease, rates of substance use, and much more. Thus, not only is the NHMRC investing less money into men’s than women’s health, but this is occurring over a backdrop of shorter life expectancy among males than females. And imagine for a moment if these data were reversed. Imagine if it were women who were dying four years earlier than men from the various causes that I just listed. There would be national outrage. A day of observation for women would be declared, and numerous offices and committees would be established to promote awareness of and resolve women’s health issues.

    Thus, when it comes to the aim of equity advocates, who seek to create equal health and life outcomes between different demographic groups, their interests and sympathies never seem to extend to men, because if they did, they would acknowledge the life expectancy difference and advocate for action to try to minimize the difference. The fact that equity advocates do not do this reflects either cognitive bias or intellectual and moral bankruptcy. 

    Some individuals might claim that the greater funds allocated for research on women’s than men’s health is incidental. For example, someone might say that the NHMRC is simply funding the projects that are put forward to them and that incidentally these projects just happen to be more focused on women than men. However, such rationale is untenable because it is the NHMRC who sets the research agenda for the country. It is the NHMRC who puts out calls for grant applications on specific research topics. Researchers then respond to these calls.

    Thus, the NHMRC is perhaps the single most important structural factor that can change the proportion of research funds that are allocated to research on men’s and women’s health. As their own data show, they have known of the unequal amounts of NHMRC funds allocated to men’s and women’s health since at least 2013 (and likely much earlier than that). At any time, the NMHRC could change this by prioritizing men’s health in their research agenda and making calls for research projects to help better understand and treat men’s health issues. And perhaps the NHMRC is beginning to listen.

    On October 9th of this year, I was pleasantly surprised to receive notification of a new subscriber to The Nuzzo Letter. The new subscriber was neither an exercise physiologist, an objectivist, a men’s health advocate, nor an anonymous casual reader. Instead, the subscriber was an agency within the Australian government. And with that said, I would like to end this post by welcoming the NHMRC’s communications staff to The Nuzzo Letter. Welcome!

    I hope you find the content interesting and informative. I hope you will comment on posts and engage with other subscribers. And who knows, maybe you will give me some of my taxes back by donating to The Nuzzo Letter. Or, alternatively, you could keep your donation and invest it into research on men’s health.

    Related Content at The Nuzzo Letter

    SUPPORT THE NUZZO LETTER

    If you appreciated this content, and understand that it is very unlikely that the NHMRC will donate to The Nuzzo Letter, perhaps you could consider supporting The Nuzzo Letter with a one-time or recurring donation. Your…



    Get full access to The Nuzzo Letter at jameslnuzzo.substack.com/subscribe
    11 min
  • The Repetitions-%1RM Relationship Updated After 20 years

    I want you to pretend for a moment that today is your first day lifting weights at the gym. You have a hired a personal trainer to create and guide you through a resistance exercise program. In one of your first sessions with your personal trainer, they assess your maximal strength. They do this by testing, what is called, the one repetition maximum or 1RM. The 1RM is the maximal amount of weight that you can lift for a given exercise. For the sake of this example, we will say that your trainer has tested your 1RM on the barbell bench press exercise and found that the maximal amount of weight that you can lift one time is 100 pounds.

    Such strength assessments are conducted by exercise professionals for a couple of reasons. One is to quantify how strong you are at the start of your program and then compare this to how strong you are at the end of weeks or months of training to determine if the exercise prescription was effective at increasing your strength. If your strength increases, this means you and your trainer are on the right track. If your strength remains the same or decreases over that time, the trainer will need to make the necessary adjustments to your future exercise prescriptions.

    A second reason that an exercise professional might assess your 1RM is to have a better understanding of what weights to prescribe to you throughout your training program, particularly for exercise sessions where the trainer might not be available to supervise you. So, just as your physician might prescribe a medication with a specific dosing requirement, your personal trainer should do the same for your prescription of exercise. Your trainer should tell you how much weight to lift and how many repetitions you should be expected to complete when lifting that weight. For example, if your trainer believes that the most effective way to increase your upper-body strength is to have you complete the bench press exercise with a weight equal to 80% of your 1RM, this means that you will exercise with a load equal to 80 pounds, as your 1RM was 100 pounds. But the trainer should also provide you with a sense of how many repetitions you should be expected to complete when lifting this load. But how does the trainer do this? How do they know how many repetitions someone should be expected to complete for a given weight? This is the sort of question that can be answered by the field of exercise science.

    The particular question that we are dealing with here is what is called the repetitions-%1RM relationship.* The repetitions-%1RM relationship is foundational knowledge within resistance exercise programming. This relationship tells personal trainers, strength coaches, and exercise physiologists approximately how many repetitions an individual can be expected to complete when lifting a weight that is a certain percentage of that individual’s 1RM.

    For approximately 20 years, a table of the repetitions-%1RM relationship has been published in a textbook that is assigned to nearly all exercise science students when they learn about the theory and application of resistance exercise. This textbook, which I studied from and cherished as an undergraduate student at Slippery Rock University from 2002 to 2006, is authored by the National Strength and Conditioning Association or the NSCA. The NSCA is an international leader in the dissemination of knowledge on resistance exercise. Any student who seeks to work as a strength and conditioning coach or as a lecturer or professor of resistance exercise will typically be required to pass the NSCA’s coaching certification exam, which will involve memorisation of the table on the repetitions-1RM relationship. 

    The NSCA’s table on the repetitions-1RM relationship, provided below, has two columns (see Table 1). The column on the left lists percentages of the 1RM, ranging from 65% to 100%. The column on the right lists the number of repetitions that an individual can be expected to complete with each relative load, assuming the individual gives their best effort to lift the load as many times as possible. When lifting a heavier load, which is closer to their maximum, the individual is predicted, as you might expect, to perform fewer repetitions than when lifting a lighter load.

    NSCA TABLE OF THE REPS-%1RM RELATIONSHIP

    For example, the personal trainer who prescribed to you a load equal to 80% of your 1RM on the bench press, would, based on the table, predict that you would be able to complete eight repetitions before then failing on your nineth attempt to lift the weight. However, if your personal trainer prescribed a weight equal to 65% of your 1RM, then the table predicts that you would be able to complete 15 repetitions.

    However, various aspects of the NSCA’s table require consideration. First, the table was created from a small number of studies conducted a couple of decades ago. Second, in those studies, and others since that time, there has been some indication that the number of repetitions that an individual can be expected to complete might differ based on the exercise being assessed and characteristics of the individual such as their sex and whether they have previously participated in a weight training program. Finally, the NSCA’s table provides only a point estimate or single number of how many repetitions might be expected. It does not tell you the range of repetitions that an individual might be expected to complete at each relative load.

    With all of this in mind, I chose to lead a research effort designed to re-evaluate the repetitions-%1RM relationship to determine whether the current NSCA table requires an update. My colleagues and I conducted a meta-regression to estimate the number of repetitions that can be completed at various percentages of the 1RM. We also explored if the relationship is moderated by sex, age, training status, and the exercise performed.

    To do this, I searched the entire history of exercise research to find papers that reported results from repetitions-to-failure tests. A repetitions-to-failure test involves study participants being prescribed a given relative load and completing as many repetitions as possible with that load. In total, we identified 952 repetitions-to-failure tests which were completed by 7,289 study participants in 269 different studies, the earliest of which was published in 1961.

    From the data, we were able to update the repetitions-%1RM relationship and generate a new table for students to learn from and for exercise professionals to prescribe exercise from. That table, provided below, includes a new point estimate for each relative load as well as the 95% confidence intervals. Compared to the NSCA’s table, our updated table provides slightly higher estimates for the number of repetitions that can be completed across the loading spectrum. Also, whereas the NSCA’s table provided estimates for loads as low as 65% of the 1RM, our table provides estimates for loads as low as 15% of the 1RM, though we acknowledge that such light loads are rarely used in most training programs and that the accuracy of the estimates generally becomes more imprecise with very light loads.

    NEW MAIN MODEL TABLE

    In our analysis, we found that sex, age, and previous experience with resistance exercise did not significantly impact the number of repetitions that can be expected at various relative loads. However, we found that the repetitions-%1RM relationship is not the same for all exercises. We found that the leg press is unique in this regard. At a given percentage of the 1RM, individuals can complete significantly more repetitions in the leg press exercise than in most other exercises. For example, there was a clear difference between the number of repetitions that could be completed during the leg press compared to the bench press.

    In our hypothetical example, the personal trainer prescribed a weight to you for the bench press equal to 80% of your maximum. From our new table, you would…



    Get full access to The Nuzzo Letter at jameslnuzzo.substack.com/subscribe
    13 min
  • One Million Dollars for Research on “Gender Equity” in Motor Vehicle Accidents

    On September 13th, here on The Nuzzo Letter, I discussed an advertisement for research grants aimed at funding projects in Australia that “address equity issues across the entire higher education student lifecycle.” I explained that the grants were intended to help improve higher education outcomes for six groups. One of the groups was “women in non-traditional areas” while the other groups were based on demographic characteristics that were not gender-specific but that were generally associated with poorer educational outcomes. That men were not considered a cohort of their own in this call for grants was unusual given that in Australia men comprise 43% of university degree earners, and men have earned fewer university degrees than women in Australia for the past two decades. Based on this information, I concluded that the call for grants was evidence of a potential gender bias against men – that is, an inability to recognise male neglect, suffering, or disadvantage.

    Here, I want to introduce another possible example of gender bias against men in research funding. In this example, the research funds have already been awarded.

    In July of this year, the Australian Research Council – a key funder of university research in Australia – announced some of the projects it would be supporting. One of the projects was titled, “Toward equity in crash protection.” The project was awarded $1 million Australian dollars.

    The type of equity being referred to in this project is “gender equity.” This phrase is used almost exclusively to refer to outcomes where women are believed to be behind or neglected and this funded project is not an exception to this trend.

    The stated aim of the project is to explore pathways that cause women to be at increased relative risk for death and serious injury from motor vehicle accidents. From the findings, the researchers plan to recommend interventions or policies that can be implemented to “close this gender gap.”

    You will note that the researchers referred to relative risk of death and injury from motor vehicle accidents. By relative risk, the researchers are referring to death and injury statistics that have been normalized to some other factor, perhaps number of hours driving a vehicle. Expressing data relative to some other potential confounding factor is legitimate but the surrounding context should always be considered. Here, the surrounding context involves consideration of the absolute number of deaths from motor vehicle accidents and the political nature of the research funding process.

    According to the Department of Infrastructure, Transport, Regional Development and Communications, approximately 400 male drivers die each year in Australia in motor vehicle accidents, and that number has remained stable since 2012. For female drivers, the number of annual deaths is about 120 to 150, and that number has gradually decreased since 2012.

    The sex difference in deaths from motorcycle accidents is even greater. Each year, since 2012, approximately 170 to 200 men have been killed driving motorcycles in Australia. The number of women killed each year has been about 10 to 15. Thus, data on absolute numbers of deaths from driving accidents provide an entirely different story about gender equity.

    Both relative and absolute risk data are valid ways of reporting study results. Together, they form a complete understanding of injury epidemiology. However, in the case of research into sex differences in motor vehicle accidents, it is unclear why the absolute number of deaths would also not be framed as a “gender inequity” or a “gender gap.” In other words, why does relative risk take precedence over absolute risk, when total body count is perhaps what should be of most concern given the topic at hand?

    In my opinion, gender bias and a feminist academic culture, which exacerbates this bias by incentivizing researchers to de-contextualize data to obtain research funds, is the reason that the relative risk data has taken precedence in this research. The way that this research has been framed appears to be an example of what Seager and Barry have called “gamma bias,” which is a type of gender bias in which men’s issues are minimized, while women’s issues are emphasized.

    Gamma bias has practical consequences. By minimizing absolute risk, researchers minimize men’s health issues. Also, the factors used to normalize data to be relative risk should not be overlooked, as they can reveal insights into the male experience, including the good that men bring to society. For example, though more motor vehicle deaths among men than women can be attributed, in large part, to particular driving behaviours among men, such as speeding and driving under the influence of alcohol, men also drive longer distances, spend more time driving, and drive more frequently at night. Men are also more likely to drive during inclement weather due to their higher levels of comfort and confidence in driving in such conditions. Thus, though poor decision making contributes to more male than female deaths while driving, men also undertake more of the overall societal workload associated with driving. This includes driving taxis and Ubers, driving big rigs on long hauls, and driving the family on vacations and during blizzards. Moreover, to the extent that a researcher argues that a woman’s increased relative risk for injury is due to cars and their features being designed more for the average male than female body, this, if true, would make sense, given that men spend more time behind the wheel.

    In closing, the one million dollars granted by the Australian Research Council on the topic of gender equity in crash protection might help to better understand factors that put women at greater relative risk in motor vehicle accidents. And perhaps this will lead to solutions that reduce this risk. My concern here is that the misguided focus on “gender equity” throughout all of science is leading to the prioritization of female over male flourishment. I am not trying to throw a pity party for men. I am simply trying to highlight potential biases in thinking around the topic of gender and health, which, when practiced repeatedly on a large scale, can have compounding and regrettable effects.

    For example, do you remember that at the outset of this presentation I mentioned the research grant that was advertised to improve equity issues in education? Do you remember that this advertisement did not express an explicit concern about male students, but it did express a concern about female students, though women earn more significantly more degrees than men? Well, if academia was more interested in the male experience, perhaps funds could be awarded for programs designed specifically to teach young men about driving knowledge, skills, behaviours, and risks. Sadly, in the current academic climate of gender equity, such programs do not appear to be a priority. This is terribly unfortunate, not just for the young man who might benefit from this education, but also for the first responder, who will need to peel the man’s body from the pavement.

    Related Content at The Nuzzo Letter

    SUPPORT THE NUZZO LETTER

    If you appreciated this content, please consider supporting The Nuzzo Letter with a one-time or recurring donation. Your support is greatly appreciated. It helps me to continue to work on independent research projects and fight for more evidence-based discourse. To donate, click the DonorBox logo. In two simple steps, you can donate using ApplePay, PayPal, or another service. Thank you.

    Thanks for reading The Nuzzo Letter! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.



    Get full access to The Nuzzo Letter at jameslnuzzo.substack.com/subscribe
    10 min
  • Women’s Studies – On the Rise or Fading Away?

    The field of women’s studies, sometimes called gender studies, concerns itself with the lives and experiences of girls and women. It is defined by the National Center for Education Statistics in the United States as:

    “A program that focuses on the history, sociology, politics, culture, and economics of women, and the development of modern feminism in relation to the roles played by women in different periods and locations in North America and the world. Programs may focus on literature, philosophy, and the arts as much as on social studies and policy.”

    This is a forgiving definition, given that feminist academics tend to define the field in more radical ways and that the field is often criticized for its ideological biases. Women’s studies is also rightly criticized for its lack of empiricism, its questionable methodologies and interpretations, and its conflation of scholarship with political activism. The field is also known for propagating unsubstantiated ideas about boys and men, such as “male privilege” and “toxic masculinity” – ideas that hinder a true understanding of the male experience and render male empathy impossible.

    Though complaints about the quality of information delivered in women’s studies programs are made regularly within and outside of academic circles, data regarding the field, such as its popularity and growth, are not readily available but could be informative. For example, data on degrees earned over a certain period might serve as a proxy for understanding trends in feminist ideas in the broader mainstream culture.

    So, I decided to collate data from the National Center for Education Statistics on the number of bachelor’s, master’s, and doctorate degrees awarded in the field of women’s studies in the United States between the 2002 and 2019 academic school years.

    The data reveal that between 2002 and 2011, there was a steady increase in the number of bachelor’s degrees awarded in women’s studies. In 2002, 904 bachelor’s degrees were awarded in women’s studies. In 2011, 1,490 bachelor’s degrees were awarded in the field.

    After 2011, there was a slight decrease in number of degrees awarded followed by a plateau, such that, over the past 10 years, approximately 1,400 bachelor’s degrees have been awarded in the field of women’s studies annually.

    Over the entire 18-year period from 2002 to 2019, the sum of all bachelor’s degrees awarded in women’s studies in the United States was 23,210. The sum of all master’s degrees awarded was 2,915, with approximately 170 master’s degrees awarded each year. The sum of all doctorate degrees was 319, with approximately 20 doctorate degrees awarded annually.

    Unsurprisingly, women have comprised the vast majority of degree earners in women’s studies. Over the 18-year period, 95% of bachelor’s degrees in the field have been awarded to women. Nevertheless, this proportion has changed over time due to increased numbers of men completing such programs. In 2002, women comprised 99% of all bachelor’s degree earners in women’s studies, but by 2019, this number had dropped to 93%.

    The total number of degrees earned annually in women’s studies pales in comparison to many other fields. For example, the number of bachelor’s degrees awarded in engineering, psychology, biology, and accounting in 2019 were all over 40,000 each, and many degree programs have grown over this 18-year period. Thus, women’s studies remains on the fringes of academia in terms of enrolment numbers, but the ideas taught in these programs continue to have a large impact on broader culture.

    A couple limitations of the data are also worth mentioning:

    ·      First, the data represent degrees awarded. They do not reflect enrolment, nor do they account for dropouts. The data also do not represent the number of courses on women’s studies offered at universities. Thus, the data do not represent the total number of students who are introduced to ideas from women’s studies programs. Some students in other academic majors might take a women’s studies class as a secondary part of their coursework; such exposures are not accounted for in these data.

    ·      Second, the data are specific to the United States. Women’s and gender studies programs are offered at universities in many different countries. Thus, the data may not necessarily reflect global trends in the field.

    ·      Third, not all universities in the United States are reflected in the data. Only universities who participate in Title IV federal financial aid program are required to make these data available to the National Center for Education Statistics. Nevertheless, this is unlikely to significantly impact data related to women’s studies programs because institutions that do not take federal money are typically small, private, and religious institutions, and women’s studies programs are less likely to be offered at such institutions.

    ·      Finally, the data represent degrees categorized by the National Center for Education Statistics as “women’s studies.” The Center also lists degrees for a category called, “ethnic, cultural minority, gender, and group studies.” Approximately 800 bachelor’s degrees in this category are awarded each year. Students in these programs might receive an educational experience similar to that of students enrolled in women’s studies programs. However, such students are not accounted for in the data I have summarized.

    To conclude, the number of degrees awarded in the field of women’s studies in the United States has levelled off in recent years following a steady rise between 2002 and 2011. The cause of the plateau is uncertain. Perhaps word has gotten around that a degree in women’s studies is not particularly useful for gaining employment after graduation? Perhaps women are not enrolling in, or are dropping out from, women’s studies programs because they do not want to be lied to about human nature or their own common sense? Or perhaps the cause of the levelling off in degrees earned is something different altogether?

    Either way, given that men comprise 50% of the population, and given that the mere existence of the field of women’s studies implies that men and women are not the same, one might then be interested to know whether trends in degrees earned in men’s studies are similar to those summarized here in women’ studies. Such a comparison might inform us of changes in interests in men’s and women’s issues over time. This comparison, however, is not possible. And the reason it is not possible is because the total number of degrees awarded in the field of men’s studies in the United States between the years 2002 and 2020 was zero.

    Related Content at The Nuzzo Letter

    SUPPORT THE NUZZO LETTER

    If you appreciated the time it took to retrieve and organise these data from government spreadsheets, design them into a graph, and then present them in a fairly coherent way, then please consider supporting The Nuzzo Letter with a one-time or recurring donation. Your support is greatly appreciated. It helps me to work on independent research projects such as this one. To donate, click the DonorBox logo below. In two simple steps, you can donate using ApplePay, PayPal, or another service. Thank you.

    Thanks for reading The Nuzzo Letter! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.



    Get full access to The Nuzzo Letter at jameslnuzzo.substack.com/subscribe
    10 min
  • Australian Research Grant for Equity in Higher Education Ignores Men

    Recently, while searching for research grants to support my own projects, I came across a call for grant applications advertised by the National Centre for Student Equity in Higher Education (NCSEHE). This is an organisation housed within Curtin University in Perth, Western Australia.

    The call for grants was termed the Small Grants Research Program. A total of 13 grants valued at $30,000 to $50,000 Australian dollars could be applied for. According to the advertisement, the program “fund[s] proposals that address equity issues across the entire higher education student lifecycle.”

    The organization listed six groups that their funds could be used to target in terms addressing equity issues in higher education. The groups were as follows:

    1.     First Nations Australian students

    2.     Low socioeconomic students

    3.     Students with disabilities

    4.     Students from regional and remote Australia

    5.     Students from non-English speaking backgrounds

    6.     Women in non-traditional areas

    On one hand, it was refreshing to see that most of the groups listed were not sex- or gender-specific but were based on characteristics associated with low educational outcomes and could be applied equally to men and women. This is how it should be. However, here, my aim is to highlight the gender bias against men exhibited by this call for grants. It is a bias via omission.

    Given that the grant is focused on equity, this implies that the overriding purpose, as misguided as it might be, is to create equal educational outcomes between groups. However, we know that the organization’s professed interest in equity is disingenuous because, as of 2021, men comprised 43% of university graduates in Australia, according to the Department of Education. In fact, men have comprised a significantly lower number of university graduates in Australia for over two decades. And just imagine if these data were reversed. Imagine if it was women, who comprised 43% of graduates. Such a statistic would cause a national outrage. It would result in significant resources being poured into community programs and university research to try to get the ratio up to 50/50. Moreover, the county would probably also declare some sort of day, week, or month of observance for the cause of women’s education. And we know that this would be the case because currently, although women earn more university degrees than do men, there are relentless efforts to increase numbers of female graduates in specific higher education fields, such as science, technology, engineering, and mathematics – i.e., the STEM fields. In fact, the call for grants includes a target group called “women in non-traditional areas.” This likely refers to women in STEM fields. Thus, not only were men not included as a target group, when the professed philosophy of equity should warrant them as a target group, but the organization still found a way to make a specific call for more research into women’s education. And to the extent that such research does lead to more women completing degrees in STEM fields, the existing difference in total degrees earned between men and women would be exacerbated.

    Here, my point has not been so much to advocate for targeted approaches for increasing educational outcomes in men, although this would not be the worst idea in the world. Instead, I am simply pointing out the unrelenting gender bias that exists against boys and men, such that even when the data are undeniably clear, such as the consistently lower proportion of men than women completing university degrees, men are still ignored as a cohort of humans who might need some attention. This is the same bias that exists when public health researchers conveniently ignore the life expectancy difference that exists between men and women.

    One reason why I am not so keen on equity approaches is because we do not necessarily know the full details behind why there are fewer male than female university graduates. For example, one contributing factor might be that men are giving the middle finger to the ivory tower of academia, which tries to tell men how “privileged” and “toxic” they are. Thus, men may be consciously walking away from or never entering universities because they have weighed up their options and determined that their lives will be better off if they do not hang around university campuses. If this is the case, and these men are correct in their cost-benefit analyses, then they should be commended for reading the room, and getting the hell out of dodge. However, at this stage, we do not have a complete understanding of why, over the past couple of decades, there have been significantly fewer men than women graduating from universities in both Australia and the United States. But we could find out more quickly, if there were research grants available to study such things.

    Related Content at The Nuzzo Letter

    SUPPORT THE NUZZO LETTER

    If you appreciated this content, please consider supporting The Nuzzo Letter with a one-time or recurring donation. Your support is greatly appreciated. It helps me to continue to work on independent research projects and fight for more evidence-based discourse. To donate, click the DonorBox logo. In two simple steps, you can donate using ApplePay, PayPal, or another service. Thank you.

    Thanks for reading The Nuzzo Letter! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.



    Get full access to The Nuzzo Letter at jameslnuzzo.substack.com/subscribe
    8 min
  • The Time I Stopped a Perth Criminal

    In June of this year, I entered the Joondalup Shopping Centre in Perth, Western Australia to grab a couple of groceries on my way to work. I entered from the south entrance. I walked down the southern corridor toward one of the food courts at the centre of the mall. The food court serves as a sort of four-way intersection for mall traffic. As I approached the intersection, I could see a man walking through the food court from the western corridor to my right. The man was thin, White, tall, and his 30s or 40s. He was walking erratically and not wearing a shirt.

    In Perth, seeing a thin man with shirt off in a public is not necessarily unusual given that the city has a surf and beach lifestyle. However, we were several miles away from the nearest beach, and June is winter in Perth.

    As the man passed through the mall intersection, he pulled on his pants to keep them from falling. I then turned left at the intersection, meaning that he and I were both now walking down the eastern corridor. The man was approximately 20 yards in front of me, with a woman halfway between us.

    As I continued to down the eastern corridor, I kept my eyes on the man. He was still moving erratically and catching glances from many people. Part of me wanted to approach the man and reprimand him for not having a shirt on in the middle of a mall. But I said nothing. I did not think it was my responsibility.

    A few steps later, I saw the man dart to the left into a store. Within a matter of seconds, the man re-appeared. But now he was wearing a sweatshirt. He had stolen it from the store. The tag was dangling off the back.

    My pulse accelerated, and I began to walk faster. As often happens in such scenarios, I was shocked at what I had just seen. It certainly is not every day that you see someone steal so blatantly from a store. I thought that a worker might soon appear from the store and go after the man. At minimum, I thought that a worker might at least yell at him. But none of that happened.

    Many thoughts raced through my mind. “What should I do? Should I grab the man from behind to stop him? Should I tackle him to the ground? What if he has a knife? Is it worth risking damage to myself over all this? Where is mall security? Isn’t this their job?”

    The man then entered the next food court intersection. He steered off toward one of the café stands; he appeared to be looking to steal some food from their countertop. However, all of their food was under cover and so he kept walking in the direction where I was also heading. Meanwhile, the woman who was in front of me approached the café attendant and warned of the man and his intentions.

    I saw the man turn the corner toward the grocery store, but by the time I turned the corner, he was gone. Near the grocery store was a narrow hallway that led to facility maintenance rooms. That’s where I thought the man went. I thought he might be trying to hide in one of the rooms.

    However, to my surprise, as I approached the entrance of the grocery store, the man was walking out of the store directly at me. He was holding a plastic container of strawberries. The container was open and he was eating the strawberries.

    Over the man’s shoulder, I could see packages of strawberries positioned in an open refrigerator at the front of the store. The man had stolen the strawberries.

    As the man approached me, I tossed my laptop bag behind my waist and pointed my finger at him, “Hey,” I yelled, “what are you doing with those? I just saw you steal them. I saw you steal that sweatshirt too.”

    The man’s response was not what I was expecting. He did not pull knife; he did not try push or punch me; and he did not try to run. He did not even try to argue with me. He submitted – immediately and completely, he submitted.

    The man quickly extended his hands so that I could take the strawberries from him. He then put his hands behind his back. He thought I was there to arrest him.

    Near the entrance to the grocery store, there was a bench against a wall. I told the man to sit there and then ordered one of the female staff in the grocery store to call security. I quickly informed her of what I had seen – from the stolen sweatshirt to the stolen strawberries. As I handed the strawberries to the woman, she tried to ask me more questions, which, under the circumstances, were unnecessary. I told her bluntly, “I don’t know. Just call security. Get them here now.” The woman listened.

    I went back to the bench where the man was still sitting, submissive. I then noticed a large scab on his bald head – who knows how it go there.

    It did not take long for me to realise that the man was mentally unwell. I could not tell whether the man was high on drugs or whether he had a longstanding mental health issue or both. Regardless, the man was fidgety and rubbed his head and grabbed various parts of his body as scattered comments came from his mouth. At times he came across as potentially dangerous, at other times, he came across as entirely feeble. He apologized to me on multiple occasions. And to his credit, the man remained seated on the bench. I told him that help was coming, though I knew it was security, not a mental health professional, who was on his way.

    Eventually, the security attendant arrived. The attendant was probably in his 20s, around 5’5’’ and 130 pounds. He appeared timid, as if it were his first day on the job. I quickly debriefed him on the situation and said, “Call your friends. Call your backup. This guy is unwell.”

    The attendant demonstrated a level of hesitation and incompetence, which seems all to prevalent in such positions these days. The attendant barely asked me any questions. And although he was, in theory, the one with the greatest power in the scenario, he came across as weakest and most lax and naïve. Rather than make the man continue to sit there and wait for a police officer to arrive, the attendant decided he would walk casually with the unwell and potentially dangerous man back to the store to return the sweatshirt. As the two of them headed off, I realised that my job was done, although I did not necessarily want it to be. “What was going to happen to the man? Would he be held accountable for his actions? What will be done about his mental health? What about the security attendant? Is he really going to be able to keep mall shoppers safe from a guy like this?”

    Nevertheless, I quickly accepted the circumstances, and that I had done all that one might be expected to do. It was now someone else’s responsibility. I went into the grocery store and bought the food I had intended to buy. After a couple of minutes in the store, I then followed the path back to where I had entered the shopping centre. As I approached the store where the man had stolen the sweatshirt, I could see the man was sitting on a customer couch in front of the store and the middle of the corridor. The security attendant was there and so was a uniformed police officer.

    To end, I want to tell you about a part of the story that I skipped over. It has to do with what the man and I were talking about as we waited for the security attendant to arrive. During that period, my goal was to keep the man distracted; to talk to him about anything, just so that he would stay seated and subdued, buying more time for security to arrive. At certain points in our chat, bits of conscientiousness and thoughtfulness seeped out from the man’s otherwise irrational thoughts. At one point, he said something about the importance of family, and he also briefly mentioned something about kids, perhaps his own. Then, as the man found himself wandering back into another state of confusion, he screamed out, “What is going on right now? Where am I? What is happening?”

    The grown man then crawled into a figurative fetal position and yelled aloud, “Mommy, mommy! Where is my mommy?”

    As I watched the police officer place cuffs around the man’s wrist as I walked by the couch, I remembered the man’s call for his mother and thought to myself, “Why di…



    Get full access to The Nuzzo Letter at jameslnuzzo.substack.com/subscribe
    10 min
  • Feminism’s Negative Impact on Men’s Health

    In the United States, life expectancy for men is 5.9 years less than it is for women. A number of factors contribute to this sex difference. Deaths from cardiovascular disease, cancer, and occupational and motor vehicle accidents are all more common among men than women. Men are also more likely to use alcohol, tobacco, and other drugs, leading to greater lifetime prevalence of drug-use disorder. Men are also more likely to end their own lives. Seventy-nine percent of all suicides in the United States are committed by men.

    Given these health data, along with greater prevalence rates of a myriad of other health conditions and negative life outcomes among men than women (e.g., homelessness, criminality, lower educational attainment, antisocial personality and conduct disorders, autism spectrum disorder, and attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder) one might expect significant and explicit attention directed by universities and state and national health offices toward boys’ and men’s health. Yet, this has not been the case. Why not?

    A major contributing factor is feminism. Feminism, which is often ill-defined, tends to refer to a set of ideas concerned with the advancement and equal treatment of women in society, culminating in greater female autonomy and power, achieved through political activism. Though some feminists from earlier generations might have had some laudable goals, contemporary feminism is associated with an epistemological framework that often distorts reality and produces some of the most incoherent writings in academia. Here, I suggest multiple pathways by which feminism is negatively impacting boys’ and men’s health.

    Feminism has led to false and damaging narratives about men and masculinity. “Male privilege” is one example. Men are more likely than women to be homeless, and 8% of men report being sexually abused before the age of 18. How then are homeless men or sexually-abused boys privileged? Feminists do not have good answers to such questions because “male privilege” is an a priori assumption that is made without going through empirical, data-driven, and inductive processes, which would lead to a conclusion that both men and women can be victims and can experience hardship.

    “Toxic masculinity” is another example. Dr. John Barry of the Centre for Male Psychology in the United Kingdom surveyed individuals about their opinions on toxic masculinity. Most respondents said the concept is probably harmful to boys and men and unlikely to improve health behaviours. In a followup study, Barry found that poorer mental wellbeing was associated with the belief that masculinity negatively influences behaviour.

    Feminism can also alter clinical treatment of boys and men. One study found that psychotherapist’s views of masculinity and patriarchy correlated with their clinical approaches. Moreover, the Guidelines for Psychological Practice with Boys and Men, published by the American Psychological Association in 2018, showed signs of a substantial feminist influence. Some of the guidelines were interpreted by experts as sensible, but other guidelines, such as those suggesting that masculinity is primarily a social construct, and that men’s mental health problems are caused by masculinity and patriarchy, received criticism. That the Guidelines expressed negative views of masculinity, and that the concept of “male privilege” was referenced throughout the document, illustrates how feminist concepts influence mental health services provided to boys and men.

    Feminism has also changed the way that research is organized, conducted, and funded. In 1990, the Office for Research on Women’s Health was created within the National Institutes of Health (NIH). The major original goal of this office was to increase the number of female participants in NIH-funded clinical trials. This goal was based on the claim that women were systematically excluded and thus underrepresented as participants in medical research. This claim was later found to be untrue, and annual reports from the Office show that women comprise 55-60% of all participants in NIH-funded clinical trials every year. Moreover, after 30 years of existence, the Office for Research on Women’s Health still states that the inclusion of women in clinical trials is one of its top priorities. Meanwhile, no equivalent office for research on men’s health has been created, though men fare worse than women on various health outcomes, culminating in earlier mortality.

    Because of its negative views of men and masculinity, feminism has also prevented widespread recognition of fathers and family structure as social factors that impact a child’s development. This is somewhat ironic given the push for research and action on the “social determinants of health” over the past 20 years. In 2005, the World Health Organization established a Commission on Social Determinants of Health. The goal of the Commission was to put forward evidence for a global “health equity” agenda. This agenda, which is still active, is grounded in environmental determinism and minimizes the roles of biology and personal choice in health outcomes. It advocates for social engineering of health outcomes via public policy. However, due to the politicized nature of this agenda, family structure has not been listed as a key “social determinant.” Its omission is indefensible given the substantial literature that shows children from fatherless homes generally have poorer health outcomes than children raised in two-parent households where the biological father is present. Family structure has been omitted from this discourse because its inclusion would require feminist-minded public health researchers to acknowledge that (a) fathers and their masculinity generally have a positive influence on a child’s development, and (b) a structural or social factor that is not government-based or controlled (i.e., the fatherless home) has consistent and significant impacts on health.

    Feminism has also led to blatant discrimination against boys and men. One of the most egregious examples comes from the World Economic Forum and its Global Gender Gap Index. This index, which purports to measure gender equality, penalizes a country’s index score only when girls and women fall behind on various domains. It does not penalize a country’s score when boys and men fall behind. Similar discrimination against boys and men has been found to occur at the United Nations, which has a feminist branch called UN Women. The United Nations does not have branch that represents the issues facing boys and men. Moreover, in the United Nations’ and World Health Organization’s report on the social determinants of health, an entire chapter was dedicated to “gender equity” in health, without mention of boys and men.

    Has feminism perhaps also done some good for men’s health? If this is the case, the results are not obvious and are unlikely to balance the harms already mentioned. At a surface level, the push for increased paternal leave might be seen as something good done for men from somewhat feminist-minded individuals. Increased paternal leave probably is good for fathers. However, the main motivator for feminist-minded individuals who champion increased paternal leave is not necessarily to facilitate the bond between the father and baby but to relieve mothers of their unpaid work as caregivers. This is a subtle yet important philosophical difference. It is the difference between the gynocentric and androcentric approaches to men’s health.

    Contemporary feminism is preventing objective recognition of male suffering, disadvantage, and neglect. It is exacerbating the male gender empathy gap. The list of topics and pathways I have provided is not exhaustive. It does not include, for example, false allegations of rape against men or the continued lack of recognition of roughly similar rates of male and female victimization in intimate …



    Get full access to The Nuzzo Letter at jameslnuzzo.substack.com/subscribe
    10 min
  • Sex Differences in Muscle Fibre Types

    The muscles that make up your body are composed of individual muscle fibres. Think of the biceps muscle of your arm as a handful of spaghetti strands. Each strand of spaghetti represents a long muscle fibre that runs from the front of your shoulder to the inner crease of your elbow. However, not all spaghetti strands are necessarily the same, nor are all of the muscle fibres that make up your biceps muscles or other muscles of your body.

    Skeletal muscle fibres differ from each other based on their biochemical and physiological properties. Based on such properties, skeletal muscles have historically been categorized as two general types: Type I slow-twitch fibres and Type II fast-twitch fibres. Type II muscle fibres are called “fast-twitch” because they shorten at high velocities and create large power and force outputs. Type I fibres, on the other hand, are called “slow-twitch” because they shorten at slow velocities and create low forces and low power outputs.

    However, there is a trade-off. Type II fibres, though strong and powerful, fatigue more quickly than do Type I fibres, which are known for their ability to create low levels of force for long periods. Marathon runners, for example, are known to have high proportions of Type I muscle fibres, whereas 100-meter sprinters and other power athletes are known to have high proportions of Type II muscle fibres. The way that muscle fibre type is determined is by having a biopsy or small chunk of tissue taken from one’s muscle and then treated chemically.

    For many years, researchers have speculated that proportions of Type I and Type II muscle fibres might be different in the average man versus the average woman. Remarkably, though biopsies of skeletal muscles have been acquired from men and women in research studies since the 1970s, the available data have never been aggregated to determine if the average man and woman differ in their muscle fibre types. Such information could help to inform discussions about sex differences in sports performance and susceptibility to disease. 

    This is why earlier this year I performed a meta-analysis of the existing data on muscle fibre types in men and women. I discovered that between 1976 and 2022 a total of 110 studies reported muscle fibre type data from both male and female participants. The number of studies included in the analysis was 3-4 times greater than two previous narrative reviews on the topic – one of which was my own.

    Data from 2,875 men and 2,452 women were included in the analysis. Most of the data were collected in the United States, Canada, and Scandinavian countries. Most of the participants in the included studies were healthy non-athletes who were between the ages of 18 and 59. The vastus lateralis muscle, which makes up the outer part of the thigh, was the muscle most frequently biopsied.

    The results revealed many sex differences. Compared to women, men had a greater a percentage of Type II or fast-twitch muscle fibres. Women, on the other hand, had a greater percentage of Type I or slow-twitch fibres. One of the measures of Type I fibres showed that, on average, 53.2% of female muscle is comprised of Type I fibres compared to 50.6% of male muscle. A second measure of Type I fibres showed an even larger sex difference.

    When considering the area or space of muscle occupied by different fibre types, sex differences were even more evident. That is, a greater area of male than female muscle was composed of Type II fibres, and a greater area of female than male muscle was composed of Type I fibres. For one of the measures of Type I fibres, the percentage area of a woman’s muscle composed of Type I fibres was 54.8% compared to 49.3% for men. Consequently, the ratio of Type I to Type II muscle fibre area was greater in women than men, and the ratio of Type II to Type I muscle fibre area was greater in men than women.

    Finally, the meta-analysis also revealed large sex differences in the raw cross-sectional areas or sizes of the muscle fibres. These large differences were observed for all muscle fibre types that were assessed.

    So, what do the results mean? What are their implications?

    The results could have implications for understanding sex differences in physical abilities, including in sports and in physically demanding occupations. Compared to women, men have a greater proportion of Type II muscle fibres, and men have larger cross-sectional areas for all muscle fibre types. This helps to explain how men are stronger and more powerful than women and how the average man is typically more successful at completing certain physical tasks in sports and at work.

    The results might also have implications for understanding sex differences in aging and development. For example, aging is known to disproportionally impact Type II fibres. Men have greater proportions of Type II fibres. Thus, men and women might be differently impacted by the aging process. In fact, a preliminary analysis in the study found that the sex differences in proportions of Type I and Type II muscle fibre types were greatest in young and middle-aged adults but then mostly disappeared in adults over the age of 60.

    Also, certain diseases differently impact certain muscle fibre types. For example, Duchenne muscular dystrophy predominantly impacts Type II fibres and is a condition found primarily in boys. Other conditions, such as spinal cord injury, diabetes, heart disease, and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease cause Type I muscle fibres to transition to be more like Type II muscle fibres. How sex differences in muscle fibre types might associate with disease susceptibility and severity is something to be teased out in future research.

    In closing, the recent meta-analysis on sex differences in muscle fibre types represents the largest repository of comparative muscle fibre type data from living men and women that has ever been assembled. The data show that, compared to women, men between the ages of 18 and 59 have greater cross-sectional areas of individual muscle fibres than do women, and men also have a greater percentage of Type II fast-twitch muscles fibres than do women. The implications of these findings for sex differences in aging and disease susceptibility remain to be understood. The implications for sports performance, however, are perhaps clearer. Larger whole muscle size, larger muscle fibre size, and greater proportions of Type II muscle fibres are just a couple of the many ways in which biological males, including transgender women, are naturally advantaged over biological females in the female category of sport. How muscle fibre types are or are not impacted by medical treatments administered to transgender individuals is a research topic to pay attention to in the coming months and years.

    Related Content at The Nuzzo Letter

    SUPPORT THE NUZZO LETTER

    If you enjoyed this content, please consider supporting The Nuzzo Letter with a one-time or recurring donation. It helps me to work on independent research projects such as this meta-analysis. To donate to The Nuzzo Letter, click the DonorBox logo below. In two simple steps, you can donate to The Nuzzo Letter using ApplePay, PayPal, or another service. Your support is greatly appreciated. A full-text copy of the paper is available at the provided link.

    Thanks for reading The Nuzzo Letter! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.



    Get full access to The Nuzzo Letter at jameslnuzzo.substack.com/subscribe
    9 min
  • Physical Activity is a Right Not a "Right"

    Participation in physical exercise is important for one’s mental and physical wellbeing. Decades of research supports this conclusion. With such evidence in their back pockets, some exercise activists have started to proclaim that physical activity is a “right.” For example, a group in England called the Sport and Recreation Alliance is petitioning government to “give every child the fundamental right to be active.” The Alliance has stated that it wants the passage of laws that require councils to “provide all children with the opportunity to be active and to coordinate and promote physical activity across everything they do.” Moreover, the Alliance wants government to create a “long-term, properly funded and child-focused strategy to transform the physical and mental wellbeing of our children.”

    Perhaps one might think that this does not sound so bad. After all, do we not want more children to be physically active? Of course, we do. But hang tight – let us dig deeper to see the underlying intellectual explanation of physical activity as a “right.”

    Such an explanation can be found in a paper by Messing and colleagues published in the Health and Human Rights Journal in 2021. In their paper, the authors argue that the “right” to be physical activity can be “derived from well-established human rights such as the right to health, the right to rest and leisure, the right to education, and the principle of non-discrimination.”

    Messing and colleagues go on to characterize this right by four dimensions: availability, accessibility, acceptability, and quality. In their conception of physical activity as a “right,” availability means that indoor and outdoor facilities for exercise be made available to everyone. Accessibility means that facilities for physical activity be within “safe reach” and that the services provided at such facilities be affordable. Acceptability means that all spaces for physical activity are “culturally appropriate,” meaning that physical activity should “respect the culture of participating individuals and are sensitive to gender and life-cycling requirements.” Quality means that facilities, goods, and services for physical activity be “scientifically and medically appropriate and of good quality” and that skilled medical personnel be there to deliver the activity.

    Thus, for Messing and colleagues and the Sport and Recreation Alliance, the “right” to physical activity means that indoor and outdoor spaces and services for exercise be made available to everyone and that these spaces be affordable, high-quality, inclusive, and nearby. But, is guaranteeing people access to things that are free or low-cost really the definition of a right? Here, I want to explain that physical activity is indeed a right but only when the concept is properly defined.

    According to the novelist and philosopher, Ayn Rand, a right is “a moral principle defining and sanctioning a man’s freedom of action in a social context.” According to Rand, the concept of a right “pertains only to action – specifically, to freedom of action. It means freedom from physical compulsion, coercion or interference by other men.”

    Thus, when objectively defined, the right to physical activity is that the movement of your body shall not be infringed upon by others, including governments, so long as the physical activity that you are participating in does not simultaneously infringe upon someone else’s rights. This right is not granted to you by government. It’s your natural right as a human being. The proper purpose of government is to protect such rights – that is, to ensure that others do not infringe upon your physical activity.

    This is not the same concept put forward by exercise activists such as Messing and colleagues and the Sport and Recreation Alliance. They seek to use the coercive powers of government, such as through taxation and resource redistribution, to exert control over those who create and provide exercise products and services. Thus, their concept of physical activity as a right is untenable within objective law because it involves violating the private property rights of other individuals. In their view, the role of government is to provide physical activity. In my view, the role of government is to protect physical activity – that is, to ensure no one violates your desire to engage lawfully with the exercise spaces, products, and services of your choosing.

    Ironically, an example of the government’s infringement upon the right to physical activity occurred on an international stage during the COVID-19 pandemic. Governments mandated lockdowns which severely restricted human mobility. A number of studies have documented that during lockdowns physical activity decreased and body weight increased. Additional research has documented that physical activity levels negatively correlate with adverse outcomes from COVID-19; individuals who were most physically active before or during the pandemic were the least likely to experience severe symptoms including death from the virus. The inability of medical and public health officials to understand the multifactorial nature of human health during the pandemic is a searing indictment on the current status of higher education programs in the areas of medicine and public health.

    Moreover, even when full-fledged lockdowns were lifted, some restrictions in physical activity still applied. For example, governments limited access to parks and gyms. One irony of the concept of physical activity as a “right” is that “access” and “inclusion” are part of that proposed concept. Yet, we know that this supposed desire to make physical activity more accessible and inclusive is ingenuine and unprincipled. How do we know this? Because during the COVID-19 pandemic there was a specific group of people for whom governments purposely limited mobility and social interaction, including at fitness centers. These people were shamefully labelled the “unvaccinated.”

    The reason that it can be confusing to understand the concept of physical activity as a right is because exercise activists have hijacked “right” as a word and concept. Redefining words is a common tactic employed by activists of the collectivist orientation. These individuals have a long history of attempting to change definitions of words to accomplish their political aims – the most fundamental of which is to obtain more power. In the case of physical activity as a “right,” activists combine two concepts – exercise and freedom – that the lay public intuitively feel or consciously know to be important, but then use this public sentiment to turn the concept of a right on its head. That is, when an individual disagrees that physical activity is a “right,” activists then claim that that individual does not believe that exercise or rights are important. This, of course, is untrue.

    As Ayn Rand once said, “Any alleged ‘right’ of one man, which necessitates the violation of the rights of another, is not and cannot be a right.”  I, like most other exercise scientists know that participation in physical exercise is good for one’s mental and physical wellbeing. However, physical activity as a “right” is untenable because it involves simultaneously violating the private property rights of other individuals. Physical activity is, indeed, a right, but only when such a concept is properly defined. The role of government is not to provide you with rights, but to protect them. May we never forget the time in which governments failed miserably to protect our right to be physically active, and instead, were the main violators of this right.

    Related Content at The Nuzzo Letter

    SUPPORT THE NUZZO LETTER

    If you enjoyed this content, please consider supporting The Nuzzo Letter with a one-time or recurring donation. Your support is greatly appreciated. It helps me to continue to work on independent research projects and fight for my evidence-based discourse.

    Thanks for reading The Nuzzo Letter…



    Get full access to The Nuzzo Letter at jameslnuzzo.substack.com/subscribe
    11 min

About The Nuzzo Letter

From the publisher's feed

Discussing exercise, men's health, academia, and romantic realism in film.

jameslnuzzo.substack.com