The Nuzzo Letter

The Nuzzo Letter

Download on the App Store

The Nuzzo Letter episodes

  • Free Will and the Need for a Romantic Revolution at the Cinema

    Are you frustrated with movies coming out of Hollywood today? Are you tired of the endless numbers of remakes and sequels? Are you unsatisfied with the stories that have no impact on your emotions other than to make you cringe? Or perhaps you are annoyed by the political messaging that is forced into movie scripts? Or maybe you have simply had enough of bad acting?

    If you answered yes to these questions, you have my deepest sympathies. We are in the midst of a regress in romantic art, and we need to work our way out of it. Here, I want to articulate a few general points about romanticism in movies which can facilitate the romantic revolution that we need so desperately at the cinema.

    First, the key ingredient to romanticism is free will. By romanticism, I do not mean romantic love, although romantic love is often featured in movies within the romantic school of art. Instead, romanticism refers to a type of art in which man is depicted as having agency or free will. By free will, I mean the ability to focus one’s mind to make decisions. I do not mean that the story’s main theme is about free will. I mean that the movie shows the main character – the hero – using cognitive effort to achieve his goals. This typically means that the main character seeks to achieve love or happiness, to solve problems, to stop crime, to win a competition, and so on.

    In contrast to Romanticism, which depicts man how he ought to be or could be, with the hero being the ideal embodiment of this, the Naturalistic school of art depicts man as a sort of helpless being who has limited or no capacity for free will and thus little or no ability to improve his life. Movies from the Naturalistic school lack true heroes. Main characters in these movies often go through mundane daily activities or get beaten down by their environments. They lack ambition and goals and have little command over Nature, including their own impulses. Such characters might be drug addicts, criminals, or bad parents, usually the types of individuals who make for the bad guys in romantic movies.

    Second, the most important aspect of a movie is its plot. The plot (correctly developed), according to novelist and philosopher Ayn Rand, is a “purposeful progression of logically connected events leading to the resolution of the climax.” In a romantic movie, the plot typically revolves around the hero making various decisions and taking certain actions to overcome challenges to achieve his goals. The climax of a Romantic movie is usually the point in the plot where the hero makes his final and most important decision – a decision that resolves the story and all other characters linked to it.

    In a naturalistic movie, the plot will feel more disjointed or confused, with connections between scenes and characters not entirely clear. Life does involve a series of connected decisions. Thus, a rational viewer of a Naturalistic movie that has little logic in its plot structure is likely to feel uneasy while watching it. The viewer’s uneasiness stems from the fact that they are being shown something that is antithetical to life. Though neither bad acting nor subpar cinematography are desirable in a movie, a movie’s plot is its most important feature because its progression reflects the degree to which the script writer believes that man does or does not have free will.

    Movies, like all other art, reflect the artist’s and thus society’s value premises. The reason that many of today’s movies do not move your soul is because values are often not taken seriously, and when they are taken seriously, they are not in line with human nature and flourishing. We also live in an age where it is considered offensive to show that one way of life is objectively better than another. And this creates a state of moral ambiguity without clear distinctions between good and evil and right and wrong. Moreover, some of today’s supposed most prominent intellectuals have declared that free will is an illusion and that you stand no chance against your environment, unless of course, you relinquish your freedoms to them so that they can control the environment for you. In other words, you are told that you can cannot control your own destiny – that is, your own journey or life plot. For a romantic revolution to occur in the cinema, free will and its role in plot structure must be understood and defended.

    Related Content at The Nuzzo Letter

    SUPPORT THE NUZZO LETTER

    If you appreciated this content, please consider supporting The Nuzzo Letter with a one-time or recurring donation. Your support is greatly appreciated. It helps me to continue to work on independent research projects and fight for my evidence-based discourse. To donate, click the DonorBox logo. In two simple steps, you can donate using ApplePay, PayPal, or another service. Thank you.

    Thanks for reading The Nuzzo Letter! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.



    Get full access to The Nuzzo Letter at jameslnuzzo.substack.com/subscribe
    6 min
  • Cowardice and Anonymous Editorials in Biomedical Research Journals

    Academic publishing is currently experiencing a number of problems. Authorship inflation, long review times, and lack of payment for reviewers’ work in appraising manuscripts are just a couple of examples. Here, I highlight another issue in academic publishing – one that has received little attention, but that readers of scientific journals should be aware of.

    Editorials in academic journals are brief pieces written by the journal’s editors about findings from new studies, about journal news, or about broader trends in research and medical practice. In 2019, I discovered an editorial published in Lancet Public Health [1] that stated some questionable things about obesity. For example, the editorial stated, “obesity can still too often be regarded by some as an individual responsibility resulting from poor choices and motivations.” The editorial continued, “stereotypical perceptions that people with overweight and obesity are somehow responsible for their weight remains pervasive.” In other words, the author was suggesting that an individual does not have the capacity to control their own body weight. I was interested to see who would say something so blatantly ignorant and false in a health journal. To my surprise, no author name was listed online or in-print with the editorial.

    Fast forward to 2022. A controversial editorial titled, “Science must respect the dignity and rights of all humans,” was published in the journal Nature Human Behavior [2]. This editorial received significant media attention, because its critics quickly realized that underneath its supposedly compassionate title was a sort of totalitarian desire to limit academic discourse. In effect, the editorial was providing a cover for the journal to reject future “controversial” papers that show that different groups of people, such as men and women and individuals of different races, often have dissimilar behaviours, beliefs, interests, and life outcomes. I also wanted to know who was responsible for writing this editorial. Again, I could not find an author name listed online or in-print. Importantly, one cannot assume the author to be the chief editor of the journal, because journals often have multiple editors who write editorials.

    After performing some preliminary searches on PubMed – a larger database of biomedical research articles – I realised that these two editorials were not the only ones published with editors’ names missing. I found hundreds of anonymous editorials indexed in PubMed.

    Believing this to be a new, yet unacknowledged issue in academic publishing, I decided to quantify how many anonymous editorials were published in biomedical research journals between 2018 and 2022 [3]. Across this five-year period, I found that 2,745 editorials were published with anonymous or ambiguous authorship. Anonymous editorials accouned for 1-3% of all editorials published in a given year. This is not a large number in relative terms, but the existing number of anonymous editorials is problematic for a few reasons.

    Problem 1 is that anonymous editorials do not allow readers to assess the editor’s potential conflicts of interest. In fact, I found that many of these anonymous editorials were published without conflict of interest statements, which makes sense, given that no one individual was listed on the author byline.

    Problem 2 is that anonymous editorials do not give readers the opportunity to assess the author’s credentials, qualifications, and background as they pertain to the topic being discussed. For example, with the editorial on obesity mentioned earlier, the unknown editor probably had a background in a field such as public health or communications, and thus lacked an understanding of the interactive causes of biology, environment, and choice on body weight. When actual health professionals, such as physicians, dieticians, and exercise physiologists have been surveyed, they have been in agreement that individuals do have the capacity to control their own body weights [4].

    Problem 3 is that anonymous editorials make connecting an idea to its author difficult or impossible to establish. Thus, if the author of an editorial puts forward a problematic idea, for example, that an individual cannot control their own body weight, then that author should be held accountable for their untenable and potentially dangerous ideas. They should experience the consequences of having such ideas associated with their name, including public ridicule.

    My research also revealed that the Lancet and Nature journals are the most frequent abusers of anonymous editorials. This is an important finding to note because content published in these prominent journals has a big impact on public discourse. Over the past 10 years, medical and scientific journals have increased the amount of political content that fills their pages. Thus, one should be aware that journals might start using anonymous editorials as a way to push questionable political content on their readership.

    The solution to anonymous editorials is not difficult. It involves editors, journals, and journal publishers firmly establishing that anonymous authorship is not an ethical publishing practice. It also involves individual authors not being cowards. It involves people putting their names on anything they say.

    References

    1. The Lancet Public Health. Addressing weight stigma. Lancet Public Health. 2019;4(4):e168.

    2. Anonymous editorial. Science must respect the dignity and rights of all humans. Nature Human Behaviour. 2022;6(8):1029-31.

    3. Nuzzo JL. Anonymous editorials in biomedical research journals: few in number but potentially problematic. Learned Publishing. 36(3): 468-472.

    4. Bleich SN, Bandara S, Bennett WL, Cooper LA, Gudzune KA. U.S. health professionals’ views on obesity care, training, and self-efficacy. American Journal of Preventive Medicine. 2015;48(4):411-8.

    Related Content at The Nuzzo Letter

    SUPPORT THE NUZZO LETTER

    If you enjoyed this information, please consider supporting The Nuzzo Letter with a one-time or recurring donation. Your support is greatly appreciated. It helps me to continue working on independent research projects and fighting for more evidence-based discourse.

    Thanks for reading The Nuzzo Letter! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.



    Get full access to The Nuzzo Letter at jameslnuzzo.substack.com/subscribe
    7 min
  • Strength Equipment and the Good in Men

    In contemporary society, we are bombarded with negative messages about men. We are told that men “toxic” and “privileged,” and we are given the impression that most men are abusers of women. In media, you will be hard pressed to find stories that talk about masculinity, and men as a group, in a positive light. Here, I want to change that. I want to highlight an unrecognized good that men have provided to the world.

    Strength training, also known as resistance exercise, weight training, or weight lifting, is a form of physical activity that has been practiced since at least the time of the Ancient Greeks [1]. Typically, strength training involves placing an external resistance upon the body and lifting the load repeatedly in sets of repetitions.

    In the 1940s, Dr. Thomas DeLorme introduced his system of “progressive resistance exercise” into the medical literature, providing a theoretical basis and clinical evidence for the utility of strength training in rehabilitating individuals with polio and soldiers who were injured in World War II [2]. DeLorme’s ideas led to widespread interest in, and later acceptance of, strength training as a safe and effective way to improve muscle strength and physical function after injury. Subsequent decades of research on strength training has illustrated that regular participation in this form of exercise improves various mental and physical health outcomes [3]. Today, strength training is performed by millions of people around the world for preventive and rehabilitative health purposes, including for its ability to slow the declines in muscle size and strength that occur with aging and disease.

    Nevertheless, strength training cannot be completed without the external resistances that are placed onto the body. But what are these resistances? What forms do they take? Where do they come from? In other words, what is the equipment that makes strength training possible, and who conceives of it and designs it? Given that strength training provides many health benefits to individuals and thus to society, surely we should be celebrating the individuals who have made all of this possible, should we not?

    In 2021, I published a paper in the Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research that documented the history of patent applications for strength training equipment [4]. Using the website Google Patents, I tracked down every patent for strength training equipment that was submitted to the United States (US) Patents and Trademark Office before 1980. I discovered that 551 patents for strength training equipment were submitted to the Office between 1860 and 1979. These patents included designs for strength training implements such as dumbbells, barbells, and Indian clubs. They also included designs for larger weight stack machines and cable-pulley systems. They also included accessory items like benches and racks.

    I also examined the sex of the applicants. I found that 98.7% of all patent applications for strength training equipment were submitted by men. Thus, a good that men have brought to the world for decades, but that has gone largely unrecognized, is strength training equipment. In fact, men invent most things. A study published in 2009 found that men submit more than 85% of all patent applications across various scientific domains and countries [5].

    My research also involved performing a content analysis of the patent applications to further understand men’s rationales for their inventions and how they thought their designs advanced existing equipment. My analysis revealed that over the past 160 years, men have been trying to make strength training exercise safer, more personalized, more convenient, more accessible, and ultimately more effective. I developed the mnemonic device CHAPS MANLINESS to help people remember the various aspects of the strength training experience that men have been making better with their inventions. A given invention will not embody each characteristic of the mnemonic device but it will embody many of them. Here, is the breakdown of CHAPS MANLINESS:

    C: stands for compact. Men have often tried to make strength training equipment as small as is feasible, so that the equipment takes up minimal space at home, in the office, or at the gym.

    H: stands for home use. Men have tried to make strength training equipment that is suitable for use at home, with the thinking that home exercise can make participation in strength training more convenient for some individuals.

    A: stands for adjustability. This is one of the biggest ways in which men have advanced strength training equipment from the early days of single dumbbell or barbell loads. The reason that being able to adjust the exercise weight is important is because not all individuals have the same amount of strength. Thus, if someone cannot even lift a given dumbbell load one time, then they clearly will not receive any of the benefits of strength training. Similarly, if a given dumbbell is too light for a strong individual, then they also will not be optimizing their strength training program. Also, not all individuals have the same body heights or limb lengths. Thus, adjustable seat heights and handle positions for weight stack machines allow individuals of different body sizes to use machines in ways that optimize workout effectiveness. In sum, the concept of adjustability equates to personalization which then equates to inclusivity. That’s right – men have made strength training more accessible to individuals of various sizes and abilities. When was the last time you heard men being given credit for such an achievement?

    P: stands for portability. Men have designed strength training equipment that is easier to transport from one room or location to another.

    S: stands for simple. Knowing that exercise is a skill that can benefit from instruction, men have designed strength training equipment that is intended to be easy to operate.

    M: stands for multiplicity. Men have designed certain pieces of strength training equipment that allow for multiple exercises to be performed. This then helps to save both cost and space, as one no longer has to buy separate machines for each individual exercise.

    A: stands for aesthetics. Though not a main driver behind strength equipment innovation, men have sometimes tried to design equipment that will look more appealing to some users.

    N: stands for noiseless. Some male inventors were aware that not everyone enjoys the loud clanging noises associated with dumbbells and barbells. Thus, they designed equipment that would allow for muscles to become stronger while not annoying the neighbours or others in the gym.

    L: stands for light weight. Men have made some strength training equipment lighter and thus easier to transport.

    I: stands for inexpensive. Men have attempted to reduce the costs associated with strength training in a variety of ways. For example, inventing a machine that allows for a multiplicity of exercises can save money compared to buying one machine for each exercise that someone wants to perform.

    N: stands for no supervision. Understanding that lifting weights carries with it some risks that would be minimized by supervision during exercise, men have sought to design strength training equipment that makes supervision unnecessary. Such innovations allow individuals to exercise alone if they prefer.

    E: stands for effectiveness. Men have made strength training equipment more effective at increasing muscle size and strength via a few different pathways. As mentioned earlier, men have made the resistances and the structural features of equipment more adjustable over the years. This allows for each workout to be more individualized which will then increase the potency of any exercise dose. Another aspect of effectiveness deals with how resistances are applied to the body throughout the exercise – for example, CAM-based machines attempt to match human strength curves to try to increase the potency of …



    Get full access to The Nuzzo Letter at jameslnuzzo.substack.com/subscribe
    12 min
  • "Gender-Based Violence" and Exercise Science

    In August of 2020, one the highest ranked exercise science journals, called Sports Medicine, published a commentary titled, “Gender-based violence is a blind spot for sports and exercise medicine professionals.” The commentary was problematic for a variety reasons, and this prompted Dr. John Barry of the Centre for Male Psychology, Deborah Powney of the University of Central Lancashire, and me to team up to write a letter to the journal’s editor challenging the ideas put forward in the paper. Because our letter is not available open access, I will read it aloud here. However, before reading it, I thought I would share the unusual experience we had in getting the letter published.

    We submitted the first version of our letter to Sports Medicine on September 29 of 2022. I was surprised to see that the editor decided to send our letter out for peer review. The reason that I was surprised is because letters typically do not undergo peer review.

    Letters are typically no more than 500 words, thus standard practice is for a chief editor to make a unilateral decision on whether a letter is appropriate for publication, and this based on factors such as whether the arguments in the letter are valid and professional and whether the journal has space to publish a letter in an upcoming issue. I was further surprised because I have previously submitted letters to Sports Medicine and none of them have undergone peer review. So, I asked the editor why he was sending this letter out for review. His response was that the journal was now instituting a policy that letters will be sent out for review if they are on topics that are “potentially controversial.” What’s more, the editor decided to send our letter out to three peer reviewers – three! Full-length manuscripts oftentimes are not sent out to threepeer reviewers. Clearly, the editor was being cautious with our letter on gender and violence.

    On December 6 of 2022, after our letter was under review for approximately two months, we received the reviewers’ comments. Their comments were minor, and all three of the reviewers agreed that our letter should be published, assuming their comments were adequately addressed. So, we revised our letter accordingly, improved its quality, and we resubmitted the letter on December 15 of 2022.

    At this stage, given that the reviewer comments were fairly minor, many editors would not send the letter out for another round of reviews. Yet, the editor decided to send our revised letter back to the peer reviewers, creating unnecessary delay in the publication process. As expected, the reviewers acknowledged that we had made all of the necessary corrections, and they provided their final stamps of approval for our letter to be published.

    However, per standard publishing practice with letter exchanges, we had to wait for the researchers who we were challenging to respond to our letter. We expected to have to wait another month or two. But, to my surprise, the editor chose to send the researchers’ reply out for peer review as well. This was a shocking decision because why would the researchers’ opinion of our critiques need to be commented on by peer reviewers? It was one of the dumbest and most unnecessary editorial decisions that I have experienced in my 16 years of publishing research. Yet, the oddities of this letter exchange and review process did not end there.

    Over the course of the subsequent five months, from January of 2023 to May of 2023, I sent the editor multiple emails inquiring about the status of the researchers’ reply and when we might expect the review process to be completed. In March, I was told that the researchers’ reply was under review, but delays had been experienced in the process, and that the process should be completed in the next couple of weeks. In April, I still had not heard of a final outcome regarding the letter exchange, so I sent an email to the editor explaining in a professional manner that I thought the way that the letter exchange was handled was inappropriate and inconsistent with standard editorial practices. I informed the editor of my background as a frequent letter writer and as a researcher who has studied and published on the roles of letters in the scientific process. I argued that a letter is intended to be a short communication that is quickly made available to the journal’s readership, because doing so would help to slow the transmission of the problematic ideas presented in the original paper. The editor acknowledged my concerns and then informed me that the researchers’ reply was going through another final round of revisions.

    Another month went by, and the review process was still incomplete, so I once again emailed the editor asking for an update. The response I received was not what I was expecting. The editor informed me that the researchers had decided to remove their reply from consideration for publication. The editor did not tell me why the researchers made this decision. Perhaps, after reading our letter and after receiving feedback from reviewers, they realized how wrong they were in their paper. An unfortunate result from all of this is that our letter was completed in December of 2022 and could have been published at that time. Instead, six months have gone by, allowing for their misguided ideas to transmit throughout academia without criticism.

    On the bright side, our letter received positive appraisals from three independent reviewers and the journal has published the letter even though it is on a supposedly “controversial topic.” I will now read the letter. Please note that all of our statements are supported with references to peer-reviewed research papers.

    Also, if you enjoy our letter, and you appreciate academics who are willing to take off the gloves to restore sanity in these confusing times, please consider supporting The Nuzzo Letter with a donation. Your support is greatly appreciated as it helps me to continue to work on independent research projects such as this letter. Now, to the letter:

    Dear editor…

    [listen to the audio]

    Relate Content at The Nuzzo Letter

    SUPPORT THE NUZZO LETTER

    If you appreciated this content, please consider supporting The Nuzzo Letter with a one-time or recurring donation. Your support is greatly appreciated. It helps me to continue to work on independent research projects and fight for my evidence-based discourse. To donate, click the DonorBox logo. In two simple steps, you can donate using ApplePay, PayPal, or another service. Thank you!

    Thanks for reading The Nuzzo Letter! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.



    Get full access to The Nuzzo Letter at jameslnuzzo.substack.com/subscribe
    16 min
  • Female Exercise Scientists and the Failure to Protect Women’s Sports

    Biological males are now competing against biological females in sports. Biological males have various physical advantages over biological females, rendering this new form of athletic competition problematic. The purpose here is not to revisit the various ways in which men are advantaged over women in sports. Instead, the purpose is to highlight the failure of female exercise scientists to play a prominent intellectual role in protecting women’s sports.

    Exercise science, which is the study of the physiological, biomechanical, and psychological causes of and responses to physical activity and exercise, is one of the fastest growing academic majors in the United States. My previous research on the growth of this academic major found that between 2002 and 2017, the number of bachelor’s degrees awarded increased by 445% [1]. By comparison, the number of bachelor’s degrees awarded in nursing increased by 303%, in medical engineering by 136%, in psychology by 43%, in economics by 38%, in philosophy by 1%, and in history, the number of bachelor’s degrees in 2017 decreased by 14%. In 2017, over 28,000 bachelor’s degrees were awarded in exercise science.

    Women comprise 55% and 50% of all bachelor’s and doctorate degree earners in exercise science the United States. Women also comprise approximately 60% of all degree earners in the fields of athletic training and physical therapy, which are closely related to exercise science. What’s more, equal or greater female than male degree earners in exercise science is not necessarily unique to the United States. In Australia, for example, women comprise approximately 47% of all bachelor’s degree earners in exercise and sports science [2].

    These data on degree earners suggest that there exists a large cohort of women who, based on their academic credentials, should have a high level of knowledge of how the human body develops and functions and impacts exercise and sports performance. Thus, one might think that female exercise scientists would come out en masse to draw the evidence-based line that argues that it is unfair for biological women to have to compete against biological men in sports, particularly as many of these female exercise scientists will have themselves participated in various athletic endeavors. Yet, not only have female exercise scientists not come out en masse to draw this line, they have been altogether silent. Thousands of them – silent!

    To date, I am aware of only two papers published in peer-reviewed exercise science journals that, with arguments based in physiology, have questioned the idea of transgender women competing in the female category of sport [3, 4]. Both papers had female lead authors and a mix of male and female co-authors. The female lead authors deserve credit for their contributions to the debate, but one of the papers was published just last month, meaning that since 2018 – the approximate beginnings of the rise in transgender participation in sport – only one paper had been published in an exercise science journal that highlighted that transgender women have certain physiological advantages over biological women that are not reversed by gender-affirming treatments. That such little commentary on transgender participation in sport has occurred in exercise science journals is astonishing for a couple reasons.

    First, as I’ve just indicated, there exist thousands of potential exercise scientists to write such papers, and there exist hundreds of potential journals for them to publish such papers in. Thus, lack of qualified personnel or lack of opportunity is not a tenable explanation for the silence of female exercise scientists on this issue. Second, stacks of papers are published each month in exercise journals, and these papers are often of little interest to the lay public, and often have little direct implication for the lives of many individuals. In contrast, the topic of transgender athletes is of great contemporary interest, and the related decisions made by policymakers and sports organizations have direct implications for sports-related opportunities for women, such as scholarships and awards, and also include the possibility that women’s overall participation in sports might be negatively impacted by the current state of affairs.

    So, given that we sometimes hear that career-minded female scientists are “strong and brave,” what then underlies the astonishing low number of female exercise scientists speaking out against biological males participating in women’s sports? Here, I propose two explanations.

    First, women tend to have agreeable personalities. A number of meta-analytic studies have shown that women, compared to men, tend to score higher on scales of agreeableness, with agreeableness referring to “the tendency toward cooperation, maintenance of social harmony, and consideration of others” [5]. Thus, female exercise scientists might place a high value on inclusivity in sport and consequently find it difficult to disagree with transgender women’s participation in the female category of sport. For female exercise scientists who place greater value on fairness in competition than on inclusivity, they might disagree with biological men competing in women’s sports, but they do not appear to have the courage to express this disagreement publicly. Importantly, personality research has also shown that women are less assertive than men [5] and this lack of assertiveness would further hinder a female exercise scientist’s expression of disagreeableness and their ability to use their intellect to protect other women.

    An example of how women’s agreeableness and lack of assertiveness manifests in lack of academic publications can be seen by studying letters to the editor that are published in journals. The reason that letters can be used as a model for exploring the associations between sex differences in personality and interests versus academic outputs is because letters are usually brief expressions of disagreement with another researcher’s ideas and the opportunity to write and submit letters is equal between men and women – that is, anyone can submit a letter to a journal. Yet, large sex differences exist in letter authorship. My previous research on letters to the editor revealed that men write approximately 85% of all letters published in exercise science and physical therapy journals [6]. Similar sex differences in letter writing have also been observed in other biomedical research fields [7].

    A second potential explanation for why more female exercise scientists are not writing evidence-based papers that argue against transgender women’s participation in the female category of sport is that female exercise scientists are caught in a feminist conundrum. On one hand, if a female exercise scientist makes an inclusion-based argument that defends the notion that transgender women should be permitted to participate in the female category of sport, then she is no longer supporting the valid feminist (and non-feminist) position that women should have their own space for sports. On the other hand, if a female exercise scientist argues that a boundary needs to be set to prevent transgender women from participating in women’s sports, then this an indirect admission of female biological inferiority in terms of physical capacity. And if there is one thing that career-minded feminist academics do not want to admit is that they are in any way inferior to men. Thus, if female exercise scientists prioritize sports inclusion, they could be held responsible for a potential future decline in women’s participation in sports – a reversal to the past. However, if they adopt a boundary that implies women cannot do everything that men can do, then they have to admit that physical fitness is not a social construct. Neither of these positions is desirable for the feminist exercise scientist.

    It will be interesting to see what actions, if any, female exercise scientists ta…



    Get full access to The Nuzzo Letter at jameslnuzzo.substack.com/subscribe
    11 min
  • My Rejected Letter on Race, Homicide, and Men's Health

    In November of 2020, the American Journal of Preventive Medicine published a paper titled, “Homicide mortality inequities in the 30 biggest cities in the U.S.” A few months after the paper was published, in April of 2021, I submitted a letter to the journal’s editor, challenging some of the ideas put forward in the paper. The editor rejected my letter. The reasons for the rejection were not entirely clear but projected insincerity.

    The topic of race and homicide is relevant to the fields of male psychology and men’s health, and we are in need of open, honest, and evidence-based discussions about it. Thus, I have decided to publish the rejected letter here in full and without modification. I hope you will share it with others.

    Dear Editor,

    In “Homicide mortality inequities in the 30 biggest cities in the U.S.,” Schober et al.(1) reported Black individuals are more likely than White individuals to be victims of homicide in the biggest United States (US) cities. The authors sometimes referred to these mortality differences as “racial inequities” and suggested “structural racism” as one potential cause. The authors said their results can “inform city leaders in their efforts to address the homicide, violence, and racial inequities associated with them through the implementation of policies and programs”(1). The purpose of my letter is to ask the authors to explain why they did not discuss the characteristics (e.g., race, sex) of homicide perpetrators, and why they used the word “inequity” to describe the observed differences. Here, I explain why such information is important for interpreting the study’s results and thus important for informing future efforts to reduce homicide.

    First, Black individuals commit more homicide than White individuals. According to the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) (2), Blacks, who comprise ~13% of the US population according to the 2010 Census, committed 49% of all homicides in 2019 (n = 3,218). Whites, who comprise ~73% of the US population, committed 45% of all homicides in 2019 (n = 2,948) (2). Second, Blacks are typically killed by other Blacks. In 2019, 2,574 Blacks were killed by other Blacks, accounting for 89% of Black homicides (2). Third, Blacks are more likely to kill Whites than Whites are to kill Blacks. In 2019, 566 Whites were killed by Blacks, accounting for 17% of White homicides. In the same year, 246 Blacks were killed by Whites, accounting for 9% of Black homicides (2).

    The authors also did not discuss perpetrator or victim sex (1). In 2019, males comprised 90% of homicide perpetrators and 72% of homicide victims (2). Acknowledgment of these two facts is important because lack of attention to men’s health is a problem in the US (3). Numerous national offices, policies, and initiatives have been created to address women’s issues but not men’s issues, though men fare worse than women on many outcomes (3). Also, acknowledgement of men’s issues should coincide with discussion on the decline of the two-parent household in the US, particularly among Blacks (4). Absence of the biological father in the household during childhood is associated with increased delinquency and criminal behavior later in life (5-7).

    Finally, the authors used the words “inequity” and “disparity” interchangeably (1). The word “disparity” is causally and morally neutral. It is synonymous with the word “difference.” The word “inequity” implies lack of fairness or justice and thus infers causation. The authors did not discuss perpetration nor did they measure the cause of the racial difference in mortality. Thus, reference to the mortality difference as a “racial inequity” is inappropriate, as it would require identification of a cause that was somehow unjustly and disproportionately exuded onto one particular group. Racism as a cause is difficult to substantiate because most homicides are intraracial (2).

    James L. Nuzzo, PhD

    References

    1. Schober DJ, Hunt BR, Benjamins MR, et al. Homicide mortality inequities in the 30 biggest cities in the U.S. Am J Prev Med. 2021;60(3):327-334. doi:10.1016/j.amepre.2020.09.008

    2. Federal Bureau of Investigation. 2019 Crime in the United States. Accessed March 15, 2021. https://ucr.fbi.gov/crime-in-the-u.s/2019/crime-in-the-u.s.-2019/tables/expanded-homicide-data-table-6.xls

    3. Nuzzo JL. Men’s health in the United States: a national health paradox. Aging Male. 2020;23(1):42-52. doi:10.1080/13685538.2019.1645109

    4. Pew Research Center. Parenting in America: outlook, worries, aspirations are strongly linked to financial situation. 2015. https://www.pewresearch.org/social-trends/2015/12/17/1-the-american-family-today/

    5. Beck AJ, Kline SA, Greenfeld LA, Bureau of Justice Statistics. Survey of Youth in Custody, 1987 (NCJ-113365). 1988.

    6. Kroese J, Bernasco W, Liefbroer AC, Rouwendal J. Growing up in single-parent families and the criminal involvement of adolescents: a systematic review. Psychol Crime Law. 2021;27(1):61-75. doi:10.1080/1068316X.2020.1774589

    7. U.S. Department of Justice. Family life and deliquency and crime: a policymakers’ guide to the literature. 1993.

    Related Content at The Nuzzo Letter

    SUPPORT THE NUZZO LETTER

    If you appreciated this content, please consider supporting The Nuzzo Letter with a one-time or recurring donation. Your support is greatly appreciated. It helps me to continue to work on independent research projects and fight for my evidence-based discourse. To donate, click the DonorBox logo. In two simple steps, you can donate using ApplePay, PayPal, or another service. Thank you.

    Thanks for reading The Nuzzo Letter! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.



    Get full access to The Nuzzo Letter at jameslnuzzo.substack.com/subscribe
    5 min

About The Nuzzo Letter

From the publisher's feed

Discussing exercise, men's health, academia, and romantic realism in film.

jameslnuzzo.substack.com