
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


The sacred geese have attempted to save Rome, but the siege of the Gauls is still not over! What could possibly happen next? We continue our deep dive into the events purported to all take place in 390 BCE.
Despite the Romans apparently being surprised by the Gauls turning up on their doorstep, the Gauls have been in northern Italy for some time as far as we can trace archaeological evidence. Rumour has it that the Gauls came to central Italy in the search for cooler weather, but instead what they find is a city of Romans, and as the siege drags on, hygiene starts to emerge as a problem.
The siege is getting tedious for both sides, so amidst the military encounters, conversations start about maybe bringing the siege to a close through mutual agreement. The details of the siege consequences include lack of food, issues with cadavers, and spread of disease. And it seems neither the Romans or the Gauls want to keep going with this situation.
Those Gauls are pretty cheeky in the moment of coming to a monetary agreement to ensure they’ll pack up their siege and leave Roman territory. Not only do they ask for 1000 pounds of gold, but they have the nerve to add some extra items to the scales to encourage the Romans to pay even more than this sum. Perhaps even worse, are our sources really telling us a story of Rome resisting the Gauls, or could it be the case that ALL the city was taken and the Romans were legitimately and completely defeated? We explore the possibilities.
Is he in Ardea pumping out a training montage with the locals in preparation to swoop in and rescue Rome? Or is waiting in the wings but misses his cue to come on stage leaving Rome to deal with the Gauls all by themselves? Our sources have some disagreements which we’ll delve into.
OR
Our music is by the superb Bettina Joy de Guzman.
Lightly edited for our wonderful Australian accents
Dr Rad 0:12
Welcome to the Partial Historians.
Dr G 0:16
We explore all the details of ancient Rome,
Dr Rad 0:20
Everything from political scandals to love affairs, the battles waged and when citizens turn against each other, I’m Dr Rad
Dr G 0:30
and I’m Dr G, we consider Rome as the Romans saw it, by reading different ancient authors and comparing their accounts.
Dr Rad 0:41
Join us as we trace the journey of Rome from the founding of the city. Hello and welcome to a brand new episode of the Partial Historians. I am one of your hosts, Dr Rad.
Dr G 1:01
And I’m Dr G, hello.
Dr Rad 1:04
This is going to be a tough one. I think Dr G, in more ways than one, because for listeners who might be listening at a different point in time, we are currently recording in the midst of an Australian summer as affected by climate change.
Dr G 1:24
It is a heat wave, a tropical heat wave.
Dr Rad 1:27
Exactly. We’re having a heat wave. That’s a Marilyn reference, in case you didn’t pick up on that one,
Dr G 1:35
I knew you would figure that one out.
Dr Rad 1:39
But not only that. Dr, G, of course, we are in a year that seemingly never ends. As far as ancient Rome is concerned,
Dr G 1:47
the hottest year on Roman history’s record 390 BCE
Dr Rad 1:52
Yeah, I knew it was going to be a big one, but it’s it’s even surprised me.
Dr G 1:57
We are many parts into this effective mini series on this year, and the last time we talked about this, there were some interesting moments. There was visitations down the Tiber, aided by cork
Dr Rad 2:13
visitations
Dr G 2:14
visitations. There were sacred geese, and boy did they honk. And there were some people thrown down off the top of what we think is the Capitolini Hill rather than the Tarpeian rock, although we can’t be entirely certain. And some Roman bodies end up amongst the Gaulish forces, it seems.
Dr Rad 2:34
Absolutely yeah. So we’re right in the midst of this Gallic siege of Rome. We’ve got this stalwart band of Romans who have remained behind to defend the Capitol and all the sacred buildings and animals, apparently, that reside upon it. And when the Gauls tried to assault them, it almost worked, not quite, and that’s where we got people being flung off rocks, etc, etc, etc, yes.
Dr G 3:07
So this siege, we think, has been going on for quite some time at this point, our sources suggest that it’s anywhere between six or seven months at this stage, and everybody’s really starting to feel the effects of it would seem. So Plutarch, who I would not consider a close source to the action at hand, nevertheless suggests that the Gauls themselves are running into some trouble engaging and maintaining this siege, partly because they lack provisions, but partly because, in an encamped situation for a long period of time, outbreaks of disease are quite common. It’s hard to keep up sanitary conditions when you’re in a place where you’ve kind of constructed everything from scratch, but it’s all kind of temporary. And they’re also encamped amongst ruins of Roman buildings. Effectively, in some parts of this siege area, there’s also a growing extent of corpses because they’re engaging in various raids. And obviously some people die in those and they haven’t seemed to have dealt with those bodies necessarily in the best way possible.
Dr Rad 3:07
Well that’s just gross.
Dr G 3:07
Some of them, they’ve been able to cremate, but seems some of them, they haven’t, so they’re also amongst the dead at the same time. So this would be pushing disease outbreaks as well. But the worst thing of all, according to Plutarch, is that the Gauls came from a cool place, and as we know, one of the theories that brought the Gauls into Italy is that they were looking for somewhere even cooler. But boy, were they wrong, because Italy is hot, and even in autumn, apparently, when this siege is still continuing, it’s still quite hot, and they are unhappy campers about the weather.
Dr Rad 4:56
I could not feel more simpatico with the Gauls than right now recording this ridiculous Australian heat. God, I hope we do something about climate change so it doesn’t get any worse. Because I was going to make fun of this whole scenario and say, this sounds like anti-Gallic propaganda in a sense, where they’re like, they can’t function when it’s hot, when it gets above 35 degrees celsius, they just completely melt, like the Wicked Witch of the West. But then I’m like, You know what? I don’t think I function particularly well, when I get too hot. Mind you though.
Dr G 5:32
Yes, now, now, it comes down to it. Yes.
Dr Rad 5:36
They have been in Italy for a bit of time at this point. But maybe it’s because this is one of their forays more into, you know, central Italy, whereas when they started crossing the Alps, which I mean at this point, the Gauls are meant to have been crossing the Alps for a couple of hundreds years, like we think it starts around sort of 600 BCE, that we start getting Gallic peoples on the move and coming into Italian territory, but I think they have tended to stay further north, which for anyone who’s been to Italy, it is a bit of a different climate to other parts of the country.
Dr G 6:17
Very much so, much cooler, maybe more delightful if you’re you prefer the wintertime, but now they’re in central Italy and doesn’t agree with them, not not in their constitution. It would seem, physically, they’re having a tough time.
Dr Rad 6:32
Yeah, no. Look, this is what Plutarch has said. Is very much what Livy says. He says, look, the siege is obviously terrible because the goals aren’t making the headway that they need. They weren’t necessarily planning on this whole situation. It was somewhat foisted upon them. If we had to leave our accounts by the Romans, terrible behaviour.
Dr G 6:52
That’s right, you can’t deny an insult like that and just walk away,
Dr Rad 6:56
Even if we say like, whether we say it was the insult which, let’s face it, most people don’t think that that was probably what happened, or whether we say the Gauls were actually on their way somewhere else, maybe to do something particular, like serve as auxiliaries, or something like that. Either way, they haven’t planned for a lengthy siege, so they don’t, as you say, have all the provisions that they need. The Romans are certainly feeling it because they’re really lacking in provisions, because they can’t really leave the capital to get anything, and they just up there, God knows what kind of exercise they’re getting. Dr G, and this is exactly when, yes, a pestilence hits. Livy also mentions where the Gauls had set up their camp, that because it was low ground between hills, and there was also, like, polluted air, I guess in his in his mind, you know, because they’ve torched so many beautiful Roman buildings that barbarians, it’s just not good. And he also mentions the the corpses, and the fact that they kind of had tried to dispose of some bodies they’ve made, like, mass burial pyres. But when it comes to people who’ve maybe died just, you know, randomly and like a little siege, they’re kind of like, it’s just one body. I don’t know if I can be bothered sitting on fire.
Dr G 8:15
Bad choice. Bad choice. At least bury it.
Dr Rad 8:17
Yeah. And so this is what drives the Gauls to seek out the Romans and to try and enter, introduce get some talks going, see what they can sort out here.
Dr G 8:33
Yes, this is an interesting moment, because it seems like the siege actually becomes a bit of a fizzer, and it’s like the Gallic sack of Rome, and here we are, and everybody’s tired, and we’re months into it, and the Gauls are like, we kind of want this to be over. And the Romans like, we’d like this to be over too. And the Gauls are like, how about you give us 1000 pounds of gold.
Dr Rad 8:53
Oh, well, it gets a little bit heated before we get to that point in my account. Dr, G, there’s a little detail in mind that I particularly like, which is that the commanders on both sides are obviously talking trying to figure things out, and I guess to drive home that they were in the stronger position in this siege situation, the Gauls start making fun of the Romans and mocking them for the fact that they’re literally starving to death in front of their eyes, which, after, say, six or seven months, I can understand. And they’re like, surely the Romans should just give in. I mean, you’re clearly going to die from starvation if we don’t kill you first. Now this is not the way that you negotiate with the Romans, as we know. Dr G, it’s not going to get them on side. It riled them up so much that they started, apparently, throwing bread down from the Capitol towards the Gallic camp being like that’ll show them. We rain down bread upon you. We’re not starving to death. We’re strong, stronger than we’ve ever been. Whoa. I think I’m feeling a little woozy from the lack of food. Phew.
Dr G 8:54
First of all, the Gauls are like, is this the hill that you’re willing to die on? And the Romans are like, yes, it is.
Dr Rad 8:54
Yes, the Capitol is the best.
Dr G 8:54
This is the the exact hill that I’m willing to die on. And not only that, it doesn’t seem in any way strategic to be like, how about you guys have some of the bread. We’re having a tough time, but you’re gonna have it tougher because you can’t handle this level of gluten.
Dr Rad 8:54
That’s right, yeah, exactly. We know how you guys are. You can’t handle the food here. You can’t handle the climate here. Get outta here.
Dr G 8:54
Yeah, good luck with this bread. The Gauls are like, I will eat it.
Dr Rad 8:54
My commentator believes that this little tidbit that Livy includes might have been something that’s trying to explain a development of the cult of Jupiter Pistor, which is the story that turns up in some other sources like Valerius Maximus, Ovid, etc, etc.
Dr G 8:54
Lovely.
Dr Rad 9:41
Well, I mean, this is the thing about the way that our stories are coming together at this point in time, as we’ve talked about, Livy’s drawing on multiple things. He’s using earlier analysts. He’s also using, probably family histories that have been passed down. They might be oral stories. They might be oral stories that became something that was written down or preserved in some other way. He’s using archeological sources like inscriptions, etc, etc. But one of the things that might be influencing him is this antiquarian tradition as well, where the Romans are obviously trying to explain all sorts of details about their culture, and that’s particularly flowering at the time that Livy’s writing probably because Rome has undergone such a troubled century in the sort of late Republic and early Empire, the Romans seem to have been inspired to figure out their origins, to find out, why do we call it that place name, and, where did that cult come from? And how do we explain this building or this monument? And sometimes they might have come up with things at some point to try and explain why something is the way it is. And obviously it’s really hard for us to trace exactly how strong their evidence is for these stories. They’re coming up with another example of that is the story that we talked about last time about the crucifixion of the dogs, which happened every year, obviously, with the whole thing with the geese and the dogs and the assaults on the Capitol, if you don’t know what I’m talking about, you need to go back and listen again. It’s one of those things where it’s obviously a tradition that has survived. But is this really what happened? Is this really why the Romans had this cultural practice, or is this something that’s been woven into the account of the Gallic sack to try and explain a custom that people have kind of lost track perhaps, of exactly why they do what they do?
Dr G 12:56
Yeah, fair enough. There is a sense in which the Romans are definitely trying to figure out what their identity is like, and this is a landmark event in their imagination, at the very least, because we don’t have a lot of archeological evidence to back up.
Dr Rad 13:12
We certainly don’t
Dr G 13:13
This Gallic sack and so even this idea of a Gallic invasion that moves so far down into Central Italy is difficult to navigate from an evidential perspective as ancient historians, and the significance of this tale for the Romans is huge.
Dr Rad 13:32
Absolutely.
Dr G 13:33
There’s so much detail. This is why we’re in part five of this narrative, because they do focus in on every moment, and this idea that eventually, what it sort of boils down to is this embarrassing exchange where Rome gives up, essentially.
Dr Rad 13:59
Yeah.
Dr G 14:00
They do, they do pay the money to the Gauls. And even though both sides are looking a little worse for wear and neither are having a good time, there does seem to be a recognition from those who remain on the Capitol that they cannot stick this out, that if this does go on, ultimately they will be the losers from it. They’re not sure whether any of their neighbours are going to turn up with forces. What has happened with the messages from they has not necessarily resulted in something positive or tangible that they’ve been able to see. And there is still the looming figure of Camillus, who is in exile, and nobody really knows where he is, and nobody knows if he’s ever turning up. And even if he did, would he have any forces with him?
Dr Rad 14:42
Well, of course, at this point, they have sought him out. They’ve tried to go through the proper processes in my account, because for Livy, at this point in time, it’s the Camilla show. We know that, as you say, this story is such a big part of the way that the Romans imagine their history by the time people like. Livy were writing the traditions around it had been fairly well established. The narrative had been fairly well established. However, that doesn’t mean that there aren’t obviously these differences in exactly how the story unfolds. And certainly Livy works Camillus in in a very particular way, and he constructs the whole of his first 10 books kind of around Camillus, particularly now that we’re into this, this later period here we’re talking about, you know, books sort of five to 10, and 10 is where we unfortunately lose the detailed Livy for a little while. But yes, Camillus is a big part of that. And exactly as you say in my account, the Romans pelt the Gauls with bread, feel good about themselves and like that’ll show them. But then they turn to each other and they say, but I’m actually really, very hungry. Really, really hungry. I don’t know how much longer I can last. And you know what? I think we just used up the last of the bread to make an emphatic point, yeah.
Dr G 15:59
Do we have any grain stores on hand? No, we don’t.
Dr Rad 16:03
No, I think maybe, maybe I might have let my temper get the best of me.
Dr G 16:12
Rome – never!
Dr Rad 16:15
And meanwhile in Livy’s account, this is where we flash to what’s going on in Ardea, because that is where Camillus is in exile. Camilius-
Dr G 16:24
and now for a new chapter,
Dr Rad 16:25
Yeah. Now that Camillus has managed to have his proper appointment where he’s been properly selected as dictator, he’s getting into action. So he’s conducting a levy. He’s also selected a master of the horse, naturally, a guy called Lucius Valerius, and he’s asking him to bring his army from Veii meet Camillus in Ardea, I presume. Camillus is then starting to train the troops – Drill, baby drill! This is the time he wants to make sure that they’re going to be able to kick some Gallic ass. Yeah, gun show. Mwa Mwa.
Dr G 17:04
It’s time for a training montage.
Dr Rad 17:05
It is, yeah, it very much is. It’s a point where, if we could afford it, we would play Eye of the Tiger. He’s got them punching meat in butchers shops, in the animal warehouses. He’s got them in gray, sweatpants. They’re running up and downstairs.
Dr G 17:22
It’s all happening. Yeah, look, I don’t want to ruin Livy’s show just yet, but I’m just going to put a flag here to say that the stories that Dr Rad is about to tell you from Livy are highly contentious.
Dr Rad 17:36
Whoa, I can’t believe you’re throwing me under a bus in front of the listeners. Dr, G, they’re watching. They’e listening.
Dr G 17:45
Just putting it out there. Listen carefully. Listen well. Warning. Warning.
Dr Rad 17:50
Sorry. It’s very confusing, because we’re kind of video recording this as well as audio recording this. So I’m like, I don’t know who to address. Do I address YouTube? Do I address people who have just got me in their areas? I don’t know. Okay, so back in Rome, we’re switching back. Okay, we’ve gone from the butcher storehouse to Rome. So the army on the Capitol really is at their absolute lowest at this point in time. They are well worn down, not so much from fighting the Gauls, just just doing their regular duties that they have to do, which I presume means, you know, standing guard being centuries and presumably helping each other out to keep life turning as well as it can up there on the Capitol, because we know that some of them have family out there. It’s not just fighting men there and then obviously the level of starvation, that old chestnut, of which I’m sure it’s much worse by the bread display earlier, they are desperately wanting to hold out until Camillus shows up, because that’s the plan, as far as they’re concerned. You know, Camillus has been made dictator. They’re watching. They’re waiting. And nothing happens. There’s just nothing on the horizon. They don’t know what Camillus is up to. They unfortunately can’t hear ‘Eye of the Tiger’ from the Capitol, Ardea is just a little bit too far away, and so they’re almost getting to the point where they’re too weak to even wear armour when they’re on the lookout. They are at that level of starvation, which actually does sound pretty somber and terrible.
Dr G 17:50
That’s bad.
Dr Rad 17:50
Yeah. No surprises. So the Romans are starting to discuss, what are we going to do in terms of surrender? How do we handle this whole situation? Do we literally just surrender? You know, get us the whitest piece of fabric that we have left after being up here on the Capitol for seven months and wave it. Or do we do something like, say, ransom ourselves to the Gauls. The Gauls had said that they weren’t necessarily like looking for a lot in order to bring this whole situation to the end. Because, as we talked about, it’s not like the Gauls are having a fabulous time either. This isn’t like ‘Roman Holiday’ here. So the Senate have a meeting, naturally, process, process, yes, and they say to the military tribunes with consular power that are up there, look, just, just organise some terms. Have a meeting and somehow organising this, this can’t go on much longer, so a meeting is set up. A guy called Quinctius Sulpicius, one of our military tribunes, meets with the so called leader of the Gauls Brennus. Suspicious name, but sure, here we are, and this is where, in my account, the Romans agree to pay 1000 pounds of gold. Livy, at this moment is like, I’m wigging out, guys, this is crazy. Rome is about to become the greatest empire ever, and here they are on their knees agreeing to pay these barbarians. I mean, how hilarious and ironic, right? Guys, wink, wink, nudge, nudge. Yeah.
Dr Rad 19:22
It is an interesting moment for the Romans where they’re like, okay, not only is that an outlandish sum to ask of us, but yes, we’re going to pay it. And we have Quinctius Sulpicius, as you mentioned, is the military tribune who’s sort of leading the conference with Brennus. And they agree that they’ll deliver that gold, and then the Gauls will depart, not just away from Rome, the city, but out of Roman territory. They’re just, they’re just gonna leave everything.
Dr Rad 20:08
Which sounds extensive, but isn’t really that.
Dr Rad 20:08
It means they have to get past right at the very least, I’ve got to go, at least, keep going, get out in here, it’s going to be at least a day’s walk. And this is where we start to get the stories about the interference with the scales.
Dr Rad 20:31
Yes.
Dr G 20:31
So the Gauls are like, you know what’s going to be fun if we just keep piling things on our side of the scales? And the Romans are like, what are you what are you doing? We’re weighing out a precise measure. You can’t just keep adding things to the scales.
Dr Rad 20:31
It’s 1000 pounds, not like, whatever pounds.
Dr Rad 20:31
Yeah, and the Gauls are like, we might be hungry and willing to leave, but we still got a sense of humour. And if you want us to leave, we’re just going to add this little extra piece to our side of the scale and be like, oh, well, that’s that’s not 1000 pounds of gold. The Romans are like, you’ve got to be kidding me.
Dr Rad 20:54
Yeah. And when the Romans try and point this out in my account, this is a very dramatic moment where the military tribunes say, I’m very sorry to be that guy. But I couldn’t help but notice that the mathematics of this situation, they just don’t seem to be 100% correct. I think you might be asking for more than 1000 pounds of gold, and this is where a Gallic soldier rips out his sword, throws it on the pile where they’re stacking up all their stuff to skew the weights, and says “Woe to the conquered”, which is a fancy way of saying tough titties, guys, we get to call the shots around here.
Dr G 20:59
Yeah, this idea of this phrase that variously translated as “Woe to the conquered”, “Woe to the vanquished”, and the Gauls basically standing there at this moment of a peace treaty being like some of these ones.
Dr Rad 23:52
Dr G is giving me two fingers up for those listening in audio format only.
Dr G 23:58
And this phrase passes into Latin proverb, it becomes a thing that they say to each other.
Dr Rad 24:03
It does. Well, and this, it’s no wonder the Romans go back to this supposed moment, because it’s obviously deeply shameful that not only was their city taken, not only did the Gauls steal a bunch of their stuff and set a bunch of their buildings on fire, allegedly, not only did they massacre the elderly patricians, senators, whatever you want to call them, and not only have they continued to siege for a number of months, but they haven’t been able to get themselves out of this situation, and now they’re actually having to pay to get these guys to go. I mean, I can’t really imagine much of a lower point for the Romans at this moment in time.
Dr G 24:45
This is a huge low point. I don’t think Rome has ever been so low. I put it to you because from the very beginning, they’ve been on a upwards trajectory with some little bumps in the road, admittedly. But always quite quickly back to an upwards trajectory, and this, this is a massive blow. Most of their population doesn’t seem to be in the city. It’s limited in supplies. They’re at their wits end. They don’t think they’ve got any help coming. If they know about Camillus, which is not clear from my source material that they do, then they really are having to make the best decision that they can for their own survival under terrible circumstances, and they’re just really lucky that the Gauls agree to go away for a sum of cash, because, I mean, any other enemy in central Italy at this time, and Rome has a few of them would probably not have gone, yeah, give us some cash and we’ll go.
Dr Rad 25:48
Yeah, well, and that, I think, shows the fact that the Gauls aren’t necessarily here because they want to establish, like a permanent settlement themselves in this particular location. I think that’s why they’re happy to accept this money. Apparently, in order to go away, they’re interested in having portable wealth. And this is, this is part of the narrative that we’re given about why Gauls are on the move at this time, they are looking for more land. They’re looking for more goods. And so with them being so far south at this point in time, they probably do want stuff that they can carry – cash and carry only, thank you very much. And that might explain some of the archaeology, the fact that we don’t find a huge conflagration in the in the records when we sort of dig down deep enough, there is evidence of a great fire that probably was fairly destructive, but it’s just not the right time period. And even though we might be a few years off here with the Gallic siege, obviously, people sort of speculate it happened sort of between 390 and sort of 387 386 because of the differences in dating. But it’s definitely at around this time that this supposedly happened, this encounter. So the dating is just off. It would make sense if the Gauls were more interested in stealing things, because that wouldn’t leave any trace in the archaeological records for us to see, and it explains why, in spite of the fact that the Romans think that the Gauls set most of their city on fire, there are, in fact, still buildings and inscriptions and statues that predate the Gallic sack of Rome standing hundreds of years later into Livy’s time.
Dr G 27:24
I think there’s also something to be said for the way that the authors of the sources that we’re able to access have particular ideas about the Gauls because of Rome’s engagement with Gallia in the first century BC as well. So there’s a very particular picture that has been built up about what Gallic people are like on the basis of things like Caesar’s campaigns in Gaul and so for a Roman writer like Livy and even for a Greek writer like Didorus Siculus, there is a sense in which there is a pre-established idea about what Gallic people are like. They’re a raid and plunder kind of people. They are not about firm sort of settlements, necessarily. They’re more about moving and raiding and being able to pick up and be on the go if they need to. And those kinds of ideas, I think, are partly what is feeding into this narrative as well, because the Romans don’t conceive of the Gallic people as a people that would want to stay in Italy, even though, historically, they’ve been in the northern parts of Italy for a few centuries already, and they got to have lived somewhere.
Dr Rad 28:49
Hey
Dr G 28:50
They’ve probably put down some roots.
Dr Rad 28:52
It’s well beyond where the Romans are at this point in time. Northern Italy, what’s that? Now, this is where I’d like to do a bit of a tangent, if I may. Dr, G, I mean, I know, I know, I’m making this series even longer, but I have been doing a bit of extra reading around these accounts, because it’s so complicated, picking apart the slightly different narratives that we get and the details that we get. And as we say, we’re dealing with this thing where we’ve got this very epic, detailed narrative history, and yet at the same time, we’re kind of like, did this happen though, Livy, did it? I have some questions, exactly, so I’m going to put it to you. Dr G, where the hell did this 1000 pounds of gold come from?
Dr G 29:35
Well, I would say if it came from anywhere, it’d have to be the Temple of Jupiter Optimus Maximus, because that’s on the Capitolini hill. Otherwise, not sure.
Dr Rad 29:47
Yeah, and this is exactly the problem. This is something that one of the academics I read has delved into. If you’d like to read the article, please check out our show notes. They have tried to figure out, okay, so where’s the money coming from? Because in our different accounts, we’re given slightly different details, which probably reflects the particular perspective of the person writing. So the account that we get of this whole galaxy each of course, is that most Romans have left by the time the Gauls arrive. You know they the Romans are defeated at the Alia. They know things aren’t going well for them. They’ve scattered. We know that a lot of the population has therefore left the city. The whole idea is you just have this band of fighting men and a couple of extras who are left behind, and then, of course, the older gentlemen who are all sorted so they don’t count.
Dr G 30:37
Yeah, anybody who reasonably could go has gone.
Dr Rad 30:41
Yes, exactly. And we know that because this was seen as such a monumental moment for Roman history. Obviously, this is a story that was told and retold, and, you know, we slightly reworked over time, depending, I guess, on what the Romans needed to sort of get out of it, I suppose. So, what this person has actually suggested is that what we’re witnessing here was, in fact, a total Gallic capture of Rome. So the entire city is taken. It’s not this situation where some of the buildings are set on fire, but then the girls say, You know what? We’re going to leave you just a tiny little bit of hope so that you’re going to pierce the ransom and leave some of the buildings, etc, etc.
Dr G 31:20
I like that one, leave it.
Dr Rad 31:23
I think this is a total takeover. And then we have to figure out where are the assets coming from? Because we only have this tiny group who are left behind and starving to death. Where are they coming up with 1000 pounds of gold? Now, in Livy’s account, he is very particular that they do not use temple treasure in the ransom.
Dr G 31:43
Oh, well, that’s a problem that’s my one source.
Dr Rad 31:49
Well, the reason being, of course, and this feeds into the other things I’ve been telling you, Livy is all about protocol at this point in time. You know, the Romans have got themselves into this situation, apparently, because of their lack of attention to the signs that the gods are sending them there, they got off balance with the gods. They weren’t doing things properly, not pious enough. And so now they’re in this situation. And once they’re in this situation, when the chips are down, they’re doing everything by the book. So even when they’re besieged, they’re like, We have to go through the proper procedures to appoint a dictator. Guys, can’t just wait for someone to come in on a white horse. You know how we feel about white horses, especially if there’s more than one of them, we really got to make sure we do everything properly. You know, cross every T, dot every I.
Dr G 32:36
You know what? In our alternative history, it’s really fortunate that Camillus isn’t around, actually, because he would have talked them into giving over the temple treasure, and then it would have all gone downhill from,
Dr Rad 32:47
I don’t know, I don’t know if he would. He’s such a pious guy, it’s all very confusing. But anyway, in Livy’s account, it’s not the temple treasure, okay? Because that would be, obviously, it’s, I suppose, slightly offensive to the gods, you know, not perhaps exactly the picture he wants to paint at this point in time. And so it’s just state gold. I mean, I guess it’s possible that they just have some state gold with them, because, as I constantly point out, when discussing climate change, you can’t eat money, so you may as well use your money to fix the situation around. But yeah, so maybe they do, I suppose, have some state gold. They don’t have quite enough, and this is where Roman matrons apparently chip in some of their gold in order to make up the balance. This will come back to later, and it’s because of the Roman citizens pulling together, uniting, showing what Rome is all about, showing off those values that they’re able to make up the account. In other accounts, it absolutely is temple treasure that is used. However, we also have to question exactly the nature of this temple treasure, because, of course, we know that a lot of valuable objects have been taken. We had that whole story, Dr G about the Vestals fleeing in a cart meant for a family, and they’re far, far away, and they’ve buried some of the treasure as well, so they don’t have access to everything at this point in time, even Varro, who is one of these antiquarians we were talking about before, who we only have snippets of, he is one of the sources that we have that mentions that temple treasures were used, but also jewelry donated by Roman matrons.
Dr G 34:31
Look, it wouldn’t surprise me if they’re scrounging for every piece of gold that can get their hands on. Really, they’re confined to the Capitoline hill, so that immediately limits their physical accessibility to storage. So it’s either temples or if they do have a physical structure that houses the public treasury at this point, which is when I’m not sure archaeologists, please weigh in and let us know. Did they have a public treasury building at this point? Was it on the Capitoline? If yes, we can all start to make sense of this. But turning to the people themselves seems the ultimate answer to this as well, because once you’ve depleted all of the publicly accessible wealth, what do you do next? If you’re still falling short, and this is a very specific figure that we’ve been given 1000 pounds of gold is a massive amount to ask, and it’s the kind of round figure that that feels questionable, like many of the round figures that we get from ancient sources, but it’s obviously designed, from a literary perspective, to give us a sense of the overwhelming nature of what the Gauls require in order to go away, to perhaps lessen Roman shame around this idea that they had to capitulate, that it was a capitulation that was substantial enough to make sense, that they they did it, and it was possible, and it allows them maybe to save some face there. But I think it’s really, it’s a really interesting question that this scholar has asked, like, what gold?
Dr Rad 36:09
Follow the money
Dr G 36:10
Like where? Yeah yeah yeah. And it’s hard to follow the money when we have so little understanding of what’s going on in that archaeological record.
Dr Rad 36:19
Well, yeah, the more they pulled these threads, the more I was like, Oh, my God, they’re totally right. Because not only have all the Romans gone, not only have they apparently removed a lot of the valuables for safe keeping, the Gauls have then plundered all the rest of the parts of the city, apart from the capital. So it’s not like the Romans can sneak out and get their little piggy bank from their house that they left behind. It’s all gone.
Dr G 36:42
Although maybe that’s exactly what they did. I mean, we had that priest who snuck down into the forum…
Dr Rad 36:48
Not snuck he just walked out. He was just like, out of my way. I’ve got a ritual to perform.
Dr G 36:52
But if he could get away with that, maybe everyone’s like, you know what? I’m just gonna do a quick, sneaky run to my house. I’ll be back.
Dr Rad 36:59
I’m now come back, bring a Gallic warrior with like a spear held above somebody’s head, as a Roman, you know, pulls aside like a fresco, and it’s like, yeah, getting into their wall safe.
Dr G 37:10
Exactly. It was like, I know where the family jewels are hidden. I’ll be back, guys. Give me five minutes.
Dr Rad 37:15
I think this is the way this scholar is sort of imagining it. So basically, to preserve Rome’s dignity, as you were talking about, we have this scenario where they have at least managed to keep the Gauls off the Capitol, and even though that it’s extremely shameful to enter into these negotiations, have to pay the Gauls to go away, at least the Gauls, in this narrative, didn’t take the Capitol. You know, it was all protected. This scholar, I think, is suggesting that’s actually not the case. Everything was taken, and this is why the Romans find themselves in this scenario. And of course, they actually probably don’t have the resources. And if everything was taken, then maybe we are actually dealing with a ransom situation. Because if we think about that particular institution of Rome, the patron-client relationship, which, whilst we can’t obviously be 100% sure exactly how it played out at this point in time, it is a constant. We know it existed at this point in time, there would have been an obligation to help out. If you could, you know, call on your clients, or, you know, you know, call on your patrons. There’s an obligation there to help each other out. And so it’s possible that what actually happened in this scholar’s imagination is that the Romans are calling on outside sources, maybe even other cities. So like Caere has come up in our narrative, we know that Rome is going to, after all this is over, have a special relationship with Caere because they, you know, they were real, a real pal, a real solid friend in Rome’s time of need. And maybe this is indicative of a role that Caere played that has not made it into the narrative in the most accurate way, perhaps that you know the reason why the Romans have this sense of obligation to them, and with so many Romans sort of spread in the surrounding area, this scholar sort of highlighted that it would have been potentially possible to call on these outside sources To deal with this ransom situation, and it would explain why Livy can’t exactly pinpoint for us, where have these state funds been hidden this entire time? What’s going on with, you know, the matrons? You know, not, not even all the patricians, are in Rome. It’s not like, we’re talking about, like all the rich guys stayed behind to fight. No, they didn’t. It’s just a select group of people, so it’s just a question of, yeah, it doesn’t seem likely that they’re going to have everything that they possibly need, particularly if they are completely under Gaelic control, and the capital was potentially actually seized. At this point in time?
Dr G 40:01
Yeah, definitely. And thinking back to earlier accounts of this same situation, we know that even though some of the women stayed that the men weren’t happy about that, they thought they were just going to be a burden.
Dr Rad 40:18
Well, women can’t fight or do anything useful!
Dr G 40:25
Not from a Roman perspective, but maybe they were making the bread. Goodness knows, if I was a matron who had finally made some bread and then my fellow men had thrown it off the Capitoline, I mean, I would be ropeable.
Dr Rad 40:43
Talk about the mental load.
Dr G 40:46
And so even in the context where I think this is a nice, also a literary echo, the idea that the matrons are giving up their jewelry, because this is referencing another moment in history a couple of centuries later.
Dr Rad 40:59
Yes, well, we’ve had this happen before, not that long ago as well, like where matrons have given up, yeah, yeah.
Dr G 41:05
And again, probably that one also maybe a literary echo.
Dr Rad 41:09
You ruin everything, Dr G.
Dr G 41:12
And this idea that in in times where Rome is really in strife, that it’s actually the women who come forward and do the thing that needs to be done in order to get things across the line. And so Rome has this sort of ongoing narrative about itself, where, when it when push comes to shove, it is the matrons who stand up, and it makes all of their narratives around women being unhelpful or not useful, not in their place, blah, blah, blah, or the misogyny incredibly infuriating, because every time the Roman men have ruined it to the point where it’s not working anymore, those women stand up and say, fine, you know what? I’ll get us out of this.
Dr Rad 41:58
I’m getting a big scenario here. Okay, so these starving Roman men have just pelted Gallic soldiers underneath with the remaining bread that they have left. And then they turn around, their anger kind of disappears, and they’re like, What are we going to do now? And there are some women just sitting there on a couch, and they’re like, Well, who needs my help now, boys?
Dr G 42:25
Exactly – every time Roman women come through.
Dr Rad 42:28
Now, there is a detail that this scholar has highlighted, which I actually probably would have missed, because there’s a bit of a gap. We’ll come to it later, but there is a bit of a gap in between this moment and when this reference comes up in a few years, when we get to another moment involving our hero of the Capitol, Marcius Manlius Capitolinius, he’s going to become a real douchebag in a few years. And when he is being a douchebag, he makes reference to the fact that the patricians are somehow hiding the Gallic gold, and they’re somehow abusing public funds. And it’s thought that this could be a reference to the fact that it is definitely the plebs that have managed to escape with all their movable wealth, which might be more than usual, because, of course, we’ve just had the conquest. They things have been going relatively well for Rome. So who knows what the plebs managed to escape with? Who knows what they’ve got in Veii. But these people who have pitched in to pay this ransom, if they are indeed from outside of the city at this moment in time, they then obviously want that money to be accounted for in the aftermath of this ransom being paid. And there’s this very brief reference that sort of indicates that Livy knows, or at least he’s repeating something, and maybe he hasn’t even picked up on, you know, the significance of what he’s sort of saying here, but that there is something else that’s gone on here that’s been kind of concealed in his original narrative.
Dr Rad 42:29
Wow. Look like I said earlier. I think Livy’s account has some question marks over it, so…
Dr Rad 43:58
Well it does, because, of course, one of the things we’re going to get into in the aftermath, and I’m sorry to give this away, but there is going to be disputes about land, as we’re going to go back to that old chestnut in a few years. And it’s possible that one of the reasons why this pops up is because the plebs contributed to saving Rome in this moment. And therefore, when we’re talking about distributing land, which, of course, is a form of wealth, a base of wealth, and particularly in this sort of society here, that there is something to do with this moment of crisis in terms of why they feel perhaps they have a stake in what’s going on going forward after this particular moment. Definitely, I think it makes sense to raise all these sorts of questions, and we’re about to get to this moment in my account, and I’m sorry again for spoilers, because I don’t want to ruin the drama here, but I sort of have to highlight it now. I have no choice, Dr G, Camillus is going to show up in my account whilst this is all happening. Okay, this is where he makes his heroic return.
Dr G 45:17
Agent of chaos – back on the scene.
Dr Rad 45:19
Yeah, absolutely. And he’s going to set everything to rights. Don’t you worry. Dr G, here he comes to save the day. But it’s possible that the Gauls are the ones that actually get screwed over here. So we have this account, obviously, where the Gauls are being tricksy, because, you know, that’s what they’re like. Where’s their code of honour? But what if it’s actually the other way around, and Camillus showing up here? Maybe Camillus is showing up to make the payment, or maybe there’s, maybe there’s a band of Romans showing up to make the payment, and then they get all tricksy.
Dr G 45:59
I’m going to hold on to to what I’ve said earlier, which is that there was at least one other scholar in my corner who says Diodorus Siculus has the most accurate account of the stuff that’s going on.
Dr Rad 46:12
Look, I have read such things, even though it seems ludicrous.
Dr G 46:16
And the thing is that Camillus is in no way involved in the Gallic siege, beginning to end. He’s not there. He’s just not there, and he turns up not only after the Gauls have left, so they’ve received their payment and keeping to their word, although winking and laughing to themselves as they go, being like, wasn’t that a bit of fun. As they exit stage left, the Volscians enter stage right. And it is only when the Volscians have turned up being like, oh, Rome, this is the best thing we’ve seen. Look at you now, and the Volscians are gearing up for what they think is going to be a very easy takedown of Rome at this point, because the Romans are just sort of lying on the Capitol line Hill being like, I’m so glad the Gauls have gone and I don’t even know what I’m going to eat, because there’s nothing up here, and I don’t know if I can crawl down far enough to find a piece of bread that I threw three days ago. And while they’re doing that, the Volscians are like and it is only then, it seems, that Camillus sort of emerges out of the countryside with a fully fledged force that he’s been gathering for quite some time, probably made up from the folk of Veii and people he’s come across in the countryside who are also Roman, who like, oh, Camilius! Ah! Well! And he has turned up, and it’s the Volscians that he engages with initially, because that’s the most immediate threat that Rome is facing.
Dr Rad 47:59
Well, look, I am just going to say that Livy’s account is far more comforting than this rubbish you are spewing, Dr G, if we go with Livy’s account, then the Romans are not so impious or lame as to use their temple treasures in order to pay the Gauls. They hold onto the Capitol. There is no complete Gallic invasion the Romans at least, can say that they’ve done their duty to the city, and then they get Camillus to show up and put everything to right and put those freaking barbarians in their place. Livy’s account is the account to go for because, let me tell you. Dr G, this is the moment where Camillus settles up. Because, of course, the gods are not going to let the Romans be pulverized into the ground because they’ve been doing the right thing. They’ve been making sure that everything is appropriate. So it’s whilst there’s argument over the weight where the Romans keep saying, No, I refuse to believe that this is 1000 pounds in gold. I think you’re being a tricksy little Gaul. And the Gauls are saying, I am so evil. I have no interest in your concerns, Roman accountant.
Dr G 49:18
And it’s like, what are you gonna do about it? How you’re going to stop me?
Dr Rad 49:21
Exactly. So the stalling is when Camillus enters the scene and no money has actually changed hands. So the shame of Rome is somewhat averted by the entrance of Camillus, because whilst they’re about to make the payment, they don’t. No, instead, Camillus shows up and says, hey guys, why don’t you make like a tree and leave the Gauls say, I don’t think so, mate, we had a deal. Now this, of course, is the moment where maybe Camillus is actually showing up with the money the Gauls are just waiting to get the money. And instead of paying them, Camillus and his band start a war. And the Gauls are like, what the hell I thought we had a deal?
Dr G 50:09
I don’t want to say that this is almost unbelievable, but there’s a lot of holes in this story.
Dr Rad 50:15
It gets better. Camillus then says, pish-tosh, your deal is null and void because you made it with some other magistrate, some lowly military tribune with consular power. Whereas I am dictator. So put that in your pipe and smoke it King Brennus. Instead of a pile of gold, I’m going to be giving you a steaming pile of war. How do you like that?
Dr G 50:46
I do like how the Romans have turned into British imperial, aka Star Wars style.
Dr Rad 50:53
Entirely intentional, I assure you. I’m just following Livy’s account to the letter.
Dr G 51:00
Look. So problem number one the timeline. Camillus is not here. He’s just not here. He’s somewhere else. He doesn’t turn up. The money definitely changes hands. As far as Diodorus Siculus is concerned, the Romans give over the 1000 pounds of gold. The Gauls start to walk away. In Diodorus’ account, Camillus isn’t even appointed dictator until he turns up and the Volscians are already at Rome’s door. And Rome is like, We really need your assistance. And he’s like, Well, I need to be able to command troops, because I don’t have permission to do that, because I’m an exile. And they’re like, oh, right, right, right, right, right. Quick meeting. Quick meeting. Quick dictator title is offered. And so it’s this idea in this intense situation where the Gauls are moving off into the distance with all of the treasure, the Volscians there being like, and the Romans are like, okay, we’ll make it legal for you to lead this army that you’ve turned up with. Camilius, please, please, please. And he’s like, sure thing now that I have the legal right to do so, I’m willing to help out. And the moment of the dictatorship is post 1000 pounds of gold. It is also post the arrival of the Volscians and he’s very late in the piece. So his contribution, essentially, to the Gallic sack of Rome is zero, because by the time that he turns up the Gallic sack has happened, and he’s just picking up the crumbs and being like, I’ll help you guys out. It’s probably time that I did something. And everyone’s like, please do you’re the only one who’s been fed in six months.
Dr Rad 52:48
Look, I don’t enjoy these moments. Dr, G, but I mean, you’re just so wrong. Camillus is quite clearly coming in like the white knight that he is. He then turns around to the soldiers that he’s been drilling Rocky 1975 style, and says, throw your packs down on the ground, get your weapons. We’re gonna win Rome’s freedom through iron, not gold. Who’s with me? And everyone loses their minds, because in Livy’s account, the Romans now have every motivation to fight. They’ve got their city not in shambles, even though they kind of keep referencing the fact that it is partly in shambles, not well maintained, their families, but most importantly, their gods, their temples clearly still standing, at least in part. The Capitol, of course, not being touched. And so the grand temple on the Capitol is indeed still standing and of course, the soil, the soil itself from which they were birthed, not really, but let’s run with it. They can just see it all before them, everything that their faith, everything that their gods, everything that their land has allowed them to live for and now they get to defend, recover, avenge.
Dr G 54:29
Wow.
Dr Rad 54:31
Camillus then readies his forces and draws up his battle lines, even though this is incredibly difficult because Rome’s landscape is extremely uneven, and there’s crap everywhere because it’s been devastated, but he always makes sure that the Romans are in the best position possible to give them every chance of winning. The Gauls have no idea what’s going on. They didn’t expect this. Surprise dictator to show up with his rocky trained Sylvester Stallone forces at his back. They’ve got their weapons and armor and typically for barbarians, attack with more rage than judgment. Oh yes, we’re back into the racist territory here. But fortune was no longer on their side. So they can be as angry as they want. Fortune’s back with the Romans, Dr G, they’ve been punished enough. They’ve had to watch their city burn in part, kind of, not really. They’ve had to watch their families leave kind of, maybe not really. It’s Rome’s moment, and so the Gauls are very quickly overcome. I mean, considering the siege has gone on for as long as it is, it’s almost too hard to believe that they are so easily overcome. But this is “Alia Part Two: Judgment Day”. Rome gets to win this time. It’s all been fixed. But then comes a second battle, which is described as a more regular engagement, which I presume means that everyone knows it’s coming this time, and they’re, you know, properly attired and ready for it, and that sort of thing…
Dr Rad 56:14
Please please. I’ve got to put on my military boots.
Dr Rad 56:18
I didn’t even put on my eye makeup. My hair’s still in rollers. It happens about eight miles out on the Gabinian Way where the Gauls had withdrawn after their first disastrous defeat by Camillus. But I mean, with Camillus on the Roman side, do they even stand a chance? No, they don’t. Dr, G, they definitely do not. And they are defeated again.
Dr G 56:40
Wow, yeah, wow.
Dr Rad 56:42
I’m as exhausted as a Roman has been on the Capitoline for seven months.
Dr G 56:49
Well, look, I look forward to our next episode together, where I will tell listeners and your good self the true history of what happens with Camillus and the Gallic siege.
Dr Rad 57:03
I don’t think you can come back from this, Dr G, Livy is quite clear that the Gauls are massacred and there’s not a single survivor.
Dr G 57:09
So there is a lot of material to work with here.
Dr Rad 57:13
If that ain’t the truth, I don’t know what is. I mean, Camillus, this is like, you know, another second founding moment. He’s secured Rome, able to head back to Rome, victorious. I mean, just, everything’s just perfect again.
Dr G 57:26
Everything’s fallen into place.
Dr Rad 57:29
Totally is. I mean, is there a limit to how many times Camillus can save Rome? I just don’t think that there is.
Dr G 57:38
Yeah, look, definitely not. I mean, he’s done it again. Go sunshine.
Dr Rad 57:41
Yep. Everyone’s turning around and saying, You know what? We’re gonna start calling you Romulus, because you are the second founder of the city, Camillus.
Dr G 57:49
Dangerous, dangerous times.
Dr Rad 57:52
All right, Dr, G, now that I am spent with all that drama
Dr G 57:56
much like the Romans themselves, after these adventures,
Dr Rad 57:59
exactly, yeah, I think it’s time for the Partial Pick. All right. Dr, G, please tell us what is the Partial Pick?
Dr G 58:11
Well, we’re going to rate those Romans according to their own criteria that we made up. They are up for a total of 50 golden eagles, 10 in each category. The first category is military clout.
Dr Rad 58:29
Well, I mean, can you really put too many eagles on the fact that the Romans have just killed all the Gauls that were besieging them for so long.
Dr G 58:41
You have to think about this in terms of the 80% of the episode where they were starving to death.
Dr Rad 58:48
I’m taking a Livian approach, where I just focus on the good stuff that makes Rome look better.
Dr G 58:53
Only interested in results, guys, results only. Yeah, look, I’m unwilling to overlook the 80% of the terrible times that they had where there was not a whiff of military cloud, there was, in fact, mostly the breeze of things going badly.
Dr Rad 59:13
Yeah, okay, look, look, I will concede that it’s probably likely that Rome didn’t have a good time at this moment. Whether it was 390 BCE or 387 or whatever, it’s probably not great.
Dr G 59:30
No, yeah, not ideal. I’m glad that they’ve made a comeback, if we’re just basing it on Camillus’ military clout, yeah, according to Livy, which – question marks
Dr Rad 59:39
Should we have two ratings this time where, like, one’s the Livy version was probably what really happened?
Dr G 59:46
Yeah, look, I think it might end up being the case that we give a really high score now because Livy’s version is so powerful, and then we might give a very different score later, when we get through Diodorus Siculus and what he has to say about the same situation.
Dr Rad 59:59
Okay. Let’s do it. Let’s look at the sunshine and lollipops version.
Dr G 1:00:03
As military clout, yeah. And if we’re thinking about what Camilo has done according to Livy, very powerful, yeah, very moving, yeah. I mean, just strategy, like, yeah, not just the surprise battle, but also the second earlier, the refounding, the Romulus thing, obviously, that’s, that’s a 10, like, it does not get better than that.
Dr Rad 1:00:24
I know. I mean, it’s like a total do over. It’s literally the sequel, but it’s, it’s better than the first movie. And that never happens.
Dr G 1:00:33
Yeah, don’t turn it into a trilogy, because then things go down, it’ll stay with the second film being the best.
Dr Rad 1:00:39
Livy’s not done with Camillus, yeah. He actually is a bit like Rocky in that he will keep coming back. Will keep coming back, even when he probably shouldn’t.
Dr G 1:00:46
As long as we get to the Michael B Jordan films later. That’s fine by me. So military clout, I’m happy to offer Livy’s account just on the basis of just how dramatic it is and how fulsome Camillus powers are. It’s definitely a 10.
Dr Rad 1:01:02
Thanks. All right, what’s our next category then?
Dr G 1:01:07
The second category is diplomacy.
Dr Rad 1:01:10
Ooh, okay, well, there is some negotiation going on.
Dr G 1:01:13
We finally have some diplomacy. We definitely people from different sides coming together.
Dr Rad 1:01:20
Yes, it’s not great, either the Gauls were very deceptive and using their power to exploit the Romans, or the Romans struck a deal and then stabbed them in the back.
Dr G 1:01:34
I mean, the good news is that we don’t have to rate the Gauls because it’s not their problem, and we only care about what the Romans are up to, really, I think.
Dr Rad 1:01:42
This is true either way. I think whichever account you look at that we’ve talked about today, I think it’s probably good for the Romans. The tricky thing is there are other accounts that we haven’t got to yet of how the ransom was actually recovered, which is not by Camilius or Roman army, possibly by the people of Caere or maybe even one of Tiberius ancestors in some sort of single combat later on, didn’t mention that.
Dr G 1:02:17
Spoiler alert. Spoiler alert.
Dr Rad 1:02:19
Yeah
Dr G 1:02:20
Yeah. We won’t get to those. So as terms of how the diplomacy has gone for the Romans, in the version that we’ve looked at, which is predominantly Livy at the moment, yeah, also a little bit of Plutarch, yeah, the diplomacy has been the Romans have done their best, and even when the Gauls have goaded them and poked them and being like, whoa, to the conquered and all of that kind of stuff. And uploaded the more items – uploaded?
Dr Rad 1:02:45
Get the t shirt, get the merch.
Dr G 1:02:49
Whack another shield on the scale, and are having a cheeky time about it. The Romans have matched them yes to get out of this situation. So the Romans, For the first time maybe have been pretty proactive in their diplomacy, because they’re at their wit’s end, and they know that. They don’t – they’re in a corner. They they must do something.
Dr Rad 1:03:11
How diplomatic thought is it there that their first round of negotiations ended up with them throwing their bread supplies?
Dr G 1:03:18
Well, we can certainly give them a lower score.
Dr Rad 1:03:20
I don’t approve of the throwing of baked goods in diplomatic situations, Dr G.
Dr G 1:03:25
It’s a waste of a good pastry, that is. And I disapprove from a love of carbs perspective,
Dr Rad 1:03:31
Absolutely.
Dr G 1:03:31
So I think diplomacy may be a five.
Dr Rad 1:03:34
Okay, all right, yeah, fair enough, yeah. I’ll sit with that.
Dr G 1:03:37
Then we move on to expansion.
Dr Rad 1:03:39
Okay. Well, no matter what account you look at, no is the answer.
Dr G 1:03:44
We’ll have none of that around here. It’s not the time.
Dr Rad 1:03:46
No, even if we go with Livy’s very sunshiny version of things, they’re just getting back what they had taken from them in a very humiliating way.
Dr G 1:03:56
This is true. This is true.
Dr Rad 1:03:57
Yeah,
Dr G 1:03:58
Virtus?
Dr Rad 1:04:00
Okay, well, I think maybe Camillus. Come on. You know, you wanna…
Dr G 1:04:08
What has he done? What has he done?
Dr Rad 1:04:10
He’s been there, Dr G as the dictator. He’s trained an elite force of 80s action heroes for your benefit.
Dr G 1:04:19
Doom do-do-dooo
Dr Rad 1:04:24
Yeah. I think Camillus definitely deserve some points here if we’re sticking with our pattern.
Dr G 1:04:33
But is that virtus? I mean, that’s military prowess. Sure, that’s training up some people. That’s getting people fired up. But does that constitute an understanding of Roman manliness in this moment? I’m not sure that it does.
Dr Rad 1:04:48
I feel like it does, because of what he says to them. You know, when he turns up and the Romans are trying to be diplomatic about the fact that they’re starving to death and the Gauls are piling shields onto the weights, and the Romans are like, I don’t really have the strength to raise my index finger, but I must object to these goings on. It’s just not cricket. Camilius shows up in this moment and is like, we’re not paying you a goddamn thing. You can take your crap and get out of here. We’re gonna win it back through military powers. I kind of feel like that’s got a bit of a virtus moment to it, you know, like, maybe not like a 10, but I feel like it’s, it’s something, and then he massacres them, kills every single Gaul.
Dr G 1:05:35
Every single one.
Dr Rad 1:05:38
Yeah, I mean, practically single handedly. Now I’m embellishing, my embellished account, but
Dr G 1:05:42
What a man, what a man, what a man, what a migthy good man.
Dr Rad 1:05:46
He’s a mighty mighty good man.
Dr G 1:05:49
Camillus, er, virtus, er…
Dr Rad 1:05:51
I want to take a minute or two to give much respect to, to the man that’s made a difference in Rome’s world
Dr G 1:05:56
I do love that song, one of the classics. Okay, so what would you rate this virtus? Because I’m still a bit on the fence, so I’m interested in your perspective on this.
Dr Rad 1:06:06
I know it’s not one of those sorts of moments where, like, the gods are literally shining a beam of sunshine on his head whilst he single handedly charges into battle in like, slow motion and all that kind of stuff. But I feel like it’s got to be like, maybe a two, you know, just something, because I feel like it’s a moment. It’s a moment. I mean, you get called the second founder of Rome. I feel like it’s, it’s something.
Dr G 1:06:30
Oh, yeah, I’m not sure that that’s virtus, though. I’m pretty sure that that sort of encapsulates other things. But, yes, all right, two.
Dr Rad 1:06:37
No, but I think, you know, the the title reflects the deeds, you know, like the look, I’m just, I’m just on a high right now, and I demand those points. You can’t quote Salt’N’Peppa at me and not expect me to fight for my man.
Dr G 1:06:53
Fair enough. Fair enough. Yeah, happy for it to be. Thank you. I appreciate it. The final category is the citizen score.
Dr Rad 1:07:01
Okay, well, again
Dr G 1:07:03
It depends on which citizen you are really.
Dr Rad 1:07:05
Yeah. I mean, yeah, if you’re in exile, maybe it’s all right, but if we go with what was suggested by the academic I read, then they’re having to pay tax and they’re not even in the city.
Dr G 1:07:20
Yeah, not a lot of benefit there.
Dr Rad 1:07:23
No. I mean, the women are involved, Dr G, the women,
Dr G 1:07:26
Even the women!
Dr Rad 1:07:28
Yeah, that’s not a good sign. I saw gold jewelry. They don’t have any anymore. They don’t have any. I’ve given it away for a good cause, room itself. Even though I’m so weak from hunger, I need to have a statement necklace. Hold body upright, show off décolletage…
Dr G 1:07:50
Don’t make me give up the family jewels. I’ll die with this brooch.
Dr Rad 1:07:54
I need to have a shiny ring, so when I flip the gauze off, it sparkles in their eyes.
Dr G 1:08:02
So it’s not a great time to be a patrician matron, I would say.
Dr Rad 1:08:06
No, well, I mean nobody. I mean if you’re in the city, you’re starving to death and possibly taken captive
Dr G 1:08:11
Not ideal. If you’re in Veii, you’re kind of looking wistfully over yonder, being like, I don’t know if this is going to work out for us. And if you’re in Camillus training camp, you’re probably like, let’s get jacked.
Dr Rad 1:08:24
Well, I mean, let’s face it, is that a good time, not a good time in my books? Dr, G, that’s why I’ve never been fit a day in my life. So, yeah, I think if you’re in the whether you’re in the Rocky montage, or whether you’re in exile somewhere else, or whether you’re starving to death on the Capitoline, it’s not good, okay? Camillus is the only one happening in good time, right?
Dr G 1:08:43
He does count as a citizen as well, I suppose so. It sounds to me like we’re dealing with something between a zero and maybe a one.
Dr Rad 1:08:51
I think zero, yeah, it’s got to be zero. I think, yeah.
Dr Rad 1:08:54
Well done and dusted.
Dr Rad 1:08:56
All right, Dr, G, that means that, surprisingly, the Romans have, once again, managed to get a far higher score than I thought. But let’s face it, that’s mostly down to Livy. So Livy, this one’s for you. Rome gets 17 golden eagles. None of them probably deserved.
Dr G 1:09:15
Wow. The power of a good narrative, Livy, he’s really selling us a tale, isn’t he?
Dr Rad 1:09:20
Hey, what can I tell you? I mean this, this is a lesson in ancient historiography. You know, you got a right to please the people. Got to have some flair. Can’t just be fact, fact, fact. Yeah, have that space, that space, that Roman spice, that patrician spice.
Dr G 1:09:39
Well, I really look forward to getting together next time and maybe talking a little bit more about what Diodorus Siculus has to say about this whole situation, and just see maybe where the narrative lands.
Dr Rad 1:09:52
Then I’m going to put quite a limb. Dr, G and say I’m seeing a part seven in our future.
Dr G 1:10:00
Quite possible. In terms of my notes, we have made very little progress in this episode.
Dr Rad 1:10:05
Like a paragraph long.
Dr G 1:10:06
I’ve gotten through two dot points. It’s really not enough. I thought I’d get through maybe five.
Dr Rad 1:10:11
I’m sorry. It’s just, you know what? You’ve got to follow the money. Dr, G, you’ve got to follow the money.
Dr G 1:10:17
Yeah, oh yeah. Well, I’ll continue to do that in my research, and we’ll see where that leads us next time.
Dr Rad 1:10:23
See you. Dr, G.
Dr G 1:10:25
Farewell.
Dr G 1:10:32
Thanks for listening. If you’d like to support the podcast, you can find us on Patreon and Ko-Fi. We’ve also published two books on ancient Roman history. “Rex: The Seven Kings of Rome”, examines the different literary accounts of the earliest rulers recorded in Roman history. “Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire” is full of the sorts of stories the Romans wished you didn’t know about them, and is guaranteed to make the interesting conversation. Thank you to all our Patreon supporters. We are truly humbled by your patronage.
Transcribed by https://otter.ai
The post Episode 170 – The Gallic Sack of Rome – Part 5 appeared first on The Partial Historians - Ancient Roman History with smart ladies.
Marc Hyden returns to the show to discuss the life and times about the second Flavian emperor Titus. The Flavians were the second dynasty of the imperial period extending from 69 CE until the assassination of Domitian in 96 CE. Titus’ reign is short, but significant. We sit down with Marc to consider details of Titus’ rule of Rome and its impact across the Mediterranean, particularly involving Judaea.
Marc’s book Emperor Titus: The Right Hand of Vespasian (2025) is out now and explores at lot of the contextual details that helps us appreciate Titus’ rule as emperor from 79-81 CE.
Nero’s death leads to a period of political chaos in Rome. If you’re keen to delve into the notorious Year of the Four Emperors, we recommend checking out our interview with Dr Rob Cromarty.
Once the dust settles, the military general Vespasian ends up as the top dog in Rome. From unlikely beginnings, Vespasian sets up the Flavian family for dominance over the next thirty years and his eldest son, Titus, was his right-hand man.
It is impossible to truly understand the Flavians’ rise without considering the foothold that they had in Judaea. Military actions in the east were part and parcel of the Roman empire, but the particulars of Vespasian as the Roman general in Judaea when relationships broke down means that Vespasian (and thus the Flavians) are substantially enriched by the sack of the Jewish Temple in Jerusalem. Marc takes us through some of the key details including Josephus’ role in the conflict, the riots across the region
Apparently you can be a Roman a war, but still fall in love with a lady from the local aristocracy. The story of Titus and Berenice is one of the most interesting details of the Flavian era, and we don’t know as much about their relationship than we’d like, but there’s enough gossip to create something of a historical record! Tune in for the details of their seemingly on-again, off-again liaison.
Titus comes into full imperial power on the natural death of his father Vespasian and, oh boy, is he busy. He rules over the eruption of Vesuvius, he formally opens the Flavian Amphitheatre (aka the Colosseum), not to mention a pestilence. With all this busyness, we can only wonder how his reign would have gone if he lived for longer. But sadly it is not to be. Titus dies after a short but intense illness opening wide speculation about the cause of death. We explore some here.
Our music is by Bettina Joy de Guzman.
Lightly edited for our wonderful Australian accents.
Dr Rad 0:15
Welcome to the Partial Historians.
Dr G 0:19
We explore all the details of ancient Rome.
Dr Rad 0:23
Everything from political scandals, the love affairs, the battle’s waged, and when citizens turn against each other. I’m Dr Rad.
Dr G 0:33
And I’m Dr G. We consider Rome as the Romans saw it, by reading different authors from the ancient past and comparing their stories.
Dr Rad 0:44
Join us as we trace the journey of Rome from the founding of the city.
Dr Rad 0:56
Welcome to a brand new episode of the Partial Historians. I am one of your hosts, Dr Rad.
Dr G 1:02
And I am Dr G.
Dr Rad 1:05
Dr G, we are once again privileged to be joined by Mark Hyden, who holds a degree in philosophy and has a love for the ancient Roman world, which shines through in his publications. Mark has published books on a number of ancient Roman personalities, including Romulus: Rome’s legendary fratricidal founder; Marcus Furius Camillus – and you can check out our previous interview with Mark on Camillus; Marius, one of the towering figures of the late Republic, and the second Flavian emperor, Titus, who is the subject of this interview. If you’re keen to get into the heady detail of Titus life and rule, then we recommend Mark’s latest book, “Emperor Titus: The Right Hand of Vespasian”. Welcome to the show again, Mark.
Marc Hyden 1:55
Thank you so much for having me a second time at that. I’m gonna have to keep writing books just so I can hang out with both of you.
Dr Rad 2:02
That’s our plan. Always, always more books, more chats.
Dr Rad 2:06
All right. Well, let’s get into the questions shall we, Dr G, and find out more about the emperor Titus?
Dr G 2:12
Oh, yeah, I even like forgot to look at the document properly. So to get into it by the time we truly meet Titus in our historical sources, the Roman Empire has been going through a bit of a rough patch, you could say. So, to get us oriented, I’m wondering if, Mark, you can tell us a little bit about the state of the Roman Empire in 71 CE, when Titus enters Rome, besides his father, Vespasian.
Marc Hyden 2:41
Yeah, absolutely. So Titus was born in what’s known as the Pax Romana. This was the golden age of the Roman Empire. But matters, they weren’t as rosy as the name might suggest. They were regular conflicts with barbarians. There were threats from the east, there was periodic rioting, and there was, of course, deadly Imperial intrigue, which we all love to read about today, but then it wasn’t quite as riveting, but by the time Titus reaches manhood, he Rome is under the control of Emperor Nero. We remember him as kind of the pudgy, lackluster emperor who preferred the arts and athletic contests and an ample helping of sexual deviancy to Imperial administration. So this irked quite a bit of Romans, quite a few Romans, and his problems didn’t end there. Around 64 it comes 64 ad Rome catches fire, as we know, the Great Fire of Rome and much of the city, the majority of it, has turned to ashes. Now, Nero has been blamed for having something to do with this. It seems pretty clear that he didn’t have anything to do with it. However, with Rome turning to ashes, he saw an opportunity to build a grand estate for himself and redesign Rome in his image. And to do so, he siphoned money away from from the provinces like Gaul and even the Jewish homeland, to Rome so that he could realize his his architectural dreams. This is we hear about this, these sorts of things in the ancient accounts. And this overburdened and really upset the provincials. I mean, we don’t like taxes today, and they were even more angry about it back then, apparently. So not long after this goes down, the Jewish people who fell under Rome’s domain, they grew really weary of Rome’s heavy taxes, the constant mistreatment of them, and really it was egregious, some of the things the Romans did to the Jewish people. So as a result, they rose up in revolt. But, you know, we hear about different revolts in the Roman Empire, but this was no minor revolt. It demanded the Emperor’s attention and really immediate action. It also required generals of great repute and 1000s of battle hardened legionaries to be able to quell this, this burgeoning rebellion. So this is when we see Vespasian and Titus and 1000s of legionaries head to the east, and they lead the armies. And over the course of a few years, they neutralize city after city that had stood against Rome until the revolt was really secluded to primarily to Jerusalem, machaerus, Herodium and Masada, which is now very famous, but we see the success and Vespasian and Titus successes were a bit of good news for for Nero, but trouble was brewing in the West. He thought the problems were in the east, but the biggest problem was in the West, because that’s where a rebellion broke out to depose him, and ultimately he saw the writing on the wall, and with the help of his servant, decided to go ahead and kill himself. But that wasn’t the end of the troubles for the Roman Empire, because everyone wanted to be emperor, apparently. So this sparked a cascade of events and civil war in which first Galba, then Otho and then Vitellius all claimed to be emperor, and before long, Titus, you know, he’s sitting over there in the east and his son, or excuse me, Vespasian, his son, Titus, urges him to stake his claim. So Vespasian goes and challenges Titus, and ultimately is successful, and he defeats the corpulent Vitellius, which left Vespasian squarely in control of Rome. So that brings us. We’re in 70 ad at this point, and with Vespasian now sole Emperor with no real other claimants that are legitimate around he tasked his son with finishing off the Jewish revolt by sacking the highly fortified city of Jerusalem, which is where 1000s of rebels had been congregating. And really what resulted is this incredibly bloody, incredibly brutal and lamentable affair that supposedly left upwards of a million Jews dead, at least according to Josephus. But these numbers are a little suspect. But despite this terrible toll, Titus was victorious, and by 71 AD, which is your question, he can finally return to Rome and triumph.
Dr G 7:09
An impressive time. Not great for Judea, by the sounds of it, but the Romans, well, they do like a good victory, and it sounds like they threw everything they had at this one.
Dr Rad 7:19
So we obviously get a bit of a snapshot about what Titus was up to in his early life through that account that you’ve just given. But what else do we know about Titus public career prior to his father becoming emperor?
Marc Hyden 7:33
So a lot of Titus early career and life is a bit of a mystery. And this kind of goes into how the ancient writers looked at people they didn’t generally, they didn’t care much about their their early life when they recorded it, because it was unimportant. Now for us historians, we want to know what happened. But what is clear is that Titus was born into the Flavian family, which had, at this point, had only recently become a senatorial clan. So because of this wealth and being a senatorial clan, Titus received rudimentary education that you’d expect of a well to do child, you know, and thanks to Vespasian growing increasingly close to Claudius court at the time, Titus was eventually even educated in the Imperial Court, which was really a blessing as well as a curse, because he learned alongside Claudius’ biological son, Britannicus. And this causes some some serious problems. Claudius’ scheming wife at the time, Agrippina was the mother of Nero, whom Claudius adopted. Now this is getting kind of convoluted and complex, but that’s the way the imperial family was. Agrippina didn’t seem to like the flavians too much, at least their friends that were in the imperial court. This caused plenty of grief. But then there was also the issue with Nero, who was distrustful of Britannicus, who, you know, rightfully, he probably should have been emperor, but he didn’t become emperor. So Nero decides to have him poisoned by tainting his drink. It turns out, though, that Titus was lounging next to Britannicus when this went down, and in fact, Titus even drank some of the poison. But Britannicus died, and as we all can tell, Titus survived, although he had a long term ailment that actually stemmed from him imbibing some of this poison. But despite him surviving Vespasian and Titus, at this point, they realize they’ve fallen from favor, and they needed to see to their own safety, so they decided to lay low for a while, and it worked in their favor, because not long after, they had some developments in the imperial court that really benefited them. So Nero really got tired of his his meddling and very overbearing mother, and he first banished her, and then he had her murdered, and this is after numerous botched attempts, and he’s finally successful, and with with her dead, both Vespasian and Titus, their futures looked a lot a lot brighter at this point in fact. Is able to enter the cursus honorum, the path of honors. And he took his first step toward senatorial admission by serving, most likely, in a one year term. And really, this, really lower level college of magistrates. And that’s this might have happened around 60 AD, and it was the next year in which he probably held the military tribuneship, and he was at first stationed in Germany, and then the ancient writers tell us that Titus and his troops were eventually transferred from Germany to Britannia. The ancient writers don’t tell us why this happened, but some modern historians have pinpointed a very plausible and what I find to be a pretty fascinating reason, and it was the Boudicca rebellion. Now, as a lot of your listeners know, Boudicca was this Iceni royal, and she was a woman not to be trifled with, but the Romans decided to trifle with her anyway. They stole her property. They publicly abused her and even raped her daughters these this was an unconscionable crime, and after facing this Roman treachery and ignominy, she decided to work to kick the Romans out of Britannia. And within a short span of time, she raises this massive army, allegedly numbering around 230,000 people, and she led them into battle. And this happens around 60 ad and with relative ease, she overruns numerous cities, raises them to the ground, and shows that she can be pretty barbaric as well. But the Romans were bent on stopping her, and in 61 the following year, the local governor Paulinus defeated her in battle. And then afterwards, Boudicca either dies by suicide or illness, we don’t really know, but the remnants of the revolt remained active, and that’s where Titus enters this story. So in an effort to shore up the Romans defenses in Britannia and provide reinforcements, Nero decided to transfer some folks from Germany to Britannia. So this is, this is when historians think it’s very likely that Titus found himself there, and he may have actually seen some legitimate experience and action in the Buddha revolt, although we don’t really know what exactly he could have been doing. So the Boudicca revolt is subdued, and then, following Titus term as military tribune, he returns to Rome to kind of foster his nascent public career, promote his private business interests, including a legal practice. And he seeks the quaestorship, which is the this will give you senatorial admission at the time. And with his father’s help, the Senate presumably elects him, providing him a seat in the Senate. And through some guesswork, educated guesswork. Historians think that his quaestorship may have fallen around 64 AD which is when the Great Fire of Rome happened. But it was two years later that really propels Titus to what we think of when we hear him in 66 that’s when the Jewish rebellion begins, and Nero realizes that he desperately needs some help. So he looks around to find someone who’s someone who’s a competent general, but not particularly inspiring so he could never really challenge them, and someone who’s close by that happens to be Vespasian. He’s not a very exciting guy at the time and not thought of as a real threat. So he appoints Vespasian to command the war effort against the Jewish people, and Vespasian in turn, appoints Titus to lead the 15th legion. And as I alluded to earlier, together they sweep through the Jewish homeland and they reassert Roman control, but at a really terrible cost.
Dr G 13:38
Yeah, it’s a quite a trajectory, and one that, because the Flavians are not such a prominent family, we just don’t know those intricate details about those shifts through their career paths. But by the time we get into Titus having ruled, boy, does he get some praise and Suetonius in his “Life of Titus”, notably says, and I quote, “Titus, of the same surname as his father, was the delight and darling of the human race. Such surpassing ability had he, by nature, art or good fortune, to win the affections of all men.” End, quote, To what extent should we see this level of positivity as justified when it comes to Titus rule? Do you think so?
Marc Hyden 14:29
That’s a little bit of a complicated question. So first things first, Suetonius is one of the least reliable historians of the era. He is really a terrible historian. Excuse me, he represents or presents rumors as verifiable fact. Essentially, he also presents his histories thematically, instead of chronologically, which really makes it difficult for historians to unravel what truly happened. But that aside, now that I’ve really just uh denigrated the memory of Suetonius, does that statement ring true? So I guess my my answer, my roundabout answer, that is, it depends on which Titus we’re talking about. So as a Roman commander in Judea, Titus was he was successful, but he was absolutely brutal, and he made so many tactical errors and perhaps he also strategic errors. As a Roman prince, he acted as a spoiled playboy and was really happy to ruthlessly murder just about anyone rumored of conspiring against his father. So these are not something you would think of as the darling of the human race, but he reinvents himself as a Roman Emperor. After he succeeded to the throne, he acted like a forgiving and loving father. He spared conspirators lives, He lavished gifts on on the Roman people, and he guided the empire through some really challenging circumstances. So from the Roman perspective, Titus was about as good as it gets as an emperor and his brutality as a commander, from the Roman perspective, was probably lauded, since the Romans found it to be necessary. So if Suetonius, if his statement is referring only to Titus emperorship, then from the Roman perspective, his positivity is probably merited, at least to a degree. But we all need to be very honest with each other, calling Titus the darling of the human race, is is beyond excessive, and it’s quite a bit ridiculous.
Dr G 16:27
Just what we come to expect from Suetonius, though.
Dr Rad 16:34
Someone who had a bit of a wild young life and then reinvented themselves as emperor… I wonder who that reminds me of Dr G?
Dr G 16:43
I wouldn’t want to hazard a guess.
Dr Rad 16:46
So one of the things that we love most about Titus is his love life, because he doesn’t actually have the smoothest of love lives. What do we know about his relationships with women?
Marc Hyden 16:57
Well, it was a long time before the dating app. So things, things weren’t very smooth when we look at what the ancient accounts say about it. So this is, this is a bit of a longer, longer answer, since he he got around a little bit. So in the early to mid 60s ad, that’s when Titus marries his first wife, Arrecina Tertulla. So the union between them, it really revealed a lot about the Flavian family standing and how they are an up and coming group. Because Titus wife, or Vespasian’s wife, didn’t really hail from a particularly exciting family, but Arrecina Tertulla really was from a family of some more notable successes, notable recent successes. Even though their family was a bit more obscure in their origins, they had achieved equestrian status, so they were pretty wealthy because of this. That probably pleased Vespasian quite a bit, since he seemed to perennially just have all these financial problems. And some of that happened probably as a result of Agrippina stiming his career for a while, so he really couldn’t milk money out of the provinces or anything along those lines. So that must have pleased Vespasian. But this is really a legitimately important family that they married into, because Arrecina’s father was Marcus Arrecinus Clemens, and he was well to do, very influential, and he even served as a Pretorian Prefect. So he was, and this was under Emperor Caligula, so this was a very prestigious position in which he was one of the two commanders of the Imperial Guard. But it also means that he may have had something to do with Caligula’s assassination, whether he was active in or just had knowledge of it, but whatever the case, no one liked Caligula afterwards. So it turns out, he’s probably more of a hero than anything else. But the family aside, so far as modern academics can tell, the two newlyweds, they wasted little time building a family, and arachina had a child, and this was likely a girl named Julia Flavia, although there is scholarly debate over which family or which marriage this belongs to this child, because there’s confusion of even how many children he had. But we, we know that Arrecina dies sometime shortly thereafter, and the ancient accounts don’t tell us why. And really, this is really more of this kind of male dominated view that I think a lot of ancient historians had, where they don’t tell you what happened to a lot of these, these female characters in history. But considering that it happened so soon after birth, she might have died as a result of childbirth, which is a very hazardous thing in antiquity. I mean, very conservative estimates suggest that the maternal mortality rate in ancient Rome might have been around two and a half percent. And again, that’s that’s conservative, but that’s also very terrifying. So this may have caused Titus to to grieve to a degree he lost his first wife, but he remarries really quickly. Um. It’s not clear if he did it because he found love or Vespasian wanted to find another rich family to marry into because he needed cash. But whatever the case, Titus marries into another pretty influential family, and he took Marcia Furnilla’s hand in marriage. Now she was part of a noble family that traced its roots to one of Rome’s fabled kings, Ancius Marcus, so one of the the fourth fabled king of ancient Rome. And even in this era, they enjoyed the family enjoyed quite a bit of success and considerable wealth, which Vespasian probably appreciated. But this marriage is very short lived for an undisclosed reason, the two get divorced fairly quickly. And the ancient authors, they don’t tell us why, but what seems to be the case is that some of her family members were accused of conspiring against Nero. This was a big problem. They could be terrible. Things happened to the people that were involved in these alleged conspiracies, and the Flavians wanted nothing to do with it. They wanted to continue their rise to the top, be successful, enjoy fame and fortune, and they probably wouldn’t have faced any legal problems just being married to having Titus married this woman, however, it could have stopped their careers from ascending. So Titus probably just thought of his wise we’re going to get divorced. I’m going to move on, even though she was likely innocent of any wrongdoing. So that’s the last Roman woman that we know for sure that Titus has this really close relationship with, and the next relationship that really dominates the rest of Titus life, she wasn’t even a Roman. So after joining with his father in the east to quell the Jewish revolt, Titus noticed the Jewish king Agrippa’s sister. This is the powerful queen, Berenice. So whether it was her beauty or charisma, he was quickly smitten with Berenice, and they begin this long standing romantic relationship that it spanned many, many years, and she probably welcomed this development because it brought their her family and her people as a result, closer to the Romans, but it also helped quell probably some rumors that went around suggesting that she had an incestual relationship with her brother since They lived together, something that was probably very unfair, but the the rumor existed, so she may have welcomed this. So this, this romance, probably lasts throughout the war, and then Titus goes home, but he goes home without Berenice, but in 75 CE roundabouts, he invites her to come. There’s plenty of debate. Why didn’t she come with him? Why did they wait this long? But to me, it seems pretty clear, the Flavians probably looked at her as a little bit of a liability, and they wanted to make sure that they had stable control over their position in Rome before they brought this eastern queen to come. And in relatively short order, she did arrive, and she moves into the Imperial Palace, shares a bed with Titus. She expected that they would get married, and in fact, Titus might have even promised his hand in marriage to her already, but they didn’t feel like they needed to be married for her to act in like these official ways. And this really shocked the Romans, because she flexed her newfound power. Quintilian even complained about having to plead some sort of case before her, which he just thought was bizarre. He’s a Roman. This is, this is an Eastern queen. And to the Romans, this was really unacceptable. They believed that the members the Imperial Household, especially heirs to the purple, they were expected to marry upstanding Roman women, not foreign Queens. And I’m sure this, this generated a lot of racist comments about letting an Eastern Queen infiltrate the imperial palace, and it also conjured up images of another very unpopular Eastern queen, Cleopatra. So the Romans were very suspicious about Berenice, and they spoke out against her. And it seems like the flavians tried to contain these objections, but it became clear that the Romans were very unforgiving of this, and Titus and Vespasian knew that they had to send her back to the east to ensure that they remained popular. So they sent her on her way. It probably around 79 AD, and then it was all it was very shortly after that that Vespasian dies and Titus becomes emperor, and for some reason, Berenice comes back to Rome. We don’t know if she was invited or came out of her own accord. Whatever we know is it was a very short stint – Titus sent her back to the east. I guessed, I guess the Romans were still very unhappy with that relationship. But whatever the case, this seems like it was. She was his true love, and that would be the last time he ever saw her.
Dr Rad 24:48
Ah the tragedy.
Dr G 24:51
Yes, particularly with the parallels with Cleopatra as well, the Romans are not well set up to handle women from elsewhere. Yeah, maybe having just the capacity to lead and to be in the high echelons of Roman society. So it’s perhaps not a surprise. And I do wonder about that last visit where it’s like, can we make this work? And Titus is like, I don’t think we can. And it’s not about you, it’s about everybody else. I’d love you to stay.
Dr Rad 25:19
It’s not you, it’s Rome.
Dr G 25:21
It’s Rome. Yeah, it’s always Rome. And you’ve alluded to the things that are going on in Judea already, because obviously they play a hugely significant role in the lead up to Titus coming into this position of leadership. But this conquest also has a lot of written sources attached to it as well. So I’m interested in why the conquest at this point is so significant, and how do our written sources help us build a detailed picture of what is going on in the east in this time period?
Marc Hyden 25:54
Well, I think you absolutely have to consider this is really part of not just Titus legacy is as well as Rome’s. This is very important. But when you look at the the sources that we have for this, really the only bulked out source that we have is Josephus. He his account is what has survived. You see mentions of the Jewish War in the different, different writings. You know, Cassius Dio, Suetonius. I mean, we have these passing accounts, but nothing like Josephus has. But we also need to be careful when we read Josephus, because the Flavians essentially bankrolled him. So of course, he’s going to make Titus look fantastic. He’s going to make Vespasian look great as well. And despite all of Josephus faults this, he provides so much knowledge and so much information about Titus in his corpus of writing. So I think it’s very important to bring that in, to consider that and when you if you just look at the the war very briefly, so it’s sparked through different riots and mistreatment of the Jews by the Romans, as well as the Greek speaking population, they rise up. And Josephus is even one of the generals for the rebellion. And he’s stationed in Galilee and fights against Vespasian. And there’s the this, this penultimate battle in Jotapata, where he tries to hold out for over 40 days around about and eventually falls and even predicts that Vespasian will become emperor one day, and they decide not to execute him. So that’s also a very good tale, a cautionary tale, if you ever captured in war, tell the person that captures you, he’s going to be emperor one day, and he’ll probably spare your life. So Titus is alongside Vespasian through this. And they go through all these these cities, and there’s these exciting battles that Josephus has really provide a wealth of knowledge about. So it’s Vespasian who really wins a lot of the Jewish war. And he goes to Alexandria later on to wait until he goes to Rome and leaves Titus in charge here. And this is when Titus has 60 to 80,000 men under his command, and he uses them primarily for the siege of Jerusalem, which is extended, as I mentioned. It’s very bloody. We have terrible accounts from Josephus of cannibalism, starvation, famine. You know, I mentioned that Josephus said that a million Jews died just in the siege. Again, that’s his accounting. It’s probably an exaggeration. According to Tacitus, it’s no more than 600,000, but even if it’s 100,000 which is what some modern academics suggest, that is a massive number. So even though a lot of the other writers, Cassius, Dio, Suetonius, Tacitus, they kind of sidestep a lot of the Jewish War. Josephus gives us an amazing account and shows how important this is, not just to stabilizing the Roman Empire, but turning Vespasian and Titus into what they are. They’re able to use this to propel themselves to take over, because during the year of the four emperors, Vespasian is sitting there with all these legionaries at his disposal, and he’s able to use that to come in and take over. And meanwhile, Vespasian does that, and then Titus plays clean up sacks Jerusalem, which is critically important, and he also destroys the Temple. But I think one of the things that really is is probably overlooked by many, is what Titus did in Jerusalem helps lay the groundwork for unrest in the Middle East that persists to this day.
Dr Rad 29:37
It’s such a such an interesting time to be talking about right now. So when Vespasian eventually heads back to Rome during this troublesome time, he does so after having been proclaimed Imperator by his troops and his son, Titus is, of course, at his side. Now this is a really unusual time in Rome’s history, because it’s the first time that. That an imperial dynasty has ended and a new one is now coming in, although, of course, nobody knows that that’s definitely what’s going to happen at this point. But we’re curious to know how, how is Titus training to be emperor different from and similar to that of the Julio-Claudians who preceded him?
Marc Hyden 30:18
Yeah. So unlike a lot of the other Imperial successors Titus, he wasn’t originally groomed for this purpose. He had no inkling that he would ever be in this position, and that he had no reason to believe that he ever would be. He simply wanted to be a senator, like his father, be a lawyer and somehow find wealth, fame and success. Maybe it’s in the political realm. Maybe it’s in the military. So as I mentioned, he got this aristocratic education, climbed the political ladder, fought in the legions, but as we know, he was destined for a lot more. So once Vespasian rose to power, he very unmistakably, from the beginning, marked Titus out as a successor in some similar as well as different ways than his forebears. So Vespasian worked to ensure that Titus had a resume that of someone that you would want to be emperor, and the power to be able to seize it. So he shared consulships with Vespasian. Titus and Vespasian shared consulships. They shared a triumph together through Rome after the sacking of Jerusalem, and Vespasian ensured that Titus had the notable military successes, namely the sacking of Jerusalem to really put on his resume and build out his curriculum vitae. But beyond this, Vespasian elevates Titus to almost his equal, at least on paper. So they kind of rule together, but it was very clear that Titus was a subordinate. But as a prince, he enjoyed Imperium, he enjoyed tribunician potestas. He represented Vespasian in the Senate sometimes. And then Vespasian also makes this very novel decision to make his son one of the Praetorian Guard prefects, essentially the head of a couple legions that are stationed in and around Rome who were asked to protect the Emperor. Now, no Emperor’s son had ever held this role before, but it ensured the allegiance of the sometimes fickle Praetorians. So because of all of this, there was nobody more qualified and better position to succeed Vespasian than Titus, any of the backing of the pretorians to ensure that seamless transition. So thanks to Titus work and Vespasian’s preparations, Titus became the first biological son of a Roman emperor to succeed him.
Dr G 32:37
Oh yeah, that is an interesting detail, isn’t it, the Julio-Claudians, what a mess. So one of the incredible things that sort of happens in this period of time is that we have the Lex de Imperio Vespasiani, which is considered by scholars to be a hugely significant document. It bundles together for the first time, all of the powers, all of the privileges that had gradually become associated with the concept of the Emperor under the Julio-Claudians and because it was assumed kind of knowledge up until this point. But we now have a change in family. There’s a sense in which, how can we formalize and make it legal for this kind of de facto position of power to be passed on to somebody who’s not in that family. I’m interested in to what extent you would say that this influences Titus as he shifts from being vespasians, right hand man to Emperor himself.
Marc Hyden 33:37
Yeah, that’s that’s a bit of a tough one. So the Lex de Imperio Vespasiani has long been debated by people far smarter than than me, so like you two, far smarter than me, and it only exists in fragmentary form, so some of it’s missing, but what I will say is that this was an important piece of Flavian PR because it really it legitimizes Vespasian’s rule, it makes it clear, or at least tries to make it clear to his subjects that he wasn’t just another usurper, like like Otho or Vitellius. He was legitimate. He was different than those guys. But how did this influence Titus? That’s that’s not really clear, but I will say sure it provided a framework for him to follow as emperor, but he enjoyed a lot of that same power before he became emperor. So when he was Vespasian’s companion, but he, like the rest of Rome, they now saw Rome for what it was. It was a military dictatorship. The year of the four emperors washed away any sort of veneer of Rome being a republic or being even a constitutional principate. The truth was that armies now made emperors, not the Senate, not the people and anyone could really stake their claim to the throne and could seize it without senatorial approval or without approval even in the comitia. But it was still, despite that, it was still important to maintain the pretenses of legitimate rule and Republican forms, even though the Republic had been long, long dead. So from that perspective, it was important for Titus, and considering that at large, he gave emperors unfettered power, he probably felt like it was pretty easy to operate under those confines, but he understood that he could violate any provision he wanted, because he was an autocrat and the head and he had the Army’s backing, and that was the sad reality of Rome at this time.
Dr G 35:35
What a place to be – you’ve revealed yourself for what you are, finally
Dr Rad 35:40
The veil has been lifted
Dr G 35:42
None of this principate business
Dr Rad 35:44
I know. I know So with all this build up and it seems so promising. You know, Titus, the darling of the human race, he seems to have got his resume just right, first biological son to succeed his father as emperor, and yet he only rules for such a short time, just over two years, from 79 CE, when Vespasian passed away, to 81 CE, nonetheless, that’s still some time for him to have some achievements and certainly face some obstacles. So we’d love for you to tell us a bit more about what happens when he’s actually emperor.
Marc Hyden 36:23
Yeah, so Titus may have presided over the busiest two year span in the Empire’s history, at least up until this point, Agricola was at war in Britannia. Vesuvius erupted and laid waste in numerous cities, including Pompeii and Herculaneum. Fire ravages Rome and a plague decimates its numbers. But despite this, Titus did everything within his power and also his financial means to guide the empire through adversity, even though it supposedly led him nearly to fiscal ruin because of it, but the people just they realized the world was a different place. They were facing all of these calamities, but they appreciated Titus endeavors, because he responded to each crisis with great aplomb, or at least with the best of intentions, and they understood this. But his tenure, it was not just marked by adversity. There were tranquil moments as well. He constructed his eponymus baths. Built roads and bridges and updated aqueducts, and he finished the Colosseum, which we could all go look at today, at least well enough for the inaugural games. It probably didn’t have the final floor finished at the time, at least in stone. And he opened it, and he hosts an unprecedented 100 days of games, and they bear witness to 1000s of beasts being killed, myriad executions, and an untold number of gladiators sparring with another which the people loved. And during his tenure, he also saw that his father was deified. So you know, that’s also another great thing. If you become emperor, you can make your dad a god, which makes you the son of a god or a daughter of a god, really work. It’s a great system that they had in place there. And even though a lot of his predecessors would not have done this, he showed forgiveness to people that plotted against him in ways that they they never would have dreamed of doing so. In short, this was a very action packed two years.
Dr G 38:21
I do like the idea that many emperors start off with quite a good stint early on, only for things to go tragically downhill the further they’re in power. And I wonder to what extent Titus has been saved from that fate by dying so soon into his reign, and we will just never know he dies suddenly from a fever, which a tragedy. This is shocking to everybody, and led to great speculation, even at the time, that this was not the case of poor health, necessarily, but murder most foul
Dr Rad 38:56
Mwahahahaha
Dr G 38:59
Exactly. I’m wondering, Mark, what’s your view on Titus death based on your research?
Marc Hyden 39:05
Well, first of all, to go back to what you were talking about, about emperors having a great, you know, honeymoon period, and that’s, that’s something that they talked about. Believe it was Cassius Dio said, you know, he just didn’t live. He may not have lived long enough to become the terrible Emperor he was destined to be. We just don’t know. He might have turned into Domitian. Who knows? But to answer your question about his death, it goes back to 81 AD, so a little over two years into his Imperial administration, he and some of his followers decided to go to the countryside for a break. They wanted to get out of the busy Rome, the stench and everything else that comes with it. But as they made their journey, Titus realizes something is really wrong. He develops this incredibly high fever, and then his servants, they rush him to a farmhouse in Sabine country, near near react, and along the way, Titus’ condition continues to get worse, and he understands that this is going to claim his life, and this really confused him. So he was 41 years old, which I may humbly present as a very young age.
Dr Rad 40:12
I totally agree.
Marc Hyden 40:14
He believed that he had lived a life pleasing to the gods, and he was at the height of his power. Why would the gods take his life at this moment. So on the verge of death, he he throws open the curtains on his litter and exclaims, I have made but one mistake. Now we don’t know what that one mistake was, but we do know that he dies not long after on September 13, 81 AD in the very farmhouse in which his father Vespasian had perished. So the question of what killed him, what was the cause of death, has really vexed ancient and even some modern historians and the ancient authors, they provided kind of a slew of theories to attempt to explain what killed him, and they range from impossible to improbable. But thanks to the diligence of some modern scholars, we may have the answer, but first we have to talk about what the ancient authors thought. So, given the rapid and very unexpected death of a pretty popular emperor, the Romans grew suspicious that Titus had been slain, and some claimed that Domitian was behind it. One theory suggested that Titus, or excuse me, Domitian, had Titus packed in ice when he was sick, knowing that that would kill him. So it’s not impossible that Domitian had this done, and he may have done it along with doctor’s orders as a way to reduce Titus uncontrolled fever. But other ancient authors said that Titus died through other means. Domitian poisoned them, so more Imperial intrigue. And Flavius Philostratus even says that Domitian used a sea hair to taint Titus food or drink somehow, which which killed him. But modern academics, they’ve kind of poo-pooed that idea. They don’t believe that that would really have worked. And this also kind of reveals what the ancient writers thought about Domitian. They did not like the guy, they loathed him, and he was an easy target, at least at this point. So they latched on to all these unsubstantiated rumors saying that Domitian was somehow behind Titus death. And, you know, he did have a motive, because he became emperor, it just seems very unlikely that he had anything to do with with killing his brother, at least on purpose. Then there’s a Jewish tradition, and this is one of my favorite ones, and it suggests that a gnat flew up Titus nose, lived in his brain for seven years and slowly picked at his brain as it grew to the size of a sparrow. This is a tradition that obviously is, I don’t believe that anyone thinks of it as fact, it might be part of some sort of tale. Gnats don’t operate this way. They don’t grow to the size of small birds, at least where I live. And the Romans generally didn’t do autopsies and open up Emperor’s brains to see what’s going on in there. So this didn’t that was not the cause. Could not have been.
Dr G 43:09
That’s a real shame. That’s a real shame because, I mean, come on, if that was, that was what happened. We need to know. We need to go back and find the body, do an autopsy. Was he somehow trapped by a gnat while he was in Judea that lived in his brain.
Marc Hyden 43:24
If that is possible, I’m never going outside again. But Plutarch, he went in a different direction, said that Titus died because he loved taking a bath too much. And I also think that that’s probably not the case, unless he caught some sort of contagion while bathing with with other people. But what really seems to be the case is relatively clear in the ancient record, if you look through it through a modern lens. So if we go back, it’s September in ancient Italy, and Titus acquires a high fever that strikes him down quickly. So we’ve got several things to look at here. And Saul bastomsky theorized, based on that that Titus died from malignant malaria. It was relatively common in Titus era and region at the time. It surged in late summer and early fall, and it’s marked by a high fever that kills its victims really quickly. So it seems that was probably natural causes that led to his death. And if it was malignant malaria, then sadly, Titus, he just never stood a chance.
Dr Rad 44:29
How intriguing the potential of an emperor to have died from the Ice Bucket Challenge? Who would have thought so? Perhaps, to wrap up now that Titus has departed from this earth. What is it that you think makes Titus unique from the Emperors that came before him?
Marc Hyden 44:50
Well, he was just so different from the Julio-Claudians. For starters, he was a true warrior. He led troops. He got into the nitty gritty of battle. Unlike the Julio-Claudians, with the exception of Augustus and Tiberius, they saw some some real battle. But for the rest of the pampered Julio-Claudians, Titus was very different. He was also the first, as I mentioned, Pretorian Prefect to become emperor, and the first biological son of an emperor to become emperor. Again, very different from the Julio-Claudians, and during his short stint, he proved to be a forgiving and magnanimous ruler who eschewed killing even conspirators, and so far as we can tell, he didn’t have a single scandal throughout all of his Imperial tender tenure. Again, it was only a couple of years, but still, no scandals. Most Julio-Claudians couldn’t have said the same about about their own.
Dr Rad 45:43
Oh, yeah, Caligula had scandals pretty quickly.
Marc Hyden 45:47
Yes, they would. They stacked up very quickly. You’re right. He also gave the Romans a gift that his predecessors would have killed for the Colosseum, and he gave the Romans 100 days of games and killing, just on an industrial scale, and they loved him for it. And he was also different. This is a little less interesting, but he was different because he had the shortest Imperial tenure to date, excluding the usurpers of the year, the four emperors, of any of his predecessors. And unlike many of his predecessors, when he died, he was probably at the height of his popularity, the Romans loved him. Remember, he’s he’s the darling of the human race, although, of course, that’s exaggeration. So to close out neatly, I would say the life of Titus is one of the greatest stories rarely told. So it’s the tale of Titus unlikely ascent to power, a veritable holy war in Israel, the coliseums rise, and of course, we know Pompeii’s fall and then tragic Titus own tragic and untimely death. But for whatever reason, a lot of the story has been buried beneath centuries of silence. And you know, a lot of the ancient Romans loved and even worshiped Titus. They considered him this model of virtue, essentially as an emperor to be emulated. But modern scholars, they have overlooked him for whatever reason. They’ve cast him aside, perhaps because of his short Imperial tenure, and this has left some unmistakable gaps in the record. So I decided to take on this project and write emperor Titus the right hand of Vespasian. And hopefully, hopefully it will end his long term neglect, and we won’t have to worry about the massive gaps in the record that have been there for so long.
Dr G 47:35
Yes, thank you so much for providing all of this detail, and I cannot recommend your book, highly enough, that’s “Emperor Titus: The Right Hand of Vespasian”, because you do go into so much of the detail, particularly with what is going on in the early days of Titus building his military reputation, particularly when it comes to what is happening in Judea, which is an extensive campaign that really funds a lot of what The Flavians are able to achieve. So I think understanding that side of it better. How did this seemingly unassuming family rise to the top is really important, and seeing how Titus is able to carry on that legacy of Vespasian particularly interesting as well.
Marc Hyden 48:18
Yeah, and I really appreciate that the kind words. And it really is something I find to be pretty amazing. Everyone has heard of Vespasian, who’s interested in ancient Rome, and even his ascent is is very unlikely. And he brings he brings his family along, and as people will find out that are students of history, they’ll see the Flavian dynasty. It starts off very stable, but it goes off the rails pretty quickly. But they want to say that, you know, Vespasian and Titus, they had a good run.
Dr G 48:48
Yeah, two out of three ain’t bad.
Dr Rad 48:50
I was gonna say. I can’t help but wonder if Titus reputation is also somewhat improved by the fact that Domitian is the one that follows.
Marc Hyden 48:59
That certainly does help his standing. It also helps his standing, as well as Vespasian that a lot of the people at the time, the historians at the time, that wrote the history, they tended to bankroll so you tend to say nice things about your benefactor. So they they benefited greatly from some fantastic PR and that’s that’s another thing. If you’re going to be emperor, pay people to write your history. They’ll say nice things.
Dr Rad 49:25
That’s the mistake that Julia-Claudians made. Rookie errors. Rookie errors.
Dr G 49:34
Well, thank you so much Mark for joining us and sitting down to tell us all about Titus and the way he comes to power, and those precious two years he gets to be emperor, we’ve really enjoyed it.
Marc Hyden 49:44
Hey. Thanks so much for having me on and I’ll just have to burn through another book real quick so I can come back.
Dr G 49:56
Thank you for listening to this episode of the Partial Historians. You can find our sources, sound credits and transcript in our show notes. Over at partialhistorians.com we offer a huge thank you to you, if you’re one of our illustrious Patreon supporters, if you enjoy the show, we’d love your support in a way that works for you. Leaving a nice review really makes our day. We’re on Ko-Fi for one off or ongoing donations or Patreon of course. Our latest book, “Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire”, is published through Ulysses Press. It is full of stories that the Romans probably don’t want you to know about them. This book is packed with some of our favorite tales of the colorful history of ancient Rome. Treat yourself or an open minded friend to Rome’s glories, embarrassments and most salacious claims with Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire.
Transcribed by https://otter.ai
The post Special Episode – The Emperor Titus with Marc Hyden appeared first on The Partial Historians - Ancient Roman History with smart ladies.
We’re back with more exciting episodes from the infamous Gallic sack of Rome. If you haven’t listened to our previous eps, make sure you go back to the beginning of this tale!
We have action in three different locations in this episode – Camillus in Ardea, the remnants of the Roman army in Veii and the Romans under siege on the Capitoline.
A recreation of the Temple of the Capitoline Triad on one of the peaks of the hill (albeit in a later period). Courtesy of Wikimedia Commons.
The siege had entered a fairly quiet stage where little was happening on either side. It was at this point that one of the Fabian clan decided that his duty to the gods was worth more than his life. Gaius Fabius Dorsuo calmy descended from the Capitol, past the stunned Gauls and went off to the Quirinal to perform an annual sacrifice that was part of Fabian tradition. His piety so impressed the Gauls that they allowed him to pass, unscathed.
The Romans in Veii had selected the centurion, Quintus Caedicius as their commander. They were growing in numbers as stragglers who fled during the attack sought refuge. Latin allies also joined the Romans.
It depends on which account you read as to what happened next. Livy claims that the forces at Veii decide that they have had enough beauty sleep and now they want Camillus recalled from exile so they can seek their vengeance. Other sources indicate that they were just trying to get word to their fellow Romans that they were, in fact, ALIVE! Either way, a sprightly young man named Publius Cominus was selected to travel to the besieged city and smuggle himself onto the Capitol to deliver his message.
Whichever version you believe, somehow Camillus worms his way back into our narrative, and our hearts. Naturally, Camillus would not set foot outside of Ardea without all the paperwork being in order, but once his exile was officially over, he was ready to step into the role of dictator.
However, Camillus was still packing his bags when the Gauls noticed a possible route up the top of Capitoline. It meant scaling up a cliff face, so surely the Romans would never suspect it. It’s so crazy, it just might work.
A bronze sculpture of goose from the Capitoline Museum collection. Courtesy of Wikimedia Commons.
Slowly, the Gauls helped each other to make the difficult climb. They were so quiet, the Roman dogs did not hear the coming. But the sacred geese sure did! They caused such a ruckus that Marcus Manlius woke up and realised what was going on. This allowed him to arouse the other Romans and lead the charge against the attackers. It gets pretty grisly at this point. Best case scenario: the Gauls were hurled to their deaths. Worst case… you’ll have to listen to find out!
On a serious note, please be aware that this episode does include discussion of animal cruelty.
Q. Fabius M. f. Q. n. Ambustus (Pat)
K. Fabius M. f. Q n. Ambustus (Pat) Mil. Tr. c. p. 404, 401, 395
N. Fabius M. f. Q. n. Ambustus (Pat) Mil. Tr. c. p. 406
Q. Sulpicius -f. -n. Longus (Pat)
Q. Servilius Q. f. P. n. Fidenas (Pat) Mil. Tr. c. p. 402, 398, 395, 388, 386
P. Cornelius P. f. M. n. Maluginensis (Pat) Cos. 393? Mil. Tr. c. p. 397
M. Furius L. f. Sp. n. Camillus (Pat) Mil. Tr. c.p. 401, 398, 394, 386, 384, 381
L. Valerius (L. f. L. n. Poplicola) (Pat) Mil. Tr. c.p. 394, 389, 387, 383
OR
L. Valerius (L. f. P. n. Potitus) (Pat) Cos. 393, 392; Mil. Tr. c.p. 414, 406, 403, 401, 398
?-390: M. Folius (Flaccinator?) (Pat) Mil. Tr. c.p. 433
Pontifex Maximus; slain by the Gauls
C. or K. Fabius Dorsuo (Pat)
439-390: Q. ? Servilius P. f. (Sp. n. Priscus or Structus Fidenas?) (Pat)
Successor: [—- Furi]us Q. f. P. nepos Fu[sus] (Pat) Mil. Tr. c.p. 403
Dr Rad 0:15
Welcome to the Partial Historians.
Dr G 0:19
We explore all the details of ancient Rome,
Dr Rad 0:23
everything from political scandals, the love affairs, the battle’s waged, and when citizens turn against each other, I’m Dr Rad
Dr G 0:33
and I’m Dr G. We consider Rome as the Romans saw it, by reading different authors from the ancient past and comparing their stories.
Dr Rad 0:44
Join us as we trace the journey of Rome from the founding of the city.
Dr Rad 0:57
Hello and welcome to a brand new episode of the partial historians. I am one of your hosts. Dr rad,
Dr G 1:05
and I am, Dr G, and I am excited. We are deep in the Gallic sack of Rome.
Dr Rad 1:14
You know, I knew this was going to be a big event. Dr G, but even I had underestimated just how much detail we have to get through today.
Dr G 1:22
There is so much. And this is episode four in this mini series, this limited series on the Partial Historians channel,
Dr Rad 1:32
just when you thought the girls couldn’t do any more to the Romans they do. So Dr, G, I feel it might be necessary to do a brief recap, because we’ve already covered multiple episodes, and I suspect this will actually not be our last on the Gallic sack of Rome. So let’s revisit where the Romans are at right now.
Dr G 1:53
It’s tough times for the Romans. They have encountered the Gauls. Taking us right back to the beginning, they’ve offended the Gauls. The Gauls have marched on Rome. The Romans have hidden in their own city, being like they’ll never fight us here, and the Gauls have found them there. And the Gauls are determinedly outside the walls of the city, and increasingly encroaching into the city space itself and pillaging the local area as well, because if there’s anything that 70,000 Gauls need, it’s food and supplies, and you can’t just sit down and have a siege if you yourselves are going hungry.
Dr Rad 2:33
No, and we’ve definitely seen some brutal deaths as the Gauls have undertaken this process of sacking Rome, most tragically, perhaps, the elderly senators. So it hasn’t been great.
Dr G 2:49
The Romans did decide at a certain point that they could only feed and look after so many Roman citizens on the Capitol, which is where they’ve retreated to the high point of the city. And in a very noble gesture, it seems that the eldest of the aristocracy have decided to give up their lives by sitting down in the lower parts of the city in their own homes and just waiting the Gauls arrival. And the Gauls do arrive, and it goes exactly as you might expect. Those old men aren’t physically tough enough to resist the Gauls, and they do get killed.
Dr Rad 3:25
I feel like the Brave Heart line kind of applies here. You may take our lives, but you’ll never take our freedom.
Dr G 3:33
They die as free men. They die as Romans. There’s weird to us. I suppose it’s a good thing, as much as we criticize the patricians constantly on this show, it might be one of our characteristics as a podcast.
Dr Rad 3:46
That’s one of our partialities. One might say,
Dr G 3:49
potentially Yes, in this moment, the aristocracy do show themselves as people who are willing to put Rome before themselves in that very last moment. So I do give them kudos and respect for that,
Dr Rad 4:06
I would, but I feel like this is the kind of story that the Romans like to tell about themselves to justify this elite nonsense.
Dr G 4:15
Never believe anything that the elite Romans tell you.
Dr Rad 4:19
Perhaps one of the big problems though, that the Romans are facing Dr G is that the hero of the day, Camillus, who has been such a character throughout the past episodes we’ve been doing, he has been exiled by the Roman people. And it seems like this, at least for Livy, is one of the reasons that the Romans are in such a pickle right now,
Dr G 4:44
the best guy’s been left out. Of course, we can’t win
Dr Rad 4:47
exactly if you missing one man, clearly, you cannot resist a Gallic invasion.
Dr G 4:53
Yes, the morality of Livy never fails to inspire
Dr Rad 4:58
but in our last. Episode, we have started to see the return of Camillus. He’s got his warrior act on. Dr G He’s making himself into a Marvel superhero, coming out of exile, starting to cause some headaches for the Gauls in the region,
Dr G 5:19
and this is a very confusing part of the story, and one that historians have wrestled with, because within the context of the various narratives that we have about this Gallic sack, Camillus plays a bit part at best, and he is in it
Dr Rad 5:40
A bit part? Camillus?
Dr G 5:43
I know, I know he’s got main character energy, but one of the variations on this narrative is that in vey the commander, there a guy called Quintus Caedicius is the one who puts forward the idea that they need Camillus to be able to get through this time of trouble, and that’s before we even suppose for a moment that they and Rome know about their split forces, which it is not clear at all in other versions of the narrative, but we do have This account of Quintus Caedicius Raising the call for Camillus to be recalled and instated as dictator, and it is something that is apparently agreed to by the Roman Senate in Camillus absence. So the suggestion seems to be in some versions of the story that Camillus is still in exile and ultimately receives word that he has been appointed dictator without his knowledge, and now must do the great things that are required by a dictator. Now, on some level, you want to believe a story like that, because it sounds incredibly characteristic of the way the Romans want to believe that their republic worked. On the other hand, what we see Camillus doing is leaving Ardea raiding a Gaulish camp that is a foraging and pillaging camp, and then disappearing from the narrative again. Well, the whole Gallic sack actually happens.
Dr Rad 7:13
Well, see, this is the chronology that Livy gives me, the sack of that Gallic camp that we dealt with last time that all happens before any talk of dictatoriness. So it seems like Camillus is more just concerned. You know, he’s a concerned on looker. He’s invested in Rome’s fate.
Dr G 7:34
He’s like, I see trouble on the horizon. I see some Gauls in my local area. I should do something about that, because that’s the Roman way,
Dr Rad 7:41
exactly yes. And so that’s kind of where we were up to, I think, in our last episode. And so I don’t know about you, Dr G, but I am. I’m ready for some Gallic sacking. Ah, ah,
Dr G 8:15
we’re up to seeing one of the great parts of this story in this episode, because at the same sort of parallel timeline that we have Caedicius, sort of seeking out the dictatorship for Camillus, we also have another figure from Veii, a guy called Cominius Pontius, who seems to wander down to the city on the premise that they need to give Rome the information that there is a whole additional Roman force. So we have this moment where the Roman forces in Veii come to the understanding that maybe, just maybe the Romans don’t know that there’s a whole bunch of Romans also in Veii, and we saw the fear that had happened in the aftermath of the Battle of the Allia, where people were just running away, sort of in any direction that they could to get away from the Gauls. And we know that some of them end up back in Rome and some of them end up in Veii but they do not seem to be aware of how many have ended up where,
Dr Rad 9:22
and that would, that would make sense, I think, in the panic of a truly horrible battle which really hasn’t gone their way, that people would just scatter and you wouldn’t know what had happened to various sides of the army.
Dr G 9:36
Yeah, definitely. So you’ve got this situation where you’re running for your life. You’re not necessarily counting who’s going in your direction and who’s going in another direction.
Dr Rad 9:44
Hey, Bill, Bill, are you heading to Rome or they? I’m kind of thinking they. That’s kind of my vibe right now. Are you thinking Rome? Oh, oh, this is awkward.
Dr G 9:54
I guess I’ll catch up with you later. Yeah. Like,
Dr Rad 9:57
we’ll, you know, like, have some exile and. You with some sages, and then I’ll catch you when I see you.
Dr G 10:03
Send me a letter. Dear Bill, I’m still in Veii.
Dr Rad 10:08
Dear Marsha, our love for each other will never die. We just have to endure this siege a little longer and this separation, my darling, please hang on. Ever Yours.
Dr G 10:26
It’s a tragic time, but they’re not letter writing either. They literally don’t know anybody’s anywhere. So it seems, at some point into this whole process, and we’re of the understanding that the siege of Rome is something like six to seven months worth of siege. At some point in this process, the Roman forces that have gathered in Veii are like, maybe we could help and maybe
Dr Rad 10:52
second, wait a second, we’re here, but nobody knows we’re here. Oh my god,
Dr G 11:02
we could be the secret backup force that breaks the siege. We could.
Dr Rad 11:08
I’m sensing an opportunity, guys,
Dr G 11:13
is it strategy or is it tactics? Nobody knows. So we have this moment they come to this realization. The Romans in Veii are like, Wait a minute. We could be we could help. And they decide to send a delegate, just one person, it would seem, maybe accompanied by a few others, but only one is named,
Dr Rad 11:32
oh, he’s definitely by himself in in my account. In fact, I particularly appreciated the detail that Livy gives me that he managed to get to Rome by floating down the Tiber on some cork.
Dr G 11:48
Wow, that is not the story I’ve got. That’s amazing look.
Dr Rad 11:52
I’m all for sustainable materials, but that just seems flimsy to me.
Dr G 11:56
I mean, the cork would float, but it would have to be a very large piece of cork to work to float a human
Dr Rad 12:01
picturing him being like, you know, if everybody had an ocean, then everybody be surfing.
Dr G 12:12
Just amazing. All right, so, listeners, picture in your mind Cominius Pontius floating on a piece of cork down the type
Dr Rad 12:21
of river look. I should also add that in Livy’s account, he is described as a sprightly young thing. So surfing would be in his wheelhouse. I have to assume,
Dr G 12:32
yeah, look, I mean river surfing, it’s a whole new wave, isn’t it? So Cominius Pontius, he decides to be the one he’s the delegate, or maybe he chooses off his own back. We’re not sure, to take the happy news that there is an additional force really in vain that could surprise. We’re all alive. We lived. And so he heads towards the Capitoline Hill. And in my account, which is maybe less exciting than Livy’s. He is starting out alone, swimming the river by night, and doesn’t seem to have a cork.
Dr Rad 13:09
He’s swimming okay. Just keep swimming. Just keep swimming.
Dr G 13:14
Exactly he’s gonna be fine. He reaches one of the cliffs that leads up to the Capitoline, and it is a very difficult climb, but it is night time, and he manages to get himself up this cliff, and he gets to the top, and everyone’s like, what are you doing? He manages to convey the message to the Romans that have placed themselves on the Capitoline for defense, that there are troops at Fay and they are waiting and watching for an opportunity to attack the Gallic forces. The Romans on the Capitoline hill are like that is such good news. Thank you so much. But maybe you should go home. Don’t stay here. This is not a great place to be. So he climbs back down the cliff in the middle of the night and swims back up the Tiber.
Dr Rad 14:07
That is all very difficult in a time period without much street lighting. He’s doing some Cliff climbing and swimming in the Tiber.
Dr G 14:16
It’s a one night journey to swim from day night only
Dr Rad 14:21
one night only, really just there’s so many songs that can be added to the story.
Dr G 14:27
I’m glad you’re here to lend the sense of drama that is appropriate to this moment. He goes out for one night, swims down the Tiber, climbs a cliff, leaves a message, climbs back down the cliff, swims back up the Tiber, which seems to be more difficult, I would assume, because the tire is working against you now. Yeah, heads back into Veii
Dr Rad 14:48
well, see that’s where the cork thing makes sense, coming down. But what about going back?
Dr G 14:54
You get tired. You stop kicking your legs for a bit. You hold on to the cork board, and you lose all of your progress, but when you start again, you haven’t sunk.
Dr Rad 15:03
Livy gives me a few additional details in the lead up to this Dr G and look, I think this actually goes to show the awkwardness of this account, even though it’s obviously such a notable event, perhaps because it’s such an important event for the Romans, there are obviously going to be various things that people are trying to sandwich in for various reasons, and one of the things that they are trying to sandwich in is Camillus, because who doesn’t love a Camillus sandwich? Oh, no. How does Camillus end up in this story? Well, okay, so I’m going to start at this moment of the sprightly young thing that is Pontius Cominus, and explain how this works with my Camillus narrative. Because you know that Livy in particular is very invested in Camillus story. Pontius caminus is not actually going to Rome in my account to tell the Romans who are besieged by the Gauls up there that we live. There are people in Veii. You might not have known this, but you have this secret surprise extra force that’s reasonably sizable on your side. He’s actually there to tell them that, hey, there’s this collection of us at Veii, and we’ve decided that we need Camillus. That is His sole purpose to be like you guys need to summon Camillus, but we have to go about this the right way. And we knew back in Veii that the right way to handle this was to ask the Senate, because they’re the only ones who can really initiate this whole process. And Livy’s like, what men are the Romans. I mean, even in the darkest of times. They know that you have to follow the proper channels. You know there’s a line of communication here that must be followed. Doesn’t matter if you’re under siege. Doesn’t matter if there’s a gigantic Gallic army that’s just burnt down your city and murdered all the patricians. You still need to go to the appropriate people and get permission before you
Dr G 17:01
do anything, we will always follow protocol, and
Dr Rad 17:05
that is what he is there to do. So in Livy’s account, it’s not night time, as far as I can tell. He doesn’t explicitly say that, but what he does is, when he arrives, he sneaks up a very steep part of the Capitoline, which the Gauls had thought, meh, we need to guard that. There is no way any Roman could possibly get up that way, and that’s how he reaches the Capitol. It’s not under the cover of night. It’s just because it’s a part that the Gauls had been like. I think we need to guard that interesting.
Dr G 17:37
All right, so I mean the insertion of Camillus classic, I suppose, yeah.
Dr Rad 17:43
And basically he then he gets the permission the magistrates hear him, and the Senate decide that the Curia Comitia, or the Comitia curiata, would indeed end Camillus exile. And they decide at this moment that he would be appointed dictator. And so Pontius Cominus, then has to get back to ve to tell them, right, we’ve got permission. Everything’s happening in the proper way. The proper bodies have been performed. They’re voting, they’re talking, they’re debating. And then they have to send messengers off to Camillus, who is still in exile in Ardea, to tell him to go to they as his first point of call to, obviously, meet the men there. And Livy even explicitly says that he likes to think that Camillus would never have left Ardea until it had all been confirmed that the proper law, etc, had been passed to, like, end his exile. Because, you know what Camillus is like. He’s the straighty-180, keep it legit, man. You got to get the people’s permission. You can’t actually be a dictator. You know, take the auspices in the army until it’s all very official. Put a ring on it, guys, Wow.
Dr G 18:54
Just wow. I’m just going to put it out there. I don’t think this narrative is very plausible.
Dr Rad 19:02
Dr, G, I’m disappointed in your lack of imagination.
Dr G 19:07
First of all, it’s the people in Veii, the Romans in vain, that decide that they would like Camillus to be dictated. That does seem to be a consistent thread in most of the versions. Why would it matter for Camillus to then travel to Veii, because it’s still the Roman Senate in Rome that is making the decision to place him in that position. So if he needs clarification from anybody, it’s not the people in Veii who were like, we think this would be a great idea. What do you reckon Rome?
Dr Rad 19:36
No, he’s not going he’s not going to Veii. For that, he’s going to ve because those are the forces he’s going to use to help them. Yeah, okay, summon there, because basically in my account. So this is where I’m going to backtrack a little bit. So I actually have a little bit of build up to this moment. Livy explicitly tells me that at they the Romans have spent some time recovering. You know, they’ve been going to the spa. They’ve got cucumbers on their eyes. They’ve got the. Their hair wrapped up in little towels. They’ve got the bathrobes on, and because they’ve had a little bit of downtime, they’ve been getting stronger and braver. They’re feeling regenerated. They’re ready. And they also have additional people constantly joining them. So obviously, with the sack of Rome, there are various Roman people who are just wandering aimlessly throughout the countryside being like, Oh my God, I don’t have a city. I don’t have a home anymore. And they’ve managed to find their way to ve because, as we’ve talked about, they actually isn’t that far away from Rome. So they’ve been joining so they’ve got growing numbers there. Interestingly, Livy also tells me that there are volunteers from Latium who are joining the Roman forces at Veii, because they are after plunder. They smell a battle, and they’re down for it. Now my commentator who I consult, and sadly, this might be one of the last episodes I actually have this commentator to refer to, points out, I think, quite rightly, that this is most likely actually supplies from the Latin treaty, who are turning up. They’re not necessarily volunteers. It’s just the Latins who are obliged to give Romans military service, probably even though the Romans are down in their luck, and this probably seems like a suicide mission, they are there. I also have a really interesting detail before all of this happens, that the Roman soldiers, at they had actually spotted some Etruscans trying to do a bit of raiding while the Romans were down in their luck. And because they were at they and I guess, apparently nobody knew that they were there, they’re just sort of looking out, and they see the Etruscans, you know, being all predatory. And they’re like, oh my god, we’re in this situation, in this exiled city, because we tried to help you Etruscan people. And where has it got us sitting here in Veii watching you trying to take advantage of our situation? I mean, God, these people, these people. And this is where I first get the mention of the centurion Quintus Caedicius, seemingly the commander of they because he organizes an attack on these people. And it’s after this attack, when they sort of dealt with these predatory Etruscans, that he’s like, look, you know what? I think it’s Camillus that we need really, because he’s following, he’s following the example that Camillus has set for him before, like attacking at night and that sort of thing. And so he sort of realizes that this is the moment where I think that we need Camillus. We need a hero.
Dr G 22:37
Look, this is quite similar to the stuff that Diodorus Siculus tells us, but there are nuances of difference. So we don’t have Quinctius quidictius, for instance, attached to this idea of leading forces against Etruscan opportunists. That doesn’t seem to be a thing. The idea of the Etruscans taking the opportunity is definitely covered. So it seems that as the forces, the Roman forces in Veii are trying to look after the area that they’re locally attached to, in this moment, they notice that there are raiding Etruscan forces, and they do disrupt a number of Etruscan camps and steal the booty from them. So classic raiding mentality going on, being like my shoes. Finally, they have returned to me.
Dr Rad 23:27
You know what? My city may have been burnt to the ground, but thank god I’ve got my sandals.
Dr G 23:32
Goodness me, I’ve been waiting years to get these sandals back from the Etruscans. And so they end up in possession of a whole bunch of additional arms, essentially, which allows them to then feel a sense of confidence, being like, Okay, we could raise an armed force of some substance in this moment, which could help break the siege of Rome.
Dr Rad 23:55
Yes, and that’s, that’s exactly, I think, the point of that story in my account as well. It’s about confidence. Dr G, the Romans need to believe in themselves. Again. They’ve suffered quite a blow.
Dr G 24:06
Yeah, they do. And now they’re holding a sword in their hand. They’ve got their sandals back on, and they’re like, I can do it now.
Dr Rad 24:12
I’m ready. I can. I can. I also have this really interesting little story. Dr G, which involves people who used to be called the fabulous fabii, but who I have now dubbed the foolish fabii,
Dr G 24:26
probably a better classification for them, really,
Dr Rad 24:29
yes, although this is not a moment of foolishness. And again, I feel like Livy’s really trying to constantly build up throughout his narrative of the siege. This idea that look the Romans definitely screwed up in the lead up to this event, they ignored portents. They didn’t look at the signs properly. You know, things were not as they should have been. But once the siege begins, all we seem to see is Romans behaving correctly. And there’s this moment in the siege that Livy. Tells me about. So there’s a lull. Nothing’s really going on. The Gauls are kind of just hanging out watching being like, God so dull, just trying to make sure that the Romans really aren’t escaping at this point. And they’re obviously all up there, you know, Citadel, capital, whatever. But then suddenly, both the Romans and the Gauls are astounded to see a lone Roman leaving the area where the Romans have secured themselves. And wouldn’t you know it, it’s one of the fabii. Dr, G What? Yeah. Gaius Fabius Dorsuo, hmm. This is a
Dr G 25:41
narrative which I have never come across in any other source, so I’m fascinated to hear how this goes.
Dr Rad 25:46
Okay, so the family of the Fabii allegedly make an annual sacrifice on the quirinal hill. Okay, okay, I take it back. I do have a source on this. Okay, and it’s this moment that Gaius Fabius Dorsuo is like, well, Siege or no siege, sacrifices must be held, so I’m just going to leave by myself in the midst of this siege, and he’s all ready for the sacrifice. We can tell this because Livy tells me he’s in the gabinian Cincture, which basically means that he’s like, belted his toga so that His arms can be free. Because, as we’ve talked about before, the toga is an unwieldy garment not really made for doing anything but gesturing with one arm emphatically,
Dr G 26:29
yeah, Heaven forfend, you have to grab a jar off a shelf with two hands, because that would be impossible in your toga, exactly.
Dr Rad 26:34
And he’s having to carry sacred vessels, so he needs his hands.
Dr G 26:39
These are sacred vessels that have not been removed from Rome. I note,
Dr Rad 26:43
well, exactly. I mean, these are presumably something to do with his family, I guess. Anyway, so he leaves the Capitol. He just walks straight through the pickets erected by the Gauls, and they obviously start hurling threats at him. He completely ignores them. He’s in the zone. He cares not for these Gallic threats, he just goes straight to the Quirinal hill and starts carrying out the rights and then returns seemingly entirely confident that because he is doing the right thing, he would be unharmed. He would not let death scare him away from the proper worship of the gods the Gauls have their jaws on the floor. They are completely confounded, kind of impressed by the level of his religious dedication. And there is maybe a little insult here in Livy’s account about the Gauls being like an overly superstitious people. I can’t really figure out if it’s meant to be a compliment that the girls were impressed by the Roman but I think it’s probably more a bit of a backhander where he’s like, you know, the girls, overly superstitious, foolish people,
Dr G 27:54
fascinating, given that the whole story, and the premise of it is that the gods must be upheld at all times, and the Romans must do it in the face of All troubles. Yeah, that’s
Dr Rad 28:02
why I can’t I couldn’t quite figure it out like, I think it is meant to be a little bit of an insult, or at least, sort of playing on this idea that the goals were a very superstitious people, and so were likely to be impressed by religious dedication, which is perhaps why they didn’t do anything to this guy. They just let him pass and that sort of thing. Now this is obviously a very curious story, and there are other explanations for what is going on here. There is a fragment from Cassius Hermina, and I think this will intrigue you, Dr G who says that Fabius was not actually carrying out some sort of family sacrifice, but was instead actually tending to the cult of Vesta.
Dr G 28:46
Oh yes. Now this is where it ties in very nicely with a small fragment from Appian, because this is mentioned and the priest isn’t given a designation as part of the Fabii. The name Dorso is part of it, but he is called Dorsonote
Dr G 29:07
I think there are variations in the name, yeah.
Dr G 29:09
And apparently he does go down from the Capitol because the annual sacrifice that is required of his priesthood is required at the Temple of Vesta. And he goes down into the city. He’s carrying all the sacred utensils that he needs. He goes through the ranks of the Gauls, and they seem. It’s described that the Gauls are either awed by his courage in going through with this act, or they have a high level of respect for the piety that he’s demonstrating, which would suggest that the Gauls recognize what sacred dress and sacred utensils for the Romans even look like, which is myself, I think, a big assumption, and the fact that he looks venerable in his appearance, all of these things are enough for them to be like. Well, this. Is curious. Let’s just watch and see what happens. And so he goes and he does the sacrifice in the Temple of Vesta and returns back up the hill. So be it. And that seems to be the end of the story. Why this story is told to us is less clear,
Dr Rad 30:19
I think in Livy’s account is definitely meant to be showing the piety of the Romans, given the fact that the Gallic sack of Rome seems to be a result of their lack of attention to things like omens importance and and that sort of thing. So I feel like that’s what Livy is trying to build up here. And it is a bit of a weird story, because we don’t necessarily have that much evidence to suggest that the fabii as a gens did have a very strong connection with the Quirinal there is some sort of connection, maybe, in the way that the family set out for the battle of chimera, where most of them are apparently slaughtered. But there’s no archeological evidence to show that any of the fabii ever lived in this location. We don’t really have any other mention of this sacrifice, as far as I’m aware. So it is a bit of an interesting one.
Dr G 31:19
It is, and the quirinal is not where the Temple of Vesta is, either. So these are two different versions of a story, and it’s hard to know what might be going on here. I do suspect that, given there are variations on their story, that there’s something to it, that at some point, perhaps there was some sort of agreement made with the Gauls that it was important for this religious right to take place, and they’d only be sending one man down the hill, and would it be permitted, and some agreement had been reached which allowed it to take place. But aside from that, this doesn’t seem to be the big ticket item that leads to the next thing that happens in this siege.
Dr Rad 32:03
No, I feel like it’s just part of the redemption story of Rome. But basically, once the chips are down, all of a sudden, the Romans remember how they should be conducting themselves and start, you know, polishing their shoes, making their beds.
Dr G 32:19
I suspect that might present a kind of literary foil to what we’ve seen with camilius, journey of accidentally promising things that he couldn’t keep to the gods whoops. And in this case, if there is a Fabian connection, the idea that they have acknowledged that there was wrongdoing on their part when they were in Clusium. And this is an attempt to write things and square things with the gods in this instance.
Dr Rad 32:46
Well, yes, lest we forget, that one of the earliest analysts of Rome was from this family, yes.
Dr G 32:53
And so this could be a redemptive arc as well, but for the Gauls and what is happening with this siege, it is really the situation with Pontius Cominius That seems to spur on the next act, because at least in the account of Diodorus, for all of the fact that he goes out under the cover of darkness to make contact with the Capitoline, the Gauls do see him. Interesting.
Dr Rad 33:24
See in Livy’s account, they see the footprints that he left behind, which is weird, because allegedly, they weren’t watching this part of the cliff because they thought nobody could possibly climb it. And yet they notice his footprints.
Dr G 33:37
I do like the we’re not looking. We’re not looking. Is that a shoe? What?
Dr Rad 33:44
Nobody’s been walking up this side of the cliff. We’ve all agreed it would be insane. Quick Get me my Sherlock Holmes outfit and my magnifying glass
Dr G 33:51
exactly like, what is this? I’ve seen something suspicious in a spot I was never looking
Dr Rad 33:59
Yeah, they even actually tested out themselves. They’re like, Oh my god, maybe there is a pathway up here that we haven’t noticed. We better try it out ourselves. And, oh my god, it does seem possible.
Dr G 34:13
And this is, I think, leading into what I think is the best part of this whole story, yeah, is that the Gauls do then send a force up the Capitoline, up this notoriously difficult cliff that maybe they were watching or maybe they weren’t watching. It’s no longer clear.
Dr Rad 34:30
I think it’s probably like kind of near the most difficult part. I don’t think they’re necessarily going up exactly the same path that our sprightly youth took, but yeah, they certainly are looking at the Capitoline and being like, oh my god, I think there’s a pathway that we hadn’t detected.
Dr G 34:47
But they do take this opportunity to sort of mirror what Cominius Pontius has done, which is, under the cover of darkness, send up some men to find a pathway, a secret way up the cliff, and be like, yes, well. Well, if one man can get up to the top without being spotted, dude who gets to the top, what if we send our men?
Dr Rad 35:05
Yes, and I’m actually given a precise location. It’s the cliff near the shrine of commentus. Now this is a reference to someone, I think, more commonly known as commenta, the mother of Evander. Evander is a character we have mentioned from time to time, because he’s kind of a bit of a alternative character to Romulus, I guess, an important character to the mythical foundations of Rome.
Dr G 35:33
Yeah, Evander comes through very strongly in Livy’s writing as an alternative sort of founding figure, and perhaps this idea that it’s near this place of carmenta will reveal some meaning over time as we get further into this story.
Dr Rad 35:51
Well, yes, I mean, I presume that there apparently Evander landed at Rome on advice given by his mother, Carmentis, Carmenta. And I presume that the shrine, obviously there is there for there to honor her part in the whole story, and him being able to establish himself on the Palatine. So I wonder if maybe it is something about, something to do with, you know, like the foundations, the establishment of Rome, and, you know, like sort of connecting to those ideas, that Rome is going to survive and going to be re established, perhaps, but I might be reading too much into it.
Dr G 36:27
I think it’s useful to think of this as a foreshadowing, because definitely some of these ideas are going to return into our narrative as we get further into this story. But the Gauls do this great moment of like, well, we’ll climb up this cliff. We’ll get to the top in the middle of the night. Nobody will know, but unfortunately, and most unfortunately, they do escape the detection of the guards. Apparently, they have landed upon a relatively unfortified section of the top of the Capitol line where the guards, for whatever reason, are either not paying attention or haven’t been looking there very closely, even though somebody of their own team just climbed up there the other day.
Dr Rad 37:09
Well, look, I presume it’s because, given the way that Livy’s sort of painting this, we’re well into the siege by this point. And we have talked about these moments where there’s been a real lull, nothing much is going on, therefore Fabii, I are just wandering around the place, seemingly ignoring all the signs saying, Stop Danger, danger. So maybe it’s just because, as would happen, I think with a siege, the really tense adrenaline kind of moments have passed, and maybe they’re just, you know, getting used to life on rations, yeah,
Dr G 37:41
and it’s hard to pay attention all of the time for sure, particularly when nothing has happened for a while, and it seems that maybe nothing has happened for a while, but lo and behold, the sacred geese of Hera aren’t having any of that. They’re paying attention, and they might be the only ones on the Capitoline paying attention. The sacred geese are what raises the alarm, and it’s the honking in the nighttime that really wakes everybody up and alerts them that the Gauls have climbed up the cliff face of the Capitoline Hill. And I love this moment. I think it’s such a beautiful way of thinking about the way the gods can interfere with people’s lives. And I do like that the geese get to have a starring role in this
Dr Rad 38:32
Well, see, I’m very intrigued by all of this, so I’m not a religious expert, as you know, when it comes to ancient Rome, so I hadn’t really ever thought about this story before, in terms of questioning exactly how the animals play a part. So this is actually part of one of my least favorite stories about Rome, because in my account, in Livy’s account, it’s the dogs that are supposed to wake everybody up if there are goals approaching. So presumably it’s part of their contingent, even though they’re so desperately short on food, they have dogs up there on the on the Capitoline, and the dogs don’t wake up. They sleep through and it’s the geese, as you say, that are sacred to Juno who, who wake everybody up. And the Romans, even though they were so desperately short on food, had not eaten animals like the geese because they were sacred. So again, their piety is kind of part of the story here. Unfortunately, the fact that the dogs didn’t wake up and they were supposed to means that the Romans are going to crucify a dog every year. It’s kind of like a remembrance and a punishment of this failure, which is absolutely my least favorite thing ever to have heard about the Romans. It’s just that is horrifying. I understand how important this moment is to them. I understand it could have led to the total collapse of their civilization, but crucifixion is just the most horrific way to kill. Kill any living creature. And the idea of putting a dog that knows absolutely nothing about what is going on into that position, like, I just can’t like the fact that when animals can’t understand what is going on around them, you know, they don’t understand war, they don’t understand these, these sorts of things, crucifying them. You know, when they have absolutely no choice in it? It just, yeah, it’s the same kind of thing. I don’t understand about our world these days. I don’t understand how people can be horrible to animals, particularly animals like dogs, who just want to love and serve human beings like they just have no malice towards anything. It just, I hate this story so, so much.
Dr G 40:43
Yeah, I agree with you, and this is part of the account that doesn’t come through in the source material that I’ve looked at. And so I have, I don’t know, upwards of 15 sources for this Gallic sack, and not once has the story of the dog being mentioned. And I find that interesting as well, because I’m hearing it for the first time from Livy’s account, and it’s it is horrifying, and I think we need to take on board that this is also just one of many horrifying acts of sacrifice that the Romans engage in. And because animal sacrifice is clearly very much part of their culture, and this is a particularly cruel way to engage
Dr Rad 41:28
in it true. I think it’s the thing of, I don’t like the idea of animal sacrifice, you know, I’m very much about just treating other living things with the dignity and respect that we would expect for ourselves. I don’t believe there is a difference between humans and humans and animals, because humans are animals, but I think when it comes to animal sacrifice in Rome, it’s my understanding. Correct me, if I’m wrong here, dr, G, that when you are sacrificing an animal, you actually don’t want it to be panicked at the moment of death. It is meant to be a relatively calm procedure. So whilst it isn’t my favorite thing, at least, I can kind of understand that the animal hopefully didn’t really feel much fear. You know, I think it’s actually probably certainly a kinder way to be killed than what millions of animals around the world endure at the hands of factory farming, where they’re literally lined up like on a conveyor belt, and have to watch other animals be killed and smell the blood and smell the fear and the urine and the feces that probably goes along with that whole process. Like what we do to animals is definitely, I think, far worse because of the scale and the fact that we actually should know better by now, but at the same time, and so I guess that’s why I can kind of overlook the animal sacrifice part of ancient Rome, but this particular thing I can’t really overlook, and look, Livy, doesn’t give me the full story right at this moment. It’s actually putting together other sources that I’ve read that I understand the ongoing impact of this moment for dogs and geese. The other side of this story is that the geese are on it every year, so you do have that side of the story. But the interesting thing I did come across about the geese, and this is where they say my lack of religious knowledge sort of came into play, because I wouldn’t really have actually questioned this. But apparently, geese are not really known to be sacred to Juno. They’re not really depicted, generally on monuments connected to her. And so it’s interesting that it is geese that are mentioned at this moment. And one of the sources that I read suggested that actually maybe there were birds on the Capitol, because we know that there was an auguraculum where birds would be watched for divine signs by just how they ate their food. You know, like, do they eat a lot? Do they eat greedily? Do they not eat a lot? And you would ascertain what the gods wanted from watching that. And we apparently don’t really know exactly which birds might have been used. Of this, we know that later on, hens were used, but maybe not always hens. So maybe the geese were there because they were a part of that,
Dr G 44:11
quite possibly. And yeah, you’re quite right. I mean, if we’re thinking about Juno’s Greek counterpart, Hera, often associated iconographically with the peacock, and we seem to have a real lack of peacocks in this story.
Dr Rad 44:26
It’s a different bird altogether. Yeah, you wouldn’t
Dr G 44:29
make the mistake, I don’t think. But anyway, the sacred geese very handy in this moment one because, as we all know, geese are great guard animals, and they raise the alarm. And it’s at this moment that we get to have a new hero enter into our story, because once the geese are off and running, being like, Alert, alert, something’s going wrong, flapping the wings, honking around Marcus Manlius or Maelius, he has variations on his name. He seems to be the first and the only named figure that rushes to the defense of the Capitoline hill in this moment. He’s definitely the one who encourages others to take up their swords in this moment. And what he does is horrifying as well. He starts cutting off Gaulish hands. So as the hands of the Gauls reach over the top edge of the cliff to finally achieve the ascent that they’ve been working on all night, he starts cutting off hands. Oh, my
Dr Rad 45:34
God, I don’t have that detail at all in my story, even though he is the one who wakes everybody else up, gathers all the weapons and is like, come on, slapping people awake. Get your act together. We’ve got some stuff to do. When he spots a Gaul who had almost made his way to the Romans, he uses his shield to sort of push him and beat him back. And when this Gallic person then slips and falls, it creates this domino effect where all the goals are kind of knocked down, like, and the goals are like, Oh my God. And the goals are obviously taken by surprise that they have been spotted, even though, surely they also heard the geese, but apparently not. And so they kind of drop all their weapons, and they are just hanging on to rocks. Now this would be the moment where you’d think, okay, he could come in and slice off some hands. But all I am told is that he kills them all. So just as they’re sort of dangling on the cliff face there, he kills them all, which is horrifying, but oh my god, the hand thing. Yikes.
Dr G 46:34
Yeah. Apparently Diodorus tells us that he goes for the hands first and then pushes them back. And so some of them start tumbling off the cliff. And he keeps going with that, and he encourages others to keep going with that, because it seems to be working. He’s like, go for the hands and then push him off.
Dr Rad 46:50
I mean, look, logically, that makes sense. If they’re scaling a cliff face in order to reach the Romans, it would absolutely make sense to be like stomping, stabbing, cutting their hands, yes.
Dr G 47:01
And once you fall off a cliff face, like the Capitoline Hill is high enough that if you fall off the top of it down a cliff face, it’s going to end badly for you. You’re either going to be very severely injured with not much longer to go, or the fall will kill you. So this places the Romans in a position where they’re feeling a little bit superior. They’re like, we’ve knocked back this attack. And this is sort of opens the door for some negotiations to take place.
Dr Rad 47:33
Okay, interesting. Before you get into the negotiations, I just have to add my favorite inconsequential detail about this whole story. So as you say, Manlius is attacking all these Gauls. The rest of the Romans join in. They’re using their javelins, they’re using stones, and all the Gauls are hurled to their death. And once all the Gauls have been killed, who’ve been trying to scale this cliff, the Romans are like, ooh, bit of adrenaline pumping through them, but it’s all kind of dying down now that they can see that there are no more attackers. And the Romans turn to each other, and they’re like, finally, we can get some decent sleep, and let’s go back to bed. Amazing. I’m also told by Livy that at dawn, the Romans are woken up, you know, like the trumpet sounds, the soldiers are all called to assemble before the tribunes because it’s time, Dr G to reward the good and the bad performances of the night. Manlius, of course, is the hero singled out for his bravery, and he is given gifts, not just from the tribunes, but all the soldiers had, somehow in the space of a night where they slaughtered some goals and got a decent amount of sleep, managed to get together, and they’ve each brought half a pound of spelt and a gill of wine to his house, which was handily enough on the Citadel, which is obviously meant to be a huge sacrifice, because the Romans don’t have a ton of provisions at this moment in time, so he would presumably appreciate this more than anything else, but the bad performance is, Dr G, uh oh, what to do with not just the dogs but the men who were supposed to be on watch? I mean, guys, guys. Guys. How did you let this happen? This is kind of your one job.
Dr G 49:25
You telling me you delegated to the geese.
Dr Rad 49:30
So a tribune named Quintus Sulpicius said, I’m going to punish you all in the military fashion. Now I’m not really given any more details than that, but I presume that might mean something like decimation.
Dr G 49:45
I didn’t know they had decimation at this point in time, but it doesn’t sound pleasant look.
Dr Rad 49:49
I’m not sure exactly what that means. Is it? I mean, maybe it just means death, like in the military fashion,
Dr G 49:54
it might be a whipping of some kind. It wouldn’t surprise me if they’re being scouged with. Odds, for instance, that might be a military punishment at this point, because we don’t have a formalized military that’s true. It does make it hard to know what the military punishment would be, because this is not something that has tended to come up so far. It might be too early for decimation, but it also
Dr Rad 50:17
might not look decimation was just my guess as I was reading this because I was like, What does in the military fashion mean? I mean, look, I think we can safely say not pleasant, not something you want to happen to you.
Dr G 50:28
Yeah, obviously, yeah, if you think about the military, what’s something that you don’t want to happen to you as a military person? Many things.
Dr Rad 50:36
Yeah, exactly. But all the soldiers protest and say, no, no, no, that is, pardon the pun, but overkill. You don’t need to go that far. And they basically decide that they’re going to throw one guy under the bus completely. Wow, yeah, they’re like, it’s all his fault. All his fault. Don’t worry, listeners, Livy assures me that he completely deserves it. It definitely was entirely this guy’s fault, and so he is held off the top of a rock in punishment. Wow.
Dr G 51:09
Throw him down on top of the dead Gauls. That’s where he deserves to be. Look.
Dr Rad 51:15
I presume that is what Livy means. But I must admit, there have been some accounts that I have read that also seem to suggest that maybe Livy is referring to being hurled off the Tarpeian rock, which does happen to people as punishment in ancient Rome. But Dr, G, you know the geography of Rome, and you, I don’t think will believe this.
Dr G 51:38
I find that unlikely. I mean, yes, we do have the Tarpeian rock. Is a classic rock to throw people off, but the Romans are in a siege situation, and they’re confined to the Capitoline hill. So the idea that they would be able to get through the Gaulish forces all the way across to where the Tarpeian rock is and throw this guy off the specific rock that they like to throw people off, rather than the rock that they have that they’re on top of right now, which they’ve been defending for their lives. Seems unlikely at best.
Dr Rad 52:08
Well, I guess it would be very symbolic to hurl a Roman who you regard as having really broken his trust with the people to like, throw him down on top of the dead.
Dr G 52:19
Gauls, yeah. Serves him right. Yeah, you’re as good as the enemy to us, yeah. Well, yeah. Well, after the fall of the rock, yes.
Dr Rad 52:29
So this whole section of the account wraps up for me with Livy noting, as one might expect, that the guards for the Romans and the Gauls are now on much higher alert after these nighttime shenanigans.
Dr G 52:41
Well, well, well, maybe we do need to pay attention.
Dr Rad 52:44
Yeah, and the Gauls have definitely picked up on the fact that there is, I think, some communication going on between they and Rome. They’ve picked up on that. They saw the cork, and they were like, hang on a second. There’s only one reason for a piece of cork to be floating in the Tiber. And the Romans, of course, have almost just lost everything, so they’re like, We need to, like, pick up our game, guys. We need to get the show on the road.
Dr G 53:10
Yeah, look, I swear. Look, I’ve seen some cork, and I’m pretty sure it’s from Veii. What, man, but we’re besieging Rome. I know. Isn’t that virtus?
Dr Rad 53:23
In your account, it may be this that opens the negotiations, but in my account, we’re all about to be in for famine and pestilence. Oh, goody, yes, yes, no one shall be spared.
Dr G 53:41
Chapter Two, a siege is not a siege until you have famine and pestilence
Dr Rad 53:45
indeed, and that Dr G is where I would like to lay my hat. Ooh, the suspense. I haven’t been podcasting for 13 years without learning a trick or two about suspense.
Dr G 54:00
Well, I guess that means it is time for the partial pick.
Dr Rad 54:10
It is indeed, Dr G, can you please explain to our listeners what the partial pick is all about?
Dr G 54:15
Well, Rome has their chance to win 50 gold eagles, 10 Eagles each across five categories. I would say that the Romans made up these categories, but they didn’t. We did. We thought about them when we made them up, and maybe that will help.
Dr Rad 54:31
So what is our first category? Dr, G,
Dr G 54:33
our first category is military clout.
Dr Rad 54:38
This is very tough because there has actually been a little bit of military success on the Roman side, in some ways, it just depends how you look at it. They have apparently dealt with some marauding Etruscans in the region of they and been victorious there, largely because they follow the Camillus blueprint and then. They have also managed to beat off an attempt by the goals to break the siege.
Dr G 55:06
That’s true, cutting off a few hands, pushing people back with shields. Yeah, yeah. I mean that in a siege, that’s kind of as good as it gets, apart from busting out of the siege itself is resisting the attack on your location. So I guess maybe a five,
Dr Rad 55:25
wow, a five. That is uncharacteristically generous.
Dr G 55:29
Well, I’m thinking like, how hard is it to have a military clout moment when you’re in Siege conditions? And I’d say it’s probably pretty difficult, because one you’ve either got to summon up the courage to do an attack yourself. So leaving your defenses and going down and engaging directly, that would be more military clout, I would say, but to sort of take on the sort of the pillaging roaming camps of the Etruscans when you’ve got a split force, and also to defend yourself successfully, although, I mean, you did have to rely on the geese. Yeah?
Dr Rad 56:06
Yeah. I was gonna say, I feel like I can’t believe I’m saying this, me of all people, but I feel like five is too generous.
Dr G 56:12
I feel like the geese deserve 10, yeah, but maybe the Romans deserve less than five, now that I’m thinking about it, yeah.
Dr Rad 56:19
I kind of feel like maybe a three or four, because, like, it’s something, but they are still kind of slowly starving to death on the capital,
Dr G 56:29
okay. Well, if we’re measuring it by that, it’s a three,
Dr Rad 56:34
all right, so three, it is, all right.
Dr G 56:36
The second category is diplomacy,
Dr Rad 56:39
hmm, well, I think we agreed that diplomacy has to be something in between Roman foreign powers, because whilst there is definitely some secret messaging going on between the Romans and their fellow Romans, I don’t think that counts.
Dr G 56:55
No, that is not diplomacy. That’s a zero, yeah. Zero, okay.
Dr Rad 57:00
Expansion, I feel like this is going to be a continual zero for some time. That’s a no. Wirtus, huh? Well, I think Manlius definitely would meet some of the criteria for that with his actions in bravely waking everybody up and thrusting swords into their hands and then single handedly cutting off the hands, of course, until the Romans are awake enough to join him and help him.
Dr G 57:32
Yes, that is that is definitely a classic military style weird to us. I would love to give Cominius Pontius some points for virtus, but I’m not sure that sneaking around in the middle of the night and not being seen and having a cork board as a bit of a floaty counts as weird to us.
Dr Rad 57:49
Okay, well, what about in my account? Gaius Fabius Dorsuo, hmm. I mean, it’s more piety, I suppose, than virtus.
Dr G 57:57
But yeah, I don’t think it counts because it sits in the wrong category.
Dr Rad 58:02
He does have to walk through, apparently, an entire Gallic army to get to the criminal.
Dr G 58:08
Yeah, it’s awkward, but what you got to do, I suppose, is it weirdos. I don’t think so. Okay, fair enough. So that leaves us with Manlius as our standout character.
Dr Rad 58:17
And then it seems very appropriate that his name is Manlius when we’re talking about when we’re talking about weirdos.
Dr G 58:18
But he’s only capable of demonstrating that in the face of the geese. So it’s not like he spotted the Gauls coming up the
Dr Rad 58:32
cliff. Well, once he woke up, he spotted them.
Dr G 58:36
I see it all now. Thanks, Juno. I don’t know, maybe a four, what?
Dr Rad 58:44
No, I’m sorry you were gonna give the Romans a five for military clout when all they’d really done is fend off an attack whilst they were under a very serious siege. And they also happened to spot some Etruscans like raiding when they were at Veii and under no real threat. Absolutely not. It has to be a five,
Dr G 59:07
okay, all right, fine. I will accept five. Thank you. Our final rating is for the citizen score. Well, there aren’t
Dr Rad 59:19
really any citizens left it. They’re all in Veii or somewhere in the countryside.
Dr G 59:25
Yeah, it’s not looking great or dead. So I guess it’s a it’s a zero.
Dr Rad 59:31
I think it has to be a zero for now, hopefully things will start to turn around for the Romans soon.
Dr G 59:36
Yeah, we haven’t seen anything to suggest that the citizens are having a good time in any way. I mean,
Dr Rad 59:41
look, the only consideration I will throw in here is that, I guess with Camillus technically being appointed dictator in this episode, I can’t believe that hasn’t come up in the partial pic, maybe there’s some hope, because there are some Romans at Veii. They’re probably having a good time. They’re at the spa rejuvenating.
Dr G 59:59
That’s right, yeah, yeah. I can’t forget those guys. Yeah. It’s not clear to me that anybody’s having a good time as a citizen. So and it’s hard to when it’s a siege, yeah, and your city is basically, yeah, you’re either there on rations or you’re out in the countryside hoping that somebody will take you in without killing you. You’re very vulnerable.
Dr Rad 1:00:20
Yeah, yeah. This is true, yeah. I mean, like the people at a might be okay, but they’re still not at Rome.
Dr G 1:00:27
This is true, and though, but though maybe they don’t want to be foreshadowing, foreshadowing, foreshadowing, all
Dr Rad 1:00:32
right, so it’s probably zero, then, yeah, okay, well, Dr G, that means that I have only had to use my two hands to count again, because the Romans have finished with eight out of 50 golden eagles.
Dr G 1:00:46
Wow, congratulations, Rome scraping in at the bottom of the barrel. Not a surprise, given they’re in a siege.
Dr Rad 1:00:53
I was gonna say that guy wasn’t really expecting high scores throughout 390 BCE and I have not been disappointed.
Dr G 1:01:00
Well, it has been an absolute pleasure to discuss Ancient Rome with you. Dr Rad, as always,
Dr Rad 1:01:06
thank you. Dr G and I would like to finish up because we have talked a lot about animals during this episode, just reminding people, please be kind to your pets. They are part of your family. And also, if you feel like it, maybe donate to help some pet rescues. They’re really under increasing pressure these days, particularly in Australia. Right now, as we’re recording, it is kitten season, and they’re being absolutely inundated. A lot of these people have full time jobs and help out with these sorts of rescue operations in their spare time, whilst they’re juggling families and all the other responsibilities that we all have. And of course, there are also lots of working animals in the world that don’t have great conditions to live in and maybe go a little bit more plant based in your diet, because Factory Farming isn’t great either. The Romans may not have been fantastic when it came to animal welfare, but I’m not always sure that our society is much better.
Dr G 1:02:02
Yeah, I would definitely advocate for including more plants in your diet where possible. That is, I’d say number one, the easiest way to support animals. And yeah, I think we both donate to Cat shelters and things like that.
Dr Rad 1:02:16
So I definitely do quite a number of them. But yeah, I do sense the desperation for a lot of rescuers, and I really feel for them. So speaking about the crucifixion of dogs, just got me in mind that, yeah, if we all pitch together, hopefully we can stop these kind of places, to be honest, being necessary, because they’re really only necessary when human beings are irresponsible, all right. Dr, G until next time, I’ll catch you soon.
Dr Rad 1:02:51
Thank you for listening to this episode of the partial historians. You can find our sources sound credits and an automated transcript in our show notes. Our music is by Bettina Joy De Guzman. The Partial Historians is part of the Memory Collective, creators and educators dedicated to sharing knowledge that is accessible, contextualized, socially conscious and inclusive. To find more from the Memory Collective, head to collective mem.com you can support us by buying us a coffee on Ko Fi. But you can also support our show and help us to produce more engaging content about the ancient world by becoming a Patreon. In return, you receive exclusive early access to our special episodes and ad free content. Today, we would like to send a special shout out to Kent Johnson for not only supporting us on Kofi, but Patreon as well. However, if you aren’t feeling particularly patrician these days, please just tell someone about the show or give us a five star review until next time we are yours in ancient Rome.
Transcribed by https://otter.ai
The post Episode 169 – The Gallic Sack of Rome – Part 4 appeared first on The Partial Historians - Ancient Roman History with smart ladies.
In this episode, we discuss one of the more tragic episodes from the Gallic sack of Rome. Want to know how we got here? Check out our previous coverage!
The Romans who have remained in the city take up their defensive positions on the Capitol. The old patricians did not join them. Instead, their retired to their houses. Wearing their old robes of state, they settled down in the middle of their houses on ivory chairs to await the end.
Livy reports that some of his accounts indicate that the pontifex maximus (chief priest) led the ex-magistrates in a vow, in which they were devoting themselves to death for the sake of the city and its citizens.
The Gauls found their blood had cooled; after all, they had not had to fight the Romans to seize control of the city. They had just wandered in. They could see that the Capitol had been fortified, so they kept an eye on that area. However, it was time to go SHOPPING! All these abandoned streets and houses – it was theirs for the taking.
After some pillaging and plundering, the Gauls touched base again in the Forum. The plebeian houses in the area were locked up – they weren’t taking any chances whilst they were out of town. But the houses of the elite were mysteriously open.
As the Gauls entered the patrician dwellings, a shocking sight met their eyes. The old ex-magistrates, sitting as still as statues, dressed in their robes of state, just waiting for them. Not quite believing their eyes, one of the Gauls reached out to touch the beard of one of the patricians. How rude! The patrician clocked him in the head with an ivory mace. The Gauls were not going to show restraint now. The patricians were slain, the houses of the Roman citizens looted, and finally, the city was set on fire.
‘Destruction’ by Thomas Cole (1836), Courtesy of Wikipedia.
But not the whole city – these Gauls weren’t FOOLS! They wanted to keep a bargaining chip in their back pockets. Maybe these pesky Romans on the citadel might surrender to save their homes?
The Romans in question were in their own kind of hell as they sat on the Capitol and had to watch the destruction. Fortune had turned her back on them.
Did this mean that the Romans were going to give up? It most certainly did NOT! When the Gauls finally assaulted the Capital, the Romans were ready for them. They managed to hold the line. If the Gauls wanted to seize all of Rome, they were going to have to settle in for a siege.
As the Gauls made themselves comfortable and set about plundering the countryside, over in Ardea, the exiled Camillus heard of the attack on Rome. What could he do? Could he possibly whip up an inspirational speech and persuade the Ardeates to fight the Gallic invaders? You betcha!
Q. Fabius M. f. Q. n. Ambustus (Pat)
K. Fabius M. f. Q n. Ambustus (Pat) Mil. Tr. c. p. 404, 401, 395
N. Fabius M. f. Q. n. Ambustus (Pat) Mil. Tr. c. p. 406
Q. Sulpicius -f. -n. Longus (Pat)
Q. Servilius Q. f. P. n. Fidenas (Pat) Mil. Tr. c. p. 402, 398, 395, 388, 386
P. Cornelius P. f. M. n. Maluginensis (Pat) Cos. 393? Mil. Tr. c. p. 397
M. Furius L. f. Sp. n. Camillus (Pat) Mil. Tr. c.p. 401, 398, 394, 386, 384, 381
L. Valerius (L. f. L. n. Poplicola) (Pat) Mil. Tr. c.p. 394, 389, 387, 383
OR
L. Valerius (L. f. P. n. Potitus) (Pat) Cos. 393, 392; Mil. Tr. c.p. 414, 406, 403, 401, 398
?-390: M. Folius (Flaccinator?) (Pat) Mil. Tr. c.p. 433
C. or K. Fabius Dorsuo (Pat)
439-390: Q. ? Servilius P. f. (Sp. n. Priscus or Structus Fidenas?) (Pat)
Successor: [—- Furi]us Q. f. P. nepos Fu[sus] (Pat) Mil. Tr. c.p. 403
Our music is by the superb Bettina Joy de Guzman.
Dr G 0:19
We explore all the details of ancient Rome,
Dr Rad 0:23
everything from political scandals, the love affairs, the battle’s waged, and when citizens turn against each other, I’m Dr Rad
Dr G 0:33
and I’m Dr G. We consider Rome as the Romans saw it, by reading different authors from the ancient past and comparing their stories.
Dr Rad 0:44
Join us as we trace the journey of Rome from the founding of the city.
Dr G 0:56
Hello and welcome to a brand new episode of the Partial Historians. I am Dr G,
Dr Rad 1:02
and I am Dr ad, and we
Dr G 1:05
are deep, deep inside the Gallic sack of Rome. And so far, it hasn’t happened yet. But Just you wait, I think it’s gonna happen in this episode.
Dr Rad 1:15
Well, that just sounds dirty. Dr G, not even a minute in, and already disgusting.
Dr G 1:21
The Romans, they do it to me every time.
Dr Rad 1:26
Well, Dr G 390, as we know, is an epic year, so epic that we may not even be able to cover it in three episodes, which is kind of what we were anticipating. But I see a fourth in our future.
Dr G 1:37
Yeah, it’s quite potential. Now that I’ve sat down and re looked at my notes. I suspect today is not the day that we finish the sack. It’s going to go on a bit like a siege goes on for much longer than anybody wants it to.
Dr Rad 1:49
Exactly now we’ve got up to the point Dr G, where the Gauls are at the walls of Rome. Things are very dire. We’ve had Vestals in distress, fleeing before the horde of Gallic attackers,
Dr G 2:07
running away with all the sacred items that they can put their hands on, and hitching a ride to a nearby
Dr Rad 2:14
city. Yes, which we presume is Caere
Dr G 2:17
yeah, which is so far away that’s not nearby at all. You don’t want to walk all the way. That’s 50 or so kilometers, 30 miles. Luckily, they get picked up in a cart, yeah.
Dr Rad 2:28
And they kick out a wife and child so that they can get a ride with this guy, Albinius.
Dr G 2:35
And I think in terms of orientation, of where we’re up to in this story, I think it’s important to note that the Romans are losing most assuredly, this is not going well. They’ve already lost a major battle at the union of the Tiber River and the Allia, and they have retreated. Some of their soldiers have fled to ve that will become important, and some have fled back to Rome, also important. And now the Gaulish forces had time to sort of do their roundup of the sorts of things they like to do post battle, which is go around and cut everybody’s heads off and then make their way to Rome itself.
Dr Rad 3:09
Yes, so Rome itself, we have a force that have been left to defend the Citadel. Dr G because, God forbid, the Citadel should be captured.
Dr G 3:20
And importantly, the Citadel is on the Capitoline hill, so it is on the highest viewing point of the city. It has the best defense. And everybody’s like retreat to the highest place of the defenses. Retreat.
Dr Rad 3:35
And this is a particularly sacred part of the city as well. The Romans would indeed rather die than let this be taken so it is obviously very, very grim at this moment in time. Dr G, everyone has fled, except for this band of defenders. We’ve got sacred objects being stored in other cities because they can’t be left in Rome. They’re just not safe anymore. There’s also one other group who have been left behind in the city by choice, Dr, G, and that is a bunch of really old men.
Dr G 4:09
Ah, yes, those who are fabled not to be able to travel well, and have decided to take upon themselves the ultimate sacrifice, which is to defend Rome in whatever way that they can up until their last dying breath.
Dr Rad 4:24
It’s a very interesting episode. This the massacre of the senators, is what we’re going to entitle it. Sorry, everybody, yeah, it’s such a cheery episode. So we’ve got these guys who are older gents. They are mostly ex magistrates. They are prepared to take a stand. Dr, G, but it seems like there might be a bit more to this story than meets the eye, something something sacred, if you will, which I think will be right up your alley. But I’m just going to tell the story as Livy tells it first, and then we can get into the analysis of it.
Dr G 5:02
All right, I’m interested in your version because I have a version as well, and we’ll see where they cross over, and if they’re in
Dr Rad 5:08
any way similar, is yours Valerius Maximus?
Dr G 5:11
No, I’ve gone with, although I could have pulled from Valerius Maximus, I’ve actually gone with a little bit of detail from Plutarch.
Dr Rad 5:19
Okay, all right, so in Livy’s version, we’ve got these ex magistrates, older gentlemen. They decide that they’re going to dress up in their robes of state and triumphal robes, because they know that they are going to be meeting their deaths when the goals arrive. Indeed.
Dr G 5:39
Okay, so they’re going to go out with the accouterments of their their roles. This is a very noble thing for the elderly patricians to do. I have to say, we don’t tend to give the patricians a lot of credit on this podcast, because they tend to make terrible decisions, but this moment of personal sacrifice and acceptance of that sacrifice is incredibly noble of them, and I have to give them props for that. Yes.
Dr Rad 6:10
Now they position themselves on ivory chairs in the middle of their houses, ready to meet the enemy. Livy tells me that some historians, yes, I am quoting him there. Some historians say that the Pontifex Maximus, a guy called Marcus Folius, led the senators in a recitation of a solemn vow in which they devoted themselves to death on behalf of Rome and the Quirites, basically the Roman citizens. So this is where the sacred stuff comes into it. Dr, G, I’ll return to this later. The Gauls were not actually quite as raring for a fight at this point in time, after a night had passed and things had died down a little, I guess their adrenaline wasn’t pumping quite as hard as it had been previously. They hadn’t really faced a tough battle against the Romans as they were expecting previously, at the battle that you referred to the Ahala As we know, the Romans did not acquit themselves very well, and now, even more puzzling, it looks like there’s not going to be much resistance put up by the city itself. It’s pretty much deserted. They just wander in through the open Colline gate. They toddle along until they get to the forum. They’re kind of having a look at the temples, checking things out as they go. And when they spot the Citadel, they think, Okay, it looks like this might be a place where people are readied for battle. The Gauls decide that they’re going to station a small number of guards to keep a look at on the Citadel make sure that they’re not going to be attacked whilst they’re scouring the streets because they’re wary of that place. But most of them are now free to roam the city streets and go in search of booty. They meet nobody in the streets, and so some of them start getting into little groups and going into just the closest houses. Some of them are going into houses that are the furthest away, because they think, well, if these are far away, it’s probably going to be the most stuff in here that’s left behind. I’ll get there first. I’ll get all the really good stuff. But then they kind of get a little bit scared because they’re so far away from anyone else. And they kind of run back to the forum and go, it’s so spooky. There’s nobody here.
Dr G 8:42
Like nobody this place is creepy.
Dr Rad 8:46
Don’t leave me alone, you guys. I don’t even like going to the bathroom without a friend. So the houses near the forum are a popular place to look for booty because they’re all close to each other. The plebeian houses are all locked up. Gotta lock your doors when the goals are in town. Dr G, security first.
Dr G 9:05
Also you’re plebeian. It’s like, I can’t afford to lose any of this lock it up.
Dr Rad 9:09
I have no insurance. But the elite houses were open. The goals are, again, a little freaked out to find that these patrician houses aren’t locked up, and when they enter, what a sight they see these guys, dressed to the nines, just silently sitting there in the middle of their houses on ivory chairs. The Gauls were naturally awed by the sight of these God like creatures the patricians, it’s a trap. Well, not really. I don’t think these older gentlemen, no matter how spooky they look, are gonna be able to put an end. Oh no,
Dr G 9:56
they’ve taken a vow to death. It’s good.
Dr Rad 10:00
Yeah, so the goals slowly, I think, approach the older ex magistrates as they sit there, and they’re kind of gazing at them, almost like they’re looking at a sculpture or a piece of artwork, because they’re just sitting there unmoving. And this is where we get a story. And there are a couple of different versions about exactly how this plays out and indeed, who is the ex magistracies in question? But in Livy’s version, one of the Gallic warriors decides he’s actually going to touch the beard of Marcus Papirius. So sort of give it a stroke just see what’s going on there. Apparently, at this time all Romans had long beards. Didn’t know that.
Dr G 10:44
Yeah, wait a minute. So a couple of things. One, they seem so statue like that. You’re like, you know what? I wonder what would happen if I just gave a touch to the fuzz?
Dr Rad 10:56
Exactly. Papirius then hits him in the head with an ivory mace, which is seen as a provocative act on behalf of the Gauls, Papirius is therefore the first Roman in Livy’s account in the city in the sack by the Gauls to be killed. And the Gauls now longer have no interest in holding back. They are just looting through all the houses. They’re setting them on fire. They’re going crazy. And this is where we get the massacre of any patrician left in the city that’s not in the Citadel.
Dr G 11:32
Oh no, yeah. Okay, wow.
Dr Rad 11:36
Now, do you want to tell me your version of things before we get into what exactly is going on here.
Dr G 11:41
It is quite similar. So I suspect that Plutarch has read his Livy so he doesn’t mention anything about a religious connotation to it. There’s no involvement of a Pontifex Maximus, which is real shame, because I do love that kind of stuff. And hopefully this means that the Gauls have been cursed through their murdering of the old patricians, but I suppose we’ll have to wait to find out. But there is this sense that the city has been abandoned, and the Gauls take a few days to come to grips with that idea. So they’re sort of looking at it, and they’re like, doesn’t look like there’s many people here. Should we go in? And they do spend some time thinking about that. And eventually Brennus leads them into the forum, and they see men sitting in the forum, actually in this account, and they don’t move those patricians do not get up. They don’t make any gesture towards acknowledging that the ghouls are there. They continue to sit quietly. They’re leaning on their staffs, very appropriate old man, and they gaze into each other’s faces. So it’s almost like they’re in a circle of meditation with each other. How intriguing. And the ghouls are amazed and perplexed by this. And we do have this moment of one of them going up to a guy aptly named Papirius Marcus, as opposed to Marcus Papirius.
Dr Rad 13:10
Oh, I see what he did there,
Dr G 13:12
gently grasping his chin, stroking his long beard. So you know, keep in mind, patricians with long beards, they seem to be a thing right now, Papirius grabs his staff and smote the guy in the head. This pretty offensive to the Gaul, he draws his sword and kills the guy. So that’s the end of Papirius. And after that, the goals are like, we need to deal with this. They’re clearly all kind of dangerous. They look old, but someone just got hit with the stuff, so that’s not okay. And they then proceed to murder all the rest of them. They sack and plunder the houses of the city. They do that for days. Rome is quite substantial at this point in time, according to the historical record, as people understand it, maybe not so much archeologically, but they go through and apparently it takes them a few days at least of plundering to realize that they’ve got everything, and the only thing that remains is that holdout of the Capitolini hill and the Citadel upon it intriguing.
Dr Rad 14:15
Okay, well, let me unpack this episode a little bit, because this is obviously a moment of extreme weird or stuck to G Oh yes, the partial pick is going to have a field day at the end of the episode. Igor is already stretching his wings. He is he’s getting ready. It is possible that part of the details of this story has once again, come down to us through family tradition. Now it depends, obviously a little bit on who is named as the guy who strikes the Gaul in the head with his mace or his staff or whatever he’s holding, but in my account, it would presumably be someone from the gens Papirius, because that’s the person who is highlighted as being. Being the one that strikes the first blow.
Dr G 15:02
Yeah, makes sense. Yeah. And Livy’s Usually on top of his family histories in this sort of way. Does he make any gesture in that direction that he’s using family histories in this point?
Dr Rad 15:13
He doesn’t. But we know that he does use those sorts of sources, and we know that by the time Livy and Dionysius are writing, that they are using earlier analysts who might have had those stories passed on to them. We don’t know if Livy is consulting anybody directly in this particular story. He doesn’t mention it. But the thing that I thought you might find interesting is this hint of this idea of devotion, of giving up their lives in a sacred way. So this is something that is apparently discussed in Cicero, where he talks about this idea that someone could, in fact, devote themselves, and it had to be somebody who had held Imperium, or was holding Imperium, and if you were in a particular moment of crisis, someone who had held Imperium could kind of claim it again and do so by clasping their chin. And therefore, the reason that whoever it was hit the goal in the head is not just because, well, this guy is the enemy, and he’s going to kill me as soon as he has the chance, but because by stroking the beard, he might have interfered with what was a ritual gesture.
Dr G 16:31
Oh, very interesting indeed. Oh, I like it a lot.
Dr Rad 16:36
I thought you might have now, the reason that it’s not maybe easy to exactly trace all of this is that the later retellings don’t necessarily make all of this clear, but certainly, Livy has taken it to be more about wirtus than a religious act by This interpretation, if that’s what indeed is going on here.
Dr G 17:03
Well, look something like this calls into question a whole bunch of things to do with how does Imperium really work? Is it as simple as touching your chin and you
Dr Rad 17:15
return the hairs of my Chinny, chin, chin, dr, G, they’re a bit more numerous these days with perimenopause.
Dr G 17:21
Well, exactly. I mean, there’s so much Imperium to be taken as well. So I think to myself, if this is a ritual gesture, it might be related to how somebody comes into Imperium and how someone comes into that position of power. This might be related to it. So if there are gestural elements to the transference from one position to another, where one includes Imperium, perhaps we be on to something, and this is something that we really don’t have a lot of great sense about, or at least, I’ve never come across anything like this in my research. And so I’d be really interested to find out, because we know that there’s lots of gestural elements to Roman culture. There’s a whole bunch that are related to oratory, for instance, and we see some great interpretations of how gesture could be used in the public space in HBO as Rome as well, with the news teller, which I think is probably getting as close as anybody has come on screen to demonstrating how some of that might have looked in a public space, but the idea that there is a performative element to these things, and that there were understood deliberate physical movements and performances that you could do, I wonder how that would play out when we think about Imperium in a different way. I don’t know that you can necessarily just claim Imperium back. That seems like a recipe for chaos. Imagine all of those magistrates in the Senate.
Dr Rad 18:53
I think it has to be in a moment of particular crisis that you could have this ritual gesture and sort of be reclaiming your Imperium, Reclaiming my time, Reclaiming my time, fair enough, more power to you. But yes, this is something this, maybe this is something I could dig a little bit further into. But certainly, there are some questions about exactly who the person is. Valerius Maximus does include this story as well as of course, he would be totally attracted to this episode of weirdos as well, and he talks about ateleus, rather than Papirius being the person at the center of it. So I think this is probably why people have thought, hmm, have families got involved and tried to argue that it was in fact, their relative that struck the first blow against the Gauls.
Dr G 19:43
It is my ancestor who started the path to victory.
Dr Rad 19:47
It is my ancestor. No, it is my ancestor.
Dr G 19:51
I touched my chin at you. Haha, Imperium.
Dr Rad 19:54
In Livy’s account, there may have been division amongst the Gauls about what exists. Exactly to do once they had started attacking Rome, Livy mentions the possibility that maybe not all the Gauls wanted to trash the entire city, or perhaps there was a bit of a tactic going on here amongst the leaders of the Gauls, where they just wanted to freak the Romans out a little bit by just burning some of their buildings, thinking that the Romans who were left on the Citadel might surrender themselves if they saw that their homes were in danger, and then keep some of them standing so that there was a reason for them to come back out. Because, of course, if you destroy everything, the Gauls realize, Well, why would the Romans surrender like they’ve already lost everything they may as well hold out as long as they possibly could. So in Livy’s version, the fire at this point is not as terrible as it could have been in a city that’s just been seized by a gang of barbarians. Oh, wow.
Dr G 20:58
Interesting controversy reigns. So I do have a sense from some of our sources. And my sources are a little bit all over the shop. My best account comes from Diodorus. I flagged that in a previous episode. He’s considered the most reliable. I’m going to hold on to that moment for the rest of my life. But we do have a sense in which the Gauls set up their camp outside Rome to start the siege. All very clear cut. Diodorus claims that the Gauls have a force of about 70,000 for this, which is massive, and we then proceed with the burning of buildings. So a whole bunch of the houses get burnt. That’s obviously prudent from the Gauls perspective, because it clears their sight lines, but it also ensures that there’s nowhere for enemies to hide. In their opinion, they can concentrate solely on the main focus of their siege, which is the capitolini’s hill and the Citadel on it, which is where they know most of the Romans have been congregating. So once they clear out the city proper, it makes sense to level it to the ground. While this is happening, though, there is stuff going on elsewhere which is going to become important. So the Romans are in the middle of their siege preparations, all of their important goods, all of their food stuffs have been taken up to the Capitoline. They’re not aware of what’s going on outside. They can only see as far as the Gaulish army and beyond that, the Etruscans have started to raid into Roman territory, and this appears to be a bit of an issue. And what happens, at least from the accounts that I’ve been able to put together, is that the Roman forces that have bundled themselves up in Veii go out to meet those Etruscans and take them on.
Dr Rad 22:51
Okay, sorry. Can I pause right here? This is so far ahead in my account that I don’t think we’ll even get to this today. So I don’t know whether we maybe pause and come back to this part of your account. Or not, up to you, let’s pause.
Dr G 23:05
Yeah, yeah. I’m this is where my account goes next. It’s like, kind of like, we’re in Siege territory, and now the Etruscans are taking their opportunity with
Dr Rad 23:14
absolutely does happen, but it’s so far in the future for me that I don’t I couldn’t even imagine we’re going to get there.
Dr G 23:20
That’s incredible. What does Livy have to tell me?
Dr Rad 23:25
It’s mostly a lot of like histrionics, but, you know, I’ve got it to go through. So do you want me to tell you a little bit more? And you can just see, yeah, see where we go. We might get up to the Etruscans, but I’m not sure.
Dr G 23:35
Do tell me more. I’m keen to know what might be missing from my accounts, or what Livy might have invented.
Dr Rad 23:42
It’s mostly very emotional and speculative, but you know, all right, so I’m going to go back to the fire not having been as quite as terrible as it could have
Dr G 23:51
been. Okay, Rome’s on fire, but it’s not that bad.
Dr Rad 23:55
Okay. Now the Romans are watching on from the Citadel. Dr G, they see the Gauls wreaking havoc in various areas of the city, and it’s just so distressing for them. Dr, G, I know we do make fun of the Romans, and it’s hard sometimes not to laugh a little bit at how over the top sometimes Livy’s description is, but you can kind of appreciate, I suppose, they’re holed up. They can’t do anything about it. They’re just in total sensory overload. You know? They’re watching their beloved city be destroyed. They feel like there’s nothing that they can do about it. They’re hearing the sound, smelling the smells. It feels to them like fortune herself is putting on a show, a drama, for them to watch, forcing them to watch Rome fall apart.
Dr G 24:42
No, okay. Romans, very dramatic.
Dr Rad 24:46
It is. The Romans Now could see they have nothing left but themselves to fight for all their possessions are gone. The city has completely been taken by the enemy, and they had to enjoy. Endure this knowledge for the day, another night, another day. To be honest, the timeline is very unclear in Livy’s account, but I gather it’s several days of nightmarish events. But in spite of all of this, Dr G the Romans are still determined to fight. They’re gonna hold that Citadel and the Capitol they’ve lost everything, but that, in a way, makes it easier for them to stop dwelling on themselves and the pain that they were in personally, and just focus on the fight ahead. Wow.
Dr G 25:36
Okay, so they’re galvanized by what they’ve witnessed. They’re horrified and then galvanized
Dr Rad 25:42
they are. Now this might be a good point to mention that archeologically, there is very little trace of the Gallic sack in Rome.
Dr G 25:50
Yes. Well, there might be a few reasons for that. One, it didn’t happen.
Dr Rad 25:55
Two, wow, you just went straight there, didn’t you? After that dramatic account, you just completely
Dr G 26:00
undercut it. I think it’s important to register the details that maybe this did not happen. Second of all, that we’re talking about a Rome that is not monumental in the way that we think about it today. We don’t have a lot of stone structures. Yet. We don’t think we’ve got a few, but we don’t have heaps. So if you burn wood and your house is made of wood, how long do you do you think that’s going to last in the archeological record? Like there has to be some sort of layered process for that. If you’ve got a lot of ash and you’ve got a whole ash deposit layer, that’s kind of incredible. But if the Gauls are just sort of burning strategically, and it’s not a bad as fire around the city, as might be anticipated, then we’re talking about spot fires, essentially. That’s going to be very hard. You got to put down a whore as an archeologist to look at all the layers, and you picked a spot where maybe a house didn’t get burnt in 390 BCE, doesn’t look like there was a siege, does there?
Dr Rad 27:00
This is true, but there are some buildings that predate this time period that survive. So clearly, not everything was completely trashed, if we believe that there was indeed a Gallic sack of Rome at this time period. So the archeology is
Dr G 27:20
confusing, oh yes. And we’ve also got a sense that there are some walls. So there are speculation about when the servian walls were built. Was it under? Was it during the period of the kings, or was it later? It would be really handy if there was a wall right now, because the Romans are in a siege.
Dr Rad 27:40
So I guess the goals have given have given up on the idea that they’re not going to totally trash the city, in my account, and they are gradually working their way through building by building until all that’s left is the Citadel. And at this point, the girls turn around, and according to Livy, make a desperate resolution to attack the Citadel. But to be honest, that seems like a completely sane move to me, because they’ve pretty much looted the rest of the joint. What else are they going to do?
Dr G 28:08
It is the next logical step in a siege. But maybe the Gaulish people aren’t siege warfare types, generally speaking, they might be run in, hack people to pieces, chop off their heads later.
Dr Rad 28:20
Types, possibly so. At daybreak, the Gauls give a signal. They all gather together in the forum, and they decide to begin their attack. But the Romans are ready for them, and I guess because of the state of mind that they have adopted, they’re not acting in a foolhardy manner. They’re not overly passionate everything about their moves very calm and deliberate, which means that they really are ready to take on these Gallic attackers. So all possible entrance points to the citadels, the Romans had made sure were reinforced with guards, and when they saw that the Gauls were finally on their way, they made sure that their very best soldiers were in position, they let the Gauls advance, and their idea was that the higher up the Gauls came, the easier it would be for the Romans to push them back, because they held the high ground. So they’re thinking very strategically here.
Dr G 29:18
Yes, it makes sense. It gets steeper. And if you can push somebody over and then they do that thing with their arms, where they’re like, whoa, and it can have a cascading domino effect upon the other people behind them. It’s fantastic as a defense strategy.
Dr Rad 29:32
Now finally, our two forces meet in the midst of a declivity Dr G, which I learned is a part in the approach, where it’s lower than all the areas around it. So a perfect moment for the Romans to encounter the Gauls, and it really allows them to throw themselves in. And they managed to drive the Gauls back so definitively that the Gauls decided, whew, we cannot attempt that again. That is. Crazy that it’s just suicide, even though we so clearly vastly outnumber this tiny group of people who only have a limited amount of provisions. We can’t possibly attempt that again. And so this is where they decide that they’re just going to blockade the Romans who are on the Citadel. They hadn’t planned for this. They hadn’t foreseen this in their future, and they had actually burnt all the corn in Rome when they had set fire to the various areas in the city, or perhaps the corn in the field had just been taken to they so the Gauls decided instead that they needed to split their army. They’re going to use part of their army to go around and loot all the people that live around Rome so that they can get the supplies that they need to feed the entire group and the rest are going to stay and besiege the Romans on the citadels, and they’re going to have the supplies brought to them by the pillagers.
Dr G 30:54
Okay, so the Gauls have made some mistakes, some tactical errors. They weren’t prepared for a siege, as it turns out, the truth has finally revealed, and now they’re like we have to ravage the surrounding countryside to feed ourselves, to sustain us while we conduct a siege.
Dr Rad 31:11
And this would make sense if we go back to a theory which I mentioned before, which is that the whole backstory we have for the reasons why the Romans and the Gauls are at war is totally made up, and that it is somewhat accidental that the Gauls end up encountering the Romans, and that they were, in fact, headed somewhere else, hired as mercenaries to serve somebody else, and that this whole thing is just a chance encounter.
Dr G 31:39
Well, be that as it may. I think the most valid reason is the one where they were looking for somewhere that would be cooler to live. But they’ve ended up in Rome in July, and that’s not a great time. It’s pretty hot now. They’re unhappy, and they’re involved in a siege. So I don’t know if the Gauls are having the best year so far.
Dr Rad 32:00
Fortune is starting to, I think, look out for our little Romans again. Dr G because the departing Gauls fortune makes sure that they head towards Ardea. Why is Ardea a fortunate place for them to have gone? Why Camillus had gone there in his exile, and he was completely devastated when he heard about the attack on Rome. He was even more upset about the sack of Rome than he was by his own personal misfortune, which had driven him into this exile. But he also is confused. Dr G he doesn’t understand how he had led such valiant warriors from Rome against city of A and the falerii, and they had just triumphed completely trounce them, and then all of a sudden, the goals just walk in and take it doesn’t make sense even to Camillus.
Dr G 33:00
Now this is really interesting, because Livy is going in a direction which my narrative definitely goes in, but doesn’t enter into until way later on. So interesting. The idea that Camillus is even part of this narrative is completely questionable. When I start looking at the source material and I try to line it up in some sort of chronology that would make any kind of sense, and this is way too early for Camillus to be turning up in this narrative, in some respects, based on how his story is told in other sources, including Appian Dionysus of Halicarnassus and Diodorus Siculus. So but to recap a little bit about where Camillus is. He is in aedea because he’s been exiled from Rome, and he’s chosen exile because he doesn’t want to pay the bills and nobody’s going to support him. He’s fallen out of favor. And he does say, in that moment, he was praying the prayer of Achilles that the time might come when the Romans would long for Camillus. So he’s had that moment where he’s kind of set Rome up for this misfortune, maybe inadvertently, but he wants to be wanted, and he wants Rome to be desperate enough to want him back. Now, however, we start to see a turnaround in the books, and there’s a few different places in the narrative where this second prayer from Camillus could come in, but this would be one of the potential times where he says, I could not have prayed to the gods that the Romans might sometime long for me, if I had cherished any such feeling as that towards them. Now I pray the nobler prayer that I may render my country, a service equal to the calamity that has befallen
Dr Rad 34:44
her. That’s good stuff.
Dr G 34:47
Yes, juicy Camillus.
Dr Rad 34:50
Look, I am not surprised at all that your Greek sources would be bringing Achilles into this whole mess. Well. Debbie, you’re right. You are right. This is something that definitely academics have highlighted, that Camillus is obviously a major figure in this story of the sack of Rome, even though he’s not actually there for the sack, apparently. And certainly, other scholars have noted the lack of agreement in our sources in the order in which things happen so completely, Livy has got a different order to all of these other sources that you’ve mentioned. And it highlights, I suppose, different things about Camillus role in this whole story. To get back to my version of things, which is obviously the correct version, yeah. Camillus hears at this moment, whilst he’s wondering what on earth happened to Rome. Have the Romans lost their groove? Do I need to help them get it back? He hears that the Gauls are on their way heading out to Ardea. Naturally, the people in Ardea are in a total state of panic and have no idea what to do. Luckily for them, Camillus, the hero with the mostest, is around, and he’s struck, and I quote, with an inspiration, nothing less than divine. Oh, the gods look out for him. And he inserts themselves into their state of panic.
Dr G 36:24
Wow. Camillus.
Dr Rad 36:26
Livy tells me that Camillus doesn’t really like these sorts of meetings. Not a crowd man, not a crowd pleaser. But this is a different scenario. Get ready for an inspirational speech. Dr, G,
Dr G 36:40
I will strap myself in. Come on. Camillus, do your worst.
Dr Rad 36:44
He addresses the ardeans. He says he’s aware that he is in exile, and he wants to repay their kindness for allowing him to come and live amongst them. Did they know he has a bit of a handy little knack for war. The Ardeans owe the Romans because of the relationship they have had in the past. We’ve talked about their relationship with Rome. Previously, the Romans have lavished benefits upon them, and the Ardeans know that Camillus doesn’t need to list them all. Now, ADEA could now also not only repay the Romans for their past kindnesses, because they’ve sorted out disagreements with other cities in the past, but they could win themselves glory if they decided to take on the goals and win the goals were naturally bold, brave and big, very scary. Camillus acknowledges this, but they also need to remember that they are scatterbrained, changeable, racist comment, racist comment, racist comment.
Dr G 37:53
They can’t think when they overheat.
Dr Rad 38:00
The tend to malfunction in the snow
Dr G 38:03
exactly a strong wind knocks them right over.
Dr Rad 38:07
And I again, I’m going to quote my translation of Livy so in Camillus, words to every conflict, they bring more terror than strength. And you can see this in what they have just done to Rome. They may have just been able to waltz in and completely devastate the city, but that’s because there weren’t really any Romans around. As soon as they came up against a teeny, tiny little group of Romans. The Romans had managed to keep them in their place, and Camillus knew that the Gauls, by this stage, were getting bored by the siege. They don’t have a long attention span. Racist comment, racist comment, they’re not able to stay in one place. Racist comment, racist comment, they’re constantly wandering off into the countryside to stuff themselves with food and wine. Racist comment, racist comment, and at night, they don’t even bother to erect any protections around themselves. There are no ramparts, there are no pickets, there are no sentries. They just sleep beside a stream like animals, so much victory has gone completely to their heads that they’re not even taking proper precautions. Racist comment, racist comment, racist comment.
Dr G 39:20
Ah, well, this is in keeping with some of the comments that come through from other sources as well. Apparently, the Gauls get soft from eating all the delicious Roman food and drink, and they lose their fitness and become quite incapable of running all hardship. And when any exertion is required, they become exhausted by perspiration and shortness of breath, according to Appian. And we also have this idea coming through in Plutarch as well about Camillus capabilities in persuading the Ardeans to get involved. He doesn’t necessarily put it into a speechifying moment, but he does. Say that when they notice that the Gauls are on the horizons of Ardea, that he is able to persuade the young Ardean men in particular to pluck up their courage and support Rome’s desperate cause.
Dr Rad 40:14
Yes, this is exactly the moment that I am building to, because the end of Camillus speech, he says, Look, if you guys want to save yourselves and also win that glory for stopping the relentless advance of the Gauls, which might just be an accident, we don’t know. They need to get their arms together. They need to follow Camillus. And again, I’m going to quote my translation, not to a battle, but a massacre. Camillus says to them, If I do not deliver them up to you, fast asleep, to be butchered like cattle. Well, you can exile me from Ardea, just like I was exiled from Rome. He loves making these really bold pronouncements. Why is it always have to come down to this.
Dr G 40:59
I’ll just leave this place as well. That’s fine. Failure is exile. I understand.
Dr Rad 41:07
I’ll land on my feet. I always do. Now, the people who like Camillus at this point, as well as the people who are opposed to him are just blown away by him at this moment. Doesn’t matter which side you were on, everyone’s now on Camillus side. And again, I can’t help but quote my translation. There was no such warrior in those days anywhere. He is incomparable. Dr G so when the Ardennes left the council, they wait for a signal to leave, and when it came in the early evening, they go out to meet Camillus at the gates, and it’s not far out of the city when they stumble across the camp of the Gauls. And it was exactly like Camillus had told them, no guards, no security. And so they’re feeling very cheerful about that. Now I’m going to pause at this moment and highlight that most historians think that all of this is completely fictional.
Dr G 42:04
Yes, yes, I hate to say it. I’m sitting with those scholars. One this order of events seems mad, but also I don’t know. I mean, what’s going on guys? What is even happening in our day? What is happening in central Italy. What we do get is a sense that if we’re following this line, and this is definitely a line that Plutarch and Livy agree on, is that by cutting off this Gaulish force, which is out foraging essentially as far south as Ardea, which is indicative of some information that we haven’t covered yet, which is the length of the siege of Rome to be foraging this far south of Rome. This means that the Gauls have stripped bare everything between Ardea and Rome already, and one of the estimates in the literary sources is that this is a siege that takes about seven months and it starts in yay, starts in July and doesn’t wrap up until February of the next year. Wow. So it’s the height of the harvest, essentially when the siege begins. So the things are pretty bright for the picking. So for if we, if we’re playing with that kind of timeline, and it’s all very hypothetical, and obviously it’s the sort of thing that scholarship has lots of questions about. But let’s, let’s say for a moment that the siege did start in July for them to wind up all the way down in Ardea, which is a goodly way from Rome, like they’re nearby. If you’re driving a car today, it doesn’t take too long, but if you’re walking and you’re stripping the fields as you go, and then taking the stuff back to the people who are holding the siege, because you’re going to have to do that pretty regularly. It’s going to take a bit of time to get this far. We’re probably months into the siege already, and then Camillus, apparently, with the help of the ardean force, sacks this Gallic camp, which is a pillaging and foraging camp, and if they have booty, so be it. But they’re mostly there to pick up food stuffs and to make things easier for the siege back at Rome. So this is a bit of a blow to the siege, if this is the kind of narrative sequence that we’re looking at,
Dr Rad 44:16
for sure, and certainly, I think one of the things that modern scholars are pointing out is that all of this just seems to be set up to heighten the tensions of the story and obviously make it a real like, Ooh, what is Camillus going to do? When is he going to return? What’s going to happen? And this in Livy’s account, I think gives Camillus a role in striking a blow for revenge against the Gauls by events playing out in this manner. I’m going to have to go to a spoiler here at this point, dr, G, and that is something that I don’t think I’ve mentioned so far, which is that we do have a mention of these events in Polybius, who is using a very early source. Fabius Pictor, quite a respected analyst, one of our earliest Roman historians. In fact, I think he is the earliest Roman historian, and one
Dr G 45:08
of the ones that we kind of wish we had as well. We don’t. We don’t have a lot of Fabius pictor only through other sources.
Dr Rad 45:14
Now, he doesn’t mention Camillus at all when he’s talking about these events, and he makes mention in his account that the Romans, when the Gauls show up at their gates, pay them to go away.
Dr G 45:29
We’ll get to that. Don’t you worry. And I would also put Further to that, that in Diodorus Siculus account, Camillus does not turn up until very late in the piece as well, and he’s considered relatively accurate, I suppose, for for for some so I think that’s quite interesting as well, that Camillus does take a very different role in Diodorus Siculus account, and it’s a much lesser role than the One that Livy wants to give. I would say
Dr Rad 46:02
yes, but hey, at least Livy’s account has given him a chance to put hideous stereotypes of barbarians into Camillus mouth.
Dr G 46:11
Look, I love a good story. I don’t appreciate the racism.
Dr Rad 46:15
So Camillus and his forces from Ardea having stumbled across this camp, as you noted, Dr G, completely slaughter everyone in it. Now this is helped by the fact that the camp was complete mess and total chaos, because, you know, barbarians, stereotype, stereotype, the aedeans and Camillus just basically kill men in their sleep, anyone who is sleeping a little bit further away, they are in obviously a state of total confusion. If they do hear what’s going on, they kind of try and run away in a really panicked state. And some of them end up just running smack back into the attacking forces because they don’t know what’s going on. Some of them manage to get away, get away. And apparently a lot of them end up in antium and they’re kind of just wandering around until the locals come out and finish them off.
Dr G 47:09
That’s terrible. I
Dr Rad 47:11
know it’s a bit of a sad story, all right. Dr, G, so I feel like this is maybe a good moment for us to wrap up. We’ve got our moment of revenge upon the attacking Gauls, although it feels oddly unsatisfying after all the stereotypes that Camillus has played on thanks, Camillus once again. But that means that it’s time for the partial pick. All right.
Dr Rad 47:40
Dr, G, can you please tell us what is the partial pick all about?
Dr G 47:43
Oh, the partial pick. We are going to judge the Romans as they would have wished to be judged by their own standards. And there’s going to be 50 Golden Eagles up for grabs, 10 across, five categories each. The first of all being military clout.
Dr Rad 48:01
Well, some I guess it’s a bit of an odd one, isn’t it? Because we’ve got camilius Getting this revenge at the last minute, but he’s assisted by the aedeans. I don’t know how much that counts. And then we’ve got the Romans on the Citadel managing to hold off the Gauls, but the Gauls are sacking the city. I don’t know how I rate this.
Dr G 48:22
Yeah, it’s a challenging one. The Romans push some people down a hill, and Camillus cuts some throats while people are sleeping. Yeah, I would say that none of these are great examples of military clout, necessarily. The siege defense is the siege defense, and it’s probably great for the Romans that they’ve managed to push the Gauls back there, but attacking a camp of people who have been described and set up to be killed essentially as being not very military minded, doesn’t seem like an example of Roman military clout.
Dr Rad 48:58
So well, it’s not cidans. Yes,
Dr G 49:02
there’s one Roman in there. We give, I suppose we could give them one point for one Roman doing something.
Dr Rad 49:09
Yeah, okay, let’s give them one point. All right.
Dr G 49:12
Our second category is diplomacy. Ah, I don’t think so. I’m not feeling a lot of diplomacy, no.
Dr Rad 49:20
I mean, unless we count Camillus talking the aediles into helping out the Romans. Is that diplomacy? I feel like it’s not. That’s persuasion. Yeah, yeah, all right. Third category, expansion, most decidedly not. They’re about to lose everything they’ve
Dr G 49:39
ever had. Boo zero for expansion, yeah, our fourth category is virtus.
Dr Rad 49:46
Okay, now we have something to work with. We’ve got a bunch of ex magistracies who maybe have committed a religious act, or maybe they are just extremely virtuous men, but either way. Okay, they’re going down with the ship, Dr G, and I think it is meant to be kind of protecting Rome. You know, they’re giving their lives for Rome, and maybe trying to, I wonder if this is almost trying to win back the favor of the gods. Because remember, in the build up to this whole account, we’ve constantly been seeing the Romans get on the wrong side of the gods, and this is meant to be a sign that they’re heading towards disaster. The disaster is here, but the last moment Romans finally acting in a way that the gods can be like, I see
Dr G 50:30
you, yeah. And you could read what is happening with those men sitting in really prominent places, either in their houses or in the forum, as being within the sacred bounds of the city. So them, yes, their blood being spilt by an enemy does constitute some kind of sacrifice in a kind of ritual, God fearing kind of way. This is not just any kind of death. This is blood of Romans spilt within the sacred bounds of the city
Dr Rad 51:00
and the Romans don’t, well, they like to think that they don’t go in for human sacrifice, in spite of later things like gladiators and whatnot, but let’s not go down that path now, certainly for the Romans, a human sacrifice is the highest kind of sacrifice.
Dr G 51:17
Yes, and I dare say that if you’d asked them about Gladiators, it’s too early for that. But if, even if you did ask them in a time where it was relevant, they would say, well, they’re not Romans.
Dr Rad 51:28
This is true. But what about the vessels that get buried alive? Dr, G, what about
Dr G 51:31
them? Oh, that’s a real sacrifice. Yeah.
Dr Rad 51:35
Anyway, okay, so how much we’re gonna give them for their the massacre of the senators?
Dr G 51:41
Look, I don’t want to give them full marks, because I feel like the patricians will be rewarding them outsized for the thing, like they the reason why they’re there is because they’re physically not able to handle the travel of fleeing.
Dr Rad 51:54
So we’ll see that’s not actually something that Livy mentions. Now, obviously he’s building it up to be a really stoic moment in his story, and he wants the Romans to come out like a hero, but that is not really what they seem to be doing here.
Dr G 52:10
Hmm, okay, well, leaving that aside, yeah, we’ve got the eldest former magistracies of Rome remaining behind as a kind of divine gesture. I think that’s pretty good in terms of where to us.
Dr Rad 52:26
Yeah, I think it’s more in Livy’s account, the way it’s set up. I mean, there is probably a practical element to it in terms of, you know, where they get a run because they’re older, but it does seem more like these are old men who have long and storied careers behind them, and they’re just prepared to die. They’re like, this is my moment, and that’s why they decide to stay.
Dr G 52:48
And also like, this is my home. I am Roman. This is Rome. I stay in Rome. Yes, exactly, yes. And all of that makes sense. So I think we’re looking at maybe a seven.
Dr Rad 52:59
Okay, yep, seven is good, all
Dr G 53:02
right, and our final category is the citizen score. Is it a good time to be a Roman?
Dr Rad 53:09
What Romans? I mean,
Dr G 53:12
it’s not a great time to be a Roman. I don’t think the people on the Capitoline Hill are having a great time, but they’re alive.
Dr Rad 53:19
They are alive, but they are living on rations, and they’re having to watch their beloved city get torched and looted by people that they don’t understand and seemingly came out of nowhere. All right, sounds like a solid zero, yeah. I mean, there are still some people alive at they obviously, and maybe they’re doing a little bit better, but they’re there because they can’t go back to Rome.
Dr G 53:44
Oh yes, do not forget about they. Oh, I’ve got a lot to say about they.
Dr Rad 53:48
All right. Well, Dr, G, if that’s why we’re calling it, it means that the Romans get eight out of 50 Golden Eagles for this episode. But I have to say that’s kind of still more than I was expecting during the sack of Rome, and this is obviously for only part of the year of 390 or thereabouts.
Dr G 54:10
Look, they’ve definitely earned less. And I mean, kudos to them. The patricians are getting them over the line this time.
Dr Rad 54:19
Oh gosh, what a sad sentence to have to finish on.
Dr G 54:22
Well, I look forward to continuing. I suspect we will be talking about the Gallic sack of Rome in our next episode.
Dr Rad 54:30
Oh, I think we will. In fact, I’m actually starting to think, is this going to
Dr G 54:34
be five episodes? Yes, I’m now, yes, now that you threw a curve ball at me and you were like, we’re not up to the Etruscans. Yet in this episode, I was like, Oh no,
Dr Rad 54:45
I know how the Romans feel. By
Dr G 54:48
the end of it, we’ll be like, I’m so glad the Siege has broken.
Dr Rad 54:52
All right. Dr, G, well, I shall look forward to being holed up on the citadel with you for a few more episodes. Woohoo.
Dr Rad 55:09
Thank you for listening to this episode of the partial historians. You can find our sources sound credits and an automated transcript in our show notes. Our music is by Bettina Joy De Guzman. The Partial Historians is part of the Memory Collective, creators and educators dedicated to sharing knowledge that is accessible, contextualized, socially conscious and inclusive, to find more from the Memory Collective head to collective mem.com. You too can support our show and help us to produce more fascinating content about the ancient world by becoming a Patreon. In return, you receive exclusive early access to our special episodes and ad free content. Today, we would like to send a special shout out to Margaret, Evan and JJ Scout, some of our newest Patreon members. You can also support us by buying us a coffee on ko fi. However, if the girls have recently ransacked your village, please just tell someone about the show or give us a five star review. Until next time, we are yours in ancient Rome.
Transcribed by https://otter.ai
The post Episode 168 – The Gallic Sack of Rome – Part 3 appeared first on The Partial Historians - Ancient Roman History with smart ladies.
Marcus Furius Camillus is an ancient Roman that it is hard to ignore, especially in the early days of the 4th century BCE. He has been regularly popping up in our episodes from the era, so we thought it would be wonderful to invite on a special guest to discuss his whole life in one handy biographic episode.
Marc Hyden is the Director of State Government Affairs at a Washington DC-based think tank, as well as being a weekly columnist for the Newnan Times-Herald, Albany Herald, and Rome News-Tribune. Marc graduated from Georgia State University with a degree in philosophy.
Marc has authored many, many books on Ancient Rome. His most recent work is Emperor Titus: The Right Hand of Vespasian (McFarland, 2025), and we will be talking with him about that in a future episode. He has also authored Gaius Marius: The Rise and Fall of Rome’s Saviour (Pen & Sword, 2017), Romulus: The Legend of Rome’s Founding Father (Pen & Sword, 2020), but our focus today is going to be on Marcus Furius Camillus: The Life of Rome’s Second Founder (Pen & Sword, 2023).
We are sure you will love hearing Marc talk about Camillus, the man who served as a role model for later Roman luminaries like Julius Caesar and Augustus.
If you would like to hear more, we have a stack of episodes in our back catalogue that feature Camillus.
Our music is by Bettina Joy de Guzman.
Dr Rad 0:15
Welcome to the partial historians.
Dr G 0:19
We explore all the details of ancient Rome,
Dr Rad 0:23
everything from political scandals, the love affairs, the battles waged and when citizens turn against each other, I’m Dr rad,
Dr G 0:33
and I’m Dr G, we consider Rome as the Romans saw it, by reading different authors from the ancient past and comparing their stories.
Dr Rad 0:44
Join us as we trace the journey of Rome from the founding of the city.
Dr Rad 0:55
Hello and welcome to a special episode of the partial historians, I am one of your hosts. Dr rad, and I am, Dr G, now. Dr G, we have been basically hosting the Camillus show for a good many episodes now. And so it is with great pleasure that we welcome on our next guest, Marc Hyden. Marc Hyden is the Director of State Government Affairs at a Washington DC based think tank, as well as being a weekly columnist for The Newnan Times, Herald, Albany Herald and Rome News-Tribune. Marc graduated from Georgia State University with a degree in philosophy. Marc shares a love for ancient Rome, and has published numerous books on the subject. His most recent work is Emperor Titus: The Right Hand of Vespasian, which came out with MacFarland in 2025 and we will be talking with him about that in a future episode. He has also authored Gaius Marius: The Rise and Fall of Rome’s Savior with Pen and Sword in 2017, Romulus, The Legend of Rome’s Founding Father with Pen and Sword in 2020 but our focus today is going to be on Marcus Furius Camillus, the life of Rome’s second founder, which came out with Pen and Sword in 2023 and so I’m sure everyone is cheering right now because they want to hear much, much more about Camillus than we have ever told them. Welcome Marc!
Marc Hyden 2:28
Hey, thanks so much for having me, and I’m glad I can find some other people that I can nerd out with about Camillus.
Dr Rad 2:34
You are indeed in the right location, all right. Well, let’s kick it off with some general questions. We know that family is very important in ancient Rome. Can you please tell us a bit about Camillus’ family and background?
Marc Hyden 2:51
Sure, and you know, I started writing the book about Camillus at the beginning of the pandemic, and I was trying. I thought I would write this book chronologically, which is what I did. I decided to try to figure out start off with, well, essentially, who was his father and his grandfather? That’s kind of how these things work. And unfortunately, his whole family, more than a generation or so before him, there’s not really much known. We do know that he hailed from a patrician family, the gens Furii, and judging by some of the members names and some epigraphic evidence, they were probably of Latin stock, and they had roots in the cities of Tusculum and Medulia, not too far from Rome. However, they wouldn’t have been originally Roman from the Romans eyes. They were they were Latin. They were a little bit different, but eventually they were incorporated into the early republic. And actually they might have been incorporated even in under the monarchy. But initially, the Furii they they weren’t really that influential, at least compared to some of the other clans. I mean, we think about the great clans like the Fabii, who seemed to like have a stranglehold on early and even later part portions of the Republic. But in spite of this, the fury, they clearly did enjoy some sway in old Rome, beginning about a generation before Camillus was born. And we know this. We can see from the Fasti Capitolini and from some other evidence, I believe that the first person in his family to gain prominence with Sextus Furius. So he was a consul at some point in 488, BC, most likely, although Varronian dating is off, you know, that might have been off by at least three years or so, but he became one of Rome’s two consuls. And he was probably a direct ancestor of Camillus, or at least somehow related to him. But after he came to power then, then other people start in his family started to ascend to the pinnacle of elected Roman politics, and by the mid fifth century BC, Camillus was born into this increasingly ascendant family. And that brings me back to trying to figure out who the heck was his father and his grandfather. Father, because Livy doesn’t mention this. Plutarch doesn’t mention this. No one mentions this. So I started looking at the inscriptions from the Fasti Capitolini, and within it, it, you know, it has his name, Marcus Furius Camillus. And then there’s these weird abbreviations in there. What those abbreviations are? They tell you the shorthand of what his grandfather and his father’s name was so we know that his grandfather was Spurius, and his father was Lucius. So with that, we can deduce that his grandfather is probably Spurius, Spurius Medullinus Fusus, who happened to be consul in 464, BC. And his father was Lucius Furius Medullinus, and he served as a consular Tribune a few times after Camillus birth,
Dr G 5:45
you’re setting us up really nicely, because Spurius Furius is one of our favorite Romans of the early republic in all of his iterations, because there were a few Spurius Furii. But to know that Camillus might be related into that line as well. Well, well, it warms the heart. It makes so much sense to us as fans, thinking about when Camillus starts to rise to prominence. Can you tell us a little bit about how his early career starts to take off?
Marc Hyden 6:15
Yeah, much like his family, there’s not a whole lot known about Camillus in his early life, we know kind of the first big thing we hear about him is that at a young age, probably around 15 or 16 years old, he served in the cavalry during the Battle of Mount Algidus, which pitted the Romans against the Aequians and the Volscians. These these generational enemies that your listeners are very familiar with. And during this, this pivotal battle, the teenager, unlike what I would have been like at that age, he rode out beyond the Roman infantry’s line, and he engaged the Republic’s foes, and he had a bolt, an arrow, some sort of projectile, fired at him and it lodged in his leg. And despite it being stuck in there, and he’s probably suffering from blood loss, he urges his his steed forward and fights. He the enemy with distinction. And you know, all of his his colleagues saw this. They thought it was they thought it was excellent. They ended up winning the battle. And you know, he might have contributed to that as well, but he earned a name for his bravado, and he got plaudits back in Rome. But unfortunately, after he goes back to Rome and he has he gets to go enjoy a triumph with the dictator who won the battle of Mount Algidus. Nothing, there’s like a dark age for Camillus. The next 27 or so years, we don’t know a thing about him. We can glean some stuff. You know, he probably we he would have gotten married, and we know that he had kids, at least two boys, and he may have had many, many girls as well. And he probably worked on the family business, managing some farms and that sort of thing. But eventually he decided to follow his family’s footsteps and enter the political world. And this is, this is a kind of a mystery to me, and I’m sure it is to you, because the first office that we know of they decided to run for was the censorship. So the censorship was, was relatively new by this age. It had only been around for about a generation, but throughout much of Rome’s history afterward, the censorship was something that was a crowning achievement after a long, long career, a very successful career, not something you’re going to give some upstart freshmen. Somehow he, at least, according to the ancient accounts, he he succeeds. He’s one of Rome’s two censors, and he serves probably around 403 to 402 BC. And during that period, he did some for modernize, some some weird things. He worked to raise taxes by ensuring that orphans couldn’t get out of paying them, which sounds really, really terrible, but really he was probably, probably had to do with inheritance for very rich orphans whose parents had passed away, not poverty stricken ones. And he also worked to ensure that bachelors either paid a fine or married widows, because with all the plagues and all the wars, there were a lot of single women out there that were probably struggling to make ends meet, and he encouraged them to get married. And then afterward, after having what that was viewed as a very successful censorship, he decided to serve the state in some other ways, and he eyed the consular tribuneship. This is a very weird quirk of Roman politics, because we’ve already talked about the consuls. There’s two consuls that supposedly headed up the government in normal times, but then periodically in this era, there were no consuls. So the ancient writers suggest that since the plebeians at the time could not hold the consulship. They’d obstruct the government and force them to appoint people other than consul so they would do consular Tribune ships or tribunes and plebeians could hold that as well as patricians, and that was supposedly the genesis of it. But there’s been some modern debate. One academic suggests that consular tri. Tribunes weren’t even an official position. They were actually war band leaders that the ancient writers misinterpreted. Meanwhile, others disagree, and they believe that they were actually a real position that was elected by the Roman populace. But the reason that they opted for tribunes rather than consuls is that you could have four, six, maybe even eight consular tribunes that serve at the same time. So you could fight a lot of wars, you could manage a lot of problems, a lot more than you could with only two consoles. And at this time, Rome was surrounded by enemies, or at least potential enemies. They had so many problems, so they were they were willing to kind of bend the rules and have consular tribunes lead them. So Camillus, after that long digression, Camillus decides he wants to run for this. And he wins a term in 401, and in 398, and immediately he’s put to the test. He He wages kind of a scorched earth campaign, first against the capitanis and then the filiscans, who are both allies, frenemies, something like that, with with Rome’s really serious foe, Veii and his he was successful. I mean, there was no major, major turning points in those but he waged a scorched earth campaign that really left them in pain, and this gave him the chance to propel within Roman society and eventually become a Roman hero.
Dr Rad 11:23
Yes, let’s talk more about his reputation as a Roman hero. There are a few moments that have started to emerge in our episodes that seem to put Camillus in the limelight. So can you tell us a bit about these times in his life which seemed to cement his reputation as a Roman hero, yeah,
Marc Hyden 11:41
I’d love to so around the time that he wraps up his his second consular tribuneship, Rome has been mired in this long siege of the eye. They just this is this settlement that really was kind of the counter to Rome. They were Etruscan. It was built on this big, craggy mount, and it was very well fortified, and they had been fighting each other, supposedly since the days of Romulus. They these guys just did not like each other. But over the years, Rome slowly had started to outperform Veii and really everything tended to center generally around the city of Fidenae because of the control of a lot of different routes, communication lines and that sort of thing. Rome, at this point, they were really ready to smite their foe and just be done with it for years to come. But it wasn’t going well. They kept having embarrassing mishaps happening on the front and after about 10 years of the siege, and we’ll talk about later on, about how the siege probably didn’t actually last 10 years. But according to the ancient accounts, it lasted 10 years. It wasn’t going well. Rome decided we’ve got to just name a dictator, the dictators of today’s era. I mean, it’s, it’s a scary, very bad thing. No one wants a dictator. Back then, it wasn’t considered a bad thing. It was. It was a term of no more than six months, and they appointed someone in times of emergency so they could control the city state’s resources and focus it all on the main issue, which was vi so they appointed Camillus to do that, and he performed ably. And instead of using the same tactics that had not been working there, he decided to undermine the city. So he had these mines cleaved underneath. And while that was going on, they scaled the walls, opened the gates, and VI fell. And in fact, supposedly, you can still find some of the mines or drainage pipes that Camillus and his troops might have used today in the vicinity, which is pretty exciting for a big nerd like me. So he has the success there. It’s a very big success, but it causes him serious grief later in his life, not too much later, but we’ll get to that in a little bit his next moment that really cements him as a Roman hero comes in 394, BC. So at this point, Camillus is once again serving as a consular Tribune. And as you’ve talked about on on your podcast before, he was charged with eliminating Falerii as a threat. So he battled them. He hems them into into the city, and he begins to lay siege. And as your listeners know, Faliscan schoolmaster, you know, he’s got all these these noble children under his tutelage. He teaches them reading, writing, arithmetic and whatnot, and also lets them exercise. So every day he takes them out of the city walls, and each day gets a little bit closer to the Roman sentinels, until he’s able to finally hand these children over to Camillus. And he tells them, hey, you know, this is a great opportunity. You can take these children, use them as hostages, pawns of war, and bring the city to their knees. And the schoolmaster probably thought that he was going to get recompense. And rewarded for, for this, this terrible act. Well, instead of it working out, it really ticks off Camillus, like he’s a man of integrity, at least we’re told that he is. So he has the man stripped of his clothing, has him flogged, and, you know, in it just weird Roman form, gives all these children canes to just beat this poor man senseless as they march back to Falerii, where everyone’s watching in kind of disbelief, and they’re like, gosh, you know, this Camillus guy could have used these children against us, but he chose not to. He’s a man of honor. Rome must be a city state of honor. We’re going to be at peace. So it ends bloodlessly, and they become friends, supposedly, and that is one of the that it’s the second and a very large episode in which it really cements his his legacy. Now the last major episode comes later, and we’re talking about Rome sacking the most one of the most embarrassing and humiliating moments in the record, although there’s a canonical view, and then there’s the view of what really happened, and we can get to the reality a little bit later. But according to legend around 390 BC, this is veronian dating again in Livy, a band of Gauls known as the Senones, and were led by Brennus, King Brennus, and they defeated the Romans at the river Alia, sacked Rome, with the exception of the capitolin Hill, and then laid siege to it. They’re unable to capture it, because barbarians, of course, don’t know how to do things. So they can just, they can just make people’s lives miserable. And eventually they say, hey, we’ll leave. Give us 1000 pounds of gold. No big deal. The Romans, eventually they agree, we’ll give you 1000 pounds. They start carting it down, and the Gauls are weighing it to make sure they have enough, but they’ve actually rigged the scales so that they can get more than 1000 pounds. And the Romans, they get wise to this, and they figure it out. And when they complain. There’s the famous moment where Brennus walks up to the weighing plate and throws his sword on it. And when the Romans asked, What does this mean? He, you know, exclaims, Vae victis, or Woe to the vanquished. So while all this is going on, Camillus is living in exile. And we can we’ll talk a little later about why he’s in exile and he is appointed dictator in absentia. At first they asked him to take, take control the troops that were around Rome’s vicinity. He refuses to do it, but they they appoint him. He refuses to do it because it would be inappropriate at first, because he didn’t have the statutory power. So once they appointed him formally dictator, he takes the troops, eventually marches back into Rome, and he sees this exchange with gold, and he’s he’s furious, and he explains to Brennus, in uncertain, no uncertain terms, that he’s dictator, he’s Supreme Leader. This is not a real agreement, because he would never agree to it. And then they start to battle. He pushes them out of Rome, and then the next day, at the near the eighth milestone, they had wage a big battle. And at that point, Camillus destroys the barbarian threat and collects a lot of the gold, or at least the canonical account suggests that. So the last major episode that really lifts Camillus into being this demigod, really for Romans, is the reversal of the Senones at Rome.
Speaker 1 18:27
It’s such a big moment as well, very dramatically told in Livy and some of our other ancient sources. And I do really enjoy this idea that Camillus is furious at Brennus, because that ties in very nicely with the gens as well. So Camillus has these moments of glory. They’re pretty significant, significant enough that Romans continue to talk about them centuries later. But you’ve already hinted at the idea that there are some things that don’t go so well for Camillus. And you noted that he’s actually in exile in the lead up to this sack by the Gauls. Can you speak to some of the more controversial things that are going on with Camillus?
Marc Hyden 19:14
Yeah, and it seems, it seems bizarre that this exempla of Roman virtue is somehow embroiled in any controversy. But there’s, like, there’s several moments, so there’s quite there’s a bit of a laundry list. So bear with me. But after sacking Veii Camillus is awarded a triumph. And you know, he’s He’s excited. This is a celebratory parade through Rome that everybody wants it. Children probably dream of getting this. And he gets it, and he wants it to be pretty fancy. So, you know, he gets dressed up, most likely, as paints his face red and makes him look like Jupiter, and even secures four white horses to pull his his triumphal carriage to modernize. That’s who cares. That’s a big shrug to the road. Romans. This was symbolism the four white horses. No one had ever done this before in Rome, supposedly, and to them, this was symbolism that was more appropriate for for the gods, as opposed to a man. So he, he goes through, you know, down the via sacrum snakes the Rome, and he probably sees all these lawn lookers recoiling at his impious display. So that causes a lot of grief for what now is seems like a very minor infraction, especially when you consider what later emperors like Nero are up to my goodness, this is, this is a nothing burger. But this wasn’t the only controversy. There’s several stemming from Veii’s fall Camillus, while he was the sacking was underway or getting ready to he pledged that he would donate a 10th of the spoils to Apollo, the god Apollo. Unfortunately, he didn’t really define what the spoils were or how the tithe would get collected. And what really made collecting this tithe so difficult is that immediately after the sack, the Senate, along with Camille, has decided, you know, we’re just going to let the people go and take whatever spoils they want. We’re nice guys like that. Just take whatever you want from this poor city that we have just ravaged. So you have all these people living in poverty, that their lives might be slightly better because they got a gold bowl or a gold cup or something silver that they were able to take from Veii well, they start witnessing these portents that perhaps the gods are pretty angry that this tithe has not been paid. So, you know, priests, the Senate, Camillus, they start talking, they they realize they really shouldn’t have reneged on on their on camillius Promise. It was solemn, it was inviolable, and they needed to deliver it. So they kind of mulled over ways of trying to do this, and they settled on telling the people that they had to voluntarily donate 10% of whatever they took from the city. Well, this ticked a lot of people off. I mean, they recently had a windfall. Some of them may have already spent it, you know, buying land, buying tools or whatever, and now they had to somehow find a way to donate a 10th of it. Supposedly, everyone did it. So good for Camillus, you know, his pledge was ultimately fulfilled. But you can imagine how angry the populace was. You know this, this guy had come in and his four white horses acting like a god, and now he told me that I gotta give back 10% of of what I’ve got recently.
Marc Hyden 22:30
So rude. How do you give back 10% of a gold bowl? You had to chip part
Marc Hyden 22:31
You had to chip part of it off, I guess, I’m not quite sure. So this, this really embittered quite a few people against him, but more, as I hinted, there’s, there’s more issues related to the sack, the sacking after doing so, a plebeian Tribune named Sicinius advocated for splitting Rome in half. Said half the Senate can go to Veii, half the plebeian populace can go there. You know, it’s a great place to live, despite what the Romans had just done to it. It’s defensible. They have good land, that sort of thing, and plus, it’s going to enrich everybody, because everyone’s going to get land, and we’re all going to be very happy doing this. Well, the plebeians probably loved this. The Senate, the patricians, they hated it, including Camillus, and the reason was, you’re splitting Rome in half, that’s going to weaken them, the two cities, even though they were supposed to continue operating under the same city state, they probably would have fought each other. And also, the very religious Romans probably thought that this was a slap in the face to the gods who had cultivated Rome that space for them. So Camillus fights against his proposal, and he and the patricians are victorious. But again, a lot of the people were probably pretty upset. They thought that they were going to get farmland to settle and these sorts of things. So then finally, the last issue related to the sacking comes from a different plebeian tribium, and this is Apuleius. He filed bogus charges against Camillus, suggesting that he had embezzled spoils from the the sacked city. Now the ancient writers are pretty much in unison saying that this is false. Camillus didn’t do anything wrong. The the justification for this was supposedly that Camillus had some bronze doors on his house, and supposedly that came from Veii he was allowed to collect spoils. He probably was even allowed to collect the commander’s share of spoils. So that’s not an indictment. This was Trump. These were trumped up charges. But the problem for Camillus is that he knew he was gonna lose in court. He was not gonna be able to win this his powerful friends wouldn’t be able to help them, or at least refuse to help him. So instead of suffering the ignominy of a kangaroo court condemning him, he decides to go live in exile, voluntarily in the city of Ardea, which explains why he was absent when. The Gauls sacked Rome, but when he comes back and saves the Romans from the Gauls, the people, once again mold the idea of relocating wholesale to Veii Camillus, again, was very opposed to this, and he derailed the measure, but it probably irked a lot of Romans, and then the last piece that really that tainted Camillus legacy to a much more minor degree, had to do with Marcus Manlius Capitolinus. He was a patrician who charted his own path to power. He, for some reason, felt like he couldn’t rely on the patricians to propel him toward his dreams. And he saw the plebeian body is much larger, and he knew that they suffered under the yoke of debt. So he advocated for essentially total debt forgiveness. He said the patricians actually had enough money to pay for all their debt, pay all the debt off, and they were hiding the money. And he knew where it was, but he wasn’t going to tell him where it was at just yet, at least. So Marcus Manlius Capitolinus, decides to go a step further, like he wants power, and he tries to use debt forgiveness to do that, something that really doesn’t go far, but it seems that he starts to warm to the idea of a revolt, maybe taking over the Capitoline Hill. And he’s also open to becoming the king, which is something at that time of Rome, yeah, they didn’t like kings too much, not at all. So eventually the Romans captured him, they tried him. Camillus was involved in in this situation, and eventually they they executed him in pretty gruesome fashion. And of course, this really angered a lot of the debt stricken plebs. So Camillus many great things to talk about, but he was not without controversy.
Dr Rad 26:48
Ah, it sounds like his patrician loyalties are what often gets him into trouble. So we know that the Romans love using an exemplar in both ways, both people that are to be admired, and also people that are to be reviled. Tell us what are the distinctive qualities that we can see in someone like Camillus?
Marc Hyden 27:08
Well, Camillus, despite these faults, despite controversy, he emerges, at least in the canonical accounts and much of the literature, unscathed. Really, he’s able to find redemption. And as I mentioned earlier, a lot of his infractions were a lot. They were pretty minor compared to the later, mad emperors and all that sort of thing. So I would say, first of all, if we’re talking about the distinctive qualities that that they saw in in Camillus, first of all, he was a Roman patriot. No one could say that he wasn’t. The Romans turned on him, and they sent at least according to the canonical account, and they sent him essentially into exile. These are his friends, his compatriots, the people that he had defended. They turned on him. But then when the senonas Sack Rome, they beg him to come back, and he’s willing to do so he comes back and he saves them, and apparently he doesn’t hold any grudges, uh, afterwards. So this is, this is kind of a selfless patriotism that we see from from Camillus. He also obeyed the law to the letter. And this is something that, you know, these fastidious Romans appreciate it, so before coming to Rome’s defense, after the sacking from the Gauls, he required that the government appoint him dictator, otherwise he would only be a private citizen without any power to lead armies. Now it was pretty difficult for this besieged band of Romans to appoint him dictator. But they managed to do it, and it pleased him, and it left him feeling as though that he was obeying the law and he wasn’t violating the Constitution, the unwritten constitution, in any way, shape or form. So he obeyed, obeyed the law, and he was generally fastidious at it. He also understood inequity to a degree, and often tried to avoid its controversy. So at the beginning of the podcast, we talked about how the consulship was reserved only for patricians at this point. Now, some rich plebeians, they certainly wanted to participate in this, and they would soon be able to. But this created a lot of controversy, and despite having this incredibly long curriculum vitae, Camillus refuses to ever be consul. He’s consular Tribune, but he won’t be Consul, supposedly, because of the controversy that surrounds it, and he also respected the gods. The Romans were a very religious people. I mean, some of their religious activities and everything are just really bizarre to modernize, but it was their thing. You know, it can’t be too judgmental. But he respected the gods, and even though he forgot or somehow didn’t immediately fulfill his promised tithe to Apollo, he generally worked to keep his his other oaths and remember the the pantheon of deities and then the last. Last the last distinctive quality, I think, that I would mention, is that he was a man of integrity. In the Faliscan the Falerii episode, he refused to use children as pawns in war, and he even worked to ease strife between the plebs and patricians after the plebeian tribunes, this is later in his life, suspended government for around five years and obstructed just about everything. Camillus worked to secure a compromise that gave the plebs more power. Then, after he did that, they could finally hold the consulship and some some pretty serious priesthoods. And this ended some of the inequity, but certainly, certainly not all of it.
Dr Rad 30:40
Politician with integrity,
Dr G 30:42
such a rare combination. Well, would we ever see such a man in our lifetimes? So I think this leads us really nicely into thinking about legacy, because Camillus gets a lot of attention in our ancient source material, and a lot of these written sources in particular are coming from a much later period of time, often the first century BCE, whereas Camillus is living his life and career in the fifth and the fourth centuries. So there’s quite a long period of time between the activities he’s involved in and when we get this flourishing of material about him. So I’m interested in what is Camillus legacy for the Romans?
Marc Hyden 31:23
To the Romans, Camillus was, without a doubt, he was an exempla of Roman virtue, which is a little bit different than you know what the virtues that you and I probably hold, but for Roman virtue, he was an exempla, and he was a role model for all subsequent leaders. Now you talked about a lot of the writings come hundreds of years after he died, and that is a problem with a lot of this, that era and the monarchical era. And I think he probably was able to shine in that era, when you had increasing numbers of corrupt and base politicians and people that were involved in power grabs and tried to violate the constitution. They had someone that they could say in row in our history, that is who you should be like. Now, of course, we know what happened to the Roman Republic and then what happened to the Empire. They kind of forgot their way, but they had someone to point to when they needed to try to correct themselves and the remote the Romans, they looked at him more than just this exemplar. He was the man who who finally vanquished Veii, he saved Rome from the Gauls. He rebuilt it after they had razed it to the ground, and he worked to ensure that the city of Rome, despite numerous, to at least two attempts to abandon or partially abandon, it would continue to be the seat of the republic and the empire for for hundreds of years to come. I mean, he’s known as the second founder of Rome. He held so many consulships, dictatorships, triumphs, and even was a censorship I mean, this is a man, a bit of a renaissance man that did just about everything and did almost everything right, at least according to very good PR,
Dr G 33:09
sounds dangerous. Sounds like it might almost be too good to be true.
Dr Rad 33:14
Ah, speaking of that, Dr, G, let’s talk about the historiography around Camillus. So one of the more intriguing theories we have stumbled across when we’ve been covering this time period is that Camillus was not, in fact, a historical figure at all, or at least his life and career might actually be some sort of amalgamation, perhaps, of numerous men from his family clan, and we’re curious to hear what your thoughts are on this mark.
Marc Hyden 33:46
So I take the position that I believe Camillus absolutely was a historical character who played an outsized role in the early republic, and he probably even played a role in the sacking of Veii say this, he’s incredibly well attested in the literary record, although it does come later, he’s well attested in the Fasti Capitolini and even famed historian, I think he was famed historian, TJ Cornell casted no doubt whatsoever that he was a historical character that did some some fantastic things for the Romans. However, outside of those two things, that he was a historical character, held some public offices of some kind, and did something at Veii after that, we really don’t know. That’s when things start getting a little fuzzy. So I think we can look at some of the issues around it. You know, I talked about the siege of the eye lasting 10 years. Well, we don’t believe most historians don’t believe it actually did that was a literary creation that they tried to borrow from, the Trojan War that supposedly lasted 10 years and the mysticism around it. But we still think. I mean, Veii was a real place, and it was sacked, and there’s no reason to believe that Camillus didn’t have something to do with that. Now, plenty of people have talked about Camillus life being embellished, exaggerated and combined with his family members, and I think that absolutely probably is the case. I don’t have any reason to doubt that it would be just incredibly hard, probably, especially in this era, to accomplish so many different things, even into old age. You know, we’ve talked about the Gallic sack of Rome, but there is supposedly another war that he led against against a different band of Gauls, and he would have been in his late 70s. My goodness, in ancient Rome, that’s a ripe old age, and you’re supposed to be leading armies. I’m not so sure. So I think that there was a family, the Marcus Furius Camilla’s, his family, his descendants and relatives, that were really accomplished. And somehow it got attached into this, this one person, you know, it might have been a son that engaged the Gauls at a later time. And there’s some theories about how this might have happened. You know, the histories were very bad back then. So people, there were family histories, there were eulogies to go off of. So families might have been embellishing their own story and building up this hero, but yes, I think Camillus was real. Did he do everything that the ancients said? Almost certainly not.
Speaker 1 36:28
Oh, Camillus a man of many faces and perhaps many men at the same time. To round off this conversation, one of the things that gets bandied about about Camillus, is this idea that he is actually the second founder of Rome. And I kind of love the phrasing of this. It’s almost, it’s a very Roman idea to think about somebody in this way. And I’m interested in, to what extent do you agree with this idea that he’s the second founder?
Marc Hyden 36:57
Well, it’s romantic. Let’s, let’s, let’s not doubt this one too. I’m joking. Of course, this is a tough one, so especially with only limited knowledge, I can tell you what the archeological evidence shows, what my research has showed, and we can just put the cards on the table. So the Romans, they mostly believe that he was the second founder of Rome. And modern scholarship, of course, who cast doubt on that? Now he supposedly received the sobriquet from defeating the Senones, defeating a measure to abandon Rome for Veii and then overseeing Rome’s reconstruction. So that’s why they named him. Supposedly named him Rome’s second founder. He was another Romulus. So Romulus is the first founder. He literally founds Rome. Camillus saves it and rebuilds it. And then, of course, Marius becomes the third founder of Rome, or was at least styled that way. But there’s a lot of problems here with regard to Camillus, which, of course, is someone who thinks he’s a pretty cool guy. Breaks my heart, because Camillus might not have actually had anything to do with the Senones, the sacking in the first place, which really just kind of throws Roman history out the window. And the theory behind this, it resonates. The claim is that his exile is actually a work of fiction, because it was just so embarrassing that the Romans were sacked by a bunch of bumbling barbarians that they needed to exculpate their hero, this guy that had already sacked their chief enemy, so they sent him into exile, so that he wouldn’t have been part of this sacking and this embarrassment, at least that’s the theory. He might have been there when it happened, and then went and left the city like many other people did. But there’s actually some ancient evidence that the Romans didn’t kick the the Gauls out. They actually paid them. There are a few references to the Romans getting the the money back later, sometimes much later, which is really embarrassing for the Romans that they had to pay these people to leave, so Camillus probably not in exile, probably didn’t come save them. The last real indictment on the being called the second founder is that the archeological evidence doesn’t show that the sacking was really that bad. It was a very mild sacking, as far as they go.
Dr Rad 39:18
Well, more like a pillow tussle.
Marc Hyden 39:20
The Gauls were busy. They were doing other stuff. They were probably in the pay of the tyrant of Syracuse, Dionysus. So they were probably going south, tackling some of Syracuse’s enemies, and then if there was anyone in their way, they would just go ahead and sack them and steal all their stuff and then move on. So like they didn’t want to hang around. They probably had other things to do. But and also, the archeological evidence shows that the sacking was pretty mild, so there might not have been any reason for the Romans to talk about abandoning Rome in the first place. And if there was, it’s very possible that the that Camillus is counseled against it, but everything else. Is really doubtful. And there is one other theory that, in fact, Camillus was later grafted onto the story to replace a city Caere, which had come to the Romans aid during the sacking. Well, eventually their friendship fell apart, and they didn’t want to sing the praises of the city that they no longer liked. So they created this myth around Camillus, saving them and not the city that they don’t like anymore. That’s not they’re not cool. And even when you look at more ancient sources, Aristotle has a very curious line. So he was a little interested in what was happening in Rome, even though Rome was not important on a global scale at the time, and he said that a certain Lucius saved Rome, not a certain Camillus, which some people have theorized it was, I think it was Lucius Albinus who had selflessly tried to help the Vestal virgins. But it could have been anybody else, because being called Lucius was kind of like being called John. Now, it could be anyone. But it’s very telling that he didn’t say Camillus, and for that, it breaks my heart a little bit.
Speaker 1 41:07
Oh, Camillus, not even getting his first name, right. Aristotle, come on.
Dr Rad 41:13
Oh, well, what a fascinating look at Camillus’ life. We know we covered over so many episodes, it’s really great to be able to pull it all together into one biographic study. So thank you so much for joining us today, Marc.
Marc Hyden 41:25
Hey, thank you so much for having me and and let me nerd out on Camillus.
Dr Rad 41:28
I’m sure our listeners would love to pick up a copy of your biography of Camillus. It is highly readable, I can definitely say that. And we really look forward to having you back on to talk about the emperor Titus soon.
Marc Hyden 41:40
You know, not a second or third or fourth founder, but he’s a pretty interesting guy. I was
Dr G 41:45
going to say he’s very cool. I’m excited to talk about him.
Dr Rad 42:00
Thank you for listening to this special episode of the partial historians. You can find our sources sound credits and an automated transcript in our show notes. Our music is by Bettina Joy De Guzman. The Partial Historians is part of The Memory Collective, creators and educators dedicated to sharing knowledge that is accessible, contextualized, socially conscious and inclusive. To find more from the Memory Collective head to collectivemem.com you too can support our show and help us to produce more engaging content about the ancient world by becoming a Patreon. In return, you receive exclusive early access to our special episodes and add free content. If monthly patronage is not your style, we have merch. We have a book, or you can just buy us a coffee on ko fi. And we’d like to say big thank you to all our Patreon supporters for making special episodes like this one possible. However, if your Imperial coffers do not overfloweth, one of the easiest and most important ways to help us is to tell someone about the show or give us a five star review wherever you listen. Until next time we are yours in ancient Rome.
Transcribed by https://otter.ai
The post Special Episode – Camillus with Marc Hyden appeared first on The Partial Historians - Ancient Roman History with smart ladies.
We rejoin the Romans and the Gauls in 390 BCE at the place where the Tiber river intersects with the Alia river. Turns out that when a bunch of Fabians upset the Gauls, those Gauls decide to march south towards Rome… How many Gauls and how many Romans met at the rivers’ edge? Well, the numbers are probably unreliable but the Romans are pretty sure they are outnumbered.
There seems to be a few issues at this moment including the Roman failure to build a proper camp and – even worse – failure to take the auspices. Is this some foreshadowing from our friend Livy?
Stay tuned for a discussion of the slim layout of the Roman forces. Brennus, the putative leader of the Gauls, seems concerned that there may be some secret tactic or force that he hasn’t been able to account for. There’s also the problem of which bank of the river the battle takes place on which may influence where Roman forces end up.
Will the Romans take the day or will they flail in the face of the Gallic strength? Are there some tactics involved that scholars can discern from the literary accounts that aren’t immediately obvious?
When the day goes against Rome, the retreat seems to be chaotic. Some of the Romans retreat to Rome, which makes sense, and some retreat to Veii. This creates a host of uncertainty for the Romans who survive particularly those who head back to Rome and don’t find their comrades there. The assumption of Roman losses is significant.
The Gauls meanwhile continue to suspect that there is a surprise attack from the Romans coming, but after some time they decide it’s worth marching on Rome just to see what they can see.
Our music is by Bettina Joy de Guzman.
Lightly edited for our wonderful Australian accents
Dr Rad 0:15
Welcome to The Partial Historians.
Dr G 0:19
We explore all the details of ancient Rome,
Dr Rad 0:23
everything from political scandals, the love affairs, the battle’s waged, and when citizens turn against each other, I’m Dr Rad
Dr G 0:33
and I’m Dr G. We consider Rome as the Romans saw it, by reading different authors from the ancient past and comparing their stories.
Dr Rad 0:44
Join us as we trace the journey of Rome from the founding of the city.
Dr Rad 0:56
Hello and welcome to a brand new episode of the Partial Historians. I am one of your hosts, Dr Rad
Dr G 1:04
And I am, Dr G, very excited to be here for more of the war with Gaul.
Dr Rad 1:12
Absolutely, we are smack bang in the middle of 390 BCE listeners. So if you want a full list of magistrates for 390 BCE, you definitely need to listen to part one, because we are not going through that again. It was way too long a list.
Dr G 1:27
And also, most of them won’t matter. It’s fine, that’s true.
Dr Rad 1:31
They’ll come up in very incidental ways. So in our previous episode, Dr G, we were really setting things up again for what is about to transpire. We know we’re heading into a dark period for Rome, but in our previous episode, we were really just looking at why our sources say the Gauls suddenly seem so interested in a place so far south from where they apparently were.
Dr G 1:54
What could prompt such people to march so quickly down the whole of Italy? Well, obviously, it’s because they were insulted by the Romans.
Dr Rad 2:03
That’s right, the foolish Fabians, this trio of brothers from a patrician clan, apparently, were the cause, the major cause, perhaps, of this problem, and we left them in charge As military tribunes with consular power, leading the Roman forces against the Gauls, who have marched super speedily down the length of Italy to face them. And we were at the point where battle was about to take place near the river Alia.
Dr G 2:36
Hmmm the intersection of the Tiber with a tributary the Alia, which is just north of Rome and east of Bay, so pretty close to Rome proper, enough for people to be quite worried. Diodorus Siculus tells us that the Gauls have 70,000 troops with them, and that the Romans are only able to muster up about 24,000 in response.
Dr Rad 3:04
Yes, I believe the highest number cited by our sources for the Roman side is about 40,000 so they’re definitely massively outnumbered
Dr G 3:13
woefully outnumbered by the Gauls.
Dr Rad 3:17
I think that’s one thing we probably can say for certain, whilst numbers given in ancient sources are notoriously unreliable, particularly in this early period of history, it seems safe to say that the Romans were outnumbered no matter what they were facing at this point in time, yes.
Dr G 3:36
At this point in time, it seems that they were, yes.
Dr Rad 3:39
So Dr G, we’ve already seen that the foolish Fabians who the Romans stupidly elected to be their military tribunes with consular power in this year didn’t do a fantastic job with the levy, and their foolishness continues.
Dr G 3:58
Oh no. What have they done now?
Dr Rad 4:01
So they don’t properly establish their camp when they encounter the Gallic forces. So they hadn’t really decided on where they were going to set up camp. They don’t really set up a fortified area which the Rubens could use if they need to retreat during the battle. And you will appreciate this in particular, they do not even take the auspices or consider the sacrificial omens. They just start organizing the army like that’s the most important thing.
Dr G 4:34
Who are these Fabians? Have they never gone to war before? I know the camp is the first thing you have to establish
Dr Rad 4:42
well, and it’s so important for the Romans to be square with the gods at these sorts of moments.
Dr G 4:48
It is. I feel like Livy is clutching for a rationale for why things are going so badly for the Romans this year.
Dr Rad 4:56
Arrogance. It just keeps coming, doesn’t it?
Dr G 4:59
Like who doesn’t take the auspices?
Dr Rad 5:00
Exactly. Now the Romans being vastly outnumbered, they’re not able to organize a front line of forces that can match the Gauls. The Gauls much wider. Okay, so we can see this outnumbering sort of taking place. But this didn’t stop the Fabians from trying. They basically are trying desperately to match the Gauls in the organization. And by doing this, they actually end up compromising the military strength of the Romans, because their center was apparently very weak, because it was, I guess, so kind of spread out, or the way that the forces were organized was just kind of so spread out.
Dr G 5:47
Okay, all right. So the other thing to do is, like, your tactics need to change when you have less troops. Like, what are you gonna do? Guys, don’t try to go toe to toe with the Celts, right now.
Dr Rad 5:58
Yes, like, they would have been better off perhaps organizing themselves in a different way, even though it would have made their forces look obviously smaller. I think is the implication here. They’re just not sort of thinking straight on their right. They organize their reserves now Brennus, our Gallic chieftain, apparently, although we think that name might be made up by Livy, based on a later Brennus who ends up invading Greece couple of centuries from now.
Dr G 6:27
What’s a what’s a Brennus or two between friends?
Dr Rad 6:30
It’s a likely name. It’s a likely name. He is surprised to see that the Romans have not fielded a larger force to face him, and he’s kind of worried that there’s some secret weapon or plan afoot. This can’t be all the Romans are sending to fight someone as awesome as I
Dr G 6:52
I mean, I’ve heard about the Romans. People tell me they’re good. Is this all they got? This is gonna be a pushover.
Dr Rad 6:59
Well, and this is where I feel like, once again, we’re potentially seeing the legacy of this pestilence that struck a few years before.
Dr G 7:07
Not only is the force small, but everybody’s scrawny.
Dr Rad 7:11
Well, as you say, like hard times, right? Maybe the Romans couldn’t really field a huge army at this point in time.
Dr G 7:18
Oh, yeah. But you know what they say, hard times create hard men.
Dr Rad 7:23
The Romans would love to believe so. Brennus is trying to figure out what it is that the Romans might have up their sleeve. You know, he’s thinking, if I were to attack at this point, do they have some secret reserve forces that are going to come around and ambush me.
Dr G 7:43
Hidden cavalry unit. Everybody knows they’ve got one of those.
Dr Rad 7:46
Yeah, exactly. So he’s trying to puzzle it out, because he’s a good leader. Dr, G, he is trying to think strategically.
Dr G 7:56
Ah, are we getting into that trope where Rome can only be defeated by great men,
Dr Rad 8:01
I think we might be so what he decides is that he’s going to hit their reserves first, just in case they were going to be some sort of surprise attack, where they were going to kind of like encircle around his flank and ambush him from the rear, or something along those lines. He’s like, You know what? Strategically, I think I’m going to hit the right wing first, where there reserves, the stations, knock them out, and then I should be able to rely on the fact that I clearly have superior numbers to win the day. And Livy notes this as thus, not only luck, but generalship, we’re on the side of the barbarians. Yeah. So I the Romans love to do this, don’t they, where they can’t see themselves as losing just because they were worse. It’s also because, I guess it’s one of those things where they’re like, We were obviously at a really low point. Guys, we were not behaving as we should. The gods were not on our side. These guys, like the shame is so extreme that these guys, these barbarians, were better than us,
Dr G 9:04
The very definition of not taking personal responsibility.
Dr Rad 9:09
They love to do this kind of thing. Now, the Romans Do not behave like themselves at all during this battle.
Dr G 9:16
This is why they lose.
Dr Rad 9:17
It is they immediately let fear get to them, and so psychologically, they were beaten almost immediately. And so complete was their forgetfulness that when they decide that they’re going to run in a panic away from the Gauls, a lot of them run to Veii.
Dr G 9:42
That’s the wrong way unless, of course, you’re really keen to get back to your seven iugera that you were recently allotted and you’re like, you know what? I need to go to my safe place.
Dr Rad 9:53
Livy explicitly says that it would have been far more direct for them to go back to Rome.
Dr G 10:00
I. Ah. Now I think I might interrupt you here, because I think everything about this battle hinges on which side of the river we think the Roman forces are on.
Dr Rad 10:10
This is true.
Dr G 10:11
And there are different accounts. There are different accounts of this. And I believe correct me, if I’m wrong, Livy thinks they’re on the side that would make it easier to get back to Rome.
Dr Rad 10:21
This is true.
Dr G 10:21
So that would be the right hand side of the river, whereas Diodorus says that they crossed the Tiber ahead of the battle itself. And he places them closer to the they side of things, which is a really interesting technicality in terms of like, how do we understand the mechanics of this battle unfolding, and how would it have implicated the outcome? Obviously, we know from all of our sources, the record stands that the Gauls win this battle.
Dr Rad 10:56
What? Dr G don’t give away the ending!
Dr G 10:59
I know. I’m sorry, listeners, I’m ruining it for us all again. But the way in which it unfolds would have to be very different, depending on which side of the river people are meeting on.
Dr Rad 11:13
This is true, but Livy could not paint a more shameful picture, because we get actually very little battling. It seems like the Romans are just instantly so afraid, and they’re thrown into chaos almost instantly, it seems, and they start to run away from the goals, even before they can actually properly see them, Livy says.
Dr G 11:39
Wow, okay, I was gonna say, Well, maybe if they had seen the Gauls, and be like, You know what? Those weapons are weird, and I need to get out of here.
Dr Rad 11:48
No, I think it’s like the Gauls do start attacking a particular part of the Roman army. And for some of the others, they’re just so afraid by what they can hear, what they can sense, that they instantly just want to run away, and most of the Roman dead are killed, I can hardly say it. Dr, G, with their backs turned to the enemy,
Dr G 12:11
Oh no, the absence of virtus.
Dr Rad 12:14
Yeah. And the fact that their forces are thrown into such chaos means that more people die than need to because they’re blocking their own retreat. It’s like a fire safety plan gone horribly wrong. They just don’t know how to queue get out in an orderly fashion. So there’s all sorts of chaos going on the left wing. Have run to the bank of the Tiber, and this is where, depending on which side of the river you think they’re on, it probably affects the outcome a little bit here. But the main point is that they’ve run to the river, they actually throw down their weapons. And they’re presumably trying to cross the river to get to safety.
Dr G 12:56
It’s impossible to swim while you’re also trying to sort out a whole javelin-spear situation.
Dr Rad 13:01
The shame of it to throw aside your weapons so they’re trying to swim across apparently, according to Livy, and some of them are drowned because they either can’t swim or they are just wearing, you know, so much heavy armour whatever, they’re weighed down by it. So it’s pretty shocking. Now this is where I am going to highlight some of the scholarship that I’ve read about. What exactly is going on here. It has been theorized that, whilst this looks incredibly bad for Rome, that they conduct themselves in this manner, perhaps there was strategy at play.
Dr G 13:44
Wait, I have some things to say about that.
Dr Rad 13:50
Did the Romans know that the Gauls were active in the area? Because they’ve heard from other people, as you, as you said last episode, the Gauls are so numerous they have to support themselves by constant pillaging. So the Romans have indeed heard that the Gauls are active. They know they’re headed in their direction. Perhaps the Romans are unprepared for this, because, again, as you said, tough times, and we’ve also had the plague in 392 so they’re not at their strongest in terms of military men that can fight. So do they send out this particular force to meet with the Gauls, not with the intent of actually winning, but just in holding them at bay and slowing the Gallic advance down, so that the people back in Rome perhaps have time to organize defenses, or something along those lines, to try and prepare themselves for a Gallic onslaught, and perhaps the Romans were actually planning to retreat from this battle.
Dr G 14:57
Well, I would love, love to agree that losing a battle and losing troops and allowing men to die, trying to swim across a river, is all part of a clear strategy. I think the best thing that you could say for something like this is that maybe they were trying to buy some time, maybe. But it doesn’t go very well. And would that be the kind of thing that you would let on to anybody who was drafted into this force? Probably not, because then they’re not really going to fight. So Diodorus Siculus gives us a description of this battle as well. And he says that of the 24,000 Roman troops, they create a line from the river as far as the nearby hill. And that’s kind of the organization. He doesn’t talk about the left or the right or anything like that, but that they’re trying to create a force that allows them to cut off or meet the Gauls at any point, whether it’s at the river edge, right up into the more forested section, they station the weakest at the top of the hill. Obviously, the idea is everybody retreats there when they need to, and that’s where you create the defensive spot. He doesn’t talk about the camp. Nothing to be said about the disorganization. Doesn’t mention anything about the auspices or what might be going on with the gods in that relationship, the Celts also have a long line, and their choice troops are stationed on the hill. So we’ve got the worst of the Romans against the best of the Gauls, and that’s the kind of match up that is put to us by Diodorus. So the elite Celts really go hard at the weakest Romans, and the Romans are easily driven off the hill, so they immediately lose their fall back defensive position, instantly, as soon as the battle trumpets are bled and everybody runs in, and maybe there’s something to be said for the way that the Gaulish approach their attack, because it seems that the ferocity of the fighting or the nature of losing that strategic position almost immediately, once the battle begins, really turns the morale for the Romans upside down. They don’t handle this well. Everyone along the river edge starts to try to flee. There’s hardly anywhere to go. You either go into the river to get away from the Celts, or you run into the Celts going in the other direction. This allows the Celts to just really mow down Romans in every direction. The people who flee to the river attempt to swim. We’re not sure how many people in the ancient Roman world were swimmers. I mean, they have a river that runs right past their city, but everybody likes a bridge.
Dr Rad 17:55
They do like a bridge.
Dr G 17:57
Do you, do you swim it? Maybe. Does everybody know how to swim? Probably not. They’re taken out pretty easily. People take off their armor to make it easier to swim. This makes them easier targets to be killed, sure. So another tragedy in the making. They showered with javelins as they’re trying to cross the river, lots of missiles, people being injured, people dying, bodies in the water. We hear that the bulk of the force goes to Vay. If we’re thinking about this in terms of, could this be a Roman strategy? Doesn’t sound like it. It sounds like a Roman loss, but if it is indeed part of a broader like, what do we do if things go pear shaped in this battle? Heading to Veii is another way of protecting Rome?
Dr Rad 18:49
Well, that’s what I was going to say. See, this is the crazy thing about the Battle of the Alia. So this day goes down in Roman history, obviously, as one of the worst that they’ve ever had, and it’s clearly not because, I would say, of the numbers of people who die in this battle, I’m actually not even sure that that many Romans do, in fact die in this encounter. It’s the shame of it. It’s the way that the battle goes down. That is the terrible thing. We actually know the date of this because it was preserved, because it was so
Dr G 19:24
it was so impactful
Dr Rad 19:26
yeah, the 18th of July.
Dr G 19:28
The 18th of July
Dr Rad 19:30
yeah
Dr G 19:30
the height of summer
Dr Rad 19:32
Yeah. And, you know, it’s really freaky time of recording. We’re not actually that far away from the 18th of July
Dr G 19:37
Oh we should have held off.
Dr Rad 19:39
I did think about that, actually, but this is exactly it. If we were to say that this force was sent to encounter the Gauls only to potentially to slow down their advance, then perhaps it’s not a chaotic, spontaneous retreat today, where they just, like, don’t know where they’re going, and they run completely the wrong direction.
Dr G 19:58
Run away.
Dr Rad 19:58
Yeah, anyway.
Dr G 19:58
Oh, this is Veii. This is not where I meant to end up.
Dr Rad 20:02
This is where I wanted to end up going. Oh, my God, I went into shock. Perhaps this was the intent, because Veii is actually a fairly well fortified city. Clearly, that’s why it took the Romans so long to conquer it, yeah. And so they are kind of splitting their forces, because this is maybe another way of dealing with the situation. And, sorry, no, not and, but this is not at all how it is painted in Livy’s account. What ends up happening is, whilst we do have a significant chunk of the forces who managed to get away and head to ve the other part of the Roman forces, who run away to Rome, don’t know that they have survived. They don’t know that they’ve gone to veiy. They think they’re all dead. So they think this is a day of great slaughter, and they think a huge amount of the Roman forces have been cut down. So this is part of the whole narrative that Livy is building. It’s really starting to sound like a soap opera that there are all these guys who have gone to ve seemingly in confusion, but everyone else thinks they’re dead. So the Romans that managed to get away, which are mostly, I think, from that right wing, the sort of reserves they flee to Rome, and when they get back to Rome, they tell everyone, oh, my God, it’s cataclysmic. Most of our forces have been cut down. Everyone who’s not here right now is dead.
Dr G 21:33
Wow. Okay, now the other detail that Diodorus offers into this, which might add some some depth to some of what you’re saying as well. I think it’s additive, rather than sort of calling things into question. In this case, is that he suggests that the when the military tribunes are calling for the levy, they’re actually drawing upon all men of military age. It’s considered to be a special case situation, because they understand that the Gauls are coming.
Dr Rad 22:05
Rumor is that is not at all the case anyway.
Dr G 22:09
Rumor is flighty, but bad news is carried swiftly, and they’ve got a sense that there’s a really quite big force of Gaulish folk coming for them.
Dr Rad 22:22
They are not wrong.
Dr G 22:23
And the idea that they exercise a special power to increase the breadth of who can be levied might mean that we’re in a situation where we’ve got very young, very inexperienced young men out on the battlefield. It might be their first time. Chances are they don’t know what they’ve really seen. They haven’t been able to take in the military intelligence aspect of it. And I think when you’re running for your life, the last thing that you’re doing is looking around to see where Joe Bloggs ended up as your favorite companion. You may be like, you know, if I see him, he’s alive. If I don’t see him, he’s dead. That seems to me to be a very reasonable traumatic response to getting back to Rome and finding that he’s not there.
Dr Rad 23:12
Absolutely well in my account, nonetheless, this is where we’re at, where we’ve got some survivors who’ve managed to make it back to Rome. They’ve told everyone, we’ve lost. So many people have been killed, so many good men. It’s a disaster. They’re in such panic that they don’t even stop to close the city gates of Rome behind them. They just keep running until they get to the Citadel. That’s their safe place.
Dr G 23:41
City walls? Pah! I need more than that.
Dr Rad 23:44
Oh, the mistakes just keep mounting. Dr, G, it’s crazy. Now, of course, as you can imagine, the Gauls who are left back at the Battle of the Alia at this scene are kind of standing there, absolutely dumbstruck. They cannot believe that they have managed to triumph so completely and so quickly against the Romans. They’re stupefied. They’re kind of actually just standing there like statues. They’re thinking, there must be more to this. Surely there’s going to be some sort of surprise ambush coming at us at any moment now, but eventually they start to do what you would expect, despoil the bodies of those that they did manage to kill, and also just gather up the weapons and the armor that the Romans seemingly cast aside as they made a stampede to get the hell out of there. And this is something that we know, that you know, sort of Celts-Gallic people are famous for doing. But again, it’s not like the Romans don’t do it too. This is a standard part of warfare, but certainly they’re after resources, so they’re not going to leave anything behind. And as they’re doing that, they’re kind of keep looking over their shoulder, going, what was that? What was that is that the Romans but nothing happens, and they start to get used to the idea that maybe nothing going to happen. And so eventually they start to march in the direction of Rome to finish this business once and for all. And they manage to reach the area just outside of Rome before sunset. So romantic.
Dr G 25:25
There it is. We found it Rome, our Eldorado.
Dr Rad 25:31
Now they are again somewhat stupefied by the fact that when they reach Rome, the gates are wide open.
Dr G 25:41
Well, well, well.
Dr Rad 25:45
And not only that, there are no guardsmen or anything to be seen. No one seems to be watching out for the city, seeing what’s going on. And again, they’re like, This is too easy. This has to be a trap of some kind, right?
Dr G 26:05
Now, Diodorus gives us some different details about this actually. He says that the Gauls approach Rome with with some relative caution, but they’ve also got things that they need to do, and it takes them a little bit of time to do those things before they can get really properly set up. So before they can leave the Battle of Alia, they’ve got to behead everybody.
Dr Rad 26:29
Yes, the beheading, they do become famous for this, don’t they?
Dr G 26:33
Yeah, it’s just, it’s part of what they do. It’s a post battle insurance. People without heads…
Dr Rad 26:39
Insurance?
Dr G 26:40
People without heads don’t get back up.
Dr Rad 26:41
Oh, okay, I wasn’t picturing like that. Yep, that makes sense.
Dr G 26:47
You know, yeah, you’ve got to make sure that they’re dead. How do you make sure that they’re dead? You cut off their head. So they do that. That takes them about a day. And ultimately, Diodorus positions this as being through the whole process that the Gauls take when it comes to a post battle situation, it takes them about three days to turn up to Rome. This is plenty of time for the Romans who are going to flee, to flee. We get a famous story about the priestesses of Vesta, which you’re looking at me like. I should come back to that.
Dr Rad 27:19
I would come back to that.
Dr G 27:20
And that’s fine. I’ll hold that thought. I’ve planted the seed. And we also have this sense that the Gauls sit outside Rome for a couple of days looking at the open gates, being like, “it’s a trap”. And then once they’ve seen for a couple of days that nothing happens, they’re like, well, I guess it’s time to pillage the city. And they go in and they start wreaking havoc in the city itself, burning things down, stealing booty. And it’s at that time that they realize that the Romans who have stayed have retreated to the Capitoline Hill.
Dr Rad 27:59
Yes.
Dr G 28:00
That’s when they figure it out. They’re like, Oh, they’re up there.
Dr Rad 28:03
Yeah. And this is where the Romans plans might have gone astray. If we are to believe that the Romans had a grand plan behind all of this mess, perhaps they were trying to do something like split the attention of the Gallic forces, like some of them would pursue those who go to Veii, some of them would pursue those who go to Rome. I mean, this is really giving them the benefit of the doubt. Obviously, given what the Romans are saying about themselves at this point in time, it’s possible. But nonetheless, the full Gallic force appears to be here in front of Rome. And I do agree with you that it would make a bit more sense if this account, if there was a bit of time passing with this account, you know, and certainly when the Gauls arrive, Brennus makes sure that his forces give the city a full once over, you know, ride right around it, checking it out, reporting back what’s going on. They do, I think, probably sit and stare at it a while, but the reports are coming back constantly that we can’t see anyone. We can’t see any armed men around the walls, and they just become more and more puzzled by this situation.
Dr G 29:11
Are you sure this is Rome? Because there isn’t anybody here.
Dr Rad 29:15
Did we take a wrong turn? Were we meant to turn left, like half a mile ago?
Dr G 29:18
Is this Veii? Because I heard that didn’t have any people in it.
Dr Rad 29:22
Exactly. And in a way, if the Romans didn’t plan this, they’ve done a very good job, because the Gauls could not be more freaked out by this situation. It just seems so incredibly odd. So they decide not to enter Rome, you know, en masse at this point in time, it would be smarter for them to establish their own camp just outside of Rome itself, and they keep patrolling it, just keep an eye on it, and that sort of thing, just trying to figure out what on earth is going on. Because they’re pretty sure there are some Romans inside. However, there are many. More of the escaped army in Veii at this point in time. So certainly not all of the Roman forces are in the city. Now, the Romans inside, they’re pretty depressed, Dr. G.
Dr G 30:12
I’m not surprised.
Dr Rad 30:14
I think it’s safe to say that this is probably actually their lowest moment.
Dr G 30:20
It is pretty bad time to be a Roman. This is an unusual situation to be sure, to find yourself with the enemy at the gate, and being like hmmm hmmm.
Dr Rad 30:31
Did I look the gate? No, oh no, damn it. I knew I forgot something. Now they’re sitting around feeling pretty sorry for themselves, obviously thinking that most of their forces have been killed because they apparently don’t know about the people at they but soon the Romans have no more time for tears, because it is very apparent that the Gauls for arrive. Because even though the Gauls do not enter the sitter immediately, when they’re patrolling, they make sure that they let out eerie cries and sounds, and the Romans can hear the freaky sounds coming through. And this is obviously a moment where Livy is noting that these barbaric forces make different kinds of noises to the ones that Romans would to freak people out in this situation, which is very scary.
Dr G 31:20
The Romans make civilized war noises. But the Gauls…
Dr Rad 31:25
Yeah, when the Romans are patrolling a city and trying to freak people out, they go, whereas the Gauls, I guess, are getting out more of like ArrrOooooh, which, if you were curled up in the Citadel because you ran back there in a panic would probably be pretty freaky. So the Romans have an awful time of it. Now, Livy’s placing this as the Romans had an awful night. I’m gonna say that this is a night time after the Gauls have been there maybe for a few days when the goals are making these sounds. You know, the timeline is very unclear, but they are certainly having a terrible time of it once they realize the Gauls are circling around them, because they are, of course, expecting an attack at any moment. Why would the Gauls have followed them all the way back to the city if they weren’t planning something evil, Dr. G?
Dr G 32:20
Well, I hate to break it to the Romans, but how do they think a siege starts?
Dr Rad 32:25
Well, they’re not expecting a siege. They haven’t looked the gates. But anyway, they don’t know what’s going on. First they think, are they going to attack us during the day? That would make sense. But then when night hits, they’re like, oh, maybe they’re planning to really scare us with a night attack, it’ll be even more terrifying. So I’m imagining the Romans are on no sleep, no food, picturing all their dead friends on the battlefield, basically at a mental breakdown point by the time dawn hits on whatever day this is supposed to be.
Dr G 33:00
The timeline is a bit fuzzy.
Dr Rad 33:02
It’s a little bit fuzzy, but it’s at this moment when the Romans are at complete mental breakdown that the Gauls finally enter the city.
Dr G 33:13
Aha!
Dr Rad 33:13
Yeah. They were just building up to that. Yeah. As soon as the Gauls are inside, the Romans are magically transformed back into the valiant people, but they are 99.9% of the time. Dr G, it’s just at the Battle of the Alia that it all fell apart. They had to face some tough facts pretty quickly. There’s no way they’re going to be able to fight this gigantic Gallic force, especially considering that they were outnumbered at the Alia but now they have even less. They have a tiny army, so they have to make a decision. And what they decide upon is this, that men of military age and any able bodied senators who are left should all go and take refuge in like the Citadel on the Capitoline Hill. Wait, yeah on the Capitol yeah on the Capitol line Hill, with their wives and their children, along with whatever weapons and food that they can scrounge together. And there they will hold up. They’re going to quote, defend the gods the men and the name of Rome sounds very noble. Well, I think that this is where they suddenly start thinking about, Oh, maybe a siege is going to take place here.
Dr G 34:39
Could it be a siege? Yes, it could. Could.
Dr Rad 34:42
I think they’re trying to preserve what they see, as you know, the heart of Rome. They also this is where some of your tidbits starts to come into play, although not entirely, want to make sure that the flamen and the priestesses of Vesta. They should secure the sacred objects for the sake of the state. Now, they’re not going to secure them all in the Citadel or anything like that. Rather, they’re going to take them away so that they’re far away from where any fighting is going to be taking place, because God knows, a fire might take place at some point in this course of events. And if they can make sure that the cults can survive, then Rome survives, Dr G.
Dr G 35:28
Exactly. So getting the Vestals out of the Temple of Vesta is supremely important because of the objects that the Vestals look after. These sacred objects include the palladium, this little statuette of Pallas Athena that was reportedly bought by Aeneas all the way from the battle of Troy.
Dr Rad 35:49
Fancy.
Dr G 35:50
Very fancy, and the signs of imperium. Six miscellaneous objects do not know what they look like that are very important and are usually kept in the penus, this storage room inside the Temple of Vesta,
Dr Rad 36:09
They are very cheeky Dr G. very,
Dr G 36:11
Very. A penus inside the temple.
Dr Rad 36:14
I know. The Temple of Vesta of all places!
Dr G 36:17
I know. And so they take these six miscellaneous sacred objects, which the Romans believe as long as they possess, means that they will continue to rule. So very important to have them removed from the city at this point because the city is so endangered, and to be taken to a secret off site location.
Dr Rad 36:41
Okay, so we’ve got the cult of Vesta hopefully enduring, and therefore the Romans enduring the Citadel and the Capitol. That’s like the perimeter. If that part can survive, if that sacred part of the city can survive, then there’s some hope. Obviously, they do need younger, able-bodied men to defend this place, because they’re going to be best able to do that. But also, I think there’s an element of they’re the future as well. You know, they’re the future of Rome. And of course, you do need some people who have public wisdom, hence, some senators. But what are you going to do with a really old magistracies, Dr G?
Dr G 37:23
Well, probably eat them, I’d say, as the siege goes on, being like, look, he’s as tough as leather. But, you know, times are tough.
Dr Rad 37:31
Well, the Romans aren’t quite so cut throated. They do decide that it has you know, facts have to be faced. These are the men that are going to have to accept their fate. There’s not room for everybody left in Rome to take refuge on the Citadel and the Capitol. They have to focus on the necessary people. And so some of the really old ex magistracies, they are going to have to die.
Dr G 38:00
Oh yeah, I don’t see why this can’t lead to them being eaten.
Dr Rad 38:03
Well, no no more in the sense that they can’t be put in this area of safety, they can’t be protected. They’re just going to have to take their chances in the city. Because, after all, they’ve lived their life, they’ve reached an old age. How long do they really have to live anyway? The Romans can’t waste precious resources and space on people like this. And they’re like, yep, we accept that. You know, for the good of Rome, we accept that.
Dr G 38:30
That is not okay Rome. That is a terrible decision.
Dr Rad 38:33
Hey, you were saying they should eat them.
Dr G 38:34
Well, I mean, if you’re gonna do it, do it properly. Don’t just lead them to fend for themselves in the lower parts of the city where the Gauls are.
Dr Rad 38:42
Well, that is what’s going to happen. Now we also have a lot of common people who are called plebs in my account, who also need to accept the fact that they also are not going to be allowed to be in this citadel capital area.
Dr G 38:57
Oh no, no, no. This is going badly. Rome. You’re making some terrible decisions right now. Are you telling me that the only people who get to end up on the Capitol line Hill are patricians?
Dr Rad 39:06
I didn’t say that, but I think the implication is that they probably mostly are.
Dr G 39:11
Wow,
Dr Rad 39:12
Yeah. Now
Dr G 39:13
Rome can fall Gauls sack it. You have my permission. Get in there.
Dr Rad 39:17
Hey the plebs are cool with this to a certain extent, because the ex magistracies, all these men of glory and honor, people who’ve held triumphs, people who have held the consulship, even though I don’t know how that’s possible, because it hasn’t been around very much recently.
Dr G 39:34
Well, they would have had to, it was so long ago.
Dr Rad 39:38
They come out and they make a big public declaration that they are prepared to die with the masses, especially as they were old men. They’re not going to suck up all the resources. They’re going to be brave to the end. This is meant to be, obviously inspirational. Yeah, and they actually these older men, they try and, you know, give a little bit of a pep talk to the younger men that are going to actually be doing the defending of the Citadel and the capitol as they head towards this area and prepare themselves for what they are anticipating is going to be a siege, basically saying, you know, come on, guys, you can do this. You’re strong. The fortune of this city is in your hands. You can do it. We’ve survived worse than this. I think it’s slightly selective memory going on in Livy’s here, because he definitely says that Rome will be fine, because, after all, we’ve survived and have been victorious in every war for 367 years. It is very clear that that is not the case.
Dr G 40:47
Okay, but that’s that’s not how a win record works. You have to win every time for it to continue.
Dr Rad 40:53
Yes, but I guess you know, this is not the moment to be honest. This is the moment to try and sugarcoat things, and we have this very tragic parting scene where those that are going to be defending the capital and the Citadel have to say goodbye to everybody else, and it’s made worse by women.
Dr G 41:12
Of course it is. Yeah, classic Rome. Ruined by women.
Dr Rad 41:16
The women are running around in an absolute state, asking their husbands and sons, what on earth have you agreed to? What is going on? How is this going to affect us all legitimate questions, I feel, but it’s painted as a bit of hysteria. I think, stop asking questions now. Interestingly, Livy does note at this moment that women are allowed to go with their relatives at this point. So mostly we seem to have women going with their sons, because it’s younger men who are going to the Citadel. The sons hadn’t explicitly said, Hey, Mum, why don’t you come with me? And I’ll make sure that you live through this. But they haven’t explicitly said that they’re not allowed to come because what the Romans are doing some pretty gruesome math at this point in time where they know it would obviously be better if no women go towards the Citadel and the Capitol. Because, of course, obviously they’re completely and utterly useless human beings, Dr G, and they’re just going to be taking up space and consuming valuable resources. But they know it would have been too cruel to actually say that to them and forbid them from going. So women do go, and the Romans are mad at it, but they’re also noting that, look, we could have been a lot harsher here, but we’re just we’re “Stand Up Guys”, so we didn’t forbid women from going with their family members and trying to survive.
Dr G 42:47
The flavor of distaste that I hold in my mouth right now for the Romans, it is disgusting.
Dr Rad 42:56
Look. It might make you feel a little bit better to know that Livy’s Probably being influenced in the way that he’s building up this picture by Greek writers who have written, you know, similar scenes during warfare, specifically, probably Thucydides, when he’s writing about these sorts of scenes where it’s common, I suppose, to have these tragic farewells emotional women, it’s come up before.
Dr G 43:23
I’m not sure that I like it, though.
Dr Rad 43:26
So we now have obviously, a bunch of people who know that they’re not going to be included on the Capitol Hill because there’s not enough space, not enough food. And so they start scrambling. They spread out. Some of them make for the Janiculum. Others are just running through the countryside. They’re heading to nearby towns. There is zero plan. There is no one in charge of this. They’re just trying to go with their gut, like, what’s the best situation right now? And these are mostly the plebeians, definitely, because it seems like Rome is a goner, so it’s time to up sticks and get out of there before the Gauls realize that the Romans actually have apparently just left the gates open by accident.
Dr G 44:12
Well, I put it to you that even if the gates were closed at this point in time, there’s not enough people around to really make a difference. It would only take one real solid push from a Gaul to be like, wait a minute, guys, it’s unlocked.
Dr Rad 44:29
Now this is where we get a moment that I know you will enjoy. We hear what’s happening with the flamen and the Vestals who are trying to get out of Rome with some of the sacred objects.
Dr G 44:41
Oh, yes. What does Livy have to say about this?
Dr Rad 44:43
Well, I mean, these people, they are so honorable, they’re not even thinking about what they would take in an emergency. I mean, this is where it would be fun to sit around and be like if you were an ancient Roman in 390 what would you take to escape the Gauls?
Dr G 44:58
I’d take the Palladium.
Dr Rad 45:00
They’re not even thinking about their personal stuff. They’re just trying to think, what sacred objects should we take with us? Because, of course, they can’t take all of them, because they’re going to have to carry and walk with whatever they have, apparently. Now, the interesting detail that Livy includes here is that it is the flamen of Quirinus who is with the Vestals at this moment in time.
Dr G 45:22
The flamen of Quirinus, so related somewhat to the ascension of Romulus.
Dr Rad 45:28
Well, this is the thing, right? So this is where I actually would love to have your POV, if I may. So there are obviously three major flamens In Roman religion, the Flamen of Quirinus is one of them. And then we have the Flamen Dialis, and then we have
Dr G 45:50
the Flamen Martialis.
Dr Rad 45:52
That’s the one. I always forget that one. Now, apparently it is quite unusual for the Vestals to be associated with the Flamen of Quirinus.
Dr G 46:04
Yes, but that’s only because perhaps it’s unusual for us to think about the Vestals in connection with the Flamen of Quirinus. So we have the most information from our ancient sources on the Flamen Dialis And then the flamen Martialis and the least on the flamen Quirinus. So we’re kind of caught in a crossroads of like, is it unusual that the Vestals are in league with this guy right now, or is it just unusual for us and what we know about how the priesthoods were all interconnected, so the flamens sit sort of adjacent alongside the pontificates, but outside of the pontifice as well, to a certain degree, and the Vestals sit under the pontificies. So we often expect that the Vestals will be hanging out with a greater or a lesser pontificate. But that’s not the way that things work. At a sacred perspective, in the Roman mindset, if your gods are interconnected, and they all are on some level, there’s going to be relationships that you have across the spectrum through all of these priesthoods at different times of the year, different points and moments of ritual practice, and we just don’t know. We don’t have much evidence.
Dr Rad 47:25
Mmm interesting. Okay, well, nonetheless, it’s this little band that are together now, not only are they going to be carrying-
Dr G 47:32
A highly unlikely bunch of characters, all quite quirky and on the run from the Gauls.
Dr Rad 47:39
What will they get up to next? So they obviously have to carry some stuff with them, but they also decide that they’re going to protect some objects by burying them. So first they place them in jars, presumably to make them easier to find, and also to keep them clean, and they decide that they’re going to bury these jars in bury them in a shrine next to the flarman’s house, and I quote, where is now forbidden to spit.
Dr G 48:09
We’ll have none of that around here.
Dr Rad 48:11
No, and this is where they start heading out. They’re also heading in the direction of the Janiculum. It seems like they ultimately have the goal of reaching the city of – is it Caere?
Dr G 48:23
Oh, well, that’s quite far away, but it is in that direction.
Dr Rad 48:27
Yes. Is it Caere, though, is that how you pronounce it? C, A, E, R, E, yes. Okay. Caere.
Dr G 48:33
Well, that’s how I pronounce it. I can’t guarantee it’s how it should be.
Dr Rad 48:36
They’re heading in the direction of Caere, which is quite far away. I don’t know how on earth they’re expecting to walk that way
Dr G 48:43
About 50 kilometers away
Dr Rad 48:44
And this is where they encounter a young plebeian boy, take it away. Dr G.
Dr G 48:49
A young plebeian boy.
Dr Rad 48:51
Correct, that correction. This is where they encounter a noble plebeian.
Dr G 48:55
A noble plebeian, oh, with the very definition of an oxymoron. So they’re leaving Rome. They’re wandering through the countryside with the sacred items that they’ve decided need to be carried with them. They encounter a guy called Lucius Albinus, one of the common people he’s described as and he assists them in their flight. So he’s got a cart, pushes his wife and children out of the cart, and says, my ladies, my priestesses of Rome, please hop in my cart. Humble though it is, his wife’s on the ground, “Oi! Lucius!”
Dr Rad 49:41
So why are you supposing I walk 30 miles to Caere?
Dr G 49:45
Yeah, we’re not even halfway. And so, kicks the wife and children out of the cart, takes up the Vestal Virgins, and by doing so, ensures that they’re able to get far enough away from Rome to preserve the sacred items now heaven forfend that we find out whatever happens to his wife and children that he leaves unceremoniously on the side of the road in favor of the Vestals.
Dr Rad 50:12
I think it’s very clear that they do not matter.
Dr G 50:14
They don’t make it. Maybe that’s what happens. But through this gesture, we see the continuity of the Roman state is preserved on a sacral level.
Dr G 50:25
Absolutely
Dr G 50:25
So a very important tale.
Dr Rad 50:26
And what is really – what is really interesting about this story so often, when we tell these sorts of stories, we’re like, well, this character is clearly a lay tradition that’s been added in because some family probably wants their ancestor to get a name drop or something like that. But apparently he actually appears quite early in the tradition of this story. And some of the historians I have read actually think that Albinus is, in fact, a historical figure.
Dr G 50:58
Well, it wouldn’t be the first time a plebeian has made it into an historical record, but this is a story that does get retold. So there is a version of this story in Flores who’s much, much later, and the idea that this could also have ended up in priestly records, yes, is the sort of thing that makes scholars more likely to think, “Oh, well, if it keeps cropping up in these other historians, then chances are there might be a sacral record of it.”
Dr Rad 51:30
Yeah, well, Dr G, I think we might have gotten to a moment where it’s perhaps time to wrap up, because we’ve got the Romans who are remaining in the city, getting ready to defend the Citadel. They finally got their game face on, and they are ready to face the Romans. We’ve got plebeians and a few other people scrambling through the countryside finding refuge, apparently, in very far away places. Because, yeah, Caere is an Etruscan city, which is 30 miles away.
Dr G 52:05
I was going to say, it’s like 50 kilometers away from Rome. Like, if you’re going to run away from Rome, like, do it properly? Run away.
Dr Rad 52:13
Look, I guess that’s the thinking, right? The Vestals are like, I really have to go. If they catch me, it’s all over. We’ve got the Gauls finally realizing that it is not a trap, it is just stupidity. And they’re tentatively coming into Rome and checking out what is going on. And we also have a bunch of people who are indeed still left in the city because they’ve either decided not to go, it’s just not practical. But we also have a body of older ex magistracies, etc, who are scattered throughout the city, and where they have taken up residence is, well, in their residence, they’re in their houses, and they are waiting to die because they’re pretty sure that the Gauls are going to obviously check out all the houses. Eventually they will come across them. They’re kind of expecting that they will die and whatever sort of melee breaks out. And so with Rome, once again, I’m really sorry, listeners, I really thought we were going to get to the actual sack of Rome, but it seems that, once again, we’re just on the precipice of the sack of Rome that is about to ensue. And it is indeed time, Dr G, for the Partial Pick.
Dr Rad 53:27
Oh, boy. Dr, G, the Partial Pick. Let’s tell us what in theory it’s about, and then see how the Romans do.
Dr G 53:35
In theory, the Partial Pick is a chance for the Romans to be scored against some criteria that they might have cared about if they were still with us. And it is worth a total of 50 gold Eagles, and there are five categories, so they get marked out of 10 for each category. I’m not anticipating great things from this Partial Pick, but.
Dr Rad 53:58
Biased?
Dr G 53:59
Well, just based on what
Dr Rad 54:01
You are, a partial historian.
Dr G 54:02
I am, a noble partial historian, a plebeian noble. So our first category is military clout.
Dr Rad 54:13
Clearly none to be had here.
Dr G 54:16
Cloutless.
Dr Rad 54:17
Yeah. I mean, look, we can maybe say that if we give them a lot of benefit out and go against what they themselves tell us happened, that maybe there was some strategy, and it didn’t quite go as they were planning.
Dr G 54:32
Oh yes, yeah, it was a strategy. It’s all going exactly as I planned.
Dr Rad 54:37
With people just running in every direction with whatever they can carry, with men kicking their wives and children to the curb so that they can take the vessels, because the vessels have no mode of transportation because nobody cares.
Dr G 54:53
Yeah? Intense. That’s a zero, yeah? Diplomacy.
Dr Rad 54:58
Well, no, I mean, it’s a state. Open warfare, wherever you look. Dr, G, yes, nobody’s tried talking. No, not anymore. The time for words is over, because clearly when the Gauls and the Romans talk, I mean, these guys have gone from basically not even knowing who each other really are to absolutely hating each other’s guts with the intensity of 1000 sons in a very short period of time.
Dr G 55:21
I think this is a great setup for enemies to lovers. I wait to see it. All right. Expansion?
Dr Rad 55:28
Well, yeah, no. I mean, as I say, they’re clearly on the brink of losing Rome itself at this point.
Dr G 55:33
Virtus?
Dr Rad 55:34
Ooh, okay. Now, is it possible that we say Albinus giving the virgins a lift.
Dr G 55:43
Is that an act of virtus? To push your wife and children out of your cart?
Dr Rad 55:51
For the sake of the eternal flame? Virgin women, close your eyes, give me a hand Vestal.
Dr G 56:01
I don’t think that’s virtus. I think what we might be able to say is virtus is the very old ex magistracies who have decided to remain in the city-
Dr Rad 56:11
Ah yes
Dr G 56:12
with their wise words and sort of moral uplift of those who surround them, being like, you know, what a noble death is, a death that is a Roman death, where you sit it out and you wait for the enemy to come and you do your best,
Dr Rad 56:26
yeah,
Dr G 56:26
and if you don’t make it, you don’t make it.
Dr Rad 56:28
yeah. And look, to be honest, I have to mention here something that will come up when we actually deal with what happens to them next episode. But they actually do do something special with their death, it seems. So it’s going to be quite the moment. That’s why I didn’t want to rush ahead into it. I didn’t want to, didn’t I wanted to give them their final moments of glory, their moment to shine. Exactly. I didn’t want to rush through it, because we’ve seen where rushing gets you
Dr G 56:55
all the way to curry, and
Dr Rad 56:57
they apparently accidentally, you know, whoops, yeah,
Dr G 57:00
I just misread the sign.
Dr G 57:03
So do we give you anything for that? Maybe a two, two. Well, it’s not like they’ve seen any goals yet. Like they know that the
Dr Rad 57:11
intention, we’re going to reward the intention, and then we’ll award the actual act.
Dr G 57:15
Well, they’ve said they’re going to do like, yeah. They’ve stated some wise virtus kind of thing.
Dr Rad 57:20
Yeah, and they’ve said to the plebeians, don’t worry, plebs, we’re gonna die too.
Dr G 57:25
I’m right here next to you.
Dr Rad 57:27
Exactly. It makes it all better, because I’m awesome. You get to die next to someone who’s awesome.
Dr G 57:32
Yeah, that’s a real benefit.
Dr Rad 57:33
I feel like, look, I feel like we maybe have to give them a three. Like, they’ll probably get more points next time, to be honest. But yeah, I feel like maybe a three.
Dr G 57:42
Okay, okay. And finally, is the citizen score?
Dr Rad 57:45
Oh, that’s got to be crashing through the ground into minus points at the moment.
Dr G 57:51
I – Yes, terrible time. First of all, you’re called up in a military levy, which is all ages. Essentially, if you can hold a sword, you could fight. Bad news, bad news. If you’re a woman in Rome, you’ve basically been told you don’t belong on the Capitol. We don’t want to say it explicitly, but please don’t agree to stay.
Dr Rad 58:08
Look. But they did allow them to stay. They just didn’t want to say to their faces.
Dr G 58:12
And I’m proud every single Roman women who were like, I know they want me to leave. And you know what, I’m not going to do it, to stick around and make a bad smell of myself, and they’re gonna have to know that I’m here. Good for you, lady.
Dr Rad 58:28
I think the unwritten thing as well is that it would have been pretty awful for the men who are left. Well, I mean, you would hope it would be awful for the men who are left to have to see their female relatives left behind in that situation. I mean, at best, a quick death. At worst, we don’t want to talk about it. If we’re thinking about an enemy attacking the city, they could have been taken as slaves, so they could have been brutalized, and perhaps in a sexual way, like it could have been really bad. So presumably, for morale, the men actually don’t want their female relatives to not be on the Capitol. But they’re just pointing out, as the Romans tend to do, because they are relentlessly pragmatic, that if we’re just thinking about the food and space, there is no place for women here.
Dr G 59:19
What are you doing?
Dr Rad 59:20
Yeah.
Dr G 59:22
I’m eating all your grain. Thanks for having me, but we’ve only got such a small amount. So to be a citizen at the moment is pretty bad. You’re either running away from the city or you’re staying in the city knowing that the Gauls are right outside doing their howly noises. So not a pleasant time.
Dr Rad 59:41
It’s close to midnight
Dr G 59:44
Exactly, and nobody wants to be around to see what happens. So I think a zero for the citizen score.
Dr Rad 59:50
Yep, which means that the Romans, amazingly, have managed to get some points on the board. They’ve got three golden eagles this time, Dr G. I have to admit, I wasn’t actually anticipating that when I read this account, I was like, this is just going to be zero.
Dr G 1:00:05
Across the board, they did better than we thought.
Dr Rad 1:00:07
But you know what? This is the thing. This is why we have the categories, right? Because even when things are going poorly for the Romans, this is the moment where you bound to have some sort of story to uplift in the histories. And that story is probably going to involve some sort of behavior on behalf of, I don’t know, the citizens or the patricians or something like that, which actually gives them some golden eagles. Just when you think they’re going to have absolutely zero.
Dr G 1:00:32
They do something. They pull it out of the bag.
Dr Rad 1:00:35
Yeah, it’s actually the incredibly average moments when things are kind of sailing smoothly and nothing’s really happening that they’re probably going to get absolutely nothing.
Dr G 1:00:43
Yep, and it’s like you didn’t even try this year Rome, exactly. Wow. All right, so I would say that I’m very much looking forward to our next conversation.
Dr Rad 1:00:54
We really will be talking about the sack of Rome. Look, you say that, but
Dr G 1:00:58
I have a lot of things that happened before the sack of Rome.
Dr Rad 1:01:02
Okay, well, I’m on the precipice of the attack itself.
Dr G 1:01:06
Okay, well, we’ll see. I look forward to it,
Dr Rad 1:01:09
yeah, yeah. I feel like we’ve, we’ve left things on a very Gaulish Roman encounter where somehow this has become an aggressive goodbye.
Dr G 1:01:22
Yeah? Thank you for listening to this episode of the Partial Historians. You can find our sources sound credits and transcript in our show notes. Over at partialhistorians.com we offer a huge thank you to you, if you’re one of our illustrious Patreon supporters, if you enjoy the show, we’d love your support in a way that works for you. Leaving a night’s review really makes our day. We are on Ko-Fi for one or four ongoing donations or Patreon, of course. Our latest book, “Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire”, is published through Ulysses press. It is full of stories that the Romans probably don’t want you to know about them. This book is packed with some of our favorite tales of the colorful history of ancient Rome. Treat yourself or an open minded friend to Rome’s glories, embarrassments and most salacious claims with “Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire”.
Transcribed by https://otter.ai
The post Episode 167 – The Gallic Sack of Rome – Part 2 appeared first on The Partial Historians - Ancient Roman History with smart ladies.
We’re about to embark on a stunning period of Rome’s history in the middle Republic. Strap yourself in, this one is going to a take more than a couple of episodes. We are, of course, dealing with the years that were 391/390 BCE. We begin with some of the important details that emerge for the latter part of 391 BCE which will have flow on effects for 390 BCE, which is the big ticket year that we’ll be navigating in this mini-series.
The title may have given a little away, but the Gauls are in Italy. North Italy specifically, but they are going to be travelling south and pretty soon they arrive on the doorstep of Clusium.
The Etruscan people of the city of Clusium seek support from the Romans. Unusual, yes, good for storytelling, also yes. Clusium is deep in Etruscan territory and yet it seems the Romans are willing to send a delegation to see what the Gaulish fuss is all about. The delegation is made up solely of Fabians, who are apparently meant to be neutral, but that aspect of the situation falls away pretty quickly when one of them kills a leader of the Gauls…
Rome (and particularly the Fabians) have really upset the Gauls! So much so that the Gauls make a bee-line for Rome moving swiftly through Etruscan territory to arrive at the point where the Tiber meets the Alia, just north of Rome itself. The speed of the Gallic movement catches the Romans off-guard and that’s just the beginning of their woes.
Our music is by Bettina Joy de Guzman.
Lightly edited for our wonderful Australian accents
Dr Rad 0:15
Welcome to the Partial Historians.
Dr G 0:19
We explore all the details of ancient Rome.
Dr Rad 0:23
Everything from political scandals, the love affairs, the battles waged and when citizens turn against each other, I’m Dr Rad.
Dr G 0:33
And I’m Dr G. We consider Rome as the Romans saw it, by reading different authors from the ancient past and comparing their stories.
Dr Rad 0:44
Join us as we trace the journey of Rome from the founding of the city.
Dr G 0:54
Hello and welcome to a brand new episode of the Partial Historians. I am Dr G.
Dr Rad 1:01
And I am Dr Rad.
Dr G 1:03
And together we are going to sally forth into the year that was 390 BCE.
Dr Rad 1:11
Oh, this is going to be such a big one, Dr G, I’ve already said it I predict multiple episodes in our future.
Dr G 1:16
I mean, I hope so, because I feel like I haven’t finished doing all of the reading for this episode, and if we’re doing it in just one, I don’t think I’ve gotta – there’s too much to pack in. It’s not gonna happen.
Dr Rad 1:28
Could not agree more. Dr, G, could not agree more. Now, just to do a quick recap of where we were from, 391 BCE, because I feel like these years are very tied together: 391 and 390. In 391, we talked about the fact that the Gauls are really making their presence felt in the northeast of Italy, specifically. And this is really something that’s been happening kind of behind the scenes, I guess, for our podcast, for centuries, by this point in time, because the Celts, of course, or the Gauls, whatever you want to call them, we’re talking about a really huge culture that has been spreading out all throughout all sorts of areas of Europe. And whilst there are, of course, local differences, because we’re talking about mostly tribal sort of people, the thing that seems to unite them is certain, certain aspects of their cultures, like language, maybe some art styles, maybe things like burial practices. Unfortunately, most of the written evidence we have for these cultures comes from people who are outsiders, like the Greeks and the Romans. But essentially, for centuries, they have been spreading and spreading and spreading. They’ve been coming into contact with the Celts. They’ve been coming into contact with the Etruscans. But around this time, in the early fourth century BCE, things seem to have taken a turn. Now this may be because, as I said, whilst we tend to refer to them as this sort of homogeneous group like the Celts. We are talking about different groups that are on the move for different reasons. And we know from Livy’s account, even though it might not be perfectly accurate, that there are different groups who are migrating at different times. And one of the last groups, he says that cross over the Alps and into Northern Italy is the Senones. Yes, and this group apparently landed on the doorstep of an Etruscan place called Clusium last time we spoke.
Dr G 3:34
Yes, dramatic. And apparently the Romans are friends with the people of Clusium, which is a surprise to us all as Roman historians, because Clusium is deep inside Etruscan territory. In a way, that means that it’s quite far from places like Veii, which is that southernmost Etruscan city that the Roman Rome has now just taken a few years before. And the people to the north of they directly to the north, far more south than Clusium have been like, we don’t want a bar of these Romans. So the idea that somehow Rome has springboarded over a whole bunch of people who don’t care about them to be friends with the population of Clusium defies historical belief.
Dr Rad 4:18
Well, I feel like that’s just what they’re telling the Celts, you know, they don’t want to, they don’t want to have a lack of unity, I suppose, in the face of the Celts, because, after all, they’re not friendly enough to send an army at this point in time when the Clusi, when the people of Clusium, come to the Roman senate for help, they say, ‘No, we are not going to send an army.’ And after all, we talked about this last episode, why would people this far north come all the way down to Rome to ask for help? Is it because the Celts really are just like on a rampage, and they feel like the Romans being untouched are the best people to ask? This might be where that conflict with Volsinii comes into it because the Romans have been in that region relatively recently, and maybe that’s what puts them in the mind of the people from Clusium. But to be honest, most modern historians think that this is crap.
Dr G 4:18
I was going to say even the question about the Volsinii, I feel it’s a bit problematic right now.
Dr Rad 4:18
100%
Dr G 4:18
That’s fine. That’s fine. Let’s not let historical potentials and probabilities get in the way of a great story that the Romans are pretty sure they want to tell us about this.
Dr Rad 4:36
Exactly, exactly. Instead, we’d rather listen to their side of things, which is that the people of Clusium come to them for help when the Gauls arrive and start attacking them, and they’re like, Help. Help. There are these strange, long haired people with odd weapons that look something like a sword, who are attacking us. We just don’t know what to do. Will you help us? And they say we’re not going to send an army, because we’re not that close. Boundaries. However, we will send ambassadors who will say to the Gauls, Talk to the hand. Just back off. Back off.
Dr G 6:04
Yeah, you don’t want to get involved with this. You don’t know what you’re going to be dealing with. Watch out.
Dr Rad 6:10
Oh, you’re telling us you want a piece of this action?
Dr G 6:14
I don’t know if you’ve noticed, but I’m a Fabian, and that might not mean anything to you, but it should. It really should.
Dr Rad 6:21
We’re fabulous in a terrifying way, yeah. So we’ve got this situation, and on top of that, there have been some signs Dr G that the Romans really should have been paying attention to, especially before they send a somewhat aggressive embassy off to Clusium. There have been multiple problems in the last couple of years, like the plague. That could be a sign that the gods are angry with you. We’ve had the censor of dying in office, maybe being replaced incorrectly. We’ve had voices divine, voices ignored, ignored, moving out in the middle of the night and talking to plebeians and then ignored. It’s not been great. And then on top of that, the one man that could have saved everyone from this Celtic attack has been exiled for no very good reason.
Dr G 7:13
Are we talking about Camillus?
Dr Rad 7:15
Oh, am I talking about Camillus? Who else could I possibly want to even talk about Dr G, he is just that much of a freaking hero at this point in time.
Dr G 7:27
The things that the Romans value, they really have me questioning everything
Dr Rad 7:31
I know, I know, so Rome, whether it recognizes it or not, is in a tight spot at this moment in time. Now, before we get into the magistrates, I did leave us on a bit of a cliffhanger at the end of 391 I didn’t give you the full exchange between these ambassadors, the three fabulous Fabians and the Senones, who are attacking Clusium, so I thought that might be a good lead in to the magistrates for 391 and I think you’ll see why when I get to the end of this exchange. Are you ready?
Dr G 8:04
I am ready.
Dr Rad 8:18
Excellent. So part of the issue with this whole situation is that the fabulous Fabians, this is where they transition into the foolish Fabian stocky, because they’re meant to be approaching the Gauls in a peaceful, diplomatic manner that all this trouble just gets swept under the rug.
Dr G 8:48
Easy, does it? Boys? Easy, back off. Back off. You know you go your way with Gauls.
Dr Rad 8:56
Unfortunately, Livy describes them as more like Gauls than Romans, which means that they are dialing the aggression up to 11.
Dr G 9:06
Wow.
Dr Rad 9:07
Yeah. Livy, yeah. So basically, when they extend their initial offer, which is, look, these guys are our friends. We’re the Romans. Pretty awesome. Just, uh, you know, move on your way, please. The Gauls say, look, we’ve never heard of you guys before. Either you might not know us, but we don’t know you. However, we acknowledge that you must be someone impressive if the people of Clusium are turning to you for help, because we’re obviously ferocious warriors.
Dr G 9:45
As you can see by our manner of dress, ie naked.
Dr Rad 9:49
Exactly. We’re all born naked, and the rest is drag, Dr G. Now the Gauls say we’re not going to turn away from this offer of peace. Peace that you Romans have put forth on behalf of this Etruscan city. We understand the idea of seeking the diplomatic route and not just jumping straight to warfare. We appreciate that you guys didn’t just come here with an army. So here’s the proposition that we have for you, the people of Clusium must give us some of their land. After all, the reason that the Gauls are here is that they need it.
Dr G 10:33
Yes, we are land poor. We require some of your finest grass, thank you.
Dr Rad 10:38
See this is where it contradicts, like the other stories that we’ve heard right about why the Senones have turned up here. You know, there are all these reasons that were given for, you know, Celtic migration in this time period, but realistically, it probably does come down to the fact that a they do tend to have been a bit of a migratory people. They’ve spread over a very large part of Europe already. It just seems to be their way. But yeah, they’re probably looking for resources of varying kinds.
Dr G 11:06
They’ve done this before. This is not their first time around the traps. They’re like, Clusium? It’s just the last on a long list of people who have fallen before us.
Dr Rad 11:15
That’s if it even happened, because, after all, there’s nothing in the archeological record to support this. Now they point out that, apparently, the people of Clusium had more land than they could possibly farm at this point in time, anyway. So they’re like, it would hardly be, you know, it’s not much of a wrench. Just give us some land.
Dr G 11:38
Yeah, you’re just sitting on it. Wasteful.
Dr Rad 11:39
Yeah? Exactly. So the Gauls want to hear the response of the people of Clusium in front of the Romans, because I guess the whole idea is that the Romans are meant to be kind of like referees-
Dr G 11:52
the neutral party
Dr Rad 11:53
-yeah, something, yeah, exactly. And if their offer is rejected, then it’s on like Donkey Kong, there’s going to be a fight right then and there, because this is, it’s basically like them being bought off. You know, they’re like, if you can just give us the land, then it’s peace. But if you don’t,
Dr G 12:17
Or if you, if you don’t give us the land, I’ll break your legs. If you give us the land, it’s gonna be fine.
Dr Rad 12:24
And then they say to the Romans, on top of that, we would like you to stay and watch, not just because you seem to be some sort of mutual referee in this scenario, but also because we would like you to see if war is the result just all this awesomeness. Touch this skin, baby. Touch all this skin. It’s going to be quite the show.
Dr G 12:47
You haven’t done war until you’ve done Gaulish war.
Dr Rad 12:51
Yeah, they’re basically saying you don’t understand we are the best, like Celtic warriors. Nobody can beat us. We’d like you to stay and watch the show.
Dr G 13:02
You’re surprised that we’re here, and what I can tell you is we got here by winning.
Dr Rad 13:07
Yeah. You haven’t heard of us? Well, baby, our name will be on your lips after this demonstration. The Romans, of course, completely unimpressed.
Dr G 13:18
Well, this is yeah, given what we know about the Romans.
Dr Rad 13:22
Yeah, and this seems to have hit them the wrong way, as you can imagine, with the Romans, they’re like, I’m sorry. Just who the hell do you guys think you are marching in, demanding land from the people who live there, and threatening war if they refuse. That is just rude. What the hell are you guys even doing in Etruria anyway? So things are starting to get a bit-
Dr G 13:51
-okay. It’s getting heated. Okay. It’s going to turn into a pub fight very soon.
Dr Rad 13:55
Yeah. And this is a very this is where we get the very famous response from the Gaulish people. They say, I’ll tell you where our right comes from, right here. And this is where it’d be great if this podcast was actually a video, because I could pull out a sword. They point to the tip of their sword, and they’re less like, this is how we come to be in Etruria. This is our freaking passport, mate. And they say, All things belong to the brave.
Dr G 14:22
Ooh, I like that. The Romans are going to steal that one for sure.
Dr Rad 14:27
Absolutely they are. So tempers are running high for everyone at this point in time, the Etruscans, the Romans, the Gauls, they are all at fever pitch. So naturally, they all race for weapons, because when you’re angry, it’s best to take action immediately.
Dr G 14:48
Yes, yes, yeah, don’t think about it too much. Respond with violence.
Dr Rad 14:51
Definitely not. So a fight ensues. Now this might have been expected, if not for the fact that the Fabians join in the fight on the side of the people of Clusium.
Dr G 15:06
Okay, well, this is perhaps not surprising that they would make that choice, given that they’d been called in by Clusium in the first place, but that does void their position of apparent neutrality.
Dr Rad 15:21
Yes, this is apparently breaking a very big rule. In fact, my translation and Livy calls it the law of nations, which makes it seem incredibly formal for the early fourth century BCE.
Dr G 15:35
Guys, I don’t think we’ve got nations yet, and we’re not going to have them until the 19th century.
Dr Rad 15:40
Nonetheless, what they have done here is seen as breaking a very sacred trust. They are meant to be there as neutral observers, in a way you know, they’re meant to be there as diplomats. They’re not meant to be getting involved in any war. There’s been no formal declaration.
Dr G 16:01
The fight is between the Gaulish people and the people of Clusium. And it’s like, it just so happens that the Romans are there today, but they’re not involved, and for the Romans in particular. But it sounds like Livy’s maybe extrapolating this out to all peoples of this era. Is that there is a sacred element to warfare, and the process of going to war, and the Romans have not done all of the appropriate steps to suggest that they would be the people picking up swords.
Dr Rad 16:30
Absolutely. I mean, how many times have we been through the way that the Romans declare war, right?
Dr G 16:36
Like it’s laborious, and they’ve done none of the steps they’ve taken, no fetiales with them. This is a terrible idea, foolish Fabians.
Dr Rad 16:45
Exactly. So this is just another instance of arrogance on behalf of the Romans. So before we were talking about the arrogance of, say, the military tribunes with consular power, ignoring the plebeian who came to them with the divine warning, now we’re seeing the arrogance of the Fabians joining in. This is exactly the kind of stuff that is seen as inviting doom in to the city. Because not only do the Fabians join in, because that might not have been a big deal if they’d like hung in the back and just shouted moral support, but they do it in a very obvious way. Apparently, they make sure that they’re standing right in the front. So that’s very obvious. And then one of the brothers in particular, Quintus Fabius, charges right out, gets into a fight with one of the Gallic leaders and kills him.
Dr Rad 17:31
Oh, awkward.
Dr Rad 17:33
Yeah. Not only does he kill him, he then stops and decides he’s going to despoil the body right then and then, right in front of everybody, right in front of everybody.
Dr G 17:54
While I’m eating my salad!
Dr Rad 17:57
In public? You’re gonna take the weapons in public?
Dr G 18:00
What?
Dr Rad 18:01
Now, I guess it’s because it makes it incredibly obvious, like, in the heat of battle, somebody gets killed. Yeah, you don’t have time to stop and clock who it is. However, the fact that he then stops and is like, I’m going to despoil the body right here, right now.
Dr G 18:19
Cover me. I need to despoil someone. Oh.
Dr Rad 18:22
Word very quickly spreads throughout the Celtic forces that it was a Roman who was responsible for this very prominent Gallic chieftain being killed. So the Gauls decide that they’re going to retreat. But this is not over. They now have the Romans on their list, some of the younger Gauls are saying, let’s just head to Rome straight away. Let’s settle this right here, right now. It actually makes me feel like there are kind of like young patricians amongst the Gauls, as well as in Rome itself, because we then have the older Gauls saying, no, no, let’s do this officially. Let’s send some envoys. Let’s make it clear to Rome why we are upset. Let’s use our words make sure that there is like a formal process happening here. The Romans need to give us these three Fabian brothers, because they have violated this law of nations, which, again, I find hilarious that the Celts are now talking in these terms. But sure, they’ve done something wrong, and they want these guys handed over to them, presumably to, oh, I don’t know, torture and kill them.
Dr G 19:41
Just ask the hard questions, you know. All right, well, this is really interesting. So it sounds to me very much like Livy has vastly more detail on this initial incident that happens between the Gauls and the Romans, because these ideas are coming up a little bit in other sources, but definitely not to this level of detail. Like Clusium is mentioned quite a lot, and we know that it is in northern Central Italy, on the west side of the Apennines, which makes sense, because the Gaulish people, from what we understand, have come over the Alps and are now occupying the whole area between the Alps and the Apennines. So that whole Po Valley region is part of where they’ve set up, and now they’re moving south. It would seem, these three ambassadors sent to Clusium, recorded in just about every source and identified as Fabians very frequently. Also Quintus Fabius is definitely also identified as the one who kills the Gaulish leader, which causes so much upset, and that comes up in Appian. And then we have the emergence of a questionable figure who is called King Brennus?
Dr Rad 21:03
Yes, this is the supposed leader of the Senones. Many questions raised about the name. It seems to be perhaps a retrojection.
Dr G 21:13
It does. We do have a Brennus that is in the historical record from a sort of a century, 150 years in the future, and we think that this is a retrojected name, nevertheless, they’ve got a leader, so that’s good.
Dr Rad 21:25
And you know what? It’s pronounceable. Dr, G, I’ll take it Brennus, I can say it.
Dr G 21:30
Brennus.
Dr Rad 21:30
Yeah.
Dr G 21:31
Ah Brennus, what are you up to now, Brennus? Well, and this issue with Rome having done completely the wrong thing in this situation where they were supposed to be acting neutrally allows the Gauls to take the upper hand from a sort of sacred perspective and a legal perspective. But that doesn’t mean that they’re not against intimidatory tactics, sure. So they send their biggest, strongest, most imposing Gauls as their delegation of ambassadors to Rome just to sort of be like. This is what we all look like. This is what it would be like if you were on the battlefield with us. We only eat grain and terrible beer, and we’re fighting fit and ready for anything. Are you sure, Rome, that you still want to uphold this insult against us?
Dr Rad 22:25
Yeah, well, that’s exactly where Livy takes this. When the Gauls voice their unhappiness whilst the Senate put their head in their hands and go, Oh my god, the Fabians, they do not condone what those guys did by any means, but I guess they are aware of what would happen to them if they handed them over to the Gauls for punishment. They’re so elite, the Romans cannot possibly agree to this request, but the Senate, also in Livy don’t want to be blamed if by sheltering these privileged, upper class little twats. They don’t want to be blamed if a war results, because they have taken the side of people who clearly done the wrong thing. And so in Livy’s account, they actually seek the opinion of the people.
Dr G 23:23
Interesting. So in terms of we’re getting into the territory now where, in my source material, and I’m so excited for this, the note in the Loeb edition of Diodorus for this year, because we’re heading straight into this 391-390 crossover, is that Diodorus Siculus seems to be the most robust and accurate of the sources that we have for this time period.
Dr Rad 23:49
Unbelievable. How did it come to this?
Dr G 23:51
So while I appreciate what Livy might be saying, I’m going to hold on to the nuanced hope that Diodorus Siculus is going to come through for me with these details, because he does say that the Senate gets together about this issue, they understand the severity of it, and they do agree to hand over the Fabians, because there’s really no other path out from this. There’s been a grave offense against the gods, as much as anything else, the right thing to do is to hand these guys over. It’s not going to be pleasant. The Fabians aren’t going to be happy, but it needs to be done. And then the father of the three brothers who were the ambassadors stands up and says, I am not going to let you send all three of my sons off to the Gauls. He gets in front of the people and persuades the people to overturn the senatorial decision, which Diodorus tells us is the first moment in Rome’s history where the people go against a senatorial suggestion because – what we understand about how the Senate operates is that they don’t provide a legal avenue for anything. What they do is they provide advice. It’s just that you always follow their advice.
Dr Rad 23:51
Kind of like advice while staring down the barrel of a gun.
Dr G 23:51
Yeah, I’m going to suggest to you that you really want to do this thing right now, and you look at the shotgun, point it at your face, and you’re like, it’s a great plan, and I’m on board. I love it. I love everything about it. Yeah, I think what you’ve done here is really unique and special. This is not one of those moments. It seems to be something that divides the people as well, and creates a division moment for them, where they potentially go against the Senate for the very first time. And I find this a fascinating moment for the Romans to be having in their internal politics, because they’ve been fraying around the edges for a little while. Despite their success with Veii, they’ve been on struggle street in terms of the pestilence and what appears to be their economic issues that are just ongoing. It’s just not a great time. And now we’ve got this internal wavering between, how do the mechanisms of tradition of governance operate? And now things are going to get worse for Rome,
Dr Rad 26:22
Absolutely, because this is where I lead into the magistrates for 390 regardless of what we think exactly happened. And I love your account that, to me, kind of actually makes more sense. And we have seen instances like this before, where a man has gone before the people, and, you know, begged them to spare his children based on the achievements of his family, the contributions they have made, etc, etc. This is not the first time that that kind of thing would have happened in Rome. That kind of stuff mattered. So that kind of makes sense to me. I give you points, Diodorus Siculus. But regardless of what happened or how the Fabians were saved, what really tips things over and how we lead into the magistrates for 390 is that not only are the Fabians spared the fate of being handed over to King Brennus, but they somehow end up as military tribunes with consular power in 390 BCE, this is where I would love to talk about who the magistrates are, Dr, G.
Dr G 27:25
Well, I’m glad you’ve brought it up. So we’ve got this idea that in some of our other sources, Appian in particular, mentions this idea is that not only does Rome acknowledge the wrongdoing of the fabii, but instead of handing them over to the Gauls, they refuse to do that and then go on to elevate those three Fabians into the position of military tribunate With consular power for the next year, so that in the next instance of violence, it is legitimized and anything is now possible, they’re going to arm those guys to the hilt to go back to Clusium, or wherever the Gauls happen to be, and rightfully run them through with swords rather than, whoops, I was supposed to be an ambassador. Oh, my bad. I’m wearing the wrong hat right now. Let me just change that.
Dr Rad 28:19
I was, I was just trying to stretch my arm with a spear in it, and the spear just kind of fell, yeah, and launched itself through your groin. Sorry about that.
Dr G 28:29
Yeah. I mean, it was an accident. Let me just put on my military tribune with consular power hat for a moment. Oh!
Dr Rad 28:38
Unbelievable. And understandably, of course, the Gauls see this as, hello wound, meet salt.
Dr G 28:46
Yeah, the Gauls are not happy about that. Fair enough. I wouldn’t be either. But I think this means we are now officially up to 390 BCE.
Dr Rad 28:54
We are officially in 390 BCE now.
Dr G 29:28
Well, we do have a range of magistrates to get through. So let me take you on a journey. You can guess the first three military tribunes with consular power. It’s Quintus Fabius Ambustus, Kaeso Fabius Ambustus and Numerius Fabius Ambustus, the foolish Fabian, and one of them still with like a sore hand from all the stabbing like Ow. We may also have Quintus Sulpicius Longus. Quintus Servilius Fidenas, who we have previously seen as a military tribune, and Publius Cornelius Maluginensus. So all of these names should be familiar, except for Longus, who I don’t think has appeared before. They’re all patrician, keeping in that grand old idea of sure military tribunes with consular power is open to the plebs, but nobody ever puts themselves forward. I don’t understand!
Dr Rad 30:28
Well. I love, actually, the fact that Livy says about the election of the Fabians that wealth and power mattered even more to the people, and that’s why they got elected.
Dr G 30:39
Oh…
Dr Rad 30:39
Livy, what? What are you talking about? What have the conflict of the orders even been about? It’s like all these moments where he talks about how the plebeians get swoony whenever they’re confronted with the very bluest of blood.
Dr G 30:54
I just go weak at the knees. Yeah, I’m all gorgonzola dolce. Yeah. Look, it’s tough. We also have surprise, surprise, a dictator.
Dr Rad 31:06
I don’t know if we should say his name. I feel like it ruins it.
Dr G 31:12
We’ll leave that for you to guess everybody. No, it’s Marcus Furius Camillus.
Dr Rad 31:17
Ah, he’s back, back, back, back, back again.
Dr G 31:21
It’s his big ticket year. His master of the horse is Lucius Valerius – we think – Poplicola. Now, he was previously a military tribune in 394. We have seen this guy, he’s got a little bit of experience. Obviously, he likes horses, or -because we’re not sure – it could be Lucius Valerius Potitus, also a man of great experience, was consul in 393, 392, and military tribute in 414, 406, 403, 401, and 398.
Dr Rad 31:54
Experienced people out of the way,
Dr G 31:56
Yeah, we don’t know which one. It’s definitely a Valerius.
Dr Rad 31:59
Well, and this would kind of make sense, because we’ve talked about the fact that it’s possible that the Fabians are showing up in here because of an earlier source babies picked up, and therefore, maybe we’ve got some families sometimes being inserted into the history of this period, maybe when they actually didn’t have anything to do with it. It’s hard to know or exaggerating their role, perhaps, although I don’t know why you’d want your ancestors to be these three douchebags. But also, with the Valerii, there is also an earlier source from this clan as well that Livy sometimes is relying on. So again, it would kind of make sense to see Valerii here as well. Not that I’m saying that they’re making it up, but again, to highlight their family’s role in this, to make sure that it’s remembered, perhaps it makes sense.
Dr G 32:51
That’s right. I mean, if you can’t be Camillus, attach yourself to him
Dr Rad 32:56
Very tightly. Ride those coattails, baby.
Dr G 33:00
Literally, we also have some pontifices named which I think is it’s always a good time for me when we get in – we’ve got some named religious folk.
Dr Rad 33:10
I thought you’d be excited.
Dr G 33:12
I am, but I’m not so sure if I’m excited about the names. A potential Marcus Folius Flaccinator. Oh, the Flaccinator!
Dr Rad 33:22
A priest who’s a Flaccinator? I haven’t heard of such a thing.
Dr G 33:27
He’s just flacking around here and there. Anyway. His name comes up quite a few times in different sources. So it seems to be real. We also have another person, Gaius or Kaeso, Fabius Dorsuo, which does not sound like a Roman name to me –
Dr Rad 33:43
very strange
Dr G 33:44
But let us not ask too many questions about that.
Dr Rad 33:46
And a patrician?
Dr G 33:47
There are various spellings on that as well. Yeah, and a patrician, yeah? Well, he is a Fabian, so I suppose he has that going for him.
Dr Rad 33:54
I know. But it’s such a weird cognomen.
Dr G 33:56
It is. What is going on? Not entirely sure. We also have a reference to an augur or a pontifex, not entirely sure. Quintus or Servilius, Priscus or Structus Fidenas. This is how little we know his name. His name is, Servilius. All the other names seem to be up for question, Servilius, son of Publius, who is succeeded by somebody who we know even less of their name, it might be Furius Fusus, but what’s their praenomen? No idea. And we have some other notables as well who aren’t in magisterial positions, but we should probably just keep an eye out for a guy called Quintus Caedicius, Brennus, obviously, of the Gauls, Cominius Pontius and Marcus Manlius, also known as Marcus Mallius.
Dr Rad 34:59
Macho, macho man.
Dr G 35:01
Oh yeah, the things he’s gonna do just to wait. I love it. These are the folk that I have on deck for this banner year of 390 BCE, also known in popular culture as the Sack of Rome by the Gauls.
Dr Rad 35:20
Ooh, there we go. Well, Livy is definitely leaning into the drama of this moment. You know, I said before, when we were talking in a previous episode that he kind of skimmed over what seems to be a fairly major moment for Rome, and that is Camillus supposed trial and his exile and all of that kind of stuff. But that’s because he wants to get to this moment. Dr, G, I mean, wants to. I’m sure it was shameful, but he, he certainly wants it to balance out his narrative.
Dr G 35:48
I just don’t know why you wouldn’t draw emphasis to all of the things that goes wrong for Camillus, because surely that will put everything on a slightly different balance in the end, in terms of his narrative.
Dr Rad 36:00
Don’t worry.
Dr G 36:01
But, but I don’t know where he’s going with his narrative, because I haven’t read him. So?
Dr Rad 36:10
Camillus will get his moment in the sun again, don’t you worry. So Livy is definitely building up a sense of impending doom as we get closer and closer to the Sack of Rome by the Gauls. And the way that he tells the story of 390 it’s very much a big narrative. That’s the sense that we get. So Rome is now facing this enemy that they know almost nothing about, which is a very unusual situation for them, because they are generally fighting people that they can throw stones at
Dr G 36:41
Yeah, the guy next door, that guy, I know how he swings. I’ve seen it a million times, and I want my sandals back.
Dr Rad 36:48
How many times have we traded sandals? It’s getting crazy. Now, unfortunately, this whole magistrate list that we’ve just gone through highlights a very odd choice for Rome at this moment, but they’re facing an unknown enemy with strange weapons, and yet they don’t choose a dictator straight away, even Livy thinks this is cray-cray.
Dr G 37:16
Guys, you got an enemy on the doorstep, and what are you doing about it? Military tribunes with consular power will do.
Dr Rad 37:23
Yeah. Let’s have about six or seven or eight guys in charge. That seems legit.
Dr G 37:29
Could it be that they’re not expecting the Gauls to do what the Gauls do?
Dr Rad 37:34
Look it’s possible. And this is where I might highlight something that is actually going to make your ‘Meanwhile in Sicily’ segment very worthwhile for everybody. So we have had this whole backstory about the foolish Fabians, the people of Clusium, etc, etc. Some modern historians, however, have suggested that it is actually an accident of history that the Gauls, perhaps the Senones, end up on Rome’s doorstep, that in fact, they had been hired to act as mercenaries by the tyrant Dionysus. Wait, is it Dionysius?
Dr G 38:19
Dionysius of Syracuse.
Dr Rad 38:19
Dionysius of Syracuse, and they’ve been hired by this guy to be mercenaries whilst he’s trying to, I don’t know, fight people of Krypton down in Southern Italy.
Dr G 38:30
We’re gonna have a pincer movement, essentially. What’s going to happen is, you’ll move from the north, while I come up from the south. And what we’ll do is we’ll wedge them, and then we’ll steal all the Roman pizza and go home.
Dr Rad 38:44
Yeah. So maybe they were actually on the move, and the reason that they were heading, you know, so far south, is because they have a job to do, and the sacking of Rome is just something that they happen to do on the way that there’s actually no beef in particular, not first really paid, not really and that might explain why the Romans don’t automatically pick a dictator at this moment in time, because whilst they might be aware that there are more aggressive Gauls than usual on the Rome causing some problems. They might not have been anticipating an attack. You see it all heads up, Dr G.
Dr G 39:26
Well, and I think from a practical level, if I’m putting my ‘What if I pretend I was a military historian’ hat on, I’m definitely not. So this could go badly. Military historians, please contact me and comment on this episode. But where Clusium is, we’re talking a good sort of, I think, about 100 kilometers north of Rome. So definitely, in terms of what is going on geographically for the Gauls to move as far south as they do to come to. Rome’s doorstep, which, spoilers everybody, that’s what’s going to happen. They have to have gone through substantial amounts of Etruscan territory, plus other Italic peoples who are in contact and live in those areas as well, and to basically have had the agreement that they can move through those lands freely and take what they need. Because we are told, Diodorus Siculus tells us that the Gaulish force, equates to, by the time gets to Rome, it’s about 70,000 strong.
Dr Rad 40:34
Yes.
Dr G 40:35
We are not talking about a small band of nude Gaulish warriors. We’re talking about 70,000 people armed coming through substantial tracts of Italian land to get to Rome. And to do that, they would have had to strip the land bare, just from a logistics perspective, to keep themselves alive. You know, how do you eat? How do you fuel? What are you going to do? How do you take all of your stuff with you? People are either letting you through and letting you strip part of their fields, being like, I don’t want to encounter those guys. Please, just take what you need and go.
Dr Rad 41:12
And for God’s sake, put some clothes on.
Dr G 41:14
Please. Also this tunic, I made it just for you. And the idea that nobody would be resisting them, I think is part of the bigger question that I have about the narrative at this point. Because if they’re not encountering any resistance, what does that tell us about how things are going for the Etrurians [i.e. Etruscans], by and large, across the board, because it seems like we’ve talked about Rome having this sort of shocking time of it’s not a prosperous time. That also seems to be true for the Etruscans. What we do know from archeological records is that trade goods have really dried up, so people aren’t buying and selling in the same quantities that they were 50-70 years ago. So is Etruscan territory just ripe for the picking, and you can just take an army through there, and nobody’s gonna stand in your way. I don’t know.
Dr Rad 42:05
Well, and to build into that larger picture, whilst I am by no means an expert on what is happening for the Celts at this point in time, I believe that there has, it’s mooted that there have been some problems for some of the Celtic groups that we’re talking about, and that some of them have become sort of more militaristic. And this, obviously, is probably also driving some of the reasons for migration at this point in time. And it is thought, I think, that the Senones, if it is indeed this group, that the Romans are encountering, are one of those groups that has become like a slightly more aggressive breed of Celts, and they have actually come from what is now modern day Champagne, I believe.
Dr G 42:53
Hmmm, one of the great theories that is put forward in one of the ancient sources is that the Gauls move south because they are too hot. They just need to cool off somehow. Let’s, let’s go south. And I hate to break it to them, but it’s going to be a long way south before they hit somewhere cool.
Dr Rad 43:10
I was gonna say, yeah.
Dr G 43:11
It would have been cooler if they went back over the Alps.
Dr Rad 43:14
Yeah, Italy is not the place.
Dr G 43:16
No.
Dr Rad 43:16
Particularly Southern Italy.
Dr G 43:18
Yeah. So I feel like they took a wrong turn, maybe got a bit lost, and they’re like, I’m trying to find somewhere cool.
Dr Rad 43:24
Yeah, but this is not the narrative that Livy is building up here. I mean, it’s kind of funny in a way, that the Romans are taking this path where it’s like, it’s all our fault, when actually it might have been kind of a weird accident of history, but that’s not the way they’re playing it. What Livy tells me is that now that we have these military tribunes with consular power, half of which are made up of foolish Fabians, things do not get any better. In 390 BCE, they are no wiser now that they are magistrates.
Dr G 44:01
Damn.
Dr Rad 44:02
Yeah.
Dr G 44:02
I thought, I thought wisdom came with the position.
Dr Rad 44:05
Automatically, politicians become smarter as soon as they are given an official title. Instead, these guys are preparing for war, but they’re conducting the levy of troops like they’re about to just go trotting out across the field and fight the Volscians, just like they always do. They don’t seem to be preparing for anything extraordinary, in spite of the fact that they have been explicitly told to their faces that the Senones are awesome.
Dr G 44:37
Well, this is what happens when you don’t listen, when people tell you the truth and you just don’t hear it.
Dr Rad 44:43
Yeah, now on top of that, the Gauls are, of course, as we’ve said, even more riled up than they would normally be, because they have found out that the Fabians, instead of being punished in any way, have in fact, been rewarded, it would seem, by being given. In an official state position and leading the Roman people so they could not be any angrier at this moment in time.
Dr G 45:07
It’s, it’s an insult of a high magnitude. Not only did you not handle these guys ever, but you’ve rewarded them. And now, now what?
Dr Rad 45:16
Yeah, and this is where we get a little racist aside from Livy, where he says that the Gauls were naturally prone to uncontrollable anger slash rage.
Dr G 45:26
Wow.
Dr Rad 45:28
Now this is something that comes up in a number of Graeco-Roman accounts, the idea that these barbaric people, I’m using my flesh rabbits here, Dr G, are prone to extreme emotions, one of which is anger.
Dr G 45:43
Yes, wow. And we can tell this because obviously they don’t have moderatio. They don’t know how to, you know, balance things out, yeah?
Dr Rad 45:52
Because clearly the Romans are so good at that.
Dr G 45:54
Yeah, that’s what I’m saying.
Dr Rad 45:57
Yeah. So their rage is fueling them at this point in time, and they are on a quick march, which is super speeded after all the anger, because they are absolutely spoiling for a fight with the Romans. They just breeze through all the cities in between where their main camp, obviously was, and Rome itself. They do, of course, cause consternation as they go, but the Gauls make it very clear to everybody as they’re rushing past, can’t stop, can’t speak, Sorry, can’t chat. We’re dealing with Romans. They’re the people we’ve really got a problem with here. Yes, I would like that bread. Yes, I am going to steal your sheep. But don’t you worry, not you. I have a problem with I’m not angry with you, but I angry with you. I’m angry with Romans.
Dr G 46:38
I’m having some emotions, and I’m directing them accordingly. Out of my way. Don’t make me hurt you.
Dr Rad 46:44
Yeah. Now the Romans, of course, had had plenty of signs that trouble was coming, but what really-
Dr G 46:46
All the people fleeing from the north being like the Gauls are coming!
Dr Rad 46:57
What’s really freaking the Romans out, though, at this moment in time is the speed of the calls. They’re like, this is like some sort of ancient blitzkrieg. Has someone given them crystal meth? How are they moving so fast?
Dr G 47:12
Well, I suppose, maybe they don’t have a lot to carry.
Dr Rad 47:16
Now, the Romans have tried to get their own army together as quickly as possible, but they actually don’t get very far outside of Rome before they encounter the Gallic forces. So they meet at this now very famous place, Dr G where the Tiber and the Alia rivers converge about 11 miles outside of the city. This is where the encounter that is going to remain imprinted on Roman brains for centuries is going to take place. So we’re meeting at what will become known as the Battle of the Alia, the Gauls are already there and waiting, Dr G, they’ve set themselves up. Well, they’re making lots of noise because they are barbarians, wink, wink. They can’t help themselves. What are the foolish Fabians going to do next? I think we might have to leave it on a cliffhanger and find out next episode.
Dr G 48:18
Nooooo! To position Alia. So if we think of a being really quite close to Rome, just a little bit to the north.
Dr Rad 48:28
Yep
Dr G 48:29
Alia is north of Rome, but east of they right, so a little bit further over, because the Tiber sort of wraps around, and the Alia is a tributary that feeds into it. So I think we’re in for a fascinating time. I’m looking forward to our next episode together, but before then, it must be time for the Partial Pick.
Dr G 48:54
It definitely it’s time for the Partial Pick. I just wasn’t sure if there was going to be a ‘Meanwhile in Sicily’.
Dr G 49:01
Oh, well, I feel like I’m going to save my ‘Meanwhile in Sicily,’ perhaps for the last episode.
Dr Rad 49:02
That sounds fair.
Dr G 49:03
Yeah.
Dr Rad 49:03
All right, then it is indeed time, Dr G, for the Partial Pick. So, Dr G, what is the Partial Pick all about?
Dr G 49:18
The partial pick is about judging Rome as they deserve to be judged.
Dr Rad 49:24
I feel like we’ve been pretty judgy this episode already.
Dr G 49:28
Just you wait the judgment begins for real. Now, they are capable of winning 50 golden eagles. Is they amazing in every single category, there are five categories. They get 10 each if they do amazingly well. So our first category is military clout.
Dr Rad 49:49
I would say not.
Dr G 49:50
We haven’t seen any military-i-ness yet. We’ve seen preparedness for military encounters, but not an actual fight, unless we count what the ambassadors did.
Dr Rad 50:01
I was gonna say
Dr G 50:02
It’s not military, but they were supposed to be neutral.
Dr Rad 50:05
They were, but I was gonna say for military clout. Do we count the fact that one of the Fabians managed to kill a Gallic chieftain? I mean, sure he wasn’t supposed to, but he did. Probably no.
Dr G 50:18
No. I’m – yes – I feel like we’re on a zero here.
Dr Rad 50:22
Let’s not be like the Romans reward bad behavior.
Dr G 50:24
Yeah? Let’s not. The second category is diplomacy. If we could give minus marks, this would be the time.
Dr Rad 50:32
I was gonna say, this would be the episode to give them minus marks, yeah?
Dr G 50:36
So a clear zero. Expansion?
Dr Rad 50:40
Most decidedly not, they’re going to be lucky to hold on to their own city, let alone anywhere else.
Dr G 50:45
Welp. Virtus?
Dr Rad 50:48
Ooooo again. I feel like minus points might –
Dr G 50:51
I was gonna to say, whatever the Fabians did, it was bad enough that even the Romans agreed that it shouldn’t have been done.
Dr Rad 50:57
I’m sure somewhere out there, somewhere. Camillus is being very virtuous, but we don’t know what he’s doing.
Dr G 51:07
Well, I mean, he’s apparently in Ardea, of which, you know, not the worst place to be in the world, but not near Rome, and that is going to become an issue in future episodes. And lastly is the Citizen Score.
Dr Rad 51:21
Well, again, I feel like it’s pretty bad, although the citizens seem also blissfully unaware of the real threat to them at this moment in time.
Dr G 51:33
And if we follow Diodorus Siculus, this is a moment where the people stand up to the Senate.
Dr Rad 51:39
That’s true. That’s true. Does that make, but that’s the thing, they kind of make the unfortunately, in this situation, they actually make a terrible decision.
Dr G 51:49
Proving, once again, why the senators should be in charge. And you know what? And also they’re persuaded to do it by the Fabians’ dad, and so it’s not like they’ve gone out and being like this is a terrible thing of their own bat. They’ve been persuaded that this is a terrible thing by the guy who is most emotionally invested in the ongoing continuation of his son’s lives.
Dr Rad 52:12
And also he persuades them, I believe, by drawing on just how fabulous the Fabians have been all this time they’re like, guys, like, look at the family I’m from. I mean, come on, we’re lucky. Two of us survived. You can’t kill more of us.
Dr G 52:29
Now we’ve tried so hard to repopulate.
Dr Rad 52:32
We’ve done such an amazing job. Here we are, like, 80 years later, standing strong.
Dr G 52:37
Proving once again, that we should not send our men out by themselves.
Dr Rad 52:41
You know what? This is, again, it’s like a Krypton thing, you know, like, the further away from Rome we get, the worse we become.
Dr G 52:49
Terrible. Terrible.
Dr Rad 52:50
Yeah. And so this is the thing. It’s, it’s kind of one of the this is where I actually kind of don’t believe Diodorus this account, in one sense. I mean, regardless of whether your patrician are probably in family matters to Rome, sure. So it’s possible that what he said happened happened, but I still feel like it actually is far more likely that the Senate are protecting some of their own.
Dr G 53:14
Hmm, yeah. Well, it wouldn’t – we would be unsurprised by that.
Dr Rad 53:18
Yeah. I mean rich and privileged people trying to make sure that other rich and privileged people don’t pay the price for a really terrible thing that they’ve done. Who’s ever heard of that happening in history?
Dr G 53:33
What? The consequences of my own actions?
Dr Rad 53:36
Young patricians being absolute douchebags and just getting away with it.
Dr G 53:42
So I get to keep my Ferrari. You do.
Dr Rad 53:45
Yeah, Dad, all I did was kill a Gallic chieftain. You can’t take away my time on my Game Boy. Game Boy, wow. Really dating myself with that reference, aren’t I? Xbox. I’m going to edit in Xbox.
Dr G 54:01
So I think for the citizen score, I think we might be sitting at maybe a five, because,
Dr Rad 54:05
Oh god, that’s generous.
Dr G 54:07
Well, they haven’t been directly attacked themselves yet, and they don’t realize how bad it is, and they have taken some like affirmative action for their own power, potentially being like, you know what, Senate, no, we’re gonna put those guys and save them.
Dr Rad 54:20
Yeah, I know, but still, like the lingering effects of plague, the economic downturn, can it really be as good as a five?
Dr G 54:28
I don’t know, but it’s certainly, certainly not terrible.
Dr Rad 54:31
I feel like it’s more a three. I mean, Gauls are rampaging. They might not be in Rome yet, but they are rampaging.
Dr G 54:37
Look, what you can’t see, you can’t fear. Four, I say.
Dr Rad 54:43
Duh, all right, fine, four, which means Dr, G, if my math is correct, four plus zero plus zero plus zero plus zero equals four golden eagles for Rome.
Dr G 54:56
Wow, yeah, look, you had me stunned when you’ve said, ‘If my maths works,’ I was like, there’s nothing to do maths on. There was only one score. I see what you did there? Rome, yeah, look, I don’t anticipate it getting any better next year either.
Dr Rad 55:14
Let’s face it, the citizen score is gonna drop.
Dr G 55:17
It’s gonna go down.
Dr Rad 55:18
Alright, Dr G, well, I can’t wait to get into our next episode on 390 BCE, and believe us, listeners, you do not want to miss this.
Dr G 55:35
Thank you for listening to this episode of the Partial Historians. You can find our sources, sound credits and transcript in our show notes. Over at partialhistorians.com. We offer a huge thank you to you, if you’re one of our illustrious Patreon supporters. If you enjoy the show, we’d love your support in a way that works for you. Leaving a nice review really makes our day. We are on Ko-Fi for one or for ongoing donations or Patreon. Of course, our latest book, ‘Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire’, is published through Ulysses Press. It is full of stories that the Romans probably don’t want you to know about them. This book is packed with some of our favorite tales of the colorful history of ancient Rome. Treat yourself or an open minded friend to Rome’s glories, embarrassments and most salacious claims With ‘Your Cheeky Guide to The Roman Empire.’
Transcribed by https://otter.ai
The post Episode 166 – The Gallic Sack of Rome – Part 1 appeared first on The Partial Historians - Ancient Roman History with smart ladies.
We are thrilled to sit down with Dr Francesca Fulminante to chat all about the development of settlements in central Italy from the Bronze Age to the Archaic Period of Rome. Dr Fulminante shares insights from her recent monograph: The Rise of Early Rome – Transportation Networks and Domination in Central Italy, 1050-500 BCE (2023) (Cambridge University Press).
This is a period where archaeological investigation reigns supreme requiring researchers to get into the nitty gritty layers of settlement patterns and trading networks. We’re thrilled to learn from Dr Fulminante as her research involves the investigation of complex societies in central Italy during the Bronze Age, looking at things like social stratification, settlement organisation, and craft community practices. Dr Fulminate is a Senior Research Fellow in the Department of Anthropology and Archaeology at the University of Bristol, and is an Associate Professor at University Roma Tre. Her work also involves offering continuing education training at the Universities of Oxford and Cambridge.
Coming to grips with the early evidence for Rome and central Italy involves understanding some of the overlapping terminology used by archaeologists and historians, who are coming to the evidence from different perspectives. Terms like the Bronze Age and Iron Age come to us from archaeology and anthropology while specific periods like the Archaic period and Early Roman Republic are much more society specific and tend to come from historians. This overlap can create a little bit of confusion, so here’s a rough breakdown (including some of the overlapping terms):
Dr Fulminante takes us through the early settlements of the Bronze Age and the transition to permanent structures in stone rather than perishable materials that occurs in from the 8th century BCE onwards. What does the evidence suggest for the development of ancient cities and the interconnections between them? Tune in to find out!
Things to listen out for:
Our music is by Bettina Joy de Guzman.
Lightly edited for our wonderful Australian accents 🙂
Dr Rad 0:15
Welcome to the Partial Historians.
Dr G 0:19
We explore all the details of ancient Rome
Dr Rad 0:23
Everything from political scandals, the love affairs, the battles waged and when citizens turn against each other, I’m Dr Rad
Dr G 0:33
And I’m Dr G. We consider Rome as the Romans saw it, by reading different authors from the ancient past and comparing their stories.
Dr Rad 0:44
Join us as we trace the journey of Rome from the founding of the city.
Dr G 0:57
Hello and welcome to a brand new episode of the Partial Historians. I am one of your hosts, Dr G
Dr Rad 1:05
and I am Dr Rad,
Dr G 1:07
and we are very excited to welcome Dr Francesca Fulminante to the show. Hello!
Dr Fulminante 1:14
Hello, thank you. I’m very happy to be here. Thank you for the invitation.
Dr G 1:18
We’re very excited to chat to you. So for listeners who want a little bit of background information, Dr Fulminante is a senior research fellow in the Department of Anthropology and archeology at the University of Bristol and an associate professor at University Roma Tre and also teaches in continuing education at Oxford and Cambridge universities. Her research involves the investigation of complex societies in Rome and the surrounding regions, looking at things like social stratification, settlement organization and craft community practices. And we are really thrilled to be having a chat with Dr Fulminante today because of her work that is associated with these early periods of what becomes Rome. And this is really where we in the podcast have been situated for a long period of time. So I think delving into this from a new perspective is going to be really fun. So one of the key publications is “The Urbanization of Rome and Latin Vetus from the Bronze Age to the Archaic Era”, which came out in 2014 and we’re going to be talking a little bit about some of the ideas that come up in Dr Fulminante’s latest book, “The Rise of Early Rome: Transportation Networks and Domination in Central Italy 1050 to 500 BCE”, which came out in 2023 with Cambridge University Press. So I’m super excited for this. I’m like, this is the period of Rome where we’re like, what is even happening? What is going on? And this is the kind of work which I think is really going to shed new light on what we can say about this period. So when we’re thinking, just to get us sort of in the headspace, I’m wondering, Francesca, if you can help us with what does it really mean when we talk about things like the Bronze Age and the Archaic Period in this context? Because I think for listeners, these things can kind of seem a little bit murky, even though they might be quite defined. So what would you say about this?
Dr Fulminante 3:25
Now, certainly that’s a bit of technical terms and jargon for the for the archeologists, but the period between the Bronze Age and the Archaic period is a long period starting from 2300 BC, which is the beginning of the Bronze Age, to 500 BC, which is the end of the Archaic period. And as you said, it’s an important period, because it is when a lot of important city in western Europe were born, and with Western Europe mainly, I mean Crete, Greece, Italy and Spain. For Northern Europe is a bit different because the process is a bit later. So between the Bronze Age and the Archaic period, we have this process where in the early Bronze Age, some permanent settlements are formed, especially on top of hilltops, because are more defendable and people are a bit more safe. And then there is this tendency for settlement to go in higher places then the villages of the Bronze Age sometime develop into large settlement of the Iron Age, and this is between 1800 BC, or another process happened like in southern Etruria, especially when a lot of small village are. Abandoned, and the people converge on this larger plateau, the large, broad urban settlement they later will become the city of the Archaic period. And as I said, some of the city of the Archaic period are still long lasting until now, like Rome, Bologna, or which are probably more known in Italy, or also some lesser known cities, like Cerveteri or Palestrina that are also in Lazio and Etruria. So it’s really a very intriguing time, because we have these, really the summit of urbanization, the beginning of lives, as we know today, because in the Bronze Age there were only villages. So people will still live in huts and maybe add a little garden around the house from which they could get their sustainment. Then in this is still the case in the produr Urban pier, but as I said, they already lived in the big big settlement that will be later cities, a very important time. Is the middle of the eighth century before Christ, because that is the time when we are the development of fortification of communal cult places. Is the beginning of the forum in Rome. So even if all these structures are still imperishable material. So, for example, the fortification wall is in Earth an earthwork. The cult place is still an hut. The farm is just an open space. So there isn’t any building, but there is already the political place, the places where political action happens. So there is probably already a community of citizens. So archeology normally thinks that the middle of the eighth century BC is when really cities start as a community. Then in the Archaic period, which is when we go down to the fifth century, all of these perishable buildings are made in stone. So we have the beginning of houses with stone foundation. We have the big Capitoline temple on the Capitoline Hill the other temple in Rome, the big sewage collector, the Cloaca Maxima. So really, city starts to look up a little bit more like we know a city today. So that’s why so exciting, because we have a complete transformation from a little village of little arts and perishable material to the proper city that we we know of today. That’s what I find so exciting, to be able to study such a moment of important transformations.
Dr Rad 7:50
It’s actually not a period I suppose most people know much about, and I don’t think even many academics necessarily spend a lot of time looking at this really early period, what drew you to researching this time?
Dr Fulminante 8:05
Yes, thank you. Well, maybe a little bit by chance and a little bit because I was so lucky to be born in Rome. So actually, I didn’t want to be an archeologist since I was a child, but it was a matter of choice. When I arrived at university. My first choice at university was to be a philologist, so actually to study the literary sources of the ancient world. But then at the University of Rome, there was a course in archeology. And I said, okay, I want to try that. So I went to the course in archeology, and the topic was exactly this one, that it was by about that time that the fortification wall around the Palatine was discovered and starting to be talked about. So I got fascinated by these early discoveries, and then I also did a dig in the form Romanum. And really I enjoyed very much because, because I realized that archeology is for me, at least for me, it’s fascinating, because you have always new discoveries and new things to study and to learn about. I’m sure also the ancient sources can be re evaluated and rediscovered. But in a way, is a little bit more limited. While with archeology, there is always something new and exciting happening. So that’s why I decided to go into the material side of history. But still, I use both. I try to combine both, because, in fact, actually, in my in my book, I also tried a bit to combine both material culture and literary sources.
Dr G 9:49
Fantastic. A word to the philologists out there. You’re going to have to change your habits. You got to find some new material guys, the archeologists, they’re they’re on to you. They know you’re just working with the old stuff.
Dr Fulminante 10:02
Yes, we actually have to collaborate.
Dr G 10:07
So you note in your book that there are some real challenges around defining exactly what makes an ancient city a city, and it’s an active discussion amongst scholars. So I’m interested in your take on what are some of the key features of ancient cities that emerge from your research. And obviously my lead in, because of my bias, is how unique or ubiquitous was Rome in the context that it’s in, sitting in central Italy amongst other sides.
Dr Fulminante 10:42
Yes, this is the question of 100,000 million dollars. But of course, even if the city started to be debated since ancient orders, is still very much a topic of debate. I would say that in the last 30 or 40 years, maybe the dominant model was, was looking at, because we are in a classical tradition, was to look at Greek and Roman cities, to see what define Greek and Roman cities, and take that as a model. So, as I mentioned, the idea of a city, especially a certain by Gordon Childe made a list of 10 characteristics. So the characteristic were having fortification, having a population of a certain size, having at least a certain level of trade, having at least a certain level of cross specialization, having at least a certain level of cross specialization, building, architectural building, and so on. And I maybe I not mentioned all the terms, but roughly about that, what I like is actually they but this kind of to do list or shopping list, sometimes it’s a bit difficult, because you can have some aspects and not some other. So how you develop, how you define, which are the real city, only the one there they take all the 10 characteristic or also the one that tick eight out of 10 is a bit debatable. I like the perspective that we was actually an inner perspective from the ancient people. I there is a while ago, there has been a big study conducted by the Copenhagen, Copenhagen Research Institute, and they tried to to define what is a city. So they started collecting all the cities in in Greece, and try to see what they had, as you said, what they had in common and what’s not so. Partially, they came up with the traditional view, as I just said, so fortification, an agora, religious building, political building, craft trade, as I said. But also they they published an article, which I found very interesting, because they they found out that in the ancient description, an inscription is something written on stone. They were they were common in the ancient Roman Greece. Sometimes they were public, public description, like the dedication of a monument, or there was a treaty inscribed on stone so everybody could see what the treaty said. And in this inscription, the word “poleis” is actually mostly used to indicate the community of citizens. Is not easy to indicate the physical city, but actually the people. So I think that’s why we have to look to define a city, and in that sense, I believe as going back to what I said before, when we have a forum or an agora where we know the citizen was taking decision, or when we have a communal place for cult activity, when we have a fortification that indicates the communal intent of people to work together for a common goal, that is where we start having a city. Another important aspect that I emphasize is my work is also the point of connectivity. So we have to think that, as you, as you said, was wrong, peculiar, or was like many others? Well, no, it was. It was actually like many others, not only in central Italy, but in the wider Mediterranean. City didn’t born and grow on their own, but they developed in collab, in a sort of collaboration. My work, and also some other more recent scholar are talking about networks of cities. So it’s important the connectivity among them, and also the fact that when one node develops some new techniques on novelty, it spreads to the other and so on, so they develop a sort of of reciprocal influence. And this is a bit of a new concept developed in the last 10, 10-15, years. Because before, before that, there was a traditional idea that this, the first cities were born in the Near East. And I’m actually not denying that. Of course, they were the the earlier, the most important ones. But then the idea was that the city then moved to central Greece with the Minoan and Mycenaean civilization, and then through the colonies to Western Europe, as I try to demonstrate in my work, actually, as we have partially said in this podcast, there was already a lot going on locally from the Bronze Age onward. So as I said, it’s probably, rather than seen as a diffusionist movement from east to west, is more likely to be seen as a network. Now, the only thing I wanted to add is that, on the other hand, I did also some some more recent research on a particular phenomenon, which is burial under the houses. And actually that one seems to follow, again, a little bit the movement from east to west. So I think a little bit both perspective are throwing away. So the cities of the Near East are really the first one, and more important, probably they had an impact on all the rest, but also, at least since the Iron Age onward, the other, the little the other cities in Europe, like I said, in Greece, in Italy or Spain, probably developed as a network. And we also see in the in the tomb of people, because we have some important warriors that are mainly the chief of the cities that have objects coming from all the parts of the Mediterranean. So clearly they were talking to each other and exchanging gifts, an idea it was a sort of Mediterranean elite that was trading and ruling the cities.
Dr Rad 17:56
This idea of connectivity couldn’t be more perfect for my next question as a segue. So why is it that understanding the transportation networks is a really valuable way to get an insight into this period of Rome’s history and their relationship with the rest of Central Italy?
Dr Fulminante 18:14
Certainly. Yeah, that’s the core of my latest book. So basically, transportation are partially determined by the environment. Of course, routes have to follow, obviously, the easiest route. And if there is a hill or a river in the way, they cannot continue, of course. But they also are the output of social political organization, because in between different policies, there has to be at least a certain amount of cooperation or collaboration to for them to be connected by a reciprocal route. So if we, if we study the organization of transportation routes, both mainly terrestrial, which are man made, but also fluvial. And in fact, actually, my most recent research is looking at the combination of the two, our river influence, roads and road influence, or at least how they work together. So I was saying the organization the transportation routes, tells us also something about their political organization. So I started the transportation system both in the southern nechuria, which is the region to the north of the Tiber, which was inhabited by the Etruscans, and the region around Rome, which was called the Latium Vetus. And what my analysis of the transportation system discovered I did network analysis, and maybe in the next later, I can explain. Aid a bit more what this network analysis is, we used some mathematical indexes. And what the mathematical indexes told us was that Etruria, Southern Etruria, was a bit of a more cooperative region. So and we know also this from the settlement, from the size of the settlements. There was at least four or five big, large settlements of 200 in 200 hectare each, and none of them was dominating. So it was a bit of a more of equilibrium between the different cities, the different polities, while in Latium Vetus, what we can see is that only Rome, in the proto-urban period that I mentioned before, became largest. 200 hectares. All the other little cities in Rome was smaller. So in a way, the system was more centralized and hierarchical. And I suspect, of course, I mean, anybody can demonstrate anything for sure, but I suspect that this was made it more impactful, the fact that he had a centralized organization, more hierarchical that was able in India and eventually to prevail to the less hierarchical organization of Etruria. That’s the conclusion I draw from my book.
Dr G 21:39
Interesting. So those Etruscans, they’re very cooperative, but it doesn’t help them in a pinch. When it comes down to it, they’re like, oh, wait a minute. So I think this might be actually leading slightly in the direction of this idea that when we think about the Bronze Age, and Rome is just a small village, and then it sort of explodes in the early Iron Age into a size that’s sort of comparable with these Etruscan settlements to the north. And then, as you say, it starts to outstrip its neighbours. It becomes the largest settlement in Latium Vetus. And you pose the question in the book, why was Rome successful and not Veii and I’d really love your take on this, because we’ve just covered the fall of Veii from, like the written source material perspective, and obviously that’s a very dramatic moment for the ancient sources when they are thinking about this. But I’m interested in what does the archeology kind of suggest to us about the rationale for they falling and Rome succeeding?
Dr Fulminante 22:40
Yes, yes, partially is one of the reason is the one I mentioned before. So these different political organization of the two region, but also a very, a very important point, I think, is actually the, really the key position of Rome. Because another point that came out from my book is that often these cities developed around their forum. So often the forum of the cities, the principal place is at the middle of a crossroad of regional and inter-regional routes, and in a way, via Rome, were actually really special. And not only we can see that from the geography because they are both nearly opposite each other in near the Tiber, but actually also my mathematical calculation gave some similar indexes for the two cities. So really, so they had similar trend, so really shown that they were specular. But I think probably what, what really helped Rome, and I’m sorry I have to maybe go back to the ancient sources. It’s really his position on the fort of the Tiber in the middle of Italy, because really, that was a very important crossing point connecting the sud [the south], the north of Italy, the center of the region. So it was really, really an invaluable position, even if I’m going back actually to the traditional explanation. But I think that they see probably the more the more plausible, so a combination of both very favorable position, a good political organization, and also another thing, but not last thing, is also important, that we know that Rome was always open to accept people in his citizenship. So from the very original myth of the of the Latin and the Sabines, so they incorporated the Sabines. And then later in the Roman Republic and also in the Imperial time, they always accepted people within their political community. So I think this, this combination favorable position, good political organization, and openness to the foreigners.
Dr Rad 25:16
Intriguing. I was really hoping you were also going to mention the tunnel that Rome apparently dug in today as part of your research.
Dr G 25:29
Yeah, and Veii’s position on this tufa outpost. It’s completely unassailable. Clearly.
Dr Rad 25:35
Now we’d like to get a bit technical, if we may, you mentioned earlier that part of your research involves this network science approach when you’re trying to explore the early connections between the Etruscan and Latin communities. This is completely new terminology to us. So can you please tell us a little bit about what a network science approach is and how it might better help us to understand relations in the Archaic period.
Dr Fulminante 26:04
Yes, the network science actually developed within the social science. In its origin, it was used to study, for example, a group of children in a classroom or people in an organization. And it was used, for example, to to analyze this relation in this sense. So for example, you have a group of school children, and you ask them, Who is your friend? Who do you talk to most? Who do you share your secret with? Who do you ate? And then, so you have this these children are represented by nodes, and their relation, which is if they share a secret or not, or if they are friends or not, is represented by a link that can have a positive value if they’re friend, or a negative value if they are not a friend. So you build a graph with these the nodes are the children and the link is their relation. You build a graph, and then you can model a certain scenario. So for example, you can find out that Camilla is very central to the group, because she shares secret with everybody, but actually the more popular guy is Rob or whatever. And similarly, in an organization, you can distinguish between the official hierarchy and actually what the gossip and the not official communication tells you so often, you can get different insight on one organization, and this can be transferred to cities and regions as well, where the nodes are the cities and the links of you can value the link, for example, on the basis of the distance, is one value – of distance a day. And similarly, you can calculate which center is more central, in the sense that, for example, if you have an ideal traveler, which center is passed by more often by this ideal traveler. So you can you can understand which settlement is travel more often, or which settlement is key to control flows among other cities. Or you can check which settlement is actually the most connected regionally, so it can reach the old region more easily all these sort of measure and values. And probably I also would like to understand in this, in this particular case, to thank some Spanish colleagues that work at the University of Barcelona that specifically helped me with we using these, these mathematical tools, and they were very good because they also made them very accessible to me. As my husband says, I’m really an art student.
Dr G 29:18
I was already intimidated when I was like, I think we might be speaking with a mathematician. So I’m so outside of my field right now, but what you’re saying, the way you’re describing, it sounds super important, actually. So if we’re thinking about how cities are connected to each other, I think obviously this flows in nicely to thinking about how that sort of warrior culture was operating with those high value goods that might be traded amongst those networks. And then, as we get further into thinking about the significance of centrality, because you’ve already mentioned that Rome is ideally positioned in some respects, because it’s right on the Tiber where it’s on the Tiber as well, and so is it sitting in one of these central node locations in terms of his network?
Dr Fulminante 30:01
Yes, it was actually also mathematically. It turned out that it was one. It was a central node in that sense as well, and and also had a lot of links to the connecting cities. So yeah, it was basically demonstrated also mathematically the geographical and environmental assumption, yes. And also the other thing I want you also said correctly, the goods and yeah, you can do networks also based on objects, and in the further in different studies, in an article, I did some of that, the only thing is with objects. So in this book, there is only the roads analyzed. In another article, I take also into consideration the impact of the object, but it’s a bit more difficult to do those because, because also of the natural excavation, sometimes you have a site that has been very well excavated and another one that has not, and that creates a bit of an imbalance. So it’s not so easy, actually, to be networks of objects, but we are trying to do that. Different scholars are also trying to do that.
Dr G 31:19
Yeah, I think this is always the challenge, isn’t it? With archeology, it’s like, how, how good is the site when you find it eventually. And I think this leads nicely into thinking about how rivers connect into this idea of transportation as well. So you mentioned that roads and rivers are operating side by side as part of this network system. What are some of the connections that we’re seeing between the Etruscans and the Romans in the Archaic period when it comes to river networks?
Dr Fulminante 31:47
Yeah, that’s also an interesting question. I analyze both the system separately, so only Etruria within, within without connecting it to Latium. And then I consider also both the regions together, also also with the friend of the Spanish colleagues. And first of all, what emerged from the analysis was that rivers apparently were more important in the Bronze Age than in the Iron Age, at least internally to the region. Because, yeah, probably, as I said, with the Iron Age, there is also, we know also from the tombs, that a lot of charts and chariots are going to be used more often. So probably, indeed, road routes were developed a bit more. But when actually you combine the two, both Etruria and Latium, what you see is a much more close collaboration. And especially it emerges that the in the archive period, the river that grows exponentially in importance, is the time arrival. And that’s actually also it combines very well with what we know from other sources, and from, as you said, from general trade of the objects, that actually because, because Rome is unifying the whole region, we have a much more commerce and trade starting to flow from the internal part of Italy to the coast and vice versa. So I was quite happy with that, because once again, the mathematical model was partially converging with what we know from material culture and literary sources. So definitely, they the river and the roads are collaborating. But especially, they collaborate very well, especially from the arcade period. And this is also the time when the Tiber emerge as as a sort of river motorway in central Italy.
Dr G 34:02
It’s getting busy out there. Look out! It’s just more barges going up and down.
Dr Rad 34:07
I’m thinking about another important aspect of Rome itself. How has your research helped to expand our understanding of the forum Romanum in terms of its function and role in this transportation network in the region.
Dr Fulminante 34:21
Yes, I partially answered earlier on. It turns out that, therefore, as I said, exactly at the crossroad, and we actually, if I may supporting and corroborate in this point, I will bring in the study also of a colleague of mine, Amy Russell, who has written a very nice paper on the different perception of the foreign in the past and now in Rome. So our point is that if you think about the forum Romanum now, it’s all very enclosed within the boundaries, and it feels like a closed space, while Via di Fori Imperiali nowadays feels like an open space because it’s crossed by the road Via di Fori Imperiali and all the Imperial Fora are open. But actually, if we try to get a more close perception as the ancient, we have to think that the forum, the forum, was a bustling place, with a lot of vehicles and people going in and out and across, especially from and also from the Via Sacra, with the triumphal route and all of that, while the Imperial fora were enclosed in their big construction, and they all had the colonnade around them, both the Formum of Augustus, and later the Forum of – the transitional Forum of Nero, and also the Forum of Trajan, so I found it actually quite interesting that the perception of people today and what probably was originally in the past is actually the opposite. And as I said, we have to fit. We have to remember that the forum was this open place at the at the crossroad of important regional and inter-regional routes. So very, very much a melting pot and a place of encounters.
Dr G 36:22
I think this is fascinating to keep in mind, because when we think of the forum, I think for a lot of Roman historians, particularly, we think about it as this political space, and it is public, and it is open to a certain extent, but it’s very much about what’s happening in the city, and about the city, rather than it being a connective place that is drawing together a whole bunch of network systems to come together in a central location. And so I think that’s great for expanding our appreciation of the multiple things that the forum is doing at the same time in terms of the way it sits in that space and the way that people are interacting with it.
Dr Fulminante 37:02
Yeah, exactly.
Dr G 37:03
So to wrap up, I’m interested in what is the one thing about the Archaic period of Central Italy that you’ve learned from your research that you’d love to see become more broadly understood.
Dr Fulminante 37:18
I think partially, all what we have, we have said just now, but I’m, I’m particularly, as you said, I think I’m particularly attached to this year – to this idea – of connectivity, because I think it brings a little bit more of a democratic view into into the origins of Rome, and then the other one I’m also particularly attached to, even if it’s partially the traditional one, is really the important of the position of Rome, because that was a very traditional view that had been a little bit abandoned by scholar and a bit trivialized. But actually I think that it really still holds some value. So I would like to bring it a bit more forward. And then, as you said, I also find the fascinating this idea of of the forum as connecting places, that I’m very much surprised how much these ancient communities were multicultural and multi-vocal, more than we tend to think. And probably we could learn a bit more about this respect.
Dr G 38:35
Absolutely. Yeah, there is plenty to learn. And I think giving Rome its due for sitting in that central location and making the most of it as it goes along.
Dr Rad 38:48
I was going to say I feel like the Romans themselves will be thrilled with your conclusion.
Dr G 38:54
The Romans will be very pleased with the outcome of this conversation. Thank you so much Francesca for sitting down.
Dr Fulminante 39:03
Yeah, I opened up to bias. I was brought up in Rome so I might be a bit biassed.
Dr Rad 39:09
Nonsense. Nonsense.
Dr G 39:10
Totally okay. I can appreciate it. Rome is the most beautiful city in the world, and it continues to be so, and I’m not going to pretend otherwise. I think your bias is perfectly aligned with mine. Thank you so much for taking the time to join us, Francesca and to share your ideas. I think they’re really valuable.
Dr Fulminante 39:29
It has been a pleasure.
Dr Rad 39:30
Thank you so much.
Dr G 39:41
Thank you for listening to this episode of the partial historians. You can find our sources sound credits and transcript in our show notes. Over at partialhistorians.com. We offer a huge thank you to you if you’re one of our illustrious Patreon supporters. If you enjoy the show, we’d love your support in a way that works for you. Leaving a nice review really makes our day. We’re on Ko-Fi for one off or ongoing donations on Patreon, of course. Our latest book, “Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire”, is published through Ulysses Press. It is full of stories that the Romans probably don’t want you to know about them. This book is packed with some of our favourite tales of the colourful history of ancient Rome. Treat yourself or an open minded friend to Rome’s glories, embarrassments and most salacious claims with “Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire”.
Transcribed by https://otter.ai
The post Special Episode – Central Italy and the Emergence of Rome with Dr Francesca Fulminante appeared first on The Partial Historians - Ancient Roman History with smart ladies.
391 BCE is jam-packed with action, but the event that stands out is the arrival of the Gauls in centre stage. It’s time to surf the Celtic Wave!
The year began well for the Romans as they recovered from the pestilence that had caused such havoc the year before. Finally, they were strong enough to take down the Sappinates and the Volsinii who had tried to take advantage of their illness. Scoundrels! And it wasn’t hard at all – these guys barely put up a fight!
In spite of their success on the battlefield, there were signs of trouble ahead. A humble plebeian, Marcus Caedicius, heard a god speak to him in the dead of the night whilst he was on the Nova Via. The god (Aius Locutius, the speaking voice) told him that the Gauls were coming and that he had to let the magistrates know right away!
The magistrates showed zero interest in anything this lowly pleb had to say. Um, why was this lowly man even talking to them? Didn’t he know they were patricians? And the Gauls? They were so far away, the Romans had barely even heard of them! Ridiculous.
Arrogance continued to be a problem for the Romans. Having ignored a message from the GODS, they now turned on the best man who ever lived, Camillus.
The last thing Camillus needed was drama as his young son had just passed away. However, the tribune of the plebs, Lucius Apuleius, cared not. He was coming after Camillus over the way he had handled the spoils captured from Veii. Did he embezzle some of the booty? Were there suddenly two fancy bronze doors in his house that might have once belonged in Veii?
Camillus was outraged by these accusations, but after consulting with friends and clients, he realised that he did not have the support he needed to beat the charges. Rather than wait around to be convicted, Camillus went into exile – but not before asking the gods to make the Romans rue the day they had driven him away! Pretty please, gods of Rome, prove his innocence and put them in a situation which only Camillus could fix. Then they’d have to come back on their knees!
A Celtic bracelet, 4th century BCE, Courtesy of the Met Museum.
Envoys from the Etruscan city of Clusium now arrived in Rome, seeking help against some troublesome Gauls who had arrived in their neighbourhood. This seems like an odd turn of events for so many reasons. The Romans did not have a strong relationship with Clusium. This was an Etruscan city quite some distance to the north. Perhaps they had been inspired by Rome’s performance against Volsinii?
Although the exact details are questionable, there is no doubt that Gallic tribes had migrated into northern Italy. There are many stories associated with this Celtic wave, including some family intrigue, the lure of Etruscan fruits, wine – oh, and land! We wish we had more accounts from the Gauls/ Celts themselves, but we have to let the archaeology speak for them. The evidence confirms Celtic migration over the Alps and into northern Italy from the 5th century BCE and Livy seems to have been inspired by Herodotus in his own account of the varied Celtic peoples who crossed the Alps.
Livy believes that it was the Senones tribe who rocked up at Clusium in the early 4th century, one the last to make the move. Although there is little archaeological evidence to suggest contact between these groups, let’s not interrupt Livy’s narrative. The people of Clusium were freaked out by these strangers and decided to turn to Rome. Surely the Romans would remember that they had not helped Veii out during the recent war? That must count for something?
The Romans were not so sure. They decided to send the three sons of Marcus Fabius Ambustus as ambassadors to have a wee chat with the Gauls. They would issue a stern warning and hope that the new arrivals went on their merry way. No one wants a war, guys! In fact, the Romans would love to make new friends.
How did the Senones respond? You’ll have to tune in for our epic multi-episode coverage of 390 BCE!
L. Lucretius – f. – n. Tricipitinus Flavus (Pat) Cos. Suff. 393, Mil. Tr. c. p. 388, 383, 381.
Ser. Sulpicius Q. f. Ser. n. Camerinus (Pat). Cos. Suff. 393.
L. (or M.) Aemilius Mam. f. M. n. Mamercinus (Pat) Mil. Tr. c.p. 389, 387, 383, 382, 380.
L. Furius L. f. Sp. n. Medullinus (Pat) Cos. 413, 409, Mil. Tr. c.p. 407, 405, 398, 397, 395, 394.
Agripp. Furius Sex. f. -n. Fusus (Pat)
C. Aemilius Tr. f. Tr. n. Mamercinus (Pat) Mil. Tr. c.p. 394.
L. Apuleius
Quaestors
Sp. Carvilius
M. Furius Camillus (Pat) Mil. Tr. c. p. 401, 398, 394, 386, 384, 381
P. Cornelius Scipio (Pat) Mil. Tr. c.p. 395, 394?
L. Valerius Potitus (Pat) Cos. 393, 392, Mil. Tr. c.p. 414, 405, 403, 401, 398
Q. Fabius M. f. Q. n. Ambustus (Pat) Mil. Tr. c. p. 390
K. ?Fabius M. f. Q. n. (Pat) Mil. Tr. c.p. 404, 401, 395, 390
Num. Fabius M. f. Q. n. (Pat) Mil. Tr. c.p. 406, 390.
Our music is by Bettina Joy de Guzman. Sound effects thanks to Orange Free Sounds.
Dr Rad 0:15
Welcome to the Partial Historians.
Dr G 0:18
We explore all the details of ancient Rome,
Dr Rad 0:23
everything from political scandals, the love affairs, the battles waged and when citizens turn against each other, I’m Dr rad,
Dr G 0:32
and I’m Dr G, we consider Rome as the Romans saw it, by reading different authors from the ancient past and comparing their stories.
Dr Rad 0:44
Join us as we trace the journey of Rome from the founding of the city.
Dr Rad 0:58
Hello and welcome to a brand new episode of the partial historians. I am one of your hosts. Dr rad,
Dr G 1:06
and I am your other host. Dr G,
Dr Rad 1:10
now. Dr G, we are emerging from a very dark time in ancient Roman history. 392 BCE is not well known to the general public, but we discovered it was a year of a terrible pestilence where, if you got sick, you might very well catch an itch that could cause you to scratch your way through your flesh to your very bones,
Dr G 1:34
horrifying, and the sort of thing that the Romans want you to forget, but we’re going to remind you About every time
Dr Rad 1:40
it happens, honestly, I keep getting the shivers every time I think
Dr G 1:46
disgusting. It has been a troublesome time for the Romans recently, despite what appears to be the stellar victory of a Fe and the Aequians being easy to conquer, but seemingly coming back every year anyway, like some kind of, I don’t know, zombie enemy.
Dr Rad 2:08
I was gonna say, like a Jack in the Box, just
Dr G 2:11
when you think they’re gone, they’re back, and we are now heading squarely for what appears to be a much bigger disaster. I would say that this year is a lead in to what is going to be an epic problem for Rome. I
Dr Rad 2:25
would say so I think we’re going to do an episode on 391 BC, which is this episode, and then it may take us, like five or six episodes to get through the next lot.
Dr G 2:38
Strap yourselves and listeners, we’re heading onto a bumpy road for the Romans. Yeah,
Dr Rad 2:43
please, please be forewarned. 390 BCE will not be covered in a single episode.
Dr G 2:49
It is unlikely, but even 391 I have to say, because it is a lead in to what is going to happen. Everybody is talking about it. And when I say everybody, I’m just going to give you my list of sources, not because I’m trying to show off, but because it’s confusing in my head, and I gotta have them all written down. There’s the Fasti Capitolini, no surprises there. I also have Valerius, Maximus, Plutarch’s life of Camillus, Cicero’s On the house, Pliny’s Natural History, Appian’s Italic wars, Dio Cassius, The illustrious men by the unknown author, Dionysius of Halicarnassus makes a reappearance, as does his epitomator, likewise, Eutropius, Diodorus Siculus is back with his ongoing series. Meanwhile, in Sicily, and this is way more sources than I usually have. Fortunately, most of them are saying very similar things. So I think that’s going to be the crux of the issue. When we get into
Dr Rad 3:54
it, I was going to say, you’re making me feel extremely sheepish, because my list of sources is Livy
Dr G 4:02
and I’m not sad about that. I think Livy is providing us with the consistent narrative that is anchoring all of our episodes at the moment. So I think you’re doing a very valuable and important job in tackling Livy, because it’s providing the groundwork for all of the sort of chaotic bits and pieces that I have little chips that I’m I throw into the bowl at the party and hope will one day make something great.
Dr Rad 4:27
I’m not gonna lie, when people think Fiona Radford, they think consistency.
Dr G 4:33
See, there you go.
Dr Rad 4:35
Yeah. All right. So Dr, G, as you say, this will be a big one, because it’s the lead up to one of the biggest disasters in early Roman history, if not perhaps the biggest disaster in early Roman history. So without further ado, let’s try and leave plague behind if we can, because we’ve learned nothing from analytic history. It’s that disease outbreaks only ever last. 12 months Exactly. They can’t exceed that time period. It’s impossible. Let’s delve into 391, BCE, Oh.
Dr G 5:20
Huh? 391 What a time, what a place
Dr Rad 5:32
now. Dr, G, I would wager that the list of magistrates is going to take us a good 10 minutes. So let’s get cracking. All right,
Dr G 5:40
we have a return of the military tribunes with consular power.
Dr Rad 5:45
Yes, yes, just reminding our listeners that apparently the reason for the switch from consuls back to military tribunes with consular power was because it’s possible to have multiple military tribunes with consular power, as in more than two. And the theory is that if you have more than two less likely that they’ll all get gravely ill and scratch themselves to death.
Dr G 6:06
It does also mean, if you’ve got wars on many fronts, you’re able to send a commander in every direction possible, which is exciting news. So we have six military tribunes with consular power, which is really reaching the upper threshold of what the Romans are capable of delivering. In this magistracy, we have Lucius Lucretius Tricipitinus Flavus, hmm. Now, this guy was suffect consul in 393 so he was around a couple of years ago, and I did trip over his name, I think, in the previous episode when we talked about him. So I’ve really practiced
Dr Rad 6:46
for this. He’s asking for it with that many syllables, outrageous,
Dr G 6:49
exactly, Latin. What are you trying to do to me? Exactly. He is joined by Servilius Sulpicius Camerinus, also suffect consul in 393,
Dr Rad 7:02
gang back together. The gang’s back together.
Dr G 7:05
Yeah, they’re like, we’ve served together before. It’s gonna be fine. We’ve got a guy who we’re not sure of, the praenoman. He could be a Lucius or he could be a Marcus, but he’s definitely an Aelius Mamercinus. This is his first time in the role. Congratulations.
Dr Rad 7:22
That won’t be his last, from the looks of things
Dr G 7:24
certainly won’t, but this is where it all begins. We also have Lucius Furius Medullinus, whoa, the Furii are back in town, he was previously consul in 413, 409, and also, previously military Tribune, about seven times, wow. So he has a lot of experience under his belt. Who knows how many gray hairs He is joined by Agrippa Furius Fusus, so from the same gens, and this is the only time that this guy appears in the Fasti. No other role, no other time. It’s a special year. A small round of applause for Agrippa Furius Fusus,
Dr Rad 8:12
we don’t often get the name Agrippa mixed in with the Furii clan. I feel
Dr G 8:19
this is an odd situation. I don’t think anybody is comfortable with it. Scholars have some questions,
Dr Rad 8:25
yeah. See, the only thing we’ve learned about Roman names is that they have a certain pattern to them. You just start to get a feel for it after talking about them this many times.
Dr G 8:34
That’s true, and definitely different genses have different preferences when it comes to their praenomens. So you start to see patterns there. I think the reason why he appears might become more clear as we get further down the list. Sure the last military Tribune with consular power is Gaius Aemilius Mamercinus. And if you thought I said his name already, you’re almost right, because two of those three names appeared earlier in the list. So this guy is definitely part of the Aemilii gens, and definitely the same branch of the family as the guy, Lucius or Marcus Aelius. They don’t have the same father, they don’t have the same grandfather, so they’re slightly different branches of the family, but they’re pretty closely connected. You would think
Dr Rad 9:20
a lot of patrician domination. Dr G, and I’m not thrilled about it.
Dr G 9:24
There is a lot of patricians in this list. All of them are patrician and Gaius Aemilius Mamercinus was also previously military Tribune in 394, okay, so he’s got a little bit of experience. So the only newcomer here is Agrippa Furius Fusus. Now things get more complicated as we move away from the military tribune with consular power. And this was going to lead into, I think, some of the discussion we have about the source material, because we have a tribune of the plebs listed a guy called Lucius Apuleius. We also have a Quaestor listed, Spurius Carvilius. We have the interregges, who came up in the previous year. They’re listed for this year as well, Marcus Furius Camillus, Publius Cornelius Scipio and Lucius Valerius Potitus. And then we get into our legates, slash ambassadors.
Dr Rad 10:25
Oh, the troublemakers. I like to call them Dr, G
Dr G 10:31
and well, listeners, if names are confusing for you, you’re in the right spot, because we’re these guys are clearly all related, and it appears that they must all be brothers from the names, the patterns of the names, we’ve got Quintus Fabius Ambustus. He is the son of Marcus, grandson of Quintus. You’re like, okay, then we have Kaeso Fabius Ambustus, son of Marcus, grandson of Quintus. Then we have Numerus Fabius Ambustus, son of Marcus, grandson of Quintus. So these three all related, all Fabian fabulous all from fabulous Fabians, all from the Ambustii sub branch of the family. So I guess we’ll see what happens there. Absolutely
Dr Rad 11:27
it’s going to be an interesting ride with these three Dr G if they really did what they are accused of. But I mustn’t get ahead of myself. Are you ready to dive into 391?
Dr G 11:41
Yes. Ma’am. All right.
Dr Rad 11:43
So it was on a sunny summer’s day in July, the first day of July, in fact, when our new military tribunes, with consular power, took over after that dreadful time of plague. Dr G now, lest we forget, the Romans had made a declaration of war from their sick beds, and now that they were feeling friskier, it’s time to fulfill on that promise.
Dr G 12:13
Yes, wow. We wouldn’t want the gods to be disturbed, would we?
Dr Rad 12:17
We most certainly would not, and so it’s just as well we have so many military tribunes with consular power because they can be split up into pairs and sent off to conquer some people. We have Lucretius and Aemilius being placed in charge of the war with Volsinii, one of the fabled Etruscan 12 Cities much further north than the Romans usually venture, but they started it, and then we have Sulpicius and Furius being placed in charge of the war with the city that we’re presuming is not that far away from the Volsinii. The Sappinates, I’m going to call them, they decide to deal with Volsinii first, as it is a bigger place, as you might imagine, given that we actually know where this place was once upon a time, but again, bit of a snooze as far as military campaigns go. Dr, G, I don’t know what is going on with these enemies of Rome, but apparently, once the Romans launch their attack, the Volsinii, their line just breaks apart pretty much straight away. The Romans use their cavalry to cut them off, and the Volsinii, their cavalry, wave the little white flag and defeated pretty quickly.
Dr G 13:38
Well, all I can say is that, from the way you’ve described them, they’re far inside Etruscan territory. They’ve been living that soft Etrurian life, surrounded by their buddies, other friends. They haven’t had to prep themselves for war. They haven’t had to defend their city. And now, all of a sudden, these angry little Romans turn up and like
Dr Rad 14:00
exactly giving them a taste of their own medicine after they dared to invade Roman territory whilst the Romans were scratching themselves to death, the smaller city that we don’t really know where it was, the saponates, they saw how things worked out for the larger, presumably more prosperous neighbor city of Volsinii, and they decided, You know what, I don’t think we want to fight the Romans
Dr G 14:29
run away. So
Dr Rad 14:31
they decide, much smarter to hide behind their city walls and just brace themselves for an attack. Shit Quick, get into the cupboard. Now, the Romans are on a high because presumably, you know how you feel after you’ve gotten over a serious illness. You know, they just, they just happy to be outside. Quite frankly, they’re skipping happily around, lootering and plunging. Ring their way through the fields of both the Volsinii and Sappinum, or whatever this place is called. Finally, the people of Volsinii get sick of this and say, You know what, whatever we took from you in the previous year, we’ll give it all back. If you could just stop. All right, you already won the battle. Please, for the love of God, would you just put an end to this once and for all
Dr G 15:28
you see this sheaf of wheat, have it back. Hang
Dr Rad 15:32
on a second. I can give it back to you. I swear. Just give me one second, which actually, I think, gives credence to our theory that a lot of the warfare that is going on in this time period is really just people constantly swapping sandals. Seems like it. They also say that not only will they give back anything that they took in the previous year, they will provide the salaries of the soldiers that the Romans used in this little campaign, because, after all, we are working under the pretense that there is such a thing as military pay at this moment in time. Roman sorts, that sounds like a good deal. Cha Ching and they agree to a 20 year truce, wow. Etruscan rascals,
Dr G 16:19
okay. Well, I mean, how did the Volsinii know that Romans are paying their troops? How do they know?
Dr Rad 16:27
Presumably, whilst they were plundering the Roman fields, they got wind of this amazing innovation of the Romans. Hmm, I’m suspicious. I am grasping at straws here trying to make this
Dr G 16:41
Livy, what are you trying to do to us? He really wants to embed this idea in his narrative. I could see where he’s going. Very clever, Livy.
Dr Rad 16:49
It’s not that it’s impossible that there’s something being provided to the soldiers of Rome, but as you and I have talked about, there are just so many problems with the way that it is presented to us. And look, this isn’t the first time this has happened after all, remember the whole filiscan affair. They also agreed to pay the soldiers, apparently, after Camillus won them over with his sense of honor. It
Dr G 17:13
does seem to be one of the innovations that has emerged in maybe the last 20 years of Roman history, which is that people are like, what if we just pay you to go away and stop fighting us and people like you know what? I agree,
Dr Rad 17:27
yes, and it’s something that will have a long history in many places, not just Rome now. Dr G, this is where your knowledge of Roman religion is going to be counted upon, because back in Rome itself, a portent appears by the name of Marcus Caedicius. What an unfortunate name. He went and told some of the military tribunes with consular power that when he was in the Nova Via or the Nova Via for those that like the sound of a V in the dead of night, he heard a voice. Now, presumably, this voice was very clearly divine, because he said it was even more distinct than a man’s. I’m imagining booming. I’m imagining stereo surround sound. And it told him that he needed to inform the magistrates of Rome that the Gauls were coming. Dun, dun, dun.
Dr G 18:31
Oh no, the Gauls. How would they even who are the Gauls? I’m
Dr Rad 18:37
not going to get into that right this second, but in Livy’s time, there was apparently a small chapel of some kind where this portent took place, presumably to mark the occasion, and it was located just above the Temple of Vesta. Very interesting, I thought that might get your attention. Look, I have a couple
Dr G 19:02
of Vesta things to mention in this episode, but that’s not one of them that’s really interesting. I do have this story as well, related by Plutarch in his Life of Camillus. And again, the guy’s name is the same, Marcus Caedicius, and he hears this voice, and he doesn’t see the person, but it seems louder than a man’s.
Dr Rad 19:28
It’s not a person, it’s a god. I made it very clear.
Dr G 19:35
Tell the magistrates that they must expect the goals. He goes to the tribunes, apparently, and tells them, and they laugh at him.
Dr Rad 19:43
No, that’s exactly what Livy says, things that the magistrates couldn’t have cared less, and, oh, so shameful. Dr, G, but it’s all because of his social class. They’re like, You disgusting, stinky pleb. We’re not going to pay attention to anything you say laughable. And then. Point out that the gulls are so far away the reference barely know anything about them. Ridiculous. Couldn’t possibly be a concern. Evil laughter, twirling of mustache, stroking of white cats,
Dr G 20:15
yeah, like we’re not going to be worried about the chicken people. They live over the Alps. As far as we’re aware, it’s like a completely different continent,
Dr Rad 20:24
yeah. So they’re very unconcerned, but this was obviously something that was marked later. This is apparently the only time when a voice like this was really heard before something disastrous happened for the Romans. So that’s kind of interesting, I
Dr G 20:40
thought, as an omen, yeah, that’s important. Yeah, I don’t
Dr Rad 20:45
know. I don’t know if it’s the only time in Rome’s history where they heard big, booming surround sound, James Earl Jones, Morgan Freeman style voices talking to them. But certainly, as a warning, you know that something was coming. And so they did, apparently, mark out this site, and it was something set up to the cult of Aius Loquens or Locutius. But I don’t believe that the exact site of this altar has been 100% nailed down. Okay, it is thought that this character of the lowly plebeian who gets laughed at is a later addition. I know you’ll be shocked to hear that,
Dr G 21:29
but in a way, it kind of makes sense. It was like, if we emphasize that this is a portent that is ignored by the Roman the powerful sections of Roman society, then you might then suggest that, well, the gods have realized that putting a message forward through the ears of a plebeian is worth nobody’s time, because the Romans don’t get the message because they just laugh at the guy instead,
Dr Rad 21:54
I know, and I love the fact that they set up This little thing to what seems to be a native God, which is the God of the speaking voice, basically.
Dr G 22:11
Well, I think that’s cool. I mean, the Romans do like things like that. They’re like, we’re not sure to who to attribute this to, yeah. And thus, it must be a new god that we’re not aware of.
Dr Rad 22:21
Yeah. Now look, Dr G, this is just the first of many times that we start to see why the Romans are about to face a terrible year in 390 BCE. And the overarching thing that unites all of these little incidents is that the Romans are brought down by their own arrogance. I mean, who could have seen that coming? I think, I think you and I have spent a long time focusing on this very quality of the room.
Dr G 22:49
Look, I’d like to say I’m shocked, but I can’t even summon up shock.
Dr Rad 22:56
Yeah, now I tell you what you are going to be shocked by, and that is the brevity of the next part of my account. The magistrates obviously have foolishly decided that they’re going to ignore what is very obviously a message from the gods. And then, to make it even worse, in Livy’s vision of things, not only do they turn against divine aid, they turn against the only human in Rome who could possibly have helped them in their time of need. That’s right. I’m talking about Marcus, Furius
Dr G 23:31
Camillus. Oh, Camillus, that guy, yeah, the old Golden Bowl Stuff up, man. Oh,
Dr Rad 23:41
yeah, that’s right. Camillus is going through a tough time in 391 BCE, Dr g1, of his young sons had suddenly and unexpectedly died, perhaps scratched himself to death.
Dr G 23:54
It’s quite possible. Yeah, we certainly don’t, well, at least my sources don’t provide the exact detail of what led to the death of the child, but given that we’re in a situation contextually, which is like high levels of pestilence and disease, seems likely that the young and vulnerable would possibly be targeted and die.
Dr Rad 24:13
Look, I’m gonna go out on a limb here and say most likely plague. So Camillus is licking his wounds, dealing with his grief. It’s not a great year for him. Unfortunately, it’s exactly this moment that his enemies decide they’re going to pounce. Camillus is a hero to the Romans, but as we have seen, it’s not been all smooth sailing, and he’s certainly ruffled some feathers along the way, mostly plebeian feathers. Dr G now he seriously annoyed the plebeians because he was firmly against the idea of splitting Rome in two and sending half of the population to they. That didn’t go down well, because a lot of the plebs were in favor of that. Particularly some of the tribunes of the plebs, they were definitely down for that. And he also did not win any friends with that whole Oh, hey, I forgot to tell you about this crazy promise that I made after you all got your cut of the spoils of a turns out, I’m gonna need some of that back. Whoops. Whatever went on with that whole thing. Camillus Glory has been somewhat tainted in the eyes of some of his fellow Romans. So this is where the tribune of the plebs enters the story Lucius apollous. He indicts Camillus over the way he handled the spoils of Veii. Now Livy really does not give me many details, and this is the shocking part. This is going to be all about the trial of Camillus and how at least his exile, and Livy handles it in just a couple of sentences. Oh, boy. I know you would think this would be a huge set piece in Livy’s account, but I mentioned this to you before. He’s trying to build up a bigger picture here. He wants symmetry in what he’s dealing with here, and in order to achieve that symmetry, he just doesn’t have the time or the inclination to talk much about this episode, so I don’t get much detail. But what seems to be clear by piecing together multiple sources is that Camillus is essentially being accused, perhaps of it might have been something like maybe he didn’t pay his fair share of the tithe, maybe. But it seems far more likely that he’s being accused of something akin to sort of embezzling, like mishandling some of the booty, something along those lines, and the evidence it’s right there in plain sight. Dr G, two huge bronze doors freshly installed on his house the brazenness of this man. Now you might say, Well, surely the whole idea of taking stuff from vase that you can put it to some use. If you stole two huge bronze knockers, why not have them front and
Dr G 27:06
center? Well, exactly,
Dr Rad 27:09
but look, this is to maybe be some of the evidence that they’re pointing to. And so Camillus calls together his consillium, so group of friends that he trusts and family members and wants to hear their take on what is going on, because obviously he is going to have to go through a trial. He’s not really in the mood, the mindset, and he wants their advice. He doesn’t perhaps hear what he was expecting to for a man with such a career behind him, because particularly, some of his clients who are plebeians say, Look, man, you’re going down. It doesn’t matter whether you’re guilty or not guilty, you are going down. We can’t really say that we’re actually going to be voting to acquit you, because that would be career suicide. All we can say is that you’ll probably get a slap on the wrist and a fine, and we’ll help you to pay the fine, but we’re still going to vote you guilty. It’s going down, and Camillus decides that he should therefore just go into exile before the trial could take place. But before he leaves, he makes a very important vow to the gods. Again, he hasn’t learned his lesson at all. Dr G, he just keeps talking to them. No. He says to the gods, please, if you know that I am truly innocent, then make sure that my fellow Romans will regret bitterly that they have driven me away and that they will want me to come home soon. And with that, he’s off into the sunset, and in his absence, he is found guilty and fined 15,000 asses whilst he’s in exile.
Dr G 29:00
Goodness me, Camillus. He’s a controversial character in some respects, I think, because he does demonstrate military prowess all the time, and yet his relationship with the people of Rome is tumultuous, and it’s positioned this way in all of our source material and this story about how Camillus gets into exile crops up in just about anybody. Who’s anybody. This is why I have such a long list of sources. They’re all giving a certain version of this tale. Yes, so Valerius Maximus positions this story in a section which he is entitled On in gratitude.
Dr Rad 29:42
Delightful. Subtle hint,
Dr G 29:45
no, no, just, uh, there’s an agenda here, just letting you know. And in this account, Camillus is accused by Apollo’s, the tribune of the plebs, of embezzling spoils and. Not just that, but there isn’t a complaint made that there are 15,000 asses missing from the state treasury.
Dr Rad 30:10
Ooh, extra detail,
Dr G 30:15
the detail about him having lost a son, is here in this particular version, this idea that Rome and Camillus are laden with calamities right now, and that he’s condemned and sent into exile, that’s the substance of Valerius Maximus. But this idea is not he doesn’t mention anything about these fancy bronze doors. He talks about embezzlement specifically, and that there’s missing funds from the Treasury, and Camillus is found to be wanting in this
Dr Rad 30:44
particular case, and this is why the quaestors are involved. It may
Dr G 30:49
be possible there are different versions of this story, and in some cases, it’s the Quaestor that brings the accusation. So then we get into Plutarch’s Life of Camillus. Obviously, Plutarch sees Camillus as heroic enough to deserve a life in the parallel lives. So he’s seen, in some ways, as a moral exemplar. So that’s important. So a lot of the framing of the things that go badly for Camillus are going to be lessons about how to do things better. He gets denounced to the citizens as a hater of the common people, sounds very much like a tribune of the plebs move and begrudging to the poor and the enjoyment of their rightful booty. So they have that situation in the background of this accusation being brought by apalaisus. Again, the charge is theft of Etruscan goods, and here the bronze doors do make a reappearance. The bronze doors belonging to the booty had been seen at his house, not necessarily the front doors, but maybe he was keeping them inside. Look,
Dr Rad 31:52
I may have got caught up in my description.
Dr G 31:57
You see those doors over there? I’m going to do some improvements later. And he does get together with his friends to discuss the case, and they say we’re not going to be able to help you with this. So everybody seems to be convinced that he’s going down. Whether he’s actually guilty or not. Is another matter entirely. Hey, if the bronze doors fit, yeah. And they’re like, we got the bronze doors in your house, man, what are you going to do? They say, though, that if he is punished with a fine, they’d help pay it. And that seems like a pretty generous offer, but it’s the sort of thing that makes Camillus really mad, because that means that people don’t believe him enough to defend him against these charges. They’re just willing to help him out with the inevitable fine.
Dr Rad 32:40
He’s got bronze doors in his house. He doesn’t need help with a fine. He needs faithful friends
Dr G 32:45
Exactly. He’s like, Well, that’s not good enough. And it’s like, that’s not loyalty. You’re not on my side. You’re just gonna help me out when I get the fine, what does that say about you? You don’t believe my side of the story. I found the bronze doors. They were on the side of the road. It
Dr Rad 33:02
was a council cleanup. I swear
Dr G 33:05
I got them off the back of the truck. What are you talking about?
Dr Rad 33:07
Facebook, marketplace. I mean, everything’s
Dr G 33:09
just too cheap on there. Exactly what was I supposed to do? It was a bargain. So he can’t endure this, and he’s determined to just depart the city and willfully goes into exile. So there’s some stories say that he gets charged and he has to go into exile. Others suggest that he leaves before this trial takes place. So he’s preemptively engaging with the whole situation. And Plutarch also gives us this detail about the prayer to the gods. I’m just like Camillus, my buddy.
Dr Rad 33:42
I know. Stop it. Just stop talking to them. Talk to somebody else. Talk to your stuffed teddy bear. How
Dr G 33:47
did this work out for you last time? Man, not well, not well. You got into trouble with Apollo. You had to do the whole gold bold debacle. You sent a ship around Italy. It didn’t go well. There were pirates, and you’re telling me you’re going to pray to the gods again, all right, like get a wife. Well, I figure you must have one children, but you know, the guy can’t take a hint. So it’s like he might be a great military general. But is he clever? No, he is not. He prays to the gods that, if with no justice, but through the wantonness of the people and the abuse of the envious. He was now being driven from his country, the Romans might speedily repent and show to all men that they needed and longed for. Camillus
Dr Rad 34:34
got the ego on this guy. You’re
Dr G 34:36
gonna want me. You’re gonna need me. You’re gonna ask me back.
Dr Rad 34:42
What you to want me
Dr G 34:46
exactly. And then, to top it all off, Plutarch then begins the next paragraph with after he had, thus, like Achilles, invoked curses upon his fellow citizens, he removed himself from the city.
Dr Rad 34:59
That’s quite an accusation, because Achilles is a very emotional, messed up guy who really screws up everybody’s plans with his mopiness.
Dr G 35:14
You can see where it might be going. But look, I also
Dr Rad 35:17
see this as a convenient, excellent stage left, because what all of this means is that Camillus is conveniently not around when disaster strikes. Now you might say, well, actually, Dr Rad, that seems inconvenient. No, he is a hero, and it’s convenient that he is not around when the disaster first strikes, and then he might just get to, oh, I don’t know, swoop in and save the day. We’ll have to see.
Dr G 35:46
Well, yes, exactly. So this is the kind of thing where Cicero’s positioning of this situation is a handy way to get a lens on how Romans might be thinking about this kind of thing, because he brings up some great characters in the same breath, Kaeso Quinctius, Marcus Furius Camillus and Marcus Servilius Ahala. And we’ve had Ahala come across our table before. Oh, and Kaeso, yeah, guys who go out of their way to do things which are exceptional outside of the bounds of the expected, but ultimately benefit the Roman people. But the Roman people can’t see it for what it is and get annoyed at them. So it’s like the Roman population is condemning the means by which great men achieve great things and punish them for not doing it in the proper way when greatness required moving outside of the rule set. And this is kind of the way that Cicero sees it, because obviously he’s talking about himself in a classic Ciceronian fashion.
Dr Rad 36:55
Camillus Cicero exactly the same, because
Dr G 36:59
he ultimately is bringing up Camillus to talk about the way that he had to leave Rome without any sentence being placed upon him. He had to go into a voluntary exile to be restored honorably later on, because people realized that he would done the right thing. And this is obviously a reference back to everything to do with the whole conspiracy that Cicero was a part of bringing down in his view. So Camillus is one of these figures that gets positioned as a hero out of the patrician tradition.
Dr Rad 37:36
Absolutely yes, and there’s a lot of details around this account which are questioned in modern times, the fine, the size of the fine, whether there was indeed a trial of this nature. It’s all a bit questionable. However, it does seem likely that maybe Camillus wasn’t in Rome after a certain point in 391 BCE, or thereabouts, because, as we’ve talked about, Roman dating is a little skewff,
Dr G 38:03
well, it’s also the situation where, depending on the sort of angle that you take with the scholarship, there is the argument that Camillus is not a real figure. This is true. A lot of this story is completely made up.
Dr Rad 38:17
I wasn’t gonna go down that path after G
Dr G 38:19
today, or that there is an amalgamation of a variety of people into this singular story. To give it more potency,
Dr Rad 38:28
absolutely, many Furii, many, many. What do you get when you combine many Furii? I
Dr G 38:35
So, as an additional detail, so we’ve got the idea of Spurius Carvilius. This quaestor comes up. Yeah. Now this is a very late source, so it can probably be dismissed as not quite as on the money as maybe some of the other stories. But Pliny the Elder in his Natural History talks about Carvilius, the quaestor, bringing the charges against Camillus, the accusation being about the doors in his house. But while I was reading that small paragraph, because this whole book, 34 of the natural history, is about metals,
Dr Rad 39:11
oh, I was gonna say it’s about doors, I was trying to think what the theme could be. It’s about metals. Of course, it’s
Dr G 39:16
about and a mere two sentences above that completely irrelevant to what we’re talking about, but I’m going to mention it anyway, because it involves the Temple of Vesta. Ah, so one of the things that said is that the Temple of Vesta should be covered with a coating of Syracusan metal.
Dr Rad 39:34
What does that mean? I don’t know what that means. Don’t know what
Dr G 39:37
that means. I’m not sure what metals do the Syracuse
Dr Rad 39:41
have? I wouldn’t know where to even start, and where did this
Dr G 39:45
ordinance come from, and when was it applied. And does that mean that the temple was shiny on the outside? Because that’s incredible. I’m living for that dream. Let us reconstruct the temple with a shiny exterior that bore. Finds people in the summertime.
Dr Rad 40:03
In the summertime. Ah, my eyes. All right, awesome. Okay, are we ready to advance with our tail?
Dr G 40:11
Are we ready to advance with our tale? I mean, that is a great question. I mean, I don’t think I have too many more things from this year. It’s more variations on the same detail. So if you’ve got other things on this year is probably a good time to move to them, because I’m willing to learn.
Dr Rad 40:25
Okay, well, let’s throw ourselves back into the histrionic way that Livy is positioning Camillus departure. Camillus is gone, and he was the only man who could have possibly prevented the capture of Rome, which is going to happen in 390 BCE, that’s right. Another spoiler. It’s really hard to tell the story of the preceding years without constantly giving away what’s going to happen in 390 BCE, yet more signs that trouble is a brewing, envoys arrive from Clusium. Ah, yes, Clusium, that’s right. Clusium is in the Etrurian regions of Italy, and they are wanting help because they have encountered the Gauls, Dr G
Dr G 41:14
horrifying. What are the Gauls doing in Etruria? Okay, well,
Dr Rad 41:18
this is where I’m going to tell you a little bit about the Gauls. It’s actually occurred to me that this would be a good special episode for us. Episode for us, actually, because I do not know that much about the Gauls, apart from the fact that they are going to be running afoul of the Romans For hundreds of years, and it’s not going to end well for them, although they do put up a amazingly good fight against the
Dr G 41:42
Romans. The girls,
Dr Rad 41:43
this is a very generic term. Sometimes you will also see reference to the Celts, as well as a particular brand of these people. To be honest, we wish we knew more about who these people that lived over the Alps really were. So as we can tell, they were a more loosely organized peoples than the Romans, but they are widely spread out, so that is really no shock. I mean, again, if you look at the amount of territory Rome actually occupies at this moment in time, teeny tiny compared to the areas that these people are going to conquer and take over, but tribes do seem to be the way that they mostly organize themselves. Most of what we know about them at this moment in time comes from the people that they are fighting against, and this is part of our problem. We are constantly going to be battling the racism that tinges Greek and Roman accounts of what these people are up to, how their society is organized, all of that kind of stuff. But what does seem to make sense is that there is some contact between them and other peoples through trade that seems legitimate, and that the dominant peoples in a Celtic slash Gallic society would be a warrior elite. Hmm,
Dr G 43:09
you know, I have some details about why the Gauls are in Italy. If you, if you’re interested,
Dr Rad 43:14
by all means, please. So
Dr G 43:17
Dionysus of Halicarnassus re enters the narrative. Nice to see you. Dionysius, I’m glad to be here. So it all starts, apparently, and I’m pretty sure this is a tall tale, but I like it, so I’m going to retell it anyway, so you can laugh along with me. Lucumo is a prince of the Etruscans.
Dr Rad 43:38
Ah, yes, I know this story, but please continue.
Dr G 43:42
He has a loyal man called Arruns who is acting as a guardian for his son. And Arruns looks after Lucumo’s son, even when Lucumo passes away, raises this child to power. You would think the child would be grateful. The child is not grateful. The child is a little
Dr Rad 44:02
power player. The theme is ingratitude. Dr G, the theme is ingratitude.
Dr G 44:06
It certainly is. And as this kid grows up, he clamps eyes on Arrun’s young, beautiful wife, and decides he wants her for his own. Arruns is pretty unhappy with that situation. And not only does he believe that his wife has been corrupted, but he has seen this young man talking to his wife in public, which means she is definitely not chased anymore. It is impossible, if you’ve had a public conversation with a man, you must have also slept with him. That’s the only
Dr Rad 44:41
explanation. That’s what I tell my stepdaughter.
Dr G 44:45
Never talk to a man in public unless you’ve already slept with him. Everybody will assume that you have. So I mean the Romans and their ideas, and also the Etruscans and their ideas. Yeah. So anyway, Arruns gets his dander up about this, and. And he’s deciding that he’s gonna leave Etruria, it’s gonna pack up his wagon and he’s gonna go. So he takes everything that is needful for an important and long trip. He packs Lots of wine, lots of olive oil and many baskets of figs, and packs it all up in his wagons, and he heads out of Italy all the way to Gaul and that is where he met the Gaulish people. And, you know, they’re, they’re kind of like, what’s in those wagons, buddy? And he’s like, Oh, sit down. Hear my sorry tale. Have a beverage. Have some figs, have some wine. Brought the popcorn. girl and The Gaulish people are flabbergasted. Their taste buds are exploding in this moment. They cannot believe it. They’ve been flavoring their food with rancid lard
Dr Rad 45:55
all this time, and now they’re tasting the rainbow,
Dr G 45:58
and now they’re like, olive oil. They’ve also been drinking bitter barley fermented beer, like the low of the low, and now they’re tasting this delicious Italian wine. And they’re like, oh my god, it’s it’s incredible. I just don’t even know what to do with myself. And this fresh fruit, these figs, they’re amazing. They’re like, where did you get this stuff? And Arruns is like, well, I have great news for you. It’s from Etruria. It’s actually not that far away, really. Yeah, we’re pretty close. And I can tell you that these people don’t know how to defend themselves for shit. They are. They are lazy, sitting around making wine, kind of people, and you could just walk right in there and take your share. And you know what the Gauls say we’re
Dr Rad 46:48
in? Yeah, absolutely. Although it seems a bit harsh to the horse here, trust guns, they seem pretty dominant for quite some time.
Dr G 46:54
Arruns doesn’t think so, and his heart has been broken, so he does not care. Is he telling the whole truth to the Gaulish people? Maybe not. Is he worried about the outcome? Probably not. But we do have our first example in all of recorded history of the French now being jealous of the Italians and wanting what the Italians have for themselves. And this is going to set up a narrative that will last 1000s and 1000s of
Dr Rad 47:23
years. Wow. Well, Livy actually does mention that story as well. However, he does cast a little bit of doubt on it by saying, Look, I’m not gonna contradict the story, which to me, kind of indicates that he’s thought about it and thought Is this realistic? I don’t know. He says that it’s generally agreed. And I’m quoting my translation there that the Gauls who attack clusium were not the first Gauls to cross over the Alps. And I’m kind of like, well, duh, Livy, because there’s a lot of questions in this story. First of all, Clusium. Clusium, of all places. Dr G, it would seem that perhaps this particular location might have been decided upon, because later on, the Romans and Clusium, they’ll have some affairs. But right now, it’s quite far away. Does it make sense as a place for the Gauls to be attacking? We can’t be certain. There is certainly zero archeological evidence to support contact between the Gauls and Clusium, of all places,
Dr G 48:37
and also the idea that the Romans have an alliance with Clusium, which is one of the other pieces of information that’s bandied about. And it’s like the Romans haven’t ventured this far north. They would have had to skip over a whole bunch of Etruscan places in order to get to Clusium. To be like, let’s be friends, and for the Clusians to agree and be like, Sure,
Dr Rad 48:56
exactly yes. Not a lot of this makes sense. You Latins
Dr G 48:59
from a little backwater. Why not? What we can
Dr Rad 49:02
say is that gold slash Celts, whatever you want to call them Celts, even they probably were migrating because they were after the usual stuff, land, well, and stuff, really. And by stuff, I mean, sandals, really, resources, animals, fruits, wine, whatever is going and it could be because they need more space. Maybe they’ve had a bit of a population boom. Perhaps, we’re not really sure, but there are waves, it would seem, of tribes, sort of coming over, and gradually they’re setting themselves up in the sort of northeast of Italy, sort of Po Valley area. And this would be something that would be interesting to Livy, because, lest we forget, he is from Padua, which is in Cisalpine Gaul. Yes, exactly. Look at him go. And this is one of my funnest little things true. Remember about Latin because we know I don’t understand Latin, but CIS Alpine Gaul literally means Gaul this side of the Alps, as opposed to trans Alpine Gaul, Gaul that side.
Dr G 50:12
Yes. Never listen to people who tell you that cis and trans have not been in use for 1000s of years, because they have
Dr Rad 50:18
Yes exactly. Yes, exactly. So we do have these waves of migration happening. And as you can imagine, that does lead to conflict between the people that are there and some of the people that are there are Etruscans. We do have some archeological evidence showing the conflict between Etruscans and Celts there are apparently, and I’m quoting my source here, which is Gary Forsythe’s book, horseshoe shaped sandstone tombstones from the Etruscan community of Felsina, dating to the early fourth century BCE, where you may See a noble Etruscan warrior on horseback doing battle with a nude Celtic dude on foot. Well, there you go. So this is going, we’re going to see increasing influence. And I actually did not know this. I can’t believe I didn’t know this. But a lot of the police names in this part of Italy actually come from the Celtic tribes and whatnot that set themselves up here, like bologna. I did not know that. I should have known that, but I didn’t.
Dr G 51:28
Oh, look, yep, the north of Italy. It is different from other spots of Italy. Yeah, there’s different influences going on
Dr Rad 51:36
now, as you might imagine, here in lies our difficulty, right? Because we have almost nothing from the Etruscans in terms of their writing. Most of what we have that sort of tells their history is, in fact, archeological their writing doesn’t really tell, like narrative histories, and it’s very, very limited, and so we don’t get much. And then, of course, the other people, they’re going to come into contact with the Greeks and the Romans, as I mentioned before, and they don’t necessarily have the understanding necessary, particularly at this early time, to understand all the subtle nuances between these different Celtic groups of people and tribes that they might be encountering. They do get to know some of the names of these different groups and that sort of thing. But as for giving us, you know, a nuanced portrayal of who these people are, I’m afraid we just don’t have it. Dr, G, oh, sorry. I know, I know we might be wondering, because Livy actually does something interesting here. He actually gives quite a lot of detail, though, about the history of the contact and where these people are coming from. And I have to say it’s unlike anything I have read in Livy so far. It actually does remind you a lot of the kind of stuff that Herodotus does, and that might be what he’s imitating here.
Dr G 52:47
Interesting. He’s getting into a bit of an ethnography. Is he
Dr Rad 52:51
a little bit? Yeah, he goes on this little disc like he doesn’t often do that, like he might go into a bit of a backstory, but as you know, Livy’s not always one for detail. He sometimes skims through things very quickly. He talks about the fact that, from his point of view, of view, from his sources, what other sources? Not really sure. We think they might be Greek, not really convinced. Apparently, there are a couple of potentials, like maybe some of our is writing and a person called Timagenes, but we’re not really sure. Seemingly, he actually was probably using more Greek sources than vara. But anyway, he says that 200 years passed between the initial crossing of the Gauls into, you know, the north of Italy, and their attack on Clusium, which is happening right now in this very year, and that the people from Clusium, the Clusinii, which sounds a bit like fangirls of George Clooney, were not the first Etruscans who had had to fight the Gauls, that there had been lots of conflict going on between the people of this region. And this is where we get some of the classic racist style remarks, I suppose, from Livy. He talks about certain tribes having, you know, incredible savagery. And we’re going to see constant references to the the temper of these particular people. What we think is actually happening is that these groups that are migrating into Italy probably coming via Switzerland and maybe South Germany, and not actually possibly Gaul itself. Now, one of the stories that Livy relates is that during the reign of Tarquinius Priscus, the Celts, one of three divisions of the Gaulish people, were being ruled by another tribe. And I’m going to butcher this pronunciation, I apologize, the Bituriges, the Bituriges, Bituriges are the better. Yeah, the Bituriges, the Bituriges, perhaps the Bituriges. And it’s from this tribe that a king was given to the Celts. This man’s name was Ambigatus, Ambigatus, very ambiguous of him. I know, I know he was. A man of considerable talent, but also had a lot of good luck, which meant that he became quite a distinguished leader, and the Gauls became extremely prosperous under his rule. They had just so much corn and so many babies being born. I mean, they were Scrooge McDucking themselves all over the place. They were just diving into their pits of money.
Dr G 55:26
It’s a tough life, but someone’s gotta live it.
Dr Rad 55:29
As Ambigutas becomes old, he didn’t want to see his kingdom remain so large, because that would be crazy. It’s too much prosperity. Gotta dish it out a little bit. So instead, he decided to send his nephews via his sister, Bellovesus and Segovesus. They’re the names I’m going for. I apologize for my pronunciation on a quest to find new homes which could be given to them by the gods and oh boy. Oh boy. Dr G, these nephews were up for the task. Now, the king assures his nephews that they’re going to be taking a large number of followers with them, so that no one’s going to be able to stand in their way. Now, this sounds kind of crazy. On what planet have you ever heard of someone being like, we’re just too prosperous. We’re going to share this prosperity around in this manner. It sounds
Dr G 56:24
like somebody having some difficulties with some nephews and being like, you know what? I’m going to arm them up and send them in opposite directions, and then they’re going to leave me alone,
Dr Rad 56:33
possibly, or it’s just a really weird explanation for the fact that, actually they need more land, they need more territory, and they need to conquer it. So they’re given various areas where they’re going to like, this is divvied up by lot like where they’re going to go. And it is Segovesus, who is assigned the Hercynian Highlands, which is the upland districts of South Germany, including places now known as like the Black Forest, Bohemia and so on, and Bellovesus, he is directed by the gods straight into Italy. Now he is leading extra members from the tribes, the Bituriges, the Arverni, the Senones, the Haidui, the Ambarri, the Carnutes and the Aulerci. I’m sure I just mispronounced a whole lot of Celtic names there. And they have a mixture of infantry and cavalry with them. And they, of course, then have to come across the difficulty of how they’re going to get across the Alps,
Dr G 57:42
I’d recommend elephants
Dr Rad 57:46
the little bit before that time, and I don’t think they’ve packed any elephants, unfortunately, so they have some difficulties. They’re a bit hesitant. They’re kind of intimidated by the sight of the Alps. And I do understand where they’re coming from. The Alps are pretty big, so it’s superstition that apparently makes them pause at this point in time the exact details of their crossing. I’m not even going to go into it, because, again, it seems like Livy probably has got it wrong in terms of what was possible, etc, etc, at this point in time. But once we have these guys across the Alps, because they do indeed make it across. They are soon followed by other goals, who start setting themselves up in various places in the north of Italy. So it’s a waterfall. Dr, G, it’s just being unleashed.
Dr G 58:32
Yeah, they found a path, and then they told everybody about it, and now everybody’s on the other side of the mountains.
Dr Rad 58:39
Yep, exactly. We’re told that it’s the Senones who seem to be the last to migrate, and the reason why I’m mentioning them is that Livy thinks it’s people from this tribe that went to Clusium and then eventually will go on to Rome. Spoilers. Again, you
Dr Rad 59:20
so the men of Clusium rock up to Rome because they’re completely freaked out by this attack by the presumably Senones group of the Celts slash Gauls. And it’s not just because it’s an attack, it’s also because they’re really strange people with crazy weapons that the people of colus have apparently never seen, even though they’re kind of in this area of Italy and the goals have been there for a while. I think so I question this Dr G, but let’s just move on with our narrative. You
Dr G 59:53
say move on, but I’m not sure that I can. What kind of weapons do these people have that they’ve never seen before?
Dr Rad 59:59
Oh, they just seem strange. I mean, I think we can definitely question Livy’s narrative here, because if the Gauls have been migrating for like, the last 100 years or so, would there be weapons that the people of clusium Haven’t seen? Are the Celtic weapons even that different from the kinds of weapons that the Romans would use. These are all legitimate questions. Dr G, I’ve never
Dr G 1:00:23
seen that handle before. Barbarians.
Dr Rad 1:00:27
You call that a knife. Why? Exactly, yeah. So there’s much talk about the disruption that is happening in this part of Italy at this point in time. And you might be wondering. Dr G, why on earth would the people of clusium turn to Rome of all people for help in their time of need? Because there is no alliance between any people in Etruria and the Romans at this moment in time. About the only thing that the men of clusium have to recommend themselves is the fact that they did not side with they during Rome’s recent war with they.
Dr G 1:01:07
Look that doesn’t score them big points, surely. Well,
Dr Rad 1:01:11
nobody did. Nobody did. That was kind of the point, wasn’t it? But anyway, now they’re seeking help from the Roman Senate. Roman Senate don’t want to rush into anything here, for exactly that reason. There is no formal Alliance here. They don’t really see why they should be helping the people of Clusium, per se, Clusium is very far to the north, after all, however, they do agree to offer a limited kind of assistance, and this is where our ambassadors come in. Dr G the three sons of Marcus Fabius Ambustus, are dispatched as ambassadors to Gaul and tell them off Officially
Dr G 1:01:54
in the name of Rome. Oh, yes. Well, there’s nothing like an official Roman telling off is there. And who better than the fabulous Fabii.
Dr Rad 1:02:01
precisely they’re going to dazzle the Celts with their fabulousness. So when they arrive, they say, How dare you pick on friends of Rome, particularly this group of people in Clusium who have done nothing to provoke you. Celtish people, the Romans do not want war. Dr G, this is what they tell the senes. Well,
Dr G 1:02:26
that’s a change of offense, isn’t it? Somebody should interrogate this more closely. I think
Dr Rad 1:02:31
it’s more they don’t want war with this particular group of people because they don’t even know who they are.
Dr G 1:02:37
Yes, it’s always better to go to war with your friends, people that you know
Dr Rad 1:02:41
precisely. They say, look, you’re strangers to us. We don’t know much about you. We would rather be on friendly terms with you, Gauls slash Celts slash Senones. And even though the response to this would kind of make sense sitting in 391 I would like to leave it on a bit of a cliffhanger there. Dr, G, but yes, this is, this is what we’ve got. We’ve got Romans talking to the Celts at this moment on behalf of their kind of friends, not friends, frenemies from Clusium. And I’m going to get into exactly how this exchange plays out. I think next time?
Dr G 1:03:20
Oh, oh, well, I look forward to finding out what happens next.
Dr Rad 1:03:26
One thing I can say is that Livy is probably relying on a source that relied on Fabius Pictor.
Dr G 1:03:35
Oh, okay. Well, that makes things more interesting. No wonder there’s so many baby I involved.
Dr Rad 1:03:42
Well, that’s exactly it. It’s probably the case that a lot of the stuff that we’re dealing with at this point in time, as it has been for quite some time, is drawing on like family histories and family traditions that have been passed down. And if those people go on to be some of the source material that Livy is using, well, some of their relatives get a spotlight thrust upon them.
Dr G 1:04:07
Well, well, well, okay, a point of Tension we have reached you.
Dr G 1:04:41
Meanwhile, in Sicily, I will try to cover this quickly, but there are some pretty fun things that are happening in Sicily at this point in time. According to Diodorus Siculus, he gets three of the names of the military tribunes correct and one of them terribly wrong. Him and two not mentioned at all, but be that as it may, what’s going on with the tyrant of Syracuse, Dionysus. He’s taken his army to Hipponium, which is a colony of the Locrian people. It’s in Calabria, and he’s hanging out there, partly because he is in favor with the locrians. And by in favor of the locrians, he likes them because they agreed to his marriage suggestion. The Rhegians
Dr Rad 1:05:31
refused. Finally, somebody sees sense. They were
Dr G 1:05:34
like, Sure, you can marry one of the nice girls. You’re my favorite people in southern Italy, I’m gonna do things for you. So now, when he starts taking over things, sometimes he gives a bit of the land to the Locrians, being like, you guys, here’s a gift. And they’re like, cheers, thanks. I’m sure that’s making the locrians very popular with all of their neighbors. Meanwhile, the Rhegians and their situation, because that’s made him really angry. He’s still stewing over that. So he decides that what better than to attack them directly? That’s really what needs to happen now. And he builds up to it with a sort of a sneaky, I’m just putting some supplies here. Don’t worry about it. We’re going to be moving on shortly. And the Rhegians, for some reason, are like, okay, it’s a transportation mover. That’s fine.
Dr Rad 1:06:24
Sounds like the Cuban Missile Crisis.
Dr G 1:06:28
I mean, the Rhegians, they should have, maybe they should have realized it gets to the point where so many supplies are building up outside of their city. They’re like, Excuse me, you said you were moving on. He’s like, Well, I’m not moving on. It’s a siege.
Dr Rad 1:06:45
Like, oh no, wow. A surprise siege.
Dr G 1:06:48
Well, yeah, one that they didn’t see coming for a little while. Apparently, even though all the stuff was arrived, I was gonna say another siege engine that’s curious,
Dr Rad 1:06:58
all these weapons, no surprise. What’s going on?
Dr G 1:07:02
Not smart guys. Not
Dr Rad 1:07:04
smart day for another several months. Yeah.
Dr G 1:07:07
What is this? The Trojan War, anyway. So aside from the Rhegian’s silliness in this moment, they decide, once they realize it is a siege and the target is indeed them. They wheel themselves into action. They sign up a guy called Phyton as their general.
Dr Rad 1:07:29
Once again, could be a character in the Marvel Universe. What is going on?
Dr G 1:07:33
I think, I think they got the Greek from these guys, so they went with it. And he’s well organized, and he decides that they’re gonna attack the siege engines. That’s the first plan, and it’s a good plan. They burn a whole bunch of the siege equipment, and this means that they’re fighting outside of the walls, which also means that they’re engaging with the Sicilian Greeks. Dionysus himself gets struck by a lance in the groin. Apparently, it’s more common than you’d think, because we’ve had other characters in history so far this has happened to it’s a weak spot, apparently. Well, yeah,
Dr Rad 1:08:10
I mean, to be fair, what I would say to most people out there, if attacked by a man is kick him in the crutch and run. If I had a lance, I’d probably use that too.
Dr G 1:08:20
Exactly, you know, go for the soft spot, yeah. So he barely escapes death, apparently, and has difficulty recovering from this wound.
Dr Rad 1:08:28
Well, yeah, fair enough. It hurts a lot, a lot of vasectomy. Nevertheless, the siege
Dr G 1:08:35
continues. So, you know, I imagine the case being that Dionysus, the tyrant, is sort of wheeled off to a tent nearby, and is lying there, sort of trying to recover, and is still like continue the siege. So he’s still in charge. He’s still around. The siege continues to happen. Meanwhile, there’s also the Olympic games happening. Of course, it’s a big year, and Dionysus decides to send a team to the Olympic Games. He’s like, I’m Greek. I’m allowed to go. And he’s very keen to have some professional poets recite his poetry. He considers himself a poet. Oh,
Dr Rad 1:09:15
of course he does. Of course he does. He just fits with the whole tyrant modus operandi, doesn’t it to write terrible poetry and force other people to listen to it. The
Dr G 1:09:24
entitlement does not end. He was madly addicted to poetry. So the trouble is that he sends his professional reciters of poetry to the Olympic Games, and people come along to listen because they’re like, Oh, well, you know, let’s see what he’s got to offer. And then they hear the verse them, and the verse is so bad, they start to
Dr Rad 1:09:47
be pleased to hear that actually, you know, I’m actually getting strong vibes from like the Barbie movie, like when they’re all sitting around the fireplace singing Matchbox 20.
Dr G 1:09:56
So people at the Olympic Games are laughing at. Dionysus poetry. It doesn’t matter that it’s being recited by professionals. That’s not enough to cover up the inferior quality of the verse itself. Ouch. Even worse, he has chariot tier teams involved that get involved in crashes so they get eliminated from the competition. So that’s a
Dr Rad 1:10:19
blow that’s fairly common, though, isn’t it? But
Dr G 1:10:23
not only that, other members of the team that get through that whole process, there’s a shipwreck on the way home. So he loses a whole bunch of his Olympic team in the return journey as
Dr Rad 1:10:33
well. Nobody talks about this in the history of the Olympics,
Dr G 1:10:37
exactly. Everyone’s just like, turn up. Do the Olympics win a wreath? Have a good time. We
Dr Rad 1:10:41
talk about Munich, we talk about all this other stuff, but where is the shipwreck of 391, approximately,
Dr G 1:10:48
exactly, exactly the shipwreck. And this, it’s devastating, because not only is Dionysus dealing with the fact that he’s lost a whole bunch of his team in the return journey, but the ones who managed to survive to get home start spreading the stories about his terrible poetry and how it was received, because that’s the story of the Olympics for them. And he catches wind of this, and he’s so annoyed and so frustrated, you can just imagine he’s trying to sit up, but he’s got this groin wound. He’s like, but my art poetry, my soft parts.
Dr Rad 1:11:27
There once was a tyrant from Syracuse, yes, exactly, really, really didn’t like to lose
Dr G 1:11:34
it’s that kind of poetry. You know, he invented the limerick, and nobody appreciated it. So frustrating for him. Anyway, the good news is that he has his advisors who managed to persuade him that he is actually the object of envy, and people are laughing at him because they’re jealous of his
Dr Rad 1:11:58
talent, of course, of course, now. And so the key
Dr G 1:12:03
thing is to not give up and to persist with your art until eventually, that envy transforms into admiration. So his devotion to his writing is not subdued by this devastating Olympic Games. And I imagine, you know, he’s in pain. He’s probably going back to writing his poetry as well. Now, the other small little detail that Diodorus Siculus provides about this year 391 is that the Romans fight a battle at Gurasium. Oh, Gurasium. Yes, I tried to find Gurasium. We don’t know where Gurasium was. It feels like another made up name by Diodorus Siculus.
Dr Rad 1:12:47
I was going to say, is it because it doesn’t exist? Well,
Dr G 1:12:50
I sometimes wonder whether he’s misreading a source that he’s looking at when it’s written down, or that somebody has told him a piece of information and he’s tried to remember it orally, and then misspelled it. And somehow the misspelling has come into it, because he says it’s with the Volscians, and that would not be out of keeping with where the Romans are at right now. Sure, like the Volscians are far closer than the Etruscans in the north or, yeah, and even the Aequii things like that, the Volsinii and they he says that the Romans slew a great number of the enemy, which is also the kind of thing that’s relatively believable for the Romans in this time period. It
Dr Rad 1:13:33
is. But Dr G, this is not where I’m at in my narrative. My narrative is telling me that the Romans are being given sign after sign, and they keep really ticking off the gods in return. Well,
Dr G 1:13:44
but I mean, the good news is that we’ve got six military tribunes for consular power this year, and one of them could be going against the Volscians.
Dr Rad 1:13:52
That’s true. Not all of them have been given a specific campaign,
Dr G 1:13:57
and that is my detail for 391
Dr Rad 1:14:00
Oh, well. Dr G, I think that means it is time for
Dr G 1:14:04
the partial pick.
Dr Rad 1:14:12
Oh, that was a long episode, Igor. Let’s get into it. What is the partial pick? All About? Dr G, ooh,
Dr G 1:14:19
the partial pick where we rate Rome against her own standards, with a possibility of 50 golden eagles, 10 across five categories. The first category is military clout, huh?
Dr Rad 1:14:34
Well, well, well, well, the
Dr G 1:14:39
Romans fought a battle at Jerusalem. I
Dr Rad 1:14:43
I’m just thinking hard. I’m not really feeling a lot of military clout coming out of this year. It’s really a lot more about the Gaul. There’s a lot of detail about tribes going here and there.
Dr G 1:14:55
Hmm, yeah, Livy got really wave laid by the detail, didn’t he?
Dr Rad 1:14:59
He did. But. We do have the conflict with a Volsinii, we do, and potentially the other place that just hid behind their walls. Don’t mind if I do. Yeah, we do have a little bit of conflict. So I guess maybe, like a three or four again, I don’t know.
Dr G 1:15:21
Look, I think we’ve got even less detail than we had for the previous year. So maybe a three,
Dr Rad 1:15:24
yeah, I’m just looking at my detail again. It really isn’t lot. At least there’s a bit more strategy here. The Romans used their cavalry to cut off their cavalry, and they surrendered, and then the other people were too scared, and then they plundered. There is a bit more detail. Now, you know what, four, because they get the salaries paid for. Oh yeah, that’s a bit fancy, isn’t it? It is a little bit I think they deserve a four for that and a 20 year truce.
Dr G 1:15:51
A 20, well, let’s save that for diplomacy, shall we? No, I
Dr Rad 1:15:54
know, but I just mean, like militarily, it says something. I feel, I feel it. All
Dr G 1:16:00
right? A four, okay, a four. The second category is diplomacy, okay.
Dr Rad 1:16:06
Well, they do agree on a peace settlement, which seemingly makes them like BFFs with the Etruscans all of a sudden, and they do send ambassadors to just talk to the Gauls. It’s probably not entirely true. It seems like the earliest versions of this story had two unnamed ambassadors going to Clusium, and they weren’t going there as ambassadors. They were going there to spy.
Dr G 1:16:52
Well, that sounds almost more likely, but from a diplomatic perspective, sending ambassadors somewhere, that’s diplomacy, getting a truce fixed up. That’s diplomacy,
Dr Rad 1:17:03
yep, yep. All right, so what are we going to give them, like a three, sure. Okay, that’s, that’s our next category, expansion. Not really. They’re traveling, but they’re not expanding.
Dr G 1:17:16
They’re expanding their horizons. They
Dr Rad 1:17:18
are. They are. They’re definitely looking much further north than they ever have before, but their gaze is directed there by others.
Dr G 1:17:27
All right, that’s a zero. Yeah, the fourth category is virtus,
Dr Rad 1:17:33
not particularly, I would say it’s a pretty grim year. Actually got military tribunes laughing in the face of poor little plebeians. You’ve just heard God speak directly to them. Sorry, yeah, a God speak directly to them.
Dr G 1:17:48
I mean, could he just be
Dr Rad 1:17:50
mad? Mad as a hatter, they say.
Dr G 1:17:53
All right, no, virtus. And finally, the citizen score,
Dr Rad 1:17:57
hmm, well, there certainly is a sense of lingering disease in the air that’s not great. We’ve got war with the Volsinii and another place, maybe, but it’s victorious.
Dr G 1:18:08
In both cases, it seems that Rome is posting a victory.
Dr Rad 1:18:11
Yeah. Is that good news? Because they’re still they’re still fighting. They’re still out there in the field
Dr G 1:18:16
well, but they’re also not saying that there’s been substantial losses. So as far as
Dr Rad 1:18:23
battles go, yeah, if anything, they’re indicating the opposite, I would say.
Dr G 1:18:26
So it’s probably as good as it can be for when you’re being very aggressive. It’s actually it’s
Dr Rad 1:18:31
making me realize just how much Livy spends time talking about the Gauls I have almost nothing about what’s actually happening in Rome. It’s all about the Gauls and their various waves of migration.
Dr G 1:18:44
And then these guys came over the Alps, and then these that
Dr Rad 1:18:47
is literally what he does for like he’s seriously invoking Herodotus. There is such a long passage where he talks about and then these guys, and then these guys, and then these guys encounter these guys, and then they take this pass, and they take that pass, and they go over here and they encounter these people. Honestly, I couldn’t keep it all straight
Dr G 1:19:04
on that account, I can say it must be a great time for the Roman citizens, because they’re not getting dragged into anything yet. They’re just sort of hanging around at Rome being like, didn’t know the goals existed.
Dr Rad 1:19:14
That’s pretty much it never loved yet. But the fact that the Etruscans are worried by these people? Hmm, I don’t know.
Dr G 1:19:23
Okay, well, it’s not having a direct impact on Roman citizens, though,
Dr Rad 1:19:27
not yet, but it will fairly dramatically and soon.
Dr G 1:19:32
Well, yes, but like, that’s, that’s a trouble for next
Dr Rad 1:19:36
that’s a 390 Roman problem. Yeah, okay, fair enough. All right, so citizen score. What are we saying? Then? Is it like a five? It like a five? I suppose it’s not too bad, yeah, but there is that playground, maybe a four, and Camillus is gone, which they might be happy about.
Dr G 1:19:51
Look, I think that’s a win. It’s back to a five.
Dr Rad 1:19:55
Actually, that’s true. Is Camillus being gone like a bit of a victory for them?
Dr G 1:19:59
Yeah, I think so that’s definitely what they wanted.
Dr Rad 1:20:02
Well, I mean, some of them, not all of them, all right, so are we going to say five? Okay, all right, in that case, Dr G, it is a total of 12 Golden Eagles for Rome. I don’t know why. I just said it like that, 12 Golden Eagles for Rome.
Dr G 1:20:19
Huzzah. Well, they did better than the year before. Let’s see if they can keep it up,
Dr Rad 1:20:26
that they won’t
Dr G 1:20:28
just be like, let’s be optimistic. People talk about 390 as being a terrible time, but we don’t know yet, because we haven’t
Dr Rad 1:20:35
done it. That’s right. I mean Gaelic sack. That could just mean Santa Claus, a tribal bag of some sort,
Dr G 1:20:43
exactly, yeah, turned up with the Christmas presents Exactly,
Dr Rad 1:20:47
exactly. It’s like the Celtic version of Santa Claus, exactly, all right. Dr, G, well, I look forward to spending, presumably, at least three episodes talking about 390 BC, with you. Oh, I
Dr G 1:21:00
look forward to it.
Dr Rad 1:21:12
Thank you for listening to this episode of the partial historians. You can find our sources sound credits and an automated transcript in our show notes, Our music is by Betina Joy de coosman, the partial historians is part of the Memory Collective, creators and educators dedicated to sharing knowledge that is accessible, contextualized, socially conscious and inclusive, to find more from the memory collective head to collectivemem.com. You too can support our show and help us to produce more fascinating content about the ancient world by supporting us on Ko fi or by becoming a Patreon. In return, you receive exclusive early access to our special episodes and ad free content. Today, we would like to send a special shout out to someone who always buys us a coffee on ko fi. Kent Johnson, however, if your pockets are a bit light on the denarii, please just tell someone about the show or give us a five star review until next time we are yours in ancient Rome.
Transcribed by https://otter.ai
The post Episode 165 – Surf the Celtic Wave appeared first on The Partial Historians - Ancient Roman History with smart ladies.
In this special episode, we tackle the second half of the 1963 epic, Cleopatra.
In the first part of this double-header, we tried to keep our focus on Cleopatra and Caesar and the initial challenges faced by #TeamCleo. However, today we get to delve into the second half of the movie when Cleopatra and Antony get it on. This means we finally get to discuss ‘Le Scandale’, aka the Taylor-Burton affair that developed on the set once these two clapped eyes on each other. Their passion would result in two broken hearts, a publicity sensation and not one, but TWO, marriages (and divorces).
Cleopatra (1963) is a classic example of how the context of a film can shape how the history was received. It’s hard not to see some weird parallels between Taylor & Burton and Cleopatra & Antony. We need to work on some couple names before this gets too confusing. Cleotony? Antra? Tayton? Burtay? We’ll keep workshopping these ideas.
Elizabeth Taylor and Richard Burton in December 1963, just after the completion of Cleopatra. Courtesy of Tullio Saba on Flickr.
One thing we have concluded after three hours of discussion: don’t start shooting a movie without a finished script.
If you enjoyed this discussion, you might be interested in checking out The Plot Thickens, who are doing a whole season on Cleopatra (1963).
Drs G and Dr Rad discuss ancient sources such as Florus, Cicero, Appian, and of course, Plutarch’s Life of Antony.
Brodsky, Jack, and Nathan Weiss. The Cleopatra Papers : A Private Correspondence. New York: Simon and Schuster, 1963.
Geist, Kenneth L. Pictures Will Talk : The Life and Films of Joseph L. Mankiewicz. New York: Scribner, 1978.
Humphries, Patrick. Cleopatra and the Undoing of Hollywood : How One Film Almost Sunk the Studios. Cheltenham: The History Press Ltd., 2023.
Lloyd Llewellyn-Jones, and Daniel Ogden. “CELLULOID CLEOPATRAS or DID THE GREEKS EVER GET TO EGYPT?” In The Hellenistic World, 275-. United Kingdom: The Classical Press of Wales, 2002.
Royster, F. Becoming Cleopatra : The Shifting Image of an Icon. 1st ed. 2003. New York: Palgrave Macmillan US, 2003. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-137-07417-1.
Southern, P. Cleopatra. Gloucestershire: Tempus, 2007.
Taraborrelli, J. Randy. Elizabeth. London: Pan Macmillan, 2006.
Wanger, Wanger, and Joe Hyams. My Life with Cleopatra: The Making of a Hollywood Classic. New York: Vintage, 1963.
Wyke, Maria. Projecting the Past : Ancient Rome, Cinema, and History. New York: Routledge, 1997.
Our music is by the wonderful Bettina Joy de Guzman.
Dr Rad 0:15
Foreign Welcome to the partial historians.
Dr G 0:18
We explore all the details of ancient Rome,
Dr Rad 0:23
everything from political scandals, the love affairs, the battles waged and when citizens turn against each other, I’m Dr rad,
Dr G 0:32
and I’m Dr G, we consider Rome as the Romans saw it, by reading different authors from the ancient past and comparing their stories.
Dr Rad 0:44
Join us as we trace the journey of Rome from the founding of the city.
Dr G 0:54
Hello and welcome to this brand new special episode of the partial historians. I am Dr G
Dr Rad 1:03
and I am Dr rad, and we
Dr G 1:07
are going to discuss the second half of Cleopatra, the blockbuster film from 1963 starring Elizabeth Taylor and Richard Burton. And this means that it’s a follow on from our part one looking at the same film, but it also means things are about to get far more complicated in terms of things to do with the production and things to do with Cleopatra and Mark Antony.
Dr Rad 1:35
Absolutely. We definitely recommend you go back and listen to our part one, but just to set the scene. Dr G to do a quick little recap in part one, where we were focusing a little bit more on the first half of the movie, where it was about Caesar and Cleopatra’s relationship. Mostly, we highlighted how this production was beset with problems from the get go. They had ongoing issues with weather being unusually temperamental, which meant that sometimes their sets were damaged, or sometimes they just couldn’t film. We also have the ongoing issues of Elizabeth Taylor’s health, in spite of the fact that she was one of the most beautiful movie stars of all time and commanded an insanely high fee to play Cleopatra, just goes to show you that money cannot buy you happiness or health. She was plagued with lots of health issues throughout this production, including a particular bout of, I believe, pneumonia, which almost killed her and meant she actually had to have an emergency tracheotomy and then plastic surgery to cover up the tracheotomy scar. On top of the fact that the film company that was producing this movie was in dire financial straits. Cleopatra was meant to be the movie that saved the studio spoilers. It did not.
Dr G 2:54
We’ve got to spend money to make money. That’s how it works in the film industry.
Dr Rad 2:59
All right, that’s how it works. So there’s all sorts of complications. And of course, all of these issues have a domino effect sometimes in that we’ve sort we seen how Elizabeth Taylor’s health problems meant that casting issues arose because the initial Caesar and Antony, they had had to be recast, etc, etc. So it has been complicated, and they’ve had to relocate from pine wood studios in England to Cinecitta in Rome, and this is where most of the actual filming takes place, because there was very little done in England, unfortunately,
Dr G 3:37
well, fair enough. And the weather is apparently nicer in Italy anyway, and more conducive for Taylor’s health, as we’ve discussed in the previous episode. So probably good news for her, really, it is.
Dr Rad 3:48
But even in Rome, they did still have unusual weather problems. Like, I believe there was a particular day where it rained so hard their forums set flooded, like, really badly, they could film. And this is what keeps happening. Because I must admit, one of my big sources for preparing for this episode was Walter Wanger and Joe Hyams My Life with Cleopatra, which is essentially Walter Wanger’s kind of diaries from when he was the producer of his film, because this was he really his baby from the get go, he was the one that really drove a lot of this production. And when you’re looking at it in diary form, I actually feel quite sorry for him in many ways, because there are just so many times so he’ll be like Rex Harrison called in sick. Richard Burton too hung over to shoot. Elizabeth Taylor had more medical issues. It’s just endless. And then on top of that, you add in the diary entries where he says something, like, it was too cold, there wasn’t enough this, there wasn’t enough that it was too rainy. Like there’s just endless delays where they can’t film what they were intending to or There was even one instance where they shot a scene between. Antony and Cleopatra. And one of the issues they faced was that they were filming in this Todd ao cinematic style, one of these widescreen technologies. And this is partly because it benefits Elizabeth Taylor, because who invented Todd AO, why her third husband, Mike Todd, who died tragically in a plane crash, that wasn’t nice, but it did mean that she inherited his Todd AO filming method, but it’s an incredibly cumbersome way to film, and none of the Italians studios have a way of actually processing the film, viewing the film, et cetera. So what they would have to do is every time they shot something, they had to fly it back to America to get processed, et cetera, and then it would get back. And apparently there was a particular scene that they shot, and then on the flight, the film wasn’t packed properly, and it compromised the quality. They couldn’t process it. It came out all like foggy and weird, and so they had to re shoot it. And it’s just this kind of stuff that seems to keep on happening, just endless delays. In fact, one of my favorite delays, which I think you will also appreciate, there was even an incident where a cat managed to get into the set and give birth to kittens underneath Cleopatra’s bed, and they realized that they were there, because all of a sudden, these tiny, little newborn kittens screamed during a love scene between Cleopatra and Antony, so they had to pause filming. Incredible. They then had to, I think, actually dismantle the set, like to, I mean, probably dismantle the bed, because whilst they could get the mother cat out relatively easily, these kittens were so young, they were still blind and couldn’t see what on earth was going on, so they weren’t going to be coaxed out by food or anything like that, and it costs them in delays and labor and all of that kind of stuff, $17,000 just to get rid
Dr G 6:52
Wow. Okay, the fateful cats interrupting the filming. There is a really particular scene in this second half of the film where Cleopatra and Antony are having an argument of some kind, or a really intense conversation where they’re just agreeing about something, and it’s shot in so many different ways and in different costumes, almost to kind of suggest that this is an ongoing conflict that they have. But you get the feeling from the production side that this is actually because, for whatever reason, there was some complexities with shooting it, and they weren’t able to get everybody in the same place, in the same time, the same costumes. And so they were just like, we’ll just shoot it in pieces, and we’ll just piece it all together from whatever we’ve got, or it’s a mishmash to make sense of, something that was a lot bigger and more complicated, that did take place over a number of different scenes. And in the end, they were like, We don’t have time for this. We’re just gonna have to Franken scene. It into some sort of montage argument. And I was like, Wow, guys, wow.
Dr Rad 7:50
Yeah, I believe that’s when Antony comes back after having married Octavia. But yes, I agree. I would love to know if that was intended to show the passage of time, and the fact that they’re not resolving this argument quickly, or whether it was something more on the production side, I mean the fact that they were filming it in different costumes, but the same argument kind of suggests that maybe it was a deliberate choice that they did want to show the passing of time. But it’s hard to know, because, as again, we highlighted in the previous episode, but it bears mentioning here. Originally, this was meant to be two films, one called Caesar and Cleopatra, and one called Cleopatra and Antony. And what ended up happening with the production nightmare that ensued is that the people who worked on the movie were forced to combine it into one very long epic, and therefore a lot of stuff obviously got cut out, and we unfortunately don’t really know what that stuff was, because whilst at the end, I do have a statistic here for you, there was over 450,000 feet of film that was shot, which would have taken you 96 hours to watch
Dr G 9:03
Oh, my goodness. So
Dr Rad 9:06
there’s definitely some missing footage.
Dr G 9:08
I want the full release, please. The director’s cut only.
Dr Rad 9:12
That would be a hell of a Director’s Cut. Whilst there’s obviously there was extra footage that was shot. Not a lot of her has ever managed to be recovered. You know, it’s quite fashionable, particularly in like the nine particularly in like the 90s, there was a real spate of doing these restorations. Spartacus was one of those films that got restored in the 90s, but Cleopatra, there hasn’t been much footage that has showed up from those those cuts, which is a real shame, because we know that the original Director’s Cut was a lot longer than what we now have. I mean, there’s, there’s a few disputes about the exact number, but I believe that Mankiewicz. Mankiewicz was actually taken off the film and was told he wasn’t allowed to do the editing, but he eventually did get rehired. This is part of the production drama going on with studio heads changing at 20th Century Fox as. Were trying to grimly cling to life and try and keep the studio afloat, and there were real disputes between the new head of Fox, which who was Darryl Zanuck, and then Mankiewicz. Zanuck seems to have kind of switched his position from blaming the fact that this movie had been poorly managed by the film company, to blaming Mankiewicz personally for a lot of the failings of this film and the fact that it went so over budget, etc. So he’d removed him, but then he did bring him back, but we know that his cut was originally a lot longer than what ended up being the cinema release, because Zanuck was a bit more ruthless, probably because you didn’t have that personal attachment to it. And then even after the release of the film, there were so many audience complaints about the film being boring and too long that it was then cut down again, which I think is the version that we now tend to watch. Wow.
Dr G 10:58
Okay, so even watching it on the gloriously restored as much as possible, Cleopatra DVD set, which I possess, which itself is a relic at this stage. Maybe I’m not seeing the full flourishing glory that appeared in the cinema. Well, it just
Dr Rad 11:12
depends. I mean, if you if you’re watching something that’s about four hours long, that’s probably the original cinematic release, but if you’re watching anything that’s under four hours, then you are probably watching a truncated version that was cut down after people complained it was too boring and too much talking.
Dr G 11:28
I hate it when people are talking all the time. No, I definitely watch the four
Dr Rad 11:32
hours. There you go. So you’re probably watching the the original cinematic release and
Dr G 11:36
just too much talking. That’s That’s my review on that exactly.
Dr Rad 11:40
Now, of course, we are focusing on the second half of this film today, and I feel like it’s appropriate that we were talking about all these production issues, because what a number of people who worked on this film have said that the person who suffered most from all the cutting that went on in the editing room was Mark Antony slash Richard Burton followed closely, you’ll be pleased to know Dr G by Roddy McDowall slash, Octavian, yeah,
Dr G 12:09
well, I mean, Cleopatra is the star of the show, and Burton ends up his Antony is often a brooding Grumpy Pants who is not very good at expressing his feelings and tends to blame Cleopatra for everything. That’s how he comes across. Yeah.
Dr Rad 12:25
Well, this is exactly it. I think that a lot of people were very disappointed with the way that he came across in the final version, and they felt it was because you were missing a lot of the other side to him. They kind of just focused on one part of the storyline. However, I’m getting ahead of myself. Let’s go into who is Richard Burton? Dr, G,
Dr G 12:45
I believe he’s an English actor. Is he not?
Dr Rad 12:49
Bite your tongue. He’s a proud Welshman. Thank you very much.
Dr G 12:53
Whoops. My My apologies to all Welsh listeners out there. He is obviously an excellent Welsh actor,
Dr Rad 13:01
Richard Burton is well known to us now because he became obviously a big star. And it’s not that he was an unknown when Cleopatra was being made. And I don’t know about you, Dr, G, but I could listen to his voice all day
Dr G 13:15
long. Look, I do think he has a lovely vocal tone to him, and he does a good Shakespeare. That’s what I’ll say for
Dr Rad 13:23
him. He does. He does so. Richard Burton is an interesting person. He didn’t come from like a massively wealthy background. He was kind of a self educated man. Apparently could speak multiple languages, very well, versed in Shakespeare and poetry and all that kind of thing. He was doing fairly well for himself. And Cleopatra came along, but probably more on the stage than the screen. Most of the movies that he’d been in before Cleopatra had not been gigantic hits, so much so that when they found they needed a new person to play Antony, and his name came up the director slash writer at this point was Joe mankowitz. He was a big fan of Burton. He thought he embodied the kind of qualities that they wanted for their Antony. However, the guy who was at that time the head of Fox wasn’t interested. Okay, so this is Spyros Skouras. Ah, yes, I recall this name. Yeah, not interested. Did not think that Burton was enough of a box office draw for an epic like this. Everyone else tried to really fight hard for him, like Wanger and Mankiewicz say, look, we’ve got Elizabeth Taylor. We don’t really need any more of a box office draw than that. Let’s give him a go. And so eventually, in May of 1961 they managed to talk Skouras into hiring Burton, and in order to do that, they actually had to spend about $50,000 to get him out of a pre existing contract he had for a musical on Broadway called Camelot mm.
Dr G 14:59
Oh, he sings as well. Look,
Dr Rad 15:03
the reason why it’s so interesting that Richard Burton, I think, ends up playing Mark Antony, is that Mark Antony is represented a particular way in our source material, and that has an awful lot to do with your main man, dr, G, Octavian slash, Augustus slash the young Caesar, whatever you want to call him.
Dr G 15:22
Yes, Augustus is the ultimate winner of the civil war that we’re going to see unfold to a high degree in this part of the film. And so it is his perspective on Antony that really resonates in the subsequent source material. And boy, is Antony portrayed as the villain. And part of this is because of the nature of the rivalry that Octavian slash Augustus and Mark Antony share, which is their they’re basically competing for, who is the best man left in Rome. This is the very tail end of what historians will talk about as the late Republic, and after this civil war, we move away from the idea of the republic in really particular ways and but up until this point, it’s always been about like personal competition in the public arena between men at a political level Who has the best claim to be persuasive. And unfortunately, in this period, Mark Antony is not in Rome as much as Octavian is. So Octavian has a greater share of the listeners ears of the persuasive folk, and he also does some things which are pretty terrible in order to sully Antony’s reputation. And I’ll get into some of that as we get further into like the action of the story of this film, but suffice it to say that he comes across poorly in our ancient source material, and this is then perhaps reflected in the portrayal we see on screen as well, because we know that for this movie, as you noted in the previous episode, some ancient sources are cited as inspirational writers. They are,
Dr Rad 17:12
and one of the one of the big influences, is definitely Plutarch. And Plutarch is one of those writers who near and dear to my heart. Dr, G, because I feel like he has often inspired cinematic adaptations. I think his writing is at the heart of most popular versions of Spartacus story. Not that he writes about Spartacus personally, but he writes about Crassus, and Spartacus comes up whilst he’s doing that. And I think very much we see the moralistic way that Plutarch writes about Antony in his life, of Antony coming through a lot of the time in popular understandings of Mark Antony. And this is, I think, because of what Plutarch is doing, right? He writes biographies. Biography in the ancient world is about presenting exemplar. You want to live like this person. You don’t want to live like this person. These are the qualities we value. These are the qualities we despise. And that is very clear in the life of Mark Antony. It’s not that he is dehumanized by Plutarch and there’s probably a reason for that that I could even say is political. Let’s face it, Mark Antony’s bloodline is in that of the Julio claudians, thanks to his relationship with Octavian sister, brief though it was, but also, I don’t think anyone would want to completely trash his reputation, nor is it entirely in octavians interest to completely trash his reputation, just like they don’t want to wholly undermine Cleopatra. You want to beat a worthy opponent, and also can’t, like flat out lie about someone either. It’s like what we often talk about. There’s a lot of spin put on source material that we deal with. There are lots of gaps. People get a bit creative sometimes, but at the end of the day, it seems unlikely that our sources are trying to flat out lie a lot of the time.
Dr G 18:58
Definitely and certainly, Octavian is skirting a pretty fine line during his lifetime in terms of what he says about Antony and when he says
Dr Rad 19:07
it, yes, absolutely, but definitely, in Plutarch, we get this idea that Antony is a charismatic, convivial, well liked person who unfortunately has particular weaknesses which become more of a problem as he ages, and particularly in this period here where he’s in his rivalry with Octavian and one of those will end up being His love for women, particularly domineering women like Fulvia, who was one of his earlier wives, and, well, actually shouldn’t even say earlier wives. There’s a bit of overlap between Cleopatra and and then obviously Cleopatra as well. So we get material coming through talking about him as being kind of enslaved in. By his love for Cleopatra. I’ve even actually got a little excerpt here, which I thought kind of summed it up. So plutak says such then was the nature of Antony we’re now as a crowning evil. His love for Cleopatra’s supervened roused and drove to frenzy many of the passions that were still hidden and quiescent in him and dissipated and destroyed whatever good and saving qualities still offered resistance, and he was taken captive in this manner,
Dr G 20:31
goodness me, so we get something comparable from Appian, actually, in his civil wars, where he says Antony was amazed at Cleopatra’s wit, as well as her good looks, and became her captive as though he were a young man, although he was 40 years of age, it is said he was always very susceptible in this way, and that he had fallen in love with her at first sight, long ago when she was still a Girl, awkward grace, and he was serving as master of the horse under gabinius at Alexandria,
Dr Rad 21:06
which is referenced in this movie, by the way, it
Dr G 21:09
is. I do like this little tidbit, because the situation gets reversed. What we hear from Cleopatra in a scene when she’s with Antony is that she had noticed him when he’d been in Alexandria under gabinius. So the detail comes from Appian, but the credit in the film is given to Cleopatra, probably to smooth over the fact that it’s a bit awkward for an adult man to be crushing on a young girl to avoid that. Yeah, to avoid that
Dr Rad 21:43
exactly, and yeah. And then I’ve also got a little quote from Florus, which I thought I would go to, because you can always rely on Florus for saying things incredibly brutally. I think he kind of takes original source material and then amps up just how dramatic it is. So he explicitly says that Antony was a slave to his love for Cleopatra, the Egyptian woman demanded the Roman Empire from the drunken general as the price of her favors, and this Antonius promised her as though the Romans were more easily conquered than the Parthians. Dot, dot, dot, forgetful of his country, his name, his toga, and the emblems of his office, he soon completely degenerated into the monster, which he became in feeling, as well as in garb and dress.
Dr G 22:28
Ooh, yes. And I see that the film definitely picks up on some of this stuff. So we rarely see Mark Antony wearing things that are particularly Roman in style, and he transitions very quickly to often appearing in clothing that we would interpret on screen as being more Greek in nature, which is in keeping with the Ptolemaic rule of Egypt at this time. And well, these kinds of ideas coming through in florus, in Plutarch, in Appian, they’re all drawing upon the sorts of things that were said about Antony in the political invective of his day, Octavian is out there making those sorts of criticisms. Likewise, Cicero not a fan of Mark Antony lays in pretty hard and so we do get a lot of historically preserved criticism of Antony. And from a Roman perspective, it makes a lot of sense. This is a guy who has left Rome essentially to the land that has been divvied up to him to look after. There’s been an agreement between Octavian and Antony about which sections of the Roman Empire they’ll look after. Respectively. On a strategic level, the lion’s share has been given to Antony, but none of it includes Italy, and therein lies his problem, because he’s sitting on the outskirts. He’s supposed to be looking after a lot of territory, and I think, from Antony’s perspective, he’s trying to make the best of it. It makes sense to get Cleopatra on side. She is in charge of Egypt, which is famously known as like the grain store of Rome. You need to have Egypt on side. How do you do that? Well, you take Cleopatra as a lover,
Dr Rad 24:15
and you knock her up a few times. Just for good measure,
Dr G 24:18
those children are always going to sell the grain to Rome at a good price? Well,
Dr Rad 24:22
this is exactly it. So this is the picture we have of Antony coming through in the ancient sources. And obviously it’s partly because of exactly the issue that you highlighted during his lifetime, and then the fact that he loses the civil war with Octavian, although Octavian wouldn’t paint it as a civil war, but let’s be real. And then on top of that, Octavian slash Augustus happens to live completely unexpectedly for many, many decades after this victory, which means that he really gets to solidify his version of exactly what happened, what Antony was like, why he failed. Yeah, and it’s part of, I think, the strategy of the way that Octavian is trying to spin this particular conflict. He doesn’t want it to appear like a civil war. He wants it to be a war against Cleopatra, against Egypt, which we all know in effect, is also a war against Antony. But that’s what I think he really wants to emphasize with what he is doing. It’s really about Cleopatra, it’s her fault. She’s this foreign devil woman, witch who has enslaved Antony with her Eastern charms. And that way, it kind of softens the blow, I think, a little bit to Antony’s reputation, to paint him in this way that it’s it’s Cleopatra using her charms and exploiting his vulnerabilities and weaknesses that have led to this situation, and this, I think, is what we see coming through in the film a little bit. But also, I think it comes down to what Mankiewicz, who was the main screenwriter and the director on this movie, he was very much drawing from Shaw and Shakespeare for his vision of things. And that makes sense, because Shakespeare obviously used a lot of Plutarch as well, so that’s probably partly where it came from, but also he had a vision that Antony’s main motivation was often this perceived sense of being less than Caesar, of having a bit of a chip on his shoulder after Caesar is assassinated, that he’ll never be as good as Caesar, which is an interesting take, because I must admit, that’s something I don’t think you get in the source material.
Dr G 26:36
I think we have too much source material coming from Octavian side to see that one coming through. Yeah, particular. And I think you’ve made a good point about Augustus legacy of being able to cement his own version of the story. Because as we go through the histories, it doesn’t seem like there’s that much in it between these two. Yeah, in terms of the troops that they’re able to bring to the table in terms of who is supporting, who like, even at the height just before the Battle of Actium, where Octavian does some things that I’ll get into later, some people in Rome leave. They walk out in support of Antony because they see part of what Octavian is doing as a violation of Roman values, and they walk out in defense of Antony over it. So it’s not the case that Antony is lacking support in Rome, but it is the case that because he loses his version of events, doesn’t get to have the same traction over time, and all of this is playing into how Antony gets portrayed in this film from a Roman perspective, positioning Cleopatra as the main enemy is a huge insult to Antony. This This means his masculinity has been completely undermined. No Roman worth their salt in their patriarchal system would allow themselves to be held under the sway of a woman like this. Antony seems up for it, though, and in the same way that they criticize Fulvia for the way she behaves in a very active way, going out, doing things in support of her husband, Cleopatra is like puvia writ large on a much grander scale. This is a woman who is in charge of a whole nation. The Romans aren’t happy about that, but it does mean that Mark Antony can’t be much of a man,
Dr Rad 28:32
no. And this comes down to, as you say, that inherently Roman understanding of how power works, that in order to exercise Imperium, in order to be a politician in Rome and make decisions for others, you need to be able to show that you can control yourself and your own household. You need to prove that you have the self control, the discipline, the wisdom, all of those things that come together and Antony the way that he is painted with his tendency to be a drunkard, party a little bit too much and sleep around is seen as dangerous. It’s seen as undermining that sense of Roman morality, because it shows he has weakness, like it’s fine to have sex with whoever you want within the you know the rules of the Roman world for most people, but it has to be within those bounds. It’s about that self control. And Antony is seen as going beyond and that scene with his relationship with Fulvia, with Cleopatra, Plutarch has that famous quote which I wish I had in front of me right now, where he talks about how Fulvia broke Antony in for Cleopatra because she was such a dominating wife. I think it’s something along the lines of Fulvia wished to rule a ruler and command a commander, and that it’s thanks to Fulvia that Cleopatra. Was able to just take over because Antony was used to following a woman’s orders. That is exactly the kind of stuff where not being in control of yourself and having someone who’s not supposed to exercise power, in a Roman system, having power over you, this is all like, red flags. Red flags. Antony should not be holding power. It’s got to be Octavian guys. He’s the only logical choice
Dr G 30:21
well, but I would like to put it out there that it’s perfectly fine for a woman to be the DOM and a man to be the sub. And realistically, Romans just need to get on board with that kind of stuff. And it’s clear that they’ve got a long way to go. I’m really interested in talking about things to do with the scene where Mark Antony is kind of really early on in this part of the film, is struggling in the east, and he doesn’t want to go to Egypt. He’s resisting going to Egypt and asking Cleopatra for help. And he’s having some struggles with that, because he he thinks it’s inappropriate for him to go to her. He wants her to come to Him. And He sends His faithful companion, Rufio, to go and get Cleopatra,
Dr Rad 31:04
who, by the way, I have to say, I think, is the actual star of this movie. I love Rufio. He’s
Dr G 31:09
great Rufio. I mean, he, yeah, he’ll, he has his moments, that’s for sure. And so he does the bidding of Antony in this Cleopatra refuses. She says she isn’t going to step outside Egypt. Why would she do that? Egypt is her place. He’ll have to come to her. So they’re having a tussle of the wills, which I quite like. And then is what happens next, which I think is one surprising given what has just been said, but also fascinating. So I’m interested in your take on what is happening next with these
Dr Rad 31:38
two. Well, this is their famous meet cute, isn’t it, even though we know, because we’ve just talked about it, that they probably crossed paths when Cleopatra was very young and Mark Antony was younger, their meet cute, in the source material, is usually seen as them coming together on the barge at Tarsus. Now this makes no sense, because not only did they meet when Cleopatra was very young, potentially, but obviously, they probably hung out all the freaking time when she was ceases partner. There’s no way that when she was in Rome, for example, she and Antony weren’t bumping into each other all the time. And we see this in the movie, right? Antony is there at meetings where Cleopatra is also present and Caesar is also present, but this is the moment where their relationship
Dr G 32:26
begins. Something has changed, somebody’s dead, someone’s available, exactly. And what happens in Silesia stays in Silesia. But this is,
Dr Rad 32:36
this is actually one of those things, though, where I feel like it’s made such a big deal of in the source material, and then it becomes kind of a staple. I think, of movies that go this far into Cleopatra’s life, if they don’t stop with the death of Caesar for example, there are certain moments you just gotta have, and the meeting at Tarsus is one of those. And you see that even in painting. So even if we’re going into visual forms of telling this story before film is even invented. We see the meeting at Tarsus as being a moment that painters often go back to as well. And one of the things that also highlights the production problems with this film, because they were filming where they were in Italy, they actually had to build these boats, all of the battles and stuff. Everything you see, they’re not little miniature models that have then been made to look like real ships. These are actual ships that they had to build because they were filming in Italy.
Dr G 33:27
I love that. I hope they kept those ships, but I’m guessing they didn’t. I actually don’t
Dr Rad 33:32
know what happened to them, but I actually think that this barge scene, I feel like it actually wasn’t a particularly early shot. I feel like when I was looking at the dates, I should have written this part down, but I feel like when I was looking at the dates of when they shot what I feel like this was towards the end of the production that they shot it. And obviously it was huge deal, because it’s a big set, having like a barge, they had to have the purple sails. They do explicitly note that they had to make them out of polyester rather than silk or cotton, because they would have faded in the sun if they were made from natural fabric. So they were like, we can’t be historically accurate. Sorry, guys, we tried our best.
Dr G 34:10
It’s amazing. But I do like this idea that the way they explain it and allow Cleopatra to keep her power and dignity in this moment is that she classifies the gigantic barge that she’s brought all the way to Tarsus as Egypt. She’s like, as long as I’m on this boat, I’m Egypt. And even then Mark Antony’s like, I’m getting on that boat. And it’s like, Dude, she’s actually come so close. All you have to do is take a step. She’s making it so easy for you now, and he’s still, like, Grumpy Pants about it, and then he gets really drunk at the dinner that she holds for him. The guy is just a bit of a loser. You have to I mean, at this point, it seems like, well, we can see why he’d be into her. She’s gorgeous, but like, why would she be into him right now?
Dr Rad 34:57
And this is exactly the thing, right? This, again, comes. Down to the way that the Antony comes across in this particular movie. The guy who ends up in charge of what we now know as 20th Century Fox, who took over after the boardroom coup, which takes place towards the end of the filming of this movie, is Darryl F Zanuck. He takes the place of Skouras, and he ends up being the one to call the shots. Darryl F Zanuck had a real issue with the way that Antony was portrayed in this movie as well. He actually thought that one of the big failings of the movie was the fact that Antony came across as weak, and he hated the way that their relationship came across. I believe his famous quote is that if he ever encountered a woman who treated him the way that Cleopatra treated Antony, he cut her balls off.
Dr G 35:49
Okay? So this is somebody from the the Roman mold who also needs to learn that it is okay for a lady to be in charge.
Dr Rad 35:57
Yeah, look. Darryl F Zanuck is someone who contributes a lot to cinema. He was a great filmmaker, but he was certainly a man of his time. It’s pretty well documented. I believe that he made extensive use of the casting couch system. I believe from four to five every day he would interview, and I’m using my flesh rabbits here, new acquisitions when he was in charge of CEO. So he’s a very man’s man of this time, which we would now look at and say, bit of a sexist pig, I would imagine.
Dr G 36:32
Yeah, sounds like it a sex pest, and probably somebody who’s sexually assaulting people, by the sounds of it,
Dr Rad 36:38
great. Yeah. Certainly, definitely sexually exploiting people at the very least. But yeah, he is a typical man in position of power at this point in time, I think. But he is a great filmmaker. People marvel at the way that he was actually able to pinpoint issues when looking at films. So there’s something to be said, I suppose, for his particular interpretation of the second half of the film as being the particular problem, and Mankiewicz and the people who defend him would say, Well, that’s because you cut out so much and it was meant to be two movies. Thank you very much. But we don’t really know, obviously, because we don’t see, we don’t see exactly what they were seeing. We don’t have all the footage. But I think this is where we need to acknowledge Dr G, the thing that makes this movie particularly famous, which of course, is the real life affair that develops between Elizabeth Taylor and Richard Burton. And this is where, this is the favorite part of always talking about this movie, because you can’t make this stuff up. It is so bizarre how much Elizabeth Taylor and Richard Burton seem to kind of embody the people that they are playing. Because, of course, Richard Burton is known as a fantastic acting talent, particularly as you noted with his Shakespearean abilities, definitely acknowledges a man with prodigious acting talent. Unfortunately, it was somewhat undermined by his drinking. He was a terrible alcoholic, and it came, it’s seems, from a defensiveness and an insecurity within him, perhaps feeling uncomfortable about the idea of kind of selling out and, you know, going to Hollywood, and this is the movie that made him a big star. It’s not just because he was playing Mark Antony in this movie. It’s because of the affair that developed between him and Elizabeth Taylor whilst this movie was filming, he went from being somewhat known to being a household name. His salary, I think it’s probably was times by about 50, like it was insane, he could command like $500,000 a picture after this. Can’t really emphasize just how much this particular affair boosted him, and yet, at the same time, kind of was his undoing in that it set his career on a particular path that it seems he wasn’t entirely comfortable with and accepting of within himself. And I’m not sure that Elizabeth Taylor and Richard Burton were the best couple for each other. It’s not that they didn’t have a fiery, passionate romance. They obviously loved each other very much, but it seems to have been in a somewhat destructive mode, and you can kind of see that obviously, in one of their most famous films together once they were actually an established couple Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf, if you’ve never seen that, it’s a masterpiece, but again, almost because it seems like they’re channeling a little bit how they actually were at certain points in their relationship. But I digress. Let’s get into this. Dr G so Elizabeth Taylor, at the time of Cleopatra filming in 1962 is about 30 years old. Richard Burton is about 36 when they pulled Richard Burton out of his contract again, this is speaking to the production issues. He actually didn’t have a lot to do most of the time. They didn’t budget their time very well because it was constant changes in shooting, etc, etc. So he was often just cooling his heels for a few months without much to do, because of the fact that the scheduling was all over. Place, and I, once again, must say that the biggest issue with this film, it does come down to the studio. Just like with Spartacus, you should never start filming a big budget picture if you don’t have a complete script. And that’s what it comes down to all the time. It makes it very interesting for people like me, who love to see how how history gets thrown together, but it means that the history a lot of time is actually, quite frankly, completely chaotic and random, because it’s purely born of a lack of time.
Dr G 40:30
Yeah, you just got to get through it as best you can. Throw it in there, do something. I’m not sure this is the sort of thing that would ever fly today in terms of making a film if you didn’t have a robust
Dr Rad 40:41
script, if you
Dr G 40:46
hadn’t planned it all out correctly in terms of your storyboarding and things like that, there’s no way you’d get to a point where you’d get funded. So the idea that studios are just sort of kind of like we’ve got an idea and we’ve got half a script. Let’s start is, I feel like this is very mid 20th century approaches to filming.
Dr Rad 41:06
Well, look, I disagree. Actually. I think that kind of stuff does still happen. I think it just depends how it comes together. If you’ve got, like, a big name, big director and an idea that seems to work. Sometimes, I think these things can still happen. But part of the reason why it happens, obviously, with this production, is that they they need to get filming because the studio is hemorrhaging money, and it’s such an expensive shoot. I mean, the sums are a little bit different depending on what point in the production you’re talking about. But even if they don’t film anything, it’s costing like $65,000 in like 1960s money, just to keep the production itself going. So it’s a huge amount of money. Elizabeth Taylor alone is getting $3,000 a week in expenses. So just the amount of money that this kind of film is hemorrhaging. And so they’re pushing to just get started with the actual filming. And it just, it’s just such a bad idea. Everyone tries to point it out to them. Mankiewicz is like, look, what if we just had a finished script, and then I know exactly where I was going. And it means this is why we have so much footage, because Mankiewicz is writing after he’s finished filming for the day and on weekends for a lot of this production, which means that you’re not getting his best work. You’re getting what he’s pumping out while popped up on drugs and then coming down from things, and whilst he’s exhausted and tired, and his method, because of what the pressure the studio is putting on them to film is to film everything and then cut it out later, which is so expensive to do, it’s not at all cost effective, and it means that they’re probably creating sets and costumes and stuff that were unnecessary because they end up on the cutting room floor. But nonetheless, I’m digressing once again. Let’s talk about Elizabeth Taylor, Richard Burton, so much like Cleopatra and Antony, they had met before. They were not strangers to each other. Yes, they hadn’t exactly hit it off. They didn’t hate each other, but wasn’t really much chemistry when they met the first time, and they didn’t know each other super well. However, on January 22 1962 the first scene was shot that involved both Elizabeth Taylor and Richard Burton, and it was apparently the scene where all Caesar’s friends who were Senators in Rome are meeting at Cleopatra’s Villa while she’s hanging out, and they’re all milling around and discussing things. Now, if we are to believe what was written later, everyone sensed electricity between Taylor and Burton immediately. However, you know, they’re good looking. People could be nothing. But it’s on January 26 1962 that Walter Wanger in his diaries, his published diaries, records that Joseph Mankiewicz, Director, such screenwriter, called him in to tell him that he’s pretty sure there’s an affair going on between Elizabeth Taylor and Richard Burton, because he’s quite friendly with them, and he doesn’t really want to keep it a secret that there is something going on to backtrack a little bit to what we talked about last episode. Keep in mind that Elizabeth Taylor already had just copped a lot of flack for breaking up somebody else’s marriage with Debbie Reynolds and Eddie Fisher, and she’s only just recently married. Eddie Fisher herself, Richard Burton is in a slightly different boat in that he has been married to one person for a little bit of time and has children with that person, Sybil, his wife. Now, Richard Burton had a reputation, and this is where, again, kind of weird. So not only is he a bit boozy, like Mark Antony supposedly was, Although
Dr G 44:40
who knows who better to cast in the role,
Dr Rad 44:44
but like Mark Antony, supposedly was Richard Burton, was a womanizer. He kind of prided himself, I think, on betting every leading lady he acted across. And his wife kind of knew about that, but always looked. Other way, I guess, and saw it as just something to tolerate, and that it wasn’t anything serious, and that their relationship was solid, because he was that classic case of, oh, he always comes home after playing around, you know, he’ll always come home to his wife. He’ll never leave her, Oh,
Dr G 45:16
the 20th century, just, I’m unhappy already. This is going badly. First, you’re telling me about this film, guy. Now you’re telling me about Burton boo, yes. I don’t know
Dr Rad 45:29
if this makes it any better or worse, but I know that Darryl senek wasn’t the only one doing that.
Dr G 45:35
That does not make it okay.
Dr Rad 45:36
Yeah. Anyway, so very quickly, rumors get out. And this is, again, partly to do with not just the magnitude of this production. I mean, it’s taking up so much space and everything in China, you know, Rome, but it’s also the fact that this is Elizabeth Taylor we’re talking about. She’s just kind of got a bit more sympathy back after all her health problems and the fact that she almost died, and she was everyone kind of acknowledges that she won an Oscar for Butterfield eight, kind of because they were like, Oh, you almost died. We forgive you. Have an Oscar, not really because it was her best role, or anything like that, but she’s just getting that sympathy back. Nonetheless, she’s glamorous. People are interested, and the paparazzi are a feature of life in Rome at this time, like really intrusive press photographers. We are familiar with that in our world, but it actually wasn’t something that you would necessarily encounter everywhere. And it’s not that there isn’t like a media industry surrounding the film industry in America. Obviously there is, but this is, I think, much more chaotic, much less control. They’re much more intrusive. There are all sorts of things that they try in order to get the inside wear on the production. It seems that people who are working for Elizabeth Taylor and Eddie Fisher in their home are probably on the payroll of the paparazzi. We’re talking about a film production which has 1000s of people employed as laborers and extras and that sort of thing. So it’s super easy to get people involved somehow, if you promise them a bit of cash and they can get you some inside photos. One of the more notorious incidents, which was documented by the producer Walter Wanger, was that they found out that there was a woman who had been hired to work in the publicity department who was wearing a very big bouffant 1960s style on her head as like her hairdo, and it’s because she was actually hiding a camera in there. What amazing. There was even an incident when two priests presented themselves asking for donations at the Burton residence. And luckily, the housekeeper was like, Who exactly did you say you were collecting for? It turns out these guys were paparazzi just trying to get inside the Burton household and get a bit of a scoop, because by February, the rumors are everywhere about a love affair between Elizabeth Taylor and Richard Burton and what this potentially means.
Dr G 47:53
Wow. The timeline is very short. It seems to
Dr Rad 47:57
it seems to develop remarkably quickly,
Dr G 48:02
they see each other, and they’re like, You know what? Let’s do it.
Dr Rad 48:05
It’s all, yes. Richard Burton’s not exactly discreet about it. Chris Mankiewicz, who was the son of Joe Mankiewicz, and was working on the film as a younger man, reported that Richard Burton walked into his makeup trailer one day and announced that he had screwed Miss Taylor the night before. So
Dr G 48:21
you know, well, that man’s not keeping secrets, is
Dr Rad 48:25
he? No, no, not exactly. Now you might imagine that the studio would be thrilled about this, right? Because any publicity is good. Publicity. Sex sells.
Dr G 48:33
It adds to the drama. That’s like, what? What are they going to be like on screen together? I’ve heard that they’re doing it. It’s like now I need to see it for myself. There is
Dr Rad 48:43
some awareness of this. There’s a very famous quote from one of the publicists on the film saying Everyone’s going to want to see this film, to try and see on screen what they know is happening off screen. But there is actually also a lot of fear about a romance like this, between two people who are married to other people, and they actually referred to it at one point as a cancer that will destroy us all. Oh, yeah. And this is this kind of highlights the hypocrisy, which actually Walter Wanger was somewhat aware of and sort of wrote about, even though this is the early 1960s we’re talking about the swinging 60s attitude has not fully kicked in, we’ve still got some real 1950s hangovers for a public affair like this between two married people. You know, adultery writ large, this is not okay, and it’s particularly not okay on Elizabeth Taylor’s part, obviously it makes her seem very much like the Octavian version of Cleopatra.
Dr G 49:40
Ah, yes, all right, well, so Octavia does portray Cleopatra very poorly in his dealings, and obviously it’s to his benefit to do so, because he needs to manufacture consent for his war against Egypt, slash Antony. And one of the great ways to do that is. Is through denigrating Cleopatra. And I think this leads really nicely to the issue that crops up in 32 BCE, which is jumping ahead in terms of the action of the film, but is very illustrative of what Octavian is up to, because we do get this scene where he reveals the contents of Mark Antony’s will in Rome. And it is this that is seen as the impetus that turns any doubters that are left in the city to Octavian side, because the contents of that will is explosive Mark Antony is giving everything to Cleopatra and his children with her, and basically setting up for himself to be buried in Egypt as well. Now was that will? A real will? So these are all sorts of problems that historians have because apparently Mark Antony had deposited HIS WILL with the Vestal virgins. This is where I become interested in this.
Dr Rad 51:09
This is where you’re in our interests collide. Yes,
Dr G 51:13
all of a sudden, you’ve mentioned my favorite people, Vestal virgins. So one of the roles that the Vestal virgins had during the late Republic is to hold important documents. They were seen as a bit of a repository, a safety deposit box, if you like, of Rome, which makes sense, because, you know, lock it in that safe one of the things that the Vestal Virgins hold on to and keep inside the temple are the signals of imperial power, so they represent the safety of the state. So the idea is, if you put a document with the Vestals, it’ll be as safe as it possibly could be. Oh Antony, you could not be more. That is not how it works. Octavian manages to demand that the vessels release the will to him to the point where they can no longer resist his demands for it. He then also seems to have managed to persuade the two individuals who had placed their witnessing seals on Mark Antony’s will to change sides. And there’s a whole bunch of illegality with this, because the role of those two as witnesses to the will itself is to verify it when it’s opened upon the death of the person whose will it is. And Mark Antony is not dead in 32 BCE when that will is opened, but they do, nevertheless stand up and publicly verify that those are their seals, and they endorse the contents that are about to be revealed. All of this is part of a bigger play by Octavian to produce the required emotional response. So there’s good reason to question whether this will is real, but we don’t know, and we’ll likely never know, and we’ll likely never know, and the film navigates this as well, because it is part of octavians limited screen time to reveal these details to the Romans in a way that allows them to be like, yes, we need to go into battle. We will turn up to Actium. Let’s do the business.
Dr Rad 53:23
I think this is very interesting, because it the fact that they chose to include that part, I think, is trying to, once again, show how subservient Antony has become to his Cleopatra. And I would have liked to almost have seen some more of these difficult scenes be tackled, but it would have been hard, because one of the things that they don’t do in this movie is they don’t show the fact that Cleopatra and Antony also have children with each other. It’s just Caesarion. It’s Caearion, and that’s it. Cleopatra’s a one and done kind of mum in this particular story, which means you don’t get to see the donations of Alexandria. You get this reference to the idea that Antony is tossing the empire in Cleopatra’s no doubt very well deserving lap, as Octavian says, but you don’t get to see the full moment of the donations of Alexandria. And that’s always an episode in the Antony and Cleopatra story that I find particularly intriguing. We I think we only get it in Plutarch’s account, but we get this description of Antony staging this very elaborate pageant where he’s all dressed up. Cleopatra’s all dressed up. Their children are all dressed up. Caesarion’s there as well. They are given these crazy titles. And he divvies up all this land between them, some of which is definitely not his to give away. It’s obviously just a title thing. And some of their children are like toddlers. They’re like, four years old, so the idea that they were going to command it anyway is weird. And he definitely, I think, highlights in this. The donations of Alexandria, that Caesarian is Caesar’s actual son. I think it’s the first time he sort of comes out publicly says it that Caesarian is definitely Caesar’s son, and that he’s kind of his rightful heir. Is, I think, the implication of that. So this would seem to be, I think, almost a moment where Antony is perhaps trying to do his own version of like a propaganda war against Octavian but the way that it’s been documented in our surviving material, I think again, is trying to show that Antony isn’t thinking
Dr G 55:29
straight. Well, how could he be he’s under the sway of that woman?
Dr Rad 55:33
Yes, exactly. And the funny thing is, I had not actually realized how quickly Taylor and Burton’s romance also exploded. I mean, I knew it happened during filming, but the pace of it is really crazy. So essentially, they start filming together in January. They start sleeping together. It would seem by the end of January, February, everyone kind of knows about it and wants to know more about it, but they’re trying to minimize word getting out. Deny. Deny. Deny is the attitude and the studio obviously have a love hate relationship with this particular affair. Because on one hand, it’s getting a lot of attention for the film, which they need, because they need this expensive film to work, but it’s also a negative thing because of the moral judgments involved. And it’s in April that we start to get Taylor and Burton sort of giving up, kind of shrugging their shoulders and deciding that they’re going to give the paparazzi what they want, which is photos of the two of them together. Nothing overly sexual, but definitely out and about, like a couple, you know, holding hands well dressed and that kind of thing. And after they do that, and seemingly, kind of give the paparazzi this information, we get a very big denunciation of Elizabeth Taylor by the Vatican in April of 1962
Dr G 56:57
Oh, well, there’s a shock. I’m more thinking about Sybil and Eddie, the respective spouses of the two, maybe calling each other up and being like, What the hell is going on?
Dr Rad 57:11
Yeah. Well, there’s this very public denunciation of Elizabeth Taylor by the Vatican. There’s also a very nasty open letter, which is published in a Vatican newspaper, not by the Vatican themselves, but by a reader. And obviously, it’s one of their newspapers. I’ll read you some of the famous quotes from this letter. So they basically rip into her for having short and frequent marriages, they say, even considering the one that was finished by a natural solution, as in the marriage that resulted in her husband’s death in a plane crash. There remain three husbands buried with no other motive than a greater love killed the one before. And they go on to say, essentially, think of the children. Elizabeth Taylor, for God’s sakes, think of the children. These children need an honored name, more than a famous name, a serious mother, more than a beautiful mother, a stable father, rather than a newcomer who can be dismissed at any time. Wow.
Dr G 58:06
Okay, well, I hope somebody’s written an equally shocking letter about Burton and his ridiculous antics, because that would make it fair.
Dr Rad 58:16
They did not. And the US papers obviously pick up on this, and it gets published all over the United States as well. So Elizabeth Taylor and Burton are told to sort of lay low, but they end up sneaking off without telling anybody, and going on a little weekend away this gets reported on, and I think it’s around this time, in sort of late April, that the news of the affair spreads from just sort of tabloid, trashy, kind of newspapers into more serious newspapers, like the Sunday Times. And this is when Sybil Burton starts paying attention, because she’s learned to look the other way. And even though her house is surrounded by reporters and her children are being followed, she’s actually just ignoring it as she always has, apparently, and not giving in to the emotions of the situation. But when she sees it being reported in what she views as a serious newspaper, this is when she starts to get upset and think, oh my god, maybe this isn’t just, you know, an onset affair like all the others.
Dr G 59:21
Wow. Sybil, I’m so sorry.
Dr Rad 59:23
I know it’s, it’s really horrible. And there’s, look, there’s all sorts of things which obviously got misreported. Like there are stories about Elizabeth Taylor having, like, a suicide attempt, which everyone is fairly certain was just food poisoning that got misreported. So there is a certain amount of misreporting going on here. Richard Burton ended up dubbing it les gandal, but it is Elizabeth Taylor that cops most of the negativity, because most Italians, obviously Catholics at this point in time. So a lot of them, if she’s out in the street, abuse her as like a whore and a home wrecker, whereas Richard Burton doesn’t cop that kind of abuse, which. Again, is a little bit like it was in ancient Rome. I was
Dr G 1:00:02
gonna say this was a real mirror to the way Ancient Rome treated these sorts of things as well, because it’s definitely Cleopatra who is receiving the brunt of the criticism and throwing Mark Antony under the bus is just part of the cherry on top, as it were,
Dr Rad 1:00:21
absolutely So, whilst there was definitely a lot of fear about this affair, it seems that after about four or five months, everyone realized that, okay, this is not just an affair. This is becoming a relationship. And we start to, I think, see that the other marriages with Eddie Fisher and Sybil Burton are over essentially, and Elizabeth Taylor and Richard Burton are kind of making a go of it for real. Now this is important in terms of how people receive the history, okay, particularly if you’re watching it in the aftermath. By the time I was watching this as a teenager, obviously Richard Burton was dead, I think Elizabeth Taylor wasn’t far off. And so I was well aware that they do end up being together, that they do end up getting married. You know, a couple of years later, they even liked each other so much that, after they got divorced in 1974 they got married again not long after that, and then they got divorced again. So I was kind of aware about how their story played out, but I know that for a while it was pretty real, and they made some very interesting movies together as a partnership, and that even after their divorce, they were still, I think, passionately in love with each other. They just couldn’t be together. So I kind of wonder if that colored perhaps the way that I viewed it as opposed to how someone viewed it at the time. Because I think with all the gigantic amount of press that was around it, I mean, the reports about it are insane in terms of, it was the only story that anybody wanted. You know, people were paying insane amounts to get pictures of them together, particularly like candid shots, not just photos of them doing what they were supposed to be doing on set. It was the biggest story of the time. In fact, basically the hottest ticket for like, a visiting important person, you know, even if they were nothing to do with the film industry, was a visit to the set of Cleopatra, because it was just all anybody cared about. I kind of feel like maybe one of the reasons why people seem to have been kind of underwhelmed by this film at the time is because there was so much hype about the Taylor Burton Cleopatra, Antony romance, whereas when I looked at it, I hadn’t had to live through that hype, and so I wasn’t as underwhelmed when I sort of see their their relationship play out on screen. I don’t know how did you feel when you were watching them together? Dr, G, my,
Dr G 1:02:36
I think I’m in a similar position as yourself, because we’re of the same generation. So I obviously knew about how it turns out in the end for Elizabeth Taylor and Burton. And I think if I’m putting myself in the shoes of somebody who was watching in the cinema in 1963 like what would have that been like, and I would have been looking for the passion on screen between these two, and we certainly get a sense that there is something between them. Definitely, the relationship between Cleopatra and Antony on screen in this film is quite different and far more passionate than the relationship between Cleopatra and Julius Caesar, yep. But we also have the nature of the way that Cleopatra has really attached herself to Julius Caesar over the course of her early political career. And so I think about scenes like on the barge where Mark Antony notices Cleopatra’s necklace, which is made of coins that have the face of Julius Caesar on them, which I kind of love as an artifact. And I was like, you know, would she have done something like that? That’s kind of amazing, but I feel like that’s quite dramatic, and him ripping that necklace off, because for him as Mark Antony, this is a moment of jealousy, and it’s like, that man is dead. He’s dead and gone, and you need to get over him, and I’m right here in front of you, flesh and blood, you know, as in charge of rumors possibly can be and what are you doing? And this idea then quickly transitions to Cleopatra’s revelation that she actually did find him quite attractive and fell in love with him from afar when she was a young girl.
Dr Rad 1:04:23
She kept that secret the whole time she was with Caesar, didn’t she? Don’t
Dr G 1:04:27
mention, don’t mention my crush on Mark Antony. I was just a girl. He was pretty hot. And luckily, Richard Burton’s a pretty good looking guy, I would say, for his time period, and he holds up on screen quite well, but is nothing like what we know Mark Antony looked like from the from the ancient sources. But obviously Cleopatra is in the same sort of situation, because she has come through over time and has been received as an incredible beauty when all of the source material. Real does try to draw attention to the fact she’s actually intelligent, and the visualizations we have for her, she seems like, you know, a woman. It’s not like the bust of Nefertiti or something, where you’re like, that woman is an incredible beauty. Yeah, it is like Cleopatra, the bus that we have of her, and the coinage that we have for her suggests that she’s in charge, and she’s a woman, and she looks like a chick. Yeah, cool. You know, she may have been quite beautiful in real life, and she may have presented and come across in terms of her character, is quite charismatic, but we don’t get the sense that, like she’s like supermodel, or anything like that, which is kind of how the reception has moved over time, particularly in the west. So Elizabeth Taylor is kind of like the exceptional 20th century height of that and subsequent actresses who have played Cleopatra sort of fit into that Hollywood mold as well. And it’s like it’s got to be somebody who’s exceptionally good looking, because surely, that’s the only way to be in charge of a whole country as a lady. You don’t hire Angela Merkel to play Cleopatra, although maybe you could somebody with some political savvy. But no, forget about that. So we get these kinds of ideas coming through, I think, where we want to see the passion on screen, and we do see it come through in various ways. I mentioned that argument that has been sliced and diced in different ways, and it looks like it’s either a deliberate montage or production disaster, I don’t know, but we see those arguments happening between them, and we get the sense that there is a fieriness between these characters, which we also simultaneously suspect is the firiness that is between these two people. It doesn’t seem like there’s a huge line between the acting and who they are. And maybe that’s part of the appeal of this movie is that we feel like, in some ways, that when we’re watching it, we’re not watching Cleopatra and Mark Antony. We’re actually watching the blossoming and complexing of the relationship between Taylor and Burton that runs through the whole thing, and he gets more and more angry as the film goes on. So when we get to Actium, and it is all going so wrong, Mark Antony spirals, and I feel like watching it from the vantage point of a millennial, that what I’m seeing is the way that Burton is probably going to spiral over the course of his
Dr Rad 1:07:20
marriage. What’s so weird about it, right? Because it’s exactly that, when you look at it at a superficial level, Burton’s, you know, this party boy and drinker and womanizer, but with talent, which seems to sum up the version of Antony Cleopatra is a sexy, intelligent politician, which is kind of the version that we get with a lot of extravagance, obviously, because she’s insanely wealthy and she’s extremely powerful, in the style of a Hellenistic monarch, which is judged, I think, by the Roman sources. But it’s actually just how it was in her part of the world, which is a little bit like Elizabeth Taylor, who was insanely wealthy and made a fortune off of Cleopatra, not just because of the way that her contract stipulated her salary, which was, as you know, like the first time a woman got paid a million dollars to play a role, but also the nature of the ongoing financial support that she had, and the fact that the production stretched well beyond what they are anticipating. And then the Todd AO staff, her production company, being involved. And then she also actually had a clause in her contract that she kept making money on any subsequent releases, so like videos, DVDs, that kind of stuff. So Elizabeth Taylor walked away from Cleopatra a very wealthy woman. It was not a financial flop, as far as she was concerned, even though it might not have been the greatest thing for the studio ever. But then their relationship becomes one where it seems that they do it’s partying, it’s excess, it’s booze, it’s passion, which kind of seems to be a bit like the version of Antony and Cleopatra that, again, we get in what I can only assume is somewhat Augustan propaganda. You know, that idea that they had, that society of the inimitable livers, they get dressed up like slave girls and low class people and go out on the town and get into all sorts of mischief. They have crazy, extravagant feast. It’s obviously propaganda, but for Elizabeth Taylor and Richard Burton, it’s kind of true. I mean, there’s even a famous jewel that he gives her to add to her incredible collection that is called the Cartier Burton diamond. And we do see Burton kind of descend into alcoholism, his talent not fully realized because of this. Now, I would never say that it’s because of Elizabeth Taylor that that happened, but it does seem that Cleopatra is a moment which sets his career and life on a particular trajectory, as I said before, which means that he loses the stability that he had, I guess, with his relationship with Sybil and his children and his family life. And again, we kind of get the sense that Antony loses the stability that he had with. Full veer and Octavia by turning away from his Roman wives for his Cleopatra. So it is kind of an interesting parallel. But I think that is also because of the propaganda surrounding both of these stories. Cleopatra and Antony suffer from the propaganda wars Taylor and Burton. I mean, their relationship was under a microscope from the get go. I therefore feel that that’s perhaps why people were a bit underwhelmed, and also the fact that there’s a very distinct difference in the tones between the first part of the movie with Caesar and then the second part of the movie with Antony. And I think that’s because they were meant to be separated. You see Cleopatra much more on the style of a lover in the second part, whereas in the first part, she’s much more the politician
Dr G 1:10:43
well, but we also see a dichotomy set up for her in terms of how men respond to her as a powerful individual. So if we take the Battle of Actium as an example of this, she’s on the main general ship, which makes sense. You’re not going to put her in one of the war vessels. She’s back where the strategy is happening. But Antony is out and about. For some reason, he’s decided to lead from the front, which is an odd choice, but the fact that she stayed behind, and she’s involved in the decision making, and when she learns the details that it’s unlikely that Antony has survived, she’s like, Okay, it’s time to skip out of here. Let’s go so she’s decisive. She’s the decision maker. It doesn’t go well for her on the day, but she can see the pragmatism of having to get back to her homeland, skip out of there, do the business. Mark ante cannot handle the fact that Cleopatra is a pragmatic leader. This is when he starts to spiral. This is the beginning of the end for him. He can’t believe that she’s left when, for all money, she thinks he must be dead, and it makes sense for her to go. He can’t handle it, and he never really comes back from that. Everything about him in this movie and in this portrayal of Antony is now a downward spiral towards the end, and he gets a bit of an epic ending. He has this scene, which I can’t verify in historical sources, but I kind of enjoy it anyway, where he decides that when he hears that Octavian is coming. He’s like, All right, we’ve got to set up. We’ve got to meet them. Sets up a camp. Everybody abandons him. He
Speaker 1 1:12:27
wakes up the next morning. Everyone’s got to know it’s so sad.
Dr G 1:12:31
His camp is empty. And I was like, buddy, you have lost everybody. He decides desperately to do a one person charge against the Roman forces anyway, doesn’t go well, and has to retreat and then, and then we’re just like, you know, a step or two away from the noble suicide. So for Mark Antony, seeing Cleopatra in action as a war leader, as a pragmatic person, it’s not something that he can handle. Whereas I feel like if the situation had been different, and let’s say that Cleopatra was on the same ship, and it was Julius Caesar out there one, Julius Caesar would not have decided to go out and lead from the front, I don’t think, because he’s not that kind of guy, no, but he also wouldn’t have blamed Cleopatra if she had left, if she thought he was dead, because he’s a bit more pragmatic in the same way that she is. So there’s something fantastical about Antony’s desire for how Cleopatra should be, and what he thinks leadership might entail when he’s also in it, which I think is really fascinating. I think they’ve given a nuance to his character, or at least the performance that Burton has brought to that has really emphasized that there is a delicate weakness to Antony in all of this, which is ultimately connected to Cleopatra, but the weakness comes from
Dr Rad 1:13:57
Him. And this is, I suppose, maybe what we can sort of start to wrap up on this movie often cops a lot of flack for destroying the studio system, for almost bringing down 20th Century Fox, which did actually eventually recoup its money from Cleopatra, but only once the rights, I think, were sold to television and DVD releases and that sort of thing. So it took a long time for them to actually make money on this movie. But I kind of see that as being their fault, quite frankly. As Joe Mankiewicz said, Cleopatra was first conceived in emergency, shot in hysteria and wound up in blind panic. And the Studio does make a lot of decisions which are super questionable and cause a lot of these expenses, on top of the fact that life happens and the accidents make it even more expensive on top of that. And so I don’t like it too when people talk too negatively about this film, because I still feel like it actually is a really good movie. I do see its flaws. I do see its weaknesses, which I see again, as being the result of the hurried way that it was all put. Together. But I think Elizabeth Taylor also cops a lot of flack for this film, because she is seen as, like Cleopatra, a metaphor for Hollywood itself, of its waste, its extravagance, its greed, its lack of morality, all of that kind of stuff, which I actually don’t think is entirely fair. I think a bit like Cleopatra was the victim of propaganda from Octavian Elizabeth Taylor has come to be the face of this film and what it represents. And she’s criticized a lot because she did actually walk away with quite a tidy little sum from this movie. But I don’t think that’s exactly fair. I think that she’s an actress. This is a business. She actually made a really shrewd deal, which the studio entirely signed up for. Therefore, why shouldn’t she make the money that’s in her contract? And she herself also, I think, was really passionate about this film. She actually refused to attend a lot of the American premieres, in solidarity with the fact that this was not the film that she and Joe manquitz want, and, you know, Walter Wang and all these other people wanted it to be. She felt it didn’t live up to the vision that they had, that it was meant to be a film about a really intelligent woman with a with a vision, and that that was lost with all the editing drama that went on. And there is a lot of parallel, I have to say, between the making of Cleopatra and Spartacus. They both are films that a lot of their weaknesses come from the fact that script was not locked down before they started filming. And then on top of that, there were movements in the studios that were controlling those movies in terms of the executives that were in charge. Those executives have different visions and different reactions to the film, and so there was movement at the sort of executive level which then impacted the way that the film was edited, and that editing then has an impact on how it all came together, because with Joe Mankiewicz only being able to do a certain amount of the editing, and Darryl Zanuck kind of also making executive cuts. It’s just not what they had planned. And then I think by the time it came out, that it was maybe a bit out of sync with the world as it was then. But when you think about when the movie started to be produced, that was 1958 that’s when the idea germinated. They started filming in 1960 by the time it comes out, sure it’s 1963 and attitudes are changing. The world is changing.
Dr G 1:17:28
It’s a long period. It’s a long gestation process for a film to go through as well, and for have so many different voices disunified in their idea about what it should be to try and bring it together. It
Dr Rad 1:17:41
suffered from a lot of bad blood, I think, because not only were critics very harsh, and I feel like they were very harsh, partly because of the big build up towards it. I mean, a critic in Newsweek actually said all that remains are the high points at six hours. Cleopatra might have been a movie at four hours, it is the longest coming attraction for something that will never come and I actually think that that’s probably a bit of a fair point. But again, I don’t think the creatives are necessarily the people to blame here in this particular story. But also, it also does not kill the production of epics. There are epics that come after this, and we still make epics to this day. I mean, I think you can look at obviously, like things like the Marvel and Star Wars and all of that kind of stuff, Avatars, your Titanics. Epics can still be really big box office business. The problem is, when they fail, they just become
Dr G 1:18:36
spectacle. Yeah, look, I’d love to see some of the cutting room floor footage from this film. And as you say, not a lot of it has come out. It would be really interesting to see what the best version of this film could have looked like. And I think we’ll probably always be dissatisfied
Dr Rad 1:18:55
in that regard. Again, very like Spartacus, there were things that were added in, you know, once Zanuck was in charge, like filming of battle scenes like fasalia and Philippi, which were filmed and added in. And they were meant to be extra scenes, I think, with Richard Burton, but they never happened, because he was on another project by the time that they got around to doing it, or something along those lines. So like with Spartacus, the vision is muddled, because the production was muddled, and so we don’t perhaps get the Cleopatra that we want. We don’t perhaps get the Antony entirely that we want. Caesar probably is the one that gets the most credit. Rex Harrison was actually nominated for a Best Supporting Actor for his role as Julius Caesar, and he would go on, like, a year later to win Best Actor. Sorry, actually, was it best actor? I think it was Best Actor for playing Henry Higgins in My Fair Lady. Well, there you go. The interesting thing which kind of sums up, I suppose, the way that this film was, was sort of envisioned when they were promoting this film. The original posters that they started putting out were, oh. Of Elizabeth Taylor, very slinky, reclining on a couch and behind her like a creep Antony, kind of over the top of her, and Rex Harrison was nowhere to be seen. It was only because he kicked up a stink that you have Caesar added in as a character, which is crazy, because he’s the one that most people actually enjoyed his performance, period,
Dr G 1:20:19
yeah. Well, what a complicated and interesting representation of Rome and Egypt on film. Yeah, and I’m so glad that we’ve spent this time talking about it and delving into the details and look justice for Octavian because they give him a scene where he doesn’t participate in the Battle of Actium and makes it very clear that he’s been sitting on the sidelines. I
Dr Rad 1:20:44
will acknowledge it is definitely said that Richard Burton suffered the most because apparently his performance as Antony was magnificent, and people think a lot of his best scenes ended up on the cutting room floor. But they also highlight that Roddy McDowall, who was brought on to the film to play Octavian because he was a friend of Elizabeth Taylor’s, also suffered a lot. He also had a lot more material, and instead, he becomes this very drab little character, although I do enjoy his scenes, but he certainly comes across as well, let’s say a version of Augustus that would appeal to me.
Dr G 1:21:16
Look, I think he comes across really well. There’s this smarminess to his performance I really appreciate, and I feel like he’s giving it his best shot based on, like, what the source
Dr Rad 1:21:26
material? He’s a schema, for sure, but, yeah, it’s, it’s certainly not a version of Augustus, I think that many people would recognize, which is interesting, all right. Dr, G, well, I think we talked for almost as long as the original cut of Cleopatra.
Dr G 1:21:43
It seems fair. It seems to do it honor and service. Yeah, absolutely.
Dr Rad 1:21:56
Thank you for listening to this episode of the Partial Historians. You can find our sources, sound credits and an automated transcript in our show notes. Our music is by Bettina Joy De Guzman. The Partial Historians is part of the Memory Collective creators and educators dedicated to sharing knowledge that is accessible, contextualized, socially conscious and inclusive. To find more from the Memory Collective head to collectivemem.com today, we would like to send our gratitude to all of our Patreons who make special episodes like this one possible. If you would also like early and ad free episodes, please consider joining our partial band. Until next time we are yours in ancient Rome.
Transcribed by https://otter.ai
The post Special Episode – Cleopatra (1963) – Cleopatra and Antony appeared first on The Partial Historians - Ancient Roman History with smart ladies.