
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


392 BCE, the year that went down in history for “a campaign in no way memorable”. Ah, that Livy, he paints quite a picture, doesn’t he?
The campaign in question involved our consuls for the year. Yep, consuls! The plebeians were still in a blissful mood after receiving some of the land from Veii in the previous year and so they didn’t fight for military tribunes.
The consuls took care of a few domestic matters, such as holding the Great Games promised by Camillus during the siege against Veii and dedicating the temple to Juno (another of Camillus’ promises).
Once the gods had been satisfied, the Romans were off to fight the Aequians at Mount Algidus in the titular “campaign in no way memorable.” Come on Aequians, put up a proper fight! The decisive victory (and possible capture of the city of Liphoecua) earned the consul Valerius a triumph as he slaughtered so many of the fleeing enemy. His colleague, Manlius, was given the lesser honour of an ovation. Guess he didn’t kill as many men who were running away in terror! You can’t reward that kind of behaviour in Ancient Rome.
An image of a triumph from the Arch of Titus. Courtesy of World History Encyclopedia.
War found the Romans again in 392, this time with the Etruscan people of Volsinii and the Sappinates (which we presume was near Volsinii). The Romans could not respond with their typical vigour as they were hit by a horrific plague. Famine and pestilence were rampant in their part of the world, thanks to drought and a heatwave. These are the same environmental crises and disease mentioned by Dionysius of Halicarnassus for the previous year, which goes to show how the dating for this period is a tad confused.
With the Romans too ill to fight, they send angry messages to their new enemies that they will get their revenge… just as soon as they can stop vomiting.
No one was immune from the pestilence. Censors had been elected in 393 BCE, but now one of those elected, Gaius Julius, died in office and was replaced with Marcus Cornelius. Spoiler alert, but we are only a couple of years away from the Gallic sack of Rome. This happened in the same lustrum as events such as the death of Gaius Julius. Livy asserts that the way he was replaced caused issues with the gods, and that the Romans would ensure the partner of deceased stepped down from office and two brand new colleagues would be placed in office in the future. This may not be accurate, but it certainly shows that the Romans were committed to the idea of collegiality.
When the consuls also fell ill, they decided the Romans needed some fresh auspices. It was time for an interregnum! The consuls stepped down from office, and power was shared amongst the interreges until military tribunes with consular power were elected.
We know what you’re thinking – why interreges? This was a position created to deal with the transfer of powers between kings. It’s interesting that the Romans continue to use this position long into the Republic. The last time we saw interreges was only a few years earlier in 396 BCE.
We do mention a couple of Latin terms in this episode, so here is your handy glossary in case you need it!
Coin of Syracuse (Dionysius I: 405-367 BC) – Head of the Nymph Arethusa between the dolphins; Quadriga and weapons – Naples, Archaeological Museum. Courtesy of Carlo Raso on Flickr.
Consuls
Censors
Our music is by Bettina Joy de Guzman.
Dr Rad 0:15
Foreign Welcome to the partial historians.
Dr G 0:18
We explore all the details of ancient Rome,
Dr Rad 0:23
everything from political scandals, the love affairs, the battles waged and when citizens turn against each other, I’m Dr Rad,
Dr G 0:33
and I’m Dr G, we consider Rome as the Romans saw it, by reading different authors from the ancient past and comparing their stories.
Dr Rad 0:44
Join us as we trace the journey of Rome from the founding of the city.
Dr G 0:58
Hello and welcome to a brand new episode of the partial of his historians. I am Dr G and I’m Dr Rad, and together we make up the Dream Team.
Dr Rad 1:11
We do indeed Dr G, and we’re here to tell people all about what’s happening happening in ancient Rome in the early fourth century BCE
Dr G 1:21
I know, and it sounds like sounds like it might be old news, but for anybody who’s been paying attention to Roman history, it’s going to be exciting news, fresh, new, innovative, different.
Dr Rad 1:33
Indeed, it shall now. Rome has been going through very exciting times recently. Dr, G, I mean, the conquest of Veii still reverberates through every year that we have been discussing,
Dr G 1:45
and I think that will happen for quite some time. To be honest, the ramifications of Rome’s defeat of they are extensive and ongoing, and maybe not in ways that the Romans necessarily are going to enjoy, as we’re about to find out.
Dr Rad 2:02
This is true. This is true, but the last time we have been discussing this, there’s been some division within the Roman population over what to do with this brand spanking new city for them, obviously not in the scheme of the world city of they, because it’s a pretty substantial conquest, and they haven’t always agreed what they’re going to do with it.
Dr G 2:26
Yes, they have not thought ahead. I don’t know if they anticipated that they were going to win ultimately,
Dr Rad 2:33
but it does say about their confidence.
Dr G 2:36
But if they had, they haven’t really considered what they’re going to utilize the land that they’ve gained for, or necessarily what they’re going to do with what appears to be the ruins of a so it still seems to be perfectly serviceable as somewhere to live. And some of the Romans, particularly from the plebeians as we understand it, are quite interested in maybe making a small shift slightly north of the Tiber to take in the scenery of Veii and to start afresh, a new life with a little bit more land and space, maybe get away from those pesky patricians,
Dr Rad 3:15
indeed, and some people, maybe The patricians see this as horrifying beyond belief, the idea that you would leave Rome for a city that’s just been conquered, disgusting.
Dr G 3:29
Where’s your sense of morality? Where’s your sense of loyalty?
Dr Rad 3:34
Yeah, so it’s given us some nice, potentially kind of conflict of the orders, stuff, or maybe it’s just general, as you say, like lack of organization here, but definitely some tense times after the conquest of Veii which means Dr G, we’re ready to sail off from 393 BCE, and sail right On into 392, BCE.
Dr Rad 4:28
all right. Dr, G it’s 392 BCE, I’d love to hear who the magistrates are, and this seems to have become, by default, your job.
Dr G 4:38
I think it has, mostly because my source material has gone all screw with we have consuls for this year. What I know madness. This seems to be a trend now, if you like, because we did have consuls in 393 as well, but that was after a big gap. And. All of a sudden, we’re back in consul territory. What does this tell us about Rome? We’re not really sure, no, but we’ve got the Fasti Capitolini, which is this later document that’s put together, which purports to be the magistrate list for each year, and when it contains more than two in the highest slot, the assumption is that they can’t be consuls. Now, is this how early Rome was truly organized? It is almost impossible to know. But when we only have two names, the assumption is that we must be dealing with a consulship, this traditional divide of regal power amongst two Roman citizens in order to keep things in balance,
Dr Rad 5:42
and not just any Roman citizens, exclusively patricians. Oh,
Dr G 5:47
those guys, indeed. And so for this year of 392, BCE, we have Lucius Valerius Potitus, who was consul in the previous year, and also somebody who has a long history in the role of military Tribune with consular power in 414, 406-403-4013 98 a Titus. He’s been everywhere, yeah, showing up a lot. And his companion in the consulship is a guy called Marcus Manlius Capitolinus. But we are not so sure about this guy’s praenomen, so it is listed diversely amongst our sources. He’s also sometimes referred to as Aulus, and that comes up in Diodorus Siculus, and then also known as potentially Titus, which comes up in Dionysus of Halicarnassus. So we’re not entirely sure which Manlius Capitolinus we’re dealing with here, and it seems to be a little bit up for grabs now in terms of other figures that may be of interest, that is it for the list of magistrates, that’s all I have. But I do have some other notable figures that are going to come up from my side quest, “Meanwhile in Sicily”, so obviously, Dionysius, the tyrant of Syracuse, is going to be out and about. He’s about to bring his brother Thearides into the mix, so that should be fun for all of us. And we also encounter a guy called Heloris who is from Syracuse as well, but ends up leading the army of the city of Croton. And I’ll get more into that when the time is right,
Dr Rad 7:41
I feel like we’re venturing into Superman territory or something with a place called Croton, either that or salads.
Dr G 7:52
Look I like a good salad, and when you’re down that way, I think it’s the best kind of food,
Dr Rad 7:58
all right. Well, Dr, G, I of course I’m returning to my ever faithful Livy. Livy’s account for 392 does connect a little bit with what had happened the previous year, with that debate about what to do with Veii so you might recall that because consuls were agreed on, as you’ve noted, was a bit of an unusual thing. We haven’t had consuls for a while, seemingly because when you have military tribunes with consular power, there is at least the chance that you might have a plebeian ruling. I mean, that really doesn’t seem to have been a consideration at all. It has not been mentioned in a really long time. But that seemingly is one of the things that the population are concerned about, and why we haven’t had consuls for quite some time. Is it perhaps, maybe more because Rome is at war and needs lots of people who can go and fight them. Who knows? But we ended up, after the consuls had been elected, they put forward a decree where, apparently, a parcel of land from the conquered Bay was given out, I believe to every plebeian, it was a little tricky to understand exactly who was going to be getting it, but I’m pretty sure it’s probably every plebeian, pre born Roman citizen. This
Dr G 9:15
seems to be to every free born citizen. So that could encompass patricians as well, yes, and if it did, I imagine the patricians would be slightly more happy about it. But I do find it fascinating, because for all of the argument against going to Veii in the first place, like, how dare you leave Rome, all of a sudden, this land is all parceled out to people. What are you supposed to do with it?
Dr Rad 9:39
In the translation I have of Livy, and I admit I did not go and check the Latin, which I probably should have, but it says to every plebeian, and not alone, to the heads of families. So in other words, I I’m taking that to be not just the pater familias of a plebeian family, but legitimately, to every plebeian. I mean the subtext here. Various men, I would say I’d
Dr G 10:02
find it highly surprising if the freeborn women of the plebeian class were offered seven iugera of land outside of Veii, although it would
Dr Rad 10:11
be nice. I know the little holiday home, they can set up little spas a farm of one’s own, yeah, but that’s because the plebeians were so happy by this resolution in the previous year. That’s why, apparently, they allowed for consoles to be, once again, a thing in 392, BCE. They’re just not angry anymore. You know, they’ve lost the fight.
Dr G 10:33
It’s fine by all means. Have consuls. I’ve gotten what I want
Dr Rad 10:37
exactly. Now, one of the guys that you mentioned, potentially Marcus Manlius Capitolinus, he is definitely going to be a figure to watch, and there is a bit of dispute about how he actually got the last part of his name as well. So Capitolinus, in some versions of his story, is a name that he wins. And I’m not going to tell you how, because that would give the game away. But, you know, it’s one of those special titles that a Roman could potentially be awarded in recognition of some sort of action, usually in a battle or something like that. However, it could actually just be because that’s where his family lived, yeah, yeah,
Dr G 11:19
because this is not the first time we’ve encountered a Capitolinus, I
Dr Rad 11:23
know, but there’s a particular story surrounding this guy. Watch this space. So, yes, watch this space, but that’s a bit of an explanation for why his name might have come about. It’s actually very boring when you think about it, in the sense that it could be a glorious military Act, or it could just be his address.
Dr G 11:42
Well, I guess we’ll just have to find out together. I’m sure when the time is right, you will tell me the details. I
Dr Rad 11:49
will. I will. Now we’ve got to tie up a few loose ends in 392, BCE, dr, G so the consoles decide that this is a year that they should hold the great games, because Camillus had made a vow that this was going to happen during the war with Veii if Rome was victorious, and it was so obviously got to make sure those promises to the gods are fulfilled. And it’s also in this year that the temple to Juno is dedicated. Now again, this relates to actions taken by Camillus during the war with they remember when the Romans are like, hey, Juno, why don’t you pack up all your stuff here in this loser city, move on over to some guys with way more style.
Dr G 12:34
And she’s accepted that offer. And so obviously she needs a temple now, exactly.
Dr Rad 12:39
So they’ve obviously been working on that, and it is officially dedicated. Officially dedicated in this year. So if this is all looking very promising, the Romans look like they’re getting very square with the gods. Consuls are back. Patricians are at the top of the tree. I mean, what more
Dr G 12:53
could you want? I was going to say it sounds like a patrician dream right now. I know now
Dr Rad 12:59
I love this little detail that I think you will also appreciate, because it’s not often we’ve got often we’ve got to speak about the ladies recently, apparently, Livy notes that there were throngs of very excited matrons present at the dedication of this temple. And he also says it in a way that I find intriguing as a historian, he says tradition relates that throngs of women were fangirling all over this temple, I know, says something about it being passed down,
Dr G 13:30
perhaps. Now, do we know which version of Juno we’re talking about here? Does this become Juno of the Capitoline, or is this another version of Juno
Dr Rad 13:42
initial? Initially this temple to Juno is placed on the Aventine, which is interesting, because that’s outside the pomerium, probably because at this stage, the Romans are a little bit suspicious of this Juno. She is, after all, someone who’s only very recently made the switch. You don’t want her inside the pomerium until you’re sure that she’s in for a long time, and not just a good time. Yeah,
Dr G 14:09
you gotta build trust, you know, foreign god until proven otherwise,
Dr Rad 14:13
exactly switching away from domestic affairs. Dr G there is a war with the Aequians, which takes place on Mount Algidus. Not very exciting, though, because even Livy gives me almost nothing and says it was a campaign in no way memorable.
Dr G 14:31
Wow, Well, if I recall rightly, the last few times that we’ve talked about the Aequians, you’ve assured me that they’ve been completely destroyed by the Romans, so it wouldn’t surprise me if they don’t put in a good showing this time.
Dr Rad 14:45
I know, and apparently what Livy means by it was in no way memorable. The Romans had basically beaten them before they’d even started fighting. I never know how that’s possible, but maybe they just gave them a really dirty look, and the Aequians just shooken their little huh? Yeah, maybe sandals. I don’t know what the Aequians would have been running around
Dr G 15:03
in, wow, okay, the fearful glance and then the running away,
Dr Rad 15:08
yeah, the Aequians flee before the Romans after this non fight, and Valerius, the Consul, pursues them, and again, we see a mass slaughter of Aequians. How these people keep bouncing back? I will never know the women in this place must be constantly pregnant to keep this city going.
Dr G 15:26
It does sound intense every time they’ve come up against the Romans recently, it has not gone well for them. So how many Aequians Could there be left? Are they drawing from supporters from further south to replenish their lines? Goodness
Dr Rad 15:40
knows, I only wish Livy would give me some numbers here. All he tells me is that Valerius was given a triumph for this mass slaughter of fleeing Aequians. Manlius, the other Consul, was obviously also involved, but not as much, because he was given the lesser ovatio.
Dr G 15:58
Oh, I see Well, not quite as fancy as a triumph, but I suppose when the Aequians have run away, you’ve got to celebrate somehow.
Dr Rad 16:05
Now we also have a war developing with the people of Volsinii.
Dr G 16:10
Okay, where are these people? Are they related to the Volscians? Or are they slightly different?
Dr Rad 16:15
This is apparently the first time that we have come across this in Livy’s account. It’s weird, because I kind of feel like I have, I’ve mentioned it before, but maybe it came up in a different way, but it is one of the 12 fabled Etruscan cities, but it’s much further north than anything we’ve talked about before. Apparently it’s about 50 miles north of Falerii. And no, that’s not my own statistic there. Obviously I would never be talking in miles if it was, but it’s, it’s quite a long way away.
Dr G 16:46
Okay, okay, so that’s pretty deep into Etruscan territory.
Dr Rad 16:49
Yes, unfortunately, it’s at this moment that famine and pestilence strike against the Romans and their little mini empire that they are building, apparently caused by drought and a heat wave. And the Romans were so ill they couldn’t really field an army against this enemy, which made the people from this place, the volcsinians, ease. What a mouthful. Overly confident. Dr, G, uh oh, that doesn’t sound good. They joined forces with the people of Sappinates. Don’t ask me, where that is. We don’t know, presumably, not that far away. A typical Volsinii Move Yes. Now they decided that together, whilst the Romans were sick, they were going to start invading Roman fields. So the Romans pulled themselves out of their sick beds and very shakily declared war on everybody.
Dr G 17:56
Hmm. I really wish I had more source material for this year, because it sounds exciting on some level, and I wish I had something to contribute.
Dr Rad 18:04
Well, get ready for it, because we’re about to have the death of someone very important. Oh, yeah, there was a sensor in place at this time called Gaius. Julius. He obviously gets sick at this time and dies.
Dr G 18:23
Okay, so we had the census listed a couple of years ago. Now, I think it was actually only last year. It might have been the last year, yeah, and usually, although we’re not sure about this early period of friends history, caveat always that the censorship does take at least a few years to fully enact so it’s the kind of position that you might hold in an ongoing fashion over two or three years in order to get the job done. Now, would that be required in this early period of Rome’s history?
Dr Rad 18:53
I don’t know. Well, according to Livy, definitely yes, because this guy is still in there and he dies, and we actually have confirmation of this in the Capitoline Fasti. So they also indicate that there was a guy with this name who was a sensor at this time, and he died.
Dr G 19:11
Yes, these are all details that I have recorded for 393, where there is a suffect censor brought in to replace poor Julius.
Dr Rad 19:23
That’s right, because they basically just slot in a guy called Marcus Cornelius to take his place. Now, later on, the Romans see this as a dumb move. They feel like they were too hasty and maybe didn’t pay proper attention to the details, because they think this is something that maybe annoyed the gods, you know, got to carry all things out, yeah, because it’s during this particular lustrum that Rome is going to face some serious misfortune. So from then on, Livy tells us the Romans did not replace any censors who died. In office instead the partner who was elected alongside this censor, because, you know, the Romans love having multiple people sharing the same office, had to step down, and you had to bring in a totally new pair.
Dr G 20:16
I see, okay, so you couldn’t just have half the pair continue, and with a substitute in place, he had to get rid of everybody start
Dr Rad 20:23
again. This is what Livy says anyway. It may be something that Livy is saying as a kind of way of upholding the Roman notion of always having colleagues together, I guess, bound, as it were, by a sacred obligation.
Dr G 20:44
Well, the Romans do love that. They take that very
Dr Rad 20:46
seriously indeed. Now, our poor consuls, they also fall ill with the plague that is all around Rome at this time. Oh, no. And they decide that therefore fresh auspices are needed through an interregnum.
Dr G 21:03
Oh, okay, well, this is explaining a lot of the outstanding names that I had for 393, let me go back to that year, because I do have that sensor, surfactus. And then there’s also all sorts of things. Oh, actually, wait a minute. Wait a minute. I have some interreges that come up in
Dr Rad 21:25
391 Oh, that would be these guys. Yeah,
Dr G 21:30
okay, can I excitedly tell you their names? You
Dr Rad 21:33
may. I’m just going to explain the rationale for having them, of course. So
Dr G 21:36
please do.
Dr Rad 21:37
The consuls step down. So again, a bit of a you know, colleagues acting together, the colleagues that act together stay together. Dr G following the Senate’s instructions. And the concern seems to be obviously around the idea that if they have interreges Or perhaps military tribunes rather than consuls, then they’re not going to be left in the lurch, because there’ll be so many of them that they can’t all die of the plague. Look, there’s some logic to it. You’ve got to admit sure, like, yeah, the more people that are in office, the less likely it is that they’ll all die.
Dr G 22:18
Yes, yes, indeed. We won’t talk about disease theories or how viruses work.
Dr Rad 22:24
Sure. I mean, yes, they can all get sick, but will they all die? I
Dr G 22:29
think My bigger question at this point might be, why do we have interreges at all? This is a very old position that we haven’t seen since the very early days of the Republic. And even then, it’s a bit questionable, because what is really happening here, and interreges is meant to be a substitute, replacement, short term, for an absent king. And as we know, Rome doesn’t have any
Dr Rad 22:58
king, I know, but they do still revert to this whole idea of the interreges, I feel like it is just a still, the thing that they see as like a temporary placeholder whilst they’re sorting out magistracies. It doesn’t seem to be super long term this one, as you’re about to note, as we slide into the magistrates of 391 there are only a few of these interreges who kind of pass the hot potato to each other before they then elect military tribunes with consular power. Okay.
Dr G 23:24
Well, our Interreges, as far as I’m aware, are Marcus Furius Camillus, ding, ding, ding, star of the show, Publius, Cornelius Scipio, yep. And Lucius Valerius Potitus,
Dr Rad 23:38
exactly. And that’s exactly the order that they go in. Camillus is made the first interrex ,he then chooses Scipio to be the next interrex. And then Scipio runs like crazy around the forum before he tags Lucius Valerius Potitus. And then we have the six military tribunes chosen for 391 BCE,
Dr G 23:58
which is very interesting, because Lucius Valerius Potitus was Consul, so he’s been taken out of that position and then placed in this interim role as interrex instead. It’s all about the formalities. What’s going on in Rome. It’s a chaotic time for everyone.
Dr Rad 24:17
It is. Would you like to tell us who else we have? Because whilst the list for 392 is very short, the list for 391 is as long as your arm.
Dr G 24:26
Well, I’d love to but first of all, I’ve got some things to say about 392 if indeed we’re leaving that year, we are leaving that year. Wow, things have not stopped in Sicily plague or no plague, yeah. You know, people could be dying in the center of Italy, but down south, well, they’re having a rollicking old time. So Diodorus Siculus does bracket this whole section, which I’m entitling Meanwhile in Sicily with some Roman information. So we do have this idea that we’ve got a guy called Lucius Valerius. Yes. And someone called Aulus Mallius, which is almost correct as consuls in Rome, and he dates this to the archonship of Antipater in Athens, which would place our date at around 389 to 388 BCE. And we know that Rome’s dating is a bit out of sync with other places, and we’re never really going to get quite back on track with that until quite some time later. But nonetheless, you
Dr Rad 25:30
honestly, you could be right. I think about that, because there definitely are a lot of questions about the dates of the events that we’ve been talking about recently, as you know, and as you know, they are thought to be out by three years most of the
Dr G 25:44
time. And it seems like on any given year, the Roman dating is out by 234, years. Yeah, really unclear. What’s two or four years? It’s just a whole Olympiad. It’s fine, exactly. So we’re down in Syracuse and Dionysus, the Tyrant of Syracuse. He has been having a back and forward time because previous to this, he decided he was going to do an invasion of the boot of Italy. He was like Sicily. Is not enough for me. I need the mainland. Not only that, he has what appears to be an exceptional array of forces, 20,000 infantry, what? 3000 cavalry, 40 ships of war, and 300 transport vessels for food supplies.
Dr Rad 26:32
And I believe these numbers for a second. Dr G, he’s
Dr G 26:35
loaded the way that the Romans never will be. So he gets to Messina, that’s the gelato, yeah. Just have a sneaky gelato for anybody in the world that is not based in Australia. Messina is a gelato brand, a
Dr Rad 26:53
very famous one. If you have a visit, please do try some.
Dr G 26:56
Yeah, come to Messina. Have some gelato so he gets to Messina rest his troops there. While he’s doing that, he dispatches his brother, Thearides We’ve never heard mention of before, but apparently has been around this whole time. Thearides is tasked with 30 ships, and he send to the island of the Liparians. Now they get sent there. So the Liparians are slightly north of Sicily.
Dr Rad 27:23
Are these the guys, the pirates we were talking about?
Dr G 27:25
Yeah, the Liparian Pirates, yeah, yep. They’ve got their own island.
Dr Rad 27:29
The most ethical pirates in the world.
Dr G 27:31
They seem like good guys, they do, but they are also harboring 10 ships of the regians. And the regians are the people who are in Calabria, which is Reggio Calabria, so you can basically see their city from Messina and Dionysus of the Syracuse hates them with a fiery passion, and he knows that the Liparians are harboring regian ships, so he is not happy about that, and he sends his brother with three times As many ships as he’s heard the reckons have. And he’s like, deal with that. So he does. He heads up there, seizes the ships, seizes the crew, brings them all back to Messina. Dionysus promptly throws them into prison and turns them over to the messenians. Being like, have fun with them. I don’t care about them anymore. And then he takes his whole army to a place called Colonia. And unfortunately, we don’t have any idea where Colonia is, but we think it must be on mainland Italy. Sometime, he lays siege to that city, and really starts to lay into them day after they siege engines, frequent assaults on the city itself. I
Dr Rad 28:40
hate to say it, dr, G, but I feel like they brought this on themselves with the name of their city for heaven’s sakes maybe just asking to be conquered.
Dr G 28:50
Come on. So the Greeks of Italy, and there are many, they are not happy about this. This is obviously a problem. And they’re like, What are we going to do? The city of Croton is nearby. It’s the biggest city nearby, and it also has the largest number of exiles from Syracuse, presumably people who are anti the tyrant. So the decision is made to give the crotons command of the war effort on mainland Italy,
Dr Rad 29:19
Crotons in command.
Dr G 29:24
They are. They’re in command. They’re doing their things. And they choose a guy called Heloris, who’s also from Syracuse, another disaffected individual, to lead their army. They’re like, this is going to be great. We’ll seek a man who’s angry in charge, and then we’ll go for Dionysus, and we’ll get that man. He’d been banished previously by Dionysus, so his hatred levels were pretty high, and everyone could tell he was a very angry man about it, and they’re like, this is the guy to lead the war effort. We need somebody with that kind of strong, passionate outlook who will not be deter. Third from what is needed to succeed, he is given a command of 25,000 infantry and 2000 cavalry. So this is slightly smaller than the sorts of numbers that Dionysus is fielding at the moment, but it’s still quite substantial. It is for this time period. For this time period, it’s massive. Do we believe it? I don’t know. I
Dr Rad 30:26
don’t believe anything. Diodorus says
Dr G 30:30
they end up meeting slightly east of this place called Colonia at a river, and you’re like, okay, so be it and Heloris being the angry, disaffected exile that he is with his nurtured hatred for Dionysius, he is riding in the Vanguard with 500 of his best troops. He’s like, I’m gonna have at him. Let me at him. This ends up being a bit of a problem, I would say, for Heloris, because they don’t realize that Dionysius knows that they’re coming, and so they do get ambushed. It is unexpected for the crotons. They are not happy campers, and it is not long before Heloris found himself in desperate straits, as Diodorus tells us, and he is trying to find a way to extract his troops with minimal losses. And he also sends out a messenger quite quickly for backup and reinforcements. But the trouble is that the time frame’s not it doesn’t work out for him. He’s sending for help. By the time help arrives, it’s kind of too late. Dionysus troops have closed in, surrounded Heloris, and the 500 men, most of them, have been slain, even though they’ve really tried to resist. I feel like the thing that you want to imagine here is a bit like that monumental battle that happens in Game of Thrones, where Jon Snow is nearly nearly crushed, yeah, in the whole situation, it seems of that order of magnitude, Dionysus just has so many more troops. It’s something that hilarious is not able to get over. So we’ve got this situation where the Italian Greeks are really trying to defend their homeland, or what they see as their homeland. The Italians might disagree, and it’s not going so well. So what are they going to do? Obviously, they’re feeling a little bit desperate. They’re feeling a little bit subdued after this loss, and because they’ve lost their leader, the whole armed force that has been put to the field by the crotons tends to lose its way a little bit. They don’t have the clear leadership that they need. They retreat to a hill, and immediately, Dionysus forces are ordered to surround that hill and to begin a siege. These are people that are caught out in the countryside with not enough supplies, and they’re now trying to fortify in a place that is not set up for their defense. They’ve got to construct it from
Dr Rad 33:09
scratch. I was going to say this sounds like it’s going to be a short siege.
Dr G 33:13
It may be a short siege. It doesn’t take very long for them to suffer from the heat or from a lack of water, like they have some food supplies, but they’re camping out on a hill, and we’re talking Southern Italy. It’s a nice, warm part of the world, even winter’s quite nice. So they sent a herald to diocese, and they basically say, we’re willing to surrender. You know, we would like to offer ourselves up for ransom, all of this kind of thing. He orders them to lay down their arms. And he doesn’t necessarily accept this idea of just sort of the ransoming. He actually wants them to feel violated in some way, huh? So we get Dionysius the tyrant, not a nice guy, just
Dr Rad 34:05
putting it out there. Oh no. I mean, I guess it’s all in the name again, isn’t it? He
Dr G 34:09
basically has them stand there having surrendered for another eight hours in the hot sun. Oh, my God. And then takes a staff and has places it in the ground. Has the troops come towards him and counts them as they come. The Count comes to about 10,000 what? So he basically is asking them to pass under the yoke, this idea of the you’ve got to pass under the stars. Oh,
Dr Rad 34:39
no, it’s more the 10,000 I was saying that about not the not the act.
Dr G 34:43
Well, they had sent 25,000 so the fact that only 10,000 had survived to be fortified on this hill in the first place, the losses already were quite significant.
Dr Rad 34:53
Did he get a Cornetto and he licks it in front of their face, and he’s like, Oh yeah, that tastes real good. Too bad. This is the last. Last 110
Dr G 35:02
Dr Rad 35:26
This is insanity. What’s the point of all this, if he’s just going to let them all go free with no repercussions whatsoever?
Dr G 35:34
Well, I think the thing to keep in mind is that his bugbear is not with the crotons. His problem is with the Rhegians, and you might ask yourself, well, how did he come to have a problem with the Rhegians? Because that’s never been clear why he’s got an issue with them, but the story is now told to us. Diodorus Siculus does reveal the reason why he hates the Rhegians, and it’s because at some point earlier on, he had wanted to marry well, and he had offered to marry the best of the Rhegian’s daughters, and the regians insulted him by only offering him the daughter of the public executioner. Wow.
Dr G 35:34
It’s like the rape of the Sabines all over again. So much heartbreak in history when men are not given the brides that they seem to think they deserve.
Dr G 35:52
Yes, there is nothing quite like the entitlement of a young man who thinks he deserves it so because of this slight that had happened, I’m not sure how long ago, but it still smarts for Dionysus, because obviously he didn’t accept to marry the public executioner’s daughter. You shock
Dr Rad 35:52
me. Dr, G rude. Let me guess he gave that match the axe.
Dr G 35:52
Oh no, yeah, it was dead in the water, if you like. He requires the Rhegians. In this moment, he asked for 300 talents, and because he’s in a superior military position right now, they’re not in a position to refuse. He also takes all of their ships, all 70, we are told, and he orders them to deliver him 100 hostages. And this is on the back of the fact that the Greek Italians have put all of their forces under the command of Heloris of Croton, formerly of Syracuse. And so the Iranians themselves have put forces into this so they themselves aren’t able to raise something to defend themselves. So when Dionysus marches straight up to them and says, it’s now time to pay up for your grievous insults, they’re like, Oh no, we can’t defend ourselves.
Dr Rad 37:49
They can’t really do that right now.
Dr G 37:51
So he takes the hostages, sends them to Syracuse, and then he levels the city to the ground and gives the territory to the Cauloniates. Oh, the territory of the Cauloniates. So these are the people who was fighting originally to the Locrians. So it’s getting very confusing.
Dr Rad 38:11
I was gonna say you’ve lost me completely with the geography. Now all I’m thinking about is the Crotons and how you really should be more concerned about them, because the closer they get to the sun, the more their powers of being able to see through things with their bare eyes, and the ability to fly. You gotta watch it get stronger, get stronger every time. But they move at super speed too. They can leap tall buildings if they existed in this time with a single bounce.
Dr G 38:37
I mean, it’s really quite concerning, but it seems that what Dionysius, the Tyrant of Syracuse is trying to do is to turn the Greek Italians against each other and to splinter them off into sort of subgroups, so that they no longer able to reinforce each other and you can sort of more easily take them over. Okay, that seems to be the gist of it. So he’s had a really big year, and we’ve also learned a little of his tragic backstory.
Dr Rad 39:03
So watch this space where the douchebaggery began.
Dr G 39:07
Yeah, everybody’s got a villain origin story. And when you’re a guy, it always relates to the things that you were denied, that you didn’t really deserve but you thought you did. Yeah, there you go. The other thing I’d like to bring to 392, because I had such a dearth of source material,
Dr Rad 39:24
like literally nothing. It doesn’t seem to have been a great year for Rome, either, to be fair,
Dr G 39:28
because I had so little. The only other thing that Diodorus tells us is that the Romans take the city of Liphoecua, which we don’t know where that is from, the people of the Aequi.
Dr Rad 39:41
Oh, okay, I was gonna say that just sounds like a really strange place name for the part of Italy that we’re in.
Dr G 39:49
I mean, I think he’s wrong, but I don’t know how to make that right, so we would know what was going on. And he does say that in accordance with the vows or the consuls, great games are held in honor of Zeus. Ah, there you go. So we do get that sort of link up. We’ve got some agreement, yes, there’s some agreement, which Romans had games and then got really sick, the great games? No, well, Diodorus doesn’t mention any of the sickness, so he’s on to the big ticket items that are happening in
Dr Rad 40:17
Rome. Squeeze me. Everybody got sick. It was a pretty big deal. They head interreges.
Dr G 40:25
But was it as interesting as what Dionysus, the tyrant of Syracuse, was up to? Apparently, not,
Dr Rad 40:31
maybe not. But that’s because they were too ill to be interesting.
Dr G 40:35
Well, there you have it. Guys. You heard it here first, the Romans, too ill to be interesting, just some of the time. So in the light of the dearth of information that I possess for 392 I was like, let us turn to the secondary sources. What do scholars have to say? And that’s how I ended up reading Bernard’s 2018, piece Rome, from the sack of Veii to the Gallic sack. Spoiler alert.
Dr Rad 41:00
Damn it, those spoilers, they just keep coming up. It’s usually
Dr G 41:05
me. I’m sorry. I’m sorry. Don’t read it. Listeners don’t read it. I will just tell you some of the pertinent things, and it’s not going to be about the Gallic sack. So one of the questions that scholars have about this period is, what is going on with Rome’s economy, because we know it hasn’t been going well. And you’ve mentioned things like this pestilence there’s and this has been going on for a couple of years. It would seem as well. They’re not having a great time, but they’ve also just come into a whole new stack of land by taking they’ve gained a whole bunch of territory and booty, and presumably booty, and also potentially labor force, because whoever has been enslaved as a result of that conquest is now flowing into the Latin enslavement system, charming. So there’s going to be bodies to go around in a horrifying way. This is just the way ancient Italy worked. I don’t agree with it, but we do have this idea that there is economic disruption, decline, things, people aren’t thriving. If we think about this narrative of Rome against the Aequians for the last few years as well, it’s this backwards, forwards thing where, apparently the Aequians are always decimated, but Rome isn’t seeming to make great grounds. It’s not like they’ve had a significant conquest. These sorts of things suggest that what is happening at the moment in this early period of the fourth century is a little bit of a stress, because it seems like even taking they and having all of this new land doesn’t necessarily enhance the prosperity of the Romans to a significant degree.
Dr Rad 42:52
Oh, it’s a lot of blood, sweat and tears. I mean, that’s why they had to introduce the whole idea of military pay, which they almost certainly did not do.
Dr G 43:01
Well, exactly. And so we’ve got all of this suggestion that this is a struggle in terms of a military situation, there’s a lot of warfare, but not a lot of gains. They is a big exception to that. But even under the circumstances that Rome wins, how is that really being incorporated into Rome’s economic situation? You would expect it by
Dr Rad 43:27
being doled out to the plebeians. That’s how, yeah,
Dr G 43:31
you would expect it to be uplifting people, a little bit more than seems to be suggested by any of our source material, written or otherwise. And so this is the kind of case that Bernard is bringing forward, is that we’ve got labor and land, but we don’t seem to see ongoing benefits to those acquisitions by the time we get 30 or 40 years down the track, the initial injection of these things into their economy seems to have really worn off, and they’re back in what feels like an economic and manpower crisis again. So the whole situation with pestilence, the ongoing situation of people being killed in warfare, but not really gaining any traction. This doesn’t seem to be a flourishing time for Rome, or for any of their neighbors, and the interesting things that are happening in South Italy, where they seem to have less pestilence, that doesn’t seem to be going well for anybody either. They’re engaged in this tussle of warfare as well. So there’s a real pressure on people everywhere, it would seem right now to have the resources that they need to be satisfied with them. One of the drivers of warfare is not feeling like you’ve got enough, and there is a desperate attempt to gain more in order to do the needful. So there’s a pressure on resources, and everybody’s feeling the pinch, and this is leading to a lot of decisions that are making life more difficult for everybody.
Dr Rad 45:00
Be, as you were saying that last little bit, it actually really made me think of our own time to a certain extent, not that we live in anything like the hardship of a Roman in the early fourth century BCE, but when we look around and compare ourselves to other people, and we have this real aspirational mindset of where we need to be, and we feel like we’re we’re very pinched at the moment. You know so much talk about cost of living, crisis and that sort of thing, and, oh boy, there’s some foolish decisions being made in the world,
Dr G 45:36
definitely. And there’s this sense in which it’s just not, it doesn’t seem possible to really flourish. There’s just too many impediments, whether it’s related to the weather, whether it’s related to population issues, whether it’s related to the inability to capitalize on gains and whatever is up with Rome’s economic system, is something that is of interest to scholars, partly because we we’re going to see the emergence of coinage soonish. But how are they doing it? They still have concepts like debt that definitely exists by now, sure. And a lot of Romans seem to be in debt, yeah. How do you get yourselves out of something like that? And what does success for the Romans really look like in this period? And expansion doesn’t seem to necessarily bring the expected benefits.
Dr Rad 46:23
Well, it is one thing to take place. It’s quite another to hold it. And that’s, I think, why we see so much back and forth, sometimes between the Romans and their neighbors. However, to all of this discussion. Dr G, I think the Romans, if they were here right now, would say to you, listen, little lady, no pain, no gain.
Dr G 46:45
Well, fair enough, just putting it out there, is that it seems like a complicated time, and that some of those complexities might be shielded from us by the nature of the source material. Yeah, like, what does the archeological record look like? How much is Livy really reflecting what we’ve actually got in terms of the history itself, and these are things that we’re not sure about.
Dr Rad 47:06
Well, this is the thing we know that Livy is working from sources that are probably pretty patchy, or at least he’s working from sources which have had to put their accounts together from pretty patchy accounts, and looking back writing from their vantage point, I think it would make sense to present this time period as one of Roman expansion, and later on, expanding is what the Romans do best. So it seems like perhaps the beginning of something glorious for the Romans, and they is just such a conquest. You know, it would seem that this would have to be a period where Rome was doing really well, but perhaps, yeah, when you actually peel back the narrative a little bit, it’s like, oh, well, it’s a little bit more up and down than that.
Dr G 47:55
Definitely, definitely. Well, that is all I have to say on 392,
Dr Rad 48:01
well, I am shocked that my I think five sentences turned into quite this lengthy and episode. Dr, G, so Bravo for your Meanwhile in Sicily, and also, what’s really going on in Rome. Segments,
Dr G 48:14
what’s really happening? I have questions.
Dr Rad 48:18
That means that it is time for the partial pick.
Dr Rad 48:27
Been too long since I heard your voice, Igor.
Dr G 48:30
Igor, well, the partial pick our chance to judge Rome against her own standards. There are 50 Golden Eagles up for grabs, 10 in each category, the first being military clout.
Dr Rad 48:46
Well, according to my account, the Romans win a very impressive victory, while apparently filing their nails. At the same time,
Dr G 48:56
I was going to say, all they did was raise their eyebrows. I
Dr Rad 48:59
know they just gave him a bit of blue steel, and those people went running for the hills. And from then, it was just a matter of Schwing, schwing, which is swords, it’s nothing dirty.
Dr G 49:10
Ah the schwing, schwing. Well, even Diodorus of Siculus says that I shouldn’t say Diodorus. I was gonna say Diodorus Siculus. I think it’s because I’m so used to say Dionysius.
Dr Rad 49:28
Oh, I’d like to actually expand the name. I think it should be Diodorus of fully Siculus,
Dr G 49:36
If only, if only, sometimes he does great. He does say that the Romans take a city of the Aequians.
Dr Rad 49:42
This is true. This is true. I think they do have a victory of some sort against the Aequians. So that’s something. But then, of course, we do have them being too ill to do much more than angrily declare war whilst vomiting into a bucket by their bed. Well, I mean, their fields are being ravaged. Dr G, and they’re just. Sick to do anything about it.
Dr G 50:01
Well, that’s true. They’re not able to stop the pillaging from happening. Not
Dr Rad 50:06
really. There’s a threat there. I mean, they’re not taking it lying down, even though they are taking it while lying down
Dr G 50:13
in good Roman style. That’s right, all right. Well, maybe it’s a two,
Dr Rad 50:20
okay, that’s a little me, like I was just trying to temper it a little bit. I wasn’t trying to go too crazy here. I feel like it maybe has to be like a maybe a four and maybe a four, yeah, well, I mean an effortless victory, where they barely do nothing but massacre the Aequians, a triumph, an ovatio Dr G, that does suggest
Dr G 50:44
something fancy did happen. And the other one got a triumph, which, you know, isn’t bad for raising your eyebrows on any given Sunday. All
Dr Rad 50:51
right, four, it is. Thank you. Thank you.
Dr G 50:54
Our second category is diplomacy.
Dr Rad 50:58
Well, I would say definitely not. There’s angry staring and declarations of war all around. That’s a zero, yeah, even, even in “Meanwhile in Sicily”, it’s nothing but fighting.
Dr G 51:11
I’m not getting the Sicilians any points, never, expansion,
Dr Rad 51:18
huh? This is a tricky one. I don’t really believe Diodorus. It just seems to be more a encounter. It doesn’t seem to be about expansion. At this point in time.
Dr G 51:28
They take a whole city. It’s not diplomatic, no, I know, but I just don’t believe him. Wow, there’s going to be a day where you will rue those words.
Dr Rad 51:40
Look, I’ll give them a one on the odds that Diodorus is correct.
Dr G 51:45
I mean, I don’t think they’ve engaged in any diplomacy. Taking a city is not
Dr Rad 51:48
isn’t this expansion?
Dr G 51:51
Oh, yeah. Don’t mind me. Expansion, yes. How many points were you giving? I’m
Dr Rad 51:59
in the future. Dr, G, come join me.
Dr G 52:03
I’m right with you. I’m right with you. Temporary lapse.
Dr Rad 52:06
Maybe one, I don’t know, maybe one, it’s not mentioned in Livy, and if it’s not mentioned in Livy, it’s not a fact.
Dr G 52:13
Wow. All right, the bias is starting to show through.
Dr Rad 52:17
That’s our next t shirt, by the way. One, one, okay, one, Ah,
Dr G 52:28
okay. Weirdos. Do we see any signs of weirdos?
Dr Rad 52:32
Not really. I mean, I do admire them for maintaining their militaristic attitude whilst extraordinarily ill. But I don’t think you count that as weirdos,
Dr G 52:43
yeah, waving your pitchforks while vomiting. No, okay, that’s a zero, and then the citizen score.
Dr Rad 52:52
I don’t think this is very good either. I mean, sensors are dying and causing problems with the gods. The consuls get sick and they have to resign. Presumably, barbains are not immune to this disease. I don’t think it’s good. Dr, G,
Dr G 53:06
it doesn’t sound ideal. And having just finished off talking about this year with things aren’t great on the economic front, or the labor market front, or any kind of front that we’re aware of, I can’t make a convincing case. I don’t think for the citizens having a good time right now, I
Dr Rad 53:24
think it has to be a zero. Wow. Well, I mean, you know, it’s really serious, the pestilence,
Dr G 53:31
it’s all bad. Yes, this is a continuation of that one where I described, Dionysius of Halicarnassus. Described it as people scratching their skin down to the bone. Oh, yeah. I mean, this is, this is not a good time, all right, zero, okay. Well, they haven’t done very well, have
Dr Rad 53:48
they? They haven’t really. It’s a grand total of five Golden Eagles out of a possible 50. Well, that’s Rome for you. Look lady for giving me so little material to work with. I was gonna
Dr G 54:02
say sometimes the source material just doesn’t give us enough to be able to hand out any points.
Dr Rad 54:07
You know what? I think it’s because they feel like they deserve a sick day. No, history doesn’t stop when you get the plague Rome, clearly not horrifying stuff. There’s another t shirt for you.
Dr G 54:20
We’re gonna have a whole shop of T
Dr Rad 54:21
shirts. Podcast. I’m on a roll. What can I say? Well,
Dr G 54:26
it has been a pleasure. Dr, rad, and I look forward to our next conversation
Dr Rad 54:30
indeed. Dr, G,
Dr Rad 54:39
Thank you for listening to this episode of the partial historians, you can find our sources sound credits and an automated transcript in our show notes. Our music is by Bettina Joy De Guzman. The partial historians is part of the Memory Collective, creators and educators dedicated to sharing knowledge that is accessible, contextualized, socially conscious and inclusive. To find more from the memory collective head to collectivemem.com. You too can support our show and help us to produce more engaging content about the ancient world by becoming a Patreon. In return, you receive exclusive early access to our special episodes and ad free content. Today, we would like to send a special shout out to some of the newest members of our partial band, Robert Finch, Rachel Parker, Tom King and Jonathan Lance. You can also support us by buying us a coffee on Ko fi. However, if you haven’t exactly been rolling around in that captured booty lately, please just tell someone about the show or give us a five star review Until next time we are yours in ancient Rome.
Transcribed by https://otter.ai
The post Episode 164 – A Campaign in No Way Memorable appeared first on The Partial Historians - Ancient Roman History with smart ladies.
Cleopatra was released in 1963 and has gone on to herald the end of the golden age of the historical epic in Hollywood. Known as one of the most expensive films to ever be made, its troubled production and the on screen connection between Taylor and Burton have both cemented its place in cinematic history.
We have a look at some of the issues that led to production delays and there were a lot! From tricky weather conditions, Taylor’s health troubles, to issues with the script, there wasn’t an issue that this film didn’t face in the journey to release. Dr Rad delves into the details of the factors that influenced the production including:
The historical pedigree of Cleopatra is based on a few different sources including credit given to Plutarch, Appian, and Suetonius! The impetus for the film was also based on the book published in 1957, The Life and Times of Cleopatra by Carlo Maria Franzero. There’s a depth of references throughout the film that have support in the ancient sources. Dr G considers:
Keen to delve more into Cleopatra? Check out our conversation with Yentl Love about the reception of Cleopatra over time.
Our music is by Bettina Joy de Guzman.
Lightly edited for our wonderful Australian accents 🙂
Dr Rad 0:15
Welcome to the Partial Historians.
Dr G 0:19
We explore all the details of ancient Rome,
Dr Rad 0:23
everything from political scandals, the love affairs, the battles waged and when citizens turn against each other, I’m Dr Rad
Dr G 0:33
And I’m Dr G, we consider Rome as the Romans saw it, by reading different authors from the ancient past and comparing their stories.
Dr Rad 0:44
Join us as we trace the journey of Rome from the founding of the city.
Dr Rad 0:58
Hello and welcome to a special episode of the Partial Historians. And this one has been a long time coming. Dr G.
Dr G 1:07
it has I’m very excited to be talking about the epic, grand, magnificent, over budgeted 1963 version of Cleopatra.
Dr Rad 1:21
Absolutely we couldn’t believe it. We realized that we’ve talked about this a lot on other podcasts, and then we kind of forgot that we’d never done it for ourselves.
Dr G 1:32
We’ll go into even more nerdy depths of what is happening in this film and why, and I’m very excited to learn from you. Dr Rad, because I know history on film is your jam, and I’m excited to see what I learned from this whole process.
Dr Rad 1:48
I have some film detail for you, Dr G. In fact, I’d like to start with a quote, If I might, from the writer slash director of the film, Joseph Mankiewicz. He said that “Cleopatra was the toughest three pictures I ever made. It was conceived in a state of emergency, shot in confusion and wound up in a blind panic.”
Dr G 2:12
Well, and that gives us a taste of things to come, doesn’t it?
Dr Rad 2:15
It really does a bit of a background detail, if I might. Dr G about this film, setting it setting it all up. So 1963 when Cleopatra was released, we are getting towards the end of the golden era of Hollywood, that time when epics were everywhere. Cleopatra is sometimes blamed the end of the public’s fascination with epics, but I’m not so sure that that is the case. We’ll have to get into a bit of debate about that.
Dr G 2:45
I think it’s certainly pretty opulent. I’m happy to watch it again and again, not too frequently, though, because it is very long.
Dr Rad 2:53
It is very long, and we will get into why that is in a second. But there’s certainly been a lot of attention on this film since its release, and that’s partly because there was a lot of publicity, obviously, around the film’s production, but also since the film’s release, people who were involved with the film have published books and memoirs about this movie. So we’ve got things like my life with Cleopatra by Walter Wanger, who was the producer. We’ve got the Cleopatra Papers, which was written by some of the publicity men who were involved from the side of 20th Century Fox, Weiss and Brodsky. And so there’s just so much material about this film, which I think feeds into the legend itself.
Dr G 3:37
Oh, excellent. I’m so glad there’s good source material on this film as well, because I have planned for our conversation by thinking only about the historic, historical events and what has happened in the course of the film, and how that matches up to our ancient source material. So I think the combination of your perspective on the film production and me chiming in with little details being like, what about this might lead us down some interesting paths.
Dr Rad 4:05
Well, we should perhaps tell our listeners, Dr G that this movie was originally meant to be two epic films, one about Caesar and Cleopatra and one about Cleopatra and Mark Antony. Following in that grand tradition, we think this is going to be a multi-parter special episode for us as well.
Dr G 4:26
Which I think makes perfect sense, because when you do look at the film, the first two hours is Julius Caesar and Cleopatra, and then it’s set up with the intermission, and you’re like, alrighty, then take a short break, and when you come back, it is all Mark Antony and Cleopatra. So you can see how they might have wanted to have two separate films, but for some reason, they ended up sticking them together instead.
Dr Rad 4:53
Absolutely. Now let’s just go through the basic cast, just for people who may not have seen the film. As Cleopatra,we of course, have the gorgeous Elizabeth Taylor, the most beautiful woman in the world. We have Rex Harrison, veteran actor as Caesar. But Dr, G, did you know that he wasn’t meant to play Caesar in this movie?
Dr G 5:13
Really? He does a very good job, I think.
Dr Rad 5:15
He does do a very good job. But, and this is part of the endless production troubles that plagued this film. The original actor who was slated to play Julius Caesar was Peter Finch, illustrious English-Australian actor best known for his role in Network where he’s as mad as hell, Dr G, and he’s not gonna take it anymore.
Dr G 5:40
Oh, another classic. Okay, but he drops out and we end up with Rex Harrison instead?
Dr Rad 5:46
We do, and it’s purely because of the timing, yes. He had actually been, Peter Finch, was actually hand selected by Elizabeth Taylor to play Caesar. They had starred in a movie called Elephant Walk together, and she liked him, but because of all the delays, he had to move on to another project. Similar thing for our Mark Antony, of course, infamously played in the end by Richard Burton, but originally was meant to be played by Stephen Boyd, whose name you might recall, because he plays the bad guy in Ben Hur and he also stars in Fall of the Roman Empire.
Dr G 6:21
Okay, so this man has been around epic films, and he’s looking for his next turn. Is it a timing issue for him as well?
Dr Rad 6:29
It absolutely is.
Dr G 6:30
Well, I think it’s really lucky that we have Richard Burton to be honest, because this is one of the things that sort of goes down in film history, is watching these two on screen together.
Dr Rad 6:43
Absolutely. Now, as the producer, we have another veteran, Walter Wanger. Walter Wanger was involved in so many movies in his career, the ones that perhaps stand out, I think that people might have seen these days would be Queen Christina, Foreign Correspondent, Joan of Arc – the one with Ingrid Bergman – I Want to Live, and the Invasion of the Body Snatchers. He also had two turns as the president of the Academy of Motion Pictures, Arts and Sciences in then, well, basically in the late 1930s and the early 1940s. His last film, however, would be Cleopatra.
Dr G 7:23
The end of the Wanger is near.
Dr Rad 7:27
And then, of course, finally, we have as director a couple of people. We had Robert, sorry, Ruben Mamulian, who was the initial director, but he was replaced with Joseph L Mankiewicz, who was an esteemed writer slash director. I adore Joseph Mankiewicz. He was involved in some of my absolute most favorite classic movies. He was the writer director of All About Eve and also A Letter to Three Wives, which I really, really recommend. If you haven’t seen that one.
Dr G 8:00
I haven’t I’ll put that on my list classic films.
Dr Rad 8:04
Yeah. And finally, as composer, I couldn’t help but mention Dr G, that Alex North is the composer for Cleopatra, because he was also the composer on Spartacus.
Dr G 8:15
Ah, all right, another Golden Era film veteran in the wings.
Dr Rad 8:23
Absolutely. He also worked on Prizzi’s Honor, The Agony and the Ecstasy, Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf, The Misfits, The Children’s Hour, I’ll Cry Tomorrow, Viva Zapata! and A Streetcar Named Desire.
Dr G 8:34
Impressive resume.
Dr Rad 8:39
Yeah. So we have said, the point of all this, Dr G, is that we’ve got a huge amount of talent on this movie, and that’s just obviously the tip of the iceberg. There’ll be other notable names that come up as we go through this detail. But with all these people on board, you would think that we are going to get a priceless example of cinema.
Dr G 9:00
I mean, I think we do, don’t we? I mean, at the very least it looks so opulent, you can almost see the money dripping off the screen. It’s incredible.
Dr Rad 9:10
Absolutely. Let’s talk a little bit about the money, shall we?
Dr G 9:14
Please, let’s.
Dr Rad 9:14
So to give you a bit of an idea. Few years before Cleopatra came out, there was, of course, the gigantic success that was Ben Hur. Ben Hur cost around $15 million to make, which was pretty pricey for, you know, 1950s movies, but of course, it was a smash hit, lots of Oscars, so money well spent. Cleopatra was not meant to cost anywhere near as much as that. It had a $2 million budget and a 64 day shoot assigned to it, both of which it would blow out of the water, eventually costing $44 million in 1960s money. It’s very hard, of course, to adjust for inflation, etc, etc, but it is estimated that in today’s money, we’d be talking something in the neighborhood of $400 million.
Dr G 10:11
Well, I mean, they’re only $42 million over budget.
Dr Rad 10:16
A drop in the pan.
Dr G 10:17
Yeah, I’m surprised nobody pulled the plug on this film before it got well out of hand, because to spend that much money, somebody at the at the studio has to keep saying, yes, I’ll give you another extension on finances for this project. And I am assuming that the film itself, in terms of, like the production days the film, you said it was 64 day shoot? I as a as a lay person who doesn’t study film very often, even my understanding is that it took way longer to shoot this film than the 64 days.
Dr Rad 10:51
It definitely did. And I think, look, this is why I particularly gravitate towards this movie. Because, as you know, you might have heard, I wrote a little bit on Spartacus in my time, and one of the things that I like about Spartacus is that it’s a piece of history that was pieced together by multiple people. It wasn’t something that was conceived of and executed by one author. And so I think it’s really interesting to consider as a historian, when you’ve got multiple people who are contributing to the construction of something, particularly when they’re doing it, seemingly in a rather haphazard manner, a lot of the time, because it really obviously affects the version that you get on the screen. And I think Cleopatra 1963 is another classic example of how this movie came together in such a haphazard way that the history as well, I think, has been affected, and that’s why it’s such an interesting example for people who were interested in the ancient world on film to consider it was actually originally conceived of in 1958, I believe. It was meant to actually starred Joan Collins at first, but eventually Elizabeth Taylor was the woman who was inextricably tied to this project, and it was Walter Wanger’s baby from the get go, the producer, Wanger, who I mentioned before. But it encountered production issue after production issue, and it had such a troubled time, and a lot of it was, to be honest, was also out of their control. So in the very early days, it was weather that was often causing the most issues.
Dr G 12:32
Okay, well, that’s not anybody’s fault. Can’t do much about the weather.
Dr Rad 12:36
Yeah. Well, basically they start the art director. So you mentioned the opulence of this movie. The art director, John DeCuir, I’m presuming his name is, had started constructing sets in places like Pinewood in England, and the weather did serious damage to these sets. Elizabeth Taylor herself was plagued by illness in the early days of this project. I think a lot of people probably know that she actually almost died during these illnesses. She had to have an emergency tracheotomy, and then she had to have plastic surgery to try and remove the tracheotomy scar. And all this kind of stuff is somewhat out of the control of the people who are working on the production.
Dr Rad 12:36
Yeah definitely, these are things that you can’t anticipate and you can’t plan for and you just have to work around them if you want to bring the whole project to life. So, yeah, if you’ve got sets that have been destroyed by bad weather, obviously you have to think about where you’re going to rebuild or how, and if your lead is, you know, suffering from illness and then recovering from surgery, what are you gonna do? We can’t film Cleopatra until we have Cleopatra on set. You know what I’m saying?
Dr Rad 12:40
It’s funny how it works like that. You know, having your lead actress around, how it assists with the production.
Dr G 12:40
And she’s basically in every single scene. There are very few scenes which she does not appear in so the load for her, in terms of, like the workhorse nature of her having to be on screen so much throughout this film, means that she’s, if she’s not in top shape, you’re gonna have delays.
Dr Rad 12:40
Absolutely. And it’s also, I think, partly, and this is where 20th Century Fox has to take some responsibility. There also seems to have been multiple decisions being made about where exactly this production was going to end up being filmed. They kept on debating, you know, are we going to proceed filming in London? Are we going to film in Rome? Are we going to film in Hollywood? Like, what is going to happen with this production? So there were a lot of delays, I think, caused by that, although they were probably responding to the problems. But basically what that means is that we’re a few months into the shoot of this film. They’ve already spent a fortune on the movie, and they only have about 10 minutes worth of workable film.
Dr G 14:57
Oh, oh no. I. Yeah, this is gonna be bad guys. I think we need to double down and spend more money.
Dr Rad 15:06
Well see, and again, this is exactly it. Right? You raise a very valid point of, why would they proceed with this movie when they’ve already spent so much and they have very little to show for it? Why not just, you know, claim as much insurance money as they can. I don’t think they could even get as much as they spent. I think by the time, I think by the time we’re about almost six months in, they’d spent, you know, between six and $7 million and they could only get about 2 million back in insurance costs. So why wouldn’t they just pull up stumps and, you know, take it as a loss and just forget about the whole thing. And I think that part of the reason is actually Elizabeth Taylor herself, Dr G,
Dr G 15:47
Is she living to play Cleopatra on screen? Is that what’s going on here?
Dr Rad 15:51
She is keen to play her but I think it’s more the fact that they believe in her bankability, because, and this is where we get into some of the scandal behind this particular film, Elizabeth Taylor had something of a reputation by the time she was filming Cleopatra, she’d already had multiple husbands by the time she was cast to pay Cleopatra, and her most recent husband was a guy called Eddie Fisher. Eddie Fisher had been married to American sweetheart of the screen, Debbie Reynolds. Now, if this is sounding a little familiar to some of you, yes, these are the parents of Carrie Fisher or Princess Leia of the Star Wars movies. So essentially, Elizabeth Taylor had been kind of demonized because she had supposedly stolen away Eddie Fisher from Debbie Reynolds. And so she was very much seen as a home wrecker. She was like the evil seductress type, or as Debbie Reynolds was the the good wife, the good mother, the really cute baby faced, you know, sweet as pie actress. That was her image at the time. And this is how these two women were represented when Elizabeth Taylor went off to make Cleopatra. However, the fact that she had then become so gravely ill and then managed to recover, I think, meant that people were ready to forgive her, perhaps for those perceived transgressions, and she was awarded an Oscar, her very first for a movie called Butterfield 8. And so it seemed like this would be the moment to be on the Elizabeth Taylor train. You know, part of her her come back, in a way, not that she was doing badly or anything. She’s obviously still making lots of movies, attracting a lot of attention, but it seems like this would be a moment to be part of her – I don’t know what’s the right word, to be part of her, um…
Dr G 17:51
Her rising star. This is a moment to be capitalized upon, potentially. If she is, as you say, recent Oscar winner, then there’s obviously that sort of sheen to her as well, where it’s like, you’re going to get to see a great actress who has a reputation that sometimes leads into the seductress, and she’s going to be playing Cleopatra, who, in popular imagination, is known for seducing Roman men.
Dr Rad 18:19
Absolutely. And it’s always funny how the women who are chosen to play Cleopatra, whether it’s real or imagined, they do often have these connotations in their personal life. Sometimes it’s entirely manufactured, and it might not be a fair way of looking at them, but I think it’s really interesting that they often bring that to the role you think about. Even the Cleopatra set were mooted, but never have been. I mean, Angelina Jolie was supposed to play Cleopatra at one point in time, and that was back when, you know, her personal life was a bit more scandalous than it is these days. There is often that connection with the Cleopatra players.
Dr G 19:02
Yeah, let’s get a artist whose personal life seems to be mirroring the artistry we’d like to see on screen.
Dr Rad 19:09
Yeah. And of course, her personal life during the filming of Cleopatra would then take on a life of its own, but we’ll get into that in our next episode. I think, um, now they also, I think, 20th Century Fox, really wanted to cash in on the epic, the, you know, the the genre itself. They knew that the Ten Commandments and Ben Hur, King of Kings, Spartacus, had done really well at the box office, and they were looking for something that would also bring in huge profits to 20th Century Fox. There were internal issues in the company at the time. So a Greek, American guy called Spyro Skouras was the president of Fox at the time, but there were people within Fox who were trying to get him out. That there were factions within the company and that, I think. Also affected the way that decisions were often made with this movie, skuas was definitely on board to try and, you know, wipe out the memories of box office failures that had been in recent years, to restore himself to glory with the huge success of something like Cleopatra. He also, I think, contributed a bit to the indecision about where they were going to film, etc, etc. But Elizabeth Taylor’s production company was involved in the Cleopatra filming, and her production company being involved meant it had to be a European filming, which basically meant that they, instead of using Fox’s own studio lots they were going to end up filming eventually in Cinecittà the very famous film studios in Italy. Now you would think that that would mean that they might therefore enjoy good weather, because usually in autumn and Rome, it’s quite a nice time to be there. But as luck would have it, there was unusually stormy weather in Rome in the autumn where they were meant to start filming, and there was amazing weather in LA, so in some ways, they perhaps should have just been filming in LA. But of course, as we said, you cannot always predict the weather.
Dr G 21:16
Yeah, that’s unfortunate. And I guess the complexities of having Elizabeth Taylor production company needing to lean in a particular direction, where, obviously it would have been cheaper for 20th Century Fox to do it in their own studios. It’s just adding complexity to what is already something that’s quite complex already.
Dr Rad 21:34
It absolutely is. And also filming in Rome was also going to be good for Elizabeth Taylor’s health, the issues that she had had were very much focused on her lungs. London weather wasn’t fantastic for that. So moving to a warmer climate was also going to hopefully mean that she wasn’t going to become too ill to work again.
Dr G 21:59
Very interesting. Oh, very interesting. Now,
Dr Rad 22:02
I know we wanted to get into the history. Dr, G, so one of the things that I really like about this movie is that if you look it up on IMDb, whilst you will see a number of screenwriters credited amongst them, you will also find Suetonius, Appian and Plutarch.
Dr G 22:18
I’m so glad to hear that, because it is very clear, from what we see in the way that the story unfolds, that somebody, at the very least, was reading their ancient sources. And I think this is really ideal, because as I was watching, re-watching, because I have seen this film many times before, I was going through and just making notes about the things that were happening, and just putting asterisks next to things where I was like, things where I was like, I’d like to check if that’s a proper historical detail. That’s an interesting thing for somebody to have said, or that’s an interesting thing for something to have happened. Who are these people? Can I find a reference to them? And by and large, you can. So there’s many interesting figures. For instance, Ptolemy, the brother of Cleopatra, is positioned in the opening of the film as having three key advisors, and one of them’s the Chief Eunuch, Pothinus. One of them is his tutor Theodotus. And then there is the general who’s in charge of his armed forces, a guy called Achillas. And each of these three are attested in the historical record with these names. And I think, you know, this was a great start for me. I was like, Oh, look, Ptolemy surrounded by his henchmen. And while there are some nuance of difference, so for instance, we get the story that when Pompey the great is fleeing from Greece in the wake of the Battle of Pharsalus in 48 he ends up fleeing to Egypt. It is Achillas, the general of Ptolemy and some other Romans who had been previously stationed in Egypt and had stayed that managed to bundle Pompey up and execute him. And one of the early key differences that we see in this film is that when Julius Caesar arrives in Alexandria and he meets all of these advisors of Ptolemy, Achillas is there basically as a foil to the other two advisors, and he seems to be a bit more pragmatic. And it seems that he’s aware that Julius Caesar would not have been happy with the execution of Pompey, whereas in the historical record, he was definitely a key player in making sure that that had happened. But yet, what we see is that Achillas’ position there’s maybe slightly more nuanced in his understanding and appreciation of Roman politics than the other two advisors of Ptolemy. So we see like little differences, coming through, but the fact that they have the same names that we see in the ancient sources, and the fact that they’re there at all on screen doing this kind of stuff, which is giving us this richness to what Ptolemies court looked like, I think, is impressive. Like, that’s a choice that they have made in the production to be like, let’s try and follow the source material for some of this stuff.
Dr Rad 25:21
Absolutely and I think that this is perhaps a good moment to perhaps quickly summarize exactly what this movie covers. I mean, to be honest, it’s a bit hard to know exactly what they intended to cover all of the time, because so much of this movie ends up on the cutting room floor, because they end up taking the two epics that were meant to be and forging it into one. And we’ll talk about why that happened again, probably in a future episode on this. We are essentially focusing on the part of Cleopatra’s life where Caesar enters so where Caesar winds up in Alexandria as he’s pursuing Pompey as part of the Roman Civil War, and then ends up getting embroiled in the civil war that’s going on in Egypt between Cleopatra and her siblings. And we follow Cleopatra all the way through her relationship with Julius Caesar into her next relationship with Mark Antony, and the film ends with her death. Spoilers, everybody. That’s where we’re going to end up. And it is interesting, I suppose, in some sense, that you could look at this film and I suppose be critical of the fact that it’s therefore focusing on the part of Cleopatra’s life, which involves Roman men and love affairs. That’s definitely what this movie focuses on. And it was actually based on a popular Italian novel at the time by C M Franzero, and there’s a little preface from that book that I thought I might read to you, Dr G. says, “women are the most interesting creatures on earth. Men can only be judged in light of their attitudes to women. The love may prompt some men to accomplish great deeds, but in a woman, love is the only motive of life.”
Dr G 27:02
That’s it, that’s, what?
Dr Rad 27:03
That’s, that’s a little thought I’d like to read for you.
Dr G 27:05
No, okay, all right, so I think one of the ways in which this film suffers is that it does seem to be trying to do two things at once, and, maybe because of the cutting room situation, it’s doing neither particularly well. Because we have this sense that Cleopatra is a political animal – that does come through in the film, but it’s not done ultimately, in a very nuanced way. And we also see this leaning in on like the seductress element, and this idea of Cleopatra, sort of bringing men into her orbit and then having her way with them. And in some respects, that doesn’t go so well either. But what we see in this opening of the film – so to give just a quick sort of like plot summary, here we have Julius Caesar is basically turning up in Alexandria. He is met by Ptolemy the 13th and the advisors, and that’s where this whole thing kicks off. And it’s not until we get a little bit further into the film that Cleopatra turns up in her rolled up carpet being brought in by her loyal servant, Apollodorus.
Dr Rad 28:33
Classic
Dr G 28:35
Classic moment in cinema. There is a moment where Apollodorus is holding the carpet and you’re like, I know there’s not a body in there right now. It’s not body shaped. It’s just not and then there’s then there’s a cut, and we switch to the part where he rolls it out, and it’s like, oh, there she is.
Dr Rad 28:50
Surprise. She’s been dieting so that she could fit into that carpet for weeks.
Dr G 28:54
Ah, like she was practically invisible. And then there she was. And all of this allows us to bear witness to this idea that Cleopatra is a little bit more savvy than your average Ptolemy. So you know, she immediately does things like point out that his maps are wrong, and these sort of little gestures are a hint towards this idea that she is political, she is strategic, and it’s a shame that that I think doesn’t get a little bit more play time as well, but we quickly sort of deviate into this storyline where Julius Caesar is kind of forcibly, sort of seduced her to some extent, and she says, You’re not going to like me this way. And I think that’s a really interesting moment in this film early on, but other things that are happening. So once Julius Caesar has met Cleopatra, she’s come out of the carpet, he’s very excited about that, and they start working together. She makes the proposition that she should be in charge more so than the brother. And there’s fighting in the streets. So Ptolemy’s forces have ended up embroiled with the Roman soldiers in various ways, and the fighting that has broken out starts, it seems, on the Nile, but then progresses onto the shorelines, and we have this infamous burning of the Alexandrian library.
Dr Rad 30:28
Not the books, Dr. G, anything, but the books.
Dr G 30:31
Nooooo. And for anybody who watches this film who loves books, you will obviously be on Cleopatra’s side. She is outraged by the burning of the library. She lays into Julius Caesar. She blames him for this, and I think that’s an important moment, because it gets you on side with her. But it is also something where we’re not quite entirely sure that that is something that historically happened. So people talk about the burning of the Library of Alexandria, and we actually don’t know and really what is happening here. So there are some suggestions that the location of the library would have been inside the palatial complex. That’s as far as we can sort of take where it might have been, because originally it was established by the early Ptolemies as a way of generating their own power and knowledge. So it should have been pretty well protected. And we don’t get a sense that the palace is at any stage under threat, not in the film, not historically. And then, having said that, we’ve got differences in our ancient source material as well. So we’ve got later sources who are suggesting that the library is fine, even into the third century CE, the library is there. It is functioning. If it was burnt. It wasn’t burnt to such a degree that everybody’s like, we can’t rebuild it.
Dr Rad 32:01
It’s just a light singe-ing.
Dr G 32:03
It’s just over, now it’s gone. So if it had burnt, it is revived, or alternatively, it wasn’t burnt at all. And we’re really just not sure about what is happening here, but touching on it does allow Cleopatra’s character to have this sort of moment in the sun with the audience, where it’s like, if you like books, you’re going to be on her side.
Dr Rad 32:25
I think it’s also meant to be, as you say, a nod to her being intellectual, that she values this knowledge, and also that she values the heritage of her own dynasty, the Ptolemies. And perhaps also, maybe more broadly, Egypt. But I think you do get a sense of her connection with her ancestors.
Dr G 32:48
You definitely do, and that, I think, comes through pretty clearly in this. And the other thing that historically is quite interesting in this early part of the film is the idea that Julius Caesar is visiting the tomb of Alexander the Great.
Dr Rad 33:05
I love this scene. I’m so glad you’re talking about it.
Dr G 33:09
I will come to the beautiful translucency of that sarcophagus.
Dr Rad 33:12
Absolutely, Alexander, glistening like a little chocolate.
Dr G 33:17
Hmm beautiful. I was like – the money they spent on this! Alexander the Great dies in the east. That’s pretty well established. It’s sudden. There’s controversy about that, and the ancient source material gets really weird, really quickly about this. The idea seems to be that his body was taken quite quickly back to Macedonia, Greece, back into the area of where he came from, and was embalmed there, which I think should be our first question. And then the first Ptolemy took that body, now preserved, to Memphis in Egypt, which is nowhere near Alexandria, just for the record, and then hundreds of years after that, the body somehow gets moved to Alexandria and ends up about 1000 kilometers from where Alexander the Great died. So we have this sort of tricky story that happens over centuries where Alexander dies in one place, is embalmed in another place, is then moved a couple of times, ends up in Alexandria. We don’t know too much about the tomb itself. Details are pretty thin on the ground. Strabo describes it, but he’s also there in the late Republic. So to what extent that carries through into other periods. It might tie in nicely to the Cleopatra moment he’s there in the sort of the 10 years after the Battle of Actium. And it seems that the whole complex is also inside the palace, and that the Tomb of Alexander the Great is particularly recessed amongst what might be other tombs of Ptolemies. And that would make sense. The Ptolemies see themselves as very much connected to Alexander the Great and the inheritors of his world. So they would obviously position themselves as being close to his body if they could. It seems that they do that. But if you wanted to see Alexander the Great, there were a couple of caveats. He was brought out to you, not you went to him.
Dr Rad 35:30
Well, naturally.
Dr Rad 35:33
You wait
Dr Rad 35:34
And it’s marm in like harm, not man like spam.
Dr G 35:38
And so how long he spends in his sarcophagus is anybody’s guess, because presumably he’s not removed that often. But you know, they wheel him out and they wheel him back. And part of the controversy for that is, why is that even going on? But also, further to that, Alexander the Great had potentially stipulated, and we don’t know why that he wanted to actually be buried in the Oasis at Siwa. Now pay attention, everybody. This is a reference to Assassins Creed Origins. So Siwa is where your main character starts in that video game. Great news, Siwa, lovely little oasis place. What would Alexander the Great want to do with that? It is not clear at all.
Dr Rad 36:28
Doesn’t seem grand enough for Alexander.
Dr G 36:30
No, what’s going on? So the other source that we have for this, because I was like, do we have any historical evidence that Julius Caesar actually visited the tomb of Alexander the Great? This is hard to track down. Everybody says that he does, but they don’t usually provide their source reference, which is frustrating. But Lucan, in his epic poem of the Civil War, does talk about this in a way that is directly critical of Julius Caesar.
Dr Rad 37:02
Yeah, Lucans not a fan, from memory.
Dr G 37:04
Lucan is not a fan. He sees the whole thing as a disgrace, really. He sees Alexander as a “chance marauder whose sudden death solaced the world”.
Dr Rad 37:18
Wow.
Dr G 37:20
So the idea that anybody is going to visit this particular individual in death does not rate highly on Lucan’s radar, and Julius Caesar gets roundly criticized for having done it. So I’m interested in, like, the sarcophagus itself, as it’s depicted in the film. What are your thoughts?
Dr Rad 37:44
Look to be fair, I have never looked into what Alexander’s sarcophagus might have actually looked like, because as far as I’m aware, we have no idea where Alexander the Great’s body is, nor do we know where Cleopatra’s body is. I’m presuming they’re all underwater, like most of ancient Alexandria, but I don’t think it would quite look like that. It looks almost like a Swarovski crystal, or something along those lines. What are your thoughts?
Dr G 38:14
Look, because we don’t know, and every so often, a new news story comes out where they’re like, we found it: it’s the tomb of Alexander the Great! And it’s a bit like the news stories that were coming through a few years ago. Of like we found Pliny the Elder. I’m like, did you?
Dr Rad 38:31
Oh, yeah, and the news stories are constantly coming through about finding Cleopatra.
Dr G 38:35
So yes, both Alexander the Great and Cleopatra sit in this realm of we would love to have their bodies, because I can only imagine the kind of cheap and horrifying restorations of their faces that people would do if they thought they had that skull. Cleopatra, turns out she had a big nose. Ah, but with reconstruction…
Dr Rad 38:59
But how could you tell? The nose is the part that goes first, Dr, G!
Dr G 39:04
No, but, I mean, you got to look at the coinage. I think the worst that I’ve seen is the one that was like, clearly Britney Spears. They’re like, this is Cleopatra reconstructed. Wait a minute.
Dr Rad 39:16
Yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah
Dr G 39:18
So we have this idea of we don’t know where the bodies are, historically, we don’t know where the sarcophagi are. And this film has a lot of sort of sarcophagi type scenes, because we’ve got this tomb of Alexander the Great we also then end up with what appears to be a funeral temple to the deified Caesar later on, and then we also have Cleopatra’s own area for her end. But maybe we’re getting ahead of ourselves.
Dr Rad 39:53
I would like to zoom in on what actually happens whilst they are visiting Alexander the Great because I think that this is actually the perfect scene to kind of understand the way that Cleopatra was meant to be in this film, and the vision for her, and the way that it didn’t quite manage to be executed. So when they see Alexander’s tomb together, Julius Caesar tells Cleopatra that he cried the first time that he came to visit because he had accomplished so little. And that’s the part that you’re referring to that everybody repeats about Julius Caesar’s visit to Alexander’s tomb. Cleopatra then urges him to carry on Alexander’s dream, which she classifies as one world, one peace, one nation. Now this, oh, and of course, she wants Alexandria to be the capital.
Dr G 40:51
Obviously
Dr Rad 40:52
Naturally, naturally, she sees that as being the capital. But she’s like, You know what? It doesn’t even really matter, because we can just all be one people. And it’s this moment where she reveals her pregnancy with Julius Caesar’s child, which what is an intriguing possibility. Of course, we kind of write off Caesarian, the child that Caesar and Cleopatra actually did have together in real life, because he gets murdered by Octavian in the aftermath of Cleopatra and Antony losing Actium, etc, etc, as you would expect, he’s perceived as a rival. However, what a fascinating possibility to have this child out there who does unite Caesar and Cleopatra’s families together. I mean, the mind boggles when I consider how the world might have been different if that boy had lived beyond his teen years. But I’m getting distracted. The main thing, I think, is that they really did want Cleopatra to come across as a political, intellectual figure, whilst the love story obviously was important and the sexy stuff was important, because a Cleopatra movie that does allow you to do those things, you know, King of Kings and those sorts of biblical epics like Ben Hur it’s a little bit harder to be, you know, so sexy when it’s getting on with Jesus, doesn’t seem respectful, you know, but Cleopatra always opens the door for a certain level of sexiness and love and passion. But they did also want to have this, and that’s also, I think, because, I think that’s also why they brought on board Joseph Mankiewicz. Mankiewicz was well known for preferring to write and direct powerful movies about women. So that’s why I particularly highlighted his involvement in movies, like A Letter to Three Wives, and, of course, the absolutely phenomenal All About Eve. So he was really interested in women. He got along really well with Elizabeth Taylor. He kind of knew how to work with her. She was obviously huge star by the time she came on board Cleopatra. And one of the reasons, I think, that they also pushed ahead with making this film, when it seemed like all the signs were Stop, stop this immediately, just walk away, was partly because Mankiewicz was brought on board. The first director doesn’t seem to have particularly impressed anyone. I don’t know that he was handling everything as well as he perhaps could, and apparently he was a bit of a perfectionist. But Mankiewicz was someone who they thought was going to come in with a fresh vision, and they really did want this to be a vision that was centered around a fusion of sort of Elizabeth Taylor and Cleopatra, because obviously it’s meant to be about her. And I think he wanted her to be a bit of an Eleanor Roosevelt JFK esque kind of figure. Because lest we forget, this is during JFK presidency that they are writing and conceiving of this movie. And so I think it was meant to somewhat embody, as well, a bit of the the freshness, the hope, I think, that was coming around in that early 1960s era for many Americans. And Joseph Mankiewicz, when he came on board and looked at the script, he thought, Oh, my God, this is an absolute disaster. He didn’t like what he saw the one of the guys who’d been working on the early script had never even met Elizabeth Taylor. He was just judging her based on what he’d seen of her on film. And so the biggest issue that Mankiewicz face was the script, and so he desperately wanted time before he started work on actually filming the movie to write an entirely new script, but unfortunately, they wouldn’t give him the time that he needed because they’d already started production, which means that people like Elizabeth Taylor were already getting paid to stay on this project. So she was getting about $50,000 per week plus $3,000 for expenses.
Dr G 45:03
Oh, hello
Dr Rad 45:04
Yeah, and that’s just for Elizabeth Taylor. Apparently the expenses to keep the production running, even whilst it was technically shut down, was around $45,000 in terms of their overheads. The insurance company weren’t going to cover their losses, and so they only gave him a really small amount of time to try and work on the script before he had to start filming again. So he did his best. There were a few other people he was working with, guy called Lawrence Durrell and Sidney Buchman, who was actually a blacklisted writer who’d moved to London to escape that HUAC era, and they sort of hold themselves up in a hotel for a while and tried to pump out the best scripts that they could. Mankiewicz wasn’t thrilled with everything that he was getting from the other writers. They weren’t the people I don’t think that he had wanted to work with. But nonetheless, they also got a guy called Ronald McDougall who also worked on the script. So as you can see, we’ve already got, you know, many people coming together working on this script. It is a total mess. And what ends up happening is that they have to go into filming without a finished script. And this is a very similar situation to what happened on Spartacus, like they have a basic idea of where it’s heading, obviously, and they have got multiple drafts and scenes and that sort of thing, which have been pumped out by these various writers, but they do not have one script that they know that they’re going to be working from. And what that means is that Mankiewicz is signing up to not only direct the film and shoot all day, but he’s then committing to writing the script at night, so in the very first period of filming. So filming resumes in September in Rome, where they kick off with the filming. He is producing and directing by day and writing at night, six days a week, and then on Sunday, that’s his entirely writing day.
Dr G 47:12
That sounds exhausting, and I’m not even trying to do it.
Dr Rad 47:15
It is. And essentially what ended up happening was they had to make a few adjustments, as you can imagine, during the shooting, I think eventually they switched to sort of starting at around midday with the actual filming. But certainly, what Mankiewicz was doing, he ended up being propped up entirely by drugs. Basically, he was being given drugs to help him to stay awake and complete his work, and then he had to be given drugs in order to be able to sleep at night.
Dr G 47:44
This is the classic tragic Hollywood studio story from this period.
Dr Rad 47:49
It absolutely is, and Mankiewicz said of the strain of this film on him, I’m not biting my fingernails. I’m biting my knuckles. I finished the fingernails months ago.
Dr G 48:02
Buddy. Nothing’s worth this.
Dr Rad 48:06
But yeah, it is. It is absolutely crazy. And this, I say this, I say all of this because I feel like it is relevant in terms of, just like with Spartacus, you don’t really end up with a clear version, perhaps, of who Spartacus was, and what his rebellion was meant to be about, and all of that kind of stuff. I feel like that’s why we get a slightly mixed portrayal of Cleopatra in this film, because the script was always such, you know, such a such a mess. Basically, it was always being worked on, and it was way too long, and this is one of the reasons why. Again, it sort of blew out in terms of in terms of the way that not all scenes are brilliant. I mean, even though I think Mankiewicz was a fantastic writer, definitely his writing was not always up to scratch. Rex Harrison even asked him to rewrite some of his scenes as Julius Caesar, because he wasn’t really happy with them, and that’s really because Mankiewicz was working under such time pressures that he would just write to get something down and didn’t have time to edit them, a feeling I know well from our own projects.
Dr G 49:17
I think it is pretty clear from what we see on screen, that there are ideas about how Cleopatra will be, and they’re executed variably. And there’s also a sense in which you, at times, are watching these performances, and you feel like the actors are being sort of pushed in a particular direction as well. There are times where all of a sudden, characters are shouting at each other. It doesn’t necessarily seem like there’s been an appropriate build up to that, and part of that can be put down to like filmic style of the period, but some of it also feels, feels like maybe there’s some confusion about what is required in a scene. There’s maybe conflicts between actors and director about what should happen, and for the actors themselves trying to maintain a sense of the continuity of the character when they’re being presented with such varied material, it shows a little bit on screen at times, and not to a positive end.
Dr Rad 50:27
Absolutely and certainly there was sometimes a bit of tension on the set because of those sorts of issues. Apparently, Elizabeth Taylor would often turn up late on the set, even when the starting time was noon, when they switched to what are apparently called French hours in November of 1961 so that’s about, I guess, they were filming for about, what, two to three months before they switched to those different hours, and Rex Harrison kind of resented the fact that she was just turning up late and didn’t really make apologies or get into any trouble for it. She also had all these special conditions as a part of her contract, like she didn’t have to work for the first two days per menstrual cycle, which Rex Harrison kind of resented that she got this slightly diva-ish, I suppose, treatment.
Dr G 51:14
Uh hello, has he ever had a menstrual cycle? Does he know what the first two days are like?
Dr Rad 51:19
No, that’s what I mean. Like as someone who is, you know, at this particular stage of my life, I’m like, well, yeah,
Dr G 51:26
Like, don’t ask me to be in front of a camera.
Dr Rad 51:29
But just to give you an idea of Mankiewicz schedule during like these, these periods, although it did dig a little bit better with time. So after those first few months of real horror. Taylor Burton and Harrison all agreed to take salary cuts in order to try and shorten the working working week for Mankiewicz because he was just so exhausted, but he would basically be working at about 5:30 to 6am – he would take something called Dexedrine. He would then have a shot after his lunch to keep him going through the afternoon and another shot after dinner to keep him writing until around 2am and then at 2am he would be given a shot so that he could get about three to four hours sleep.
Dr G 52:10
It’s just dehumanizing.
Dr Rad 52:13
I know it’s crazy. It’s amazing, actually, in a way, that they finished this movie, I can’t understand how Mankiewicz managed to get through it. I mean, I think the thing is, for this particular movie, it is the end in the road for a lot of the people involved. Skouras will be replaced as the president of 20th Century Fox. Walter Wanger will also not make another movie after this. And Mankiewicz also will be kind of done in the film industry after this movie.
Dr G 52:41
Yeah, everybody’s going to be burnt out, that’s for sure.
Dr Rad 52:43
Well, some of them, they were forcibly removed. But yeah, sure, let’s go with burnout. That’s nice. Let’s say burnt out. Yeah. It basically wasn’t until the end of May in 1962 I believe that Mankiewicz had finished enough of the screenplay that he wasn’t writing at night after filming all day. So, but that’s, if you think about it, September to May. That’s still quite a long time that he was having to work like this.
Dr G 53:11
That is intense.
Dr Rad 53:12
It is.
Dr G 53:14
Oh boy, oh boy. All right, so some historical details. So there is a mention early on in the film that Caesar doesn’t have enough legions in Alexandria to deal effectively with Ptolemy’s forces. And we’re reminded that Caesar only has two legions in Alexandria, and everybody’s pretty sure that that’s not going to be enough to deal with Ptolemy’s army, particularly if Ptolemy takes a turn, which he does. And this whole situation is alleviated at a certain point by the arrival of the forces of Mithridates. And this is an exciting moment, and I immediately put an asterisk next to it, and I was like, Mithridates, what’s he doing over here? This is not where he belongs usually, what is going on historically? And this is where we start to get into the broader politics of like, what is the Roman Empire at this point in time? Because they have a lot of influence throughout the whole Mediterranean. And this guy was a real figure, and he did turn up in Alexandria and support Caesar in this moment. So all of this is lining up very nicely with our historical material, this particular Mithridates, because we need to emphasize that there were many of these people with this name. He was the illegitimate son of Mithridates, the fifth Euergetes, the king of Pontus, and he grew up in the Royal Court of Pontus, not only that, but his career is bumped along throughout his life by Caesar’s support. So these two know each other, and he secures a whole bunch of privileges. He’s in Rome from Caesar in the 50s BCE, so before Caesar goes on his like, really long jaunt to Gaul, Caesar is playing the political field and helping this guy out with furthering his career. So when Caesar needs some help in Alexandria. Mithridates comes along and plays at the table. He is able to bring a certain amount of armed forces with him, and that helps against Ptolemy the 13th. So he gets rewarded for his support. He ends up being given some additional territory around Pontus, which he goes back to, and all of this works out very nicely for him. So this sort of stray reference in the film to this figure from the east and Caesar, playing it up as like, you all told me, two legions wasn’t gonna be enough. I had a plan. Mithridates. I talked to him before I got here, everyone’s like, ohhh. And we get a sense that Caesar is politically savvy. Has anticipated everything that’s going to happen and already had a plan in place that he wasn’t revealing to people, because that’s the way he does business, and that’s how he gets to be in charge of stuff. We also have the moment where Caesar acknowledges Caesarion as his son.
Dr Rad 56:24
Absolutely.
Dr G 56:25
This is not something that we necessarily feel like we’re on a firm footing on in terms of the historical sources. Definitely, Cleopatra claims that this is Caesar’s child, and the dates do line up in the sense that he is in Egypt in 47 and when he leaves later that year, he’s there in 48-47 when he leaves to go back to Rome, Cleopatra does bear a child, and it would make sense that it would be his.
Dr Rad 57:04
Oh, I have no doubt that it is his child. It’s more that I don’t think he ever publicly acknowledged him as such.
Dr G 57:10
And we have this whole scene in this film where he does this public acknowledgement, which I think is fascinating, because then we get to cut almost immediately to a scene of the senators in Rome talking about Caesar and what’s happening in Egypt, because bad news travels fast. And I think what’s really interesting about that moment is that Octavian is already positioned as being a senator in Rome. He’s there, he’s in the crowd. He’s making his grumpy faces that will become so classic in this film, but we see sort of a compression of Octavian’s career to the point where he is already a powerful figure in Rome.
Dr Rad 57:56
Which doesn’t really add up with what we know.
Dr G 57:58
Yeah, in this very early 40s period where that is not possible. He won’t be old enough.
Dr Rad 58:06
Yeah
Dr G 58:07
Just not old enough. The maths is not mathing right now, but he’s there, and it works from a filmic perspective. So I can see why they’ve done that. But this whole situation also compresses what is some pretty intense movement around the Mediterranean for Julius Caesar, which the film doesn’t capture. The film kind of gives us a version of Julius Caesar’s movement as he leaves Greece after the Battle of Pharsalus, goes to Alexandria, stays there for ages, has a baby with Cleopatra, gets the word that he should take up the dictatorship in Rome, and at that point, goes back to Rome. And it’s a little bit more complicated than that, because he does a whole extra few trips in there. So after the Battle of Pharsalus, yes, he goes to Alexandria. By the time we get to mid-47 he sets off for Rome, and it’s later that month where Cleopatra has the son. So he’s not there when Caesarian is born. But he doesn’t go directly back to Rome. He goes via Asia Minor. So he confronts a guy known as Pharnaces the Second at a place called Zela. And it’s a shame to skip over this moment in the film, because this is Caesar’s fastest victory, and is the one that prompts the phrase that we get in Plutarch, “veni, vidi, vici”, I came, I saw, I conquered.
Dr Rad 59:38
Nice.
Dr G 59:40
That’s when he does it, and then he gets to Rome. Ultimately, in October of 47 doesn’t stay there for very long. Things are not great for Caesar in Rome. I mean, he’s in the middle of a civil war, which he’s a major player in. So he leaves in December, and he heads back to. Africa, not Egypt. So he’s heading south, basically, and that is where he’s recruiting new men. And in then, in early 46 of that year, he wins a victory at Thapus, which is in Carthaginian territory. And a little bit after that, Cato the Younger, one of his opponents commits suicide in Utica, also in Carthaginian territory. So it’s all of this activity which then leads Caesar back to Alexandria, and then because of his role in defeating some of his Roman opponents in North Africa, that’s when the dictatorship stuff starts to happen. So there’s discussions of that. And so we’ve got this real complexity of what’s going on for Julius Caesar at this point in time, which is really smoothed over by this film. As far as we can tell from the film, he’s hanging out with Cleopatra, having a great time defeating Ptolemy, being at her coronation, both crowning her and then kneeling, which I think is a great move on his part. But yeah, so there’s some things going on here that we don’t get to see in the film, and also some things that a little bit anachronistic, but I can see why they’ve done them.
Dr Rad 1:01:15
I completely agree with you in the sense that obviously there has been a gigantic compression. However, I guess this is where, if I was arguing from the film side of me, that is that you have to compress events often to make them fit into a film. And if we consider this to be the movie that it is Cleopatra, it’s about her, not about him. And so whilst, yes, it’s complicated, because obviously in trying to set her up in a particular way in the movie, they are obviously going against historical fact, and they are misrepresenting Caesar to a certain extent. I’m kind of like, what would you do? I mean, this film is already so long. How could you deal with all of this stuff that Caesar is up to and still be addressing what the film is meant to be about, which is Cleopatra’s life and relationships.
Dr G 1:02:08
Yeah, exactly. And we get a sense from our source material as well that what Julius Caesar really wanted to happen in Egypt is for the co-rule to go ahead as it was supposed to. He wasn’t really supposed to be taking sides, and didn’t really seem to want to until he had to. So the fact that he hesitates on the whole Ptolemy situation historically is not useful for this story at all, and positioning his immediate interest in Cleopatra at the forefront of what is going on here is an important device to give her the leverage, initially, that she needs in order to push herself into power as sole ruler. I mean, obviously, Cleopatra has many siblings, as you noted earlier. It’s not just Ptolemy the 13th. There are others who are also trying to find their way into sole rule, and those complexities are also glossed over. So there would be a way, I think, to create a Cleopatra film that really does focus intensely on the familial politics that she’s dealing with and how Julius Caesar becomes an instrument within that. But that’s not how this film navigates any of this situation.
Dr Rad 1:03:27
No and that’s where you come back to sort of what I was saying earlier in that this film was obviously chosen to essentially kick off with Caesar entering her life and Anthony exiting it with her. And so it is very much focused on what is Cleopatra up to whilst the Roman men are in the picture a lot of the time. However, I do understand that at the time that this movie was created, I feel like they would have been less comfortable about making a movie that started before that, because, let’s face it, even these days, even taking into account the wider range of source material that we have where, finally, you know, a lot of the Arabic sources about Cleopatra in translation and all of that kind of stuff. At the same time, we don’t know a huge amount about Cleopatra’s early life. A lot of what we can piece together about her early life we’re piecing together from the movements of her family members. What’s her dad doing? And what does that mean for Cleopatra? What are her brothers and sisters up to as they scheme to take the throne from their father? And so we we do know a few things, but there’s not a ton of insight into her life in this time period. So I can kind of understand filmmakers in that era before second wave feminism, or all of that kind of stuff, not perhaps feeling comfortable to do that, but it does obviously craft her in a particular way. However, I think the reason why I like the Cleopatra and Caesar part of the movie more is that I like the interplay between Rex Harrison’s Caesar and Elizabeth Taylor’s Cleopatra. Obviously, it’s not perfect, but I do think they have kind of a fun dynamic. I mean, it’s not sexy at all, but then again, should it be? This is the thing, right? Caesar was an awful lot older, you know, several decades older than the teenaged Cleopatra when they first met. Most academics believe that whatever union these two had was largely political in nature. Sure, they might have got along. Okay, she was smart, he was smart. She’s a good politician. He’s a good politician. But at the end of the day, the reason that they are together is for political reasons. So I can kind of forgive the lack of sexual tension between Taylor and Harrison in this part of the movie.
Dr G 1:05:52
Yeah, it does make sense, and I think we start to see a shift in the way that they are operating in political alliance with each other. When this film shifts to Cleopatra in Rome, this sort of sets up a new dynamic for them, because up until this point, it’s been Julius Caesar in Alexandria, so he’s had to be sort of stepping his way carefully through the local politics, as well as dealing with whatever is being thrown at him from the Romans from afar. But now we see a whole reversal of this situation, with Julius Caesar in the place where he’s supposed to be, even though maybe it’s more tense than we would imagine, and Cleopatra is entering into a different political sphere. I love the arrival scene of Cleopatra in Rome. I think it’s one of the greatest, the greatest cinematic scenes of all time.
Dr Rad 1:06:58
And, not surprisingly, a nightmare to shoot by all testimony.
Dr G 1:07:03
Of course. I mean, it looks like it was done outdoors, so I can only imagine the weather. But also, Ceasarion is much older than he’s supposed to be. Realistically, he should have only just been born, but he’s a small child. Now, don’t worry about that. He’s five or six. Now, some time has passed, and we have this grand entrance where Cleopatra is gradually, slowly approaching the Roman Senate.
Dr Rad 1:07:33
She’s getting closer, hope she doesn’t fall.
Dr G 1:07:38
Is that a sphinx you brought with you? I really enjoy this whole moment, because there, there is an element of historicity about this. We do know that she goes to Rome to negotiate an alliance, becoming one of the “allied kings and friends of Rome”, so that’s essentially why she’s there. And it’s also the case that Caesar is now in a position where he’s effectively won his Civil War, and he’s able to conduct his great triumph. And we see a lot of white horses just putting it out there.
Dr Rad 1:08:20
Hmm controversial.
Dr G 1:08:21
Is it okay? That’s a reference for listeners to our narrative side of the show.
Dr Rad 1:08:28
That’s what I was going to say, to understand why we’re flagging that, see episodes on Camillus.
Dr G 1:08:33
Yes, see the Camillus episodes for why that might be a problem. Caesar is now in this position where he’s quite powerful in Rome, he has won this civil war. Cleopatra turning up is acceptable because there needs to be an alliance negotiated. She’s now the top dog in Egypt, so she’s got to get the paperwork sorted out for that. And we also know historically that this is when Caesar is starting to spend a lot of money on building programs, which includes a statue to Cleopatra. So it’s all sort of happening in the right kind of way. It’s not strictly historically accurate.
Dr Rad 1:09:10
Yeah, historically, we know that Caesar did set up a statue of Cleopatra in the Temple of Venus Genetrix, I believe.
Dr G 1:09:19
Correct. He did, and she’s placed her statue is slightly smaller than the goddess’s statue, but they’re next to each other, cute.
Dr Rad 1:09:29
Symbolism. I think this is perhaps a good point for us to perhaps start wrapping up. I think definitely the part this part of the movie, the Caesar and Cleopatra part, is the one that intrigues me most, in terms of the way that Cleopatra’s identity is conceived. I’m going to ignore slightly Julius Caesar’s just because, as I say, I feel like the main point of this movie is to make a movie about Cleopatra. And first of all, I think it is interesting that there actually is a nod to the fact that she is a blend of things, that she is not just one thing, because historically, Cleopatra is often conceived of in terms of her race and gender first and foremost, and those aspects of her identity and gender often reflect the context in which they are made and the anxieties of the time in which the film is made. And so we often do see quite orientalized versions of Cleopatra in very early conceptions of her, even going beyond film looking at artwork and that sort of thing her race is, is definitely something that shifts with the discourse around race at the time that something is made. And I think similar things go for the way that her gender is represented. You know, is she hyper feminine? Is she hyper sexualized? All of those kinds of things. I think what is interesting about this movie is that the whilst obviously the the way that she’s dressed, the makeup, and the way that she refers to herself often does play up the typical aspects, which is the highly Egyptianized version of her playing into this idea of her as a foreigner, which I might add, Dr, G, thanks to Augustus, he was the first one to really lay up her foreignness, because it was convenient to do so when they became enemies and in the propaganda war that he ended up fighting with, Mark Antony but I’m not going to get dragged into that.
Dr G 1:11:35
Save that for the next episode.
Dr Rad 1:11:38
Yeah. So we have her talking to Caesar about herself being, as, you know, as fertile as the Nile, that she will bear him many sons and and certainly with the this idea of her being, being Egypt, you know, and we definitely see lots of references to her being particularly tied up with the cult of Isis, and the goddess Isis, which, again, I actually don’t have a major problem with, because we know that that was also the case, and Isis is a deity who has particular connections, obviously, to Aphrodite. By this point in time, Aphrodite obviously having connections to Venus. It’s all coming together with Caesar’s connections with Venus as well. So all of that kind of stuff. I actually can appreciate why they’re doing it. But there are also these references to her Greekness, to the fact that she is part of the Ptolemaic dynasty. Caesar himself, when she is berating him for being a barbarian in her eyes, which, I think, again, is really interesting to see Cleopatra actually spinning that racial narrative back on Caesar. He starts talking about her being, you know, the product of, you know, inbred, incestuous generations. And so he’s talking about her family’s practices. He’s talking about her in connection with her relatives and her ancestry, which absolutely, very important to Cleopatra. We can’t conceive of her without the Ptolemaic dynasty. She’s absolutely drawing on what previous Cleopatras, previous Arsinoes, previous Berenices, have done in the hundreds of years that the Ptolemies have been ruling over Egypt. And we do also see these references to her Greekness, the fact that she is from this Macedonian background, which is really interesting, because you don’t generally get any reference to that being made in a film whatsoever. And whilst you do also get the sensualness of Cleopatra in these representations, and you obviously the way that she interacts with Caesar, you know, the whole rug thing when he comes to visit her, bath the way that she carefully stages it. You do also get to see Cleopatra as a mother, which is generally not something that is incorporated in many versions of Cleopatra, and I think that’s because as a society, we tend to conceive of motherhood as being inherently unsexy, that once you have had a kid, that’s it, that part of your life is over. The sexy part was meant to just lead you into motherhood, and now that you’re there, that’s it. It’s all about nappies and, you know, and bedtimes, nursery stories, and you don’t get to have both, whereas Cleopatra’s motherhood in this particular instance, it’s obviously conceived of as being very political and and you definitely see only a strengthening of that bond with her and Caesar through this child, particularly because we’re explicitly told that Calpurnia is barren and that Caesar doesn’t have any children through her. So I actually think it’s really interesting, the way it comes around, and even the fact that Cleopatra is very self conscious in the way that she stages that bath scene when Caesar comes to visit her, so that she’s having just, you know, like a regular kind of little, you know, spa day or whatever. And then when she hears Caesar is coming, she’s like, let’s put on a show. Romans will have certain expectations, and I can’t disappoint them. And so she’s deliberately playing up to that idea, which, in a way, I think is kind of making fun of us a little bit in the audience, in a kind of wink wink, nudge nudge sort of way, because let’s face it, we also have ideas about what we want to see from a Cleopatra movie, and often the makeup, the hairstyles, the costumes, all of that kind of stuff is is geared to meet our expectations, even though the filmmakers might know it’s not necessarily the most accurate version, they know that they need to deliver something that the audience is going to accept as this is Egypt on screen. This is what Cleopatra on screen looks like. And so they know they have to hit those classic moments. Of these are in Cleopatra meeting with the rug, Cleopatra’s baths.
Dr G 1:15:44
Is she bathing in milk? Check.
Dr Rad 1:15:49
Yeah. And in the next film, there also be those classic moments, like Cleopatra’s barge coming in to meet Antony. There are those classic moments that have to be hit because they have become the real standout moments of Cleopatra and so, yeah, I kind of think it’s fascinating the way that this film, actually, I feel, is playing a little bit more with her gender identity than is often given credit for.
Dr G 1:16:09
Hmm, yeah, we definitely get to see her opting in to building part of the myth, if you like. I think the bath scene that you’ve mentioned is a really good one, because she has been spying on Julius Caesar, so she has overheard the sorts of things that he’s been saying about her when she’s not around, so she knows exactly what he’s expecting to see in the same way that when he in another conversation that they have slightly earlier on, I think she does mention to Caesar that she knows that he went to the tomb of Alexander the Great. This is prior to them going together. And he was like, oh. It’s in that moment where he realizes that she has a spy network, and she has ways of finding out information, and she’s across far more than he may have previously given her credit for, and it’s in that sort of exchange where you seem like, oh, maybe she is a savvy political player. Maybe I should be paying attention to this side of things. And he kind of suspects that he would be spied on, but he’s not expecting the extent to which she has the information. And I think that’s interesting as well, because it does put her in the powerful position in that relationship, like, you’re on my territory. There’s nothing that happens around here that I don’t know about.
Dr Rad 1:17:35
Absolutely. And I think that the way that they position it, I kind of can appreciate because it is natural that Caesar has sometimes more insight into certain political phenomena because he is so much older he’s been around the block many, many times. And Cleopatra is meant to be a young woman at this point in time, sure, a young woman who’s managed to survive the Ptolemaic court, so let’s not underestimate her political savvy either. She’s already seen her father lose his throne because of her sister’s actions, and then her father take it back and execute her older sister. So I’m not trying to downplay the fact that Cleopatra obviously has grown up in perhaps even a more troubled environment than Julius Caesar has, but certainly I don’t mind him being the older statesman in in this particular movie, it’s done in a way that doesn’t ick me, like it does in the Vivien Leigh version of Cleopatra and Caesar, where it is, it is disgusting, the relationship between them at times, and it’s so patronizing, whereas in this case, I think you do get a Cleopatra who is very politically savvy. I mean, like the fact that she knows when there’s, like, an attempted assassination against her, you know, she’s actually sitting around being quite casual. She notices that her taster hasn’t properly taken care of something, and she just very calmly, is like, drink it, drink it again, and the woman dies, you know, because it was an assassination attempt. She does have that savvy, and she does give Caesar, you know, she does talk back to Caesar. She’s bold, and she shows her intelligence, but there are those moments sometimes when Caesar, obviously, can also bring in some, you know, some insight into a situation. So I do kind of like the dynamic, the fact that, you know, it is tit for tat. It’s playful, but in a way that isn’t disgusting, like in the Vivien Leigh version.
Dr G 1:19:26
And we also see, particularly when they’re in Rome, there’s a scene where Julius Caesar is in council with some of the other senators, and it seems like a fairly private moment, but Cleopatra is also present, and he starts to express what he really wants, and that is to be in charge of everything. And obviously this is a little bit dramatic, and not in keeping with what we know from the historical sources, but the fact that Cleopatra is present, and the fact that towards the end of that scene, Mark Antony accuses her of being the product of this change in Julius Caesar is an interesting sort of moment, because it does lean into this idea of, can a woman sort of prompt a man in his ambitions in a particular way, which is a very stereotypical kind of seductress vision. It’s a very Lady Macbeth kind of thing. But we’ve also just witnessed Julius Caesar off his own bat say these things, and nobody has prompted him, nobody has prompted him to say those things. He’s just gotten himself worked up, and he’s revealed something about his own truth that has made everybody in that room uncomfortable. She just happened to be there. Well, I think that’s interesting as well.
Dr Rad 1:19:26
Yeah, exactly No. I completely agree. It’s like, this is what the men are seeing, but they’re not really appreciating the whole picture, because it’s easy to blame the woman, which is absolutely what happened. Cleopatra cops a lot of the blame. I think actually, she’s kind of perfectly summed up in one of Julius Caesar’s lines to her back in that scene in front of Alexander’s sarcophagus, Caesar says to her, “you have a way of mixing politics and passion, but where does one start and the other end?” I think that is kind of how Cleopatra is operating. I mean, it is often seen as a, I suppose, a bit of an unfeminist thing to say that Cleopatra might have used sex in a political way, but maybe we can also say, well, these are also used sex in a political way, in this particular sense. And the advantage of being a woman, and I’m citing Dr Kara Cooney’s work on this, the advantage of being a woman is that you can solidify your relationship through sex. And a child, obviously, you could absolutely solidify any relationship through sex, no matter the gender of the participants, but in this day and age, biologically, it’s only possible to actually fuse that together in a child if you’re a man and woman. So in a way, that is potentially an advantage that Cleopatra has in dealing with these men. And it’s really nice to see a movie that actually allows that part to be included in the story, because, I say so often the focus is just on the sect, the romance, the passion, and they forget about the motherhood that is a key part of Cleopatra’s identity, particularly because Caesarion ends up being someone that Cleopatra promotes herself, as far as we can see with, like the Temple of Dendra and that sort of thing, as a kind of co-ruler. She’s obviously setting him up to take over the dynasty in the future, I would say. But one thing I would like to quickly highlight before we completely leave, and what reminded me about the bath scene. Elizabeth Taylor’s body attracts a lot of attention and commentary, both at the time and subsequently, because Elizabeth Taylor did notoriously fluctuate a lot in her weight during the filming of Cleopatra, and that’s partly because, as we’ve said, the filming goes on a lot longer than was intended. And look, she wasn’t well. She was going through a lot, which we’ll probably get into a little bit more later on, but certainly, her fluctuating weight has attracted a lot of attention, and that has also been, I think, subsumed into this idea of the excesses of Cleopatra in a way that is obviously not enjoyable, but it is also connected to the conditions that Elizabeth Taylor herself had on this particular film, which were record breaking at the time, particularly for a woman in Hollywood. Now, it’s not unusual for studios at the time to want to promote a movie by combining a little bit of the character with their actress, you know, having them become sort of one and the same. So it’s no wonder that Elizabeth Taylor has become so connected with this particular character that she played. And this is not the first time that this had happened to her. At the time that she was involved with Eddie Fisher and getting involved in, I was gonna say breaking up the marriage, but obviously it takes many people to break up a marriage at the time that she was involved in that triangle, let’s say, and I should perhaps say, that she was friends with Debbie Reynolds, by the way, by the time she was involved in this triangle with Eddie Fisher, Debbie Reynolds, and she was recovering from the very tragic death of the love of her life, Mike Todd, who had died in a plane crash very unexpectedly. And she apparently actually sort of saw Caesar in this movie as being like Mike Todd. So, yeah, Mike Todd, being her, her Caesar, basically. She had been in a movie called Cat on a Hot Tin Roof, which is about a woman of loose morals, to put it in the time, the vocabulary of time seducing somebody else’s husband. So Elizabeth Taylor has has known this sort of treatment from Hollywood studios before, but her body the film itself, they all become sort of emblematic of the excesses of Hollywood, and that connects really well, obviously, with this idea that Cleopatra was supposed to be excessive. We have stories of her extravagance that are preserved to us, like the famous one from Pliny the Elder of her dissolving this amazing pearl in a glass of vinegar so that she can drink it and say she has drunk something insanely expensive that doesn’t seem to be possible physically. But those stories are very popular. If you look at portraiture of Cleopatra, often, pearls are a big symbol of hers, and so Elizabeth Taylor showing off her body in this particular bath scene has definitely attracted commentary because of the way that people have had no problems talking about her weight losses and gains throughout this movie, and the way that she sometimes has, you know, abundant cleavage showing, or she often has abundant cleavage showing in all of her costumes, which were tailor made for her by Irene Sharaff, one of the big designers in Hollywood. And I’m going to finish up by telling you a bit about her salary. Dr James,
Dr G 1:26:02
dr, because just a minute, I mean, her, her costumes are incredible. There are some. There are some. In particular, I’m just like, Oh, I wish I had a body that would look that good in a costume. That’s so, you know, the costume designer did an amazing job, I think. Oh, and she look,
Dr Rad 1:26:19
she look. She complained a little bit about the fact that she had to keep altering them, because Taylor’s weight did fluctuate, but she had 60 costumes. Elizabeth Taylor made it very clear that she planned to steal them all because she thought that they would. She actually could see that they were going to start a trend like the Taylor Cleopatra trend. In terms of the fashion. Apparently, Elizabeth Taylor also was allowed to sometimes do her own makeup. So some of those makeup looks might have actually been Elizabeth Taylor’s own kind of invention, which seems interesting, but she attracted a million dollar fee for this, and this was the first time that any actress had received such a salary from a studio. The way that this was broken down, it was meant to be about $125,000 a week in salary, as well as other expenses, such as $3,000 a week in living expenses. Plus her food was paid for, plus where she was staying was paid for, plus she received first class round trip airline tickets for any movie location shoots for herself, three other adults and her three children that she had at the time, she needed two Penthouse Suites at the Dorchester in London, a Rolls Royce Silver Cloud limousine at her disposal at all times. And also, as we’ve talked about, her production company was involved in the production of this film, so she was also benefiting from that, which meant that the movie had to be shot in Europe, not the USA, for tax reasons, she also made sure that the movie was going to be shot in Todd ao. Now, Todd-AO was something that she had inherited from her husband Mike Todd when he died, who had pioneered this particular widescreen technique. Now this was important because 20th Century Fox had their own widescreen technique called CinemaScope that was particularly famous, which means that she got royalties from the use of Todd-AO, and they couldn’t use CinemaScope, and it meant that the sets had to be built in a certain way, because that’s the way that widescreen works. You have to make sure that’s going to look a certain way on the screen. So she would end up making around $7 million from this particular movie. So even though she later bad mouthed it and said that she didn’t like her own performance, she certainly made a mint from it. And let’s face it, she wasn’t doing too badly when she entered she was already famous for being wealthy, for having had multiple marriages and love affairs and that sort of thing. So the fusion of her own identity with that of Cleopatra, the excesses of Hollywood and the studio system at the time, and the fact that those excesses seemingly lead to a downfall,
Dr G 1:29:06
like a little bit of life mirroring art. And you know, these things are all going together. I mean, the perfect casting for Cleopatra.
Dr Rad 1:29:15
I would think absolutely so. That perhaps seems like a good moment for us to wrap up. Dr G, as I predicted, this episode has become as bloated as the movie itself.
Dr G 1:29:28
It is time, dear listeners, for an intermission.
Dr Rad 1:29:34
We will be back to talk all about Cleopatra, 1963 and the second half of the movie with a focus on Richard Burton slash Mark Anthony, next time.
Dr G 1:29:49
Thank you for listening to this episode of the partial historians. You can find our sources sound credits and transcript in our show notes over partialhistorians.com. We offer a huge thank you to you, if you’re one of our illustrious Patreon supporters, if you enjoy the show, we’d love your support in a way that works for you. Leaving a nice review really makes our day. We are on Ko-Fi for one or ongoing donations or Patreon, of course, our latest book, Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire, is published through Ulysses Press. It is full of stories that the Romans probably don’t want you to know about them. This book is packed with some of our favorite tales of the colorful history of ancient Rome. Treat yourself or an open minded friend to Rome’s glories, embarrassments and most salacious claims. With Your Cheeky Guide To the Roman Empire.
Transcribed by https://otter.ai
The post Special Episode – Cleopatra 1963 – Cleopatra and Caesar appeared first on The Partial Historians - Ancient Roman History with smart ladies.
We’re still in the year 394 BCE and we’ve seen Camillus has had a run in with the Falsican Schoolmaster. In this episode we move on further into the action of 394 BCE and look at 393 BCE as well. Is Camillus learning how to keep a low profile? He is praised from his success over the Faliscans and he doesn’t rush for a triumph this time. But the challenge remains, that Camillus’ forgotten vow to Apollo might be about to bite him on the bottom.
Rome is pretty intent on fulfilling Camillus’ forgotten vow to Apollo and this means a boat trip is in order. But sailing to Greece is not for the faint hearted, especially when you have such precious cargo as a golden bowl in tow. Tune in for adventures on the high sea!
The Aequians, a thorn in Rome’s side? Yes indeed. Do our sources agree? Of course not. It’s Diodorus Siculus against Livy, duking it out with Siculus having just a mention of trouble, while Livy comes packing details. We take you through the chaotic details. The conflict centres in the town of Verrugo but watch out for mention of Tusculum as well.
It’s time for the Roman census! We also see a return of the consulship in 393 BCE! The tussle about moving some of Rome’s population permanently to Veii is back on the agenda. There’s a faction in favour of a move to Veii and a faction against. Our sources seem to position this as a patrician/plebeian divide, but it might be more confusing or complicated than that.
Somehow, the Aequian forces, that were absolutely devastated in 394 BCE are BACK baby but their appearance seems only a flash in the pan compared to Rome’s troubles at home. There’s tribunes of the plebs to worry about, factional infighting over what to do about Veii, and some trials to contend with as well. It’s an exhausting time to be in Roman politics! Enter scene right: Camillus… How important was the tribune of the plebs right of veto? The question is raised in Livy’s narrative.
All reelected from the previous year…
Our music is by Bettina Joy de Guzman.
Lightly edited for our wonderful Australian accents
Dr Rad 0:15
Welcome to the Partial Historians.
Dr G 0:19
We explore all the details of ancient Rome,
Dr Rad 0:23
everything from political scandals, the love affairs, the battles waged and when citizens turn against each other, I’m Dr Rad.
Dr G 0:33
And I’m Dr G, we consider Rome as the Romans saw it, by reading different authors from the ancient past and comparing their stories.
Dr Rad 0:44
Join us as we trace the journey of Rome from the founding of the city.
Dr Rad 0:58
Hello and welcome to a brand new episode of the Partial Historians. I am one of your hosts, Dr Rad
Dr G 1:06
and I am, Dr G
Dr Rad 1:09
Dr G, we are still stuck in ancient Rome in 394 BCE.
Dr G 1:15
When will we ever leave this time period? There must be other parts of history we must explore. But for now, there are too many details for us to move on. So 394 has been a pretty epic year. So far, yeah, Camillus has done some pretty fancy stuff with the Faliscans in order to get them to agree that Rome should have some sort of sway over them, but they don’t seem to have to go through a whole siege process to achieve that. But you tell me, there’s even more to this year than that incredible story.
Dr Rad 1:56
There is more than Camillus and the Faliscan schoolmaster, which sounds like a bad porno.
Dr G 2:02
I would pick up that erotic literature.
Dr Rad 2:05
Yes. Now, unfortunately, there is more to it than that. We have a little bit more on Camillus. But then I have some other people actually doing things in ancient Rome, if you can believe it.
Dr G 2:16
Other people? Doing things in ancient ROme? Oh, this is too much. We’ll have to start a podcast together.
Dr Rad 2:18
I know. Well, I mean, you know, it’s really been the Camillus show in the 390s BC, hasn’t it so far?
Dr G 2:26
So far.
Dr Rad 2:28
All right, let’s get into the rest of 394 BCE
Dr G 4:34
All right. I am very excited to hear where this is going. And despite what I said in the previous episode about having nothing left to say about this year, I believe I do have something more to say that’s very exciting for me.
Dr Rad 4:51
It is. And I mean, I’m, I think we’re kicking it off with a really good story. So strap yourself in. Dr, G, so as we know, because. Camillus is just the most awesome human being on Earth. He’s resolved that whole situation with the Philistines, which means that he’s allowed to come back to Rome, and there is no techie triumph for him this time. Dr G, he’s keeping it a little bit more under wraps.
Dr G 5:20
All right, all right. Keep a low profile, accept the praise, but don’t go all out with the horses,
Dr Rad 5:26
Yeah, he’s just getting on with his life. He just wants to live, Dr G, why can’t people just let him live? I’ll tell you why, because of that vow he made.
Dr G 5:38
That pesky vow.
Dr Rad 5:39
Yep.
Dr G 5:39
Yeah, look, don’t ever forget the gods. And also don’t put people in a situation where they now owe money when they didn’t have to before it’s rude.
Dr Rad 5:49
Look, it is. But as we know, the money side of it has kind of been resolved by this point in time. Remember those darling little Roman matrons giving over their gold jewelry and their ornaments. They’ve got the gold they’ve got a bowl. They know that they want to give it to Apollo, but it hasn’t happened yet. And the senators are worried because Camillus therefore hasn’t resolved this whole vow situation. So they are going to send that bowl to Apollo at Delphi. And this is where our special legates that we talked about our ambassadors in the previous episode when we were listing those magistrates. So Lucius Valerius, Lucius Sergius and Aulus Manlius. Now they all are sent with this golden bowl and present in a single warship. And just when you think that things are going to be resolved for Camillus, they’re captured by none other than pirates. Ahhahaha matey!
Dr G 6:50
Oh, no, yeah, it’s a real disaster. Okay, yeah, Plutarch does go into a little bit of detail about this. So to take a golden bowl to Delphi, you do have to sail around the whole shoe of Italy to head around to the other side to get to Greece. Well, I hate to break it to you, but there are lots of islands in the Mediterranean and lots of seafaring peoples, and they love nothing more than picking off a lone vessel heading on its way with a golden bowl to Delphi.
Dr Rad 7:27
Yes.
Dr G 7:27
So this is happening very close to Rome, realistically compared to the length of the journey proposed. It is off the Aeolian isles, which are just north of Sicily.
Dr Rad 7:42
That is what I am told as well. I’m told that these are pirates from Lipara. So I guess, given the you know, given the area that they’re from, maybe they should be more like Mamma Mia. Will you please give me the golden bowl?
Dr G 7:58
Maybe. But they’re very likely to be Greeks. And they’re like, I see your golden bowl –
Dr Rad 8:04
Opa Opa! Don’t smash that. That’s made of gold. Can I throw some more stereotypes in here?
Dr G 8:10
And you’re heading to Delphi, you say, well, how convenient. They’re our people, we’ll be taking that bowl. Don’t you worry about it. We’ll get it there for you.
Dr Rad 8:17
Yeah. Now, Dr, G, there’s something about 394 BCE, there is a worrying disease which the Romans don’t usually suffer from circulating, which is morality. I think morality became contagious in 394 because not only do we have Camillus acting so nobly in the first half of 394, but they seem to bump into pirates with a heart of gold as well as their gold bowl.
Dr G 8:49
Yes. Kindly pirates, yes. Well, yes, it’s very Guybrush Threepwood for people in the know. These pirates – Dr Rad is shaking her head –
Dr Rad 9:02
I’m not in the know
Dr G 9:03
Other nerds from the 90s, join me in this moment, the Liparian pirates notice that there is something ritualistic and religious to this whole ship, and once they are close enough to listen to the people on the other vessel. They realize that prayers and supplications are involved, and they’re carrying very precious cargo for Apollo and nobody, not even Liparian pirates, want Apollo to be dissatisfied, because they’d be taking on the risk themselves. If they took the bowl, they could be seen by Apollo as interfering in the whole process. So they decide to not run the vessel down and not capture it.
Dr Rad 9:53
That is so different to the version of the story that I have. Do you want to hear mine?
Dr G 9:58
Oh, yes, please, because there are. Are other details I just haven’t gotten to them yet.
Dr Rad 10:01
Okay, all right, in my version, the pirates actually do capture them and the booty. And normally they would go home and just split it up amongst themselves, but they have a chief magistrate called Timasitheüs Timasitheüs Timasitheüs – look it sounds Greek, who apparently was much more like a Roman than he was anything else, okay, including these other pirates he’s associating with. And he respects the aim of the mission. He respects the envoys. He respects the gods. And his attitude is so ethical that it impresses the people around him very much as well. And he starts treating the Roman captured envoys like guests of state. He then gives them ships so they can continue their mission to Delphi and he also allows them to take those same ships back to Rome again. So impressed are the Romans with this treatment that they enter into a covenant of hospitality with timascius, and there are gifts given to him by Rome which say on the gift card. Thank you so much for not wrecking our lives and the life of Camillus, our main man.
Dr G 11:26
A beautifully told rendition of the tale. Now, some of this, some of this detail, is conveyed by Plutarch as well. So despite not running the vessel down, they do tow it to shore and have a good look at it. Okay? So they look at all of the items, particularly this beautiful golden bowl, and they are thinking about maybe they will take the goods. And this is when Timasitheüs intervenes as the general of the Liparians, and persuades his crew to let everybody go, and then provides additional vessels so that there is a convoy, essentially, so they’re not just a lone ship, desperate times Romans
Dr Rad 12:17
Ripe for pirates, yeah,
Dr G 12:18
yeah. Don’t just be like, stick to a herd. Like, yeah, where are your friends?
Dr Rad 12:23
What were the Romans thinking? I mean, why would you send this precious golden bowl out by itself in the world?
Dr G 12:29
Okay? But let’s for one moment. Let’s let us pause, because I think this might be the first time the Romans have ever sent a ship anywhere that we know about.
Dr Rad 12:38
No, they said those guys should go and check out the laws of the Greeks.
Dr G 12:42
Yeah, and there’s the grain supply situation, but that’s just up and down the coast. But like, how many ships are they ever sending anywhere? We don’t really, don’t really get a sense that they are great seafaring people at this point.
Dr Rad 12:54
No, surely they’ve used a ship or two in their time.
Dr G 12:58
Well we’ve got this one boat, that’s the one we use for everything. So I don’t think we get the sense that the Romans aren’t sea savvy. I mean, who sends one boat?
Dr Rad 13:11
That’s true, and they are more land expansionists at this point in time.
Dr G 13:16
Yeah. How long have they controlled Ostia? So yeah, I’m not entirely convinced that they’re a great naval power at this point. So, but perhaps this is also about generating this idea of we’ve got friends further afield. The Liparians, look at that, making friends at the same time that we’re making enemies elsewhere.
Dr Rad 13:41
Well, this is an interesting thing, because this is actually a formal agreement that they’re entering into with these people. And the idea of having these sorts of arrangements, obviously, is that it is scary to go out into the wider world. If you know, no matter where you’re from, whether you’re from Rome or elsewhere, you kind of do need to have, obviously, places where you can feel safe and be assured of receiving hospitality, and that’s really what they’re talking about with this sort of agreement here, because otherwise, yeah, you are a bit vulnerable. And where do you go when you need to make a pit stop or sleep somewhere for the night. It’s it’s a bit risky, isn’t it?
Dr G 14:24
Definitely, and this is tapping into very particular Greek ideas about hospitality and the idea that strangers can possibly be gods in disguise. And because you cannot be sure about the nature of a stranger, it behooves you to treat them well and to treat them perhaps better than you would treat just a regular stranger of your own town, treating them with the greatest hospitality that you can provide in order to ensure their protection and your own and that idea of a reciprocity developing between peoples over time is. Certainly something that has bounded the Greek world together since at least the Homeric epics. So to see this idea start to permeate into the Roman world, perhaps we shouldn’t be so surprised to see it. And I wonder if it is the leperians that suggest this hospitality element, or whether it comes from the Roman side.
Dr Rad 15:21
It’s hard to say. I feel like the Romans are won over. And the interesting thing about this story is that when the Romans eventually annex Lipara, where these people are from, which doesn’t happen until 252 they apparently respect the rights of the descendants of this Timasitheüs. So there is obviously some sort of historicity for this interaction for them.
Dr G 15:49
Well, this golden bowl is going on quite a journey.
Dr Rad 15:52
Isn’t it? I know, I know it’s crazy. So anyway, at least now the golden bowl’s delivered. Apollo can be happy he has something to eat his spaghetti in. Not spaghetti, I don’t know what vine leaf rolls
Dr G 15:52
Eating his dolmades, delicious.
Dr Rad 15:52
Olives something – taramosalata, yum. Okay, now let’s switch to what else is going on in Rome, as you alluded to in our last episode. Dr G, there is also war happening with the Aequians.
Dr G 16:24
Oh, yes, I’m excited for the details about this. All I have is this single line from Diodorus Siculus, like war was also waged with the Aequians. I was like, wow, okay.
Dr Rad 16:34
Well, let me tell you. Dr G as is often typical of this year, it’s very up and down. No one really knew in the city, or even those actually involved in the warfare who was winning while it was happening, the guys who were in charge of it, military tribunes, Gaius Aemilius and Spurius Postumius.
Dr G 16:53
Okay,
Dr Rad 16:54
Yes. Now they start off commanding the army together. Once they have managed to defeat the Aequians. They sent Aemilius to Verrugo with a garrison of soldiers, whilst Postumius was put in charge of destruction, yeah, rock and roll, to really take these people down, because the Aequians continue to be a thorn in Rome side?
Dr G 17:22
Okay, well, sure. I mean, I can see how the Aequians might continue to be a thorn in Rome side. That makes a lot of sense. It doesn’t necessarily gel very well with the other detail that Diodorus Siculus offers, not that he should necessarily be considered correct.
Dr Rad 17:41
I was gonna say, Are you seriously saying Diodorus should be trusted over Livy? Livy?
Dr G 17:50
I’m not saying that. I’m just saying for the benefit of pursuing our source material in these different directions, because the other thing that Diodorus talks about is that the colony that is sent to Sutrium, just north west of Rome, was expelled by people from the city of Verrugo, and that sounds like the city of Verrugo and its people might be being stretched in a couple of different directions if they’re also facing hostilities from the Romans as well.
Dr Rad 18:20
You will see where this all fits in in just a moment. Dr, G, you’ve got your little impatient pants on there.
Dr G 18:28
Oh no. Let me hold my four white horses.
Dr Rad 18:31
Postumius is feeling a little cocky, because it seems like they’ve got this whole affair wrapped up. Feels like Rome is going to conquer the Aequians once again, and so as he is journeying along his way, he doesn’t make sure that his soldiers are traveling in the proper formation.
Dr G 18:49
Oh, okay, that could be a disaster. That’s about efficiency!
Dr Rad 18:54
Could be? Is, Dr G, is indeed the Aequians cleverly managed to ambush him and his men. The Romans, of course, are not prepared for this, because they’re not in formation. Get in formation. What? How many times do you hear that in a military movie and they’re thrown into a complete state of disarray? They run into the nearby hills, and it seems like chaos is now the thing that is catching not morality. It spreads to virugo and the other Roman forces who were stationed there spreading like wildfire throughout the Roman troops.
Dr G 19:29
Wait a minute, how does, how does the chaos get to Verrugo?
Dr Rad 19:34
Because it’s chaos, Dr G, need I say more.
Dr G 19:38
I really want a map so I knew where all of these people were in relative distance to each other, because this sounds a little unbelievable, Livy.
Dr Rad 19:47
Look, we don’t really get told exactly where Postumius is when all this is happening. We only know that they were together, these two Roman commanders, and now they are separating. But how far apart they. Actually got before this happened, before the gay bodies? Yes, exactly. So Postumius starts to gather his men into a position where they’re going to be safe, and gives them a severe ticking off for panicking and running away. He’s like, didn’t you learn anything from the Faliscians earlier this year? Honestly, especially against the Aequians, they are not worth your panic. The army altogether, like a little chorus admit that they deserved that ticking off. They had really stuffed up and they were going to fix it. You just watch them. Dr G, take them to the Aequian leader, and you will see.
Dr G 20:38
Wow. Okay, so they get themselves into formation. They pull themselves up by their bootstraps. They’re like, I’m ready now.
Dr Rad 20:44
Yep, they say the army collectively that they would happily submit to any punishment if they had not been able to capture the aequian camp by that very evening. Stop questioning the details. Lean into it. Lean into my narrative.
Dr G 21:04
I have some questions.
Dr Rad 21:06
Postumius is very happy to hear this, and says, All right, I think you’ve got the right mindset. So go and grab a burger, and then we’re going to be ready to go. Got it now, the Aequians had stationed themselves in a way where they were trying to cut off any possible retreat from Verrugo. They’re trying to be strategic here, the two armies clash. The battle starts during the day, but because there is enough moonlight, there must be a relatively full moon, the battle continues into the night. In fact, Livy says they could see just as well as during the day.
Dr G 21:51
Okay? Well, if that’s not a sign of impending pestilence I don’t know what is.
Dr Rad 21:56
Now. Shouts were heard in Verrugo by the other army stationed there. The Romans in the other army thought that their camp was being attacked, and they were incredibly alarmed. Aemilius, their commander, tries to calm them down, and then they flee in a chaotic way to Tusculum.
Dr G 22:15
Oh, really?
Dr Rad 22:18
Yeah, there’s a lot of chaotic fleeing happening in 394, BC, on every side.
Dr G 22:28
By moonlight?
Dr Rad 22:29
Yeah
Dr G 22:29
Quick, flee up that hill.
Dr Rad 22:32
Rumour now makes it to Rome that Postumius and his army have been annihilated because I guess the people who escaped from Verrugo have just heard sounds. Now, Postumius, once day has dawned, and there’s no real fear of any more ambushes from the Aequians, he rides out amongst his troops, reminding them of their vow, and gets the Romans all psyched up by doing this. You know, they’re like, Yeah, we did make a promise. The Aequians therefore did not stand a chance against the Romans at their full psychological powers. They were killed as they ran away from a wave of Roman fury. Apparently, this is what always happens when the Romans fight more with their anger than their valor, according to Livy, oh, really, okay, the aequian army is completely wiped out. Dr, G, I know I’ve said that about 50 times during this podcast, but I mean it this time.
Dr G 23:36
Do you?
Dr Rad 23:37
I really do
Dr G 23:38
All right, so the Aequians really cop it. The Romans are too fierce to be resisted, and the chaos has now become contagious in the opposite direction, has been caught by the enemy.
Dr Rad 23:53
It has but luckily, as the Romans back home are all in despair, Postumius gets to ride on into town with the best news ever that they were mistaken, that nothing bad was happening. It was just a battle. It was just a battle that was overheard, and the Romans have won. And so he gets to parade around and his little laurel wreath being like, hey, look me up.
Dr G 24:16
Fancy pants, all right.
Dr Rad 24:19
And that is all I have for 394, BCE.
Dr G 24:25
Well, that is a great story, and I’m glad you told it to me, because I really was like the Aequians just sort of came out of nowhere in my source material, and then they were gone in a flash. But it sounds like, with more detail, that that’s also what happens to them in Livy.
Dr Rad 24:42
It is really. There is more detail, but it’s a lot of confusing detail, because you don’t exactly know where everybody is in this story, apart from the people in Verrugo, it is a bit unclear exactly what is going on, apart from a reference to some hills that they run into. That’s about as specific as I can be, but certainly it seems like an excuse for the Romans to smack down the Aequians.
Dr G 25:10
Wow. So they’re doing well. This year. They’ve fought two wars on two fronts, and it’s a two from two in terms of victory. Wow.
Dr Rad 25:20
Should we venture into 393?
Dr G 25:44
I think we should
Dr Rad 25:59
Okay.
Dr Rad 26:00
Well, 393, then Dr G tell me who are our magistrates.
Dr G 26:05
Oh, look, this is very exciting. We have consuls now. It was so long ago since we had consoles that I went to check the last time Rome had consuls instead of military tribunes. So consular power was 409 BCE, so it’s been a while, over 16 years ago. So I don’t sure if any Romans, uh, remember what it’s like to be a consul, but here we are. We have Lucius Valerius Potitus. Now he was one of the guys that was listed as a legate-ambassador the previous year.
Dr Rad 26:42
True.
Dr G 26:43
So traveling on the vessel with the golden bowl. And he has been military tribune so many times. And he is joined by somebody who were not sure exactly of the praenomen, could be Publius, it could be Servilius, Cornelius Malugunensis.
Dr Rad 27:04
My least favourite name.
Dr G 27:07
Such a tongue twister. And he was previously military tribune in 397, so we’ve got a guy, Potitus, with a lot of experience, and we’ve got a Cornelii with a little bit of experience in the role. He’s been around a lot, yeah. And to offer some immediate spoilers to this, we also have suffect consuls for this year.
Dr Rad 27:31
Controversial, yes,
Dr G 27:33
Yes, it is early in the piece for there to be suffect consuls, so early that it means that something has gone terribly wrong with the consuls.
Dr Rad 27:44
Yeah. So suffect consuls basically come in when the original consuls, for some reason, cannot fulfill the terms of their magistracy.
Dr G 27:51
Exactly. And people might be more familiar with how the suffect consul works in the imperial period, where people just step away from the role and other people come to fill it in, that’s not what’s going on here. There has to be a really good reason for the consuls to not serve the whole year. So I’m guessing we’re about to find out why that might be but, but we have suffect consuls. We’ve got Lucius Lucretius, Tri cip pin itnus, –
Dr Rad 28:21
Tricipitinus.
Dr G 28:22
Oh. Tricipitinus, oh, I’m glad you’re here to help me. Lucius Lucretius Tricipitinus Flavus, this is his first time in the role, so a new kid on the block, but I suppose everybody has to have their first time, don’t they, and it won’t be his last.
Dr Rad 28:39
No.
Dr G 28:40
And Servilius Sulpicius Camerinus also first time in the role. So that’s that deal. And then we also have censors listed for this year. So I kind of foreshadowed that-
Dr Rad 28:55
It’s been a while since a good census.
Dr G 28:58
Yeah, I foreshadowed that in the previous episode that there’s definitely a censorship on the horizon. So Lucius Papirius Cursor is one of the censors, as is Gaius Julius Vopisci Illus. Notably, everybody mentioned so far is a patrician, and there is also a suffect censor. I know,
Dr Rad 29:25
Whaaaat?
Dr G 29:27
It is bad news all around for people, I think. Marcus Cornelius Maluginensis.
Dr Rad 29:35
Again?
Dr G 29:35
I know, I mean they keep popping up, don’t they? Is the suffect censor and there will be a reason for this as well, as we’re about to find out, Dr Rad.
Dr Rad 29:49
And then, isn’t there also a tribune of the plebs?
Dr G 29:53
If there is, I don’t have it listed.
Dr Rad 29:55
The tribune of the plebs, we also should mention, once again, we’re going to be talking about Titus. Sicinius in this year.
Dr G 30:02
Are we? Oh, see, I have him down for the next year, pretty sure. But, uh, well, I guess we’ll see.
Dr Rad 30:08
You will see, indeed. So in 393 Dr G, we are back thinking about this idea of resettlement. So the tribunes of the plebs had initially proposed back in 395 that some of the Roman population moved to Veii. They’ve been, apparently trying to push it ever since. The patricians are very much over my dead body about this whole situation. But we’re returning to this issue now. The plebeians have been trying to keep the people who are for the move today in office, as we know. That’s why Sicinius keeps coming up, because he was the guy with the original idea. The patricians want to make sure there are also going to be people who are against this move. The plebs, however, managed to get more of their preferred candidates into office, so more people who are going to be pro than against it. So once again, it seems that we’re seeing that there is a bit of a divide amongst the tribunes of the plebs, where there are some amongst their number who are amenable to patrician wheelings and dealings and willing to use their veto power for what the patricians are pushing for, whether it’s because they also agree, because, as we talked about, this whole patrician plebeian divide, it’s not as hard and fast as it sometimes seems. They might have class interests in common or political interests in common? Who knows, but we have seen this as a tactic that the patricians use for.
Dr G 31:50
Alright, so things, we’re getting to this kind of sticky point where maybe we’re going to see some movement on this issue in favor of the plebeians.
Dr Rad 32:00
We’re definitely going to see some movement on this issue. Now, this is why we have consuls this year, because the patricians decide that they’re going to get their revenge, because they’re very concerned about the types of characters that have managed to get into the office of tribune of the plebs. So they’re like, You know what? Forget it. No more. Mr. Nice guys. We’re not going to have military tribunes. We’re going to have consuls, God damn it. And there’s nothing that the plebeians hate more than consuls. We haven’t had them for ages out of respect, but since you are being so callous with our feelings, we’re just going to go ahead and do it so we can try and book you that way.
Dr G 32:37
Wow. Okay, so I mean, it doesn’t take much for the patricians to be upset with the tribune of the plebs. I would say that anytime we see tribune of the plebs mentioned, they’re not happy campers.
Dr Rad 32:48
No, basically if they open their mouth the patricians are usually upset.
Dr G 32:51
It does seem like a bit of a power move to put some consuls in. Does it work?
Dr Rad 32:59
Well, we definitely have, apparently, a suite of tribunes of the plebs who are very in favour of this motion to move some of the Romans today, the consuls had been elected specifically because they were the kind of men that the patricians knew would launch a vicious counter attack against any such move. And so every single person in Rome is caught up in this gigantic patrician versus plebeian smackdown. Unfortunately, right at this moment, a place called Vitelia, a Roman colony, is captured by the Aequians. Apparently, this was a colony that was set up within Aequian territory. So it makes sense that the Aequians wanted it back.
Dr G 33:47
Okay, I’m not really sure what to make of this. I mean, it makes sense for the Aequians to make a military move at this point in time. They’ve just suffered some defeats at the hands of the Romans. They’re probably not happy about that. So making some moves while the Romans seem to be preoccupied with their politics at home, seems like a good plan for them.
Dr Rad 34:10
My question is, Dr G, I just said to you that the Aequian army had been wiped from the face of the earth. How were they retaking this colony?
Dr G 34:17
I guess it’s the women and children doing all that.
Dr Rad 34:22
Now, luckily, the Aequians decide because they are treacherous bastards that they were going to attack at night time. However, this ended up playing out to the advantage of a lot of the colonists, because they managed to all head in a particular direction, which was pretty much clear of any Aequians. So most of them are not slaughtered in the streets or in their beds, but they actually manage to make their way back to Rome and Lucius, Lucretius, one of the consuls, is put in charge of dealing with this. He manages to defeat the Aequians, who just seem to be a massive pushover at this point in time and returned to Rome in glory, but he couldn’t enjoy it because there was something very disturbing awaiting him in his hometown. I try.
Dr G 35:16
Goodness me, this is kept becoming outrageous.
Dr Rad 35:19
Yeah
Dr G 35:20
A trial?
Dr Rad 35:21
A trial. It is the trial of two of the plebeian tribunes mentioned from earlier on. You might remember that when we first met Titus Sicinius, we also heard mention of tribunes of the plebs called Aulus Verginius and Quintus Pomponius. Now you might be been thinking to yourself, why am I listing these guys if they don’t do anything? Because this Dr G, because what happens after they serve? I see so they’re not serving in this year, they are not. What seems to have happened is these guys are apparently the colluders. They’re the ones that have been won over by the patrician faction and had been persuaded to use their veto powers to kill the bill about they earlier on, or at least to argue against it very strenuously. So the Senate being mostly patrician, we think, although we know that that’s not always the case, but they come together and agree that they need to defend these men because they were representing patrician interests. They were not accused of not having done their jobs, but the problem was that they had taken this stand against the proposed move to they so that’s why the patricians feel like they have to come to their defense. Now, the plebeians, of course, hate them with the passion of 1000 suns.
Dr G 36:50
Yeah. I mean, they’re getting in the way they’re supposed to be looking after the plebeians, but they’re doing anything, but
Dr Rad 36:55
Exactly now, because the plebeians are so passionate in their hatreds, these guys end up being found guilty in their trial, and they are each ordered to pay a fine of 10,000 mighty fine asses.
Dr G 37:13
Wow. Okay, so even with the patrician support, they’re not able to pull off exoneration.
Dr Rad 37:21
Well, see, here’s the thing. Dr G, it seems like the patricians had said that they should defend these guys, but how good was that defense? Really? I have no details here. Livy personally says that this verdict is ‘shameful’, and I’m quoting from my translation there, so he’s definitely on the side of the patricians here, and this is where Camillus comes back into our narrative. Camillus is particularly vocal saying, how could the plebs turn on their own tribunes like this? Especially because there’s a very worrisome implication, which they seem to have overlooked. But Camillus being the sharp little cookie that he is, rule follower as we know him to be, strict man always, he sees it. The implications is that the plebeians had actually kind of gone against some of the powers of the office of the tribune of the plebs, because by holding these guys as guilty of doing something, they’ve basically said that they’re not allowed to use their veto, because that’s all these guys did. They’re just like, nope, we’re not in favour of it. We veto this whole idea of moving today and by then attacking them, going after them, putting them on trial and finding them guilty. Camilla thinks that they have essentially taken away what has been a cornerstone of the power of this office all this time. He thinks that the plebeians would now find that the patricians would not put up with the cheek of the tribunes of the plebs, because why would they when they don’t have to? And Camillus also ticks off the consuls saying that they had not done anywhere near enough to shield waginius and Pomponius, who had got into this whole thing because of the patricians in the first place.
Dr G 39:19
Well, there are so many things that need to be said in response to this debacle.
Dr Rad 39:23
I know.
Dr G 39:26
Goodness me. Okay, first things first, when does the tribunate get its veto? We don’t know.
Dr Rad 39:34
We don’t know.
Dr G 39:34
We don’t we don’t think it’s this early, though. We don’t have reliable evidence for a while yet. So that’s our problem number one. Problem number two is Camillus entering the fray here to offer his moral perspective, because he’s been positioned as moral guy, so now he gets to stand up and do moral stuff all the time.
Dr Rad 39:58
Yes, yeah.
Dr G 39:59
And this. This feels like a very convenient twist in the narrative. Certainly, I think we can say for sure that if it is the case that these tribunes were working in collusion with the Senate in order to bring about a particular result that involved them not voting in favour of something that it would be appropriate for the Senate to look after them in the trial. The fact that they are fined anyway suggests that nobody looked after them very well, yeah, at the very least. So it was not worth it. So then, what is the lesson that we learn here? Never trust the Senate. Don’t. Like they’re they’re not going to be, they’re not going to have your back.
Dr Rad 40:46
Seriously, have you not learned to not trust the patricians already?
Dr G 40:53
They do not have your back, and they will not look after you, even when you vote in their favour. So if anything, I think this should be an exciting moment for the tribune of the plebs to realise how free they are in order to just pursue a really progressive agenda. And that is what I would advise them if I was Camillus in ancient Rome.
Dr Rad 41:19
Well, Dr G, it will not shock you to learn that there are many historians who would agree with you that this seems like a really weird occurrence, and we have no way of knowing, obviously, what actually happened and what this really represents. However, let’s unpack a couple of things here. So first of all, if this were true, this would be the only time in which a plebeian tribune is actually called into a trial because of their just like normal conduct during their terms of office. So that’s strange. That doesn’t usually happen. We’ve seen it happen with consuls and stuff before, but it does not usually happen with tribunes of the plebs. It also is a little bit similar to some previous cases that we have talked about, from 423, and 401, when we’re talking about consular tribunes who were prosecuted and find similar amounts, yes, so it’s possible that those sorts of details are maybe being borrowed here.
Dr G 42:22
Yeah, the 10,000 asses is a familiar trope for a fine, but maybe that’s what fines are. Maybe that’s the going rate.
Dr Rad 42:29
We don’t even believe that there are fines being issued at this point in time.
Dr G 42:33
Do they even have money? We’re still not sure exactly.
Dr Rad 42:36
Exactly. So a lot of these details are red flag.
Dr G 42:39
Where are they getting the asses from? Nobody knows.
Dr Rad 42:42
From my pants that’s where.
Dr G 42:43
They’re certainly not minting them.
Dr Rad 42:46
Can’t stop myself. All right. So the other thing is, if this Verginius is from the same family as a previous plebeian tribune from 461, this is a real break in family characteristics, because, to cast our minds all the way back to there, there was Verginius, who served as a tribune of the plebs in that era, and he ended up being responsible for the prosecution of Kaeso Quinctius, the son of Cincinnatus, who was that uber patrician douchebag who got sent into exile.
Dr G 43:20
Okay, I mean, we’re getting deep into the lore here, of like, what is happening at a gens level in terms of political priorities, because that’s the kind of patterns that the Romans really like. And if he’s not conforming to type, something’s up here.
Dr Rad 43:38
Yes. Now, as you know, in the past 10 or so years, there have definitely been some questions raised about, do we actually have accurate lists of all the magistrates for all the years? And the answer usually is, no, we do not.
Dr G 43:56
Do we have lists? We do. We have lists.
Dr Rad 43:59
We have lists.
Dr G 44:00
Do we trust them? To a certain extent.
Dr Rad 44:04
Yeah. Now what is possible is that there is a basic record of some sort of trial involving men with the name Verginius and Pomponius, and because our later writers don’t have records for magistracies like military tribunes or consuls with these names, they’ve thought, Oh, well, these guys must be plebeian tribunes, and they’ve constructed the narrative that way. However, it is possible that they actually served in some other sort of capacity, like maybe as a military tribune, and that’s what this trial is about, because that would be in keeping with what we have seen previously.
Dr G 44:49
I like this theory. It makes a reasonable amount of sense, and certainly we get this mention of these tribune of the plebs just a couple of times. And. And we don’t really know much more than than what is in Livy. So I’m curious about where he got the material from, because certainly it doesn’t come up in it, in the sources that I have access to.
Dr Rad 45:13
Now, to get back to my narrative, Dr G, Camillus, pontificating and constant irritating speechifying really irritates the plebs more and more every day, they are starting to dislike him. They are turning on him once again. Doesn’t help matters that Camillus is also egging the Senate on relentlessly to take a stand against this proposed motion. He doesn’t like this idea of anyone moving to vein this way. He’s like, You know what? Guys we’ve got to represent, we’ve got to take a strong stance. That means you need to be in the forum every day, every day, so that you are there and ready when the vote finally happens. Because if you stay ready, then you don’t have to get ready.
Dr G 45:59
Wow. It’s a bit like the lesson about walking in formation, isn’t it? You know, just it is, if you’re organized, it’s not ever going to be a problem.
Dr Rad 46:09
Boy Scouts all the way. Now he says you have to take a stand, because this whole motion is a strike against Roman gods, the Roman city, their very origins, which is really what the patricians said from the get go, but now it’s in Camillus mouth, after all, if Camillus were just thinking about himself, I mean, it would be good for they to be occupied. It would be a constant testament to his glory. If he was just concerned about himself, Dr G, he could be reminded of his awesomeness every day by gazing upon the representation of they that apparently would have been included in his triumph, if this were a triumph held many, many years later when that kind of thing happened and Livy’s getting confused, back on track, but it was sacrilege for Camillus to even think about that anachronistic detail. They after all, not only was it a conquered town, not only was it a loser, it had been deserted by its own gods. How could the Romans even consider leaving their own city for a place like that?
Dr G 47:20
I mean, it is the classic sort of rich person way of thinking, isn’t it, where you’re able to value things beyond the material world and your material situation, and to assume that those things are more valuable than people’s rights to have a life. Because it’s like, what people,
Dr Rad 47:41
What? What?
Dr G 47:42
What the plebeians
Dr Rad 47:43
Quality of life for all? I’m sorry I can’t make sense of the words coming out of your mouth right now.
Dr G 47:49
I know it’s outrageous, but the way that the plebeians are pushing for this is partly because they felt land strapped for a while. The whole last century has been an argument about releasing public land so it can be used once more by the public. So the idea that we’re now in a situation where some land has become available, like they went and conquered a whole other town.
Dr Rad 48:16
Why else would they be conquering this stuff, if not to use it?
Dr G 48:18
No, we’re just gonna let it sit there like a ruinous monument to Camillus’ glory. And it’s like,
Dr Rad 48:25
You see that? I conquered that.
Dr G 48:28
Yeah, that pile of rocks over there that was me.
Dr Rad 48:31
See that tunnel? That’s how I entered it.
Dr G 48:33
No!
Dr Rad 48:34
That’s what she said.
Dr G 48:35
Everybody just wants to have their own little farm and to do what they want, and now there’s this opportunity to have it more evenly distributed amongst the Roman population, and the rich guys are prancing around being like, under no circumstances will we ever allow this to happen, not in our backyard.
Dr Rad 48:56
Well, I don’t even know what it is they’re planning with it. I mean, is this because the patricians were sinisterly planning to make they their own. Like, what were they planning? There’s no counter to it, apart from the fact that this would be a grave dishonour to their own city. But, like, what else we gonna do with it? Guys?
Dr G 49:15
Yeah,
Dr Rad 49:15
Just leave it sitting there?
Dr G 49:16
This is like the classic. We assassinated Caesar, and now we’re not really sure what happens next?
Dr Rad 49:21
I actually, I really do think that the patricians must have been planning to take this over themselves, and they just irritated that the plebs want it anyway. Nonetheless, the leading senators, other rich dudes, so moved by Camillus speeches that they all come together, young, old. Doesn’t matter, Dr G, they unite. And so when the law comes forward, they are all ready in the forum, and they spread out amongst the tribes, because it’s the tribes who are going to be voting for this. And as we know, they vote tribe by tribe, like as a group, and say whether. They’re for or against this particular law now, they take a slightly unusual tactic for rich, powerful dudes. Rather than threatening, murdering, beating other people in their tribes, they actually try and talk them into it. They try and persuade them with their words, Dr G, and they even resort to tears and begging in their effort to convince them – don’t leave Rome. We’ve all fought so hard for it for generations. Look around you because we’re in the forum – look at all the temples, and they basically guilt trip the other people in their tribes. They’re like, guys, we belong here. This stuff, these gods, we all belong here. Don’t take this stuff to Veii. It will be like they actually conquered Rome rather than the other way around. You’re getting it all mixed up. It’s all backwards. This is not the natural order of things now, because the patricians did not resort to violence, as they so often have in the past, but begged and importantly, brought in the gods. The vote was defeated. However, it was close. Dr, G, apparently only one more tribe voted against it than for it.
Dr G 51:34
Interesting. This is definitely not the direction my sources take on this.
Dr Rad 51:40
Okay. Well, I’ve only got a little bit more detail here that I might quickly relate. Just to round this off, the senators are so chuffed, so elated by the fact that this law has been defeated. The consuls, the very next day, put forward a decree that is passed in the Senate that seven iugera of land from Veii should be given to every pleb, you know, basically to every freeborn man. And this would hopefully entice them, and this is a really left field detail to have children, because I guess they know that there’s something out there waiting for them, that they actually have the means to support them. But it’s just interesting that they throw the kids detail in there. Because I was like, are we talking about like a failing population here? And this is certainly what some of the later academics have interpreted. They’re like, is there some sort of manpower crisis going on here. Are we trying to create new family units or something to take over these parcels of land that are being passed out because to compare seven iugera is a lot more than what has previously been handed out. So for example, when the whole Labici situation was being sorted out, they were only given two iugera, so this is a lot more, and it also seems to be kind of what they wanted in the first place, which was some of the land of Veii.
Dr G 53:19
Well, this is the thing. And so, yeah, to jump in with a little bit of detail from Diodorus Siculus, he just goes into this description of the Romans portioning out allotments of the territory of they sure each holder is given four plethora, which is a Greek unit of measurement. And I assume, let’s assume, for the sake of convenience, that that’s about equivalent to seven Roman iugera
Dr Rad 53:49
Sure
Dr G 53:49
But they’re given a reasonable chunk of land, and the idea that there might be a suggestion of please make some babies, may be partly connected with the idea that if you have the land and you’re able to farm and you’re able to subsist, you will be able to also then engage in child rearing and production, because you have a sense that you’re able to survive and to create enough to do that.
Dr Rad 54:16
Sure.
Dr G 54:16
So that might be what’s happening there, but it does sound very much like the plebeians are getting what it is that they asked for. Because in order to farm the land of Veii, you would obviously have to go there to do it.
Dr Rad 54:31
Yeah.
Dr G 54:32
It doesn’t farm itself. It doesn’t sit there idly, and then you pop up, and it’s like some sort of remarkable paradise where it’s all produced itself. If you don’t go and work it, it’s not going to do anything. So does this mean that the vote was defeated by one tribe, or does it mean that Livy’s really clutching at straws to try and make the patrician perspective the dominant perspective? And to not have them have this loss partly, maybe in light of the things that happened later in the republic that he’s aware of, and he wants to position this in a really particular way, I do wonder.
Dr Rad 55:13
Oh, there’s definitely a lot of late Republican undertones to everything going on here.
Dr G 55:20
I suspect so. I suspect so. And having said that, the other thing that seems to come up is this idea of pestilence, which maybe feeds, in a little bit, to the concerns about children as well, if you’ve got a generational issue. Okay, so the Fasti Capitolini lists the four consuls, the two initial consuls, and then the suffect consuls. And the suggestion seems to be that, potentially, the first two were elected incorrectly and problematic. But the suggestion with the censors, because one of them gets replaced, is that one of them dies in office, which is a problem.
Dr Rad 56:07
Yes.
Dr G 56:08
And it’s such a problem that Dionysus of Halicarnassus actually mentions this idea and talks about this pestilence visiting Rome. There’s a lack of rain. There’s been severe droughts, and we know that Rome has been going through some of this stuff a few years ago now, but it seems to be back on the cards. Orchards aren’t producing fruit, grain isn’t coming to fruition for a proper harvest, and everything is a little bit suspect, and it seems like people are eating the food, and there’s something wrong with it as well. So it’s not just a pestilence that is spreading, but it seems to be something that people are getting from eating poorly as a result of the harvest not going well, right? So some people end up with pustules breaking out on their skin, and these turn into really large ulcers.
Dr Rad 57:07
Ughhh
Dr G 57:08
That kind of, that kind of pestilence, yeah, like plague, like pestilence, and people basically are scratching their flesh down to the bone is how it’s described.
Dr Rad 57:21
Uggh
Dr G 57:23
It is, that is how severe and painful this process is for people. So while this is happening, it seems like maybe either the consuls are elected incorrectly, or they die in office. Seems like a potential.
Dr Rad 57:38
Well, certainly it’s one of the suffect consuls who takes charge of situation with the Aequians.
Dr G 57:44
yeah, and so, yeah, whatever is happening there like Rome is not in a good way. So beyond the disputes and the protests and the speechifying and the Camillus standing up and doing his business, it seems like things aren’t going very well this year in a physical, fundamental way. And the only other thing that I have on this year is that there is a whole series of problems that Rome has that do relate to warfare. So the war with the Aequii, they take a city called Liphlus.
Dr Rad 58:27
Terrible name.
Dr G 58:28
It’s a terrible name, and we don’t know where it is. And they also apparently start a new war with the people of Velitrae, because apparently they were revolting.
Dr Rad 58:39
They are disgusting. I didn’t want to say, but since you said it.
Dr G 58:42
First, that’s that’s how they’ve been described. Velitrae is an ancient Volscian city, so it’s kind of adjacent to Aequian territory. It’s nearby. And there is also a city called Satricum, which revolts from the Romans as well. Satricum is nearby to Velitrae, just to the south of the Alban Hills near the Pontine Marshes. So there is a whole series of things that are going wrong for Rome. At this point, it would seem they’ve won Veii but they seem to be having problems to the south, all over the place, and they also send a colony to Cercii. Now –
Dr Rad 59:30
You’re welcome.
Dr G 59:31
Thank you. Thank you. Cercii a becomesCirceii, which becomes San Felice Circeo, which is known as a bit of a Roman getaway beach town these days, but it’s quite for further south as well. It’s on a southern promontory. And so whatever is happening in this southern area doesn’t seem to be great. So the desperate measures taken with Veii may be a response to other issues that they’re having.
Dr Rad 1:00:02
The manpower issue is suddenly making a lot of sense.
Dr G 1:00:07
Yes, a manpower issue does make sense. If there is a pestilence war on multiple fronts, they’re losing more men than they’re breeding. It’s not great.
Dr Rad 1:00:15
No. And dare I say it? Dr G, perhaps their attention has been on the north a little too long.
Dr G 1:00:22
Yes, it does seem like things are now starting to get out of hand to the south. And to close out this year, I also have some details about ‘Meanwhile in Sicily’, my side series. Meanwhile in Sicily, so there are pirates, there are. There’s plenty of them. And then there are tyrants as well, including this, Dionysus, the Tyrant of the Syracusans. And he has decided, on the back of his great victory, defeating Magon of the Carthaginians a couple of years ago, now that he’s going to launch an offensive against the Greeks in southern Italy, because he doesn’t like them either.
Dr Rad 1:01:02
Uh oh.
Dr G 1:01:03
Yeah, he’s got the manpower. He’s got 20,000 infantry, 1000 cavalry, and 120 ships. So let’s think about it Sicily, very small island, very close to Italy proper. The Romans sent one ship with a gold bowl. This guy is just sitting around with he was 120 ships in Sicily just waiting to launch them at somebody, and that’s not counting any of the other islands around there as well, with people who love ships. So the Romans, did they take a risk? They certainly did. One ship. We’ll just sail through the Straits of Messina. It’ll be fine. Nobody will notice us.
Dr Rad 1:01:44
Grab some gelato. It’d be great.
Dr G 1:01:45
Yeah, delicious. So Dionysus takes his first offensive against the Rhegians. Now, this is the city that goes on to be Reggio Calabria. So it’s basically the city that is in on the opposite side of the Messina strait. So very close you can see it from Sicily. You look over and you’re like, there are people over there. And if you’re Dionysus of the Syracusans, you’re like, I’m gonna kill ’em! So he sails over there, full pelt, crosses over there, then does a bit of a land attack as well, heads over to Locris, which is on the east coast of the same little bit of the foot of the boot, and he’s sort of flailing around in there, causing a mess for everybody. And while he’s doing that, the people of Rhegium are calling out for support. So then a whole bunch of ships, 60 ships, get launched from a place called Croton. Now, Croton is also on the east side of the foot of the boot, famous, mostly because it’s the home of Pythagoras.
Dr Rad 1:03:02
Get out of town. He was born in the boot of Italy?
Dr G 1:03:04
Yeah, that’s where he lived. Yeah,
Dr Rad 1:03:07
I never liked math.
Dr G 1:03:08
Pythagoras, everybody’s like, he’s a Greek. And I was like, Sure, but like, Magna Graecia, please.
Dr Rad 1:03:13
Yeah.
Dr G 1:03:14
So yeah
Dr Rad 1:03:15
So what are we just handing these citizenship cards out to anybody now?
Dr G 1:03:19
Apparently we are. Croton was founded by the Greeks ages and ages ago, around about 710. Pythagoras lives around, what, circa 530 and now we’re in this situation where, you know, 100 plus years later, it’s time for an attack from Dionysus, the tyrant of Syracuse.
Dr Rad 1:03:45
Guy sounds like he’s going to be an ongoing problem.
Dr G 1:03:47
Uh, yes, there is a reason why I’m telling you these stories, because eventually it’s going to matter. Eventually it will matter. He gets into a whole sea battle with these 60 triremes that are sent from Croton. He narrowly escapes in his own vessel eventually, but he loses a whole bunch of people during this naval attack, and the Rhegians are bringing their ships in, but he loses his ships in a strong wind, so he eventually has to retreat. So that’s a bit of a problem for him. He gets out of there. But in the meantime, what he has done is he’s managed to also set up an alliance with the Leucani. Before he’s had to take his forces back to Syracuse. Right now, the Leucani are the first Italic peoples that you encounter in Italy, if you’re moving from the south up, okay, they’re an Italic people. They speak Oscan, and they are sitting just above where this Magna Graecia stuff is going on. So they’re interacting with these people all the time. But they also consider themselves their own people, and they’re they consider themselves be native Italians as well. So. So he manages to form an alliance with this block, and while he’s still figuring out what he’s going to do with the whole shoe of Italy, now that he’s had to head back to Sicily with his tail between his legs. So it’s not over for him, I don’t think, but he’s he feels like he’s made some gains, even though it’s not quite as good as he would like it to be. And that is 393.
Dr Rad 1:03:47
Okay, well, Dr G, I think you know what that means. It is time for the Partial Pick!
Dr Rad 1:03:47
So, Dr G, tell us what is the partial pick all about?
Dr G 1:03:47
The partial pick is about seeing how Rome gets along when measured by its own sense of what is good and reasonable. So there are 50 Golden Eagles up for grabs across five categories. We will see how they do.
Dr Rad 1:03:47
All right. Dr, G, what is our first category?
Dr G 1:03:47
Military clout.
Dr Rad 1:03:47
Okay. I mean, there’s a decent amount of this flying about. It seems a little confusing, but it’s there.
Dr G 1:03:47
Okay, I think it has to be balanced by the chaos. There’s the there’s the lack of formation, there’s the running away.
Dr G 1:04:54
Temporarily. Dr, G, I mean, come on, they were probably barely out the gate.
Dr G 1:06:31
Well, I mean, it can’t have. They made great victories. I’m not sure that they have. And we also have to take account of the fact that the South seems to be revolting,
Dr Rad 1:06:40
Yeah, look, there definitely seems to be issues that are not mentioned in this year, if the Livy for sure, but from Livy’s point of view, it’s a pretty good year.
Dr G 1:06:53
Have they lost more than they’ve won?
Dr Rad 1:06:55
I don’t think so. I think that they have managed to hold the line against the Aequians in Livy’s account and not in other accounts.
Dr G 1:07:09
Intriguing. All right, I’d be willing to give them a, I think I’d give them about a four.
Dr Rad 1:07:14
Yeah, okay, fair enough. It’s nothing stupendous. Let’s face it, yeah, it’s not great. It’s not, although there is that, you know, battle in the moonlight.
Dr G 1:07:23
Oh, well, yes.
Dr Rad 1:07:25
You can try to resist. Okay, but yeah, four, I’m happy with four. I don’t think it’s anything spectacular by any means. And really could have used a bit more detail Livy to make sense of how this all actually happened.
Dr G 1:07:42
Yeah, I think Livy’s clutching at straws. That’s what it’s that’s what it sounds like from your retelling of it. The second category is diplomacy.
Dr Rad 1:07:50
Okay, hmm, not really. No, no. There’s just a lot of warfare, people revolting, people being captured, again, new colonies, old colonies. It’s all over the place.
Dr G 1:08:01
Yeah, no, yeah. Third category is expansion.
Dr Rad 1:08:07
Noooo, but kind of if we believe Diodorus: Cercii.
Dr G 1:08:13
Oh, yeah, they do send out for a colony. I could give them one for that. I suppose
Dr Rad 1:08:20
it’s a new colony.
Dr G 1:08:23
I don’t know how. No, I don’t think it’s new. So the same place, it suggested that Tarquinius Superbus is actually the one who founds a colony there initially, and then it gets taken by the Volsci, when the Volscians are under leadership of Coriolanus
Dr Rad 1:08:41
Right
Dr G 1:08:41
So that’s going way back in time, and the Romans haven’t had a chance to really deal with that for for the longest time, because they’ve never been able, for 100 years, they haven’t had a chance to do they haven’t been able to get that far south again, so unless they found a new way down. But yeah, there’s this idea that it’s been about 100 years since Rome has had any influence there.
Dr Rad 1:09:08
Fine, one point.
Dr G 1:09:11
Okay, the fourth category is Virtus.
Dr Rad 1:09:14
I don’t think so. I mean, Camillus is certainly taking a very high, mighty, mighty stance a lot of the time, but it’s not really the same as what he did in the previous episode with the Philistines.
Dr G 1:09:28
I think the question would be, would the patricians label what Camillus does in this year in terms of the speechifying and all of that? Would they classify that as virtus?
Dr Rad 1:09:43
You always tell me that I can’t count speechifying as virtus.
Dr G 1:09:47
Excellent. That’s and our last category is the Citizen Score.
Dr Rad 1:09:54
Oft. Okay, well, this really depends on whether you’re following your sources or mine, because mine, it doesn’t seem. Too bad yours. It seems absolutely horrific.
Dr G 1:10:04
The pestilence is not great, yeah, it is described in horrifying terms by Dionysus of Halicarnassus. But they, I do have some suggestion that they’re, they are allocated some land from Veii.
Dr Rad 1:10:20
That’s true. There is the land. So, yeah, it’s not all bad news. Okay, so maybe like five, I don’t know, I guess. How do you score scratching your skin down to the bone? Hmm.
Dr G 1:10:38
It’s a two. Could have been worse!
Dr Rad 1:10:42
Yeah, it’s not great look. It’s It doesn’t sound great, but the land would be important, because it does feel like they kind of got somewhat what they were after. I mean, I know that what they were after was really about actually moving half of everyone to they it wasn’t about having land allotments, at least in the way that it’s represented in Livy. So I do understand there is a difference, but at the same time, is there that much difference? I remain unconvinced of that.
Dr G 1:11:16
Yes.
Dr Rad 1:11:17
Oh, I don’t know. I don’t know.
Dr G 1:11:20
Neither do I, but,
Dr Rad 1:11:22
Oh, we do have the victory over the treacherous tribunes of the plebs, if we believe that that’s what happened.
Dr G 1:11:30
So in a political sense, then we might be talking it’s it’s probably gone all right. But if you caught the pestilence, things have gone pretty badly, so maybe you’re three,
Dr Rad 1:11:42
Yeah, okay, three it is, which means, dr, G, that once again, I am safely counting on just my own hands, because the Romans have come out with eight out of a potential 50 golden eagles.
Dr G 1:11:55
Goodness me. Sad, sad.
Dr Rad 1:12:01
I think the question is, because, if you’re relying on Dionysius of Halicarnassus for some of these details, you know that Livy and Dionysius don’t always match up. And see, I actually haven’t read that far ahead of 393 at this point in time. So it’ll be interesting to see if some of the details that you’ve mentioned in this year come up at another point of Livy. That’s what I’m curious.
Dr G 1:12:22
Yeah, it’s quite possible that the pestilence comes up next year, maybe Livy,
Dr Rad 1:12:28
maybe we’ll see, and maybe Livy’s Just like, you know what? It’s too gross. I don’t want to talk about illnesses,
Dr G 1:12:35
I’m done with pestilence, not this time.
Dr Rad 1:12:35
I’m over it. I’d rather talk about Camillus. Camila is a great guy. He’s my hero. That’s who I want to talk about.
Dr G 1:12:41
Yeah, it is reading a bit like a hagiography. I have to say.
Dr Rad 1:12:46
Yeah, everybody’s talking about me.
Dr G 1:12:51
Well, it has been a pleasure, as always, Dr Rad.
Dr Rad 1:12:55
Indeed. And I’m really glad that we haven’t had massive technological issues like we’ve been having recently.
Dr Rad 1:13:00
Fingers crossed, fingers crossed.
Dr Rad 1:13:03
All right, I’ll see you in 392.
Dr G 1:13:13
Thank you for listening to this episode of the Partial Historians. You can find our sources sound credits and transcript in our show notes. Over at partialhistorians.com. We offer a huge thank you to you, if you’re one of our illustrious Patreon supporters, if you enjoy the show, we’d love your support in a way that works for you. Leaving a nice review really makes our day. We’re on Ko-fi for one off or ongoing donations or Patreon, of course. Our latest book, Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire, is published through Ulysses Press. It is full of stories that the Romans probably don’t want you to know about them. This book is packed with some of our favourite tales of the colorful history of ancient Rome. Treat yourself or an open minded friend to Rome’s glories, embarrassments and most salacious claims with Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire.
Transcribed by https://otter.ai
The post Episode 163 – Camillius’ Conniptions appeared first on The Partial Historians - Ancient Roman History with smart ladies.
In this episode, we continue to follow the adventures of that most amazing of Romans: Marcus Furius Camillus! This is one of his real shining moments of virtus.
Although the Romans have just conquered Veii, there was tension on those mean city streets. The patricians and plebeians were locked in a disagreement over what they should do with this new territory.
However, Camillus had military matters to attend to. He was placed in charge of subduing Veii’s allies, the Faliscans. This was no easy task as the enemy was well-prepared and the city of Falerii was easily defended.
Camillus was making some headway, but it looked as though this conflict was going to turn into another length siege. Boo!
Fortune sided with Camillus as the leading school teacher in Falerii decided to betray his people. He was in charge of the children of all the most important families in town, and what better way for kids to get exercise than to be marched right into the Roman camp?
We don’t want to give too much away, but what Camillus does next will make you swoon like a love-sick teen. Oh, and it also gave us our next idea for a T-shirt, so thanks Camillus! You sure are a swell guy!
M. Furius L. f. Sp. n. Camillus (Pat) Mil. Tr. c. p. 401, 398, 386, 384, 381
L. Furius L. f. Sp. n. Medullinus (Pat) Cos. 413, 409, Mil. Tr. c. p. 407, 405, 398, 397, 395, 391
C. Aemilius TI. F. TI. N. Mamercinus (Pat) Mil. Tr. c. p. 391
L. Valerius L. f. L. n. Poplicola (Pat) Mil. Tr. c. p. 389, 387, 383, 380
Sp. Postumius – f. – n. Albinus Regillensis (Pat)
P. Cornelius -f. -n (——–) (Pat) Mil. Tr. c. p. 397 or 395
[?] Catlus Verus
Q. Pomponius
T. Sicinius
A. Verginius
L. Valerius Potitus (Pat) Cos. 393, 392, Mil. Tr. c. p. 414, 406, 403, 401, 398
L. Sergius (Fidenas) (Pat) Mil. Tr. c. p. 397
A. Manlius (Vulso Capitolinus) (Pat) Mil. Tr. c. p. 405, 402, 397
Our music is by Bettina Joy de Guzman. Sound effects by Orange Free Sounds.
Dr Rad 0:15
Music. Welcome to the partial historians.
Dr G 0:18
We explore all the details of ancient Rome,
Dr Rad 0:23
everything from political scandals, the love affairs, the battled wage and when citizens turn against each other. I’m Dr rad and
Dr G 0:33
I’m Dr G, we consider Rome as the Romans saw it, by reading different authors from the ancient past and comparing their stories.
Dr Rad 0:44
Join us as we trace the journey of Rome from the founding of the city.
Dr G 1:00
Hello and welcome to a brand new episode of the partial historians. I am Dr G.
Dr Rad 1:08
And I am Dr Rad.
Dr G 1:11
We are about to launch in to the year 394, BCE. But before we do that, I think we just need a little bit of a recap. Where are we up to in Roman history? What has been going on? Dr, rad,
Dr Rad 1:27
well, it’s as usual, has been quite tense. Dr G, there’s been a lot of drama after the capture of a which you might not have been expecting, because it seems like that should be a happy time for everyone.
Dr G 1:39
Yeah, you would have thought so. But it seems that with every victory comes an additional cost, sometimes a burden to the physical self, sometimes a burden to the psyche of Rome.
Dr Rad 1:53
Well, they’ve definitely been fighting over the issue of the tithe that Camillus promised he had vowed that he was going to give a 10th of whatever they captured in terms of the booty and that sort of thing to the gods, specifically to Apollo. And this turned out to be a huge issue, because he forgot to mention that until after everyone had got their stuff and then gone out and spent it, or used it, or whatever it was they were doing with it.
Dr G 2:21
Yeah, it seems to be a huge issue. And part of the reason why it’s such a big problem is that the promise was based on gold value. So it’s not just the old exchanging of the leather boots that has been going on for decades now when we talk about booty, but Rome has come into some serious prize money, essentially through the sacking of Veii and Camillus has forgotten to mention to anybody that 1/10 of that needed to be reserved for Apollo because of his promise to the gods that if they helped him out, he would give them a gift in return. And all of a sudden, we find some very angry Roman soldiers on our hands, and they’re angry with reason, good reason, I would say, Absolutely.
Dr Rad 3:07
We also have this drama over the colonies. So the Senate had suggested setting up a colony on the border of Volscian territory and Rome, I believe. And the plebs were like, You can’t fool us. We know that that’s crappy land. You’re just trying to distract us. What we want is they. We want to make they an extension of Rome. We want half the population to go and live there. And the Senate were horrified by that suggestion, and so there’s been some fighting between the patricians and the plebeians over what is going to happen to the actual city of they
Dr G 3:49
Well, I guess I wonder if 394 will lead us any closer to some conclusions about the rising internal issues that Rome seems to be Having on the back of a very big military victory,
Dr Rad 4:03
I’m really looking forward to the hissy fits that are going to be thrown. Dr, G,
Dr G 4:08
Well, without further ado, let’s launch into 394, BCE,
Dr Rad 4:22
ah, all right. Dr, G, it is 394, BCE, and I would love you to tell me all about the magistrates for this year. Oh,
Dr G 4:49
we have a whole bunch of people in power, in various positions. We do. It is a big year. So we’ll start with the military tribunes with consular power. Hour. This has been a pretty common occurrence year on year for a while now that rather than having consoles, we have a slightly lesser prestige position that can be filled by more than two people. And the idea is, at some point, maybe we get some plebeians involved. But yet again, we find ourselves in a situation where it’s all patricians in the position of military Tribune with consular power.
Dr Rad 5:30
I wish I could say I’m surprised. Dr, G, but my mouth is firmly closed. My jaw is very far from the floor. You’re
Dr G 5:37
like, tell me something I don’t know exactly.
Dr Rad 5:41
I’m just resigned to the fact that this is just how it is now.
Dr G 5:44
Yeah, not only are there more positions, but that just means we have to deal with more patricians. Great. Yeah, fantastic.
Dr Rad 5:51
Yeah. In fact, the plebeians have come up with a very good way of actually giving more patricians more power. Really,
Dr G 6:00
it’s working out really well. So we have first cab off the rank is the very famous at this point, Marcus Furius Camillus,
Dr Rad 6:11
dictator extraordinaire, from 396,
Dr G 6:15
Yep, he’s back again. We’ll see how that pans out for him. He is joined by Lucius Furius Medullinus, yeah, and this guy’s had a whole bunch of positions. His name is very familiar. There is also Caius Aemilius Mamercinus. This is his first appearance. Why? Hello there, young man. But from a distinguished family, a very distinguished family. The Aemilii are one of the oldest and best families. Thank you very much. Lucius Valerius Poplicola, also first appearance,
Dr Rad 6:50
again, distinguished family, though very distinguished family.
Dr G 6:53
The Valerii in particular, this line of the Poplicola. Yes, they’ve had quite a previous century. So good to see them hanging out still. They are joined by Spurius Postumius Albinus Regillenisis, also his first appearance. But again, the postumii, very, very prestigious family and also a this is where we start to get into the hazy territory we have a Publius Cornelius, but we’re missing part of the name. So because we’ve only got the prinomen pubulus, and we’ve got the gens name, the nomen Cornelius, this kind of leaves it wide open as to which Publius Cornelius we could have on our hands. And this has led to me consulting the digital prospography of the Roman Republic. Have fun, everybody. It’s out there online. You can check it out for yourselves. And so we have this Publius Cornelius, and the speculation is that it’s either Publius Cornelius Cossus, also a patrician or Publius Cornelius Scipio, who was previously in the role in 395, so doing a sort of a double duty there and then we also, in addition to that, have what might be a seventh military Tribune with consular power. I know an odd and prime number. I shall not stand for it Rome, a guy called Catlus Verus, who is only cited by Diodorus Siculus, which I know might make you think untrustworthy, probably not a real person. It
Dr Rad 8:41
sounds like a weird addition to have a seventh one. It does to be his name on top of it. Yes.
Dr G 8:48
Not only numerically, are we in uncharted territory in terms of how many military tribunes with consular power we have at this point, but also the name doesn’t quite stack up to anything we’ve ever seen before. So that doesn’t help us place this person, especially
Dr Rad 9:03
amongst like, we’ve got like, the Aemilii, we’ve got Servilii, we’ve got Cornelii, we’ve got Postumii, all names that I am very familiar with, Dr G, but throw this guy into the mix, yeah,
Dr G 9:15
who is this guy? Who is this Catlus Verus, and what is going on here? Who’s
Speaker 1 9:21
that man seven around with you?
Dr G 9:27
Apt, very apt, Diodorus Siculus has some questions to answer, but we can’t take him off the list because our evidence is so so little most of the time that we’re just gonna leave him there with
Dr Rad 9:40
a huge question mark, fair enough, dangerous.
Dr G 9:43
So far so good. Then we have the tribune of the plebs. Now these three names will be very familiar, because they all served in the previous year. All re elected, apparently, Titus Sicinius, Quintus Pomponius, and Aulus Verginius. This
Dr Rad 10:01
is something that was foreshadowed by Livy, because, remember, there wasn’t really a resolution to this question of a colony at Veii, or extending Rome into Veii, or dividing Rome in two and setting up another Rome at Veii. However, it was they were pitching it. These guys were integral to that, and you will see how this all plays out. Dr, G, it’s gonna be interesting. Because, well, you know, I don’t want to say too much, but they might not all be playing for the same team. Oh, I’m not speaking about their sexuality. I was gonna
Dr G 10:33
say, and I was like, who’s batting for the other side? And also, I approve wholeheartedly. All right, so the tribute of the plebs. We’ll see how that pans out for this year. I’m interested to see where that goes, because I’m pretty sure your it sounds like your evidence is trending in that direction, whereas my evidence might not be. And then we also have a category that is labeled as legates, slash ambassadors, people who have been delegated a specific task by Presumably, the military tribunes. And this relates to the infamous golden bowl of Apollo yes, that has been put together from the 10% that everybody has complained about so bitterly. This includes guys like Lucius, Valerius Potitus, who is a very well known military Tribune with constable power from previous years. And Lucius Sergius Fidenas, who served in 397 and Aulus Manlius Vulso Capitolinus, also previously a holder of the military Tribune position. So they’re all people with deep political experience, all very well known. This may be why they’ve been delegated this very important task.
Dr Rad 11:52
Absolutely, it is all right. Dr, G Well, are you ready for the drama of 394, BCE, I really am.
Dr G 12:01
And do you want to know why? Why? Because I do have some source material, including Dionysus of Halicarnassus.
Dr Rad 12:10
Oh, really get out of town. Here’s Ben. Oh, my God. Well, this truly is a banner year for us. So, as you know, tents in Rome. And therefore we had the plebeians pushing hard to have the same tribunes of the plebs elected, because they thought that that was how they were going to get this whole division between Rome and Veiicity colony thing happening that they were keen on. But we also, of course, have the patricians who have literally said that they would rather die than see that happen. And so they also want to make sure that they’ve got people who are Uber patricians serving as military tribunes. So the senators, of course, push hard to get none other than Camillus elected, saying that they need his military expertise. I mean, it’s got nothing to do with this whole very issue. It’s just that there’s, you know so much war going on,
Dr G 13:01
we really just need somebody who’s got the chops exactly now,
Dr Rad 13:06
the tribune of the plebs, they clock this, and they make sure that they stay as quiet as little mices and restrain themselves until camillas has to go off and fight with the Faliscans, because, lest we forget, Dr G in the previous year, Rome had to mop up the whole vase situation by dealing with vase allies like Capena and the Falerii. And so that’s what Camillus is doing, because the people of capenna had surrendered, but the Falsicans, they had not. The Faliscans are holding out. Classic, they are holding out. They sound adorable, but they’re clearly no pushover. However, they didn’t really accomplish very much, apparently. And this seems very typical for the plebeians in Livy’s version of things, the people had kind of cooled off on the whole idea, after being very fiery about it the year before, where it seemed like they were actually going to murder people in the name of this bill that they were proposing. Instead, the tribunes of the plebs don’t make much headway. Meanwhile, Camillus is off earning further glory for himself against the Falsicans, and I kind of feel like his reputation needs this Dr G, because the whole triumph after they and then the whole tithing thing, he hasn’t done him any favors. Yes,
Dr G 14:25
people do think he overstepped with his very fancy triumph, and not to mention the whole situation with the 10% and forgetting the promise business. So he does need something at this point to kind of restore his reputation. So handily, he is quite a military expert, so maybe going against the Falsicans is a way for him to gain redemption.
Dr Rad 14:50
I think that’s the idea, perhaps. Now the city of Falerii is like they itself, also in quite a strategic position. Dr, G, I don’t know if you’ve ever visited that. Actually, I
Dr G 15:00
have not, but I hear that it’s sort of on a rocky outcrop, so it’s pretty easily defensible. Is that correct? I’m
Dr Rad 15:07
actually going to quote Ogilvie here, because I have also never been there, but apparently it commands both the Tiber highway and the overland routes to Etruria.
Dr G 15:16
Oh, okay, it’s at the crossroads. Very important then, yeah,
Dr Rad 15:21
but you’re right. You’re right about it standing on a narrow rocky outcrop,
Dr G 15:25
it seems pretty in keeping with this area. So in this similar situation with Veii, is that they’re they’re built on the top of these nice tooth outcrops that have a good commanding position, so they can look down upon anybody approaching them and have a view over the landscape to see what’s going on. So, yeah, makes sense, yeah.
Dr Rad 15:45
And that’s exactly why Rome wants it, I think, very much like they it’s in a strategic situation for trade, like, if the Romans control this, I think things will be better for them, and it’s also easy enough to defend once they’ve captured it. All
Dr G 16:01
right, okay, so it’s just the tricky part they need to do. Then it’s just a little bit of capturing,
Dr Rad 16:07
exactly, just the capturing. So at first the Faliscans do it sounds like a very sensible thing in this situation, given what we’ve just been talking about. And they stay safe behind their walls, safe within the city. Oh,
Dr G 16:20
well, hello. I think we’ll just stay over here and you can have fun wasting yourselves outside of our city walls.
Dr Rad 16:26
Yes, and Camillus, he knows what’s that. He decides that he’s going to try and provoke them into coming out to defend the territory around them, because he starts attacking the surrounding fields and farms.
Dr G 16:40
Okay, this is a pretty classic siege tactic, because you don’t actually want to do a siege. You would much rather have an open pitch battle that you can then win and then take the geography. So really, the key for the Faliscans in this scenario is to resist as much as possible the temptation to leave their city. But they do leave
Dr Rad 17:00
their city. Dr, G however, they don’t want to go too far away. They know they’ve got defensible walls behind them, so they set up their camp only about a mile outside the walls of their city, thinking that the Romans probably couldn’t get too close to them, because it would just be too difficult because of the way that the ground was. It’s described as being rough and broken, in other words, uneven, too difficult in the stiletto heels that the Romans would be wearing for such an occasion, and also, the roads up there would be too narrow and steep. So it wasn’t going to be easy to get to their camp if they just stayed close enough to the city. Okay? So
Dr G 17:38
for Rome to take this camp, they’d really have to spread their forces, really quite thin, to a degree that presumably the Falsicans could easily pick them off exactly.
Dr Rad 17:48
Now, Camillus has a prisoner, and he forces this prisoner to act as his guide. The Romans then leave their camp under the cover of darkness, and that enables them when the sun rises the second that it crosses that horizon, bam. The Romans are in a brand new position, and the Faliscans are like, What the hell. How did they get there? I blinked, and they moved, and it was a much better position for an attack. How dare they Yeah. I mean, it must have seemed like, you know, David Copperfield or something like,
Dr G 18:22
what is this sorcery? Now,
Dr Rad 18:25
this sounds very reminiscent of the tunnel idea. Dr G Camillus had his men working in three shifts so that there was never not work being done building a rampart. And if they weren’t building then they were on guard.
Dr G 18:38
Okay, okay. So far so good. Very siege, like, all right, yep,
Dr Rad 18:42
the Falsicans decided that they’re going to try and stop the building from going ahead. But he managed to defeat them, and the Faliscans got so panicked after this loss that they ran right past their camp. Apparently they didn’t even see it. They’re like, I’m not stopping there. I’m going all the way to the city. Just absolutely panicked, running, wait a minute,
Dr G 19:01
surely they would have seen their own camp. Well,
Dr Rad 19:04
look, it doesn’t say they didn’t see their own camp, but they were just like, Nope, that’s not good enough. That’s not safe enough. I’m heading straight to the city.
Dr G 19:10
I need real walls, not these wooden Palisades. Yes, I think
Dr Rad 19:15
they sensed that that was going to be the safest place for them, unfortunately, and they were wrong. It’s Camillus that we’re dealing with here, and many of them are killed before they managed to make it back to the town. Fascinating, I know now what this means is that the camp was captured, and of course, including all the booty, which is handed over to the quaestors.
Dr G 19:35
Okay, okay, so if we’re talking about a military camps booty, then we’re back to like you found a nice pair of leather shoes, again,
Dr Rad 19:42
maybe a new sword, although presumably they had the swords with them when they
Dr G 19:46
were running, I panicked. I wouldn’t be leaving the good stuff in the camp. You know
Dr Rad 19:49
now, the soldiers who are serving under Camillus are extremely annoyed by this situation, because first they’ve had to endure serving under. To Camillus, who’s, whilst he’s admirable and all, he is extremely strict, and I think we’ve been getting that sense from him this whole time. I mean,
Dr G 20:08
I suppose we could assume that, although it’s not something that immediately comes to mind, from what I’ve read about him so far, he seems very traditional there. Well, if he is capable of getting a military force to dig a complete tunnel underneath a whole city. In order to take it, as is the case apparently, with Veii, then you would need some real discipline with your troops. So exactly I’m willing to allow it. I’m not sure that the sources have necessarily emphasized it, because they do love telling you when somebody is harsh.
Dr Rad 20:38
Well, it’s not so much harsh. I think he’s just strict, and I definitely get that sense from him. I mean, the whole vow thing the way that he had to get the pontiffs involved, and he was like, do we include the land or not include the land? I don’t know, guys, you tell me it all seems very much. This is a man who was very traditional and conservative and likes to play by the rules. Okay,
Dr G 20:59
all right. Well, he needs to work on his memory. That’s all I can tell him. Well,
Dr Rad 21:03
the soldiers are extremely annoyed because they’re like, look, it’s one thing to serve under you in these conditions, but now you’re handing the booty over to the questors like you’re supposed to, instead of just letting us have it. That’s
Dr G 21:16
outrageous. Following the rules, I won’t stand for it. However,
Dr Rad 21:21
under Camillus command, they have, of course, now begun a siege against Falerii.
Dr G 21:26
Okay, so they’ve done the thing where they’ve encountered the military camp of the Faliscans, and they’ve managed to push the Faliscans back to the city. So we’re now getting into the siege proper,
Dr Rad 21:36
yeah, and they’ve got their rampart constructed thanks to Camillus, so we’re ready.
Dr G 21:40
And also maybe it makes sense, from Camillus’ perspective, to hand over all of the booty to the quaestors, because then he’s never again in a situation where he forgets one of his vows and has to try and recoup the 10% from the troops themselves, he can just recoup it from the booty that was taken as a collective and hand it over to the choir stores, and then what remains can be redistributed to the troops.
Dr Rad 22:03
Yeah. He’s like, hey, Marge, get over here. Take control of this. I can’t trust my memory. You need to keep track
Dr G 22:07
of this exactly. It might just be a safeguard for him. The
Dr Rad 22:13
way that this ensues is very much what you would expect for a siege. We see skirmishing going backwards and forwards. Sometimes the people from the town would raid the Roman outposts as they’re camping outside the city, and sometimes they would attack back. And it just led to, like, some low level skirmishing. And it seems like this could obviously go on for a really long time. Essentially, we are once again locked in a stalemate. Dr G, especially because the Faliscans were clever little cookies. They had made sure that they had enough food supplies to last them during a siege inside the wall. So it really could have been a whole another vase situation. Are you ready for another 10 years?
Dr G 22:56
Oh, always, yeah. Always up for a 10 year siege. That’d only be 20 years of my life that’s fine, however,
Dr Rad 23:02
Fortune smiled down upon Camillus as she is want to do. Dr, G, okay,
Dr G 23:08
well, I think this might be where our sources might begin to link back up again. So I’m interested to hear where this goes. Let me take you through the drama that I’ve got when it comes to Camillus besieging of the city of Falerii. I It’s been going on for a little while, not 10 years. Thank goodness we’re in the first year of the siege. But it seems like there is a particular school master who lives amongst the Falsicans, and he starts walking the boys of the prominent families outside of the city for their constitutional and as time progresses with this siege, these walkings with the schoolmaster become more and more wandering away from the city and Closer and closer to the Roman camp until eventually, he brings the school children to a Roman outpost and proceeds to hand over these sons of prominent families to the Roman soldiers at this outpost, which seems to be a little bit insane. Like, what is this guy doing? And it seems that he wants some sort of reward for giving fuller eye to the Romans. He sees this as a trade option, because these are high value hostages, the sons of the most prominent families of the Faliscans. What more could the Romans want? So these kids are rounded up by the Roman soldiers at this outpost. They’re brought to Camillus. And he looks at this situation, and he says, I’m not I’m not having this at all. He’s like, this is treachery of the highest degree. There will be no honor for me as. Roman military commander to take the city of Falerii through accepting this proposition from this schoolmaster. Ultimately, he thinks there has to be a better way, and what he does is he has the schoolmaster handed over himself to the sons of the prominent families and tells them that they’re allowed to do whatever they like with him, preferably beat him up on the way back to the city, and sends them all back to Falerii with the message that this is not how he ever wants to treat with another city. Under no circumstances is this the right way to do about it. Now, in some accounts of this, Camillus does seek the permission of the Senate in terms of what will be the best thing to do, and in other accounts, he makes this decision himself. Hmm,
Dr Rad 25:55
interesting in Livy, it is very much him making this decision himself and just being like, Hey, dude, to the teacher, this is you are a gigantic douche bag, and I have far too much respect for the honor of my enemies and their leaders to enter into any sort of arrangement with an asswipe like you.
Dr G 26:17
How dare you bring these children before me?
Dr Rad 26:20
Yeah, well, in my account, the only sort of additional detail this is all basically your account matches up with mine entirely. But in my account, the only additional detail that I really have is that the guy who was employed to work with these kids is apparently the resident smarty pants, the foremost scholar, as he has described, which is what you’d expect. He’s basically the best teacher with the best education. And what else would you expect for the children of the leaders of Falerii? Well,
Dr G 26:53
exactly. And this seems to be a situation where Camillus is given the opportunity to demonstrate his moral, upright self in a new military situation, which has all of the hallmarks at the moment, up until this point of looking like they 2.0 but we’ve got this brand new sort of situation unfolding, and it becomes such a prominent story that it starts to make it into all sorts of works. It’s one of the things that Camillus becomes really quite famous for. So this story also comes up in Valerius Maximus. It is dealt with in Plutarch’s Life of Camillus. Frontinus mentions it in his stratagems A guy called Polyanus.
Dr Rad 27:44
Sorry, what was that? Again?
Dr G 27:45
I wish I was joking, but that’s his name, polyanus in his stratagems, and it also comes up in much later sources like Cassius Dio and Eutropius, and also the kind of anonymous Aurelius Victor. So this is the kind of story about Camillus that the Romans really, really like. And I would say that this is a big flag in terms of, like, thinking about, who is Camillus, how does he get received later on, and we know that he’s got some sort of niggling troubles with how he is perceived in his life and times, but this seems to be a standout moment in terms of what he is capable of as a thinker and a military strategist, because this really does work out for him. Not only does he send the school children back with the school teacher in tow, with being whipped by the boys, which must have been fun for them, I suppose. But when they get back to the city, the Faliscans immediately want to go into a treaty with Camillus. They’re like, we will talk with you, like, let us not do this siege. We’re willing to figure out what we can do to get out of this military situation. Because actually, you’ve been really respectful. You could have just taken all of our sons and you didn’t. Let’s chat. I
Dr Rad 29:16
know it’s it’s so bizarre for so many reasons. I mean, first of all, let me just say that I’m sitting here quietly sweating as a teacher at the thought that I would ever have my arms tied behind my back and my students given metal rods to beat me with as we walk through some woods. I kind of like think you know, if you go down in the woods today, you’re sure of a big surprise. I
Dr G 29:40
mean, my only advice to you would be, don’t try to hand over the school children to their enemies. You’ll be fine. Look, I
Dr Rad 29:47
like to think that I have as much morality as Camilla does in this situation, but it is really interesting, because Livy, of course, really leans into this moment. He wants to make a big deal of it. As you say, the Romans love. That. And he when he’s talking about what it is he wants to do, he says things like, the Romans would never use their weapons against children, even when they’re storming a city, let alone take unarmed children in these sorts of circumstances, we only attack other adults who bear weapons and provoke a fight. And I’m kind of like, okay, Rome, all right, let’s be honest.
Dr G 30:25
Oh yeah, jets guys, the truth now, yeah, you want to say that you’re very fancy and you play by all the rules, and everybody knows that that’s not true. I
Dr Rad 30:34
love Camilla’s code of honor. It is absolutely how it should be, because Camilla’s very much sees this as a situation where the Romans and the Philistines are both people of honor, and that there are standards in place during warfare. He actually talks even about this being part of human nature. He says nature has implanted this on both sides. Is code of honor, which all sounds fantastic, and this is probably the stuff that right wing people who gravitate towards the Romans really froth over, but we know it’s actually not true in practice in Rome’s history, exactly,
Dr G 31:10
Rome is notoriously violent to anybody it encounters that it doesn’t like, and the fact Camillus is really an exception, rather than the rule here. And there’s also that sense that this story is held onto so strongly by the Romans that it makes you wonder if it’s more of an invention than anything else, like they’re trying to define themselves through stories like this. So to be honest, which Faliscan is going to open the gate of a siege, a besieged city for the school master to go for a bit of a wonder with the kids.
Dr Rad 31:45
I know it just sounds so strange.
Dr G 31:48
I mean, the city has been thoroughly compromised. If somebody has agreed to do that, I
Dr Rad 31:52
know my school would be like, I’m sorry you haven’t done a risk assessment. Or if you have, you clearly haven’t taken full stock of the danger. Yeah, like
Dr G 32:01
you’re gonna have to fill out more forms before I can let you out. You know, we’re under a siege right now. Gonna
Dr Rad 32:06
be way more paperwork. You gotta get parental permission. It’s all gotta go on the ball.
Dr G 32:11
So I think to myself, there’s something up with this story, and it’s definitely working in Camillus favor, and it’s working in a Roman definition of self capacity as well. The Romans want to believe that they’re like this, and what a perfect story to encapsulate the way that they want to see themselves as noble warriors who would never do anything to the young men of prominent families of the enemy. Well,
Dr Rad 32:37
unless we forget, there is a bit of a call back here to the whole situation at Veii. I don’t know if you remember, but once the Romans were more or less in control of a and they’d broken through the tunnel, remember that Camillus had tried to be relatively humane with the people there as well. Yes, in terms of this idea of you only fight with people who are also holding weapons, if people put down their weapons and they can just be captured, that sort of approach. So this is in keeping with Camillus reputation. But he does actually say in Livy’s account that he wants to win the way he won in Veii against the Faliscans, and he wants to do it with honor, the Roman way by dint of courage, toil and arms,
Dr G 33:25
very fine Roman qualities, yeah,
Dr Rad 33:28
which, of course, is something that the Faliscans also apparently value as a truan people. And as soon as they hear it, as you say, they are so flawed by Rome’s integrity that they just lie down, rip off their clothes and say, oh my god, Camillus, just take me. Now. We surrender
Dr G 33:44
the city. It’s yours.
Dr Rad 33:49
Camillus, of course, says, butcher clothes back on. Ma’am. I need to ask the Senate for permission to take this city. Well,
Dr G 33:56
the thing is that they don’t actually take the city. In the end, from what I can tell, what they agree is that the Faliscans will pay Rome a sum of money, and that sum of money will be considered to have closed the military deal. So effectively, the Falsicans are giving Rome the booty that they would have won through violence, and then Rome goes home.
Dr Rad 34:17
That’s true, as in my account, the way it all plays out is that Camillus says, well, thank you so much for surrendering to me. Really appreciate it. And they do a little fist bump, and then Camillus sends the request to the Senate. When the request goes before the Senate, they actually have envoys from Falerii who say, Yes, we are very happy to hand ourselves over. But let us be clear, it is all thanks to Camillus, because apparently all the people in Falerii, particularly the leading magistrates, were dead against this idea of ever surrendering to Rome. They said we would rather go down like they go down in flames, than willingly hand ourselves over to Rome or declare P. Peace against this particular enemy, but Camillus actions have completely changed their mind. They’re just like mind blown. This guy could have taken an easy victory, but instead, he put his ethics first. Just come and take whatever you want, arms hostages the city, it is all yours. We shall be faithful to you and live under your rule, because you guys are clearly awesome, because you produced this man. Wow.
Dr G 35:27
Okay, so how to get the Faliscans to turn from enemy to fan girl? And it’s like, just send the school kids back.
Dr Rad 35:34
Yes. Was it all a ploy all along? Did the Faliscans willingly send out the kids because they were like, You know what really goes for some fresh produce about now?
Dr G 35:47
Well, you are 100%
Dr Rad 35:49
right. Dr G, the Falsicans are indeed ordered to pay the Roman soldiers salaries for that year so that no Roman had to pay the tax, which apparently was what was funding the military, pair of soldiers, even though we’re not entirely sure that that was happening. Oh,
Dr G 36:05
I see. Oh, they’re starting to weave all of these details together into a fabric that might be just half truths. Interesting room interesting before I move on, because I do have some other details about this year. I’m wondering if there are any more details that you have about the Falsicans and what has been going on there? Well,
Dr Rad 36:23
certainly we can start to break it down a little bit more in terms of how this all came together. It is possible, as you say, that Camillus did capture Falerii, and that was the basic story that the Romans knew, and that at a later point, it got connected with this story of a Faliscan school master, and maybe that’s how this story came to be, because, as you say, doesn’t 100% add up in terms of the way everyone is acting and the way that Camillus talks about this notion of honor the details that are included in various accounts on the Roman side. It does sound to some academics like they are kind of Greek, and it might be something to do with the fact that the Faliscans did have contact with Greek people. You know, they’re in that region. It’s possible that they had indeed adopted a sort of Greek education system, perhaps, and that that’s what they’re talking about with the particular education system that’s going on here, where you have one learned school master in charge of everyone’s children.
Dr G 37:32
We’ve adopted the Greek school, and it’s peripatetic, and so they must wander. That is the rule. Yes,
Dr Rad 37:39
exactly. But apparently, if you think about what Camilla says about this whole situation, it kind of might be borrowing a little bit from Plato in his Republic. Okay, some of those ideas. Yeah, I’m open to that fascinating. But certainly what we’re seeing here, if we look at the larger story, we’re seeing Rome become more and more of a player in central Italy, because we just have more and more territory resources being opened up to them. And basically the Tiber Valley is kind of theirs now, yeah,
Dr G 38:11
and I think this is where a little piece of information from Diodorus Siculus does come in handy, because he says that in addition to this conclusion of the peace with the Faliscans. Simultaneously, Rome is also waging war on the aqui eye yet again, and that they’ve also sent out a colony despite the arguments about, will we colonize Veii, they have apparently also sent a colony to a place called sutrium. And this is an ancient town in what is now modern Viterbo. So we’re talking about a place that is to the north east of Rome. And we’re talking about Etruscan territory again. It also, like many of these southern Etruscan towns. Is located on a tufa Hill, and has a history of Etruscan culture in its archeology and then later Roman influence. So it definitely falls under Roman sway at some point. But he also tells us that this colony was expelled by the enemy, the enemy, being unnamed, but involving people from Verrugo, who is another one of these places that has come up for the Romans a few times, and there’s been tussles over verugo. So Rome has its military fingers extending in many directions at the same time at this point, and this seems to be an increasing change that has come about through the adoption of the military tribunes with consular power, because they’ve just got more top military men to command soldiers. But these other things aren’t getting anywhere near the same kind of airplay as what we’re hearing about some of these stab. Out moments from Camillus. So I think it’s interesting that it what you say about them controlling the Tiber Valley at this point, because they do seem to be actively extending and pressing to the north in various directions, both east and west, just trying to secure everything about that area for themselves. So really, taking all of that sort of southern Etruria and militarily, and whether they’re winning all the time, it’s not clear, but they certainly are pushing continuously at this point, absolutely,
Dr Rad 40:34
we can clearly see that Rome has become very expansionist in this turning of the century period, you know, just before we headed into the three hundreds. And now that we’re in the 390s we can very much see that that is their policy, whereas previously, it’s been very much about what is happening in Rome, and they’re more or less just fighting people when they have to interestingly. Dr, G, I’m going to point out a little detail here. I didn’t mention this once before, I think in probably one of our episodes on the conquest of a but did you notice that one of Camillus important victories during this campaign happened at dawn?
Dr G 41:10
At dawn? Yes, because
Dr Rad 41:13
remember, some academics have suggested that Camillus was actually a mythical character who became sort of humanized and became a human figure, because he is very closely associated with deities like Apollo and also Mater Matuta, who are associated with the sun and the dawn, and a lot of his major military moments happen at dawn as well. Well,
Dr G 41:42
you know, maybe he likes to wake up early. Maybe he’s one of these 5am bros. I don’t know. Look. I
Dr Rad 41:48
mean, he seems very traditional and conservative. So I would not put it past him to be a morning person, which I definitely am not. So I’d never be accepted in Rome. I am
Dr G 41:57
definitely a morning person. So I’m happy for Camillus success waking up and doing things before the sun gets up is great, and if he’s doing things on the cusp of dawn, even better. So, you know, people are starting to wake up, and then they’re horrified, being like, Oh no, he’s arrived already. I don’t even I’m still in my pajamas. Camillus
Dr Rad 42:19
also might be a figure in a wall painting that we haven’t mentioned for quite some time, because it’s usually a wall painting that we bring up in connection with the seven kings of Rome. But do you remember a tomb painting the Francois tomb at Volsci? Well,
Dr G 42:36
I’m not going to say that. I do, but I’m open to having it described to me.
Dr Rad 42:39
Well, basically, there have been several figures that have been theoretically connected with some of the people that we’ve talked about. So for example, Servius Tullius, maybe being the person in this tomb painting called Macstrna, the Vipinas brothers. And we’ve also got potential reference to a Tarquin family member on this tomb. It’s hard to know, obviously, because there’s so many question marks about a trust and culture and about how exactly these names would translate. But there is also a figure in this wall painting called Marce Camitlnas. Ooh,
Dr G 43:14
okay, I can see the similarities coming through now. Yeah.
Dr Rad 43:18
So certainly some people have wondered if this, again, if it represents something to do with, you know, mythological people, or people of legend, and Camillus maybe, is somehow woven into that. It’s really interesting. Certainly, the name Camillus suggests someone who is extremely pious, because that word, Camillus can also be used to refer to a young boy who served priests during rituals. So that connection with religion is potentially there. It might be that Camillus is made into a bit of a historical personage by being given the various actions of maybe some real furious family members, and that that is, again, how this sort of legend is created, but it is all extremely tenuous and theoretical. Here. Not everybody gets on board with this whole idea, but it’s interesting because the Francois tomb, of course, is Etruscan, and of course, we’re talking about his connection with conquering important intruscan cities and outposts.
Dr G 44:27
Yeah. I mean, I do have a slight degree of skepticism that at this point in Rome’s history, we’re still dealing with myth and legend, because we’ve had a century or more of various figures that seem to be clearly families, even if those families are sort of extending their lines back a little bit, we’ve got all of this evidence to suggest that there is a burgeoning political culture at Rome and. There’s clear evidence archeologically for expansion during this period that the idea that we’re still dealing with myth and legend seems maybe a little bit too much like if you had said to me at the very start of the Republic, if we were still in like 509, or the 490s and this figure came up, I’d be more inclined to be like, sure, we might be dealing with, like, a little bit of legend, a little bit of myth, some of the old stories coming through. But it feels like we’re in a much more firmly historical period at this point, even though our sources are still giving us what feels like moral tales and things like that. We’ve also got things that are going to come up spoiler alert for next year, the census, we do have real records by the looks of it, and at some point we have to decide, does it count as history, or is it just a story, or is it that hazy nexus between both where, just like we can’t know all of the details about most of these figures, should Camillus be any more speculative than the other people we’ve been talking about for the last 20 years? And I’m not sure that he should. He doesn’t seem out of kilter with other ideas about Rome and how it operates. Somebody had to have broken the siege at Veii. Why not this guy? Absolutely,
Dr Rad 46:27
I think it’s very much a chicken and the egg sort of situation with this particular tomb, because the issue is that it was created at around this time. So it’s interesting in the sense that we have so little from the Etruscan point of view. Unfortunately, most of the stuff that we have that is written down in Etruscan culture that’s managed to survive, it doesn’t tell us narratives about their past. So we really don’t know how they would have told the story of their interactions with Rome. And the reason why, I suppose you might associate it with the sort of myths and legends. Side of things is that it depends on how much you believe in what happened during the Regal period. Because if you kind of accept that this might be telling a story about interactions between Rome and Etruria, it depends on whether you think Servius Tullius and the Tarquins are. How real are they, you know, and having Camillus mixed up in that story. I mean, it makes sense, because he is part of the story of interactions between Rome and Etruscan places. But it is that question of, well, if the if you think that those people from the Regal period are mythical, though, does it mean that Camillus is also a mythical figure who’s figured into this story? Or can you have both, you know, historical elements and mythological elements. But then again, you could accept that Servius Tullius and the tarquins were also very real. We certainly felt like they became like the Roman kings became more real as time went on as well. So there’s a lot of questions about this story, and we don’t know what the meaning of these particular tomb paintings are. But certainly it’s just interesting to note that Camillus might potentially have been represented in some sort of creation of a story about contact between Rome and Etruria from an Etruscan point of view.
Dr G 48:14
Yeah, I think that’s absolutely fascinating. So thank you for reminding me of this piece of evidence, because I know we, as you were going through the names, yes, we have talked about this before, but it’s been a while. So
Dr Rad 48:26
it has been a couple 100 years. You know, returning
Dr G 48:28
back to Camillus, being a part of it, I think, is fascinating. So what it tells us? I’d say we’re not entirely sure. The fact that it tells us some things incredibly interesting, absolutely, and
Dr Rad 48:41
it’s also it’s just that possibility. It’s the same thing with Servius Tullius and the Tarquins. We have no idea if there is a definite connection between these people that we hear about in the Roman narratives and the people who are in this tomb painting. But it’s such an intriguing idea that there is a connection in terms of what you were saying as well. I think about the idea of dealing with myths and legends, I totally know what you mean. It feels very historical the time period that we are in now. But we also know that there is still a lack of perhaps reliable narrative material that people like Livy are using. They’re often having to connect to the dots themselves in order to construct its history. And Camillus becomes so important in terms of how later people want to use him and want to imagine him. We see people like scipionus, we see Augustus. We see Caesar take him as a role model, and so him becoming an exemplar. It’s not so much that he’s necessarily, I suppose, mythological, but certainly that his reputation becomes somewhat embellished, because he becomes this exemplar of particular Roman virtues at moments just like this one. Yeah,
Dr G 49:50
exactly. And I was thinking about this as well in terms of, we’re still in a period for the Romans of oral history transmission, rather. Other than historiography. So it is quite plausible as well that somebody like Camillus does some incredible stuff. Stories are told about him, and the retelling of those stories become more and more like exemplar through the process of them being retold to the point that when people do start writing down the stories, they have already crystallized into a kind of mythic tale through the process of ongoing, generational oral tradition. And I think that might be another possibility for Camillus, yeah,
Dr Rad 50:39
and that’s obviously something that’s so part of these elite Roman families that would have strong oral traditions as well about what their family members had done exactly. Let’s pause it here. Well, Dr, G, that means that it is time for the
Unknown Speaker 50:56
passion pick you.
Dr G 51:04
Mmm, the partial pick. All right, we’re going to be judging Rome against its own standards, and they can win up to 50 gold Roman Eagles through the five categories,
Dr Rad 51:20
and we’re only judging half the year because Dr G, I have got more information on 394 so this is on, like the first part of 394 the Camillus part. Goodness
Dr G 51:28
me. Well, that’s the next episode. Is going to be a wild ride for me, because I’m fresh out of evidence. So I’m looking forward to what happens next in 394 but for now, let us judge part one, the Camillus side of 394,
Dr Rad 51:42
what’s our first category? Dr, G, military
Dr G 51:45
clout.
Dr Rad 51:47
All right. Well, I mean, I think this is pretty good. It’s kind of up there with Veii for me. I mean, it’s not a 10 year siege, sure. And I wouldn’t say that Falerii is quite as important as they but it’s still significant enough. Now
Dr G 52:00
there is a military component to the Roman victory over Falerii. I but ultimately they take it through negotiation, I would say, rather than military force. I mean, they do set up a siege, yeah,
Dr Rad 52:17
but there was that whole moment where the Falsicans were driven screaming past their camp to the walls of the city, and lots of them were killed, and they got to take the booty.
Dr G 52:26
Well, we wouldn’t want to forget that part of it, but we wouldn’t. We also have to take account of things like they’re also waging war against the aqueai. Apparently,
Dr Rad 52:39
they are, and that’s that, but that comes in the next part of my year. Oh, the Camillus part for me. Okay,
Dr G 52:45
well, I’ve already mentioned their war, so I’ll give them a point for that. How about a six? Okay,
Dr Rad 52:51
well, okay, all right,
Dr G 52:55
feel like I’m being pretty generous, considering they the way that they won the Falerii situation, hey,
Dr Rad 53:02
hey, that took some serious military ethics for them to win against the Faliscans. Thank you very much. But
Dr G 53:11
wait, because I think the very things that you’re wanting to give them points for, for military clout, they’re gonna get really strong scores for diplomacy and weirdos. So just hold your horses.
Dr Rad 53:24
Diplomacy, my four white horses. Hold
Dr G 53:26
your four white horses, but don’t use the bit of triumph at the risk of offending people.
Dr Rad 53:32
That’s a deep cut for people who have listened
Dr G 53:37
to it is in jokes only for our very niche listeners, thank you. Thank you. That’s right. The second category is diplomacy.
Dr Rad 53:44
Okay, fine, tell me, what do you want to give them for diplomacy? I want to give them 10. Wow. Okay, well, yeah, I mean, I feel like
Dr G 53:56
I have never seen any Roman be so diplomatic. They sent back all of the potential hostages. Said This is outrageous. One kid didn’t hold on to a single kid. They’re like, send them all home, because that’s where they belong with their families, and whip that teacher while you do it, young men. So yeah, so much diplomacy. And in some accounts, Camillus does seek advice from the Senate about how to proceed, which you could see as a bit of a diplomatic moment for him. And also, we’ve got the envoys from the Falerii being like, well, we weren’t ever going to give up, but you’ve managed to persuade us
Speaker 1 54:38
they’re gonna give you. Never gonna let you down. Well,
Dr G 54:42
yeah, they’re so floored by what Camillus has done. They’re like this changes everything we we give you the city. Tell us what you need.
Dr Rad 54:53
Yeah, you’re right. This is probably about the best diplomatic moment we might ever have.
Dr G 54:58
I I’m happy to hang my hat.
Dr Rad 55:00
Hated the people of a because it had been a situation that had dragged on for so long, but he’s still restrained and respectful of human life as much as a Roman can be in those situations, in that example as well. So this, to me, is just in keeping with that episode. Yeah,
Dr G 1:00:15
exactly. So on that score, I’m probably giving this about a seven, maybe
Unknown Speaker 1:00:20
a seven.
Dr Rad 1:00:23
Wow. Okay, why not higher, dare I ask? Well,
Dr G 1:00:26
I mean, he’s not showing off any wounds in front of everybody. So, you know, it’s not, it’s not classic, virtus. He
Dr Rad 1:00:33
kept his shirt on. You heard it here first everybody. Dr, G doesn’t want to give Camillus 10 out of 10, because he kept his shirt on correct shirts
Dr G 1:00:42
Shirts Off for Virtus. print that should be printed on the T shirts.
Dr Rad 1:00:48
I was gonna say that has to be our next t shirt.
Dr G 1:00:52
That’s, that’s the slogan I’m running with, and I hope it works out for
Dr Rad 1:00:56
me. Yeah, I’m literally looking on to red bubble right now.
Dr G 1:01:01
Excellent, excellent. All right.
Dr Rad 1:01:03
Well, look, I still think, Okay, I’m still gonna fight you on this. I still think he deserves an
Dr G 1:01:06
A, all right. Well, I’m gonna be open to persuasion there, sure. Why not? Okay, thank you. You were outraged. I was like, why that’s a great score.
Dr Rad 1:01:15
Well, considering that we’ve been mostly giving zeros, sure, but nonetheless, I still think that this is not going to be repeated too many times.
Dr G 1:01:23
I think you’re right about that. All right. This leads us to our last category, the citizen score. Okay,
Dr Rad 1:01:29
now, perhaps not quite as good for the Romans on this front, because it’s a bit middling, to be honest, a bit I mean, they do
Dr G 1:01:38
have to go to war on a number of fronts. So for the average Roman who is asked yet again to leave their harvest to go and stab some of their neighbors, I mean, it’s not the best time. And
Dr Rad 1:01:51
they don’t get booty. They don’t get the booty. Remember, it goes to the quaestors first.
Dr G 1:01:55
Well, they don’t get the booty. But do they do get paid? They do and
Dr Rad 1:01:59
by the enemy. Could it be any,
Dr G 1:02:02
yeah? I mean, those, those dollars, are pretty delicious when it comes from the feller. So all in all, it’s probably a five, yeah,
Dr Rad 1:02:13
because don’t forget as well that we also have this ongoing issue back at home over this whole idea of a colony at Vay, which Okay, the pleb seemed to have cooled off on the idea at this moment in our narrative. But nonetheless, there is still conflict and tension about it. Yeah, okay, so we’re saying a five.
Dr G 1:02:33
Yeah, we’re in a situation where things could be better. Yeah, I’m saying a five, all
Dr Rad 1:02:39
right. Dr, G, that means that the Romans receive a grand total of 29 out of 50 golden eagles. Oh, that’s pretty impressive, I know. And I really honestly, normally, I count the score on my fingers, to be totally honest, because it’s so low, I never need more than 10. So that was really putting me to the test. Oh, they’ve had a shocker recently. But, you know, well, actually, they haven’t. I think it’s just, I think it’s just a fact, for a long time they haven’t. We had that brief moment with Veii where it was pretty good, but see, even then, because we had to split it up into multiple episodes, they weren’t getting high scores every single episode. So
Dr G 1:03:19
now Rome’s back. Camillus is back. Rome’s back. It’s all happening. It is all
Dr Rad 1:03:24
happening. So Dr, G, I look forward to talking with you again and closing off this surprisingly epic year of 394, BCE,
Dr G 1:03:32
looking forward to it.
Dr Rad 1:03:40
Music. Thank you for listening to this episode of the partial historians. You can find our sources sound credits and an automated transcript in our show notes. Our music is by Bettina Joy De Guzman. The partial historians is part of the memory collective creators and educators dedicated to sharing knowledge that is accessible, contextualize, socially conscious and inclusive, to find more from the memory collective head to collective mem.com you too can support our show and help us to produce more fascinating content about the ancient world by becoming a Patreon or buy us a coffee on ko fi. In return, you receive ad free episodes and exclusive early access to our bonus content. Today, we would like to say salve to Naomi, Eric and Anders, who are enjoying their one year anniversary with us. Thank you so much for being part of our partial band. However, if you’re feeling like a crazy dictators, while policies have impacted your funds, please just tell someone about the show or give us a five star review until next time we are yours in ancient Rome.
Transcribed by https://otter.ai
The post Episode 162 – Shirts Off for Virtus! appeared first on The Partial Historians - Ancient Roman History with smart ladies.
In our latest special episode, we were positively tickled to be able to chat to Dr Jane Draycott about her latest historical biography Fulvia: The Woman who Broke All the Rules in Ancient Rome (published with Atlantic Books).
For the uninitiated, Fulvia is one of the more notorious characters from the Late Roman Republic. If you’ve heard of her, it is probably as the wife of Mark Antony – the one he first cheated on with Cleopatra. What an honour.
However, in this episode, you will get to hear why Dr Draycott thinks she is so much more than that. Join us to hear all about Fulvia’s other husbands, her many children and the rhetoric that destroyed her reputation.
Dr Jane Draycott is a historian and archaeologist and is currently Lecturer in Ancient History at the University of Glasgow. Her research interests are extensive and include: displays of extraordinary bodies in the ancient world; the depiction of the ancient world in computer games; and domestic medical practice in ancient Rome.
In 2023, Dr Draycott published Prosthetics and Assistive Technology in Ancient Greece and Rome with Cambridge University Press.
2022 was a huge year for Dr Draycott in terms of publications!
We know that you will be running out to get yourself a copy of Fulvia once you have heard the fascinating details shared in this episode.
And for keen listeners, rest assured that Dr Rad was keeping a tally throughout the interview of all of Augustus’ hideous crimes 🙂
Our music is provided by the wonderful Bettina Joy de Guzman.
Dr Rad 0:00
Welcome to a special episode of the partial historians today. We are joined by Dr Jane Draycott, who is a historian and archeologist and currently Lecturer in ancient history at the University of Glasgow. Her research interests are extensive and include displays of extraordinary bodies in the ancient world, the depiction of the ancient world in computer games and domestic medical practice in ancient Rome. In 2023 Dr Draycott published Prosthetics and Assistive Technology in Ancient Greece and Rome with Cambridge University Press. Now 2022 was a huge year for Dr Draycott in terms of publications. First, there was a co edited collection, Bodies of Evidence, Ancient anatomical Votives, Past, Present and Future with Routledge Then, there was a co edited volume, Women in Classical Video Games with Bloomsbury. Third, there was an edited volume, Women in Historical and Archeological Video Games with De Gruyter and fourth (and we’re already tired thinking about this much coming out all in one year) the biography Cleopatra’s Daughter, Egyptian princess, Roman Princess, African Queen Bloomsbury, which was all about Cleopatra Selene. So we are completely thrilled to be sitting down with Jane today to discuss her latest historical biography, Fulvia, the Woman who Broke all the Rules in Ancient Rome, which has been published with Atlantic books, Fulvia is one of the most fascinating women of the late Roman republic, very deserving of having a full length treatment. So we’re excited to get into the details, because she is rudely often overlooked for those. Julio Claudian hussies.
Dr G 2:00
hello and welcome to a brand new special episode of the partial historians. I am Dr G
Dr Rad 2:08
and I am Dr rad,
Dr G 2:10
and we are thrilled today to be sitting down with Jane Draycott to discuss her latest historical biography, fauvia, the woman who broke all the rules in ancient Rome. So Fulvia is one of the most fascinating women of the late Roman republic, so very deserving of having a full length treatment such as this one. And so we are very excited to get into all of the details. Welcome, Jane. Well,
Jane Draycott 2:42
hello. Thank you for having me. It
Dr G 2:45
is an absolute pleasure. It is a bit of a fan girl moment for me, because I love your work. And before we get too far into the nitty gritty details of Fulvia’s life, I’m wondering if you can tell us a little bit about what drew you to the study of Fulvia and what inspired you to write a biography about her different
Jane Draycott 3:07
ways I could try and answer this question, and I think all of them would be true in sort of some small measure. I mean, the first is that I suppose, as someone who has studied the Roman Republic and the early Roman imperial period for probably what, how do I do this about aging myself? And I’ve been teaching it for a long time as well. I’m a, sort of been broadly aware period, broadly aware of the historical characters in it. And to be honest, it’s never really been that interesting to me, because I’m more of a social historian. I’m not a political historian. I also really don’t find men that interesting. Sorry, male listeners, also
Dr G 3:53
ancient Rome,
Jane Draycott 3:55
yeah. So, so people, people like Cicero and Caesar. I’m just like and politics the same. I don’t really care about, you know, senatorial debates and that kind of stuff. I’m much more at the sort of from below sort of situation, you know, like, yes, okay, you’ve got the great men in Senate who are making all decisions. But what does that actually mean in day to day life for everybody else? And so I’ve never really paid a huge amount of attention to that sort of history. But when I wrote my first popular history book, Cleopatra’s daughter, and I focused on Cleopatra Selene And as part of that, I looked at Cleopatra and Antony and their relationship, and how Cleopatra Selene came to be, literally, I became sort of aware that there was a lot of other interesting stuff happening at that time. I mean, I teach a course on Cleopatra. I never really wanted to be someone who worked on or someone who people thought worked on Cleopatra, because it just seemed to be so obvious. You know, you’re sort of like, oh. You’re a woman, you’re a historian. Of course, you’re interested in Cleopatra because she’s, like, literally, the only you know, ancient woman who ever did anything interesting. And so you sort of, yeah, that’s exactly, that’s the reason. That is the that’s the reason why. But for me, because I worked on Greco Roman Egypt. That was my PhD, was on, you can’t really avoid Cleopatra. You can’t really avoid the sort of the end of Ptolemaic Egypt and the start of Rome in Egypt and everything that goes along with that. And if you work on sort of the late Republic, the Augustan Principate, you also can’t really ignore Antony and Octavian and the Second Triumvirate and that sort of thing. And so I guess I was looking for ways that I could approach this period from a different angle, an angle that I found personally interesting. Because I don’t, as I said, I don’t find men interesting. I certainly don’t find like male rivalry, you know, toxic masculinity, particularly interesting, either. And so cleopatraini was a way in, because she sort of breached Egypt and Rome and North Africa in the end. And there was a sort of a brief period where I touched on Fulvia, because, of course, Antony was married to Fulvia at the time that he met Cleopatra, and it did play into the perusing war and the sort of the the way that the the initial enmity between Antony and Octavian changed into this kind of rather fake, you know, bromance with with the Pact of Brundusium and the marriage of of Antony to Octavius sister’ Octavia. And so when I was looking for something to do for my next topic. And I did want to work on something female related, simply because I find, I find women interesting. I think that there, there is not so much about women, really, Roman women. I mean, if you go into the sort of the bookshop and you look at the shelves of the ancient history section, there is a lot of stuff about politicians like Caesar, military campaigns, about various different wars, and for women, you know, there are some things about the the judicallian empresses and stuff like that. But, and there’s loads about Cleopatra, inevitably, there’s a whole shelf of, there’s Tutankhamun and Cleopatra, that is the the Egypt section.
Dr G 7:25
That’s all you get people that’s all of Egypt,
Unknown Speaker 7:29
3000 years apart. But sure, whatever, you know. And so basically, I was sort of thinking about, Okay, well, what, what would be the logical thing to do here? And my agent and my editor, they actually said, Well, you know, what about this phobia character? She sounds quite interesting. And so I sort of thought right then, and I started, I started looking a little bit more because I came into it from, you know, she was married to Anthony, and she was the victim of a lot of sort of hostile invective. But when I read more about her, I was like, Oh, she actually, Anthony is the very end of her very interesting life. You know, he is her last husband. He is, he’s one small part of a much longer and more interesting life. Because that’s, that’s the other thing as well. It’s that ancient history is one of those funny things where people sort of pop up and suddenly, you know they’re 30 years old, or 40 years old, or whatever else, but you’ve never heard of them before because the ancient historiography just didn’t think they were interesting. That ancient writers don’t care about children. They don’t care about people’s early lives. They they only really care about once. Once they’re sort of adults and they are doing military or whatever sorts of things. And so I found that she was actually very interesting. She was very active. She there was a lot that could potentially be said about her, and it was also what she represents, as well as someone who is very literally on the point where the Republic dies and the Empire was born, and she’s right there. And she is, as I argue in the book towards the end, she is actually, I think we could see her as one of those individuals in history where there really is this kind of point where things could have gone very different ways. And she was right there, and she was involved in that, if she, if she hadn’t died, when she had died, and and things might have turned out quite differently. And obviously various people, I guess you could say all people are important, and all people have, you know, an effect, a ripple effect, what we do. But some people are a bit more important and a bit more ripple creating than others. And I think Fulvia was one of those people, and because she is a woman in this time, she’s not had as much attention as if she had been a man in the same situation. So think about Antony, for example, and how much attention he has got. I mean, even he has fallen victim to. Of being Caesar’s sidekick, you know, and Octavians, sort of, you know, the loser of the of the battle between them, and Cleopatra sidekick, too. Whereas thing Antony and his own right is very interesting. There is a lot that could be said, and it hasn’t been said because it’s been sort of covered over by other looking at other people or other events. And so I think we’ll, we can talk a little bit later, I suppose, about why Fulvia isn’t more widely known. I mean, people who study ancient history know about her because she’s, she’s one of the women of the late Republic. You know, along with Servilia and Caesar’s daughter, Julia and Cicero’s wife and daughter, that they we know who they were, and we know that they were important to these people in this period, but she hasn’t had that, that sort of very lavish popular history, TV, film, etc, treatment at all. So I think a lot of people don’t necessarily know her, but they know the period, and so doing a book about her allows them to approach the period in a different way, and see it from a different perspective, someone who’s not a consul or a general or a senator, but who is on the periphery of all of those things.
Dr Rad 11:11
I know it is crazy that there hasn’t been a movie about Fulvia when you actually think about how action packed her life seems to
Jane Draycott 11:20
be. It is. It is interesting. I mean, when you, when you think about the way that this period tends to show up on film, it’s pretty much always about Caesar. It’s, it’s, it’s following Caesar through his career and then to his assassination. And if it goes beyond that, the it then pivots to Cleopatra, when you, when you when you think of it like that, and the way that TV shows and films are sort of created primarily in a sort of by by by male creatives, the big the big budget ones that are seen as sort of epic. It’s primarily male directors, male writers, and it’s about men, male, male actors playing these male characters. And they don’t really have a lot of women in them, you know, if they have women, it is as the sort of the the love interest. And so if you’ve got, you’ve already got Cleopatra and she, she is sort of, literally every single sort of a woman you could possibly want rolled into one that you can put on film. And then as a foil, you’ve got Octavia, who is you the good girl, the lovely, kind, gentle, caring, Roman wife, Roman mother. And there’s no room for Fulvia there, because you’ve already got, you know, the ball buster and and the sort of the the vamp and the sort of the the kind of aggressive, power hungry, money hungry, whatever, woman in the form of Cleopatra. And so you can’t, you know, have two of those. I mean, this is why I think if there was a story of Mark Antony’s life and you, you would have to include Fulvia. And I think you could sufficient, if you want, if you cared to, you could differentiate full beer and Cleopatra very much. But in, in in TV and films, it’s like, well, another woman, another female character, you know, too confusing. Too many women here already. They’re just
Dr G 13:17
taking up too much space. Well,
Dr Rad 13:20
let’s think a little bit about this, because obviously one of the issues for a woman in ancient Rome, as opposed to someone like Cleopatra in ancient Egypt, in that they couldn’t really hold anything officially, in terms of political office. So I’m going to really embarrass you and quote you to yourself, a woman could not hold any sort of political or military office herself, yet she might exert influence upon those who could. So let’s talk a little bit about a different husband of Fulvia. How do we see this particular idea upheld when it comes to thinking about Fulvia’s first marriage to Clodius Pulcher, a person who probably also deserves his own movie because of the controversy he excited in his lifetime. And yet, where is it Hollywood? Where is it? You
Jane Draycott 14:07
know, it’s funny. Where you said you were going to quote my words back to me. I have the brain of a bird, so as soon as I finish something, I feel about
Dr Rad 14:16
it. I’m glad I’m not alone in that. So I was like,
Jane Draycott 14:19
it doesn’t embarrass me, because I’m like, Oh yeah, that’s good. Those are good words. Yes, I find I thank Clodius quite interesting, and for much the same reasons, actually, as several other people at this period, in that we do not we do not know what he looked like. We have no portrait of him. We do not have any thing from his perspective or anything else. Everything about him is is mediated through primarily Cicero, who obviously hated his guts and and sort of other people as well, who who found him rather problematic because of his his sort of when it comes to Fulvia’s marriage to him. I mean, the thing. We don’t really know very much about that at all. We know that happened because she is obviously involved in the sort of events surrounding Clodius’ death and the funeral and the riot and the trial of Milo. So that is where we hear about Fulvia for the very first time. So we don’t know when she was born, and we don’t know really much about her, her childhood. We can, we can sort of venture to reconstruct based on knowledge of who her parents were and what their situation was. And you know that she had two children with with Clodius, so she’s, you know, a relatively, relatively young as Roman girls women were when they first married to marry him, and she has this marriage, and these children, and what we what we know about their marriage is based on what Cicero tells us when he’s trying to blacken Clodius’ reputation, he tries to argue, in the ultimate act of victim blaming the man that got, you know, brutally murdered in the street and then run over by their horses and carriages and things like that. But it was all his own fault, because he actually, he was planning to murder Milo himself, but he severely, you know, underestimated how large Milo’s entourage was and how many, you know, gladiators with with lethal weapons would happen to be in it at that point in time. And so the thing that Cicero tried, that the smoking gun for Cicero is, is that clearly close was up to no good, because usually Fulvia went everywhere with him, and on that particular day she was not there. And why was she not there? This is suspicious. And so the interesting thing about that is, is like, Well, I mean, you could say a lot about Cicero’s attitude to women, including his own wives, but the idea that it’s weird for a Roman man to want to spend time with his wife.
Dr Rad 14:20
Gives me goosebumps just thinking about it.
Dr G 16:58
What is Roman masculinity?
Jane Draycott 17:00
is, I think this is interesting for us to think about from from Fulvia’s introduction to politics. I mean, we know that her own father was not really a political animal. He had a speech impairment, and so that might have been part of it. He just didn’t. He was just rich and that, well, that was fine, not everybody. I mean, this is the other thing about the Roman Republic. We get this sense, everybody’s constantly trying to be the Consul General. And actually, a lot of guys were just like, You know what? I’m going to enjoy traveling around the ancient Mediterranean. Enjoy my villas. I’m going to enjoy, you know, my my my philosophical works, etc. But her stepfather, her mother, her parents divorced, and her mother remarried someone who became a consul, and was was at this very point in the in the sort of late 60s. So she certainly had sort of access to politics, you know, with her, with her stepfather, the Consul, and it was through him, it’s, it’s thought that her marriage to Clodius was arranged because the pair of them were connected. And so I think that there’s something there that we can think about, that she, her marriage gives her sort of portray in into Roman politics and Roman populist politics. I mean, she, her three husbands, are all we could say populist politicians. They all hold the office of Tribune, so they all have a specific political position we, I wouldn’t go so far as to call it ideology, but, you know, they have certain ways of doing things, and so she is given, I would say I would see it as a introduction to this world, and this, this way of of potentially attempting to connect with the plebs, the the generally ordinary people, the extent to which any of The Roman populist politicians genuinely cared about the plebs. I cared about the plebs. I mean, we can, we can debate that. I think till the cows come home. It is actually
Dr Rad 18:48
probably something we should unpack for our audience, so our listeners would be very familiar with the idea that the tribune of the plebs is a troublesome person who is out there to make politics difficult for everybody. However, it’s a little different, because we’re in the 390s BCE, and this is much, much later. This is hundreds of years later. Perhaps we can quickly unpack the landscape of late Republican politics and this idea of the big clash that’s happening between those who are trying to rule through more populist measures and those who disdain such politics.
Jane Draycott 19:26
Disclaimer, I did say earlier, though I’m not, I’m not really one for the for the political history, but I do think it’s something that happens in this period. So what we see in the first century BCE is this this increasing dominance by individuals and they, they are obstructing political business for their own benefits. So we have Sulla, we have Marius. We have the first triumvirate of Caesar and Pompey, and Crassus ,Antony. We have Octavian, and they are all stepping outside of the system the way that it was designed. So they they are not holding power for the short periods of time that they are supposed to. They they extend and extend and extend their Imperium, and they make sure that their armies are loyal only to them, rather than to the state as a whole. And I mean, I sort of again, I think that I wouldn’t go so far as to say it’s exactly the same as what’s happening today, but you can see why people would become, shall we say, dissatisfied and discontented with the political system that it is dominated by a handful of extremely wealthy individuals who do not really care about anything except themselves and sort of limited circle of other people, and are using all the they have their disposal. And these powers are considerable, not to make other people’s lives better, but to just enrich themselves, give themselves the the best assignments and things like that. So one of the things I find quite interesting about Caesar’s assassination is that there was this period where, when Caesar came back from Egypt from the civil wars, that there are apparently all these ideas that he had. And we hear about some of them in Suetonius and Plutarch, but he was going to alter the course of the Tiber, for example. And he’s going to do this because the Campus Martius, and then the part of Rome where the Tiber bends around, was prone to flooding horribly boggy and stagnant and unhealthy. And by changing the course of Tiber could actually be an improvement for people’s like the ordinary people’s lives in the city of Rome and other other initiatives like that. And so on the one hand, the the ancient historians are like, oh, you know, he thinks he’s a god. Make these big, enormous, sweeping changes to the way that things have always been, and we don’t like that. And for ordinary people, like, Well, my house isn’t going to flood anymore, and I’m not going to die of malaria. I think that’s pretty good. Yeah.
Dr G 21:52
I mean the time, it does have this terrible reputation,
Jane Draycott 21:55
when the when the so called liberators, Brutus and Cassius and all their cronies. They assassinated Caesar, and they just assumed that everybody would be as happy about it as they were, and the entire city just sort of looks at them, and they’re like, What did you do? Why did you do that? And we’re going to kill you. Run up to the capital, and they’re like, hide themselves in the temple. Because they’re just like, Oh, whoops. We didn’t have Canberra afterwards. We just thought everyone would be as happy about it as we are, because our senatorial dignity has been tarnished by, you know, Caesar clemency. And it’s like, yeah, that’s exactly what everyone else cared about. You know, you cared about your senatorial dignity, and not you know how they were going to eat and you know how they were going to sort of support their families and everything else?
Dr G 22:44
No, no. But I think it’s really interesting, because what it does is it sets up the idea that the politics of this period is really at a knife’s edge, like people are holding the extremities of their positions, whether they are coming from that tribunate position of I’m supposed to be upholding the will of the people in particular ways, or they’re coming from that more senatorial position of the consulship and those more rigorous prestige positions on the cursus honorum, everybody is heading towards great and greater extremity. And I think this actually flows in nicely into thinking about Fulvia’s reputation, because everybody is so on edge that everybody is willing to take the nth degree in the way that they pursue their opinions about topics and people. And she has an incredible reputation in the ancient sources. So I’m keen to know a little bit more about what are some of the big accusations that are leveled against her. So you’ve sort of foreshadowed Cicero a little bit, but I’m sure he’s not going to be the only one who comes up here.
Jane Draycott 23:54
So I think Cicero starts it to be perfectly honest. I mean, he it’s interesting the way that when he talks about Fulvia in relation to Clodius, he mentions her a couple of times in a very sort of detached way. He’s he’s talking more about Clodius than he is about her. And I think it’s interesting that 10 years or so later, when he’s talking about her in relation to Antony, he talks about her in a very different way, and how much of that is about phobia herself, and the way that her, her behavior has changed. That’s probably part of it is that, you know, back back in the day, when she was a sort of young, you know, early 20 something widow, there was only so much you could really say about her in public. And then towards the end, when, when she’s a mature woman, mother of five, and very much involved in in political and military business, he can say different things about her. And of course, the standard way that you go about directing sort of negative. Of invective, oratory, etcetera, towards your enemies as you is you criticize things like their masculinity. I mean, in some respects, nothing really much has changed. You know, you attack people based on certain characteristics. And one of those characteristics, this is where Antony gets attacked, first, over Fulvia, later, over Cleopatra. So Cicero in his Philippics, really. And so in some of his letters, I mean, they weren’t, they weren’t necessarily widely disseminated at the time. You know, you get from his his letters, this is what he does, actually think what he’s talking to his friends about, and he is criticizing the amount that Fulvia is involved in the business of running Rome, because Antony, he is away. He is He is off doing military things, first in the sort of the triangle period, when when there was the sort of the civil war against the the liberators, and then subsequently, when he is off in the east, sorting out the mess that the civil war left behind that so he’s not there. And so who is running things in his absence? Well, the person who always runs everything in the absence of the patio familias, and this is, this is not something new, really. When, when Cicero was in exile after his his consulship, who was running things for him, his wife Terentia, was running things she she was running her her estates, his estates. She was trying to deal with the consequences of his exile. She was trying to arrange marriage for their daughter, etc. And so Fulvia is is basically no different to any other Roman senatorial wife, because in this period, wives did not go on campaigns with their husbands. They did not go with them to their their provinces. When they were being a provincial governor, they stayed at home. And so while they were at home, they were running things in their husband’s absence. They were the ones that were seeing, you know, the the clients, and acting as patron and sort of doing that kind of thing. And so this is what Fulvia’s doing. She is She is basically acting in Antony’s place while Antony is away. And Cicero is not happy about this. I mean, he’s not happy about what Antony is doing, but he’s also not happy about the fact that Fulvia is is the means by which he’s doing it. Yeah. So, so the reason, then, that we we get such negative accounts of Fulvia is is partnered with what Cicero was writing at the time, and Cicero’s perspective, and also octavians perspective as well, with the poetry he wrote and the propaganda surrounding the perusing war. But also later than that, in 40 BCE, when Antony, and Octavian. Fulvia has died, conveniently, it must be said for both of them, and they form the Pact of Brundisium and Anthony marries Octavia. There is this agreement that the convenient and expedient thing to do, basically blame everything on Fulvia so that the two guys can wipe the slate clean, and they can make their alliance, and they can make the marriage, and they can enter a new era as as sort of brothers, not just brothers in arms, but actual brothers, because they’re linked now by marriage. And so that’s the second stage of it. Is this agreement that will blame everything on Fulvia. And then later than that, once Octavian is the last man standing, and he becomes Augustus. He spends the next, sort of 40 years of his life, and brain attempting to whitewash everything that he did earlier. And so in the in the progress of the process of him doing that, there are people that he ends up using to sort of hang all the bad stuff on. So, you know, the prescriptions, that’s not his fault. He was young, he was innocent, he was he was overruled by Anthony and Lepidus. And also Fulvia because, you know, she was adding, adding names to the prescriptions as well, and and so this is, I suppose it sort of crystallizes in the Augustan principled and then all of our latest sources who were drawing on this period as the history being written by the victors, that sort of thing. They are using those official stories. And so as time goes on, Fulvia becomes more and more and more of a villain, until we get to Cassius Dio who is the one with the really sort of lurid account of how she abused Cicero’s head. And Dio, he has, he has lots of he loves a little bit of color. I mean, his his descriptions of Cleopatra lying on her couch and attempting to seduce Octavian by showing him Caesar’s love letters and things that the weirdest seduction strategy you can imagine. You want
Dr Rad 29:33
to hear what got your great uncle going.
Jane Draycott 29:35
I know, like father, like son, you know, yeah.
Dr Rad 29:40
But the Romans, I mean, let’s face it, they do like that kind of stuff, right? They do like following in the footsteps of their fathers, not
Jane Draycott 29:47
as much as the Ptolemies, I think. Yeah.
Dr Rad 30:20
The interesting thing, I suppose, about this late Republican period is that there are quite a few women running around, seemingly violating these traditional standards of behavior, particularly those for women. And so you’ve got Julia the Elder, for example, Augustus, only biological child, who infamously ends up in exile because of her bad behavior. And of course, you also have to go back to the Clodii, Clodia Metelli. What is it that makes her different from them, like, How is her behavior and the way that she breaks the rules different to those sorts of women in some ways,
Jane Draycott 30:55
I don’t think it really is. It’s, it’s that she’s, she’s unlucky in that she is the one who is held up as as the sort of, the paragon of bad behavior, and through, through her links to, to Antony. So this is one of the interesting things about her, because, on the one hand, a lot of what she was doing, I don’t think was particularly different. And yes, I mean, potentially, she she was, she was breaking rules, in the sense of, you know, that whole thing about the the letter of the law and the spirit of the law, but she wasn’t doing anything that lots of other women weren’t also doing in this period, but the prominence that she comes to because of who it is that she happens to be married to, and The the fact that he is drawing so much criticism from from the person who I mean, if we if we didn’t have Cicero’s letters and his speeches, I think our view of the late Republic and the fall of the Republic would be quite different. And it is interesting that we have two separate accounts of the Capitol area and conspiracy and but from people who were there at the time, and the Cicero’s tells us one thing, and Salus tells us something different, or puts quite a different spin on it. And so, you know, it’s something that I think should be born in mind that the sources are hostile towards her, but the the source is hostile towards her, that the two, the two people who, the person who writes about this period is, is hostile towards her and her husband and her previous husband as well. Um, it’s also one of the reasons I think I don’t really have a problem with with Fulvia, supposedly, like enjoying the fact that that Cicero was was murdered because he’d been a thorn in her side for years. He had defended the man who had murdered her first husband and who had apparently planned to murder her son, the man who drove Antony out of out of Rome, and meant that she was being targeted and her other children were being targeted, and who were making very inflammatory speeches and writing about her. I mean, really, is it a bad thing that she was pleased that he was there? So, you know, thinking, oh
Dr Rad 33:07
yeah, Sister sounds like a jerk from her point of view, from her, from her perspective. And also remember
Jane Draycott 33:11
that Claudia had been her sister in law, and had probably been someone that she because she was older, she she was probably someone who she admired and, and, and thought was, was, yes, this is the kind of, the kind of life I want to lead, to be this sort of rich and influential woman with this great life, I kind of, I want some of that for myself. And so, you know, Cicero wrote the pro killio and destroyed, you know, Claudia’s reputation. So, so he had done a lot of wrong to her and the people that she loved, and even if she didn’t necessarily love them that much, they were still her family. They were still people that were associated with her. And so I don’t think it’s unreasonable for phobia to be very anti Cicero. And I think it’s more unreasonable for Cicero to be anti phobia, to be perfectly honest, because how much of it was his, his own personal sort of opinion of her, and how much of it was him using her as a way to get to other people. And that’s, you know, she’s collateral damage in his campaign against against Anthony. Yeah, that’s
Dr G 34:17
that’s not fair, definitely. And there’s this moment where, in the wake of the murder of Clodius, she is sometimes attributed as giving a public speech, which seems to be quite moving to the people of Rome. And I wonder if that’s where it started for Cicero, because Cicero has the task of defending the murderer, and all of a sudden, things are being swayed by somebody who ultimately is outside of the rhetorical tradition, or ought to be. She may have had theoretical training, but she’s not supposed to be good. At it, and she’s not supposed to be standing up and saying stuff like this in public, and effectively maybe showing him up. And so I wonder if that’s where Cicero started. He’s
Jane Draycott 35:13
chewing for some reason he finds plastic bags incredibly tasty, and obviously it’s not really something he should be hunting. But back to the question. I mean, this is, this is another example, actually, of Fulvia doing something that is not actually a bad thing for her to have done. So women were responsible for the funeral, or a lot of the sort of funerary rights. They were the ones who were supposed to, sort of, you know, prepare the deceased, and they were the ones who were supposed to mourn and, you know, wail and tear their hair, tear their skin, rend their clothes, etc. And so she’s not doing something that, or at least see the thing that she’s doing, the very basic kind of fundamental core of it is what she’s meant to be doing as a Roman woman who has who has been bereaved. It’s then how she is developing that, or how she is potentially steering that in the direction that she wants it to go. And yes, the direction that obviously other people like Cicero and Milo don’t want it to go. They don’t they don’t want people to feel bad for Clodius, you know, the husband and the father. They want people to think, oh yes, that that rabble rouser, he’s gone. That’s brilliant. And so I think this is something that we sort of see with her again and again, is that the things that she does are very sort of standard, traditional Roman Republican Woman things to do, but the way that she perhaps does them, the way that she expands them, the way that other people see them as as inconvenient. This is what draws the ire and that it’s possible to put this negative slant on it. Because perhaps, you know, she’s very high profile, she’s she’s very visible, she’s first. She’s She’s Clodius’ wife, and if she’s with him all the time, then people can see her. And then she’s Antony’s wife. And if she’s with him, or she’s with him when he’s when he’s around, and if she’s acting in his stead when he’s not, again, she’s very visible. She’s making herself visible because she needs to remind people of Antony. I mean, this is because, partly the the the one of the motivations for the Perusine war is that Antony is not around, and Octavian is attempting to woo the soldiers and the Veterans away from Antony by giving them like land that that has been promised to them and making him their patron. And so Fulvia, along with Antony’s Brother, don’t forget, and his brother, Lucius, who is Consul at that time. The pair of them are like, no, no, hang on. You know, Antony deserves to be involved in this. He deserves the credit for this. You you can’t do this. And cut him out of it completely. And so Fulvia is there to represent Antony. She’s got his sons, their sons with her, to represent the next generation. And this is the other thing I think that that is important to remember, is that she’s got five children. You know, she she is pretty much the ideal Roman wife, because she has produced children for all three of her husbands. She’s given all three of them a son. In Antony’s case, she gave
Dr G 38:19
them two. I mean, that’s incredible, good work. You know that is, that is peak Roman woman, right there.
Jane Draycott 38:26
I mean, she, she is married to her second husband, cheerio, for, like, literally a matter of months before he goes off to Africa and he leaves her with, you know, his his son. He’s his only son. So, you know she, she is she, she did better than Livia. She did better than Octavia. You know, Octavia had, like one, one boy out of about five children. Livia had had two sons with her first husband, but didn’t have any, any children at all with with Octavian. So she is actually the kind of woman that that Roman women in this period should be aspiring to be, because she is. She’s ticking all the boxes. I mean, this is what makes it so funny, really, that she and so sad, that she gets the criticism that she gets. Because realistically, she is doing that is expected of a Roman matron, and yet, because she’s doing it for the wrong people, it becomes something that that she, she loses all of the positives, and she, you know, the negatives are amplified.
Dr G 39:26
It sounds like some people might be jealous and are trying to ruin her reputation, but I think you’ve touched on the children, and this is a nice lead into thinking about them. What is fulvius legacy in terms of her children. Do we know anything about what happened to them?
Jane Draycott 39:44
Tha patchy nature of ancient Roman history is that we don’t know very much about people that we really should know about. And so one of the things that we don’t tend to know about is what children were doing, what happened to children. And and what you end up having to do is, if they don’t make it into the sort of literary, uh, sources of the period, you end up having to do sort of prospography with inscriptions and things like that to try and find out what happened to people. And so Fulvia has five children. She has a son and a daughter with with Clodius. And we know about the son because he is mentioned in the course of the sort of the trial of Milo, because there is this suggestion that Milo, after murdering Clodius, was going to go to the villa and murder the young the young boy, the young Claudius. Then we hear about him in a letter that Antony sends to Cicero some years later, when Anthony was married to Fulvia, and he is he’s close young Clodius or Claudius, and he seems to go by Claudius, his he’s a stepfather, and he’s sort of, essentially, he’s trying to get Cicero to just let it go with his sort of enmity with with Clodius, and sort of agree to kind of focus on the next generation. And at this time, Cicero is sort of sucking up to ants. He’s like, Yes, all right, then and then after that, what we hear about just just briefly in a later source, is that however much promise he had as a young man, he basically goes off the rails and sort of eats himself to death and falls into a life of dissipation. We have his funerary urn with with his sort of epitaph on it, and that allows us to sort of reconstruct his political career. So he has the standard cursus honorum political career, but because he’s having it under the Augustan principle, where everybody’s focused on the imperial family, we just don’t really hear anything about it. So he has what seems to be a sort of a normal senatorial life in this period. And that’s that’s basically it. Her daughter Claudia, after she’s divorced by Octavian we don’t hear anything about her again. And so possibly, possibly she died, possibly She remarried, and just had, you know, again, the standard Roman life of marriage, children, etc, with the three younger boys. That’s where things I think are really sad. And this is, this is one of the things that doesn’t get so much attention. So Young Curio, he goes to Egypt with Antony and Antony’s and Fulvia’s oldest son, Antyllus. So clearly, Antony has has been this boy’s father. He’s been married to Fulvia since, since he was a baby. He was Curio’s, one of curious closest friends. So I think it’s quite nice that Antony sort of stepped in and married Fulvia and sort of took on her three prior children. But this is, this is very bad for this young man, because he’s he is around 18 when the invasion of Egypt happens, and Octavian murders him. He comes to a sticky end because of who his his stepfather and his mother are. The same thing happens to Antyllus. Antyllus is murdered, and he is even younger. He’s 16 or so when, when he’s murdered in Egypt. So that’s two of Fulvia’ssons gone around about the same time. Antyllus gets more attention because he’s included in the Plutarch Life of Antony, which is where we get most of our details of this at the end of this period in Egypt from. And then Curio is just mentioned briefly in a different source. And then the one that everybody, I think knows the most about is Ulus, the youngest, and he is raised by Octavia. So he he is only a bottler, perhaps when Fulvia dies in 40 and so he ends up going into Octavius household during her marriage to Antony. And so he probably didn’t have any memories of his father, or very, very few memories of his father, because Antony spent most of his his, you know, the next sort of 10 years between, between the marriage to Octavia and his death, off in Egypt or off in the east or trying to campaign against papius. So, so Iullus doesn’t really have any memories of his mother or his father. He’s been raised by Octavia, and he again, like his oldest brother, probably as Clodius Pulcher. He he goes off the cursus honorum. He reaches the point of consul. He’s never allowed to command an army or govern a province. He’s kept very close to to Augustus in Rome. And then he gets tangled up with Julia and her intrigues and her adulteries. And he, he is forced to fall on his sword over that. And so, except for, well, we don’t know what happened to Claudia, the daughter, but the four boys all come to quite sad, pathetic ends in one way or another, and three of them die by violence at the hands or or sort of indirectly, at the hands of Octavian or Augustus, and so I don’t know how much of that we can attribute to his feelings about Fulvia. He doesn’t seem to have liked her very much. His poetry on the subject and the way that he campaigns against her in the in the Perusine War, that seems to imply that he’s quite anti Fulvia, possibly because she represents all the things about women that he really doesn’t like, but that it’s probably part of it that he wants to make sure that there is literally nothing left of Fulvia or Antony in Rome that can be a problem for him during his his reign.
Dr Rad 45:17
It is wild, though, how those families keep intertwining. I mean, the fact that Fulvia could have been octavians mother in law. I mean, was who she
Jane Draycott 45:26
was, yes, yeah. And Claudia had been a little bit older, and if she had had a child with Octavian, you know, again, it’s these things. Of things might have been quite different, because Octavian only has Julia with with his his second wife, scribonia, and she, she becomes very important for the Julio-Claudian dynasty, because she is, she’s literally the, the only sort of direct line of descent from from Octavian, as opposed to Octavia.
Dr Rad 45:56
absolutely crazy. And then for one of their children to be so enmeshed in Julia, he’s one biological child’s downfall. It is crazy. So Fulvia obviously lived at a time that we very much see now looking back as a crossroads for Rome, that tipping point from Republic to Empire, and given that the Romans were a big fan of the exemplar when they were writing their histories. So these examples of how to live your life or how not to live your life, can you perhaps explain what Fulvia’s potential legacy would have been for people living under Octavian slash, Augustus and then into the Julio Claudian dynasty? This
Jane Draycott 46:37
is a really interesting thing to think about, because there is this question of how long were people’s memories. And one of the things that Tacitus actually he when he opens the the Annals, he opens it with the death of Augustus in in 14. And one of the things he talks about is how, basically, because Augustus had lived so long, you know, he was, he was 74 or so when he died. And so he had been in control of the the the Empire, really, for 44 years, and had plenty of time to sort of rewrite history to his liking. And so he talks about the fact that one of the reasons that Augustus is able to do this is because literally, everybody else was dead, and nobody, nobody alive, remembered what it was like. Or very few people remembered what it was like to live under, well, a functioning Republic. I mean, some of them did remember what it was like to live in in sort of times of horrific Civil War where people were being murdered in the streets, and their bodies threw in the Tiber and prescribed and all the rest of it. And so he’s sort of like they were seduced by the promise of peace. And like, Oh yeah, Tacitus, that’s terrible. You know this idea that you might actually be able to live your life and grow to old age and see your children grow up and not be in danger of assassination or or street gangs or conscription or whatever else. Yeah, so bad
Dr Rad 48:05
to not have their father brutally murdered in the street and have to start a riot,
Jane Draycott 48:09
exactly. And so with the question of Fulvia, the the interesting thing is, is that how, how long did people remember her for bearing in mind? She was sort of replaced by Octavia. She was replaced by Cleopatra, and there were attempts made to present Roman women in a different way. So part of octavians strategy was to highlight Octavia, to highlight Livia, and to present them as these paragons of Roman womanhood, and to give them the same sort of legal and sort of religious protection that the best virgins and the Caribbeans had to make it make them sacrosanct, so that they couldn’t be used against him the way that he had used Fulvia and Cleopatra against Antony. And so there is this. This is a concerted attempt through this period to sort of rebrand Roman women, I suppose. I mean we have, we have the Augustan or the sort of moral legislation, the attempts to get both women and men married and having babies for the Roman state, and the attempts to keep the senatorial and equestrian orders separate from the lower orders and stop people marrying foreigners and non citizens and things like that. So there is this attempt being made to tell Roman women that you you should be like this. You should behave like this. In the material record, we see things like the araparius and all of the the coins and the cameos that present this image of, you know, woman, babies, etc. And I mean, we know with the times that we’re living through that it’s not that easy that you the state, can tell people all day long that you should get married, you should have children, you should behave like this, and plenty of people can say no, thank you. You know, get get your your nose out of my private life. Get out of my bedroom. I’m going to do what I want to do. Do. And we know that he wasn’t so successful because he kept having to reintroduce more moral legislation to try and get people behaving the way he wanted them to. So Fulvia is also she is mentioned in the histories as as time goes on. She’s always being mentioned alongside Antony and Cleopatra and everything else. So clearly people remembered her, and they they had a certain amount of information about her. And the thing that I think is is really thought provoking, is the way that the women of the imperial family behave in in the sort of the next few decades. So you have Octavia and Livia, for example, who are trying very hard to be as public as they can be, but in very sort of specific ways. You know, they’re presenting themselves as wives and mothers, and they’re quite successful at that. They it’s the where it starts to fall down is this sort of subsequent generation. So you see Julia the Elder and Julia the Younger being really quite stupid
Speaker 1 51:05
with their adulteries and their conspiracies. It’s like, really very risky you’re doing this so, you know, okay,
Jane Draycott 51:13
and then you have Agrippina the elder and Agrippina the younger and Messalina as well. And there are elements of the things that they do. They the accusations made against them, the allegations about their behavior. These are quite similar to Fulvia you have this so Agrippina and Messalina are both accused of having people killed so that they can seize their property. So this, this seems to be this, this sort of standard accusation against women. Women are greedy and they covet things that they’ve got no business coveting. And good men find themselves coming to bad ends because these women want their villas and want their gardens I mean, it’s funny, really, because one of the one of the things I think is quite amusing about Fulvia is that she’s never accused of wanting, you know, jewelry and pretty dresses and all the stuff that women are supposed to want. She she’s accused of wanting money and property and power and and diplomatic, you know, advantage and things, which I think is great,
Dr Rad 52:12
which is similar to Agrippina, isn’t it? Because when Nero tries to bribe her with dresses, she’s like, nooo, thank you!
Dr G 52:19
Not my flavor, actually. And
Jane Draycott 52:21
I mean that that in itself, gives us a perspective on Roman women, that that, you know, that that we all of the sort of the sum tree legislation and things like that, and the the all the writing about the cosmetics and the perfume and the the silk and the things that that women are spending their husband’s money on. It’s like, well, yeah, some women, maybe not all women. You know, some women were like, I’ve got my own jewelry and my own silk man, because my thanks. I want some other stuff. I want the stuff that actually matters. But, but, yeah, so. And we see with acropony The elder the the her involvement in Germanicus is military campaigns, the fact that she goes with him, the fact that she she uses their marriage and their children in the camp, and is able to transfer some of the troops loyalty from Germanicus to her and to her children, particularly Caligula, who would, of course, grow up to sort of try and take advantage of that. And so it is this all, is this all coincidental? Are these women just doing this stuff with no knowledge of Fulvia, or no interest in Fulvia, or was there a sort of a slightly more calculated approach to it, that just as as I said earlier, she she was actually a pretty good Roman wife and mother. She was doing the things that Roman wives and mothers are expected to do, and so were women looking to her and thinking, Oh, yes, I will do some of that. But then they too, found that there is clearly a very fine, almost invisible line as to what it’s okay to do and what it’s not okay to do, and especially for high profile women who are very visible to to members of the public, like the imperial family, they they seem to have have difficulty. I mean, Livia has difficulty. It’s one thing. During the the reign of Augustus, she seems to get away with literally everything that she wants to do. But when it comes to the reign of Tiberius, he is like no mother go away. You know, I’m a 50 year old man. I’m not having you tell me what to be involved in my reign. And he, he does very much try and put the brakes on everything that Augustus had apparently been happy enough with her doing. And so, yeah, when women can go so far, but when they, when they reach that invisible fine
Dr G 54:42
line, well, it seems like the fine, the fine line might just be being on the more powerful side, essentially, because what Agrippina the elder is doing is actually very similar to what Fulvia is doing. As you say, and you. For both of them, it works out quite differently, because one is in the imperial family at that stage, and obviously they’re holding all of the cards. And Fulvia is not furious.
Jane Draycott 55:11
Is not happy about Agrippa and the elder either. I mean, he is very angry about her behavior, and is treats her very brutally after the death of Germanicus. So she she is sort of, she manages, for a little while, while Germanicus is alive, she manages to sort of thread this needle. But once he’s gone and she’s lost her male protector, then it is a different matter. She is much more vulnerable. He refuses to allow her to remarry, because he he doesn’t. He doesn’t want to face any more influential men or any more Imperial babies. And this is, this is something that Fulvia, I mean, she, she had experienced the death of two husbands that left her vulnerable, but she always had another husband that she she could then turn to to protect her and and the same thing with with Livia, for example, she she is protected during the life of her husband, but then once her husband is gone, she she has lost her plausible deniability. As long as your husband is letting you do things, it’s fine. And then as soon as he’s He’s gone, he’s not doing it. Other people have got things they want to say about it, even your son, or your horrible son,
Dr G 56:20
really interesting to think about, isn’t it, this whole period is just such a fascinating moment in Rome’s history, and we’re so lucky to have so many sources. I think this is part of how we get to that sense of it being interesting, because I’m sure every period of history has the capacity to be as interesting. And it’s just we’re lacking source material, but
Jane Draycott 56:41
we’re not looking in that. We’re not looking at the right direction either. We’re not looking at the right people. I mean, one of the things that, and I sort of, I didn’t think this initially, when I was researching formula and I was writing the book, by the end of it, I came to realize that one of, one of the sort of the really interesting things about her is how important she was in the sense of what happened when she was no longer around. You know, it’s, it’s like, you you don’t necessarily realize that someone is the linchpin of your social group until they’re not there anymore, and then suddenly no one, no one’s getting together. No, no. You know nothing’s happening. And you’re like, I didn’t realize that that person was the heart of the group, but they clearly are, because without them, we’re terrible. But with Fulvia, I think the really interesting thing to think about is, if she hadn’t died in 40 when she did, I think Roman history would have been quite different.
Dr Rad 57:32
It is so frustrating that she died at that moment. It’s
Jane Draycott 57:35
not that she I mean, she was one of these sort of quite dynamic, mover and shaker type people, but it was as much where she was situated and all of her connections that that was part of that. And so, so if she hadn’t died in 40 she, let’s assume that she had stayed married to Antony. And even if she hadn’t stayed married to Antony, she was still the mother of his children and the the mother of his political heirs in Rome. And so while he was away in the 30s in Parthia or attempting to take water Parthia and in Egypt and everything else, he didn’t have anyone protecting him in Rome anymore. His brother Lucius had gone to Spain and seems to have just died because he didn’t. He’s not really featured again after the Peruvian war. And so Fulvia was not in Rome on the spot to protect him. And so Octavian is able to completely demolish his reputation and do things like the will that may or may not have been fake that he opens and says, Oh, Antony wants to be you know, he wants to move Rome to Egypt. He wants to be buried with Cleopatra. He wants to leave all of his money, etc, to his Egyptian children, and so on so forth. If Fulvia had been around, that would not have happened like Antony’s will. Would have been different if that even was Anthony’s will. She had four young boys growing up to be Roman politicians, all of whom were part of very influential Roman families. So she had her oldest son, Publius Clodius Pulcher she had her second son, Gaius Scribonius Curio, and then she had her two sons of Antony. And so those four boys, growing up would have been able to basically take control of the Senate and have have a lot to say in Antony’s defense. In Rome, they would have been able to run things to Antony’s advantage, and then at the same time with if Antony had been able to put all of his his Eastern children into the positions that he and Cleopatra had planned for them, he already had. He had his his eldest child, Antonia, was already married into an Eastern royal family, and the four, those four children sort of ruling different parts of Near East, with Fulvia’s four sons ruling the Roman West. I mean, that’s the thing that I think is really interesting, what the world would have looked like, and when, when people would try and speculate on what would have happened if, if Antony and Cleopatra had won the Battle of Actium, how would his people look different things? Never think about that. They think more in the sense of Oh, Antony’s in Egypt, and the Roman Empire moves its focus to the east and and things like. It’s like, yes, but think about what’s going on, what would be going on in Rome at that point. And Antony would dominate Rome as well in the traditional Roman way. It wouldn’t have been Oh. Rome would become Egyptian and go Eastern. There would have been highly placed Romans in the Roman political system making sure that Rome sort of ticked over as well. And, and that is something that, because I hadn’t really thought about that until I came to the end of a writing book, and I was like, oh my god, this is, this is really, potentially this fascinating sort of counterfactual history element of it. And of course, the Julio Claudian dynasty as we know it, would not have existed, because Octavius daughters, Antonia Major and Minor, would never have been born. And therefore, the only thing Augustus really had going to him without his Julia and her, her children with with Marcellus or Agrippa and well, the three boys die young, and the girls have have troubles with their own. So he Julio-Claudian dynasty would would be, would have been very different as well, assuming it had even, you know, come to be. So Fulvia is the sort of at the center of this very interesting, sort of complex network of cause and effect. And if you take her away, or you put her back in, you know, she, she, it really is. These are, these are turning points for world
Speaker 2 1:01:28
history. Absolutely. Octavia obviously has completely conflicted loyalties between Antony and Octavian. In that decade, she’s hardly going to do the same sort of job that Fulvia would have done if she had lived and remained his wife. And
Jane Draycott 1:01:45
she does, she does try. And then she she does, apparently, voice, you know that it’s very hard to be the wife of one imperator and the sister of another imperator, it’s like, oh yeah, cry me a river, Octavia. But, I mean, she starts to try. She tries to support Anthony as much as she can,
Dr Rad 1:02:01
totally but that’s exactly it. It’s still not the same, because Fulvia just doesn’t have that, you know, that obligation to Octavian at all in spite of their brief familial relationship,
Jane Draycott 1:02:15
he might have been quite keen to remarry her daughter. Then Julia wouldn’t have been born, and potentially he’d have had other so. So yes, it’s for people who dismiss Roman women as not being important because they don’t hold the political or military offices. And why do we need women’s history? Oh, it’s just work, nonsense, etc. Well, individual women can actually be quite significant, whether it’s because of the things that they say and do, or whether it’s simply because of the person that they are in the position that they’re in, they can have quite far reaching effects on on things and then. So that’s that’s another, another reason, I suppose, why I wanted to sort of write this book and write books like this that sort of put the women back in, because women are 50% or slightly more of the population, and they, I mean this all of our important family period. I mean, I went once sitting down and trying to work out Roman prospography In this period. It, oh, my God, it brings on a migraine. Once you start doing that, you realize marriage was really important. And we hear about the men because it’s the men that have the public facing life and the literary and material and documentary evidence for them, but they are marrying women from other families, and they are creating links. And when you think about it, if you once you’ve traced all the family trees, you realize that the fall of the Republic was basically an extended family squabble. It
Dr Rad 1:03:53
does increasingly feel that way, especially when you consider that. As you pointed out, Antony’s children with Octavia become key players and makers of the Julio Claudian dynasty, Antonia Maior and Minor, without them, you don’t have the members of the Julio Claudian family.
Jane Draycott 1:04:12
But even even beyond that, outside of our specific sort of Fulvia, Anthony, Octavia, Octavian sort of situation, Fulvia was related to Caesar through marriage. You have, you have families like the she was, well, she was related to the Clodii by marriage. And they were related all the they were all married to the girls. Were all married to important members of individual families and things so, so really, what we’re seeing in the Roman Republic, because the Roman senatorial class is so basically incestuous. I mean, they’re all marrying each other cousins are marrying second cousins and so on so forth. So they are fighting amongst themselves and their own families and their own extended families. And it’s sort of, it’s almost like, you know, someone. Those situations where, at the reading of the Will all of the descendants start fighting over who gets the biggest share of it? And that is basically what the fall of the Republic is. It’s all these, all these related people, related by blood, related by marriage, fighting over who gets to have the biggest share. And they’re not. They’re not very good at sharing. It’s a zero sum game – one Person has to come out on top, and that means everybody else has to lose. And that’s why we find ourselves in this situation.
Dr G 1:05:30
Roman history summed up so well,
Dr Rad 1:05:33
the Romans not very good at sharing,
Dr G 1:05:36
not very good at sharing and ruining everything in the process,
Jane Draycott 1:05:40
just like any elite, really, if we, if we think about it, any any modern country, you know, they’re sucking up all of the money and all of the resources, and they’re wondering why all of the sort of people beneath them are getting progressively more annoyed about sex.
Dr G 1:05:57
Well, thank you, Jane, so much for coming on the show. It has been excellent to have a good old chat about Fulvia, the late Republic, how all of these pieces might be fitting together with what’s going on with women. Where are they? What are they up to, and and how is this influencing the very nature of history itself. And I love your consideration of the counterfactual history here as well, and Fulvia’s central positioning as this kind of linchpin person that is really holding different types of potential rooms together within herself, so the way she decides to act is pivotal, not just for her, but for everything that it influences the moment of her death is obviously pivotal, as well, as you’ve noted. And I would encourage anybody who is interested to seek out your book and to delve into the details even further. So thank you so much for your time. Thank you for having me, and
Speaker 2 1:07:03
clearly we’re sending out the message to Hollywood that it’s a mystery that Fulvia has been so overlooked in popular culture given her importance, as demonstrated by this chat. Yes, because,
Jane Draycott 1:07:14
because what Hollywood is doing currently is is green lighting, lots of stories about complex women and overlooked minorities.
Dr Rad 1:07:33
Thank you for listening to this special episode of the partial historians. You can find our sources sound credits and an automated transcript in our show notes at http://www.partialhistorians.com Our music is by Bettina Joy De Guzman. You too can support our show and help us to produce more fascinating content about the ancient world by becoming a Patreon. In return, you receive exclusive early access to our special episodes, just like this one. However, if you lost all your money betting on a chariot race, please just tell someone about the show or give us a five star review. Until next time we are yours in ancient Rome.
Transcribed by https://otter.ai
The post Special Episode – Fulvia with Dr Jane Draycott appeared first on The Partial Historians - Ancient Roman History with smart ladies.
It’s 395 BCE and we explore the events that are the result of the epic year of 396 BCE. The Romans ended 396 BCE on a high with their military success against the southern-most city of the Etruscans, Veii. But is all well in the Roman world? That may depend on which god you talk to…
The defeat of Veii leaves the northern peoples – the Capenates and Faliscans – open to Rome’s wrath. Their resistance to Rome means that war is on Rome’s agenda. This may also explain why we see military tribunes with consular power.
Despite the threats to the north, Rome seems intent on setting up a new colony down south towards Volscian territory. Does Rome really have the resources to spare for such an endeavour after a ten-year siege and problems north of Veii? Well, historians have some questions about that!
Camillus’ glorious leadership in taking Veii seems to be undermined by the his vow to Apollo which he had apparently forgotten. This creates real problems as the 10th portion to be offered to Apollo was not collected when the booty was distributed and now people OWE the gods… Will Camillus’ reputation emerge unscathed?
Our music is by Bettina Joy de Guzman.
Lightly edited for our wonderful Australian accents 🙂
Dr Rad 0:15
Welcome to the Partial Historians.
Dr G 0:19
We explore all the details of ancient Rome,
Dr Rad 0:23
everything from political scandals, the love affairs, the battled wage and when citizens turn against each other. I’m Dr Rad
Dr G 0:33
And I’m Dr G. We consider Rome as the Romans saw it, by reading different authors from the ancient past and comparing their stories.
Dr Rad 0:44
Join us as we trace the journey of Rome from the founding of the city.
Hello and welcome to a brand new episode of the Partial Historians. I am one of your hosts, Dr Rad,
Dr G 1:05
And I am Dr G and I am super excited because we are no longer in 396 BCE.
Dr Rad 1:14
396 was clearly the best year ever. So I don’t know why you’d even say that. It’s quite hurtful. Frankly,
Dr G 1:21
The Romans are probably sad that it’s over, because they had a great time in the end, although it didn’t start out quite so well,
Dr Rad 1:28
although there were some ups and downs, admittedly, so let’s talk about it. Dr, G, why was 396 so great in the end?
Dr G 1:36
In the end, it is the conclusion of the 10 year siege of bae and a whole bunch of reasons the Romans have been really building up this moment in their written history centuries after the event. So this is viewed many years later as a hugely significant moment in Rome’s history, because it is their first major conquest of a significant Etruscan city.
Dr Rad 2:08
Absolutely, they have more than doubled the territory that they originally possess. So it’s quite impressive, and it’s all down to one man, Dr G, if we’ve learned anything from history, it is that conquering large cities and other nations can only be done by one man,
Dr G 2:26
a single man, a man called Camillus.
Dr Rad 2:30
That’s right, Camillus is the hero of the hour in the siege of they but there are signs of trouble ahead. Dr G even in his moment of glory when he led this victory against Veii, there have been some problems. He tripped to have he tripped when talking to the gods. I mean, is there any humanity left in the world?
Dr G 2:55
It’s like going to a party and spilling the drink all over yourself. Tragic times everybody kind of gasps, being quite concerned, tripping over while you’re talking to the gods is obviously a bad sign. But I think even worse is that there’s a whole bunch of promises that he makes to gods as well.
Dr Rad 3:19
Foolishly
Dr G 3:19
I wonder how that’s going to go for him. I really do.
Dr Rad 3:23
Yeah, well, because it’s required the people to come back and donate part of the booty that they took from the conquest of Fae in order to satisfy the requirements of this vow that he made to Delphic Apollo, who had prophesied Rome’s success against Veii. So obviously, the Rome, you know, Apollo, did them a solid, and they want to, they want to pay him back. And they want it to be something nice. They don’t want it to just be, you know, a supermarket box of chocolates. They want it to be something really special.
Dr G 3:57
They do. And so Camillus is promise to Apollo is really the crux of the issue for him, in the end, because despite the success of the conquest of they, they still have this outstanding promise to keep to Apollo. And apparently Camillus forgot. Awkward. So not only does he trip over, he’s a little bit forgetful, and he does have a moment as well, on a more positive note, where he asks Juno, who is the titular goddess of Veii, if she will switch sides, and she agrees. So that works out for him quite well, but this situation with Apollo may be going to come back to bite him on the bottom, as it were.
Dr Rad 4:48
And speaking of his bottom, Dr G, he sat it upon some white horses. No, not really. He would have been in the little thing behind it. But we did also have some issues with his triumph. He has not. To earned himself Good Will because his triumph was considered OTT in the worst possible way.
Dr G 5:07
Goodness me, what has he done now?
Dr Rad 5:12
So that’s basically the sticky situation in which we find ourselves. Dr G, there’s been lots of good news coming out of 396 which we had to cover in three episodes, but there have definitely been signs that it’s not going to be all smooth sailing for our hero, Camillus.
Dr G 5:29
I’m glad you’ve mentioned smooth sailing that will come up later.
Dr Rad 5:33
Indeed. So Dr, G, I think it’s time For us to dive into 395 BCE.
All right, it’s 395, BC, Dr G and I would like to ask you to take us through the magistrates for the first time in a while.
Dr G 6:28
Oh goodness me. I’m not even used to this job anymore. Everybody bear with me while I butcher some Latin for you. We have six military tribunes with consular power for the year of 395 now they’re all patrician. So way to return to form Rome, we have Publius Cornelius Cossus, first time in the role Publius Cornelius Scipio, first time in the role. Kaeso Fabius Ambustus. Now, he has been a military tribune before in 404 and 401 so he’s got a little bit more experience. Yeah, we then have Lucius Furius Medullinus. Another Furii enters the fold. Now he was also previously consul, so he’s had the top notch job in 413 and 409 but he’s also been a pretty regular military tribune with consular power as well. 407, 405, 398, 397 so probably the most experienced of the bunch this time round, our Furius. Then we have Quintus Servilius Fidenas, also previously military tribune with consular power in 402, and 398, so Medullinus and Fidenas have served together before. They’re maybe their friends, maybe their rivals, and Marcus Valerius Lactucinus Maximus, he was also previously military tribune with consular power in 398, so we have a full compliment, if you like, of military tribunes. There’s a whole stack of them this year, and you think to yourself, you guys have just won a siege. Do you really have so many problems on so many other fronts that you need so many so many military folk? But I guess we’ll find out. I’m looking forward to what Livy might have to say about this year, and I also have the name of three tribunes of the plebs?
Dr Rad 8:41
Yes. Finally, it’s been too long.
Dr G 8:45
Somebody’s got to stand up for the common man. Let it be the tribune of the plebs. So in this role, we have a guy called Titus Sicinius, another man called Quintus Pomponius, and finally, Aulus Verginius.
Dr Rad 9:04
I, too, have these names strategy, and I’m very excited about it.
Dr G 9:09
I’m looking forward to learning what’s going on, because, as per usual for me, at the moment, I have few sources that will give me a breakdown on what’s going on, analystically, for this time period. So I’m going to sweep you away with other details instead, at some point in this episode.
Dr Rad 9:27
You always do, Dr G, well, okay, so let me set the scene a little bit. Now. I have mentioned previously that for Livy, Camillus is obviously a huge focal point, to the extent that academic think, he might have actually structured his first 10 books around Camillus appearance, as in, not the way that he looks, but like when he shows up in this.
Dr G 9:55
Don’t be like that,
Dr Rad 9:56
Although I’m sure he’s hot
Dr G 9:57
I’m sure he was a buff dude. He needs a tribute.
Dr Rad 10:02
Now they being captured is obviously a very big moment, as we have been saying in Rome’s history. But there’s something else that now lies ahead, and it’s very difficult for Livy to pretend that that is not on the horizon. Dr G, so I’m going to have to spoil it, even though I think I’ve mentioned it about 100 times already. Whilst Rome has managed to conquer they it is only years away from being conquered itself.
Dr G 10:32
Oh, no, the spoilers,
Dr Rad 10:34
I know, I know, but I can’t help it, because that is seemingly what Livy is now building to.
Dr G 10:43
He’s gotten this major situation with Camillus done and dusted, and he’s like, Okay, on to the next disaster.
Dr Rad 10:50
Yeah, pretty much. He’s obviously got details in the analysis histories and records that came before him. He’s probably got some dates, like when colonies were founded. He’s probably got some details about when military campaigns were happening for Rome, maybe some legal details. But as we always say, when it’s this early on in Rome’s history, he’s still trying to figure out how it all fits together, and so we have to kind of be aware that this is what he’s thinking about when he’s constructing the history that he’s writing.
Dr G 11:26
Definitely so Livy is operating from the shoulders of giants, as far as he is concerned, to write his own history, and this means that he has to navigate the tricky waters of whatever the sources that we don’t have privy to, but he did have left behind.
Dr Rad 11:47
Now you asked Dr G why so many military tribunes? Well, obviously it’s because you want to have military tribunes, because you want to dangle that carrot always in front of the plebs. You go, you could, maybe get a magistrate. Maybe you could, maybe you could. Maybe you would keep working towards it. Keep working towards it. Just keep swimming. Just keep swimming.
Dr G 12:09
And rude. I mean, I mean, if you wanted to give people that sense that it’s possible, surely just have at least one plebeian in there each year,
Dr Rad 12:19
Never! I would rather die than see grubby little paws sully the office of the chief magistracy.
Dr G 12:29
I think this leads us deeper into the thorny problem of what does it mean to be an elite Roman in this very particular period of Roman republic? So we could say that we’ve just left the really early Republic, and we’ve started to step into what will be known as the middle Republic, but it’s a little bit hazy as to what is going on and where all of these very privileged, elite patrician people are coming from. And Rome has a whole history of bringing in new people all the time, and being quite accommodating, really, for people, right from the point of Romulus saying, this is a city of asylum, essentially. So we do have a lot of spread-outness of where family lines seem to come from in Rome. And obviously Rome emerging as a republic, those early, early patrician families get to say that they’re Roman, but obviously they have to have come from somewhere else, because Rome didn’t exist before, before. So exactly this whole idea of who counts as the highly privileged here and who does not is the sort of thing that has framed our understanding of the struggle of the orders, but does become an ongoing issue for how we understand Roman power, because it seems pretty clear from our source material that there is this simplistic division being offered to us when actually the nature of family life and who gets to progress into politics is far more complicated, as would make sense for the fact that Rome is an expanding power that’s open to absorbing people into it and also encouraging foreigners to come and stay.
Dr Rad 14:15
The little known fact Dr G that Livy actually inspired the Avril Lavigne smash, ‘Why did you have to go make things so complicated?’
Dr G 14:25
It’s all making sense now.
Dr Rad 14:27
I know, I know. All right, so the reason, potentially that we also have military tribune so is that there is still some war on Rome’s front. Now, lest we forget, Dr G they has been conquered, but these allies have not and so we have the two Cornelii amongst our military tribunes being sent off to war against the Faliscans. And then we have Valerius and Servilius at war with Capena, because they had both sided with Veii. So.
Dr G 15:00
Yes. Now both of these places, if I remember rightly, are to the north of Rome, and so they’re heading into that Etruscan territory situation, which is-
Dr Rad 15:10
Is it Etruscan territory anymore?
Dr G 15:16
Well, those Romans have changed everything, haven’t they? But certainly we’ve talked about the Faliscians and the Capenates as being people who are sort of further north than Veii and have realized at a certain point that this whole siege situation of they is going to be a problem for them, and now those chickens are coming home to roost by the sounds of it.
Dr Rad 15:38
Oh, they’re coming home all right. So the Roman commanders decide, You know what, we’ve had enough of attacking cities. Let’s just take it easy and completely devastate the surrounding countryside and take everything that the farmers who live in that surrounding area have to offer. In fact, and I quote my translation of Livy, they said they wanted to leave not one fruit tree in the land, nor any productive plant.
Dr G 16:04
Wow, yeah, it’s like the Romans have turned around after all of this siege work that they’ve conducted. And being like, you know what? I really miss pillaging, pillaging. I haven’t done that for years now.
Dr Rad 16:15
And you know what? I like apples and oranges. Actually, I can’t, I can’t remember if they would have been growing. Probably not.
Dr G 16:22
No, definitely not. If we’re talking about fruit trees. Oh, goodness, what would have been growing in Italy in this tim period?
Dr Rad 16:29
Pears?
Dr G 16:30
Listeners, weigh in and tell us, probably pears, yes, lemons, potentially, and olive trees for sure.
Dr Rad 16:40
Yeah. Anyway. So this works very well against the capitates completely subdues them. They seek peace. The Romans are like, Yep, sure, that’s what we really wanted. However, those pesky and adorable Faliscans continue to resist.
Dr G 16:57
How dare they?
Dr Rad 16:59
Now I’m going to take you back to Rome. Dr G where apparently there were, and I quote, again, disturbances of many sorts. Seems that the Romans are not sitting back and reveling in their victory. Now, what these disturbances are exactly? Who knows? Livy doesn’t tell me. He just tells me that there are problems and that the Senate needed to do something in order to shut people up because they were sick of hearing them complain.
Dr G 17:26
All right. I mean, these disturbances could be anything. Then it could just be an errant sign from the gods to weird things turning up in the water supply. Nobody knows
Dr Rad 17:36
it could be. Look, I suspect it probably has something to do with the fact that the Romans have just come into a large amount of territory and booty. I think this is probably all connected. They’ve not happy with Camillus entirely. He tripped. He had white horses in his triumph. It’s just all too much. Dr G, it’s very overwhelming. So they decide to put a colony on the Volscian frontier, and they need 3000 citizens in order to make it viable, allegedly. And so they set up a board of three to decide what how this is going to play out. And they determine that anybody who goes to this new colony would be given three juguera and 7/12ths in terms of their land, which I believe. So. I think a jugera is about 28,000 square feet.
Dr G 18:29
Oh, well, that doesn’t help me at all. I’m a metric kind of girl.
Dr Rad 18:32
Yeah, no, it doesn’t help me either. Look, it’s all it’s just space. It’s just space.
Dr G 18:38
I believe a jugera is supposed to be the amount of land that one can profitably farm to exist for yourself and your family. So three is a pretty nice gesture. It is. But Volscian territory, I mean, they’ve just taken Veii, the Volsci are in the other direction.
Dr Rad 18:56
Well, this is the thing, right? So first of all, let’s just have a quick reality check. There’s my sound effect. I’m putting on the brakes.
Modern academics have found it extremely dubious that Rome would have 3000 citizens to spare for said colony. They think that perhaps about 300 might be more realistic for this time period.
Dr G 19:22
Hmm, okay. Now, does this story in any way parallel the suggestion that people remove themselves from Rome and inhabit they instead?
Dr Rad 19:35
This does have to do with that. I’m going to get there in just a moment. So we probably got, yeah, we have probably got essentially just a small band of colonists who are going to set out and set up this new colony. Now, back to Livy’s account. The plebs are not at all impressed by this suggestion, because they feel this new colony is clearly just a diversion. They’re trying. Trying to buy off the plebs with crappy, stupid land and banish them to this stupid frontier when they could be going to Veii, which is right there, and they can see it and everything. They want to live in Veii even more than they want to live in Rome itself,
Dr G 20:24
Ooo okay
Dr Rad 20:24
In fact. And this is where what you said comes in. They even discuss at this point, why don’t we just all pack up shop, leave Rome behind, move today. I mean, after all, location, location, location, Dr G, it has a better location. It has nicer buildings. It has the theater, the museums, the art, the comedy, the promenades. Clearly, this is a genius plan.
Dr G 20:52
It also serves as cover for a plebeian secession that could succeed being like we’re out of here, guys, not only are we leaving Rome, but we have a better place to go. They is positioned on the top of a tufa outpost, essentially, so a sort of semi hard rock outcrop, so it’s easily defensible. That’s the idea. This is why it took Rome so long to besiege it and to take it over. But now that Rome possesses it, it should be theoretically easy for them to defend as well. So if somebody wanted to take they from them, you would expecting at least another 10 year siege, if not longer, because the Romans understand how sieging that place works, and probably have some ideas about how to combat that.
Dr Rad 21:45
No tunnels!
Dr G 21:48
Don’t let anybody build any tunnels. That is a suspicious trap door in the ground. Where’s that going all the way to they, my friends. So for the plebeians to sort of up sticks and be like, You know what? I just gonna move to this empty city over here. A whole bunch of them were probably involved in the conquest anyway. So they know what they’re getting themselves into. They probably realize the amount of rebuilding work that would need to happen there. I’d be interested to see how this pans out for them, though.
Dr Rad 22:18
Well, Dr G, this is where probably the most famous ad for tacos comes in, because the plan is that they’re going to send half of the plebs, but also half of the Senate to they so they weren’t planning on just sending plebs, and they basically asked the Senate, why can’t the Romans be in both cities? ¿Por Qué No Los Dos?
Dr G 22:42
Fair enough, yeah. Finally, we’ve conquered something. Let’s divide after conquering,
Dr Rad 22:50
the patricians were outraged at this suggestion. They literally said that they would sooner die than ever. Let such a suggestion even come to a vote, Dr G, let alone make it reality.
Dr G 23:04
Okay, so the senatorial faction is basically against this whole idea that half of them might have to live somewhere else.
Dr Rad 23:12
Yes, that’s what they say. This is a terrible idea. They say, look at us as Romans. We are constantly having internal problems in bickering amongst ourselves. If there were two Romes, it would be double trouble, so much worse. And how dare the plebs want to go and live in they? I mean, they just lost a war. Loser. Rome was the winner of that conquest, and everyone should want to live there, because it is clearly the superior place to be. Okay. The patricians would never be leaving behind their fellow Romans or their beloved city, no matter what you could threaten them with anything, Dr G, becoming too feminine, becoming too Greek, and they’d say, No, never, I’m not afraid of you. I am staying right here, okay, and this is where the tribune of the plebs comes in, touchy, okay?
Dr G 24:14
Yeah, I was gonna say somebody needs to stand up to this kind of mad rhetoric, because you’re not gonna ever be able to hold ve unless you put some of your own people in there, and it’s a matter of who’s it going to be
Dr Rad 24:27
Pish posh with your sensibilities.
Dr G 24:30
How dare you be military strategic in this time, I’m having emotions!
Dr Rad 24:35
So this is where the tribune of the plebs come in. The patricians say that no one would be following this idea, were it not for Titus Sicinius. He’s apparently the one that came up with this brilliant idea. And they’re like, You know what? Why don’t you just make him the new founder of this place that you want to go and live? Because if you go to they. You’re going to be leaving behind the best founder that ever existed, Romulus. I mean, you’re literally spitting on the son of a God who founded Rome, but whatever.
Dr G 25:12
Wow. Okay, so things are getting tense in the public discourse, aren’t they?
Dr Rad 25:18
I really love it when the patricians get hysterical. It’s my favorite.
Dr G 25:22
Well, I think pulling out the Romulus card is a big one, though.
Dr Rad 25:26
Yeah, apparently this is a little reminiscent of, once again, an episode in Greek history. So there are similar arguments put forth when some of the Athenians refused to leave Athens at the time of the Battle of Salamis. So it’s possible that Livy is borrowing a little bit from Herodotus here.
Dr G 25:51
Okay, now that is interesting, because if Livy is borrowing from Herodotus, then also Livy must be aware of the level to which the Athenians engaged in a colonization process across the Mediterranean. People were leaving Athens all the time to found colonies. They weren’t against the colonial settlement thing.
Dr Rad 26:15
I think it’s more the rhetoric he likes, not so much the endless colonization that he’s praising. But after all, he’s not saying he’s against color colonization. It’s more because he I think he’s in favor of them just doing what they’re told, going to this volscian colony. I suspect the patricians have something else planned for they. Uh, oh, yeah. Now we don’t know very much about this Titus aequinius character, but the name might sound familiar to you. Dr, G, so we don’t really know anything else about this guy, except that he comes from a family that is known to stand up for the plebs, like he’s got that association happening.
Dr G 26:53
Hmm, okay, so there is a reasonable understanding that he might act to type in this case, yes.
Dr Rad 27:03
Now this debate led to some absolutely disgusting accusations. Dr G that the senate slash patricians, it’s never clear who Livy’s exactly talking about, had once again, perhaps persuaded some of the tribunes of the plebs to side with them on this whole Veii colony idea.
Dr G 27:26
Oh no, stop it. Every time I think that we’ve got the plebs like lined up and finally, something’s going to happen, undermined by the patricians.
Dr Rad 27:36
Yeah, so the plebs are clearly intending to fight hard for this idea. They are heading down the path of starting a violent riot, but they are prevented from doing so because the senators have an ingenious way of handling it, much like handling a difficult toddler who’s having a complete and utter meltdown. So whenever it looks like during the debate, violence is about to kick off. They say to the people, go on, beat me. Kick me, attack me. Ha, that’s what you want, isn’t it? You want to see these distinguished silver foxes with all their blue blood splattered everywhere. You want to see people with amazing political experience who’ve been decorated with many honors, disgraced by their fellow citizens, and this makes the plebeians think twice and decide not to attack.
Dr G 28:29
Wow. Okay, yeah, and that’s only takes. You never want to see me bleed
Dr Rad 28:41
Now Camillus, he resurges in my narrative here, he is constantly ticking off the people just nag, nag, nag. Dr G, he is disgusted by the fact that they are so caught up in other concerns and do not seem to realize that they have yet to make the contributions that have been asked of them for the gift to Apollo. Tick tock, Dr G, tick tock.
Dr G 29:06
well, yeah, you can’t keep a god waiting that’s gonna that’s gonna turn out badly in the end, I would think
Dr Rad 29:13
now he’s particularly concerned, as it seems like the people of Rome are considering that the tithe only included movable wealth. However, he’s like, I don’t know. Maybe it should also include they, I mean, like the actual land. This is part of the parcel, after all, this is what people are fighting about. The Senate have no idea. So they ask the pontiffs to weigh in, and they go in and they have a meeting with Camillus. They have a sit down. They have a chat. They then decide that, as Camillus made the vow before he won the victory and before the Romans were in control of the land, it also has to be included in the tithe 1/10th
Dr G 29:56
What?
Dr Rad 29:57
I know
Dr G 29:57
Okay. Okay, so, uh, interjection, interjection, Plutarch’s Life of Camillus. I do have some source material on this, okay, not a lot. Admittedly, I had no idea that they were going to try and include a 10th of the land taking.
Dr Rad 30:14
Oh, it’s all going to be counted.
Dr G 30:16
Yeah. Look, people do turn against him. That seems pretty clear. So part of the issue is related to what is known as the 10th of the spolia. So anytime that they take something, if a promise has been made to a god, there’s a specific percentage that needs to be handed over as part of this and in this case, it’s understood that Apollo deserves a 10th of the spoils taken of Veii. Now, Plutarch doesn’t specify one way or the other, whether this includes land. It doesn’t seem like the pontiffs get involved at all, but the problem is that everybody has already taken their portion of the booty and also possibly already spent it.
Dr Rad 31:01
Wow.
Dr G 31:04
Not everybody is a rich patrician with a lot of wealth on hand. Some people make their living when they’re on campaign As citizen soldiers. This makes sense if you’re not harvesting your own crop because you’ve been called away to a campaign instead, then the booty is really your payment. Rome doesn’t have a standing army at this point in its history, and as we’ve learned just very recently, in terms of the siege of a we get the first inkling that they might have given a payment for some of the soldiers to stay the winter in location, and even that’s contested. So the idea is that you have to win, because that’s how you make the money, in order to allow you to keep living your life. Because if you haven’t been there for the harvest, you haven’t been able to do that work, and it’s had to be delegated to other people in your family who haven’t been on campaign. So that workload is a problem, and so the booty is crucial for your life in terms of how you do business and do merchant, sell-y, type, buying, type, things, trade, whatever. So the fact that they had their booty and they’ve their booty is now gone, is perhaps not a surprise. The problem is that now they’ve been told, after the fact, that 1/10th of all of it needs to be given over for this promise to Apollo, which Camillus apparently forgot. And people are angry about this, because it’s not going to be the booty that they have to give over. That 10th is going to have to come out of their own savings, whatever they have, in order to fulfill this promise, because they weren’t told about it at the time, and they can’t get out of it now, because the gods are unhappy,
Dr Rad 33:01
Camillus really should start writing things down.
Dr G 33:04
Well, yeah, Camillus, what’s your strategy? You’re gonna keep a diary.
Dr Rad 33:10
What they decide is that money needs to be taken out of the treasury. The military tribunes with consular power, are told to go and buy some gold with this however, there is not enough gold to be had, and so, Dr G, hold on to your hat. The matrons decide that they’re going to personally intervene. I don’t know how long it’s been since we mentioned a woman, but they’re entering our narrative right now. Matrons meet privately. So these would be married women, ladies, and they voluntarily decide that they’re going to bring in all of their jewelry and donate this so that enough gold can be had for this super special gift to Delphic Apollo
Dr G 33:54
Yes. Now this is an amazing moment in Roman history, and I don’t want to overstate how amazing it is, but it’s pretty amazing that something like this is being mentioned at this point in the Republic. So Plutarch has this idea as well, and it talks about how there’s a scarcity of gold in the city. The women, on their own determination, come forward and give their gold ornaments to get the gold weight up to where it needs to be in order to function as a 10% tithe to Apollo. And this is incredible to me for a number of reasons, one, because it serves as an early mirror, if you like, to something that happens in the Punic Wars.
Dr Rad 34:48
I was going to say, does give me flashbacks or flash forwards? I don’t know how you describe that.
Dr G 34:52
Yeah, I think, I think Livy is maybe offering something here that serves as a bit of a contrast slash compare with what happens in around about 215 BCE, not to spoil things for people, because it’s going to take us another 10 years to get that. But they do bring in what is called a sumptuary law during the Punic Wars, the lex Oppia, which is basically restricting the wealth of women and their display of it because they are in a military and fiscal crisis because of the ongoing Punic War, and that is then mirrored, compare contrast to then what happens in the Civil War triumviral period in 42 BCE when the Romans do try to impose a tax directly on women to try and fund some of the insane warfare that is going on, they’ve taxed everybody
Dr Rad 35:51
No taxation without representation, buddy boy,
Dr G 35:55
yeah, and we get this really famous moment from Hortensia who stands up and says, exactly as you’ve put it, no taxation without representation. We’re not going to have it. So the fact that the women in this example are voluntarily getting together for this gesture, I wonder if Livy is trying to set this up as a bit of an exemplar for women.
Dr Rad 36:19
Oh I think he definitely is.
Dr G 36:21
This is, this is maybe how you’re supposed to do it, rather than waiting to get taxed or to complain about getting taxed, why don’t you do your civic duty and come together and volunteer to hand over all of your jewelry like women in 395 BCE. Thank you very much.
Dr Rad 36:42
It was with the golden times.
Dr G 36:45
Oh, the golden days.
Dr Rad 36:48
Now the Senate are incredibly touched by this gesture. Little tears form at the corner of their eyes, Dr G and they start mumbling about having allergies and it being hayfever season. They then permit the matrons a special honor in recognition of this contribution, which is, they’re allowed to drive around in four wheeled carriages to any festival or games that are being held and on holy and working days, which I feel like it’s every day that doesn’t make any sense, they’re allowed to drive around in two wheeled cars.
Dr G 37:25
Ah, no, no. Well, holy and working days, yeah, you could have a nefas day where you wouldn’t be allowed to do it, I would say. Now this is very different from the kinds of awards, if you like that the Senate grants to the women in Plutarch. And it is, yeah, he doesn’t talk about carts at all. And Plutarch-
Dr Rad 37:49
Carriages thank you not carts. What are they vegetables?
Dr G 37:54
Probably, I don’t what are they made out of trees? So Plutarch is writing hundreds of years after Livy, so we might want to dismiss his claims as being maybe a little bit more far fetched. But it is interesting. What he does say is that these women are rewarded by the Senate that when they die, that they can have a suitable eulogy spoken over them well in the same way that men can, and this is effectively an example of what is known as a an encomium. So encomia are speeches of praise. They are very particular.
Dr Rad 38:42
That seems waaay too early Plutarch.
Dr G 38:45
It does seem way too early. And I was also looking into it being like, when do we have some really solid examples of women being commemorated and praised in really formal speeches that we could understand as encomia, yeah, and there, there is one from this period, really, but it is in Greek, and it’s an encomium to Helen of Troy.
Dr Rad 39:12
Oh, that doesn’t count.
Dr G 39:14
We’re talking about very different categories of women at that point, because Helen of Troy, as we know, was the face that launched a 1000 ships, and she’s-
Dr Rad 39:23
She may not have even been real!
Dr G 39:26
Oh, well, you know, you’d have to ask Herodotus, he’s pretty sure she went to Egypt. But Gorgias, the guy that writes this encomium to Helen, he’s actually a native of Sicily, so he’s not that far like he’s part of the Greek world. He’s definitely in Magna Graecia, but he is also in Italy in that broader sense. So it’s not completely impossible that as early as this time period, we have women who are granted the honor. Of being commemorated with encomia, but plutarchs distance from the fact kind of raises the question, I think, a little bit. But anyway, I thought this was interesting enough to follow up on, because I was like, really this early. I was like, fascinating, but the carriages made far more sense. Well, the carriages make far more sense. I would say, yeah.
Dr Rad 40:23
See, I just don’t know that we have even had that many examples for men. You know, where like it’s specifically recorded that that kind of public speech is given for a man, let alone a woman?
Dr G 40:35
Well, the implication in Plutarch is that it was usual for elite men to receive this kind of honor upon their death.
Dr Rad 40:43
Sure, from in the empire, yeah.
Dr G 40:46
And I think this is where we can start to sort of build a case that, like maybe Plutarch is retrojecting just like way, way too much here. And the idea that it would have been unusual in his time period for women to receive this kind of honor gives you a sense of just how long it takes for women to get any sort of respectful foothold in public society, in terms of the Roman history across the board, even when we get into the Empire.
Dr Rad 41:17
All right. Well, nonetheless. Dr G however it happens, whether there are nameless matrons involved or not, the gold is finally collected up, and they have it made into a beautiful golden bowl to give to Apollo. However, now that the vow has been taken care of, and Camillus is dabbing the sweat from his brow, the tribunes of the plebs enter the scene once more to stir up trouble. They want to make the plebeians absolutely furious with the patricians, but especially with Camillus. They accuse him of basically having given them absolutely nothing. Thanks a lot. Camillus, everything that you won at Veii has gone to either the state treasury or the gods. Blaah, that’s what we think of you. Where’s our cut? Huh? Huh? We’ve supported this venture for the last 10 years. What are you playing it?
Dr G 42:17
It is a grave accusation
Dr Rad 42:21
Any patricians, well, which I’m presuming, patricians, to be honest. He says, leaders that were not there at this particular meeting were trashed. The tribunes of the plebs and the plebeians join in bitching behind their back. But if you were there, they attach you right to your face. However, that means that you were able to defend yourself. And if they once, they started doing that, once again, they use that same sort of strategy. It basically shut the plebeians right up because they were embarrassed for making these accusations against such eminent, amazing, outstanding people as the patricians. I mean, they’re kind of really tremendous. You know, they’re really tremendous, absolutely outstanding. I love it.
Dr G 43:04
I do like the idea that the patricians are like these kind of like legendary, mythic creatures, and the plebeians are sort of going up to them and sort of poking them with a stick from behind, being like, is it moving? Can I insult it now and then, when it turns around, they’re like, run away again.
Dr Rad 43:21
It does seem like that. It makes the plebeian seem completely ludicrous, which I think is Livy’s intent. Now, the plebeians could tell that they weren’t going to get their desire of the Rome. They situation, the ¿Por Qué No Los Dos? happening in one year. They’re like, this is going to be a long haul thing, guys. So they try to make sure that they get the exact same tribune of the plebs elected in the next year, because they know that they’re going to support their demands. The patricians, once they get wind of this, try to make sure that the people who were against it get elected as military tribunes with consular power, basically meaning that we end up with the same military tribunes with consular power and the same tribunes of the plebs holding office in the next year.
Dr G 44:18
Well, this sounds like a chronology issue to me, I’m just flagging it now…
Dr Rad 44:23
It might well be, but how dare you point it out? Livy had covered it up so skillfully,
Dr G 44:28
no one will ever know.
Dr Rad 44:32
Yeah. And also, when you actually look at the list of people, it’s not the same, like there are some people who are the same, but it’s not the same,
Dr G 44:40
Okay, well, that’s reassuring. So Livy’s just making some stuff up. He wants it to be this way.
Dr Rad 44:45
Well kind of and kind of not. Basically, there are some military tribunes with consular power who are the same, and certainly the tribunes of the plebs are the same. So that part is true, if we believe that this is all actually happening, and Livy’s not just tap dancing because he can’t make the magistrates work.
Dr G 45:03
Well, yes, I mean, the less said about that, the better. I’ve already mentioned my skepticism. Well, that’s all I got, Dr G.
Ah, well, you’re lucky I’m here because goodness knows what’s happening in Sicily.
Dr Rad 45:19
What is happening in Sicily? Are there still tyrants running about?
Dr G 45:22
Oh yes, things are chaotic. So Diodorus Siculus manages to get every single name of the military tribunes correct to to the degree that he has six names, and they can be allocated out to six individuals differently.
Dr Rad 45:38
Amazing.
Dr G 45:39
He doesn’t have the full names of anybody, but he’s got some names, and they all kind of work. But the situation in Sicily is heating up, so the Carthaginians have decided that they’re going to launch their attack. Very exciting. They’re bringing troops with them from Libya and Sardinia. So they’re coming in a kind of like two different directions, down to Sicily,
Dr Rad 46:05
A pincer movement
Dr G 46:07
I know – with boats, I’m not sure if it works the same for islands, but I guess we’re about to find out. And apparently, also some folk from Italy from the mainland, who Diodorus Siculus describes as barbarians, Italian barbarians. So goodness knows what’s happening in the south of Italy right now. I feel for them. I’m pretty sure they’re not barbarians, but they have been labeled as such. So the Carthaginian forces are being led by a guy called Magon and he is rivaling off against the tyrant of Syracuse, essentially, a guy called Dionysus, who we’ve talked a little bit about before.
Dr Rad 46:57
Yeah,
Dr G 46:57
So these two are coming. It’s all coming into a kind of a crescendo of a lot of warships. Definitely, battle is going to take place. The Carthaginians start to storm the interior of Sicily. So they make landfall. They start to get in there. They’re gathering disaffected Sicilians along the way, because not everybody’s excited to have a tyrant ruling over them. Goodness knows why?
Dr Rad 47:26
There’s no accounting for taste.
Dr G 47:27
But then just depends. But they get to a place called Agyris, and Agyris is the linchpin on all of this. So Agyris is both the name of a place the name of the guy who’s in charge of the place, and that makes you suspicious as well. I mean, like Agyris leading Agyris with the Agyrinaeans. But anyway, this guy seems to be very powerful, and he and Dionysus get together, and they agree that they will repel the Carthaginians as a united force. So it’s kind of like two tyrants are now getting together here in Sicily to repel the Carthaginians. And it works partly because Magon’s forces are so stretched. So the Carthaginians have not only had to sail all this way to get to this island, but not everybody is happy to see them. So everything is a hostile situation of a moving battle line, and also logistics and supplies. So the further they get into the interior of Sicily, the harder it’s going to become. And so by the time they get to this Agyris, where Dionysus and this leader have made a pact to deal with the Carthaginians, the forces are so stretched that they just can’t handle it anymore. So deep in hostile territory, the Carthaginians decide that it’s not going their way. They’re lacking supplies. They’re at a complete disadvantage in terms of the terrain, and they sue for peace. And so this is a sort of a tricky year for the Carthaginians, because they started out being like, so bold and being like, we’ve got this. We’re pulling forces from everywhere. We’re so well organized, and they really couldn’t do it in the end. So this is great for Dionysus. He is able to take possession of more cities in Sicily as a result, and he’s also got a new ally on the island as well. So it is a bit of an issue. Now, Diodorus Siculus is also totally across everything that is happening for the Romans, and he has a single sentence for them. Which is such was the state of affairs in Sicily and in Italy, the Romans pillaged the city of Faliscusa and the tribe of the Falisci.
Dr Rad 50:12
Aha.
Dr G 50:14
That’s all he’s got to say.
Dr Rad 50:18
Well, he’s pretty on the money, I suppose you just left out all the interesting internal flappy fighting that’s going on.
Dr G 50:25
Yeah, just a minor details of missing that’s all but exactly clearly, so Didorus Siculus, giving us this really in depth history of Sicily is going to become more and more useful as Rome’s influence starts to expand
Dr Rad 50:41
Absolutely.
Dr G 50:42
He also spends a lot of time talking about Greek history, which I am tending not to focus on right now, but that might become interesting as well at some point, and when I think it is, I’ll start to bring that in as well. But yes, I have very little Roman history to share, sadly, but things progressing in Sicily, the Carthaginians, the people of Sicily. It’s all happening. Sardinia is involved. And those Italian barbarians, whoever they are,
Dr Rad 51:10
I’m going to imagine that there’s Samnites or Oscans or somebody like that.
Dr G 51:14
Yeah, I feel like you know anybody in the south, I suppose, could be classified in this group.
Dr Rad 51:20
Yeah, probably not the Samnites. All right. Dr G, that means it is time for the Partial Pick.
Why? Thank you, Igor, so. Dr G, tell us, what is the Partial Pick and what are we doing here?
Dr G 51:41
Goodness me, the Partial Pick, this is where we rate Rome according to some of its own conventions. So there are five categories. Each is worth 10 gold Roman eagles. So they can achieve a maximum score of 50 golden Roman eagles, much better than a bowl, I would say.
Dr Rad 52:03
I was gonna say, I have something to confess. We actually ran out of enough gold for the Eagles, so I’ve donated my own jewelry collection for this episode. That’s my dedication.
Dr G 52:12
There will be a speech of praise said over your body when the time is right.
Dr Rad 52:18
All right, what’s our first category, Dr G?
Dr G 52:21
Our first category is military clout.
Dr Rad 52:24
Okay, well, I think yes, there is definitely some stuff going on here. We have got a very easy victory, it seems, over Capena. And whilst we don’t have too much detail in this year about the Faliscans, the Romans aren’t losing against them. Hmm.
Dr G 52:43
It sounds like everything’s going really well.
Dr Rad 52:45
It does. I mean, not, not, not the most impressive campaigning we’ve seen. There are no tunnels, unfortunately, hmm, but none other procedures have been broken, something, it’s something. Hmm, maybe a four, okay, four issues, all right, what’s our next category?
Dr G 53:03
Diplomacy
Dr Rad 53:05
Hmm, I feel like no, not at all.
Dr G 53:11
Okay, that’s a zero then easy peasy.
Dr Rad 53:14
Yeah.
Dr G 53:15
Expansion
Dr Rad 53:17
Well, yes. I mean, if capenna is, well, I don’t think appendix necessarily becoming part of Rome, per se, they’ve just made peace with Rome.
Dr G 53:26
Yeah, and it doesn’t sound like a territorial conquest. It just sounds like the usual pillaging, and yeah,
Dr Rad 53:34
like they’re not fighting really.
Dr G 53:35
Stop, please stop this.
Dr Rad 53:38
I’m sick of this, please just let us lie down
Dr G 53:40
Please I want to eat my olives
Dr Rad 53:43
Exactly.
Dr G 53:45
All right. The fourth category is virtus. Do we have any manly men demonstrating great masculinity?
Dr Rad 53:53
Kind of. I don’t feel like it really classifies of virtus, per se, but we do have, of course, the patrician senators basically scaring the plebeians into shutting up.
Dr G 54:09
I don’t think so.
Dr Rad 54:12
They intimidated into being quiet.
Dr G 54:15
That’s intimidation. Virtus, is the root from which we will get the word virtue eventually. So I’d hate to think that intimidation comes into the same sort of category.
Dr Rad 54:26
No, but they’re doing it like a manly way. They’re like, Hey, I have so many amazing honors to my name, and I’m such a cool dude, and I’m all patrician and stuff. What about it? You want to take me on? You want a piece of me? You want a piece of me?
Dr G 54:41
I’m just going to continue shaking my head, because everybody who listens to a podcast can understand a head shake.
Dr Rad 54:48
All right, fine.
Dr G 54:50
I think it’s a zero,
Dr Rad 54:51
Okay,
Dr G 54:53
All right, Okay, excellent. And finally, the citizen score. Is it a good time to be a Roman citizen? And I’m going to pre empt this and say, I don’t think so.
Dr Rad 55:02
No, you would think it would be the best of times, Dr, G, given that you just double the size of your city. But unfortunately, because you can’t live where you want, it’s not so good.
Dr G 55:14
Yes, no, this is unfortunate because, yes, Rome has achieved this great thing. You would expect some benefits to float with people from it, but instead, what we see is like you have to repay back the booty somehow, out of your own money, because I forgot the vow.
Dr Rad 55:30
And look, there’s definitely an undertone that Livy feels like the people are being a little spoiled, and that they’re exaggerating how bad things are, but you’ve got to admit that there’s obviously some truth to what is being said about them having to give stuff back,
Dr G 55:48
Exactly. And I think it’s debatable about whether, if you have to move somewhere away from your home in order to be a colonist somewhere else, that may or may not be a good thing, depending on your perspective
Dr Rad 56:00
Well, the Veuu thing – they’re keen on that they want to move today, because they already has nicer houses and nicer public buildings. They want to be in a better place, you know. So they’re quite happy to be colonists there. And apparently they can see it
It’s so close, I can smell it!
Exactly, yeah, right in front of their noses.
Dr G 56:23
It is very close, not gonna lie.
Dr Rad 56:26
So look, they do have tribunes of the plebs standing up for them, and they are putting up a fight. Does that count for anything?
Dr G 56:34
Well, and the fact that the it seems that Rome’s military exploits in this year haven’t been disastrous for the people who have had to enact them.
Dr Rad 56:42
Yeah?
Dr G 56:42
I think, yeah, that is often as good as it gets when you’re a Roman citizen. So I’d be inclined to maybe give it a five, like-
Dr Rad 56:51
Really? Oh my God, that’s like crazy generous. I thought it was like a three.
Dr G 56:57
I’m happy to be negotiated down. But yes, obviously it could be far worse.
Dr Rad 57:03
It could be worse. I feel like a four, because they’re definitely not getting their way. And there is that rumor that maybe some of the tribunes of the plebs have been bought off by the patricians, and that’s why they’re not able to 100% push this deal over the line.
Dr G 57:20
Ah, yes, that’s a good point. I hadn’t been thinking about that. Yes, okay,
Dr Rad 57:24
All right. Four, it is, all right. Dr, G, that means the Romans have ended up on a grand total of eight golden eagles. You would think-
Dr G 57:34
Wow
Dr Rad 57:35
they would have so much more after such a massive conquest. But no, once again, they have ruined it by fighting amongst themselves.
Dr G 57:44
They always find a way to let themselves down. I was like, Rome, you’ve got so much potential, just don’t let yourself down like this.
Dr Rad 57:51
Do you know what it is upsetting we didn’t get to talk about the women at all in that Partial Pick. They don’t factor into that at all. Well, it’s been so long, Dr G, so long since I talked about a woman.
Dr G 58:04
And it’s not like we got to talk about a woman. We got to talk about women
Dr Rad 58:09
Yeah, a nameless group of women who were probably invented to embarrass women who were real and living much later.
Dr G 58:17
Yes, I suspect so. I mean, that’s my concern, certainly from the later sort of evidence where we definitely have women being like, I am not paying your tax. Got to be kidding me, and you’re like, that sounds more historically accurate,
Dr Rad 58:34
All right. Dr G, well, I think we better leave Rome there reveling in its measly eight golden eagles, but in good news, it means my jewelry collection is somewhat restored.
Dr G 58:55
Thank you for listening to this episode of the Partial Historians. You can find our sources sound credits and transcript in our show notes. Over at partialhistorians.com we offer a huge thank you to you, if you’re one of our illustrious Patreon supporters, if you enjoy the show, we’d love your support in a way that works for you. Leaving a nice review really makes our day we’re on Ko-Fi for one or four ongoing donations or Patreon. Of course, our latest book, ‘Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire’, is published through Ulysses press. It is full of stories that the Romans probably don’t want you to know about them. This book is packed with some of our favorite tales of the colorful history of ancient Rome. Treat yourself or an open minded friend to Rome’s glories, embarrassments and most salacious claims with’Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire’.
Transcribed by https://otter.ai
The post Episode 161 – ¿Por Qué No Los Dos? appeared first on The Partial Historians - Ancient Roman History with smart ladies.
Rounding out our trilogy of special episodes on Ridley Scott’s Gladiator II, we are joined by gladiator expert, Alexandra Sills.
Special Episode – Gladiator II with Alexandra Sills
Alexandra holds a BA in Classical Studies from Birkbeck College, University of London and a MA in The Classical Mediterranean from the University of Leicester. Alexandra’s MA dissertation was awarded the Mark Pluciennik prize in Archaeology & Ancient History. Alexandra has published outreach articles for Bad Ancient and Working Classicists and recently published an academic article entitled ‘The Tropification of Hollywood Heroes Thrown Into the Arena’ for Melita Classica in 2023. Alexandra’s current research focuses on gladiators in the ancient world and their reception on film and television. We’re thrilled to have her on the show to discuss all things gladiators.
We start with a history of the development of the gladiator in the Roman world including:
Are there things that Gladiator II gets right from the perspective of the ancient evidence? We discuss the possibilities with Alexandra.
Fred Hechinger plays Emperor Caracalla, Pedro Pascal plays General Acacius and Joseph Quinn plays Emperor Geta in Gladiator II
Gladiator II – Macrinus played by Denzel Washington
Check out our other episodes on Gladiator II with experts Dr Lindsay Steenberg and Professor Martin M. Winkler.
Our theme music is by Bettina Joy de Guzman.
Lightly edited for the Latin and our wonderful Australian accents!
Dr Rad 0:15
Welcome to The Partial Historians.
Dr G 0:19
We explore all the details of ancient Rome,
Dr Rad 0:23
everything from political scandals, the love affairs, the battled wage and when citizens turn against each other. I’m Dr Rad.
Dr G 0:33
And I’m Dr G. We consider Rome as the Romans saw it, by reading different authors from the ancient past and comparing their stories.
Dr Rad 0:44
Join us as we trace the journey of Rome from the founding of the city.
Dr G 0:54
Hello and welcome to a new, very special episode of The Partial Historians. I am one of your hosts, Dr G.
Dr Rad 1:04
And I am Dr Rad.
Dr G 1:07
And we are super thrilled to have a special guest with us today, Alexandra Sills. Now I’ll just give you a quick bio. Alexandra Sills holds a BA in Classical Studies from Birkbeck College, University of London, and an MA in the Classical Mediterranean from the University of Leicester. Alexandra’s MA dissertation was awarded the Mark Pluciennik prize in Archeology and Ancient History. Alexandra has published a range of articles for Bad Ancient and Working Classicists, and recently published an academic article entitled ‘The tropification of Hollywood heroes thrown into the arena’ for Melita Classica in 2023. Alexandra’s current research focuses on gladiators in the ancient world and their reception on film and television. And if you haven’t guessed already, we are thrilled to have Alexandra on the show to discuss gladiators. And of course, the most recent foray of gladiators on the big screen, Ridley Scott’s Gladiator Two. Welcome Alexandra.
Alexandra Sills 2:21
Hello. Thank you for having me. Absolutely thrilled to talk about this film. There’s so much to talk about.
Dr G 2:28
Soooo much to talk about. So to get us started, a soft launch, if you like, into this foray. What makes a gladiator in the ancient Roman world. When do they originate and when do they go out of fashion?
Alexandra Sills 2:45
Okay, that’s a really good question, and it’s one that’s got quite an interesting answer, I think, because everyone assumes that they’re really stereotypically Roman. But actually, the Romans stole the idea from other cultures, and we’re not entirely sure which other cultures they got the most inspiration from, because nobody bothered writing that down. But we do know that down in Campania, which is the area around Naples and Pompeii, they were having fights long before they did in Rome. That tended to be something that they did after battles with prisoners of war and sometimes during feasts. And also, the Etruscans were having combats as well. So the Romans were looking to the north and to the south and seeing, Oh, this is actually quite a fun entertainment. Why don’t we try it? So the first recorded fight in Rome, according to Livy, was in 264 it was for a funeral of a former consul, and it was put on by his sons. They decided that they were going to have something to make this particular funeral, something really memorable for everyone who turned up. And the Romans had just won a battle, and some of the guests were told, brought along some prisoners of war as guests, as presents for the family. And someone had the idea, let’s make them fight. So they did. And there were three pairs of gladiators at that first funeral, and then as funerals, it became, you know, popular to have that first one, obviously, was a hit. You see more and more and more gladiators being at each funeral until that part of the funeral could last multiple days, and it was put on either by the tomb or in the forum, if it was particularly big, and the whole of Rome would come out. And it was the point was not necessarily as a sacrifice to the dead, because that’s not something that the Romans were particularly interested in. But it was a show, particularly since these men were former consuls, and that’s a military role to show some military prowess, particularly, and. Prisoners of war, they’re usually caught with their own kit and their own skills, so they don’t need a lot of training, and so that they could be presented as a celebration. This is a former consul he was in charge of the army, and look, we’ve got prisoners of war fighting to the death, because we can do that because we’re winners. So that’s how they kind of started. And then Julius Caesar decides, I’m going to use this to my political advantage. Because why not? So he, of course, Julius Caesar started to say, I need to put on some games, because I can see how they’re making my peers really popular and look fantastic, especially to voters, but no one in my family’s died. What do I do? So he starts,
Dr Rad 5:48
What a tragedy.
Alexandra Sills 5:50
No one’s dead. It’s awful. So he starts putting on games 20 years after his family members have died, slightly delayed saying, Oh, I wasn’t rich enough to do it before, or, you know, I didn’t have the means, but I can do now, and I want to catch up. And it was always –
Dr Rad 6:09
We’ve all had those situations where your to do list gets away from you.
Alexandra Sills 6:13
Especially when your to do list is as long as his was. But, you know, he was saying, I can do it now, so I should, and it was very convenient that it was always in a year where he needed to win an election soon. So then you start having laws brought in by the senate saying, Julius, he’s been nuts. We need to put caps on how many gladiators you can have at a funeral, for instance. And he is assassinated before he can start completely divorcing funerals from gladiators. But then you get Augustus, and he’s been watching and he thinks, yeah, I can’t have rivals putting on a show bigger than I can. I’m going to monopolize gladiatorial combat, take it away from funerals and just make it mine. I’m the only one who can do it.
Dr G 7:04
Oh, the classic Augustus power move.
Dr Rad 7:07
It’s my thing. Yeah.
Alexandra Sills 7:08
Yeah. And that’s when it starts turning into the Imperial thing, where it’s put on by the emperor for the people, instead of by the sun for a dead father. And it carries on going and getting bigger and bigger and bigger for a couple of centuries, and we don’t really see it decline until the four or five hundreds. So it happened for an awfully long time. 1000s and 1000s, 10s of 1000s of gladiators were fighting across the entire empire.
Dr Rad 7:37
That is crazy when you think about it.
Dr G 7:39
It becomes quite an industry, hmm.
Dr Rad 7:42
I know now for some people seeing gladiator or gladiator two or some such might be the extent of their exposure to gladiators. You know, this is might be where they’re learning about gladiators. So thinking about gladiator two, tell us what are some perhaps surprising things that this film gets right about gladiators?
Alexandra Sills 8:08
So one of them seems to be accidental, but I’m going to go with it anyway.
Dr Rad 8:13
I love when historical movies do this.
Alexandra Sills 8:15
They had a character who was played by a Palestinian actress, and we don’t know who she was, but we think from the the stills that have been released that she was part of the staff of Denzel Washington’s character, but for reasons unknown to be diplomatic, she was cut from the film, and apparently it’s her narrative arc has been replaced at the last minute by a character who is the doctor in the gladiatorial school. And that’s brilliant, not for the actress, but for my purposes, because it does show that gladiatorial combat was not brutal, but survivable. And that, because they were huge investments and they were worth a lot of money, you would absolutely provide the best medical care available. For instance, one of the most famous doctors from the ancient world, chap called Galen started his career in Pergamon in Turkey as a gladiatorial doctor. And he credits his wonderful breadth of knowledge with spending two years with these guys who are getting sliced open all the time so that he can actually See inside what’s happening with tendons, muscles, internal organs. He wouldn’t have got access to that otherwise. So he credits two years at a gladiatorial school with giving him the wonderful amount of knowledge that meant that he could later come to Rome, and I think, you know, be a doctor for emperors, for goodness sake. So, yeah, the the gladiators were getting injured a lot. We don’t have a lot of gladiatorial skeletons. There’s a cemetery in York and a cemetery in Ephesus, and both of those cemeteries have skeletons with huge amounts of wounds, some of them we can tell time of death. This is what caused the guy to die. But there are also loads of wounds that have shown signs of healing and show signs of care in the healing as well, not just breaks, but cuts, slices. These bones are, you know, they tell a story. There’s even some bones. There’s one from York, which has got bites in it, you can see the teeth marks.
Dr G 10:43
Oh, God.
Alexandra Sills 10:46
And they go deep. I think it was into a hip bone. And, my goodness, I can’t imagine how that must have felt. I think they’ve measured the gaps between the teeth and how big the teeth are. I think they said it might have been a bear.
Dr G 10:58
Wow
Alexandra Sills 10:59
Horrifying.
Dr G 10:59
Okay, yeah,
Dr Rad 11:02
The hip bone’s connected to the jaw bone
Alexandra Sills 11:07
But, yeah, absolutely, these guys would have had the top line of medical care. So it was really nice that, accidentally, they had this character added at the last minute and gave him that profession, because it does show that they were receiving some care. They weren’t just thrown away the first time they got a cut, because a cut is more dangerous in many ways, because you can get an infection.
Dr Rad 11:32
So I agree. I really liked that aspect of the doctor character was probably one of my favorite parts, because it wasn’t something that you actually saw very much of in the first movie, either. So that was like a new addition. And yeah, I agree that was a really nice touch. And it also does show, as you say, that the Romans, as much as obviously, we struggle with this aspect of their culture, sometimes it does show that they weren’t just keen to throw away the lives of these particular fighters. That wasn’t the purpose of these games, which I think is what people think. Sometimes they think the Romans wanted to see death. And I’m like, Well, it’s a little bit more complicated.
Alexandra Sills 12:17
Yeah, they absolutely weren’t going to see death. They were going to see how men reacted to impending death with dignity. It was like a kind of teachable moment. If you’re going to die, do it with some dignity, like these guys are, but they weren’t going for that. Specifically. They were going to see how you prevent your death through skill, through discipline. So it wasn’t going to see people die. It was going to see people try to kill using skill and discipline, but also to save their own skins, and that was a far, far more important aspect.
Dr Rad 12:56
Now, Little Timmy, we’ve brought you here for your fifth birthday so that you can learn life’s most important lesson.
Alexandra Sills 13:03
I mean, it’s, can you imagine the wiggles?
Dr G 13:07
It’s a whole new show now.
Alexandra Sills 13:12
But yeah, it was. It was not a conveyor belt of of death and destruction like we sometimes see in Hollywood. It was much more about the tactics and thinking things through. And you can see them thinking what their next move is going to be. How am I going to defend from this blow? So I think instead of, you know, just like mindless violence, we should consider it like how some people watch sport now from sofas. They’re not just thinking, ‘yeah, get him’ necessarily. They’re thinking, ‘okay, if it was me, I would go this way around, and I would make sure that I’ve got this defense’. And I, you know, we should think of the spectators as kind of back seat drivers, and they’re analyzing little pieces. It’s not mindless. They they know what they’re looking at. And they’re thinking, Yeah, okay, I like that. That technique is going to work. I think, yeah, okay, that’s good. Or I really don’t like that guy’s style. Does he not realize he’s leaving this side of his body, and, you know, undefended, what’s he doing? That kind of thing. We should consider them to be connoisseurs. I think that’s, that’s the better way to think about it.
Dr Rad 14:31
Yeah, which we’ve normally seen as, like, this crazy, mindless mob, which is what we normally see in movies, yeah,
Dr G 14:36
Uh oh, not the, not the crowd in the film.
Dr Rad 14:40
Not the crowd. Look, he’s coming in with the two swords, and he’s chopping that guy’s head right off. I hate it when he does that.
Dr G 14:49
Classic. I think this leads in really nicely to thinking about what, what makes a cinematic gladiator, as opposed to an an ancient world old gladiator. So we’ve got this idea that there there’s a sophistication to the fighting, a sophistication to the way that they’re looked after. The crowd is intelligent, knows what they’re looking for. How does this compare to the idea of the cinematic gladiator, and some of the tropes that come through in that version of the gladiator?
Alexandra Sills 15:24
Yeah, I’ve looked at a lot, a lot of screen gladiators for my research, and there are certain things that happen almost every single time. So one of them is the spectators will just be bloodthirsty, mindless, an anonymized mass incapable of any sophisticated thought. So let’s get rid of that straight away. One of the other things that makes a screen gladiator is that they don’t start off in a lowered position. The gladiator in Rome was the lowest of the low they were classed as infamia, which is where we get the word infamous, obviously. And that’s the same class as sex workers and funeral directors, because funeral directors, they touch corpses so they’re not clean anyone who sells their body. Sex workers, actors, these are people that you might cheer when you see them perform, but you’re not going to want to be seen next to them at a dinner party. That would be awful. But screen gladiators, they don’t start off as enslaved people or something like this. They’re always noble in their own way. They’re not, you know anyone plucked from obscurity, that they’re always generals or Starfleet commanders in Star Trek, that kind of thing, and they always have to be demoted before they can be thrown into the arena. And we see this in both gladiator movies, because Maximus is a general. Acacius is a general. Lucius is, you know, grandson of an emperor who is a general. So these guys aren’t the lowest of the low. They’re performing for plebs, because that’s what these spectators always are plebs. But they always have to have an honor that they’ve always had. They can’t earn honor in the arena. They can only claw some of it back, which I think is interesting, because that’s not what gladiators were doing in the real world. They were plucked from obscurity and completely self making their honor, rather than having to fight for it back. And there’s there’s other things that make a screen gladiator. You’ve always got to have a wife who’s killed horribly, or a family member who’s tortured.
Dr Rad 18:03
Gives you a reason to fight. Gotta get that rage.
Alexandra Sills 18:07
Yeah, it gives you, it gives them a reason to fight, but it kind of gives the audience permission to approve of them doing these horrible things that we see. If it was any other character beheading another for no other reason than this guy told me to you’d think it was awful, and that’s how we think of their opponents, who are not given any backstory. They’re just awful, aren’t they, but our heroes have something noble to fight for because they’re mourning or they have a love interest that they want to get back to, so it kind of gives them a humanity that therefore gives us permission to say, Yeah, okay, we’re gonna let you stab that guy, because we understand why you want to do it. And that is kind of giving us permission to not be the mindless, bloodthirsty mass of the Roman spectators, even though we’re all watching the same thing, which is interesting, because the Romans kind of did give their spectators permission to watch this by anonymizing their gladiators. They did the opposite. They didn’t give them back stories and make them underdogs. And you know, talk about the loved ones that they had at home. The Romans, put a helmet on them, gave them stage names and absolutely no personality whatsoever, so that they were dehumanized in a way that the spectators could think, yeah, okay, I can watch them die because I can’t see their face. I can’t see the fear on their face. There’s no emotion there. It might – it’s barely a person. We can watch them die if necessary, but we do the opposite. We give them families, and we give them hopes and dreams and a reason to escape the arena and the life that they can just see for themselves, just over the horizon, if they can just get out. So I think that’s an interesting kind of inversion to what we do.
Dr Rad 19:58
It is interesting.
Alexandra Sills 19:59
Yeah.
Dr Rad 19:59
Yeah, yeah. It is interesting when you think about the comparison to, like, modern day, you know, WWF fighters or MMA. I can’t even remember what those things are called, because I’m no interest in them whatsoever in real life. But we also don’t do that with them either, like you don’t have them coming out going, well, here’s Steve Austin, and he’s got a lovely wife, who’s 35 at home and two adorable children. He is going to slam his opponent. Nor can you actually imagine, in ancient Rome someone announcing Spartacus coming out and saying, This is Spartacus. He was sold into slavery with the love of his life. He’s going to be fighting for her today.
Alexandra Sills 20:38
Yeah, they would have thought that was bizarre. So yeah, it’s, it’s interesting that for us, obviously there has to be a storyline to make a movie, although someone needs to perhaps remind Ridley Scott that storylines need a bit more work. It’s, it’s not just that we need a narrative arc, but they all have the same ones. They all have the murdered wife. They all have a love interest outside of the murdered wife, just to give them a little bit more love to still to come. They all have the same inner turmoil, which means that pretty much every gladiator on screen, including in fantasy, sci fi comedy, they all copy Spartacus, in a way, and it means that they’re all kind of copy pastes. It’s always the same storyline, just in a slightly different setting, which
Dr Rad 21:38
is an interesting thing to bring up, actually, because whilst I know the Starz series is quite different, and there are so many versions of Spartacus which don’t follow this particular storyline, but the really famous Spartacus from 1960 he actually doesn’t start from a high point. He, I mean, his character starts from a high point. That’s what we’re meant to leave, right? But he actually does start from obscurity. He’s meant to be the mines. So in that, in that respect, he doesn’t fit this particular trope, but we see enough of him, in terms of his training at the gladiator school and the relationship that he builds with verinia that a lot of those tropes you’re talking about apply. And that’s exactly what Howard Fast was going for he as incredibly unlikely it was that somebody would be taken from the mines and put into the arena. He wanted to have that particular arc where he goes from nothing to being this incredibly noble, admirable person, and that’s what we see in in that movie, but, but that is weird. It’s weird to see, yeah, coming from slavery.
Alexandra Sills 22:42
I think that’s really interesting, because Howard Fast obviously has him as this messianic figure that manages to really, truly threaten Rome. And let’s be honest, he really did truly threaten Rome. And yeah, but you know, we all know how that movie was made, and he had to be brought down a peg or two – communism – but the Starz series has him as a warrior who who’s telling the Roman general, if you did it my way, we’d be winning this battle right now, which you know feeds in again, the more that gladiators develop on screen, the more they have to have martial experience before the arena. Not only is it a shortcut, a narrative shortcut, you don’t have to train them because they’ve already, you know, won all of these big battles, but they –
Dr Rad 23:35
And they’re brilliant. They’re naturally just brilliant.
Alexandra Sills 23:38
They’re all, you know, prodigies of of warfare. But it’s really interesting. Even in in speculative fiction, you’ve got say, Katniss Everdeen, going into the Hunger Games, they make sure to mention she’s an ace with a bow because of her hunting. In all of them, you have to have this kind of, don’t worry, guys, this person’s going to be fine, or perhaps not fine, but they’re going to do well because they have prior experience that ties along with their inner honor. So yeah, it’s it wasn’t a surprise to me when they had Lucius in that first battle, you know, doing his thing, being amazing, even though he clearly had no training as a child back in Rome, he’s received it elsewhere, and now he’s a military genius, just like the other ones. Of course, he is.
Dr Rad 24:35
Well, I mean, this is, I’m so glad you brought up Lucius Verus Aurelius, supposed hero of this film, perhaps the most disappointing aspect of Gladiator Two, not because of you, Paul. I’m not blaming you, but yeah, let’s talk about him and how he is matching up to these tropes. Because, yeah, you’re totally right. He was a little pampered imperial prince when we saw him last, and now he is a rugged, masculine sword on legs.
Alexandra Sills 25:08
Yeah, none of this decadence that you see in Rome, obviously that would be awful.
Dr Rad 25:14
I turned my back on my noble heritage.
Alexandra Sills 25:17
So we obviously you see him first tending his farm. Because, guess what? His dad had a farm. It’s in his blood, tending his farm with his wife, and they have a little bit of a kiss over the laundry. And you know she’s going to be dead in two minutes.
Dr G 25:36
Yeah, the setup is real.
Alexandra Sills 25:38
So she immediately gets pushed into a refrigerator off of a wall, into the sea within minutes. And you know that’s going to happen because it happens. Every single one of these stories follows the same path, the same narrative blocks. So you knew she was going to die, and she does thankful at least that they gave her a bow and arrow so that she at least went down fighting, which is a massive improvement.
Dr Rad 26:02
Women are always now military geniuses as well, but not genius enough to not get killed immediately in their very stylish corseted kind of breast armor.
Alexandra Sills 26:13
Oh, the boob armor. Yeah, that wall had crenalltions. She could have hidden herself perfectly well, but no, she stands up completely undefended. Of course she does. So, yeah, he’s obviously devastated. His wife’s just died. Because you have to have them devastated. It gives them a reason to fight the imperialism itself. Isn’t enough of a reason, because that happens to all of them. You need to give them personal reason, because they are special. They’re the main character. So he’s given his reason. That’s lovely. You see her go off to the underworld. Nice touch. I have to say, I enjoyed seeing Charon. I do think it was a bit of a missed opportunity. I love seeing Charon with his little boat, bless him, but I think they could have tied in, if you’re going to have anachronisms, go for it, but I think it would have been really cool to see his wife get on the real Charon’s boat over to the underworld and then in the arena later to feature the Charon character that you sometimes see in literature in the arena, who was a member of the staff dressed as the god, the Etruscan version of the God, who would come in with a hammer. And if there are any prone gladiators, and you think, are they dead? Are they faking it? Are they just trying to get out of, you know, being stabbed, the usual way, Charon would come on as massive hammer and whack him on the head, just to make sure that they were truly dead and weren’t faking it. I thought that would have been such a wonderful call back. You could have had him have it like a PTSD episode when he sees this guy dressed as Charon and remember his wife and go into berserker mode. But, you know,
Dr Rad 26:34
That would have been cool.
Alexandra Sills 27:34
It would have been cool, but you know, that would have required a movie that had more time spent on the script, maybe.
Dr Rad 28:08
It irritated me at the time that they had that afterlife segment, because to me, it was just trying to give Lucius the Maximus thing with the grain. It was just his version of the grain that we constantly saw Maximus, you know, running his hand through with the sad music. And, yeah, the biggest thing I hated, I suppose, about this movie was how much it was just trying to hit those same notes as the first film, and doing it so badly.
Alexandra Sills 28:35
Yeah
Dr Rad 28:36
That, yeah, it actually irritated me. But I do see where you’re coming from, and I like your vision.
Alexandra Sills 28:41
Yeah, you know, if there is a Gladiator Three, and apparently there is going to be, you know, call me. I work for cheap.
Dr G 28:49
Yeah, get some real gladiator information in there. You know, stack that script with something really cool.
Alexandra Sills 28:55
He doesn’t allow, you know, experts on on set. I think he did talk to someone beforehand with the script, but they weren’t allowed on set because he was so annoyed about the Napoleon comments, it would have made the film better having the expert on set. It didn’t have to be, you know, every day, but just little things would have been anyway.
Dr G 29:20
Well, I was thinking, like, in terms of thinking about these tropes related to the cinematic gladiators. Obviously Lucius is fitting right in there, and also creating this kind of, like mirror image, if you like, to Maximus, which is obviously part of what this film is all about. But now that we’re talking about Charon as well, and this element of the Underworld, I think it’s time to hit that note of Virgil’s Aeneid. And the quotation that is floating through this film that gets repeated again and again, and it’s a famous translation of Virgil’s Aeneid. It comes from John Dryden and. And it’s Aeneid Book Six, lines 126 to 129, for the cool kids in the crowd who want to go and have a look at their Virgil’s Aeneid, “The gates of hell are open night and day. Smooth, the descent and easy is the way, but to return and view the cheerful skies in this the task and mighty labor lies.” Now, I think, first of all, it was hilarious to me that we saw it in English in some places. But this also is a direct reference to Aeneas attempt to go down into the Underworld. So, yeah, this is an idea that comes through in a lot of ancient heroic literature. This really symbolic katabasis, a journey to the underworld, where you survive and are able to return.
Alexandra Sills 30:52
Yeah.
Dr G 30:53
And I’m interested in your perspective on what’s going on with Lucius and this idea of the journey to the Underworld. There’s clearly a moment where he’s getting access to seeing parts of the Underworld in moments. So yeah, I’m keen for your thoughts on this.
Alexandra Sills 31:09
I thought it was really interesting. And to start off, I thought, Oh, they’re making a real attempt to engage with, you know how the ancients thought about death. Then I thought, maybe I’m giving them too much credit, but it was interesting the way that they made him quote that they’re they’re not only harking back to the education that he had as a childhood and that he clearly still remembers. He he still connects with that part of his identity before he was forced to flee. But I thought it was interesting because it’s clearly marking Lucius. He’s got an education. He’s elite, he’s noble. He can quote Virgil, he’s noble, and that’s how you can tell he’s not your average gladiator. And in a film that’s supposed to be saying that gladiators can change the world, even though that we know that they didn’t. It’s interesting that they have to mark him out as superior to the other ones. He’s different. It’s only the exceptional gladiator that can change the world, because the rest of them are mindless drones who just, you know, they have a sword put in their hand and do as they’re told. So I did think it was interesting that they kind of had to make him the literary gladiator. He’s got a mind. He thinks for himself. Oh, okay, fine. Everyone clapped. But yet, I thought it was again interesting to think of his whole journey as a katabasis. He goes into the arena. It’s the liminal place of death. He’s constantly trying to communicate with his dead father, who, of course, failed in his katabasis. They’re not always successful in Greek literature, I think it was, oh, who was it? Theseus went down there, and Hercules went down there. Someone didn’t come back up. And I can’t remember who my professor, who taught me my katabasis module, is currently slamming her head against the table.
Dr G 33:08
The important point is that not everybody makes it some attempt it and do not return.
Alexandra Sills 33:11
Absolutely. Some attempts fail. And it’s important to remember that the katabasis is a huge undertaking that is supposed to be difficult. That’s why it’s such a great story. So, yeah, he, of course, goes into the arena. It’s a place of death communicating. He wants to achieve something. You don’t just go down there for a holiday. You’re going down to achieve something. And it brings it back to the idea that his father didn’t survive. And the thing is, with the first film, it ends with a positive note, Maximus has died, but he sacrificed himself for the greater good, and everything’s going to be fine now, and we’re going to end with a sunrise to symbolize it. But the problem with coming up with a sequel that never should have happened is you have to admit to yourself, we’re following history. So we have to say to our audience, the whole first film happened for nothing, because it didn’t change anything. And in fact, it’s worse. So it’s kind of putting that katabasis in to say the first katabasis was amazing, but it failed. You didn’t come back out of the arena. So technically, it wasn’t a katabasis at all. It was just a really elongated suicide mission. But Lucius, he knows this in advance. He’s watched one happen before. He’s thinking about the past all the time. It’s like he’s read the Odyssey and the Indian that have got these maps of the underworld, and this is how he’s going to survive. He’s going to learn from previous trips into the liminal space full of death. So I did think that was interesting, particularly since he does survive. But it’s actually in in all of the other gladiatorial stories, you’re far more likely to survive in sci fi, fantasy, speculative fiction, if you’re the protagonist, loads of your friends will die. But in the swords and sandals, your chances of dying are much higher. So Spartacus, obviously, he doesn’t die in an arena, but the battle is shown as one large arena. So he obviously does. He has to. Pompeii Milo, played by Kit Harington, with his 0% body fat, he dies again, not in an arena, but you could talk about Vesuvius as you know, the ultimate opponent. He dies.
Dr Rad 35:45
He’s close to an arena.
Alexandra Sills 35:46
Yeah, he’s he’s adjacent, and Maximus dies. Lucius is one of the only swords and sandals gladiatorial protagonists to actually reach the end credits with all of his limbs intact and still breathing. So that’s pretty incredible. So the whole katabasis motif that they’re using is pretty fitting, because not only in the literature, but in the movie history of gladiators, the swords and sandals ones, they don’t leave generally. So yeah, I thought it was interesting. But again, if you’re, if you’re going to introduce these ideas and then announce another sequel that perhaps doesn’t need to happen, you’re going to need to change it again. So it’ll be interesting to see what they do. If they do, I don’t know.
Dr G 36:41
I’m very excited for Gladiator Three, which doesn’t involve the arena at all, but is just senatorial politics, as Lucius tries to wrangle everybody into line in in the way and manner of Tiberius and getting frustrated and then maybe leaving Rome again, being like, you know, I’m done with you guys, I can’t.
Dr Rad 37:04
that would be cool if we had a Tiberius inspired Lucius, I’d be on board for that. But I have to come back to this idea that that Lucius survives. I totally get what you’re saying about the particular storyline they’re possibly following. But as someone who constantly disappointed me in this film, what do you think about the lack of a tragic death volusus, I mean, would it have made it a better movie if he also, I think, died, or is it too much like Maximus?
Alexandra Sills 37:38
They did follow the storyline of the first one almost exactly, and they had to change it somewhere. But I do think he probably should have died, because, for a start, we know that he never became emperor. So you’ve got that hurdle, you’ve you’ve changed history so much, either you’ve got to start saying we’re going completely fictional, or you’ve got to admit this guy should have been dead for a couple of decades already. What I found interesting was the way that Macrinus is constantly talking about Lucius rage and how it’s a gift. Never let it go. It will carry you to greatness. And I thought that that probably unintentionally, had kind of parallels to Achilles in the Iliad, his rage is a tool that will carry him to greatness. Because Achilles, everyone knows the name Achilles now. And I thought that was an interesting parallel. On the other hand, for a gladiator, I think rage is the last thing that you want, because rage makes you careless, and we do see him being fairly careless at times during the movie.
Dr Rad 39:01
And that’s a big difference with Maximus, actually.
Alexandra Sills 39:03
Yeah
Dr Rad 39:05
That’s a bit of a difference with Maximus, because Maximus is dead inside. He is calm and calculated when he is forced to fight because he doesn’t care. He’s like, I don’t care if I live or die. I don’t he like. He has a certain level of rage towards certain people and about certain things, but it’s nothing like what Lucius is shown to have in this particular film I don’t think.
Alexandra Sills 39:29
No, you’re right. I think Maximus died when he saw his family at the farm. Really exactly Lucius is angrier. It’s not an anger that particularly goes anywhere. It’s kind of –
Dr Rad 39:47
We’re told he’s angry, but is he? I mean, he has moments, but it’s like when people tell me, you seem upset and I wasn’t upset, but then I feel upset because they’ve said that. I feel like that’s what happens to Lucius. People say You seem angry. You seem filled with rage. And he’s like, what?
Alexandra Sills 40:02
Well, I am now. What are you trying to say about my face?
Dr Rad 40:03
Exactly! What are you trying to say about me?
Alexandra Sills 40:09
For a start, he he’s sent straight to the arena, which, again, it didn’t happen the there’s a line Macrinus says in the film, gladiators are nearly all prisoners of war. That might have been true in the middle Republic, but it’s certainly not true into a mature empire. There were, there was no point. By that point gladiators, and this is something that the film doesn’t understand, gladiators were highly, highly specialized. They were fighters, but they weren’t soldier fighters. They weren’t transferable skills necessarily. You wouldn’t put a legionary in untrained into an arena, just as you wouldn’t send an army of gladiators out onto the field, because it’s not the same style. So we see a little bit of training, but we don’t see the weird differences in between the gladiators. So for instance, the retiarius with his trident and net, that’s weird, and it’s cool because it’s weird. They’re seeing something that they don’t see on battlefields, all of these different types, the retiarius, the mermelo, they’re all highly, highly specialized in style, and that’s what gives you the novelty, the diversity in fights, because they’re not all the same. Every single fighter has a different style. They’re always put on against the same type of opponent, so that’s specifically what they train for. And because of this, this specific styles and training that they need, they weren’t using prisoners of war. They were much more likely to have a stable of gladiators that was mainly enslaved people that they’d bought for the purpose and would train from scratch so that they didn’t have any bad habits from their previous life. You could train them to do exactly what you wanted them to do, and volunteers from from free men. So again, the fact that he’s a soldier, the fact that Acacia Maximus, they’re all soldiers, and that’s supposed to set them apart. I think actually, it would have been a more interesting film to say, yes, these guys are battlefield whizzes, but it doesn’t help them in the arena, because this is an entirely new ball game.
Dr Rad 42:45
Well, I think it’s how they fight when we see them in battle scenes, because they are the hero. We are still seeing them in these kinds of moments that I think Livy would have loved, these fantastic jewels on the battlefield between them and another fantastic warrior from the other side, which is the kind of moment that historians like Livy enjoyed celebrating, but was not really, obviously what most people would have experienced being in the Roman military. You know, you have to be a team. You have to work together. It’s not about the one guy breaking through the lines and, you know, and challenging the other leader of the other side, that’s so unlikely to happen all the time.
Dr G 43:31
I think it also hits towards the problem of filmic gladiators, in the sense that the arena fighting in no way resembles what we would expect from the ancient evidence for how these things were conducted. So we know that there were umpires essentially who were always looking on and making sure that the rules of gladiatorial combat were being followed, and allowing for breaks and pauses and also seeking additional advice if needed. So there’s a whole apparatus around ancient gladiatorial fighting, which we I don’t, not in my expectation or not in my experience. And both of you have watched more gladiator films than I have so but I have not seen that on film?
Alexandra Sills 44:21
No, I mean, Spartacus Starz has probably the closest to what I would call authenticity in the fights, but even they don’t show a lot of referees or things like that, then they’re more consistent with their pairings, for instance. But there are certain things I would love to see a fight between two rivals, and they’re constantly calling ref, ref. Are you gonna? Are you seeing this?
Dr Rad 44:50
We agreed nothing on the face! I’ve got a really important date later on today.
Dr G 44:57
That’s right, the old falling over and clutching the legs. Being like, Oh, you got me!
Dr Rad 45:03
And they’re like, typical, he’s from Spain.
Alexandra Sills 45:09
And there is always this argument of, you can’t do authentic Roman fighting styles because it doesn’t work on screen. But it certainly worked for an arena where you’ve got people in a huge seating area who could still perfectly see what was going on.
Dr Rad 45:28
I think that’s because of what we’ve been trained to expect. There’s a certain with all of these things, like what you’re talking about with you, the tropes and the way that gladiator films mimic each other so closely, there’s a reason for that, right. Hollywood is, in its bones, conservative, because the number one goal is to make money, and the best way to make money is to stick with the sure thing, something that you know is going to pay dividends. And so you take the formula that’s always worked, and then you tweak it a bit, and there is something to be said for audiences going in and knowing what to expect and enjoying that, because they know what to expect, like for example, I am sadly and tragically. I know for 2024 almost 2025 will be 2025 by the time we release this, a fan of the James Bond movies. Why? Because I know what I’m getting when I go into a James Bond movie, and I get really upset when they play with the world. I don’t like it. I don’t like to I mean, spoilers everybody, but I didn’t like it that they killed off James Bond. Didn’t like it, didn’t care for it. And so I think that’s something to be said for gladiator films as well. We know what to expect. It’s a particular style of fighting. It’s a particular way of showing the arena sequences, and we enjoy it with a twist.
Alexandra Sills 46:46
Yeah, I think. And to be fair, that does mirror the Romans. That’s why they had these styles, so that they knew what to expect, so that they could analyze the tiny details, and, you know, learn, learn the ropes themselves, so that they could comment. So it is a fair comment. Um, I would love to see shields, though. I say this all the time, the shield. And this goes into another one of my points that I really wanted to make. There’s nowhere near enough nipples on display. All of these guys have got massive breast plates on, and this works if you’re on a battlefield. But the whole point of gladiatorial combat was it was different from being a soldier if you have all this armor on, the fight becomes too easy. If you’re half naked and you’re just wearing a little loin cloth and some padding around your arms and legs, it suddenly becomes a lot harder. The stakes suddenly become a lot higher. We should be seeing nipples left, right and center.
Dr Rad 47:56
So you’d like them with three nipples.
Dr G 47:59
Hollywood, are you paying attention?
Alexandra Sills 48:01
And this is where the shield comes in, because all of a sudden the shield doesn’t become something that’s handy. Suddenly it becomes absolutely essential. And you’ve got two different types. You have the scutarii. They’re using the Roman-style scutum, and which is quite large. It should, if held in the right position, come just above the base of your helmet, and then go just below your knee, so it’s covering most of you, which means that your opponent can see metal helmet, scutum, metal grieve. They’re seeing a tank. You’re an armored tank. And then you’ve got the guys the parmularii. They’re using the small parmula style sheet shields, which are smaller, sometimes round, about the size of a dustbin lid. And they’re a little bit smaller so they’ve got more on display, which means that their Greaves and their arm things are longer to compensate for that, but they have to work a little bit harder to protect their torsos as well. They’re the light that they didn’t really have heavy weight or light weight, so they don’t have weight classes at all. But if you think about it this way, you’ve got the tanks with the big shields, and you’ve got the more nimble guys with their little shields. They’ve got to move a bit harder.
Dr Rad 49:16
So not only guys, you know, they’re they’re pros and cons, basically.
Alexandra Sills 49:20
Absolutely. So not only have you got these guys that have got different fighting styles because of the gear that they’re wearing, you’ve also got a little bit of novelty and a little bit of diversity there in the styles, but it becomes something that’s absolutely essential, and it’s not just for defense. You can use it as an offensive weapon, and all of a sudden, the fights become more interesting because of that, because you’ve got to have two arms constantly working at once, which involves more brain power, more tactics. When we’ve seen fights on screen, they they look exactly the same as the. Jewels in medieval movies, because they don’t use the shields either. I think it’s just an opportunity maybe to show a different style, because it’s fun to watch. There was a little bit of shield work on the star Spartacus series, a little bit of shield work in the new ‘Those About To Die’ series on Peacock, and it does kind of demonstrate that it’s not, you’re not a soldier, and they’ve got these massive breast plates on, and it became a whole plot point, didn’t it with he’s got his father’s breastplate on, and it protected him.
Dr G 50:41
I mean, it does make you invincible. It’s like, it’s incredible, that breastplate, whatever it’s made out of, that’s what I want mine made out of.
Alexandra Sills 50:49
His plot armor was literally plot armor, which was a little bit on the nose for me, not, not the most subtle.
Dr G 50:58
No, no, and you’re expecting tragedy at that point, and that’s the moment that we don’t get the tragedy, and you realize something else is going to happen instead, you’re like, Uh oh. Taking this – you’ve mentioned Macrinus earlier, and so I want to bring things around to him, because to me, he is my favorite character in this film, yeah, but there is Denzel Washington, I think, brings the most amazing performance to this, and everybody else is kind of just trying to, like, actively catch up. But one of the things that I think is really interesting that they’ve decided to explore is the sort of fluidity of sexual expression that comes with this character, and we see this particularly with his interactions with the senator Thrax. And I’m interested about your perspective on how this sort of shapes up in comparison to the ancient evidence we have for Roman sexuality, particularly in this imperial period.
Alexandra Sills 52:00
Okay, so speaking about ancient sexuality, I think it’s interesting that all of the gladiators in particularly, in particular, are all very heterosexual, apart from in Starz Spartacus, which I don’t think is likely, personally, with Macrinus. I think it’s really interesting that they decided to go the way they did. And by what I’ve read about various interviews, particularly from Denzel Washington, is that he was pushing for it more than perhaps Ridley Scott intended. I heard there was a kiss that got cut. I would have loved to have seen that.
Dr G 52:40
Yes, I heard that too.
Alexandra Sills 52:41
Yeah, I think it’s interesting when these films put in ideas about race, gender and sexuality, but we have to be careful, because they’re always doing it from a modern perspective. So for instance, when we’re talking about black gladiators, they’re always doing it from a post 1960s experience in America. And I think they’re doing the same kind of thing with gender and sexuality. They want to talk about how the Roman world was different. It’s alien, but they’re doing it in a way that is commenting on the modern world, just a little bit too much for comfort. So for instance, in these movies, in the first one, the only queer character was a giraffe-
Dr Rad 53:41
Which was delightful.
Alexandra Sills 53:42
In the second in the second one, it’s Macrinus. Turns out to be evil. Sorry, spoiler alert, and the emperors are queer, coded and they’re evil. I would have liked to have seen something that wasn’t so cheap and predictable. I think it is possible to show that sexuality was entirely different without trying to take pot shots at wokery in a movie. So that that disappointed me, especially with the the Severans, because how do we show that they’re bad? We could show them doing bad things, or we could show them in makeup and and, you know, demonstrate, oh, these guys are gay, and that’s how you know that they’re bad. I thought that was really disappointing,
Dr Rad 54:40
Especially because, as you say, with Caracalla and Gaeta, this was a real opportunity, which people might not be aware of, because these are not particularly well known emperors, I would say. And I mean people who’ve been to Rome, they might have heard Caracalla name because of the baths, but they’re not very well known. They haven’t been shown widely in popular culture before, so people don’t really know them as personalities particularly well, the same way that they know someone like Caligula or Nero. And what they might be unaware of is where these guys come from, their parents, I suppose, in to put it into modern terms, that people would understand people of color and casting, and then the makeup on top of that, and then the queerness, I mean, it’s just it’s taking you so far away from reality. Now that might not be a problem if it was doing something interesting with it or doing something creative with it. But as you say, I was really disappointed that really Scott chose to go this direction, because I feel like it actually did him no – it just it did nobody any favors to go this direction. It didn’t add anything to the story. I don’t think it was just so problematic on so many levels, like when we saw the trailer and we saw their makeup, we were like, What is going on with that? And then to actually get into the movie and realize we were 100% right? And that was the message that Ridley Scott was trying to send. I was like, dude, what is this here? Like, I know you. I know you are an older director, but to me, that should bring wisdom. Yeah, you harking back to these 1950s 1960s things that we saw in Spartacus, where, you know, Crassus is the evil one, so he’s queer. It’s just, yeah,
Alexandra Sills 56:30
Exactly, yeah. It was cheap and it was unimaginative, and it could have been so much better, particularly Caracalla. Not only was he a person of color, but in the first film, you’ve got Commodus, who wishes that he was a guy that soldiers could identify with and admire, but Caracalla was the soldier’s emperor. They loved him. He loved them most of the time, but he was someone that they could identify with because he was a rough, tough, military type.
Dr Rad 57:07
Yeah, that’s where his name comes from, right?
Alexandra Sills 57:10
Yeah, exactly. And instead, you’ve got, I mean, it’s a film that talks about Rome is corrupt, and the fringes are where you will find honor. And then in the next breath, says, but the fringes are also they’re a different race, so let’s not be too kind about them. Then you’ve also got a wasted opportunity. With Caracalla being the type of emperor that Commodus wishes that he was, it would have been great to see Maximus son go up against the Emperor that his uncle wishes he was.
Dr Rad 57:48
Absolutely.
Alexandra Sills 57:49
It would have been great.
Dr Rad 57:50
Yeah, and this is where it’s like, okay, you don’t have to stick to history. Nobody’s saying that these days, most academics we speak to totally get that movies are not history lessons, and therefore you’re allowed to have creative license, but when you’re going against the history, and you’re not doing something better with it, and the actual history would have made for a better storyline, that’s where I’m lost, because I’m thinking the same thing as you. I’m thinking this film could have been so much better if you’d actually paid attention to the history, because it’s more interesting than what you came up with, which isn’t creative, it is rehashed garbage.
Alexandra Sills 58:26
Yeah and I think, I mean, I do agree it is a movie and it’s not, it’s not a lecture in some institution. On the other hand, I think that if a movie production shows attention to detail with the source material to the tiniest details. It also goes hand in hand with them being the type of production that spends time and effort thinking about smaller details, like, I don’t know, the narrative characterization, the dialog. I think it’s interesting that we can see very clearly that films that don’t care about authenticity also have terrible scripts and terrible dialog awful it’s the ones that pay attention to the little details that they’re the type to get the big details right. And I think this is why this movie was so disappointing, because it felt so it felt like something it’s difficult to describe. And the reason is because I’ve recently been doing some research on how the first gladiators movie has been viewed since by far right extremists, particularly in America, and reading that researching for that paper was so disheartening. I. Because I had to ask myself, why do they love the first film? What is there to see? So I was reading blogs and reading what they’re saying, you know, why are there people dressed as Maximus in the January 6 riots? There’s got to be reason for it. So I went back to look at the first film. And there is racism, there is misogyny, there’s all these kind of things, homophobia. In the second film, I can see all of this, except it’s been the volume has been turned up on it. Not only have you got whitewashed severins, who are now queer because queer equals evil, but you’ve got Macrinus. Macrinus is a black man who’s angry, which is, in itself, quite the trope already, is it not? But I think it’s really dangerous in the current climate to have a black man who used to be a slave and is now freed to go on such a revenge story, I think it’s sending the wrong message. You can’t free these men. You can’t give them equal opportunities, because they’re still angry, and they will come back at you with a sword in their hand. I think that’s the first film has become very popular with alt right groups, and I think the second film is going to be even more so. And the messaging in it, I get a little bit frustrated with it’s just a movie, because I’ve just spent, you know, a year deep, diving into people who don’t think it’s just a movie. They think it’s a manifesto, and it is having real world consequences, to the point where, if you see on social media, for instance, someone with a gladiator in their profile picture, nine times out of 10, if you read that bio, you’re going to be absolutely horrified.
Dr Rad 1:02:01
So that’s that’s accurate to say, in the sense that I don’t say any of these things, because I don’t think release got has any talent, obviously, hugely talented director, I love a lot of his movies, and I know that this isn’t held an opinion, held by every historian out there, but I actually really loved the first Gladiator, not because I am part of an alt right group. I should say.
Alexandra Sills 1:02:26
Yeah, it’s hard that you have to clarify.
Dr Rad 1:02:28
Yeah, exactly, but because it did exactly what I was just talking about. It did fictionalize the past massively, but it did so in a way that I think it still spoke to something that I recognized in the Rome that I study, which is that nostalgia for the Republic, which people like Tacitus, I mean, that’s their that’s their thing, that’s their brand. And so I recognize that, and also a character like Maximus, I recognize the Cincinnati’s character type, and I love seeing it on the screen. I totally recognize the way that people like to look at Marcus Aurelius and the way that he was characterized as well. And so I felt the first movie, whilst fictionalizing, still said something about the Rome that I studied, and it didn’t do it in such a problematic way that I couldn’t get into it. And it was cinematically stunning. This is the this is the thing with Ridley Scott, right? He is such a talented director, and he works with people who are obviously hugely talented as well in terms of the esthetic that they create. So all of his films, whether the storyline is good or not, are visually arresting. I mean, Napoleon Woo, My God, what a slog, and yet visually amazing, gorgeous, beautiful. Couldn’t floor what I was seeing, floored what I was hearing and the actual storyline. And that’s the danger, because we humans are very visual creatures. I mean, Ridley Scott himself is a visual creature, right? He’s influenced by other films. He’s influenced by art. Hell, Gladiator was supposedly inspired by a piece of art, and so surely he must understand the power of visual media to influence people’s real world actions, because that’s exactly why that’s a mythology that we’re fed about the reason that he got involved in the first gladiator film in the first place.
Alexandra Sills 1:04:14
Yeah, I mean, he’d already cast Caracalla and Geta with the palest actors he could have possibly found, I think, I can’t remember whether it was go to a Caracalla, but one of them was originally supposed to be Barry Keoghan, who is really incredibly pale, but he decided that he wanted to go off and do, I think it was Salt Burn, which, you know, is a whole different movie. So that’s why we got, I think it was Fred Hechinger, so he was Caracalla, who’s even paler, if that was even possible, because, you know, Barry Keoghan is properly Irish, milky white. And then to add white on top of that, and then to have Denzel Washington and with his authentic accent, for instance, which I know has caused issues, because, you know, everyone’s saying it’s New York accent, and that’s inauthentic. So is British RP. Sorry to disappoint everyone, on both those counts, noone ever spoke in an English accent in Rome. But I think what disappointed me so much was that all of these they’re not even micro aggressions, their aggression aggressions, and they felt more deliberate this time around.
Dr Rad 1:05:27
Agreed, yeah.
Dr G 1:05:28
Yes it was – It was turning up the dial on the lack of subtlety.
Alexandra Sills 1:05:32
Yeah, it was. It was the Gladiator Two, frankly, that perhaps 2024 deserved.
Dr Rad 1:05:40
Maybe, yeah, with Trump being elected into office, I he, I mean, I think that’s the thing with the first one, I could feel Ridley Scott channeling, you know, Suetonius and Tacitus in the way that he was characterizing some of the people in the film and the storylines that he was going for, not that they don’t have enough scandal going on anyway. There’s plenty there to play with, but I could feel that real Tacitean and Suetonian kind of influence. And so I was like, oh, okay, he’s channeling the source material there. But with this one, for some reason, I just did not get that same feeling. Instead, I was like, Oh, this is actually making me feel uncomfortable. This doesn’t feel like he’s channeling something from ancient Rome. This feels different somehow. And I really didn’t expect that from him. I mean, this is the guy who directed Thelma and Louise, like didn’t expect this.
Dr G 1:06:32
But I think you’ve make a fair point in the sense that what we’re looking at with GladiatorT wo is not a film that’s necessarily interested in the history it’s interested in Gladiator the original film,
Dr Rad 1:06:44
That’s true.
Alexandra Sills 1:06:45
Yeah.
Dr G 1:06:45
So like all of its touch points are not Tacitus. For instance, like we see a very sort of truncated Senate, they seem even less capable than they did in the first film, yeah? And yet, here we are. And so everything is kind of revamped, but, but with an expectation that your main source is Gladiator.
Dr Rad 1:07:16
That’s true, yeah? And Gladiator was channeling Spartacus and Fall of the Roman Empire, and maybe, I think we ended up getting back to this point with another person we were talking about this film with, and I sort of wondered that I’m like, is the problem that Ridley Scott was drawing on previous masterpieces like fall of the Roman Empire and Spartacus, which are really interesting films about ancient Rome, even though they also fictionalize. And with this one, he is just drawing on Gladiator. Maybe that’s the problem.
Alexandra Sills 1:07:45
I think it shows that he he’s demonstrating that he believes that Roman was corrupt and needed to be fixed, but also that he has no idea how to fix it. Because, as you say, the Senate is even worse in this film. But the whole point of both films is that they should go back to a Republic where the Senate are the dominant power.
Dr G 1:08:05
Yeah, terrible idea.
Alexandra Sills 1:08:07
Yeah, exactly. Both Maximus and Lucius are saying, oh, Republic, Republic. And you’re looking at senators like, like tracks in the second film, and you’re thinking, Well, why? Why are you trying to bring these people back to the point where, when Macrinus says his speech about Rome is corrupt and he could knock it over, and he intends to, I started thinking, Yes, show me that. Show me that. Because the Senate is useless. These emperors are useless. If we’re going to have any kind of revolution, don’t put the Senate back in charge, that would be the worst thing possible. But Macrinus at least shows some sense that he understands how Rome works.
Dr Rad 1:08:47
Yes, exactly, well. And that’s that’s what the previous Gladiator had, though, see again, and this is what it got from Spartacus. It had Gracchus.
Alexandra Sills 1:08:55
Yeah.
Dr Rad 1:08:56
which Spartacus also had Gracchus? Literally, the same character name and everything. They have these senators who are meant to be the inspirational ones, the ones that know what to do, and the senators in the first Gladiator, they at least do have intellectual discussions, debates about what room should be doing in this film. Oh, my God. I mean you, you don’t get any of that. And Gracchus, even though he’s still alive. Oh, we get the tiniest snippets of him, and one of them, he’s being killed and so it’s not the same!
Alexandra Sills 1:09:28
It was a quicxk scene as well, wasn’t it? Derek Jacobi deserves a grand death scene. If he’s gonna have to die, don’t just quickly slit his throat and then move on immediately to a next shot. Give him, you know, let him cook. He is one of the best actors in the world. Well, what a waste.
Dr Rad 1:09:46
I have confidence that if anybody could do a death scene theatrically and over the top, it’s him.
Alexandra Sills 1:09:51
Exactly. I mean, I know that they cut a lot from the first film, and I know that Ridley Scott has said this was my final cut, but I wonder what is on the cutting room floor, and what scenes with perhaps Derek Jacobi, and perhaps even with Thrax showing a little bit more backbone and a little bit more intelligence, because I don’t think in this film, Macrinus was right. I said it. Macrinus was right. He should have won, because he was the only one who knew what should be happening and had the balls to do it.
Dr G 1:10:30
Yup.
Dr Rad 1:10:31
Yeah.
Dr G 1:10:31
Yeah, that scene in the river was a setup. I mean, yeah, he should have survived. And Lucius clearly that breastplate should not have held up under those circumstances. And we could have moved back into something of a historical narrative, actually. I mean, macarinus does become emperor at some point, not in this way historically, but certainly eventually in our source material. Are there any historical inaccuracies that you haven’t mentioned so far that really drove you crazy about this film.
Alexandra Sills 1:11:08
Yeah, yeah. So and this, this happened a little bit in the first one as well, but much more in the second one. The film doesn’t really understand that the program in a day at the Colosseum was very rigid. In the morning, you had beast hunts. In lunchtime, you had executions, and at the afternoon, part of the show, you had the gladiators, and they were separate, with different sets of performers. Or condemned. You didn’t mix and match. You did. Certainly didn’t have someone who would fight a rhino one day and then fight a human the next. That didn’t happen and and I understand that they wanted to do it because it looked good the animals that they used. We know there have been a couple of academics, and I will mention no names who have gone in the medium and said that there weren’t rhinos. And we know that there were actually, I think it was Pompey Magnus bought the first Rhino over there were rhinos in the arena. Often what there weren’t was people writing them.
Dr Rad 1:12:17
Does seem dangerous.
Alexandra Sills 1:12:18
That was a little bit jumpy the shark for me. I think if you’re going to have someone riding an animal, you can do it. I would have suggested a war elephant, because we know that the ancients had loads of those, and the Romans came up against them often. So you could have had an elephant instead of the rhino with an archer on top, which is something that Roman soldiers would have had to deal with. That would have been brilliant. The sharks were, I wouldn’t have minded the sharks if they’d have looked better. They obviously weren’t in the arena. Because, yes, again, the Romans did know what sharks were, despite what some people have gone in the news to say, um, however, they had no way of catching, transporting and keeping them. They did have crocodiles. We know that they had crocodiles because they wrote about it. What I do wonder is perhaps those about to die also had a flooded Colosseum scene, and they had crocodiles. So I’m wondering if Ridley changed it because he’d been beaten to the punch and he knew it was going to be really second, and he didn’t want to be seen as copying either way have a shark, because if the Romans could have they would have just make them look better.
Dr G 1:13:34
Oh, you want some improvements to the CGI. Fair enough. Fair enough.
Dr Rad 1:13:38
As an animal rights person, I’m embracing this new trend to have CGI animals instead of actual animals knowing what’s happened to animals entertainment in the past. I’d rather they were paid with CGI because of what’s happened in the past. And I totally, I agree with you about all those, all those points, I have to say. Dr, G, this is one thing that I have to bring up as something that we haven’t talked about yet, Lucilla. I have to know Alexandra. What’s your opinion on Lucilla?
Alexandra Sills 1:14:16
Well, she should have been dead in the first film, if we’re going by the history. She died before Commodus in history, but she survived the first film, and that’s only because the only female person in their production team on the first film said, we’ve got two women, only one of them talks, and you’re talking about killing them both off. A woman has to survive, please, if the year is 2000 so in Gladiator Two, I think we’ve got four women, and two of them talk, so yay for progress. So she should she should be dead already. I thought that in the first film, she. Is weakened by her maternal instinct, and that kind of declaws her as being the premier politician in Rome because she is smarter than anyone else in that room. In the second film, they, they discuss that she misses her son, and perhaps it’s depression, but they, they’ve, they’ve really weakened her into just a woman who cries a lot, and I think that’s so sad, because she’s still the smartest person in any room. And the death scene again, pushing women into refrigerators, perhaps she did need to die for that narrative, but good grief, could she not have gone down slightly fighting it was I thought Lucilla, they really did a disservice to a wonderful character there.
Dr Rad 1:15:53
Yeah, and look, that’s, that’s what I think I have to say again, just in case Ridley Scott listens to this episode. I don’t think any of the actors did bad jobs with the parts that they were hand they were handed. I really think that a lot of the issues in this film come down to the storyline and the characterization. And again, it’s not about me being a historian who’s like you went against history. It is about the lack of a solid, consistent, coherent storyline, good characterization that makes sense for all of the characters. That’s really what this film is lacking more than anything. Visually, great. No problems really there, apart from those monkeys. And as I say, I can see all the actors were trying really hard to do a good job with what they had, but what they had was not a lot. That’s my final take on it.
Alexandra Sills 1:16:54
They were trying to deliver Michelin starred acting with a McDonald’s menu.
Dr G 1:17:02
I think that’s an excellent way to put it, and yeah, and also an excellent point to, to conclude, Like, what an image. Well, thank you so much for coming on the show.
Alexandra Sills 1:17:19
That’s a pleasure. It’s been delightful. I don’t like the movie, but I love you guys, so
Dr Rad 1:17:24
That’s also a good point to finish on.
Dr G 1:17:27
I think that has been our real challenge in this process, is that we got very excited for Gladiator Two, lined up interviews, then went and saw it and was like, oh no!
Thank you for listening to this episode of The Partial Historians. You can find our sources sound credits and transcript in our show notes over at partialhistorians.com we offer a huge thank you to you, if you’re one of our illustrious Patreon supporters, if you enjoy the show, we’d love your support in a way that works for you. Leaving a nice review really makes our day. We’re on Ko-Fi for one or four ongoing donations or Patreon, of course, our latest book, Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire, is published through Ulysses Press. It is full of stories that the Romans probably don’t want you to know about them. This book is packed with some of our favorite tales of the colorful history of ancient Rome. Treat yourself or an open minded friend to Rome’s glories, embarrassments and most salacious claims. With Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire.
Transcribed by https://otter.ai
The post Special Episode – Gladiator II with Alexandra Sills appeared first on The Partial Historians - Ancient Roman History with smart ladies.
We return for the final instalment on the fall of Veii in 396 BCE.
In our previous episode, we witnessed the actual conquest of the great Etruscan city.
Now it’s Camillus’ time to bask in the glory!
Camillus has managed to secure victory for Rome, and one of the advantages now that it’s all over is that sweet, sweet booty. Everyone knew that Veii was wealthy, but Camillus is staggered (pun intended) by the number of captured spoils. As he offered detailed thanks to the gods, he stumbled. The Romans were a superstitious bunch, so although Camillus tried to gloss over this trip, it was seen as an omen. Camillus, and perhaps Rome herself, were destined to take a mighty tumble. Foreshadowing!
But that all lay in the future. Camillus had to decide how to divvy up the booty. He tried to take the sensible path and consult with the Senate, but he failed to please most of the populace with his choices. Ingrates!
The fate of Veii’s tutelary deity, Juno Regina, was an even more delicate matter. The Romans hoped they could persuade her to switch her allegiance and residence to Rome. Juno agrees to make the move and was initially established in a new temple on the Aventine. That little minx!
This is the first example of the ritual of evocatio, which we sometimes see pop up when Rome conquers Etruscan cities. This may have something to do with the fact that the rite probably originated in Etruria. We wish we knew more about this fascinating practice, but as usual, we have more questions than answers. The religious calendars of Rome indicate that the cult of Juno Regina did begin at around this time, so this may lend some support to our historical narrative. Either way, Veii has now not only been conquered, but stripped of divine protection. OUCH.
No white horses here! Mosaic depicting a quadriga of the factio prasina (‘the greens,’ representing the spring), 3rd century AD, from Rome, National Archaeological Museum of Spain, Madrid, courtesy of Carole Raddato on Flickr.
Back in the city, the Romans are thrilled with this military victory. The matrons don’t even need to be told by the Senate to go and thank the gods in the temples. Hold my purse, Julius! I have praying to do!
Camillus was mobbed by crowds upon his return. No one will be surprised to hear that Camillus was awarded a triumph. EVERYTHING about it was OTT. The Senate decreed FOUR whole days of supplications, and Camillus and FOUR white horses for his chariot. With such a showy display, Camillus was thought to be likening himself to Jupiter and the sun god.
Not everyone thought this triumph was in good taste. After such an important victory, Camillus was eroding those warm fuzzies in record time. That is, of course, if we can believe the details. It’s hard to know what the norm was for a triumph in the early 4th century BCE.
Camillus ignored the haters, and busied himself with all the vows and promises he had made to various deities. There were temples to build for Juno and Mater Matuta, and then there was also the matter of gifts to Apollo. Camillus had pledged one tenth of the booty seized. The pontiffs decided that this needed to come from the people, who were less than impressed with a request to return some of their share of the spoils.
The year wrapped up with peace being secured on multiple fronts. Perhaps after seeing Veii’s defeat, the Volscians and Aequians decided to sue for peace themselves.
396 BCE truly was an epic year. We think you’ll agree once you’ve listened to all parts of our trilogy that it deserves to be known as ‘The Year That Had Everything’.
Our music is by Bettina Joy de Guzman.
Dr Rad 0:15
Music. Welcome to the partial historians.
Dr G 0:18
We explore all the details of ancient Rome,
Dr Rad 0:23
everything from political scandals, the love affairs, the battles wage and when citizens turn against each other, I’m Dr rad and
Dr G 0:33
I’m Dr G, we consider Rome as the Romans saw it, by reading different authors from the ancient past and comparing their stories.
Dr Rad 0:44
Join us as we trace the journey of Rome from the founding of the city.
Hello and welcome to a brand new episode of the partial historians. I am one of your hosts. Dr. Rad
Dr G 1:02
and I am. Dr, G,
Dr Rad 1:04
dr, G, it’s been a long time since we have had a year where we have needed not one, not two, but three episodes to get through all the history that the Romans packed into this year.
Dr G 1:17
It is shocking, made all the more shocking by the fact that my source material doesn’t give me any indication of what year stuff is happening in. So pull me up when I go too far ahead just in my pure excitement, because as far as Plutarch is concerned, there is a lot going on in this year, and he does not stop to tell me when the year might have changed. Look,
Dr Rad 1:40
it’s fair enough. It’s fair enough. As we know, the Romans are a little bit creative with their dating at this point in time. So you know what just we’ll just call it circa 396, BCE,
Dr G 1:51
there was some stuff, and it happened around about now.
Dr Rad 1:55
I think that’s actually the academic consensus at this moment in time, that there was stuff happening around about now,
Dr G 2:03
certainly, I mean, that feeds in very nicely to the difficulties with the idea of a 10 year siege of they this is true, and the way that that builds into that sort of literary analysis of this whole moment in Rome’s history. But I’m actually very excited to learn that there is indeed a third episode to be had, because when we finished the last episode, I was like, I think we must be done. And this is the problem when you no longer have an analyst, source tradition to go on, there’s more, it turns out. Well,
Dr Rad 2:34
look, this is what Livy tells me anyway, so let’s do it. Dr, G, a brief recap for the listeners that have not listened to part one and part two of 396, the fall of a as we have chosen to call it. Well,
Dr G 2:47
first of all, do yourselves a favor. Pause right now go back to the previous two episodes. So the basic Upshot seems to be that Rome has run into some real strife on a lot of different fronts, and it does not look like it’s going to be a super great year for the Romans, if the first episode in this series is anything to go by, they suffer some defeats. Everybody’s a little bit unhappy. But then all of a sudden, things take a turn, and this seems to be when we bring a dictator onto the field. And the dictator is a very, very special character, and Camillus is his name,
Dr Rad 3:31
absolutely so important is he that It is theorized that Livy may have organized his first 10 books around the life of Camillus. That’s just how significant.
Dr G 3:42
Wow. Livy. Livy’s a fanboy. Okay?
Dr Rad 3:45
He wanted to. It is theorized. Anyway, Livy, at no point says this, but it is theorized that we hit book five, book six, right when Camillus appears. So, you know, right in that middle part where he’s like, I need a big character. I need a lead.
Unknown Speaker 3:59
I need a hero,
Dr G 4:03
and Camillus seems to be shiny and fancy and very capable, although in some of the other source material. And I’m going to be interested to hear your perspective of how this sort of clashes maybe with Livy is some of the things that Plutarch has to say are less than positive.
Dr Rad 4:22
Nobody’s Perfect, or should I say, Pobody’s nerfect. Dr G, but he just has some really standout moments, and this is one of them, because, of course, last episode, we had a very big moment. Was this the tunneling moment? Well, okay, you might call it the tunneling moment. Other people would call it kicking Veii’s ass.
Dr G 4:43
Well, fair enough, there’s nothing quite like digging a tunnel that goes right underneath a major temple inside your enemy city, and then popping out just the right time to interrupt a sacrifice to then finish the sacrifice yourself in order to. Complete the Omen, that means that you will be victorious in this whole war, rather than the people who had started doing the sacrifice in the first place. Hey,
Dr Rad 5:10
you’re a religious historian, you should appreciate the effort that they went to in order to get that sacrifice and make sure that the Omen was going to work in their favor.
Dr G 5:20
If we learn anything, it is timing and the gods is crucial, yes.
Dr Rad 5:26
So we had this rather dramatic scene where finally, finally, Veii, the thorn in room sighed for literally decades. Dr G has fallen, and we left off at a very interesting moment, which is when Camillus got to step back after commanding the Roman forces and go, ooh, I’m picturing like Aladdin’s Cave of Wonders now, the amount of booty, huh, just overwhelming. Who knew you could pack all of that into that type pair of jeans Give it to me, and he’s so overwhelmed that he has to make this big pronouncement, this big prayer, and that’s the moment that we finished on last time, because he makes this very important vow, which is talking about how he wants to give thanks to the gods. But if any of the gods or any Roman men were getting a little jelly of his booty, then it was going to be up to him to try and sort all of that out, hopefully without harm to himself. In the state while he was doing this, he fell,
Dr G 6:31
yes, this was an awkward moment. He went for a bit of a trip, caught himself and sort of corrects himself quite quickly, and is like, huzzah. It’s a sign that the gods are on my side, and everybody else is kind of like seeing him stumble, being like, it’s a bad sign, and he really tries to cover it up. So that’s an awkward moment, and maybe has some slight foreshadowing. But I do like the sort of self sacrifice aspect of this, where he’s kind of like whatever happens from here, gods, let it be upon my head and not upon all of the Romans. I’ve done my best to turn this whole thing around, and I’m willing to take one for the team.
Dr Rad 7:13
Although he does have the proviso that he would rather it didn’t hurt him, like I’m happy to sort it out, but I’d rather it wasn’t at my own expense again. And maybe
Dr G 7:23
the tripping, maybe the tripping over then is like the first thing where the gods are like, Haha, it’s like, no.
Dr Rad 7:30
Now you might find some pedantic academics, Dr G, that say that all of this is a little bit too convenient. There’s a little bit too much foreshadowing going on here, but I say this is, quite frankly, a relief to see an experienced Roman politician who had a very important moment stuff it up and fall over, because it’s exactly the kind of thing that I would do. Why I never wear heels when I need to walk on a stage anymore, because I know there’s too much of a risk that I will fall and break my own neck. Yeah,
Dr G 8:03
it’s not worth it. You do not want to put the gods on notice like that. So I mean, Camillus seems to be as
Dr Rad 8:09
hubris wearing heels to the port occasion where you have to walk in front of a crowd. Now,
Dr G 8:13
I’m too old for that kind of thing. Exactly. I just wear stylish flats. So Camillus has this sort of moment where he’s overwhelmed by what he sees. And Plutarch does pick up on this as well. So the boundlessness of the wealth is apparently so overwhelming to Camillus that he burst into tears. And I kind of, I love that we don’t, we don’t often get these moments of Roman men having a good cry. But if a Roman man is going to have a cry, it turns out it’s when he sees a real pile of treasure he has just spent a long time conquering. I was going
Dr Rad 8:48
to say it’s not exactly what you’d hope. You kind of think maybe the birth of his first child, or something like that might merit such tears. I
Dr G 8:57
don’t think we can credit the Romans with having a high emotional intelligence at this point, but piles of booty un hitherto seen before is enough to bring a sparkle nail tear to the eye of Camillus, a
Dr Rad 9:13
manly tear, just like Kirk Douglas, single tears now. Dr, G, this is the moment that we left off, and so it’s time to delve into the rest of 396, BC, normally this is the point where we would, of course, do the magistrates, but again, see part one already done all the Latin, not doing it again.
Dr G 9:30
And also, guys, you don’t need to know most of those names. No.
Dr Rad 9:33
Camillus, that isn’t clear. We’ll
Dr G 9:37
be talking about Camillus, and almost exclusively about Camillus,
Dr Rad 9:41
yeah, so the grain of truth to what we’re looking at here, Dr G, is that there’s no doubt that Veii was a very wealthy city, and that it was indeed a coup for Rome to have conquered Veii, which indeed they did. That is all historical fact. As far as we can see, it might not have been. And quite as dramatic as the sources. Of course, would have us believe, if you look at the archeology, there’s a relative amount of continuity at this site. However, drama is what I want, and so I’m going to lean into Livy’s narrative here.
Dr G 10:16
Please do. Let’s not let the archeologists get in the way of a good story,
Dr Rad 10:20
definitely not. This is why I chose history of archeology. I don’t have to break a sweat, and it’s far more dramatic. So the following day, all those who were captured from they sold into slavery. Now this is, unfortunately, part of, you know, the beauty that we’re talking about here, the Romans obviously have an opportunity to make money from selling off their captured enemies, and this is kind of how things often work in the ancient world,
Dr G 10:50
okay, but logistical question, who has the money to buy said slaves? It seems like the whole region is in a bit of an economic downturn, as far as I understand it, and people have been scraping together funds from wherever they can. Are you saying that there’s like a traveling slave trader situation of caravans that comes to pick up the people and somehow has wondrous amounts of money to buy the ball to take them elsewhere? What’s going on here?
Dr Rad 11:19
Indeed, there is an older man named proximo who stopped by with his traveling van. And he happened to have an outstanding gladiator that he just bought, a guy called Maximus, as well as his new best friend, a guy called Juba. And on his travels, on the way to Rome to see Marcus Aurelius and whatnot, he stopped by to purchase all the slaves.
Dr G 11:41
I’m pretty excited for that. I mean, finally, now we have the real truth coming out.
Dr Rad 11:46
Yeah, no, look, you’re quite right. When we look critically at this story, this is a pretty big moment for Rome, because it’s, it is something that historically will happen where Rome has these big conquests and it will accrue a lot of people as a result of said conquests. However, early Rome definitely is thought to be a bit too poor, perhaps for widespread slavery. It is thought that the appearance of slaves is something that might have been added later, because it makes sense, given what they know of how Rome does business later on, if you get Madrid.
Dr G 12:22
Yeah, that makes complete sense to me. Certainly there would be a whole bunch of people who are displaced in this moment. So I think the question for the Romans would be, who gets to live and who gets to be killed? And often that would mean, if there’s no ready way to sell the men, a lot of them would get killed. And if there’s not so much of a trade going on for women and children as slaves, they might be colonized in a very unfortunate and violent way.
Dr Rad 12:57
It is possible, and unfortunately, we obviously don’t have a huge amount of detail. Now, the thing is, there is no doubt that there was a conquest of a at around this time, circa 396, as we said, it is possible that there were indeed some people taken into slavery at this point in time. This might actually be the first historical moment where we do see a large scale capture of people who become POWS and then become slaves. It’s possible, however, the main reason that the Romans use slaves, particularly on a large scale later on, is that as they gather more land and they’re building more industry and more agriculture, you need the physical labor more. So slaves have a real purpose at this point in time, it’s thought that, given the scale of Rome and given the way it’s operating, you’re probably more likely to have a slave for domestic service purposes, so someone to clean your house, cook your food, that kind of thing. And that would be, I think, a very rich person who has the means to do that, or you might have them to show off your wealth, you know, to have someone purely dedicated to the opening and closing of a particular door in your establishment. But again, that would be, I think, the minority in Rome at this moment in time.
Dr G 14:12
Yes. I mean, the other thing that could be happening here is that there is an acceptance of conquest on part of a lot of the population of Veii, and they continue on in some of their traditional roles, farming locally and things like that, under the understanding that they are now being co opted into Rome’s population. So this is one of the things that comes up in Plutarch where it’s a discussion about is this the time for Rome to divide its own population into half in the sense that they should send half the senators and half the people of Rome to populate they so that there is a dedicated Roman presence there, and keep the other half in Rome proper. Self, and by so doing, extend the really firm boundaries of Roman power with Roman people,
Dr Rad 15:07
and keep those Slinky minxy Etruscans in line, keeping an eye on them having a man on the ground, as it were.
Dr G 15:16
But of course, most people are pretty upset by this, because who gets to stay in Rome your own home, and who has to leave to go and live in Veii, which is obviously just had a massive siege over many years, take place, so it’s not like the funnest place to go to live, but also it’s like you’re being pushed out of your own home in order to do this thing. So there is a real division set out in Plutarch around this idea of, should people go to vey and try to populate it and colonize it directly as part of a security measure? And if so, who would do that? And some people are upset about that possibility as well. Oh,
Dr Rad 15:59
so many possibilities. It’s so hard to know what actually happened here. Oh, my, I just don’t know where to turn Dr, G, look all I can tell you in favor of my version of things, where it’s very much just about the slavery. Thank you. Is that the first recorded slave market? So obviously you need a market if you’ve got lots of people that you want to sell, isn’t until 259
Dr G 16:22
Okay, well, that we are a long way from 259
Dr Rad 16:26
but this could be the first record of a mass enslavement, and it’s because it’s a one off the room is like, well, we don’t need the market for this. We can handle
Dr G 16:32
this ourselves. We’re like, what we do? What do we do with so many don’t know, yeah,
Dr Rad 16:36
for Livy, I think it’s very much about what then happens with the money. Follow the money. Dr G, so the money raised from selling all these people, because apparently they do sell them, all goes into the state treasury, which might seem sensible, because I’m sure it’s depleted after this whole siege, and then also all the other warfare the Romans have been waging. But the plebs are furious about this.
Dr G 17:04
Are they now? Why? What’s
Dr Rad 17:07
this is a big part of Camillus downfall. You know, he has a moment where he peaks with the conquest of Veii and then it’s going to
Dr G 17:15
go trips over, and it’s all downhill from there.
Dr Rad 17:19
Yeah, well, no, I mean there. It’s not quite there yet, but this is definitely the fly in the ointment, and it will come back to haunt him. So with the question of booty, people didn’t really give Camillus enough credit, in Livy’s opinion, because he had tried to do the right thing by asking the Senate, look, I’ll do what you want me to do. Just tell me. And remember, we had that whole debate in Livy between Appius Claudius and Licinius Calvus, a patrician for being facing off, but they thought Camillus was just basically looking for an excuse to be a tight ass. Did not feel thankful towards the senators. Basically, it’s the Licinii who get a lot of the credit for their role in saying, Look, we should really split this with, you know, we should be, we should be the popular people, and make sure the plebs are looked after. So they get a lot of credit. But the plebeians are angry with everybody else, including Camillus. Okay.
Dr G 18:17
Now, does this in any way relate to the matter of the 10th portion of the spoils?
Dr Rad 18:25
No, not quite, okay. Quite yet we’re almost there. Quite Yes,
Dr G 18:30
yeah, like, yeah. I’m just trying to figure out where my next bit of information slots into this narrative. We will get there. I remain uncertain as to why the plebeians are upset, because surely, if the money is going into the state treasury, eventually it’s going to filter back out to them, because that’s how they get paid. Look,
Dr Rad 18:48
this is what Appiah Claudius was suggesting. Annoyingly, it does seem quite common sensical that that would be a good thing to do, because then Rome itself is in a better condition, and maybe there’s less of attacks on them. I mean, not that we think that there actually was attacks, but in this narrative, various attacks, so it would make sense. But they’re not happy with this whole solution. They wanted. They wanted what the like any I had suggested, to happen. So there you go. Now. Now we turn, of course, to what is happening at Veii. So once the Romans have stripped the city of its citizens, because they’re in slavery now, and stripped the city itself of anything else that’s movable for their own personal gains, they instead, now turn to the temples, and this is where I feel like your religious knowledge will come in. Dr, G, because this is a very big moment. They are respectful, because, of course, these are the gods that they’re dealing with here. And one assumes, and also, academics have kind of proven that there is obviously a bit of a religious link between the Romans and the Etruscans for certain deities and practices, and that. Sort of thing, so they come in respectfully. The youth from the army were chosen to perform this very special task. They had to wash their bodies and wear white clothing. And they were told that now is the moment to take the goddess Juno to Rome. And this is again harking back to something that Camillus had done before he had embarked on his big campaign against Veii, he had said to Juno, hey, you’re looking fine, toots, how about it? Hmm,
Dr G 20:30
all right, so this is a really important moment, because this is the Juno that becomes the foremost Juno in Rome. It is that part of the Capitoline triad of gods. This is THE Juno. So there are many versions of Juno. The Romans love having aspects of their gods and goddesses. And the understanding that the Romans have about where Juno, who is part of the Capitoline triad comes from is this story in some cases. So the idea behind this is that Juno is the foremost Goddess of they. So when we think back to that tunneling story and going through that whole siege process, it is a tunnel that comes up underneath Juno’s temple. And if you were to go to the Veii Archeological Park today, which I would definitely recommend, they’ve done a partial reconstruction of what this temple was supposed to have looked like at the time. So we do have good archeological evidence that there was a temple, a pretty significant one from this time period in Vay. So we think that’s where things match up nicely, but then we get this incredible story. And I don’t know necessarily about the details Livy is offering, but Plutarch tells us that everybody assembles Camillus is sacrificing and performing prayers to Juno and asks her directly, was she ready and willing to leave a and come to Rome? And everyone hears the goddess speak, and she says, I’m ready take me to Rome. It’s where I belong. And they’re like The Goddess is speaking to us. Take me away
Speaker 1 22:23
a few, not that long, miles away from here.
Dr G 22:30
So you know this sort of beautiful moment where people are not sure where the voice comes from, but it’s a female voice. It’s thought to be the goddess Juno. And this is the idea that the Romans know as evocatio, yes, the idea of inviting a foreign god or goddess to your own city and them accepting, and then you going through the ritual process. They do this with some frequency as Roman history progresses. And this seems to be the first example of it happening.
Dr Rad 23:04
So many firsts Dr, G, my goodness, you’re absolutely right there. This is a big difference, I think, between Livy and some of the other accounts, like Plutarch. It is not Camillus, who personally does it. He is the one that had initially extended the invitation and been like, hey, listens, you know, you just, you just think about this while I sack this city, and I’ll be back when it sits all over, you know, see what you’re thinking, see where your head’s at. So it’s very much the youth that do it in this particular version. And Livy tells me that they went to the temple very respectfully. Once they had got changed and washed, they were very concerned about touching the image of Juno, because as far as they were aware, in Etruscan custom, only a priest from a very particular family was allowed to do this then one of the years. And he says it could be either one of these options here, either was struck with some sort of divine inspiration, oh, or was making a joke and actually asked, you know, Hey, you want to get her own and the rest saw that. She nods her head. However, Livy does acknowledge that afterwards people reported that she’d actually said she was willing to go.
Dr G 24:20
Right, okay, so presumably we’re talking about a stone sculpture I would or maybe a bronze. That’s also possible, potentially even terracotta. Well,
Dr Rad 24:31
apparently Etruscan. I’m quoting directly from Ogilvie here, who does a commentary on Livy, which is very helpful to me. He says that Etruscan cult images were designed to be carried, as is proved by the discovery at ve of terracotta statue bases with slots seven centimeters in diameter through which wooden poles could be slipped.
Dr G 24:49
Oh, very interesting. Yes, I was like Etruscans are famous for their terracotta work, so that would make complete sense. So rather than having to like. Carry a really large lump of rock back to Rome. It may very well have been a really nicely painted terracotta statue. And they slipped some rods in and went on their way, although the chances, the chances of terracotta nodding, I’m just letting that one pass me bye. Dr, rad,
Dr Rad 25:22
but look either way. Livy says, Look, however this actually went down. He’s clearly aware that there are many versions of this story. It’s definitely felt that the Romans didn’t really have to force her. Juno was on board with this whole situation, and therefore she’s able to be moved. She is transported to the Aventine. It is here that Camillus dedicates a temple, which she had promised her he would do if she made her way to Rome and left they behind. Yeah,
Dr G 25:48
so this is really interesting. So one of the ways that we can think of this Juno, if we were to give her an epithet, is to call her Juno Regina the queen. Juno, the Queen principally associated with the city of Veii, and she does also have connections with some other places, Ardea, which is nowhere near Veii, and Rome’s kind of
Dr Rad 26:12
we have talked about Ardea, definitely we
Dr G 26:14
have, yeah, it’s, uh, on the other side of Rome, though, so a bit further away. And Lanuvium, which I can’t remember exactly where it is right now, but this idea that Juno Regina has a Military Warrior aspect to her, so the young warrior story of them washing themselves and dressing up nicely for her would make complete sense in that context, If they’re trying to impress her. And this idea of her arrival on the Aventine also connects nicely into what we know of some of the broader archeology at Rome, where we have some really old temples. So her placement on the Aventine seems to be relatively short lived. She eventually gets transferred to the Capitoline, but in the meantime, the Aventine is very much associated with the plebeians, so this, I think, has some very positive connotations for how Rome is feeling about this war, maybe how they’re trying to build some positive feeling with the plebeians around some of the things that the plebeians might not be feeling so good about. But also emphasizes that this war, from the Romans perspective, was a completely just war.
Speaker 2 26:23
It is a really interesting thing because it’s thought that the ritual of evocatio, I feel like I’m saying avocado whenever I said the ritual of evocatio is thought to be potentially Etruscan itself in origin, and it’s also different to this thing called exoratio, which I believe is when you do still ask a deity whether they want to switch sides, but they’re allowed to remain in their original place. Oh,
Dr G 28:05
interesting. It’s like, Oh yeah, sure, I’m with you guys, but I’m just gonna stay here because it’s just more comfortable. Just
Dr Rad 28:11
gonna set it up exactly the way I like it, and it’s just such a hassle moving. I hate
Dr G 28:16
I don’t mind dating, but I just need to live by myself, you know, yeah. And
Dr Rad 28:21
the interesting thing is, as well, we’ve talked before, I mentioned in one of our previous episodes about they that even though we do sometimes laugh at some of the details that the Romans have added to this story, like the whole Trojan War aspect and that sort of thing, we have suggested that they are basing this account around priestly records, because there are quite a lot of religious happenings that seem to form very important moments in this story. And that might be the bare bones that they’re working with, and then had to fashion the rest of the story around. And the fact that the cult of Juno Regina starts at around this time, circa 396, it again, sort of adds up and adds that bit of historicity, I suppose, to this whole account.
Dr G 29:05
And it’s certainly not the last time the gods are gonna have a little bit of influence on this year. I would say,
Dr Rad 29:11
Yes, exactly, obviously, now that all this stuff has happened, and as you say, it seems completely justified, they got all this booty, even though they’re a little bit cranky about it, the Romans can see just how amazing this is at the moment that it happens, apparently, because they say it’s, you know, the most important city in the whole Etruscan universe that they have managed to conquer,
Dr G 29:33
a bold claim, considering it’s at the most southern tip of Etrurian power. Yeah, and
Dr Rad 29:38
they do feel like Livy specifically notes that the Romans just feel extra good about it, because it does seem like the gods just allowed Rome to take it, and that they, you know, didn’t have to try like that hard in the end to get over the line. And that’s that’s surely a sign that the gods were on the side.
Dr G 29:54
That is some creative narration. Ever I’ve heard it, not only have we spent. An ample amount of time, considering all of the years of this siege, which has taken forever, but now we’re spending three whole episodes on just one year related to this. This is not a fast process Rome, and you have not been doing great at this.
Dr Rad 30:16
Well, I think it’s, I think it’s that idea that they had held out for so long. It seems like it must have been that the gods had deserted they and allowed the Romans to take it, even though, I mean, it’s kind it is kind of ridiculous. Obviously they took it by force. But they feel like, well, you know, like it was an effort, but at the same time, the gods clearly we’re on our side for this whole thing.
Dr G 30:42
Yes, once they got through all of those weird things to do with the Albin Lake omen and all of that sort of stuff, you know, they managed to wrangle it to a point where Juno’s like, Yeah, I’ll come to Rome. Hi, boys. So
Dr Rad 30:56
the Romans, obviously, this is just like the happiest day of their lives so far, and they’ve had some happy ones, but this one really takes the cake. They feel like they had been on a real roller coaster ride with they. And even before the senators asked them to do anything, the Roman matrons, they’re racing to those temples to thank the gods because remember they’d raced to them and being like, please, please save us. Please. And now they’re like, well,
Dr G 31:21
thanks a lot. You did save us, and we appreciate it very much. Exactly,
Dr Rad 31:24
now, the Senate decreed supplications for four days, which is apparently much longer than they usually go for. Okay,
Dr G 31:34
all right, so this, this would require a lot of sacrifice. I don’t even
Dr Rad 31:39
want to think about it, and then, as Camillus is heading back towards Rome, more people than had ever done this before run out to meet him along the way, because they’re just overjoyed. And he is the man. He’s still at his peak, even though they’re a little bit cranky about the whole booty situation. It’s almost like he’s become one direction all by himself. I know exactly he’s being mobbed by fans. Now, this is an interesting finish to the year, which is all about Camillus triumph. Now, apparently Camillus triumph was considered to be OTT by the standards of circa 396 because in his triumph, he had a chariot drawn by four white horses. Some people were not pleased by this. In fact, it was labeled in my translation as undemocratic and irreverent. Oh, really, yeah, apparently this sign and this is where we’re going to get I’m going to delve into the details in a little bit. But what Livy is explicitly noting is that this seems like Camillus is trying to make himself the equal of Jupiter and the sun god. And it’s outrageous.
Dr G 32:44
Goodness me, all right, so Plutarch does have a little bit of detail on this. So he does celebrate a triumph. It is labeled as being with great pomp, as you would expect. And we do get a repetition of this idea of the four white horses harnessed to a chariot which he had mounted and drove through Rome, a thing which no commander had ever done before or afterwards. So great and so fancy was this moment. So Plutarch also suggests that this is the moment where Camillus gets himself on the wrong side of the citizens.
Dr Rad 33:23
in agreement on that. Yeah, this is where it starts to go wrong.
Dr G 33:27
He is now on a bit of a slide, because people are like, yeah. I mean, taking they was an incredible piece of work, and that’s exactly what we signed you up as dictated to do. But these horses, man, it’s a lot. I
Dr Rad 33:39
mean, a horse is a horse, of course, of course.
Dr G 33:43
But for white horses, that’s almost two white horses too many. And this is
Dr Rad 33:48
where it gets a bit confusing, because we don’t have enough evidence about what color would usually be used in a triumph in terms of what Color Horse, certainly white horses do seem to have some sort of connection with the gods, so that part makes sense. However, as we usually find Dr G, it does seem like a lot of stuff has been written later, and they’re projecting some of the late Republican nonsense onto Camillus, to a certain extent, because we really whenever anybody’s talking about a triumph, apparently, the only time they often really mention the color is when white horses are used. So it’s a bit difficult to figure out what color he was supposed to have or how we’re supposed to deal with that. Definitely, chariots drawn by white horses are connected to Jupiter and soul, the divine sun god, so okay, and certainly later, people like Julius Caesar will have four white horses in 46 BCE, possibly because of the divine connection, but also possibly because he’s trying to imitate. Right? Camillus, like the story that has been built up around Camillus triumph, because again, probably all our later sources have to work with is the fact that they know Camillus had a triumph, and therefore they’re putting the details that make sense to them onto this Triumph.
Dr G 35:15
So I think one of the things that we might note is that white horses would have a recessive gene, so they’re more unlikely than other types of horses, and this would make them special. And that’s fine, and that is where you might start to produce a connection to the divine and things like that, things that we don’t know about triumphs at this point in time, is everything. So like, what is the root of the tribe?
Dr Rad 35:41
A small detail, a small detail. Well, we
Dr G 35:44
have a Campus Martius, so that’s fine. That’s where they’re supposed to get organized for the start of their triumph. But beyond that, the topography of Rome is completely different. So what’s the route? What’s expected? How many horses? What else is going on? All of these things are kind of up for grabs in this early period, and we, we just don’t know. So clearly, the the four horses has really stuck in people’s minds, and Camillus will go on and continue to build his reputation. He’s on a little bit of a downhill at the moment, but I suspect, yeah, I suspect we need to be prepared for the comeback, and when people try to emulate Camillus in later generations, they’re not doing it because of this particular incident, necessarily. No, there’s going to be some other things that he does as well, but certainly his triumph is seen as a display of vanity, so it is lacking in moderatio, one of the famous Roman qualities, precisely we’re supposed to have arrogant,
Dr Rad 36:49
arrogant. Who does he think he is? Well,
Dr G 36:53
exactly, yeah. And there seems to be also a problem of a forgotten vow to the gods.
Dr Rad 37:00
Oh, yes, okay, we’ll get to that in a moment. Please do Romulus is the only figure, time wise, who’s mentioned as having a triumph like this with the four white horses before Camillus. That means that, theoretically, if we’re accepting when Romulus apparently reigned. That means it’s literally been hundreds of years, and then Camillus is doing this. Now, I will of course, mention that the sources that mention Romulus having a triumph like this are written in the Augustan time period, and after so talking about papius of it, and then Daya, who’s much, much later. So it’s very hard to know it’s a chicken and the egg situation. Where did this come from? Was it mentioned for Romulus first and then was attached to Camillus? Or was it mentioned for Camillus and then attached to Romulus? Who knows? But certainly it’s interesting that those two figures are attached to this particular story. But as the other thing we can sort of break down is the way that the triumph is sort of playing out, where it’s got these different aspects to it. And again, I’m going to draw an Ogilvie, if I might, to tell you about them. So first off, there is maximum imperatorum. Sounds like a Harry Potter spell, but it’s not. This is where a victorious general is hailed as Imperator, and he basically can hang on to this until he’s back in the city first historically seen in the case of Scipio Africanus in 209. BCE,
okay, so we might have a little bit of retrojection here as well, potentially.
Yeah. Then there’s the grates dis agentium, the victory. And this is where the Senate gets the choice of whether they say, you know, let’s have a day of public Thanksgiving. Let’s do supplications. Let’s make sure that we’re giving thanks in the temple. Everybody, don’t be ungrateful. And then, of course, we have the official supplicationes. I’m going to say, supplicationes, yes. Now apparently, the next time, we have four days of supplications, 203, and 197, so whether it’s really a thing at this point in time, hard to say, we then have the adventus. Now this is not a technical part of, you know, a general coming into the city, but it’s when he arrives, and everyone’s like, Oh my god, I just want to like fan girl every because they just like, so amazing right now. And then there is the Triumph itself. You can have all the other parts without necessarily also having a triumph attached. So I just thought it was interesting to sort of note that that breakdown there
Dr G 39:43
is like also like these gradations of honor that you can go through, because you can go through a whole bunch of things, and the Senate might still decline the actual triumph. It is a senatorial decision about whether a triumph goes ahead or not. And. This is why their role as an advisory body is also feels like a little bit of a fur fee, because if they say no to a triumph, you’re supposed to accept that as a victorious commander and not go ahead with your triumph, even though you might think that you’re entitled to one, and there can be good reason for believing that you’re entitled to one things that enable you to have a triumph. You’ve got to have certain criteria in place. You have to be somebody who is in possession of full Imperium. So you have to be a top tier military commander for this period of time, and in this particular year, that means you’re either a military Tribune with consular power or you’re the dictator. They’re the only two roles that would allow it. You have to have killed a minimum number of enemies, and that minimum is set at about 5000 according to Valerius Maximus. So it’s a lot.
Dr Rad 40:59
So we’re really applauding murderers. Basically,
Dr G 41:04
welcome to Ancient Rome. Is the music
Dr Rad 41:07
as they march down, going secular.
Dr G 41:16
Probably it would make sense. They’ve got those one note trumpets. They’re going for it. And it’s at that point, if you fulfilled those criteria, it’s not a civil war situation. It is foreign enemies killed. It’s full Imperium. And it’s then the agreement of the Senate that those things have come together in the right order, that the Triumph can go ahead, and the triumph itself has what we believe to be an Etruscan history anyway. So this is where the Romans and the Etruscans are all kind of mixed up in this sort of cultural ocean of sharing, because
Dr Rad 41:54
makes it even more ridiculous that we had to go through 10 years to get to this point.
Dr G 41:59
I went and took an Etruscan city just so I could have an Etruscan celebration,
Dr Rad 42:05
also because I wanted Juno to leave you for me.
Dr G 42:10
Yeah, it’s like two boys fighting over a girl. Yeah. So the triumphator, the person celebrating their triumph will don a nice, really, very special purple robe. We know the purple robes are quintessential Etruscan things. They get them from the Phoenicians because the Etruscans are a trading people. There is the very special triumphal chariot. And I wish I now knew more about it, or had done more reading on it, about this horse controversy,
Dr Rad 42:37
the quadriga. Yes, yeah,
Dr G 42:41
clearly, four horses is the way to go. But which four horses choose your colors wisely, the four
Dr Rad 42:46
horses of the Apocalypse, please.
Dr G 42:48
What a triumph. There is a golden crown that’s part of this, which is known as the Corona Etrusca. So it doesn’t get any more Etruscan than
that. My God, honestly, the roof, they can’t
help themselves, and the person celebrating the tribe also gets to carry an ivory spectre. So that’s pretty cool. Do
Dr Rad 43:11
you mean an ivory sceptre?
Yes, yes, an ivory sceptre, not a not a spectre, not a ghost.
Carry this didn’t look like Jupiter.
Dr G 43:25
Thank you for that important correction. I got carried away by the triumph. On
Dr Rad 43:30
the other hand, a specter would be ivory, if Casper is correct.
Dr G 43:35
I mean, I assume so. Yeah. So the whole triumph thing anyway, has this really Etruscan undercurrent to it anyway, and there seems to be this nice interweaving of Latin rituals into this as well. The idea that you move on foot from a certain point you get off that chariot. Doesn’t matter what the horses are. You gotta hop off it at some point and walk up to the capital line. That is important. That’s the last phase. Everybody watches. You do a little bit on foot. Interesting. And the idea seems to be that, from the Roman perspective, this is all something that’s coming through, through the connection to those Etruscan kings, we get that middle to late period of Etruscan influence in the Roman monarchical period.
Dr Rad 44:26
Indeed. Well, that makes sense, because Dr G The next thing that Camilla says, this is when he officially can go about his business with the temple. So we’ve mentioned these previously, Queen Juno established on the Aventine, and then a temple to mata matuta is set up in the forum boarian, which you mentioned previously, mahamatuta being a deity that does have an interesting connection to Servius Tullius. So going back to that monarchical period, and we do, of course, have archeological remains which have been identified with this temple. So again, little bit. Bit of perhaps confirmed detail there of what’s actually going on, and now Camillus is able to rest easy. His deed is done. He no longer has to be dictator. Now, a little detail I’m going to add here, dr, G, which is interesting, obviously I mentioned previously when we were talking about Camillus. It’s not that he wasn’t necessarily a historical figure, but certainly it is believed that some of the stories that have sprung up around him might be, dare I say it, legendary. What way now Mater Matuta is a Roman goddess of the dawn, and apparently, if you look at Camillus whole career, he does win a lot of his battles at dawn. He also makes a vow to Apollo, which we’re going to get back to in a second. And then, of course, we have this idea of him getting bit too uppity and acting like the Sun God with his triumph. So there are all these interesting connections between Camillus. In fact, some scholars have gone so far. Although I’m not saying I necessarily believe this. I’m just mentioning it as to say that Camillus actually wasn’t a historical person, but rather a mythical figure who became attached to the story of a and a couple of other events, obviously, in Roman history that we’ve yet to talk about and was turned into a human goodness
Dr G 46:29
me, okay, well, somebody will need to have a chat with Plutarch. Plutarch is doing his very level best to make a human story out of this situation.
Dr Rad 46:43
I like to think he’s a human he’s a real boy. Dr, G, a real boy.
Dr G 46:47
He’s not made of wood at all. So the thing about Plutarch is that the life of Camillus is part of a pair. And yeah, Plutarch is writing this whole series called The parallel lives. That’s what he calls it. That’s what we call it, and it’s a good time to be had. We know we’re not getting straight up history necessarily. We already are well aware from the genre of writing and the way that he structures this work, that he’s very interested in drawing moral comparisons between Greeks and Romans. So you’ve usually got a Greek and a Roman compared. And what’s usually quite nice about this is that there is a bit of a Prologue setting up the pairing, and then there’s a bit of a comparative Epilogue to sort of make hit home all of the sort of parallels that he’s been striving towards over the course of both of the lives.
Dr Rad 47:47
Well, children, what have we learned?
Dr G 47:50
Exactly so the level of the didactic approach is very close to the surface with Plutarch Now, what’s interesting in this particular case is that the parallel life is the life of Themistocles. Okay, mm, and Themistocles is this very famous Athenian general who does some great stuff fending off the Persians. And then things take a bit of a turn for Themistocles, and he ends up with the Persians, the complexities of which I won’t get into here, but it’s it’s a tough time for to be a Themistocles. And he is sort of labeled as this really ambitious, maybe overweening in his ambition, and it leads him to make some poor decisions. And Camillus, by comparison, seems to come off as a bit more of a moderate. He’s ambitious for Rome, yes, not for himself necessarily.
Dr Rad 48:53
Yeah. I definitely think he’s very heroic and Livy, yeah, yeah.
Dr G 48:57
It does mean that some of the things that happen to Camillus are a little bit more hilarious as a result, because if he’s doing it for Rome, he might have done a better job being
Dr Rad 49:06
being a hero. I don’t mean it in the sense that, yeah, he’s completely perfect. He definitely makes some big missteps, and he pays for it, but certainly on the whole, I think Livy’s a fan
Dr G 49:16
look, and he’s in a great position right now. He’s just done a wondrous deed in finally breaking the siege of Fae. Indeed, Romans could not be happier about that, although they’re a tad upset about the horses. You know, it’s all about balance.
Dr Rad 49:32
I mean, it’s a bit of much.
Dr G 49:36
I know it was a 10 year siege, but white horses, really,
Dr Rad 49:39
that’s the way it’s gonna be, little darling.
You go riding on the horses, yeah, yeah,
okay, that’s enough of Daryl Braithwaite for Americans. You probably have no idea what that song is, but I’m hoping Daryl Braithwaite made a breakthrough in America, and you do actually recognize that song. You do need
to look. Up this song. So the lives have this comparative aspect. It’s usually pretty explicit. What we lack with the comparison of Themistocles with Camillus is both the Prologue and the Epilogue comparison. Ah, you’re kidding. All of the juicy details seem to be missing. Unbelievable. Yeah, so apologies in advance. We’re going to have to extrapolate directly from Plutarch without him didactically telling us exactly what he wanted us to get out of this life. And I’ll attempt that as we go along.
Okay, all right. Dr, G the final episode that Livy mentions. It’s a small detail, but an important one, before we’re into 395, BCE, and that is the moment that you have been waiting for, which was the gift to Apollo. Yes. Now remember that Camillus had pledged a 10th of the booty to Apollo, if he’d, you know, done them a solid, which he had, as it turned out. Now, the priests, pontiffs, I should perhaps say, decided that the people had to be the ones to carry this out. So to go back to the previous episode, we’d had this debate between Licinius and Appius Claudius and Licinius had seemingly carried the day in the sense that he said, Look, if people want to go and rock up to they and take what they can carry. They should be like to do that. They’ll feel really personal, passionate about it. It’ll be great, you know? And then, of course, we had the slight snarkiness over the booty being given into the state treasury at this point. So there’s been some issues. But when the priests make this decision, this means that for the people that had gone to Veii and taken some booty, they would have to now bring some of it back. Oh yeah, cool guys. No, definitely not cool. Yeah. So after much debate about exactly how they were going to tell the people about this, they decide on a plan that they think will upset the people the least, which is they say, look, anyone who wants to make sure that they are fulfilling a promise that had been made to the gods and make sure that 1/10 is donated to the state treasury, well, I mean, obviously that’s a good deed done. You’re making sure the gods are on side Rome’s looked out for. And you know, we’re definitely going to use whatever you turn over. We’ll use the money to turn it into a really beautiful gift for Apollo. Thank you so very much. That is something that will become, I think, very important for us to talk about at a bit of a later date.
Dr G 52:36
Yeah, so this idea of the 10th part needs to be returned. It seems to have gotten very confusing, because apparently, Camillus had made a vow before setting out on this mission, that they would dedicate a 10th of the booty to the Delphian God, which is another way of describing Apollo. Sure. So that’s that’s a big deal, because Apollo isn’t even in Italy. The Delphi had gods in Delhi.
Dr Rad 53:04
Well, I mean, but he, but the Delphic Oracle had obviously told them very important details which were key to their victory. Dr, G,
exactly. So they consulted the Delphic Oracle about this Alban Lake situation, and the Delphic oracle was like, yeah, that’s, that’s a real omen. You should definitely do something about
Dr G 53:19
that. Like this battle
Dr Rad 53:21
lakes don’t just rise, people.
Dr G 53:24
That’s right, if you don’t pull out the plug, that thing’s gonna overflow. It’s gonna be a problem. You know, get onto it. Guys drain the lake. They had listened to the Delphic Oracle, done the business that was required. It had been a turning point, apparently, in the siege, and now it was time to give a gift of some kind. And Camillus said, said that they would definitely consecrate a 10th of the booty to Apollo so big call. He claims to have forgotten that vow at some point, accidentally. So he admits this much later on, not during the time period, but does confess that he had forgotten about this vow. How he had managed to forget this vow is anybody’s guess, particularly if, as a literary trope of a figure, that he might be some sort of divine solar entity, I
Dr Rad 54:24
know, right, looking out for your bro Apollo. Yeah, this
is a very human failing for Camillus to have. Nevertheless, this puts everybody into a state of shock, because everybody has picked up their plunder and they’ve started to enjoy it. So that means they’re spending it, they’re melting it down. They’re trading it with other people. Nobody’s really quite sure what a 10th of anybody’s plunder looks like at this point. So everybody’s a little bit in uproar, and Camillus not being certain that he wants to accept this as part of his problem as dictator. Later decides to refer that matter to the Senate being like, you guys make a decision about that, and this is when the priests become involved, and they say the gods are going to be angry if you don’t fulfill this vow. And that means everybody needs to get on board with finding a 10th and bringing it along so we can make a really beautiful bowl for Apollo. That’s what we’re going to do with it. Guys bring us the metal. We’ll melt it down, and it’s going to we’ll turn it into a very elegant and stylish Golden Bowl. Nobody’s happy about that. There was much complaint and others like, how big is that bowl gonna be for Apollo,
yeah. Is it gonna be gigantic? Because there’s a lot of beauties, if you had apparently, Yeah,
Dr G 55:46
nobody’s ever seen so much beauty in all of their lives. And it’s gonna be the largest bowl possible. That seems to be where Plutarch is heading. And I don’t want to necessarily go into further detail, because I feel like that might be tipping us into the next year, by the sounds of it, yes,
Dr Rad 56:01
Camillus is going to be an ongoing issue for Rome. Love him and hate him, as they do. We will pause there. The only detail that I have left to tell you is to completely switch our focus, which is what Livy loves to do, particularly at the end. The Volscians and the Aequians, whilst all of this is going on, have decided this is their moment to dispatch some envoys and ask for peace with Rome. Because, lest we forget, with all this talk of a apparently, the Romans were also waging war with several other peoples at this point in time. That
Dr G 56:32
does explain why they have six military tribunes with consular power they are. They are facing it from every direction.
Dr Rad 56:38
They are now, the Romans agree, but only because they want to, and they are sick to death of war, not because the Volscians and the Aequians actually deserve war. They deserve so much war. Dr, G, those rapscallions
Dr G 56:55
look it’s an interesting moment in time for these two, because it’s not like the Aequians and the Volscians necessarily always offer peace. So I wonder what’s been going on that we haven’t heard about over the course of this year, indeed,
Dr Rad 57:09
but that is, unfortunately, all the detail that Livy gives me. Dr G, which means that it is time for the partial pick. You.
Okay, I feel exhausted by 396 Tell me. Dr, G, what is the partial pick and how are we going to use it to rate Rome the
Dr G 57:55
partial pick. So the Romans, we measure them against some criteria that we think the Romans would approve of. Each category is worth 10 golden Roman Eagles, and that means that it is possible for Rome to achieve a perfect score of 50 Golden Eagles if they outdo themselves in every category. So our first one is military clout.
Dr Rad 58:21
Now this is tricky, because technically, they have conquered they in this year, but not in this episode. It’s already
Dr G 58:29
happened. That’s true, and I think we gave them lots of points for it last time. So there’s been no military no additional military conquests that I’m aware of. But
Dr Rad 58:39
there is the peace with Volscians and the Aequians just sneaking in there.
Dr G 58:40
Oh, yes, but we can’t assume from that anything about the military, if we haven’t been told anything, yeah, it’s definitely not military conquest, that’s for sure. No, despite the stunning fallout of their victory of a I think it’s a zero for this year’s for this particular episodes. Yes, iteration,
Dr Rad 59:02
okay. Zero, no additional conquest, lazy, no additional
Dr G 59:07
pick yourselves up. Roman, get with the program. The second category is diplomacy, and I think this might be where we might be able to say something about the Aequians and the Volscii. Yes,
Dr Rad 59:18
even though the Romans would very much like to continue waging war. They at least recognize that maybe now is not the time. Yes,
Dr G 59:27
and they didn’t offer peace, but they accept the peace offer. So that’s okay. I think that’s like a three or four. Yeah,
Dr Rad 59:36
let’s give them a three. It seems very, you know, thrown away there by Livy at the end there, they
Dr G 59:41
certainly don’t take the initiative. So no, I don’t want to give them too much credit expansion.
Dr Rad 59:47
Well, I feel like they kind of has to count again for this one, does it? Well, yeah. I mean, it’s very significant, as we talked about last time. It’s perhaps more than doubling the territory that Rome has, maybe increasing it in. By up to 60%
Dr G 1:00:01
okay, but we gave them points for that last time, and it’s not like they’ve expanded into it again,
Dr Rad 1:00:10
like Appius Claudius with your logic
Dr G 1:00:12
like a steel trap. Virtus,
Dr Rad 1:00:16
hmm, tricky one, this one, but I feel like no Camillus is definitely doing some stuff, but I feel like it’s not what the Romans consider to be virtus. It’s
Dr G 1:00:28
really interesting, because I feel like a triumph, on some levels, is like the ultimate expression of weird to us. But then he does this thing with the horses, and everybody’s a little bit upset about how much weird to us he does it with.
Dr Rad 1:00:40
I know that’s what I mean. Like Livy actually says, In translation, of course, that his triumph was more brilliant than popular meaning. I think it was dazzling to watch, but everyone was really cranky while they did it
Dr G 1:00:52
amazing. So in some respects, I feel like this puts us at an interesting point of conflict when it comes to this idea of weirdos. So weird to us, this old fashioned Roman sense of manliness is really bound up in physical displays, the celebration of masculinity, and in that sense, a triumph is like the ultimate expression of Roman masculinity. It doesn’t get much better than that, but because the people are upset about how he does it, I think we have to take some points potentially off what he could have got if this was something that everybody was really happy about, yes,
Dr Rad 1:01:32
and certainly the people are happy to see him. I mean, that’s part of the account that we get, you know, people rushing up to acclaim him. It’s not like everybody’s against, yeah,
Dr G 1:01:42
it’s only when he does the weird white horse thing. Is
Dr Rad 1:01:45
it weird? Dr, G, is it?
Dr G 1:01:47
Well, I mean, what’s a normal horse to you? All right, so I guess a brown one, I don’t know. Should we say, like a seven? All right.
Final category is the citizen score.
Dr Rad 1:02:00
Oh, such a roller coaster. I think for the citizens this year, they were happy in the previous episode to go and get stuff from Veii this year, not happy that all the proceeds from the slaves has gone into the state treasury. So it’s kind of, they’ve kind of got a little bit of both, you know, they’ve got a share of, you know, some of the takings of a but they haven’t got everything handed to them and they’re upset about it. I think this tyre thing is going to be a real problem as well. But no more war. No more
Dr G 1:02:28
war for now, definitely, there’s peace with the neighbors. That’s that’s important. That’s a plus. I think having to return some of the booty is a bit of a negative, because you would like people to be upfront with you about that. You’d rather get taxed before you get your pay rather than after you get your pay. This
Dr Rad 1:02:45
is very true. I’d be very upset if my employer did that. Were they like, Here’s your money? Oh, well, sorry. Sorry, not
Dr G 1:02:54
that they don’t do that anyway, but they use other mechanisms. Uh, watch out for taxation, my friends, it’s a problem. So it is both a good time to be a Roman citizen, but also maybe an annoying time to be a Roman citizen. So I think I’m giving them, I’d be inclined to give it about a five, because it’s like they’re not in the most danger that they’ve ever been in. They’ve had a military success. There’s peace and with some other really particular neighboring figures. Celebrations are happening. Celebrations are happening. Everyone likes to try out fix that for the horsey business. And then it’s the 10% tax on the stuff that you already took, where you’re like, Excuse me. And then also the things in the treasury where they’re like, Oh, well, that’s a bit rude. I
Dr Rad 1:03:42
think Livy’s trying to pay. To paint them to be a little bit ungrateful, a little bit unreasonable, but yes, I take your point. All right. I think so. Is it a five? Do you think like a five? I think I think a five, okay, which means Dr, G, we end up with a very even 15 golden eagles, which, if you add it together with what we had last time and the time before, that is actually a pretty spectacular score for one year. What’s
Dr G 1:04:09
the total score? Because there were like 30 something last time. Look, I
Dr Rad 1:04:13
can’t remember precisely, but I think we’d be in the 40s, for sure, if not at 50, to be honest. Wow. So 396, the year that had everything.
Dr G 1:04:23
It’s very exciting. Well, there you have it. Dear listeners, 396 BCE, what a time. I know I can’t imagine that 395 is gonna be able to top it. Well, we can only find out by going there together. Indeed, I’ll
Dr Rad 1:04:39
see you next time. Dr, G you
thank you for listening to this episode of the partial historians. You can find our sources sound credits and an automated transcript in our show notes. Our music is by bettine. Joy De Guzman, you too can support our show and help us to produce more fascinating content about the ancient world by becoming a Patreon or buy us a coffee on Ko-Fi. In return, you receive exclusive early access to our special episodes. Today, we would like to say Wilkommen Bienvenue, Welcome to our latest Patreons, Rachel Tom, Jonathan and the Sun Eater. Thank you so much for being part of our partial band. However, if you’re feeling the pinch of an empire wide economic crisis, please just tell someone about the show or give us a five star review. And if you’re looking for something cheerful and Roman to read, you can grab yourself a copy of our latest book, Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire. Until next time we are yours in ancient Rome.
Transcribed by https://otter.ai
The post Episode 160 – The Fall of Veii: Part Three appeared first on The Partial Historians - Ancient Roman History with smart ladies.
WARNING! This post and episode both contain spoilers!
We are back to discuss Gladiator II, the sequel to Ridley Scott’s smash hit Gladiator (2000). Gladiator II is set in the joint reign of Caracalla and Geta. These emperors were brothers in real life, but not the creepy twins shown in the movie. However, let’s not get caught up in historical detail! After all, Lucilla should have been executed by Commodus in the first film if we were sticking to the facts.
Special Episode – Gladiator II with Professor Martin M. Winkler
In Gladiator II, we learn that Lucilla’s precious son, Lucius Verus, was hidden away in the provinces after Commodus’ death and became alienated from the imperial family. He clearly inherited the military skills of his real father (Maximus or Russell Crowe), as Lucius is something of a local hero in his new home.
But no one can resist the power of Rome forever. After a military defeat, Lucius ends up in the arena and spends the film wrestling with his past, his trauma and the corruption of Rome. Just like his dad!
Whilst Lucius Verus is the hero of this film, as is so often the case in movies about Ancient Rome, the villain steals the show. Macrinus (Denzel Washington) is a master manipulator, skilfully playing a dangerous political game. Will the ghost of Maximus past allow Lucius to finally set Rome on a virtuous path? Or is Rome doomed to be dominated by corrupt politicians?
And boy, do we have a treat in store for you all! We were privileged to talk to a giant in the field of classical reception, a man who has spent many decades studying Roman history on film.
The cover of Professor Winkler’s volume on Gladiator (2000).
Martin M. Winkler is Distinguished University Professor and Professor of Classics at George Mason University in Northern Virginia. His research interests include classical mythology, Roman history, classical literature, the classical tradition, and classical literature, history and myth on film. Professor Winkler’s list of publications is long indeed, but we will cite a few of our favourites. The Roman Salute: Cinema, History and Ideology (2009), Ovid on Screen: A Montage of Attractions (2020) and most recently, Classical Antiquity and the Cinematic Imagination (2024). Professor Winkler has edited and contributed to volumes on the films Troy (from 2004), Kubrick’s 1960 Spartacus, and importantly for today, Ridley Scott’s original 2000 Gladiator.
We hope that you enjoy our conversation with Professor Winkler in which we discuss:
Our music is by Bettina Joy de Guzman.
Dr Rad 0:00
Hello, listeners, prepare to be entertained. Sorry. I just can’t help myself when we’re going to be talking about Gladiator and that is indeed what this special episode is all about. We return with another one of our special installments on Gladiator II, the sequel to the 2000 smash hit where we get some of the old gang back together. There’s Lucilla, there’s Gracchus, there’s Lucius Verus, and we meet some new historical characters like Macrinus, as well as the Emperors Caracalla and Geta. Please make sure you check out our show notes for a plot summary if you haven’t seen the film yet. And Be warned, this episode does contain spoilers, and now I think it’s time that we get into the arena on with the episode!
Welcome to the Partial Historians.
Dr G 1:09
We explore all the details of ancient Rome,
Dr Rad 1:14
everything from political scandals, the love affairs, the battles wage and when citizens turn against each other. I’m Dr rad,
Dr G 1:23
and I’m Dr G. We consider Rome as the Romans saw it, by reading different authors from the ancient past and comparing their stories.
Dr Rad 1:34
Join us as we trace the journey of Rome from the founding of the city. You music.
Hello and welcome to a special episode of the partial historians. I am one of your hosts, Dr rad, and I’m Dr G, and we are here once again to discuss gladiator two, which is currently taking the world by storm. We are so fortunate to be joined by a true giant in the field of history on film, Martin M Winkler is distinguished university professor and professor of classics at George Mason University in Northern Virginia. His research interests include classical mythology, Roman history, classical literature, the classical tradition and classical literature, history and myth on film. Professor Winkler’s list of publications is long indeed, but we will cite a few of our favorites: The Roman Salute: Cinema, History and Ideology, which came out in 2009, Ovid on Screen:, A Montage of Attractions from 2020 and most recently, Classical Antiquity and the Cinematic Imagination in 2024. Professor Winkler has edited and contributed to volumes on the films Troy from 2004 Kubrick’s 1960s Spartacus, and importantly for today, Ridley Scott’s original Gladiator from the year 2000. We are extremely excited to have one of the world’s leading academics in classical reception here to talk about Gladiator II. Welcome, Professor Winkler.
Martin Winkler 3:15
Thank you very much, ladies. Dr Rad and Dr G, I should say for your kind invitation. I have never made it to Australia in person, so maybe in this virtual trip, I can at least partly, partially remedy the situation. I also might be allowed, I hope, a personal confession. The cinema and classical antiquity are two of my sort of what greatest lovers, and particularly in conjunction. So any chance I get to talk about them together, I jump at so I’m particularly grateful for you to give me the chance to talk about this new release, Gladiator II, which has not taken me quite by the storm that you mentioned just to remind a go, but that’s okay.
Dr Rad 4:05
That is okay. That should provide plenty of things for us to
Dr G 4:07
talk about. That is some good foreshadowing, I think. So obviously
Dr Rad 4:12
we want to draw on your expertise about the first film as well as the second film. So what we found particularly interesting about this new gladiator is that Ridley Scott has teamed up with some of the original cast and crew for this sequel, including production designer Arthur Max, costume designer Janty Yates, with perhaps a bit of help from somebody else for the military costumes, we think this time, as well as producer Douglas Wick, you’ve already noted in your work on the first film that Scott tries to present us with a Rome that is very lived in, but we also know that Scott and his team, the first time, were very inspired by the paintings from the Victorian era of Rome. What is your reaction to the aesthetic of this sequel?
Martin Winkler 4:54
Well, if by aesthetic you mean visual style, I think I am a bit underwhelmed,, if I may say so, by the secret, the first Gladiator, the enormous success that it was, surprisingly worldwide, the first big screen, silver screen, epic, huge epic, center set in antiquity, was obviously also and deservedly quite influential. The new Gladiator, I think gladiator too is a bit of a disappointment. The Connect and this also seen individual style, I think others, and I have pointed out to some of the Victorian background in Victorian also European painting, most famously, Gerome’s painting, Police Verso, the thumbs up, thumbs down, seen in the Coliseum with a gladiator, over raising a sword, over falling gladiator and so on that. I think was perhaps the direct inspiration for Scott to take on this project, as you said at the time when he was thrown this in between. So yeah, I’m not quoting verbatim. He said something like, Yes, I can make that kind of movie. I noticed some of these pictorial backgrounds or influences in Gladiator II, also less so perhaps Gerome, than the British Dutch painter. One of my favorites, actually Lawrence Alma Tadema that influence, I think, could be seen in certain scenes here and there. On the other hand, the Greeks and Romans indemus paintings usually are appear in very sunny, beautiful, pleasant, relaxing, vacation type, almost surroundings, and there’s very little of that in Gladiator II. That’s also true for gladiator one, the first gladiator which presented a sort of dark, bloody kind of image of Rome. I’ll say a quick word about the Coliseum in just a moment. But before I do so, let me add that the lived in quality that I think actually was very strongly there and to be seen in the first gladiator brought the computer generated images, the animation to life. I meant that, particularly at that time, I do not I meant it particularly because these days 3d or other sort of computer animations of Roman architecture or other historical periods in architecture take very great pains to show you as accurately as possible the buildings, The streets, the sculpture architecture, what have you. But usually it’s kind of a dead city or dead environment. There’s hardly anybody around and in the cyber room, as I might call it, particularly the first Gladiator. That was not the case. Yeah, that really was a kind of lived in sort of environment. And one of its strongest visual science in this regard, I think, was the Coliseum, which was the main place of action, the main what place of spectacle in that film. And the coliseums had at that time, was built, I think, up to one or two stories, and everything else was computer generated imagery. But the low views, low angle views of the Coliseum on the one hand, and the very spectacular flyover, as it’s usually called, on the other hand, I think, very successfully conveyed the impression of what an amazing building this was, notwithstanding all the death and destruction and bloodshed and animal slaughter that was going on, or would be going on, as simply as an architectural marvel. I think the first gladiator put that point across very, very effectively and impressively too. Remember also the year, another famous moment when Maximus and the other Gladiators, for the first time, enter the arena through this dark tunnel and then are in the year on the sand in the arena, and look around and you have sort of, if not 300 Yeah, I think it’s actually 360 degrees, sort of panoramic shot. Yeah, they’re looking up, and it’s, it really is a kind of big wow effect. I’m saying this because, and this leads on to the fact that I was underwhelmed, as I said earlier about the sequel the Coliseum in Gladiator two, which, of course, again, is a major site for action spectacle near plot development. And such looks by comparison. May I be totally frank, it looks almost puny. I was very, very disappointed the power of the images that the first gladiator had in this regard, and then others do, for that matter, I think was largely, largely an angle, and I think that’s symptomatic, perhaps, for the film as a whole. Not to mince any words, I was a bit disappointed. It’s a common tourism that sequels to earlier films are usually books. Sometimes too are inferior. That’s usually true, although there are exceptions. But later too, I don’t think is an exception. It’s by no means boring or poorly put together anything like that. Scott is a far too good director for that, and the whole thing, of course, is far too expensive to do for anybody to get away with a sloppy job. But it’s, I think. Think a somewhat perfunctory, pale rehash of the plot with some new characters and with connections back to the risk of the plot of gladiator
Dr G 10:10
Yeah, no, I think that what you’re saying is like there’s a parallel of smallness of what we see on the screen with gladiator two, in some respects, to the smallness of the story that comes across, yes,
Martin Winkler 10:21
yes, I think that’s that’s true. Because, for one thing, the story, the plot in later two is pretty much predictable. It is painfully predictable, if I may say so, for anybody who remembers later to one. Now, many people these days in 2024 may not be up on recent viewings of later one, as probably you two are, and as I am, yeah, I’ve watched gradator on, I don’t know how many times by now, I recently revisited it too. That I think, is another kind of well, as I said, it’s sort of a rehash. Almost since the originator came out in 2000 there had been talks, had been talk or questions about, will there be a remake? It was difficult to do that because the year or Maximus is dead at the end. So how can you do this? So it took her. It took a long time for that remake to come out, but I don’t think Scott or anybody else did their own reputation much of a favor. I believe actually, Russell Crowe said something to that effect some of the plot developments. And I don’t know if I’m allowed to give spoilers, say spoilers, or give anything away. Well, the big revelation that the hero then turns out to be, well, it’s not that big of a revelation that it turns out to be the son of Lucilla, but the super revelation is that he now is also the son of Maximus. And that flies in the face of everything that near the first later film and Lucilla and Maximus and there, to a large extent, actually quite intriguing backstory of as lovers and then being separated and all coming back together in order to battle Commodus, the evil Emperor. This is a pale rehash in glator two of that constellation. And that’s, I think that’s a disappointment, you know, I think both the audience and perhaps if I may say so also, even Lucilla, as a character of Lucilla in Gladiator II, deserved a lot better than that. And I
Dr G 12:18
would definitely agree with that. And I think this leads really nicely into thinking about some of the parallels that we see between Maximus as the protagonist of the original film and Lucius as kind of this heir to Maximus, as is revealed in Gladiator two. I think this is one of the moments where, when Dr Rad and I left the cinema, that was one of the things where we’re like, Oh no, that’s that’s what they decided to do. They decided to make Lucius the son of Lucilla and Maximus, when that intriguing connection that they did have offered a hint of that possibility. But you think to yourself, within the terms of Imperial politics, it would be very unlikely that such a child would be raised as he was in the Imperial Household. So I’m interested in your thoughts on the characters of Maximus and Lucius as they compare as separate examples of the heroic in each of these films.
Martin Winkler 13:14
Well, that is practically no contest. I think Russell Crowe wins. Wins this one very easily, either hands down. He’ll be thrilled to hear that, either hands down or thumbs up, whichever way you want to put this, as you remember, Gladiator in 2000 or actually in 2001 won the Oscar for Best Picture, and Crow won for best best actor. I don’t think there is any danger of that sort of thing being repeated this time around, although, of course, I’m not a prophet. I may word be wrong. Crow really had a major presence in the film, as he did also in many of his earlier films, particularly with also which are not that well known in the US, those he made in in Australia, his native country, the actor who plays solutions is, I’m not saying by any chance that he is bad. Paul masculin is a good actor, but his character is so underwritten and so thin in terms of characterization, because he’s basically the sort of a warming up of Maximus, of an inferior Maximus, I should say, or mini Maximus.
Dr G 14:20
I think, I think you should say that.
Martin Winkler 14:23
Sorry, but I think that’s, that’s what it is. In addition to that, there’s also very little psychological conviction to this. The boy Lucius that he turns out to be, grew up with his mother, as we saw in in the original Gladiator. It’s hardly likely that when he comes back to Rome as an adult, he does not recognize her or repudiates her, as he does in the film and that sort of thing for that, the boy, I think was, was far too old. So that’s not, that’s not, at least, to me, it was not convincing. The very fact that he repudiates Lucilla when he’s in the prison is an echo. Of, I think, a very powerful scene in the first Gladiator, when Lucilla visits Maximus imprisoned. You know, the scene then culminates, then in the famous, I think of the bottom line, you know, the lady has finished with me. And it’s, it’s a subdued, I think, erotically, quite, yeah, with an erotic undercurrent, you know, the former levels reunited and such, at least momentarily. The very fact that in Gladiator II, the rehash of that scene, if I may say so, Lucius actually yells at her. At Lucilla shows you that the strong connection emotional, intellectual, if you like, also connection between the two lovers, now, between mother and son is is very weak. If you can’t get something across, be loud and noisy, then an audience won’t notice. That’s unfortunately sort of the general maxim these days.
Dr Rad 15:50
Yeah, I must admit, I agree with you that I think when I was reflecting on the film Lucius was probably one of the biggest disappointments, and it it wasn’t something I thought about very much, because I guess our attention is so much on working Phoenix and Russell Crowe and those sorts of characters in the first one, but the child who played Lucius actually did a fantastic job in the first movie. I thought in terms of acting like an imperial Prince and the way that he interacted with Maximus and, yeah, to have him turn out to be like this? And I, as you say, I don’t think it’s necessarily the actor’s fault. I think it’s definitely he was trying to do the most he could with a bad script for his
Martin Winkler 16:33
largely underwritten, underwritten character, because he just goes, he’s put the script puts him, and there’s the direction also, they put him through the motions. You know, yet you’re here now, and you have to go to this, this, this, and this and this, in order to end up at certain subject. The one exception to this I would like to add, after all my negative comments, is the plot development, which, in retrospect, is quite predictable, but at least it took me by a surprise, is to have father and I’m sorry, stepfather and son or step father and stepson, then meeting in the arena and Jewel it out now if that had actually happened, and if the one, if one of them had defeated the other one, rather than a case, the husband of Lucilla being shot by an by hail of arrows that could have actually made from intense climax. Because whichever way this goes, does Acacius skip loses or defeat, loses at least, or does lose defeat acacia and then an appeal to the crowd, thumbs up, thumbs down. That could have made for, I think, quite an exciting ending. Spectacle. Ending this way it’s, it’s almost like a cop out. The characters are not pushed to the extreme that in that epic heroes, or particularly tragic heroes, often do get pushed to. So the final duel, you know, the sort of big climax. Then this postponed, and it’s a duel between Lucius and Macrinus, whose name, unfortunately, is pronounced macronus In the film, and that’s a disappointing view, too. After two and a half hours, almost two and a half hours, you deserve a bigger climax, a bigger action climax and Gladiator. One firm essay called it that delivered, because you had Crow and Joaquin Phoenix, who was a really, really, really great villain. So you have the great hero and the great villain facing off, and the fact that Maximus then dies, yeah, he kills the bad guy has this to be expected, but then dies himself adds greater potency to this. And then when Lucilla says he was a hero of Rome, as is repeated in later it has a resonance in later II. It virtually does it because there’s, there’s nothing to resonate, I dare say,
Dr Rad 18:43
yeah, the way that that final duel ends with Lucius surviving again, it’s kind of like another slight disappointment. He
Martin Winkler 18:50
survives and he gives a speech to the soldiers, I dare say, also the the audience, and the whole thing ends on talk. And talk is not an action. It’s not to be recommended a lot of films not to be recommended, to come in action films, no,
Dr Rad 19:04
if the way that the film plays out, the way that the action is paced, it is a bit off, given that they’re obviously trying to mimic so much of the first gladiator they missed some of those key things that made the first gladiator so good. So gladiator two takes us back to Ridley Scott’s vision of ancient Rome, and it’s obviously a generation ahead of where the first film ended. So we’ve skipped all the way over Septimius Severus rise to power. He’s not mentioned, really, and we’re in this situation where Septimius Severus has died and his sons are co Emperors of Rome. There’s obviously an argument to be made for the convenience of that with the 24 years between the first gladiator and then gladiator two. But there’s obviously a lot of challenges with getting the same actors who were in the first film to play the same parts in this particular movie. But there also might be a narrative reason for Scott to have chosen. To set the film in this particular time period. What do you think are some of the advantages of leaning into this co-emperorship between Caracalla and Geta?
Martin Winkler 20:09
Well, the chronology, let me say quick word about that. First, if you don’t mind the chronology, the condensation or telescoping, if you might say so of chronology is not a surprise in Gladiator, the first Gladiator, Commodus, gets his from Maximus pretty soon after he takes power. The real Commodus route from 180 to 192 that’s 12 years. So why if he was this bad, sort of a creepy psychopath and psychotic or whatever else, how could he have lasted for that long? So he doesn’t, and that’s that’s perfectly okay in a dramatic conversation of a story. In let me just mention a couple of other examples from earlier epic cinema, if you don’t mind, in the big 1951 MGM spectacular Quo Vadis is Nero dies with the help of his former concubine or lover, acti shortly after the fire of Rome, but he ruled, which was in 64 ad but he ruled and died and was overthrown only in 68 so what happened in between that’s inconvenient for the condensed narrative there to feel like that presents. So it gets swept under these total carpet, which is perfectly okay, because epic storytelling and cinema and such, all novels for that matter, are not history lessons. The death of Commodus shortly after his accession in Gladiator is actually apparent on the earlier film from 1964 the fall of the Roman Empire, which was usually not acknowledged as the model for Gladiator when Gladiator, it came out in 2000 which made me somewhere between SAD and MAD at that time, because film may make a personal confession, the fall of the emperor is my number one favorite Roman film. And they are also the duel, the public duel between the analogy of the returning hero and earlier friend of the Emperor the man called Livius. They duelled it out on the in the Roman Forum, not in the Coliseum. But that also happens shortly after comet, or, comparatively, shortly after Commodus takes power. So leaving out all kinds of episodes or even rains of emperors inside the story is not a problem. The question is, Does having two villains instead of one an added advantage, sort of two for the price of one, or is it the opposite effect? I think it’s the opposite. And I’m not saying this because I just want to be contrarian about a contrarian about her gladiator two, or Scott, or anything like that. Far from it. For one thing, the part the screen time that the two emperors, or the actual supervisor Tempus have is not that extensive, so they never really have a chance to show their villainy. That also is far more superficial than it need be in the first Gladiator, it was significantly different and far, far more effective, particularly the creep you seen between Commodus and Lucilla on the bed, which is almost leads almost to incestuous seduction, and then later when he loses in the story of Emperor Claudius and the busy bee. These are very, very well written and also very powerful and visually beautifully staged and edited scenes. Caracalla and Geta have nothing to show for themselves. In that regard, there’s one obvious instance of sheer madness which is also very silly, and that’s the monkey becoming a concert, which seems to be sorry, which seems to be parent on Caligula making his horse in kitata concert. So it’s a pale rehash of that. But for the first time I saw the first time I saw the Emperor Geta, I was wondering whether he had not walked in from a zombie movie. The sort of pale, bloodless, I’m sorry to say this so bluntly to me, excuse me, you know this bloodless face, and then the sort of eye makeup, the pale eyes, yeah, highly emphasized eyes. That’s something that was effective. I don’t think it is. It is effective in 2024 unless it’s a zombie movie. But that was very, very effective in the sonnet era, when emphasis on the eyes, particularly in the absence of speech, except for brief movements of intertalks and such, the expression laws of actors had to become, had to go through, mainly through their faces, if that could be helped by the eye makeup and sort of the circles above and around and below the eyes, so that the eyes sort of look received recessed or dark and such. That could be very, very effective. And that was the case not only for actresses playing, you know, the female parts, but also for actors quite often. And at that time, I think that really worked nowadays Well, am I the only one to have thought of zombies in this regard, if that’s the case, and if the listeners disagree, I stand corrected. No,
Dr G 24:49
I think, I think it’s a great observation, but it does put me in mind of like, what would lead a creative team to make the decision to embody getter in. That particular way, and I think about the way that the Colosseum is supposed to be really big, even if it doesn’t quite have the overwhelming effect that we want it to have in this film. But it might be something that would be useful for an emperor to illustrate and draw attention to their expressiveness, for a crowd that might be really far away from where they’re sitting. Now, it doesn’t really gel very nicely with what we know about Ancient Rome and the way they thought about cosmetics and used them, necessarily, but I can see how they might have made a creative cinematic leap to how do you get an emperor to express themselves on a really big stage in a way that’s quite unique and visually striking, and that might be part that
Martin Winkler 25:43
may well be true. I agree with you in this regard. On the other hand, I don’t think that invalidates the weakness of the character as such. Again, contrast to work in Phoenix, he didn’t have to resort to that sort of thing. He had the power as an actor in protecting that power. Yes, he was dressed in sort of very fancy robes, also invented completely by the Oscar winning costume designer. But that’s another story. He didn’t have to resort to, as I said, resort to that kind of crutch, if I may say so. It’s particularly sad because Caracalla, and this is an advantage of moving the story on, onto the the early third century, our Caracalla to Edward Gibbon in the history of the decline for the Roman Empire. Empire was one of the evil, bad Roman emperors who brought about, or did a major, but major contribution, in a negative sense, to propelling Rome to the Decline and Fall, invasion of barbarians and whatever else. And that, in a manner speaking, here is a completely missed opportunity. So instead of having one great hero and one great villain, you have two heroes, or let’s say one and a half, Lucius and Aacius, because Acacius doesn’t get that much screen time either. And you have two villains who don’t, in combination, barely measure up to one really memorable villain. And if you’re not convinced, think back I mentioned earlier, follow from the Empire and providers. Think back on Peter Ustinov as one of the most memorable screen dealers of all time, if not the number one, most memorable one, who could pull all that off by himself. And Ustinov also was nominated for an Academy Award. I think he should have had it. Or think back on the earlier comment displayed by Christopher Plummer in the fall of Roman Empire, a suave villain in an almost may I say this in an almost sub Laurence Olivier way. If you think back on Olivier in Kubrick’s and Spartacus, these are really, really great villains, the two emperors here. Well, even if they had been one, or they had been combined into one, they could not hold up a chalice to the other great villains to drink the toast to, or something like
Dr G 27:53
that. And it seems a real missed opportunity, because the story of Caracalla and Geta historically is incredibly fascinating and full of tension, and because we seem to be missing a lot of the backstory that they could have lent into it, does a real disservice to these two as villains, because there is a lot to delve into in terms of what’s going
Martin Winkler 28:15
to there would be another sort of dysfunctional dynasty in Rome or something like that. On the other hand, not to say nothing but negative things here, on the one hand, on the other hand, I’m very happy to see that Geta and Caracalla finally made it onto the big screen, because I’m not aware maybe you are. I’m not aware that they’ve ever been a part of a historical epic, not in not on television and not in the cinema. If anybody knows of of a film or a TV show or whatever. Please, let me know. Put
Dr G 28:43
the call out to our listeners.
Dr Rad 28:45
Get researching guys. Okay, yeah, I must admit we were. We were also similarly, a bit disappointed with the way that they were portrayed and seemingly the fact that they overlooked their heritage as well, in the in the way that they cast them, and then also made them up. It just didn’t there was just so much they could have done with that, which would have been so interesting, particularly with Denzel Washington being a major character in this film. And it just was just passed over so completely. It was, yeah, a bit of a disappointment.
Martin Winkler 29:19
You just made a good point. I hadn’t thought about this. But what if you re imagine this and push the story back a little further in time during the rule of Macrinus, although he was in power only for two months, but we already saw that telescoping history was not a problem. Would that not have been much better and more effective to have a great actor be the anti, the bad force, the bad power, the villain against a great hero. Could that not have worked? Because watching nothing really, would have pulled off being a villain with great ease, and it would have been, I think, very convincing. Then,
Dr G 29:58
yeah, and I think. A way he kind of steals the show from a villain perspective as well, because he does seem to be a more well fleshed out character in terms of the dialog that he gets to express, but also the way he has gone about delivering that character on screen as well has produced a Macrinus that is really interesting. And you can feel that this is somebody who is not just pushing towards power, but has the capacity to take it when the opportunity arises. I think that’s
Martin Winkler 30:28
completely on target. I agree entirely. That’s very true. And that’s sort of an indication that his character was underwritten and he was underused. Yeah,
Dr Rad 30:37
I kind of feel that that’s exactly what we kind of dancing around here the fact that the people who are meant to be the main heroes and villains in this film, so Lucius and then Caracalla and getter are not really given enough to do in the script to fulfill those roles. And really the General and Macrinus are the ones that are more interesting. The acting, I think, just comes across better somehow. And I feel like I wanted to know more about those characters, and they just didn’t get the screen time.
Martin Winkler 31:09
You’re right again. But I said earlier two villains for the price of one, I should have said to three, because the third villain really should have been the real villain. He overshadows Washington really overshadows the other two. And that shows their punniness as characters, not as emperors in history and such. I’m not saying that, but as dramatic characters here, they sort of almost fade into into the background. And the very fact that Macrinus kills Geta shows you that this is not really, yeah, it’s not the hero who kills the villain. It’s a villain who should be the real villain, killing a minor villain, and so on. So there are various perspectives. That’s it. It’s an example of the road and not taken, or various roles not taken in the screenplay. Yeah, the story could have been far more powerful, and I think in that sense, worthy, or worthy, or at least of the origin, than it turns out to be. I
Dr G 31:59
definitely agree with that?
Dr Rad 32:01
Yeah, definitely. Now, there is a particularly striking scene in the sequel where Lucilla and her husband, the Roman General Acacius, secretly meet with key members of the Senate with a view to taking down Caracalla and Geta and the Senator Gracchus, played by the great Derek Jacobi, who was in the first film, take the lead by suggesting that instead of returning Rome to the Senate and the people that Lucilla would be the appropriate person to raise into power, this position is later at odds with Lucius dream to restore the Roman Republic. So what might we learn here about the reception of Rome on screen. Well,
Martin Winkler 32:43
let me take on the part of a podcast villain, maybe one more time, and answer your question, what do we learn here? My direct answer would be, not very much. That’s because what Lucius? When Lucius talks about the Republican such, he just channeled his Maximus. That’s just a repeat of repetition of what was far more powerful and far stronger in in Gladiator, the first Gladiator, the fact that the senator Gracchus, who represented in the first Gladiator, represented, to, you know, the traditional senatorial quote, unquote, good government of Rome. That goes back to Senator Gregor, played by Charles Lawton in Kubrick’s ospartakers, who really was sort of the last Republican one. I’d say in that film, the return of the imperial government to the Senate, actually, during the Empire, was not entire, an entire anachronism, because this was being discussed, I think I pointed this out in the book and Gladiator in one of my chapters. This was actually discussed after the assassination of Claudius. It didn’t go anywhere, but at least there was people were talking about this, you know. And there was sort of, perhaps a hankering to the good old days of the Republic, except that the fall of the Republic was anything, but any good or days. But that’s another story. So we, I don’t think we learned a lot about this here. That’s another disappointment, because the gladiator two was filmed, I think, earlier this year, and edited. It filmed in something like no more than two months or such. So this was a very rapid, surprisingly quick production. At that time, the entire modern history of research and autocrats target and some Putin and Trump, to mention only the most prominent ones. This is something that sort of cried out to be incorporated as a modern analogy. But there is nothing like that in the film, and everything is another big missed, missed opportunity. Allow me briefly to point to a film we haven’t mentioned yet, we haven’t yet mentioned here. And this is about comparisons film Troy from 2004 which was produced here, about the chosen war and so on, and was produced during the time that the Iraq war was. Going on, and Peterson in an interview, or actually, probably more than on one occasion, said it’s kind of strange. I’m just paraphrasing this. I’m not quoting verbatim. He said something like the following. It’s strange when you come back from a day of shooting out on the location and editing whatever else to your hotel room, and you turn on the television and the same story is on the news. So Peterson was clearly aware of the not just chosen war, but also modern connection of this Homeric epic, the chosen one bed in the myth and the contemporary political situation. But there’s virtually nothing like that in in Gladiator II.
Dr G 35:38
This is a real missed opportunity, isn’t it? And I think one of the ways that we could potentially consider this is through the lens of the Senate itself, because the Senate is kind of some of them are revolutionary. Some of them are looking to depose Caracella and Geta. But more often, we see them in moments of hesitation. They’re failing to act when they have opportunities, and they don’t seem to be powerful within any particular structures in which they operate. There is a sick of phantism that is going on for them. And my first question about this was really related to like, how does that sort of match up to what we might know about the Roman Senate in this period of Rome’s history, but it might also be the case that it helps us think about what’s going on with politics today, and maybe the weakness that we see in this group is maybe a reflection of some of the frustrations people have with what appears to be the weakness of government structures In the here and now. Oh, that’s a
Martin Winkler 36:41
nice point, yes, and that’s something that I think deserves more thought, certainly on my part, and perhaps on some of the our heroes parts too. The sycophantism, as you rightly call it, of the Senate in later two is very striking. And I think that actually does have whether intention or not does not matter a modern analogy, and that is the sequence of all the Republicans, including those who were against Donald Trump in 2016 because famously, those who were called the never Trumpers all became Trumpers. I doubt if there was a single or maybe one or two exceptions mid Romney, for instance, when it comes to mind. So that’s that’s very much the case. On the other hand, there’s also a a Roman analogy to this. As you probably noticed, there is a quotation from Tacitus in in Gladiator two, not verbatim, but it takes up the famous saying, uh, by Caratacas, they make a desert and call it peace. So this the image of the Senator, I think also has a strong Tacitian analogy or echo, because Tacitus is a very, very anti Imperial historian. I think that’s safe to say. And he wrote from his own experience. So yeah, having been a concert, a concert subject, I believe, actually himself, I was reminded very strongly of one of the most famous sort of sententia sentences in Tacitus, which is also one of my favorites upon the accession of Tiberius after the death of Augustus, when he says in Rome, everybody rushed headlong into slavery, concerts, senators and the Knights. So this abject secrecy is clearly an indication that in the empire you really have, well, you still have the Seminoles of the Republic. The Republic has not been formally abolished. You still have a Senate. You have people’s assemblies and whatever else but the Empire, the Emperor calls the shots, and the Senate is basically kind of a rubber stamping body of executives, with some exceptions and sometimes you do have good consults and what have you. In addition to that, this scene, particularly when Caracalla decrees his monkey to be or quotes for the vote for his monkey to be called declared Council. I think there’s a more direct analogy to this, rather than tassien. One of that is to be found in the 1964 the fall of the Roman empire. There’s the scene in the Roman Senate in which Commodus sitting on his throne beneath the lupa Romana, the Roman wolf with these babies, Romulus and Remus and so on, one of his henchmen and sycophants proposes a motion that, or rather, asks Commodus for the permission that the city of Rome be renamed the city of Commodus the office Commodiana in them as in fact, there was some talk about that back at that time. And this, this is great moment in which Christopher Plummer really rises to the occasion. You know, he sort of rubs his fingernails against his costume, looks at it in contemplation and and then says, I allow it, or I permit it in such a very condescending way. And everybody breaks out into great. Of applause and cheering and so on and so on and so on so this abject bootlicking. Or, you know, you know what, kissing, I won’t even say it there.
Dr G 40:12
It is permitted to say such things on this we’ve said worse.
Dr Rad 40:15
Thank you.
Martin Winkler 40:16
So there, in that sense, one might say later too, fits very well into this sort of anti Roman, bad Roman history kind of archetype that goes back to the silent era. Yeah,
Dr Rad 40:27
it’s very interesting. I love to actually do a more comprehensive study of the influence of the Tacitus vibes on Roman film, because I feel like even when it’s not about a period that Tacitus wrote about, Tacitus still really has an influence over the way that directors and screenwriters sort of conceive of Rome under the emperors. That that’s
Martin Winkler 40:47
actually a nice point. That’s something one should pursue further. Tacitus are sort of the presiding ghost, the eminence grise over over Hollywood’s history. I think he would have
Dr Rad 41:01
liked to know he had such an influence. Pleased him greatly. So thinking very much about power and how it plays out in this film, you know, we’ve talked about, obviously, the villains, the heroes, we talked about the Senate. But in the first film, I think we had quite a strong presence from the Praetorian Guard in particular, and the army were also quite important to the plot in the first film. What is your opinion of the way that the Praetorians and the army come across in this sequel, again,
Martin Winkler 41:30
by comparison with the original, the sequel suffers significantly. The good point that the film makes, as did the first one, I think too, is that the Praetorians are pretty much the Emperor’s personal army, which they were in history. Also, in that sense, they were kind of a counterweight, if you like, to the regular army. And for that, there is a very strong, at least one very strong modern analogy, and that is in Nazi Germany, yeah, the SS, or first the SA and SS, and then only the essay or the SS, sorry, the portrait of the Praetorians in the original gladiator actually brought this out quite obviously, the black uniforms, the drumming and everything. In fact, if I may, point to a contribution to the gladiator book that I edited some years ago, there’s a contribution by Arthur Pomeroy, called the vision of a Fascist Roman Gladiator, in which he follows through some of the iconography, not just the pretorians, but also the triumphal scene when Commodus enters home with the Coliseum in the background and what have you. So that’s, I think that’s a strong point in the original Gladiator here. The point is still there, but it’s barely brought up. It’s sort of de emphasized, if it’s there at all. So in that sense, also, it’s not nothing. Then the rehash, really, of the original.
Dr Rad 42:52
I did wonder whether he’d actually read your book
Martin Winkler 42:57
and been like, oh, I would be flattered, but I doubt it’s very strong.
Dr Rad 43:03
I noticed the same thing. I thought the way that the Praetorians were costumed and just the general way that they were so much in the background in this film, even though they were still playing a significant role at times, it was just such a pale limitation of the first movie, and they were so de emphasized, I was like, oh my god, did he notice that? We all noticed nacino returns from that first movie I
Martin Winkler 43:27
saw somewhere. It may have been on the IMDB that there is a much longer cut of gladiator two, which runs to well over three hours, or three and a half hours, or something like that. I believe 220 minutes that might, presumably that will end up on home video at some point to make more money. So we should perhaps withhold final judgment on related to two until, if it ever shows up, until that and we can see that that footage, I’m not holding my breath, and I’m not expecting a great improvement, but at least some improvement in that regard. So it made us be that this is a bit of a sort of too much of a cutting down to get the film out into release before Christmas, or something like that.
Dr Rad 44:10
Yeah, I think Napoleon definitely suffered from trying to pack too much into the time that was allowed for the release, because even though it was beautiful, it was just such a was very, just such a pared down version of Napoleon’s life.
Martin Winkler 44:30
Yes, yes, yeah. Good point too.
Dr G 44:32
So thinking about things that may potentially be disappointing, we do get a great reference to John Dryden’s translation of part of Virgil’s Aeneid from book six, the gates of hell are open night and day, smooth the descent and easy as the way, but to return and view the cheerful skies in this the task and mighty labor lies Now this seems like they’re. Trying to draw a parallel between Lucius journey in this film and the idea of the katabasis and going through that descent, potentially to the underworld, and returning back from it. Do you think this might be justified for Lucius’ journey in the film?
Martin Winkler 45:19
Perhaps less so in a mythical Greek katabasis sense, than in a dramatic plot development sense. There is a brief moment early on when Lucius ends up in the water and sees care under the ferryman and such. You know when his wife has been killed and so on. And I understand that in an earlier screenplay written by the musician Dick cave, there would would have been a much longer underworld sequence. Who knows? Maybe that’s in the long version that we don’t see, at least not yet. So that’s a possibility. At the same time, this kind of thing is an effective plot development or plot device. It’s basically a story pattern. It’s not so much the rise and fall of a bad guy, you know, like Nero or something like that, but rather the fall and rise in terms of both Lucius and also Maximus in the two gladiator defense. So you have Maximus as a general farmer who becomes a general close associate, friend, soul mate, almost of the Emperor, Marcus Aurelius. He comes into line for power, becoming Emperor himself. Then he has a reversal of fortune, a very bad one. He becomes a slave and a gladiator, and then he comes back as the Avenger. He kills the bad guy, the Emperor. And although he dies, had he not died, he might have been programmed emperor, but at least he saves from the Gladiator. One perspective, he saves Rome from the tyrant. And now Senator Gracchus and the other senators, if they get to act together, can perhaps try to return Rome to the central government that Marcus Aurelius, and historically also had envisioned in Gladiator II. It’s very similar. The young prince gets saved, hustled away from Rome to Africa, where he is more of a commoner, but becomes prominent in his community, sort of military leader and so on. He’s defeated. He becomes a slave Gladiator, yes, as with the Maximus. And then he comes back and reasserts himself, and he survives, and he proclaims that the times of tyranny and so on are over. All of that has yet another, has yet another, very strong earlier parallel in the story of Ben Hur who starts out as a rich and powerful Prince of her as is called in the William Wyler, 1959 film, with the Roman as his friend. They become bitter enemies. He also has to fall into tragedy, fall from grace. He becomes an abject slave, galley slave, as it were, although let me just add this in parenthesis. The people who wrote the Roman military galleys were not slaves, but Marines, David soldiers, if you like. So he survives by the grace of God, literally, in this case, Jesus, and he comes back and avenge us himself. So it’s this, this basic arc from falling from the heights into abject misery and then coming back. And that’s a very, very clever Well, it’s primitive, like simple or simplistic, but it’s a very clever plot device. It’s also so much adaptable that you can put, put this template, if you like, or over practically any story, any kind of heroic story. And heroes always have their setbacks, and then come, yeah, come back more gloriously. And so you see candidates at this weekly you see this. This is basically shape in fight scenes, boxing scenes and whatever in the cinema, the one who gets most punishment first almost always wins. That’s the basic story, and that has an ancient rhetorical or historiographical slash rhetorical parallel when in debates, whoever you hear, whoever speaks first, practically never wins. The one who wins the debate is the one who speaks last, because otherwise it will be very under magic, let down and enter a climax. You know? Why? Why do we report the speech of somebody who doesn’t win at the end?
Dr Rad 49:03
That actually such an interesting point. I hadn’t thought about that potential. Parallel with Ben Hur and that actually leads me to a question which I feel only you could really answer, which is Ridley Scott, obviously, is an older director at this point in his career, and he’s directed many smash hit movies, and he had a background where he grew up, obviously, when these films that like Quo Vadis and Spartacus and Ben Hur were actually out in the cinema for the first time, and you have actually noticed in your work, the influence of his previous experience watching epics as a child, and also his background in making TV commercials had on the earlier film, particularly, I think, from Fall of the Roman Empire, Spartacus, and even with those potential Nazi influences, with Triumph of the Will and the way that it was shot, I was wondering, apart from Ben Hur, were there any other cinematic traditions that you noticed in Gladiator two that might have been in. Influencing the way it came together, not specifically.
Martin Winkler 50:04
I don’t think it’s yet another installment, or episode, if you like, in the usually negative portrayal of the Romans that has been the case from day one or even day one in the history of cinema, or even before day one in the history of novels. Think back on The Last Days Pompeii, Quo Vadis, Fabiola. It’s usually evil pagans against good Christians. Gladiator patterning itself on the Fall of the Roman Empire, and later too, fortunately, does not fall back onto this very horrid which is one saving grace of both of the gladiator films. But again, the impulse of that, or for that, comes from follow the Roman Empire. On the other hand, let me add that the entire narrative tradition of Romans on screen, or even of history on screen, is basically one big, mighty river, mighty stream. And that’s a stream of sameness, largely with exceptions, of course. So let me put it this way, if you don’t mind, let me quote a saying by Alfred Hitchcock, who said at one point, and he should know, the master of suspense. He said a movie is only as good as its villain. And we talked about this earlier, and you that Caracalla and Geta are not really good enough, not really good enough as as villains. So if you have a great villain, you can have a great story. And that worked really well in Spartacus, in Ben Hur in the earlier Gladiator, and follow me about the two Commodus films and so on. So there is a huge tradition in all of this, and it’s very difficult, consciously or even unconsciously, if you like to deviate from this and that regard to both gladiator and Gladiator two are, just as I said, additional episodes in this long road that Rome has gone in the history of popular media and earlier, as I said, in novel so stage plays and similar kind of things. The cliches of the about the Romans are so indirect that it’s, as I said, very, very difficult to go against these that reminds me of something completely different. So if I may be more depressed and ask for just a moment, let me mention the following. I remember, and I may be wrong in remembering this incorrectly. I remember when the first X Men movie came out many, many years ago, it was advertised as well. This is great, and the special effects hasn’t happened. I never been seen before, so I went. I was very much underwhelmed by that film, too, and I never bothered to watch any of the secrets. But there is one moment that I still remember in which one of the hero characters, or soon to be hero characters, I think it was Wolverine. I may be wrong. The one paper you Jackman. He comes to a kind of school, and there’s a school room with a Blackboard, and the Blackboard is has been erased, except for three words, they are still readable on the blank board. And presumably, and the classroom itself is empty too. So presumably this was the subject of the lesson that had gone on there before. And the three words are, I quote, The Roman Empire. So the Roman Empire is sort of the paradigm of an evil empire, be it Star Wars or transfixion or whatever else, or or in history, and not just an evil empire, but also a fascinating empire. You can’t get Romans out of your system. And if you do spectacle, yeah, and cinema is primarily a visual medium, stating the painfully obvious, if you do spectacle, you can’t really go worse, or do do worse than with recreating room or the Roman Empire and its decadence, so gladiatorial games, chariot races or orgies and on and on and on. So in that sense, the creation of the past is as much fictional as the creation of the future in science fiction. And Scott’s Blade Runner, and also Alien two of his I think really great films are in character or in principle, not that much different from what we have here. So historical epics or future epics set in the future, heroes, villains, shows the story patterns don’t really change, which is just as well, because they are tried and true.
Dr G 54:14
And I think to a certain extent, there’s a an audience expectation for stories to have particular arts, particularly in cinema, and particularly when it involves the Roman Empire, to start to to wrap up this conversation, because this has been so interesting, but I also can see that, you know, we’ve talked for a long time, actually, no, no, it’s been. It’s you,
Martin Winkler 54:39
you can, you can throw me to the lines, or crucify me or visually like
Dr G 54:46
look. We’ll create a suitable spectacle, it’s fair to say. But Hollywood does have a tendency to lean in to the spectacle. Obviously, that’s part of part of its job, in a way. Yeah, but there is that potential to sort of cross a line into things that might start to feel a little bit too much. And I’m wondering if there were any moments that stood out for you watching gladiator two, where you’re like, Oh, I think that might have gone a bit too far.
Martin Winkler 55:15
To be frank. No, not anymore. That’s because at my age, I’ve seen so much that virtually nothing surprises me anymore. In that regard, I do admit that during gladiator two, I had to laugh several times. But that’s, that’s, that’s another thing. The his talking inaccuracies are to be expected. You can’t help that. That’s because of the fictionalization, if you like. Let me put it that way, of the past. That’s something that you find in antiquity itself. Also consider we talked earlier I mentioned briefly the film Troy for the Trojan War. Consider that in antiquity of the chosen war, which to us, is basically mythology, even after the excavations of Troy, the discovery by Freeman and what have you, and others too, to Greeks and Romans and antiquity of the Trojan War was a historical fact. So when you retell this, as Virgil does, the fall of toy in the indeed other historical epics, Greek religions putting plays on tragedies on set among Trojan characters, The Trojan Women, by Euripides and many others, they take great liberties with the quote, unquote facts, as they probably understood this. A case in point is the story about Helen who, in one version, pretty much canonized by Homer in The Odyssey, I’m sorry, in the Iliad. And then perhaps also reinforced in The Odyssey is in Troy during the entire war in another version. And to read this, I’m sorry, Homer hints had this in the Odyssey briefly too. Helen is in Egypt. Hence the modern HD. Helen Egypt, in Egypt. What have you now in Euripides, two plays, the chosen women. Helen is now a captive of the Greeks because she’s been in tour the entire time. In another play by Euripides, she wasn’t there at all. And the entire chosen war was sort of over a few times phantom Helen, the image of Helen and what have you now. How can this be? How can one of the same author, the great, very learned author, he repeat this play so freely with what probably he also considered to be fact, the fact of the chosen war. So either she is Helen is entering or she’s not. But he does it both ways. He has his cake and eats it too, in one play this one and the other play the other one. So that’s perfectly okay. So history, historical facts are flexible. They can be reinterpreted, and usually are. This will probably remind you of a great book from maybe two decades, 25 or so years ago, Hayden. Why it’s meta history, which deals with historic, modern historiography, not ancient historiography as literary artifacts. And historians also sift through the facts. It’s not just an amalgamation of anything that comes in, sort of like a squirrel, as if a squirrel were collecting historical nuts and then presenting all of them. They sift and sword and put them into a coherent, explanatory kind of storyline, as Tacitus did, As Sallust, Thucydides, everybody really did, and the ancient historians also gave a moral slant to the effectual accounts. One of the greatest examples is probably also at least in English, is Gibbon with this gigantic history of the client for the Roman Empire, so and that that is a literary kind of work, allow me to mention maybe one more example, one of the greatest, perhaps the greatest, German historian of ancient Rome, Theodore Mommsen. He wrote a gigantic book, history of Rome, for which he received a Nobel Prize in literature. So why would a historian receive a literary, poets, novelist, whatever kind of prize? But it makes sense to come back to the subject matter here I came across, not too long ago, across something that the late great French director Jacques Rivitte, who in the 60s, 50s and 60s, was associated with the French New Wave for cinema, the Nouvelle bar. He said, at one point in a conversation or interview, I forget, I quote this almost verbatim in English. He said, As soon as something is put on film, it becomes fiction. And I think that is exactly right. The lament by historians, oh, this is wrong. That is wrong. They should have done this. It wasn’t like that. That’s all true. It never was like that. In the best case scenario, it could have been pretty much like that, but certainly, we never know for sure. And of course, the filmmakers, the studios, the producers, the actors, the screenwriters. They’re not classic scholars or classical historians, and they don’t make their movies for classicists and people with PhD in Roman history and what have you. They’re popular writers. And I don’t mean this in a negative sense. Apart from it,
Dr G 59:56
I’m not sure anyone should put a classicist or historian in. Charge of attempting time, because they’d be crippled by the details, I think, and I don’t know if it would ever see the light of day, because of the frustrations with the whole process of trying to pull the production together to be accurate as possible.
Dr Rad 1:00:13
Your point there, which is very well taken, leads me to my final question for you. As someone who also loves looking at history on a film. I’ve often found that the way that I can explain it best to my students is that there’s a difference between accuracy and authenticity on the screen, and this is often something I think you find filmmakers and also the people that write about historical filmmakers talk about which is this idea that they’re not necessarily trying to get every little detail right. They don’t actually necessarily care about getting every little detail right, but they do want to have an accurate feel to the movie, or, as you’ve put it, staying true to the spirit of the period overall, looking at the film altogether, because we’ve talked about it in little pieces today. Do you think that Gladiator II does stay true to the spirit of the period? It
Martin Winkler 1:01:05
stays true to the spirit of the historical period, third century, early third century. Ad, sort of given the fact that this was pretty much the beginning, or more than the beginning of the decline of the empire, I mean all the violence and decadence and whatever in that sense, yes, but again, it’s not specific enough for you to make a point about about that. On the other hand, Scott stays too to the spirit of his own time and his own spirit and his own experience as a filmmaker, because glad the two obviously goes back to Gladiator, and that goes back to as you saw Spartacus problema and and what have you. He also stays true to himself. You pointed out earlier that he had his first start in making advertisements for television. And these are very, very sort of tiny mini films. And rapid editing is sort of a necessity, a cynical one, for that. So hence the rapid editing in later the special effects, the volume, the cranked up volume of the sound, and whatever else that is now familiar to moviegoers. You mentioned his film, Napoleon, I think that’s a good example of playing fast and loose with history and still getting across a kind of, at least sort of fleeting, if you like, impression of what the past may have been like, although they are, think they are much better films said during the Napoleonic era, including films about Napoleon himself, I have said many bad things about Scott, particularly in the connection with related to so maybe as my last word, let me mention his first film, the feature film that which I think is still his best, and also my favorite of his, and that is the duelist with Harvey cartel and Keith Carradine. That’s very, very powerful film, also a heroic story, not on this sort of overblown epic spectacle, three hour platform. It’s because of the story by Joseph Conrad, which is a great source, and Scott rises to the occasion. It’s a beautiful film, beautifully shot. It reveals a little bit of his television, TV ad, aesthetic, if you may not, come in a ring composition back to the subject of aesthetic that was brought up first, but it holds very well together. And I think that’s perhaps the essence of Scott even at the very beginning. Many of his other films, and I can’t claim to have watched all of them, many of his other films are sometimes too long, too overblown, alien and breed one I will gladly accept from that. But if anybody, if those of our listeners have not looked at the dualists, please do so. I think it’s a very rewarding experience. It’s now available in the beautifully restored blu ray edition, so I recommend it very, very early. Oh, that’s good to know it
Dr Rad 1:03:49
is. And I think that’s a good point to finish up on, because I think the reason why we’ve been picking apart gladiator two today is because we all really liked the first one. It was such an interesting addition to the catalog of films about Rome. And even though, obviously there’s a lot to say about the historical inaccuracy of that film, it really embodied what I think I love about history in general, which is that history is good to think with. It helps you to reflect on your own time and also on the time that it’s about. And I think that that’s what I was missing from gladiator two. I didn’t have that same urge to reflect or to use this film to think about anything that I find particularly interesting. It did seem like just spectacle, and I know that Ridley Scott is capable of delivering so much more, and that’s why I think I was disappointed at the end.
Martin Winkler 1:04:39
Yes, I would sign off on that completely too. Maybe he has a much bigger and better, bigger and qualitative sense, better surprise in store for you with his upcoming films. Who knows? So let’s not put paid to him yet. Absolutely,
Dr G 1:04:53
I will always thank him for creating the first film that, that gladiator film. I mean. It sort of sets the tone for a way. A lot of scholars in our generation think about Rome in that period as a touchstone for how does that sort of shift if we look at the ancient evidence, but it’s also, I think it’s a great film. It’s actually really powerful film, and it’s one that I’m happy to re watch and obviously I revisited it in order before I saw gladiator two at sort of us, I was like, well, obviously I need to re watch Gladiator, you know, I’ve got to be prepared. Obviously, it’s another moment where I was like, Oh, I have to watch this film again. And it’s not a burden to do that with gladiator because the performances are so well executed, I think, and the world building feels really quite strong. So thank you so much for taking this time to sit down and chat with us. We’re immensely privileged to have you here and to learn from your insights. Not
Martin Winkler 1:05:54
at all, it’s my pleasure entirely Thank you, and thank you for being such gracious host. And I hope I was not too disappointing with or my natural negativity.
Dr Rad 1:06:04
We had the same sort of feeling. We enjoyed going to see it, but we had the same feeling, which was that the sequel was just trying to hit those same beats and yet just didn’t execute it effectively enough for it to be anything more than really a shadow of the first film, which, as you say, is quite common for sequels. But I was kind of hoping, because of the gap between the first and the second, that Ridley Scott would maybe have a bit of license to break free
Dr G 1:06:35
from and really craft a new story. Yeah, exactly, yeah. That didn’t seem to be the case, sadly.
Dr Rad 1:06:43
Well, listeners, if you enjoy learning about Rome on film, I definitely suggest that you go and consult one of the many excellent volumes that Professor Winkler has edited over the years. They are filled with very insightful articles from lots of academics, and I can definitely say that a lot of my work on history on film has been based on something from one of those volumes, and they’re very readable, so please go and check them out.
Thank you for listening to this special episode of the partial historians, you can find our sources sound credits and an automated transcript in our show notes. Our music is by Bettina Joy De Guzman. You too can support our show and help us to produce more engaging content about the ancient world by becoming a Patreon. In return, you receive exclusive early access to our special episodes, and you get to make suggestions for future episodes. Today, we would like to thank all of our wonderful Patreon and Ko fi supporters for helping us to cover the costs of making the show and taking it in new directions. However, if you have spent all your money at the Coliseum on larks tongues and wren’s livers, please just tell someone about the show or give us a five star review Until next time we are yours in ancient Rome
Unknown Speaker 1:08:09
You
Transcribed by https://otter.ai
The post Special Episode – Gladiator II with Professor Martin M. Winkler appeared first on The Partial Historians - Ancient Roman History with smart ladies.
The Fall of Veii is finally upon us – or perhaps we should say it was finally upon them! After a shameful defeat early in 396, the Romans decided to appoint a dictator. It is time for a Republican hero to burst into the spotlight. Welcome to the stage, Marcus Furius Camillus!
Episode 159 – The Fall of Veii: Part II
Camillus is a legendary figure of Rome, possibly in more ways than one. He was held up as an exemplar for generations. Even the emperor Augustus was a fangirl. We have mentioned him before, but it is his service as dictator during the siege against Veii where we get to see him shine for the first time.
Bronze Sculpture of Marcus Furius Camillus ca. 1st century AD from the Capitoline Museum. Courtesy of Ancient Times Blog Spot.
The appointment of Camillus restored a sense of optimism to Rome and people were literally queuing up to serve under him. With suspicious ease, Camillus dealt with Veii’s allies, the Faliscans and Capenates, before turning his attention to breaking the siege once and for all. Through clever use of tunnels and military distractions, the Romans defeated their enemy – at last!
Rome has been engaged in almost constant warfare with neighbouring towns and cities for an exceptionally long time, but it is hard to overstate the importance of this conquest. Not only was Veii a wealthy and serious rival, but this acquisition also doubled the size of Rome’s territory. To quote Camillus as he surveyed the battlefield, “Cha-ching!”
However, Camillus made some promises to the gods both before and after this final battle, promises that will have various impacts for our hero and for Rome….
Stay tuned for the next instalment on 396 BCE!
Need to catch up on the first part of 396 BCE? Check out Part One on the Fall of Veii!
Our music is provided by Bettina Joy de Guzman. Sound effects courtesy of Orange Free Sounds.
Dr Rad 0:15
Music. Welcome to the Partial Historians.
Dr G 0:18
We explore all the details of ancient Rome,
Dr Rad 0:23
everything from political scandals, the love affairs, the battles wage and when citizens turn against each other, I’m Dr Rad and
Dr G 0:33
I’m Dr G, we consider Rome as the Romans saw it, by reading different authors from the ancient past and comparing their stories.
Dr Rad 0:44
Join us as we trace the journey of Rome from the founding of the city.
Dr G 0:58
Hello and welcome to a brand new episode of the partial historians. I am Dr G
Dr Rad 1:06
and I am Dr Rad,
Dr G 1:08
and we are in the middle of what is a chaotic time for ancient Rome. It’s the year 396, BCE, and oh, boy, are they not having a good time, as far as we can tell so far,
Dr Rad 1:26
indeed, 396 is a very big year for Rome. However, the start of it was not great. Mm,
Dr G 1:33
not great at all. It seems like there were some reversals in the field. There were some poorly planned ambushes and some confusing dealing about with Father Son combinations in the military tribunes with consular power.
Dr Rad 1:48
Yeah. Just for those who didn’t listen to our last episode A) I’d probably go and do that, because this is a bit of a narrative that we’re building here. However, we’re dealing with the end of the siege of Veii, an Etruscan city just to the north of Rome. Rome has had a somewhat complicated relationship with over the years, extending all the way back. And whilst the ancient sources make reference to the fact that, oh yeah, there was this truce from the second big conflict between Rome and of Veii, and it run out, and then there was a king, and he was a bit of a douche bag. And not only did the Romans not like the king of A, but the Etruscans didn’t like the king of Veii, and that’s why all of this happened. In spite of that, as Dr G rightly pointed out in our previous episode, it’s probably really about resources, trade influence in the region, because these are two increasingly important places, I would say, in the previous century that we’ve been looking at. Now we’re entering a whole new century.
Dr G 2:54
It does seem like they is the Southern tale of Etruscan influence in the fifth century, BCE. And so the big power base that is through central to North Italy is the is a true area, the Etruscan people, and Rome is now this sort of growing player in the center of Italy. And they seem to want a slice of the Etruscan pie. They’ve decided maybe they has to go to make way for the growth of Rome itself into a grander place.
Dr Rad 3:28
And we’ve got some allies of ve who have realized that a growing Rome is no good for them. That’s true,
Dr G 3:37
and Rome itself has been cultivating a whole bunch of their neighbors into being, variously allies or enemies, depending on how they’ve been treating them to the east and to the south. So there is a kind of a sense that there are a couple of blocks of power developing. The Etruscan block has been around for a long time, and it seems like maybe it might be on the wane in various ways, particularly when it comes to this southern edge where Rome is butting up against it. But there’s also this sense that there are now growing disputes amongst Rome and her other neighbors, some of which are turning violent. The Volscian The Aequians, have been long on the radar. But there’s also the
Dr Rad 4:22
turning violence.
Dr G 4:25
There’s also the Hernicians and the Latins that seem to have come together with Rome. Now, before we get too much further into the action of this year, I want to hark back to something that came up a couple of episodes ago now, where you were talking about the Roman electoral process and the concept of the praerogativa. Yes,
Dr Rad 4:49
this is how Calvus was apparently chosen for election to be one of the military tribunes with consular power in 396 even though he was not running for said election.
Dr G 4:59
How. Could it be possible to get elected in when you’re not even running? Well, no, the power of the praerogativa may be the answer to this question. Now we don’t know too much about it. In this very early period, like many things to do with ancient Rome, we only become more sure about stuff when we hit about the mid to late third century BCE. So we’re about 150 years away from having any good information to work with.
Dr Rad 5:28
So probably be in our 60s for the time we get to that.
Dr G 5:31
But those problems aside, this comes out of the concept of the comitia centuriata, which is this idea that some voting took place in a military style setup, where people were organized into centuries at some point in Rome’s history, the idea of the electoral centuries deviates very wildly from the military setup. That’s not our problem right now. We don’t know what’s going on, really, but we have this group, the comitia centuriata. They all turn up in their little groups. In their centuries, they head to the Campus Martius, and they get involved in a voting thing. Now, the prey rogativo Part of this is a invention that we don’t know when it starts, but it is an innovation where they change who gets to be the first entry to vote. And it used to be the case that it always followed the same order. You would start with the equestrians, strangely enough, and then you’d get into the other groups. But with the concept of the prerogative of what you could do is that you could have a nominated group from one of the higher echelons of society be the first one to vote. It was kind of like a lucky draw, but only the best of the best got to be put into the draw to be selected in the first place, and then they would kind of set the tone for how the rest of the vote should go. Now it wasn’t the case that all the other centuries, necessarily immediately would fall in line with what was voted for by that first group that was chosen as the prey rogativo. There seems to be some ideas that come to us in our very much later sources of the Republic like Cicero, that there was a bit of an omen component to all of this. So it was read as a bit of a sign of how the electoral result was going to go. So there was a persuasive factor in it that for the Romans would have been quite important, because they hold a lot of importance in things that relate to the gods and omens and signs. But that didn’t necessarily seal the deal. But if you had a group that came out and decided that they wanted somebody in to be voted, like this situation with calvis, who hadn’t been nominated, hadn’t put themselves forward, hadn’t canvas or any of that sort of thing, that could really turn the tide for something, because all of a sudden everybody like, yeah, we need that guy, yeah. Why wasn’t he running? And that might have a cascading effect. I
Dr Rad 8:05
think it definitely did. Everyone decided they wanted a taste of that vanilla bean plebeian.
Dr G 8:13
And so this is how you might get somebody voted in who didn’t stand for a position, absolutely,
Dr Rad 8:19
unfortunately. Dr G, he hasn’t got much longer in this position that we’re talking about. We did list our magistrates in the previous episodes. By the way, everyone I know you’re used to us listing out who all the magistrates are. So if you want to know the full details, please go and listen to the previous episode.
Dr G 8:36
I was going to say, I’m not going to put myself through that again. Yeah,
Dr Rad 8:40
definitely not. It’s way too much Latin for anybody to have to repeat. So we were up to this point in my narrative of Livy, where a rumor had gotten out of hand after the Romans had suffered a military reversal in the field against these allies of they, the Faliscans and the Capenates, who, by the way, were not themselves Etruscans, but were allied with they, because they were geographically and presumably politically tied to they, and they understood that the Romans were going to be coming for them, so they had managed to secure this success. Everyone’s panicking in the city. Women are praying. The Romans feel like it really is time for Veii tofall because they’ve done everything that the gods wanted them to do. They have drained that stupid album Lake, which had too much water. They have also made sure that the issue in the previous year where you had the magistrates elected improperly, that’s been resolved. So they’ve repeated whatever rituals or held whatever festivals or sacrifices needed to be held again, so they’re ready. They’re like now is the time God’s to show us that you’ve been paying attention. Have you been paying attention to all the things that we have done to please you? And it turns out, Dr G. That maybe they just have, however, before we get to that moment, it’s time for a dictator to be elected. Because clearly, with one military Tribune with consular power, dead in the field, and the other one disgraced, because this defeat is so embarrassing, you need someone with real chutzpah.
Dr G 10:20
Well, it does make sense, because everybody in Rome, as we noted in the previous episode, is in a bit of a panic. People have rushed to the temples being like guards, help us out. People have run to the walls of the city to look over and be like, can I see the enemy approaching? Like, is it a bird? Is it a plane? No, it’s the Etruscins. So that level of panic is the kind of thing that sets the stage up really nicely for the ultimate panic move that Rome has, which is put a dictator in charge, and
Dr Rad 10:56
are you ready to meet him? Dr G my name is Marcus Furius Camillus, father to other people with a similar name, related to people who are Spurius Furius and
Dr G 11:08
I will have my vengeance
Dr Rad 11:12
in this life all the next. I’m part of the Furii clan, but I’m always very calm. Actually, I
Dr G 11:17
feel like we could both be a pretty good Russell Crowe. Maybe we should do that one time.
Dr Rad 11:21
Well, Rusty, if you’re listening, love to have you on the show, mate. Let’s collaborate. So Marcus Furius Camillus is part of our favorite gens, the fury eye, however, lacking the praenomen that we prefer.
Dr G 11:37
He is no Spurius. That’s true, he’s
Dr Rad 11:39
no Spurius. But you know what, it seems like, the ancient Romans didn’t care as much about the alliteration of their names as we did, because he is definitely, I’m gonna get a limb, the most famous of the Furii clan. I’m not gonna go into all the details about him right now, because that will obviously unfold as we go into this. But the whole fall of a that is about to happen very much tied up with this particular figure.
Dr G 12:04
You’ve given away the game too soon. I’m
Dr Rad 12:06
sorry, but I feel like I’ve said it at least 100 times by now, everyone should know. So there’s a few important elements to the story of the fall of a which, as we’ve said, is so crucial to the way that the Romans view their own history. They say this is such a big thing that happens to them, and Camillus is a part of that. Now, we’ve talked in the previous episode about the fact that people like Livy are writing much later. They’re building on a variety of sources. You know, family Chronicles, epic poetry, archeology, presumably like some remains and stuff that they see around and one of the things that they would probably have seen people like Livy. I mean, when I say they there’s a statue of Camillus that was erected and still around, I would say, in his time period. And Camillus actually becomes a really important figure for the way that the Romans think about themselves and what makes a virtuous citizen. You know his story has huge resonance throughout the ages. He’s someone who inspires later, people like the scipios, who we’ll hear about during war with Carthage, Sulla and even your favorite Dr G Augustus, yes. So
Dr G 13:18
Camillus ends up having this incredible reputation. That means that he has a type of fame that within Roman society is pretty rare. It’s ongoing. People refer back to him. He gains a whole bunch of prestigious kind of epithets that are associated with him. This is the start of his journey in some respects that we’re going to be looking at in this particular episode. And I think it’s going to be the culmination of his career as a whole, which I reckon we’ll we’ll do a wrap up episode where we we look at all of that in detail, because this is going to be part of his story, but not the whole of it. And this is the start of the sorts of things that will make his reputation. But it’s not like he gets off to like a fantastic start now, obviously it is an amazing thing to be made dictator. That doesn’t happen to most Roman politicians. There is only a select group of these people that end up in this role, and the idea of the dictator is really a product of need. So Rome has found itself in a desperate situation. They think that everything is looking terrible, and they turn to a single individual and say, can you take charge of everything? Carte blanche while you’re in power, look after this problem and solve it for us. And they choose Camillus in this moment. And it would be amazing if we knew what it was about Camillus that made him the preferred choice. And maybe Livy talks about this, but certainly none of my sources reveal that to me.
Dr Rad 14:57
I was going to say I’m so glad you asked.
Dr G 15:01
I’ve set you up so well, gonna give you
Dr Rad 15:03
a bit of foreshadowing here about Camillus, there is a bit of doubt about whether he actually existed
Dr G 15:10
or, Oh no, he’s
Dr Rad 15:13
one of those people. Look, I think a lot of people agree that he is a historical figure. However, like with a lot of things from this time period, including the fall of they he’s been so mythologized, and there have been so many layers added to him, including, again, by Augustus, the fact that Augustus is like, hey, who am I going to put in my gallery of heroes when I’m working on the forum of Augustus, I know. I’ll put Camillus in there. It’s hard to untangle all of those different layers, because we don’t see a clear emergence where the Romans are gradually adding things. So it’s really hard to know exactly who Camillus was, where he came from, but certainly the fall of they has become an important part of his great story as a citizen of Rome. I think I would say that in the scholarship, most people think that this particular part of his story, this fall of a part of his biography, is probably one of the earlier events that are attached to Camillus and his legend. So whether that makes you feel more secure or not, dear listeners, let us know.
Dr G 16:30
Can I tell you some of the things related to this incident that come up in the source material that I have so you can verify against what Livy might be telling us. So it seems that he becomes dictator. And I don’t have heaps of details about how that comes about, but I suspect it’s the usual way. And then he’s basically in charge of the siege of they and that that seems to be the main thing that he has to take care of. They’re like, solve that problem for us, buddy. Yeah, it’s only been 10 years that have been great to have a solution. And he’s like, Sure, I’m your man. And then I get a various sort of combination of things where he either deviates from that plan slightly and does some things with the Faliscans, or he remarkably
Dr Rad 17:18
Dirty.
Dr G 17:20
He does something for Faliscan. I don’t know if you’re into that sort of thing, but, uh, yeah, something’s going on there. And I can talk about a bit more of that detail later if it indeed fits in this year. And that’s the other thing that I’m struggling with with my source material, is I’m not sure what sits in what year for some of this stuff. But the other story that gets told about the siege of Veii is that he wraps it up quite quickly with a series of tunnels.
Dr Rad 17:44
How dare you ruin the end of my story. I’m sorry, Livy, you’re totally on path. I don’t have much information either about why Camillus is the one who’s chosen. However, lest we forget, Dr G he was one of the elected magistrates for this year, and he is from the Furii who have been very much a part of our narratives for the past 100 years. So one can only assume it’s because he is part of a fairly prominent, influential, powerful Roman Gens. I will say one thing I have noticed whilst reading about Camillus, and made me reflect, because, as I say, he is held up as this Roman general par excellence. He is the fatalis Dux, the fateful leader, the one who comes when Rome needs it the most and turns things around in a really spectacular fashion. It made me realize that, like with movies, often the good guys are more boring than the villains. I mean, look with Roman history, as we talked about, because certain families are thought to have certain character traits. Sometimes it just feels like you’re meeting the same person again and again, because they seem to be very similar to each other if they’re from the same family, like with the happiest Claudius of the world that we have met, but there’s still something kind of fantastic about how evil those sorts of people are in our minds, by our standards, whereas someone like Camillus, I don’t get a strong sense of his character. And maybe this is because he’s been a little bit mythologized. Hmm, maybe it’s also because the Roman virtues for someone to be considered an exemplar, because Camillus definitely becomes an exemplar. So that’s where the Romans tell a story about a person and hold it up so that other Romans can learn from their example about how to behave politically, how to behave as a citizen, how to behave militarily, because that’s part of their whole idea of citizenship. And being a good Roman, Camillus is definitely one of those. And it’s been a little while since I feel like we’ve had one of these figures who is an exemplar for others to follow well,
Dr G 19:48
but it’s not like he is a clean, straight laced exemplar that you can just hold up and be like, Look at this heroic figure who does everything right, because he seems to get. Whole bunch of things wrong.
Dr Rad 20:01
Well, does he or did the Romans get it wrong and then they felt really bad about it? No, wait
Dr G 20:05
for it. I mean, I I assume that Livy would have this story about Camillus. But part of the problem for Camillus with the siege of they and however he takes it and the complexities of this tunnel system are outside of my source material, but I’m excited that they’re there, because I always think tunnels are highly unlikely in the ancient world as a system. But you know, how long does it take you to dig a tunnel? I don’t know. And how many tunnels did you have? I don’t know. Have they been working on them for nine years? And it’s just that Camillus finished the tunnels. I don’t know that could be believable, but there is this story that is also told in companion with this story about how great he is, and how he is this sort of exemplary leader, where he seems to have a bit of a mixed relationship with the gods.
Dr Rad 21:02
Should we save that for later in his story? I
Dr G 21:06
don’t know. I mean,
Dr Rad 21:09
look, I tell you what I’m gonna say, let’s save it, because I think I know what you’re going, where you’re gonna go, and that’s like the end of the narrative that Livy gives me. Oh, you reckon okay. I reckon so. I reckon so. Look, I do think I know what you mean, and I’ll just say at this point in time that, yeah, you’re right. But Roman examples, I don’t think have to be perfect. It’s more that, I suppose it’s more that they are thought to teach something important in at least the majority of their life. And look, I think his failings also say something that’s important too. It’s not that they can’t make mistakes. To me, they tend to be a little bit robotic, almost in the way that they behave. But anyway, we will see. So we have our dictator Camillus, who we will go into later. We also obviously need a master of the horse, every dictator’s assistant,
Dr G 21:58
Yeah, gotta have somebody to do the paperwork. I mean, exactly.
Dr Rad 22:02
Can’t expect the dictator to do it. He’s got way too much to do. We’ve got Publius Cornelius Scipio. Now this is a name that might ring some bells to people. So the scipiones come from the malukinensis, that horrible name that we hate to say. And he is actually listed in the Fasti as Publius Cornelius Maluginenses. Now, what does that say to you? Dr G,
Dr G 22:28
that says to me that the scipios are trying to borrow his story from later on. Yeah, they decided they wanted to hop on that bandwagon. There might be two branches of that family. And yeah, I’m not, I’m not sure. But I mean, the Cornelii are a very exceptional, well known foundational partition family as well. So yeah, the layers of the way that these families will then branch out is going to become important to understanding how Roman political structures operate, because it the family thing is huge. So, yeah,
Dr Rad 23:01
look, it’s not impossible that there is somebody from this family at this point in time which will become a very big deal. But we don’t have someone that we feel super confident about from this family until the 350
Dr G 23:17
I was gonna say, I feel like, yeah, it’s too early for scipiones. This
Dr Rad 23:21
is the general feeling, but nonetheless, here they are again, potentially showing us that the analysts or Livy are using sources from this family, and that’s how they end up in earlier periods than they perhaps should be. How convenient? Yes, with the dictator, chosen master of the horse, chosen Rome, apparently, like they’ve had a makeover. They’re feeling wildly optimistic. All of a sudden, their morale is through the roof. I mean, Rome is just literally bursting with possibility at this moment in time. Dr, G, it’s
Dr G 23:56
a quick turnaround. It’s the like the highs and the lows. Rome is having a very emotional roller coaster ride right now. They’ve they’ve had that huge dip where they’re like, the ambush and the tragedy, and now they’re like, and now we’ve got the best guy in as dictator, and it’s going to be great. I
Dr Rad 24:12
love the way that the Romans work. Now the first thing that Camillus does as dictator is he decides he needs to dish out punishment for anyone who ran away from the encampment at they during all that horrible panic. Oh, no, yeah. He’s like, you found that scary? You found the Falsicans and the Capenates coming at you scary. I’ll show you scary, my friends. So he deals with that situation because he can’t have cowards, right? Certainly not involved in a siege. Can’t have that, Okay, fair enough. He also needs to set a levy. Gonna need some troops, obviously. So he sets a levy. He then rushes out to they, because He wants to spread that optimism to the encampment in front of they. Then he’s back to Rome. Him for the levy, which he had set before he left. He’s just zipping all over the place. And because Camillus is so amazing, there are no problems at all with this Levy. In fact, everyone is super keen to get in line and serve Camillus. I was
Dr G 25:15
gonna say this is why they made him dictator, because obviously he’s charismatic, and it’s like, it’s hard to resist. And you’re like, sign me up if I have to die, I want to die under Camillus, exactly
Dr Rad 25:27
what the Romans are feeling at that point in time. In fact, not just the Romans. Dr G, the Latins and the Hernicians, who you alluded to earlier, also said, Rome, we’re totally behind you in this my friend, Sign me up. What a man and Camillus gives official thanks to their allies in the Senate. He’s like, thanks very much, guys. Presumably this means that there were envoys who had been sent from the Latins and hanisians who made some sort of official presentation. Got my slideshow here. Sorry, the PowerPoints just on the on the fritz. Just wait one second. So
Dr G 26:02
this is the location of Veii. This is Rome. And as you can see, we just down here. And so what we’re going to do is we’re going to send some of our men up to Rome, and then they’re going to join with Rome, and then they’re all going to move north, you see, and that’s how we’re going to do it.
Dr Rad 26:16
Bob’s your uncle, mate, sweet as. Camillus’ also makes some large promises. Dr G he says that there will be great games, not just games, great games celebrated if they is taken, and this is apparently in pursuance of a senatorial decree, which seems anachronistic, because we don’t think the Senate issued senatorial decrees at this moment in time. But let’s ignore that and pursue our narrative. He also says that he will restore and rededicate the Temple of Mater Matuta, which had been originally set up by my favorite King Servius Tullius. Yes,
Dr G 26:58
yes. Now this does come up in some of my source material as well. So this also is Plutarch, who also insists that the master of the horse is Cornelius Scipio, which I did nothing with in my notes originally, because I was like, yeah, that’s not a thing. But now that you’ve mentioned it, I can, I can confirm that that is an idea that continues. But yes, this idea that there will be a dedication to the Goddess mata matuta and the great games is something that Plutarch definitely goes into. And Mater Matuta herself is a pretty ancient kind of deity. So she’s known in Italy. She’s known in Rome. And the matuta name has a couple of different meanings, the idea of in the right moment. So she’s the mother of the right moment. This is also translated as the good mother. And so there’s this sense in which she is also has bears resemblance to later Christian figures as well. So she’s often depicted holding a child with a solar disc around her head. And might be giving some people some imagery. How
Dr Rad 28:11
suspicious,
Dr G 28:13
and we know that she has an archeological record that goes back to at least the seventh century BC. So there’s some votive offerings that are found in Latium that are connected to her. Hers is one of the oldest temples that we know about archeologically in Rome as well. So her temple is right near the forum boarium, which, if you’ve been to Rome, or you plan to go, is right across the road from where you’ve got the guy that you can put your hand in the Mouth of Truth, the Mouth of Truth just across the road. And there’s a very impressive circular temple there that you can see that’s to Hercules Victor, which is a much later temple. But below that there are some foundations for a temple to mata matuda, so she’s considered quite ancient, even within the archeological record of Rome. So for Camillus to heart, back to her, there is some good evidence to suggest that that’s not a crazy thing to do, that she is a goddess that the Romans are already very interested in and have been interested in for a long time. And maybe this is a moment of potential renewal for her cult, which is kind of exciting.
Dr Rad 29:25
Of course, it’s not crazy. It’s Camillus that we’re talking about here. He’s going to do everything to inspire the Romans and make sure that they get this amazing victory, which is right there, Dr G, right
Dr G 29:40
so close, so close, we can almost see it. We
Dr Rad 29:43
can almost see it. So Camillus and his army, freshly gathered, march out. They fight those darn Faliscans and Capenates in the country of the Nepesine, which I believe refers to the town of Nepi which. If you were going to Italy nowadays, would be known as nepi and as you might expect, is to the north of Rome. Everything’s to the north of Rome at moment.
Dr G 30:10
I mean that. I mean that, obviously this is their big deal at the moment, everything to the north.
Dr Rad 30:16
So as you would expect, Camillus is very prepared. He has thought things through, unlike titanius and gaucius from the previous year. And so everything goes to plan. The Romans completely trounce the enemy. They take their camp. They take loads of booty. And I can’t emphasize enough loads of booty. How
Dr G 30:40
big is the booty? A lot.
Dr Rad 30:42
Yes, exactly. It’s very, very impressive. Most of it is given to the quaestor, though not directly to the soldiers. That’s going to become an important detail later. I think remember
Dr G 30:55
this detail, the quaestor has all the booty
Dr Rad 30:59
they’re off to find ve itself, and this is where they start to take a different approach, because Camillus is a genius. So previously, because it was a siege, you’ve got men on both sides, and they’re constantly engaging in minor skirmishes. 10 years of minor skirmishes. Oh god, yeah, I’m gonna throw this at you, and you’re gonna throw a stick at me, and I might throw something sharp and pointy, and
Dr G 31:29
your mother smells of elderberries.
Dr Rad 31:31
Yeah. I don’t know what a skirmish looks like in a siege, but you know, particularly between the town walls, where the Romans have set up this. Okay, that’s obviously where the action has been concentrated for the past 10 years, but we can all say it’s not really going anywhere fast. So Camillus says to the people who are assembled there, no one is to fight unless I personally give you a specific order that you are allowed to fight. So no fighting whatsoever. I don’t care what names they call you. I don’t care if they’re giving you the stink eye. I don’t care if they spit in your general direction. Not happening.
Dr G 32:08
All right, so if the population of they were to decide to make an attack under these circumstances, are the Romans just to lie down and let it happen to them?
Dr Rad 32:20
Look, these are questions I don’t have time for. Look, I presume if they were attacked, obviously, that would be a different story. But he means no more skirmishing. Just lay low. You don’t need to fight. Just walk away. Just walk away.
Dr G 32:35
Don’t think you’re in charge of this siege. And start your own skirmishes because you’re feeling in a bad
Dr Rad 32:40
mood. Instead, it’s time to dig, send down 30 feet of rope. Now this is what is where we come back to what you were talking about, the tunnels. The plan is they’re going to dig a mine that will take them right to the Citadel of they and for those of you who don’t watch enough fantasy stuff, or aren’t into ancient warfare, when we’re talking about the Citadel, we’re talking about the heart of they also
Dr G 33:08
don’t think too hard about this from a geographic perspective, because the city of they, as we know, is sitting on a plateau of tufa. So it’s going to take some time to hack away at the sheer rock that this city is sitting on to create a whole series of tunnels.
Dr Rad 33:26
Camillus is way ahead of you. Dr G, he has a plan. Okay? He knows that in order to get through this as quickly as possible, he needs someone to be digging at all times. So he splits the men into six groups, and each group has to work for six hours at a time, and then they rotate. So that way the digging is happening day and night, night and day.
Dr G 33:52
This is a Okay. So we’ve got a workforce that is operating 24/7, for however long it takes to cut through all of that rock. Yep, cool.
Dr Rad 34:05
And now this is an interesting point, because we’ve been talking a lot about tunnels when it comes to things connected with Veii. So obviously we’ve talked about the tunnel that was built in order to drain the excess water from the Alban Lake, which apparently needed to happen in order for the Romans to secure victory against Veii, and that would be the moment when they became vulnerable, the vulnerable Veieans, that’s right. Yep. We also, lest we forget, Dr G had a tunnel mentioned in a previous conflict with Veii when Fidenae was the bone of contention back in the 430s or the 420s who knew when that was taking place? But definitely earlier than this. I
Dr G 34:49
think the thing to keep in mind here is that once Livy has introduced the idea of tunnels into his narrative, it’s just going to keep going. So. Once we have this concept of tunnels being used for military purposes, everybody gets excited, and now you can use them all the time. It seems challenging. Like Veii is a city that is sitting in a reasonably hilly area. It is a volcanic area. It gets its water not just from the nearby river, but also from the spring systems, which are endemic in this region of Italy because of the volcanic activity. So there is a lot of natural sort of water courses that are happening underground. You could follow some of them potentially and open them up more. That might be a way to build some tunnels, but it does seem like a tricky business. I’m not saying that the Romans aren’t capable of it, but I do have some questions, and I’m not sure that we’ve seen archeologically that there’s any evidence for tunnels underneath they although I’m happy to stand corrected, please atroccologists, get in touch with us and help us out with this thorny question of the siege of Veiiand the tunnels that are apparently associated
Dr Rad 36:04
with it. Well, I can’t class myself as an Etruscanologist. However, it is possible, as you’ve said, that this seems to be part of the narrative in multiple ways. And we know that there is actually some sort of tunnel with the Alban Lake situation. So there is some proof there. It’s possible that, obviously this became an older part of the story, that people like the analysts and then Livy had to weave the narrative around it and incorporate it somehow. It is an entirely out of the question, because we know that the Greeks did use siege mines. So for example, there is one used at the siege of platea by the plateans. So that does happen. We do also know that there are these things, these cuniculi, which are drainage tunnels, which are found throughout the landscape in this area. It is possible that rather than, say, digging it, which, as you say, might be tough, maybe the Romans found a drainage tunnel that had been blocked up or closed off, and they just emptied it, and that’s what they were doing. However you are quite right. I believe that at the moment, we haven’t found one where you might expect to find one. So there definitely are some questions about this, but I don’t want to discredit Camillus, because the Romans certainly think he is the ants pants.
Dr G 37:32
Yes, I was going to
Dr Rad 37:34
say the bee’s knees. Yeah, as you say, it’s all very quickly turned around. You know, Camillus can tell that victory is near because of his genius digging program. They’re digging for victory.
Dr G 37:48
They’re digging, yeah,
Dr Rad 37:51
and he knows that he is getting very close to being able to seize they. And he also understands just what this will mean for Rome. This is such a big deal. They is really their only big competitor in this region, as we’ve talked about, in spite of the political reasons that we’re given for this conflict, there’s an awful lot of other stuff at stake here too. So Camillus knows that this is going to be really, really big. In fact, he’s expecting that there will be more booty in the capture of a wealthy Etruscan city like they then. The Romans have perhaps ever captured before, if you put everything that they’ve done all together,
Dr G 38:25
especially considering they’re often like just exchanging booty and finding refining their sandals that they lost last time, this would be a chance to actually acquire new stuff.
Dr Rad 38:35
I’m telling you, you know, laundry markers could have changed everything for them. Now, thinking ahead, because Camillus is a planner, as we know. He’s no titanius organucius. He’s worried about, what is he gonna do with all this booty? What are you gonna do with all that junk, all that junk inside your trunk?
Dr G 38:54
That’s a good question. What is he gonna do? Well,
Dr Rad 38:57
he understands that the soldiers might turn against him if he’s not seen as being generous enough to them with this booty. So there’s obviously an expectation that, given that they have put aside their weekend plans to help him conquer they there is an expectation that they will be rewarded for their efforts. However, the Senate might be angry if he’s too generous to the average soldier. Now I should say Livy actually says the fathers, but as we know, he uses these terms very interchangeably, so I’m presuming he means the Senate, because he immediately writes to the Senate and says, Look, victory is getting near. It’s going to be amazing. What should I do with all the stuff that I’m about to capture so brilliantly? The Senate had different opinions, and this is where we get into my favorite part of this narrative. We go back to our friend old puble. Licinius calvis, Oh, Mr. Moderate himself, all right, Mr. Moderate himself, who was apparently too old to be magistrate, and yet his son says to him, Dad, I want you to take the floor. Hmm, why would this happen? You ask good question. Dr, G, there is absolutely no reason why this would happen. It would be extremely odd for someone who is not a magistrate and a plebeian to boot, randomly be asked to be the first to speak on such an important matter over all the patrician senators who apparently are staring daggers at him right now. Why is he considered so senior in the Roman state right now that after being the first plebeian military Tribune with consular power, after coming out of nowhere in 400 all of a sudden, four years later, he gets elected without running for office when he doesn’t want to do it. He’s like, Oh, take my son. And everyone’s like, Yeah, cool. And then in a moment of great, important public debate, and his son’s like, Dad, I want to hear from you. Everyone’s totally fine with this look. I
Dr G 41:12
think I am incredulous, and I hear the incredulity in your voice as well. So I think we’re on a similar sort of emotional wavelength here. But I also wonder about the nature of what characterizes the Senate, because this is true. Age is definitely a huge factor. Of considerable years
Dr Rad 41:36
old and his memory’s going asides going exactly
Dr G 41:38
this is guy’s bit deaf, having trouble seeing doesn’t seem like he’s up to the gig. Is old enough that he feels like he should nominate his son to do most of the work. But when push comes to shove, his son is like, actually, I think my dad needs to take the floor and have something to say. There is a very conservative tradition amongst the senators about who gets to speak and when. Sure, and we know a lot of that from later periods of history, not so much this period. But if this group of fathers, which for so long we just assumed was all patrician, but as it has turned out now, seems to have always had at least one Levy.
Dr Rad 42:23
It’s this guy and his family the whole time, the
Dr G 42:28
whole time, maybe they’ve been there for a while. So he may actually be in a position of quite seniority within the context of the Senate itself, and often asking the oldest to speak first is less about monetary capacity or other ways that you might measure somebody’s worth within the context of Roman society, and is actually that idea of the fathers and the wisdom that comes from your elders. And potentially, this is what’s going on for calvis In this moment, where they’re like, he is really old. Maybe he’s got something to say.
Dr Rad 43:08
Look, I hear what you’re saying. I totally get it. You’re right. He is very elderly. But the idea that there aren’t equally old patricians who I mean, think about all the times we read out the list of magistrates and we’re like, oh yeah, this guy’s had about eight. You know, I just find it hard to believe that the one military tribuneship With consular power that he’s held somehow makes him outrank everyone else. Just considering that we had not heard of this guy up until a few episodes ago. It just seems so funny. And again, it kind of indicates that Livy must be leaning on Licinius Macer or Macer, depending on your preference, as a source who wrote about his family’s achievements when he was writing his work. So I just kind of feel like that maybe has something to do with it. On top of which, as we said last time, most of our sources, apart from Livy, agree that the dad is the one who’s the magistrate. So this would indicate that if he’s the one who’s speaking first, he’s speaking, because he’s an old magistrate in power. That would make sense this whole idea that his son held the office in his place. And then thought, You know what, this is my moment to shine, but Dad, you take the floor.
Dr G 44:27
Look. I could still believe that. To be honest, the idea is not so much that Calvus is not the preferred candidate in flavor of his son. He’s delegated some of the job to his son. He may still very well be the magistrate, and even if he’s not, and technically, his son is fulfilling the role. Everybody knows that it was Calvus The elder that people wanted in the position, so they’re still going to defer to him, because he’s got all of the cache. That has been built up through everything else. We’re missing the incidents that’s Yeah,
Dr Rad 45:07
totally. Anyway. Look, there are some questions. There are some questions clearly, but we will proceed.
Dr G 45:12
And like many things, we do not have the answers. So
Dr Rad 45:17
Licinius Calvus Senior, he stands up and he says there should be a public proclamation issued where anyone who wants some of the spoils that are going to come from, they need to get up and go to the camp at Vay right now. That’s the way you stake your claim. You get up and you go, wow. Strange system. But okay, I guess it dips. It’s basically ancient Roman. Dibs.
Dr G 45:42
We are not carrying it back for you. You won’t have to go yourself
Dr Rad 45:47
too much stuff. It’s a wealthy city like come on, guys, unreasonable. Now our old friend Appius Claudius is now going to take the floor in opposition to Calvus. For those of you who haven’t listened to the past million episodes that we’ve released, appias Claudius, the Appii Claudii, they’re known for being Uber patricians, very conservative. So no shock that this particular Appius Claudius thinks that this is an outrageous suggestion, far too generous, not at all fair. In fact, indicates that this dude is too old. He’s gone crazy, lost his marbles. No. Thank you.
Dr G 46:25
This is a bullock suggestion. Yeah.
Dr Rad 46:27
Now, you know, I hate to side with someone from this family with my natural leftist leanings. However, once again, there is a little bit of sense to what he says, If we believe this whole narrative, which is that Rome has been going through a lot of warfare lately. In case no one’s noticed there’s a siege going on, that’s kind of why we’re having this conversation. The Treasury is drained because of all this conflict. They should instead use whatever booty comes from the capture of a to pay the soldiers once again. Dr G, they the siege of a it all comes back to this question of military pay. Okay,
Dr G 47:09
well, that would make more sense in many respects, absolutely, let’s pay the people who have done the job.
Dr Rad 47:15
On top of which he actually points out that this would be of benefit to the plebs, because, whilst they’re not getting the booty in their pocket immediately, it would mean that less war tax is required to fund military pay, which apparently is something else that exists at the moment, and we’ve had discussions about the reality of that, but I’m not going to get into it again. So everyone would benefit in one way or another, if they just were sensible and put the booty in the bank.
Dr G 47:45
All right. Well, okay, so that means somebody’s definitely going to have to carry it from they to Rome, because how did it? Can’t just stay in Veii. That’s not how gaining wealth works. It’s all based on the physical stuff you’ve you’ve got to move it.
Dr Rad 48:00
Look, I hear your practical sense coming through. Miss Virgo, but I don’t think that this is what Appius Claudius is most worried about. His big concern is that lazy city slicker types are going to swoop in and take the rewards won by others and the real fighters, the real heroes, Dr G the men who’ve been on the front lines would miss out. So this is another very important point that he makes, that noble fighters from Rome always are the least greedy, and therefore they’re going to miss out if the Romans don’t take some sensible steps here. Wow.
Dr G 48:41
This is just a moment where Rome is like, we’re about to be more successful than we’ve ever been, and we do not know how to handle that.
Dr Rad 48:50
Oh, yeah, absolutely. It’s their lottery day, and they’re like, oh my god, we’re gonna be millionaires. What do we do? A new house. We put in a pool.
Dr G 48:57
I need a financial planner. They haven’t even won yet. They’re getting well ahead of themselves. It’s
Dr Rad 49:04
a shoe in Dr G. I mean, this is the funny thing, right? After a 10 year siege, I love the fact that everyone keeps saying, Oh, they’re trying to build it up to be like the Trojan War. Like this is nothing like the Trojan War in the sense that it seems like a foregone conclusion at this point in time. We all know it’s really hard to tell the story of the siege of a without giving away the ending, because we all know where it’s going, because they knew before it happened that it was going to happen. But anyway, now Livy is doing his thing here, where he has very contrasting speakers. You know, Calvus, obviously, is our vanilla bean plebeian, very moderate. Appius Claudius, once again, going in hard like his family always does, being able to play the plebeians like a fiddle and the patricians, to be fair, everybody loves a good speech from one of the Appian Claudius. However, Licinius comes back. Licunius Calvus comes back with another attack. He’s. Says, Look, this money is going to cause huge problems. Let’s be honest, the plebeians are going to arc up if we don’t look after them, and it’s going to lead to them making outrageous demands, like laws that might be to their benefit outrageous. Why not take this moment to get the plebs on side by being very generous. They are extremely tired. We can all see that they’ve been very cranky every morning. They’re not in a good mood. They’re teary all the time.
Dr G 50:32
10 years of a siege will do that to you? Yeah.
Dr Rad 50:36
They’re also broke, after so many years of having to pay this apparent war tax, which obviously is paid by everybody. It’s not just something that’s peculiar to the plebeians. However, obviously it’s toughest for the poorer people who are apparently the plebeians, at this moment in time to pay this particular war tax. It would mean so much to them as well, in a symbolic sort of way, if they were able to take something from the enemy rather than have decisions made for them and then be divvied up to them, is some form of payout or some sort of benefit, it would mean more to take it with their own hands, to be like, Aha, I’m taking this vase, and I don’t care What you have to say about it, person from Veii, you’re my enemy. The Senate would also come away from this looking like the coolest dudes. They’d be Mr. Popular all over the place, and we could all use a little bit of that.
Dr G 51:38
Goodness me, what a time to be alive as a Roman watching.
Dr Rad 51:44
I feel like I have to tell you where this debate ends up.
Dr G 51:47
Please do. I mean, I have some details, but I’m just not even sure where they fit at this point in time. So I’m really waiting for the end of this debate so I can figure out what to tell
Dr Rad 51:55
you next. I told you, this is a long 396, it’s a big year. Yeah, it’s amazing. I’m enjoying it. In the end, they go with Licinius, and a public proclamation is made that if you want a payout, you need to go to they and get it yourself. Oh, boy,
Dr G 52:12
after Appius Claudius was so reasonable and everything
Dr Rad 52:14
I know. Look, I have to admit, there is something annoyingly pragmatic about what he says, and that was the case the last time we had a big speech from somebody from this family. I can’t actually remember if it was the same guy. It probably was. Wasn’t that long ago. So lots of Romans do indeed hit the road and go to the camp because they want to get their pair out.
Dr G 52:35
I want my booty. They open the walls.
Dr Rad 52:39
Now, I know we are getting to a bit of a long point with this episode, but we’re so close to they actually falling I feel like I have to take you there. Dr G, take me there. I’m ready. So in the camp Camillus Is there, like a good general and a good Roman, he takes the auspices to make sure that everything is in their favor now. Dr G, do you want to tell us a bit about why he’d be doing this. What are the auspices?
Dr G 53:01
Well, it’s very important you can’t undertake any military action without consulting the gods first. So the auspices is when you look at the patterns of bird movements, generally speaking. So if you have been in Europe, you will have probably been lucky enough at some point to see a muration of starlings. For instance, the patterns that these birds make when they move around the sky can be incredible. Now, it’s not just starlings that you might be interested in. It could be eagles. It could be vultures, whatever’s out there, but reading and interpreting those signs gives you an indication of maybe how the gods are feeling whether it’s a good time to do a bit of an attack where it’s time to open up those tunnels and burst out of your Trojan tunnels, slash horse, is it time? Nobody knows. So consulting the birds can really help with something like that. So Camillus undertaking that duty, it does make sense. As a dictator, there is a sense in which there is a religious element to the role, and he could be very well in charge of looking after that side of things as well. So he may have some people on hand to help with the interpretation, but definitely he would be allowed to lead something like that, and it would be important for him to do so in the eyes of everybody from the Roman side, to make sure that everything is okay for going ahead with whatever happens next.
Dr Rad 54:29
Well, he clearly got the green light from the birds, and so he goes out, prepares the soldiers. He also chooses this moment to make a vow. Now, I know you’re going to want to jump in on this, but I’m I’m just going to tell the narrative and then we can unpack it later. So he makes a vow that he was led by Pythian Apollo. So probably because of the connection the Romans have had in recent years with this whole siege the lake Delphi. And with this God on his side, he is going to be able to conquer they and as a token of his appreciation, he is going to send Apollo the most gigantic box of Lindt chocolates. No, I’m just kidding. He’s going to send a tithe of whatever spoils he captures to Apollo. He also asks Juno, a very important goddess in ve to switch sides and come and live in Rome once they have totally trashed the city where she currently is hanging out. And he promises he would set up a really lovely temple with a white picket fence and a slide in the backyard, if she would agree to come over.
Dr G 55:44
He’s like, hey, girlfriend, you want to come over to my place? Forget these guys.
Dr Rad 55:49
Yeah. Now there’s a moment that we’re going to have to talk about with that later, but for now, I’m going to proceed. So Camillus now makes his advance against fair that much anticipated moment. He’s many soldiers on his side, because the Romans could not be more enthusiastic about this. And they attack. They on every side. However, this is not the key to victory. Dr G, this is a mere distraction from the real attack, which is, of course, through the tunnels. That’s right, we’ve seen the Romans do this many times, where they have a distraction and then the real thing going on elsewhere. This is a popular military tactic. Now the people of they did not know that the odds are totally stacked against them at this point in time. Of course, we know that there’s been an old soothsayer from they who’s totally betrayed his people by telling the Romans everything, maybe under torture, to be fair, but they don’t know that. They don’t know all the stuff that the Romans know at this point in time. They don’t know that the Delphic Oracle has said that they is going to fall. They don’t know that the gods had been made these promises if they switched sides and desert them so they have no idea of what is coming. They also have no idea about the mine. Apparently, all that digging was incredibly quiet. They had silences on their pickaxes. So they just do what they would normally do. They run to the ramparts. They’ve got their weapons. They’re wondering why? All of a sudden, after being pretty Quiet on the Western Front for a while, No, I shouldn’t say that pretty quiet on the Northern Front for a while, the Romans are being incredibly energetic in their attack. They’re like, Oh, what is going on? That’s been very, very tame, and now all of a sudden it’s like, they’re mad men, and we’re being attacked on all sides, what is going on. Now, I do love this next part, because Livy tells me specifically, and I quote my translation at this point, men introduce a tale. For those of you who love historiography, this is history being made before our eyes. People, this is Livy telling me that he doesn’t believe this story for a second, but he’s going to include it anyway, because it’s become a part of the folklore of the fall of they, and that is that the king of they, the douchebag that barely started all of this, just because he wasn’t very well liked, was making a sacrifice. Now, the Romans in the mine have dug so deeply into they that they can actually hear what is going on, because they haven’t broken through the wall yet. But you know, they can hear it. They hear the soothsayer that is with the king say that whoever cut up the innards of the animal that he’s about to sacrifice would win this war between Rome and they. So they instantly seize their mermaid. They’re like now, go, go, go, go, go, go, go. They break through the wall, they grab the entrails, they race back through the mine, and they present Camillus with the entrails so that he can be the person who cuts them and wins the war. Sounds tasty and not at all slippery. I know delightful, just the kind of thing you want to hear before a meal. However, Livy knows he’s talking about something that happened a really long time ago, and I love what he says about it. He says this story more fit to be displayed on the stage that delights in wonders than to be believed. It is worthwhile neither to affirm nor to refute. He’s like, You know what this is for the movies. I’m not even gonna talk about it. It’s not worth my time. What
Dr G 59:31
a tricky moment in Roman history, bursting in on a sacrifice. And, yeah, you know, stealing the entrails.
Dr Rad 59:41
You can see why. You know, I said in the previous episode that this part of Livy, where he’s talking about the fall of Veii is often something that people like to capture. This is where I think you can get that sort of cinematic feeling from Livy, even he knows it. Let’s get back to reality in the mind filled with soldiers and all of us. Sudden, they break through into the temple of Juno, which was on the Citadel of a which was their target point. So all of a sudden they are attacking some of the people from they from behind. You know, they’re not expecting this. Obviously, they had no idea that the mind was there. Even though the Romans can hear them, they can’t hear the Romans naturally intriguing others. Others race off to break down the gates. Women and slaves inside, they are apparently throwing stones and tiles at the Romans from the roof, and some of the Romans then retaliate by attacking them with fire. Interesting little detail there. We do know some things about roof tiles. They are often thrown.
Dr G 1:00:41
They can be deadly. Yeah, those things are
Dr Rad 1:00:44
heavy. The horrific sound of war fills the air. Women are screaming, children are crying, men are shouting. It did not take long for soldiers to be thrown over the walls of their city and the gates of they to be opened. The Romans are able to storm this enemy city. Battle is taking place literally everywhere. It’s
Dr G 1:01:14
happening in the streets. Now, the weakness of the tunnel coming from within, it’s not looking good for they
Dr Rad 1:01:21
and so Veii is taken. Dr G, it falls, just like we knew it always would, thanks to that trait of this there and the lake and the Delphic Oracle. And as it all starts to wind down, because the Romans have secured their victory, Camillus has his heralds proclaim that anyone without weapons will be spared, because, being an all round nice guy, he wants to prevent a lot of unnecessary killing from taking place. So those without weapons handed themselves over. The Romans, however, now turn their eye to the really important part of this mission, and that is booty, and that might be a good place, I think, to pause, because they has now fallen, but there’s a whole lot of stuff that we’re going to need to unpack about that next episode, I think. And as we get into the question of booty,
Dr G 1:02:18
yes, I think so. Now, one of the things that is common in the sources that I have is a prayer that Camillus makes to the god Jupiter, amongst others. And I’m not sure about where that happens in this timeline either, because it hasn’t come up in Livy’s account yet. So there is this one thing about Camillus journey this far as dictator and into the heart of they, which I think is worth mentioning because it’s going to start to have some consequences for him. And this is the moment where he offers a prayer to the gods, and in the moment of doing so, he makes some promises, like, I want this to all go really well. I’ll do whatever is needful to make sure that the gods are kept happy. I’m willing to accept personally any blame for stuff that doesn’t go well with this whole situation. So as dictator, and also fulfilling that kind of religious service function in this role, he’s really trying to make sure that everything gets pulled off really nicely. And the weird detail that continues to come up about this moment is that, as he’s doing this whole prayer thing and being like, let’s make this whole situation as great as possible. I’ll make this as good as I can. I’ll do whatever is needful. I’ll make the sacrifices. I’ll give you the things later, if as long as we can pull this off, God’s help me out. At the end of the prayer, he has a bit of a fall down. He has, yeah, he stumbles. So he has this moment where he’s like, I’m going to make this go as as well as I can be in right relationship with the gods. But the moment where he turns around, because apparently he’s veiled his head, which is a very traditional and appropriate Roman thing to do in this context of addressing the gods, to appear veiled as he turns around, slipping seems to be a pretty bad sign about how all of this is going to work out, either for Rome or for him, and I feel like that leaves us with another little bit of a cliffhanger, even though we seem to be in a really successful moment for Rome and its siege of a which seems to be in the midst of concluding now in a very successful way for the Romans. But this little religious stumble is perhaps going to be a problem for old mate Camillus. Yes.
Dr Rad 1:05:00
Now look, you are totally right in Livy’s account. It’s when he’s looking at all the booty that the Romans have just gathered after they’ve finished the fighting part of this evening’s entertainment, and he it’s just more than he could ever imagine. And that’s when he starts doing that thing where he gives thanks to the gods. And it is an interesting prayer, and it is one, I think, that repeats in Roman history. We might talk about that a bit again another day. But it’s certainly that idea that he says, Look, if any of the gods or any other men thought that he was being given too much good fortune and would get jealous of him, then he would personally sort that out and deal with that, hopefully without damaging his own prospects and life, and without any damage to Rome itself and the Roman people, which is a really weird thing to say, if you think about it, it’s not that. He’s not just saying thanks for the booty he’s making this really weird thing. And as you say in Livy’s account, he does fall over, which everybody sees as an omen, apparently. But I agree with you. I think it is more indicative of the fact that in Camillus’ life there are going to be some low lows as well as some high highs. Oh
Dr G 1:06:18
boy. Well, strap yourselves in. Listeners, Camillus, wild ride has only really just begun, it would seem, oh
Dr Rad 1:06:26
yes. And so, dr, G, I think it’s time for the partial pick.
Dr G 1:06:37
Okay, the partial pick? Well, Rome, let’s see how you stuck up against your own credentials. We have five categories of which they can earn up to 10 golden eagles in each one. So if Rome is being as Rome as it possibly could be, they could end up with 50 golden eagles. So let’s see how they go. Okay,
Dr Rad 1:07:00
so for this part of 396, military clout. Dr, G, what do you reckon? Wow.
Dr G 1:07:06
I mean, top notch military clout. I mean, they’re wiping the floor. They’re taking a whole city. It’s all going really well. There’s tunnels, there’s wall assaults. Everybody’s having a great time. People sign up willingly to the levy.
Dr Rad 1:07:21
Going, great, go to the plebs. Insight,
Dr G 1:07:25
it’s basically as good as it could be. Yeah, I feel like, you know we’re we’re nine or 10 territory here. I think
Dr Rad 1:07:31
so too, because, you know, it’s not just they obviously remember, Camillus has dealt with the Faliscans and Capenates with zero trouble. I mean, so little trouble. We don’t even get an account of what exactly happened. We just get told that it’s done dusted. Well,
Dr G 1:07:44
I might be able to tell you some more details about what happened, at least with the Philistines next episode. Oh, yeah.
Dr Rad 1:07:50
No, that. We’ll get to some stuff about them. But I mean, the the initial, the initial, putting them in their place, that’s just effortless, done
Dr G 1:07:57
and dusted. Yeah, yeah. Military clout, 10 out of 10. Golden Eggs.
Dr Rad 1:08:03
Remember the last time we did that? In fact, I don’t know if we’ve
Dr G 1:08:06
ever given a 10. Yeah, this is impressive stuff. The second category is diplomacy.
Dr Rad 1:08:13
Okay? I feel like this is not as good. I mean, we do have the Latins and Hernicians coming to Rome and saying, Whatever you do Rome, we’re there for you. And Camillus being like, Thanks, guys. I tip my hat to you. I tip my laurel wreath,
Dr G 1:08:31
yes, but it’s not at all clear that the Romans necessarily went out of their way to source that support in this particular instance, or whether the Latins and hanushe came to Roma, were like, Well, looks like you could use some help. Or, you know, so it’s not the details of it is not clear. So the idea, the central question here is, how much negotiation is being employed by the Romans in order to reach their goals? And since I’m not sure about that, but they do have some help, so we have to assume there’s some negotiation, even though we don’t know what it was. Then maybe we’re looking at like a four or five.
Dr Rad 1:09:11
Oh, wow. That’s way more than I was going for. I was gonna give them like a two.
Dr G 1:09:16
I’m clearly having a good day where I’m being very generous.
Dr Rad 1:09:20
You know what? You’ve been infected by Camillus spirit, just like the Romans were. You’re feeling wildly optimistic. I am being way too generous.
Dr G 1:09:29
Well, how about a three then, okay, three, it is expansion. Yes.
Dr Rad 1:09:35
I mean, this is a really big deal. We will talk about this, I’m sure, multiple times. But just to give the listeners some sort of perspective, dr, G, now that they falls under Roman control and remains there, estimates vary a little bit, but we’re thinking that this basically doubles the territory of Rome, maybe even more than double, maybe adds like another. 60% to what they currently possess. It’s a really, really big deal. They is a very prosperous Etruscan city.
Dr G 1:10:07
This is a massive moment. So yeah, if you think about it on just a scalable level, like Rome, is nothing like this sort of Imperial Rome that you see in popular film and things like that. This is a small city state that controls adjacent areas that are local to the city, and that’s true for all of their neighbors as well. So Veii is its own city state, and they have more of a connection to a true area than they do to the Latins or the Romans or anybody like that. So this is effectively doubling, if not more, as you say, the capacity of Rome in terms of what they control, because they’ve now taken a whole major other city, yes. So this is huge, off the charts, massive in terms of expansion,
Dr Rad 1:10:59
yeah, and an Etruscan one at that. I mean, come on, we know that taking land is obviously going to mean a lot for the Romans, because we’ve had these ongoing issues of debt, and we’ve had questions about public land, which, look, they’re probably anachronistic, but they’re being raised so in the narrative that we’re dealing with, this would definitely be a big deal. Plus, as you highlighted in the previous episode, its resources, its influence in the area. I mean, they don’t really now have another major rival in this Tiber Valley area. Yeah,
Dr G 1:11:33
Yeah, it’s pretty impressive. So in terms of expansion, I think we’re also looking at a nine or a 10.
Dr Rad 1:11:40
Let’s give them a nine. I think.
Dr G 1:11:45
Are they ever going to expand as much, percentage wise, upon themselves as they I was
Dr Rad 1:11:50
gonna say yeah, there are Yeah. There are some other victories and expansions that are obviously going to be very important. But in terms of percentage, I feel like this is a big one. This is huge, okay, so maybe 10, yes, proportionally, it’s all proportional. Rome, don’t get too
Dr G 1:12:07
my Camillus enthusiasm continues, indeed, all right, that leads us to the category of virtus. Ooh.
Dr Rad 1:12:18
This is a bit of a tricky one, because Camillus is obviously a very impressive, important figure, as the Romans think of him. But would you say we’ve really seen an act of virtus? Dr, G, no, yeah, I don’t think so either, not in this moment I think comes later in his career.
Dr G 1:12:38
Yeah, it’s not like so for Camillus to be participating in, like a classic virtus moment, we’d expect things, something like leading from the front, so him actually popping out of the tunnel first, for instance, could have been a thing. It wasn’t he clearly sent people ahead. Other things that might constitute weirdos for him is him facing off with the king of they and having a one on one combat. We don’t hear anything about something like that happening. So whoever that guy is, he seems to really fall off the radar. And we don’t get that sort of really personalized commander on commander thing that you would also definitely classify as a weirdos moment. So yeah, in that sense, like it’s not that Camillus isn’t doing a great job. He clearly is. He’s encouraging everybody. But those things aren’t considered traditional Roman weird tours. No,
Dr Rad 1:13:32
exactly. And also, I’m not so sure I subscribe to this idea of the king of a I mean, he pops up at the beginning of this story to get this war started, pops up at the end. We never really get much information about him, apart from everybody hates him. Who is this guy? Well,
he ain’t no Lars Tolumnius, that’s for sure
Yeah, okay, so not really. And surprisingly, even though we get this very cinematic description of the fall of a in Livy, where, again, he’s probably going for a bit of an epic moment there. We don’t get anyone who is singled out for their achievements, which I find surprising. I feel like that would surely have been a moment for somebody in Roman history, but maybe they just don’t want to detract from Camillus. You know, this is his moment
Dr G 1:14:19
to shine, yeah, yeah, like kimberlius have his moment in the sun. And the other point where you might potentially have some weird to us is in the senatorial chamber with the speech exchanges and how those go down depending on what people say. But it sounds like it’s a very reasonable debate, and it’s not the sort of one where people start showing off their scars or anything like that. So we’re not getting into like big masculine Roman energy there, either. We’re just getting some exchanges of opinions, which seems pretty standard for the day. Yeah, so I’m gonna say zero for virtus, because I’m not seeing any clear examples. I’m
Dr Rad 1:15:00
not, but you did just give me a great idea for a T shirt. It’s not BDE, it’s B, R, M, E,
Dr G 1:15:10
well, you know, I’m happy to make more T shirts. And our last category is the citizen school.
Dr Rad 1:15:18
Well, I do feel like there’s some things to celebrate here, even though normally, you and I would say that wartime is probably not a fantastic time to be wartime Rome not a great time. They seem to be extremely excited about this one, and it goes very well for them. As I say, it’s almost effortless in spite of all the mining. And then also the people who weren’t even involved in the siege get told to grab their stuff and head on out to the camp and, you know, take some spoils for themselves.
Dr G 1:15:57
Line up, get yourself a piece of a
Dr Rad 1:16:02
I love to think of they as being like the Berlin Wall is these days. You know how people say, you know, I have a piece of the Berlin Wall. I feel like that’s what people in Rome would be saying, they, Oh, my, my great grandfather still has a piece of they. You know, he still has some jewelry that he wrestled out of the hands of a crying woman. This
Dr G 1:16:22
bowl came from the temple in Veii, you know? Yeah,
Dr Rad 1:16:26
pretty much I feel like that is something that you would be trading in if you were a dealer of antiques in Rome. So
Dr G 1:16:35
everybody has the potential to increase their wealth slightly. And so part
Dr Rad 1:16:40
of it to be part of history. Dr, G, yeah.
Dr G 1:16:43
Oh, it’s great. Yeah, fantastic. Sack of a city, get in there constructed
Dr Rad 1:16:49
before our very eyes. I mean history, not the city. The city is being torn down before our very eyes. I
Dr G 1:16:54
was like, kids do not do as the Romans did. No, not cool. Okay, so, but on the citizen score level, as far as the Romans are concerned, this is a great time to be a Roman citizen. You’ve got this real opportunity. It seems like the fighting was pretty easy in the end, they just needed that little push off the edge, which was the tunnel system. And once that happened, it was like a house of cards, and now it’s booty Central, so probably at least a five, if not more, I
Dr Rad 1:17:24
think probably more. I reckon we have to go an eight for this one. I mean, not a 10, because obviously people are still dying, but I feel like it has to be an eight. Everyone seems very excited. There’s not a whiff of tribune of the plebs in this entire account. Yeah,
Dr G 1:17:42
they’re not even listed as magisters for the year. That’s how unimportant they are, yeah.
Dr Rad 1:17:47
And I mean, we’ve also got, you know, a plebeian hero as magistrate, or his son as magistrate, speaking up and winning against Appius Claudius, although, once again, it seems like class loyalty is bit of an issue, because he is talking about the fact that, hey, let’s get the plebs on side, and they’ve been doing it tough, clearly not associating himself. I think with that particular group of people, it
Dr G 1:18:13
does sound like there’s a lot of unbelievable things that are happening for this year. I’m happy for it to be an eight. Let’s do it. Fantastic.
Dr Rad 1:18:19
Well. Dr, G, hold on to your hat. The Romans have actually got over 25 Golden Eagles. For the first time in a really long time. We’re at the grand total of 31 golden eagles. Oh,
Dr G 1:18:36
my goodness, that is massive. I know we haven’t even
Dr Rad 1:18:41
talked about the whole year. I mean last episode, because we only did the very beginning of the year. They only got one. But if you add that one, it’s 32 so far and counting. For 396, BCE, very impressive,
Dr G 1:18:52
Rome, after what feels like a real sort of a desert scape of partial picks for the last few years, they’re making a resurging comeback Absolutely,
Dr Rad 1:19:05
and we haven’t even finished this year yet. Dr, G, I still have so much more to tell you.
Dr G 1:19:12
Well, I look forward to our next episode together.
Dr Rad 1:19:15
Indeed, you
music. Thank you for listening to this episode of the partial historians. You can find our sources sound credits and an automated transcript in our show notes. Our music is by Bettina Joy De Guzman. You too can support our show and help us to produce more fascinating content about the ancient world by becoming a Patreon or buying us a coffee on ko fi, in return, you receive exclusive early access to our special episodes. Today, we would like to say hello, hello, hello to Hannah, Dillon, Karl, Aether and Not who are enjoying. Their one year Patreon anniversary with us. Thank you so much for being a part of our partial band. However, if you spent all of your money in the post Saturnalia sales, please just tell someone about the show or give us a five star review until next time we are yours in ancient Rome.
Transcribed by https://otter.ai
The post Episode 159 – The Fall of Veii: Part II appeared first on The Partial Historians - Ancient Roman History with smart ladies.