The Petal: Australian Case Law Daily from JADE OpenLaw

Send us Fan Mail

One state, every court, one brief. Tasmania for the week of 21 to 27 August, a compact week honestly reported: five decisions, led by the estate costs judgment with the cascading orders worth copying.

• Rosewarne and Rosewarne v Rosewarne (No 3) [2026] TASSC 56 - the three costs scales, the bring-into-account rule, trustee indemnity, and cascading draft orders. JADE
• Baird v Goodwin [2026] TASSC 61 - sentencing reasons in busy lists; no discounting against future concurrency. JADE
• Tasmulch Pty Ltd v Minister for Business, Industry and Resources [2026] TASSC 59 - judicial review of a ministerial decision. JADE
• Arrowsmith and Sherriff v Carter [2026] TASSC 58 - constructive trust between former partners. JADE
• DPP v Harrison [2026] TASSC 60 - high risk offender supervision (doctrine only). JADE

Theme music by Michael Green SC.

Send us Fan Mail

One state, every court, one brief. Queensland for the week of 21 to 27 August, merged into a single weekly edition: nine decisions, led by the family handshake that equity enforced where the Statute of Frauds would not.

Features.

• Ou v Wang [2026] QSC 168 - the handshake the Statute of Frauds could not save: part performance, promissory estoppel, sham analysis, tracing. JADE
• Malligan v Chevron Apartments Pty Ltd; Cantavenera v Chevron Apartments Pty Ltd [2026] QSC 195 - off the plan terminations tested on the contract machinery. JADE
• McKay v Queensland Ballet Company (No 2) [2026] QSC - estate litigation, round two. JADE
• Dunstan v Registrar of Births, Deaths and Marriages (No 2) [2026] QSC 200 - judicial review of the registrar, orders worked out. JADE
• Bowral Capital Pty Ltd v Real [2026] QSC 197 - commercial lending dispute. JADE

The appellate trio (full treatment in the national weekend edition).

• McEwan v Director of Public Prosecutions [2026] QCA 153 - privies and issue estoppel (full treatment in the national weekend edition). JADE
• R v SFD [2026] QCA 152 - uncharged acts and the propensity standard (doctrine only). JADE
• R v RBU [2026] QCA 151 - preliminary complaint: credibility, never reliability (doctrine only). JADE

Theme music by Michael Green SC.

Send us Fan Mail

One territory, every court, one brief. The ACT for the week of 21 to 27 August, busier than its reputation: eleven decisions, led by the ex parte injunction that survived its own disclosure audit.

Features.

• Whats your addy Pty Ltd v Hedley [2026] ACTSC 305 - ex parte injunctions: the full and frank disclosure duty, its limits, and the director/employee distinction. JADE
• GRE Sales Pty Ltd v Commissioner for Fair Trading [2026] ACTCA 26 - security for costs on appeal: the full framework, and no special position for government litigants. JADE
• Sami v Nepal [2026] ACTSC 306 - the quality of life benefits map: WPI in sequence, limitation preserved nunc pro tunc. JADE
• Girvan v Civil Construction Hire Pty Ltd (No 2) [2026] ACTSC 313 - interrogatories category by category; inadequate denials come home. JADE
• DPP v Kustic [2026] ACTSC 309 - trafficking sentence: reward differential, parity, proceeds (doctrine only). JADE

The rapid file.

• Arizapa v Monty [2026] ACTSC 303 - appeal from the magistrates court. JADE
• Ashell Homes Constructions Pty Ltd v Kobus (No 3) [2026] ACTSC 304 - pleadings, round three. JADE
• DPP v Pricsina [2026] ACTSC 308 - joint trial ruling. JADE
• Boardman v ACT [2026] ACTSC 316 - civil claim against the territory. JADE
• Osborne (a pseudonym) v Vaughn (a pseudonym) [2026] ACTSC - pseudonyms preserved. JADE

Theme music by Michael Green SC.

Send us Fan Mail

One state, every court, one brief. South Australia for the week of 21 to 25 August, a quiet week honestly reported: four decisions, led by the testamentary capacity judgment that speaks directly to solicitor file-taking.

• Rogers v Rogers [2026] SASC 115 - testamentary capacity: the evidence hierarchy, and the solicitor file note as capacity insurance. JADE
• Narciso v Narciso [2026] SASCA 99 - family provision: standing, exceptional circumstances, and utility disciplining the extension. JADE
• Fulton (a Pseudonym) v The King [2026] SASCA 97 - judge-alone reasons adequacy and DNA transfer reasoning (doctrine only). JADE
• Susan Rose Padley v South Australian Housing Trust [2026] SASCA 100 - public housing eviction upheld (full treatment in the national weekend edition). JADE

Theme music by Michael Green SC.

Send us Fan Mail

One state, every court, one brief. Western Australia for 21 to 24 August, merged for the catch-up: eight decisions, led by a charitable trust remade under the new statute.

Features.

• The Public Trustee v Attorney General of Western Australia [2026] WASC 350 - the new charitable trusts machinery worked in full: notice, evidence, thresholds, and the as-close-as-possible test. JADE
• The State of Western Australia v Hoskin [No 4] [2026] WASC 346 - HRSO contravention: the three limbs and the offender onus on substantial compliance. JADE
• The State of Western Australia v Kpb [No 5] [2026] WASC 351 - the seven-proposition substantially-comply test reproduced; least restrictive option applied. JADE

The rapid file.

• Legal Services and Complaints Committee v Williamson [2026] WASC 347 - disciplinary processes confirmed. JADE
• Kanowna Mines Pty Ltd v Grange Resources Ltd [No 2] [2026] WASC 348 - discovery round two on ordinary principles. JADE
• Niroda Holdings Pty Ltd v Dbngp (WA) Nominees Pty Ltd [2026] WASC 349 - pre-action procedure between holding companies. JADE
• Bacha v Cordero Jimenez [2026] WASC 352 - wills and estates. JADE
• Suppressed [2026] WASCA 113 - suppressed judgment, noted for the record (no public link). JADE

Theme music by Michael Green SC.

Send us Fan Mail

One state, every court, one brief. Victoria for 21 to 24 August, merged into one edition for the catch-up: ten decisions, led by an employer chasing its confidential information out the door a departing executive left through.

Features.

• Cyara Solutions Pty Ltd v Mitchell [2026] VSC 531 - restraining misuse of confidential information after an executive departure: precision, genuine secrecy, business realities. JADE
• Sutherland (a pseudonym) v Watts (a pseudonym) [2026] VSC 548 - ceasing to act: detailed affidavits required; the real moving party pays. JADE
• RM v DPP [2026] VSC 544 - youth sentencing: mitigation proved, not recited (doctrine only). JADE
• Re Crowe [2026] VSC 547 - bail: building exceptional circumstances from accumulated factors. JADE
• Re Harrison [2026] VSC 549 - bail application. JADE

The appellate pair and the rapid file.

• Lifestyle Management 2 Pty Ltd v Dowling [2026] VSCA 201 - management fees void where the tenant cannot ascertain the amount (full treatment in the national weekend edition). JADE
• Spencer v Medical Board of Australia [2026] VSCA 195 - interlocutory stays and concurrent proceedings (full treatment in the national weekend edition). JADE
• Marriott v Grigorovitch [2026] VSC 535 - personal injuries claim survives summary dismissal. JADE
• Lam v Leung (Costs) [2026] VSC 540 - appeal costs follow the event. JADE
• Doran v Astrazeneca Pty Ltd [2026] VSC 536 - product liability case management. JADE

Theme music by Michael Green SC.

Send us Fan Mail

The tribunals weekend. Nineteen decisions from five tribunals across the 21 to 23 August reporting window, led by the contempt referral ruling in Greenwich v Latham: where robust criticism of a tribunal ends and scandalising begins.

Features.

The rapid file.

Theme music by Michael Green SC.

Send us Fan Mail

One state, every court, one brief. The New South Wales weekend edition: twenty-three decisions from the 21 to 23 August reporting window, led by provisional liquidators appointed over a corporate group whose controller treated legal obligations as optional.

Features.

• In the matter of Ironbark Holdings Australia Pty Ltd [2026] NSWSC 1004 - provisional liquidators over the group: conduct-driven appointment; undertakings from the source of concern are no substitute. JADE
• R v Delaney [2026] NSWSC 1003 - the mental health impairment defence worked through: three steps, the substance-use carve-out, model consequential orders. JADE
• Roberts Jones Badgerys Creek Pty Ltd v Transport for NSW [2026] NSWLEC 108 - just terms: the statutory disregard needs a direct causal connection; owner bears the onus; before-and-after methodology. JADE

The appellate weekend, with the NSW lens (full treatment in the national weekend editions).

• Health Care Complaints Commission v Kirby [2026] NSWCA 168 - tribunal constitution: a health practitioner member must practise; jurisdictional error, appealable as of right. JADE
• Director of Public Prosecutions (NSW) v TH; DPP (NSW) v MB; DPP (NSW) v Sharp [2026] NSWCCA 125 - the bias trilogy: ex parte communications, the double might test, redetermination. JADE
• Alex v R [2026] NSWCCA 121 - jury internet research; sheriff vs judicial investigation; no proviso for fundamental irregularity. JADE
• NR v R [2026] NSWCCA 126 - judicial interventions assessed on number, terms and tone; trial audio received. JADE
• Acopian v R [2026] NSWCCA 127 - pretext call admissions; correctness standard on s 90 review. JADE
• Hu v Green Estate Australia Pty Ltd [2026] NSWCA 170 - adjournment for replacement counsel; the s 138 ethics holding. JADE
• Bolton v WAM Active Ltd (No 3) [2026] NSWCA 171 - release of security: prove the liability will inevitably exceed the fund. JADE
• Mohareb v Nine Entertainment Co Holdings Ltd (No 3) [2026] NSWCA 167 - second set-aside motion as abuse; own-motion vexatious referral. JADE

The rapid file.

• Douglas v Lin (No 2) [2026] NSWSC 1000 - statement of claim struck out. JADE
• R v Smith [2026] NSWSC 999 - Supreme Court criminal judgment (cited without commentary). JADE
• Chih-Wen Yeh v Ku-ring-gai Council [2026] NSWLEC 1536 - development appeal.
• Elser v Woollahra Municipal Council [2026] NSWLEC 1538 - development appeal.
• Qi v Northern Beaches Council [2026] NSWLEC 1539 - development appeal. JADE
• Wills v Valuer General [2026] NSWLEC 1540 - valuation appeal. JADE
• Valuation appeals v Valuer General of New South Wales [2026] NSWLEC 1532, 1533, 1534, 1535 - the valuation appeal cluster, decided together. JADE

Theme music by Michael Green SC.

Send us Fan Mail

The federal weekend. Nine Federal Court decisions from the 21 to 23 August reporting window, led by children's best interests as a primary consideration in migration decisions.

Public Law.

Commercial.

Practice & Procedure.

Theme music by Michael Green SC.

Send us Fan Mail

The weekend edition. Sixteen decisions from six Australian courts of appeal across the 21 to 23 August reporting window, led by the Court of Criminal Appeal on private communications with a judge who had reserved judgment.

Public Law opens with the apprehended bias trilogy and the constitution of health disciplinary panels.

Criminal (care register: doctrine only).

Commercial.

Practice & Procedure.

Theme music by Michael Green SC.