The Petal: Australian Case Law Daily from JADE OpenLaw

Send us Fan Mail

One state, every court, one brief. A quiet Monday of two, both worth their place: an acquittal eight years on, and the costs of economy in argument.

Features.

• R v Cronn [2026] QCA 159 - statements against interest in the parallel civil file as fresh evidence; acquittal entered, not a retrial. JADE
• Huang v Body Corporate for the Dorchester CTS 10749 [No 2] [2026] QCA 160 - a necessary respondent keeps its costs; adopting an intervener's submissions is efficiency, not surrender. JADE

Full typeset judgments are in the Judicial Ledger. Theme music by Michael Green SC.

Send us Fan Mail

One state, every court, one brief. Seven decisions, led by the irrigators' class action against the Murray-Darling Basin Authority - dismissed across sixteen common questions.

Features.

• Doyle's Farm Produce v Murray-Darling Basin Authority [2026] NSWSC 1036 - no duty of care to individual irrigators; incongruity with the statutory framework; hindsight evidence excluded; the Cessnock inference confined. JADE
• RS v Commissioner of Police (NSW) [2026] NSWCCA 128 - subpoenas after prosecution disclosure; the state angle on today's national lead. JADE
• Zou v Ji [2026] NSWSC 762 - deceit and misleading conduct decided on the WeChat record; passing on a false document turns on adoption. JADE
• R v Baziad (No 3) [2026] NSWSC 1038 - murder sentencing worked through the SNPP guideposts; body disposal as aggravation; doctrine only. JADE
• R v Lui (Sentence Judgment) [2026] NSWSC 965 - manslaughter sentencing consistent with the jury's verdict; eight strands of corroboration; doctrine only. JADE
• Cooper View Developments v Woollahra Municipal Council [2026] NSWLEC 1562 - the affordable housing bonus, calculated to the square metre. JADE
• McCourt v Mosman Municipal Council [2026] NSWLEC 1564 - joinder application. JADE

Full typeset judgments are in the Judicial Ledger. Theme music by Michael Green SC.

Send us Fan Mail

Six decisions from the Federal Court. The lead: a payday lender's algorithm watched customers' bank accounts and helped itself - seven unfair terms, hundreds of thousands of contraventions, a $3.5m penalty.

Features.

• ASIC v Venture 5 Group Pty Ltd [2026] FCA 1278 - unfair contract terms in small amount credit contracts; proposing and relying now separate contraventions; replacement terms, injunction and adverse publicity. JADE
• Rodrigo Gomes Da Silva v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2026] FCA 1277 - a five-year-old assumption about the applicant's children was legally unreasonable; cancellation quashed. JADE
• LKQD v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2026] FCA 1270 - Direction 110 comparative risk methodology; claimed supports must demonstrably reduce risk. JADE
• Campbell v McIntyre (No 2) [2026] FCA 1279 - ex parte full disclosure enforced; injunction discharged, 80% indemnity costs; forum challenge failed. JADE
• Top Ryde Financial Services v Rams Financial Group (Trial Management) [2026] FCA 1271 - the simplifying-note framework for complex litigation. JADE
• Dixon (Trustee) v Templer [2026] FCA 1272 - distributing without a statement of affairs under s 146. JADE

Full typeset judgments are in the Judicial Ledger. Theme music by Michael Green SC.

Send us Fan Mail

Seven decisions from five appellate courts, and a criminal law day. The lead from Sydney rewrites subpoena practice in criminal trials: if the prosecutor disclosed it, the disclosure is the starting point.

Features.

• RS v Commissioner of Police (NSW) [2026] NSWCCA 128 - legitimate forensic purpose after prosecution disclosure; take the defence case as framed; the evidentiary mosaic. JADE
• R v Cronn [2026] QCA 159 - the complainant's own later words as fresh evidence; conviction quashed and acquittal entered, not a retrial. JADE
• The State of Western Australia v Matanga [2026] WASCA 121 - general prison conditions are not mitigation without personal evidence; immediate imprisonment substituted; doctrine only. JADE
• Lagdon v The State of Western Australia [2026] WASCA 122 - totality and manifest excess restated; willingness of a child under authority never mitigates; doctrine only. JADE
• Motor Accident Commission v Raccanello & Ors [2026] SASCA 95 - the Calderbank checklist at work; restitution of overpayments with 7% interest. JADE
• Huang v Body Corporate for the Dorchester CTS 10749 [No 2] [2026] QCA 160 - adopting an intervener's winning submissions does not forfeit costs. JADE
• Mobourne v The King [2026] VSCA 210 - fresh evidence limits on sentence appeals; Verdins moderation needs evidence; doctrine only. JADE

Full typeset judgments are in the Judicial Ledger. Theme music by Michael Green SC.

Send us Fan Mail

Brand new: the first Australian Capital Territory edition. One territory, every court, one brief. Four decisions from the ACT Supreme Court to open the account.

Features.

• Demczyszyn v ACT Height Safety Pty Ltd (in liq) [2026] ACTSC 325 - breach of statutory duty proved, so no reduction for contributory negligence under s 102(2); texts, experts and the rule in put-your-case. JADE
• Laura Hall (a pseudonym) v Trustees of the Roman Catholic Church (No 2) [2026] ACTSC 326 - no power to compel a medical examination; the stay is the pressure point; reported with care. JADE
• DPP v Terry Barajas (a pseudonym) [2026] ACTSC 324 - the young offender sentencing checklist; doctrine only. JADE
• Bolaram v ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal (No 2) [2026] ACTSC 323 - judicial review. JADE

Full typeset judgments are in the Judicial Ledger. Theme music by Michael Green SC.

Send us Fan Mail

One state, every court, one brief. Western Australia for the weekend: six Supreme Court decisions, and costs is the theme, led by when a hopeless case earns indemnity costs and why fabrication must be put squarely.

Features.

• Varelis v Rispoli [No 2] [2025] WASC 554 (S) - indemnity costs for groundless contentions; fabrication findings need the allegation squarely put in cross examination. JADE
• Bin Saad v WA Police [2026] WASC 366 - accused's costs after dismissal for want of prosecution; item 6 is reasonableness, not a cap. JADE
• Boston v Ellena Pty Ltd [2026] WASC 363 - oppression injunction refused: advertising is not selling, and an undertaking neutralised the prejudice. JADE
• Re Charitable Trustee a; Ex Parte Charitable Trustee a [2026] WASC 365 - judicial advice for a charitable trustee. JADE
• Wilkinson v WA Police [2026] WASC 364 - appeal grounds. JADE
• Minchin v Director of Public Prosecutions [2026] WASC 362 - sentence appeal. JADE

Full typeset judgments are in the Judicial Ledger. Theme music by Michael Green SC.

Send us Fan Mail

One state, every court, one brief. Victoria for the weekend: a single decision, and no padding, but every litigator who has asked to vacate a trial date should hear it.

Features.

• Manda Capital Holdings Pty Ltd v Pappas (No 2) [2026] VSC 554 - vacating trial dates after Aon: the transparent unvarnished explanation, and why liens, new solicitors and discovery complaints were not enough. JADE

Full typeset judgments are in the Judicial Ledger. Theme music by Michael Green SC.

Send us Fan Mail

Where most people actually meet the law: thirteen decisions from three tribunals. The lead is an appeal panel finding a constructive failure to exercise jurisdiction, claims pleaded but never decided. Reported with care: pseudonymised and disciplinary matters are doctrine only.

Features.

• Baptista v Hyper Apps Pty Ltd t/as Hyper Startup Studio [2026] NSWCATAP 273 - constructive failure to exercise jurisdiction: pleaded claims and accessorial allegations never determined; remittal. JADE
• Secretary, Department of Customer Service v Tricon Builders Pty Ltd [2026] NSWCATAP 271 - appeals as of right need pure questions of law, precisely identified; Briginshaw for the regulator. JADE
• Adams v Van Go Fit Pty Ltd [2026] NSWCATAP 270 - repudiation is a mixed question needing leave; procedural fairness grounds need the complete record. JADE
• Oris & Otis Pty Ltd v Point to Point Transport Commissioner [2026] NSWCATOD 115 - on review the tribunal may go harder: suspension became cancellation, public safety paramount. JADE
• Maman v Health Care Complaints Commission [2026] NSWCATOD 114 - reinstatement: the onus of showing you are no longer unfit; insight, conditions, supervision. JADE
• Pointon v Holstein [2026] QCAT 386 - unlicensed builders recover actual costs only, and only on evidence; s 42 QBCC Act worked through. JADE
• Reese & Anor v Torque Concreting and Constructions Pty Ltd [2026] QCAT 387 - void contract, negligence steps in; directions to rectify carry the evidentiary weight. JADE
• Kavanagh & Ors v SAAROQ Pty Ltd t/as Stroud Homes Wide Bay No 2 [2026] QCAT 388 - costs quantified: rule 86 offers, sixty percent solicitors, ninety percent counsel. JADE
• Choi v The Body Corporate for Macquarie Place CTS 10897 (No 3) [2026] QCATA 127 - stays: arguable case, nugatory effect, balance of convenience; fire safety outweighed entry objections. JADE
• Duck v Chief Executive, Department of Transport and Main Roads [2026] QCAT 390 - tow truck accreditation: the appropriate person test, video evidence and Briginshaw. JADE
• Queensland College of Teachers v TXU [2026] QCAT 392 - teacher discipline, reported under its pseudonym. JADE
• SEB v Department of Justice [2026] QCAT 389 - judicial review, reported under its pseudonym. JADE
• Forrester v Pacific Pines Central [2026] QCAT 391 - interlocutory orders. JADE

Full typeset judgments are in the Judicial Ledger. Theme music by Michael Green SC.

Send us Fan Mail

One state, every court, one brief. South Australia for the weekend: two decisions, no padding. Reported with care: a child protection appeal and a matter of serious violence, doctrine only, pseudonyms preserved.

Features.

• State of South Australia v AC [2026] SASC 119 - the unacceptable risk framework in full: non-discretionary, correctness on appeal, the full report over the summary. JADE
• Rawatxay v The King [2026] SASCA 102 - say the arithmetic aloud: uncertainty on time served in the non-parole period is material error; treated in our Court of Appeal weekend edition. JADE

Full typeset judgments are in the Judicial Ledger. Theme music by Michael Green SC.

Send us Fan Mail

One state, every court, one brief. Queensland for the weekend: six decisions, led by one of the first full judicial outings of the Trusts Act 2025, a lost deed, a vesting date and a rectification in one application.

Features.

• Re: Asdew Pty Ltd (as trustee) [2026] QSC 202 - the new Trusts Act at work: jurisdiction over a foreign-law trust, a photocopy standing in for a lost deed, vesting extended, names rectified. JADE
• ABC v A Magistrates Court of Queensland [2026] QSC 203 - non-publication orders in extortion cases reach third parties; deterrence can rest on inference. JADE
• Genuity Pty Ltd v IG Power (Callide) Ltd [2026] QSC 194 - construction maxims at work: express interest excluded the general costs clause; specific beats general. JADE
• Lake v Hermann [2026] QSC 193 - judicial review. JADE
• Lake v Hermann (No 2) [2026] QSC 201 - correction of orders. JADE
• R v Small [2026] QCA 158 - plea offers and parity; treated in our Court of Appeal weekend edition, doctrine only. JADE

Full typeset judgments are in the Judicial Ledger. Theme music by Michael Green SC.