The Petal: Australian Case Law Daily from JADE OpenLaw

Send us Fan Mail

One decision, taken at full depth: the NSW Court of Appeal's manual on default judgments for possession, and on why none of it moves without evidence. Leave thresholds, the discretionary irregularity rule, the onus of a bona fide defence, a backdated notice of appearance, and where procedural fairness ends. A clean Thursday edition.

Features.

• Events by Lush Pty Ltd v Capital Securities Mortgages Pty Ltd [2026] NSWCA 180 - leave to appeal refused: no issue of principle and no reasonably clear error; UCPR r 36.15 irregularity power is discretionary and needs sufficient cause; the onus of a bona fide defence on the merits is not excused by irregularity; a backdated notice of appearance filed after judgment does not vitiate it; requiring a draft defence is not a procedural trap; stays dissolved. JADE

Full typeset judgments are in the Judicial Ledger. Theme music by Michael Green SC.

Send us Fan Mail

One state, every court. Time and its price: the extension manual and a limitation appeal decided under yesterday's five member bench standard, a costs cap on the court's own motion, a group proceeding built around its lead plaintiff, youth bail under the amended Act with care, and a $340,000 lesson in waste management. Wednesday's word from JADE rides after the lead.

Features.

• McIntyre v State of Victoria [2026] VSCA 213 - extension of time framework; full treatment in today's Court of Appeal brief. JADE
• Woodford v Fernando [2026] VSC 562 - s 23A limitation extensions reviewed for House v The King error per Northern Grampians v Fox; synthesis not summation; presumptive prejudice and the applicant's onus. JADE
• Integrated Technologies Australia Pty Ltd v Lai [2026] VSC 559 - registrar appeals are hearings de novo; s 65C costs caps on the court's own motion; security in tranches to avoid stultification. JADE
• Holmes v Knowmore Legal Service (No 3) [2026] VSC 560 - initial trial carries common questions and the representative plaintiff's individual claim together; efficiencies must be concrete. JADE
• Re VW [2026] VSC 555 - youth bail: two-step exceptional circumstances and unacceptable risk test after the adult crime adult time amendments; child status preserved; doctrine only. JADE
• Re Ipenburg (No 2) [2026] VSC 561 - variation of bail conditions. JADE
• Environment Protection Authority Victoria v Renex [2026] VSC 563 - first contested civil penalty determination under the EP Act 2017: deterrence controls, single penalty for a series, $340,000 restorative payment in lieu of penalty. JADE

Full typeset judgments are in the Judicial Ledger. Theme music by Michael Green SC.

Send us Fan Mail

NCAT takes a practitioner's name off a published decision, three years on, and the Appeal Panel writes the internal appeals manual. Wednesday's word from JADE rides after the lead.

Features.

• Health Care Complaints Commission v Hxx (No 2) [2026] NSWCATOD 117 - retrospective anonymisation under s 64(1)(a): the power reaches already-published decisions; exceptional circumstances shown by severe, medically evidenced psychiatric impairment caused by ongoing publication; prior publication does not make an order futile; the successful applicant still paid the contradictor's costs. JADE
• Sentient Corp Holding Pty Ltd v The Owners, Strata Plan No 48216 [2026] NSWCATAP 274 - internal appeals: questions of law as of right, everything else needs leave and a substantial miscarriage of justice; evaluating competing strata manager appointments under s 237, including unorthodox terms. JADE

Full typeset judgments are in the Judicial Ledger. Theme music by Michael Green SC.

Send us Fan Mail

One state, every court. The offer of compromise no defendant could accept, equity unwinds a family transfer, a proceeds of crime template, and the injunction that could not stop the machines. Wednesday's word from JADE rides after the lead.

Features.

• Smith v Visy Pulp and Paper Pty Ltd (No 2) [2026] NSWSC 1013 - a single undifferentiated offer against multiple defendants may be incapable of acceptance and never engages r 42.14; the comparison is net of workers compensation payback; ambiguity risk stays with the drafter. JADE
• Donatiello v Donatiello [2026] NSWSC 1043 - unconscionable dealing: the three-limb framework applied; knowledge versus mere notice per Amadio; passive acceptance can suffice; contemporaneous documents decide gift or sale. JADE
• Commissioner of the AFP v Ilyas & Ors [2026] NSWSC 1047 - ex parte restraining, custody and control orders under the Proceeds of Crime Act, property by property; reasonable grounds to suspect; mortgagee carve-outs; protective orders only. JADE
• Jackson v Secretary, DCCEEW [2026] NSWLEC 115 - interlocutory injunction refused: inability to locate an authorising instrument proves nothing; Carltona and deemed authorisation; delay and quantified impacts on the balance. JADE
• Solo v R [2026] NSWCCA 130 - parity done properly; full treatment in today's Court of Appeal brief. JADE
• Carrafa v Dyball [2026] NSWSC 1040 - settlement enforcement. JADE
• BKA v State of New South Wales [2026] NSWSC 1045 - leave to sue. JADE
• Kilby v State of New South Wales [2026] NSWSC 1046 - leave to sue. JADE
• Lorbek Luxury Cars Pty Ltd v Council of the City of Sydney [2026] NSWLEC 1571 - signage controls. JADE
• Simpson v Sutherland Shire Council [2026] NSWLEC 1555 - development appeal. JADE
• Khan v Cumberland Council [2026] NSWLEC 1568 - development control orders. JADE
• Dangar (Penrith) Pty Ltd v Canterbury-Bankstown Council [2026] NSWLEC 1566 - development application. JADE

Full typeset judgments are in the Judicial Ledger. Theme music by Michael Green SC.

Send us Fan Mail

Two decisions that teach method. Melbourne's working manual for extensions of time, and Sydney's step-by-step parity analysis. Wednesday's word from JADE rides after the lead.

Features.

• McIntyre v State of Victoria [2026] VSCA 213 - extensions of time: the multi-factor test; substantial unexplained delay lifts the merits threshold to strong or even exceptional; the frank and thorough affidavit checklist; the wrong court costs sanction; false imprisonment needs no plea of unlawfulness. JADE
• Solo v R [2026] NSWCCA 130 - parity is not head-sentence arithmetic: joint criminal enterprise parties answer for the full range of acts; a Form 1 on a co-offender's sentence does not inevitably create disparity; subjective differences explained the gap. JADE

Full typeset judgments are in the Judicial Ledger. Theme music by Michael Green SC.

Send us Fan Mail

One state, every court, one brief. Four decisions, led by a mining group against its own former global law firm over where the fee fight belongs.

Features.

• Eepl Holdings v Clifford Chance [2026] WASC 368 - anti-arbitration injunctions on ordinary anti-suit principles; a permissive arbitration clause binds once exercised; arbitration regime given primacy over a general jurisdiction clause. JADE
• Lrl as Administrator of the Estate of the Late Nll v Worthington [2026] WASC 370 - compromise approval for a person under disability: the PD 4.2.2 checklist, Sosa v Carter principles, restriction orders and Public Trustee machinery; doctrine only. JADE
• Vercon Pty Ltd v Alamdar Tiling Pty Ltd [2026] WASC 371 - statutory demand set aside: genuine dispute on contracting identity; offsetting claims quantified without meticulous detail. JADE
• Nicholas Ni Kok Chin [2026] WASC 369 - leave to commence refused. JADE

Full typeset judgments are in the Judicial Ledger. Theme music by Michael Green SC.

Send us Fan Mail

One state, every court, one brief. Six decisions, led by the five member bench on limitation extensions, with the state practitioner's angle, and two quiet workhorses from equity.

Features.

• Northern Grampians Shire Council v Fox [2026] VSCA 214 - House v The King governs extension review; promptness runs from knowledge of the acts, not the limitation period; national treatment in today's Courts of Appeal brief. JADE
• Trappitt v The King [2026] VSCA 212 - bound by counsel's forensic choices; delay weighs alone. JADE
• Goussis v The King [2026] VSCA 209 - s 317: on the cards, no need to prove documents exist. JADE
• S & P Gomes Pty Ltd v Gannawarra Shire Council [2026] VSCA 211 - want of prosecution; indemnity costs from the overarching obligations. JADE
• Le v Milosevic [2026] VSC 552 - wills construed, not corrected. JADE
• In the matter of the Pocklington Investment Trust [2026] VSC 557 - judicial advice as the trustee's insurance. JADE

Full typeset judgments are in the Judicial Ledger. Theme music by Michael Green SC.

Send us Fan Mail

The nation's tribunals, one brief. Six decisions across three tribunals, led by an enforcement fight over what a decades old approval actually approved.

Features.

• Mason and Shire of Serpentine-Jarrahdale [2026] WASAT 102 - de novo review; historical approvals construed with their application documents; enforcement discretion factors. JADE
• Cripps v Victorian Fisheries Authority [2026] VCAT 713 - a refusal to vary is itself reviewable; the deeming provision defeats the positive/negative distinction. JADE
• Gurusinghe v Medical Board of Australia (No 2) [2026] VCAT 706 - stays in professional discipline: eight factors, evidence of prejudice, conditional stays; doctrine only. JADE
• Poole and WA Country Builders Pty Ltd [2026] WASAT 103 - security of payment machinery keeps money moving. JADE
• Flynn v Secretary NSW DCCEEW [2026] NSWCATAD 263 - s 96(1) leave after declination; contract workers, causation and the comparator. JADE
• Blum v Monash CC [2026] VCAT 620 - noted on the docket. JADE

Full typeset judgments are in the Judicial Ledger. Theme music by Michael Green SC.

Send us Fan Mail

One state, every court, one brief. A single decision that maps the youth jurisdiction: does mandatory licence disqualification bite at referral to a family conference.

Features.

• Question of Law Reserved No 1 of 2025 [2026] SASC 124 - mandatory disqualification is an act of sentencing; a family conference referral is interlocutory and diversionary, the notwithstanding clause is not engaged; disqualification may return by undertaking or on sentence. JADE

Full typeset judgments are in the Judicial Ledger. Theme music by Michael Green SC.

Send us Fan Mail

One state, every court, one brief. Three decisions: two sexual offence appeals treated with care, and the costs review judgment every assessing practitioner will bookmark.

Features.

• R v GBX [2026] QCA 161 - jury notes need objective indicators of misunderstanding; split verdicts tracked the evidence count by count; doctrine only. JADE
• R v DCZ [2026] QCA 162 - faded recollection on one count is not recantation; intermediate defence evidence need not be rejected beyond reasonable doubt; doctrine only. JADE
• Thompson v MacMillan [2026] QSC 206 - the eight point review checklist; principle reviewable, quantum not; perusing versus examining under the scale. JADE

Full typeset judgments are in the Judicial Ledger. Theme music by Michael Green SC.