The Plato Paradigm

The Plato Paradigm

Download on the App Store

The Plato Paradigm episodes

  • 0246 Lysis 220d
    There is no friendly/dear thing if the truly friendly/dear thing towards which it is friendly/dear does not have in it the bad. This, at least, is a summary of Socrates' summary of the new position on the like being a philon to the like.

    Here I read through Platonic dialogues, translating and commenting on the Greek text as I go.

    The resulting analyses may be found at:
    https://theplatoparadigm.com

    The full analyses include Euthyphro, Io, Hippias Minor, and Lysis, with extract/summaries from my books on Hippias Major, Meno, and Politeia (Republic)
    15 min
  • 0245 Lysis 220a
    To exemplify Socrates' deliberately confusing formula, if we take the son from the last episode, it is only because of the bad (the hemlock) being added to the good (the son), that there becomes a need for the friendly (the things contributing to the removal of the bad - wine, and the cup). Were the son perfectly well, there would be no need for such things which are not actually friendly in their own right.

    Here I read through Platonic dialogues, translating and commenting on the Greek text as I go.

    The resulting analyses may be found at:
    https://theplatoparadigm.com

    The full analyses include Euthyphro, Io, Hippias Minor, and Lysis, with extract/summaries from my books on Hippias Major, Meno, and Politeia (Republic)
    15 min
  • 0244 Lysis 219d
    Socrates develops the possibility that like can actually be friendly to like into a slightly different argument with a somewhat horrific example whereby a father values his son above all other things, but in an emergency supposedly values all the things contributing to the wellbeing of his son. He has not yet said that wine and the winecup are friendly to the son, but he should at some point if this argument is to follow from his earlier argument.

    Here I read through Platonic dialogues, translating and commenting on the Greek text as I go.

    The resulting analyses may be found at:
    https://theplatoparadigm.com

    The full analyses include Euthyphro, Io, Hippias Minor, and Lysis, with extract/summaries from my books on Hippias Major, Meno, and Politeia (Republic)
    15 min
  • 0243 Lysis 219c
    Now Socrates considers the case of like being friendly to like - something which was rejected in one of the earlier arguments. Like being friendlly to like allows for a chain of friendly things, all being friendly because of the ultimate reason for them acting together.

    Here I read through Platonic dialogues, translating and commenting on the Greek text as I go.

    The resulting analyses may be found at:
    https://theplatoparadigm.com

    The full analyses include Euthyphro, Io, Hippias Minor, and Lysis, with extract/summaries from my books on Hippias Major, Meno, and Politeia (Republic)
    15 min
  • 0242 Lysis 219a
    Back to the argument concerning the body being a friend of the medical art because of disease. This time, the argument has a new twist. The body is a friend of the friendl medical art because of the hostile disease, but now we also have to deal wtih health, which is why the medical art "takes up the friendship". Health, too, is a friend.

    Here I read through Platonic dialogues, translating and commenting on the Greek text as I go.

    The resulting analyses may be found at:
    https://theplatoparadigm.com

    The full analyses include Euthyphro, Io, Hippias Minor, and Lysis, with extract/summaries from my books on Hippias Major, Meno, and Politeia (Republic)
    15 min
  • 0241 Lysis 218d
    Socrates revisits the eristic argument about the neutral body having sickness in it, and it doesn't sound any better this time around.

    Here I read through Platonic dialogues, translating and commenting on the Greek text as I go.

    The resulting analyses may be found at:
    https://theplatoparadigm.com

    The full analyses include Euthyphro, Io, Hippias Minor, and Lysis, with extract/summaries from my books on Hippias Major, Meno, and Politeia (Republic)
    15 min
  • 0240 Lysis 218c
    Socrates expresses dissatisfaction, just when he has led his current audience to think that he has successfully hunted the boys.

    Here I read through Platonic dialogues, translating and commenting on the Greek text as I go.

    The resulting analyses may be found at:
    https://theplatoparadigm.com

    The full analyses include Euthyphro, Io, Hippias Minor, and Lysis, with extract/summaries from my books on Hippias Major, Meno, and Politeia (Republic)
    15 min
  • 0239 Lysis 218b
    Socrates is concluding the argument with both boys which combines the arguments he had had with them separately. With Lysis, the Philon is not of like with like, with Menexenus, the Philon is not of opposite with opposite, with both, the Philon is of the not like and not opposite (i.e, the neutral) with the good. This apparently successful outcome agreed to by both boys is a dismal failure for Socrates, and he will have to try harder to rouse them out of their stupor.

    Here I read through Platonic dialogues, translating and commenting on the Greek text as I go.

    The resulting analyses may be found at:
    https://theplatoparadigm.com

    The full analyses include Euthyphro, Io, Hippias Minor, and Lysis, with extract/summaries from my books on Hippias Major, Meno, and Politeia (Republic)
    15 min
  • 0238 Lysis 217e
    Socrates is still developing the notion of two different kinds of agent, one making a thing appear, and another making a thing be. He has moved from the examples of disease in the body and whiteness in hair to ignorance in - we may assume, since he doesn't say yet - the soul. We learn (please don't!) that a totally expert and a totally inexpert person would both not philosophize. Only the neither expert nor inexpert would philosophize. By analogy with the neutral body loving the physician in order to remove the disease, we might suppose that the neutral soul would love the expert in order to remove ignorance, but not in order to acquire expertise. We need not take the argument literally, but in order to understand the fallacious nature of the argument, we must start by taking the argument at face value.

    Here I read through Platonic dialogues, translating and commenting on the Greek text as I go.

    The resulting analyses may be found at:
    https://theplatoparadigm.com

    The full analyses include Euthyphro, Io, Hippias Minor, and Lysis, with extract/summaries from my books on Hippias Major, Meno, and Politeia (Republic)
    15 min
  • 0237 Lysis 217d
    Socrates develops his sophistic argument that what is neither one extreme nor its opposite may contain one of the extremes without acquiring the characteristic of that extreme, or indeed may acquire that characteristic. The boys accept everything he says, despite his best efforts to confuse them.

    Here I read through Platonic dialogues, translating and commenting on the Greek text as I go.

    The resulting analyses may be found at:
    https://theplatoparadigm.com

    The full analyses include Euthyphro, Io, Hippias Minor, and Lysis, with extract/summaries from my books on Hippias Major, Meno, and Politeia (Republic)
    15 min

About The Plato Paradigm

From the publisher's feed

Pericles had decided to begin his eulogy of the fallen soldiers by mentioning their ancestors. Socrates treats the ancestors as the material cause of the fallen, but by the same causal reasoning, he…