Where the Salem Witch Trials Records Really Come From (and What’s Missing)

We dig into the biggest surprise at the heart of the 1692 Salem Witch Trials: the official Court of Oyer and Terminer record book is gone, and what people call “trial records” are mostly pretrial examinations, warrants, depositions, bills, diaries, and printed observers’ accounts. We explain how magistrates like John Hathorne and Jonathan Corwin shaped the surviving dialogue-style transcripts, why those documents get mistaken for trial proceedings, and what sparse trial records typically looked like by comparing to the surviving 1693 Superior Court files. We trace how writers such as Cotton Mather, Robert Calef, Thomas Brattle, John Hale, Increase Mather, and others preserved competing narratives, and how Samuel Sewall’s diary fills crucial gaps. We spotlight the decade-long scholarly effort behind the 2009 Records of the Salem Witch-Hunt, the myths it overturns (including confessors being tried and executed), and how New England and even Scotland show how missing records can distort history for centuries.

00:00 What Records Survive

01:09 Examinations Not Trials

03:07 How Trials Worked

04:31 Published Accounts Clash

06:31 Proving Records Existed

08:37 Where Records Went Missing

09:52 Scribes Shape History

11:38 Records of the Salem Witch Hunt

13:58 Myths the Paperwork Busts

14:44 Beyond Salem and Abroad

16:59 Other Sources and Daily Paper

18:20 The Devil’s Book That Never Was

19:50 Voices of the Accused

20:26 Why Records Matter 

End Witch Hunts: https://www.endwitchhunts.org

The Thing About Witch Hunts: https://aboutwitchhunts.com

The Thing About the Salem Witch Trials: https://aboutsalem.com

Connecticut Witch Trials History: https://connecticutwitchtrials.org

Watch us on YouTube: https://youtube.com/@aboutwitchhunts

Samuel Wyllys Papers (CT State Library): https://ctdigitalarchive.org/node/3907524

Samuel Wyllys Papers (Brown University): https://www.riamco.org/render?eadid=US-RPB-mswyllys&view=inventory#ref15

Salem Witch Trials Documents - High Quality Scans: https://pem.quartexcollections.com/collections/salem-witch-trials-collection

Buy Books from our Bookshop: https:/bookshop.org/shop/endwitchhunts

The Toothaker Family: Folk Magic, Witchfinding, and Tragedy in the Salem Witch TrialsA folk healer known as “Dr. Toothaker,” Roger Toothaker was the only male healer/physician accused of witchcraft in 17th-century New England, and his story pulls our Salem Witch Trials podcast into a web of witchfinding, fear, and family fallout. After leaving his wife Mary Allen Toothaker and their children behind in Billerica, Roger was arrested in May 1692 for allegedly afflicting Salem Village girls and died in Boston jail; testimony linked him to diagnosing victims under an “evil hand” and to a “witch bottle” said to kill a witch. Soon Mary Toothaker and their young daughter Margaret were accused, and daughter Martha Toothaker Emerson was jailed after dramatic examinations and spectral allegations, while son Allen testified against aunt Martha Carrier. Though Mary and Martha were ultimately cleared, war violence later killed Mary and took Margaret captive, underscoring how folk magic, Andover/Salem Village accusations, and ties to Carrier made the Toothakers prime targets.

00:00 Meet the Toothakers

00:13 Roger's Early Life

01:05 Healer Turned Accused

01:51 Testimony and Witch Bottle

03:05 Mary and Margaret Accused

04:07 Roger Dies in Jail

05:01 Martha Emerson Arrested

06:59 Specters and Confession

08:04 Mary Toothaker Confesses

09:25 Allen Testifies Against Carrier

10:20 Acquittals and Release

10:54 War and Aftermath

11:47 Legacy and Reading List

We dig into original Salem Witch Trials documents to map, step by step, how Bridget Bishop moved from first mention to execution—and how “evidence” worked in 1692. Using the arrest warrant (April 18, 1692), competing examination records by Ezekiel Cheever and Samuel Parris, and a trail of statements, depositions, and jail paperwork, we trace the case built on spectral evidence, old grievances framed as supernatural harm, and accusations drawn from other prisoners’ confessions. We follow Bridget through transfers between Salem and Boston jails, the June 2 physical search for “witches’ teats,” five indictments for afflicting the core afflicted girls, and the death warrant ordering her hanging on June 10. We also track the long aftermath, from missed restitution efforts to her eventual naming in Massachusetts’ 2001 exoneration act.

00:00 Anatomy of a Trial

01:02 Arrest Warrant Breakdown

02:47 Preliminary Examination

05:19 Spectral Evidence Claims

06:49 Past Harm Testimony

08:52 Confessions Implicate Bridget

09:31 Jail Transfers and Records

10:43 Witch Marks and Indictments

12:42 Death Warrant and Execution

16:39 Costs and Restitution

17:53 Exoneration in 2001

19:06 Subscribe and Closing 

Links:

• Salem Witch-Hunt Facebook Page: https://facebook.com/salemwitchhunt

• High Quality Scans of Original Court Documents - Peabody Essex Museum Salem Witch Trials Collection: https://pem.quartexcollections.com/collections/salem-witch-trials-collection

• Bernard Rosenthal, ed., Records of the Salem Witch-Hunt: https://bookshop.org/a/90227/9781107689619⁠

• Salem Witch Trials History YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCliis4vjMIUgg3wcA0pXeYQ/

• ⁠Salem Witch Trials Daily Hub: https://aboutsalem.com/salem-witch-trials-daily/⁠

• ⁠The Thing About the Salem Witch Trials: https://aboutsalem.com⁠

• ⁠The Thing About Witch Hunts: https://aboutwitchhunts.com⁠

• ⁠Mary Beth Norton, In the Devil’s Snare: The Salem Witchcraft Crisis of 1692: https://bookshop.org/a/90227/9780375706905⁠

• ⁠Emerson W. Baker, A Storm of Witchcraft: The Salem Trials and the American Experience: 

• https://bookshop.org/a/90227/9780190627805⁠

• ⁠Marilynne K. Roach, The Salem Witch Trials: A Day-by-Day Chronicle of a Community Under Siege: https://bookshop.org/a/90227/9781589791329⁠

Step into Salem in 1692 as we follow Bridget Bishop from her life in Salem Town to the courtroom that condemned her. She was the first person executed in the Salem Witch Trials, convicted on testimony about specters, poppets, an “unnatural mark,” and long-running neighborhood quarrels—despite insisting she had never harmed the accusers and did not even know them. We trace her documented history from England to Massachusetts, her three marriages, earlier accusations that faded for lack of evidence, and the legal machinery that made her case the opening death sentence for the Court of Oyer and Terminer. We also confront how Bridget has been misremembered, explore modern portrayals like Cry Innocent and screen adaptations, and highlight memorials, exoneration, and the living legacy of her descendants.

00:00 Bridget Bishop Introduced

00:40 Life Before 1692

02:24 Arrest And Examination

04:47 Spectral Evidence Piles Up

06:08 Trial And Execution

07:04 Myths And Mixups

07:36 Remembering Bridget Today

09:02 Stage And Screen Portrayals

09:57 Memorials And Exoneration

10:49 Legacy And Descendants 

End Witch Hunts:  https://endwitchhunts.org 

The Thing About The Salem Witch Trials: https://aboutsalem.com

The Thing About Witch Hunts: https://aboutwitchhunts.com

Salem Witch Trials History: https://youtube.com/@aboutwitchhunts

Buy A Book About The Salem Witch Trials: https://bookshop.org/lists/the-salem-witch-hunt-collection-curated-by-the-thing-about-salem-podcast

⁠Salem Witch Trials Daily Hub: https://aboutsalem.com/salem-witch-trials-daily/⁠

⁠Mary Beth Norton, In the Devil’s Snare: The Salem Witchcraft Crisis of 1692: https://bookshop.org/a/90227/9780375706905⁠

Bernard Rosenthal, ed., Records of the Salem Witch-Hunt: https://bookshop.org/a/90227/9781107689619⁠

⁠Emerson W. Baker, A Storm of Witchcraft: The Salem Trials and the American Experience: 

https://bookshop.org/a/90227/9780190627805⁠

⁠Marilynne K. Roach, The Salem Witch Trials: A Day-by-Day Chronicle of a Community Under Siege: https://bookshop.org/a/90227/9781589791329⁠

High Quality Scans of Original Court Documents - Peabody Essex Museum Salem Witch Trials Collection: https://pem.quartexcollections.com/collections/salem-witch-trials-collection

Why did the 1692 Salem witch trials require an entirely new court, and how did that court reach a 100 percent conviction rate? This episode examines the Court of Oyer and Terminer, the special tribunal that prosecuted witchcraft accusations across colonial Massachusetts, and lays out the legal machinery, the magistrates, and the evidentiary standards that decided who lived and who died.

When Sir William Phips took office, the province faced overcrowded jails, an invalidated court system, and dozens of pending witchcraft charges with no legal venue to resolve them. The court he created relied on spectral evidence and a bench of prosperous, legally untrained men, a combination that shaped one of the most consequential criminal proceedings in early American history.

Chapters

00:00 Welcome and Overview

00:32 Why a Special Court

02:06 Meet the Judges

03:43 Earlier Witch Trial Experience

05:10 Spectral Evidence Explained

06:26 Ministers Weigh In

06:49 Oyer and Terminer Results

08:01 Superior Court Replaces It

11:04 Reprieves and Stoughton Fury

12:29 Aftermath and Next Episode

What you will learn:

• Why a special court became necessary in 1692

• How the new Massachusetts charter dismantled the old court system

• Who sat on the bench

• What legal training the magistrates actually possessed

• How spectral evidence functioned as proof

• Why Connecticut had foreclosed spectral evidence decades earlier

• How conviction rates differed under the two successive courts

• Which condemned prisoners avoided execution

Hosted by Josh Hutchinson and Sarah Jack.

End Witch Hunts

The Thing About The Salem Witch Trials

Buy A Book About The Salem Witch Trials

William Phips was the last person anyone should have trusted with one of the most consequential legal crises in American history. No formal education. No legal training. No political experience. The man who put him in charge of Massachusetts was Increase Mather, the most powerful Puritan minister in colonial New England.

Phips arrived at the Salem witch trials as governor of Massachusetts Bay with a life behind him that had nothing to do with governance. There was a Spanish shipwreck, a knighthood, a failed military campaign, and a financial disaster that forced the colony to print currency for the first time. By the time he sailed into Boston Harbor in May 1692, the jails were already full of the accused, the Court of Oyer and Terminer was waiting to be built, and the pressure to act was immense.

Josh Hutchinson and Sarah Jack examine the full arc of William Phips, the contradictions he embodied, the power he held during the Salem witch trials of 1692, and what he did and did not do with it.

What You Will Learn:

• The kind of man Puritan New England handed its witch trials to

• What it took to become the most powerful man in Massachusetts without ever learning to write

• How a man who could not read until age 21 came to control the Salem witch trials

• The Spanish shipwreck that launched a political career

• Why New England's most powerful minister chose an illiterate treasure hunter for governor

• The military disaster that forced Massachusetts to print money for the first time

• What the ministers actually told Phips about the witchcraft cases

• The accusation that landed inside his own home

• Who Phips blamed when the Crown demanded answers

Hosted by Josh Hutchinson and Sarah Jack.

End Witch Hunts: endwitchhunts.org | aboutwitchhunts.com

#WilliamPhips #SalemWitchTrials #Salem1692 #AmericasFirstKnight #ColonialAmerica #MassachusettsHistory #WitchTrialsHistory #IncreaseMather #RebeccaNurse #PuritanHistory #EndWitchHunts #ThingAboutSalemWitchTrials #NewEnglandHistory #AmericanHistory

Links:

Emerson W. Baker and John G. Reid, The New England Knight: Sir William Phips, 1651-1695: https://bookshop.org/a/90227/9780802081711

From Witch Trials to Revolution: Salem Village on the Front Lines

We connect Salem’s darkest legacy to the opening clash of American independence with historian Dan Gagnon, Danvers resident and author of A Salem Witch: A Biography of Rebecca Nurse. Our conversation brings the Revolution into the very streets of Salem and Salem Village (today’s Danvers), where coercive acts, a moved provincial capital, troops on the Salem Common, and General Gage’s presence near the Rebecca Nurse Homestead turned imperial policy into daily reality. Tensions surge as the Massachusetts legislature outmaneuvers Gage in Salem, town meetings defy his bans, and crowds force him to release arrested patriots. The action escalates with Leslie’s Retreat—an armed standoff over a raised bridge—and then the Lexington Alarm, as Danvers militia (including descendants of witch-trial families) race to Menotomy for some of the day’s most savage fighting.

00:00 Welcome and Introductions

00:12 Dan Gagnon Background

01:06 Witch Trials to Revolution

02:34 Rights and Rising Tensions

03:05 Salem Becomes Capital

05:14 Defying General Gage

06:26 Town Meetings and Protests

08:15 Leslie's Retreat in Salem

11:00 Lexington Alarm Response

14:05 Menotomy Bloody Fighting

17:07 Losses and Legacy 

Links:

Rebecca Nurse Homestead: rebeccanurse.org

A Salem Witch: A Biography of Rebecca Nurse by Dan Gagnon: www.bookshop.org/Shop/endwitchhunts

End Witch Hunts endwitchhunts.org

About Witch Hunts aboutwitchhunts.com

Salem Witch Trials History YouTube: https://youtube.com/@aboutwitchhunts

Every April 30, bonfires burn across Europe on the same night witches were said to gather on a mountaintop and make their covenant with the devil. That image did not stay in Europe. It crossed the Atlantic, embedded itself in colonial New England theology and law, and by 1692 it was being sworn to in witchcraft trials that sent nineteen people to their deaths. In this episode, hosts Josh Hutchinson and Sarah Jack follow that thread from a German mountain to a Danvers pasture — and the path runs straight through a Maypole, a folk magic discovery hidden inside a colonial home, a decades-old grudge over rancid butter, and a pear tree that has been standing since before the trials began and is still standing right now.

In this episode, you will learn:

• Why Walpurgis Night and the Salem witchcraft sabbath descriptions share the same historical roots

• How one colonial settler's May Day celebration became a theological threat to Puritan authority

• What a single word in William Bradford's writing reveals about how Puritans understood folk magic and social control

• Why witchcraft gathering testimony carried such evidentiary weight in colonial Massachusetts courts — decades before Salem

• How one man's actions in the 1620s left a thread running directly through the 1692 witch trials

• What a 400-year-old pear tree in a Danvers parking lot has to do with the Salem witch trials

The Thing About the Salem Witch Trials is part of the End Witch Hunts podcast network. Learn more at endwitchhunts.org.

#SalemWitchTrials #Witchcraft #FolkMagic #WalpurgisNight #ColonialHistory #AmericanHistory #WitchHunts #1692 #Puritans #NewEnglandHistory #MayDay #ThomasMorton #JohnEndicott #EndWitchHunts #SalemHistory

Salem Witch Trials History YouTube

The Thing About the Salem Witch Trials

Salem Witch Trials Daily

The Thing About Witch Hunts

Support Our Work, Buy a Salem Witch Trials History Book!

ESPN has a history podcast, and they used it to cover the Salem Witch Trials on the 50th anniversary of the ergot theory. Hosts Josh Hutchinson and Sarah Jack, descendants of Salem Witch Trial victims, respond to Stupiracy's April 2nd episode on whether moldy rye bread caused the accusations of 1692.

What you will learn:

• What the ergot theory is and why it has circulated for 50 years
• How the historical symptoms from Salem do not match ergotism
• Who was executed and who died in jail during the Salem Witch Trials of 1692
• Why the devil, not bread mold, was the legal framework driving the prosecutions
• The witch legends and actual 1692 witch trials in ESPN's own backyard in Connecticut

Hosted by Josh Hutchinson and Sarah Jack of The Thing About Witch Hunts Podcast. Learn more at www.aboutwitchhunts.com

#SalemWitchTrials #WitchTrials #ErgotTheory #Salem1692 #SalemHistory #WitchHistory #RebeccaNurse #MaryEasty #GilesCory #ESPN #Stupiracy #ConnecticutWitchTrials #AmericanHistory #WitchHunts

Links

Margo Burns on Moldy Bread Theory

Best Books on The Salem Witch Trials

The Thing About the Salem Witch Trials

Salem Witch Trials Daily

The Thing About Witch Hunts

On April 19, 1692, Salem witch trials magistrates conducted their busiest day of examinations yet. Four accused witches appeared before the court in colonial Massachusetts. Two confessions were recorded. And the Puritan legal proceedings that would lead to nineteen executions shifted into a dangerous new phase.

In this episode of The Thing About the Salem Witch Trials, Josh Hutchinson and Sarah Jack break down the examinations of Giles Cory, Abigail Hobbs, Mary Warren, and Bridget Bishop using the firsthand courtroom notes of Samuel Parris and Ezekiel Cheever. If you love American history, colonial history, or the true story behind one of the most dramatic legal crises in Puritan New England, this episode is for you.

In this episode you'll learn:

• What Giles Cory said under examination, why his answers about a cow house drew the magistrates' suspicion, and how the afflicted responded to Giles Cory's every movement in the courtroom

• How Abigail Hobbs became the first confessor since Tituba, what her confession revealed about life on the colonial Maine frontier, and why Abigail Hobbs' testimony produced the first legal accusation against Sarah Wildes of Topsfield

• What Mary Warren claimed about the afflicted accusers that the Salem witch trial court chose to ignore, and why Mary Warren's examination collapsed across four separate appearances before the magistrates

• How Bridget Bishop defended herself against charges of witchcraft in 1692, what the cuts in Bridget Bishop's coat had to do with spectral evidence, and why her answer about not knowing what a witch was became a trap that led to her hanging

The Thing About the Salem Witch Trials is hosted by Josh Hutchinson and Sarah Jack of End Witch Hunts nonprofit and The Thing About Witch Hunts podcast. For day-by-day coverage of the 1692 Salem witch trials, follow Salem Witch Trials Daily podcast.

Salem Witch Trials Daily Videos & Course

The Thing About Salem Website

⁠The Thing About Witch Hunts YouTube⁠

⁠The Thing About Witch Hunts Website

Sign the Petition: MA Witch Hunt Justice Project

Massachusetts Witch-Hunt Justice Project

Support the nonprofit End Witch Hunts Podcasts and Projects