In June 2011, 20-year-old Indiana University student Lauren Spierer vanished after a night out in Bloomington—launching one of the most widely followed and perplexing missing persons cases in America. On this episode of The Tom Gulley Show, Tom examines the timeline, the key locations, the people involved, and the troubling gaps that have kept this mystery unsolved for more than a decade.
With clear, fact-driven analysis and respect for Lauren and her family, Tom walks through the hours leading up to her disappearance, the surveillance footage, the witness statements, and the ongoing theories that continue to circulate. This is not sensationalism—this is an informed, level-headed look at a case filled with lingering questions and heartbreaking uncertainty.
In this episode, you’ll learn:
• Lauren Spierer’s final confirmed movements and the critical timeline
• What investigators discovered—and what remains unexplained
• The role of witnesses, friends, and conflicting accounts
• How early decisions and missed opportunities shaped the investigation
• Theories surrounding the case and why none have led to resolution
• Why the disappearance continues to resonate nationwide
If you follow true crime, missing persons cases, or the complex realities of investigations, this deep dive brings context, clarity, and sober reflection to a mystery that still haunts the community of Bloomington.
Subscribe for more fact-focused explorations of history, crime, culture, mysteries, and the human stories that shape our world—only on The Tom Gulley Show.