The True Crime Reader

The True Crime Reader

By Kristen BarenthalerTrue Crime
Download on the App Store

The True Crime Reader episodes

  • A Death in Belmont: The Strangler, the Carpenter, and the Wrong Man?

    Today we’re stepping into the uneasy intersection of personal history, racial injustice, and one of the most infamous crime sprees in American memory. Sebastian Junger’s A Death in Belmont is a work of creative nonfiction published in 2006, and it revisits a murder that occurred in the quiet suburb of Belmont, Massachusetts in 1963. The killing of Bessie Goldberg took place during the terrifying period of the Boston Strangler murders, which gripped the Boston area from 1962 to 1964. Junger’s book examines this single crime not only as a historical event but as a deeply personal mystery, because on the day Goldberg was murdered, Albert DeSalvo—the man who would later confess to being the Boston Strangler—was working as a carpenter in the Junger family home.

    5 min
  • Deadly Dames: The Art of the Femme Fatale

    Welcome back to The True Crime Reader, the podcast where the past meets the macabre, and every story is more than just a headline—it’s a window into human darkness, complex motivations, and the societies that shaped these stories. I’m your host, and today we're immersing ourselves in the chilling world created by Tori Telfer in her acclaimed book, Lady Killers: Deadly Women Throughout History. This isn’t just about shocking crimes—it's about the overlooked, misunderstood, and underexamined reality that women have, for centuries, been perpetrators of some of history’s most disturbing murders.

    19 min
  • Bonus: The Poisoner’s Handbook: Murder and the Birth of Forensic Medicine

    Welcome to The True Crime Reader, where we explore crime through the lens of history and storytelling. Today, we’re stepping into Jazz Age New York—a city alive with speakeasies, smoky backrooms, and a dangerous secret weapon: poison. Our guide is Deborah Blum’s The Poisoner’s Handbook, a gripping account of how two men—Charles Norris and Alexander Gettler—changed the course of forensic science forever.

    3 min
  • Controlled Substances, Uncontrolled Consequences

    Prescription for Pain: How a Once-Promising Doctor Became the “Pill Mill Killer” by Philip Eil delivers a haunting narrative that grips both true crime aficionados and those concerned with America’s opioid crisis. The saga of Dr. Paul Volkman, a once-brilliant physician whose career trajectory led him from the highest echelons of medical achievement to four consecutive life sentences in a federal prison, is a cautionary tale at the dark intersection of medicine, greed, addiction, and unchecked pain management practices. Volkman ran a network of cash-only pain clinics in rural southern Ohio, becoming, by government estimates, the largest single prescriber of oxycodone in the country from 2003 to 2005. Over the course of nearly three years, his actions resulted in a wave of suffering, addiction, and death across the Appalachian region, culminating in a sensational federal trial and a precedent-setting sentence for a physician.

    19 min
  • Confidence Game: Anatomy of a Fake Heiress

    Welcome listeners to another episode of The True Crime Reader. Tonight, we peel back the velvet curtain of New York’s elite to reveal one of the city’s most audacious deceptions: the saga of Anna Sorokin, who reinvented herself as “Anna Delvey”—a mysterious German heiress, Soho party fixture, and master con artist. Our story dives into the true events chronicled in Rachel DeLoache Williams’ gripping memoir, My Friend Anna: The True Story of a Fake Heiress. This is a tale of psychological gamesmanship, the intoxicating allure of luxury, the fragility of trust, and the sobering aftermath of betrayal.

    19 min
  • Belle Gunness: Swipe Right for Death

    Tonight, we descend into the shadows of early twentieth-century America — to a quiet farmhouse on the outskirts of La Porte, Indiana. Here, beneath the unassuming soil of cornfields and hog pens, a hidden horror festered and grew.

    I'm your host for The True Crime Reader, and in this episode, we unearth one of the most mystifying and gruesome chapters in American true crime: the life and unsolved mystery of Belle Gunness.

    Dubbed "Hell’s Princess" by author Harold Schechter, Belle Gunness was many things: a Norwegian immigrant, a wife, a mother, a hard-working farm owner. But she was also a monster hiding in plain sight, a woman whose acts shattered every expectation — and whose legacy continues to haunt a century later.

    Join me as we unravel the strands of her life and crimes — from her lonely beginnings in Norway, through a trail of bodies and unanswered questions in Indiana, and to her chilling disappearance. We'll dive into her psychology, the violent ingenuity of her methods, the investigation that followed, and the public’s shocked reaction — all set against the turbulent backdrop of early 1900s America.

    21 min
  • A True Crime Road Map

    Welcome back, true crime aficionados, to another deep-dive with The True Crime Reader. I’m your host, and today we’re unwrapping an unusual new entry in the world of true crime literature: “50 States of Murder: An Atlas of American Crime” by Harold Schechter. If you ever wondered how geography—yes, the physical, cultural, even psychological landscapes of each state—can shape the crimes and criminals that haunt their history, this is the atlas you never knew you needed.

    14 min
  • Two Teens, One Bus, and A Nation Watching - “The 57 Bus” by Dashka Slater

    On a November afternoon in Oakland, California, a single reckless act aboard the 57 bus changed two lives forever. In this episode of The True Crime Reader, we dive into Dashka Slater’s acclaimed narrative nonfiction, The 57 Bus. The book traces the story of Sasha, a teenager who identifies as agender, and Richard, a Black teen from Oakland, whose impulsive decision to set fire to Sasha’s skirt sparked a criminal case that reverberated far beyond the city.

    We’ll explore:

    • The social and cultural divides that framed this tragedy

    • How Slater weaves together themes of identity, justice, and empathy

    • The broader questions the case raises about juvenile crime, bias, and forgiveness

    This episode isn’t just about the crime—it’s about the human stories behind it, and the way one bus ride became a lens for examining race, gender, and the justice system in America.

    18 min
  • Flames of Deception: "Burn Boston Burn" by Wayne Miller

    In this episode of The True Crime Reader, we dive into Wayne Miller’s explosive account of the largest arson case in American history. Burn Boston Burn chronicles the terrifying string of fires that swept through Boston and its suburbs in the early 1980s, set by a group of men whose motives ranged from greed to revenge. With more than 260 fires ignited, the city was gripped by fear as investigators raced against time to uncover the perpetrators.

    We’ll explore Miller’s insider perspective as a federal ATF agent, unravel the psychology of the arsonists, and examine how meticulous detective work finally brought the fire-setters to justice. This episode doesn’t just recount the flames—it illuminates the human cost, the resilience of Boston’s communities, and the chilling reminder of how quickly chaos can spread when destruction is deliberate.

    13 min

About The True Crime Reader

From the publisher's feed

Step into a world where true crime and literature collide. The True Crime Reader guides listeners through some of the darkest cases ever put to paper.