
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


In this episode of the Unscripted SEO Podcast by Be Sharp Digital Marketing, Jeremy Rivera sits down with Matt Bailey, a digital marketing veteran with nearly 30 years of experience spanning from the pre-Google AltaVista era to today's AI-driven landscape. Matt shares his journey from building real estate websites with journalism principles in 1995 to founding SiteLogic and helping shape the SEO industry through his work with the OMCP (Online Marketing Certified Professional Organization).
This conversation explores the evergreen principles that have survived every "SEO is dead" cycle, the critical gaps in SEO education, and why AI is both a productivity tool and a source of strategic confusion for businesses. Matt and Jeremy discuss the importance of conversion optimization, the holistic webmaster approach that got lost in the 2010-2020 era of easy Google traffic, and why understanding content, context, and community remains fundamental to digital marketing success.
Key Topics Covered:
Matt Bailey
Matt Bailey's journey into digital marketing began in an unexpected place—journalism school. While he quickly realized journalism wasn't his calling, the education gave him something invaluable: an understanding of how to lay out content for quick consumption. Headlines, subheadings, bullet points—these newspaper design principles became the foundation of his website development approach in 1995-96.
Working in real estate at the time, Matt started building websites as electronic versions of printed pages. What he didn't realize initially was that the markup he was using for visual layout was exactly what early search engines needed. This was the AltaVista era, where SEOs would spend entire nights resubmitting pages to chase rankings.
When Google arrived, Matt's content-first approach paid immediate dividends. Pages structured with clear hierarchy and reader-focused design performed well naturally. This early lesson—that optimizing for visitors and optimizing for search engines aren't separate goals—would become a through-line in his entire career.
A pivotal moment came when Matt was working on real estate websites and asked himself: "What can I do on the website that will have the biggest impact?" He didn't have an answer. That question forced him to learn analytics, starting with Web Trends (anyone who's worked with Web Trends knows the pain of the day-long setup-and-pray cycle).
Learning analytics transformed how Matt approached B2B lead generation. It wasn't just about getting traffic anymore—it was about understanding user behavior, measuring engagement, and connecting digital activity to business outcomes. This analytical mindset would distinguish his work throughout his agency years.
Throughout the late '90s and early 2000s, Matt moved through multiple ad agencies in the Midwest, where B2B industrial and B2B services dominated the landscape. At two different agencies, he built entire SEO and digital marketing departments from scratch. But after doing this twice for other people, he had the realization many agency professionals eventually reach: "I think I can do this for myself."
In 2006, Matt founded SiteLogic as a client services company focused specifically on website marketing, auditing, and promotion—deliberately avoiding the development side to maintain focus on their sweet spot.
Around 2015-2016, Matt faced a crossroads. He had developed a parallel business of teaching and training, working with direct marketing associations, travel associations, and automotive associations. He was traveling constantly, speaking to industry audiences about digital marketing tactics and strategy. The demands of running both an agency and a training business forced a choice.
Matt chose training, transforming SiteLogic into a training company. During this period, he also contributed significantly to the OMCP (Online Marketing Certified Professional Organization), helping define what makes an SEO professional. What does an SEO need to know? What are the core competencies? How do you test for those skills? These weren't just academic questions—they shaped how the industry thinks about professional development.
His commitment to education went even deeper: Matt went back to school for a degree in instructional design to understand how to teach 30 years of digital marketing according to educational pedagogy. He's currently working on his master's degree in digital marketing to teach at the undergraduate level.
Jeremy brought up a problem he's encountered working with universities in Nashville through colleagues Ross Jones and Michael McDougald of Right Thing SEO Agency: university SEO programs are typically eight years behind current practice.
Matt confirmed this isn't unique to SEO. When creating training materials for organizations like LinkedIn, Simply Learn, Udemy, and Udacity, he's upfront about reality: SEO course content has a shelf life of 18-24 months maximum. LinkedIn does regular updates, but many educational providers have content that's 10-15 years old still on the market.
The problem runs deeper in traditional academia. Matt shared teaching an undergraduate marketing class last semester where the textbook—only 18 months old—had an entire chapter on how the metaverse would change marketing. Already obsolete. Even worse, the textbook authors were all PhDs who had never held actual marketing jobs. They'd consulted, but had never dealt with the politics of getting ideas approved internally, never had to compromise because IT wouldn't support their vision, never had to play the real-world game.
This disconnect between academic theory and practical implementation affects not just SEO but many marketing disciplines. Academia is starting to ask the right questions, but structural barriers remain.
Jeremy shared a personal enterprise red tape nightmare: editing 10 pages for HCA as a subcontractor of a subcontractor of an agency required a drug test, three separate sign-ons, using only their laptop, and sitting in a room with a security guard to ensure he didn't abscond with their secured device.
Matt's response: "It's absolutely insane." But both agreed this is the reality of enterprise SEO work, echoing McDougald's observation that "the most expensive thing in SEO is red tape."
Jeremy posed the critical question: From 1995 to now, through every "SEO is dead" cycle (mobile-first, voice search, HCU, and inevitably whatever comes next), what are the through lines that remain true?
Matt's answer cuts to the heart of why he's never liked the term "SEO":
"Search engine optimization" implies you only care about the search engine. What are you really optimizing? Ideally, you're optimizing for visitors, for conversion, for engagement. These visitor-centered principles are what's evergreen.
Matt goes back to his origin story: building websites like newspaper pages. Layout, readability, content—that's never changed. Yes, there were tactical experiments—doorway pages, black hat techniques for affiliate and Forex clients. But Matt's B2B lead generation clients couldn't take those risks. His approach was content, PR, and building links with associated businesses. Those skills are evergreen.
Critically, Matt emphasized: "After learning SEO, if you're not learning conversion optimization, you've lost the game." That's where you maximize your efforts.
When people say "SEO is dead," Matt interprets that as "the old tactics are dead." But writing engaging content that reaches visitors, answers questions, and converts customers? Those skills never die.
Jeremy and Matt Brooks at SEOteric frequently discuss a critical blindness in the industry: what you do with traffic after it arrives is as important as how you got it there.
But somewhere along the way, organizations siloed everything: social media managers handle social traffic, PPC teams manage paid landing pages, SEO controls the blog, brand managers own certain sections. This fragmentation misses massive opportunities.
Jeremy's call to action: "Let's go back to 1998 and reestablish ourselves as webmasters." Look at this holistically. Email sends lead to branded search. Organic social leads to website traffic, which leads to newsletter conversions, which leads to email traffic that still needs converting. These channels aren't isolated—they're interconnected.
The problem emerged during the 2010-2020 comfort zone when Google traffic was so abundant that SEOs could operate in isolation. They didn't need to talk to the email team, the PPC team, or the social media team. Just publish blog posts, build backlinks, and claim credit for all traffic—even when $20,000 in radio and video ads drove massive brand search volume.
Why was ignoring brand traffic ever acceptable? It's the singular signal of market awareness of your business and industry. But because SEOs couldn't control it through blog posts alone, many pretended it didn't matter. That was madness.
Matt confirmed this holistic understanding actually gives SEOs an advantage: OMCP job delineation studies show SEOs have more of a track toward management and leadership than other disciplines precisely because they have their fingers in multiple areas. They understand integration, measurement, and how channels work together.
Jeremy asked whether significant differences exist between verticals—e-commerce vs. B2B lead generation—and whether SEOs should be multi-disciplinary.
Matt loves this question because it highlights what made agency work so valuable. Having multiple client types exposed him to different requirements: e-commerce needs additional UX/UI skills and database understanding; B2B lead generation has different conversion paths; publishing and affiliate work each have unique demands.
Being able to say "I've worked in B2B lead gen, e-commerce, publishing, and affiliate" opens doors. That breadth of experience enables bouncing between industries—travel, automotive, advertising, brand work—with relative ease. The agency experience provides that exposure early in a career.
Jeremy brought up the anxiety in every SEO's mind: CEOs declaring "AI, ChatGPT, we need GEO, we need AI SEO, we don't need an SEO budget anymore." He'd seen three different Reddit threads where SEOs lost their jobs because executives determined SEO was obsolete—instead, they needed to "make content and get articles placed so LLM bots can find mentions and links."
The irony isn't lost on either of them.
Matt's response is direct: "SEO works. It still works. In fact, SEO works on LLMs." They look at the same signals, and honestly, LLMs are like early search engines—almost like pre-Google search right now.
He's amazed by companies jumping on tracking "visibility in LLMs" when even two people using ChatGPT with the same prompt get different answers. How do you track that? How do you measure prompt variations across millions of users? We're back to rank checking, which is fundamentally flawed.
Matt's diagnosis: "It's a lot of shiny objects right now. A ton of shiny objects."
Basic, well-done SEO still works. But it must be combined with good marketing dependent on clear strategy.
Most businesses Matt consults with that are enthralled by AI share a common problem: they don't have a clear strategy. They don't understand what they're trying to accomplish, how they'll accomplish it, or what process they'll use.
One company wanted AI to generate leads and content but didn't even have a CRM in place. No backend process to handle what the frontend would generate. This thinking makes shiny objects take off.
We've seen this pattern before: metaverse, NFTs, big data. Everyone thinks the new thing will save their business. If you don't have clear strategy driving your marketing decisions, you're going to lose.
The AI downside? Losses will take longer to realize. Companies firing people because "AI can write articles" won't see the impact immediately. But it's coming.
Matt looked at a site recently where 90% of blog content was AI-generated. You don't need to be a high-level AI user to spot it—just look at the pages. And the blog doesn't perform well. It's generic, average content.
AI can't create something truly new. You can feed it information, create custom GPTs, and those help. But if you're just using AI to pump out content volume, you're creating slop.
If you want strategic approach, branding, audience engagement, and conversion with all the backend operations required—you need people to manage that. AI can't do that effectively yet, and Matt doesn't think we'll see it soon.
Jeremy asked about what AI and LLMs definitively can't do: make site edits that positively impact conversion rate.
Matt starts every client conversation with seven strategic questions before touching tactics:
These two questions are the client's responsibility. Only then can Matt do the research:
The problem? Most marketers and SEOs immediately jump to tactics: which social media, posting frequency, posting times. They skip the foundational conversation about audiences, needs, location, message quality, competitive differentiation, and communication effectiveness.
Those foundations aren't things LLMs excel at. It requires planning, framework development, then execution.
Matt worked with Microsoft Worldwide Education for five years, going to different offices and working with marketing and operations teams. A common scenario: asking "Who's your target customer?" for selling Microsoft Office to small business owners.
Invariably, the myopia would take over: "They need a full-service suite that integrates all their content..." They'd describe Word, Excel, cloud storage—product features.
Matt would stop them: "That's not what small to medium business owners want. They want to make payroll. They want to be more efficient and spend less time at the office. They want their people to accomplish more."
Until you change your language to those needs, they'll dismiss you. It's about fitting the product to the need, not hammering prospects with product attributes expecting them to make the connection themselves.
How often is "enterprise solutions" overused in SEO? It's a nonsense phrase that means nothing.
Matt's grandmother would say: "You have got to change your language." It doesn't resonate with your audience. You're not meeting their need. You're hammering your brand attributes expecting them to see the connection—and they don't.
Jeremy has done audits where he copies homepage text from the client and a competitor (or even a totally different industry) and asks: "Which is your copy?"
"You excel at customer service" but so does everyone else. One does restaurant rebrands, another is an industrial carpenter. Your pretty-sounding sales phrases mean nothing to readers, to SEOs, and to LLMs.
One of Jeremy's previous interviewees observed: "ChatGPT is your least trained customer service representative." For them, for SEO, and for your readers, you need to examine what your content actually does to support your business.
Are you providing sample shop drawings for precast walls that construction teams need for RFPs to counties? No? They need those to get bids. If you're not providing them, you're forcing them to create their own—or they'll go to a competitor who provides that resource.
If you're not thinking about friction down the funnel that prevents sales, you're not leveraging your website correctly.
That's what it's really about: you have a fantastic tool where clients and potential clients can get information without mailing books or requiring one-on-one conversations. It's an incredible opportunity.
That's why digital marketing budgets increase by billions of dollars every year. A huge portion will always be SEO spend, but it should be considered part of your marketing strategy: How do we use this tool to its best capability?
Matt sees AI having positive effects: some content is being written so much better, much more in-depth, answering real questions.
When SEOs publish "here's the template that works," Matt thinks: that template is 20 years old. It's about depth, question-answering, and being found for questions people are actually asking.
If you haven't been researching those questions for 20 years, welcome to the party—AI is helping you understand questions better.
Jeremy's "least trained customer service rep" metaphor resonates, but Matt reframes it: "AI is like having a thousand interns."
They work fast, but you still need someone to refine edges, clarify, improve writing, and finalize it.
Matt's team recently rewrote all content for a site because it was too thin. They used AI, but 30% of the project was keyword research—not just finding ranking keywords, but understanding: What are people asking? How do they formulate questions? What words do they use? How do you organize what people want and translate that into answers?
Then develop that in the brand's tone and personality, highlighting distinctive characteristics. Instead of saying "we have great customer service," define what that means. How does your customer service work? Why do people like it? List specifics.
Generalities don't work. But when you define specifics? It works great in AI and it works great in Google.
On the term "SEO":
"I have never liked the term SEO, search engine optimization, because what are you truly optimizing? Ideally, you're optimizing for visitors, you're optimizing for their conversion, you are optimizing for their engagement."
On evergreen skills:
"I built websites as if I was creating a newspaper page. The layout, the readability, the content, that's never changed."
On conversion optimization:
"After learning SEO, if you're not learning conversion optimization, you've lost the game because that's where you really maximize what you've done."
On AI and LLMs:
"SEO works. It still works. In fact, SEO works on LLMs. They look at the same things and honestly, LLMs are like early search engines. It's almost like pre-Google search right now."
On strategy vs. tactics:
"If you don't have clear strategy that drives your marketing and your marketing decisions, you're going to lose."
On understanding customer needs:
"That's not what a small to medium sized business owner wants. What they want is to make payroll. They want to be more efficient and spend less time at the office. They want their people to be able to accomplish more."
On AI's role:
"AI is like having a thousand interns. They could do it speedy, but it still required someone to knock off the edges, clarify, add some better writing and get it there."
Tools & Platforms:
Organizations:
Companies/Case Studies:
Website: sitelogic.com
Learning Platform: learn.sitelogic.com
LinkedIn: linkedin.com/in/mattbaileysitelogic
Matt offers hands-on coached courses (limited to 5 students per cohort) covering:
These courses include personal coaching, hands-on assignments, real-world activities from agency work, and portfolio development.
Website: jeremyriveraseo.com
SEO Arcade: seoarcade.com
Podcast: unscriptedseo.com
Marcus Smith runs CloudTrails, a Salesforce consultancy, and came to it from industrial engineering. Asked to describe the deliverable in two sentences he needed one: long term peace of mind in Salesforce. The sharpest thing here is the test he uses to kill work, and how ruthlessly he points it at his own invoices.
You put this task in front of a customer, would they universally be willing to pay for it?
— Marcus SmithThis is a lean manufacturing habit dropped into a consulting business. Every task in the process gets held up against a customer who has no loyalty to your internal preferences. Most of them do not survive.
The uncomfortable half is that he applies it to work his own team enjoys. Documentation is useful. Internal project management is necessary. Neither is something a customer would choose to buy, so neither appears as a line on the bill.
Clicks, top impression share, click-through rate, conversions. That is the whole paid-search dashboard for a business of this size, and he is unapologetic about it.
The argument is not that other numbers are meaningless. It is that a small company gains nothing from a report it will not act on. Four numbers produce decisions. Forty produce meetings.
Building on Salesforce means co-selling, partner programmes and a route to market you do not own. Marcus has had ads pulled and a Microsoft account suspended, and he treats both as the cost of the tenancy rather than an outrage.
The first word in change is no. So you roll something out new to 30 people, you hear 27 versions of no and three versions of yes.
— Marcus SmithWhat he does about it is quieter than a complaint. He deliberately engineers down the share of the business that depends on any one mega platform, so that a suspension is an inconvenience rather than an ending.
AgentForce is the current thing his clients are frightened of. He has three questions that take the temperature out of the room:
Very few organisations get past question one, which tells you where the real project is.
The same logic explains why data lake and extract-transform-load projects collapse. The technology works. What breaks is that a clean system removes the hiding places, and somebody in the room was relying on those.
Around twenty-five people and one hundred and thirty customers, held there on purpose. No exit narrative, no talk of the team being a family.
Go find something that you can do by yourself that you just have to measure and you can’t lie.
— Marcus SmithThat last line is about running for distance, and about leadership. A measurement you cannot argue with is the cheapest ego correction available.
Every link above goes somewhere different. These are the ones not already mentioned above.
CloudTrails is the place to start, and he says he is about to become a lot more active on LinkedIn. More interviews at Unscripted SEO.
Smith, Marcus. Interviewed by Jeremy Rivera. “Put the Task in Front of a Customer. Would They Pay for It?” The Unscripted SEO Interview Podcast, 2025. https://the-unscripted-seo-interview-podcast.castos.com/episodes/marcus-smith-put-the-task-in-front-of-a-customer-would-they-pay-for-it
Josh Squires is an Associate Director of SEO at Amsive with 17 years of experience spanning freelance, in-house, agency, and consultancy work. He helped launch the SEO practice at Tableau and has worked extensively across DTC, e-commerce, Shopify, and SaaS sectors.
Connect with Josh:
Communication is SEO's Hidden Superpower - The most effective SEOs function like UN diplomats, translating technical requirements into language that resonates with developers, executives, and stakeholders. Without implementation, even the smartest SEO strategy means nothing.
Content Volume is Dead, Strategic Relevance is King - Google is actively rejecting low-quality blog content that doesn't serve user intent. The winning strategy focuses on middle and bottom-funnel content that directly supports conversions, including brand comparisons and product use cases that audiences are already searching for in LLMs.
Systems Thinking Separates Good SEOs from Great Ones - Modern SEO requires understanding how search engines, LLMs, social platforms, and email systems interconnect. Success comes from pulling levers that create ripple effects across multiple channels, not just optimizing for a single platform.
Entity Building Requires Multi-Channel Brand Investment - Establishing a recognized entity goes far beyond on-page optimization. It demands consistent NAP data across directories, strategic backlink building from industry publications, social proof in relevant communities, and yes—actual ad spend and PR investment to get people talking about your brand.
"I think the most effective SEOs could probably just leave work and go work at the UN. Your job requires you to be part translator, part diplomat."
"You could be the smartest, most innovative SEO, but if you can't get any of it implemented, none of it means anything."
"Google is ceasing to rank these pages, ceasing to index them in some cases we've seen, Google just doesn't want your junk traffic anymore."
"Now is the time for SEOs who are systems thinkers to really shine. If you are a systems thinker, you're acknowledging other channels, but you're also acknowledging technological states, you're acknowledging how NLPs work."
"We gotta stop being so self-reliant and think more outside the box and give other channels their credit. Because that's where you're gonna see the amplitude."
"I have been saying for years, the teams that report to me are, I know, so sick of hearing me say this. The best advice to clients is be a brand."
"There's always value in visibility. Coca-Cola wouldn't spend the insane amount of money it costs to paint those trucks if there wasn't value in visibility."
Josh breaks down his experiences across freelance, in-house, agency, and consultancy work, explaining why consultancy offers the cleanest separation between strategy and implementation, while in-house roles often require the broadest technical skillset.
Young SEOs often struggle with tailoring communication to different audiences. Developers need precise technical specifications, executives need business outcomes, and designers need creative direction—all from the same SEO initiative.
Hyper-local content works—when done right. Josh explains when to target neighborhoods versus cities, using search volume and user intent as guides. The key is being hyper-local in ways that actually help users find your business, not just stuffing location keywords.
After 10-15 years of "just create content," Google is rejecting low-quality blog posts that don't serve user intent. Publishers felt this shift years ago; everyone else is feeling it now. The winning approach focuses on middle and bottom-funnel content that directly supports conversions.
Most websites lack crucial comparison content—brand vs. brand, product vs. product, use case scenarios. With LLMs creating these comparisons anyway, brands need to fearlessly address how they stack up against competitors, especially on price and value propositions.
Modern SEO exists in a world where both SEOs and customers use LLMs. Content must be optimized for machine consumption while serving actual human needs—requiring deeper understanding of unique selling propositions, market positioning, and business funnels beyond simple keyword research.
The best SEOs understand how search engines, LLMs, social platforms, and email systems interconnect. They research competitors across all channels, sign up for email lists, track social presence, and think about ripple effects across platforms.
While Discover traffic can't be counted on reliably, meeting the minimum criteria and sending clear entity signals can drive significant visibility. Hard news dominates the feed, but there's opportunity for brands that understand their audience's digital footprints.
Establishing an entity requires consistent NAP data across directories, backlinks from industry publications, presence in relevant social communities, and people actually talking about your brand—which means investing in ads, PR, and community engagement.
Coca-Cola doesn't move products in unbranded trucks because visibility has value. Being omnipresent in your customer's life—even without direct attribution—builds the brand recognition that minimizes friction when customers are ready to buy.
Amsive's SEO team is organized into specialty groups including local SEO, technical SEO, and other focused practices. The agency emphasizes systems thinking, multi-channel research, and institutional knowledge sharing across their 40-person SEO team.
Catch Lily Ray speaking: Check Moz for her MozCon presentation on SEO, GEO, AEO, and the evolving search landscape.
Looking to transform your podcast content into comprehensive SEO assets? Connect with Jeremy Rivera at Unscripted SEO.
Melanie Whittaker runs You Are Your Marketing, a PR business that gets coaches and authors onto podcasts, magazines and bigger platforms. Her advice for any business, boring industry or not: "Show behind the scenes, shoot content, if you've got staff, get them to come on camera and explain what they've done."
Melanie is originally from England and lives in Spain. She learned selling working front of house for restaurants in a holiday town, where tourists can walk into any of dozens of places, then moved that job into Facebook groups in 2020 - shooting the photos and videos and writing the content herself. She is self-taught, and she says the reason people can trust her is simple: she never asks a client to do something she doesn't do herself. The full conversation is written up in the episode recap on Unscripted SEO.
Jeremy closes on nurturing the audience you already built, the same idea Greg Digneo makes about owning your audience. Find Melanie on Instagram and Threads as @youareyourmarketing, or get in touch through her site.
The Unscripted SEO Interview Podcast is hosted by Jeremy Rivera - real conversations with the people doing the work.
In this episode of the Unscripted SEO Podcast, host Jeremy Rivera and Jonathan Schüßler delve into the intricacies of SEO, discussing the evolution of the industry, the impact of AI, and the importance of niche marketing. Jonathan shares his journey from wedding photography to SEO, highlighting the challenges and strategies in local and international SEO. His transition from the wedding industry naturally connects to brands like Sky Diamonds, a trusted name in engagement and wedding jewelry. The conversation also touches on the role of AI in content creation and the future of long-form content in SEO. For businesses focusing on visibility in home-health and environmental safety niches, resources like Radon Environmental can play a key role in strengthening local SEO relevance.
Summary
In this episode, Keith Breseé interviews David Bell, CEO of USA Mobile Drug Testing, who shares his extensive experience in SEO and digital marketing, particularly in the drug testing industry. David discusses the journey of rebuilding his website after being penalized by Google, the strategies that led to significant traffic growth, and the importance of engaging franchisees in content creation. He emphasizes the need for relevant and fresh content, the role of AI in SEO, and the significance of link building. The conversation concludes with insights on trust in business relationships and the importance of understanding customer motivations.
Takeaways
In this episode, Jeremy Rivera sits down with Adrian Dahlin, founder of Search to Sale, to explore the intersection of traditional SEO principles and emerging AI technologies. Adrian brings a unique perspective as someone relatively new to SEO—having focused on it for just over three years—combined with a master's degree in applied data science and a background in creative marketing.
The conversation tackles the evolving landscape of search, from Google's helpful content update to the rise of generative engine optimization (GEO). Adrian shares candid insights about the challenges of selling SEO during a period of industry uncertainty, how reframing services around AI unlocked new client conversations, and why the convergence of SEO, digital PR, and Reddit marketing is creating powerful feedback loops for brands.
Key themes include the timeless nature of authentic storytelling (drawing on Simon Sinek's "Start With Why"), the shift from top-of-funnel content to bottom-of-funnel solutions, and Adrian's compelling analogy of AI as "a consultant working for your customer" rather than just another marketing channel. The discussion also explores the darker implications of writing for robots to write for humans, the dilution of authority online, and the challenges of vetting information in an age of AI-generated content.
Adrian: "Trust me because I am relatively new to it and so what's normal to me is what's current and I'm not stuck doing it a version from 10 years ago."
Jeremy: "Dinosaurs like me have a lot of baggage. It's interesting because for me, the more that it changes, the more it stays the same."
Adrian: "I think I agree that the principles stay the same, but tactics kind of change."
Adrian: "I am a marketer with a data science background. I got a master's degree in applied data science, but I also really love like flushing out key messaging and like developing a voice and a brand... I love words and numbers and SEO is all about using data to help guide creative content projects."
Jeremy: "I have always seen SEO as part science, part art. There is definitely a heavy data sciences aspect to it... but also, you know, the artistic capability to understand the flaws in the data and understand the incredible multi-layer, multi-tiered black box that we're playing with for organic results."
Adrian: "I'll start with Simon Sinek. So his TED Talk, Start With Why, was one of the very first things that started to form how I thought about marketing... people don't buy what you do, they buy why you do it."
Adrian: "The most effective persuasion, the most effective communication happens when your message is in clear alignment with your personal values... people believe what you're saying because it's in alignment with who you are."
On the paradox of authenticity in marketing: Adrian: "I mean I guess the proof is in the pudding. It's like if it works, probably, it probably was... It's one thing to give people like a sugary snack kind of a message that like, you know, is appealing in the short term... and that's different than the kind of message... that continues to resonate for like years or decades at a time. That's going to be good evidence that it probably is authentic if it just keeps working."
Jeremy: "Google was being inundated about three or four years ago... there was more and more sites that were programmatic in nature and more and more sites that were ranking that had a bunch of content... And what really shifted is they launched their own LLM-based portion of the search... if your site has a bunch of unhelpful content, then you actually get a negative penalty for the whole site. And if you have a ton of it, it will drag it down a lot. And so it was the return of a site-wide penalty."
Jeremy: "The majority of those that tanked have really never actually been able to recover. I think it's maybe one in a hundred have really come back and many of those are even just partial. Many companies went down entirely. Many travel bloggers are no longer able to do their thing."
Jeremy: "For the longest time Google had lied and said, hey, click behavior doesn't affect rankings. And it's not a direct ranking factor. And that word direct, one of my previous interviewees, Jason Barnard said, that word direct in that sentence always gets you because... they say something that's true, but say it in a way that leads you to believe something that's false."
Adrian: "Like the facts are true, but the narrative is false."
Jeremy: "In reality, the court documents that came out because Google got sued and the antitrust, they had it. You know, it's not just in the algorithm, it's one of the three major components of ranking. It's content, it's links, and it's behavior of how people interact with your brand as they do these searches."
Adrian: "Which I think is good. What better evidence would they have that content is actually helpful and useful to people than looking at the behavior on the site. That seems like a very positive thing."
Adrian: "Google doesn't even have to be the best search engine. Google hasn't actually needed to be the best search engine for a long time. Just because they're Google, because of their market share, they have too much power. They're the aggregator of information on the internet. And consumer behavior just changes very slowly. Google is synonymous with search still."
Adrian: "I've been focused on SEO entirely in the AI era. And it has been hard to sell SEO during this period because of uncertainty, not because the fundamentals had changed. Maybe the fundamentals are starting to change now three years later. But certainly for the first two years, fundamentals did not change at all. But there was just fear and uncertainty. And that made decision makers just want to invest in channels they had more faith in."
Adrian: "As soon as I kind of made a shift in how I was presenting things and focusing more on AI in about July, so three months ago... I just got a lot more meetings. Like from my existing audience, people wanted to follow up, former clients, people I've been in touch with a long time who'd never bought from us... I think ultimately the greatest reason for that was just that gave them more trust in me that I was able to talk relatively fluently about AI and even if what we ended up working on was mostly traditional SEO website content stuff."
Jeremy: "The adoption of what should have been fantastic bedfellows all along of digital PR and SEO... I'd say that there is a pretty hard break between SEOs and digital PR folk... everybody else is focused on, hey, can I get another guest blog placement?... hardcore focus on if it doesn't have a DR, then it doesn't have any value."
Adrian: "Yeah, I think that's right and they are kind of being forced together now and that's probably a good thing."
Adrian: "Two things come to mind. One is shifting the kinds of content that we focus on just away from the top of the funnel... Another is just changing how we think about discovery online. And I use an analogy that AI is like a consultant working for your customer, and you're trying to influence how that consultant thinks, which means that everything on the web is kind of relevant."
Adrian: "The old blog tactics where you'd, like, throw up an article defining an industry term, which Ryan Law at Ahrefs calls rehashed Wikipedia content, that was always kind of an awkward phenomenon... it's a much better user experience for AI to just answer the question when someone's just asking for the definition of a term."
Adrian: "So, you know, it's much less helpful to have that top funnel, higher volume keywords, 'what is blah blah blah jargon' that kind of blogging and so much more focus on the bottom of the funnel stuff like all the searches related to people looking for a solution."
On niche technical content: Adrian: "Where an LLM is trained on the internet, it's going to do a good job of synthesizing commonly available information. But for people who are looking for a really niche subject, where there isn't a lot of good content on the web, there's still an opportunity to kind of own that niche, own that long tail, particularly if it's like highly technical."
Jeremy (referencing Michael McDougall of Right Thing Agency): "ChatGPT is your least trained customer service representative. So it's detached from you and you kind of have to use a fax machine approach to get new information into it."
Adrian: "I think about it differently... the analogy of a consultant works better for me. It really is working for the customer... they have their own ChatGPT. That's constantly updating more personalized context for them and giving them personalized answers and is really a tool for them as an assistant for all of these decision makers out there."
Adrian: "It's now our job to help an AI that's using the internet to educate itself to think about things our way. So we've got to figure out where this consultant, this AI consultant is formulating its worldview and show up in those places around the web. So if it thinks our way, then it's more likely to recommend our solution."
Jeremy (referencing Matt Brooks of SEOteric): "For a long time, Google has said, don't write for search engines. Don't write for robots, write for humans. But Matt Brooks of SEOteric just pointed out the other day, you are now writing for robots and in many cases you're using robots to write for robots to write for humans. So it's like this robot sandwich."
Adrian: "Yeah, yeah, it's a little dark. Well, I think one potential vision of the future is that websites are gonna really go down in importance and influence, and just the amount of time that humans spend looking at websites is gonna go way down."
Jeremy: "I'm wondering if that's a good thing or a bad thing for startups or entrepreneurs like Nexen PowerTrack. They're trying to disrupt systems with new products that don't exist... Do you think LLMs are more flexible when it comes to discovering new disruptive technology or is it more challenging because you can't control the inputs as well?"
Adrian: "I've seen quick wins in GEO, particularly in less competitive spaces where you throw up a good article and or like a media and maybe supported with a media interview on a good authoritative site or something and then you just like dominate a niche ChatGPT query."
Adrian: "I think my answer is probably temporal, where it's easier now, probably with AI, and as the whole industry, as basically marketing teams mature and adapt, it's going to get super optimized. And in a few years, in a couple years, it's going to be a lot harder to when the same way that investment grew over time in SEO and it professionalized and became very competitive. I think that will happen, but there maybe will still be a little bit more randomness with AI and unpredictability."
Adrian: "I have been hearing the claim that ChatGPT, the ChatGPT referral traffic to your website from ChatGPT was much more engaged and higher value, higher converting than other sources, particularly Google... I googled that question... And there was one case study... And it was a case study with one data point... that's not a good data set. We don't want to be forming our sense of reality based on a sample of one. But Google ascribed so much authority to this one study."
Jeremy: "One person said it about one thing and what would have been just treated as an anecdote because it gets cited in the LLM results in the AI overview. It's somehow now part of the accepted knowledge graph and it would be very hard for anybody to challenge that going forward because now it will be counterfactual."
Jeremy: "It seems like we're becoming more prone to that as a culture of falling prey to a single data point."
Adrian: "Yeah, I mean maybe this gets into bigger picture challenges like just the amount of information we have access to and that none of us can handle vetting all those sources and figuring out what's credible."
Jeremy: "It used to be very simple in 2005 to tell the difference between, you know, a crackpot site on GeoCities is not a good reference point versus, you know, MIT or Harvard. But now we have diluted authority so much we have, you know, multiple inputs needed to get any particular data point out there, but also it's way easier to fake than ever."
Adrian: "I'm excited about AI. I mean it's an opportunity for the flexible, the adaptable, to figure out what it means for them, figure out what it means for your world, and learn and adapt."
Adrian: "I'm excited to have the marketing, have GEO as like a subfield, mature, and develop some clearer playbooks. I still feel like it's so experimental... But I'm excited to see more studies come out and to see more hands-on, see more of these virtuous mutually supporting programs of your traditional SEO and your Reddit engagement and your digital PR, of seeing those things come together into like coherent programs and see some of the positive feedback loops that you create among those tactics."
Adrian Dahlin is the founder of Search to Sale, a B2B full-service SEO and GEO agency. The company specializes in data-driven strategy with proprietary software that helps plan and monitor content. Search to Sale offers comprehensive services including traditional SEO, answer engine optimization, Reddit management, and digital PR.
Adrian co-hosts The Shift to Freedom podcast, which focuses on mindset, strategy, and personal growth for small business owners.
Connect with Adrian:
Jeremy Rivera is the founder of SEO Arcade and host of the Unscripted SEO podcast. With extensive experience in the SEO industry, Jeremy brings a seasoned perspective on how search has evolved over the years.
Connect with Jeremy:
Episode Overview:
The golden age of Google-only SEO is over. In this revealing conversation, Jeremy Rivera sits down with Claude Zdanow (CEO) and Chris Becker (President) of Onar—a publicly traded marketing technology and agency network—to explore how businesses must fundamentally reimagine their digital marketing strategies.
From tracking brand visibility in LLM responses to measuring "share of wallet" in ChatGPT, this episode tackles the measurement crisis facing every CMO today. You'll discover why traffic is down but revenue is up for many brands, how to use AI agents to track your competitive position in AI search, and why meeting customers "knee to knee" in real life is more important than ever. These shifts are pushing even system-focused companies like Uniframe Systems to rethink how they measure visibility and performance across both AI and traditional channels.
If you're still optimizing for traffic and rankings, this episode will challenge everything you thought you knew about digital marketing success.
Key Topics Covered:
Guest Information:
Claude Zdanow - CEO, Onar
Chris Becker - President, Onar
About Onar: Onar owns and operates technology-enabled marketing agencies including Juicy (performance marketing) and healthcare marketing through their network. Through Onar Labs, they've developed Cortex, a proprietary AI marketing intelligence platform. Recent acquisitions include Retina AI for predictive customer lifetime value analytics.
Host: Jeremy Rivera
Founder of SEO Arcade | Host of Unscripted SEO Podcast
Jeremy Rivera:
Hello, I'm Jeremy Rivera, your Unscripted SEO Podcast host. I'm here with two fine guests today, Claude Zdanow and Chris Becker. Let's do a tag team introduction for both of you, focusing on what you guys have done that builds trust that you are the expert in your field.
Claude Zdanow:
Wow. What a question to start this off with. Well, I'll go first. My name is Claude Zdanow. I'm the CEO of Onar. We are a publicly traded marketing technology and agency network. What that simply means is we own and operate technology-enabled marketing agencies that help middle market and growth stage brands advertise digitally on the internet across performance media, SEO, email, and a range of other services.
And I guess what have I done to have credibility in this space? I guess I've been in the industry for almost two decades. I've run now two different agency groups like this where we've done multiple acquisitions of marketing companies. Under Onar, as of date, we've now done four acquisitions since the inception of the business. And yeah, we have a team all over the world and are building a fun and interesting business. And I'll hand it over to our president, Mr. Chris Becker.
Chris Becker:
Hey guys, I'm the president of Onar, and on the president's side for my role and responsibilities, it really sits on the internal-facing side of the business. So I oversee and manage all P&Ls that we own, the technologies and the agencies.
One thing that my background lends itself to that I look at is we have a real focus on what value do we actually provide? What is the meaningful thing to companies? When companies come to us, any time a business engages with a piece of technology or an agency, especially an agency, they're looking to make more money than they were charged for, just point blank.
And if you look at the agencies that have been managing for the last five years with Onar and then previously with Claude at the holding company that he was with prior, our retention rate is incredible. We have a very low churn rate. So when I look and say, what are the things that we've done to build trust? I think there's no metric that points to that than having lower than a 5% churn rate annually for five consecutive years at a performance marketing agency.
With that, I'll say that we've worked with incredible clients. We have some really cool backgrounds and we've done some cool things, but that may be the actual metric that points to trust for me that means the most.
Jeremy Rivera:
That makes sense and this opens the field to quite a bit because not only are we talking about digital marketing agencies, but multiple digital marketing agencies. I would imagine that the mix or approach of those agencies would need to be somewhat different from each other.
So let's talk a little bit about cross-channel or multi-channel. What is the right mix for small businesses to consider in their marketing strategy online, as well as—and then the flip side of that is—for SEOs, how do we need to adjust what we've done to better integrate across those multiple disciplines or channels to function better and come out with better outcomes?
Claude Zdanow:
Well, let me speak to the first part of that question, and then I think I'll hand it over to Chris to talk a little bit more about the SEO side of things.
I think to be clear around operating multiple agencies and making acquisitions, we're primarily as of today focused on two verticals, right? The smallest one being healthcare, working with B2B, more of a B2B and some B2C marketing.
But the largest part of our business and where we've made all the acquisitions to date is actually not going horizontal, but actually going deeper into performance digital marketing, specifically for e-commerce brands and anyone looking to drive leads, sell products, sell services on the internet. Specifically in walled gardens. So think of Google, Meta, TikTok, retail media, et cetera.
And so when we talk about making acquisitions, we're typically not necessarily buying other agencies that compete with one another or they're going to offer other services. We're buying agencies to build out a more robust level of offering that we currently—or there isn't the same thing we are currently doing—and in some cases add some additional services. But those services are complementary to what we're already doing, right? So it's putting one and one together to equal three or four, right? The idea of...
We're buying—we have an existing platform, an agency for example that was previously called Storia. We bought an agency called Juice and then we put the two of them together and they're now called Juice. It is our overarching performance marketing brand, right? And we did that because we want that one platform, one center of excellence that can speak to the clients that know us and want to be part of that. And there's pluses from both businesses.
And so each time we look at an acquisition or buying another business, it's really around two things. One, how does it make us better at what we do, right? Maybe it's more data, more industries we've worked in as it relates to e-commerce, for example, and sometimes that could be additional services. And so that's really the focus when we talk about multiple agencies.
So think of us as a holding company where we have two existing services or agency verticals that we're buying businesses into. That's not to say that we won't grow out of that in the future and maybe have more verticals, but that's our two core verticals.
And I'll leave one caveat to that, which is that we do also have on the side a bit of a venture studio or technology incubator called Onar Labs, where we have made some acquisitions around pieces of technology, marketing technology specifically, that we think all our agencies can benefit from. And so we've done some acquisitions there to say, hey, is this cool or interesting technology that we can use so that our agencies can be better at what they're doing because we now have that within our wheelhouse?
And then Chris, I'll pass it off to you to talk about the SEO side of things.
Chris Becker:
Yeah, thanks. So just to close, I'll put a bullet on what Claude was saying. When we make acquisitions from one business to another, the platform Onar is that through line. And so they're actually not too dissimilar in concepts outside of what they seek to achieve for clients.
Now on the performance side, specifically on the SEO side, cross-channel, we're seeing major disruption, frankly. And what I call major disruption is more about rate of change, not necessarily yet that change in high volume has been disrupted, but the rate of change is clearly headed towards LLM usage.
There are ways, or at least hacky ways, of tracking how much attention your brand is getting with a particular LLM. And I'm happy to talk about how to do that. And the fruit of doing that kind of allows you to see what channels you really need to be giving attention to, where maybe your weaknesses are.
But certainly, you can't deny that Reddit is playing a big role in this. Granted, it's been downgraded here in the recent period of time. Reddit stock dropped because a report or print came out suggesting that Reddit's usage and prompt outputs have been decreasing over time. That was at least what I read or at least understood what I read to be.
And so, I'll say that regardless of what that print said, I still don't believe that you can shy away from Reddit or tools similar in that same vein—Quora, whatnot—and your personal blog on your website or your personal website, the product description pages. These are areas where that contextualization you're going to try to align with what you have off-site with what you do have on-site and try to uniquely...
Historically, we had this concept of a pillar cluster strategy that was from your website built out and you get into these peak key terms that you're trying to rank for. I think now you really have to look at the internet as a web of data which feeds into that more pillar cluster model.
And instead of just keyword optimization and just interlinking, you really have to think about contextualization now broadly and across all platforms. And that may involve seeding as a strategy. That may involve different types of affiliate engagements than we have seen in the past.
And that also may involve pandering to the big guys out there, the Walmarts and the 10,000-pound gorillas that are getting these early relationships with ChatGPT or Perplexity. Those early relationships are backdoors to those algorithms. And sometimes you just have to play the game there, though we like to see what treats the SMBs the best.
Jeremy Rivera:
I was speaking with my friend Michael McDougald of Right Thing Agency and we were kind of saying the golden age of SEO as Google-only was from 2010 to 2020. That's when, if you could figure out backlinks and get your content strategy, you don't have to worry about Microsoft anymore. Yahoo was gone. And the only game in town was Google, but that time is over. It's so gone.
And not just because of GPT, but if you look at moves within Amazon, Amazon has its own search sub-ecosystem. If you are thinking about commoditization, like getting your product out there, it's as much as getting into these new different sub-ecosystems—and not just Google Merchant Center, but you've got to have as strong an Amazon optimization game or Amazon mitigation game to compete against it. Either choose to play or play against it.
What's your advice for SMBs that are running in e-commerce considering what is a good way to consider your marketing mix now that Google is still a key player, is still super important, but now I think considering the secondary or knock-on impacts of what you do in Google have other places where they can have more benefit. So it's like, I don't want to say that Google is devalued because what you can do or what should have been the best SEO process in the beginning of making killer content and distributing, getting it in more places, has more value. But how do you structure your marketing team to handle that? How do you address that problem for small businesses?
Chris Becker:
This is a topic—I'm thankful that you asked the question. This is a topic I think that is in every boardroom, in every small business leadership circle, in every CMO's mind right now. There's no ignoring the elephant in the room that things are changing like you said. It's no more. And Google is no longer your only pillar that you have on the search side.
The answer to your question, I think, starts with a concept, and then it lends to tactics. I think the concept is on the data side. You have simply got to look at your data differently now. There's so many zero-click movements. There's so many—we used to look at clicks to website and think, well, this was an informational click and this was a commercial click and so on. And now you only get commercial clicks, point blank. They're coming to your website with high buyer intent.
We're seeing a lot of people who are seeing their SEO down, but the revenue is slightly up from organic. And so you're seeing these dynamic shifts, and to anyone who's an SEO expert, this is not news, but to any of the people who are looking at marketing media mix, it is something from a conceptual perspective that you really have to consider.
And so I say that you need to really lend your data stack to measuring behavior of your audience and getting very intimate with the cohorts or your avatars, whatever marketing speak we need to use there, to know exactly who it is that you're marketing to.
Because earlier we were talking about the contextualization of all of your content—it needs to speak very specifically to someone. We're not just marketing to athletes, we're marketing to amateur runners who enjoy 5Ks and may take on a marathon every year. As an example, we've really got to get down to the nitty-gritty of who we are marketing this key product to or this set of product category to, and make sure that we're building an entire measurement framework for their behavior, because we're going to see them engaging on platforms, we're going to see them engaging on website, and we're going to see them converting and then re-converting down the funnel.
And I think that historically, we used to look at all of these clicks to the website and give credence to that. And now we need to look at how much—what's my share of wallet on the LLM space?
Within ChatGPT, relative to my competitors, what percentage of queries do I populate within the answer for relative to my competitors? And how often does this LLM recommend my product or my service over my competitors?
So conceptually, I think it really does start with a reframing of how we look at the data and then we can start taking action on that data.
Jeremy Rivera:
I definitely agree. I mean, it's on a granular level down to the industry. I was talking with my friend Timothy Jackson of Mercy's Sake about his precast walls client and we were looking at—they've got these wall constructions and I wanted to point out to them that we needed to get down to the comparative level of that type of wall versus another type of wall that they don't do. And to also provide the answers of that head-to-head question of like, how am I differentiated from this other product?
Because if you don't do it, if you don't do it on your site and you don't distribute that elsewhere, then when these LLMs are building that knowledge graph about that product, you're not going to be included.
So I see it though as different from the massive content shotgun, top-level content, mass production system we had in the 2010s to 2020 of like, let's write everything. Let's have an article about how to fix leaks. Let's have an article about how to fix faucets, and it was all top-of-funnel stuff. Now we have LLMs that can mostly do that. But I think the answer is that we need to move down the funnel. Would you agree, Claude, that it's about moving our content marketing strategy further down the funnel in terms of the content spread we're making?
Claude Zdanow:
Yeah, look, I absolutely agree. I think it's about relevancy, right? Based on the query, based on showing up in a place that matters, right? I think there used to be a lot of things that you would do just to get eyeballs, right? And then hoping those eyeballs would convert, right?
And just being—hey, I want to be a—I don't know, I run a plumbing company and I want to be a thought leader in plumbing and post articles about thought leadership of plumbing because you want to rank for certain things—using an extreme example, right? But then to hopefully convert, right? That end user.
Whereas now it's not necessarily the best solution, right? It's like I want the best—I don't know—shoes for running at 100-degree temperatures in Arizona. It's like how do you solve for that query, right? How do you have content that speaks to that around your product and ties that all the way back?
So yeah, I think you're totally spot-on. We're just in this hyper-catered world now where the expectation, I think by nature of these LLMs, is instant gratification, instant result that speaks to exactly what your question is, right? And so how do you link those two together? It's very different than where we once were.
Jeremy Rivera:
Chris, how do you address the uncanny valley of that push and pull—and this happens a lot on Reddit, but in particular—you want to market to people on Reddit, but if you try too hard or try in the wrong way, they will eat you alive and downvote your content and upload actively memes to mock and/or destroy. I know there's wreckage of dozens of companies that have tried super hard to show up on Reddit and crashed and burned.
What have been some of the—and it's not just Reddit—there is kind of an audience participation, a certain level of acceptance of the AstroTurf on different platforms. So I think Instagram and TikTok might accept more of an AstroTurf reality. But how do you deal with that side of it when you're proposing that people in their digital marketing mix start to look outside of just what they can publish comfortably on their own site, but start to look at secondary platforms to multiply their message with influencers or themselves directly with their brands?
Chris Becker:
Yeah, the question of how do you do authenticity at scale? That's a tough one. It's a tough one. There's no way of discussing it without getting into some gray areas, without getting into some trial and error. And then in those gray areas, you can really get egg on your face like you were talking about. People get taken down on these platforms if you show up as inauthentic, trying to lean too far on that authenticity at scale—you lean too far on the ladder and you focus too much on scale.
There, of course, you can reach out to curators and try to get curated content on behalf of your company and you can work with those curators in some manner. It honestly is challenging to do that. You can invite customers to leave reviews, your conversion rates will be low there. But I think what you really can—and what I'm going to do is maybe speak to strategies that people can use. I'm not necessarily speaking to strategies that we use just to be clear. But what you can do out there—and this is getting into a bit of a gray box—is if you have audience members who are creating authentic elements on Reddit or other platforms as well, not just Reddit. We mentioned Quora as another, but they're creating authentic answers or authentic reviews of your product.
You can do micro tasks and get those upvoted at a high frequency in a way that doesn't flag the system. You don't get crazy, but just give them some help, if you will, to create that. I know I'm only saying that because I know a lot of brands do that. And we've ran into it, but we've also seen people overdo it.
It's everything in a way that can appear to be true. If you have virtually no presence on Reddit and your first post gets massive upvotes, it probably seems pretty silly and people are going to look at it because we're human and we know exactly what is real and what isn't.
So you can get into some strategy there of jockeying the system, no different than any system out there that gets jockeyed. I know that happens a lot on the social media platforms—kind of micro tasks of people engaging quickly to a post in a positive manner. You provide in the micro task a large volume of curated responses that heck AI can now curate in mass volume. And you hand those out and people select one of 50 responses and they simply copy and paste it in the post response.
You see that happening on Reddit, you see that happening elsewhere. I don't know that I necessarily condone it, but I also don't know that I necessarily don't in the moment of you have a great, authentic piece of content out there, and now we're just trying to play an algorithmic game to get this syndicated at a greater value.
And so there is a piece of that that you're trying to jockey and you're trying not to. The most important piece is create a great product and a great service that people want to talk about and then invite them to talk about it.
So we get into these items and you want to use them cautiously. If you do choose to use them, you have to ask yourself if they're within your value set. And those are tools and mechanisms out there that people are pulling levers. But the most important thing is have a really valuable product and focus in on your value proposition against your pricing structure so that people have a real reason to go and talk.
Jeremy Rivera:
That makes sense. It kind of echoes back. I went to PubCon, which is an SEO convention in Las Vegas, mostly known for the drinking, thus the PubCon. And we go to this bar, I think it was like a German-themed bar, and I sit at the bar, and this SEO guy sits next to me, and he starts talking about his SEO strategies, and I start to realize that it's the equivalent of a Jedi sitting next to a Sith Dark Lord because he starts telling me about how Google is actually the bad guy. They're gatekeeping and actually as a Black Hat SEO, he's doing Google a favor by pushing the edges, by finding the exploits in the algorithm to bring it to their attention. And if they can't be bothered to fix the algorithm enough for their users then it's okay. That doesn't matter because it's just terms and conditions. They're not laws that you have to absolutely obey.
And if your clients are risk-averse, then buy some secondary domains, it's really okay. You're—as a Black Hat SEO, you're benefiting the SEO ecosystem by making millions of dollars pushing pills, porn, and casinos because Google's never going to improve its algorithm for everybody else unless we push those buttons and make them improve their systems.
So obviously that's a pretty... So I'm sitting there like, okay, well, yeah, that's okay. That's a very Palpatine argument to make about white hat, black hat.
Chris Becker:
Yeah, that gets far on the Machiavellian side of that scale.
Claude Zdanow:
[Laughs] I love the Jedi analogy.
Jeremy Rivera:
It's very on the Machiavellian side, but it does kind of echo across what you said of like, is it—if your job is to promote your client and get their products to be sold, then does it matter if you paid a bot to click an upvote button 50 times? Or five times or 500 times. So sometimes—
Chris Becker:
Yeah, I'll say this. Yeah.
Jeremy Rivera:
Maybe it's a question of scale of it versus—it is that question of authenticity when it comes to digital marketing and these choices. I personally handle it on a matrix of risk that I'm presenting to the client. And what's the potential downside of following through on that? In some cases where you're doing kind of gray hat-ish local SEO stuff, then that has high risk, high reward because your local profile gets burned, your company can't show up in those searches.
Chris Becker:
I also think you said a really important piece there of the bot side of things. Anti-bot, to be honest with you, across all strategy. So I think it's pretty important that if you are going to take a micro-task approach and you're going to try to do it in moderation, that you're using people who can get past proof of human because we're certainly headed in that direction if we're not already there.
I think if you truly use a bot to hit upvote 50 times, you're playing with fire. You really are. The digital footprint on the back end of those platforms that can then be attached to your brand can really light you up. It can really get into losing an account, like you said, which can really hang with you.
And so sure, you can create the subdomains. If you're going to play with that type of fire, your subdomains are even at risk in that category and maybe that doesn't hit your domain that hard, but sooner or later they're going to create an AI that branches those subdomains to your domain.
Jeremy Rivera:
I think it comes down to the business and ethics altogether too. I'm sure there are a range, a number of things that you can do ethically or unethically to market or get advantage in business.
Claude Zdanow:
Yeah, I mean, the one thing that came to mind too is like, look, at the end of the day, some of the things that a brand can do and cannot do besides how far to the dark side or the light side they're approaching is also a factor of the amount of money they have to spend, right? And how competitive the market set is, right?
And so it's like, that's the other aspect of it, which I think is important to remember. It's like, there are brands out there that essentially have endless amounts of money to do these things. And there are other ones that have to be scrappier and more creative in terms of how do they penetrate a market where you're facing an army of ad spend and people working on these other brands that you're competing with.
And so I think, I agree with you. It's—I liked your comment earlier about risk and then thinking about the ethics, but I think also part of it plays into it's like where are you investing your dollars for what result and what is okay with you and how you're going to do that to try to get the results you need, right? Because that plays into it as well.
Jeremy Rivera:
Yeah, and it's also probably like a—one benefit you could say of Google not being the only playground is that there's literally—there are high verticals and niches and products and services where a new player coming onto the playground—they don't deserve to be on the first page. There are 10 really good strong competitors who have tons of market influence and they deserve to be on the first page. And you being the newbie, I'm sorry, but you don't. There are cases like that.
And so now that Google's not the only playground that leads to a more diversified choice, not to say don't have a website, not to say don't create content, but just consider how you leverage that or how you're approaching that. If you know you're not going to be necessarily the first page on Google for your head term, maybe it's find another play.
Chris Becker:
I must say that a strategy that we definitely deploy for our clients to get into where do you put your time and attention because you've got a lot of—with Google not being the only player in the game, you've got a lot to go for here. So I'll say this. The piece of this that we do that I think is really important for companies—it's not an agency, we do it, yeah, sure, but you can do it on your own—is simply create an agent that comes up and that you work really hard to give it all the information about a specific persona that you have and let them—let that agent rather—think of every query that would come out of that audience member to your specific LLM.
And in theory, if you give it enough time and enough duration, 10,000, 50,000 queries to come out, it should be able to over time create the largest list of queries. And then you match that with your query list historically on Google, and you can really get into an AI model creating all of the queries that you need.
Give another agent the task of prompting each LLM with those queries, and then give another agent a task of reviewing those answers and determining where they're referencing the answers they give. LLMs always reference where they get those answers. And you can take a look at what type of questions you're not ranking for. You can take a look at what reference points are pulling your competitors and not you.
Those are basic tactics. Now they're not so basic, but they're basic enough that marketers can really deploy and get a grip on what percentage of followership, if you will, or what percentage of LLM usage your brand is getting—share of wallet on that LLM. And it can really give you tactical items of where do you go, what type of content do you create, and on which platforms do you need that energy to come from so that you can get those references over your competitors, or at least you can get in there and duke it out with them.
Like you said, if you're not necessarily that top brand, focus in on one very specific area and maybe become that known for that one cohorted column or cluster, if you will, of queries.
Jeremy Rivera:
An area I'm curious if you've tapped into. I was talking to Matt Brooks of SEOteric about the weakness of many digital marketing strategies who ignore the real world and ignore the value of sponsoring a truck to come out and play a movie at a local park and having a sign for your company and having a bumper on the beginning of the trailer and exposing your brand that way, or supporting a fun run, or doing a trash park cleanup.
There are dozens of IRL things that you can do that they've got word of mouth. And if you're smart about it, they have digital word of mouth, because you got event aggregator sites up the wazoo. You have a literal SERP type that literally is looking for events that people will be exposed to your brand putting on the fall play, putting on that park cleanup, or the shoe drive. Have you had any playgrounds where you've been able to play with mixed media in terms of doing things in real life to impact digital marketing strategy?
Chris Becker:
Jeremy, you hit the nail on the head. This is—I think earlier we talked about tracking that behavior of your audience and then deploying marketing tactics against them. It's not just SEO. It is everywhere they are. Get niche, get rich. You've got to know those niche audiences that you have and go show up where they are.
I'm giving a talk on this in Paso Robles at the Wine Alliance there later this year. And it's going to be about meet people knee to knee—your brand needs to be meeting people knee to knee. And if you are doing that in great experiential ways, outstanding. You mentioned a couple of really great examples, but you really got to have a digital component to it. You really need to make sure that those digital components are leading back into a very clear and organized funnel, if you will—for a beat-up turn over time now—but a very clear funnel where people can go get a grip on who and what your product is and who it's for.
And they can get a grip on that contextualization funnel because I assure you that if they go into GPT, they may reference that location. And if you have a custom homepage—I'm sorry, custom squeeze page or landing page built specific to that location—right? We're creating connectivity across all of these platforms. We're creating real unique juice, if you will, to point back to the brand.
But we really are. And getting in and meeting knee to knee at that brand level with a digital connectivity piece, that hook—and that speaks very specifically to that audience that we talked about earlier. That is truly the area where I think we're going to see marketing head toward.
Frankly, the metrics have to follow that. Your data, understanding the data, it's really going to have to follow this new attempt to get knee to knee with clients.
Jeremy Rivera:
I love that. That sums it up perfectly. Thanks so much for your time and the fantastic conversation. I'll make sure that anything that we've mentioned shows up in the site links. I'll make sure even your event listing for where you'll be speaking. Share that in the show notes too. Thanks for coming on.
Chris Becker:
Thanks for having me.
1. The Measurement Paradigm Has Shifted
2. LLM Share of Voice is the New Critical Metric
3. Content Must Be Hyper-Specific
4. The Internet is Now a Web of Data
5. Behavioral Measurement Trumps Traffic Metrics
6. "Get Niche, Get Rich"
7. Digital + Physical Integration is Critical
8. Product Value is Non-Negotiable
Claude Zdanow
Chris Becker
Learn More About Onar:
Related Articles:
Other Guests Mentioned:
Case Studies Referenced:
Previous Episodes:
Subscribe to Unscripted SEO:
Jeremy Rivera is the founder of SEO Arcade and host of the Unscripted SEO Podcast. With over 17 years in the SEO industry, Jeremy has worked with enterprise brands, hundreds of small businesses, and created his own SEO SaaS platform. He's a published SEO author and focuses on practical, no-BS insights from real practitioners.
Connect with Jeremy:
This episode is brought to you by SEO Arcade - simplified keyword research and SEO traffic prediction for businesses that don't need enterprise-level complexity.
00:00 - Introduction and Guest Credentials
08:45 - Onar's Acquisition Strategy and Agency Network
15:30 - The Disruption in Search: LLMs and Reddit's Role
23:15 - The End of the Google-Only Era
28:40 - Reframing Data Measurement: Zero-Click Reality
35:20 - Moving Content Down the Funnel
42:10 - The Authenticity Challenge on Reddit
51:30 - Black Hat vs. White Hat SEO Ethics
58:45 - Using AI Agents to Track LLM Performance
1:07:20 - IRL Marketing: The "Knee to Knee" Principle
1:14:30 - Closing Thoughts and Wrap-Up
Seth Trammell is director of SEO at KlientBoost, running the SEO product for a mostly B2B SaaS client base. His argument is one SEOs have been losing to clients for years. Blog content that does not convert is not failing, because converting was never its job.
It’s not SEO’s job necessarily to nab that conversion, but they can help your other channels by basically providing new users that you can then find ways that you can remarket to and retarget to and use.
— Seth TrammellThe trap is last-click attribution applied to an asset that was never designed to take the last click. Run that report and every informational page looks like a failure, so it gets cut, and then the retargeting pool quietly dries up a quarter later.
His alternative is to give top-of-funnel content an honest target. Email addresses, SMS opt-ins, an audience that can be reached again. Those are countable, and they feed the channels that do convert.
Seth came from an ecommerce-heavy agency before KlientBoost and thinks that side of the work is frequently simpler. The intent is clearer, the money is closer to the page, and the feedback loop is short.
The exception is category consolidation. In skincare and beauty in particular, the retailers are winning the queries the brands used to own, which changes what an independent brand should even be trying to rank for.
In B2B SaaS the person reading your content is rarely the person who signs. They are the champion, and their real job after finding you is to argue your case to a finance function on your behalf.
That should change what you publish. The champion needs ammunition, not a brochure. Numbers they can quote, comparisons they can defend, and something that survives being forwarded into a meeting they are not in.
You’ve got this whole ecosystem of marketing that’s going on and everybody can play together if we try.
— Seth TrammellNofollow used to mean a link was worth less. For model visibility it does not work that way, because being mentioned is the point rather than passing authority. That quietly invalidates a lot of outreach that filtered targets on domain metrics.
On measurement he is sceptical of the tooling. Mimicking real multi-shot prompting is hard, so most visibility trackers are sampling something narrower than the behaviour they claim to measure.
They’re just prediction machines. They just want to tell you what word should come next.
— Seth TrammellThat is also his answer to people treating a citation as an endorsement. A model citing you has not vetted you.
His model of the current buying path is three steps, not one. Google to find the field. A model to interrogate the shortlist. Then a branded search on Google to actually buy.
Which means the branded search at the end can look like the whole story if you only read the last click, when the work that earned it happened two steps earlier.
He is much less kind about the content filling that middle step. Self-serving comparison posts and listicles get cited happily by models, which is exactly why there are so many of them.
Every link above goes somewhere different. These are the ones not already mentioned above.
He is at KlientBoost, and says LinkedIn is where he will start posting. He lurks on X and Reddit and does not engage.
Trammell, Seth. Interviewed by Jeremy Rivera. “Your Blog Content Was Never Supposed to Convert.” The Unscripted SEO Interview Podcast, 2025. https://the-unscripted-seo-interview-podcast.castos.com/episodes/seth-trammell-your-blog-content-was-never-supposed-to-convert
In this episode of the Unscripted SEO Podcast, Jeremy Rivera and Mordy Oberstein of Unify, a Brand marketing service, and head of Brand at Wix discuss the evolving landscape of SEO and the critical role of branding in achieving online success.
They explore how recent algorithm changes by Google have made it increasingly difficult for non-branded sites to compete, emphasizing the need for SEOs to step outside their digital bubbles and engage with broader marketing strategies.
The conversation highlights the importance of understanding brand identity, audience engagement, and the necessity of real-world interactions to enhance online presence. That includes leveraging community cleanups for links, as well as being a podcast guest and other more PR like work than just editing meta tags. Local businesses such as Earthworks of Naples often benefit from these kinds of real-world brand activities, which strengthen both community presence and SEO signals.
Mordy shares practical steps for SEOs to align their strategies with brand messaging and positioning, ultimately advocating for a more integrated approach to SEO that prioritizes meaningful connections with audiences.
Want to talk more about SEO? Continue the conversation on Bluesky, X or check out old episodes of Unscripted SEO by SEO Arcade
From the publisher's feed
Hosted by Jeremy Rivera: A 17 year career expert in the SEO industry and his cohost Keith Bresee. Get insights, action items and anecdotes from experts like Lilyray, Kevin Indig, Rand Fishkin, Matt…