This episode details the enduring mystery of Judge Theodore Harlan and his wife, Eleanor, who vanished from their Maine home in 1955. Their disappearance, marked by a blood trail leading to the sea, has remained unsolved for seven decades, becoming a local legend. The document explores the Harlans' background, the events of the fateful night, the challenges faced by investigators, and various theories ranging from murder to staged disappearance or even supernatural explanations. Despite ongoing speculation and renewed interest in the case, the truth about their fate remains elusive, captivating Eldridge Cove and beyond.