A burned map with the target house circled. A blackened hunting knife in a roadside ash ring. And a timeline that narrows to minutes before a panicked evidence dump. We take you from Bonnie Von Stein’s bandaged hospital bed to a midnight search on a rural road, where a farmer’s tip turns a hazy home invasion into a meticulously planned attack.

We walk through the Sunday night dinner that anchors the timeline, the medical details that undermine a simple narrative, and the tension around who could have known about a recent inheritance, a planned shift to Treasuries, and a life insurance stack that now looms large. Bonnie opens up about money, keys, and house routines; the detectives track painters, housekeepers, lawn crews, and a pet sitter with a key. Then the evidence shifts the ground: charred jeans, a Reebok sole, and two sheets of paper, one a hand-drawn map of Smallwood with Lawson Road labeled and the Von Stein address marked. The attack looks planned by someone unfamiliar with the neighborhood and hurried enough to leave the knife and map where a passing farmer might notice a fire.

As storms roll over a packed chapel, the investigation grinds on. A missing blunt weapon suggests a second dump site; a daylight grid search comes up empty. Relatives worry that Chris and Angela seem oddly calm; a peer describes Chris as fragile, unlucky, and rumored to use drugs. Nothing proves involvement, but the fire’s timing, the map’s intent, and the drive toward Raleigh tighten the circle. Through it all, Bonnie cooperates fully, even providing a blood sample, while her doctor expects a quick discharge and treats her as a victim without hesitation.

This chapter is about planning, proximity, and the secrets that make or break a case. Follow the evidence from ICU to asphalt and decide what matters most: the money trail, the map, or the missing club. If this deep dive gripped you, follow the show, share it with a friend, and leave a review telling us which clue you think the detectives should chase next.

Send us a text

Support the show